As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

September 1901

12 articles

In the story →

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

A relative of Dr. William York, whose disappearance triggered the hunt for the Bender family, is interviewed in St. Louis about the old case amid a fresh rumored sighting of Kate Bender. He recounts his brother's fatal 1870s journey and his own role in the posse that found the body buried in the Bender garden.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 11 days earlier.

Wrong

The St. Louis Republic · 1 September 1901 · page 39 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

RELATIVE OF A BENDER VICTIM REVIEWS OLD CRIME.

WRITTEN FOR THE SUNDAY REPUBLIC.

See moreSee less

Although it is a fact generally settled in the public mind that the infamous quartet of murderers, the Bender family, have been tracked down, one of the family is occasionally "discovered" living under an assumed name in some part of the country. The latest report of this kind is the recent alleged discovery of Kate Bender in California, where she is supposed to have been seen and recognized by a man who knew her in Kansas.

Since this reported discovery of Kate Bender the fact has come to light that there is living at the present time in St. Louis a brother of Doctor York, the last victim of the Benders, and the man whose murder led to their flight and to the facts concerning the series of cruel murders they committed.

This man is Julius H. York, a railroad emigrant agent, of No. 3833 Russell avenue. Mr. York recalls all of the details in connection with the brutal murder of his brother and of the subsequent discovery of his dead body, which was buried in the Bender garden. He himself was a member of the posse which pursued the family. When seen at his home recently Mr. York consented to tell the story of the Benders and of their last murder, that of his brother.

Doctor W. A. York Began His Fatal Journey in March, 1875.

"It was in the month of March, 1875, that my brother, Doctor W. A. York, left his home in Fort Scott, Kas., to go to the home of his parents in Independence," said Mr. York. "He traveled on horseback and was mounted on one of the finest animals that was ever brought into the State of Kansas. The horse was one which was ridden by him during the four years of his service as surgeon in the army. It was a fine animal, and in those days, when good horses commanded a high price, was worth quite a figure. When my brother left his house he gave his wife some money, together with his gold watch, as he did not feel altogether safe with the valuables on his person.

"About three weeks before my brother commenced his journey one of his neighbors in Fort Scott had borrowed his wagon, and, together with his little daughter, had gone on a trip the route of which had taken them in the same direction which he intended to take in his journey to Independence. The man and his daughter had been gone some two or three weeks, and as nothing had been heard from them since their departure their absence was causing much comment. As my brother rode away he remarked that he feared his neighbor had met with foul play, and that he intended to make inquiry about him along the road.

"With that remark he rode away. Some three weeks passed before our family began to grow suspicious regarding his unexplained absence. His wife thought that he had arrived at Independence, and our family supposed that he had not yet left his home at Fort Scott. Letters were finally exchanged, however, and his mysterious disappearance at once became known. Search was instituted to ascertain his whereabouts. A party composed of my two brothers, Edward and Colonel A. M. York; myself and quite a number of others, went to Fort Scott and took up the route which my brother had taken. We followed him until we got within fifteen miles of Independence, when we could find no further trace of him. The last news we learned of him was at the house just the other side of the Bender home, where the family living there remembered seeing him. All trace of him was here abruptly lost. The Benders, when questioned, professed to know nothing about him. We did not at that time suspect them of any knowledge of his disappearance.

Bender Family Fled While The Search Was in Progress.

"As we passed on and commenced our search in another direction. A week or so passed, and the neighbors of the Benders commenced to notice something wrong around the Bender premises. Not a member of the family had been seen since our visit there, and the stock at the place was uncared for. A horse and cow lariated out in the yard had eaten a circular plot of grass in which they were tethered bare to the ground, and had evidently had no water for several days. An investigation was made. Some of the neighbors called at the house and found the doors locked. The Benders had escaped.

"This fact was reported to us and our suspicions were at once aroused. We went to the Bender home, broke down the doors of the house and entered. What we found there has been told over and over again. We saw the blood stains upon the wall and found the fatal trap-door. We saw the black curtain which hung behind the chairs at the dining table, and behind which Kate Bender had stood with hammer in hand when she beat out the brains of the victims who were decoyed into the house and seated at the table.

