As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

April 1899

2 articles

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

An 1899 article about the butter and poultry trade at Independence casually recounts the twenty-year-old legend of the murderous Bender family, who lured travelers into their roadhouse and killed them for money. It repeats the popular but unverified story that vigilantes pursued the fleeing Benders and that the family was killed and buried on an Arkansas River island.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 796 days later.

Wrong

The Topeka State Journal · 29 April 1899 · page 2

in the wholesale markets. "Broilers," as spring chickens are called in the trade, are packed in the refrigerators during the summer for the winter trade and lie in the ice from six to eight months belore they are sent to market. The best season for buying broilers is June and July. They bring the biggest prices in January and Feb ruary. The town of Independence was the home of the notorious Bender family, who, twenty years ago, on the road to Cherryvale, enticed travelers into a sort of roadhouse, from which few men with money ever emerged.

See moreSee less

Guests were usually seated in a room with their backs to a calico curtain, and while Kate Bender, the siren, entertained them "old man Bender" hit them in the back of the head with a hatchet or an ax. When night came the family buried its victims in the garden and took care of the travelers' teams in some manner, generally driving them over into Indian Territory and selling the horses and wagons for what they could get. A number of mysterious disappearances gave the Bender tavern a bad name, and nnally, after a brotfter of State Senator York was seen to enter the place and never appeared again, a vigilance commit teo visited them and advised them to leave the country within twenty-four hours. The friends of York were not satisfied with the report of the committee, and when the Benders packed up and started on the western trail followed them into the night. Nobody knows what happened, but the popular impression is that the entire fam ily was buried in the sand of an island in the Arkansas river, and its outfit burned The Benders used to turn up occasionally in distant places all over the country, but

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A newspaper piece about the butter and poultry trade digresses into a nostalgic retelling of the Bender family's murders near Independence, Kansas, twenty years earlier. It repeats the popular but unverified rumor that vigilantes caught and killed the fleeing Benders, burying them on an island in the Arkansas River.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 795 days later.

Wrong

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 30 April 1899 · page 10

re unprteoaiar people for debt under the ancient English masters and servant act. Six or eight debtors are now in Jan." ever emerged. Guests -were usually seated in a room with their backs to a calico curtain, and while Kate Bender, the siren, entertained them "old man Bender" hit them In the back of the head with a hatchet or an ax. When night came the family buried its victims in the garden and took care of the travelers teams in some manner, generally driving them ever into the Indian Territory and selling the horses and wagons for what they could set.

See moreSee less

A number of mysterious disappearances gave the Bender tavern a bad name, ard finally, after a brother of State Senator York was seen to enter the place and never appeared again, a vigilance com mittee visited them and advised thm to leave the country within twenty-four hours. The friends of York were not sat isfied with the report of the committee, and when the Benders packed up and started on the western trail followed trtm into the night. Nobody knows what hap pened, but the popular Impression is thrt the entire family was buried in the sand of an island in the Arkansas river, ani its outfit burned. The Benders used to turn

See the clipping