An Associated Press dispatch reports that a woman who died near Rio Vista, California, under the names Mrs. Cavin and Mrs. Peters was actually Kate Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family, based on a deathbed-style confession to a friend named Jack Collins. The account recounts her alleged escape route after the murders and her later life, including time as a nurse and eventually running a brothel.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Daily Sentinel · 5 May 1910 · page 1
LIVED UNDER ASSUMED NAMES [By Associated Press.) Rio Vista, Cal., May s.—That a woman who had lived here for nearly 30 years under the name of Mrs. Ca vin, and subsequently that of Mrs, Peters, and who died recently, was really Kate Bender, of the notorious Bender family of Kansas murderers, is the statement made by Jack Col lins, a resident of this place. The woman was found dead at her home near here last Monday evening, having died a week or ten days be fore from natural causes. She was 76 years old, and had been conduct ing a resort of ill repute for several years.
See moreSee less
Of late, however, she had been living alone. According to Oellins, who was a close friend of the woman, Mrs. Pe ters revealed her identity to him a number of years ago while critically ill and believing that she was at the point of death. Collins declares that the woman gave him a detailed ac count of the many murders which she and her brothers committed in the Bender home at Cherryvale, Kans.
A woman named Mrs. W. Peters died at Rio Vista, and locals speculated she was the notorious Kate Bender of the 1873 Kansas murders, allegedly having confessed this to a General Collins a decade earlier. However, Dr. Endicott, who knew her, denied any knowledge of such a confession or connection to the Benders.
The San Francisco Call · 5 May 1910 · page 3
DEATH ADDS TO BENDER MYSTERY
MARRIED SKA OPTAI.V About 30 years ago the woman came to Rio Vista, after having lived in San Francisco, where, jt J s said, she was employed as a nurse by Dr. C. C. O'Don nell. She married Captain John Gavin, a whaler and arctic sealer, but was separated from "him and resumed tlie name of Peters, which she said was her maiden name. . In Rjo Vista the woman kept a road house. Ten years ago: .she wa's taken seriously ill and it was then that she is alleged to have made her confession to General Collins.
See moreSee less
' . r The Bender murders were peculiarly atrocious crimes .and the, fato of the murderers has been a subject of con tinual speculation ever since the crimes were discovered. One story was to the effect that the four members .of : the Bender family were lynched at the scene of their outrages in : 1873. The Benders— father, mother; John, a son, and Kate, the daughter— ran a tavern -at Cherryvale, near Galena, Kan. The place was regarded with suspicion by the countryside. One day in June. 1873, Dr. Wiljiam York dis appeared after having been seen trav eling in the direction of. the'- Bender tavern. . : .: . Ivater a search was made of the Bender place and in the cellar the man's glasses were found. The search was continued and the bodies .of 12 victims were-found buried in the yard" Nothing definite was - learned of the Bender family after that..
A Dr. Endicott denies knowledge of any deathbed confession by a Mrs. Peters linking her to the Bender family, while the article recounts her life as a roadhouse keeper in Rio Vista who once married a sea captain. The report reviews the original 1873 Bender murders and the many unresolved rumors about the family's fate, including lynching claims and other identification attempts.
The San Francisco Call · 5 May 1910 · page 3
MARRIED SEA CAPTAIN
Woman in Murder Cases ? [Special Dispatch to The Call] niO VISTA. May 4.— Was Mrs. W. Pe ters, whose lifeless body was found to day In her dwelling on the river shore, the notorious Kate Bender, who. with her parents and brother, was implicated in June, 1873, at Cherryvale, Kan., in the murder of 12 men. Living alone and avoided in a dilap idated house the woman had few friends in her last days, but it 'is told today over her remains that 10 years ago. she confessed to General John Collins that she was Kate Bender.
See moreSee less
It is said that she admitted that her part in the horrors was to lure men to the Bender tavern. After the family crimes were discovered, the alleged con fession continued, Kate Bender escaped from the Kansas town, went to "Chi cago, then made her wayto the Atlantic seaboard and came to San Francisco in a sailing vessel around Cape Horn. Dr. R. H. Endicott, formerly of Rio Vista, now living in Oakdale, has "been mentioned as knowing the story of the woman's career. In a telephone inter view with a Call correspondent tonight Doctor Endicott said that he knew nothing of any confession that Mrs. Peters might have made and nothing that would . tend in any way to-con nect her witli the Bender family. .
A 1910 report claims Kate Bender, the last surviving member of the murderous Bender family, was found dead in Rio Vista, California, after living secretly for years under the name Mrs. Kate Peters. The story says her true identity was revealed only after an old employee, Happy Jack Collier, broke his silence.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Washington Times · 5 May 1910 · page 1
NOTORIOUS MURDERESS KATE BENDER IS DEAD
Old Employe. SAN FRANCISCO, May 5.—Kate Ben i der, the famous ax woman of the no torious Bender family, of Cherryvale, Kan., and the only member of that mur derous sextet to escape the vengeance that their numberiess crimes inspired, was found dead in her home at Rio
A San Francisco dispatch reports that a woman living under the name Katie Peters, who died in Rio Vista, California, was secretly Kate Bender, the notorious member of the murderous Bender family of Cherryvale, Kansas. The claim rests on a deathbed confession she allegedly made in 1899 to an employee named Happy Jack Collins, who only revealed it after her death in 1910.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Times · 5 May 1910 · page 1
Vista, Cal., Tuesday. Her body would doubtless have gone into the grave under the name which had shrouded the identity and early life of the foremost i.urderess in the crim inal annals of this country, had not arn old man, who has known her secret for eleven years, broken his silence today. Under the name of Mrs. Katha Peters, the murderess lived in a small white house on the Sacramento river, about a mile from the center of the village. For the last month she lived practical lv alone. A chance phrase dropped by “Happy Jack” Collins, who had been in Kate Bender's employ from 1889 to 139, re vealed the secret of the woman's ident ity.
