As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

August 1901

41 articles

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The report claims the notorious Bender family of Kansas, who murdered travelers at their hotel two decades earlier, has been located in northwestern Colorado. A $10,000 reward is offered for their arrest, with officers expecting capture within days.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Connecticut Western News · 1 August 1901 · page 2

Twenty years ago the Bender fami ly of Kansas became notorious for their wholesale murders in Labette county where they ran an isolated hotel and killed and plundered the unsuspecting traveler. The family were driven out of the county before the crimes were fastened upon them, and the portrait of John Bender has been used extensively by phrenologists and criminologists t depict the degenerate. Last week the Benders were located in the northwes

See the clipping

Meade County News · Meade, Kan. · and 1 other paper

Kansas authorities issued a formal requisition to Colorado's governor for people believed to be the notorious Bender family, based on a rancher's claim that his wife, suspected to be Kate Bender, had tried to poison him and leave him for a train. A deputy sheriff was dispatched to Colorado after several old acquaintances reportedly identified the suspects as the Benders from twenty-eight years earlier.

Meade County News · 1 August 1901 · page 3

REQUISITION FOR BENDERS. Said to Have Been Found at Fort Collins, Colorado. Topeka, July 25. A requisition has been issned from the governor's office on the governor of Colorado for the notorious Bender family. The com plaint is made by Frank Ay res, a ranchman living near Fort Collins, Col., who claims that he was married to a woman whom he now thinks was Kate Bender. lie claims that the woman gave him "knock out drops" some time last February in the hope of killing him. To avoid suspicion he was carried in an unconscious condi tion to a near by railroad track and left on the rails to be killed by passing trains.

See moreSee less

He was found by friends and rescued. He suspected his wife and began working up the case against her. Governor Stanley placed the requisi tion in the hands of E. L. Barton, a deputy sheriff from Labette county, and he left at once for Colorado. The supposed Benders have been iden tided by' several persons who knew them twenty-eight years ago in Kansas. Ayres claims that he was married to the Bender woman for fourteen months prior to the attempt to poison him. Mrs. Ayres, who is supposed to be Kate Bender, is said to have seven divorced husbands who are all living.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Chanute Times · Chanute, Kan. · 2 August 1901
  • Meade County News · Meade, Kan. · 3 July 1902

Mexico Weekly Ledger · Mexico, Mo.

The report states that the four members of the Bender family, long sought for a series of murders in Kansas, have allegedly been located near Fort Collins, Colorado, prompting Governor Stanley to issue requisitions for their arrest. The identification rests on claims by Frank Ayres, who says Kate Bender was once his wife, supported by four men sent to verify her identity.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Mexico Weekly Ledger · 1 August 1901 · page 1

BENDERS REPORTED LOCATED

Topska, Kas., uly 23. -The four members of the notorious Bender family, guilty of a score of murders, are said to have been located In Colo rado and Governor Stanley to-day Is sued requisitions for their apprehen sion. The accused consistof father,mother, daughter and son. The former two would now be more than 70 years old, while their children are past the 60 mark. They are now said to be near Fort Collins, Colo. Information to this effect wag given to Governor Stan ley by Frank Ayres, of that place, who asserts that Kate Bender, the daugh ter, was once bis wife.

See moreSee less

Four men who went to Colorado to identify her, sup port the statement of Ayres. Tba Benders lived on a small farm near Galena and for years, as it de veloped after their flight 27 years ago, had lured travelers to their place, murdered them for their money and buried their bodies in the yard around their home or under the house. The house was arranged with trap doors. All four of the members of the family were accused of aiding in the murders. Ad investigation into the disappear ance of Dr. York, brother of a Kansas State Senator, who had stopped at the Benders', and whose bones were found beneath the house, led to the flight. Heavy rewards for their arrest were offered by the State, but they were never captured, although many false clews were run down.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

A Kansas governor expresses skepticism that the Bender family was lynched by a border posse, noting no one has claimed the long-standing reward for proof. He also recounts how, during Governor Glick's term, two men privately claimed the Benders were hanged but would not testify, leading the state to withhold a reward requisition.

The Butler Weekly Times · 1 August 1901 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THINKS THE BENDERS ESCAPED.

Governor Stanley Interested in New Clews Regarding Fugitives.

See moreSee less

Topeka, Kan., July 29.—Governor Stanley has come to the conclusion that the members of the notorious Bender family of Labette are not all dead and he is prepared to assist officials who are searching for them. The governor does not believe that the Benders were overtaken by a posse of citizens just over the border in the Indian territory and killed, according to the popular version of the affair. He said to-day:

"If the people who claim to know and be able to prove that the Benders were killed shortly after their flight from Labette county and buried in the bed of the Verdigris river are telling the truth why haven't they come forward and claimed the reward of $500 which the Labette county authorities have kept standing for years for proof of the death of the Benders? I do not believe the stories of deathbed confessions and such that the newspapers have been printing. It has been found that the Benders bought tickets at Thayer, ten miles from their farm, for Humboldt at least three days before their flight was discovered They were probably 1,000 miles from Labette county before the posse which afterward claimed to have killed them left the scene of their murders."

Atchison, Kan., July 29—When George W. Glick was governor of Kansas the Benders were "discovered," and he was asked to issue a requisition and offer a reward. While the matter was under discussion, two men from the southwestern part of the state called on him and said, in confidence: "We know that the Benders were hanged two days after the discovery of Dr. York's body. A posse of ten men pursued the Benders, and hanged them. We know it; we will not admit that we witnessed the hanging, but we know that they were hanged." The men were prominent and reliable, and they convinced the governor that the Benders were where they belonged. As a result, the requisition was not issued.

See the clipping

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

Governor Stanley of Kansas concludes that not all members of the notorious Bender family are dead and offers to help officials searching for them. The report comes decades after the Bender murders, as authorities continue the long hunt for surviving fugitives.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Butler Weekly Times · 1 August 1901 · page 1

THINKS THE BENDERS ESCAPED. CERVERA SIDES WITH SCHLEY. Governor Stanley Interested in New Only Praise for Santiago Hero From ; Clews Reuardiot; Fugitives. the Spanish Admiral. f Topeka, Kan., July 20. Governor! Vichy, France, July 2 s. Admiral I Stanley has come to the conclusion Cervera. w ho was defeated bv the: that the members of the notorious t Americans at the battle of Santiago. ! Bender family of Labette are not all j which engagement has caused a con-' dead and he is prepared to assist of- ! troversv in the Tinted States naval j h'-ials who are searching for them, j department, has this to say regard-; The governor does not believe that ing Admiral Sehlev and the Brook-'

See the clipping

The Dupuyer Acantha · Dupuyer, Mont.

