As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · As the Papers Told It

Act Six

The Only Absolutely True Story

July 1891 – June 1907

The stories of how the Benders died multiplied: hanged from the rafters of their own house, hanged by seventeen men on the Verdigris, hanged by a posse of ten. In 1897 a former private secretary to Governor St. John called the lynching story wholly without foundation, and in 1901 Governor Stanley sent to Colorado for a family of four, among them a woman whose husband said she was Kate Bender.

Hanged from their own rafters, says a freighter

A St. Joseph dispatch passes on a story told by Tom Doolittle, an old freighter at Nickerson, Kansas: searchers led by York's brother forced a confession from the old woman, hanged the father, mother and son from their own rafters, shot Kate, and buried all four in a nearby creek bed. The paper says it, ‘if true, settles all question’. Later accounts in this act put the deaths elsewhere.

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Madison Daily Leader · 16 July 1891 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HUNG THE BENDERS

A Queer Story Concerning an Old Sensation Told by a Kansas Man.

See moreSee less

An Old Time Freighter Says the Notorious Family Were Hung to the Rafters of the House,

And That He Helped to Do It—A Bold Robbery Committed on a Chicago Street Car.

ST. JOSEPH, MO., July 16.—K. B. Randolph, an attorney of this city, who has just returned from Nickerson, Kan., says that he there made the acquaintance of Tom Doolittle, an old time freighter, who told him a story of the famous Bender family, which, if true, settles all question as to the whereabouts of the family of murderers. Doolittle says after the murder of York a band of searchers, headed by the murdered man's brother, went to the Bender house and extorted a confession from the old woman. They then quietly proceeded to hang the old man Bender, his wife and son to the rafters of the house. During this proceeding Kate Bender uttered some protests and was shot to death. After the family had been dispatched York's avengers took their bodies to an old creek bed some yards distant from the house and buried them. The attention of a family living on an adjoining ranch was attracted to the Bender place some days after by a starving calf, and their absence was first made known to the public.

See the clipping

A convict's statement: they escaped to Texas

Captain W. H. Ward, once private secretary to Governor St. John, tells the Journal the lynching story is ‘wholly without foundation’. He trusts an 1879 statement by Sam Merrick, a Michigan convict, who said he met Kate, John and the old woman in Texas in 1873, going by the name Gardner, and visited their camp as late as 1876. Labette county declined to pay to follow it up.

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 31 January 1897 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

THE BENDER FAMILY.

SUPPOSITION THEY WERE LYNCHED IS ERRONEOUS.

See moreSee less

THE OFFICIAL INVESTIGATION.

SHOWS THE MEMBERS OF THE FAMILY ESCAPED TO TEXAS.

A Convict of the Michigan State Penitentiary Knew Them Well—He Makes a Statement—Tells of Their Life on the Frontiers.

To begin with, you would like to know the best way to go to the place where I last saw the Benders. If I were going there I should go on the cars to Denison, Tex. Then I would go by saddle horse, arms and outfit to camp out, to Henrietta, Clay county, Tex., which is about 110 miles west, settled all the way. On the way would stop at Red River station, to make inquiries for Tom Lawrence, Del Short or Dugan and others. At Henrietta find Dan Koozer, a brother of Ed Koozer, who is with them. If I didn't find where they were I would go to Domes' ranch, about 120 miles a little south of west. The place where they were camped when I saw them last is sixty-five to seventy miles from there, southwest in the mountains and at the head of Pecos river, no road or trail to it, but it is not likely they are there now. I think they have either gone farther south on the Stake plains or in the Gaudalupe mountains, or have gone with the Kickapoos, southwest of Saltello, Old Mexico.—Extract from the statement of Sam Merrick, a Michigan convict, regarding the Bender family.

"The prevailing impression that the members of the Bender family, the noted murderous pioneers of Labette county, Kas., were lynched is wholly without foundation," said Captain W. H. Ward yesterday. Captain Ward was private secretary to Governor St. John, of Kansas, during the administration of the latter from 1879 to 1883. At that time the efforts to trace the Benders were still active, and much information regarding them passed through the hands of Captain Ward. He is now a resident of Kansas City, Kas.

"Several years ago," said Captain Ward, "a Chicago paper printed an article, purporting to be a letter from Kansas City, in which the writer claimed to have seen and talked with a dying man who had confessed to complicity in the lynching of the Bender family. The writer of the article failed to reveal his own identity, or that of the 'dying man' who had told the story. The dates and facts mentioned were so erroneous as to show that the story was the product of a faulty memory and a vivid imagination, but from its publication the opinion seemed to become general that the lynching of the Benders was an actual fact. The story was absolutely unfounded, and the Benders escaped. Probably some of the members of the family are still alive."

The facts in the matter, as they appeared from the investigation made by the Kansas state officials, seem to show conclusively that the lynching story was a myth. It was about April 4 or 5, 1873, that a wagon, team and dog were found abandoned in a ravine back of the little town of Thayer, Neosho county, Kas. An account of this was published in the Thayer Headlight at the time. This was in the days when that territory was on the frontier, and the finding of the team was one of the strange happenings which not infrequently occurred on the border of civilization. It created considerable comment, but it was not until about thirty days later that the real excitement occurred.

On May 3, 1873, a posse searching for Dr. York, who had been missing for several weeks, came to the Bender residence, and found it abandoned. In the stable was tied a calf which had been left behind and which had been starved to death. Everything indicated that the place had been without occupants for a month or more. The Benders' place had been a sort of half-way house and its unexpected desertion created surprise. About the place were discovered several sunken mounds resembling new made graves, and the members of the posse, on opening one of them, discovered in it the body of Dr. York. Seven or eight more of these mounds were opened and in each a body was found, two bodies being taken from one of the mounds. Then the mysterious abandonment of the team in the ravine near Thayer was recalled and persons who knew the Benders and their team went to Thayer to investigate. They identified the horses and dog as having been the property of the Benders.

