As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · As the Papers Told It

Act Seven

Dead Once More

June 1908 – August 1910

When nine bodies were found at Laporte, Indiana, in 1908, the papers brought out the Benders again. The Chicago Tribune printed a deathbed account in which five vigilantes shot all four on the night they fled. In 1910 Kate died again at Rio Vista in California, and in a comic column by Irvin S. Cobb a sea serpent unsighted all summer listed her latest death, in Chicago, among the season’s old standbys.

Nine bodies in Indiana recall the Benders

The finding of nine bodies at Laporte, Indiana, sends this Colorado paper back to the Bender case. It says the family are credited with 37 killings, that nine bodies were found, and that Dr. York's brother traced him to their house after they had gone. It names the father William Bender, aged 60; the 1901 requisition papers call him John.

Cañon City Record · Cañon City, Colo.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Cañon City Record · 4 June 1908 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

37 PERSONS KILLED BY THE BENDERS IN KANSAS

The finding of nine bodies in Laporte, Ind., recalls the old Bender murders in Kansas. The Bender family lived in Labette, near Cherryvale, in 1872. They are credited with having killed 37 people.

See moreSee less

Of these the bodies of nine were found, but represented the killings of the last six months of the Bender family's stay in Kansas. The family consisted of William Bender, aged 60; his wife, aged 55; and two children by a former wife, Kate, aged 25, and John, aged 23. They lived in a 16x20 house in a remote region. This shack was divided by a canvas partition.

The plan was to get travelers who had stopped for food and shelter to sit with their backs to the canvas wall and then Kate would strike them from behind with a hammer. The old man would then finish the job with another hammer, a board would be taken up from the floor and the victim's throat cut over it. Horses and clothes were taken away by confederates, and the Bender's would keep the money and valuables. Their crimes were discovered by the murder of Dr. York of Independence, Kansas. His brother traced him to the Bender hut, but the members of the family had made their escape.

Of the nine bodies found all but two were identified. It was thought that the others had been taken far away from the hut and buried.

See the clipping

George Downer's deathbed story of the posse

The Chicago Tribune reports that George Evans Downer, a businessman of a Chicago suburb for thirty years, told his family on his deathbed that he was one of five vigilantes who overtook the Benders the night they fled. The Benders fired first, he said, and all four were killed. Earlier accounts in the set had them hanged, by ten or by seventeen men.

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Topeka State Journal · 13 July 1908 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

HELPED KILL BENDERS.

Chicago Citizen Makes a Confession on His Deathbed.

See moreSee less

Chicago. July 13.—The Chicago Tribune says:

"After thirty-five years the fate of the Bender family of Kansas has been solved. All four of the human butchers who lived on the 'Murder farm,' on the road from the Osage mission to Independence, were put to death on the night of their flight by a vigilance committee of five men, of whom one was George Evans Downer, a respected and honored business man of a Chicago suburb for the last thirty years.

"Mr. Downer had sworn secrecy but on his deathbed told the story to his wife and son, and a few intimate friends. His eldest son, Pierce Downer, took down the story.

"It will be remembered that the Benders fled after the disappearance of Dr. York. It has always been supposed they got clear out of the country. As a matter of fact they were put to death on the night of their flight by Mr. Downer and four members of a vigilance committee. The five men, convinced that the Benders were guilty of monstrous crimes, had started for the farm to arrest them. They only proposed to turn them over to the authorities. The Benders, however, had fled.

"The posse in hot pursuit overtook them. The Benders opened fire, and the posse fired in self defense. Old man Bender, John and the old woman were killed in the wagon. Kate tried to escape on a horse which was shot from under her. She was captured but, after confessing, grabbed a gun from one of the posse and attempted to shoot. She fell dead at the same moment, shot through the head. The bodies were all buried by the four remaining members of the posse, one having been killed in the fight."

See the clipping

An Arizona paper mocks Kate's many deaths

The Arizona Republican greets another report of Kate Bender's death with sarcasm. It holds that a pursuing posse killed her with the rest of the family soon after the crimes, and says she ‘has died at irregular intervals ever since’. Six days later an Abilene paper prints a Rio Vista, California, claim of the same kind.

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later. CorrectionThis set right 11 earlier articles: The Washington Times, 5 May 1910, Rock Island Argus, 5 May 1910, The Topeka State Journal, 5 May 1910, The Topeka State Journal, 5 May 1910, The Roswell Daily Record, 5 May 1910, Santa Fe New Mexican, 5 May 1910, Santa Fe New Mexican, 5 May 1910, The Guthrie Daily Leader, 5 May 1910, The Daily Ardmoreite, 5 May 1910, The Laramie Republican, 5 May 1910, The Laramie Republican, 5 May 1910.

Wrong

Arizona Republican · 6 May 1910 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Kate Bender is dead again. That serves that inhuman female right for her horrible crimes which shocked the country almost a generation ago. She was properly killed by a pursuing posse with the rest of the Bender family soon after. She has died at irregular intervals ever since. She ought to die next year, and the year after, and so on, until her accumulated death agonies may be sufficient to expiate her bloody crimes.

