As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · As the Papers Told It

Act Four

How They Were Killed

September 1884 – October 1888

In 1884 Captain J. C. Reeves named the men of a party he said had overtaken the Benders in Indian Territory, where one man, whom he would not name, shot all four. By 1885 a half-filled cellar hole was all that was left of the house, and opinion was divided between those who believed the family had escaped and those who believed in a silent mob.

Captain Reeves says he saw them shot

Capt. J. C. Reeves of Appleton City, Mo., tells a St. Louis Republican reporter he rode with the party, Col. York in the lead, that overtook the Benders by the Grand River in the Indian Territory. One man, whom he will not name, shot all four, and ‘there was no resistance offered’. In 1901 Julius York, the doctor’s brother and himself one of the searchers, called the Indian Territory story false.

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · Sedalia, Mo.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 9 September 1884 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE BENDER FAMILY.

The Killing of the Desperadoes, Related by Capt. J. C. Reeves, An Eye-Witness of the Tragedy.

See moreSee less

The Names of the Party Given, and the Story of the Slaying Told in Its Details.

St. Louis Republican.

The sudden disappearace of the members of the murderous Bender family after the revelation of their numerous atrocties, and the failure of all efforts to discover the whereabouts of the fugtives, enshrouded the whole affair with an air of impentrable mystery. The veil was not lifted until some twelve months ago, when the Republican published the story of one of the avenging party which overtook and annihilated the whole family in the Indian territory not far from the banks of the Grand river. The author of that graphic narrative, Capt. J. C. Reeves, of Appleton City, Mo., is at present a transient guest at the hotel Barnum, and when seen by a Republican reporter last night he cheerfully consented to give all the details of the Bender's tragic ending, except the name of the man by whose hand they were slain.

"When Dr. York was missed," the captain began, as he lighted a fresh cigar, "Col. York traced his brother to the house occupied by the Benders. Being unable to obtain any further information of his lost brother he returned to Independence, Kas., and communicated the result of his investigation to Capt. Stone, sheriff of Montgomery county. The next day Col. York and Capt. Stone visited the Bender residence and they were received by the man who married Kate Bender, and who went by the name of John Bender. John Bender admitted that Dr. York had stayed ai their house and asserted that he had heard nothing of the doctor since. Being unable to obtain any satisfaction Col. York and Capt. Stone retraced their steps to Independence. A posse was formed and the company started forth determined to investigate the matter to the bottom. When they arrived at the Bender homestead the birds had flown. The house and garden were examined, and in the garden were found nine bodies of which one was recognized as that of Dr. York. Public indignation att his discovery knew no bounds, and the excitement became intense."

"What was the next step taken for the purpose of avenging this wholesale butchery?"

"A party consisting of S. S. Peterson, deputy United States marshal, Col. York, Bill Wright, George Dawson and myself was formed to follow the trail of the Benders. We tracked the wagon to Thayer, Kas., where we found the wagon abandoned. At this point we took the railroad cars for Chanute, on the M. K. & T. railroad. At Chanute we procured another wagon and proceeded in the direction of the Grand river, which runs through the Indian territory. It was in the Indian territory on the banks of the Grand river that Col. York, who was in the van of the party, overhauled the Benders. They all died very suddenly and they are buried in the Indian territory near where they fell. I have nothing more to say. That ends the story.

"Were they shot?"

"Yes; they were shot with a sixteen-shot repeating Henry rifle."

"Who did the shooting?"

"That I am not at liberty to state."

"Did Col. York offer any reward for the discovery of the Benders?"

"No, he did not, although he was worth $100,000 at the time. The government offered $10,000 reward but nobody claimed it."

"Do the Benders lie close to the river?"

"Yes."

"Are you certain that they are all killed?"

"I saw them killed, all four of them—old man Bender and his wife, John Bender and Kate Bender."

"Were they shot by one man?"

"Yes, by one man only. He killed them. Bang, bang, bang, bang. Every shot counted."

"Where were you when the shooting was done?"

"I was sitting on my horse a few yards from the man who did the shooting. I entered into an agreement not to tell anything about it."

