As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

June 1886

1 article

Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · Butte, Mont.

A woman arrested as a possible Kate Bender, using the alias Mrs. Younkers (formerly Susie Stone, born Susan Warfield), has her background traced from Wales through Nevada, Colorado, and New Mexico. A former deputy sheriff who knew the real Kate Bender states this woman does not match her in appearance, casting doubt on the identification.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 28 days earlier.

Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · 12 June 1886 · page 4

"BRONCHO SUE'S" HISTORY

some trouble occurred, which compelled Raper to abandon his family, apparently forever, at least in a letter to his wife he so expressed himst If .stating that it was 1 'pretty hard'for a man to have to leave his children forever on account of d—d thieves." It also appears that when this trouble oc curred, the Rap rs were living at Elko, Ne vada, at which time they had three chil dren, the oldest one, named Robert, hav ing afterward died at a place called Sheri dan. From 1870 to 1875 we fail to learn anything of her whereabouts during the time.

See moreSee less

It was in 1872 that the Bender murders were committed, at which time Mrs. Younkers would have been 28 years of age. she being 41 years old now. That of age corresponds with the age of the notori ous Kate Bender at that time, but W. A. Graham, who was a Deputy Sheriff under Major Bahney, Sheriff of Cherokee County at that time, says that he knew Kate Ben der well and carried her photograph for tour years, and that Mrs. Younkers is noth ing like Kate Bender, either in form or in features, and we think that Mr. Graham

See the clipping