This retrospective news item compares the newly uncovered murder farm of Mrs. Belle Gunness in Laporte, Indiana, to the earlier Bender family killings in Kansas. It recounts how the Benders murdered nine or ten people for robbery, buried them near their house, and vanished before capture, with conflicting rumors about their fate.
The inurder farm ruu at Lnporte. Ina'.. by Mrs. Belle Gunness, or Guin ness, recalls a similar place, the Ben der f:irui. lu Montgomery county, Kan. The Mender family consisted of old man Bender, his wife, a daughter, Kate, and a son. They are supposed to have murdered nine or ten persons on their premises, the bodies being burled lu the Immediate vicinity of the house. Robbery was the motive In each case. It was not until Dr. York was mur dered that suspicion was directed against the Benders. They almost Im mediately disappeared, aud there were all kinds of stories as to what became of them.
See moreSee less
Ono was that members of the York family waylaid and murdered them, that a vigilance committee forced a confession from them an:l then dis posed of their bodies after killing them, but each of these lias been deulcd. Two women were arrested at one time who were supposed to be Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender, hut they suc ceeded in clearing themselves. A large reward was offered at the lime of the Render family's disappearance f><r their capture. Like the Benders. Mrs. Gunness bur led her victims In the yard near her house. They Included two men she had married, her three children and other men and women lured to the i farm and murdered or slain In Chica
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Thirty-five years after the Bender murders, a Chicago report presents a dying man's eyewitness claim that he helped track the fleeing Benders and watched Kate Bender shot through the forehead by vigilantes atop her family's bodies. The account, attributed to George Evans Downer of Downers Grove, is offered as the long-sought truth ending decades of rumors about the family's fate.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 13 July 1908 · page 8
SHOT BY VIGILANTES.
S Stories of their annihilation by the sheriff and United States marshals : have been told only to be discredited. ; The man who tells the wonderful story gives nothing from hearsay, i nothing from rumor or reasoning, but his is the recital of an eye witness, of , a man who watched the fiends at work, who helped to organize tho posse which pursued the fleeing murderers, end was present, gun in hand, until . Kate Bender, fighting to the last
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A former vigilance committee member recounts how Dr. William York's disappearance spurred the search for the Bender killers, with a reward offered by the governor. He also retells a lawyer's story of a woman peddler who stayed overnight at the Benders' and fled in terror after witnessing John Bender sharpening a knife, escaping to Cherryvale.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 13 July 1908 · page 8
Bender crimes. I had had considera ble success in ferreting out criminals ana wnen peopi? Degan to disappear mysteriously on the road from Osage Mission to Independence I felt a great desire to get to the bottom of the mat ter. This desire was Increased by the disappearance of one of tho - best known citizens of that part of tho country, Dr. William H. York, of In dependence, a brother of Senator A. M. York. Tho senator Instituted a .search, the governor offered a reward of, $500, and I, with many others, set myself to find out the murderer.
See moreSee less
"It was fit this time that a friend of mine, a lawyer, called me into his of fice In Independence to llcten to the story of a woman canvasser. The wo man, who was tall and good looking, wanted to know how she could recov er possession, of some goods that she had left a"the house of tho Benders. She said she had reached their house in the afternoon and had tried to sell them some of her goods.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A self-described witness recounts Kate Bender's dramatic escape through a creek and later claims to have spied on John and Kate burying a bundle, prompting him to form a five-man vigilante posse. The posse pursues the fleeing Benders by horseback in the dark, exchanging gunfire as the account breaks off mid-chase.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 13 July 1908 · page 8
Committee of Five. "After they had made several trips and all was quiet I left my retreat and hastened to Cherryvale, determined to act. I informed four other vigilantes
The Chicago Tribune reports that a dying Chicago businessman, George Evans Downer, confessed to his family that he was part of a five-man vigilance committee that killed all four Benders the night they fled their farm. He described a gun battle and burial of the bodies, ending decades of uncertainty about their fate.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Topeka State Journal · 13 July 1908 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
HELPED KILL BENDERS.