Senator A. M. York, a brother of Dr. York, states that he last saw the Benders on April 3, 1873. It is supposed they left their Labette county home the following day, and that the team was abandoned the night of April 4, or the morning of April 5. The station agent of the old Leavenworth, Lawrence & Galveston railroad (now the Southern Kansas branch of the Santa Fe) at Thayer, remembered, and his records bore out his recollection, that four persons, the descriptions of whom answered to that of the Benders, had purchased tickets at his office April 5, from Thayer to Humboldt, Kas. Here the absolute trace of the Benders was lost. It is supposed that they went on the Leavenworth, Lawrence & Galveston to Chanute or Humboldt, where they could have made close connections with the south bound train of the Missouri, Kansas & Texas, for the frontiers of the Indian Territory, which was then populated largely with criminals and desperate characters, fugitives from justice.

The investigation of the disappearance of the Bender family conducted during the administration of Governor St. John, and the information resulting therefrom, all of which passed through the hands of Captain Ward, is exceedingly interesting. The most important feature was in the statement of Sam Merrick, a convict confined in the Michigan state penitentiary at Detroit. The statement is corroborated by all the other evidence which could be secured by the officers. It conclusively removes the theory that the Benders were lynched. In substance Merrick's statement follows:

"In 1872 I was with Lee Dyer's herd of cattle at the old Spark ranch, on the Little Wichita river, about four miles from the mouth of it, in Clay county, Tex. Missouri Bill had charge of the herd at that time. The house was one of those double log houses built before the Indians drove the people out in 1868. We stayed in one end of it. In the other was a family by the name of Slimp. They used to talk about their affairs to me. They said their sister would come down in the fall or winter with their cousins, the Benders, from Labette county, Kas. Floyd, their second son, said their mother and old Mrs. Bender were cousins. Their mother was dead. I went to the Arkansas river in September. In 1873 I guided Dan Waggoner's herd to the Big Wichita. In the spring of 1873 I passed near Slimp's place and stopped there to get a bridle that belonged to me. Their sister had come a little while before on the cars to the end of the Missouri, Kansas & Texas, and then hired a conveyance from Sherman, Tex., to Slimp's. The Benders had come three days before with a team. I was made acquainted with the old woman and John and Kate. They went by the name of Gardner. Kate was called Jennie Gardner. The old man and Slimp and another man, who came with them, were away looking for some safe place to go, somewhere on the head of the Little Wichita, they said. John went by the name of Bill. The old woman talked a little 'Dutchy,' but John and Kate did not. In coming through the nation they all wore men's clothes.

"They crossed the Arkansas river at the Old Creek agency, passed through Stonewal, Chickasaw Nation, and crossed Red river at Sobe Leaves, following a route that was not traveled much. While I was at Slimp's Frank McPherson, brother to Missouri Bill, who had been a conductor on the railroad between Sedalia and Parsons, killed a man, at Parsons I believe, at any rate it was a Dutchman, a restaurant keeper, and he got away from the officers by jumping through the car window, arrived. He stayed at Missouri Bill's at Red River station. Before I left that country in March the Benders had moved about thirty-five miles farther west onto Wanderer's creek, west of the Pecos river. I did not come back until the winter of 1874. I stayed at Missouri Bill's. Frank McPherson had gone to the Bender camp, which had moved to Prairie Dog canon, about twenty miles still farther west. While I was there a dectective named Sullivan came to Henrietta in search of the Benders. John Bender went into town to see him, and came back and said he was not afraid of that fellow, he was too stylish, but there might be others with him. I went South and came back through the Staked Plains in 1876. I went over to the Benders' camp, which was sixty-five or seventy miles from the nearest whites. Kate complained of their poverty and John said they would always be worth $1,000 apiece. (The amount of the reward offered for each of them.) Kate dressed like a man most of the time. They thought they would leave in the winter for some other place, for they were afraid the buffalo hunters might run across them. They wanted to go North, but the Apaches said they would find a good place for them in the Guadalupe mountains. The Kickapoos wanted them to go to Old Mexico. They said they would go either to the Gaudalupe mountains or some other place on the Staked Plains. I told them of a good place at the head of the Colorado river of Texas. It is a place a person might pass close to and not know it was there. I was there with some Indians. I left there to come North and have not seen them since that time. I have been a prisoner since 1877.

"The Slimps were living between McKinney and Pilot Point, Tex. They might know where they are, but if a stranger should make any inquiry of them, or of any of the others, they would not find out anything, and they would send word to the Benders if they know where they are, which is more than likely, and a man's life would not be worth more than a cartridge, for he would be killed."

This statement of Merrick was made in the fall of 1879. It was submitted to the county authorities of Labette county, but they felt that so much money had already been expended in an effort to capture the Benders that they could not afford to bear the expense of following up the clue. Merrick has since been released from prison and his whereabouts are unknown. The detective, Sullivan, of whom he speaks, had called on Senator York, a brother of Dr. York, one of the victims of the Benders, before he had gone to Henrietta, where Merrick knew of him. His statement regarding Frank McPherson is substantially correct, and his description of the Benders tallies exactly with that given by those who knew them well. Captain Ward states that he often stopped at the Benders' house while they were in Labette county. He placed implicit confidence in Merrick's statement, and ridicules the theory that the Benders were lynched.

See the clipping

The Bender farm, twenty-four years on

An Oswego Independent reporter finds the old Bender farm overgrown with weeds and cockle burs, and hears that people nearby are ‘pretty well satisfied’ about what became of the family. A letter from Jesse McDaniel, who helped dig up the bodies in 1873, recalls that the Benders' neighbor Rudolph Brockman, now on trial for killing his daughter, was hoisted by a rope three times and still denied knowing anything.

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

The Topeka State Journal · 16 February 1897 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

FARM ACCURSED.

Crops Wont Grow on the Old Bender Place.

See moreSee less

No One Can Be Found Who Will Stay There.

NEW BLOODY CHAPTER

In the History of a Neighborhood of Murderers.

Brockman Who Murdered His Child, Lived Next the Benders

Oswego, Feb. 16.—The Independent sent a reporter to the old Bender farm the past week who describes the historic spot as it is today, nearly 24 years after the York murder:

Nine and one-half miles northeast of Cherryvale, in Osage township, this county, section 13, you strike the northwest quarter of the Bender farm. Three large mounds on the south and east are known as the Bender mounds.

