Two women believed to be surviving members of the notorious Bender family, Mrs. Eliza Davis and her mother Mrs. Monroe, arrived at St. Louis amid a grand larceny trial, with Davis reportedly implicating her mother. Detectives express confidence in their identity as more witnesses and physical evidence are examined in connection with the case.
Wichita Eagle · 1 November 1889 · page 1
THE INFAMOUS BENDERS AGAIN ON KANSAS SOIL
St. Louis, Mo., Oct. 31. On the Chicago & Alton train that arrived at the union depot at 7 o'clock this mornini: were two women who are supposed to be the last survivors of the infamous Bender family whoso blood curdling history seat such a thrill of horror through the country about eighteen years ago. The two were Mrs. Eliza Davis, who was on trial for some-
Deputy sheriffs transported two women, one claimed to be Kate Bender and the other alleged to be her mother, the notorious Mrs. Bender, from Michigan to Kansas following a grand larceny trial in Niles. They were to be jailed in Wichita while awaiting trial in Parsons, Kansas for the Bender murders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Wichita Eagle · 1 November 1889 · page 1
Eliza Davis, who was on trial for someroe, whom Mrs. Davis, during her trial, claimed is the notorious Mrs. Bender, the mother of the Kansas family of murderers. Mrs. DayiB, in allegine Mrs. Monroe to be old Mi. Bender admits herself to be Kate Bender and on ber own admission will be made to suffer in company with her mother, piovidinc Mrs. Monroe is proven to be tho notorious murderess. The deputy sheriff who accompanied tho two women had beeniuNiles, Micb., for several days during Mrs. Davis' trial for grand larceny, awaiting the conclusion, that they might immediately start with tho two for Labette county, Kansas.where
A special dispatch reports that Deputy Sheriff Dick of Labette County, Kansas escorted two female prisoners believed to be Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender through Sedalia, Missouri toward Parsons, Kansas. The report credits the arrest to Mrs. Albert McCann, who sought revenge for her father's murder by the Benders years earlier and stands to gain a reward if the women are convicted.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Wichita Eagle · 1 November 1889 · page 1
THE STORT OK THEIR ARREST. St. LOUIS, Mo., Oct. 31. A special to the Republic from Sedalln, Mo., pays. Deputy Sheriff Dick, of Labette county, Kansas, passed through Sedalia this afternoon en route to Parsons, Kan., with the two female prisoners who are thought to bo the notorious Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender. Mr. Dick was living iu Latette county at the time of the Bender murders and knew the Bender family well. He says theie is no doubt he has thu right partie". Tne uarrative of their arrest at Nile, Mich., as related by him, di-cloes one of the neatest pieces of dutoctive work eve perpetrated by a womau.
See moreSee less
The arrest was at the instance of Mrs. Albert Mc Cann, ot McJherson, Kan. If thev? pirlies are convicted she will get 110,000, but It was not money she was after. Hie worked for revenge Her father, John M Sand ford, was murdered by the Benders at Windsor, Can., twenty-four years ago. They lied thu country and located on a farm in I.jibette county, four miles south west of where Parsons now stands. They 'tavern" and did their deadly work. When the Bendermur-
A newspaper brief reports that Mrs. Eliza Davis, discharged from custody in Niles, Michigan, on a larceny charge, is now believed to be the daughter of old Mrs. Bender, tying her to the infamous Kansas Bender murders. The item treats this identification as a new, unverified development in the long search for the fugitive Bender family.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 1 November 1889 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Two women arriving in St. Louis on an Alton train were reported to be the last survivors of the notorious Bender family, long wanted for a string of murders. The dispatch frames them as being taken toward Kansas, evoking the family's horrific reputation.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
St. Paul Daily Globe · 1 November 1889 · page 5
OP BLOODY MEMORY. Old Mrs. Bender and Her Daugh ter Kit Route to Kansas. St. Louis. Mo., Oct. 31.— 0n the Chi cago & Alton train that arrived at the
Two women, Mrs. Eliza Davis and her mother Mrs. Munro, arrived in St. Louis under guard, believed to be Kate Bender and old Mrs. Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family. They were being taken on to Kansas to stand trial for the Bender killings after Davis's acquittal on an unrelated larceny charge in Michigan.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
St. Paul Daily Globe · 1 November 1889 · page 5
OF BLOODY MEMORY.
Old Mrs. Bender and Her Daugh ter Kit Route to Kansas. St. Louis. Mo., Oct. 31.— 0n the Chi cago & Alton train that arrived at the union depot at 7 o'clock this morning were two women who were supposed to be the last survivors of the infamous Bender family, whoso blood-curdling history sent a thrill of horror through the country fome eighteen years aso. Thet*o were. Mrs. tliza Davis, who was on trial for some time in Niles, Mich., on the chartre of grand larceny, aud her mother. Mrs. Munro, whom Mrs.
See moreSee less
Davis during her trial claimed is the notorious Mrs. Bender,the mother of the Kansas family of murder ers. Mrs. Davis, in alleging Mis. Munro to be old Mrs. Bender, admits herself to be Kate Bender, and on her own admis sion will be made to suffer in company
Deputy sheriffs escort two silent, veiled women—believed to be Ma and Kate Bender—by train from Michigan through Chicago toward Kansas, where they are to be jailed in Wichita pending trial. The report also credits their capture to Mrs. Albert McCann, who sought revenge after a deathbed confession implicated the Benders in her father's murder years earlier.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
St. Paul Daily Globe · 1 November 1889 · page 5
leaving that place on the Chicago & Alton last nigtit. As soon as the train stopped in the union depot this morn ins, the women were assisted to alight by the deputy sheriffs, and made their way at once to the breakfast room, where they remained mitll the de parture of tho Missouri Pacific train for Kansas City, bearing them with it on their way to Emporia, Kan., where their trial is to take, place. While awaiting their trial they wiil be locked up in the jail in Wichita. The two women were dressed in plain dark clothes and both wore veils, which were pulled down over their faces dur ing the entire tinio they remained at the depot.
See moreSee less
As for replying to any questions put to them, they absolutely refused to make any reply whatever, and maintained a rigid silence, and were evidently heartily glad when called upoii a few minutes later to board the train for their journey West to escape their questioner. At every previous towu at which the Benders stopped on their way to Kansas they maintained the same . reticence they evinced at the union depot.
Mrs. Almira Monroe and her daughter, suspected to be Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender of the infamous Kansas murder family, were escorted through St. Louis by a Labette County deputy en route to Kansas. The women refused to talk, with the daughter admitting her mother's identity but denying that she herself is Kate Bender.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 1 November 1889 · page 5
KEEPING A SECRET.
Btnnlier and Frank Kourse, aged 16 years, hour. Then they went into the ladies' wait ing room and remained there until their train was made up, when they entered it, and they did not leave the car after that While at the depot they posi tively refused to talk to anybody. Mrs. McCaun, of Lansing, Mich., was also in the party. .It was through detective work performed by her that the women were arrested. She is a daughter of one of the Bender victims. The prisoners declare she is not in her right mind, and that there is nothing in the charges preferred by her.
See moreSee less
Deputy Sheriff Dick is well acquainted with the crimes of the Benders, he having unearthed the first' corpse discovered in the secret burial ground of the family in Kansas. He is confident the pair are Mrs. Bender and the friend, Kate. The Kansas officer kept his presence in Michigan very quiet, and nothing was known of it, except by the authorities, until he arrested the two women and was ready to take the train and leave the State. Quite a scene occurred when he made the arrest Mrs. Monroe made a vigorous resistance and declared she would not be taken alive; she
A Kansas deputy sheriff who had discovered the first Bender victim's body tracked down and arrested two women in Michigan, convinced they were Mrs. Bender and her daughter Kate. One woman fiercely resisted arrest before turning calm, while the younger woman admitted her mother was Mrs. Bender but denied being Kate, claiming to be another sister.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Pittsburg Dispatch · 1 November 1889 · page 5
scene occurred when he made the arrest Mrs. Monroe made a vigorous resistance and declared she would not be taken alive; she would die in her tracks first. Deputy Sher iff Earl, of Niles, forced her into a carriage, however, and she was taken down to the depot There her mind changed completely. She became very cool and-calm, and treated the whole matter as a huge joke. Her daughter had little to say. She stated that her mother was Mrs. Bender, but denied that .she herself was Kate Bender. She said she was another sister, and that when the proper time came she wonld make full disclosures.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Two women arriving in St. Louis are rumored to be survivors of the notorious Bender murder family from Kansas. One, Mrs. Davis, claims under trial for larceny that she is Kate Bender and that her mother, Mrs. Munro, is the infamous Mrs. Bender.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 1 November 1889 · page 1
Of the Crimen of the ft'uiuoua llender* Re* caiied-Kate Homier in St. Louin. St. Louis, Oct. 31.?On the Culcago A Alton train that arrived at the Union depot at 7 o'clock this morning, were two women, who were supposed to be the last survivors of the Infamous Ben der family, whose bloodcurdling history sent u thrill of horror through the coun try somo eighteen years ago. The two were Mrs. Ellta, Davis, who was on trial for sonic time in Nlles, Mich., on thechurge of graud larceny, uud her mother, Mrs.
See moreSee less
Munro, whom Mrs. Davis, during her trial, claimed is tho notorious Mrs. Bender, the mother of the Kansas family of murderers. Mrs. Davis admits herself to be Kate Bender, and on her own admission, will be made to suffer In company with her mother, provided Mrs. Munro is proven to be tho notorious raur eriss.
A mother and daughter, Mrs. Davis and Mrs. Munro, were taken into custody in St. Louis after Mrs. Davis claimed her mother was the notorious Kate Bender. The report notes Mrs. Munro admits to being Kate Bender, tying the pair to the infamous Kansas murder family from nearly twenty years earlier.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Wheeling Register · 1 November 1889 · page 1
BENDER MURDERESSES. Tnp Notorlnnn K*»rn4M f’rlinlri'il* H«»llevbil to it* Cutlgh . St. Lons October Hi.— On I be Chicago and Alton train that arrived a* the Union deptul 7 o'clock this morning were two women who wore mpp.vscd to he the last eorvivorscf the infamon-. Bender f»Oiily, who o blood-curdling biatoiy 8>nt n thrill cf horror ttaioogh the con d try some eighteen years ego. The two were Mia. Elz» Davie, who wan on trial for earn-1 tune in Niles, Mich, on tfco charge of grand larceny end her mother, Mrs.
See moreSee less
Mnmo, v h< m Mre. Devis dnritg her trial claimed was the no’or ona Mrs. Bander, the mother of the Kansas family of mnideieia. Mra. Davia alleges Mr9 Mnnro to lit old Mu lender, adn its hmelf to he Kate Bender, and no her own admission will he made to suffer in com pany with her mother, provided Mrs. Mnnro is proven to he the notorious mur deress.
During a grand larceny trial in Niles, Michigan, testimony suggested that Mrs. Monroe, mother of defendant Eliza Davis, was connected to the Bender murders, with Eliza claiming her mother was actually old Mrs. Bender. Kansas officers had been investigating for ten days and were seeking extradition to bring the suspects to Labette County, Kansas for trial.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Leavenworth Advocate · 2 November 1889 · page 1
over $1,000,000. He is president of the Y. M. C. A. _ Kansas Officers After the Benders. Niles, Mich., Oct. 30. —Mrs. Eliza Davis was discharged yesterday on the charge of grand larceny. During the trial many facts were adduced tending to show that Mrs. Mon.roe, Mrs. Davis’s mother, was connect ed with the Bender murders in Kansas. By her own admission Mrs. Monroe has had seven husbands and a number of them have mysteriously disappeared. Her daughter Eliza insists positively that Mrs. Monroe is old Mrs. Bender. Much interest was man ifested, and many blood-curdling and hor rible revelations were brought out during the examination.
See moreSee less
Officers from Kansas have been in the state for ten days investigating the case and are satisfied that they have at last dis covered the notorious Bender family. A requisition has been asked for and as soon as it arrives the parties will be taken to Labette county, Kansas, for trial.
The article reports that Mrs. Bender and her daughter Kate, wanted for the notorious 1873 Kansas murders, were finally captured in Niles, Michigan, living under assumed names. It recaps the original case, including Senator York's investigation into his missing brother that led to suspicion of the Bender family.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Morning News · 2 November 1889 · page 4
Tbe Bender Murderers. Tbe notorious Mrs. Bender, and her I daughter Kate, have been caught, and are on their way to Labette county, Kan., tbe scene of their many orimee. They were discovered at Niles, Mich. Mrs. Bender wsi living under the name of Mrs. Monroe, and the daughter was known as Mrs. Sarah E Davis. Mrs. Bender resisted arrest, and declared that she would not go back to Kansas. The officer* very quickly caused her to change her mind. The daughter, Kate, declared that she was not the Kate tbe officers wanted.
See moreSee less
She was fully recog nized, however, and finally made some damaging statements against her mother. The crimes with which these women are charged were committed in 1873 in a frame house that stood on the highway in Labette county, Kansas. The house was upon the open pairie, and was far removed from any other dwelling. The Bender family oc cupied it. A sign was displayed from it announcing to travelers that they could be accommodated with meals and lodging In 1873, there were very few people in that part of Kansas, but a great many travelers passed the Bender house on their way to counties further south. The Bender family consisted of three persons, the old man Bender, bis wife, and his daughter Kate. In the early part of 1873 a brother of Senator York, of Kansas, started for one of the southern counties. He did not reach his destination, and Senator York Began an investigation of his whereabouts. He was traced as far as the house of the Benders. The Bender family denied having seen him. Senator York began to suspect that he had been murdered, and determined to search the Bender premises. The Benders became alarmed and fled while Senator York was away seeking assistance. A search of the Bender premises resulted in startling revelations. Not only were the remains of the brother of Senator York found buried in tbe garden, but also tbe re mains of quite a large number of other persons, ail of whom, it appeared from the examination of the bodies, had been mur dered. The way the Benders dealt with their victims was this: They murdered only travelers who were alone, and who, they had reason to think, carried a good deal of money. Each victim at meal time was so placed that his back was close to a light quilt that was suspended from the ceiling. Behind this quilt old man Bender stood with a big club, and when a favorable opportunity presented itself he struck the unsuspecting guest a terrible blow on the buck of the head. The guest was knocked senseless, if not killed. He was at once dropped through a trap-door into the cellar, and there a knife was driven through his heart. Tbe body was then robbed, and at night was carried to the garden and buried. The discoveries made at the house of the Benders created a sensation, not only in Kansas but througbout the entire country. The Benders were vigorously pursued, aud it is said that old man Bender was caught in the Indian territory and shot The women escaped, and all trace of them was lost until they were discovered the other day in Michigan. Doubtless it will not be difficult to get sufficient evidence to bang them.
The report recaps the 1873 Bender killings in Labette County, Kansas, describing how travelers were robbed and murdered using a hammer and trapdoor cellar, prompted by the recent identification of a Bender woman in Michigan. It claims the family fled after Senator York investigated his missing brother and that old man Bender was later caught and shot.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
A dispatch from Richmond, Indiana recounts ex-Kansas newsman Ed Parker's story that a Cherokee Indian witnessed the whole Bender family killed by vigilantes in 1873, with relics dug up to support the claim. Parker uses this to cast doubt on the current report that Mrs. Bender and Kate have been captured in Michigan.
