As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

August 1908

11 articles

The Nezperce Herald · Nezperce, Idaho

This report on the Belle Gunness 'murder farm' case in La Porte, Indiana, draws a comparison to the earlier Bender family killings in Montgomery County, Kansas, suggesting Gunness may have been even more bloodthirsty than Kate Bender. It recaps the Bender case, noting the family allegedly murdered nine or ten people, then mysteriously vanished with their fate never confirmed, despite rumors of vigilante justice.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 20 days earlier.

The Nezperce Herald · 6 August 1908 · page 2

THE LA PORTE MURDER FARM

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Montour American · Danville, Pa.

A dying Illinois businessman, George E. Downer, claims he was part of a Kansas posse that tracked down and killed the entire Bender family in 1873, breaking a decades-old vigilante pact of silence. He describes Kate Bender shot through the forehead atop her family's bodies after a desperate fight.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 26 days later.

Wrong

Montour American · 6 August 1908 · page 3

SECRET KEPT MANY YEARS.

was present, gun in hand, until Kate Bender, fighting to the last, plunged, with a bullet in her forehead, across the bodies of her mother, father and brother. George Evans Downer of Downer's Grove, grandson of Pierce Downer, who founded the settlement in 1823, told the story, fully believing he was on his deathbed and that it was his duty to publish the truth to the world, says a correspondent of the Chicago, Tribune. A compact entered into by the members of the vigilance com mittee at the time kept his lips sealed all these years, but realization of the fact that if he dkl not speak the truth might never be known induced him to tell how he assisted in the extermina tion of the fiendish family.

See moreSee less

Mr. Downer lived at Independence, Kan., during the bloody reign of the Benders. lie personally visited the Bender farm on the road between Osage, Mo., and Independence. He went several times In an effort to gain a clew to the mysterious disappear ances from that neighborhood. It will be remembered the Benders fled after the murder of Dr. York. It has al ways been supposed the butchers got clear out of the country. As a mat ter of fact, as Mr. Downer revealed for the first time, the Benders were put to death the night of their flight. Downer, whose visits to the Bender place had convinced him that the Ben ders were guilty of monstrous crimes, associated himself with four other men in an effort to capture the human butchers. They had no idea of inflict ing summary Justice themselves. They planned to capture the Benders and turn them over to the legal authorities. They discovered that the Benders had fled aad took up the trail only a few

See the clipping

Deutscher Herold · Sioux Falls, Süd-Dakota

A dying man named George Evans Downer reportedly confessed on his deathbed in Illinois that he had been part of a Kansas vigilance committee that caught and killed the Bender family decades earlier, ending the long mystery of their fate. He says he kept the secret for decades under oath but would not take it to his grave.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Deutscher Herold · 6 August 1908 · page 2

Das Ende der Familie Bender. Eine blutige Tragödie.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Deutscher Herold · Sioux Falls, Süd-Dakota

A German-American man recalls decades later how he joined a vigilance committee in Kansas after people vanished near the Bender family's homestead, including Dr. York. He describes hearing a young woman's terrifying account of staying overnight with the Benders and then visiting their shanty himself to investigate.

Deutscher Herold · 6 August 1908 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Deutscher Herold · Sioux Falls, Süd-Dakota

A German-American writer recalls visiting the Bender family's roadside inn before their crimes were discovered, describing its layout, the bench where victims were seated before being killed, and the unsettling demeanor of the family members, especially Kate Bender. The account, published decades later, reflects on growing suspicion of the family despite finding no direct evidence at the time.

Deutscher Herold · 6 August 1908 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

Decades after the Bender murders, a Chicago man's deposition claiming the family was tracked down and killed by a posse sparks arguments among Kansans. A former policeman who knew Kate Bender disputes details of her beauty and the escape story, while an old scout offers yet another account of the family being killed near Camp Supply by outlaws.

CorrectionThis set right 4 earlier articles: The Florida Star, 31 July 1908, The Florida Star, 31 July 1908, The Florida Star, 31 July 1908, Deutscher Herold, 6 August 1908.

The New Haven Union · 9 August 1908 · page 23

Talk of Famous Case. George Evans Downer, of Chicago, is not the only man who claims to know v/hat became of the Bender family of murderers, of Labette county, Kansas. When he, made a deposition recently to the effect that the Benders were pursued and killed by a posse he start ed a discussion and never-ending argu ment. Everybody in Kansas iff talk ing about it, and whenever you meet a Kansan on the streets of Denver he doubtless will undertake to tell you some "inside history” concerning the r.otorious case.

