As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

July 1901

60 articles

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

Labette County commissioners voted to withdraw the $2,000 reward for conviction of the Bender family murderers, originally offered February 2, 1875. The report notes the reward was never claimed despite some suspects being tried and acquitted, and mentions that Montgomery County and the State also had standing $2,000 rewards.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Topeka State Journal, 29 April 1899, The Wichita Daily Eagle, 30 April 1899.

The Butler Weekly Times · 4 July 1901 · page 1

Been Standing 20 Years. At the regular June iietin of the countv torninis(iorjen a motion was passed withdrawing the s2,.iO re ward offered for the ,-onvktion of the notorious Bender family of murder ers who operated in Oag towuehip. Labette county. Kan.. atout iniro years ago. The reward wa. offered FVr.ruary 2, 1875, and has nevr been claimed, although u?pects have ln trid and acquittd. Various reason have been a-u:ii-ed for the withdrawal of the reward at tM rime. It is reported that Montgomery countv has a andinr-ward of 2,000 for their conviction and that the State also has a standing r-ward of $2.000. Ex.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

With Labette County withdrawing its reward offer, two new claimants have come forward seeking the state's $2,500 Bender reward. Mrs. Josephine McCann claims she captured two Bender women in 1889, while Frank Ayer claims to have found the Benders in Colorado and even married Kate Bender there.

The Topeka State Journal · 9 July 1901 · page 4

WANT BENDER REWARD

Claim the $2,500. Rival claims for the state's reward of S2.500 for the arrest of the Benders, are lodged with Attorney General Godard as a result of the revival of interest by the withdrawal of the Laoette county reward a few days ago. Mrs. Josephine McCann, of Joplin.MO.

See the clipping

The Daily Sentinel · Grand Junction, Colo.

A Cherryvale report says cattleman Frank Ayers claims to have located the Bender murderers living under the name Baker in Colorado, and that he was once married to Kate Bender himself. The account traces her supposed movements through the Black Hills, Salt Lake, and Fort Collins before her brief marriage to Ayers ended in separation.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Daily Sentinel · 11 July 1901 · page 2

ABOUT THE BENDERS. Interest in the Famous Kansas Murderers Revived--AreThey Living in Colorado? Cherryvale, Kansas, July 10 Interest 1 in the Bender murders, now almost a generation old, is revived by the appear ance in this town of Frank Ayers, a cat tle man of Manhattan, Colorado, who not only say-i that ho has located the murder rs but that Knto Bender was once his wife. Ayres says that the family he suspects goes by the name of Baker in Colorado, and that he knew them first in the early 70s, when they appeared in the Black Hllie country, where they lived seven t“on years, almost starviug.

See moreSee less

May Bakor, whom, he sayp, answers '0 the description of Kate Bender, went to Salt Lake and married a woman who de serted her. She married agaiu and her second husband was sent to the peniten- ; tjary, Then Ayres says she married him ' on abort acquaintance at Manhattan, where be tiled a claim and built, a house for her. All went well, he sa yd, until they ' moved to the Baker horn > at Fort Col line. There trouble began to brew and it was not long until they were living apart.

See the clipping

The Black Hills Union · Rapid City, S.D.

Decades after the Bender murders, competing claimants seek Kansas's long-standing $2,000 reward by asserting they have located the family. Cattleman Frank Ayres claims he unknowingly married Kate Bender in Colorado and knows the whole family's whereabouts, while Frances McCann of Joplin renews her own earlier claim.

The Black Hills Union · 18 July 1901 · page 3

CLAIM BENDERS ARE LIVING IN COLORADO

Whole Tribe Is. Topeka, July 12.—Frances E. McCann of Joplin, Mo., lays claim to the re ward offered by the state in 1873 for the arrest of the notorious Benders, whose butcheries about that time shocked the world. Mrs. McCann, it seems, called on Attorney General God ard last fall on the subject for the first time. She is the same woman who, in November, 1889, caused to be arrested and brought to Kansas from Michigan two women, who, she alleged, were the women of the Bender family. They were held in custody until April, 1890, when they were discharged.

See moreSee less

Mrs. Mc Cann, in a letter to Attorney General Qodard yesterday, insists that she was right then and now renews her claim for the reward. Mrs. McCann's latest demand no doubt is caused by the claim of one Frank Ayers that he has found the Benders in Colorado. In April he ap peared in Labette county making tha claim and tried to induce the local au thorities to send for the persons he accused. He stayed uround Cherryvalc, near the scene of the crimes, and Os wego, tho county seat of Labette coun ty, until the county board withdrew the reward of $2,000. The reward of 52,000 offered by the state, however, still stands, and Mrs. McCann is Ayers' rival for it.

See the clipping

The Black Hills Union · Rapid City, S.D.

In 1901, nearly thirty years after the Bender murders, cattleman Frank Ayres claims he located the family living under the name Baker in Colorado and that he was once married to Kate Bender. He describes a bizarre tale of drugging, a mysterious assault, and being nursed back to health by the woman he believes is Kate Bender, while trying to get Kansas authorities to pursue the suspects for the reward money.

The Black Hills Union · 18 July 1901 · page 3

Cattleman Ayres Confident. Cherryvllle, aKs., July 12.—Interest in the Bender murders, now ulmost a gen eration old, Is revived by the appear ance in this town of Frank Ayres, a cattleman of Manhattan, Col., who not only declares that he has located the murderers, but that Kate Bender was once his wife. Ayres came here late in March .and has been here ever since trying to Induce the authorities of La bette county, where the murders occur red, to co-operate with him and bring the suspects to Kansas for trial. This town is in Montgomery county, adjoin ing Labette, where the murders were committed, but it was from here that the search of the murderers was insti tuted twenty-eight years ago, and since the most of the witnesses live here Ayres naturally came here to make his start.

See moreSee less

Ayres Bays that the family he sus pects goes by the name of Baker in Colorado, and that he first knew them in the early '70s when they appeared in the Black Hills country, where they lived seventeen years, almost starving. May Baker, who answers, he says, to the description of Kate Bender, went to Salt Lake City and married a Mor mon, who deserted her. She married again and her second husband was sent to the penitentiary. Then Ayres says she married him oil a short acquaint ance at Manhattan, Col., where he filed a claim and built a house for her. All went well, he says until they moved to the Baker home at Fort Collins. Orig inally John Baker, or John Bender, wag with them and afterward drifted back ,to Colorado, going to work in a livery stable at Boulder. More recently he 'has gone to Longmont, where he haa •charge.of a string of race horses.

See the clipping

The Black Hills Union · Rapid City, S.D.

A man named Ayres recounts being drugged and nearly murdered, nursed back to health by a woman he believes was Kate Bender, now living under the name Baker in Colorado. Multiple townsmen who traveled to Colorado believe they have identified the woman as Kate Bender, but authorities remain hesitant to seek extradition despite a standing $500 reward.

The Black Hills Union · 18 July 1901 · page 3

Tries to Interest Officers. Ayers has spent much of his time at Oswego, the county seat of Labette county, and for awhile he interested the county attorney, but that office has Bince weakened and now Ayers is work ng with the county commisisoners, /ho paid the expenses of the seven nen who went to Colorado to see the Alleged Benders. So far, however, no steps have been taken to obtain a requisition for the Bakers. The coun ty has been at so much expense to ap prehend suspected ones since the crime?

See moreSee less

occurred that the authorities are slow to act. Ayers went to see Governor Stanley in April and the governor told him that the reward of $500 a head for the Benders still stands. AyerB, how ever, can't move until the county com missioners give their consent, and since they have hesitated so long it is hardly probable that they will act. A Seputy sheriff of Jasper county, Mo., ivho had heard Ayers story, wants to take a hand in the matter and if the Labette county authorities refuse to act, he says he will make the trial on his own responsibility. The murders, so far as can be traced, accurred in the fall of 1872 and winter ind spring of 1873.*

See the clipping

The State Ledger · Topeka, Kan.

A Topeka dispatch reports Governor Stanley issued a requisition for members of the notorious Bender family, after a rancher named Frank Ayres accused a woman he married as his wife of being Kate Bender and attempting to poison and kill him near Fort Collins, Colorado. A deputy sheriff was dispatched to investigate, and several old acquaintances claimed to recognize the suspects from Kansas twenty-eight years earlier.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The State Ledger · 20 July 1901 · page 2

REQUISITION FOR BENDERS. Said to Have Been Found at Fort Collins, Colorado.