The Indianapolis Journal · 2 November 1889 · page 4
SAYS THE BENDERS ARE DEAD
Recollections of a Cherokee Indiau Who Claims to Have Seen the Family Slaughtered. Epfteinl to the Imllanapcil! Journal Richmond, Ind., Nov. 1. Ed Parker, who; was working on a paper in Kansas when the Benders took their flight, aud again iu Parsons when tho report was rife ten years ago that "old man Bender" and his wifo had been .found in Colorado, says his work there convinces him that old Mrs. Bender and Kate have not been found in Michigan now. Working in the office was an Indian boy who said his father saw tho whole Bender family killed in 1S73, and -Parker
A reporter investigates claims that two arrested women are old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, finding evidence of a massacre site described by a Cherokee informant. However, a man who knew the real Benders fails to identify the prisoners, noting the old woman spoke flawless English (unlike the German-accented original) and Kate Bender's appearance didn't match, leading locals to believe vigilantes had already killed the real Benders years earlier.
The Indianapolis Journal · 2 November 1889 · page 4
SAYS THE BENDERS ARE DEAD.
Parker, a reporter, easily found the spot, and by digging unearthed harness irons, wagou-tires, pieces of chains,- etc, among a bed of ashes. This convinced them that tho old Cherokee s 6tory was true. But Parker says ho has confidence in Lerov F. Dick, whom ho knew person ally well, and if ho will say tho prisoners are old Mrs. Bender ami Kate, ho will be lieve it. Yet Parker says that at tho. frame time. IH7 ho went to see Colonel' York, the leader of the pursuers, at Fyt Scott, and asked him what he thought of tho repoiied capture.
See moreSee less
His response, with a knowing look, was that when he was tho sole survivor of tho band ho would tell the fate of the Benders, but till then ho musS be silent. A special from Oswego, Kan., says: Deput3' Sheriff Dick arrived here this morumg with hps prisoners. iThey were me t at the station by Prosecuting Attorney Morris, who placed them in a carriage and had them conveyed to a private .residence, the location of -which he will reveal to no one. There they were kept all day aud no one was perm tied to see them, not even the reporters or persons who had come to town to seo if they could identify the prisoners. One man was admitted to see them by Mr. Morris, but he would not say who it was. Ho did say, however, that tho man had known the Benders and that ho had failed to identify the prisoners as old Mrs. Bender and Kate. When he know the Benders, fifteen years ago, the old woman could speak only Ger man. Mrs. Griffith, who is supposed to be the old woman, speaks nerft-ct English, without a hint at German accent. Kate Bender, he told Mr. Morris, bore no resemblance whatever to Mrs. Davis, There is no excitement whatever here over the arrival of the prisoners. Tho people are convinced that the vigilantes who, fif teen years ago, started out to avenge the Bender murders did their work well, and that no member of the family is now alive. Former acquaintances will be taken to see the prisoners, to-morrow, in tho endeavor to identify them. The preliminary exami nation has been set for Monday. llattle lletweeuiOyftter lirate and roller.
Kansas officers brought a woman calling herself Mrs. Munro from Niles, Michigan, back to Kansas, alleging she is the infamous Mrs. Bender wanted for the Labette County murders. Her daughter, Mrs. Davis—recently acquitted of grand larceny—insists the woman is indeed Mrs. Bender, while some believe Mrs. Davis herself is Kate Bender.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
Chicago Eagle · 2 November 1889 · page 2
Tilt: BKtiDKR CRIMES HI.C A 1. 1 1. 1). Belief thai ,W-.. Bender lias Been Living in Mirhiaan. Kansas officers have taken to that State from Nilos, Mich., a Woman calling herselt Mrs. Munro, whose daughter was acquitted the other day of a charge of grand larceny. It is alleged that the aged dame is the in famous Mrs. Bender, whoso family many years ago committed many murders in Labetta County, Kansas. Mrs. Davis, the daughter, insists that the Munro woman is, in fact, Mrs. Bender; and many persons believe that Mrs. Davis is herself the not ',
Deputy Sheriff Dick brought two women, Mrs. Almira Griffith and Mrs. Eliza Davis, to Oswego, Kansas on suspicion they were Ma Bender and Kate Bender, but a man who had known the real Benders failed to identify them. The townspeople believe the vigilantes who pursued the Benders fifteen years earlier had already dealt with the actual family.
Heavy Snow Fall Throughout the Northwest. Omaha, Neb., Nov. I.— Heavy snow has been falling hero since - early this morning. The storm played havoc with the railway telegraph wires and over land trains generally. A fall of about six inches of snow was 'reported at the Union Pacific headquarter from several towns in Western Xebraska, while in Wyoming a blizzard isprevailing, and it is feared a blockade will compel the suspension of trains. Telegraph wires on the Burlington are broken at several points west of Omaha.-. Trains on the Elkhorn branch were delayed more or less owing to the heavy fall of snow in the territory traversed by that road.
See moreSee less
The snow is reported to have fallen as far west as Valentine, and the latter point reports that the mercury iv the posed that Bolaud was the name by which tie was known ia these places. i j NOOXE KNOWS THEM. Failnro to Identity Sheriff Dick's Ir- --c Prisoners as the Benders, i ' : Oswego, Kan., Nov. I.— Deputy Sher iff Dick, who arrested Mrs. Almira Grif fith, of Niles, Mich., and Mrs. Eliza Davis, of Lansing, Mich., on the sup position that they are two of the notedBender family,arrived here this morning with his prisoners. They were met at the station by Prosecuting Attorney Mains, who placed them in a carriage' and had them conveyed to a pri\ate residence, the location of which he will reveal to no one. 'Ihere they were kept all day and no one was permitted to see them, not even the reporters or persons who had come to town to see if they could identify the prisoners. One' man, Mr. Morris said, was admitted to i see them, but be would say who it was. He did say, however, that the man had known the Benders, and that he bad failed to identify the prisoners as old Mrs. Bender and Kate. When he knew the Benders fifteen years ago, the old woman could speak only German. Mrs. Griffith, who is sup posed to be the old woman, speaks per fect English, without a hint at accent. Kate Bender, he told Mr. Morris, bore no resemblance whatever to Mrs. Davis. There is no excitement whatever here over the arrival of the prisoners. The people are convinced that the vigilantes who fifteen years ago started out to avenge the Bender murders did their work well, and that no members of the family are now alive. Former acquaintances will be taken to see the prisoners to-morrow in the endeavor to identify them. The preliminary exami nation has been set for Monday. - - . NOT THE PARTIK3 WANTED. - j
A man who knew the Benders fifteen years ago said the arrested woman spoke perfect English, unlike old Mrs. Bender who only spoke German, and that Kate Bender looked nothing like Mrs. Davis. A separate witness, Edward Parker, recounted an old Cherokee's eyewitness account of vigilantes killing the entire Bender family in 1873 and burning their bodies, a site he later excavated and found wagon and harness remains.
York, the leader of the pursuers of the Benders at Fort Scott, and asked -him what he thousiht of the reported cap ture of the Benders in Colorado. His response, made with a knowing look, was that when he was the sole survivor of the band he would tell the fate of the Benders, but until then he must be silent. ;;;":' '
A brief item claims notorious Kate Bender and her mother have been captured at Niles, Michigan, living under aliases, with Kansas officers escorting them home. It states Kate has confessed, while sarcastically comparing the news to expected hoaxes about Tascott and Charley Ross.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 2 November 1889 · page 2
'"" ,7' ' . " "T" . , The slabs are to be hermetically sealed ,...,., , . and the tomb will be made so strong n 11 1 iht Inmli will I. a ii. diIh on qImii.i. that only a determined effort by pro fessional body-snatchers could rob the coffin of its contents. It is now thought that the notorious Kate Bender and her mother bave been captured at Nilea, Michigan, and officers from Labette county, Kansas,
A Niles, Michigan trial revealed testimony suggesting Mrs. Monroe, mother of defendant Eliza Davis, was actually 'old Mrs. Bender' of the infamous Kansas murder family, with multiple vanished husbands cited as evidence. Kansas officers investigated for ten days and the two women were being transported back to Kansas to face charges related to the 1873 murder of Col. York.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Dickinson Press · 2 November 1889 · page 2
CAUGHT THE NOTORIOUS BENDER.
The Fiemlish Kansas Hag Ilctrayed to the rolice by Her Own Daughter. NILES, Mich., Oct. 81.—Mrs. Eliza Davis was discharged Tuesday on the charge of grand larceny. During the trial many facts were adduced tending to show that Mrs. Monroe (Mrs. Davis' mother) was connected with the Bender murders in Kansas. By her own ad missions Mrs. Monroe has had seven husbands, and a number of them have mysteriously disappeared. Her daughter Eliza insists positively that Mrs. Monroe is old Mrs. Bender. Much interest was manifested and many blood-curdling and horrible revelations were brought out during the examination, Officers from Kansas have been in the 6tate for ten days investigating the case, and are sat isfied that they have at last discovered the notorious Bender family.
See moreSee less
Taken llaek to Kansas. NILES, Mich., Oct. 31.—Mrs. Monroe and her daughter, Sire. Davis, believed to he the famous Mrs*. Bender and lier daughter, Kate Bender, who were im plicated in the terrible series of murders in Labette county, Kansas, years ago, have started West in charge of Deputy Sheriff L. F. Dick. The particular charge laid at their door is the assassina tion of Col. York in 1873.
Seven people who had known the Bender family were brought to Oswego, Kansas, to view Mrs. Griffith and Mrs. Davis, arrested in Niles, Michigan as suspected Bender women. Only two witnesses thought Mrs. Davis resembled Kate Bender, while five others saw no resemblance, and the preliminary hearing was postponed to November 14.
The Indianapolis Journal · 3 November 1889 · page 2
CANNOT IDENTIFY THE
Benders but three tunes, was euro that Mrs. Davis was Kate Bender. James Phillips was of a similar opin ion. Five others, however, who had been well acquainted with the Benders could seo no resemblance, and laughed at the idea of the prisoners heme the Benders. J. T. James, of Fort Smith, Ark., has been employed by one of Mrs. Davis's former liusbanus to aeienu me prisoners, lie ar rived hero to-day and after a consultation with County Attorney Morris it was decid ed that the preliminary examination bhould be postponed until Nov.
See moreSee less
It. Mrs. Davis todav consented to see tne reporters, fehe safd Mrs. McCann. who was instrumental in procuring their arrest, was a spiritual ist and mesmerist and had her (Mrs. Davis) completely under her control when ever they were.alone. - m Township Trustee Fight Ended, pedal to tlm IiulJauapoll Jxmutf.
Mrs. Davis, held with her mother on suspicion of being Kate and old Mrs. Bender, claimed a spiritualist had mesmerized her into making false statements. Of seven witnesses who had known the Benders, only two tentatively identified the women while five saw no resemblance, and the preliminary hearing was postponed to November 18.
Wichita Eagle · 3 November 1889 · page 1
NO ONE IDENTIFIES TIIEM. The prisoners have not yet been identi fied as members of tbe murdeous family. Seven persons who had kuown tho Ben dors well were taken to see the suipects today, but only two of them could ccmo anywhere near making an identification. One old man kuown as Uncle Joseph Storey, who had seen tbe Benders but three times, was sure that Mrs. Davis was Kate Bender. James Phillips was of a himilar opinion. Five others, however, who bad been weli acquainted with the Benders, could seo no resemblance, and laughed at the idea of the persons being the Benders.
See moreSee less
J. T. James, of Fort Smith. Ark., has been employed by one of Mrs. Davis' former husbands to defend tue prisoners. He arrived hero today, and after a consul tation with County Attorney Morris it was decided that the preliminary examina tion should be postpoued until Novem ber 18.
Mrs. Griffith and Mrs. Davis, arrested in Niles, Michigan on suspicion of being the elder Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, have not been positively identified despite being viewed by seven people who knew the real Benders. Mrs. Davis claimed her accuser, Mrs. McCann, was a Spiritualist who had exerted mental control over her.
Oswego, Sax., November 2. Mrs. Grif fith and Mrs. Davis, who were arrested at Niles. Mich., on suspicion of being the old woman Bender and Kate Bender, have not yet been identified as members of the notorious family. Seven persons who had known the Benders well were taken to see the sMpeets to-day, but oalytwoof them could come anywhere nev making aa identification.
In Oswego, Kansas, witnesses who knew the Bender family were brought to view Mrs. Griffith and Mrs. Davis, arrested in Niles, Michigan on suspicion of being the elder Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender. Only two of seven witnesses thought Mrs. Davis resembled Kate Bender, while five others saw no resemblance, and the preliminary examination was postponed to November 18.
The Indianapolis Journal · 4 November 1889 · page 3
Cannot Identify the Benders. Oswego, Kan., Nov. 2. Mrs. Griffith and Mrs. Davis, who wero arrested at Niles, Mich., on the suspicion of being the old
Suspects Griffith and Davis, arrested in Niles, Michigan on suspicion of being Old Man Bender and Kate Bender, were shown to seven people who had known the Benders. Only two thought there was a resemblance, while five others saw no likeness and dismissed the identification.
Weekly Courier-Journal · 4 November 1889 · page 1
Oswego Kan Nov 2— Mrs Griffith and Mrs Davis who were arrested at Niles Mich on the suspicion of being the old woman Bender and Kate Bender have not yet been identified as the mem bers of the ' noted murderous family Seven persons who had known" the Benders well' -were taken to see the sus pects to-day but only two of them could come anywhere near - making an Iden tification An old man known as Uncle Joseph Storreyfl who had seen the Bend ers but three times was sure that Mrs Davis was Kate Bender James Phil lips was of a similar opinion Five others however who had been well-acquainted with the Benders could see no reoemDianoe ana jaugnea at tne idea of the prisoners being the Benders J' T James of Ft Smith Arkt has been employed by one of Mrs Davis former husbands to defend toe prisoners lie arrived here to-day and after a consul tation with County Attorney Morris it wbb decided that the preliminary exam ination should be postponed until No vember 1 8 - Mrs Davis to-day consented to see the reporters She said Mrs Me Cann who was instrumental in procur ing their arrest was a spiritualist and mesmerist and had her l-urs Davis) completely under her control whenever they were alone -
In Oswego, Kansas, witnesses who had known the Bender family were brought to view Mrs. Griffith and Mrs. Davis, arrested in Niles, Michigan on suspicion of being Old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender. Only two of seven witnesses thought they recognized the women, while five others saw no resemblance, leaving the identification unresolved as a lawyer arrived to defend the suspects.
The article reports that Deputy Sheriff L. F. Dick brought two female prisoners through Sedalia, identified as 'Old Mrs. Bender' and her daughter Kate, wanted for the infamous Labette County murders eighteen years earlier. It credits their capture at Niles, Michigan to detective work by Mrs. Allen McGann, whose father was allegedly a Bender victim, and recounts the discovery of the Bender farm graveyard.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 5 November 1889 · page 1
Deputy Sheriff L. F. Dick, of Par sons, Kus.. passed turough the city last evening with two female prison ers who have been identified as Old Mr? Bender and daughter, Kate, of the notorious Bender family who per petrated a dozen atrocious murders in Labette county, Kan., eighteen years ago and for whom a reward of $5,000 each is still standing. Depuly Sheriff Dick wns living m the county at that time and knew the family well. He says there is no doubt but what his prisoners are the persons wanted.
See moreSee less
They were ariesied at iNiIes, Michigan ann a neat piece ot detective work by n woman, Mrs. Allen Mc Gann. of McPherson, Kas., was there by disclosed, and she will ge a re ward of 810,000, but it was not money she was working for. It was a labor of love and revenge, for her father Mr. John W. Sanford, was one of Ben der's victims. They murdered him at Windsor, Canada, twenty-four year3 ago, and fled the country going to Labette county, Kaneas, where they
The report describes how Mrs. McCann, daughter of Bender victim John Sanford, spent years tracking down a woman who confessed to being involved in her father's murder, eventually locating her in Niles, Michigan. It claims Kansas officers obtained a requisition after being presented proof that the women arrested as 'Mrs. Monroe' and 'Mrs. Eliza Daws' were truly the long-missing Bender women.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 5 November 1889 · page 1
direction ot JBenders and were never seen again. Little remark was caused as the missing ones were from distant points and had no friends in the fate. One afternoon Dr. York, a well known v'tvsician of Kansas, acc mio years oiu, ieit r arsons and were never seen again alive. F ailing to hear from him his fi lends instituted a diligent search. The brother of the missing man, an attorney now living iu ir near Tupeka, headed the parly. Dr. York and his boy nere traced to the Bender ranch and there the frail ceased.
