As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

May 1908

21 articles

Coeur D'alene Evening Press · Coeur D'alene, Idaho

Excavation at the Guinness farm in La Porte, Indiana uncovers additional skeletons, drawing comparisons to the notorious Bender family murders in Kansas. Investigators now theorize that Mrs. Bella Guinness may have survived the house fire and be hiding in Chicago, since the headless body found in the ruins remains unidentified.

Coeur D'alene Evening Press · 7 May 1908 · page 4

INDIANA WOMAN MURDERS MANY Is Rival of the Bender Family of Kansas Fame

Kansas Fame LA PORTE, Ind., May 7. —This city Is In the throes of a murder mys tery that takes rank wlih the notori ous crimes committed by Ur. Holmes of Chicago und the Bender rurnlly of Kansas. The gang of rnen excavating on the Guinness farm, under the direc tion of Sheriff Hmulzer, came upon another disturbed spot within six feet of the place where yesterday four bodies were dug up, and upon dig ging three feet down found a wooden box, which fell to pieces as their spades hit it.

See moreSee less

Under the dirt the men found the skeleton of a man lying face downward. Continuing their digging at the same place, the men came upon the skeletons of two more persons, but there was no clothing or anything at tached, and It was impossible to tell whether they were male or female. The ground Is being further exca vated. The body found in the box had been dumped in carelessly. On top of it was debris, including a little tin stove, evidently a baby's play thing. Monstrous Murderess.

See the clipping

The Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.

A newspaper report on the Belle Gunness murder farm in Laporte, Indiana, draws parallels to the earlier Bender family killings that shocked the nation. It recounts how the Benders ran a wayside inn and murdered travelers, discovered only after they fled.

The Star and Newark Advertiser · 7 May 1908 · page 8

MURDER AS A WOMAN’S TRADE. The gruesome story of systematic murder that comes from Laporte, Indiana, presents all the features of the Bender family case that horrified the civilized world a few years ago. The Benders kept a lonely wayside Inn, and their business was the murder of travelers who stopped there. Only after those interested had fled to parts unknown were their frightful crimes discovered, the evidence bein^ their victims buried on the spot. On a well-kept farm at Laporte a woman with a nature of an incarnate fiend has maintained a house of murder and a cemetery for her victims.

See moreSee less

It seems inconceivable that either a man or a woman could singly perpetrate such a series of crimes, and the theory is advanced that several of the bodies found buried on the farm had been forwarded in Jrunks by a murder band in New York for private Interment. Whether the woman was burned in a fire that con sumed her dwelling, or whether she fled, is another unsolved mystery. But whether dead or alive, or whether or not she murdered all the unfortunate people whose bodies have been disinterred, Mrs. Belle Guinness takes her place in the front rank of the female criminals whose revolting careers have made mankind shudder. SOME CURRENCY LEGISLATION, PERHAPS.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A newspaper draws parallels between the 1908 Belle Gunness murders in Indiana and the Bender family killings in Kansas 35 years earlier, noting both used decoys and buried victims on their property. It then recounts the history of the Benders' homestead near Cherryvale, Kansas, describing their grocery-and-lodging ruse for travelers.

Omaha Daily Bee · 8 May 1908 · page 4

KANSAS TRAGEDY. Indiana's Private Graveyard a Duplicate of the Benders'.

The Benders drifted Into Labette county, from whither no one ever knew, early In the spring of 187?. and at once sought and "entered" a government homestead a few miles out from the town of Cherryvale. They chose a level bit of prairie land In a narrow valley, along which ran the main traveled road leading from Fort Bcott. Osage Mission and other points to Inde pendence, the seat of the United States land office. They plowed up a few acres, planted a few fruit trees and constructed a low, one-story frame house, about four teen by twenty-four feet In dimensions.