See moreSee less

It must be said, however, that Downer's lurid yarn is not generally credited. He described the Bender girl, Kate, as being a creature of surpassing beauty. ‘ Now comes former policeman S. C. Carpenter, who was acquainted with Kate Bender, and who says she had features like a big raw-boned man and was about the ugliest mortal that ever crossed the plains. He also under takes to knock in the head some vital points in the Downer narrative, notably that concerning the alleged escape of a woman who called at the Bender place. Carpenter talked yesterday to a Post commissioner, who also obtained a statement regarding the fate of the Benders from Capt. Charles Christy, an old scout of the early days. Christy has information that the Benders were killed at a point about 30 miles from Camp Supply, I. T., on Red river, by a band of outlaws, who feared that if the family were found traveling with them they, as well as the Benders, would be hanged by in dignant people. Former Policeman Carpenter was also personally acquainted with Dr. York, one of the victims of the blood thirsty Benders. "I remember when he was missing," says Carpenter, “and the commotion that was caused by the discovery of his body. I saw the 18 men leave Inde pendence fo hunt for Dr. York, and they all rode horseback. For years I remembered their names, but with time comes forgetfulness. Besides Dr. York and Ed were John Debuler, Wil liam Wright, Joe Davis, Pat Bennett, Isaac Davis, known as ‘Red,’ a Mr. Brock, afterward elected sheriff of Montgomery county, and others not in my mind at the present time. “I saw the seven murdered men and the little girl, as their bodies were taken up and laid near the house of the Bender ranch. All were taken from a small patch of broken ground south of the house. There had been a few fruit trees planted in the ground, but only for a blind to throw people off their guard. The house was about 14 by 26 feet—built on the plan of a coun try school house—the front facing north. A few shelves and a small amount of goods were in this front room. A curtain formed a bed room on the east side of the inner part of the house, leaving a hall along the west side from the storeroom to the

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

A 1908 report recounts Capt. Charles Christy's claim that the Benders were killed by outlaws near Camp Supply, Indian Territory, for fear of being lynched alongside them. It also includes former policeman Carpenter's recollections of Dr. York's murder, the search party, and the grim exhumation of victims at the Bender ranch.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 23 days later.

Wrong

The New Haven Union · 9 August 1908 · page 23

FATE OF THE BENDER FAMILY

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

Decades after the Bender murders, a correspondent challenges another witness's (Downer's) account of the Bender homestead's layout, including claims about a well, pump, and a fleeing peddler woman. He also disputes descriptions of Kate and John Bender's appearance, calling his own memory more reliable.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.

Wrong

The New Haven Union · 9 August 1908 · page 23

Benders In my mind’s eye Just as they looked, and I never thought old Ben der was a weazened-looking man. • To me he appeared a powerfully built fel low. The old woman was very large, but somewhat stooped. Downer say3 Kate was a beautiful girl. Weir, > if so, I am no Judge of good looks, for I thought she was about as homely a mortal as ever crossed the plains. She had features like a blg^aw-boned man. She had no lady-Hke or refined; ap pearance. John was more refined and did not look like any of the rest.

See moreSee less

"Downer says D-. Avery was with him. Delos Avery lived within a block of us. He was a hamessmaker, working In Tom Harrison's harness shop, and I know he didn’t even stop work to go to see the Bender burying ground. "I saw the old Dutchman hanged that Mrs. Beard speaks about. He was not hanged by a vigilance committee, end was not left hanging. By the time all the dead were taken up there were thousands of people on the ground and they became Infuriated. "The old Dutchman lived about a mile west of Bender’s house. The crowd of people tried to make him tell something about the Benders. He said he had suspected all was not right, but he knew nothing about them. "He was hanged to a crossbar on top of his big gatepost, and after a few seconds he was let down, but again protested Innocence, and was strung up again and left until unconscious. He was again let down, and after he had been revived was told to talk. He told the crowd he knew nothing about the Benders, but he asked them ’to hot bring him to any more, and if they hanged him to leave him hanging. They then let him go,’ . "My brother wrote me a few years ago saying that William Wright, was dead, and on his deathbed he said they killed the Benders and sunk their bodies in Trayer lake. Whether this is so or not I won’t say, but I know William Wright was with the men Who were hunting Dr. York. , "I agree with Col. York when he said that if a posse had killed the Benders there would have been no secret to keep, but It would have been a pleasure to tell It to the world.”