See moreSee less
The family had grown into disrepute and a careful examination of the premises was made. Pending the search the Benders fled, and sus picion became certainty. Renewed enort3 to hnd the bodies were made, for all hope of discovering the unfor tunate doctor had been abandoned. At last the father and son were fouud in one shallow grave near the house. A posse was organized which took the trail of the fugitive?. Upon their return the. vigilance committee gave it out that the Benders had escaped their vengeance. Other reports or a directly opp j3tng char acter were also circulated, so that the fate of the murderers has, like the whereabouts of one Tascott, always been a matter of uncertainty. After the finding of the bodies of Dr. York and his child further search was made and the graves of eighteen or tweit'y more victims were found. Several were identified as those cf cattle bu -ers who carried large sums of money. A trap door was discovered in the floor of the principal room of th 4 house, opening into a cellar, Tue unconscious victims were seated over this door aud precipitated to their death below. The murders of the Benders are believed to have all been committed within the period of eigh teen months. The farm on which the Benders
This report recounts the discovery of Dr. York's murder, the uncovering of the Bender family's killing spree, and the subsequent search for mass graves on their farm. It also notes the farm's later notoriety as a tourist attraction and site of superstition.
A former Kansas constable now living in Los Angeles dismisses recent reports of the Bender women's capture as false. He claims the entire Bender family was actually killed near Coal Creek shortly after Dr. York's murder in 1872.
The Renders Were Exterminated. Los Angeles. Nov. 6.?Mr. Cabely of this place, who was constable of Havana town ship, Montgomery county, Kan., in 1872, when the Benders made their alleged escape, laughs at the story of the capture of the old woman and Kate. He docs not criminate himself di rectly. but gives it out that the entire Bender family was exterminated near Coal creek, in the ltoek Hill section, immediately ufter the murder of Dr. York. Mr. Cabely is a reliable man.
The report reveals that Mrs. Monroe had fabricated a Bender sighting story merely to obtain a free trip to Kansas. Yet the same column also repeats a claim that the notorious Bender family had been located in Michigan and was being returned to Kansas to face justice for crimes committed eighteen years earlier.
The Globe-Republican · 6 November 1889 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
It now transpires that it was Mrs. Monroe who "worked" Mr. McCann. She invented the Bender story just to get a free ride to Kansas. O, Kansas is a great state, and people will do almost anything to get here!—Hutchinson News.
The notorious Bender family has been heard from at last, way up in Michigan and returned to Kansas where they will have to answer for their atrocious crimes comunitted in this state some eighteen years ago. We only hope the officers may have the original Benders of Cherryvale notoriety.
Two women, Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Sarah Davis, suspected of being Bender family members, were extradited from Michigan to Labette County, Kansas. A Kansas City police officer claims the real Benders were long ago captured by vigilantes and burned to death, making identification now impossible.
Monroe and Mrs. Sarah Davis, and Fri day they were brought to Labette county this state by Deputy Sheriff L. F. Dick. The following history of their crimes, and an interview with a Kansas City official, is taken from the Evening News of that city: the interview. "Identify the Benders!" exclaimed a city officer, who was one of the pioneers of southern Kansas during the Bender excitement. "If charred bits of bones and white ashes which have long since been tossed to the winds can be gathered together and be identified, then the Benders can be found.
See moreSee less
There were wild times in the southeastern part of Kansas during the early part of the 70's, and the vigilants ruled society with laws of iron. The Benders did not escape them. They were taken from their wagon, which was subsequently found and bound to trees around which a mammoth brush pile was built and then Ignited. I have seen the Benders sev eral times, and Kate Bender, the girl, was one of the handsomest women in that part of Kansas. The brother of Dr. York now lives in Topeka. He knows of the Benders1 death and that is why he has never taken steps to investigate the supposed arrests of those criminals." "How do you know the Benders were burned?" "I do know it, but I will not say how. I know of two who were there and saw it. At first the band was sworn to keep the matter of the retribution a secret, but it has come to light from time to time and it is useless to keep the secret longer. Too many innocent persons have suf fered by it. You can set it down that the people arrested in Michigan will never be proven to be the Benders of Cherryvale, and Labette county will be short the expenses of transportation."
A source claims the Bender family was captured by Kansas vigilantes in the 1870s, bound to trees in a brush pile, and burned alive, asserting two witnesses confirm this. The article also recounts an unrelated 1880s hoax where a theater owner's con act was mistaken for the real Benders by police.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Responding to news of a Bender arrest, a Topeka police chief recounts an old rumor that vigilantes seized the Bender family, tied them to trees, and burned them alive in the 1870s. He suggests this is why relatives of a victim never investigate later reports of captured Benders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Portland Daily Press · 6 November 1889 · page 1
THE BENDERS WERE BURNED.
Tale of Bones and Ashes. tr ... . n_ ir.. it_ _i_ w 'l* i... news t*iat tile Benders have been arrested by Kansas officers is received here, among those who are cognizant of the facts iu that notoriou i case witli much incredulity. Cuief of Police Speers was seen in regard to the mutter, as he is the best posted man on criminal affairs iu the West. He was one of the pioneers and was interested in the Bender excitement in 1878, when the party was run out of Kansas.
See moreSee less
He said: "If charred bits of bones and white ashes which have long since been tossed to the winds can be gathered together and identi fied, then the Benders can he found. There were wiid times in the southern part of Kan sas in the early part of the seventies, and the vigilantes ruled society witli laws of iron. The Benders did not escape them. They were taken from their wagon, which was subsequently found, bound to trees around which a mammoth brush pile was built and then ignited. I have seen the Benders several times, and Kate Bender, the girl, was one of the handsomest women in that part of K msas. The brother of Dr. York now livts in Topeka. He knows of the Benders’ deaths, and that is why he has never taken the trouble to investigate the ar rests of supposed members of the family.”
Deputy Sheriff Dick of Labette County, Kansas passed through Sedalia, Missouri, en route to Parsons, Kansas, escorting two female prisoners believed to be the notorious Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender. The report notes ongoing uncertainty about their true identities.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
New Ulm Weekly Review · 6 November 1889 · page 2
Thc Long lost Bender Family. Deputy Sheriff Diok of La Bette county, Kan., passed through Sedalia Mo en route to Parsons, Kan., with the two female pris oners who are thought to be the notorious begun Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender. Mr Dick by»d.™&
A distiller named Edward Spellman claims the real Benders have finally been caught in Niles, Michigan, based on an elaborate investigation by Mrs. Albert McCann, who tracked down a woman who allegedly confessed to helping murder her father. The report details how McCann pursued the suspect for years before notifying Kansas officials of the supposed capture.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
New Ulm Weekly Review · 6 November 1889 · page 2
rest was at the instance of Mrs. Albert McCann of McPherson, Kansas. If these parties are convicted Bhe will get $10,000. But it was not money she was after. She worked for revenge. Her father, John W. Sanford, was murdered by the Benders at Windsor, Canada. They fled to this country and located on the farm in Kansas, where they kept their "tavern" and did their deadly work. When the Benders murdered Mr. Sanford, Mrs. McCann, was but
This report recounts how Mrs. McCann, whose father was allegedly murdered by the Benders in Canada, tracked down and had arrested two women in Michigan believed to be the long-sought Bender women. Her case rested on a deathbed confession from an acquaintance years earlier, though the suspects later recovered and fled before being relocated.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
A report from Niles, Michigan says that Mrs. Monroe and her daughter, Mrs. Davis, believed to be the notorious Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, have been taken west to Kansas in the custody of a deputy sheriff. They are linked to the infamous Labette County murders years earlier.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Morris Tribune · 6 November 1889 · page 4
Taken the Benders to Kansas.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A dispatch from Niles, Michigan reports that Mrs. Monroe and her daughter Mrs. Davis, believed to be the infamous Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, have been taken west to Kansas in the custody of a deputy sheriff. They are specifically charged with the 1873 murder of Col. York in Labette County.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Morris Tribune · 6 November 1889 · page 5
JLIONDOX, Nov. 4,—Mr. McKinnon has received the following advices from Zan zibar: Letters from Stanley, dated Vic toria Nyanza, Aug. 29. have been re ceived. Stanley had with him Emin Bev, Castati, Ossman Taftin, Steirs, Nelson, fJephson, Parke. Bonny and 800 people flfcconipaning him toward Mpwapwa. All were well, There wt-re reports that Wa delia had been taken by the Mahdists. Taken the Benders to Kansas.
Officers left Niles, Michigan, escorting a woman calling herself Mrs. Monroe and her daughter, Mrs. Davis, amid claims the older woman was the notorious Mrs. Bender and the younger was Kate Bender. The Benders were infamous for murders committed years earlier in Labette County, Kansas.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Mower County Transcript · 6 November 1889 · page 6
It was said that the aged dame was the infamous Mrs. Bender, whoso family years ago committed many murders in Labette County, Kan. Mrs. Davis, the daughter, was also thought to be the
A mother and daughter in Niles, Michigan, were extradited to Kansas after being identified as the notorious Bender family, accused of murdering Col. York in 1873. The identification came from a woman named Mrs. McCann, who claimed the mother had confessed decades earlier to killing her father.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Butler Weekly Times · 6 November 1889 · page 2
SUPPOSED BEXDE113 EXTRADITED. The Oi.i Woman and Her Daughter (.'ail glit In .Viciiisan. Niles, Mich., Oct. 30. During the trial of Mrs. Eliza Duvirt yesterday, on the charge of grand larceny, many facta were adduced tending to show that Mrs, Munroe (Mrs Da vis' mother) was connected with the JUender murders iu Kansas. By her own admission she has had seven husbands and a number of them have mysteriouslydisappeared.Herdaugh ter Eliza insists positively that Bhe is old Mrs. Bender. Much inter est was manifested and many blood curdling and horrible revelations were brought out during the exam ation.
See moreSee less
Officers from Kansas, who had been in the state for ten days inves tigating the case and were satisfied that they had at last discovered the notorious Bender family, at once asked for a requisition for the pair, and when they arrived to-day Mrs Monroe and her daughter, Mrs. Da Tis, the latter supposed now to be Kate Bender, started west in charge of Deputy Sheriff L. F. Dick. The particular charge laid at their door is the assassination of Col. York in 1873.
Deputy Sheriff Dick transported Mrs. Almira Monroe and her daughter Mrs. Eliza Davis, suspected members of the Bender gang, from Niles, Michigan to Kansas. Mrs. Francis McCann, who had spent years tracking the women after a deathbed confession, claims the elder woman is Mrs. Bender and the younger is Kate Bender, though Mrs. Monroe denies any Bender connection.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Butler Weekly Times · 6 November 1889 · page 2
When .she had her plans perfected she notified the Kansas officers and presented proofs satisfactory to them that the women were the long ost Benders and a requisition was made for them. Such is the story of Mrs. McCann, who caused the ar rest of these supposed Benders. English Spavn Liniment removes all Hard, Soit, or Calloused Lumps an Blemishes irom horses, lilooa spavin Curbs, Splints, Sweeney, Stifles, Sprains Sore and Swollen Throat, Coughs, Ltc Save $50 bv use of one bottle. Warrant, ed. old by W. J. Lansdowv, Drug
A report describes two women arrested in Niles, Michigan—Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Davis—amid claims from Mrs. McCann that they are actually Ma Bender and Kate Bender. Former Kansas residents who viewed the prisoners could not identify them as the Benders, and many believed the real Benders' remains lay buried in Indian Territory.
The Butler Weekly Times · 6 November 1889 · page 2
THE TWO WOMEN DESCRIBED. Mrs. Monroe is a toothless, hid eous old crone of 70 and chatters like a migpie upon the slightest provocation. She denies any con nection with the Benders whatever and denounces Mrs. McCaun in strong terms. Mrs. Davis is a woman of 45, far from haudsome and is not at all com municative. Her daughter, aged 3 years accompanies her, Dick says that the mother and daughter quarrel bitterly at inter vals when left to themselves and each accuses the other of being re sponsible for the position in which they are placed at present.
See moreSee less
A large crowd among the num ber former residents of Parsons and Oswego visited the car containing thft party this evening, but were un able to identify the prisoners as the Binders. The opinion largely pre vails among them that the bones of the .Benders are Deneatn the sod. in the Indian Territory and that the parties arrested in Michigan have no connection with the Benders what ever.
Authorities in Niles, Michigan believe they have identified Mrs. Monroe as the notorious 'Old Mrs. Bender,' based on her daughter's testimony and a history of vanished husbands; a requisition for extradition to Kansas has been requested. Kansas officials in Topeka express skepticism about the identification, noting hope of capturing the real Benders had largely been abandoned.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Watertown Republican · 6 November 1889 · page 3
BENDERS IN THE TOILS.
NfL’JS, Mich., Oct. 30.— The notorious Bender family, whose horrible crimes form one of the bloodiest chapters in the bloody history of Kansas, have been found at last. Of this there is no longer any doubt. Mrs. Eliza Davis was discharged yesterday on the charge of grand larceny. During the trial many facts were adduced tending to show that .vlrs. Monroe, Mrs. Davis’ mother, was connected with the Bender murders. By her own admission Mrs. Monroe has had seven husbands and a number ot ttiem have mysteriously disappeared. Her daughter Eliza insists positively that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Monroe is old Mrs. Bender. Much intercut was manifested and many blood-curdling and horrible revela tions were brought out during the examination. Officers from Kansas have been in the state for ten days investigating the case, and are sat isfied that they have at last discovered the notorious Bender family. A re quisition has been asked for, and as soon as it arrives the parties will be taken to Labette County, Kansas, for trial.
The report recounts the history of the Bender family's inn-based murders in Kansas, including the discovery of Dr. York's body and others after his brother grew suspicious. It notes skepticism in Topeka that the woman just arrested in Michigan is truly Mother Bender, and repeats an unconfirmed rumor that the family was once caught and killed by a posse.
Watertown Republican · 6 November 1889 · page 3
Travelers Murdered in Their Beds—Kan sas Authorities Doubtful. Topeka, Kas., Oct. 30. —The statement that the woman arrested at Niles, Mich., is Mother Bender is doubted here although there is no reason why it may not be true. So long a time has elapsed since the family disappeared that all hope of capturing the mur derers has been abandoned. The Ben ders kept a small inn on the road from Parsons to Cherryvale. Travelers often stepped there for dinner, and when on a long journey frequently put up there for the night.
See moreSee less
These, if their enter tainers had reason to suspect that they had any money, never got farther on their travels. Considerable excitement was occasioned in that part of the state by the frequent disappearances re ported, but no search w as made until Dr. York, of Independence, went on atrip to Fort Scott, but did not return. That was in May, 1873. The Doctor’s brother, Col. York, went to Fort IScott to find him. On his way he stopped at the Benders’ home, and their replies to his inquiries aroused his suspicions. He re turned to their house the next day with a posse of men and a search warrant. Thep found the place deserted. Exam ination or a spot in the yard where earth had been freshly turned revealed the body of Dr. York. Further search resulted in the finding of eight or nine other bodies. Search was made for the family, but they had fled beyond pursuit. It was reported that Col. York and friends overtook the party and killed the old man,his wife and the son and daughter, but the report was never confirmed. If the parties ar rested in Michigan are Mother Bender and Kate, tney can be convicted with out trouble, if they escape lynch law.
