As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

December 1889

4 articles

Wheeling Sunday Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A sheriff in Oswego, Kansas wrote to a Michigan sheriff on behalf of a woman suspected of being Kate Bender, claiming she had lived at Wild Fowl Bay with her husband Hiram Johnson in 1873-4. This alibi evidence suggested the suspects were not actually the Bender family.

Wheeling Sunday Register · 1 December 1889 · page 1

NOT THE BENDERS.

Their Identity. East Saginaw, Mich., November 30. —A new phase in the Bender case has b«en developed. The sheriff of Oswego, Kansas, wrote a letter to the sheriff of Huron county, in this state, on behalf of the woman snspected as Kate Bender, in which he states that she alleges she lived »t Wild Fowl Bay, now known as Baj jort, with her hnsband in 1H73-4. She jives her husband’s name as Hiram John son.

See the clipping

Dodge City Times · Dodge City, Kan.

The sheriff at Oswego, Kansas writes that a woman held there claiming to be Kate Bender says she lived near there in 1870-71. Investigation by the local sheriff confirms this claim to be true.

Dodge City Times · 5 December 1889 · page 1

One of the Ifeud'-r Women. East Sao cmv, Mm, December 3. The sheriff at Oswego, Kansa, writes here that the woman held there aa Kate Bender clause to have lived near here in i87 -1. Investi gation by oar sheriff shows this to be true, Drbt ltedurtlon.

See the clipping

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · Sedalia, Mo.

The report details Richard Duncan's arraignment for murdering the Williamson family in Texas, a crime unrelated to the Benders. It also notes two women held in the Labette County jail in Kansas who claim to be the notorious Kate Bender and her mother, awaiting trial.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 33 days later.

Wrong

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 10 December 1889 · page 3

ARE NOT THE BENDERS

Foster Lester, a 16-year oldllad killed 23 squirrels with a shot gun in the Flat Creek bottoms in two hours yester day. The timber in that section is fairly alive with that kind of game just now. children traveled in a wagon, bought by The two women now in the Labette r i i t ijuui.au, win it xie auu lanaers roue on I -i , -r . . hoKtTM.0!;nB;nfi,;amon county jail at Oswego, ian., awaitparty were seen and identified bv many on 1DS trial 113 tne notorious Kate Bender

See the clipping

Dodge City Times · Dodge City, Kan.

The Oswego Independent reports that two women suspected of being members of the notorious Bender family have been moved to new guarded quarters at a private home. They have not confessed, and authorities await proof of their whereabouts during the years the Benders operated in Labette County before further proceedings.

Dodge City Times · 12 December 1889 · page 1

Tho sessions are always held with closed doors, and the object of tho or ganization is for the reduction of freights and for the benefit of the grain men and farmers of this section of the coun try. Oswego Independent: The alleged Bender women have been assigned new quarters by the sheritr, and are now at tho home of Ed Smith, in the western p3rt of the city, under guard. So far as the reporter is able to learn, there have been no new developments in the csee. There is no back-down cthe part of the women, and so confession, it would appear, even should they be proven guilty, can ever be wrung from the lips of either of them.

See moreSee less

The defend ants will have plenty of time between bow and the aittusg at tb Mxt4eim of that - dkatruttsssut. t ta strtasfcaahVtkMz a- - r i -1 1 - . . .. - - ,-l3 .- " . N...!-a J -".J -mr - - . -1 -mt Til Jy-vaJSsfeSKTSSC-e- ',PV'J -s-v-i-V-" s?.&3gi2tim&3zf&siZ t-.i-iiaif-iiSi!.

See the clipping