As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders

As the Papers Told It

The Wichita City Eagle, 15 May 1873The Andrew County Republican, 7 May 1875The Van Buren Press, 15 May 1877The Iola Register, 8 November 1889

Original newspaper accounts, 1873–1910

May 1873 – August 191046 newspaper articles in the story, 1,156 in the full archive

In May 1873 searchers at a roadside house in Labette County, Kansas, dug up eight bodies, among them Dr. York, brother of a Kansas state senator, and a child of eighteen months. The family that had kept the house, a German couple, their son and their daughter, who advertised that she could heal the sick, had been gone some weeks.

For nearly forty years the papers caught the Benders again and again: in Iowa, Utah, Texas and South Carolina, in an old couple jailed at Fremont, Nebraska, in 1880, in two women brought from Michigan to Oswego in 1889. Others said a posse had killed them in 1873, and no two accounts of their end agreed.

The numbers

1,156newspaper articles
1,237printings
412newspapers
50states and territories
448months in the papers

Each article is counted once, however many papers ran it. Printings counts every paper that ran it, so an article reprinted in five papers is one article and five printings.

How much the papers printed

Month of 1 May 1873: 85 printingsMonth of 1 June 1873: 18 printingsMonth of 1 July 1873: 16 printingsMonth of 1 August 1873: 4 printingsMonth of 1 September 1873: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1873: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1873: 8 printingsMonth of 1 January 1874: 3 printingsMonth of 1 February 1874: 5 printingsMonth of 1 March 1874: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1874: 12 printingsMonth of 1 May 1874: 11 printingsMonth of 1 June 1874: 4 printingsMonth of 1 August 1874: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1875: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1875: 2 printingsMonth of 1 May 1875: 2 printingsMonth of 1 October 1875: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1876: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1876: 3 printingsMonth of 1 April 1876: 11 printingsMonth of 1 May 1876: 4 printingsMonth of 1 November 1876: 3 printingsMonth of 1 December 1876: 6 printingsMonth of 1 January 1877: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1877: 22 printingsMonth of 1 May 1877: 16 printingsMonth of 1 June 1877: 2 printingsMonth of 1 July 1877: 3 printingsMonth of 1 August 1877: 2 printingsMonth of 1 September 1877: 2 printingsMonth of 1 May 1879: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1879: 19 printingsMonth of 1 October 1879: 2 printingsMonth of 1 March 1880: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1880: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1880: 270 printingsMonth of 1 September 1880: 3 printingsMonth of 1 October 1880: 6 printingsMonth of 1 July 1881: 1 printingMonth of 1 April 1882: 4 printingsMonth of 1 January 1883: 3 printingsMonth of 1 June 1883: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1883: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1883: 2 printingsMonth of 1 December 1883: 4 printingsMonth of 1 February 1884: 2 printingsMonth of 1 September 1884: 21 printingsMonth of 1 October 1884: 12 printingsMonth of 1 November 1884: 2 printingsMonth of 1 December 1884: 11 printingsMonth of 1 January 1885: 4 printingsMonth of 1 February 1885: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1885: 3 printingsMonth of 1 May 1885: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1885: 5 printingsMonth of 1 January 1886: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1886: 1 printingMonth of 1 June 1886: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1886: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1887: 4 printingsMonth of 1 February 1888: 3 printingsMonth of 1 April 1888: 9 printingsMonth of 1 June 1888: 3 printingsMonth of 1 October 1888: 4 printingsMonth of 1 November 1888: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1889: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1889: 11 printingsMonth of 1 November 1889: 142 printingsMonth of 1 December 1889: 4 printingsMonth of 1 January 1890: 6 printingsMonth of 1 April 1890: 12 printingsMonth of 1 May 1890: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1890: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1891: 22 printingsMonth of 1 August 1891: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1893: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1894: 3 printingsMonth of 1 March 1894: 1 printingMonth of 1 April 1895: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1895: 3 printingsMonth of 1 July 1896: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1896: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1897: 3 printingsMonth of 1 February 1897: 3 printingsMonth of 1 April 1897: 4 printingsMonth of 1 August 1897: 3 printingsMonth of 1 September 1897: 11 printingsMonth of 1 October 1897: 2 printingsMonth of 1 November 1897: 2 printingsMonth of 1 February 1898: 1 printingMonth of 1 April 1899: 2 printingsMonth of 1 May 1899: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1899: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1901: 60 printingsMonth of 1 August 1901: 45 printingsMonth of 1 September 1901: 13 printingsMonth of 1 October 1901: 4 printingsMonth of 1 November 1901: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1901: 3 printingsMonth of 1 March 1902: 16 printingsMonth of 1 April 1902: 3 printingsMonth of 1 June 1902: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1902: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1902: 2 printingsMonth of 1 October 1902: 1 printingMonth of 1 April 1903: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1903: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1904: 11 printingsMonth of 1 February 1905: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1906: 3 printingsMonth of 1 June 1907: 3 printingsMonth of 1 May 1908: 26 printingsMonth of 1 June 1908: 15 printingsMonth of 1 July 1908: 33 printingsMonth of 1 August 1908: 15 printingsMonth of 1 September 1908: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1909: 4 printingsMonth of 1 May 1909: 2 printingsMonth of 1 December 1909: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1910: 59 printingsMonth of 1 June 1910: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1910: 1 printing13 May 187315 May 187316 May 187329 May 18731 June 187319 July 187331 July 187319 December 18732 May 18748 May 18747 May 187525 April 187613 April 187715 May 18772 August 18807 August 18808 August 188010 August 188011 August 188014 August 188016 August 188017 August 18809 September 188411 November 188515 May 188613 October 188831 October 18896 November 18898 November 188927 November 188914 January 189016 July 189131 January 189716 February 189728 April 189723 July 19011 August 19012 August 19011 September 190112 March 19046 June 19074 June 190813 July 19086 May 191012 May 191028 August 191018731874187518761877187818791880188118821883188418851886188718881889189018911892189318941895189618971898189919001901190219031904190519061907190819091910270 printings in the month of 1 August 1880