Hand County Press · Miller, S.D. · and 3 other papers
Two women arrested in Michigan on suspicion of being Mrs. Bender and her daughter Kate were brought to Oswego, Kansas, but a man who had known the Benders failed to identify them. Locals believe vigilantes who hunted the Benders fifteen years earlier succeeded in killing the family.
Benders, and he failed to identify the prisoners as old Mrs. Bender and Kate There is no excitement whatever here over the arrival of the prisoners. The people are convinced that the vigilantes, who, fifteen years ago, started out to avenge the Bender murders, did their work well, and that no member of the family is now alive.
Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn. · 6 November 1889
The Iowa Plain Dealer · New Oregon, Iowa · 7 November 1889
Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · 8 November 1889
Los Angeles Daily Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Prompted by news of Kate Bender and her mother's reported arrest in Michigan, this retrospective recounts the Bender family's wayside inn murders in Kansas, the vigilance committee, and the exhumation of sixteen victims. It notes conflicting accounts of the family's fate—one claiming they were shot by vigilantes, another that they escaped and were never found.
Los Angeles Daily Herald · 7 November 1889 · page 4
The repotted arrest of Kate Bender and her mother in Michigan recalls the history of one ot the most fearful crimi nal episodes that ever occurred in this country. The Benders kept a sort of wayside inn in Montgomery county, Kansas. A number of people had sud denly disappeared, and all traces of them were lost after they had been seen on the road upon which the Bender inn was situated. At last, in 1872, a conspicuous politician and citizen of Lawrence dis appeared, and was last seen in the Ben der vicinity.
See moreSee less
A vigilance committee was organized and a younf brother of Kate Bender was seized and closely ques tioned. He broke down, and disclosed the whole horrible mystery. The Bender house, it is now said, was surrounded, and Kate and her mother put under ar rest. However this may be, a search was made for the bodies of the victims. Thirteen bodies, including that of Mr. York, were exhumed in the Bender orchard. Three more were subsequently discovered. It seems that the Benders placed their victims in a certain position at the table, and that they were struck with an ax from behind, when an open trap door would receive their bodies. Oi cjurse the motive was robbery. A Mr. N. Coberly, who resides in this city, says that Kate and her mother were taken by tbe committee to an isolated place and riddled with bullets, and that young Bender was similarly disposed of after he had
A former constable of Labette County, Kansas, now living in Los Angeles, claims the entire Bender family was killed shortly after fleeing following Dr. York's murder, allegedly in the Rocky Hill region near a creek. This is offered as a belated explanation for their disappearance seventeen years earlier.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 7 November 1889 · page 1
danger. Mr. Cabely of Los Angeles, California, who was constable of Havana Township, h h annua, In 1872, when the Benders made their escape, says that the entire Bender family was exterminated Goal Creek, In the Rocky Hill region. Imme diately after tho murder of Dr. York. William Dixon and Joseph Gilbert quarrelled Id Buffalo, New York. oq
A report from Niles, Michigan describes the arrest of Mrs. Monroe and her daughter Mrs. Davis, suspected to be Ma Bender and Kate Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family, now being taken to Kansas to face charges tied to the killing of Colonel York in 1873. The piece recounts how Mrs. Frances McCann of McPherson County came to suspect their identity through a strange dream-related confession by Mrs. Davis.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 7 November 1889 · page 4
AFTER MANY YEARS.
Are Taken to Kansas. HOW THEY WERE DISCOVERED. Niles, Mich., Nov. 1. —Mrs. Monro and her daughter, Mrs. Davis, believed to be the famous Mrs. Bender and her daughter, Kate Bender, who were im plicated in the terrible series of murders in Labette County, Kan., years ago, started WeOt Wednesday in charge of Deputy Sheriff L. F. Dick. The par ticular charge laid at their door is tho assassination of Colonel York in 1873. The history of the Bender family, and especially of their atrocious mur ders of Dr. York and others in Labetto County, Kan., eighteen or twenty years ago, bids fair to be ug&in made fresh in the public mind.
See moreSee less
Their home on the roadside in that new and sparsely set tied country was a veritable charnel house. Their murderous deeds scarcely have a parallel in history. Mrs. Frances E. McCann, of McPher son County, Kan., the wife of a wealthy and respected merchant of that place, la credited with discovering the identity between Mrs. Monroe and old Mrs. Bender. Mrs. McCann's story is about as follows:
An account describes Mrs. Davis confronting a woman believed to be Mrs. Bender, who eventually admits her family's identity and recounts additional murders including one near Dowagiac. Photographs of the suspect are sent to people who knew the Benders in Kansas and are identified as matching Mrs. Bender.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 7 November 1889 · page 4
HOW THEY WERE DISCOVERED.
and my sister cut his throat." Mrs. Davis told Mrs. McCann of other crimes and murders committed by her step-mother, supposed to be Mrs. Bender, and was asked: "Isn’t your mother old Mrs. Bendert" The woman flew into a passion and refused to talk further In a subsequent conversation she acknowl edged that they were the Bender family. She then threatened Mrs. McCann if she ever revealed what she had told. Mrs. Mo Oann drew from her the statement that old John Bender and his son John were in the woods in Montcalm County. Mich., and that Mrs Bender was in Niles. Mrs.
A woman named Mrs. Almira Monroe living in Niles, Michigan was identified by her own daughter and by witnesses who had known the Benders in Kansas as the notorious Ma Bender. Kansas officers investigated for ten days and sought a requisition to extradite her and her daughter for the Kansas murders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Oskaloosa Herald · 7 November 1889 · page 4
HOW THEY WERE DISCOVERED.
the woods in Montcalm County. Mich., and that Mrs Bender was in Niles. Mrs. McCann at once opened up a correspondence with Dr. K. J. Baiene, then postmaster here, and with Marshal Sbillady. Subsequently she came here and convinced herself that she was on the right track, and she has been en gaged ever since in gathering proofs. Mrs. Davis also told Mrs. McCann that her step mother had killed a woman in Portland, this State, and committed various other crimes, including the burning of a child and the murder of one of her husbands at Dowagiac, twelve miles from here.
See moreSee less
It is known that the man did mysteriously disappear from Dow aglM. The woman, Mrs. Monroe, supposed to be Mrs. Bender, has been a wanderer all her life. She has had many hus bands and many temporary homes. She has lived here about ten years, but claims she was here at the time of the Kansas murders. A tintype of the suspected woman sent to a man named Cole in New York, who knew the Benders and was at their house in Kansas two weeks before their flight, was sent back with this reply: “This picture is an exact likeness of Mrs. Bender.” One sent to L B. Smith, of Parsons. Kan., was recognized as Mrs. Bender. Several months later Mrs. Sarah Davis made an affidavit that her mother, Mrs. Almira Monroe, was none other than Mrs. Bender, one of the Kansas
Kansas lawmen traveled to Niles, Michigan, to take custody of a woman calling herself Mrs. Monroe and her daughter, Mrs. Davis. The pair were suspected—though not confirmed—to be the infamous Mrs. Bender and her daughter Kate, wanted for the Labette County murders years earlier.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Iowa Plain Dealer · 7 November 1889 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A Los Angeles man, formerly a Kansas constable, dismisses stories of capturing the old Bender woman and Kate, claiming the entire Bender family was actually wiped out near Coal Creek right after Dr. York's murder. He does not implicate himself directly but suggests vigilante killing ended the case in 1872.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Indianapolis Journal · 7 November 1889 · page 2
The Benders Were Exterminated In 1872.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A former Kansas constable named Cabeely dismisses reports of the capture of old Mrs. Bender and Kate, calling the story fictitious. He suggests instead that the entire Bender family was killed near Coal Creek in the Rocky Hill area shortly after Dr. York's murder.
The Emporia Weekly News · 7 November 1889 · page 1
- Xo Truth iu the Report. Los Angeles, Nov. 6. Mr. Cabeely of this place, who was constable of Havana township, Montgomery county Kansas, in 1872, when the Benders made their alleged escape, laughs at the story of the capture of the old woman and Kate. He does not crim inate himself directlv, but gives it out that the entire Bender family were exterminated near Coal creek in the Rocky Hill section immediately after the murder of Dr. York, Mr. Cabely is a reliable man.
Two women, Mrs. Eliza Davis and her mother Mrs. Monroe, were detained after arriving in St. Louis, suspected of being the notorious Kate Bender and her mother, infamous for the Bender family murders. Detectives planned to transport them to Labette County, Kansas, for trial, pending proof of Mrs. Monroe's identity as the elder Bender murderess.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Emporia Weekly News · 7 November 1889 · page 3
CACGHT AT LAST. The Bender's Caught Kate and ber Mother Retained to Kansas. St. Louss, Oct. 31. On the Chicago & Alton train that arrived at the Union
Two veiled women believed to be Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender are transported under guard toward Kansas for trial, having been identified and tracked down through the efforts of Mrs. Albert McCann, whose father was allegedly murdered by the Benders. The report details McCann's long pursuit, including a deathbed confession from an accomplice and the eventual arrest of the suspects in Niles, Michigan.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Emporia Weekly News · 7 November 1889 · page 3
CAUGHT AT LAST.
DlCK Of T.ahttrtn onnnt-n 'Vonaoo passed through Sedalia this afternoon cu.uuio n trarsons, ivansas, witn tue two female prisoners who are thought to be the notorious Mrs. Bender and Kate liender. Mr. Dick was living in Labette county at the time of the Bender Tniiriipl-fl nnrl hmn thn Ron. der familywell. He says .there is no oouDt ne has the right parties. The narrative of their arrest at Niles, Mich igan, as related by him, discloses one of the neatest pieces of detective work ever perpetrated by a woman. The ar rest was at the instance of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Albert McCann of McPherson, Kansas. If these parties are convicted she will get $10,000, but it was not money she was after; she worked for revenge. Her father, John M. Sanford, was mur dered by the Benders at Windsor, Can ada, twenty years ago. They fled the country and located on a farm in La bette coutny, Kansas, four miles south west of where Parsons now stands, where they kept "tavern" and did their deadly work. When the Itnnderit murrtoroil Mr f - . V. M.. UV.kS, V., .X&10.
This 1889 article reviews the Bender family's crimes at their roadside inn near Cherry Vale, Kansas, describing how travelers vanished and suspicion grew after Dr. York disappeared while investigating. It recounts the posse's search of the Bender property and the eventual flight of the family.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Saline County Journal · 7 November 1889 · page 1
TBB BatBBRJnv CaUstata. Ts r. There ate bat few wbo uaacquainted with lb leading feataree of tba crimes of Um Header family. Merder d light and uaatin.e of II bara of tb outfit, aad robbery their aiwuBtt m me. in active one ef th family were tbe old maa, bla wife. Kate Bender and John Bender, tb daughter aad eon ef Ibe well-matched pair. There waa another ana, a aaxall boy, who seems to have vanished from the face ef the earth, although be waa ant killed al lha lime hia relatives are aaid to have met their .nH.i.n aad merited punishment.
See moreSee less
Old man Bender kept n sort of way-side Inn for traveler, some distance out of Cherry vale. Stock men going out to buy cattle and strangers whose business took them down toward the line of the nation were tbe guests. Men well .quip ped Willi money left Parsons, Cher ry vat le and other towna, their rand leading in the direction of Bender's and were never seea again. Little remark waa caused as the missing ones were from distant points and had no friends In tbi neighborhood to Inquire into Ihelr fate. Oa afternoon tr. York, a well known physician of Kansas, accompanied by his eon, a little boy about ". years old, left l'sr-ou. and were never seen agnin alive. railing to hear from ham his friends instituted adlllg. nt sarb The brother of the missing insii, an attorney now living in or near Topeka headed the pern Dr. V art and his baa were traced io the Bender ranch and there the trail ceased. Tbe family hail crown Into di-iepiitr and a careful -lamination of the premises waa made IVu.ling the search the Benders t. -.n.l suspicion I ecime certainly Kcnewed elTnrls , tin. I
A Los Angeles man named Cabely, who was constable in Montgomery County, Kansas, in 1872, dismisses reports that Bender women were captured, claiming instead that the whole family was killed near Coal Creek shortly after Dr. York's murder. He does not implicate himself directly in the alleged killing.
Wichita Eagle · 7 November 1889 · page 2
THE BENDERS EXTERMINATED. Los Angeles, Cal., Nov. 6. Mr. Cabely of this place who was constable of Havana township, Montgomery county, Kansas, in 1872 when the Benders made their alleged escape laughs at tho story of the capture of the woman and Kate. He does not criminate himself directly but gives it out that the Bender family was exterminated near Coal Creek in the Rocky Hill section immediately after the murder of Dr. York. Mr. Cabely is a reliable man.
The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · and 1 other paper
Officers left Niles, Michigan with a woman calling herself Mrs. Monroe, alleged to be the notorious Mrs. Bender of the Labette County murders, along with her daughter, thought to be Kate Bender. The report reflects one of many identifications made during the long search for the Bender family after their 1870s crimes.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Kanabec County Times · 7 November 1889 · page 2
It was said that the aged dame was the infamous Mrs. Bender, whose family years ago committed many murders in Labette County, Kan. Mrs. Davis, the daughter, was also thought to be t&e notorious Kate Bender.
Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · 8 November 1889
The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn.
Kansas officers departed Niles, Michigan on October 30th with a woman calling herself Mrs. Monroe and her daughter, Mrs. Davis, believed to be the long-sought Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender of the infamous Labette County murders. The report reflects the ongoing suspicion that these two women were the notorious fugitives.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Worthington Advance · 7 November 1889 · page 2
WEST AND SOUTH.
Davi3. It was said that the aged dame was the infamous Mrs. Bender, whose family years ago committed many mur ders in .Labette County, Kan. Mrs. .Davis, the daughter, was also thought to be the notorious Kate Bender. THE strike of the journeyman tailors in Chicago ended on the 30tb ult. in a victory for the employers. THE vice-president of the Chicago & Alton railway denied on the 30th ult. the reported consolidation of his road with the Union Pacific.
The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · and 2 other papers
A Detroit report reveals that Mrs. Eliza Davis, who had claimed her mother was the original Mrs. Bender, is a fraud who used the story to get free rides to Kansas. In Kansas, only four of twelve people who tried to identify the Michigan suspects as the Benders could see any resemblance.
The Worthington Advance · 7 November 1889 · page 2
MRS. ELIZA DAVIS A FRAUD. The Woman's Bender Story Gotten Up by a Clever Professional Impostor. DETROIT, Mich., Nov. 4.—It transpires here that Mrs. Eliza Davis, of Lansing,
River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 7 November 1889
Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · 8 November 1889
Paper unidentified
Deputy Sheriff Dick transports two female prisoners believed to be Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender through Missouri toward Kansas, asserting he is certain of their identity. The report details how Mrs. Albert McCann tracked the women for years to avenge her father's murder by the Benders in Canada, finally locating them in Niles, Michigan.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 7 November 1889 · page 1
The Los Lost Bender Fawily. Deputy Sheriff Diok of La Bette county, Kan., passed through Sedalia Mo., en route to Parsons, Kan., with the two female pris oners who are thought to be the notorious Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender. Mr. Dick as living in La Bette county at the time of th Bender murders and knew the Bender family well. He says there is no doubt he has the right parties. The narrative oftheir arrest at Niles, Mich., as related by him, dis closes one of the neatest pieces of detective work ever perpetrated by a woman. The ar rest was at the instance of Mrs.
The report recounts Mrs. McCann's story of tracking down two women she believed were Kate and Ma Bender to Michigan, based on a deathbed confession and years of pursuit. It then presents a rival account from investigator Edward Parker, who cites an old Cherokee eyewitness claiming the entire Bender family was ambushed and burned by vigilantes in 1873, with physical evidence later unearthed to support this.