See moreSee less
“One night In the winter of 1839 she called me into her bedroom,” said Col ling. “She had been ill for several weeks of pneumonia and it looked bad for her. “I am Kate Bender,” she said. “‘Af
A man named John Collins claims a woman he knew as Mrs. Gavin/Mrs. Peters was actually Kate Bender and confessed to him details of the Bender family murders before dying of natural causes. The report also includes a secondhand summary of the original Bender crimes near Cherryvale, Kansas in the 1870s.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Evening Times-Republican · 5 May 1910 · page 1
Resume of Bender Crimes. Kansas City, May 5.—It Is not known here how many murders tfhe Bender family committed In Kansas. They kept a store, which is believed, how' ever, to have been maintained only as a decoy for travelers. Kate Bender professed to be a magnetic healer. Her role was to make love to wayfar ers who sought shelter at the Bender homes, and lure them to a corner of the room where her brothers, concealed behind curtains would crush their skulls with clubs. Robbery was the motive of the crimes. After the family fled the bodies of nine victims were found on the Bender place.
A California newspaper reports that a woman known as Mrs. Gavin or Mrs. Petters, who ran a resort in Rio Vista, has died of natural causes and was allegedly Kate Bender of the infamous Bender murder family. The claim rests solely on deathbed confessions reportedly made to a local resident, John Collins, with no official confirmation.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Rock Island Argus · 5 May 1910 · page 1
Rio Vista, Cal., May 5. Kate Bender of the notorious family of Kansas murderers is dead here, ac cording to a statement made today by John Collins, a resident of this place. The woman, who was known as Mrs. Gavin and later as Mrs. Pet ters, was found dead in a resort she conducted. She died from natural causes. Collins declares the woman gave him detailed accounts of many murders she and her brothers com mitted near Cherryvale, Kan., In the 70's. Taylorvllle, III., Is Dar.k
A man named Jack Collins claims that a woman who died near Rio Vista, California, known as Mrs. Gavin and later Mrs. Peters, confessed to him years earlier that she was Kate Bender of the infamous Kansas murder family. He describes her alleged role luring victims to their deaths and her supposed escape route from Kansas to California via Chicago, New York, and Cape Horn.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Topeka State Journal · 5 May 1910 · page 1
KATE BENDER AGAIN
lytic stroke. Collins declares the woman gave him a detailed account of many murders which she and her brothers committed in the Bender home at Cherryvale, Kan. in the seventies. Her role, according to Collins, was to make love to the unfort unate wayfarers who sought shelter at the Bender house and lure them to a corner of a room, where her brothers. concealed tehind a curtain would crush their skulis with heavy clubs. Rob bery was the motive of the crimes. During the investigation of the mur ders by detectives, the woman escap ed to Chicago, afterward going to New York, and sailing from there around Cape Horn to San Francisco.
See moreSee less
There she became a trained nurse and married John Gavin, a whaler. Ten or 15 years later they were divorced and the wo man then began a life of shame. The dead woman was 76 years of age. A reward of $5,000 was at one time offer ed for the capture of Kate Bender. Story of the Benders.
The report recounts a dying woman's alleged confession that she was Kate Bender, describing her role luring victims while her brothers clubbed them to death at the family's Kansas inn. It also recaps the known facts of the Bender murders, including the discovery of nine bodies after Dr. York's disappearance led to the family's exposure.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
A California man named Jack Collins claims a recently deceased woman known as Mrs. Gavin/Mrs. Peters confessed to him years earlier that she was really Kate Bender of the murderous Bender family. A separate Kansas City item recaps the basic facts of the Bender case and the nine bodies found on their property.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Roswell Daily Record · 5 May 1910 · page 1
THE BENDERS Rio Vista. Calif.. May 5 That a woman who lWed here nearly thirty years under the names of Mrs. Gavin and Mrs. Peters, who recently died, waj really Kate Bender of the notor io.ts Bncbxfamily of Kansas murder ers, is tae statement made by Jack Collins, a resident of tais iplace. The womaa was found dead at her home near hep) last Monday. She had been conducting a resort of ill re pute for several years and lately had been living alone, according to Col lins a close friend of the woman.
See moreSee less
Collins says that Mrs. Peters re vealed her identity to htan several years ago while she believed she was on her death bed. Collins declares she gave him a derailed account of tae murders she and her brothers com TnJtted in the Bender home at Cher ryvale, Kansas, in the revenues. Dur ing tbe investigation of the murdora the woman escaped to Chicago, after wards going to New York and silling around the Horn to San Francisco. Taere she became a trained nurse, married John Garvin, a whaler, and ten or fifteen years later began a life of shame. The woman was 76 years of age. A reward of $5,0H) as at one lime offered far her capture. Kansas City. Mo., May 5. It is not known how many murders the notor ious Bender family committeed while .ivins; in Ijaliette county, Kansas, but afcr ti. v fled nine bodies (were found on tae place. The family con sisted cf William Bender, nged six ty; his wife, aged fity-flve; Kate, aged twenty-five and John aged twenty-three. Bender professed to be a magnetic healer. The Bender bouse was situat ed on the Main highway between In dependence. Kansas, and the Osage mission.' The Benders kept a little store, but it was said to be a decoy for neary travelers, more than any thing else. T.ie fate of tihe Bender family af ter their crimes were discovered has never been definitely known to this day. Some have said the entire fam ily wera kil'.ed by tihe pursuing posse, while others hive said that Kate es caped. o
A Rio Vista, California man claims a woman who died locally under aliases Mrs. Gavin and Mrs. Peters was actually Kate Bender, confessing her family's Kansas murders to him years earlier. The report recounts her supposed escape route after the killings and her later life, including nursing, marriage, and eventually running a brothel.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Santa Fe New Mexican · 5 May 1910 · page 1
MURDERED WEARY WAYFARERS
years ago, while believing that she . was on her death bed. Collins declar ed she gave him the details of the acpniiiit nf ihe manv murders which she anfl hep brothers commltted in the Bender home at Cherryvale, Kan., in the seventies. During the investiga tion of the murders, the woman escap-
A newspaper report claims a woman who died was Kate Bender, detailing her alleged escape to Chicago, then San Francisco, a career as a nurse, marriage to a whaler, and later a life of prostitution. The same article also restates the original Bender family crimes and admits their ultimate fate was never definitively known.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Santa Fe New Mexican · 5 May 1910 · page 1
MURDERED WEARY WAYFARERS
Committed Many Murders. Kansas City, Mo., May 5. It is not known how many murders the notor ious Bender family committed while living in Labette county, Kansas, but after they fled, nine bodies were found on the place. The family con sisted of William Bender, aged 60, his wife aged 55, Kate, aged 25 and John aged 23. Kate Bender professed to be a magnetic healer. The Bender house was situated on the main highj way between Independence, Kan., and Osage, Mo. The BendefT&ept a little store, but it was said to be decoy for weary travelers more than anything else The fate of the Bender family after thei.r crimes were discovered, never have been definitely known.