The item describes a Colorado man named Ayers who claims his wife is Kate Bender, the notorious Bender family member reputed to be the most bloodthirsty of the clan. The paper treats the story skeptically, noting a rumor that vigilantes had already killed off the Benders nearly thirty years earlier and suggesting Ayers may be imagining things.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Dupuyer Acantha · 1 August 1901 · page 4

AUGUST 1, 1901. Admiral Schley has at last demanded an investigation of the charges of dis obedience and cowardice laid at his door ■by Sampson and his friends. The oripij nai Sampson is reported to have done, considerable execution with ihe jaw j bone of an ass but under modern con ' ditions the weapon has proven suitable , only for self destruction Tes notorious Bender family has again been discovered this time by a man named Ayers in Colorado who claims that his own wife is none other than Kate Bender, who had the reputa tion of being tho most blood thirsty of the inhuman family.

See moreSee less

There is a plausi ble story f o the effect that a posse rneieci out border justice to all of tue Benders nearly thirty years ago, and it is possible ' that Mr. Ayers has been troubled by the nightmare of indigestion. But what <1 revenge to take upon his cook! ' "The determination of Judge Dubose to bow to the will of the court and serve the sentence of six months imposed up on him for contemptwithout seeking ... . , j 1 any especial fa% 01 \%.i Je ^ccop e j

See the clipping

Aberdeen Herald · Aberdeen, W.T.

Kansas authorities claim four people living near Fort Collins, Colorado are the long-sought Bender family, infamous for murdering travelers at their Kansas farm over 15 years earlier. Governor Stanley issues extradition papers based on identification by a man claiming Kate Bender was once his wife.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Aberdeen Herald · 1 August 1901 · page 3

NOTORIOUS BENDERS LOCATED.

Be Living in Colorado. Topekn, Kan., July 25.—Four per sons, said to be members »f the notor ious Bender gang, accused of com mitting a score of murders at their home near Galena, Kan., over 15 years ago, have been located near Fort Collins, Colo., and Governor Stanley has issued requisition papers on the governor of Colorado for their return to this state. The first steps toward bringing the suspects to Kan sas were taken upon the representa tions of Frank Ayets, of Fort Collins, who asserts that one of the quartet, Kate Bender, was once his wife.

See moreSee less

Governor Stanley issued the requisi tion upon affidavits of four men who went to Colorado to identify the sus pects. The Benders committed a series of murders, the most atrocious ever recorded. They lived on a small farm near Galena and for years, as it developed after their flight, they had lured travelers and buried their bodies in the yard around the house. All four members of the family were ac cused of aiding in the murdsrs. The family consisted of man, wife, daugh ter and son. The parents would now be in their 70s and the children about 50 years of age.

See the clipping

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · and 1 other paper

Four people believed to be members of the notorious Bender family were located near Fort Collins, Colorado. Frank Ayres claimed one of the women was his former wife, Kate Bender.

Wood County Reporter · 1 August 1901 · page 2

Four persons believed to be mem bers of the notorious Bender family of Kansas, were located near Fort Collins, Colo. Fran! - Ayres declares one of them Kate Bender, his former wife. The body of Miss Phoebe Miller of Lansingville, N, Y., a teacher at the Shelter for Unprotected Girls, who was burned to death in the fire which destroyed that institution at Syra cuse, was recovered. Gov. Benton McMillin of Tennessee positively stated that he would not be a candidate for a third term as gov ernor. It is understood he will be a candidate to succeed United States

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Northern Wisconsin Advertiser · Wabeno, Wis. · 1 August 1901

Northern Wisconsin Advertiser · Wabeno, Wis.

Kansas authorities issue warrants for the arrest of a family in Fort Collins, Colorado believed to be the notorious Benders, based on a complaint from a rancher who says his wife, suspected to be Kate Bender, tried to poison him. Former Labette County neighbors traveled to Colorado and signed affidavits identifying the family as the Benders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Northern Wisconsin Advertiser · 1 August 1901 · page 2

GREAT CRIMES RECALLED

Colo., who answer the descriptions of the notorious Bender family.' 'Che whf rants are for John Bender, Mrs. Befiw der, John Bender, Jr., and Kate Bea-I der - t JJ E. L. Burton, George MdFai^jiflS!J G. F. Edwards and W. A.,Disco, deputy sheriffs of Labett county, have left U Jr, Colorado to arrest the family, .and^x-" pect to return to this city by the latter oart oi this week. V The complaint is made by Fsaefk "* Ayres, a ranchman living nejU' Ffcrt Collins, Colo., who claims that he was married to a woman who he ; now! thinks is Kate Bender. He claims''

See the clipping

Northern Wisconsin Advertiser · Wabeno, Wis.

Labette County commissioners sent former neighbors to Colorado to identify a family suspected of being the Benders, resulting in affidavits sent to Governor Stanley. The report recaps the original Bender murders, describing their inn, the killing method, the discovery of eleven bodies, and the 1873 York murder that triggered their flight.

Northern Wisconsin Advertiser · 1 August 1901 · page 2

GREAT CRIMES RECALLED

line of the Mexican Central near Montezuma. Several passengers on the train were severely injured, some of whom are expected to die. A Pull man palace car, which had been side tracked to allow another car to be coupled to the train got beyond con trol oi the brakemen and started down a steep grade. The train backed up to catch the flying car and. on reaching it, a collision occurred. In an effort to benefit her own health by seeking the alleged healing powers of John Alexander Dowle, Mrs. Mamie King of Winemac, Wis., lost her 8-year-old daughter, Jennie, by diphtheria.