Farms surrounding it are well tilled, improved and abound with orchards and vines—the curse of human blood rests upon the Bender farm—it is a mass of cockle burs, weeds and matted grass. Not but the land is not as rich and fertile as the land adjoining, but the parties who have owned, rented and farmed it for 20 years past, seem to have operated it in a disheartened and meaningless way. A small strip of corn had been planted along the line where the bodies were found—the stalks looked like popcorn on other farms, and were scarce higher than the enormous cockle burs, which seem more than usually laden.

When the reporter made the trip through the tangled mass and emerged into the road he presented much the same appearance of a colt which has been running loose in a corn field all winter. While engaged in disengaging himself from the friendly burs, the reporter asked something about the history of the township in a criminal way and was astonished to learn that in a strip of land embracing that upon which he stood, 2½ miles north and south and 1½ miles east and west, 13 violent deaths had occurred. There were the nine Bender murders; an old man by the name of Hallifield, a storekeeper at Mortimer, who shot and killed his young wife and himself—jealousy; in 1887, Wes Ratcliff, 19, a farmer's son, suicided by shooting, for reason he had shot his father's mule; and the killing eight years ago of John Geary in self-defense by a brother of Ben Parks, who married Geary's daughter against his will. Then there was the Forest-Buckles transaction of 12 years ago. After an altercation with Forest one night, Buckles fled the county that night without hat or coat. Forest was arrested for murder, the people were greatly excited, wanted to lynch somebody and somebody did get strung up, but escaped with his life. Buckles was still missing, and staid missing a number of months, and the case was continued from term to term and he eventually turned up sound. The Bender farm is now owned by Margaret Keefe but was previously the property of Silas Yeagle—it pays no dividend, and the interest on the mortgage is steadily increasing, as if nine murders were not enough to damn it and render it forever cursed, a Kansas mortgage—has fastened upon it, and hot winds blight the corn, the rust strikes the oats, and the voracious little black devils of chinch bugs destroy the wheat.

People in the immediate locality of the famous Bender farm are pretty well satisfied as to what disposition was made of the Benders. So much so, that when effort has been made to follow various clues in recent years, men of standing and property holders have discouraged the movement.

Jesse McDaniel, late of Labette county, now of Fall River, writes to the Independent of the crime. He says:

I notice in your columns that Rudolph Brockman is now on trial for the murder of his daughter, Mary, under aggravating circumstances. From the fact that his farm in Osage township joins on the west the notorious Bender farm, and from the part he played in the excitement following the flight of this murderous family, whose crimes shocked the whole country at the time, it brings to mind recollections of the past which may be of interest to the rising generation and to those who have located within the confines of the south tier of counties.

In the spring of 1873 (I cannot give the exact date) I was in Independence on Wednesday, and excitement was high—one Dr. York, brother of State Senator York (at that time) was missing, and men were scouring the country in search of him. He had left Ft. Scott and was traced to within, I think, one and a half miles of the Bender place on the previous Thursday. There all trace was lost and he disappeared completely. I went with others to the place where he was last seen and the search was renewed. We were at the Bender farm frequently. Saw Kate Bender and was all over the farm. As we abandoned the search and before dispersing to our several homes, quite a number of su stopped at the house that evening. Kate told us if we would come the next day she would throw herself in a clairvoyant state and tell us where Dr. York was, if dead. Not having faith in that kind of business, did not go. On the following morning, Friday, we went to Thayer, Kan., and saw a team standing some distance from the L. L. & G. railroad, one mile south of the city, close to a pond, which attracted our attention as being something unusual; no one with it, or no cover on the wagon. On the next morning we again went to Thayer for the early morning train, and saw the team still there. A cold rain had set in. I noticed the team were eating the wagon box. I went to the nearest house and inquired as to the team and was told by the woman at the house (now Mrs. Cody of Oswego, I think) that it was there Friday morning when she got up and no one had been near it since. We reported it to Ed Malburn, a liveryman at Thayer, and asked him for the sake of humane treatment, to get the team and care for it, which he did that afternoon.

Three weeks from the following Thursday was at Independence when a man from the Bender neighborhood came in and reported the Benders gone and that there were dead bodies in the house or cellar, as the stench was such when he opened the door that he could not enter. To say that people became excited, does not express it. A crowd started for the scene at once. Owing to pressing business I did not get there until the next day. The house was examined from top to bottom. The stench came from the cellar. It was dug out to fresh earth on the sides. No bodies were found, but as the stench arose from decomposed human blood, it was an evident fact that murder had been committed. The house was moved from its foundation, but no clue was discovered to the burial place of the bodies.

In the evening a depression was found the size of a grave in the lately plowed and harrowed ground south of the house. At this place the body of Dr. York was found. Four bodies were taken out when we arrived, and I helped to take out the remaining five, four grown men and one little girl about 4 years old. One of the dead men was the father of the little girl. He had lived a few miles west of Independence, and his wife having died, started with four horses and his little girl to return to Indiana to his people. The sight still haunts me. In a hole about four feet in diameter, nearly round, and about four feet deep, were father and child. The father was doubled up in order to get him in the middle of the hole and the little child placed on top of him. She had on a little hood, from which her flaxen curls were seen, mittens were on her hands which were pressed over her face as though to keep the dirt out of her eyes—that child was buried alive.

From the construction of the house you will understand how these murders were supposed to have been committed—two rooms were down stairs, one living room, and one in which they kept some refreshments, such as oysters, crackers, etc. The partition was studding, covered with heavy ducking. A wooden bench was across the room at that point. Any one sitting down on the bench would naturally lean his head against the partition. A blow from a hammer in the hands of a person behind the partition crushed the skull of the victim. (A hammer was found whose end fitted the indentations in their skulls.) After their throats were cut the bodies were dumped into the cellar until such time as they could be buried in secret, in the darkness of night.

After the bodies were disinterred and identified, finding that the victims had property in the shape of two wagons and seven horses, it was the conclusion of all that the Benders had help from the outside, as far as disposing of the stock was concerned. Upon inquiry it was found that the Benders had but one neighbor with whom they had social intercourse—one Dolph Brockman. He was visited by a committee, but denied strenuously any guilty knowledge of the Benders. A rope was placed about his neck and he was elevated by willing hands. He was let down and still denied knowing anything. The third time he was hoisted and again let down. And now it is this same Brockman, a quarter of a century later, accused of one of the foulest crimes ever committed by man—the murder of his own flesh and blood under circumstances most damning and foul.