Chicago Citizen Makes a Confession on His Deathbed.
See moreSee less
Chicago. July 13.—The Chicago Tribune says:
"After thirty-five years the fate of the Bender family of Kansas has been solved. All four of the human butchers who lived on the 'Murder farm,' on the road from the Osage mission to Independence, were put to death on the night of their flight by a vigilance committee of five men, of whom one was George Evans Downer, a respected and honored business man of a Chicago suburb for the last thirty years.
"Mr. Downer had sworn secrecy but on his deathbed told the story to his wife and son, and a few intimate friends. His eldest son, Pierce Downer, took down the story.
"It will be remembered that the Benders fled after the disappearance of Dr. York. It has always been supposed they got clear out of the country. As a matter of fact they were put to death on the night of their flight by Mr. Downer and four members of a vigilance committee. The five men, convinced that the Benders were guilty of monstrous crimes, had started for the farm to arrest them. They only proposed to turn them over to the authorities. The Benders, however, had fled.
"The posse in hot pursuit overtook them. The Benders opened fire, and the posse fired in self defense. Old man Bender, John and the old woman were killed in the wagon. Kate tried to escape on a horse which was shot from under her. She was captured but, after confessing, grabbed a gun from one of the posse and attempted to shoot. She fell dead at the same moment, shot through the head. The bodies were all buried by the four remaining members of the posse, one having been killed in the fight."
A Chicago business man, dying, claims on his deathbed that he was part of a vigilante committee that shot the four Bender family murderers while they fled across the prairie near Cherryvale 35 years earlier. He describes the desolate Bender farm and the trapdoor murder method, breaking a long-kept vigilante pledge of secrecy.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Detroit Times · 13 July 1908 · page 4
BENDER FAMILY'S FATE TOLD AFTER 35 YEARS
Here is a portion of his amazing story: j "I had been trailing man after man who had disappeared in the last few months and I knew they had all been seen for the last time wlthia a few miles of the Bender farm.
A man recalls visiting the Bender farm multiple times while investigating disappearances, describing the family's odd behavior and the house's layout. The account ties into the later theory that Kate Bender was actually Belle Gunness.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Detroit Times · 13 July 1908 · page 4
BENDERS ON PRAIRIE
Kate Liked ths Occult. “Kate posed as a 'medium,' and It was her reputation In this regard that made so many people certain that, no matter what happened to the rest of the Benders, she got away. It was this that made people all over Che country Insist that she and Mrs. Gun ness were Identical. She used to claim that she was 'controlled' by the spirit of an Indian princess. “I stayed but a short time, and was unable In any way to confirm my sus picions. There had been gossip ever since the Benders came to that part of the country about their apparently contradictory poverty and wealth.
See moreSee less
“I dropped in again and found ev erything as before John was away, as before, and I never did have the pleasure of meeting that member of the family. Kate talked with me, at first with reserve and later with ani mation, discussing city and country life, spiritualism, and other things. “A third time I called, and this time there was a decided, though Indescrib able change In their demeanor toward me. Kate was hospitable, but the air of the old folks betrayed suspicion, and their glances were anything but friendly. I started to sit In & chair, but was asked to sit on the bench. I had no suspicion about the bench then, but I did feel mighty uncomfortable. I made my visit brief and felt good when I was out of there.
A self-described vigilante recounts spying on the Bender family burying victims' clothing, then organizing a posse of five who chased the fleeing Benders across the prairie in a gun battle. He claims the old man and John Bender were shot dead, while Kate escaped on a horse after cutting it loose from the wagon.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Detroit Times · 13 July 1908 · page 4
The Suspicion Confirmed
“After they had made several trips and all was quiet I left my retreat and hastened to Cherryvale. deter mined to act. I Informed four other vigilantes on whom I could depend and we organized as a committee of five “tf’e glanced over the place and found they evidently had made up their minds to move In a hurry. This gave us the Idea that they must have been Informed of our approach and must, therefore, have confederates. This Influenced us after all was over to keep secret what we had done They had left much of their stuff and In the stable was a calf tied up and evi dently unfed or watered through the ; day.