"In the cellar under the trap-door we found blood upon the walls and floor, but there was no further trace of any crimes. We were certain that we had located the place where Doctor York had disappeared, and accordingly commenced a search of the premises. One of the party passed through the garden near the house, and noticed a sunken spot in the ground which looked like a grave. Going to our wagon, he took out the end rod and stuck it in the top of the sunken place. It struck something hard a short distance below the surface, and a spade was secured. After a few moments' work we uncovered the body of Doctor York, which had been crowded into a small box. His head had been beaten with a hammer and the features were almost unrecognizable.

"After this discovery we continued our digging, and the result was that we unearthed seven other bodies, two of which were the bodies of my brother's neighbor and his little daughter. They had been buried in the same grave. The whole neighborhood at once formed itself into an armed posse and the search for the missing Benders was commenced.

Members of the Family Were Traced to Walnut.

"We traced them to the small town of Walnut, a few miles distant, where they had driven in a covered wagon. They had left their team and wagon tied in the streets and had then boarded a train. We were never able to find any further trace of them. Stories that have been told and retold about their being caught on the banks of a small stream in Indian Territory, and of their being killed and buried there, are all false. Nobody ever heard of the Benders after they boarded the train at Walnut. True, they have been reported found a thousand times since, but the stories are not true. Of course, I have my own theory as to what became of them, but it is merely a theory.

"In disposing of the plunder which they got from their victims, it is my theory that they had a string of confederates all the way from Kansas to Indian Territory. When their exposure was brought about they fled to some of these confederates. When the search for them became too hot they were killed by their confederates to avoid exposure. I am certain that Kate Bender escaped, and may be living to-day. About twelve years ago I was in Chicago, and was on board a street car when I saw the face of a woman I am absolutely certain was Kate Bender. Before the car could be stopped she had disappeared.

"I knew all the members of the Bender family well. I stopped at the house a number of times, and talked with all of them. The family consisted of four persons: Old man Bender, his wife, Kate, the daughter, and a son, John. They looked like criminals. Kate was a tall, angular type of woman, with the hardest face I ever saw. She was as strong and muscular as a man. The old woman was gray-haired and her eyes were set far back in her head, giving her a wicked expression. John, the son, looked to be a villainous character. The old man was rarely seen around the place.

"The fine horse which my brother rode was never seen again, and probably was disposed of by the Benders through their confederates. I have often thought that robbery may not have been the motive for which he was killed. He may have made inquiries about his missing neighbor, which led to his murder. The Benders may have killed him to allay suspicion of former crimes. My brother's widow and son are now living in Southern Texas." JULIUS H. YORK.

See the clipping

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

Investigators tracing a missing man's last known movements found his trail went cold near the Bender homestead, though the Benders denied any knowledge of him. Days later, neighbors noticed the Bender property abandoned and the livestock neglected, prompting a formal investigation.

The St. Louis Republic · 1 September 1901 · page 39

VICTIM REVIEWS OLD CRIME. when we could find no further trace of him The last .news wa learned of him was at the house Just the other side of the Bender

See the clipping

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

A searcher describes finding the Bender home abandoned after the family fled, with blood-stained walls and a trap door leading to a cellar where victims were killed. The party also located Dr. York's body buried in a shallow grave in the orchard after probing suspicious ground.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.

Wrong

The St. Louis Republic · 1 September 1901 · page 39

to grow suspicious .regarding his unex plained absence. His wife thought that he had arrived at Independence, and our farnJ . Ily supposed that he had not ret left his .home st" Fort Scott. Letters were finally -. excaangsd.. however, and his mysterious dl- . appearance at once became' known. Search was Instituted to ascertain his whereabouts. .A pertr roroposed of my two brothers.- Ed- . y ward and Colonel A. '31. York; myself 'and " quits a number of others, went to 3Tort- ' Scott and took up the route which my .

See moreSee less

brother had taken. We followed him .until --rs got within fifteen rail of Independence. -sJ l.i mffifji EverybodyIn -Erie County knew that this will would reveal the secret of the old plo neer'j cherished "plan," and everybody was curious to know what that plan would bouse and found the doors locked. The Benders had escaped. "This fact was reported to us and our suspicions were at once aroused. We went to the Bender home, broke down the doors of the house and entered. What we found there has been told over and over again. We saw the blood stains upon the wall ana found the fatal trap-door. We saw the black curtain which hung behind the chairs at the dining table, and behind which Kate

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Decades after the Bender murders, an aging Black Hills scout named Pierce relates a secondhand story from a now-dead friend who had joined the 24-man posse that searched the abandoned Bender roadhouse. The article frames this tale as proof that authorities need search no further for the vanished Bender family.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 24 days later.