An Associated Press report claims a woman who died near Rio Vista, California, using aliases, was actually Kate Bender of the infamous Bender murder family. The identification comes from a man named Jack Collins who says the deceased, known as Mrs. Peters, confided her true identity to him years earlier.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Guthrie Daily Leader · 5 May 1910 · page 1
KATE BENDER DECLARED DEAD IN STATE OF CALIFORNIA HER LOVER EXPOSES ALLEGED IDENTITY
A Romanes of Death. The story of the Menders Is known to all old residents of both Kansas and Oklahoma, It was a story ol murder, the most foul and uncalled for of all Southwestern history. How man) people met death in that Ben der taVfB between the Santa Ko trail and the Indian territory Hue will never be known. A body of settlers, aroused because the brother or a prominent attorney had been slain there, went down and finished what few of te I lender family Wlls there the death was a sure one, but from that hour until now there has been a story afloat to effect that Kate Hen der either bad sscapod In advance or was spaVi-i by tin' lender hut rough settlers who rode thai night t() ascSl tain what became ot the numerous guests of the Bender tavern.
Decades after the Bender murders, this report recounts persistent rumors that Kate Bender escaped the vigilante killings or was spared, including a tale linking her to outlaw 'Jack' Wright. It reflects on how the gruesome Bender story has become legend across the Southwest.
A California man named Jack Collins claims that a woman who died locally under the names Mrs. Gavin and later Mrs. Peters was actually Kate Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family, having lived under an assumed identity for nearly thirty years. The woman reportedly ran a resort and died of natural causes, with Collins claiming she had confided her true identity to him years earlier.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Daily Ardmoreite · 5 May 1910 · page 1
DEATH CLAIMS KATE BENDER MEMBER OF NOTORIOUS FAMILY OF KANSAS MURDERERS IS DEAD IN CALIFORNIA. LIVED UNDER ASSUMED NAME!
Name of Gavin Conducted a Re-1 sort There For Many Years. Illo Vlstu. Culir.. .May 15. That the woman who lived here for near 1 thirty years under tho name of .Mrs. Gavin and suhseipiently Unit of Mrs. Peters, who died recently, was really Knto Bender of thu noto rious lJender family of Kaunas mur derers, Is tlio statement made by Jack Collins, a resident of this place. The woman was found dead In !i r home near hero last Monday even ing, hstvliiK died a week or ten days hoforo from natural causes. She had been conducting a resort here for several years, but lately had been llvliiK alone. According to Collins, a friend of the woman, Mrs. Potors revealed her Identity to him a number of years ago.
A resident of Rio Vista, California claims that a woman who died there recently, known locally as Mrs. Gavin and Mrs. Peters, confessed before believing she was dying that she was actually Kate Bender of the infamous Kansas murder family. He says she described the killings and her escape route after the crimes were discovered.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
El Paso Herald · 5 May 1910 · page 1
Rio Vista, Cal., May5. That a 'wo man who lived hero nearly 30 year under the names of Mrs. Gavin and Mrs. Peters, who died recently, was really Kate Bender, of the notorious Bender family of Kansas murderers,ls a state ment made by Jack Collins a resident of this place. ' Tho woman was found cead in her home near here last Monday. She had been conducting a rsort of ill repute for several years and lately had been living alone, according to Collins, a close friend of the woman. . Tells Story of Life. - ' Mrs. Peters revealed her identity xo him several years ago while believing she was on her death bed, Collinsyde
A 1910 Kansas City dispatch recounts the notorious Bender family of Labette County, Kansas, who ran a store/hotel used to lure and kill travelers before fleeing after nine bodies were found. It notes their final fate was never confirmed, with some claiming a posse killed them and others saying Kate escaped.
El Paso Herald · 5 May 1910 · page 1
History of Benders. Kansas City, Mo May 5. It is not known how many murders the notor ious. Bender family committed while livittsr in "LnBott roimtv. TCn-nsoc hn j ater they fled nine oodles were found yon the place. The family consisted of William Bender, aged 60; his wife, aged 55; Kate, aged 25, and John, aged 23. Kate Bender professed to be a mag netic lisaler. The Bender house was situated on the main highway between Independence, Kansas, and the Osage mission. The Benders kept a little store and hotel, but It waj said to be a decoy for weary travelers more than anything else.
See moreSee less
The fate of theBender family, after their crimes were discov ered, has never been definitely known. Some have said the entire family was killed by a pursuing posse. Others have said Kate escaped.
A special dispatch from San Francisco reports that Kate Bender, the last surviving member of the notorious Bender murder family of Cherryvale, Kansas, was found dead in her home at Rio Vista. The report states she had lived alone for months and may have died around April 18.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
San Antonio Light and Gazette · 5 May 1910 · page 11
Special Dispatch. San Francisco, May s.—Kate Bender, member of the famous Bender family of Cherryvale, Kansas,, and the only one who escaped vengeance for their numerous crimes, was found dead in her home at Rio Vista yesterday. It is sup posed she died about April 18. The wo man had lived practically alone for sev eral months and her death was discover ed accidentally.