The farmers of the United States are getting wealtny. The banks are bulg ing with their money. Abandoned farms and farm mortgages are a thing of the past, and instead of paying from 6 to 10 per cent for money, our western farmers, after buying all the neces saries and luxuiies they want, have money to lend. The census returns giving the area of various states show that the one which has the largest amount of land under water is Florida, and the least, in proportion to size Wyoming. tion in the hands of E. L. Harto^fl deputy sheriff from Labette cpj and he left at once for Colorado, fl The supposed Benders have J

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A Kansas requisition was issued for a family near Fort Collins, Colorado, identified by several Labette County residents as the long-missing Bender family. The complaint came from a man named Frank Ayres, who claimed his wife, believed to be Kate Bender, had tried to poison him.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Topeka State Journal · 23 July 1901 · page 1

DECOYED TRAVELERS.

Colorado for the notorious Bender fam ily. The complaint Is made by Frank Ayres, a ranchman living near Ft. Col line, Colorado, who claims that he was married to a woman whom he now thinks Is Kate Bender. He claims that the woman gave him "knock out drops" some time last February In hopes of killing him. To avoid suspicion he was carried in an unconscious condi tion to a. nearby railroad track and left on the rails to be killed by passing trains. He was found by friends and rescued.

See moreSee less

He suspicioned bis wife and began working up the case against her. He found her family living near Ft. Collins and he had E. M. Dock, V. A. Monyhan and T. B. Smith from Cherry-vale, Labette county, Kansas, go to Ft. Collins and Identify "the family there as John Bender, alias Chas. Read, Kate Bender, alias Mrs. Chas. Read, John Bender, Jr., alias William Baker, Kate Bender, Jr.. alias May Grant, alias

See the clipping

In the story →

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A man who suspected his wife of poisoning him tracked her family to Fort Collins, Colorado, where three Kansas witnesses swore under oath that the group matched the long-sought Bender family under aliases. Kansas's governor authorized extradition papers for a deputy sheriff to pursue the case.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Topeka State Journal · 23 July 1901 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

GET THE BENDERS

Requisition For Notorious Kansas Murderers Issued.

See moreSee less

Have Been Identified Near Fort Collins, Colorado.

OFFICER ON THE WAY.

Will Bring the Bloody Family Back to Kansas.

Have a Record of at Least Eight Murders.

DECOYED TRAVELERS.

Were Killed While at Table in Farm House.

Crimes Committed 28 Years Ago and Family Disappeared.

Frank Ayers, Husband of Kate Bender, the Informant.

A requisition has been issued from the governor's office on the governor of Colorado for the notorious Bender family.

The complaint is made by Frank Ayres, a ranchman living near Ft. Colline, Colorado, who claims that he was married to a woman whom he now thinks is Kate Bender. He claims that the woman gave him "knock out drops" some time last February in hopes of killing him. To avoid suspicion he was carried in an unconscious condition to a nearby railroad track and left on the rails to be killed by passing trains. He was found by friends and rescued. He suspicioned his wife and began working up the case against her. He found her family living near Ft. Collins and he had E. M. Dock, V. A. Monyhan and T. B. Smith from Cherryvale, Labette county, Kansas, go to Ft. Collins and identify the family there as John Bender, alias Chas. Read, Kate Bender, alias Mrs. Chas. Read, John Bender, Jr., alias William Baker, Kate Bender, Jr., alias May Grant, alias May Ayres.

Governor Stanley placed the requisition in the hands of E. L. Barton, a deputy sheriff from Labette county, on Saturday, and he left at once for Colorado.

The supposed Benders have been identified by several persons who knew them 28 years ago in Kansas. Ayres claims that he was married to the Bender woman for 14 months prior to the attempt to poison him.

The following exhibits accompany the application for a requisition:

"We, the undersigned, E. M. Dock, V. A. Monyhan and T. B. Smith, each being duly sworn doth depose and say: That we have been residents of the state of Kansas and in and about the city of Cherryvale and Osage township, in the state of Kansas more than 30 years and that we have recently gone to Ft. Collins, Larimer county, Colorado, and other points in said state and have seen recently the four persons supposed to comprise and be the 'Benders' and have been made familiar with the history of the supposed family of 'Benders' so far as known and obtainable and from our remembrance of said family and the history thereof we are now convinced that they are the persons wanted in this county for a series of crimes and murders committed in this county some 28 years ago.

"We do further swear that we were neighbors and lived in the vicinity in which the 'Benders' lived, in this county and were acquainted with the 'Benders' during their residence in said county at said time; that from our acquaintance and judgment at this time and the history of the suspects we could not now be more certain of the identity than we are at this time, and we are convinced that they are the 'Benders' in our own minds. However there is some possibility that we may be in error of judgment at this time and we do not believe that it is possible for anyone to be conscientiously more certain than we now are from the limited opportunity and observation that we have had of said parties and we further believe that if said parties could be further observed and better opportunities afforded such as could be had and if the parties were in custody that the question of identity could be settled by us and other parties who knew them at that time in a very short space of time, and we further believe that the result would be their complete and satisfactory identification as the 'Bender' family and the parties who committed the crimes as above stated."

E. M. DOCK, V. A. MONYHAN, T. B. SMITH.

M. E. Sparks also visited Ft. Collins and makes a short affidavit to the effect that the women he saw in Colorado are the notorious "Bender" women. Frank Ayres makes affidavit to the killing of William York on the 25th of April, 1873, supposedly by the "Benders."

B. F. Deinst makes the following affidavit which accompanied the application for the requisition:

"B. F. Deinst of lawful age being first duly sworn deposes and says, I was well acquainted with John Bender, Sr., Kate Bender, Sr., John Bender, Jr., and Kate Bender, Jr., who lived in Labette county, Kansas, from the winter of 1870 to some time in the latter part of April, 1873. They moved to Labette county, Kansas, in the winter of 1870 and located on section No. 13, * * * and built a house thereon and cultivated a part of the land. I was well acquainted with the premises during that time and know that they had the exclusive control of it from the time they moved there in 1870 until they left in 1873. During the time they lived there a number of persons were missing and traced to that neighborhood, and at the time it was believed that they were murdered by someone. Finally, some time in April, 1873, one William H. York was missing and traced to the neighborhood of the Bender farm where he was last seen in his lifetime. A determined search was made for him and earnest inquiries were made at the Bender farm for him, and immediately thereafter the said John Bender, sr., Kate Bender, sr., John Bender, jr., and Kate Bender, jr., left their home and went to parts of the country unknown, without any cause except they believed they were suspected of being the murderers of said William H. York; and after they left were not heard of or found, although diligent search and inquiry was made for them at the time. When they left, they left some stock which had broken out and was at large, and a calf which apparently had starved to death as it was almost eaten up by hogs, also a team of horses at Thayer, where it was reported that they had taken a north-bound train. They also left some household goods and grain. After they had left, and on about the 6th or 7th of May, 1873, in company with a number of others I helped to dig up a number of dead bodies upon the farm on which the Benders had resided. The graves were from four to ten rods south and southeast of the house, the nearest one to the house being the one in which we found the body of William H. York. The marks of the graves were hidden by the ground being frequently plowed over and the subsoil removed or hidden. We found one body which was identified as the body of York. The only clothes we found upon the body of York was an undershirt, and it was found in the grave face down. On the head of the body of said William H. York was a dent or wound which was a smashed or broken place in the skull, and which said wound was the cause of his death. I was present at the coroner's inquest and heard the evidence of one E. York, and know the body which he testified was the body of Wm. H. York was the same body we had dug up near the Bender house, as hereinbefore set out.

B. F. DIENST."

At the time of the murder the state of Kansas offered a reward of $500 apiece for the "conviction of the murderers of York." The reward has been outlawed, but Governor Stanley says that if the "Benders" are convicted of the crime he will pay the reward.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Witnesses who had known the Bender family in Labette County swear affidavits asserting their confidence that women and men located in Colorado are the notorious Benders, while acknowledging some possibility of error. The affidavits, including one from B. F. Deinst detailing the Benders' residence and the disappearance of William York, were submitted to support a requisition for custody of the suspects.

The Topeka State Journal · 23 July 1901 · page 1

K. M. IM1CK. V. A. MONYHAN. T. B. SMITH. M. E. Sparks also visited Ft. Collins and makes a short affidavit to the effect that the women he saw in Colorado are the notorious "Bender" women Frank Ayres makes affidavit to the kiilin of William York on the 2"th of Aprif 1873, supposedly by the "Benders" B. F. Deinst makes the following affi davit which accompanied the applica tion for the requisition: "B. F. Deinst of lawful age being first duly sworn deposes and says I was well acquainted with John Bender Br..