Every printing of every article, by the month it ran. The marks under the line are the articles in the story below; red ones were wrong.

Where it was printed

FewerMore

Printings in 50 states. Most: Kansas (142), Missouri (67), Wisconsin (61). 67 printings could not be placed in a state.

How it unfolded

46 newspaper articles in 7 acts

Act One

Wholesale Murder

13–29 May 1873

On 12 May 1873 a wire from Parsons reported eight bodies found near where the body of Dr. York had been found, one of them a child of eighteen months. The family who had kept the house, a German couple with a son and a daughter, had left some weeks before and abandoned their team at Thayer. More than three thousand people came to see the place, some by special train, and the first report of a capture came within days.

Eight bodies on the Bender farm

A wire report from Parsons, Kansas, dated 12 May 1873: eight bodies, one a child of eighteen months, found ‘under the house of the Bender family’ in Labette County, near where Senator York’s brother was lately found. The family left, it says, about two weeks before. A fuller Kansas City Times dispatch in the set puts the graves in an orchard south of the house, and the flight about 7 April.

The Daily Phoenix · Columbia, S.C.

The Daily Phoenix · 13 May 1873 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Union but one or two will be represented. PARSONS, KANSAS, May 12.—Eight dead bodies, including one of a child eighteen months old, have been found under the house of the Bender family, thirteen miles West of here, in Labette County, and near which the body of Senator York's brother was recently found. The Bender family left the County about two weeks ago, but the excitement is so great and the determination to bring the guilty parties to justice so strong, that no effort will be spared to effect their arrest. WASHINGTON, May 12.—The schooner

See the clipping

Three thousand people at the graves

The Wichita paper reports three more graves found on Tuesday, over three thousand people on the ground and a special train of seven cars just arrived. Several people have been arrested, but the Benders have not been heard from, and large rewards are expected from the county and state. It passes on, as ‘reported, but uncertain’, a claim that the little girl was buried alive with her father.