A Rio Vista, California report claims a woman who died recently under the name Mrs. Peters was actually Kate Bender of the infamous Bender murder family, based on a deathbed confession she allegedly gave to a friend named Jack Collins. The account recounts the Bender family's methods of luring and murdering travelers in Kansas, and traces her supposed later life as a nurse, wife, divorcee, and finally a woman of ill repute.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Ogden Standard · 5 May 1910 · page 1
NOTORIOUS KATIE BENDER
But she recovered and fearing that Collins he says would make her con I fession known she offered another man 50 If lie would set fire to a houneboat in which Collins lay a vic tim of a paralytic stroke Collins declares the woman gave him a detailed account of many mur ders which she and her brothers com mitted In the Bender home at Cherry j vale Kas in the seventies Her role j according to Collins was to make love
The report recounts a dying woman's alleged confession to being Kate Bender, describing how she lured travelers to their deaths while her brothers hid behind a curtain to club them. It also recaps the original 1870s Bender murders in Kansas, including the discovery of nine bodies after Dr. York's disappearance led to the family's exposure.
The Ogden Standard · 5 May 1910 · page 1
KATE BENDER
tween Independence Kansas and the Osage mission Tho Benders kept a 1 little store supplied with food for man j and boast but It la paid to have been I a decoy for weary travelers rather than anything else The Benders lived in a frame house about twenty feet long and sixteen feet wideOne room was divided by I
A Rio Vista, California resident named Jack Collins claims that a woman who died locally under the names Mrs. Gavin and Mrs. Peters had confessed to him years earlier that she was actually Kate Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family. The report recounts her supposed escape route from Kansas through Chicago and New York, around Cape Horn to San Francisco, and her later life as a nurse and madam.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Laramie Republican · 5 May 1910 · page 1
MURDERED IN KANSAS WHOLESALE CRIMES RECALLED BY DEATH OF WOMAN NOW CLAIMED TO BE NOTORIOUS KATE BENDER.
Gave Account of Murders. Collins declared that she gave him a detailed account of the many mur ders she and her brothers committed in the Bender home at Cherryvale, Kas„ in the seventies.
A newspaper reports the death of a woman alleged to be Kate Bender, recounting her supposed escape via Cape Horn to San Francisco and later life as a nurse and prostitute. It also recaps the original Bender family murders in Kansas, noting nine bodies were found and that the family's ultimate fate was never definitively established.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Laramie Republican · 5 May 1910 · page 1
NINE BODIES FOUND.
Claimed to Be Healer. Kate Bender professed to be a mag netic healer. The Bender house was situated on the main highway be-t tween Independence, Kansas, and
A California man named John Collins claims a dying woman revealed herself to be Kate Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family, confessing details of killings committed at the Bender home in Cherryvale in the 1870s. The report recaps the family's method of luring travelers to their deaths.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Montgomery Advertiser · 6 May 1910 · page 1
NOTED MURDERESS DEAD KATE BENDER ENDS HER CAREER IN CALIFORNIA
vale, Kan.. In the seventlea. ——— V— Had Grlaly Kword. Kansas City. May 6--Itla not known how many murders the Notorious Ben der family committed while living In Kansas. Kate Bender professed to he A magic healer. Her role was to make love to the unfortunate wayfarers who sought shelter at the Bender house and lura them to a corner of a room where her brothers, concealed behind a curtain, would crush their skulls with heavy clubs
A satirical editorial comment notes that Kate Bender, of the notorious Bender murder family, is reported dead yet again, something that happens periodically. It sarcastically claims she was properly killed by a pursuing posse along with the rest of the family soon after their crimes, and jokes she should keep 'dying' for years to come.
Arizona Republican · 6 May 1910 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Kate Bender is dead again. That serves that inhuman female right for her horrible crimes which shocked the country almost a generation ago. She was properly killed by a pursuing posse with the rest of the Bender family soon after. She has died at irregular intervals ever since. She ought to die next year, and the year after, and so on, until her accumulated death agonies may be sufficient to expiate her bloody crimes.
A man named John Collins claims a woman who died in Rio Vista, California, confessed to him years earlier that she was Kate Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family. The report also recaps the known facts of the Bender family's crimes at Cherryvale, Kansas in the 1870s.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
New-York Tribune · 6 May 1910 · page 3
DEATH OF KATE BENDER
Maine, Massachusetts and San Francisco. { she and members of her family committad | in the Bender home at Cherrvvale, Kan. in the TNs. Kansas City. Mo.. May 5.—It is not how many murders the notorious known Bender family committed while ltving in
An unnamed woman reportedly gave a detailed account to authorities of murders committed by the Bender family at their Kansas homestead in the 1870s, prompting newspapers to recap the original case. The report reviews the family's methods—luring travelers with promises of lodging or healing, then killing them with an axe for robbery—and notes recurring rumors over decades that fugitive Kate Bender was still alive, including one theory linking her to murderess Belle Gunness.
New-York Tribune · 6 May 1910 · page 3
— John, twenty-three. Kate and John were Kate and John wer children of Bender by a former wife. The Benders kept a little store. which is believed to have been only a decoy for travellers. Kate Bender professed to be a magnetic healer. Her role was to make love to wayfarers who sought shelter at the Bender house. lure them to a bench besid= | a canvas partition, behind which her | brother concealed himself and crushed the vietim’s skull with an axe. Robbery was the motive of the crimes. The family fled as search was made of the premises.