See moreSee less

Kate Bender, Sr., John Bender Jr ' and Kate Bender, Jr., who lived in La bette county. Kansas, from the winter of 1870 to some time In the latter part of April, 1S73. They moved to Labette county, Kansas, In the winter of 1S70 and located on section No. 13 and built a house thereon and cultivated a part of the land I was well acquainted with the premises during that time and know that they had the exclusive ontrol of it from the time thev moved there In 1S70 until thev left' in 18r During the time they lived there 'a number of persons were missing and traced to that neighborhood, and at the time It was believed that thev were murdered by someone. Finally, some time in April, 1S7J. one William H York was missing and traced to the neighborhood of the Bender farm where e was last seen in his lifetime A de

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Four people believed to be the Bender family, accused of the Galena murders decades earlier, have been located near Fort Collins, Colorado, prompting Kansas Governor Stanley to issue extradition papers. The identification stemmed from a man named Frank Ayers claiming one of the women was his former wife, Kate Bender, and affidavits from men sent to verify the suspects.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The San Francisco Call · 24 July 1901 · page 1

BENDER FAMILY MAY ANSWER FOR MANY MURDERS

Colorado. " TOPEKA, Kans., July 23.— Four persons said to be members of the notorious Ben-* der family, accused of committing a score of murders at their home near Galena, Kans., over a score years ago, have been located near Fort Collins, Colo., and Gov ernor Stanley has Issued requisition pa pers on the Governor of Colorado for their return to this State. The first steps to ward bringing the suspects to Kansas were taken upon the representations of Frank Ayers of Fort Collins, who asserts that one of the quartet, Kate Bender, was once his wife.

See moreSee less

Governor Stanley issued the requisition upon affidavits of four men who went to Colorado especially to iden tify the suspects. . The Benders committed a series of the most atrocious crimes ever recorded. They lived on a small farm near. Galena and for years, as it developed after their flight, they had lured travelers and buried their bodies In the' yard around their home or under the house. All four mem bers of the family were accused of aid ing In the murders. The family consisted of man, wife, daughter and son. The parents would now be in the seventies and the children about 60 years of age. •..¦'.

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

Kansas authorities report four people believed to be the Bender family have been located near Fort Collins, Colorado, with the governor issuing extradition papers based on claims from a man who says one suspect was his wife, Kate Bender. The article recaps the original Bender murders near Galena, Kansas, twenty years earlier.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Rock Island Argus · 24 July 1901 · page 1

BENDERS ARE FOUND AGAIN. Gang of Degenerate YVhkh Committed Many Nunlrrt e,r iinleua. Kin. 9 Topcka. Kmi.. July 21. Four per sons." believed to be members of the notorious Bender family, accused of committing a score of murder at their home near Galena. Kan., twenty year ago. are believed to have been located near Fort Collius. Colo., and Governor Stanley has isued requisition papers on the governor of Colorado for their return to this state. The first steps toward bringing the suspects to Kan sas were taken utxm the renreentations of Frank Ayres.

See moreSee less

of Fort Collins, who asserts that one of the quartette Kate Bender was once his wife. Coventor Stanley issued the requisi tion upon affidavits of four men who went to Colorado especially to Iden tify the snsiMM-t. I he Benders committed a series of th nio-f atrocious crimes ever record ed. They lived on a small farm near Galena, and for years as it developed tfler their flight had lured travelers to their place, murdered them for Iheir money and buried their iKxIles in the yard around their home or under the house. The house waJ arranged with trap doors. .Ml four members of the family were accused of aiding In the murders. ,

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A Colorado woman, Mrs. Frank Ayers, is identified by an old acquaintance as the notorious Kate Bender, with detectives watching her and claims she assaulted her husband. The report also notes a conflicting claim from a Dr. Agnes McKee Wallace that the Benders were in fact killed long ago.

The Topeka State Journal · 24 July 1901 · page 1

MARRIED SEVEN

Benders Were Killed. Fort Collins, Colo., July 24 Mrs. Frank Ayers, who, according to the statement of her husband, Frank Ayers, Is the notorious Kate Bender, is living at Fort Collins with her mother and stepfather, Mr. and Mrs. Reed. Detectives have been watching them for several weeks, but no steps have been taken here looking toward their arrest. The woman was married to Ayers about three years ago, and they lived at Manhattan, a mining camp, 45 miles west of here. Mrs. Ayers used to help Ayers chop wood and haul lumber to this city.

See moreSee less

A short time after their marriage a family of tramp emigrants came through this section. They stopped at Manhattan. Their names were Maddox, and they said they came from Kansas. Mrs. Maddox one day saw Mrs. Ayers, and exclaimed: ' That is Kate Bender." Mrs. Maddox claimed that she had known the Benders when they lived in Kansas, and the identity

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A Fort Collins woman, Mrs. Frank Ayers, is identified by an old acquaintance as Kate Bender, with details of her many marriages, her husband's accusations, and an alleged beating of him. Colorado authorities note that Kansas has sought requisition papers for her extradition, though they had not yet arrived.

The Topeka State Journal · 24 July 1901 · page 1

CAREER IN COLORADO.

was discharged. Nothing more was heard of him in this part of the country until the re cent dispatch from Cherryvale, Kas. Since the publication of that dispatch Mrs. Ayers and the Reeds have been considerably worried. Mrs. Ayers has strenuously denied Frank Ayers' statement, and says that if she Is arrested she will send'for one of her former husbands, a Mormon, named Grant, who lives ln Salt Lake City. She states that she came across the plains with her parents when she was but 4 years old, and she is over 50 years old now.

See moreSee less

She admits that they went to the Black Hills and afterward to Salt Lake, which points coincide with those made by Ayers in his state ment in Cherryvale. Mrs. Ayers and the Reeds have been In this part of the country for ten or fifteen years. Mrs. Ayers, it is said, has been mar ried seven times and her divorced hus bands are all living. Twelve years ago she was married to a sawmill hand named Lavin ln this city. Lavin soon left her. She was married afterward to Charles Lamont, who was later con victed of criminal assault, then to Frank Ayers.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A dispatch reports that Kansas Governor Stanley has requested extradition of Mrs. Frank Ayers, her mother 'Mrs. Reed,' and Will Baker from Colorado, alleging they are Kate Bender, Ma Bender, and young Bender. The account details how a chance encounter with a Kansas family led to suspicions, while Mrs. Ayers denies the charge and plans to prove an alibi.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Topeka State Journal · 24 July 1901 · page 1

REQUISITION HASN'T ARRIVED.

face with Mrs. Ayers: "Why, you're Kate Bender." The exclamation was made ln the presence of Ayres, who later went to Kansas, disguising himself as a wo man so that his wife could not trace him and at Cherryvale told the officers of his suspicions regarding his wife's family. He declares that Mrs. Reed is in reality Mrs. Bender and that she has separated from her husband, who is living in Utah, and that Will Baker is young Bender. Mrs. Ayres denies that she Is Kate Bender and declares that she will prove an alibi.

See moreSee less

She is about 50 years of age. It is said that Edward L. Burton, a lawyer of Oswego, Kan., together with an old resident of Galena, who knew the Benders, are at present in Ft. Col lins for the purpose of making a posi tive identification of the persons sus pected. Governor Orman Is out of the city but his private secretary says that the requisition papers mentioned In the To peka dispatch have not yet been re

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Kansas authorities report that four people believed to be the Bender family, accused of murdering numerous travelers near Galena twenty years earlier, have been located near Fort Collins, Colorado based on a man's claim that one of them was his wife, Kate Bender. Governor Stanley has issued extradition papers to bring the suspects back to Kansas.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Portland Daily Press · 24 July 1901 · page 2

General Knox Is now preparing the proc lamations which will be issued. Two proclamations will be iesued, the first declaring the establishment of civil government In Porto Rico and the sec ond the establishment of free trade be tween the United States and the island of Porto Rico. COMMITTED SCORE OF MURDERS. Topeka, Kos., July 23.—Four persons believed to be members of the Bender family, accused of committing a score of murders at their home near Galenna, Kas., twenty years ago, ate believed to have been located near Fort Collins, Colorado, and Gov.

See moreSee less

Stanley, has issned requisition papers on the governor of Colorado for their return to his state. The llrst steps towards bringing the sus pects to Kansas were taken upon the rep resentations cf Frank Ayres of Fort Collins, who asserts that one of the quar tette. Kate Bender, was once his wife. The Bende t lived on a small farm near Galna, and for years had lurid travelers to their place, murdered them for their money and buried their todies. An in vest’gatlon into tQe disappearance of a man who had stopped at the Benders,

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

Kansas authorities believe they have located four members of the Bender family near Fort Collins, Colorado, twenty years after the family's murders near Galena were discovered. Governor Stanley has issued requisition papers for their extradition based on a man's claim that one of the women, Kate Bender, was once his wife.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Saint Paul Globe · 24 July 1901 · page 3

~«M_ GUILTY OF MANY MURDERS. Bender Family Believed to Have Been Located in Colorado. TOPEKA, Kan., July 23—Four persons, believed to be members of the notorious Bender family, accused of committing a

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

Authorities in Colorado have identified a Mrs. Frank Ayres, living near Fort Collins, as possibly being Kate Bender of the notorious Bender family, prompting extradition papers from Kansas. Mrs. Ayres denies the identification and says she will prove an alibi.