A dying Chicago businessman reportedly confessed that he and four other vigilantes killed the Bender family during their flight shortly after Dr. York's disappearance, rather than the family escaping as long believed. His son recorded the deathbed account, which describes a gun battle, Kate Bender's capture and death, and secret burial of the bodies.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Beatrice Daily Express · 13 July 1908 · page 4
HE HELPED LYNCH THE BENDER FAMILY
Benders Were Killed in Running Fight. Sunday’s Chicago Tribune states that “After thirty-five years the fate of the Bender family of Kansas has been solved. All four of the human butchers who lived on the “Murder farm,” on the road from the Osage mission to Independence, were put to death on the night of their flight by a vigilance committee of five men, of whom one was George Evans Down er, a respected and honored business man of a Chicago suburb for the last thirty years. •‘Mr. Downer had sworn secrecy but on his deathbed today told the story to his wife and son, and a few intimate friends.
See moreSee less
His eldest son, Pierce Downer, took down the story. ‘•It will be remembered that the Benders fled after the disappearanee of Dr. York. It has always been sup posed they got clear out of the coun try. As a matter of fact they were put to death on the night of their flight by Mr. Downer and four mem bers of a vigilanee committee. The five men, convinced that the Benders were guilty of monstrous crimes, had started for the farm to arrest them. They had no idea of killing them. They only proposed to turn them over to. the authorities. The Bend ers, however, had fled. “The posse in hot pursuit overtook them. The Benders opened fire, and the posse fired in self defense. Old man Bender, John and the old wom an were killed in the wagon. Kate tried to escape on a horse which was shot from under her. She was cap tured but, after confessing, grabbed a gun from one of the posse and at tempted to shoot. She fell dead at the same moment, shot through the head. The bodies were all buried by the four remaining members of the posse, one having been killed in the fight.”
A Chicago businessman, dying, claims on his deathbed that he was one of a vigilante committee that hunted down and shot the Bender family while they fled across the prairie 35 years earlier. He describes revisiting the desolate Bender farm and its murder room before supposedly joining the lynching party.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Detroit Times · 14 July 1908 · page 6
FAMILY'S FATE TOLD AFTER 35 YEARS SAYS HE IS ONE OF VIGILANTES WHO KILLED ARCH-MURDERERS ON PRAIRIE
T had been trailing man after man who had disappeared In the last few months and I knew they had all been aeen for the last time within a few miles of the Bender farm. « “I had visited them before, but I decided to make another attempt to solve the mystery and soon dropped ta on them. A more desolate scene r could hardly be conceived. Except for their shanty, their little stone sta* Ms, their pretense at an orchard, and the few willows that bordered the . creek, the prairie as far as could be ;i aeen In any direction was unbroken * by tree, house, man or animal.
See moreSee less
“A door cut In the partition led over | S trapdoor In the floor to the rear •room, which served both as kitchen land bedroom. It was in this room
Decades after the murders, a man identified only as 'Hare' recounts how he visited the Bender homestead three times while investigating disappearances, describing the house's trapdoor and murder room. He also notes the enduring rumor that Kate Bender, the family's medium, was later identical to murderess Belle Gunness.
Kate Liked the Occult. "Kate posed as a ‘medium,’ and it ?'wa» her reputation in this regard that made so many people certain that, no matter what happened to the rest of the Benders, she got away. It was this that made people all over tiie country Insist that sue and Mrs. Gun* ness were identical. She used to claim that she was ‘controlled' by the spirit of an Indian princess. “I stayed but a short time, and was unable in any way to confirm my sus picions There had been gossip ever ; since the Benders came to that part of the country about their apparently * contradictor}' poverty and wealth.
