As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

May 1906

3 articles

Amador Ledger · Jackson, Calif.

A rancher named J.K. Morgan claims the Bender family, notorious Kansas murderers, was wiped out by cowboys in No Man's Land shortly after fleeing Kansas. The article recounts the original discovery of their crimes, including the search for missing legislator Dr. York that led to uncovering bodies on their farm.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 718 days later.

Wrong

Amador Ledger · 25 May 1906 · page 5

The Bender Family from Globe Democrat. The recent failure to locate the bodies of tbe notorious Bender family in an abandoned"weirorTtheir'former farm, near Cherry vale, Kan., brings out a statement from J. K. Morgan, a wealthy Indian Territory ranchman, to the effect that the entire Bender family was wiped out by cowboys in "No Man's Land," shortly after their disappearance from Kansas, following tbe tracing of numerous mysterious murders to thorn. *% Morgan has been a cowboy in the west for forty years, and has been located in the Creek Indian nation, near Kellyville, for the past twenty years, in the early days it was his custom, in goiug to and from his ranch with bunches of cattle, to stop with the Bender family, as be had kuowu^all of them lor some time, and he gives it as his opinion that the only reason he is alive to-day is because on these trips he was always accompanied by a force of cowboys and teamsters.

See moreSee less

The' Benders only at tacked and killed solitary travelers. The murderous career of the Ben ders was during the early 80s, ;in tbe vicinity of Cherryvale," Kan. [Sus picion finally pointed to them follow ing the disappearance of Or. York, a member of tbe Kanass legislature, and at that time quite prominent in Kansas politics. A brother of York began a search tor him and traced him as far as the Bender home. Here tbe trail ended, and, calling upon friends to assist him, York pushed tbe search. One of the guns carried by the party had a bayonet attached, and in sticking this into tbe newly plowed ground, one of the men struck something that be knew was not earth. An investigation revealed the body of a murdered man and within a snort time nine corpses were unearthed, including that of Dr. York. Morgan, tbe ranchman, was a mem ber of the vigilance committee that started on the trail of the Benders. He says that often when, passing tbe Bender farm, he would see John Bender plowing, and would ask what be was doing, but never received a satisfactory answer. It "developed afterwards that Bender was plowing so as to cover up tbe signs of a new dug grave. Following the disappear ance of Dr. York, and even before the Benders had been suspected, a band of searchers came to the Bender home at night. Morgan was in tbe party. They were told by Kate Bender, the daughter, that they must not enter the bouse as her mother was danger ously ill and their entrance might cause her instant death. Unsuspect ing, the searching party withdrew, and that night Benders left the country, taking with them two teams and wagons. Their absence, accord ing to Morgan, did not become known until the bawling of the calves on the Bender farm attraoted the attention of neighbors. The calves were starving, having had nothing to eat since the departure of the family.

See the clipping

Amador Ledger · Jackson, Calif.

A rancher named Morgan recounts his personal involvement in the vigilante search for the Bloody Benders, describing how Dr. York's disappearance led to discovery of nine bodies on the Bender farm. He also describes the family's escape and the unsuccessful pursuit into Indian Territory as far as Atoka.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 718 days later.

Wrong

Amador Ledger · 25 May 1906 · page 5

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Amador Ledger · Jackson, Calif.

A 1906 article recounts an old vigilante named Morgan's claims that the Benders fled to Indian Territory after neighbors noticed abandoned calves on their farm. Morgan claimed cowboys later killed an entire family matching the Benders' description in 'no man's land' after accusing them of murdering a missing cowboy.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 377 days later.

Wrong

Amador Ledger · 25 May 1906 · page 5

Hanged Blacksmith Three Times. Morgan says that before the trail of the Benders was found, after their sudden departure from Kansas, that it was believed then, and is still his belief, that a local blacksmith knew all about the family. The vigilantes hanged the man three times, in trying to force him to reveal what he knew regarding the benders, but he re mained mute. Among the persons, murdered byjtbe Benders, was a girl, perhaps 11 years old, and who had been buried with her father, whom tbe Benders also killed.

See moreSee less

When these bodies were unearthed by tbe vigil antes, the position of the girl's body bore evidence that she had been buried alive. One boy was killed, who had but 25 cents with which to reward his murderers. He left bis uncle's farm, expecting to be absent form home only a day, but never re turned. He had but recently come from the east, and, although having considerable money, he left it all

See the clipping