The Minneapolis Journal · 24 July 1901 · page 1

IS IT KATE BENDER?

Frank Ayres and her father, known as Mrs. Reed in Fort Collins, where they re side, and Will Baker of Longmont. Mrs. Ayres formerly was the wife of Charles Lamont, who is serving a fourteen-year term In prison for criminal assault. After she secured a divorce from Lamont she married Frank Ayres and they lived on adjoining ranches near Manhattan, a min ing camp forty miles from Fort Collins. Two years ago a family from Kansas aamed Maddox, going through that por tion of Cokrado in prairie schooners, camped at Ayres' place.

See moreSee less

Mrs. Maddox is said to have exclaimed on coming face to face with Mrs. Bayres: "Why you are Kate Bender!" Ayres later went to Cherryvale, Kan., where he told the officers of his suspicion regarding his wife's family. Mrs. Ayres denies that she is Kate Bender and declares that she will prove an alibi. She is about 50 years of age.

See the clipping

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

Kansas Governor Stanley issued requisition papers to extradite four persons believed to be the Bender family from near Fort Collins, Colorado, based on identification by a man claiming to have married Kate Bender. The report recaps the original crimes: a family of four who murdered travelers at their Kansas farm using trapdoors, fleeing after a body was discovered beneath their house.

The St. Louis Republic · 24 July 1901 · page 14

BENDER FAMILY SAID TO BE ALIVE.

About 5,000 people were In attendance, de spite the torrid weather. . , A " ?3m-& &vj&?frg.-r-?iz-,&. i&W.r them for their money, and burled their bodies in the yard around their home or un der the house. The house was arranged with trapdoors. All four members of the family were accused of aiding in the mur ders. An investigation Into the disappear ance of a man who had stopped at the Benders and whose bones were found be neath the houao led to the flight one night. A heavy reward for their arrest was offered by the State, but 'they were never found.

See the clipping

The Butte Inter Mountain · Butte, Mont.

Four people believed to be the long-sought Bender family, infamous for a series of murders near Galena, Kansas, have reportedly been located near Fort Collins, Colorado. Governor Stanley has issued requisition papers for their arrest and return based on affidavits from men sent to identify them, including a man claiming to have once been married to Kate Bender.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Butte Inter Mountain · 24 July 1901 · page 1

IN THE TRAP. FOUR MEMBERS OF THE MURDEROUS BENDER FAMILY LOCATED IN COLORADO. GOVERNOR OF KANSAS ISSUES REQUISITIONS FOR THEIR ARREST AND RETURN.

i score of murders at their home near Galena, Kan., over 15 years ago, have ueen located near Fort Collis, Col., and dovernor Stanley has issued requisition papers on the governor of Colorado for their return to this state. The first steps toward bringing the suspects to Kansas were taken upon the representations of Frank Ayers of Fort Collins, who asserts that one of the quartette, Kate Bender, was once his wife. Governor Stanley issued the requisition upon affidavits of four men who went to Colorado to identify the parties. The Benders committed a series of the most atrocious crimes ever recorded.

See moreSee less

They lived on a small farm near Galena, and for years, as it developed after their flight, they had killed travelers and burled their bodies in the yard around their home, or under the house. All four members of the family were accused of aiding in the murders. The family consisted of man, wife, daughter and son. The parents would now be in the 70's and the children about 50 years of age.

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

Kansas Governor Stanley issued requisition papers to Colorado's governor for four people believed to be the Bender family, located near Fort Collins and accused of the notorious murders near Galena, Kansas two decades earlier. The identification came from affidavits by men sent to Colorado, including a man claiming to have once been married to Kate Bender.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Beatrice Daily Express · 24 July 1901 · page 1

Coventor of Kama* I (sues Requisition for Four 8uspects In Colorado. Topeka, July 24.—Four persons, be lieved to be members of the notorious Bender family, accused of committing a score of murders at their home near Galena, Kan, 20 years ago, are be lieved to have been located near Fort Collins, Colo, and Governor Stanley has issued requisition papers on the governor of Colorado tor their return to this state. The first steps towards bringing the suspects to Kansas were taken upon the representations of Frank Ayres of Fort Collins, who as serts that one of the quartette, Kate Bender, was once his wife.

See moreSee less

Governor Stanley issued the requisition upon affidavits of four men who went to Colorado especially to identify the sus pects. The Benders committed a series , of the most atrocious crimes ever record ed. They lived on a small farm near Galena and for years, as it developed after their flight, had lured travelers to their place, murdered them for their money and buried their bodies in the yard around their home or under the house. The home was arranged with trap doors. AU four members of the family were accused of aiding in the murders. An investigation into the disappearance of a man who had stopped at the Benders, and whose bones were found beneath the house,

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The Kansas City Journal reports that Labette County commissioners withdrew their long-standing reward for the Bender family's capture at their last meeting. The article recounts that despite numerous arrests and investigations over the years following the family's 1870s flight, none were confirmed as the actual killers, though a persistent rumor held that a vigilante committee had tracked and executed them in Indian Territory.

The Salt Lake Herald · 24 July 1901 · page 2

Bender Reward Offer Withdrawn

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The article reviews the various rewards offered for the capture of the Bender family, including state offers and private rewards from Colonel A.M. York and Labette County commissioners, noting these remain unclaimed decades after the family's disappearance. It argues that the popular belief that a vigilante committee had secretly caught and executed the Benders in Indian Territory is likely false, since such an act would have earned praise rather than condemnation, making the prolonged secrecy implausible.

The Salt Lake Herald · 24 July 1901 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Labette county commissioners offer a $680 reward for proof that the Bender family was captured by vigilantes and put to death. The report also corrects exaggerated claims that the Benders killed 37 people, noting that careful search only ever revealed seven bodies—three in the cellar and four in the yard.

The Salt Lake Herald · 24 July 1901 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Kansas Governor Stanley issued requisition papers for Mrs. Frank Ayres and her mother Mrs. Reed of Fort Collins, alleged to be Kate Bender and her mother of the notorious Bender family. The identification stemmed from an encounter with a Kansas family who recognized Mrs. Ayres, with her husband later disguising himself to flee and inform Kansas authorities of his suspicions.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The San Francisco Call · 25 July 1901 · page 3

on coming face to face with Mrs. Ayres: "Why. you're Kate Bender!" The exclamation was made in the pres ence or Ayres. who later went to Kansas, disguising himself as a woman, so that his wife could not trace him. and at Cher ryvale told the officers of his suspicions regarding his wife's family. He declares that Mrs. Reed is in reality Mrs. Bender and that she has separated from her hus-

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A report describes efforts to identify a woman named Mrs. Ayres as the fugitive Kate Bender, which she denies, promising an alibi. A lawyer from Kansas and an old Galena resident who knew the Benders are traveling to Fort Collins to attempt positive identification, while extradition papers have not yet reached the Governor.

CorrectionThis set right 5 earlier articles: Rock Island Argus, 24 July 1901, The Portland Daily Press, 24 July 1901, The Saint Paul Globe, 24 July 1901, The Butte Inter Mountain, 24 July 1901, The Beatrice Daily Express, 24 July 1901.

The San Francisco Call · 25 July 1901 · page 3

be fcr the control of Southern California. Senator Flint spent most of to-day in band, who Is living In Utah, and that "Will Baker Is young Bender. Mrs. Ayres denies that she Is Kate Bender, and declares that she will prove an alibi. She Is about 50 years old. It is said that Edward L. Burton, a lawyer of Oswego, Kan., together with an old resi dent of Galena, who knew the Benders, are at present in Fort Collins for the pur pose of making a positive identification of the persons suspected if possible. Governor Orman is out' of the city,' but his private secretary says that the requi sition papers mentioned in the Topeka dispatch have not yet been received.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Kansas Governor Stanley requested Colorado's governor to extradite four people believed to be members of the notorious Bender family, allegedly located near Fort Collins. The identification stemmed from Frank Ayres, who claimed one suspect was his former wife, Kate Bender, with affidavits from men sent to verify the suspects.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Paper unidentified · 25 July 1901 · page 6

REQUISITION FOR BENDERS

Executive to Turn Over Farnous Murder Family. '1 opeka, Ivan., July 2i.--Four pei^sohs, ijelieve»l to be members of the notorious fiender family, accused of committing" a score of murders at their home near Galena, Kan., twenty yeai's ago, are believed to have been located near Kort 'ollins, t'olo, «o»vernor Stanley has issued requisi tion papers on tne governor of Colo rado for their return to this state. The lirst steps towards bringing the sus pects to Kansas were taken upon the representations of Frank Ayres, of Fort Collins, who asserts that one of the quartet, Kate Bender, was once his wife.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Kansas Governor Stanley seeks extradition of Colorado residents Mrs. Ayres, her mother (Mrs. Reed), and Will Baker, alleged to be Kate Bender and other Bender family members in hiding. The identification stems from a chance encounter with a Kansas family who recognized Mrs. Ayres as Kate Bender, though Mrs. Ayres denies this and claims she can prove an alibi.