See moreSee less
1 *"I dropped in again and found ev erything as before. John was away, ;as before, and I never did have the pleasure of meeting that member of the family. Kate talked with me, at with reserve and later with ani mation, discussing city and country Hie, spiritualism, and other things. “A third time I called, and this tlmo there was a decided, though indescrib able change in their demeanor toward me. Kate was hospttable. but the air of the old folks betrayed suspicion. their glances were anything but friendly. I started to sit in a chair, bat was asked to sit on the bench. I had no suspicion about the bench then, bht I did feel mighty uncomfortable. I made my visit brief and felt good When I was out of there.
A man recounts spying on John and Kate Bender burying victims' clothing, then organizing a five-man vigilante posse to pursue the fleeing family. He describes a nighttime gunfight on the prairie in which the old man and another Bender were killed, while Kate escaped on a horse.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Detroit Times · 14 July 1908 · page 6
•ad hastened to Cherryvale, deter mined to act. I Informed four other ' vigilantes on whom I could depend | sad we organised as a committee of five
A dying man in Downers Grove, Illinois claims he was part of a vigilante band that tracked down and killed the Bender family decades earlier, keeping the act secret for over 35 years. The report recounts the original Bender murders and notes that rumored sightings of the family had surfaced over the years in connection with other notorious criminal cases.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Americus Times-Recorder · 15 July 1908 · page 3
Extermination of Murder ers Told By Vigalante. Chicago, 111., July 14.—(Special) ! What purports to be the true solu i tion of the Bender family mystery
A Civil War veteran named Downer recounts decades later how he spied John and Kate Bender burying victims' clothing, then led vigilantes who tracked the fleeing family and killed them all in a gunfight. The story claims Kate Bender confessed before being shot trying to escape, and that the killings were kept secret for years.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Americus Times-Recorder · 15 July 1908 · page 3
Reward for Benders
When they reached the Bender farm the family had packed up all their belongings and fled. The vigi lantes pursued and when they came up with the Benders were fired upon and a battle ensued, in which all the Benders and their horses were killed. The bodies were buried and their belongings destroyed by fire. . Kate Bender, according to the story made a confession, and was shot af ter an attempt to escape from her captors, one of whom she wounded. The fear that friends of the Ben ders might retaliate it is claimed, was the reason for keeping the facts sec iret all these years.
The article references a deathbed confession, published in the Rocky Mountain News, claiming a surviving vigilante finally revealed how the Bender family was pursued and killed 34 years earlier, after keeping an oath of silence. It claims this account disproves the persistent Kansas myth that Kate Bender escaped with help from one of her pursuers.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Daily Sentinel · 16 July 1908 · page 2
The Adams trinl lias been concluded. We are inclined to say that it was conducted in tins most fair and impartial manner. W e also think that the position that The Sentinel took right at the start, to frown down upon any inclination upon the part of the defense or the prosecution to try tlielr side of the case through the public press, was largely responsible for the manner in Which the trial was conducted. The reports that this paper contained, conceded by all to have been the most extended appearing in any paper in tlic state, have been entirely Impartial.
