As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · As the Papers Told It

Act Five

Overtaken at Last

October 1889 – January 1890

In October 1889 a woman at Niles, Michigan, said her mother was old Mrs. Bender, and Kansas officers took both women to Oswego. A Topeka woman who said the Benders had killed her father pressed the case. In November the women were held for trial without bail, though the sixteen witnesses examined were evenly divided, and in January J. T. James said he had affidavits placing both women in Michigan from 1870 to 1874.

A Michigan daughter names her mother

Nine years after Oswego, the trail turns to Niles, Mich. Mrs. Eliza Davis, just discharged on a grand larceny charge, insists that her mother, Mrs. Monroe, is old Mrs. Bender; Mrs. Monroe admits to seven husbands. Kansas officers, ten days on the ground, say they have ‘at last discovered the notorious Bender family’, and a requisition has been asked for.

Wichita Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Wichita Eagle · 31 October 1889 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE BENDERS AGAIN. STARTLING STATEMENTS BY A MICHIGAN WOMAN. Mrs. Davis, of Niles, Swears Her Mother is Old Mrs. Bender. Several Suspicious Circumstances Connected with the Story—Kansas De tectives on the Ground. OLD MRS. BENDER. Mrs. Eliza Davis, of Niles, Mich., Says Her Mother is that Person. NILES, Mich., Oct. 30.—Mrs. Eliza Davis was discharged yesterday on the charge of grand larceny. During her trial many facts were adduced tending to show that Mrs. Monroe (Mrs. Davis' mother) was connected with the Bender murders in Kansas. By her own admission Mrs.

See moreSee less

Monroe had seven husbands and a number of them have mysteriously disappeared. Her daughter Eliza insists positively that Mrs. Monroe is old Mrs. Bender. Much interest was manifested and many blood curdling and horrible revelations were brought out during the examination. Officers from Kansas have been in the state for ten days investigating the case and are satisfied that they have at last discovered the notorious Bender family. A requisition has been asked for and as soon as it arrives the parties will be taken to Labette county, Kansas, for trial.

See the clipping

One Kansas column, two opinions

The Dodge City paper prints two items side by side. A paragraph from the Hutchinson News says Mrs. Monroe ‘worked’ Mr. McCann and invented the Bender story ‘just to get a free ride to Kansas’, much as a Nevada paper had said of the 1880 pair. The Globe-Republican's own note hopes the officers have ‘the original Benders of Cherryvale notoriety’.

The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Globe-Republican · 6 November 1889 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

It now transpires that it was Mrs. Monroe who "worked" Mr. McCann. She invented the Bender story just to get a free ride to Kansas. O, Kansas is a great state, and people will do almost anything to get here!—Hutchinson News.

The notorious Bender family has been heard from at last, way up in Michigan and returned to Kansas where they will have to answer for their atrocious crimes comunitted in this state some eighteen years ago. We only hope the officers may have the original Benders of Cherryvale notoriety.

See the clipping

The accuser who tracked them to Niles

A Sedalia dispatch follows Deputy Sheriff L. F. Dick taking Mrs. Almira Monroe and her daughter, Mrs. Eliza Davis, to Oswego. Their accuser, Mrs. Frances E. McCann of Topeka, says the Benders killed her father, John W. Sanford, at Windsor, Can., twenty-four years earlier, and names Mrs. Davis as Kate. A conviction would bring her $10,000, though the paper says she wanted revenge.

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas · and 2 other papers

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Iola Register · 8 November 1889 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

THE BENDERS.

An Old Woman and Her Daughter Taken to Kansas From Michigan Charged With Being Two of the Notorious Bender Family.

See moreSee less

SEDALIA, Mo., Nov. 1.—Deputy Sheriff L. F. Dick, of Oswego, Labette County, Kan., arrived in the city yesterday afternoon from Niles, Mich., having in charge Mrs. Almira Monroe and her daughter, Mrs. Eliza Davis, of Lansing, alleged members of the famous Bender gang of murderers and outlaws. The party remained in the city upward of three hours and departed for Oswego over the Missouri, Kansas & Texas at night.