See moreSee less

Another child is sick with the disease and other members of the household at 1411 Michigan avenue. Chicago, are threatened. As medical attention is barred neighbors in the vicinity fear an epidemic of the disease. The conferences between Adjutant General Corbin and General Chaffee probably will result in radical economical and administrative re forms in *he army of occupation* It is estin. ited that the cost of main taining the American army in the Philippines can be reduced by 60 per cent. The principal change will be the reduction of the present force to between 20.000 and 30.000 men. The abolishment of the present army dis tricts is contemplated and three brigades, with permanent head quarters at Manila. Dagupan and Iloilo or Casu, will be substituted in their stead. Brick de Graff of La Crosse, whoso wife fell from the sixth story of a Chicago and died at the county hospital, appeared at central police j station and said that the woman was his wife and that he left to go on a trip to Milwaukee. Reading of her accident he returned to Chicago. ‘T am afraid she committed suicide," said he. "She had been drinking heavily and was despondent." The police are convinced the fall from the window was accidental. A dispatch from La Crosse says that the woman had been divorced from De Graff for habitual drunkenness and had previously attempted suicide. Foreign. Anew liberal cabinet was appoint ed in Denmark. Russia has demanded of the porte two coaling stations on the Persian gulf. Cardinal Vaughan gave a reception in London in honor of Cardinal Gib bons. Count Leo Tolstoi, who is ill at Tula. European Russia, is much weak ened. Czar Nicholas has relaxed the rigor ef some of the Russian press restric tions. Mma. Schmafcl of Paris has started married to a woman who he ; now! thinks is Kate Bender. He claims'' that the woman gave him "knockoffjk drops” some time last February pS| hopes of killing him to avoid cion. He was carried in an uncon scious condition to a nearby railroad and left on the rails to be killed by passing trains. He was found by freinds and rescued. He suspected his wife and began working up the case against her. Ayres says that the Bender family left Labett county after their series of crimes and went to the Black hills, where they lived for seventeen years. They then moved to Colorado, where Ayres met and married Kate two years ago. The county commissioners of Labett county, who have never given up the search for the Benders, sent E. M. Dack, V. A. Monahan, T. B. Smith, and M. E. Sparks, former neighbors of the Benders, to Colorado to identify the* Benders. They declared they believed the persons now in Laramie count? are the members of the notorious Ben der family and made affidavits to the effect, which were placed in the hands of Gov. Stanley. A family suspected# as the Benders was tried in Labett county in 1889 and released for want of evidence. The Benders were squatters on land in the western part of Labett county, Kans., which was claimed by rival rail way companies. The family lived apart from tl. ir ncigkbots, aid con sisted of one eld man, hie wife, and a son and dauca.er I-lato. They kept a wayside inn, with a ra’.can attachment, ten miles west of Galesburg. Here travelers often put up for the nigtft,'" and it was usually the case that they took lodgings for eternity. At any rate, the doom of travelers was sealed the moment they crossed the Bender threshold, and so numerous became the disappearances that investigation followed, and a series of bloody crimes for gain were unearthed, which stand without a rival in criminal history. The house was admirably and pur posely arranged for the double purpose of robbery and murder. The front room was separated from the back by a thin curtain, simlar to that placed over folding doors. When a man en- > tered whom the family proposed to rob ■ he was invited to take with his back to the curtain. t eral travelers arrived together arw' wayside inn. Then an eqtnU nuptber of members of the family, for blood and booty, concealetKthems/lves behind the curtain, and, dach selecting a victim, would wait the given signal and opportune moment to the unsuspecting guest. Eleven bodies were dug up O’n.mllt

See the clipping

Lincoln County Record · Pioche, Nev. · and 1 other paper

Four people believed to be members of the infamous Bender family, wanted for a series of murders near Galena, Kansas over fifteen years earlier, were reportedly located near Fort Collins, Colorado. Governor Stanley issued requisition papers based on affidavits from men who traveled to identify the suspects, including a man who claimed to have once been married to Kate Bender.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Lincoln County Record · 2 August 1901 · page 2

Notorlou. Hrnilcr Family Believed to Have lleen Located In Colorado. Four persons said to be member of the notorious Bender family, accused pf committing a score of murder at their home near Galena, Kan., over Gfleen years ago, have been located pear Fort Collins, Colo., and requisi tion papers for their return to Kansai have been issued. The first steps toward bringing the luspects to Kausas were taken upon the representations of Frank Ayers of Fort Collins, who asserts that one of the quartette, Kate Bender, wa once his wife. Governor Stanley issued the requisition upon affidavits of four men who went to Colorado to identify the suspects.

See moreSee less

The Benders committed a scries of the most atrocious crime ever committed. They lived on a small farm near Galena and for years, as it developed after their flight, they had lured travelers and burled their bodies in the yard around their home, or under the house. The family con sisted of man, wife, daughter and son, and all four were accused of aiding in the murders. The parents would now be in the seventies, and the children about 50 years of age.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Elmore Bulletin · Rocky Bar, Idaho · 1 August 1901

The Mountain Echo · Yellville, Ark.

Thirty years after the Bender murders, Kansas authorities seek extradition of persons in Colorado alleged to be Bender family members living under aliases Mrs. Ayres, Mrs. Reed, and Will Baker. A Kansas family recognized one woman as Kate Bender, though she denies this and claims she can prove an alibi.

The Mountain Echo · 2 August 1901 · page 1

THE NAMES THEY GO BY.

Denver, July 24. The persons alleged to be members of the •Bender family for whom, accord ing to a dispatch from Topeka, Governor Standley has issued requisition papers on Governor

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Governor Stanley of Kansas granted a requisition to Colorado for four people believed by citizens of Montgomery and Labette counties to be the notorious Benders. The report recounts the original 1872 Bender murders near Cherryvale, Kansas, where travelers were killed behind a canvas partition in the family's home.

Paper unidentified · 2 August 1901 · page 2

IS THE BENDER FAMILY NOW IN COLORADO?

NOW IN COLORADO? Topeka. Kan.. July 24.—(Denver News Bpeclnl.)—Governor Stanley liat granted a requisition ou.the governor of Colorado for four persons who are believed by reputable citizens of Mont gomery ami Labette counties to be the notorious Benders. The affidavits upon which tbe requisition was granted were made by E. 11. Duck, T. B. Smith, V. A. Monylinml aud M. E. Sparks, who went to Colorado esiH*cially to see the four suspected persons. They de clare that while without further In quiry they are not prepared to swear positively that they are the persons wanted, they flnnly believe them to he so.