See the clipping

A Kansas official's lynching story, secondhand

Reprinted from the Chicago Chronicle: an unnamed Kansan, ‘a man who has held high political office in the state’, repeats what an old man who said he led the party told him. Seventeen men roped the family at the farm, searched it, then hanged all four by the Verdigris river at night and buried them in the sand. The headline calls it the ‘Only Absolutely True’ story.

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Topeka State Journal · 28 April 1897 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

LYNCHING OF THE BENDERS. The "Only Absolutely True"

Story Published.

See moreSee less

Captured and Slain by Friends of Dr. Yorke.

Seventeen Vigilantes Use Lassoes to Catch Them.

YELLOWHAIREDCHILD Found in the Cellar, Arouses Cowboy Wrath. Story Related in Chicago by a Kansas Man.

[From the Chicago Chronicle, April 26.]

When the murderous Bender family disappeared from their Kansas farm shortly after their final murder—that of Dr. Yorke—it was reported that they had escaped, it was hinted that they had been lynched and some frontier folk submitted the theory that possibly they had committed suicide. But the real story of their dropping out of sight has never been known until within the past week. One of the best known men in Kansas, a man who has held high political office in the state and is known and trusted the length and breadth of it, stopped at one of the principal hotels in the city a few days ago. A writer for the Chronicle, knowing him to have been personally familiar with the facts surrounding the mystery of the disappearance of the Benders,hunt- ed him up and asked him about the matter.

'Why do you want to rake up that old affair?" he asked.

"Because you know and I know that the true story of it has never been told," was the reply. "And I know that you have the real facts in your pos- session. Look at this letter. You were right there in the county when they went away, but of course you knew nothing of their disappearance except from what you learned afterward." "Of course," said the Kansan imper- turbably. "Come up to my room." The two repaired to the Kansan's room and the story was soon told.

"I know all about it, as do a dozen men yet living in my state, and I sup- pose you might as well have it as it actually happened. I got the bottom facts from an old fellow living on the Ninnescat river last fall and it made a deep impression on me. You know I was well acquainted with Dr. Yorke and his brother. Doc was the last man the Benders killed. His brother, you may recollect, was the state sena- tor who sprung the $7,000 bribery sen- sation in Kansas when Anthony and Pomeroy were running for senator. Well, when Yorke was missed the neighbors and some friends of the missing man decided that there was reason to pay a visit to that farm. This was what the old man told me, you understand. He said there were seventeen of the party and not a rifle or a shotgun in the crowd. There were four cowboys who were as handy with a rope—a lasso, you know—as any men on the range, and a few had navy sixes strapped on.

"The searchers made up their minds to go over there and rope the outfit and make a search of the house, the cellar, barn, yard and all about the house. If they found murder there the Benders were to swing. If mistaken, they intended to present their regrets and apologies. Well, they drove up to the house and the women were there. The old woman was inside and Kate was at the wood pile chopping wood like a man. A big, strapping hell-cat of a woman she was. John was just leading a horse to a watering trough, and the old man was not in sight then. The seventeen were in the yard and ready for business quicker than snakes. Three of the boys looked after the teams and fourteen rushed in on the family. "Jim—well, one of the cow punchers, roped John around the neck before John knew what had happened. The horse he was leading broke loose as the man's feet went into the air, and some of the boys yelled: 'Whoa, there! whoa, there!' That brought the old man out of the barn and another of the boys roped him by one of his legs as he stepped out and stretched him on a manure heap like a steer. Meanwhile a couple of the boys had covered the old woman with six-shooters and tied her hands and feet with a rope taken along. She was as sullen as a Sioux squaw, and looked like one a little bit, too.

"Three of the boys had made a rush for Kate, but she backed up against the wood pile, swung her ax and yelled, 'Come on, you cowards.' The boys could have picked her off with their guns, but they didn't want to kill her before an investigation. But they held her to the wood pile with their revolvers until a couple of cowboys came up. One of the ropers made a swing and caught her ax and jerked it out of her hand as neatly as anything you ever saw. The other rope caught one of her arms as the ax was snatched away, and Kate came tumbling over in a lot of fresh cut chips and stove wood. She was cursing terribly all the time. As soon as the boys had her tied they took something off a clothes line and stopped her howling. When they got the family all tied and Kate gagged the old man explained to them that this was a little informal call, as the callers were looking for a friend.

"Three of the boys guarded the outfit and the rest commenced to search. Then old man, the leader, said: 'God above, but it was awful. The half has never been told of that slaughterhouse. Bones everywhere, and one or two decaying corpses. And Doc Yorke all right; I'll swear to that. And when we came to a little child's skull, with yellow hair like cornsilk streaming from it, the boys gave a yell and we all ran out to where those four fiends lay roped. Two of the cowboys begged me—I was the leader—to let them burn the whole Bender outfit after they had tied them to wagon wheels. I never saw a man act so insanely as that cow puncher they called Coyote Billy. I'll swear they had to take his six-shooter off him, and I hope I may never see another sun if he didn't get down on his knees and beg me to have those devils burned. He was crying, that cowboy was, and he stirred the crowd up like a prairie fire.

"'But I told them all that only a dog's death would do for that gang. No wasting of honest fuel. Hang them one by one and let each see the other die. The old man weakened some and he swore John did all the killing and that he was afraid John would kill him if he told anything. The old woman was sullen and wouldn't say a word. John asserted the old man put him up to it all and Kate sat up against a log in the yard gagged and tied, her eyes snapping like a wild cat's. We loaded them into the wagons late in the afternoon and started for the Verdigris river. It is a little stream that runs through the country between Cherryvale and Independence. It had been a dry summer and the river, or what you would call a creek in the east, was nearly dry. Here and there in the river bed were little pools of water with plenty of dry spaces along the river bed. We had brought some shovels along and we brought the Benders out and sat them on the bank of the river until the moon came out.

LYNCHING THE BENDERS.

"'The moon came out and flickered down through the cottonwoods, and I remember now I heard a whippoorwill in the brush somewhere. The boys dug them a nice, spacious grave there in the sand, and the Benders watched them while they shoveled the stuff away. It was hard work, and the boys made a sort of trench of it, and they dug it pretty deep. Along about 12 o'clock we hanged the old man. We put a lasso around his neck and swung one end of it over a cottonwood limb, and then put him on his feet in the back of a wagon and eased the wagon along until he fell off the back of it—had the tail gate down, you know. His neck wasn't broken by the fall, as the boys were anxious to give him plenty of time. Then we strung the old woman up in the same way, let her teeter around for about fifteen minutes and brought her down. The old man and the old woman died pretty hard.