The Indianapolis Journal · 25 July 1901 · page 6

KNOWN AS "AYRES" AND "BAKER."

Ayres and they lived in adjoining ranches near Manhattan, a mining camp forty miles from Fort Collins. Two years ago a family from Kansas named Maddox go ing through that portion of Colorado in prairie schooners, camped at Ayres's place. Mrs. Maddox is said to have exclaimed on coming face to face with Mrs. Ayres: "Why, you're Kate Bender." The exclamation was made in the pres ence of Ayres, who later went to Kansas, disguising himself as a woman, so that his wife could not tiace him, and at Cherry vale told the officers of his suspicions re garding his wife's family.

See moreSee less

He declares that Mrs. Reed is in reality Mrs. Bender and that she ha3 separated from her husnana, who is living in Ctah. and that Will Baker is young Bender. Mrs. Ayres denies that she is Kate Bender and declares she will prove an alibi. She is about fifty years of age. Governor Orman is out of the city, but his private secretary says the requisi tion raoers mentioned in the Topeka dis patch have not yet been received. The Benders were squatters on iana in the western part of Labett county, Kansas, which was claimed by rival railway com panies. The family lived apart from their neighbors, and consisted of one old man, his wife and a son and daughter Kate. They kept a wavside inn. with a saloon at tachment, ten miles west ot Gaiesnurg. Here travelers often put up for tho night. and it was usually the case that they took lodging for eternity. At any rate, the doom of travelers was sealed the momen" they crossed the Benders' threshold, and so nu

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A man who fled disguised as a woman tells Kansas officers he believes Mrs. Reed is actually Kate Bender and Will Baker is young Bender, though Mrs. Ayres denies being Kate Bender and vows to prove an alibi. The report recaps the original Bender family's murderous inn near Cherryvale, including the killing of Dr. William York that triggered their exposure and flight in 1873.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Indianapolis Journal · 25 July 1901 · page 6

"AYRES" AND BAKER.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

A dispatch claims persons alleged to be members of the Bender family have been located in Colorado, identified as Mrs. Frank Ayres, her mother, and Will Baker, based on an accusation from a woman named Mrs. Maddox. Governor Stanley of Kansas is said to have issued requisition papers, though Mrs. Ayres denies the identification and plans to prove an alibi.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening Bulletin · 25 July 1901 · page 1

LONG-LOST BENDERS

"Why, you're Kate Bender!" The exclamation was made In the presence of Ayres, who later went to Kansas, disguising himself as a wo man so that his wife could not trace him, and at Cherryvale told the of ficers of his suspicions regarding his wife's family. He declares that Mrs. Reed Is in reality Mrs. Bender, and that Will Baker is young Bender. Mrs. Ayres denies that Bhe 1b Kate Bender and declares that' she will prove an alibi. She Ib about 50 years of age. Governor Orman Is out of the city, but hla private secretary says that the requlBltlonpapers mentioned in the Topeka dispatch have not yet been received.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A Topeka dispatch reports that four people believed to be members of the notorious Bender family, wanted for murders committed near Galena, Kansas, have been located near Fort Collins, Colorado. Kansas's governor has issued extradition papers based on claims from a man who says one of the suspects, Kate Bender, was once his wife.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 25 July 1901 · page 2

Collins. Col. Topeka. Kas., July 23.—Four person*, believed to be members of the Bender family, accused of committing a score of murders at their home near Galena, Kas., 20 years ago, are believed to have been located near Fort Collins. Col. and Gov. Stanley has issued requisi tion papers on the governor of Colo rado for their return to this state. The first steps towards bringing the suspects to Kansas were taken upon the representations of Frank Ayres of Fort Collins, who asserts that one of the quartet, Kate Bender, was once his wife.

See moreSee less

The Benders lived on a small farm near Galena and for years had lured travellers to their place, murdered them for their money and buried their bodies. An investigation in to the dis appearance of a man who had stopped at the Benders and whose bones were found beneath the house led to their flight. They were never found. The parents would now be in their 70's and the children about 50 years old.

See the clipping

The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn.

A report states that the notorious Bender family is believed to have fled to Colorado, with steps being taken to bring suspects back to Kansas based on claims from Frank Ayres, who says one of them, Kate Bender, was once his wife. The piece recaps the Benders' alleged method of luring travelers to their farm near Galena, murdering them, and burying bodies around the trapdoor-equipped house.

The Princeton Union · 25 July 1901 · page 8

THE BENDERS AGAIN.

Topeka, Kan., July 24.Four per sons befieved to be members of the notorious Bender |amily accused of committing a score of murders at their home near Galena, Kiln., 30 yeara ago, are believed to^have been located near Fort Collins, Colo., and Governor on the governor of Colorado for their return to this/ state. The first step towards briging the suspects to Kan sas were taken upon the representa tions' of Frank Ayres of Forf Collins, who asserts that one of the quartette, Kate Bender, was once his wife. The Benders lived on a small farm near Galena arfcL-for years, as devel oped after their flight, had lured trav elers to their place, murdered them for their money and buried their bod ies in the yard around ttieir home or under their house.

See moreSee less

The house was arranged with trapdoors. All four members of the family^ were accused of aiding in the murders. An investi gation infW the disappearance of a t,^ iM vnoayytjaittuue ot a man who had stopped at the Benders and whose bones were found beneath the house led to their flight one night. Heavy reward for their arrest was of fered by the state, but they were never found. The family consisted of man, wife, daughter and one son. The parents would now be in the 70's and the children about 50 ears of age.

See the clipping

The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn.

Governor Stanley of Kansas has issued requisition papers to Colorado seeking arrest of four people believed to be the notorious Bender family, wanted for a string of murders near Galena, Kansas three decades earlier. The family fled after the body of a missing guest was found buried beneath their house, and a reward for their capture had gone unclaimed until this reported Fort Collins sighting.

The Princeton Union · 25 July 1901 · page 8

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

Three people arrested in Colorado on suspicion of being members of the Bender family are named as Mrs. Frank Ayres, her mother (Mrs. Reed), and Will Baker. Mrs. Ayres denies she is Kate Bender and says she will prove an alibi, despite a Kansas family once recognizing her as such.

The Saint Paul Globe · 25 July 1901 · page 1

THEY SAY IT ISN'T SO.

. der Family Enter a Denial. DENVER, Col., July 24.— persons i alleged to be members of the Bender ' family, for whom Gov. Stanley, of Kan : sas,' has issued requisition papers on Gov.

See the clipping

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

A Colorado man named Ayres claims his wife is actually Kate Bender and her mother is Ma Bender, prompting Kansas's governor to seek extradition papers from Colorado. Investigators, including a lawyer and a Galena resident who knew the Benders, travel to Fort Collins to attempt identification, while Mrs. Ayres denies the accusation and vows to prove an alibi.

The St. Louis Republic · 25 July 1901 · page 14

BELIEVES HIS WIFE IS KATE BENDER.

j ears ago a family from Kansas, named Maddox, going through that portion ot Colo rado in prairie schooners, camped at Ayrcs's place. Mr9. Maddcx la said to have ex claimed on coming face to face with Mrs. Ayres: "Why, j'ou're Kate Bender."

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

Women in Fort Collins, Colorado, alleged to be Kate Bender and her mother, deny the identification and claim they can prove an alibi. A lawyer and an old Galena resident who knew the Benders have traveled to Colorado to attempt a positive identification.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 25 July 1901 · page 1

DENY BEING THE BENDERS.