"Were there any United States troops present?"

"No."

"Did you see the bodies buried?"

"I did."

"Could you find the place again?"

"I could very easily."

"How were they buried?"

"We just dug a hole tumbled them in and covered them up."

"Did you find anything on the bodies?"

"We did not search them."

"How were they shot, from behind?"

"They were shot from behind and to their faces. We were very much exasperated at finding the nine bodies in the garden, and immediately we overtook them the firing commenced. They were not looking when we overtook them, but as soon as the firing began they turned round. The man was ahead that did the shooting. We had our carbines leveled ready to shoot, but there was no resistance offered."

"What description of vehicle were the Benders in?"

"They were in a two horse wagon. I think the two men were seated in front and the two women behind."

"Are you sure you got the right people?"

"We knew we had the right people. We all recognized them and identified them after they were dead. I knew every one of them. At one time I had seen them every day for six months."

"Where did you live?"

"I lived at Independence where I was running a marble shop."

"What did you do with the team?"

"We turned them loose."

"With their harness on?"

"Yes."

"Did you ever hear of them again?"

"No."

"What became of the wagon?"

"I think we burned it."

"How far were the Benders from their home when they were murdered?"

"About forty-five miles."

"What time were they killed?"

"About 4 o'clock in the afternoon. They were on the prairie on the outskirts of the town."

"How long did the killing last?"

"Only a few moments."

"Who was killed first?"

"It was all done so quickly I do not know who was killed first."

"Did any of them jump out of the wagon?"

"No."

"How far were you from the wagon at the time?"

"Thirty-five or forty steps."

"What did you do after the bodies were buried?"

"I started on to deliver the news, but after I had gone fifteen miles I was overtaken and told not to say a word about the killing. 'All right,' I replied, 'Mum's the word.' We solemnly agreed not to give the thing away, and the first time it was told to the public, except as a suspicion, was about a year ago, when I gave some of the facts to Senator Wear for publication in the Republican, but you have fuller details now than have ever been published.

See the clipping

Relic hunters and a half-filled cellar

Ed Wright, a stenographer visiting Kansas, finds nothing of the Bender house but ‘the half-filled vacuity’ of its cellar, and opinion divided between escape and a mob that never talked. His story of the discovery, a woman lodger who knew her husband’s locket, appears in no other report in the set; the others trace it to the search for Dr. York. Two hammers and a clock are kept at Parsons.

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

The Butler Weekly Times · 11 November 1885 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE BLOODY BENDERS.

A Tale of Crime Almost Without a Parallel.

See moreSee less

Ed Wright, the Stenographer, has just returned from a trip to Kansas, where he has been visiting friends. During his absence he visited the neighborhood made famous by the horrible crime of the Bender family, the discovery of which so startled the whole country about twelve years ago. He relates some interesting facts and reminiscences of the family and the location.

Where the house once stood nothing now remains to mark the spot except the half-filled vacuity that once answered the purpose of a cellar. Curious relic-seekers have carried away the last remnant of the lar. building and all its appurtenances, even to the last stone that helped to compose the cellar wall.

One circumstance that serves to maintain an interest in this event, so long past, is the fact that few, if any, know whether the Bender family escaped and are living to day in some distant country, or whether they were captured by a small mob who quietly put them to death and forever after held their peace. Regarding this point, some are of one opinion and some of another. The story has many variations, but runs substantially as follows:

In early days, while that region was sparsely settled, this family, consisting of an old man and his wife and a son and a daughter, took up their abode at the place referred to, which is about ten miles west of a little village called Galesburg, in Neosho county. There they kept a sort of wayside inn, making a business of keeping travelers over night, and, we might add, to see that they never proceeded any further in the direction of their desired destination.

When a man whom they had marked as a victim entered the door of that room his doom was sealed. He would be offered a chair sitting so that its back would be toward the curtain, and so near it that, when he sat down, the back of his head would be against it.

