An old couple seized in Nebraska
Dan Congdon tells the Omaha Bee how an old man given lodging at Richland said he had known the Benders, and how Congdon and Sheriff Gregg arrested him and his companion on 22 July near North Bend. Asked his name, the man turned to the woman, who answered ‘McGregor’. With $25,000 in rewards outstanding, the Bee thought the identity all but proved; a week later Oswego called the pair impostors.
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
Omaha Daily Bee · 2 August 1880 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
THE BOSS BUTCHERS. A Chain of Evidence Establishing the Identity of the Dodge County Prisoners.
Old Man Bender Identified by a Man Familiar With His Packing House and Himself.
See moreSee less
Young John With His Wife Children and a Strange Woman,
Passed Through Omaha Last Thursday Morning.
A Description of the Whole Outfit, Now in Iowa.
Some years ago a certain wayside house in a lonely region on Agreese creek, sixteen miles northeast of In- dependence, Kansas, and on the pub- lic road leading from that to Osage, Missouri, was the scene of a series of murders, scarcely equaled in the annals of crime. The house was about 12x16 feet; there were no rooms only as divided by canvass curtains; there was a garret up stairs; there was a small garden and a peach orchard of about three acres near the house—say 100 yards away. There were no cattle, but one cow and two horses. There was no stable or outbuildings on the premises, the horses being picketed out or tied in the wagon road about 200 yards from the house. Such was the home and surroundings of the infamous Bender family, consisting of old John Bender, his wife Kate, and their son John and his wife. It was generally understood in the neighborhood that the Benders' was headquarters for horse thieves and hard characters, and at length suspicions of even worse character were aroused.
In 1873, Dr. York, of Kansas, a brother of State Senator York, mysteriously disappeared while on a business trip through the country, and an investigation of the mystery by the latter resulted in the unearthing of a private burying ground on the Bender place, where a dozen dead bodies, including that of the missing Dr. York, were disinterred. The Benders had fled a few days previously having been alarmed by the threat of one of their visitors to have the house searched, and eluding all search were supposed to have disappeared forever. A few days since it was announced that an aged couple had been arrested by Sheriff Gregg, of Dodge county, on the supposition that they were the iniquitous old John Bender and his wife. They were taken to jail and locked up in separate cells and search begun for the rest of the family, s[a]id to be passing through the state by a d[i]fferent road, and for proof to establish the identity of t[h]e prisoners.
Although the news of the arrest of the Benders was received with considerable incredulity, as num[e]rous persons had been arrested and discharged at intervals for several years, yet a chain of evidence was constructed link by link which now seems to leave no doubt that the inhuman butchers have at last come to the end of their rope, and that the whole outfit will be in the h[a]nds of ju[s]tice [v]ery s[o]on. In addition to the circumstances stated below, a Mr. Hoofman, for the past six years a resident of Fremont, but for two years prior to July 16th 1873, a neighbor of the Bender family, and engaged in heording cattle less than a mile from their house, has indentified the old man as John Bender and got the woman to admit the fact. She however denies that she is Kate Bender and says the latter died in 1876. There are other circumstances pointing to the probability that this is no case of mistaken indenty and that in addition to furthering the ends of justice, somebody will fall heir to about $25,000 the amount of outstanding rewards, $11,000 of which is on old man Bender alone.
Mr. Dan Congdon who was the prime mover and leading actor in the arrest of the alleged John Bender and his wife called at this office Sunday morning, and furnished us the following particulars of the capture which we will give in his own language:
About dark on the night of July 20th an old man and an old woman came to my house at Richland, Colfax county, and asked for lodgings and something to eat. 'If you haven't any supper for us,' said they, 'give us a place to lie down.' I showed them out to the hay-mow. When I opened the barn door the old woman kind of pulled back, as if afraid. I asked her what she was afraid of. She said there might be some trap or hole there. I left them and my neighbor, Wm. Herndon, who lives about 100 yards from the barn, came around shortly and took them home with him. He gave them supper and breakfast next morning.
After supper at Herndon's, the old man said, 'By the way, is there any talk of this Bender murder now?' Herndon said 'No, not much.' The old man said, 'I used to know them Benders; stopped at their house many a time. They killed one man and wife and buried their two children alive.' In saying they, the old man, by a slip of the tongue, said we. Then he went on to describe the canvas wall, from behind which the fatal blow was struck, and how nice Kate used to do the work. Then he talked about the Californian who came there in the evening and asked what smelled so. Kate said it was roast meat. If he had stayed there that night he would have been done for. But he gave them a warning by threatening to have the house searched. If he hadn't threatened they would all have been captured in the house.'
The old man said that he went south with the Benders that night to the railroad, where he and the Benders parted. Next day when I heard this story I started after them and to make a sure thing I went for Sheriff Gregg, of Fremont, knowing he had the sand in him. We lef Fremont at 10 o'clock the night of the 21st. Thinking I'd find them at Rogers' Siding we got off there, searched all around that side track without succers. Took the next train for Schuyler and got there at 3:45 in the morning of the 22d. Hir-d a livery rig of Jim Hughes and got track of the party at old man Dixon's grove. We passed them by there and went on to North Bend. Drove back to Mr. York's. We were going to make the arrest there, but let them walk on agan. Took them up and gave them a r de into North Bend. On the way the old man was cursing the Mormons and pretended he hailed from the Niobrara country. We put our teams in the barn there. They sat a l t le while in front of D lon & Purcell's store and then we walked down the track and they walked down the road to the old ranch, forty rods from town. We marched out on the road and commanded old man Bender to throw up his hands. Sheriff Gregg put irons on him and the old woman. He said he was not old Bender and denied having said anything about the Benders at Richland or ever known them, and said he never was in Kansas in his life. When we asked his name he turned around to his wife and asked 'whats that?' She said 'McGregor' and said she, 'my name is Nancy McGregor.'