City to Identify Prisoners. Denver, July 25.—The persons al leged to be members of the Bender family, for whom, according to a dis patch from Topeka, Governor Stanley has issued requisition papers on Gov ernor Orman of Colorado, are Mrs. Frank Ayres and her mother, known as Mrs. Reed in Fort Collins, where they reside, and Will Baker of Long mont. Mrs. Ayres denies that she is Kate Bender and declares that she will prove an alibi. She is about 50 years old. It is said that Edward L. Burton, a lawyer of Oswego, Kan., together with an old resident of Galena, who knew the Benders, are at present In Fort Collins for the purpose of making a positive identification of the persona suspected, if possible.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Persons arrested in Colorado on suspicion of being the fugitive Bender family deny the accusation, with Mrs. Ayres and her mother Mrs. Reed claiming they are not Kate Bender and her mother. A man named Ayres accuses his estranged wife's family of being the Benders, while lawyers travel to attempt positive identification.

Omaha Daily Bee · 25 July 1901 · page 3

DENY BEING THE BENDERS

DENVER, July 24. The persons alleged to be members ot the Bender family, tor whom, according to a dispatch from Topcka, Governor Stanley has Issued requisition papers on Governor Orman of Colorado, are Mrs. Frank Ayres nnd her mother. known as Mrs. llecd In Fort Collins, where they reside, nnd Will Baker of Loncmont, Mrs. Ayres was formerly the wife of varies uamont. wno is serving n lourtccn W&T lp"D. in prison lor criminal nsjauil. - V1" fnc,s. . i l-on)

See the clipping

The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.

Kansas authorities report that four people believed to be the Bender family—accused of a score of murders near Galena two decades earlier—have been identified near Fort Collins, Colorado, prompting Governor Stanley to seek their extradition. The identification rests on affidavits from men sent to Colorado, including a man claiming to have once been married to Kate Bender.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Telegraph-Courier · 25 July 1901 · page 5

BENDER FAMILY FOUND AGAIN

Many Murders Near Galena. Kan. Topeka. Kan., July 24.—Four per sons, believed to be members of the notorious Bender family, accused of committing a score of murders at their home near Galena, Kan., twenty years ago, are believed to have been located near Fort Collins, Colo., and Governor Stanley has issued requisition papers on the governor of Colorado for their return to this state. The first steps toward bringing the suspects to Kan sas were taken upon the representa tions of Frank Ayres, of Fort Collips, who asserts that one of the quartette —Kate Bender—was once his wife.

See moreSee less

Governor Stanley issued the requisi tion upon affidavits of four men who went to Colorado especially to iden tify the suspects. The Benders committed a series of the most atrocious crimes ever record ed. They lived on a small farm near Galena, and for years—as it developed after their flight—had lured travelers to their place, murdered them for their money and buried their bodies in the yard around their home or under the house. The house was arranged with trap doors. All four members of the family were accused of aiding in the murders.

See the clipping

Milford Chronicle · Milford, Del.

Kansas authorities report that four people believed to be members of the Bender family, wanted for a series of murders near Galena, Kansas two decades earlier, have been located near Fort Collins, Colorado. Governor Stanley has issued extradition papers based on claims by Frank Ayres that one of the four, Kate Bender, was once his wife.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Milford Chronicle · 26 July 1901 · page 4

lieved to have been located near Fort Collins, Colo., and Governor Stanley has issued requisition papers on the governor of Colorado for their return bringing the suspects to Kansas were taken upon the representations of Frank Ayres, of Fort Collins, who as serts that one of the quartette, Kate Bender, was once his wife.

See the clipping

The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan.

A Kansas governor issued a requisition for four people living near Fort Collins, Colorado, believed to be the long-sought Bender family, after rancher Frank Ayers accused his wife of trying to poison and kill him. Witnesses from Labette County traveled to Colorado and identified the suspects as John, Kate, and their children under assumed names.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The American Citizen · 26 July 1901 · page 4

FRANK AYERS WINS HIS POINT He Has Been Trying For Months to Induce Kansas to Act —Many Who Knew the Benders Well Have Positively Identified the Colorado Suspects —They are Living at Ft. Collins A requisition has been issued from the governor’s office on the governor of Colorado for the notorious Bender family. The complaint is made by Frank Ayers, a ranchman living near Fort Collins, Colo., who claims ,he was married to a woman who he now thinks was Kate Bender. He claims the woman gave him “knockout drops” some time last month in the hope of killing him.

See moreSee less

To avoid sus picion he was carried in an uncon scious condition to a nearby railroad track and left on the rails to be killed by passing trains. He was found by friends and rescued. He suspected his wife and began working up the case against her. He found her family liv ing near Fort Collins, and he had E. M. Dock, V. A. Moynhan and T. B. Smith, from Cherryvale, Labette county, Kan., go to Fort Collins and identify the family there as John Ben der, alias Charles Roed; Kate Bender, alias Mrs. Charles Reed; John Ben der, jr., alias William Baker; Kate Bender, jr., alias May Grant, alias May Ayres. Governor Stanley placed the requi sition in the hands of E. L. Barton, a deputy sheriff from Labette county, and he left at once for Colorado. The supposed Benders have been identified by several persons who knew them twenty-eight years ago in Kansas. Ayres claims that he was married to the Bender woman four teen months prior to the attempt to poison him.

See the clipping

Iowa State Bystander · Des Moines, Iowa

Kansas officials believe four people living near Fort Collins, Colorado are the long-sought Bender family, infamous for a string of murders near Galena, Kansas two decades earlier. Governor Stanley has filed extradition papers after a man claiming to be Kate Bender's former husband helped identify the suspects.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Iowa State Bystander · 26 July 1901 · page 2

Found in Colorado. Topeka, Kan., July 24.—Four per sons, believed to be members of the notorious Bender family, accused of committing a rcore of murders at their home near*Galena, Kan., twenty years ago, are believed to have been located near Fort Collins, Colo. Governor Stanley has issued requi sition papers on the governor of Colorado for their return to this state. The first step toward bring ing the suspects to Kansas were taken upon the representation of Frank Ayres of Fort Collins, who as serts that one of the quartette, Kate Bender, was once his wife. Governor Stanley has issued the requisition upon affidavits of four men who went to Colorado especial ly to identify the suspects.

See the clipping

Iowa State Bystander · Des Moines, Iowa

Mrs. Frank Ayres of Fort Collins, Colorado is accused by her own husband of being Kate Bender, one of the infamous Kansas murder family, but she denies it and claims she can prove an alibi. A man named Will Baker is also suspected of being her brother, and Kansas requisition papers have not yet arrived to compel extradition.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Iowa State Bystander · 26 July 1901 · page 3

Denies She Is Kate Itender. •Denver, Col., July 26.—Mrs. Frank Ayres, suspected of being Kate Bender, one of the family of notorious Kansas murderers, ridicules the charge made by her husband and says she will eas ily prove an alibi. Her mother, known in Fort Collins, where they re side, as Mrs. Reed, Is separated from her husband, who is living in Utah. It is charged that this old woman is in reality Mrs. Bender, and that a man named Will Baker, living at Long mont, is young Bender. The requisi tion papers from Kansas have not ar rived.

See the clipping

Kansas Agitator · Garnett, Kan.

The report claims the Benders have been found again, this time in Fort Collins, Colorado, after a man named Frank Ayres came forward claiming he married Kate Bender and that she tried to kill him with knockout drops before placing him on railroad tracks. The paper notes a $500 reward still stands for the real murderers but expresses skepticism, hoping "this is no fake."

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Kansas Agitator · 26 July 1901 · page 4

-TllE Benders lave bet n discovered a-jan this time at Ft. Collins, Colo. Ofli.-crs have gone after them. Thev wer.' "discovered" this time through one Frank Ayres, who says l-e married Kate Bender, who 1 1 if tl to kill him. Kays she gave him "knock-out drops," and then she and a companion placed him on a rail road track, where he was discovered by friends, who rescued him. We hope this is no fake. At the time of the killing Ymk, the state of Kansas offend a n w ird of 500 fi e.u h 1! flu murderers. The olf.-i isotiihwi , l-n: (1 rroi Stanley says he will n.iy the n-w.iii' it the nal

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A lawyer from Oswego, Kansas, is in Colorado investigating individuals suspected of being the Benders, awaiting gubernatorial approval of requisition papers for their arrest. He insists he is moving deliberately and is unconcerned about publicity, while some remain skeptical the Benders are even still alive.

The Topeka State Journal · 26 July 1901 · page 6

ofnee. Mr Burton says that although many years have elapsed since the discovery of the Bender murders, the feeling in the vicinity is still very strong. Yet lie savs that if the criminals should be arrested and taken back there they would have the fairest kind of a trial. Mr. Durst savs that he is one of the parties who assisted in exhuming tne bodies of the persons murdered at the Bender ranch, and stood guard over them until they were disposed of. He

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Investigator Burton is preparing extradition papers, approved by Kansas's governor and attorney general, to arrest suspects believed to be surviving Benders, with help from Durst who had helped exhume the original victims. The report also details the daily life of Mrs. Ayers, a relative of the suspects, who denies allegations made against her family by her husband.