"'Then we trussed up Kate, still gagged, and the she-devil never flinched. We had been quite a little while doing this, and the coyote cowboy suggested that we just dump John tied into the grave with the others and cover him up gradually. Most of the boys were well pleased with this idea, and the cowboy, when I vetoed it, went along by the back of the wagon and eased the last Bender down.

In about two seconds he cut the rope with his knife and hollered, "He's dead, boys." So we took them all down to the Verdigris and dumped them into the trench. They were all tied hand and foot. I never was so cussed certain whether John's neck was chafed any by the rope or not, and I reckon he was about 99 per cent alive when they shoveled the sand in on him, but when I think of that young one with the hair like corn-silk I don't lose any sleep over John. The rains in the next two days washed down and covered the tracks made by the men on the river bed.' " 'Talk about the Benders getting away. It's a lie, and a black one. Their bones are rotting under the sands of the Verdigris, and I am one of a score that know it. Talk about Leroy T. Dick, that Kansas sheriff, going to Kansas City and identifying a job lot of bogus Benders! How about some of the old residenters in that neck of woods who knew the Benders? Leroy Dick knew the real Benders. How about Leroy's father, Billy Dick, didn't he live in that section? Mind you, I ain't saying a word against anyone. I helped lynch that crowd, but I didn't recognize anyone in the crowd except two of the cowboys. They've both gone over the divide since; one by the whisky, the other by the pistol route. But the Benders are rotting under those Kansas sands, and if anyone tells you they got away he's been "locoed;" he's crazy.' That's the way the old man told me," said the Kansan, as he lighted a fresh cigar.

See the clipping

A Colorado rancher says he married Kate

Frank Ayres, a ranchman near Fort Collins, Colorado, says the woman he married, who he claims drugged him and left him on a railroad track, is Kate Bender. Three men from Cherryvale swear that her family there are the Benders, while allowing ‘some possibility that we may be in error’. Governor Stanley issues a requisition and sends a Labette county deputy sheriff to Colorado.

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Topeka State Journal · 23 July 1901 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

GET THE BENDERS

Requisition For Notorious Kansas Murderers Issued.

See moreSee less

Have Been Identified Near Fort Collins, Colorado.

OFFICER ON THE WAY.

Will Bring the Bloody Family Back to Kansas.

Have a Record of at Least Eight Murders.

DECOYED TRAVELERS.

Were Killed While at Table in Farm House.

Crimes Committed 28 Years Ago and Family Disappeared.

Frank Ayers, Husband of Kate Bender, the Informant.

A requisition has been issued from the governor's office on the governor of Colorado for the notorious Bender family.

The complaint is made by Frank Ayres, a ranchman living near Ft. Colline, Colorado, who claims that he was married to a woman whom he now thinks is Kate Bender. He claims that the woman gave him "knock out drops" some time last February in hopes of killing him. To avoid suspicion he was carried in an unconscious condition to a nearby railroad track and left on the rails to be killed by passing trains. He was found by friends and rescued. He suspicioned his wife and began working up the case against her. He found her family living near Ft. Collins and he had E. M. Dock, V. A. Monyhan and T. B. Smith from Cherryvale, Labette county, Kansas, go to Ft. Collins and identify the family there as John Bender, alias Chas. Read, Kate Bender, alias Mrs. Chas. Read, John Bender, Jr., alias William Baker, Kate Bender, Jr., alias May Grant, alias May Ayres.

Governor Stanley placed the requisition in the hands of E. L. Barton, a deputy sheriff from Labette county, on Saturday, and he left at once for Colorado.

The supposed Benders have been identified by several persons who knew them 28 years ago in Kansas. Ayres claims that he was married to the Bender woman for 14 months prior to the attempt to poison him.

The following exhibits accompany the application for a requisition:

"We, the undersigned, E. M. Dock, V. A. Monyhan and T. B. Smith, each being duly sworn doth depose and say: That we have been residents of the state of Kansas and in and about the city of Cherryvale and Osage township, in the state of Kansas more than 30 years and that we have recently gone to Ft. Collins, Larimer county, Colorado, and other points in said state and have seen recently the four persons supposed to comprise and be the 'Benders' and have been made familiar with the history of the supposed family of 'Benders' so far as known and obtainable and from our remembrance of said family and the history thereof we are now convinced that they are the persons wanted in this county for a series of crimes and murders committed in this county some 28 years ago.

"We do further swear that we were neighbors and lived in the vicinity in which the 'Benders' lived, in this county and were acquainted with the 'Benders' during their residence in said county at said time; that from our acquaintance and judgment at this time and the history of the suspects we could not now be more certain of the identity than we are at this time, and we are convinced that they are the 'Benders' in our own minds. However there is some possibility that we may be in error of judgment at this time and we do not believe that it is possible for anyone to be conscientiously more certain than we now are from the limited opportunity and observation that we have had of said parties and we further believe that if said parties could be further observed and better opportunities afforded such as could be had and if the parties were in custody that the question of identity could be settled by us and other parties who knew them at that time in a very short space of time, and we further believe that the result would be their complete and satisfactory identification as the 'Bender' family and the parties who committed the crimes as above stated."

E. M. DOCK, V. A. MONYHAN, T. B. SMITH.

M. E. Sparks also visited Ft. Collins and makes a short affidavit to the effect that the women he saw in Colorado are the notorious "Bender" women. Frank Ayres makes affidavit to the killing of William York on the 25th of April, 1873, supposedly by the "Benders."