See the clipping

Mrs. Peters of Rio Vista, named as Kate

A Rio Vista, California, dispatch reports the word of Jack Collins that a woman who had lived there nearly 30 years as Mrs. Gavin and then Mrs. Peters, and who died recently, was Kate Bender. She told him so years before, he says, while dangerously ill and believing she was dying. The Abilene paper heads it ‘DEAD ONCE MORE’.

Abilene Weekly Reflector · Abilene, Kan.

Abilene Weekly Reflector · 12 May 1910 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

KATE BENDER DEAD ONCE MORE

This Time She Lived at Rio Vista, Cal., and Revealed Her Identity to a Friend.

See moreSee less

Rio Vista, Cal., May 6.—That a woman who lived here for nearly 30 years under the name of Mrs. Gavin and subsequently that of Mrs. Peters, who died recently, was really Kate Bender of the notorious Bender family of Kansas murderers, is a statement made by "Jack" Collins, a resident of this place.

According to Collins, a friend of the woman, Mrs. Peters revealed her identity to him a number of years ago while dangerously ill and believing she was dying.

See the clipping

Kate Bender, a stock joke by 1910

In a comic column by Irvin S. Cobb, a sea serpent that went unsighted all summer lists the ‘old standbyes’ that did turn up, among them Kate Bender, who ‘died again in Chicago’ after 18 years keeping a delicatessen as Mrs. Spiegenheimer. By 1910 a new Kate Bender report is something a humorist can list beside the sea serpent and the oldest living Mason.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 28 August 1910 · page 22 · transcribed from the page image

"LIVE TALKS WITH DEAD ONES"

The Sea Serpent Tells of a Wasted Summer

See moreSee less

BY IRVIN S. COBB

WE sat on the Atlantic seaboard, hard by the well known and popular ocean of that name, the Sea Serpent and I. The Sea Serpent reared his mighty bulk upon the beach and gazed up and down its damp and sandy reaches with a sad and humid eye. I sat under an umbrella which I had providentially borrowed at the life saving station nearby from a life guard who always kept one handy because he had a perfect horror of going out to save somebody in bad weather and catching his death of cold.

Except for us two the entire north Atlatic coast was deserted. Nobody was using the ocean for bathing purposes. Not a single German was committing suicide off the recreation pier that loomed in tne distance, bare and dripping. One of those dismal rains that bring the first moist threat of coming autumn beat down steadily. From a summer hotel far up the beach came drifting down upon us the strains of the kind of orchestra music that they always have at a summer hotel mingled with notes of forced laughter from a lot of vacationists who had been cooped up together just long enough to hate one another with great heartiness but hardly long enough yet to begin contemplating the idea of committing murder. Except when you're camping out and it rains I know of no place where you can learn to hate your fellow man with such intensity, in the shortest given space of time, as at a summer hotel in the latter part of August.

The Sea Serpent continued to contemplate the prospect with a wistful and a watery mien and shook his sea weed whiskers sadly. His gills worked up and down plaintively and it seemed to me that he choked a sob in his throat, for about nine feet down the neck about where I judged his Adam's apple should be, there was a slight convulsive movement.

"It's too bad, too dummed bad," he said at last in a throaty kind of a voice. "Summer is almost over. Labor Day will soon be at hand, when the honest toiler will celebrate his day of rest by walking 14 or 14 miles over rough streets while carrying on his brawny shoulder a transparency weighting upwards of 40 pounds; and when Labor Day looms in the immediate distance it's a sign that summer is on its last legs and in its last lap which is a hard place for anybody but summer or a contortionist to be.

"And not once all season have I showed in the money. All the rest of the old standbyes were on the job long before the end of June. The Belled Buzzard was reported several times in Arkansas, Texas and Oklahoma. Miss Kate Bender of Kansas died again in Chicago where for the last 18 years she has pursued the congenial calling of conducting a delicatessen store under the name of Mrs. Spiegenheimer. The Oldest Living Mason met eight or nine others of the Oldest Living Mason in a fraternal reunion. The last surviving widow of a revolutionary soldier gave out her regular annual interview stating that she had chewed, dipped snuff and smoked a cob pipe constantly for 94 years and didn't think that tobacco hurt anyone unless used to excess. The lady down in Tennessee, wife of a minister of the Southern Methodist church, who absently swallowed a card of buttons and a hank of thread at the age of seven, felt the customary tickling sensation just under the right shoulder blade and after a severe spell of coughing, coughed up a lingerie shirt waist. It seemed that all of them could come back—all but me and Jim Jeffries, especially Jim.

"I don't understand it all," went on the Sea Serpent gloomily. "There was a time and not so very long ago either when no seaside summer resort was complete without at least one visit a season from the Sea Serpent. I was kept so busy humping up and down the coast that sometimes for weeks and weeks I went without the proper sleep. I was as much a part of the scheme as the beach, the sand and sandflies, the life guard who always guards his own life so well, hence his title, the clam-bake and the dam bake, the shore dinner that tastes of the shore, the board walk and the bored walkers. And out in the interior where people often get to be 16 years old before they found out that an oyster doesn't grow in a can and where tales of the sea always went best, I was featured in all the papers regularly. But this summer I wasn't sighted once, not once. Not even any obscure hotel that couldn't make the prices high enough and the service bad enough to draw patronage in the regular way, attempted to make a bid by letting it be known that a weird monster of the deep with scales on its back had been seen just off the bathing beach by a number of veracious persons. I guess maybe the summer resorters were too busy gazing aloft at the speeding aviators and wondering whether they'd make a loud report when they fell or just hit the ground with a low mellow plunk, to be watching out across the breakers for the first glimpse of my well known lineaments and graceful yet peculiar form.