The Topeka State Journal · 26 July 1901 · page 6

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A telephone company agent who had reported on the Bender case in the 1870s says he personally knew Dr. York and believes a vigilante posse that pursued the Benders into Indian Territory likely killed them, meaning the Fort Collins suspects can't be the real Benders. He also notes a mysterious earlier visit by men who scrutinized photographs in the old Bender house, apparently detectives.

The Topeka State Journal · 26 July 1901 · page 6

TALKS ABOUT BENDER

reference to the sale of the property. It is supposed that they were de tectives. TAP.KS ABOTT BEXDFR. Port Tmpton. Col. .July 2i. K. B. Barnes, the local aeent for the Colorado Tele-j-hone company, was located at Cherry vale, Kan. .as terminal agent of the lav. enworth. Leiwrence .fe Galveston railroad, in the early 70s. and was intimately ac quainted with the circumstances attend ing the Bender tragedy. Cherryvale ia ?!rht inilerl from where the Benders com mitted their crimes. Mr. Karnes at that time was correspondent for the Kansas City Times and was present when the bodies were discovered.

See moreSee less

He was personal ly acquainted with Dr. York, who was Vliied by the Benders, and his brother. Fenator York of Independence. Kan., is the one who started the investigation which disclosed the crimes. Mr. Rurties is positive that the Port Collins suspects axe not the Benders for several reasons. About the time the dis covery was made the Benders left that rountry, headed for the Indian Territory. Jnator York started a posse in pursuit, liiO kuthoriUea aiid til people taking It up. A crowd of vigilantes followed the Binders south. Thev traced them into the Indian Territory. After a. long search the posse came back and from that time on no authentic report has ever been heard of the Benders. The supposition at that time among the people around tnere was and is .today that this vigi lance committee ran the Bendprs to earth in the Indian Territory at some obscure place and effectually avenged the crimes of Cherrvvale. Mr. Barnes knew personally many of the members of this vigilance committee, and says that from the time they re turned." when questioned about the Bend ers, the men had nothing whatever to say, but would intimape that the Bend ers would never return. He says that Mrs. Ayres of Fort Collins corresponds in age to Kate Bender. She was about 20 years old at the time she left and would now be about 50. but beyond that, according to the printed descriptions, he Bays there is no similarity. O. F. Carson, a hardware dealer ot Omaha, was a druggist" at Cherryvale at the time of the i.ender crimes, and a member of the Kansas legislature. He had considerable information regarding the Benders. Mr. Carson was at Cherry, vale for a number of years both before and after the Bender tragedy. BAKER LAUGHS AT STORY.

See the clipping

Morning Appeal · Carson City, Nev.

Kansas authorities report that four persons believed to be members of the notorious Bender family, wanted for a series of murders near Galena two decades earlier, have been located near Fort Collins, Colorado. Governor Stanley has issued extradition papers based on affidavits from men sent to identify them, including a man claiming one suspect was his former wife, Kate Bender.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Morning Appeal · 26 July 1901 · page 3

The first steps toward bringing the suspects to Kansas were taken upon the representations of Frank Avers 1 1 the quartet. Kate Bender, was once his wife. Governor Stanley issued the requisition upon affidavits of four men who went to Colorado especially to identity the suspects. The Benders committed a series of the most atrocious crimes ever com mitted. They lived on a small farm near Galena and for years, as it devel oped after their flight, they had lured travellers and buried their bodies in the yard around their home, or under the house. All four members of the family were accused of aiding in the

See the clipping

The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D.

Kansas Governor Stanley issued requisition papers to Colorado's governor for four persons believed to be members of the notorious Bender family, wanted for a series of murders near Galena, Kansas twenty years earlier. The identification came from Frank Ayres of Fort Collins, who claims Kate Bender was once his wife, along with affidavits from four men sent to identify the suspects.

The Mitchell Capital · 26 July 1901 · page 5

REQUISITION FOR BENDERS

believed to have been located near Fort Collins, Colo. Governor Stanley has issued requisi tion papers on the governor of Colo rado for their return to this state. The first steps towards bringing the sus pscts to Kansas were taken upon the representations of Frank Ayres, of Fort Collins, who asserts that one of the quartet, Kate Bender, was once his wife. Governor Stanley issued the requisi tion upon the affidavits of four men who went to Colorado especially to identify the suspects. The Benders committed a series of the most atrocious crimes ever record ed.

See moreSee less

They lived on a small farm near Galena, and for years, as it developed after their flight, had lured travelers to their place, murdered them for their I money and buried the bodies in the yard around their home or under the house. The house was arranged with trap doors. All four members of the fam ily were accused of aiding In the mur ders. An investigation into the disap pearance of a man who had stopped at the Benders', and whose bones were I found beneath the house, led to the flight one night. A heavy reward for their arrest was offered by the state, but they were never found. The fam ily consisted of a man, his wife, daugh ter and son. The parents would now be in the 70s, and the children about 50 years of age.

See the clipping

The Van Buren Press · Van Buren, Ark.

A dispatch from Denver reports that Kansas authorities have sought extradition of two Fort Collins women, Mrs. Frank Ayres and her mother Mrs. Reed, alleged to be Kate Bender and her mother, based on an identification by a Kansas family and the husband's suspicions. Mrs. Ayres denies the charge and says she can prove an alibi.

The Van Buren Press · 27 July 1901 · page 1

HOAXERS?

Kate Bender!" The Husband Heard It. The exclamation wns made in the presence if Ayers, "ho Inter went to Kansas, disguising himself as a wom an so that his wife could not trace

See the clipping

The Van Buren Press · Van Buren, Ark.

Frank Ayres claims his wife, formerly Kate Render, is actually Kate Bender of the notorious murderous family, after a Kansas traveler recognized her. Investigators including a lawyer from Oswego are traveling to Fort Collins to attempt positive identification, while Mrs. Ayres denies the charge and says she will prove an alibi.

The Van Buren Press · 27 July 1901 · page 1

KILLED PEOPLE IN KANSAS YEARS AGO

Kate Bender!" The Husband Heard It. The exclamation wns made in the presence if Ayers, "ho Inter went to Kansas, disguising himself as a wom an so that his wife could not trace him, nnd at Cherryvale told the offi cers of his suspicions regarding his wife's family, lie declares that Mrs. Reed is in reality Mrs. Bender, and that she has separated from her hus laind. who la living in Utah, and that Will Baker is young Bender.

See the clipping

The Van Buren Press · Van Buren, Ark.

The report states that four persons believed to be members of the notorious Bender family, wanted for a string of murders near Galena, Kansas decades earlier, are thought to have been located near Fort Collins, Colorado. No arrests or confirmations are mentioned, only a belief that the fugitives have been found.

The Van Buren Press · 27 July 1901 · page 1

is possible that the trial will be held In October. Four personr believed to be mem bers of the notorious Bender family, accused of committing a score ot .murders at their home near Gnlena, Kas., many years ago, are believed to have been located near Fort Collina, Col.

See the clipping

Baxter Springs News · Baxter Springs, Kan.

Kansas Governor Stanley issued a requisition to Colorado's governor for four people believed by local citizens to be the notorious Bender family. The identification rests on claims by Frank Ayres of Fort Collins, who says he recognizes them and that Kate Bender was once his wife.

Baxter Springs News · 27 July 1901 · page 6

A Requisition on the Governor of Colorado for Four Persons Suspected to Be the . Notorious Kansas Murderers. Toneka. Kan.. July 24. Gov. Staniev has crranted n requisition on the governor of Colorado for four persons who nre believed by citizens of Mont gomery and Labette counties to be the notorious Benders. The Bteps to bring the suspected ones to Kan sas nre taken upon the representation of Frank Avres. of Fort Collins, Col., who claims that he knows them nnd that the notorious Kate Bender was once his wife. He says they live at Fort Collins, in Laramie county, Col., where the father and mother are known ns Charles Beed ond wife, nnd the two children as William Baker and May Baker.

See moreSee less

He Bays the old man is il.niii 7 venrs of nee nnd his wife five or b!x yeurs younger. The other two, he says, are about 50.

See the clipping

The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn.

Governor Stanley of Kansas issued requisition papers to Colorado for four people believed to be members of the Bender family, suspected in a string of murders two decades earlier. The request followed identification efforts by a man claiming one suspect was his former wife, Kate Bender.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Irish Standard · 27 July 1901 · page 3

RECALLS OLD CRIMES.