Wrong

Paper unidentified · 14 September 1901 · page 2

All the Murderers. BE. I. Pierce, move familiarly knowa as “Dod” Dierce, one of the oldest and most reliable Indian scouts of the Black Hilly, has given out a story about the Bender fmanily, of Kansas, which seems to show that there is ro further need of the authorities search ing for the family. Plerce is a reliable man, and for the first time le tells what he knows of the case. He had a friend in the 70s, who was also well known in the Black Hilly, and before the friend died ho related to Plerce the incidents relative to the killing of all the members of the Bender family.

See moreSee less

When the York family was killed and the tragedy was traced to the home of the Benders, Plerce’s friend was among those from the city of Cherryvale who went out to investi gate the condition of things at the Bender roadhouse. There were twen ty-four men in the party, one of the men being an old buffalo hunter. They found the house deserted and in gearching the house the bedstead im the west room, about which so much has been said, was found to be full of bullet holes, and dried blood was on the mattress. They found the trap door behind the curtain, which led into the cellar, into which the dead bodies had been thrown until dark, when they were taken out into the garden “and buried. The searching party next went out into the garden and looked for the spot where the bodies had been buried, A wagon rod was used to probe the ground for a soft place, and finally a spot was found that was soft. After

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

An old buffalo hunter named Doc Pierce reveals, twenty years after the fact, a story confided to him about a posse from Cherryvale tracking the fleeing Bender family to a creek and ambushing them. The posse allegedly shot and killed old man Bender, John, the mother, and Kate, then burned the bodies and buried the remains and wagon gear.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Morning Astorian, 21 August 1901, The Topeka State Journal, 28 August 1901.

Paper unidentified · 14 September 1901 · page 2

suggest,” : When Jessie Pallama descended to digging dowp a short way the body of one of the York children wag found and the contortions of the face and body made it look as though the child had been buried alive. Ffteen bodies were found, including that of a Texas cattleman who was supposed to have been shot in the west room, The old Buffalo hunter /had been lookjug ‘around for the” trail of the family, The trail of a wagon was found and the buffalo hunter followed it up all day.

See moreSee less

About nightfall he came upon the family, camped near a creek. The scout returned to the party of Cherryvale men and reported his find. They agreed upon going back with the cout and exterminating the entire family, The posse was divided into three parts, aud the Bender family was surrounded. One of the posse accidentally discharged his rifle before the proper time, which gave the warn ing of danger to the Bender people. They immediately prepared for de fence. The buffalo hunter fired at long range at old man Bender and hit him in the back, killing him, Another volley from the posse and John and his mother fell dead. Kate was the last one to be shot. The posse then went to the scene and piled the four dead bodies in a heap and burned them, adding to the fire wagon, harness and the camp outfit, Everything that would not burn was taken to the creek bank and covered over with dirt, This is the story that “Doc” Plerce tells for the first time since his friend confided the facts to him twenty years ago. The story that Kate Bender came to the Black Hills geveral years ago and mode her residence in Dead wood, South Dakota, is not credited there, A woman did go there about fifteen years ago that had some re semblance to the famous Kate, 80 gome of the old-timers say.—New

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A searcher's account describes finding the Bender house full of bullet holes, blood, and fifteen buried bodies in the garden, including a Texas cattleman. It then relates 'Doc' Pierce's twenty-year-old secret story that a posse tracked the fleeing Bender family, surrounded them, and shot all four dead before burning the bodies and wagon.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Paper unidentified · 14 September 1901 · page 2

BENDER FAMILY FATE.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Decades after the Bender murders, a St. Louis newspaper interviews Julius York, brother of Dr. William York, the Benders' last victim, whose disappearance triggered their exposure and flight. The piece also notes persistent rumors of Bender family members being spotted alive under assumed names, including a recent alleged sighting of Kate Bender in California.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 14 days earlier.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 15 September 1901 · page 9

Since this reported discoverey of Kate Bender the fact has come to light that there la living at the present time In St. Louis a brother of Doctor York, the last victim of the Benders, and the man whose murder led to their flight and to the facts concerning the series of cruel murders they committed. This man 13' Julius If. York, a rail road emigrant agent, of No. 3KC Russell Avenue. Mr. York recalls all of the de tails In connection with the brutal mur der of his brother and >f the subsequent discovery of his dead body, which was burled In the Bender garden.