Paper unidentified · 7 November 1889 · page 1
The Be der* Were Killed. Edward Parker, who was working in Kan sas when the Bender's took their flight, and again in Parsons, when the report was ri.e ten years ago that "Old Man Bender" and bis wife had been found in Colorado, says his investigations at this time convince him that old Mrs. Bender and Kate have not been found in Michigan. Working in Parker's office at Parsore was an Indian boy who said that his father saw the whole Bender family killed in 1873. Parker inter viewed the old Cherokee who told him that while hunting he saw a camp file down in a valley about dusk, and as he was looking at it he saw a body of horse men approach, kill an old man and his eon.
See moreSee less
and then an old woman nnd her daughter. The latter fought as desperately as the men. After this they killed the horses, piled all together in a heap—the wag on, men. women and borses—added brush and burned them up, burying the burned de bris. The old Cherokee detailed thesurround ings so minutely that Parker, with the In dian's son and Ed Davis a printer ensily found the spot, and. by digging unearthed harness irons, wagon tires, pieces of chains, etc. This convinced them the old Cherokee's story was true. J. Parker says further that in 1879 he went to see Col. York, the leader of the pursuers of the Bender* of Fort Scott, and usked him what he thought of the re ported rapture of the Benders ip Colorado rlis response, made with a knowing look, was, that when he was the sole survivor ol the band he would tell the fate of the Ben ders, but until then he must be silent.
A brief item reports that Kansas officers believe a Mrs. Monro of Niles, Michigan, may actually be the notorious 'Mother Bender' from the murder family. This reflects one of many false leads pursued during the long manhunt for the Benders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Mexico Weekly Ledger · 7 November 1889 · page 4
Brown, near Milton, VV. Va. Kansas officers think Mrs Monro, of Niles, Mich., is old Mother Bender, of murder fame. The Navassa guano island rioters
The Wahpeton Times · Wahpeton, N.D. · and 1 other paper
Deputy Sheriff Dick transports two female prisoners believed to be Ma Bender and Kate Bender from Michigan to Kansas, confident they are the right parties. The arrest resulted from years of detective work by Mrs. Albert McCann, who sought revenge after learning the Benders murdered her father in Canada, eventually tracking down a woman who had confessed to the crime on her supposed deathbed.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Wahpeton Times · 7 November 1889 · page 4
THE LONG LOST BENDER FAMILY
Tke Loss Uwt Besder Fasil Deputy Sheriff Diak of La Bette county, Kan., paesed through Sedalia Mo., en route to Parsons, Kan., with the two female pris oners who are thought to be the notorious Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender. Mr. Dick was living in La Betto county at the time of th Bender murders and knew the Bender family well. He says there is no doubt he has the right parties. The narrative of their arrest at Niles, Mich., as related by him, dis. closes one of the neatest pieces of detective work ever perpetrated by a woman. The ar rest was at the ^instance of Mrs.
Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D. · 7 November 1889
Paper unidentified
Sarah E. Davis and Mrs. Monroe were extradited from Michigan to Labette County, Kansas, charged with the 1873 murder of Colonel York. Kansas officers who knew the Bender family identified the pair as Kate Bender and Mrs. Bender, though one woman claimed to be Kate's sister rather than Kate herself.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 7 November 1889 · page 5
ers, fully identifi=d Mrs. Davis as Kate Bender and Mrs. Monroe as Mrs. Bender. The presence of the officers here was not known until the #rrest was made, and the event created a senation. The old lady declared she would not be taken alive, and that she wou d die in her tracks, but Doputy Sherifi Earl forced her into the busand sfier chat she was very trzctable. The other woman was quiet, and while admiiting that Mrs. Monroe was Mrs. Bender. protested that she was not Kate. but her sister. She promises to make full
Kansas officers left Niles, Michigan, with two women, a mother and daughter calling themselves Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Davis. The women were suspected of being the notorious Mrs. Bender and her daughter Kate Bender, infamous for the Labette County murders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Hand County Press · 7 November 1889 · page 2
WMc* > ,' ,v “ £t fixing the Uqnor license in towns ana cities at 8370. Kansas officers left Niles. Mich., on the 30th ult. with a woman calling hep self Mrs. Monroe and berdaughter. Mrs. Davis. It was said that the aged dame was tho infamous Mrs. Bender, whose family years ago committed many mur ders in l>obette County, Kan. Mrs. Davis, the daughter, was also thought to l>e the notorious Kate Bender.
The report recounts how Mrs. McCann, whose father was allegedly murdered by the Benders in Canada, received a deathbed confession from a woman years later and used it to track down two women she believed were the Benders in Michigan. She notified Kansas officials, who secured a requisition for their arrest based on her proofs.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Reporter and Farmer · 7 November 1889 · page 2
them that trie women were the long lost Benders, and a requisition was sent forthem. Such is the story of Mrs. McCann, who caused the arrest of these supposed Benders. JLirkcts« NEW YORK
Kansas officers brought a woman calling herself Mrs. Munro from Niles, Michigan, alleging she is the infamous Mrs. Bender, while her daughter is suspected of being Kate Bender. The daughter insists the older woman truly is Mrs. Bender, though proof is lacking.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Telegraph-Courier · 7 November 1889 · page 6
MAY BE THE BENDERS.
Kansas Tragedies. Kansas officers have taken to that State from Niles, Mich., a woman calling herself Mrs. Munro, w’hose daughter was acquitted the other day of a charge of grand larceny. It is alleged that the aged dame is the infa mous Mrs. Bender, tvhose family many years ago committed many murders in La bette County, Kansas. Mrs. Davis, the daughter, insists that the Munro woman is, in fact, Mrs. Bender; and many persons believe that Mrs. Davis is herself the noto rious Kate Bender.
Kansas officers left Niles, Michigan, with a woman calling herself Mrs. Monroe and her daughter, Mrs. Davis. The older woman was rumored to be the infamous Mrs. Bender, whose family had committed numerous murders years earlier in Labette County, Kansas, with the daughter thought to be the notorious Kate Bender.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
River Falls Journal · 7 November 1889 · page 2
On the 30tb ult. William Trofford. a rich old farmer of Grafton. Ind., was swindled out of 85,000 on the gold brick trick. Thi. Indiana Supreme Court rendered a decision on the 30th nit. upholding lb® law* passed by the last Ix-gislature fixing tb® liquor license in towns and cities at >270. Kansas officers left Niles. Mich., on the 30th ult. with a woman calling her self Mrs. Monro® and herdaugliter. Mrs. Davis. It was said that theageddatnc was the infamous Mrs. Bender, whose family years ago committed many mur ders in Labette County. Kan. Mrs. Davis, the daughter. v.*:;s also thought to Is- ;he notorious Kate Bender.
The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas · and 2 other papers
Deputy Sheriff Dick escorted Mrs. Almira Monroe and her daughter Mrs. Eliza Davis from Niles, Michigan to Sedalia, Missouri, en route to Kansas, claiming they are the long-sought Bender mother and daughter. A woman named Frances McCann, who says her father was murdered by the Benders, claims Davis confessed to being Kate Bender and stands to collect a $10,000 reward if the identification is confirmed.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Iola Register · 8 November 1889 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
THE BENDERS.
An Old Woman and Her Daughter Taken to Kansas From Michigan Charged With Being Two of the Notorious Bender Family.
See moreSee less
SEDALIA, Mo., Nov. 1.—Deputy Sheriff L. F. Dick, of Oswego, Labette County, Kan., arrived in the city yesterday afternoon from Niles, Mich., having in charge Mrs. Almira Monroe and her daughter, Mrs. Eliza Davis, of Lansing, alleged members of the famous Bender gang of murderers and outlaws. The party remained in the city upward of three hours and departed for Oswego over the Missouri, Kansas & Texas at night.
Mrs. Frances E. McCann, of Topeka, Kan., accompanied the party. According to her story her father was murdered in the home of the Benders, and she has never believed the story that old man Bender, his wife and Kate, the daughter, had been killed in the Indian Territory by vigilantes, but for the past six or eight years she had been on the trail of the female members of the gang, and six months ago had run them down at Niles, Mich. She is positive that the right parties are under arrest, and declares that Mrs. Davis has confessed to her that the old woman is none other than Mrs. Bender. She is also positive that Mrs. Davis is Kate Bender, the most cruel and bloodthirsty of the infamous gang.
Deputy Dick is confident that the prisoners are the Benders, mother and daughter, and says that plenty of witnesses await their arrival at Labette County to identify them.
Dick says that the mother and daughter quarrel bitterly at intervals when left to themselves and each accuses the other of being responsible for the position in which they are placed at present.
If these parties are convicted Mrs. McCann will get $10,000, but it was not money she was after. She worked for revenge. Her father, John W. Sanford, was murdered by the Benders at Windsor, Can., twenty-four years ago. They fled the country and located on a farm in Labette County, Kan., where they kept their "tavern" and did their deadly work. When the Benders murdered Mr. Sanford, Mrs. McCann, his daughter, was but four years old. When she grew up and was married she settled in McPherson, Kan. Some years ago a dissolute woman came there with her husband and was taken sick at her house. She believed she was dying, and learning who Mrs. McCann was, on her supposed death bed confessed to Mrs. McCann that she helped to kill her father when Mrs. McCann was a child. While Mrs. McCann was looking up the particulars of her father's death the sick woman recovered and suddenly disappeared one night with her husband. It was several years before Mrs. McCann got a clew to her whereabouts, but she finally located her at Niles, Mich., and went there last April. When she had her plans perfected she notified the Kansas officers and presented proofs satisfactory to them that the women were the long lost Benders and a requisition was made for them. Such is the story of Mrs. McCann, who caused the arrest of these supposed Benders.
The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan. · 6 November 1889
Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan. · 7 November 1889
The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas · and 3 other papers
The report describes Mrs. McCann's years-long pursuit of two women she believes are Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, culminating in their arrest at Niles, Michigan, after a deathbed confession led her to the women. Deputy Dick and McCann both express confidence the prisoners are the fugitive Benders, with witnesses from Labette County expected to confirm their identities.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Iola Register · 8 November 1889 · page 3
night. Mrs Frances E McCann, of Topeka. Kan., accompanied the party Accord ing to her story her father was murdered in the home of the Benders, and she has never believed the story that old man man Bender, his wife and Kate, the daughter, had been killed in the Indian Territory by vigilantes, but for the past six or eight years she had been on the trail of the female members of the gang, and six months ago had run them down at Niles, Mich, fche is positive that the right parties are under arrest, and declares that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Davis has con fessed to her that the old woman is none other than Mrs. Bender, fcie is also positive that Mrs. Davis is Kate Bender, the most cruel and bloodthirsty of the infamous gang. Deputy Dick is confident that the prisoners are the Benders, mother and daughter, and says that plenty of wit nesses await thPir arrival at Labette County to identify them Dick says that the mother and daugh ter quarrel bitterly at intervals when left to themselves and each accuses the other of being responsible for the posi tion in w hich they are placed at preent. If thee parties are conicted Mrs McCann w ill get 510,000, but it was not money she was after, fahe worked for revenge. Her father, John . Sanford.
The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan. · 6 November 1889
Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan. · 7 November 1889
The Red Cloud Chief · Red Cloud, Neb. · 8 November 1889
The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas
A Mrs. Monroe and her daughter Miss Davis, suspected of being the notorious Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, were sent west from Niles, Michigan under guard of a deputy sheriff. They were specifically accused of the 1873 murder of Colonel York.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Iola Register · 8 November 1889 · page 3
Old Mrs. Bender. Nnxs, Mich , Oct. 21 Mrs. Monroe and her daughter, Miss Davis, believed to be the famous Mrs. Bender and her daughter, Kate Bender, who were im plicated in the terrible series of mur
A Kansas deputy sheriff transports Mrs. Almira Monroe and her daughter Mrs. Eliza Davis from Niles, Michigan, to Missouri, alleging they are the long-sought Bender women (mother Ma Bender and daughter Kate). A woman named Mrs. McCann, who claims her father was a Bender victim, insists she has tracked and identified them after years of pursuit, and stands to gain a reward if they are convicted.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Red Cloud Chief · 8 November 1889 · page 3
THE BENDERS. A Old Woman sad Her nanghter Takes to KanuK From Michi;r-ui Charged With Heine Two of the .Notorioo Bender Family. Sedal.ia.Mo.. Nor. 1. Deputy Sheriff L. F. Dick, of Oswego, Labette" County, Kan., arrived in the city yesterdav
A dispatch from Sedalia, Missouri, reports that Deputy Sheriff Deck of Labette County, Kansas, is transporting two women believed to be Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender to Parsons, Kansas. The arrest allegedly resulted from the detective work of Mrs. Albert McCann, whose father was murdered by the Benders and who spent years tracking them down for revenge.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 8 November 1889 · page 2
TRACKED BY A WOMAN.
Sheriif Deck of Labelle county, Kansas, passed through Sedalia this afternoon en route to Parsons, Kan., with two female prisoners, who are thought to be the notori ous Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender. Dick was living in Labelle county at the time of the Bender murders and knew the Bender family well. He says there is no doubt he hasthe right parties. The narrative of their arrest at Niles. Mich., as related by him, discloses one of the neatest pieces of detective work ever perpetrated by a woman. The arrest was at the instance of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Albert McCann of McPherson, Kas. If these parties are convicted she will get $10,000. But is was not money she was after, she worked for revenge. Her father, John W. Sandford, was murdered by the Benders at Windsor, Canada, twenty-four vears'ago when she was but 4 years old. Recently, she got a clue to the murderers while living near them in Kansas, and hunted them down.
The Hot Springs Star · Hot Spings Hot Springs, Dakota Dakota Territory, S.D.
A murder trial in Niles, Michigan reveals that the defendant's mother, Mrs. Monroe, is suspected of being the notorious Ma Bender, with her daughter Eliza insisting this is true. Kansas officers have spent ten days investigating and are reportedly satisfied they have finally found the Bender family, pending extradition to Labette County for trial.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Hot Springs Star · 8 November 1889 · page 4
'CALLED BACK' - Years Appeared Every Week for During the '70s - The Benders
The liegrj que-tiou was the principal theme for discussion iu one of tho meet ings of the American Missionary associa tion at Chicago. Several papers were read, the most interesting of which was the one by Col. J. M. Keating, of Mem phis. Col. Keating said that disfranchise ment was impossible that suffrage is necessary to tho protection of the negro. Deportation, he-says, is utterly inipossili'o for if the colored people departed it would bo greatlv against the interest of the south, The thiug to be done is to let the negro alone, and give him his rights.education and Christ ianixation.
See moreSee less
The committee on priuting was instructed to have tho paper distributed throughout the south. llltOTIIKItl'V LOVE. An Exhibition of It Over Entertaining the Pan-Amorlcans. Major Davenport, of Kansas City, slap' ped Congressman Tarsney iu the face and narrowly escaped being shot. It was all on account of the entertainment of tho All-American tourists. The mayor had vetoed, on the grounds of unconstitution ality, an ordinance passed by tho city council appropriating $1,000 for tho en tertainment. The council passed it over his veto again, and then the mayor or dered the ciliy treasurer not to recognise drafts'tipgn the treasury (or that purpose. A) a subsequent meeting of the committee murders in Kansas. Her daughter. Eliza, insists positively that Mas. Monroe is old Mrs. Bender. Officers from Kansas have taen in the state for ten days investigating the case, and are satisfied that thevhaveat last discovered the notorious Bender fam ily. A requisition has been asked for, and asi soon as it arrives the prisoners will bo taken to Labette county, Kansas, for trial. Mrs. Monroe, with half a dozen other aliases, and Mrs. Eliza Davis, her daugh ter, have apparently been identified as old Mrs. Bender and Kate. By her own. ad missions Mrs. Monroe has had seven hus bands, and a number of thom have myste riously disappeared. She has had' two weeks in which to establish her wherea l«outs from 1870 to 1875, and the statements she has mads covering those dates prove untrue, and she either can not or will not acoount for her doings.