See moreSee less
The Instructions to the member of The Sentinel staff who represented the paper at the trial was to he strictly fair In every word that wis written. The press can he a mighty lever for fairness In any community. If it is so Inclined. The Sentinel was. acting In behalf of the good name of the county, to which tills case was sent for trial, the costs to be paid by the taxpayers of a sister county and believed that the only way to do. was to permit the court and the jury to decide the case and not anticipate a verdict by an acrimonious discussion through the public press. In nil tlic criminal history of America, there is no story that attracts quite so much interest as the horrible story of the murders made by the in famous Bender family in Kansas. A survivor of the vigilante committee on Ids dentil bed gave a full account of the pursuit and death of the family, which appeared in yesterday's Rocky Mountain News. The myth that hns always obtained in Kansas that in some manner Knte Bender, the arch fiend of the family lind escaped through the connivance of one of the pursurers. is all exposed by tills death bed confession. The dying member of the band kept the secret of the manner of the death of the family for a period of 34 years, in consequence of an oath glevn to Ills fellow vigilants. 'I lie burden was too heavy to carry to the grave and he gave the whole story. The crimes of that family credit the age In which Lucretla Borgia lived and Kate Bender would have graced, the round table of the poisoners of the French and Italian periods, wherein the arts of the poisoner was considered a polite profession. It is said that the commissioners have said that they didn't can' a damn about the condition of the guard rails on the Grand river bridge, that they would repair them when they got pool and ready and not before. Of course tlmt is tin* privilege of the county commlssiners hut they may live to regret the time they have let to go by without fixing those guards. In all the reports of the Steve Adams trial The Sentinel has led by a running mile. Every Item of interest that occurred each day was reported up to the minute of adjournment. There was nothing left out of the report that was In any manner an item of importance. There is nothing like being 'JohnnV-on-the-spot, when it comes to giving a report. The declaration of the campaign committee of the Democratic party that no subscription be received over SIO,OOO leaves us out.
A Chicago man named George Evans Downer claims on his deathbed that he was part of a vigilance committee that tracked down and killed the Bender family in 1873, supposedly ending speculation about their fate. The article recaps the original Bender murders near Cherryvale, Kansas, including Kate Bender's alleged role as the killer who posed as a psychic healer to lure victims.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Advocate · 16 July 1908 · page 3
Kate Bender watt feared by men and women. Stalw^ftf,, domineering in hej manner, aid .afraid ofnothing that walke^ ^eiy-. crawled,, she also frightened the farming folk by her alleged witchcraft. She made ' po tions from root^L and herbs, and claimed for the^. magic powers. When the discovery of the many murders committed in. the Bender shanty was made it was thought fchaty Kate had deliberately created feai and repulsion. fpr her, so that neigh bors would notbother her, her mpth er, father, and brother at their chos en work of murder.
See moreSee less
Those who answered Kate's ad verUsement ahd, wayfarers who paus ed at the shanty/ for food and shelter were the victims';. <, It is believed that Kate herself wjeljded the iron ham mer which crushed &he skulls of her victims and. then,-)- cut their throats, leaving the ot&$|r ? members of the family to dispose of the bodies. , In April, 187%* the Bender family
The article retells the 1873 investigation at the Bender farm, describing the blood-soaked well, the exhumation of Dr. York and other victims including an old man and a girl, and the brutal killing methods used. It also recounts the nationwide but unsuccessful hunt for the Benders, including the near-lynching of a German man named Brockman who was wrongly suspected of knowing their whereabouts.
The Advocate · 16 July 1908 · page 3
Three additional* graves were found, and the fataiiies of missing personb all through the Middle West were heading for the Bender farm. Detectives from many- 'states started out to Jrail the murderous family, but no trace of them was found. A German named Brock-man, who knew/ the Benders, was supposed to know of their whereabout, ajid the Kan Bans took hold of him, strung him to a tree, and lowered him just In time tq save his life. He was told to tell what he knew of the Benders, but insisted even then that he know noth ing of them.
See moreSee less
He was strung up a second time, and the crowd howled to him to tell or he'd pay with his iif3 for his silence. Again when let down he vowed that he knew noth ing of the mrudera, A third time he was strung up and letdown. Then he van permitted to go. Many ar rests of suspicious - Dersons were made in the state and many vigilance commfttees started off on hunts for the Benders. None of them ever re ported finding them. , In Downer ? story h<j said that when the vigilance committee of which he was a member came upon the ^Benders in their jftl^ht and en gaged them in battje Kate *waa the r:. rjf Times) - | The story frbfci Chicago^ printed; In yesterdayfsVTtnies giving, the con fession of Qeotpyp Evans Downer; that he was ona vigilance commit tee whlc$t-J^% .down ana killed thj* notorious Beua^r, family, U his
The article revisits the Bender family legend, noting a Chicago man's deathbed claim that a vigilance committee killed and buried the whole family, a claim disputed by a former Labette County officer who says the Benders escaped into Indian Territory. It also recounts Colonel Ava E. Page's story of arresting the elder Bender in Wisconsin in 1857 for mutilating a horse, before the family later moved to Kansas and became notorious.