See moreSee less

He himself w«» a member of the posse which pursued the family. When seen at his home recently Mr. York consented to tell the story of the Benders ami of their last murder, that of his brother. Doctor W A York’s Fatal Journey in March, 1875. * "It was In the month of March. IS73. that my brother. Doctor W. A. York, left his home In Port Scott. Kas.. to go to the home of his parents In independence," said Mr. York. "He traveled on horse back and was mounted on one of the fluent animals that was ever brought Into the State of Kansas. The horse was one w ill' h Was ridden by him during the four yea. of his service as surgeon in the army. It was a tine animal, and In thoSa days, when good horses commanded u

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

A brother of Dr. York recounts how a search party traced him to the Bender homestead, found it abandoned, and eventually discovered his body and seven others buried on the property. The account describes locating a hammer, bloodstains in the cellar, and digging up the victims' remains.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Morning Astorian, 21 August 1901, The St. Louis Republic, 1 September 1901, Paper unidentified, 14 September 1901.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 15 September 1901 · page 9

tits disappearance. Bender Family Fled. “So wp passed ‘ H and commenced our search ir. another direction. A week 01 so passed. it’d fh'' neighbors of the Ben dtr.s comm1 m < •! to notice somethin; mi I i b Bender premise*. No urong h family had been seei a mcmb since our visit tic-re. and the stock a the place whs uncarsd lor. A horse an cow lariated «>i;t in the yard hud cate a circular l>l"t ol mhict' the were tether-d » r° the* ground. an

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

A man recounts finding blood in the Bender cabin cellar and then discovering buried bodies in the garden, including Dr. York's, after probing a sunken grave site. He describes the family fleeing by train from Walnut and offers his own theory that confederates killed the Benders, while claiming he later spotted Kate Bender alive in Chicago.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 15 September 1901 · page 9

burled In the same grave. The whole Jbr . neighborhood at once formed Itself Into an armed posse and the search for the missing Benders was commenced. Members of Family Traced to Walnut ‘We traced them te the small town of Walnut,, a few miles dipt ant. where they had driven lu a covered wagon. They had left their team and wagon tied In the streets and had then boarded a train. We were never able to And any further trace of them. Stories that have been told and retold about their being caught on the banks of a small stream In In dian Territory, and of their being killed and burled there, are all false.

See moreSee less

Nobody ever heard of the Benders after they hoarded the train at Walnut. Trite, they have been reported found a thousand times since, but the stories are not true. Of course I have my own Ihery as to what became of them ,but It la merely a theory. "In disposing of the plunder which they got fiom their victims, u la mv theory that they had a string of confed erates all the way from Kansas to In dian Trrrltory. When their exposure was b-might about they fled to some 0f these confederates. When the search for them became too hot they were killed by their confederates to avoid exposure. I am certain that Kate Bender escaped, and may be living today. About twelve years ago I was In Chicago, and was on hoard a street car when I saw the face of a wo man I am absolutely certain was Kate Bender. Before tho cur could be stopped she had disappeared. "I knew all the members of the Bender family well. I stopped at the house a ruimoer of times, and talked with all them. The family constated of fotnr per sons: Old man Bender, his wife, Kate, the daughter, and a son. John. They looked like criminals. Kate was a tall, angular type of woman with the hardest face I ever saw. She was as strong and muscular as a man. The old woman was

See the clipping

The Lamar Register · Lamar, Colo.

A Fort Collins dispatch reports that Frank Ayres has filed for divorce from his wife, alleging she is actually Kate Bender and was still married to another man when he wed her in 1898. Ayres denies accusations that he is mentally deranged for making the claim.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Lamar Register · 18 September 1901 · page 7

A Fort Collins dispatch of Septemlier Utli says: "In the County Court here to-day Frank Ayres, who has lioen quite prominent in the press of late in consequence of ids allegations that ills wife is Kate Bender, began suit for di vorce against Ids wife. Ayres’ grounds for asking n divorce Is that when lie married her In Larimer City, in 1808. she was already the wife of John Lavin, whom she married in INKS. He asks that the marriage be set aside and divorce granted. Tho at torneys for the plaiutilT are Garhutt A Garhutt of Fort Collins and Judge K.

