As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

Arrest of the Notorious Benders

June 1873 – May 1877

Within weeks the Benders were being arrested in Iowa and in Utah, and detectives were said to be hunting Kate in Paris; by the end of 1873 a family had been arrested in South Carolina. In 1874 a woman arrested near Topeka was released and a Salt Lake paper doubted its Utah suspect, and in 1876 two women were jailed at Laramie City. In April 1877 came the first report that a vigilance committee had lynched all four, and in May an Arkansas paper reprinted from the Chicago Times a full account of the chase and the killing.

Two Benders said taken in Iowa

An Iowa dispatch dated 31 May reports a young man supposed to be the Bender son arrested at West Liberty, and a woman thought to be Mrs. Bender arrested at Oxford. ‘There seems to be little doubt as to their identity’, it says. The pair are not heard of again in the set, two of many suspects taken up over the next years.

Memphis Daily Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Memphis Daily Appeal · 1 June 1873 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Arrest of Two of the Benders. DUBURUE, IOWA, May 31.—A young man, supposed to be a young Bender, son of the well-known Kansas murderer, was arrested at West Liberty, Iowa, to-day, and a woman, thought to be Mrs. Bender, was arrested at Oxford. There seems to be little doubt as to their identity. Both parties are being held for further developements.

See the clipping

Detectives on Kate’s trail in Paris

An Ohio editorial ranks the Bender women with Lucrezia Borgia and the Marchioness Brinvilliers, and says one or more may have reached France, where American and French detectives are hunting Kate and expect to know her by ‘her red hair and smattering of French’. It speaks of ‘the four women of the Bender family’; the Kansas reports in the set describe a family of four: father, mother, son and daughter.

Northern Ohio Journal · Painesville, Ohio

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Northern Ohio Journal · 19 July 1873 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Lucrezia Borgia was tender-hearted and solicitous for those she loved, and the Marchoiness Brinvilliers was very beautiful and generous to her friends—so that both had some partially redeeming traits in their characters as assassins by the bowl. But the four women of the Bender family, of Kansas, the peeresses of the Italian and the French women, in kind and atrocity of crime, possess no modifying graces, for they are as wholly ugly in person as they are fiendish in disposition. They are, however, "smart" withal, for one or more have succeeded in getting to France—or are believed to have succeeded in getting there.

See moreSee less

The repulsive wretch, known as Kate Bender, has American and French detectives now on her track in Paris. These detectives expect to identify her by her ugliness in general, but by her red hair and smattering of French in particular.

See the clipping

Kate reported taken at Provo

A New Hampshire paper passes on a report that Kate Bender, of the family whose crimes ‘caused such a sensation several weeks ago’, has been arrested at Provo, Utah. The report is not followed up anywhere in the set. Utah would produce another suspected Kate the next spring, and the Salt Lake Herald doubted that one.

Independent Statesman · Concord, N.H.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

Independent Statesman · 31 July 1873 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

It is reported that Kate Bender, one of the infamous family of Kansas murderers, the discovery of whose crimes caused such a sensation several weeks ago, has been arrested at Provo, Utah.

See the clipping

A family named Webb in South Carolina

A short item says the Bender family were arrested ‘a few days ago’ at Bivingsville, South Carolina. The father and mother are in custody, and officers are looking for a son and daughter said to be living in North Carolina. It adds: ‘The family name is Webb.’ No later clipping in the set returns to the South Carolina arrests.

South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 21 days later.

Wrong

South Branch Intelligencer · 19 December 1873 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ARREST OF THE NOTORIOUS BENDERS. —The Bender family, who are charged with having committed a number of murders in Kansas, were arrested in Bivingsville, Cheartenburg county, South Carolina, a few days ago. The father and mother are in custody, and the son and daughter, living in North Carolina, are being sought after by the officers of the law. The family name is Webb.

See the clipping

Doubts over the Topeka prisoners

A year after the discovery a Missouri weekly reports that ‘The Bender excitement is raging in Kansas.’ The man brought to Topeka as old Bender is said to be one Johannes Cook, and an old Prussian woman taken as Mrs. Bender has been discharged. Now Salt Lake reports a girl and a man held as Kate and John Bender, to be identified.

The Weekly Caucasian · Lexington, Mo.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 42 days later. CorrectionThis set right 6 earlier articles: The New York Herald, 10 April 1874, The New York Herald, 10 April 1874, Der Deutsche Correspondent, 11 April 1874, Der Deutsche Correspondent, 11 April 1874, Der Deutsche Correspondent, 11 April 1874, The Somerset Press, 24 April 1874.

Wrong

The Weekly Caucasian · 2 May 1874 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The Bender excitement is raging in Kansas. Old Bender, as some call him, has reached Topeka, and it is claimed the name of the prisoner is Johannes Cook, and not the notorious cut-throat. An old lady, a Prussian, was arrested near Topeka as old woman Bender, but her capturers were mistaken and she was discharged. It is feared that the guilty wretches are still at large.

And now comes another report from Salt Lake that a girl supposed to be Kate Bender, and a man supposed to be John Bender, have been arrested near there, and will be held for identification.