The Wichita City Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The Wichita City Eagle · 15 May 1873 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THOSE MURDERERS. In another place we give an account of the murders committed at Cherryvale by the Bender family and others, as is supposed. Several parties have been arrested, but the Benders have not been heard from. Three more graves were discovered on Tuesday of this week. Over three thousand people were on the ground, and a special train had just arrived with seven cars filled with people. There was intense excitement all over the country, and a firm determination to ferret out the parties engaged in the murders. It is understood that large rewards will be offered by the county and state for the arrest of the assassins.

See moreSee less

Nearly all the bodies of the dead were terribly mutilated. It is reported, but uncertain, that the little girl was thrown alive into the grave with her father, as no marks of violence were found on her body. Taken all in all there are few parallels in history so dark and foul. It is to be earnestly hoped that the rewards will be sufficiently large to insure the capture of every fiend who may have had a hand in this bloody, fiendish work.

See the clipping

Captured in Texas, it is said

A single sentence in a Massachusetts paper: the Bender family, ‘supposed to be guilty’ of the Kansas murders, have, it is said, been captured in Texas. It is the first of many reported captures in the set, and none was ever confirmed: in 1901 a Goodland, Kansas, paper noted that suspects had never been identified as the Benders and the rewards had never been paid.

Worcester Daily Press · Worcester, Mass.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Worcester Daily Press · 16 May 1873 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The Bender family, supposed to be guilty of the horrid murders lately perpetrated in Kansas, have, it is said, been captured in Texas.

See the clipping

The family behind the grocery sign

A Kansas City Times dispatch from Coffeyville, reprinted in Montana, gives the fullest early account: a German family of four, professed Spiritualists, who kept a ‘Groceries’ sign and a trap door by the stove. They left about 7 April, leaving their team at Thayer. Nearly four weeks later their starved stock roused suspicion, and searchers found Dr. York’s grave in the orchard, then probed with an iron rod: eight bodies in all.

Helena Weekly Herald · Helena, Mont.

Helena Weekly Herald · 29 May 1873 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

THE KANSAS BUTCHERY. Special Dispatch to the Kansas City Times.

COFFEYVILLE, Kansas, May 9.—I have learned the following particulars of the Bender murders from John Keefers, who lives three miles west of Coffeyville, and who, in company with John M. Crowell, special agent of the Post Office Department, was at the scene of the horror:

See moreSee less

It seems that a family of German people named Bender, who pretended to be Spiritualists, were the perpetrators of this series of most damnable crimes on record. Mr. Keefers says the scene of the tragedy is one mile east and two miles south of Moorehead Station, and six miles northeast of Cherryvale. The house is situated in a beautiful valley, surrounded on the southeast and north by a range of low hills, and in fair view of the L. L. and G. Railroad and many farm houses, though not nearer than half a mile to any one. The house is about sixteen by twenty, shingle roof, and neither ceiled nor plastered.

THE BENDER FAMILY

Consisted of four persons—father, mother, son and daughter. The age of the father was sixty-three years, the mother sixty, son twenty-seven, and daughter twenty-four. The son is described as a strong and muscular man. The family are professed Spiritualists, and the daughter claims supernatural powers, in that she can heal the sick, restore sight to the blind, and also that she could give definite information of robberies, murders, etc.

The following is a copy of Miss Bender's advertisement:

Prof. Miss Kate Bender can heal all sorts of diseases; can cure blindness, fits, deafness, and all such diseases; also, deaf and dumbness. Residence, fourteen miles east of Independence, on the road from Independence to Osage Mission, one and one-half miles southeast af Morehead Station.

KATIE BENDER. June 18, 1872.