See moreSee less
The bodies of nine victims were found on the place. The famil was pursued and some of the members were slain. but Kate, it was said, unbitched a horse from the wagon, ieaped astride its ! back and escaped. She has been reported in all parts of the country at various times since. The last previous attempt to place her was the rerort that she was identical with Mrs. Belle Gunness, who slew several men for money on her farm near laporte. Ind two vears aco
A report from Rio Vista, California states that a man named John Collins claims a woman he knew as Mrs. Gavin/Mrs. Peters was actually Kate Bender of the infamous Bender murder family, and that she confessed her identity to him before dying of natural causes. The report also notes from Kansas City that the true number of murders committed by the Bender family was never definitively known.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
The article retells the decades-old Bender murder story, describing Kate as a 'magnetic healer' who lured travelers to be killed by her brother John with an axe, with nine bodies found on the property. It recounts her legendary escape on horseback and links to a new rumor that she may be the same woman later known as serial killer Belle Gunness.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
A dispatch from Rio Vista, California claims that Kate Bender, the notorious Kansas murderess, has been found dead after running a resort there under the name Mrs. Eva Morse. A man named John Rollins says she confessed her identity and crimes to him before her death from natural causes.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
Evening Star · 6 May 1910 · page 14
Deputy Assistant Treasurer Glbsog Bender home at Cherayvale, Kan., in the * ,*111 participate, the visitors will retura seventies. She was the last of the l>enu their homes. tier family. ^ 4 ' t ' . ' ^ . i ' . /-a ^
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The report claims Kate Bender, the lone Bender family member to escape mob vengeance, has been found dead in Rio Vista, California after living under the name Katie Peters for decades. It says an old acquaintance only revealed her true identity after her April 18 death.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 6 May 1910 · page 8
MOST NOTORIOUS AXE-WOMAN DEAD
IS. A Chance Phrase. A chance phrase dropped by "Happy Jack" Collins,; who had been in Kate Bender's 'employ from 1899 to 1909. revealed the secret ? of Jhe woman's identity. - "One night in the" winter of ; 1899 she called me into her bedroom." said Collins. "She had been il! for several weeks of pneumoniaand it looked bad for her. . . ... My whole story is there, she said. "I am Kate Bender. After I learned that I was about to suffer for the terri ble murders we had committed and I could do nothing to save the other members of our family I changed my clothes and fled from the sod-house.
See moreSee less
I got away in the night and dashed to the railway station. I did not know where I was going to go. but when I arrived at the depot I found that a train would soon be along for Chicago. I bought a ticket and got aboard.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The report claims Kate Bender was living for years in California under the name Mrs. Katha Peters, and that her longtime servant 'Happy Jack' Collins revealed she had confessed her true identity to him on what she thought was her deathbed in 1899. It recounts her supposed flight from the Kansas sod-house after the murders and her new life of 'revelry' near Sacramento.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 6 May 1910 · page 8
KEPT FOR 11 YEARS
Under the name of Mrs. Katha Pet ers, the murderess lived in a smalt white house on the Sacramento river about a mile from the center of the village. She was twice married, her first husband, as she told it, being lost at sea and the second she divorc ed. Since then, her home has been house of revelry and strange acts. Her companions gone, Kate Bender lived practically alone for the past month. It was not remarked when she did not appear daily and no one thought it strange in -the last week that she had not been seen since April
A Lu Vista, California report claims a woman who died there under aliases Mrs. Gavin and Mrs. Peters was actually Kate Bender of the infamous Kansas murder family, based on a deathbed confession to a friend years earlier. The account describes her escape route after the murders and her later life as a nurse, wife, and madam.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The White Pine News · 6 May 1910 · page 1
NOTORIOUS KATE BENDER IS FOUND DEAD IN HER HOME
AFRICA. Mr*. Peter* revealed her Identity to him a number of years ago while critically ill and believing that she was at the point of death. Collins declares the woman gave him a de tailed account of many murders which she and her brothers commit ted in the Bender home at Cherryval, Kansas, in the seventies. Robbery was tbe motive for the crimes. Dur ing the Investigation of the murders the woman escaped to Chicago, going later to New York, whence she sailed
A dispatch reports that a woman found dead in her home has been identified as Kate Bender, member of the notorious Kansas murder family, with a man named Collins claiming she revealed her identity to him years earlier. Collins also claims she had confided details of multiple murders committed with her brothers at Cherryvale, Kansas, in the 1870s.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
Tägliches Cincinnatier Volksblatt · 6 May 1910 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Officials in Rio Vista, California investigate a tip that a woman who died there at age 76 was Kate Bender of the notorious murdering family, with her trail previously traced to Denison, Texas before being lost. The report also recaps the original Bender crimes of 1872-73, claiming the family murdered travelers at their roadside inn in Kansas.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
El Paso Herald · 6 May 1910 · page 4
The last heard of the family thy were in Texas. Traced to Denison, they were there lost. Many suspects have been arrested since that time, but none have proved to be the right peo ple. Story of the Bender Crimes. The criminal annals of this country present no more blood ourdling and fearful record of crime than that of the unprovoked and mercilesij' brutal murders committed by tho Bender fam ily in Kansas. Old man Bender, hln wife, son John and daughter Kate lived in a little one story frame house, 16x24.
See moreSee less
A partition of muslin divided tho in terior into two rooms, the back part of which was used for a kitchen and m tho front part of which was kept a small stock of provisions and a small counter or bar, which was used for the nnrnnfi rf tiiTfrif anv nhnnpn tT"n.Volfr ' r7nji'iccrhv Into thfviT" fVhitrhps. whon they were brutally murdered by being struck in the back of the head with an ax or hatchet, plundered of whatever effects they chanced to have and their bodies buried In the little lot in the rear of the house until it became a veritable Golgotha. In Early Seventies.
This 1910 newspaper account recounts the Bender family's killings in 1872-73, describing how victims were lured into their house and struck from behind with an ax before being buried in the yard. It details the disappearance of Dr. William York, the search party led by his brother, and the eventual exhumation of multiple bodies after the Benders fled.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
El Paso Herald · 6 May 1910 · page 4
Family Frightened Aivay. About the first of May neighbors missed, the Benders and discovered the J rhJbZv aiscoverea tne JiiS IIT ZZ ?lZ ' tlf LtJ'Ll in ,peU3Jb thOUSht had ,literally starved to death, and, as
The report describes the discovery of the youngest victim's body still wearing its red hood and mittens, and recounts how the Bender family fled by wagon and rail to Indian Territory and then Texas. It details Detective Beers's efforts to track them, including a failed deal with an outlaw named McPherson and a near-capture near Grand River that fell through due to dry conditions hampering the cavalry.