Gov. Stanley, of Kama), Issues Requi sition for Four Persons Suspected of Belnv Part of Bender Family. Topeka, Kan., July 24.—Pour per sons, believed to be members of the notorious Bender family, accused of committing a score of murders at their home, near Galena, Kan., 20 years ago, are believed to have been located near Port Collins, Col., and Gov. Stanley has issued requisition papers on the governor of Colorado for their return to this state. The first steps towards bringing the sus pects to Kansas was taken upon the representations of Prank Ayres, of Port Collins, who asserts that one of the quartette, Kate Bender, was once his wife.

See moreSee less

Gov. Stanley issued the requisition upon affidavits of four men who went to Colorado especially to identify the suspects. [The Benders committed a series of the most atrocious crimes ever recorded. They lived on a small farm near Galena, and for years, as It developed after their flight, had lured travelers to their place, murdered them for their money and burled their bodies in the yard around their home or under the house. The house was arranged with trap doors. All four members of the family were accused of aiding in the mur ders. An investigation into the disappear ance of a man who had stopped at the Benders', and whose bon.es were found be neath the house led to their flight one night. A heavy reward for their arrest was offered by the state, but they were never found. The family consisted of man, wife, daugh ter and one son. The parents would now be in the seventies, and the children about 50 years of age.]

See the clipping

The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss.

A dispatch reports that Kansas authorities seek the extradition of two Fort Collins women believed to be Kate Bender and her mother, based on a chance recognition by a former neighbor and a husband's suspicions. The women deny being Benders and say they can prove an alibi.

The Grenada Sentinel · 27 July 1901 · page 8

patch from Topeka, Gov. Stanley of Kansas has issued requisition papers of Gov. Orman of Colorado, are Mrs. Frank Ayres and her mother, known Mrs. Reed, in Ft. Collins, where as they reside, and \\ill Baker, of Long Mrs. Ayres was formerly the mont. wife of Charles Lament, who i serv ing a 14-year-terin in prison for crim inal assault. Kate Bender!" ••Why, Y After she secured a divorce from •ried Frank Ayres, Lamont she and they lived or. adjoining ranches near Manhattan, a mining camp 40 miles from Ft. Collins.

See moreSee less

Two years ago a family front Kansas named Mad dox, going through that i>ortion of Colorado in prairie schooners, camped Mrs. Maddox is said at Ayres* place, to have exclaimed on coming face to 'Why, you're face with Mrs. Ayres Kate Bender!

See the clipping

The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss.

A Mrs. Ayres of Ft. Collins, Colorado, is suspected of being Kate Bender after a Kansas family recognized her and informed officers; a lawyer and an old Galena resident who knew the Benders traveled to attempt identification. Mrs. Ayres denies the accusation and says she will prove an alibi.

The Grenada Sentinel · 27 July 1901 · page 8

KILLED PEOPLE IN KANSAS YEARS AGO

band, who is living in Utah, and that Will Baker is young Bender. .Mr*. Ay Mrs. Ayres denies that she is Kate Bender, and declares that she will prove an alibi. She in about 50 years of age. It is said that Edward L. Bur of ton, a lawyer of Oswego, Kas., to gether with an old resident of Ga Mena, who knew the Benders, are at present in Ft. Collins for the purpose j of making a positive identification of of the persons suspected, if possible. Gov. Orman is out of the city, but j j his private secretary says that the requisition papers mentioned in tlie Topeka urApaveil have not yet been j received.

See the clipping

Freie Presse Für Texas · San Antonio, Tex.

Authorities in Topeka, Kansas believe four people discovered near Fort Collins, Colorado, may be members of the notorious Bender family, accused of operating a murder inn near Galena, Kansas 20 years earlier. Kansas Governor Stanley has requested their extradition from Colorado, acting on information from Frank Anres to Fred Collins, who claims Kate Bender was once his wife.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Freie Presse Für Texas · 27 July 1901 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Durango Semi-Weekly Herald · Durango, Colo.

Kansas Governor Stanley reportedly issued requisitions for the four Benders after a tip from a man claiming Kate Bender had been his wife, placing the family near Fort Collins, Colorado. The report recaps the original murders near Galena and notes that despite rewards, the Benders were never actually captured.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Durango Semi-Weekly Herald · 29 July 1901 · page 4

BENDERS REPORTED LOCATED. Governor of Kansas Has !ssued Requi sition for Them. — TOPEKA, Kan., July 27.—The four members of the notorious Bender family, guilty of a seore of murders, are sald to have been located in Colo rado, and from evidenca at hand, the report is correct, Governor Stanley has already issued requistitions for the apprehension of the gang. The accused consist of father, moth ar, son and daughter. The f.rmer two would now he over 79 years old, while their children arce past the L 0 mark. They are now sald to be in the vicinity of Fort Collins, Colorado.

See moreSee less

Information to that effect wus given to Governor Stanléy by Prank Avers of that place, who asserts that Kate Bender, the daughter, was once his wife. Four men who went from here to Colorado to identify Lor support the statement of Ayres, The Benders lived on a emall farm near Galena and for vears, as it de veloped after their flight twenty-seven vears ago, had lured travelers to their place, murdered them for their money and buried their bodies in the vard around their home or under the house, The house was arranged witlh trap doors, All four members of the family were accused of aiding in the murders, An investigation into the disappear ance of Dr. York, a brother of a Kan sas state senator, who had stopped ot the Benders, and whose bones were found beneath the house, led to the flignt. Heavy rewards for their ar rest were offered by the state, hut they were never capturd, although a great many false clues were run down.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Deputy Sheriff Burton and Attorney Dish returned from Fort Collins, Colorado without arresting the suspected Bender family because the governor was absent to receive the extradition requisition. Burton stated he could not confirm if the Colorado family matched the Benders who vanished from Kansas in 1873, deferring judgment to Labette county authorities.

CorrectionThis set right 5 earlier articles: Milford Chronicle, 26 July 1901, The American Citizen, 26 July 1901, Iowa State Bystander, 26 July 1901, Kansas Agitator, 26 July 1901, Morning Appeal, 26 July 1901.

The Topeka State Journal · 29 July 1901 · page 7

NO BENDER ARRESTS

"Xo." "Do these Coloredo people look to you as the Benders ha.ve been describ ed?" "I haven't any very accurate descrip tion of the Benders," said Mr. Burton. "I didn't take any, because in my in vestigation at Fort Collins I wanted to be absolutely free from prejudice. I have learned all the facts in the case, but I do not want to talk before I make my report to the county commissioners and the prosecuting attorney of La bette county, who will decide on the action to be taken. They have a de scription of the Benders and, if what I report coincides with what are sup posed to be the facts concerning the Benders, then prosecutions may fol

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Oswego attorney E. L. Burton and detective Frank Dienst investigate a claim that the Benders were found living as the Baker family in Fort Collins, Colorado. Dienst, who knew the Benders personally, reports the Bakers are respectable people who in no way resemble the fugitive family, contradicting Frank Ayers' identification.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The Topeka State Journal · 29 July 1901 · page 7

posed to be the facts concerning the Benders, then prosecutions may fol low." MISSING SINCE 1S73. The Benders left their farm, between Parsons and Cherryvale, In 1873. Since then nothing definite has been heard of them. Mr. Burton was asked this morning if he did not think that old man Bender and his wife were proba bly dead. "I don't think it is unreasonable to believe they are still alive," he said. "They were very strong, healthy people, and there has never been any record of their death. Of course they would be very old people."

See moreSee less

L. S. Crura of Oswego came to Kan sas City this morning. It's all nonsense to talk of the Ben ders having been killed by a mob on the Verdigris river shortly after the discovery of their crimes," he said. "There was a big reward out at that time I don't know how many thousand dollars and these fellows would have been glad to have brought In the skulls of the Benders and claim the reward. You can't make me believe but that the Benders made their escape. Whether they have been located in Colorado or not is another story that I don't know anything at all about." PARSONS DETECTIVE'S IDEA.

See the clipping

The Star · Reynoldsville, Pa.

Governor Stanley of Missouri granted a requisition to Colorado for four people believed by citizens of Montgomery and Labette counties to be the notorious Benders. They are accused of murders committed in 1872.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Irish Standard, 27 July 1901, Durango Semi-Weekly Herald, 29 July 1901.

Wrong

The Star · 31 July 1901 · page 7

May Be the Benders Governor Stanley, of Missouri, baa granted a requisition on the Governor of Colorado for four persona who are believed by reputable citizen of Montgomery and Labette countlea to be the notorious Bender, who are accused of 87 murder In 1872.

See the clipping