See the clipping

The Utah suspect is probably not Kate

A Cheyenne paper says the young woman arrested in Morgan county, Utah, on suspicion of being Kate Bender is of Swedish blood, tells ‘a very connected story’ of her last few years, and seems modest and timid. It quotes the Salt Lake Herald: she is scarcely likely to be Kate, but a ‘semi-demented young woman’ wandering with no fixed aim.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 8 May 1874 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

The young woman arrested in Morgan county, Utah, a few days ago, on suspicion of being Kate Bender, is of Sweedish blood. She tells a very connected story of her life for the last few years, and seems to be a modest timid lady. The Salt Lake Herald says: "It is scarcely probable that she is Katie Bender, but is a semi-demented young woman who is roaming across the country without definite object."

See the clipping

The woman who hid from strangers

Reprinted from the Marshall (Mo.) Democrat: a woman many have suspected for months to be ‘the genuine Kate Bender’ has been taken into custody near the Douglass county line, and a description telegraphed for. She had lived in that county about five months, hid when strangers came, and offered a man $500 to take her out of the country, traveling by night. The set does not say what became of her.

The Andrew County Republican · Savannah, Mo.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

The Andrew County Republican · 7 May 1875 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Kate Bender. A woman upon whom suspicion has rested for some time, was taken into custody one day this week near the Douglass county line. It has been thought by many for severl months that she is the genuine Kate Bender, the genuine maiden, and heroine of the Kansas murders. Parties arrived here Tuesday and telegraphed for correct description. This woman of whom we speak, we are informed, has been in Douglass county some five monts. She has been known to hide herself on the approach of strangers, but we believe the direct cause for suspecting her consists in the fact that she offered a certain man $500 if he would travel with and take her out of the country.

See moreSee less

She mentioned that it would be her plan to travel by night and rest during the day. —Marshall (Mo.) Democrat.

See the clipping

Two women jailed at Laramie

Three years on, a dispatch from Laramie City dated 24 April says the sheriff there has jailed two women supposed to be Mrs. Bender and Kate. A description sent by telegraph that day from the sheriff of Parsons ‘exactly answers the description of the prisoners’. The arrest is not mentioned again in the set.

Daily Press and Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

Daily Press and Dakotaian · 25 April 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Two of the Benders Arrested.

LARAMIE CITY, April 24.—The sheriff has arrested and confined in jail here two women supposed to be the old woman and Kate Bender of the Kansas murder fame. A description of Kate and Mrs. Bender was sent here by telegraph to-day from the sheriff of Parsons, and exactly answers the description of the prisoners.

See the clipping

First word of a lynching

A Maryland news column carries the first report in the set that the Benders never got away: ‘It is stated’ that all four were captured and lynched by a vigilance committee while trying to leave the state, and that one of the party has confessed. A month later an Arkansas paper printed a narrative credited to one of the lynchers. Later clippings argue the point both ways for decades.

The Aegis & Intelligencer · Bel Air, Md.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 21 days later.

Wrong

The Aegis & Intelligencer · 13 April 1877 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

—It is stated that Bender, his wife, son and daughter, the notorious Kansas murderers, who have been searched for during the last several years, were captured and lynched by a vigilance committee, whi'e attempting to leave the State. One of the lynching party, it appears, has made the confession.

See the clipping

A lyncher’s account of the chase

A Chicago Times narrative credited to one of the lynchers: farmers who suspected the Benders found their house deserted, uncovered Dr. York’s body, and caught the family forty-five miles off by sunset. John was shot in the fight, Kate after she seized a revolver, and her parents after the party swore secrecy. A Kansas City Times dispatch of May 1873 had the family gone nearly four weeks before the graves were found.

The Van Buren Press · Van Buren, Ark.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Van Buren Press · 15 May 1877 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

THE FATE OF THE EBNDERS. A Narrative by One of the Men who Lynched Them—Shot to Death.

The Benders might have continued their bloody work in peace and prosperity for an indefinite length of time had they continued planting their victims in the garden. But previous to the killing of Dr. York, they had murdered a man named Jones. In February a man named Conklin, in company with another farmer, while riding along Drum Creek, and the dead body of a man caught in some drift wood. It proved to be the body of Jones. He had his throat cut from ear to ear. The body had no clothing upon it save a shirt. Some ten or a dozen farmers met quietly on the banks of Drum Creek, and after viewing the body of Jones, held a council. At this meeting the Benders were spoken of suspiciously, and it was determined to keep the discovery of the body quiet until further developments. The next day a man who evidently was a tramp, and had footed it from Independence, on his way to Fort Scott, stopped at Dutroit's house, and asked for something to eat. In conversation with this man Dutroit learned that late the previous evening, the tramp had while looking around for a place to pass the night, come across a haystack back of the Bender's house, into which he quietly nestled himself. It must have been midnight when he was awakened by voices, and quietly looking out from his nest, he saw the dim outline of three persons evidently at work digging at a short distance from him. It was so dark that he could not distinguish them, but he could hear them speak in German, a language he did not understand. His first impulse was to go out to them. But something seemed to withhold him, and after a time they finished whatever work they were at, and withdrew into the house. The tramp departed early in the morning and had tramped on, until he had stopped at Dutroit's for breakfast. He concluded his tale by remarking that it looked mighty like as if they were burying some one. Mr. Dutroit said nothing at the time, but when the party of twelve met by appointment on Drum Creek, he related the circumstance to them, and it was determined to give the Bender mansion a quiet investigation. A wagon track was discovered leading to the Bender place from where Jones' body had been thrown into the creek. The party struck out on the wagon trail, and about sunset it brought them within view of the tavern. It was then determined to forego proceedings until to-morrow, and in the morning the entire party would meet on Drum Creek, well armed, and ride over to the Bender place.