B. F. Deinst makes the following affidavit which accompanied the application for the requisition:

"B. F. Deinst of lawful age being first duly sworn deposes and says, I was well acquainted with John Bender, Sr., Kate Bender, Sr., John Bender, Jr., and Kate Bender, Jr., who lived in Labette county, Kansas, from the winter of 1870 to some time in the latter part of April, 1873. They moved to Labette county, Kansas, in the winter of 1870 and located on section No. 13, * * * and built a house thereon and cultivated a part of the land. I was well acquainted with the premises during that time and know that they had the exclusive control of it from the time they moved there in 1870 until they left in 1873. During the time they lived there a number of persons were missing and traced to that neighborhood, and at the time it was believed that they were murdered by someone. Finally, some time in April, 1873, one William H. York was missing and traced to the neighborhood of the Bender farm where he was last seen in his lifetime. A determined search was made for him and earnest inquiries were made at the Bender farm for him, and immediately thereafter the said John Bender, sr., Kate Bender, sr., John Bender, jr., and Kate Bender, jr., left their home and went to parts of the country unknown, without any cause except they believed they were suspected of being the murderers of said William H. York; and after they left were not heard of or found, although diligent search and inquiry was made for them at the time. When they left, they left some stock which had broken out and was at large, and a calf which apparently had starved to death as it was almost eaten up by hogs, also a team of horses at Thayer, where it was reported that they had taken a north-bound train. They also left some household goods and grain. After they had left, and on about the 6th or 7th of May, 1873, in company with a number of others I helped to dig up a number of dead bodies upon the farm on which the Benders had resided. The graves were from four to ten rods south and southeast of the house, the nearest one to the house being the one in which we found the body of William H. York. The marks of the graves were hidden by the ground being frequently plowed over and the subsoil removed or hidden. We found one body which was identified as the body of York. The only clothes we found upon the body of York was an undershirt, and it was found in the grave face down. On the head of the body of said William H. York was a dent or wound which was a smashed or broken place in the skull, and which said wound was the cause of his death. I was present at the coroner's inquest and heard the evidence of one E. York, and know the body which he testified was the body of Wm. H. York was the same body we had dug up near the Bender house, as hereinbefore set out.

B. F. DIENST."

At the time of the murder the state of Kansas offered a reward of $500 apiece for the "conviction of the murderers of York." The reward has been outlawed, but Governor Stanley says that if the "Benders" are convicted of the crime he will pay the reward.

See the clipping

The governor doubts the lynching stories

Governor Stanley asks why, if the Benders were killed and buried in the Verdigris, nobody has claimed the $500 that Labette county has long offered for proof of their death, and says they bought tickets at Thayer for Humboldt. An Atchison dispatch printed with it recalls two men who told an earlier governor, George W. Glick, in confidence that a posse of ten had hanged them.

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

The Butler Weekly Times · 1 August 1901 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THINKS THE BENDERS ESCAPED.

Governor Stanley Interested in New Clews Regarding Fugitives.

See moreSee less

Topeka, Kan., July 29.—Governor Stanley has come to the conclusion that the members of the notorious Bender family of Labette are not all dead and he is prepared to assist officials who are searching for them. The governor does not believe that the Benders were overtaken by a posse of citizens just over the border in the Indian territory and killed, according to the popular version of the affair. He said to-day:

"If the people who claim to know and be able to prove that the Benders were killed shortly after their flight from Labette county and buried in the bed of the Verdigris river are telling the truth why haven't they come forward and claimed the reward of $500 which the Labette county authorities have kept standing for years for proof of the death of the Benders? I do not believe the stories of deathbed confessions and such that the newspapers have been printing. It has been found that the Benders bought tickets at Thayer, ten miles from their farm, for Humboldt at least three days before their flight was discovered They were probably 1,000 miles from Labette county before the posse which afterward claimed to have killed them left the scene of their murders."

Atchison, Kan., July 29—When George W. Glick was governor of Kansas the Benders were "discovered," and he was asked to issue a requisition and offer a reward. While the matter was under discussion, two men from the southwestern part of the state called on him and said, in confidence: "We know that the Benders were hanged two days after the discovery of Dr. York's body. A posse of ten men pursued the Benders, and hanged them. We know it; we will not admit that we witnessed the hanging, but we know that they were hanged." The men were prominent and reliable, and they convinced the governor that the Benders were where they belonged. As a result, the requisition was not issued.

See the clipping

A Kansas weekly doubts the Colorado Benders

The Goodland Republic calls the naming of the Bakers of Fort Collins as the Benders ‘hardly probable’ after 28 years, and answers the governor's point about the unclaimed reward: whoever claimed it would have to answer for the killings. The editorial dates Dr. York's murder to 1872, but a Parsons dispatch of May 1873 already reports his body found.

The Goodland Republic · Goodland, Kan.

The Goodland Republic · 2 August 1901 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE CASE OF THE BENDERS.

The identification of the Bakers, of Fort Collins, Col., as the notorious Bender family, of Labette county, Kan., is hardly probable after a lapse of 28 years. Conflicting reports have been many as to what became of the Bender family. The rewards for their capture have been claimed several times but the suspects were never identified as the Benders, and consequently the rewards were never paid. One story has it that when the Benders attempted to escape after the murder of Dr. York in 1872, they were overtaken by a posse and the whole family killed.

See moreSee less

Gov. Stanley, in issung the requisition on the governor of Colorado for the Bakers, thinks that the family were not killed or the $500 reward offered by Labette county would have been claimed at the time. But who would claim the reward and then stand for the murder of the innocent children of the family? But the mystery will undoubtedly never be solved. It marks a dark leaf in Kansas history—fiendish murder on one side and, perhaps, relentless revenge on the other.

See the clipping

A York brother tells what he saw

Julius H. York of St. Louis, brother of the last victim, was in the party that dug up the doctor's body. He says the family left their team at Walnut and took a train, calls the stories of their killing in Indian Territory ‘all false’, and is certain he once saw Kate on a Chicago street car. He dates the journey to March 1875; the May 1873 dispatches show it was 1873.

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 11 days earlier.

Wrong

The St. Louis Republic · 1 September 1901 · page 39 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

RELATIVE OF A BENDER VICTIM REVIEWS OLD CRIME.

WRITTEN FOR THE SUNDAY REPUBLIC.

See moreSee less

Although it is a fact generally settled in the public mind that the infamous quartet of murderers, the Bender family, have been tracked down, one of the family is occasionally "discovered" living under an assumed name in some part of the country. The latest report of this kind is the recent alleged discovery of Kate Bender in California, where she is supposed to have been seen and recognized by a man who knew her in Kansas.