We brought them down to Fremont that day, and the next day at Schuyler. I heard there were three more in company with them, supposed to be young John Bender, Kate Bender and a young woman about 22, whose name is unknown. I didn't give that any credit until I went and investigated the matter by secreting myself, four days after the arrest, in the jail where I heard the following conversation between the old man and old woman:
Old Man—Oh Kate!
Three raps on the floor with feet.
Old Man—He's caught again this time. (Meaning John I suppose).
Kate—How do you know he's took? How do you know but he has followed them?
Old Man—That's so! Did that fellow come back that was here this morning? (Meaning the jailor).
Kate—No. I didn't see him since dinner, and the less we have to do with letter writing and lawyers, the better.
Old Man—Do you think he's not taken.
Kate—No, he went south from the railroad the last I seen of him. He did not go west.
Old Man—What are they talking about, Cherry Vale, Montgomery county, Kansas?
Kate—It was not there. I don't know where Montgomery county is in Kansas. Do you!
Old Man—I do. How do you feel? I feel as if I had got to die.
Kate—You feel as if you were going to the slaughter house.
Old Man—Damn the luck! I'll be hanged.
Kate—You had better blame me for being caught.
Old Man—No I don't. Kate, what did he say (meaning the sheriff.) Kate—Why he said we were not married.
Old Man—I wish that letter came from Springfield, Ill.
Kate—It would do you no good as you are detected and he says they will hang you. I will go back to Jacksonville, Ill., when you are hung. If I had stayed in Wisconsin and been buried with my child they would have you but not me.
Old Man—Hell! Hang me and not you? Well, that letter will get me out.
Kate—That letter is no good, you are detected.
Old Man—Not unless you have told them something.
Kate—No, I did not tell them anything.
Old Man—Do you think they will let us go to-morrow when they get that letter?
Kate—No, the reward is too big.
Old Man—What did the sheriff say anyway?
Kate—He said you were solid.
Old Man—In what way.
Kate—That you are Bender.
Old Man—Bender be d—d! I am Alex. McGregor now. The best way is to have the trial here, for it would be a bad job if they took us to Kansas.
Kate—I should say it would.
At this juncture I entered the cell to interview Kate and told her I would start for Kansas the next day and that I was afraid of being mobbed in Kansas City.
Kate—Do you think there is any danger going through Kansas City? I said there was. Kate—I'd like to wait for a letter from Illinois.
Old Man—(to Kate). You are the one at fault for telling so much at Richland the other night.
Kate—No, you gave yourself away. You done all the talking yourself. Old Man—You told something. Kate—I told them nothing; I never told lie in my life.
Old Man—I know you are going back on me, but never mind. You told him you wanted to go to Illinois. You might as well go to Kansas as one is as bad as the other.
Kate—No, I told him I wanted to get a letter from Illinois before starting. Old Man—I feel as if I was going to hang.
Here a conversation took place about the alleged ghost of Dr. St. Louis, who was to have been hung at Wahoo, but who killed himself in the Fremont jail, which his spirit is said to haunt.
On Thursday after getting a meagre description of young John Bender, Kate and the other woman. I started for Omaha. I went to the ferry and the ferryman told me he had seen such an outfit cross at 11 o'clock Thursday, answering all the descriptions except having four or five children. To make sure about the children, I went back to Fremont that night and tried to find Sheriff Gregg but could not find him. I entered the jail and told Bender, I had Kate and John arrested at Omaha and, by the way, I said, to the old man, how many children has this Kate had? The old man said four. Said I to the old man, Kate says that you done all the sleeging in the murders from behind the canvass wall
Old Man—She's a liar she's the one that done it.
I started back to Omaha Friday and crossed to the Bluffs on the transfer but found no traces except that they were seen on Broadway. I went to Neola and found a man there who said he met such an outfit Thursday evening as he was going to the circus at the Bluffs. I went from Neola to Avoca and after informing all the officials there about it. I gave up the search. That ends my fifteen days tramp. My opinion is that they are yet within a radius of 25 miles from Council Bluffs. The description, as near as can be found out, is as follows: An old three spring wagon, not sure whether covered or not. An old gray horse and an old bay, the bay supposed to be on the off side. Two dirty clad women, one of them Kate, about 44, not red headed but with sandy hair. The other can't be described She is of medium size, age about 22. Young John Bender is supposed to have a moutache and light side whiskers When last seen had a cow-boy's hat on. In the wagon were a lot of dirty children, number not known. They are traveling under the name of John McGregor, Maggie McGregor and Mary McGregor. They say they are going to various places, the last they said they were bound for being Central Iowa.
Among the places they are going to are Jacksonville, Ills., Freeport, Ill., Springfield, Ill., McGregor's Landing, Prairie du Chiene, Wis., Springfield, Ill., and sometimes they say York state. They claim they hail from the Niobrara country or Utah and last of all they are Kansas sufferers come away from Northwestern Kansas.