See moreSee less

The requisitions name four agents to receive the prisoners from the Colo rado authorities, hut only Ed L. Bur ton, a lawyer of Oswego, has gone to Fort Collins. The other three are to follow If Burton is satisfied thut the suspects really are the Benders. In 1872 the Benders lived lu Labette county, Kansas, near Cherry vale. The, family consisted of William Bender, aged about sixty; his wife, aged alnnit fifty-live; then Kate, aged twenty-five, and John, aged perhaps twenty-three. Kate nml John were children of Will iam Bender by a former wife. Tlielr house was of frame, 10x20 feet, and fronted north. There was a door nt either end, and the room was divided by ii canvas par tition. drawn tightly over upright scantlings. This partition was the death trap. The victim was decoyed to a sent close against the canvas, and Kate did the rest. Tlielr victims worn travelers through the then wild coun try, who stopped ut the Bender home for food ami shelter. Every man they killed had a horse, but only the two animals the family originally took to the farm were found after the flight. The horses. It is be lieved, were run out of the country by confederates. The deed that drove the Benders to flight was the murder of Dr. York of Independence. Dr. York had been to Fort Scott, and was returning to his home, when the Benders decoyed him Into tlielr slaughter pen and killed lilm. His brother, Colonel A. M. York, of Fort Scott. Ihstltuted a search, which led to the Beuder home, but the mur derer#‘were wary and had fled when the officers appeared to arrest them. Of the eight bodies found on the place, all were Identified except two. Be sides Dr. York, they were Benjamin 11. Brdwh of Ueilarvale, Kansas; W. F.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

This 1901 article reviews the Bender family's 1872 Kansas farmhouse and their method of murdering travelers using a canvas-partitioned death trap. It recounts the murder of Dr. York, the resulting investigation that led to the Benders' flight, and lists several identified victims found buried on the property.

Paper unidentified · 2 August 1901 · page 2

NOW IN COLORADO?

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Paper unidentified

A man named Barnes, who knew Dr. York (who led the original investigation into the Bender murders), claims that a family located in Fort Lupton is not actually the Benders. He recounts that when the crimes were discovered, York organized a posse that chased the Benders into Indian Territory, though the outcome of that pursuit is left unclear in this account.

CorrectionThis set right 5 earlier articles: Connecticut Western News, 1 August 1901, Mexico Weekly Ledger, 1 August 1901, The Dupuyer Acantha, 1 August 1901, Aberdeen Herald, 1 August 1901, Northern Wisconsin Advertiser, 1 August 1901.

Paper unidentified · 2 August 1901 · page 3

BARNES, OF FORT LUPTON, TELLS ABOUT BENDER FAMILY

York af Independence, Kansas. ■*® f who started the Invcstlga dlsclosetl their crimes, ft’tonns Is positive tlmt the Fort are not the Benders. •'■‘ 11l reasons. About the time ■ SUrorv was made the Benders BiuTconntry headed f.ir Hie Indian

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Decades after the murders, a Nebraska hardware dealer and former Kansas legislator recalls rumors that a vigilance committee tracked the Benders into Indian Territory and killed them, based on the silence of committee members when asked. The report also notes a woman named Mrs. Ayers whose age matches Kate Bender's, though her description otherwise differs.

Paper unidentified · 2 August 1901 · page 3

back and from tlint time on no authen tic report has ever been heard of the Benders. The supposition at that time among the people around there was and is to-day that this vigilance com mittee ran the Benders to earth in the Indian terlrtor.v at some obscure place and effectually avenged the crimes of coerryvnle. Mr. Barnes knew personally many of the members of this vigilance commit tee. and says that from the time they returned, when questioned about the Benders, the men had nothing what ever to say. but would intimate that the Benders would never return.

See moreSee less

He says that Mrs. Ayers of Fort Collins corresponds in age to Kate Bender. She was aliout twenty years old at the time she left and would now lie about fifty, but beyond that, according to the printed descriptions, he says there is no similarity. O. F. Carson, a hardware dealer of Omaha, was a druggist at Clierryvnle at the time of the Bender crimes, and a member of the Kansas Legislature. He luui considerable information re garding the Benders. Mr. Carson was at Cherryvale for a number of years before and after the Bender tragedy.

See the clipping

Marshall County Independent · Plymouth, Ind.

Four persons believed to be members of the notorious Bender family of Kansas were located near Fort Collins, Colorado. Frank Ayres claimed one of them was Kate Bender, his former wife.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Marshall County Independent · 2 August 1901 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Goodland Republic · Goodland, Kan.

The report discusses the dubious identification of the Bakers of Colorado as the long-sought Bender family, noting that 28 years after the murders no reward has ever been successfully claimed. It recounts conflicting rumors, including one that the Benders were killed by a posse while fleeing, and concludes the mystery will likely never be solved.

The Goodland Republic · 2 August 1901 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE CASE OF THE BENDERS.

The identification of the Bakers, of Fort Collins, Col., as the notorious Bender family, of Labette county, Kan., is hardly probable after a lapse of 28 years. Conflicting reports have been many as to what became of the Bender family. The rewards for their capture have been claimed several times but the suspects were never identified as the Benders, and consequently the rewards were never paid. One story has it that when the Benders attempted to escape after the murder of Dr. York in 1872, they were overtaken by a posse and the whole family killed.

See moreSee less

Gov. Stanley, in issung the requisition on the governor of Colorado for the Bakers, thinks that the family were not killed or the $500 reward offered by Labette county would have been claimed at the time. But who would claim the reward and then stand for the murder of the innocent children of the family? But the mystery will undoubtedly never be solved. It marks a dark leaf in Kansas history—fiendish murder on one side and, perhaps, relentless revenge on the other.

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

A dying Oklahoma man, Daniel W. Martin, claims he was part of the 1873 vigilance committee that caught the fleeing Bender family on the Verdigris River. He describes a makeshift trial, old man Bender's confession, Kate's furious cursing, and the family's secret execution and burial, with evidence destroyed.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Minneapolis Journal · 3 August 1901 · page 1

Benders were killed by this committee, and told the details of their taking off, although just what part he performed he refused to say. If his story is true it disposes of the theory that the Benders are now in Colorado. Said Mr. Martin: We overtook the Benders on the Verdigris river and a regular court was formed. Be fore the trial had proceeded far old man Bender broke down and confessed. Then that demon of a Kate turned loose the most violent storm of curses upon her father and damned him for his cowardice.

