Marietta Daily Leader · Marietta, Ohio
Twenty years after the fact, this piece recounts how the Bender family lured travelers to their roadhouse near Independence, Kansas, killed them with an axe, and buried bodies in the garden. It repeats the unverified popular rumor that vigilantes caught and killed the fleeing Benders on an Arkansas River island, though their fate was never confirmed.
Marietta Daily Leader · 6 May 1899 · page 2
A number of mysterious disappear ances gave the Bender tavern a bad name, and finally, after a brother of State Senator York was seen to enter the place and never appeared again, a vigilance committee visited them and advised them to leave the country Within 24 hours. The friends of York were not satisfied with Che report of the committee, and when the Benders packed up and started on the western trail, followed them Into tho night. Nobody knows what happened, but the. popular Impression is that the entire family was buried In the sand of an is'-''