Sheriff Dick brings in Mrs. Monroe and her daughter Mrs. Eliza Davis, believed by Kansas authorities to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender of the notorious murder family. The identification stemmed from a dream told by Mrs. Frances McCann that Mrs. Davis said was in fact a real, suppressed childhood memory of Bender family violence.
The Mitchell Capital · 8 November 1889 · page 3
STRANGER THAN FICTION
Capturing the Murderers. PAKSONS, Kan., Nov. 4.—Sheriff Dick has arrived here, having in custody Mrs. 51 on roe and her daughter, Mrs. Eliza Davis, the Kansas authorities being pretty sure that the two women are old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender. They would have been taken some weeks ago, but for the difficulty in establishing identification. The history of the Ben der family, and especially of their atro cious murders of Dr. York and others in Labette county, eighteen or twenty years ago, bids fair to be again made fresh in in the public mind.
See moreSee less
Their home on the roadside in that new and sparsely set tled country was a veritable charnel house. Their murderous deeds scarcely have a parallel in history, Mrs. Frances U. McCann, of McPherson county, the wife of a wealthy and respected mer chant of that place, is credited with dis covering the identity between Mrs. Mon roe and old Mrs. Bender. Mrs. McCann'K Alleged Dream.
A woman's dream and subsequent conversation with a relative leads to claims that the Bender family relocated to Michigan after the Kansas murders, with old Mrs. Bender now living as Mrs. Almira Monroe in Niles. Supporting evidence includes an affidavit from Mrs. Sarah Davis and tintype photographs reportedly identified by two men who had known the real Benders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Mitchell Capital · 8 November 1889 · page 3
Acknowledged They "Were Benders. Mrs. Davis told Mi's. McCann of other crimes and murders committed by her stepmother, supposed to he Mrs. Bender, and was asked: "Isn't your mother old Mrs. Bender':" The woman flew into a passion and refused to talk further. In a subsequent conversation she ac knowledged that they were the Bender fami'y. She then threatend Mrs. Mc Cann if she ever revealed what she had been told. Mrs. McCann drew from her the statement that old John Bender and his son John were in the woods in Mont calm county, Michigan, and that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Bender was in Niles. Mrs. McCann at once opened up a correspondence with Dr. E. J. Baine, the postmaster at Niles, and with Marshal Shillady. Subse quently she went there and convinced herself that she was on the right track, and she has been engaged ever since in gathering proofs. Positively Identified as Mrs. Ilender.
A group believed to be the notorious Bender family was arrested and taken to Labette County, Kansas, but people who knew the Bender women say the prisoners do not resemble them. Locals in that area remain convinced the real Benders were already caught and killed by a vigilance committee.
Two women arrested in Niles, Michigan on suspicion of being Ma Bender and Kate Bender have not been positively identified. Of seven witnesses who had known the Benders, only two tentatively recognized one suspect as Kate Bender, while five others saw no resemblance at all.
Not Yet 1<lenliflod. Oswego, Kan., Nov. 4.—Mr». Gi iiUili uml j Mrs. Davis, who were arrested at Niles, | Mich., on suspicion of being the old woman ! Bender and Kate Bender, have not yet been ! identified as the members of the noted niurI derous family. Seven persons who had known the Benders well were taken to seo ] the suspects, but only two of them could I Come anywhere near making on identified- ' tion. An old man known as Uncle Joseph i Storey, who had seen the Benders but three j times, was sure that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Davis was Kate i Bender. James Puillips was of a similar opinion. Five others, however, who had been well acquainted with the Benders, could see no resemblance and laughed at the idea of the prisoners being the Benders.
A man identified as Mr. Cabely, formerly a constable in Kansas in 1871 during the Benders' escape, claims the entire Bender family was exterminated near Coal Creek in the Rocky Hill nation. He says this happened immediately after the murder of Dr. York.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Penn's Grove Record · 9 November 1889 · page 4
Township, Kansas, In 1871, when the Banders mads tbslr saeape, says that the entire Bender family was exterm' natad near Coal Ore k, In the lloeky Hill ration. Immediately after the murder of Dr. Tors. _(jeorge Bush, oolored shot and tlaoaerauely wounded Osborn* H tsey, also enlared, in Washluslon. D C., on die evening ot the 5th. Policeman Orinoco alseApted to ariest Bosh and "^‘■llhe right breast. He still la remlver and shot Dusb two men then grappled, _during the melee, a revolver was jlso'barged, the bullet entering the officer's brain, killing him instantly.
See moreSee less
Hush died early on the morniaa of the ath. Busey Is in a critical ooi.dltlon. _William Diion and Joseph Gilbert quarrelled in Buffalo, New York, on the evening of the 6th, and during the light that followed Dixon cot Gilbert's throat, Dixon was no drunk that hs oonld not get away from the spot, and ley tar the dead man until found.
A grand larceny trial in Niles, Michigan reveals testimony that Mrs. Monroe, mother of defendant Eliza Davis, may be the notorious Kansas murderess Ma Bender, with Eliza herself insisting her mother is Bender. Kansas officers have spent ten days investigating and believe they have identified the family, with extradition requested to bring them to Labette County for trial.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
Custer Chronicle · 9 November 1889 · page 4
The Benders Found Again
Iler daughter, Eliza, insists positively that Mrs. Monroe is old Mrs. Bender. Officers from Kansas have been in tho state for ten days investigating tho case, and are satisfied that they have at last discovered the notorious Bender family. requisition has been asked for, and as soon as it arrives tLe prison ers will be taken to Labette county, Kansas, for trial. Much interest was manifested, and many blood-curdling and horrible reve lations were brought out during the ex amination. Mrs. Monroe, with a half dozen other aliases, and Mrs. Eliza Davis, her daughter, have apparently been identified as old Mrs.
See moreSee less
Bender ana Kate. During the trial maty facts wero adduced tending to show that Mrs. Monroe was connected with the Bender murderers in Kansas. By her own ad missions she has had seven husbands and a number of them have mysteriously disappeared. She has had two weeks in which to establish her whereabouts from 1870 to 1875, and the statements she ha 9 made covering those dates prove to be untrue, and she either cannot or will not account for her doings.
Sixteen years after the Bender killings in Kansas, a newspaper recounts the infamous wayside-inn murders as public interest revives following the arrest of women suspected to be the Bender women. It frames the case as one of the most notorious unsolved crimes, set in the then-wilderness of Labette County before railroads arrived.
Wheeling Sunday Register · 10 November 1889 · page 6
BLOODY BENDERS. HISTORY OF THE AWFUL CRIMES WHICH MADE THEM FAMOUS.
ern Kansas was a comparative wilderness. Labette conatv, now traversed by the St. Louis and Sau Francisco railroad and other lines, was then without other means of communication than the ‘'trails” which the pioneer and, later, the immigrants had blazed across the plains. So many years have passed since the perpetration of these crimes that the traveler on the Frisco road who now hears “Cherryvale” called out in the vernacular of the mod em brakemen will not recall the stir ring and dramatic incidents which first brought Cherryvale to public notice and gave it a name and place in the annals of crime. It was less than eix miles from there that the Bender murders were com
This 1889 retrospective describes the wild, undeveloped state of Labette County, Kansas before the Bender murders were discovered, noting how the area has since developed into towns like Cherryvale. It introduces the Bender family as German immigrants who settled to farm in the early 1870s, highlighting their reputation for spiritualism, especially daughter Kate's claimed ability to communicate with the dead.
Wheeling Sunday Register · 10 November 1889 · page 6
The report describes how the Bender family settled in Labette County in the early 1870s, posing as harmless German farmers who later opened a tavern and store to attract travelers. It notes Kate Bender's spiritualist reputation and quotes her 1872 newspaper advertisement offering healing services, which stirred curiosity but no suspicion of the family's true crimes.
Wheeling Sunday Register · 10 November 1889 · page 6
KATE BENDER'S AD. Prof. Miss Kate Bender can heal all sorts of diseases; can cure blindness, fits, deaf ness and all snch diseases; also deaf and dnmhness Residence 24 miles east of In dependence, on the road from Iodepend erce to Osage Mission, one and one-half miles son’heset of Morehead S’ation.
A former detective in Butte recounts the infamous Bender family killings at their wayside inn, prompted by a rumor about Mrs. Bender's fate making the rounds of the press. The report recaps the era's frontier conditions in Kansas and how the Benders lured and murdered traveling immigrants before escaping capture.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · 13 November 1889 · page 3
ANOTHER BENDER STORY
ers after being suspected of tbe crimes. . . , ..... I A great many people, especially those I who lived in Kansas at the time of the murders, arecognicant of the facts concern-1 ing tbe whole affair, as they were so ap palling in their nature and so horrible in detail that the most infintesimal mind I could not help but think and reflect upou I j their atrocity. At the time tbe Benders committed these horrible murders Kansas I was little more than a howling prairie. I People from other parts of the country I H ..
See moreSee less
. „ ., , , were imigrating to Kansas in th i hope of finding the born of plenty in the way of I agricultural laude. These people, who I were often overtaken at night many . ... . , , J I
This report recaps the Bender family's murders of travelers in Kansas, describing their method of luring victims with a curtain and hammer before cutting throats, and recounts how Dr. York's disappearance led to their exposure. It closes by noting a woman now held in Wisconsin may be the long-sought Mother Bender.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · 13 November 1889 · page 3
ANOTHER BENDER STORY
him would cut his throat. 1 The body would then be searched and buried in the cellar. This wholesale i slaughter of travellers was kept up until a was kept up until a prominent man, Dr. York by sud1 prominent man, Dr. York by name, sud denly disappeared: hTs disappeamnee 1 a a i_ j: j — J! »pearanct created quite a sensation in the neighbor neighbor hood, and all sorts of theories as to his possible fate were advanced by his friends and relations. A brother of the missing doctor set himself to work to solve the the problem and succeed d in tracing him to I the inn kept by the Benders.
See moreSee less
The doctor had stopped at the house and had been I murdered. Suspicion at once pointed at I the Benders as the slayers of the misait,g doctor and so strong was public opinion in favor of searching the bouse that the | in mnrderers left between two days and up to to this time have not been captured unless ^the ^the old woman now in custody in Wiscon j sin Proves to be old Mother Bender, After the family had escaped from the I scene of their butcheries a search of the cellar and garden disclosed the grinning I
The article recounts years of competing rumors about what happened to the fugitive Bender family, including widely circulated but likely false stories of a vigilance committee executing them. It then introduces a detective's claim that he traced the Benders to a ranch near Henrietta, Texas, where the young men allegedly worked as cattle rustlers.
Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · 13 November 1889 · page 3
______... ^ uu uow I comes the second chapteTof^thirhërdb^ I jX, r W t h^ I « j Benders, and entirely wipe out the vigilance | Benders, and entirely wip 1 committee portion of it:
A former Montgomery County constable, now living in Los Angeles, dismisses reports of the Bender women's capture and instead claims the whole Bender family was killed near Coal Creek shortly after Dr. York's murder. The report notes he avoids directly implicating himself in the killing.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
Dodge City Times · 14 November 1889 · page 1
THE BENDER LYNCHING
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A reporter recalls interviewing a Cherokee man in 1879 who claimed his father witnessed vigilantes killing the entire Bender family in 1873, with physical evidence later found at the site. The report also notes skepticism about a supposed 1889 capture of Mrs. Bender and Kate in Michigan, citing conflicting testimony from pursuers.
Dodge City Times · 14 November 1889 · page 1
DEATH OF THE BENDERS
Claims to Have Seen the Family Killed. RicBMOtp, Isd., November 6. Ed Parker, who was working on a paper in Kansas when the Benders took their flight, nnd again in Parsons when the report was rife, ten years ago, that "old man Tender" and his wife had been found in Colorado, saj s his work there convinces him that old Mrs. Bender
In Parsons, Kansas, public excitement continues over two women arrested on suspicion of being the notorious Bender women, with crowds traveling to Oswego to view them. The prisoners deny the identification, opinion remains divided on whether the real culprits were caught, and lawyers have been hired for their defense.
Dodge City Times · 14 November 1889 · page 1
The Benders. Pabsoss, Kas., November 6. The Bender excitemeet keeps up and the people from all parts of the county visited Oswego to set a look at the supivwed old lady and Kate. Public opinion is still divided as to whether or not the real parties hae been appre hended, and there is much speculation as to the final outcome of the arrests. 1 oth the prisoners s u der guard at the rcsdence of Thomas Lawson m Lswego. They em phatilally deny being the Fenders, and Judge Webb of this city, and J. T. James, a young lawyer of Fort Smith, Ark., ha. been employed to defend them.
Two women taken from Niles to Kansas, suspected of being Kate Bender and her daughter of the notorious Bender murder family, could not be identified as such. They are being returned to Michigan.
Williams Uriggs, an old resident of Parma, Jackson county, suicided by taking poison the other day. Ho was insured in the Purina Masouie lodge for $1,500 und in tho A. O. U. W. for $2,000. The family are unable to givo any reasous for Briggs' actions. The Michigan beef and provision com pany filed articles of association with tho Way no county clerk. The capital stock is $U0,H)J, held by Geo. Beok, Michael Cap lis, Henry Phillips. John I. Maon and Thorn s H. Cross. Tho works will bo lo cated at Sprlngwells.
See moreSee less
Mrs. Monroe aud Mrs. Davis, the two women taken to Kansas from Niles be cause a Kansas woman insisted that they wero Mrs. Kate Bender and daughter of tho famous Bender family of Kansas mur derers, cannot bo identified, uud will be
A deputy sheriff from Kansas arrested Mrs. Almira Monroe and her daughter Mrs. Eliza Davis in Niles, Michigan, on suspicion they are the fugitive Ma Bender and Kate Bender. The identification was pushed by Mrs. Francis McCann, a self-appointed detective whose father was allegedly killed by the Benders, based on Davis's supposed confessions to her.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
The Valley Virginian · 14 November 1889 · page 1
Supposed to be the Benders.
Francis E. McCann, of McPherson, Kan. through whose energy and skill tlx present new developments in the cas< were brought out. Mrs. McCann state) freely that there is not the slightesi doubt that the two captives are tin Benders. Mrs. McCann lias been so .ionruing in Niles for the past six months doing detective work on her own hook and the arrest just made are the results ; of her 1 tliors. Mrs. McCann’s father was killed by the Benders, and she has been on then track for five years. She is a slight, agile little woman, and a veritabh combination of nerve and animation, i She bases her theories on confession) made to her by Mrs.
See moreSee less
Eliza Davis, wlic she thinks is Kate Bender. The supposed Mrs. Bender appeared tc be about seventy years old. She is very communicative in her talk. She de nounced Mrs. McCann bitterly. The younger of the prisoners is forty-five years old. She Inis a bright little girl about three years eild. The case against the two women will be brought to an immediate trial as soon as the party j reaches Parsons.
At a preliminary hearing in Oswego, Kansas, four witnesses testified that two women arrested in Michigan were Kate Bender and her mother from the notorious Bender murder family. Witnesses matched physical traits and identified one woman as using the alias 'Sarah Eliza Davis,' and county prosecutors expressed confidence the suspects were genuine.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 20 November 1889 · page 1
ARE THEY THE BENDERS? Four Witnesses Swear thnt the Michigan Suspects are the Murderers. Oswego, Kan., Nov. 20. Four wit nesses who had known the Bender fam ily of murderers identified the Mic.hi. gan family of suspects as Kate Bender and her mother. The preliminary trial vi mo two women Degan yesterday and was larffelv attended C. W. Booth. T. C T)lrV .T A TTanfl and Mrs. Delia Keck all declared that tne woma,n known as Sarah Eliza Davis " mo notorious ivato xsendor, wnose fiendish deeds were almnst. hmrnmi Vm.