See moreSee less

The old man fairly grfoveled in the dirt while his tigress of a daughter told him his confession meant death to them all. After the confession ten men were chosen from the vigilantes and these ten chose a captain. The captain named a man and then the two chose another. The other seven then withdrew toward the main body, stopping only long enough to dig four graves. The three men that remained behind alone knew the exact fate of the Benders. One thing you can say, and that is that Kate Bender did not meet death in the manner that the rest did. She fought like a demon and finally was shot. After this the work was simple. The vigilantes shot the horses and then burned up everything else the Benders had taken with them and scattered the ashes.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A Black Hills old-timer named Dod Pierce claims a deceased friend once told him how a vigilante posse from Cherryvale tracked the Benders, found their abandoned roadhouse full of bullet holes and blood, and uncovered fifteen bodies buried in the garden. The story implies the Bender family itself was killed and buried there, ending the need for further search.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Sun · 5 August 1901 · page 8

BENDER FAMILY'S FATE

Benders Pierces friend wan among thotH thotHfrom limo Srfruits from the city of Cherryvale who went out outto outto to Investigate the condition of thingH nt ntthn littime time Bender roadhouse There were twenty twentyfour flu flufour four men in the party ono of tho ho men being llngau

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Decades later, a man named Doc Pierce recounts a story told to him by a friend about a posse of Cherryvale men tracking the Bender family, surrounding them, and killing all four in a gunfight before burning the bodies and wagon. The report also notes that a woman resembling Kate Bender was rumored to have lived in the Black Hills years later, though this is treated skeptically.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Sun · 5 August 1901 · page 8

BENDER FAMILY'S FATE

scout and exterminating the entire family familyTho isunilyThe The posse was divided into three parts parwand dand and the Bender family was surrounded eurroundoilOno d dOtto Ono of the posse accidentally discharged dischargedIlls I Ihis Ills rlflu rub before the proper time which gav gavthe gave gavethe the warning of danger to it the Bender people peopleThey peopleThey They Immediately prepared for defence defenceTho defencelIme lIme buffalo hunter fired nt long range at atold atold old man Bender and lilt him In the hack hackkilling U Ukiiiing killing him himAnother iiAnother Another volley from the posse and John Johnand Johnand and hi his mother fell lend Kato was the thelast thelast last ono to be shot The posse then went wentIn wontto to time scone and ilhd tIme four dead bodies a a1mm In a heap and burned them adding to thins thnflro aIre flro wagon harness and the camp outfit outfitEverything tEverything Everything that would not burn was taken takento P Pto to tha creek bank and covered over with withdirt withclInt dirt C dirtThis This is thus story that Doo Pieroo tells telUfor s sfor

See the clipping

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo. · and 1 other paper

Doc Pierce claims a posse found bullet holes, blood, a trapdoor, and fifteen bodies buried in the Benders' garden, then tracked the fleeing family and executed all four, burning the bodies and evidence. He also dismisses a rumor that Kate Bender later lived in the Black Hills.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Butler Weekly Times · 8 August 1901 · page 1

HOW THE BENDERS DIED.

The trail of an old rickety wagon was found, and the buffalo hunter follow ed it up all day, and about? nightfall came upon the family, camped near a creek. The scout returned to the party of Cherryvale men and report ed his find. They agreed upon going back with the scout and exterminat ing the entire family. The posse was divided into three parts, and the Bender family was surrounded. One of the posse accidentally discharged his rifle before the proper time, which gave the warning of danger to the Bender people.

See moreSee less

They immediately prepared for defense. The buffalo hunter fired at long range at old man Bender and hit him in the back, kill ing him. Another volley from the posse, and John and his mother fell dead. Kate was the last one to be shot. The posse then went to the scene and piled the four dead bodies in a heap and burned them, adding to the fire the wagon, harness and the camp outfit. Everything that would not burn was taken to the crek bank and covered over with dirt. This is the story that Doe Pierce tells for the first time since his friend confided the facts to him, twenty years ago. The story that Kate Bender came to the Black hills sever al years ago and made her residence in this citv is not credited here. A woman did come here about fifteen yearsagothat had some resemblance to the famous Kate, so some of the old-timers say, but it is not believed that it was she.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Durango Semi-Weekly Herald · Durango, Colo. · 12 August 1901

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

Minneapolis clairvoyants and mediums are asked by the Journal to use spirit communication to determine whether John Bender and his family survived or were killed by vigilantes. The spirits disagree, with some insisting the whole family was exterminated and others claiming Bender and two relatives are still alive.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

The Minneapolis Journal · 8 August 1901 · page 6

WHAT SPIRITS SAY

Three Living. The fate of John Bender, outlaw and murderer, cannot be determined with any degree of certainty by Minneapolis medi ums and clairvoyants. Despite the fact that they are in direct communication with the spirit world, yet In this instance they are apparently at fault for the reason that there is not a unanimity of opinion among the spirits regarding the fate of the famous outlaw and his family. In view of the wide comment excited by the recently published statements of numerous persons to the effect that they had seen and recognised John Bender in late years, and equally numerous state ments that the Benders were all killed, The Journal to-day consulted sev eral prominent mediums and clairvoyants.

See moreSee less

It was found that the spirits could not agree. Some unhesitatingly stated that not a single member of the Bender family was now alive, while others, with equal assurance, maintained that John Bender and two of his relatives, who were sup posed to have fallen victims to the rage of western vigilants, are still living and that in the near future this fact would be corroborated by the elder Bender him self. In each instance details were given con cerning the action of the vigilantes at the time they were supposed to have exter minated the notorious family held guilty of fiendish crimes.

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

Decades after the Bender murders, a newspaper consults clairvoyants about whether the family was killed by vigilantes or still alive; the spirits contradict each other entirely. One medium describes a detailed lynching and burning of the family, while another insists John Bender and others are still alive.