El Paso Herald · 6 May 1910 · page 4
tion. Fled to Texai. V Bender's team was found at Gherryville, about 14 miles from their homestead, standing hitched to the wagon, and there could be no question but that they took passage on the Missouri, Kansas & Teras railroad, and stopped at a small station called Caddo, in Indian territory. They then went some 15 or 20 miles into the country and cameed there abouV two weeks. From this point they went about 75 miles west of Deni son, Texas, and lived there for some time in a log cabin.
See moreSee less
Deteotive Beers -as employed by the statfl of Kansas, and succeeded in se curing from one McPherson a proposi tion that he (McPherson) would deliver up the entire Bender family if governor Osborne would pardon him for crimes by reason of which he was a fugitive from justice in that section of the coun try, where outlaws and bandits ruled. a perfect terror to everyone. This the j governor could not do, as no assurance of good faith on McPherson's part could t
A Rio Vista, California report claims a woman who died recently under the names Mrs. Gavin and Mrs. Peters was actually Kate Bender of the infamous Kansas murder family, based on a deathbed confession to a friend named Jack Collins. The article also includes a recap of the original Bender family murders in Labette County, Kansas during the 1870s.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Salt Lake Tribune · 6 May 1910 · page 11
she and her brothers committed In tho Bender home at CherryiJlle, Kan., in the seventies. Pier role, according to Col lins, was to mako lovo to tho unfortunate wayfarers who sought shelter at the Ben der home, and lure them to a corner of a room, where her brothers, concealed be hind a curtain, would crush tholr skulls with heavy clubs. Robbery was the mo tlvo of the crimes. During tho investigation of the murders by detectives the woman escaped to Chi cago, after which she went to New York and sailed from there around Cape Horn to San Francisco.
See moreSee less
There sho became a trained nurse and married John Gavin, a whaler. Ten or fifteen years later thoy were divorced and the woman then be gan a life of shame. The dead woman was 76 years old. A reward of $5000 was at ono time offored for the capturo of Kate Bender.
This article describes the Bender family's killing method using a canvas partition, hammer blows, and throat-cutting, followed by robbery and disposal of bodies in a cellar. It notes that Dr. York's murder led to discovery of nine bodies, but the family's ultimate fate remains unknown, with conflicting claims about whether they were killed or escaped.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 6 May 1910 · page 11
WAS EXPERT AT MURDER KANSAS CITY. May 5. It Is not known how many murders the notorious Ben der family committed while living In the early seventies In Labette county. Kan sas. Tho family consisted of William Bender, GO years of ago; his wife, aged 55 years; Kate, 25 years old, and John. 23. Kato and John were children of William Bender by a former wife. Kato Bender professed to bo a mag netic healer. The Bender house was sit uated on tho main highway between In dependence, Kan., and the Osage mission.
See moreSee less
The Benders kept a little store supplied with food for man and beast, but It is Gald to have been a decoy for woary travelers rather than anything else. Tho Benders lived In a frame house about twenty feet long and sixteen feet wide. Tho ono room was divided by a canvas partition drawn tightly over up right scantlings, This partition was the death trap. The victim was decoyed to i a seat near the canvas. Kate, behind the canvas, would render the victim sense loss with a hammer. If tho blow was not fatal tho old man followed with blows on the temple. Then the throat was cut After tho body was robbed it-was thrown Into tho cellar through a "blind door." After the family fled nine bodies wero found on the place. The murder of Dr. York of Independ ence led to the undoing of the murder ers. His brother, A. M. York, of Fort Scott, Instituted a search and found tho nine bodies on the Bender place, Includ ing that of his brother. The fate of the Bender family, has never been definitely known. At vari ous times persons who havo claimed to have been members of a posse who pur sued tho family havo given out state ments. Some have said that tho entire family was killed. Others have stated that Kato escaped.
A woman using the names Mrs. Gavin and Mrs. Peters died in Rio Vista, California, and reportedly confessed on her deathbed to a friend that she was Kate Bender of the infamous Kansas murder family. The friend says she detailed the many murders committed by Kate and her brothers at the Bender home in Cherryvale, Kansas, in the 1870s.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Barre Daily Times · 7 May 1910 · page 3
FAMOUS MURDERESS DEAD. ' Kate Bender of Notorious Kansas Fam ily Went Under Alias. Rio YUta, Cab, May C Kate Bender, of the notorious family of Kansasmur
A report claims that a woman who died near Rio Vista, California, using aliases Mrs. Gavin and Mrs. Peters, was secretly Kate Bender of the infamous Kansas murder family. The account, based on deathbed confessions to an acquaintance named Jack Collins, describes her alleged role in luring victims to their deaths and her supposed escape route to California via Chicago, New York, and Cape Horn.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Wenatchee Daily World · 7 May 1910 · page 5
KATE BENDER DIED IN SOUTH
Told of Murders. Collins declares the woman gave him an account of many murders which she and her brothers commit ted in the Bender home at Cherry vale, Kan., in the '70s. Her role, according to Collins, was to make love to the unfortunate wayfarers who sought shelter at the Bender house and lure them to a corner of a room, where her brothers, con cealed behind a curtain, would crush their skulls with heavy clubs. Rob bery was the motive of the crimes. During the investigation of the murders by detectives the woman escaped to Chicago, afterward going to New York and sailing from there
A humor column mocks a newspaper's 'discovery' that Kate Bender died in California, noting she has 'died' some 700 times in 30 years without repeating a location. It compares this to the recurring false rumors of King Menelik's death.
Some brilliant newspaper man has just discovered that Kate Bender has died in California. During the past 30 years, Kate Bender has died about 700 times, and never twice in the same place. If she keeps -it up, it will bo come a habit with her. Remember the semi-annual demise of King Menelik by Abyssinia.
A San Francisco attorney, J. T. James, denounced as false the deathbed claim of a Rio Vista woman that she was Kate Bender of the infamous murder family. James instead asserted, based on another man's deathbed confession, that the entire Bender family had been killed by vigilantes near the Kansas-Indian Territory border.