See moreSee less
lief. Two of the witnesses also testified that the elder woman known as Elmira Griffin is old Mrs. Bender, the mother oi ivate. u. li. Smith and Rudolph Brackman, the other two witnesses, agreed that tho hair, eyes and size of the women compared with that of the Bonder women. Countv Attornev Morrison and hia na. sociate are confident thoy have the ienaers, ana Judge Webb and Mr. James, the attorneys for tho defense, last evening said tho women would probably be bound ovor.
Four witnesses in Oswego, Kansas testified they recognized the Michigan suspects known as Sarah Eliza Davis and Elmira Griffen as Kate Bender and her mother, members of the notorious Bender murder family. The preliminary trial of the two women has begun, with the county attorney confident they have captured the real Benders.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Bender, tho mother of Kato. O. B, Smith and Rudolph Brockman, tho other two wit nesses, agreed that the hair, oyea and size of the women compared with th» of the Bon dor women. County Attorney Korriaon and his associate are confident they have the Benders.
In Oswego, Kansas, justices concluded a preliminary examination of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, suspected to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender. The evidence was judged sufficient to hold them without bail pending grand jury action, despite public sympathy for the prisoners.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
San Antonio Daily Light · 20 November 1889 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
In Oswego, Kansas, a preliminary trial began for two women suspected of being the murderous Kate Bender and her mother, arrested in Michigan. Several witnesses who had known the Bender family testified they positively recognized the accused as Kate Bender and her mother, though the defense remained confident of acquittal.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 20 November 1889 · page 1
THE BENDER MURDERS, Witnesses Positively Identify
Wltawii Positively lUtnllf. (I,, Michigan HuajiooU. Oswsao, Kan., Nov. 19.?Four wit nesses who had known the Bender fam ily ol murderers hsve identified the Michigan suspects sre Kate Beuder and her mother. The preliminary trial of the two womfen began yesterday and was largely attend
A dispatch from Oswego, Kansas reports that the preliminary examination of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, believed to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, concluded with three justices ruling the evidence sufficient to hold the women without bail. The case was ordered forwarded to a Grand Jury for further action.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
New-York Tribune · 21 November 1889 · page 1
THE WOMEN SUPPOSED TO BE THE BENDERS. Kansas City, Nov. 20.—A dispatch from Oswego, Kan., says: “The preliminary examination of Mis, aMonroe and Mrs, Eliza Davis, the women who am Suppos «1 to be o!d Mis, Bender and Kate Bender re sprctively, was finished late last night, and the throe ustices before whom the examination was made, deTribune. 4
A dispatch from Oswego, Kansas reports that Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, believed to be the elder Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, had their preliminary examination concluded. Three justices ruled the evidence sufficient to hold the women without bail pending grand jury action, despite public sympathy for the prisoners.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Morning News · 21 November 1889 · page 1
Held for tho Grand Jury. Kansas City, Mo., Nov. 20.—A special from Oswego, Kan., says: "The prelim inary examination of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, the two women who are supposed to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender respectively, was concluded last night, and tho three justices before whom the examination was made, decided that the evidence was strong enough to warrant their holding the prisoners without bail to await the action of the grand jury. Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Davis testified readily, answering all questions without embarrassment or apparently with out concealment. The general public here is in sympathy with the prisoners, aud much surprise was expressed when the justices announced their decision.”
In Oswego, Kansas, the preliminary hearing concluded for Mrs. Munroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, suspected of being old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender. Three justices ruled the evidence sufficient to hold the women without bail pending grand jury action, despite public sympathy for the prisoners.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
The Indianapolis Journal · 21 November 1889 · page 2
Alleged Venders Held to the Grand Jury. Oswego, Kan., Novl20. The preliminar3' examination of Mrs. Munroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, the women who are supposed to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, respect ively,was concluded late last night. The three justices before whom the examination was made decided that the evidence was strong enough to warrant their holding tho prisoners without bail to await the action ttf the grand jury. Mrs. Munroe and Mrs.
In Oswego, Kansas, a preliminary examination begins for Mrs. Almira Monroe and Mrs. Sarah E. Davis, two women alleged to be the notorious Bender women. Witnesses give conflicting testimony, with some positively identifying them as the Benders and others insisting they are not.
THE BENDERS. Preliminary Trial of the Alleged Bender Women.
and are not hurrying to Washington. The officials of the house postoflice say Hffht blue eyes, light hair, slim form there are fewer members of the house ! aml graceful step, and was about twen ; vci.- i i 1 I ty-two years old. The old lady was in Washington than they ever knew'nbout flfrvvears old and had 'Slnalli at the same date. , The attempt to J dark eyes. I thin if I met them now make a combination against Mr Reed 1 J W0llui know them. The women here, wlm ; UHin.
See moreSee less
n ti,of r !. ' i in mv opinion, are not the Benders.15 0 u wii. itou UI IWl. .UUdidates, has apparently been aban-' rr u. doned. Representative McKinlev 1 - once when coming home from a camp meeting. This was in 1872. Kate had rpx flofniirioYifc ,.. nln,l nr, !, I stand and cave in detail the historv of . , e m aeiau rDe nisu,ry oi , their lives. Mrs. Davis supposed to be , A,. i . -. . . v r ....
In Oswego, Kansas, witnesses testified at a preliminary hearing identifying Mrs. Almira Monroe and Mrs. Sarah E. Davis as the notorious Kate and old lady Bender. Several men who had known the Bender family years earlier gave conflicting degrees of certainty about the resemblance.
Paper unidentified · 21 November 1889 · page 4
He saw her afterward at a dance, and was acquainted with her sufficiently to identify her when he met her. He con tinued: "I visited the Bender place with Colonel York in the spring of 1873 looking for York's missing brother. We went to the house and made inquiries and John took us down on Drum creek to show us where, some one had shot at him. He showed us a tree perforated with bullets. From there we went home. The second Monday following we went to the Bender farm and found the place deserted, searched around and found several bodies terribly muti lated."
See moreSee less
Then the attention of the witness was directed to the defendants to iden tify them and the house became pain fully still as he scrutinized closely the features and form of the alleged Kate. Then he answered: "She bears an awful striking resemblance to Kate Bender." The cross examination brought out nothing further than what was testified in chief. The witness was unable to identify the old woman. T. C. Dick was next called and testi fied that he had had a personal ac quaintance with the Bender family, having lived close to them for two years. He knew Kate well and was familiar with her general features aud form. He saw these women get off the train at Independence a few weeks ago, and thought the younger woman filled the bill for Kate Bender, and from his recollection she was Kate. The cross examination brought nothing further than to confirm strongly his testimony in chief. ( J. A. Handley next swore: "I freighted from Fort Scott to Independ ence from 1869 to 18i3. I knew the Bender family well and saw Kate and John often. I used to stop there to buy provisions and to get Avater. I re member distinctly how they looked and would be able to identify them now." Witness was shown the women, Mon roe and Davis, and testified: "That is old lady Bender and that is Kate," pointing to each. -"' 1 'f Held Without CiMl."' Oswuao, Kan., Xov. 20. The first witness called yesterday morning for the State in the preliminary examina tion of the alleged Bender women was
In a preliminary examination at Oswego, Kansas, multiple witnesses who had known the Bender family years earlier testified for the prosecution that the arrested women, Monroe and Davis, were old lady Bender and Kate Bender. The defense countered with a witness, later shown to be color blind, who said they were not the Benders.
Paper unidentified · 21 November 1889 · page 4
L. F. Dick, of Parsons. He swore: "I have lived in Labette County twenty-one years. I know wheie the Bender farm is and knew the family well. I saw the young woman, Kate, at Sunday-school and several tinies at the house. I also saw the old lady there often and had some conversation. I have sufficient remembrance now of the Bender family as to distinctly re member how each one -.looked, and I have now in my mind how the women looked at that time. Several things in Kate were strange, and that was her belief in supernatural powers and in Spiritualism.'" The testimony of Dick was of the most importance and damaging to tho defense.
See moreSee less
Tho old woman seemed to realize it the keenest. Several times she arose to her feet anil muttered under her breath something unintelli gible. Once only and that Monday did the alleged Kate wince and show the effect the identification had upon her. The first witness introduced for the defense was Thomas James. He said: "I think I saw tire Benders often enough to know them. The old lady Bender's language was 'Dutchy.'"' Witness made a thorough examination of the defendants nd said that in his best judgment they were not the Bend ers. Cross-examination by the State proved the fact that the witness was color blind. Witness closed -his eyes and tried to describe the' defendants, but failed. Silas Toles testified. ."I know the Bender farm and the-Bender people. Saw them first when I went to buy groceries. I saw Kate and John quite often. I had a long talk with Kate once when coming home from a camp meeting. This was in 1872. Kate had
Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, suspected of being Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender of the notorious murderous Bender family, were held without bail by the Grand Jury after a preliminary hearing. The decision caused general astonishment, as all circumstances suggested a case of mistaken identity.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 21 November 1889 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
In Oswego, Kansas, the examination of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, women believed to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, concluded with three justices ruling the evidence strong enough to hold them without bail for the grand jury. The decision surprised many locals, who reportedly sympathized with the prisoners.
The Helena Independent · 21 November 1889 · page 1
HELD FOR THE GRAND JURY
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
In Oswego, Kansas, the examination of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, believed to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, concluded with three justices ruling the evidence sufficient to hold them without bail pending grand jury action. The report notes public sympathy for the prisoners and surprise at the decision.
Helena Weekly Herald · 21 November 1889 · page 7
Held to Answer. Oswego, Kansas, November 20—Tne examination of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. E'iza Davis, the women supposed to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, was concluded Ute last night. The three justices before whom the examination was made decided that the evidence was strong enough to warrant holding the prisoners without bail to await the action of the grand jury. The general public here is in sympathy with the prisoners and much surprise was ex pressed when the decision was announced.
In Oswego, New York, two women identified as Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis—believed to be the notorious Kate Bender and her mother—were examined by three justices who ruled the evidence sufficient to hold them without bail pending grand jury action. The report notes public sympathy for the prisoners and surprise at the ruling.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Great Falls Leader · 21 November 1889 · page 1
The Bender Case. OswEoo, N. Y., Nov. 20.-The exami nation of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, the women supposed to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender was con cluded late last night. The three jus tices before whom the examination was made decided that the evidence was strong enough to warrant holding them prisoners without bail, to await the action of the grand jury. The general public here is in sympathy with the prisoners and much surprise was expressed when the decision was announced.
In Oswego, Kansas, the examination of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis—believed by authorities to be the elder Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender—concluded with three justices ruling the evidence sufficient to hold the women without bail pending grand jury action. The report notes public sympathy for the prisoners and surprise at the decision.
The Salt Lake Herald · 21 November 1889 · page 1
Wile and one sixteenth Refund vv on Armis second Wilfred thud TimeI 5l the Bender Wonmen OsvEGOj Kis Nov 20The examira tion of Mrs Monroe ana Mrs Eliza Davis the women supposed to bo old Mrs Bender and Kate Bender was concluded late last evening Three justices before vvhoai the
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
In Oswego, Kansas, a preliminary examination concluded that Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Davis, suspected of being old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, would be held without bail pending grand jury action. The women testified readily and without apparent embarrassment, and the public reportedly sympathized with them despite the justices' ruling.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 21 November 1889 · page 1
ARE THEY THE BENDERS? Three Justices Decide to Hold the Subjects, But They Have Public Sympathy.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
In Oswego, Kansas, the examination of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis—believed to be the long-sought Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender—concluded with three justices ruling the evidence sufficient to hold them without bail pending grand jury action. The local public was reported sympathetic to the prisoners, and surprise greeted the ruling.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 21 November 1889 · page 1
Held to Await the Grand Jury. Oswego, Kan., Nov. 20. —The exam ination of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, the women supposed to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, was con eluded late last night. The three justices before whom the examination was made decided that the evidence was strong enough to warrant holding the prisoners without bail to await the action of the grand jury. The general public here is in sympathy with the prisoners and much surprise was expiessed when the decision was announced.
Four witnesses testified at a preliminary trial in Oswego that the Michigan suspects, known as Sarah Eliza Davis and Elmira Griffin, are actually Kate Bender and her mother. The county attorney expressed confidence they had captured the real Benders, and the defense attorneys conceded the women would likely be bound over for trial.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Mitchell Capital · 22 November 1889 · page 6
EVIDENTLY BENDERS, The Two Michigan SuKpects Identified by Witnesses. OSWEGO, NOV. 20.—Four witnesses who had known tho Bender family of murderers identified the Michigan sus pects as Kate Bender and her mother, Monday. Tho preliminary trial of the two women has begun and is being largely attended. C. AV. Booth, T. C. Dick, J. A. Handley and Mrs. Delia Keck, all declared positively that the woman known as Sarah Eliza Davis is the notorious Kate Bender, whose fiend sh deeds are almost beyond belief. Two of the witnesses also testified that the elder woman, known as Elmira Griffin, is old Mrs.
See moreSee less
Bender, the mother of Kate. G, B. Smith and Rudolph Brackman, the other two witnesses,agreed that the hair, eyes and size of the women compared with those of the Bender women. County Attorney .Morrison and his associate, Mr. Atchison, are confident they have the Benders, and Judge AYebh and Mr. James, the attorneys for the defense, said the women would probablv bo bound over. Kmptied the Safe Before Leaving,
A preliminary hearing was held in Oswego, Kansas before three justices to determine if two arrested women, Sarah Eliza Davis and Elmire Griffith, were actually Kate Bender and the elder Mrs. Bender. Witnesses gave conflicting testimony—some positively identified the women while others expressed doubt, though all agreed physical characteristics matched; one witness also described the original 1873 discovery of mutilated bodies on the Bender farm.
The Leavenworth Advocate · 23 November 1889 · page 1
Are They the Benders?
have been examined to-day. The first four all identified Sarah Eliza Davis as Kate Bender, and two of these claim Chat the older woman, Elmire Griffith, is old Mrs. Bender. The last two witnesses are doubtful about matters, but agree that the hair, eyes and size of the women agree with those of the Bender women. County Attorney Morrison and his asso ciate, are confident they have the Benders and Judge Webb and Mr. James, the at torneys for the defense, this evening say the women will probably be bound over.
See moreSee less
Oswego, Kan.. Nov. 19.—The first witness called this morning for the state in the ex amination of the alleged Bender women was 1. F. Dick of Parsons. He swore: “1 know where the Bender farm is, and knew the family well. I also saw the old lady there often. 1 have sufficient remembrance now of the Bender family as to distinctly remember how each one looked. Several things in Kate were strange, and one was her belief in supernatural powers and in spiritualism.” Witness described the finding of the mutilated bodies in the orchard and their appearance, and gave a detailed descrip tion of the house, cellar and burying ground of the dead. He said that the heads of all found except that of the little girl were badly crushed by blows from several ham mers of different sizes. “I had some conversations with old lady Bender in German and English. She had some foreign accent. I talked with this old lady here on trial at the jail at Niles, Mich. The first words said were in Ger man. I said: ‘Kan Ich nicht verkaufen’ in Dutch and she replied: ‘Das kanst du nicht,’ being interpreted reads: -Can I sell you’ in Dutch and ‘That you can not do.’ 1 then talked with them about their going up and down on the earth, but they could not tell me where they were during the years 1871, 1872 and 1873.” The witness was asked to look at the prisoners and after doing so deliberately said: “They are Mrs. and Kate Bender. 1 have no doubts as to them. Mrs. Davis told me in Michigan that she was a step daughter of Mrs. Monroe. Mrs. Davis told me this was the veritable old lady Bender and she would always so testify when per mitted to do so. Kato had a mark or mole under the left eye and I see Mrs. Davis has one under her left eye.”