COLONEL PAGE ARRESTED BENDER FIFTY YEARS AGO. Every reader of the press will re member the notorious Bender family, of Labette county, who mysteriously disappeared after murdering and rob bing scores of travelers as they came to their house seeking food and shel ter. Interest in the case has just beeri revived by the deathbed statement ol a Chicago man that he was one of a vigilance committee of five who killed and buried the whole Bender family. This statement, however, is denied by a former officer of Labette county, who says that the Benders
The article recalls that Col. Ava E. Page arrested the elder Bender in 1857 in Milwaukee County for killing a horse with a scythe, resulting in a penitentiary term. It then recounts the family's later move to Kansas and their murderous inn, speculating that the recently exposed Belle Gunness of Indiana might have been one of the Benders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 20 days later.
Wrong
The Roswell Daily Record · 17 July 1908 · page 4
BENDER FIFTY YEARS AGO.
last long. :-: :-: :-: :-: ftQ SWELL, JV.M. got a whole day's start of the officers and crossed the line into the Indian Territory. But that is not our story. Col. Ava E. Page, of Roswell, acted as an officer in placing the notorious head of the Bender family under ar rest probably for the first time in his lawless career. The arrest took place in 1857, just 51 years ago last spring. Col Page was then deputy sheriff of Milwau kee county. Wis., and one day a man came into the sheriff's office and stat ed that he had a warrant for the ar rest of one Bender, and asked Depu ty Page to serve it at once.
See moreSee less
The man stated that his horse got out and went into Bender's yard and that Bender took a mowing scythe and lit erally cut and sloshed the animal to pieces. Deputy Page rode twenty mile up the lake shore and placed Bender under arrest. The defendant was found guilty and sent to the peniten tiary. After his release from the pris on Bender took his family and moved to Labette county, Kan,- where they committed the series of crimes that formed the foundation of twenty or thirty mysterious disappearances and were the sensation of the day when discovered. The Benders had a house about sev en or eight miles from where the city of Independence now stand3 and about the same distance from Cherry vale, Kan. Travelers coming to their place' for a meal were seated with backs close to a curtain partition. While the meal was being eaten a member of the family would strike the visitor from behind with an axe, through the curtain. He was then rob bed and the body hidden. After the series of crimes was detected it was found that they had robbed their vis itors of vast sums, one traveler hav ing $10,000 when he entered the place. The fact that nobody knows what be came of the Benders atter their flight, caused the suspicion that Mrs. Gunness, whose murder plant was recently discovered " in' Indiana must has been one of the Benders.
The report recounts two conflicting confessions—one from a dying Chicago man, another from a Kansas visitor in Ohio—each claiming to have taken part in killing the Bender gang, with differing accounts of how Kate died. It treats the matter with wry humor, concluding only that Kate is presumed dead while the exact circumstances remain unresolved.
KANSAS COMMENT REST IN PIECES. The mystery of the disappearance of Kate Bender is being gradually cleared up, and, although much of the evidence appears contradictory, there is every reason to believed that Kate is dead; and so it would be ungener ous to postpone further the last sad rites. So let the ritual now be read, the requiem now be sung for her, for Kate, the doubly dead, in that she died so young. A Chicago man died-a day or two ago. Before his eyelids closed in death he told a strange story, to the effect that he was one of a party of four or five who exterminated the members of the Bender family a few hours after the story of their crimes became known.
