A newspaper recounts a story attributed to an old Black Hills scout, who claims a friend told him before dying that a vigilante party from Cherryvale found the Bender roadhouse abandoned, discovered blood and a trapdoor to a cellar, and then located fifteen buried bodies in the garden. The account implies the Bender family themselves were killed by this mob and that no further search for them is needed.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 55 days later.
Wrong
The Calhoun Chronicle · 8 October 1901 · page 6
LLo Bender family. When the York family was killed and the tragedy was traced to the home of the Benders, Pierce’s friend was among those from the city of Cherry vale who went out to Invest!- t gate the condition of things at the f 1 tender roadhouse. There were twenf ty four men in the party, one of the/ men being an old buffalo hunter. The# found the house deserted nml i# searching the house the bedstead W the west room, about which so maw has been said, was found to be full
An old-timer called "Doc" Pierce tells a story, kept secret for twenty years, of a posse tracking the fleeing Bender family to a creek camp and shooting all four dead, then burning the bodies with their wagon and belongings. The piece also notes unconfirmed rumors that Kate Bender later lived in Deadwood, South Dakota.
They agreed upou going back with the scout ami exterminating the entire family. The posse was divided Into three parts, and the Bender family was surrounded. One of the posse accidentally discharged his rifle before the proper time, which gave tin* warn ing of danger to the Bender people. They Immediately prepared for de fence. The buffalo hunter tired at long range at old man Bender and bit him in the back, killing him. Another volley from the posse and John and his mother fell dead. Kate was the last one to lie shot.
See moreSee less
The posse then went to the scene and piled the four dead bodies in n heup and burned them, adding to the Art* wagon, harness and the camp outfit. Everything that would not burn was taken to the creel: bank and covered over with dirt. This is the story that “Doc” Pierce tells for the first time since his friend confided the facts to him twenty years ago. The story that Kate Bender came to the Black Hills several years ago and made her residence in Dead wood, South Dakota, is not credited • there. A woman did go there about fifteen years ago that had some re semblance to the famous Kate, so some of the old-timers say.—New
Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa. · and 1 other paper
An old Black Hills scout, Pierce, recounts a story told to him by a now-dead friend about a Cherryvale posse that found fifteen bodies buried at the Bender homestead, then tracked and exterminated the entire Bender family at a creekside camp. The account is presented decades after the fact as finally settling the question of the Benders' fate.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 38 days later.
Wrong
Freeland Tribune · 25 October 1901 · page 2
Old Indian Soont Tells of the Killing • All the Murderers. E. T. I'leree, more familiarly known as "Dod" Pierce, one of the oldest and most reliable Indian scouts of the Black Hills, has given out a story about the Bcuder family, of Kansas, which seems to show that there Is no further need of rho authorities search ing for the family. Pierce Is a reliable man, and for the first time he tells what he knows of the case. He had a friend In the 70s, who was also well known In the Black Hill), arid before the friend died he related to Pierce tho Incidents relative to the killing of all the members of the Bender family.
See moreSee less
When the York family was killed nnd the tragedy was traced to the home of the Benders, Pierce's friend wns among those from tho city of Cherryvale who went out to Investi gate the condition of things at tbe Bender roadhousc. There were twen ty-four men In the party, one of the
"Doc" Pierce reportedly reveals, twenty years after hearing it, a secret account of a posse tracking the Bender family to a creekside camp and killing all four members in a gunfight. The bodies were allegedly burned along with their wagon and belongings, and the report also finds the cellar trapdoor and exhumes fifteen victims' bodies from the garden.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 38 days later.
Wrong
Freeland Tribune · 25 October 1901 · page 2
BENDER FAMILY FATE.
spot where the bodies had been burled. A wagon rod was used to probe tho ground for a 6oft place, and finally a spot wns found that was soft. After digging down a short wny the body of one of tbe York children wns found nnd the contortions of the face nnd body made It took as though the child had been burled alive. Ffteen bodies were found, Including that of a Texas eattjemnn jvho was supposed to have been shot In tho Vest room. Tho old Buffalo hunter had been looking around for the trail of tiia family.
See moreSee less
The trail of a wagon wns found nnd the buffalo hunter followed It up all day. About nightfall he camo upon the family, camped near a creek. The scout returned to the party of cherryvale men and reported his find. They agreed upon going back with the scout nnd exterminating tho entire family. The posse was divided Into three parts, nnd the Bender family was surrounded. One of the posse accidentally discharged his rifle before tbe proper time, which gave the warn ing of dnnger to the Bender people. They Immediately prepared for de fence. The buffalo hunter fired at long range at old man Bender and hit him In the bnck, killing him. Another volley from the posse and John nnd his mother fell dend. Kate was the last one to be shot. Tho posse then went to the scene and piled tho four dead bodies In a heap and burned them, adding to the fire wagon, harness and the camp outfit Everything that would not burn was taken to the creek bank and covered over with dirt. Tills Is tho story that "Doe" Pierce tells for the first time since his frlond confided tho facts to him twenty years ago. The story that Kate Bender came to tlio Black Hills several years ago nnd made her residence In Dead wood, South Dakota, Is not credited there. A woman dhl go there about fifteen years ago that had some re semblance to the famous Kate, so some of the old-tlmeri ay.—New York Sun.