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The piece compares the notorious Belle Gunness murders to the earlier Bender family killings, recapping the Benders' 1871 arrival in Kansas, their fake-medium murder method, and their 1873 disappearance after Dr. York's killing was discovered. It notes rumors that Labette County farmers lynched the Benders, though this was never confirmed.

Paper unidentified · 13 August 1908 · page 3

If Mrs. Gunness was or Is a reincar nation of Kate Bender she bas outdone the ghastly achievements of her former life. Of the Bender family's known victims there were only seven. The tally of the Gunness woman's crimes may neTer be made up, but It already has surpassed that of the Benders' butcheries. The parallelism of the two affairs Is otherwise remarkable. The circumstances of the earlier were as follows: In 1871 a family of four came over from Germany aud opened a small store on the country road which runs from Independence, Kan., to the Osage mission.

See moreSee less

The members of the family were father, called both William and John; bis wife; their sou, John; and their daughter, Kate, a girl of 25, who claimed to t>» a spirit medium, it was through the machinery or spiritualistic seances that the crimes were commit ted. The victim was seated In the usual dark room with bis head against a curtain. One ot the Benders, stand ing behind the curtain, then struck him over the head with a hammer. After wards, to make certain, the victim’s throat was cut, he was stripped of his valuables, and was burled at night. Dis covery came May 4, 1873, through the disappearance of Dr. William H. York, whose brother traced him as far as the Benders’ store. Unable to follow the trail beyond, the brother returned to the Benders’ place and there caught sight of something that had belonged to Dr. York. As a result of these aus picious circumstances an Investigation began, but measures were not taken, so far as Is known, to detain the Benders, who disappeared and never were heard of again. There was a rumor thnt the Kansas farmers of Labette county lynched them, but It Is wholly unsup ported by evidence and therefore Is almost certainly untrue. The crimes of the Benders were the wonder of a gen eration and the name of Kate Bender especially occupies a terrible eminence In the history of crime. Yet If the evi dence In the Laporte affair Is not mod ified or In part belled the case of Mrs. Gunness Is more singular and horrific. The Benders had the moral (or Im moral ) support of one another—the ter rible relief which comes to those who share a fntal secret. Mrs. Gunness may have had an accomplice In Lamphere or another, but that has not yet been established, and It Is not Improbable that many If not most of her crimes were committed by her alone. In any event she achieved a terrible Immor tality, leaving a name at which the world may well grow pale. The possi bilities of the human soul seem Infinite <n evil as In good.

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A dying man named George E. Downer claims to have been part of a posse that caught and killed the Bender family father, mother, son, and daughter, a secret he kept for decades. The article revisits the 35-year-old mystery of the Benders' disappearance from their Kansas murder farm.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

Rock Island Argus · 24 August 1908 · page 6

FATE IS RELATED

Daughter Wtre'Shct. When the Bender family of Infamous memory fled thirty-five years ago from their Mood reeking shanty on a Kan sas prairie, their disappearance was 9 absolute as if they had been swallowed fy an earthquake. Time and again ru mors of how they escaped to foreign countries or that a sheriff and a United States marshal had annihilated them were circulated and discredited. Their ate was recently revealed lor the first time by a niau sick unto tleath, who for over thirty years lived the life of a respected and honored business man iu a Chicago suburb.

See moreSee less

The man who 'told the wonderful tory gave nothing from hearsay, noth ug from rumor or "reasoning." but his was the recital of an eyewitness, of a man who watched the fiends, who helped to organ lite the posse which pursued the fiendish murderers and was present, gun in haud. until Kate Bender, fighting to the last, pillaged.

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A dying Chicago suburb businessman, George Evans Downer, claims he was part of a posse that hunted down and killed the fleeing Bender family on the night of their escape, contradicting decades of belief that they vanished abroad. He says a vigilante pact of silence kept this secret for over thirty years until his terminal illness compelled him to confess.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 15 days earlier.

Rock Island Argus · 24 August 1908 · page 6

Bender, fighting to the last, pillaged. with a bullet In - her forehead, across the bodies of her mother, father and brother. George Evans Downer of Downer's

See the clipping