As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

May 1886

1 article

In the story →

The Las Vegas Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

A planned jailbreak involving smuggled tools and an outside accomplice named Frank was uncovered after a note detailing the escape plan was found on one of the condemned prisoners. Investigators speculated that a prisoner known as Sue Yonkers might actually be the notorious Kate Bender of the Kansas Bender family.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 28 days later.

Wrong

The Las Vegas Gazette · 15 May 1886 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Jail Break at Socorro. The jail birds of Socorro, according to the Chieftain, have been perfecting plans for a general escape. Two of the prisoners, Jim Doyle and Jim Campbell, made their escape while engaged in the pump house, supplying the public buildings with water. When recaptured, a key was found in their possession. This caused Sheriff Russell to search all of the prisoners. He found three bottles two of which had contained sulphuric acid and one nitric acid. Besides this, files and saws made of corsest steel and boot soles were found in their possession, several being found sewed up in the dress of the notorious Sue Younkers.

See moreSee less

In the murderer's cell, where were confined those men sentenced to be hung, two awaiting trial for murder, and five for horse stealing, it was found that a slab of iron 14 x 18 inches had been cut out of the floor and hid away in the corner. Work had already begun to soften the cement floor beneath, so that the stones in the foundation could be removed and egress be effected. The sheriff concluded that aid must have been afforded from without, and suspicion fell upon a young man named Chavez, who had previously been confined in the jail for larceny, and upon young Price, the son of a lawyer then in the jail on the charge of embezzlement. They confessed having furnished some of the supplies. The supposition is that the steet window screens of the wash room were sufficiently loosened to admit of the passing in of the articles from the outside world. A note was found upon the person of one of the condemned murderers addressed to a cowboy, Franks, who had been released but a few days before. It instructed Franks when and where to be ready with horses for the escape of the party. The discovery very much dampened the hopes of the prisoners, who certainly had concocted a good scheme and had worked long upon it. But then, "The best laid plan of mice and men aft gang aglee." It is now the opinion of several well informed persons who have been investigating the matter, that Sue Yonkers is no more nor less than the original Kate Bender, the Kansas female hend.

See the clipping