Was Slain by Vigilantes SAN FRANCISCO, May 9.—Claim ing the ante-mortem statement of Mrs. John Gaven of Rio Vista, that she was Kate Bender, daughter of the notori ous family of murderers whose crimes near Cherryvale, Kan., startled the country in 1871-73, is untrue, J. T. James, a local attorney, declared today that tlio entire Bender family was killed by vigilantes when it was dis covered they were the perpetrators of the murders. James bases his statement on the deathbed confession of George Evans Downer of Downers, 111., who, when ho realized that he was about to die, acknowledged that he, with a number of others, had dealt summary justice to the Benders en the prairie near the state lino between Kansas and Indian territory.
A deathbed confession reported from Rio Vista, California claims a woman known as Mrs. Gavin/Mrs. Petters was actually Kate Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family. The informant says she described the family's method of luring travelers and clubbing them to death at their Cherryville, Kansas home.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Hopkinsville Kentuckian · 10 May 1910 · page 5
KATE BENDER IS DEAD
Rio Vista Cal May 5Kate Ben der of the notorious family of Kan sas murderers is dead here accord ing to a statement made today by John Collins a resident of this place The woman who was known as Mrs Gavin and later as Mrs Petters was found dead several days ago in her home Collins who was her friend said she revealed her identity to him several years ago exacting a promise that he should not tell anybody until after her death Collins declares I the woman gave him a detailed ac count of many murders which she and her brothers committed in the Bender home at Cherryville Kansas in the seventies It is not known how many mur ders the notorious Bender family committed while living in Kansas Kate Bender professed to be a magnetic healer Her role was to make love to the unfortunate way farers who sought shelter at the Bender house and lure them to a corner of a room where her brothers concealed behind a curtain would crush their skulls with heavy clubs
A brief news item reports that a woman believed to be Kate Bender, member of the notorious Bender murder family from Kansas, died at Rio Vista, California. The claim was one of many unverified Bender sightings and identifications that circulated for decades after the family's disappearance.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Yorkville Enquirer · 10 May 1910 · page 3
white miners and ninety negroes. This was the second mine disaster in Alabama within a period of two weeks, forty-live miners being killed In a gas explosion on April 20 Five persons were burned to death at Coulterville, III., Friday A woman, said to be the famous Kate Bender of the family of that name and notorious as a family of murderers in Kansas many years ago, died at Rio Vista. Cal., a few days ago New Orleans has a fund of $1,000,000 promised as a starter for the preliminary expenses of a world's fair to be held in that city in 1915, to celebrate the opening
A resident of Rio Vista, California named Jack Collins claims a woman who lived there for nearly 30 years under the names Mrs. Gavin and later Mrs. Peters was actually Kate Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family. Collins says the woman revealed her true identity to him years earlier while believing she was dying.
Abilene Weekly Reflector · 12 May 1910 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image
KATE BENDER DEAD ONCE MORE
This Time She Lived at Rio Vista, Cal., and Revealed Her Identity to a Friend.
See moreSee less
Rio Vista, Cal., May 6.—That a woman who lived here for nearly 30 years under the name of Mrs. Gavin and subsequently that of Mrs. Peters, who died recently, was really Kate Bender of the notorious Bender family of Kansas murderers, is a statement made by "Jack" Collins, a resident of this place.
According to Collins, a friend of the woman, Mrs. Peters revealed her identity to him a number of years ago while dangerously ill and believing she was dying.
The Port Gibson Reveille · Port Gibson, Miss. · and 1 other paper
A brief wire item reports that Kate Bender, described as a member of the notorious Kansas murder family, has died at Rio Vista, California. It offers no further detail or corroboration of her identity.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Port Gibson Reveille · 12 May 1910 · page 3
Mexican Cabinet. The body of Dr. Howard T. Rick etts, who died at Mexico City, was taken to Chicago. Kate Bender, member of the noto rious family of Kansas murderers, Rick was noto
A resident named Jack Collins claims a woman who died in Rio Vista, California, under the names Mrs. Gavin and later Mrs. Peters, was actually Kate Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family. Collins says she confessed her role in luring victims to their deaths at the Bender inn decades earlier before fleeing west and starting a new life.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Citizen-Republican · 12 May 1910 · page 3
WICKED WOMAN IS CALLED BY DEATH
,which she and her family committed |in the Bender home in Kansas early lin the '70s. Her role, according to Col jllns, was to make love to the unfor tunate wayfarers who sought shelter at the Bender house, and lure them (to a corner of a room, where her broth er, concealed behind a curtain would •crush their skulls with heavy clubs. .Robbery was the motive for the crimes. During the invewtigation of the mur ders by detectives the womnn escaped to Chicago, afterward going to New York and sailing from their around ,Cape Horn to San Francisco. There she became a trained tourse and mar ried John Gavin, a whaler. Ten or 15 years later they were divorced and the woman then began a life of shame.
A Rio Vista, California resident claims a woman who died recently under the name Mrs. Peters was actually Kate Bender of the infamous Kansas murder family, based on a deathbed confession she allegedly made years earlier. The report details her supposed escape route after the murders—fleeing to Chicago, then New York, and sailing to San Francisco where she became a nurse and later ran a brothel.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Idaho Republican · 13 May 1910 · page 3
NOTORIOUS KATE BENDER
ago, while critically ill and believing | that she was at the point of death. Collins declares the woman gave him •a detailed account of many murders which she and her brothers committ ed in the Bender home at Cljerryvale, Kansas, in the seventies. Robbery was the motive of the crimes. Dur ing an Investigation of the murders the woman escaped to Chicago, going later to New York, whence she sailed around Cape Horn to San Francisco.
A California man named Jack Collins claims that a woman who lived in Rio Vista for nearly 30 years under the names Mrs. Gavin and later Mrs. Peters was really Kate Bender of the infamous Kansas murder family. He says she confessed her true identity to him years earlier while believing she was dying.