The Minneapolis Journal · 8 August 1901 · page 6

THE ORACLES FAIL TO AGREE

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

Two spiritualist mediums, consulted by newspapers decades after the Bender murders, give contradictory seance-derived accounts of what became of the family. One claims several Benders still live, while another insists all were lynched and burned by a vigilante mob, illustrating the enduring uncertainty and mythmaking around their fate.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Minneapolis Journal · 8 August 1901 · page 6

THE ORACLES FAIL TO AGREE

thought transference from the other world —the sane uncertainty exists as to the fate of the Benders. The spirits do not tell the same story to their familiars in Minneapolis. When Dr. Heilobas was asked to exer cise his influence on the spirit world to determine the fate of the Benders for the benefit of the readers of The Journal he said: I can give you the desired information. Not a single member of the Bender family is alive to-day. Not one escaped the ven geance of the mob that went out after them.

See moreSee less

I answer you so readily because three weeks ago while in Denver I was asked the same question. I am telling you now what I then stated. At that time a man came to me who claimed he had seen one of the family but a short time before. He had in his pos session a photograph of a woman. I was told it was that of Kate Bender. By means of thought transference I discovered the woman had been dead for many years but that it was not the likeness of Kate Bender. I saw a reproduction of the scene at the

See the clipping

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

A Deadwood report relays elderly scout 'Doc' Pierce's story, told to him by a now-dead friend, claiming a 24-man posse from Cherryvale found the Bender house abandoned, discovered bullet holes and blood on a bed, and unearthed fifteen bodies—including Bender family members—buried in the garden. The account asserts this ends the need for authorities to keep searching for the Benders, implying they were killed by the vigilante search party.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Butler Weekly Times · 8 August 1901 · page 1

HOW THE BENDERS DIED.

Massacred---Tragedv Enacted on the Banks of a Creek-Bodies and Wagon Burned. Dead wood, S. I., August 4. K. T. fierce, more familiar! v known as ' Doe'" Pierce. oDf of the oldest and most reliable Indian scouts of the Black hills, has given out a story about the Bender family, of Kansas. which goes to show that there is no further need of the authorities search ing for tie remains of the family. Pierce is a reliable man, and for the first time he tells what he knows of the case.

See moreSee less

He had a friend in the 70s whowasalso well known in the Black hills, and before the friend died he re lated to Pierce the incidents relative to the killing of all of the members of the Bender family. When the York family was killed aud the tragedy was traced to the home of the Benders. Pierce's friend was among those from the citv of Cherry vale who went out to investi gate the conditions of things at the Bender roadhouse. There were twen

See the clipping

The Bellefontaine Republican · Bellefontaine, Ohio

A dying Kansas man named Martin claimed he rode with a posse that caught the Bender family on the Verdigris River, where old man Bender confessed and Kate cursed him before being killed resisting capture. He said three vigilantes alone knew the Benders' exact fate, and that everything was burned and the ashes scattered.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Bellefontaine Republican · 9 August 1901 · page 1

A Kansas man on hja deathbeda few days ago, claimed that he was with the party that followed the Bender family. He said: "We overtook the Benders on the Verdigras river," said Mr. Martin, "and a regular court was formed. Be fore the trial had proceeded far, old man Bender broke down and confessed Then that demon of a Kate turned loose the most violent storm of curses and damned him for his cowardice. After the confession three men were chosen from the vigllants and these three alone know the exact fate of the Benders.

See moreSee less

Ooe thing you can say and that is that Kate Bender did not meet death in the manner that the rest did. She fought like demon and was finally shot. The vigilante shot the horses and then burned up everything that the Benders had with them and scat tered the ashes."

See the clipping

Durango Semi-Weekly Herald · Durango, Colo.

Deadwood scout "Doc" Pierce relates a story told him by a now-dead friend who claimed to have been part of a 24-man posse that found the deserted Bender roadhouse, discovered blood-soaked bedding and a cellar trap door, then dug up fifteen bodies—including the Benders themselves—buried in the garden. Pierce insists this proves authorities need search no further for the family's remains.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Butler Weekly Times, 8 August 1901, The Bellefontaine Republican, 9 August 1901.

Wrong

Durango Semi-Weekly Herald · 12 August 1901 · page 3

shot. DEADWOOD, S. D., Aug. B.—E. T. Pierce, more familiarly known as “Doc” Pierce, one of the oldest and most reliable Indian scouts of the Black Hills, has given out a story ol the Bender family, of Kansas, which goes to show that there is no further need of the authorities searching for the remains of the tamily. Pierce is a reliable man, and for the first time he tells what he knows of the case He had a friend in the Tos, who was also well known in the Black Hills, and before the friend died he related to Pierce the incidents relative to the killing of the members of the Bender family.

See moreSee less

When the York family was Killed > and the tragedy was traced to the famIy of the Benders, Pierce's friend was among those from the town of Cher ryvvale who went out to invesiigate the condition of things at the Bender roadhouse, They found the house deserted. There were twenty-four men in the party, one of the men bhe fug an old huffaio hunier In search ing the house. the bedstead in the west room, of which there has been 80 much talk, was found to be full of bullet holes, and dried blood was on the mattress, They found the trap door beneath a curtain, which led into the cellar, into which the dead bodies had been thrown until dark, when they were taken out into the garden and huried,

See the clipping

Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut

Frank Ayres of Fort Collins, Colorado, claims his wife is Kate Bender and is seeking additional evidence against the alleged Benders, accompanied by two reported Kansas detectives. The group plans to search the Lone Pine country and Manhattan for John Lavin, Mrs. Ayres's alleged former husband, who Ayres believes is alive in Colorado and in possession of Bender family keepsakes.

Waterbury Democrat · 13 August 1901 · page 1

Being Run to Earth. Fort Collins, Col. Aug 13. Frank Ayres, formerly a resident of this place, who claims that his wife is Kate Bender, is here, as he said, to secure more - evidence against the alleged Benders. He was accompanied by two men who are supposed to be detectives from Kansas. They will go to the Lone Pine country and Manhattan, as Ayres states, to trace up the where abouts of John Lavin. who was once married to Mrs Ayres. It is asserted that Mrs Ayres says Lavin is dead but Ayres claims : to have information to the effect that he is located in Colo rado. Lavin, so Ayres says, has In his possession some keepsakes that be longed to the Bender family.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Frank Ayres, who claims his wife is Kate Bender, traveled with two supposed Kansas detectives into the Lone Pine and Manhattan area to find John Lavin, Mrs. Ayres's former husband. Ayres believes Lavin, despite reports of his death, is alive in Colorado and possesses keepsakes once belonging to the Bender family.

