As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

January 1890

6 articles

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A Kansas City dispatch reports that two women believed to be Mrs. John and Kate Bender, held in a LaBelle County jail awaiting trial for the murder of Dr. York, will probably be released soon. The brief note suggests the case against them was weak or unsubstantiated.

Alexandria Gazette · 11 January 1890 · page 2

Will Probably be Liberated. Kansas City, Jan. 11.?It Is altogether probable that two women alleged to be Mra. John and Kate Bender, who are now con fioed in the Labelle county jail awaiting trial for the murder of Dr. York, will be liberated in a few days.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

An attorney in Kansas City claims to have affidavits proving that the two women held in Labette County jail as Mrs. John and Kate Bender are actually Almira Griffith and Sarah E. Davis, who were in Michigan during the years of the Bender murders. The Labette County prosecutor has agreed to release the women if these alibi documents hold up.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Oakes Weekly Republican, 29 November 1889, The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo, 10 December 1889.

The Indianapolis Journal · 12 January 1890 · page 2

Alleged Benders to Re Released. Kansas City, Jan. 11. It is altogether probable that the two women alleged to be Mrs. John and Kate Bender, who are now

See the clipping

In the story →

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · Sedalia, Mo.

This report disputes an earlier Bazoo article claiming two women held in the Labette County, Kansas jail were Mrs. John Bender and her daughter, wanted for the murder of York. It states the women will soon be released, as their preliminary trial testimony has already been published in full.

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 14 January 1890 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE BENDERS

Not the Benders, as Was Predicted by the Bazoo in the First Place.

See moreSee less

It is altogether probable that the two women alleged to be Mrs. John and Kate Bender, who are now confined in the Labette county, Kansas jail awaiting trial for the murder o, Dr. York, will be liberated in a few days. The story of their capture last October at Niles, Mich., and their preliminary trial before three justices of the peace at Oswego, Kan., has been published in full in the Bazoo. Mr. J. T. James, formerly of Fort Smith, Ark., but now of Kansas City, [illegible] nary trial.

Since that time he has been quietly at work collecting proof which will establish the fact that the women are Mrs. Almira Griffith and Mrs. Sarah E. Davis. He now claims to have affidavits showing that from 1870 to 1874 these two women were in Michigan. The crimes with which the Benders are charged were all committed during these years.

On being acquainted of this fact the prosecuting attorney of Labette county, Mr. Morrison, wrote to Mr. James, telling him that if he could prove these facts by affidavits he would discharge the prisoners. Mr. James will go to Oswego next week with his affidavits.

In this connection it should be stated that Mr. Morrison, the prosecuting attorney of Labette county, has never had any confidence in Mrs. McCann, who caused the two women to be arrested, and has never believed them to be the Benders. At the preliminary trial twenty-eight witnesses were examined, fourteen of whom testified positively that they were intimately acquainted with Mrs. John and Kate Bender and that the parties under arrest were not the Benders. Of the others examined, three testified point blank that the two women were Mrs. John and Kate Bender. Of the remaining witnesses some testified that one of the women was Mrs. John Bender, but the other was not Kate Bender, while others identified Mrs. Davis as Kate, but did not think the old woman was Mrs. John Bender.

In an interview with a reporter for Kansas City Times yesterday Mr. James said; "I am now convinced that I will be able to show a perfect alibi for Mrs. Griffith and for Mrs. Davis. This alibi will cover the years 1870, 1871, 1872, 1873 and 1874, one year before and two years after the Benders were in Kansas, thus showing that these women eould not possibly be the ones wanted for terrible crimes with which the Benders are charged.

'I propose to go next week to Oswego, Kan., where they are now being held in jail to present the evidence I have gathered to the prosecuting attorney and through his assistance secure their discharge. As they are being held without bond until the grand jury meets it will require the consent of the prosecuting attorney to secure their release before that body convenes some time in February.

In the case of Mrs. Griffith I will show by the wife and daughter of the man Daniel Perry, in whose house [illegible] that she was in Concord township, Berrien county, Michigan, during the years 1870 and 1871. She was then working to support six small children during this time, being even compelled at times to go into the field to plow and husk corn that she might find food for her little ones. I will show by Mr. and Mrs. Seeley of the same county, and by Mr. and Mrs. Hogue of Niles, Mich., that during the years 1872, 1873 and 1874 Mrs. Griffith, then known as Mrs. Marks, resided with three children in Carrollton, a suburb of South Saginaw. Mrs. Champion of Jackson, Mich., corroborates Mrs. Perry and Mrs. Graham as to Mrs. Griffith's residence during the years 1870 and 1871. I have also a certificate signed by the mayor and sixteen other citizens of Niles, testifying to the good character and upright bearing of Mrs. Griffith during her life in [illegible]

"As to Mrs. Davis, who is thought to be Kate Bender, Mr. and Mrs. Snell, of Bay Port, Mich., swear to her residence in that city during the years of 1871 and 1872 with her husband Hiram Johnson. Mrs. Taylor makes affidavit that Mrs. Davis, then Mrs. Johnson, spent the year of 1873 upon a farm adjoining her home and but a few miles from the town of Bay Port. During this time Mrs. Johnson gave birth to her third child, which child was buried there a few months later. This death left Mrs. Johnson with two living children, which fact alone would preclude the possibility of her being Kate Bender, who was known at that time to be a young and unmarried woman. The physician, Dr. Mervin, who attended Mrs. Johnson, also certifies to the birth and death of this child. This brings the record of Mrs. Davis through the year 1873, and until the month of September after the Benders had disappeared in the previous April.

"It would be difficult to imagine a stronger case of alibi than these affidavits make. all of them from good and reputable citizens, I am satisfied that when I present this proof to the prosecuting attorney, he will agree with me as to the impossibility of these women being in any way connected with the Benders, and will at once favor their discharge."

See the clipping

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · Sedalia, Mo.

A report on a preliminary trial before three justices concerning two women, Mrs. Almira Griffith and Mrs. Sarah Davis, suspected of being the fugitive Bender women. Witnesses and affidavits were presented regarding their whereabouts from 1870 to 1873, the years the Bender crimes occurred, with Mr. Morrison promising to drop charges if the women's alibi could be proven.

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 14 January 1890 · page 8

THE BENDERS

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · Sedalia, Mo.

A newspaper report describes conflicting witness testimony in a hearing where several people identified two women as Mrs. John Bender and Kate Bender, while other witnesses provided alibi evidence placing the accused women in Michigan during 1870-1871, seemingly proving they could not be the wanted Bender women. The piece is interspersed with unrelated local news about a newlywed couple and a train incident, reflecting typical period newspaper layout.

The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 14 January 1890 · page 8

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Western Kansas World · Wakeeney, Kan.

A Jackson, Michigan dispatch reports that investigations have confirmed the alibi of an old woman held in Oswego, Kansas, suspected of being Mrs. Bender, as her account of her whereabouts during the Bender murders period proved true. The alibi of the other suspect, held as Kate Bender, remains unproven.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 49 days earlier.

Western Kansas World · 18 January 1890 · page 6

A Jackson, Mich., d'spatch says the in vestigations there sett o the case of the old woman under indictment at Oswego, Kan sas, as being Mrs. Bender. Her statements of her whereabouts during tho period of the Bender murders hae proen to be true, thus sustaining an alibi. Of the other woman, held aB Kate Bender, noth'ng has as yet been proven to sustain an alibi in

See the clipping