See moreSee less

A. Ballard of Denver. Since Ayres returned from Kansas lie has been* liv ing at the Owl Canon ranch, and has lioen evidently endeavoring to make some kind of a settlement with ids wife. It Is understood that lie has deeded her some water rights for her Manhattan ranch. Ayres is somewhat resentful of the charges by some that ids mind Is deranged. He' indignantly COLORADO NOTES. There is nn active movement In Colo rado Springs to establish regular Chautauqua grounds in the Garden of the Gods. The Fire and Police Board of Den ver have decided to prohibit prize fighting and have given the chief of police instructions to prevent tlie giv ing of any prize-fight in the city. On Saturday night, September Btli, the llallaek block at the corner of Kigliteeuth and Market streets in Don er was destroyed by lire. Loss, nearly SIOO,OOO.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A Fort Collins dispatch reports that Frank Ayres has filed for divorce from his wife, whom he has publicly alleged is the notorious Kate Bender. His grounds are bigamy, claiming she was already married to another man when she wed him in 1898; Ayres denies rumors that he is mentally unstable.

Paper unidentified · 20 September 1901 · page 3

‘they have authority to supervise the ‘exlwmllture of such money it is 'thought no serious objection to the idea will be interposed. It is the aim ‘of Captain Thatcher that the courty ‘boards shall vote for the appropi.a ‘tions this fall so they may be included fn the tax levy next spring. He desires also that a Colorado state building shall be erected at St. Louis of such a character that it may remain as a permanent feature. Such a structure, it is estimated, would cost about $60,- 000. A Fort Collins dispatch of September 11th says: “In the County Court here to-day Frank Ayres, who has been quite prominent in the press of late in consequence of his allegations that his wife is Kate Bender, began suit for di vorce against his wife.

See moreSee less

Ayres’ grounds for asking a divorce is that when he married her in Larimer City, in 1808, she was already the wife of John Lavin, whom she married in 1888, He asks that the marriage be set aslde and divorce granted. The at torneys for the plaintiff are Garbutt & Garbutt of Fort Collins and Judge E. A, Ballard of Denver. Since Ayres returned from Kansas he has been liv ing at the Owl Canon ranch, and has been evidently endeavoring to make some kind of a settlement with his

See the clipping

The Springfield Herald · Springfield, Colo.

A Fort Collins dispatch reports that Frank Ayres has filed for divorce from his wife, alleging she is actually Kate Bender who was already married to John Bavin at the time of their 1898 marriage. Ayres denies rumors that he is mentally deranged and insists he is sane.

The Springfield Herald · 20 September 1901 · page 3

It is estimated, would cost about SUO,- (HIO. A Fort Collins dispatch of September lltli says: "In the County Court here to-day Frank Ayres, who lias lieen quite prominent in the press of late in consequence of his allegutions that his wife is Kate Bender, began suit for di vorce * against ills wife. Ayres’ grounds for asking a divorce is that when lie married her in Barimer City, iu IS9S. she was already the wife of John Bavin, whom she married in INKS. He asks that the marriage be set aside and divorce granted.

See moreSee less

Tlio at torneys for the plaintiff are Garbutt & Garlmtt <>f Kort Collins and Judge E. A. Ballard of Deliver. Since Ayres returned from Kansas he has been liv ing at the Owl Canon ranch, and has been evidently endeavoring to make seme kind of a settlement with his wifi*. It is understood that lie lias deeded her some water rights for her Manhattan ranch. Ayres is somewhat resentful of the charges by some Hint ids mind is deranged. He indignantly denies these charges, and says that he in us sane as anybody.” COLORADO NOTES. There Is an active movement in Colo rado Springs to establish regular Chautauqua grounds in the Garden of the Gods. The Fire and Police Board of Den ver have decided to prohibit prize fighting nr.d have given the chief of police instructions to prevent the giv ing of any prize-fight In the city. On Saturday night, September Stli, J

See the clipping