The Topeka State Journal · 13 August 1901 · page 6

Fort Collins, Colo., Aug. 13. Frank Ayres, formerly a resident of this place, who claims that his wife is Kate Bender, arrived here and immediately started for the mountains, as he said, to secure more evidence against the alleged Benders. He was accompanied by two men who are supposed to be de tectives from Kansas. They will go in to the Lone Pine country, and Manhat tan, as Ayres states to trace up the whereabouts of John Lavin, who was once married to Mrs. Ayres. It is said that Mrs. Ayres says that Lavin is dead, but Ayres claims to have infor mation to the effect that he is located in Colorado. Lavin, so Ayres says, ha3 in his possession some keepsakes that belonged to the Bender family.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Frank Ayers, claiming his wife is Kate Bender, travels to Colorado with two suspected detectives to gather more evidence against the alleged Benders. He seeks John Lavin, his wife's former husband, who reportedly possesses Bender family keepsakes and may be alive despite claims of his death.

The Indianapolis Journal · 14 August 1901 · page 5

Seeking the Heilder family. FORT COLLINS. Col.. Aug. 13. Frank Ayers. formerly a resident of this place, who claims that Iiis wife :s Kate Bender, arrivtd here and Immediately startet! for the mountains, as he said, to secure more evidence against the alleged Benders. He was accompanied by two men who are sup posed to be detectives from Kansas. They will go to the Lone Pin,, countrv and Man hattan, as Ayres states, to trace up the whereabouts of John Lavln, who was once married to Mrs. Ayres. It is said that Mrs. Ayres Fays that Lavln is dead, but Ayres claims to have Information to the effect that he in located In Colorado. Lavin. so Ayre says, has in hH possession some keepsakes that belonged to the Bender family.

See the clipping

The Adair County News · Columbia, Ky.

Governor Stanley of Kansas granted a requisition to Colorado for four people believed to be the Bender family, wanted for a string of murders in the 1870s. Witnesses who traveled to Colorado identified them as Charles Read and family, with one claiming the woman was the notorious Kate Bender, his former wife.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 16 days later. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Minneapolis Journal, 8 August 1901, The Butler Weekly Times, 8 August 1901, Durango Semi-Weekly Herald, 12 August 1901.

Wrong

The Adair County News · 14 August 1901 · page 1

I granted a requisition on the Governor of Colorado for four persons who arc beiicvad by reputable cittzns of La bette and Montgomery counties to be the notorious Benders gctJifri d of 37 murders in Kansas in 187r The af fidavits upon which theVtquisition was granted were made by E M Dack TB Smith V A Monejhtmd and M E Sparks who went to Colorado es pecially to see the four suspected per sons The steps to bring the suspected ones to Kansas are taken upon the representation of Frank Ayers of Ft Collins Colo who claims that he knows them and the notorious Kate Bender was once his wife He says that they live at Ft Col lins Colo where the father and moth er are known as Charles Read and wife and the two children as William Baker and May Baker He says the old man is about 79 years of age and his wife about five or six years younger The other two he says are about fifty In 1871 the Benders lived in Labette county Kas near Cherryvale The family consisted of William Bender aged about CO his wife aged about 54 Kate aged about 25 and John aged perhaps 23 Kate and John were children of William Bender by a form er wife The house was a frame 1Gx 19 feet and fronted north There was a door at either end and the room was divided by a canvass partition drawn tightly over upright scantlings This partition was the deathtrap The victims nearly all travelers were decoyed to a seat close against the canvass and Kate did the rest Every mjjn they killed had a hors but pnl JtWQ animals the family took tp the farm were found after the

See the clipping

The Adair County News · Columbia, Ky.

This report describes the Bender family's killing method, detailing the canvas-partitioned deathtrap room where victims were seated and murdered, with hammers and throat-cutting as the means. It recounts how Dr. York's murder investigation prompted the family's flight, noting rewards offered but the murderers never caught.

The Adair County News · 14 August 1901 · page 1

mers III sTqe murdcr of Dr York of Ft Scott a prominent dentist led to an Investigation that caused the Benders L to flee Rewards aggregating 810000 were offered for them but they have 1 1not been apprehended It Dazzles the World No discovery in medicine has ever

See the clipping

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

Frank Ayres of Fort Collins, who believes his wife is the notorious Kate Bender, heads into the mountains with two men said to be Kansas detectives to gather more evidence. He seeks John Lavin, Mrs. Ayres's former husband, who allegedly possesses keepsakes from the Bender family and whose whereabouts are disputed.

The St. Louis Republic · 14 August 1901 · page 10

SEARCHING FOR THE BENDERS.

Colorado Man Still Insists His Wife Was Kate Bender. Fort Collins. Colo.. Aug. Ji Fttuik Ayres. formerly a resident of this place, who claims that his wife Is Kate Bender.

See the clipping

The Guthrie Daily Leader · Guthrie, Okla.

Frank Ayres, who claims his wife is Kate Bender, has set out for the Colorado mountains with two supposed Kansas detectives to find more evidence about the alleged Benders. He says he is tracking a man named Lavin, once married to his wife, who allegedly possesses keepsakes belonging to the Bender family.

The Guthrie Daily Leader · 14 August 1901 · page 3

THE BENDER FAMILY FAKE.

Has Been Revived by a Notoriety Seek-Ino-Kansan. By Associated Press. Fort Collins, Cole. Aug. 14. -Frank Ayres, who asserts that his wife Is Kate Bender, has started for ths mountains, as he said, to secure more evidence against the alleged Benders. He is accompanied by two men sup posed to be detectives from Kansas. They will go Into the Looe Pine coun try, as Ayres states, to trace up the whereabouts of Larln who was once married to Mrs. Ayors. Mis Awi .1 serfs Lavin in In (.'oloimlo l..r, hi so Ayera says, has In bin iiosueHnlon some keepsakes that belonged to the Bender family.

See the clipping

The Goodland Republic · Goodland, Kan.

Frank Ayres, who says his wife is Kate Bender, arrived in Fort Collins, Colorado, from Kansas and headed to the mountains to gather more evidence against the alleged Benders. He was accompanied by two men believed to be detectives from Kansas.