The Chanute Times · 13 May 1910 · page 7
KATE BENDER DEAD ONCE MORE
Rio Vista, California. That a wom an who lived here for nearly 30 years under the name of Mrs. Gavin and sub sequently that of Mrs. Peters, who died recently, was really Kate Bender of the notorious Bender family of Kan sas murderers, is a statement made by "Jack" Collins, a resident of this place. According to Collins, friend of the woman, Mrs. Peters revealed her iden tity to him a number of years ago while dangerously ill and believing she was dying.
A roundup of global news items from May 1910 includes a brief note that Kate Bender, described as a member of the notorious Bender family of Kansas murderers, died at Rio Vista, California. The item appears as one line among dozens of unrelated world events in a daily news digest.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.
Wrong
The Jones County News · 13 May 1910 · page 6
| who died at Mexico City, was ! taken to Chicago. Kate Bender, member of the noto rtous family of Kansas murderers I died at Rio Vista, Cal. Over five hundred lives were lost In the earthquake In Costa Rica. The
A woman known as Mrs. Gavin died in Rio Vista, California, and it is now claimed she was actually Kate Bender of the notorious Bender family of Kansas murderers. The report presents this identification as an unverified claim rather than a confirmed fact.
The Commoner · 13 May 1910 · page 11
A woman known as Mrs. Gavin died at Rio Vista, Calif. It is now claimed that she was in fact Kate Bender of the notorious Bonder fam
A dispatch from Rio Vista, California reports that a woman known locally as Mrs. Gavin and later Mrs. Peters was found dead, with a friend named John Collins claiming she had confided years earlier that she was Kate Bender of the infamous Kansas murder family. The claim rests solely on Collins's private account of her deathbed-style confession, with no corroborating evidence presented.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Columbia Herald · 13 May 1910 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A brief item reports that yet another woman claiming to be the notorious Kate Bender of Cherryvale, Kansas, died at Rio Vista. The item wryly notes this is the ninth such reported death of someone claiming to be Kate Bender.
—Big Ben Empire. Another woman claiming her self to be the notorious Kate Bender, of Cherryvale, Kanass, died at Rio Vista one day this week. Miss Kate dies and comes to life nine times as often as the nine life cat.
The item jokes that Kate Bender has died yet again, noting sarcastically that this happens at irregular intervals ever since she was supposedly killed by a pursuing posse along with the rest of the Bender family. It mocks the repeated, unverified claims of her death decades after the Bender murders.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Winslow Mail · 14 May 1910 · page 2
I but Senator Bailey has given j it out that the statehood bill j i will be the next thing consid ered by the senate after the railroad bill is out of the way 1 a At last congress has“re j membered the Maine,’ the ._ United States battleship sunk in Havana harbor twelve years ago, precipitating the Spanish American war, The ves -0 sel is to be raised and the 4 bones of the marines who were victims of the disaster will be 0 i brought home and buried in Arlington.
See moreSee less
d! >f Kate Bender is dead again. >- That serves that inhuman fe -- male right for her horrible s crimes which shocked the tcountry almost a generation )f ago. She was properly killed l | the Department of Commerce and labor shall be utilized in mal ing the public schools throughout the entire country { more practica 1 ., mere adapta ble and more serviceable to to the country. That the fed - eral government should co operate with the state univer -8 sities, colleges and schools in ; supplying qualified teachers .land uniform text books is , surely desirable. According to the terms of the proposed measure, two millions of do!- ’ lars are to be given annually ito state colleges and normal for the purpose of educating teachers who can M .
A one-line wire dispatch states that Kate Bender, a member of the notorious Kansas murder family, has died at Rio Vista, California. No further detail or verification is given in the item.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1910 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The piece mocks newspapers for repeatedly reporting Kate Bender's death over the years since the Bender murders shocked the nation. It sarcastically claims she was already killed by a pursuing posse along with the rest of the Bender family, yet keeps 'dying' again periodically.
Kate Bender is dead again. That serves that inhuman fe male right for her horrible crimes which shocked the country almost a generation ago. She was properly killed by a pursuing pos3e with the rest of the Bender family soon after. She has died at irreeruar intervals ever since. She ought to die "next year, and the yer after," and so on, un til her accumulated death agonies may be sufficient to expiate her bloody crimes. No man pleases everybody, f he does he is weak kneed, carries water on both shoulders and won't tell the truth.
See moreSee less
But when a man don,t please you be man enough to go to him and talk with him rather -han talk on the streets and say things 3-ou would not say to bis face. Yes, the New York assem bly defeated the resolution to ratify the income tax amend ment, but let no reformer be discouraged. If it is defeated by only a narrow margin in New York, it ought to canry every other state and the mat ter can be brought again in New York when the demo cratic pa-ty is stronger. Winslow Notes
A California man named John Collins claims that a woman known as Mrs. Gavin, later Mrs. Peters, was actually Kate Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family. Collins says she confessed her identity and detailed the Bender murders to him years before her death, swearing him to secrecy until she died.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Penn's Grove Record · 20 May 1910 · page 1
Kate Bender Dead. Kate Bender, of the notorious fam ily of Kansas murderers, died, accord ing to John Collins, a resident of Bio Vista, Cal. The woman, who was known as Mrs. Gavin, and later as Mrs. Peters, was found dead in a re sort she conducted. Collins, who was her friend, said she revealed her iden tity to him several years ago, exact ing a promise that he should not tell anybody until after, her death. Col lins declares that she gave him a de tailed account of many murders which she and her brothers committed in the Bender home at Cherryvale, Kan., in the seventies.
A man named John Collins claims that a woman who died in Rio Vista, California, known as Mrs. Gavin and later Mrs. Peters, confessed to him years earlier that she was Kate Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family. He says she detailed the murders committed by her and her brothers at the Bender home in Cherryvale in the 1870s.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.
Wrong
The Morris County Chronicle · 24 May 1910 · page 2
Kate Bender Dead. Kate Bender, of the notorious fam ily of Kansas murderers, died, accord ing to John Collins, a resident of Rio Vista, Cal. The woman, who was known as Mrs. Gavin, and later as Mrs. Peters, was found dead in a re sort she conducted. Collins, who was her friend, said she revealed her iden tity to him several years ago exact