"It certainly makes me feel slighted. Just when I felt that I was going to pass Sarah Bernhardt and be within striking distance of Adelina Patti's world's record for farewell performances I fall down on my reptillian face. I'd gone to a lot of trouble and extra expense for the season, too—had a lot of loose scales on my back tightened up by an expert roofer and brightened my smile with some red waterproof paint and touched up the Plimsoll marks here on my sides and even had my tail altered from an old-fashioned turbine tail to one of those double rotary reciprocators. And there I was with all the modern improvements and not a leaf stirring. Tell me, was the summer a disappointment in many other respects?"

Thinking it over for a minute, I told him that on the whole and considering everything the summer had passed off fairly well. I'd noted that the green corn had run rather to misses' and children's sizes and it had been sort of hard to get a roasting ear that a hungry adult of the male sex could anoint with melted butter and then give a creditable imitation of somebody playing a solo on a harmonicum, or if he happened to have a loose front tooth, a harmonicum solo with added xylophone effects. Also that the portion served in all the expensive New York hotels had continued to shrink until a person who called for a filet mignon, say, would carry away the idea that the chef must have cut out the order with a pair of buttonhole scissors and applied the gravy through a medicine dropper.

Personally I told him we had a quiet time of it in my own humble domicile. We had experienced the usual difficulty common to all others, in getting a good hired girl who could cook by ear. I had followed with deep interest the explanation given by the New York baseball writers for the failure of the New York teams to win the pennants in both leagues and had marveled that those western teams could make a creditable showing because as a regular New Yorker I had always understood that really the only desirable thing you could get in one of those small inland communities like Chicago or Cincinnati was a ticket on a fast train back to New York. I went one to say that, speaking for myself, I was not grieved that the racing game had received such a painful death blow in New York because the only horse I'd bet on this year was such a perfect gentleman that when he started down the home stretch and found all the other entries were mares, he just stopped and turned around and stood back to one side with a polite bow, signifying "Ladies first." Branching out then I tried to recall the things that had stirred the world at large in the past few months.

"During the summer the march of progress was steady," I said. "The hobble skirt was not so numerous as we had been led to expect from reading the harrowing advance notices sent out from Paris, but it was sufficiently ugly and uncomfortable enough to attract a large number of the fair sex. Every rightly conducted summer resort in the mountains had its Lover's Leap to show to its guests, while on the ocean where the bathing was good and the Annette Kellerman Australian diving vogue had spread, a favorite substitute was the Lover's Splash. In certain sections the exhilarating trolley party was a popular diversion and in others the exciting event known as Tag day continued unabated. In lieu of these New York has had an exciting theatrical war which resembled the more recent trouble in Spain in this respect—the king wanted to book through the open door and admit the independents while the vatican stood out for syndicate attractions exclusively.

"Doc Crippen came over for a short stay and went back again after Scotland Yard had made a yard of daffodils of itself, just like one of those old time yard-of-something pictures that you used to get for 20 soap wrappers.

"But," I added, "probably the most exciting event of the summer and one that set all classes to talking whether or not they knew anything about the circumstances, which they didn't, was the effort of the W. C. T. U. and other kindred organizations all over this broad land to induce Congressman Nicholas Longworth's wife, Miss Alice Roosevelt that was, you know, to quit smoking cigarettes. They got all worked up about it, they did so. They didn't know for certain that she smoked cigarettes. But somebody told them they'd heard a rumor to that effect. And they begged her not to, any more. They didn't say whether they'd favor a meerschaum pipe or the kind of cigars that a young wife gets when she walks into the store and tells the man she wants a box suitable for a husband who's a pronounced blond. They did not go into details at all. But, first and last, they must have sent Mrs. Longworth fully 50 sets of resolutions."

"What did she do with them?" asked the Sea Serpent, showing signs of interest.

"I haven't any idea," I said, "unless she used them to make lighters out of. I know she didn't answer. Possibly she couldn't think of anything appropriate to say under the circumstances. Anyhow, anything that would be appropriate would certainly hurt their feelings."

"Well, if I were Mrs. Longworth, I think I could bear up under that, even," said the Sea Serpent. "But all these things have nothing to do with my case except to convince me that I do not fit into the picture anywhere any more."

There was a long, gloomy pause while the rain beat down upon the dank sands and the varnish on the handle of my umbrella began to melt.

"I know what the trouble with me is," said the Sea Serpent at length. "I'm like a certain peerless silver tongue out in the middle west. I've been on the job too long to be a national sensation and not quite long enough to be a national joke."

See the clipping

← Back to Act Six: The Only Absolutely True Story