Behind this curtain, in the little apartment above mentioned, was concealed the female fiend, Miss Kate Bender, having near at hand two hammers, one large and the other small, and a sharp knife. When the unfortunate victim would become deeply interested in some exciting or amusing conversation with the other members of the family, who pretended to be exceedingly jolly and vivacious, the murderess behind the curtain would deal him a blow in the back of the head with the large hammer that would drop him senseless upon the floor; then, rushing from her hiding-place, she would deal him another blow in the temple with the small hammer; whereupon the male members would drag him to the trap-door, over which they would hold him while the insatiate monster in woman's form drew the knife across his throat, atter which they allowed the bleeding corpse to fall through the aperture into the cellar.

When a traveler was beheld approaching, some member of the family would station himself at the roadside in front of the house, and as the unsuspecting individual drew nigh would would accost him pleasantly, inquire in a friendly manner where he was going, and it it was anywhere near evening would assure him that it would be impossible to reach his destination before nightfall, and propose that he should remain over night with them, while the traveler generally acquiesced to the hospitable proposition.

It seemed that the inside of the building had been arranged with a view to the accomplishment of their ghastly designs. The front room and a small apartment back of it were separated by a thin curtain [d]rawn across somewhat in the manner of the curtains used on folding [do]ors, while in the center of the room [wa]s a trap door.

Sometimes there would be two or th[r]ee travelers stop at one time at th[is] abode, upon which occasion as [m]any members of the family would take their places behind the curtain, selecting their victims at the critical moment. Again, there would occasionally come a man who, when offered the fatal chair, would unconsciously remove it to some other position, rendering it inconvenient to strike him a sure blow from the place of concealment. Under such circumstances the family would always be very mirthful, and finally propose a game in which it would become incumbent upon the stranger, in acting a certain part, to fall upon his knees and clasp his hands in the attitude of prayer. The place selected for him to do this would be on the trap door. When in the required position Miss Kate would steal softly from behind the curtain and strike him dead as he knelt. They always aimed to make death certain, provided they thought the stranger had valuables worth the trouble.

Their discovery came about as follows: A man left his wife somewhere in eastern Kansas to go and make arrangements for settling further west, saying that as soon as matters were adjusted, which would be within a certain stated time, he would return and take her west with him. He went, and the time set for his return came, but he didn't come with it. Becoming alarmed at his prolonged absence, his wife set out to overtake or meet him. She, too, stopped to remain over night with the benders. It didn't seem to be their intention to murder her; at least not in their usual manner of performing the hellish act. While sitting in the room alone she picked up a locket that was lying on a stand. Opening it she was surprised to perceive her own picture in it, and that ceive of her little girl opposite. She knew then that the locket had belonged to her husband, having been worn by him as a charm on his watch chain. Her suspicions were aroused, but some one coming in prevented her from escaping, and finally she was taken up stairs to retire, but not to sleep. She was planning an escape from the building. After a time she arose and looked out of the window, and was astonished to see the light of a lantern swinging in a distant part of the orchard on the premises. She succeeded in stealing softly out of the house without discovery, and drew near the light, which she watched till the parties went away, and then went to the place and found a newly-made grave. She hid on the prairie all night, and when morning came, went to a neighbor's house and told her story The alarm soon spread abroad and people flocked to the house from far and near in great crowds. But the family had disappeared. Their horses were found standing hitched to a wagon not far off, and that was the only trace that could be found. A crowd gathered and formed themselves into a mob for the purpose of wreaking vengeance upon the murderers. They set off in a certain direction, and when they came back not a single member of it could be prevailed upon to say whether they had accomplished their purpose or not. Hence the uncertainty. Some claim that they did, and were afraid to tell lest it might bring them trouble. Others claim that if they had they would have been too glad to tell, as a large reward had been offered for each and every member of the family that might be brought back dead or alive. Why they should continue so silent upon this matter to even the present day remains a mystery.

Some hint that they might have overtaken the family, who, giving up some of their ill-gotten wealth, prevailed upon them to keep silent and allow them to escape. But this is only vague conjecture. There are those who believe that beyond a doubt that identical family can be found in Germany to-day if any one takes the trouble to go there and look for them. The bodies of several persons were found buried in the orchard. The graves were found by taking the end-gate rods out of wagons and sticking them into the ground here and there until they would find a soft place, which in every instance proved to be a grave. How many more have been buried in other places will never be known. Mr. Wright was granted the privilege of inspecting the two hammers that were used so often and so successfully as instruments of destruction in the hands of their villainous and bloodthirsty owners. They are harmless looking implements, but ugly weapons. The handles of each are badly splintered, as almost every one who sees them is desirous of procuring a splinter or a shaving for a relic. These hammers, together with an old clock that once belonged to the household property of the Bender family, and perhaps often tolled the hour for the burial of some poor unfortunate who had fallen into their merciless clutches, are in the possession of a gentleman named Bailey, who holds a distinguished office in the city of Parsons, Kan.—Cincinnati Enquirer.

See the clipping

A Socorro prisoner named as Kate

A New Mexico report on a foiled jail break at Socorro: a key, acids, files and saws were found among the prisoners, several of them sewn into the dress of ‘the notorious Sue Younkers’. Its last line says several well-informed persons now think she is ‘no more nor less than the original Kate Bender’. No other clipping in the set mentions her.

The Las Vegas Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 28 days later.

Wrong

The Las Vegas Gazette · 15 May 1886 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Jail Break at Socorro. The jail birds of Socorro, according to the Chieftain, have been perfecting plans for a general escape. Two of the prisoners, Jim Doyle and Jim Campbell, made their escape while engaged in the pump house, supplying the public buildings with water. When recaptured, a key was found in their possession. This caused Sheriff Russell to search all of the prisoners. He found three bottles two of which had contained sulphuric acid and one nitric acid. Besides this, files and saws made of corsest steel and boot soles were found in their possession, several being found sewed up in the dress of the notorious Sue Younkers.

See moreSee less

In the murderer's cell, where were confined those men sentenced to be hung, two awaiting trial for murder, and five for horse stealing, it was found that a slab of iron 14 x 18 inches had been cut out of the floor and hid away in the corner. Work had already begun to soften the cement floor beneath, so that the stones in the foundation could be removed and egress be effected. The sheriff concluded that aid must have been afforded from without, and suspicion fell upon a young man named Chavez, who had previously been confined in the jail for larceny, and upon young Price, the son of a lawyer then in the jail on the charge of embezzlement. They confessed having furnished some of the supplies. The supposition is that the steet window screens of the wash room were sufficiently loosened to admit of the passing in of the articles from the outside world. A note was found upon the person of one of the condemned murderers addressed to a cowboy, Franks, who had been released but a few days before. It instructed Franks when and where to be ready with horses for the escape of the party. The discovery very much dampened the hopes of the prisoners, who certainly had concocted a good scheme and had worked long upon it. But then, "The best laid plan of mice and men aft gang aglee." It is now the opinion of several well informed persons who have been investigating the matter, that Sue Yonkers is no more nor less than the original Kate Bender, the Kansas female hend.

See the clipping

London’s Whitechapel murders recall the Benders

A long article on the Whitechapel murders in London sets them beside the Bender murders of Labette County in 1873, and repeats a theory, found nowhere else in the set, tying those killings to Kate’s ‘vile incantations’. It adds that though the papers said Kate escaped, there are men in Kansas who could show where she, her brother and her parents ‘were laid beneath the prairie sod’.

The Ottawa Free Trader · Ottawa, Ill. · and 1 other paper

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 6 earlier articles: Madison Times, 21 April 1888, Madison Times, 21 April 1888, Richland Beacon, 21 April 1888, Richland Beacon, 21 April 1888, Western Kansas World, 2 June 1888, Western Kansas World, 2 June 1888.

The Ottawa Free Trader · 13 October 1888 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

THE LONDON HORROR.

WHITECHAPEL, THE DISTRICT OF THE RECENT AWFUL MURDERS.

See moreSee less

It Is a Part of the World's Metropolis Reeking in Vice and Steeped in Poverty and Misery—Some Terrible Murders of History.

London now has a horror that interests the police and public of the civilized world, and has called out a bewildering variety of opinions from experts in the morbid anatomy of crime and insanity. The plainest statement of the facts excites anger, pity and disgust. In a few weeks seven women of the lowest class of unfortunates to be found in the notorious slums of Whitechapel have been found dead in the streets; in each case the corpse was shockingly mutilated, and in all but one the whole internal organ of reproduction was removed, the line of section indicating that the act was done by a person versed in the anatomy of the parts, and skillful with the surgeon's knife. In the one case where this was not done the body was still warm and bleeding, indicating that the perpetrator had been frightened away before completing his hideous task.

During the same period the corpse of a woman similarly mutilated was found in a town in the north of England; and if, as is likely, the murderer was the same, this makes his eighth victim. The first two cases excited no great interest, as quarrels and murders are no new thing in the Whitechapel district; but the horrible monotony of the crimes has since made this a case of world wide note. It recalls the cases of the

WHERE THE MURDERS WERE PERPETRATED. noted French marquis of two centuries ago, who is said to have killed 200 females of all ages, of the French medical student who confessed to killing seventeen women, of Jesse Pomeroy, the boy murderer, and many others.

Alienists are unanimous in the opinion that the murderer is a monomaniac with a homicidal turn; and many add that he is what medical science calls a "sexual pervert"—that is, a man in whom the natural instincts have been changed by disease or excess into a blind hatred and desire to kill and mangle. Such cases are not so uncommon as the unlearned would suppose. In the notorious Bender murders in Labette county, Kan., in 1873, all the victims were men except that the little daughter of one man, traveling with her father, was killed with him; and in each case the mutilations were unmentionable. As none of the portions of the bodies removed were found, the people concluded that Kate Bender, the directing genius of the gang, who claimed wonderful healing powers and converse with extrahuman agencies, had used them in the vile incantations she practiced. It is not easy for the healthy mind to conceive of such degraded creatures; yet medical history records many similar cases, nearly all men. Women murderers nearly always resort to poison, as even the most depraved retain their natural horror of blood; but with men the exact opposite is true. The homicidal man maniac takes a wild joy in seeing the flow of blood, in looking on the ghastly wounds and the writhings of his victim.

The London police have been completely at sea, and some of the theories put forth by their chief are too absurd for one's patience. One, for instance, was that an American medical student did the deeds because he wanted to collect a number of anatomical specimens! The most reasonable theory is that the monomaniac has been injured, or thinks he has, by one of these women, and is wreaking his vengeance on the class. His cunning is wonderful—not an uncommon thing in monomaniacs. Dr. Will-

BUCK'S ROW, WHERE ONE BODY WAS FOUND. iam Hammond, the eminent alienist, very sensibly says that the police have gone wrong from the start, because they have looked only for a self evident villian, a man "whose face would go far to hang him," while the probabilities are many to one that the perpetrator is a decorous and soft spoken gentleman, living an apparently virtuous life, a man whose closest acquaintances do not suspect of crime. Such was the appearance of the noted De Retz, the French "Bluebeard" above referred to, and of the young man who confessed to seventeen murders. Incidentally it may be noted that Kate Bender was not all unattractive, and that Jesse Pomeroy was what many people would call a "fine looking boy." He was sent to the Massachusetts state's prison for life, and though the papers stated that Kate escaped, there are men in Kansas who could show you the very spot where she, her half witted brother and her parents were laid beneath the prairie sod.

Chief Inspector Byrnes, of New York city, accepts the opinion of Dr. Hammond and insists that the New York police could have caught the man by using the women as decoys. He adds:

"We caught the fellow who had a mania for throwing vitriol upon women's dresses red handed immediately after it was reported. His crime was localized. He frequented Fourteenth street. I made victims for him, and my men were thickly scattered through that district. We have no such autocratic powers as the London police, but if a crime is so plainly localized in one particular district, as in the case of these London murders, we would most assuredly arrest the perpetrator in short order."

See the clipping

← Back to Act Three: The Old Woman's Story