A preliminary hearing in Oswego, Kansas examined witnesses to determine if the captured women were truly the notorious Bender family members wanted for a string of murders years earlier. Testimony was split, with seven witnesses affirming the identification, seven denying it, and two uncertain, yet the justices ruled the evidence sufficient to hold the women for trial without bail.
The Leavenworth Advocate · 23 November 1889 · page 1
The report describes the arrest in Niles, Michigan of two women, Mrs. Almira Munro and her daughter Sarah Davis, suspected by officials and a victim's daughter of being Kate Bender and her mother. The article recounts the original Bender crimes near Cherryvale, Kansas, but argues the identification is mistaken, asserting the real Benders were killed by Kansas vigilantes.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Wichita Eagle · 26 November 1889 · page 7
been known as Lira. Almira Munro, alias Griffiths, and her daughter, Airs. Sarah E. Davis, and the charge was made against them by Mrs. Albert McCann, of McPherson, Kan., whose father, John "W. Sandford, was one of tho Benders' victims. There are many rea sons for concluding that Mrs. McCann, tka official, and the few who have identified the prisoners are mistaken, as will appear by re calling the main events of the crimes and flight of the Benders. Lato in 1S70, the northern part of Labette county, Kansas, was rapidly "taken up" by pre-emptors, and among these were the Bender family, consisting of tho two parents, eon and daughter.
See moreSee less
They kept a rude hotel in a lovely little valo in the northwest part of tho county and some six miles northeast of Cherryvale, on the Leavenworth. Lawrence and Galveston road. Lato In 1872 strange rumors of missing peoplo floated about the neighborhood, and young John Bender, who peddled a sort of "oil for rheumatism" pre pared by his sister, and posted bills announc ing hor powers as a "healing medium," was observed to take a deep interest in hearing people's opinions on the matter. Early in 1STJ, whoa tho ice in Drum creek melted, tho mutilated corpse of a new comer named Jones was found in the water; but it could not bo certainly determined that he had been murdered. Since December George "W. Longcor and little daughter had been missed. Finally, on the 9th of March, 1873, Dr. Will iam EL York, of Independence, left Fort Scott to ride homo, being well mounted and having a little money. Neither he nor his horse reached Independence, but he was traced to within a mile or two of the Bender farm. Inquiry now became very active, and tho doctor's brother, Senator Edward York, wont with n, party to the farm and minutely searched all tho roads. Finding no traco they advertised the disappearance of Dr. York quite extensively. The next day, John Bonder, Jr., was again in town, listening at tentively to any group he saw talking on the streets, and that was the last day he was ever seen In Kansas.
A 1889 article recounts how the Bender family vanished amid rumors of missing travelers, including Dr. William York, and how neighbors discovered the abandoned farm with a dying calf, leading them to probe the orchard. It recaps the chain of suspicion from 1872 disappearances through the farm's abandonment sixteen years earlier.
The report recounts how a suspected neighbor was threatened and nearly hanged for information about the Benders, noting nine murders were proved but the killers were never caught. It then quotes J. H. Beadle's 'Western Wilde' describing the idyllic prairie setting of the Bender farm and how relic hunters stripped the property bare after the murders were discovered.
Wichita Eagle · 26 November 1889 · page 7
&& , vs3o :-&.,rs'gand who was Tha otily Jma who "neigh bored." with them. A rope was biwtflj knot ted about ate neck, and ho was told to "con fess, and that di quick." In hfe fright the man forgot every word of EogBah. He was rescued by the officials only after being hanged three times. Nine murders were proved on the Benders. Every vestige of the house, stable and or chard was taken away by relio hunters ; but as far as proved the murderers were never captured. There are men, however, about Independence, who think they know just where their bodies were buried. The an nexed account of subsequent events, descrip tion of the soene and Interview with Brock mann Is from " Western Wilde," by J. H.
A dispatch from Oswego, Kansas reports that the examination of Mrs. Moore and Eliza Davis, women believed to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, has concluded. Three justices ruled the evidence strong enough to hold the pair without bail pending action by the grand jury.
The report describes a pretrial hearing in Oswego, Kansas, where two women suspected of being Ma and Kate Bender were held without bail. Sixteen witnesses testified, with opinions split on whether the women were truly the notorious Benders, while the county attorney expressed confidence in securing a conviction.
The Butler Weekly Times · 27 November 1889 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
HELD FOR TRIAL. The Bender Suspects Bound over without Bail to Await the Action of the Grand Jury. Oswego, Kan.. Nov. 21.—The Bender suspects was held for trial in the district court without bail. Sixteen witnesses have been examined, seven of whom declare that the prisoners are the benders, seven say they are not and two are undecided. The old woman, alleged to be Mrs. Bender, and Eliza Davis, the supposed to be Kate Bender, were placed on the stand and told straightfor posed straightforward stories of their lives. The stories of both women showed lives of hardship and trouble and frequent removals from place to place to keep the wolf from the door.
See moreSee less
The county attorney believes he will convict the women. The attorneys for the defense laugh at the idea, while the great growd of people are about equally divided.
Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, suspected of being Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, were examined by three justices in Oswego, Kansas, who ruled the evidence strong enough to hold them without bail pending grand jury action. The public reportedly sympathized with the prisoners, and the ruling surprised many.
Union County Courier · 27 November 1889 · page 1
ALLEGED BENDERS HELD. The Kansas Justices Remand Their Case to the Urand Jury. The examination of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, tho women who are sup posed to be Mrs. Ben ler and Kate Bender, has been concluded at Oswego, Kan., and the three justices before whom the ex amination was made decided the evidence was strong enough to warrant boldiug tho persons without bail to await the action of tbe grand jury. The general public there is iu sympathy with the prisoners, and there was much surprise when the decision was announced.
In Oswego, Kansas, a preliminary examination concluded that two women, believed to be the elder Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, would be held without bail pending grand jury action. The women answered questions calmly, and local sympathy favored the prisoners despite the justices' ruling.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Watertown Republican · 27 November 1889 · page 3
BOUND OVER WITHOUT BAIL.
XaugHK for Trial. Oswego, Kas., Nov. 20.—The prelim inary examination of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, the women who are supposed to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender respectively, was con cluded late last night and the three jus tices before whom the examination was made decided that the evi dence was strong enough to war rant their holding the prisoners withoutjbail to await the action of the grand jury, Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Davis were the lasi witnesses. They testified readily, answering all ques tions without embarrassment and appar ently without concealment. The gen eral public here is in sympathy with the prisoners and much surprise was ex pressed wnen the justices announced their decision.
An inquiry into two women brought from Niles, Michigan, identified as Kate Bender and her mother, concluded with them held over for trial at the February term of the district court. Witnesses were divided, some identifying them as the notorious Benders and others denying it.
The Emporia Weekly News · 28 November 1889 · page 2
The inquiry into the identity of the two women brought from Niles, Mich igan, as Kate Bender and her mother, ended in their being held for trial at the February term of the district court. Several witnesses identified them as the notorious Benders. But there are more who will say they are not the Benders. It is an odd case. Tiic binding twine manufacturers over reached themselves when they doubled the price of twine. The far mers very largely made a shift to get along without twine, the demand fell on and a million-dollar failure is re ported as the result.
See moreSee less
Some failures hurt, but that is not one of them. Eugene Ware of Fort Scott avows himself a thorough going antl-probibitionist, but does not think this is the time to push resubmission. Congress man Perkins is a prohibitionist and thinks if it were put to the people now resubmission would carry. The breth ren should get together on this mo mentous question. .
Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, believed to be the elder Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, underwent a preliminary hearing at Oswego, Kansas. Three justices ruled the evidence strong enough to hold them without bail pending grand jury action.
Saint Mary's Beacon · 28 November 1889 · page 3
suit involving title to the old St Patrick’s Cemetery, Washington city. The testimony in the trial ol the five men at Chicago for the murder of Dr. Patrick H. Cronin was directed yesterday to the showing that Patrick O’Snllivan was at home in bed on the night of the murder, May 4, 1889. Matt Danahay, a sahon keeper, testified that Martin Bnrke was in his saloon at the time the murder was com mitted. Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, the women who arc supposed to be old Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, respectively, bad a prelimin.ry examination at Oswigo,
At a hearing in Oswego, Kansas, several witnesses testified that Mrs. Monroe and her daughter Mrs. Davis were in fact the long-sought Mrs. Bender and her daughter Kate. The two women were being held without bail to await action by the grand jury.
The Iola Register · 29 November 1889 · page 6
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
At a preliminary examination in Oswego, Kansas, witness L.F. Dick testified he recognized the accused women as members of the Bender family, citing Kate's interest in Spiritualism and a mark under her eye. A defense witness, Thomas James, then testified that old Mrs. Bender spoke German, as the hearing continued without bail being granted.
The Iola Register · 29 November 1889 · page 6
THE WOMEN HELD. The Alleged Bender Women Held For Trial Without Bail.
tion of tho alleged Bender women was L. r. Dick, of Parsons. He swore: "I have lived in Labette Count tvven t -one ears. I knowvv here the Bender farm is and knew the famil well. I
Defense witnesses testify they do not believe the accused women are Kate Bender and her mother, citing physical differences, but cross-examination casts doubt on their reliability. The justices nonetheless rule there is sufficient evidence to hold the women without bail.
The Iola Register · 29 November 1889 · page 6
THE WOMEN HELD
defense was Thomas James. He s ud: "I think I saw the Benders often enough to know them. Tho old lady Bender's language was 'Dutch.'" Witness m ido a thorough examination of the defendants and said tlt.it 111 Ins best judgment they were not the Bend ts. Cross examination by tho Stato proved the fact that the witness was color blind. Witness closed his ees and tried to describe the defendants, but failed. Silas Toles testified: "I know tho Bender farm and the Bender people. Siw them first when I went to buy groceries.
See moreSee less
I saw Kate and John quite often. I had a long talk with Kate once vv hen coming homo from a camp meeting. This was 111 1872. Kate had light blue ces, light hair, slim form and graceful step, and was about twenty-two cars old. Tho old lady was about fifty ears old and had small, dark c es. I think if I met them now I would know them. The women hue, 111 my opinion, aro not the Benders.'' Cioss ex munition proved tint tho
A dispatch from Oswego, Kansas reports that witnesses have identified two women arrested in Michigan as Kate Bender and her mother, members of the notorious Bender murder family. Multiple witnesses testified to physical resemblances during a preliminary trial, and prosecutors expressed confidence the women would be bound over despite defense objections.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 44 days later.
Wrong
Oakes Weekly Republican · 29 November 1889 · page 2
The Bender Family. A dispatch received from Oswego, Kan sas, dated November 19, says witnesses who had known the Bender family of mur derers have identified the Michigan sus pects as Kate Bender and her mother. The preliminary trial of the two women is in progress and is largely attended. C. W. Booth. T. C. Dick, J. A. Handle, and Mrs. Delia Keck all declared positively that the woman known as Sarah Eliza Davis is the notorious Kate Bender whose fiendish deeds were almost beyond belief. Two of the witnesses also testified that the elder woman, known as Elmira Griffin, is old Mrs.
See moreSee less
Bender, the mother of Kate. G. R. Smith and Rudolph Brackman, the other two witnesses, agreed that the hair, eyes and size ol the woman compared with those of the Bender women. County At torney Morrison and his associate, Mr. Atchison, are confident tbey have the Ben ders, and Judge Webb and Mr. James, the attorneys for the defense, said the women would be bound over.
The Hot Springs Star · Hot Spings Hot Springs, Dakota Dakota Territory, S.D.
The examination of Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, suspected to be Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, concluded at Oswego, Kansas. Three justices ruled the evidence sufficient to hold the women without bail pending grand jury action, despite public sympathy for the prisoners.
The Hot Springs Star · 29 November 1889 · page 4
ALLEGED BENDERS HELD
AUGdEII IIENDEKS HELD. The Kuns»« .Tustlren Remuml Their Cane to ihe (.rnnd Jury. The examination ot Mrs. Monroe and Mrs. Eliza Davis, the women who are sup. posed to bo Mrs. Bender aud Kate Bender, has been concluded at Oswego, Kan., and the three justices before whom the ex amination was made decided the evidence was strong enough to warrant holdiug the persons without bail to await the aotion of the grand jury. The general public (hero is in sympathy with the prisoners, and there was much surprise when the decision was announced.
Two women brought from Michigan to Oswego, Kansas on Governor Humphrey's requisition faced an identity hearing before three justices of the peace. Witnesses were divided, with most noting a resemblance to the Bender women but none swearing positively to their identity.
Western Kansas World · 30 November 1889 · page 7
Delphos Eepubl:can: The Minneap olis Eebekah lodgo visited the Delphos lodge. After tho work of the lodge was transacted, all sat down to a boun tiful supper, spread in the ante room, and a good, social visit ensued. After supper, they went'back to the hall and engaged in social games until midnight, when tLo meeting broke up. It was an enjoyable occasion, such as a Eebekah ledge knows how to manage, and a profitable meeting to all who partici pated. Tho examination of the two women now at Oswego, Kansas, who were brought from Michigan on requisition o!
See moreSee less
Governor Humphrey, on the charge that they are the Bender women, was had before a court composed of three justices of the peace. Most of the wit nesses examined declared that there is a striking resemblance of the two to tho Bender women, while none positive ly swear to their identity. Some of the witnesses remember a dark spot on Kate Bender's faco, like a spot on the face of the younger of these women. But one witness was positive that he did not believe the women were the Benders. Lawrence Journal: There was a rumor on the street that the English milling syndicate which was buying up mills in the northwest hiid been looking at Kansas milling property and more I particularly at Lawrence mills. A Jour nal reporter saw Mr. Bowersock and asked him about the truth of these statements. He didn't seem to think that the matter should be talked about very much, as it was simply a business transaction, and he was very reticent in talking about it. However, he said that he had been approached by agents of the syndicate which has been pur chasing mills in the northwest, and that he had submitted plans of his mills and water power and placed a price thereon. Mr. Bowersock said that the indications are that the sale will go through. When asked what he would do with the money if the sale went" through, he said he was figuring on investing in Lawrenc? real estate. A Concordia item: Prof. J. S. Shear er, who has been in poor health for the last six months, died Thursday, of can cer in the stomach. He was buried Saturday, the services being conducted by Eev.H. Bushnell, of the First Pres byterian church. Prof. Shearer was a living example of what a young man of energy and perseverance can accomplish. At the close of the war, in which he took an active part, he could not write his own name, yet, by continued appli cation he became one of the foremost educators in the land, having held po sitions of professor of English litera ture and science in the state university; also at the state normal school at Con cordia, and was afterward principal of the Indian schools at Albuquerque, N. M. During the last seven years he had been engaged in business at this place. His loss will be keenly felt by the com munity.
A dispatch from Oswego, Kansas reports that several witnesses positively identified a woman known as Sarah Eliza Davis as the notorious Kate Bender, and two witnesses identified an older woman as Kate's mother. The preliminary trial of the two women was underway and well attended, with prosecutors confident in the identification while defense attorneys expected the women to be bound over.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 49 days later.
Wrong
Pullman Herald · 30 November 1889 · page 6
The Bender Family. A dispatch received from Oswego, Kan sas, dated November V.I, says witnesses who had known the Bender Tainily of mur derers have identified the Michigan sus pects k« Kate Hender and her mother. The preliminary trial of the two women is in progress and i« largely attended. V. W. Booth. T. V. Dick, J. A. Handle, and