Since this reported discovery of Kate Bender the fact has come to light that there is living at the present time in St. Louis a brother of Doctor York, the last victim of the Benders, and the man whose murder led to their flight and to the facts concerning the series of cruel murders they committed.

This man is Julius H. York, a railroad emigrant agent, of No. 3833 Russell avenue. Mr. York recalls all of the details in connection with the brutal murder of his brother and of the subsequent discovery of his dead body, which was buried in the Bender garden. He himself was a member of the posse which pursued the family. When seen at his home recently Mr. York consented to tell the story of the Benders and of their last murder, that of his brother.

Doctor W. A. York Began His Fatal Journey in March, 1875.

"It was in the month of March, 1875, that my brother, Doctor W. A. York, left his home in Fort Scott, Kas., to go to the home of his parents in Independence," said Mr. York. "He traveled on horseback and was mounted on one of the finest animals that was ever brought into the State of Kansas. The horse was one which was ridden by him during the four years of his service as surgeon in the army. It was a fine animal, and in those days, when good horses commanded a high price, was worth quite a figure. When my brother left his house he gave his wife some money, together with his gold watch, as he did not feel altogether safe with the valuables on his person.

"About three weeks before my brother commenced his journey one of his neighbors in Fort Scott had borrowed his wagon, and, together with his little daughter, had gone on a trip the route of which had taken them in the same direction which he intended to take in his journey to Independence. The man and his daughter had been gone some two or three weeks, and as nothing had been heard from them since their departure their absence was causing much comment. As my brother rode away he remarked that he feared his neighbor had met with foul play, and that he intended to make inquiry about him along the road.

"With that remark he rode away. Some three weeks passed before our family began to grow suspicious regarding his unexplained absence. His wife thought that he had arrived at Independence, and our family supposed that he had not yet left his home at Fort Scott. Letters were finally exchanged, however, and his mysterious disappearance at once became known. Search was instituted to ascertain his whereabouts. A party composed of my two brothers, Edward and Colonel A. M. York; myself and quite a number of others, went to Fort Scott and took up the route which my brother had taken. We followed him until we got within fifteen miles of Independence, when we could find no further trace of him. The last news we learned of him was at the house just the other side of the Bender home, where the family living there remembered seeing him. All trace of him was here abruptly lost. The Benders, when questioned, professed to know nothing about him. We did not at that time suspect them of any knowledge of his disappearance.

Bender Family Fled While The Search Was in Progress.

"As we passed on and commenced our search in another direction. A week or so passed, and the neighbors of the Benders commenced to notice something wrong around the Bender premises. Not a member of the family had been seen since our visit there, and the stock at the place was uncared for. A horse and cow lariated out in the yard had eaten a circular plot of grass in which they were tethered bare to the ground, and had evidently had no water for several days. An investigation was made. Some of the neighbors called at the house and found the doors locked. The Benders had escaped.

"This fact was reported to us and our suspicions were at once aroused. We went to the Bender home, broke down the doors of the house and entered. What we found there has been told over and over again. We saw the blood stains upon the wall and found the fatal trap-door. We saw the black curtain which hung behind the chairs at the dining table, and behind which Kate Bender had stood with hammer in hand when she beat out the brains of the victims who were decoyed into the house and seated at the table.

"In the cellar under the trap-door we found blood upon the walls and floor, but there was no further trace of any crimes. We were certain that we had located the place where Doctor York had disappeared, and accordingly commenced a search of the premises. One of the party passed through the garden near the house, and noticed a sunken spot in the ground which looked like a grave. Going to our wagon, he took out the end rod and stuck it in the top of the sunken place. It struck something hard a short distance below the surface, and a spade was secured. After a few moments' work we uncovered the body of Doctor York, which had been crowded into a small box. His head had been beaten with a hammer and the features were almost unrecognizable.

"After this discovery we continued our digging, and the result was that we unearthed seven other bodies, two of which were the bodies of my brother's neighbor and his little daughter. They had been buried in the same grave. The whole neighborhood at once formed itself into an armed posse and the search for the missing Benders was commenced.

Members of the Family Were Traced to Walnut.

"We traced them to the small town of Walnut, a few miles distant, where they had driven in a covered wagon. They had left their team and wagon tied in the streets and had then boarded a train. We were never able to find any further trace of them. Stories that have been told and retold about their being caught on the banks of a small stream in Indian Territory, and of their being killed and buried there, are all false. Nobody ever heard of the Benders after they boarded the train at Walnut. True, they have been reported found a thousand times since, but the stories are not true. Of course, I have my own theory as to what became of them, but it is merely a theory.

"In disposing of the plunder which they got from their victims, it is my theory that they had a string of confederates all the way from Kansas to Indian Territory. When their exposure was brought about they fled to some of these confederates. When the search for them became too hot they were killed by their confederates to avoid exposure. I am certain that Kate Bender escaped, and may be living to-day. About twelve years ago I was in Chicago, and was on board a street car when I saw the face of a woman I am absolutely certain was Kate Bender. Before the car could be stopped she had disappeared.

"I knew all the members of the Bender family well. I stopped at the house a number of times, and talked with all of them. The family consisted of four persons: Old man Bender, his wife, Kate, the daughter, and a son, John. They looked like criminals. Kate was a tall, angular type of woman, with the hardest face I ever saw. She was as strong and muscular as a man. The old woman was gray-haired and her eyes were set far back in her head, giving her a wicked expression. John, the son, looked to be a villainous character. The old man was rarely seen around the place.

"The fine horse which my brother rode was never seen again, and probably was disposed of by the Benders through their confederates. I have often thought that robbery may not have been the motive for which he was killed. He may have made inquiries about his missing neighbor, which led to his murder. The Benders may have killed him to allay suspicion of former crimes. My brother's widow and son are now living in Southern Texas." JULIUS H. YORK.

See the clipping

Kate Bender, disguised as an Idaho man?

The Caldwell Tribune reprints an Ontario Argus item on a rumor that Joe Monaghan, a woman who had recently died near Rockville, Idaho, after living as a man for 25 years, was Kate Bender; the Argus itself thought the Benders lay buried by the Verdigris. The Tribune calls the rumor ‘groundless’: Monaghan's sister wrote that she had dressed as a man only from a wish to be one.