This "Katie" was a red faced young woman of exceedingly bad reputation. The following is

A PARTIAL LIST OF THE VICTIMS

Of this mysterious family. The last of them was Dr. York, of Independence, a highly respected citizen, whose mysterious disappearance created so much feeling that large parties went in search of him. He was traced to Bender's house, where they said he took dinner, and then left for Independence, but no suspicion rested upon them. But the weight of guilt was heavy, and the large number in search alarmed the family, and they left the house without removing anything, drove their team to Thayer and left it where it was taken a few days after by the sheriff of that county. It was about the 7th of April when they disappeared. They took the northward-bound train at Thayer. There being no suspicion resting upon these quiet, unobtrusive Germans, and they not having been very sociable and having but few visitors, it was not known that they had abandoned their home for nearly four weeks, and when the discovery was made it was found that their calves and hogs had starved to death in the lots. These discoveries at once awakened suspicion, and search was commenced in a small orchard 150 feet south of the house. The surface had been carefully plowed and harrowed by the Benders before their departure; but the body of Mr. York had been buried so recently that the heavy rains and time had settled the ground around the grave so that the outlines of the grave were distinctly visible, and a few hours' work unearthed these horrible crimes. Dr. York's body being found, further search was made by thrusting a sharp-pointed iron rod into the earth, which soon developed the fact that there were many more graves on this half acre of ground, and by nightfall

EIGHT BODIES IN ALL WERE EXHUMED,

Of which the following is a partial list, so far as they could be distinctly identified: W. F. McGrouty, of the 123d Illinois infantry, company D; —— Brown; Henry McKenzie, of Hamilton county, Indiana, and a Mr. Lonchore and his little girl. The latter had recently buried his wife, and was about starting to Iowa. The scene Thursday was too horrible to give even a faint description of. Seven bodies, in various stages of decomposition, were lying on the ground by the side of their open graves, their sculls broken in and their throats cut from ear to ear, except the girl, eighteen months old, who must have been strangled or else

THROWN INTO THE GRAVE ALIVE.

She was in full dress, as her grandmother had dressed her that morning. She was in the bottom of the grave and her father lying upon her. The child's body showed no marks of violence. The manner in which they accomplished these deeds was this: On the house was posted the sign "Groceries," but they kept nothing but some wines. This sign called in their victims. In the floor near the stove was a trap door, two feet square, which opens into a hole in the ground seven feet deep, six feet wide at the top and three at the bottom. The earth outside of the house does not show any sign of excavation. Into this horrible hole was plunged the unfortunate victims whom they murdered in daylight. The hammers used for breaking the skulls were such as are used by stone breakers on our streets, and the handles are about twenty inches long. Upon examination it was found that the skulls were all broken on the back and right side of the head, showing that the desperate deeds have all been done by a right-handed man. The bodies have all been identified but two. The Bender family have lived at this place for more than two years, yet all the bodies found have been killed within the last nine months, and the skill shown in this terrible work, and the neatness with which all traces of their crimes were blotted out, is the best evidence that their bloody work did not commence so recently. Several hundred persons were at the scene of horror yesterday and the excitement is intense. Every one is confident that half is not yet unearthed.

THE WORK OF SEARCHING

The premises still goes on, and what may yet be developed none can tell, but the people are prepared for anything. In an old Bible, which was found in the house, and on the family record page, was written in German the following memoranda: "Big slaughter January eighth (8)," and another which read, "Hell departed." These were interpreted by a German citizen who was present yesterday. A Catholic prayer book was also found in the house, which contained the following written in German: Johanna Bender, born July 30, 1848, John Gebart came to America July 1, 18—." T. Strange, Esq., the Deputy Prosecuting Attorney of Labette county, appeared on the ground at the beginning of the search, and for some time insisted on all the rules of "red tape," and did not want anything done until the Coroner and other officials came. His desires were overruled very decidedly, and speedily the examination proceeded.

See the clipping

About these pages

Every clipping here was printed in an American newspaper at the time. The text on each card was read from the page by machine and lightly repaired; where it disagrees with the clipping, the clipping is right. Where the scan of an old page was too damaged to read, the text was transcribed again from the page image and is marked so; letters in [square brackets] were supplied where the printing itself is damaged, and the paper’s own misspellings are kept. The dates, papers, headlines and text are the papers’. The notes on why each article matters, and the one-line summaries, are ours.