The Goodland Republic · 16 August 1901 · page 3

Still After the "Bender." Fort Collins, -Col-, Aug. 14. Frank Ayres, who claims that his wife is Kate Bender, arrived here from Kan sas yesterday and immediately started for the mountains, as he said, to se cure more evidence against the al leged Benders. lie was accompanied! by two men who are supposed to be detectives from Kansas.

See the clipping

The Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon

The report claims that the notorious Bender family of serial murderers has finally been captured and is being extradited from Colorado to Kansas to stand trial, decades after their killing spree along the Osage Trail. It recounts the background of their crimes, describing how they lured travelers to a roadside inn and murdered them for robbery.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 24 days later.

Wrong

The Morning Astorian · 21 August 1901 · page 4

The Bender family are comprise 1 of William Bender and wife, his son Jtvi aird daughter Kate. The children were by a former wife of old man Bender. They were of German descent. Early in 1S70 the Bendsr came to Kinsas and took possession of a quarter section of land, the title of which was clouded. It was Wcated near here and in thick woods. It fronted the public road, iheo a maha trail' to the West. Home seekers from the East were forcd to pass alornr this trail In their search of unoccupied land oul West further.

See moreSee less

If this road had not been such a public one the crimes of thts noted fami'.v would bav been less. But It is suppose! that murder "was contem plated when they erected a rude log hut along the trail, at the top of hill. Their plans were well laid. Travellers arriving at this rude log hut were told that It was a tavern for their accommodation. Kate Bender, then a yaong. woman of thirty, qutte good looking for a farmer's daughter of the hardy West, used to beguile the weary travellers to stopv over night. That was the last ever seen of them by tbeir Iriends. Once having entered the Bender tavern a man's fate was sealed. The dining room of the Bender plsce was built orer a cellar Into which the victims were thrown, after having been murdered. It is claimed that ome were buried alive, the first blow not having betn fatal. No attention was paid by the blood-thirsty murderers to a mat ter like rhat. The method generally employed by the Benders In killing their victims was to hit them In the head with an axe. Kate Bender ani her brother John, being

See the clipping

The Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon

This retrospective account describes the Bender family's murder method—luring guests to meals, striking them with an axe, and dropping bodies through a trap door into a cellar, later burying victims in a cornfield. It also recounts the abandoned Bender homestead becoming a local, feared ruin slowly stripped away by passersby.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

The Morning Astorian · 21 August 1901 · page 4

1 1 onVers as to their identity m where abouts. If the time was not opportune that is, if the gut-st did not place himself in a handy pla'.-e for being slauifh'.er-d dur ing the meal he was attended to lat-r n in the night. The beds were ea h t'lced over a trap door, ani. after hav ing retired, the Benders -drop-d 'he trip, and when their victim fell into ; darkness of the cellar he was killed it; hand-to-hand battle. No on -' ever visited th Ren Jer horn and e.-v-ap-l t t--l!

See moreSee less

the tal--. Lik.. i ;i-'n galiows, every man who .vt l..s foil I-side was doomed from ha: v--y moment. Tv,.- horrors of the 'Times Ahl'h ha.---been comniitte In the B-n 1 r hoirn have so Instilled the pe 'I'1J of this sec tion with fear that even todjy th- ;i!i'- s--i ds idle, gradually rolling away. Tin store building, whk-h tvas ts-d t)- the Benders as a meana of get -iris Pi'ile to stop at their place more than for 'he profits they made in -elliry K od-, has ben bur.ed, but the ; ,g l.u: stands back In a clump of, -re's 'jiim -;--sted. Once In a while a t'aveller .lines along, and, not knowing .ho 'a' that followed his previous teliowv. s'. jis over nlghr, camping In tbe hut, he r.'.xt l.iy carrying away a rart 'f it f' kin-lilng wool. In a few in ire yejt. tn.-re will be nothing left of it. When the Benders first startnl on their murderous mission they founl t.v surrounding country well adapt -1 :o making a murdor trap out of the horr. -. The country had but lately been va-a -ed by the Osage Indians and the to--punchers and greasers ran at large ki.l lng any one who they thought ).., money. That Is why suspicion win t cent-red upon the Benders for s-im time. The Benders sjaw the society in to which they had fallen, and plann-d to make a murder trap of their place result of the seore; Inquiry Ju;io Jerome lias be.-n conduct Ink In :h,' .im of The Peop!.- of the State rf X.-w York against Klward O. ;i,v iion and others," .wording to the Times. Ju t i-e Jerom,. has practically concluded tlii' stvtvt sessions In this i-. al though he unnoutve.l ;h.j he w 'uid cntinue to V.ear any witnesses that th;-Jiscl.-t tttorney wishetl cxaml te N' fore him In any matter relating to Ed gar A. Wh!lm" cenf-'sslon.

See the clipping

The Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon

This article, written decades after the events, describes how the Benders lured travelers like Dr. York and Anna Koran to their Kansas farm and killed them with axes, hiding bodies in the cellar and orchard. It claims over fifty skeletons were found during the 1873 excavation, with old-timers believing the true toll reached one hundred victims.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 25 days later.

Wrong

The Morning Astorian · 21 August 1901 · page 4

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A Black correspondent from Augusta, Kansas sent a scrap of black ribbon to the governor's office, claiming it came from a vigilance committee member who witnessed the Benders buried alive. The sender claimed the ribbon was taken from Kate Bender's head, which he said was 'still libbin'.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 17 days later.

Wrong

The Topeka State Journal · 28 August 1901 · page 8

An Augusta, Kan., negro sent Luther Burns of the governor's office a two inch piece of wornout black ribbon and with it the information that he was tie of the vigilance committee that saw the old lady, John and old man Bender buried alive till they were dead, dead, dead. The ribbon is supposed to be from the present head of Kate Bender who, according to the Augusta man, is

See the clipping

The Holly Chieftain · Holly, Colo.

A Fort Collins, Colorado report describes Frank Ayres and his wife reconciling after he had accused her of being Kate Bender, a charge she had tried to fight with lunacy and libel proceedings. Despite affidavits from Kansas supporting the accusation, the couple reconciled through the intervention of a prominent local figure.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 16 days earlier.

The Holly Chieftain · 30 August 1901 · page 6

Sequel of Alleged Bender Case

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping