As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

June 1888

2 articles

Western Kansas World · Wakeeney, Kan. · and 1 other paper

A man called 'Major' recounts a story told to him by a dying friend, John, about a posse of seven led by a 'Colonel Yorke' who tracked the Benders and confronted Kate and Mrs. Bender, demanding to know what happened to Yorke's missing brother. Kate defiantly refused to talk even as the old woman pulled pistols, before being overpowered.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 133 days later.

Wrong

Western Kansas World · 2 June 1888 · page 3

Ever since tlie notorious Benders, of Kansas, disappeared from their home itead in 1873, leaving their garden in the condition of a private cemetery, curiosity has been rife as to what became of them. Many stories have been told, only to be contradicted, about the family being living or dead at some place in the Far West, but the following statement, published by the St. Louis Globe-Democrat, has an appearance of plausibility. The narrator is Major T. E. Hicks, ex pioneer, Kansas free soiler, postmaster and prospector, and now a justice of the ' peace at Americus, Kan.

See moreSee less

The story was obtained from an old friend who was dying, and the "Colonel" alluded to was Colonel Yorke, who some years ago made a sensation of national magnitude by rising in his place in the Kansas Legislature and making some state ments, accompanied by a show of green backs, which prevented the re-election of United States Senator S. C. Pomeroy, better known as "Subsidy Pom:" "John had been living near where the Benders lived at the time of the murder of Dr. York, and when we talked of the Benders I always thought, from John's way, that he knew some thing about what became of them. I was mighty curious to find out, and many's the time Pve asked him, ' John, what did become of the Benders ? but he always put me off with one answer. Each time he would say, ' The Benders? The Benders are all right,' So, although I inquired about the Benders repeatedly for my curosity was great I never could get any wiser. Well, we pros pected along until we got to Fort Yuma, A. T. There John took sick. It was while John was sick, and not long before he died, that I quizzed him again about the Benders. So at last he told me all about it, and I sat there and made notes in my memorandum book." "Was this man an eye witness of what he told you about ?" asked the reporter. "Yes; what he told was from actual knowledge. Ho mentioned no names,' but I knew who he meant when he talked about 'the Colonel.' You know, too, the Colonel had traced his brother from Fort Scott right along up to the Bender place, arid there the trail ended. Beyond that point he could find no trace of his brother and no signs of his horse. The disappearance of the horse was an important fact in his mind." "Pve always understood that they were never able to explain how that horse was gotten out of that county without some one knowing something about it." "That's true," said the Major. "My understanding has always been, and I think it comes from what John told me, that Dr. Yorke's horse was killed and buried in the pond near the Bender place. Anyway, John's story was that there were seven men in the party, and Colonel Yorke with them, and that the Colonel had come to the conclusion that the Benders knew where his brother was. He begged and implored of Kate Bender to tell him what they had done with his brother, but Kate wouldn't tell. He offered to take Kate and Mrs. Ben der back to town and see that no harm came to them if they would only confess what had become of his brother. But Kate wouldn't tell a word. Her eyes flashed and sho said, 'You can't take me.' The old woman whipped out a pair of pistols and said she would tell nothing. 'You can't take me.' She was overpowered and disarmed in an instant, for the Colonel wouldn't let there be any shooting. 'Don't fire a shot,' were his words. Finding he could learn noth ing from the two women, he got on his horse again and went back to town." "And then what?" "John said the bodies of the Benders could be found, if any one chose to look for them, in the old, unused well some three hundred yards northwest of the Bender house. That's where they were put. He didn't give me all the details of the affair, but I remember asking John 'Wasn't it an awful brutish thing?' And he said 'No, not at all. The only instruments used were the mallet and two pound liammer that had been used by the Benders in their own murderous work.' He said there wasn't a shot fired; that it was all done decently and quietly. When it was all over the party dispersed and went to their homes." "How about the Benders' team and wagon that was found hitched to a fence near Thayer, some twelve miles or more from the Bender place ?" "That team was driven off by one of the party, whether to mislead people who might want to make inquiries by creating the impressions that the Ben ders had left the country on the train or to serve some more convenient purpose. But at any rate it was the Benders' wag on, though, and driven off as I have de scribed. Whether the party ever told the Colonel what had occurred I don't know, but I do know that John had al ways contended that the Colonel could tell something if he only would."

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • · · 12 April 1888

Western Kansas World · Wakeeney, Kan.

A man named the Major recounts a story told to him by 'John,' describing how Colonel Yorke and a posse of seven confronted Kate and Mrs. Bender, failed to get a confession, then killed them with a mallet and hammer and dumped the bodies in a well. The account also explains the abandoned Bender wagon as a deliberate ruse by the posse.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 133 days later.

Wrong

Western Kansas World · 2 June 1888 · page 3

THE BENDER FAMILY

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page