Mrs. Frances E. McCann, of Topeka, Kan., accompanied the party. According to her story her father was murdered in the home of the Benders, and she has never believed the story that old man Bender, his wife and Kate, the daughter, had been killed in the Indian Territory by vigilantes, but for the past six or eight years she had been on the trail of the female members of the gang, and six months ago had run them down at Niles, Mich. She is positive that the right parties are under arrest, and declares that Mrs. Davis has confessed to her that the old woman is none other than Mrs. Bender. She is also positive that Mrs. Davis is Kate Bender, the most cruel and bloodthirsty of the infamous gang.

Deputy Dick is confident that the prisoners are the Benders, mother and daughter, and says that plenty of witnesses await their arrival at Labette County to identify them.

Dick says that the mother and daughter quarrel bitterly at intervals when left to themselves and each accuses the other of being responsible for the position in which they are placed at present.

If these parties are convicted Mrs. McCann will get $10,000, but it was not money she was after. She worked for revenge. Her father, John W. Sanford, was murdered by the Benders at Windsor, Can., twenty-four years ago. They fled the country and located on a farm in Labette County, Kan., where they kept their "tavern" and did their deadly work. When the Benders murdered Mr. Sanford, Mrs. McCann, his daughter, was but four years old. When she grew up and was married she settled in McPherson, Kan. Some years ago a dissolute woman came there with her husband and was taken sick at her house. She believed she was dying, and learning who Mrs. McCann was, on her supposed death bed confessed to Mrs. McCann that she helped to kill her father when Mrs. McCann was a child. While Mrs. McCann was looking up the particulars of her father's death the sick woman recovered and suddenly disappeared one night with her husband. It was several years before Mrs. McCann got a clew to her whereabouts, but she finally located her at Niles, Mich., and went there last April. When she had her plans perfected she notified the Kansas officers and presented proofs satisfactory to them that the women were the long lost Benders and a requisition was made for them. Such is the story of Mrs. McCann, who caused the arrest of these supposed Benders.

See the clipping

Held for trial, witnesses evenly split

At Oswego on 21 November the two women were held for the district court without bail. Of sixteen witnesses, seven said they were the Benders, seven said not and two were undecided, while both women told of hard lives and frequent moves. The county attorney expected to convict; in January a Sedalia paper would say the Labette prosecutor had never believed them the Benders.

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: New-York Tribune, 21 November 1889, The Indianapolis Journal, 21 November 1889.

The Butler Weekly Times · 27 November 1889 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

HELD FOR TRIAL. The Bender Suspects Bound over without Bail to Await the Action of the Grand Jury. Oswego, Kan.. Nov. 21.—The Bender suspects was held for trial in the district court without bail. Sixteen witnesses have been examined, seven of whom declare that the prisoners are the benders, seven say they are not and two are undecided. The old woman, alleged to be Mrs. Bender, and Eliza Davis, the supposed to be Kate Bender, were placed on the stand and told straightfor posed straightforward stories of their lives. The stories of both women showed lives of hardship and trouble and frequent removals from place to place to keep the wolf from the door.

See moreSee less

The county attorney believes he will convict the women. The attorneys for the defense laugh at the idea, while the great growd of people are about equally divided.

See the clipping

Michigan neighbors swear to an alibi

The Sedalia Bazoo, which had called the 1880 pair a myth, predicts these women will be freed within days. J. T. James of Kansas City says he has affidavits placing them, whom he names Mrs. Almira Griffith and Mrs. Sarah E. Davis, in Michigan from 1870 to 1874. The paper adds that fourteen of twenty-eight witnesses at the preliminary trial swore they were not the Benders.

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · Sedalia, Mo.

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 14 January 1890 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE BENDERS

Not the Benders, as Was Predicted by the Bazoo in the First Place.

See moreSee less

It is altogether probable that the two women alleged to be Mrs. John and Kate Bender, who are now confined in the Labette county, Kansas jail awaiting trial for the murder o, Dr. York, will be liberated in a few days. The story of their capture last October at Niles, Mich., and their preliminary trial before three justices of the peace at Oswego, Kan., has been published in full in the Bazoo. Mr. J. T. James, formerly of Fort Smith, Ark., but now of Kansas City, [illegible] nary trial.