See moreSee less
According to him, Kate was killed by one of the party, while she was narrating the hideous story of murder. Having thus re lieved his mind, he breathed his last sigh in hope of salvation. Now comes a Kansas man who is visiting in Ohio. He doesn't appear to be on his deathbed, so his confes sion naturally won't have the force of the other, but In this great Bender controversy, all witnesses are entitled to a hearing. He says that he was one of the avenging crowd who slew the Benders, and affirms that there was no such a man as the Chicago individual in the bunch, unless he traveled under an assumed name. He says that Kate wasn't killed by one of the party, but committed suicide. In either case it seems that Kate is dead; the life still there, upon her hair, but the death upon her eyea Tihs point being settled, it only re mains to let the dead and the beauti ful rest, and resume the argument as to whether Mrs. Gunness is dead or alive. During the profitless discussion concerning the lamented Kate, Belle has been neglected in a shameful man ner. Emporia Gazette.
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis. · and 1 other paper
George Evans Downer, claiming to be a former vigilance committee member, dictates through his wife a deathbed account of how the Bender family murderers were tracked down and killed decades earlier. He says a secrecy pact bound him for over thirty years, and only fear of dying with the truth untold prompted him to finally reveal it.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Iowa County Democrat · 23 July 1908 · page 5
HOW PERISHED THE KANSAS BENDERS STORY IS NOW TOLD BY A MEMBER OF THE VIGILANCE COMMITTEE, WHO TELLS THE TALE THINKING THAT HE IS ON HIS DEATHBED. KATE BENDER THE BOLDEST AND CRUELEST OF THE WHOLE GANG.
WHOLE GANG. George Evans Downer of Down er’s Grove, 111., grandson ox Pierce Downer, who founded the settlement in 16‘u6, has told the story of the man ner in which the famous Bender fam
Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis. · 29 July 1908
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.
A traveler recounts how the Bender family tried to lure her into staying overnight, saw John sharpening a knife, and fled to hide in a creek until they gave up searching for her. A detective narrator recalls how her story, combined with reports of missing men near the Bender farm, convinced him something was wrong there.
Iowa County Democrat · 23 July 1908 · page 5
Finds Refuge in a Creek. “Roused by this sight to desperate action, she made an excuse to leave the house. It was now dark and she instantly fled for the creek, which flowed near by. She ran until she no ticed at the house.and then waded out iced at the house, and then waded out in the creek up to her neck. Sh* stayed there for hours while the Benders searched for her. They at last gave up the bunt and she emerg ed from her watery hiding place wet from head to foot and without hat or shoes, both having been left at the Benders.’ She ran all the way to Cherryville.
See moreSee less
five miles distant, ar rivng in a state of collapse. , “The lawyer only laughed at the storyy seeing nothing in it hut the foolish fears of a hysterical woman.
Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis. · and 1 other paper
An aging man named Downer dictates to his family a long-secret account of his role in the vigilance effort against the Benders, describing how Dr. York's disappearance spurred a reward and search. He recounts a woman canvasser's unsettling overnight stay at the Bender house as the first real clue to the murders.
Vernon County Censor · 29 July 1908 · page 7
“I was young at the time, hut was au active member of these organiza tions of the law and order element for some r ears prior to the time of the Bender crimes. I had had consid erable success in 'erreting out crim inals, and when people began to dis appear mysteriously on the road from Osage Mission to Independence I felt a great desire to get to the bottom of the matter. This desire was in creased by the disappearance of one of the best known citizens of that part of the country, Dr.
See moreSee less
William H. York of Independence, a brother of Senator A. M. York. The senator in stituted a search, the governor offer ed a reward of SSOO and I, with many o-heis, set myself to find out the mur derer.
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis. · 23 July 1908
Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis.
A detective recalls a woman's harrowing escape from the Bender family, who threatened her with a knife before she hid in a creek overnight. He explains how her story, combined with men vanishing near the Bender farm, convinced him to investigate the desolate homestead further.
Vernon County Censor · 29 July 1908 · page 7
I The Benders returned the goods she had left and he considered the mat ter no further. But 1 had been traii t lug man after man who had disapI peared in the last few months and I 1 knew they had all been seen tor the last time within a few miies of the Bender farm, and the woman's story convinced me there was something wrong there.
