Wheeling Sunday Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
A sheriff in Oswego, Kansas wrote to a Michigan sheriff on behalf of a woman suspected of being Kate Bender, claiming she had lived at Wild Fowl Bay with her husband Hiram Johnson in 1873-4. This alibi evidence suggested the suspects were not actually the Bender family.
Wheeling Sunday Register · 1 December 1889 · page 1
NOT THE BENDERS.
Their Identity. East Saginaw, Mich., November 30. —A new phase in the Bender case has b«en developed. The sheriff of Oswego, Kansas, wrote a letter to the sheriff of Huron county, in this state, on behalf of the woman snspected as Kate Bender, in which he states that she alleges she lived »t Wild Fowl Bay, now known as Baj jort, with her hnsband in 1H73-4. She jives her husband’s name as Hiram John son.