See moreSee less

On the morrow, about 8 o'clock, the party assembled on the creek, and immediately proceeded over the prairies to the suspected house. But when they arrived there, they found the Bender ranch deserted. The Benders had noticed the squad of horsemen riding on the wagon trail, the previous evening and during the night had bundled up their effects and departed. The Benders had, at the time, four horses, a cow, and a wagon-load of household truck.

While the scouting party were canvassing the new state of affairs, Mr. Dutroit and others went in search of the spot indicated by the tramp. They searched around for sometime in vain, as the ground had been recently plowed over; but at last struck a spot that appeared moister than the rest, as though the ground beneath it had recently been turned up. No shovel being found, three of the party set to work with shingles torn from the roof of the house, and after digging a hole four feet deep, one of them, with a shout, reached down his hand and pulled up the skirt of a man's under garment, and beneath could be seen the exposed portion of a human body. This was the corpse of Dr. York, though at the time the explorers did not know it.

The track of the Bender wagon could be seen leading to the southwest. The horsemen followed it at full speed. Just before sunset the pursuers came in sight of the fugitives. They had evidently urged their teams on with all the speed possible, as they were good forty five miles from their tavern, and their animals appeared pretty well used up. There was no cow with the outfit, nor had the Benders' cow been seen or heard of from that day to this. As the pursuers came in sight of their game they gave a yell, and charged down upon them. The moment the Benders caught sight of their pursuers, the greatest consternation appeared to seize upon them. John Bender, who was walking by the side of the wagon, ran forward to the lead team, as though to unhitch them, but was evidently recalled by the old man, who handed him out an old-fashioned smooth-bore Yeager rifle. With this weapon he fired a harmless shot at the advancing horsemen, and then drew a navy revolver, and reached his hand into the wagon for another. Before he had time to draw it forth, however, a shot from one of the farmers laid him out lifeless on the prairie, the ball entering his left breast and piercing the heart.

Old man Bender stood up in the wagon, striking down the cover, yelled at his horses in German, and flourished a revolver over his head. The pursuers desired to capture them alive, if possible, but did not like to approach too near to the old man's revolver. As they were going down a roll on the prairie, one of their lead horses fell, and Kate springing out of the wagon, went to the fallen animal, as if to get it up. But instead of raising the fallen beast, she cut loose its mate, and mounting it, was endeavoring to make her escape on its back. At this the old man seemed crazed with anger, and fired his revolver at her. But he did not hit her, however, but the horse, springing forward, caught a leg in the breeching of its fallen mate, and went down and Kate under him. The old man having emptied his revolver, the pursuers charged in on him, and beat him down with their gun barrels, though he and his wife fought like tigers to the last. After they had tied Bender and his wife they got the girl out from under the horse, and found that she had a broken leg from the fall. Dutroit said Kate acted like a very devil. She cursed them, cursed her father and mother, and seemed a red hot vial of wrath.

The party moved over to a "run" and camped for the night. Old Bender refused to say a word in English, but both he and his wife cursed their captors in German. Kate Bender seemed to think their captors knew everything, and while she would not answer questions, she made no concealment of the hellish work that had been carried on at the tavern, and asserted frequently that they had killed over 100 persons. She said she had done most of the throat cutting herself; that John was afraid; that he or the old woman did well enough to knock their victims on the head, but they appeared to be afraid of them after they were knocked down.

When asked why they killed so many (referring to her assertion of having killed 100 persons) she replied that the old people (meaning her parents) liked the money, but she liked to see the blood. She was lying on the ground unbound, her broken limb preventing her escape. One of the men happened to sit down near her, when, quick as thought, she jerked his revolver from his belt and fired at him. The ball missed him, and entered the fleshy part of the thigh of the thigh of a man named Love. Before she could fire again she was shot, one of the balls passing through her head.

The old couple looked on with apparent indifference upon the horrible scene, and when spoken to, would make no reply save to give utterance to maledictions on their pursuers.

The farmers, after a long consultation as to the disposal of their prisoners. A bond of sworn secresy was entered into, and so the old man and his wife were both shot. They made no appeal for mercy, but died cursing. The following morning their effects were divided up among their captors. The bodies were buried on the spot.—Chicago Times.

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: Wholesale Murder