George E. Downer, dying in Chicago's suburbs, claimed on his deathbed that he had been part of a vigilante posse that hunted down and killed the entire Bender family in Kansas 35 years earlier. He said Kate Bender died fighting, shot in the forehead, atop the bodies of her mother, father, and brother.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.
Wrong
The Florida Star · 31 July 1908 · page 6
SECRET KEPT MANY YEARS
States marshal had aonihilated them were circulated and discredited. Their fate was recently revealed for the first time by a man sick unto death, who for over thirty years lived the life of a respected and honored business man in f Chicago suburb, The man who told the wonderful story gave nothing from hearsay, noth ing from rumor or “reasoning,” but his was the recital of an eyewitness, of a man who watched the fiends, who ‘helped to organize the posse which pursued the fiendish murderers and was present, gun in hand, until Kate Bender, fighting to the last, plunged, with a bullet in her forehead, across the bodies of her mother, father and brother.
See moreSee less
George Evans Downer of Downer's Grove, grandson of Plerce Downer, who founded the settlement in 1823, told the story, fully believing he was on his deathbed and that it was his duty to publish the truth to the world, says a correspondent of the Chicago Tribune. A compact entered intg by the members of the vigilance com mittee at the time kept his lips sealed all these years, but realization of the fact that if he did not speak the truth might never be known induced him to tell how he assisted in the extermina tion of the fiendish family. Mr. Downer lived at Independence, Kan. during the bloody reign of the Benders. He personally visited the Bender farm on the road between Osage, Mo., and Independence. He went several times in an effort to gain a clew to the mysterious disappear ances from that neighborhood. It will be remembered the Benders fled after the murder of Dr. York. It has al ways been supposed the butchers got clear out of the country. As a mat ter of fact, as Mr. Downer revealed for the first time, the Benders were put to death the night of their flight. Downer, whose visits to the Bender place had convinced him that the Ben ders were guilty of monstrous crimes, associated himself with four other men in an effort to capture the human butchers. They had no idea of inflict ing summary justice themselves. They planned to capture the Benders and turn them over to the legal authorities. They discovered that the Benders had
The Florida Star · Titusville, Fla. · and 1 other paper
A Chicago Tribune correspondent reports that George Evans Downer, believing himself dying, broke a decades-old vigilance-committee pact of silence to reveal that he and four other men hunted down and killed the fleeing Bender family the night they disappeared. Downer's account describes a gunfight on the prairie ending with Kate Bender shot in the forehead atop her family's bodies, contradicting the long-held belief that the Benders escaped the country.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.
Wrong
The Florida Star · 31 July 1908 · page 6
SECRET KEPT MANY YEARS
Benders. He personally visited the Bender farm on the road between Osage, Mo., and Independence. He went several times in an effort to gain a clew to the mysterious disappear ances from that neighborhood. It will be remembered the Benders fled after the murder of Dr. York. It has al ways been supposed the butchers got clear out of the country. As a mat ter of fact, as Mr. Downer revealed for the first time, the Benders were put to death the night of their flight. Downer, whose visits to the Bender place had convinced him that the Ben ders were guilty of monstrous crimes, associated himself with four other men in an effort to capture the human butchers.
See moreSee less
They had no idea of inflict ing summary justice themselves. They planned to capture the Benders and turn them over to the legal authorities. They discovered that the Benders had
The Florida Star · Titusville, Fla. · and 2 other papers
A dying posse member named Downer allegedly confessed to his wife and son decades later that his vigilante group tracked down and killed the fleeing Bender family on the prairie. The account describes a violent chase and shootout in which the elder Benders and John were killed, while Kate fought fiercely before being captured and calmly confessed to multiple murders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.
Wrong
The Florida Star · 31 July 1908 · page 6
SECRET KEPT MANY YEARS
Then the older Bender, who was firing from the back of the wagon, pitched out on the prairie dead, and John, his son, jumped and ran. He was shot