Since that time he has been quietly at work collecting proof which will establish the fact that the women are Mrs. Almira Griffith and Mrs. Sarah E. Davis. He now claims to have affidavits showing that from 1870 to 1874 these two women were in Michigan. The crimes with which the Benders are charged were all committed during these years.

On being acquainted of this fact the prosecuting attorney of Labette county, Mr. Morrison, wrote to Mr. James, telling him that if he could prove these facts by affidavits he would discharge the prisoners. Mr. James will go to Oswego next week with his affidavits.

In this connection it should be stated that Mr. Morrison, the prosecuting attorney of Labette county, has never had any confidence in Mrs. McCann, who caused the two women to be arrested, and has never believed them to be the Benders. At the preliminary trial twenty-eight witnesses were examined, fourteen of whom testified positively that they were intimately acquainted with Mrs. John and Kate Bender and that the parties under arrest were not the Benders. Of the others examined, three testified point blank that the two women were Mrs. John and Kate Bender. Of the remaining witnesses some testified that one of the women was Mrs. John Bender, but the other was not Kate Bender, while others identified Mrs. Davis as Kate, but did not think the old woman was Mrs. John Bender.

In an interview with a reporter for Kansas City Times yesterday Mr. James said; "I am now convinced that I will be able to show a perfect alibi for Mrs. Griffith and for Mrs. Davis. This alibi will cover the years 1870, 1871, 1872, 1873 and 1874, one year before and two years after the Benders were in Kansas, thus showing that these women eould not possibly be the ones wanted for terrible crimes with which the Benders are charged.

'I propose to go next week to Oswego, Kan., where they are now being held in jail to present the evidence I have gathered to the prosecuting attorney and through his assistance secure their discharge. As they are being held without bond until the grand jury meets it will require the consent of the prosecuting attorney to secure their release before that body convenes some time in February.

In the case of Mrs. Griffith I will show by the wife and daughter of the man Daniel Perry, in whose house [illegible] that she was in Concord township, Berrien county, Michigan, during the years 1870 and 1871. She was then working to support six small children during this time, being even compelled at times to go into the field to plow and husk corn that she might find food for her little ones. I will show by Mr. and Mrs. Seeley of the same county, and by Mr. and Mrs. Hogue of Niles, Mich., that during the years 1872, 1873 and 1874 Mrs. Griffith, then known as Mrs. Marks, resided with three children in Carrollton, a suburb of South Saginaw. Mrs. Champion of Jackson, Mich., corroborates Mrs. Perry and Mrs. Graham as to Mrs. Griffith's residence during the years 1870 and 1871. I have also a certificate signed by the mayor and sixteen other citizens of Niles, testifying to the good character and upright bearing of Mrs. Griffith during her life in [illegible]

"As to Mrs. Davis, who is thought to be Kate Bender, Mr. and Mrs. Snell, of Bay Port, Mich., swear to her residence in that city during the years of 1871 and 1872 with her husband Hiram Johnson. Mrs. Taylor makes affidavit that Mrs. Davis, then Mrs. Johnson, spent the year of 1873 upon a farm adjoining her home and but a few miles from the town of Bay Port. During this time Mrs. Johnson gave birth to her third child, which child was buried there a few months later. This death left Mrs. Johnson with two living children, which fact alone would preclude the possibility of her being Kate Bender, who was known at that time to be a young and unmarried woman. The physician, Dr. Mervin, who attended Mrs. Johnson, also certifies to the birth and death of this child. This brings the record of Mrs. Davis through the year 1873, and until the month of September after the Benders had disappeared in the previous April.

"It would be difficult to imagine a stronger case of alibi than these affidavits make. all of them from good and reputable citizens, I am satisfied that when I present this proof to the prosecuting attorney, he will agree with me as to the impossibility of these women being in any way connected with the Benders, and will at once favor their discharge."

See the clipping

← Back to Act Four: How They Were Killed