The Caldwell Tribune · Caldwell, Idaho Territory Idaho

The Caldwell Tribune · 12 March 1904 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

ANOTHER BENDER ROMANCE A rumor is current that Joe Monahan, the woman who recently died near Rockville, Idaho, after having successfully masked as a man for the past 25 years, was none other than Kate Bender, the notorious Kansas murderess, and that old man Bender and his wife are still living in Snake River Valley. The Bender family have been located a number of times and different people have beeen arrested on suspicion of being members of this family at various times, ever since their notorious crimes came to light and their mysterious disappearance followed, over 30 years ago; but it is more than probable that the remains of these human fiends lie buried in the sands of the Verdiges river.

See moreSee less

Who Joe Monnaghan was will probably never be known and still there is a chance that the mysteries that surrond her life may yet be unraveled. It is true she made her. appearance in this country shortly after the disappearance of the Bender family, but that she was the notorious Kate, we have not the slighest suspicion. The above is taken from the Ontario Argus The story is very improbable. Mr. W. T. Schnabel before leaving for Alaska received a letter from Joe Monaghan's sister in New York in regard to the estate left. Among other things she said that there was no reason why her sister should adopt a man,s attire, except a desire on the girl's part to be a man. There is no particular mystery concerning Joe Monaghan. The rumor is groundless.

See the clipping

An Oklahoma prisoner blames Kate for his arrest

J. J. Burns, held in the federal jail at Guthrie, Oklahoma, on a charge of sending obscene matter through the mails, says the woman behind his arrest, a Mrs. Lowe, is Kate Bender, and that he had courted her daughter. He traces the family from Kansas to Iowa, where they lived under the name Wilson, and on to Oklahoma. Every part of the story comes from Burns.

Paper unidentified

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 377 days earlier.

Paper unidentified · 6 June 1907 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

KATE BENDER IS ALIVE SAYS PROF.

J. J. BURNS ASSERTS WOMAN CAUSED ARREST.

See moreSee less

Seeks to Wed Daughter and Okla homan Tells of Wandering of Out law From Kansas—Fate of Atrocious

Guthrie, Okla., June 6.—If the story related by J. J. Burns is correct, he has succeeded in unraveling one of the most interesting mysteries connected with early-day border events in Kansas—the fate of the Bender family, whose atrocious murders astounded the country.

J. J. Burns is a prisoner here in the federal jail, having been brought in yesterday by Deputy United States Marshal John Dossett. He is charged with sending obscene matter through the United States mail, and had succeeded admirably in eluding the officers and arrest for several months.

Burns made the same statements to Dossett following his arrest, that the warrant for him was sworn out by Kate Bender, a member of the Bender family. Burns says that he is in love with Kate Bender's daughter, and desired to marry her, but that the match was frowned upon by Kate. Notwithstanding opposition, Burns says he went to the home of Kate Bender to pay court to her daughter, and that she had made threats and attempts to kill him. Following these threats he returned home, and is said to have written her some letters, in which he took her to task pretty severely for her interrupting his love affairs, and upon these letters she had him arrested.

Burns is himself something of an unusual character. He lives on a homesteaded claim, near Bessie, in a home. He has tunnels running from his dugout home to the well and also to his barn shed, and by means of these tunnels he succeeded several t[imes] in eluding the officers which were sent to arrest him. These underground channels gave him an excellent means of escape whenever officers came to his dugout.

John Dossett finally trapped Burns in the town of Bessie, however. It is claimed that friends of Burns, whenever an officer reached that locality, would tip the matter off to Burns, and he would elude the officer, but Dossett went to the hotel and remained there, keeping an outlook on the street, however, for Burns. Finally he saw Burns enter a hardware store, and he followed him. Walking up behind him, Dossett asked him: "Is your name Burns?" and received an affirmative reply. Burns turned around and extended his hand to shake hands, when Dossett gripped him around the wrist to prevent Burns from pulling a gun. Dossett said: "I have a warrant for you," and Burns' only answer was: "Well, I guess you've got me at last." He made no resistance whatever. Burns was in his shirt sleeves and had no gun, having left his Winchester at a place not far distant. On him, however, Dossett found three boxes of steel bullets.

Burns talks intelligently. When a newspaper reporter called on him in jail he made no hesitancy regarding the charges that the woman who caused his arrest was Kate Bender. He said:

"Following their departure from Cherryvale, Kan., they went northeast through the country, arriving at Creston, Ia., where they lived for a number of years, ten miles below Creston. While living there Kate Bender married George Boggs, who shortly afterward disappeared. In the meantime John Bender, the father, had become old and childish, and his wife and daughter thought he was talking too much. Shortly thereafter he disappeared.

"In Iowa the Benders went under the name of Wilson. Following the disappearance of Boggs, Kate married Robert Lowe. The Wilsons, or Benders, left Iowa after a number of years and settled for a time in Chautauqua county, Kan., but later came to Oklahoma, where they located on a claim.

"During the residence there Mrs. Sarah Jane Lowe's two sweethearts quarreled and one killed the other. The killing was laid to Lowe, who was arrested and convicted and actually served a term in the penitentiary for Miller's murder."

Burns got mixed up with the family by renting them his claim near Bessie, and to this claim came Mrs. Lowe, an adopted daughter, Cora Lowe, aged about 19, and Grandmother Wilson, or Bender, aged now about 87.

"I discovered after I had rented the claim to the family," Burns said, "that a conspiracy had been entered into for me to marry either the adopted daughter or her mother, and that afterward I would be got out of the way and they would secure my land.

"I want to say that I did not write the letters which it is claimed I sent through the mails. They are forgeries and were fixed up to get me into trouble. Following my quarrel with them they did have me arrested, but I was acquitted. Mrs. Lowe then left that portion of the country and went, I think, to Oklahoma City, where, to the best of my knowledge, she is still living."

Following the disappearance of Dr. York, his brother began an investigation and tracked him to the Bender home. When the party, led by York, reached the home they were told by Kate Bender that her mother was critically ill and that they must not enter. Unsuspecting, the party withdrew, and that night, according to those who believe that the Benders did escape, the family left their farm. Their absence was not noticed until the bawling of starving calves on the farm attracted attention. The searching party later found the numerous graves of the Bender victims.

Dossett was once convicted of murder, but got a new trial and was acquitted.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Five: Overtaken at Last