See moreSee less

This house was divided by a thin board partition, and underneath the rear part was dug a cellar about four feet deep, which had no stairway, but which could be entered by a trap door In the floor of the rear room. The front room waa fitted with rough shelves and contained a small stock of supplies, while across the front of the outside a straggling sign announced that groceries were for sale within, and that entertainment could be had for man or beast. The road ran within a few feet of the front door, and It was understood that the Benders did quite a thriving busi ness with the many wayfarers who were constantly passing to and fro. There were four persons In this family of murderers, two men and two women. Old man Bender was a German and could not speak a word of English. He was a morose and savage vlsaged man who sel dom spoke, even his own tongue. His wife was also German, but she had mastered enough English to attend to the store. Next came Kate Bender, the only daughter of the old couple. She spoke fairly good English, which Indicated that the family had long been residents of America, despite the Inability of the parents to talk English. Kate waa aged anywhere from 26 to 30, and In appearance was not unattractive. The fourth member of this family was John Oleger, a stockily-bullt German, who spoke good English, though he has been spoken of both as the husband and lover of Kate Bender. Outside of Kate none of the family visited with their neighbors. Though none susplcloned tha family of being wholesale murderers, It Is evident that they commenced their awful work al most Immediately after locating upon the claim. During the fall of 1872 and through the winter and spring succeeding a number of persons disappeared aa completely aa though carried from the face of the earth. Search revealed nothing of their where abouts, and while the people met together and shook tholr heads ominously and talked all manner of theories not a breath of sus picion was wafted toward the Benders.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The article recalls how Dr. York's disappearance near the Bender farm led his brother, Senator York, to investigate, eventually finding a starved calf that raised suspicion. A search of the property uncovered nine bodies buried in the orchard, including Dr. York's, revealing the Benders' method of murdering guests with a hammer from behind a chair.

Omaha Daily Bee · 8 May 1908 · page 4

A week or more after the disappearance of Dr. York a neighbor noticed the de serted appearance of the Bender farm. He made an examination of the premises and found a dead calf In the barn tied with a rope, and it was evident that the animal had perished from hunger. The dead calf aroused curiosity, then suspicion, and finally Senator York was notified. He came at once and a crowd of more than 900 people quickly assembled 1 about the Bender house. A farmer happened to be

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

An unsigned letter sent to a Louisville editor claims that accused murderess Belle Gunness is descended from the same family as Kate Bender of Kansas infamy. The same report also covers a woman mistakenly arrested in Syracuse on suspicion of being Gunness, who was quickly released after proving her identity.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Salt Lake Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1

AS KATE BENDER

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Daily Sentinel · Grand Junction, Colo.

A 1908 article recalls the Bender family murders in Kansas, triggered by the discovery of nine bodies in LaPorte, Indiana. It recounts the Benders' method of killing travelers in their Labette County house and notes that only nine bodies were found, though the family was credited with 37 killings.

The Daily Sentinel · 11 May 1908 · page 6

THIRTY-SEVEN KILLED BY THE BENDERS IN KANSAS.

l in 1872. They were credited with havJ lag killed 37 people. Of these the bodies of nine were j found, but represented the killings of l the last six months of the Bender fam ily's stay in Kansas. The family con sisted of William Bender, aged 69: his wife, aged 55; and two children by a former wife, Kate, aged 25, and John, aged 23. They lived in a 16x20 house in a remote region. This shack was divided by a canvas partition. The plan was to get travelers who had stopped for food and shelter to sit with their backs to the canvas wall and then Kate would strike them from behind with a hammer.

See moreSee less

The old man would then finish the lob with another hammer, a board would be taken up from the floor and the victim's throat out over it. Horses and clothes were taken away by confederates, and the Bender's would keep the money and valuables. Their crimes were discov ered by the murder of Dr. York of Independence. Kansas. His brother traced him to the Bender hut. but the members of tlie family had made their escape. Of the nine bodies found all but two were identified. It was thought that the others had been taken far away from the hut and hurled.

See the clipping

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa

Reporting on the Belle Gunness murder case, the Chicago Tribune draws parallels to the earlier Bender family killings of 1871-1873, recapping how the family ran a roadside inn, used spiritualist seances to lure and kill victims, and were eventually exposed after Dr. York's disappearance was traced to their store. The piece frames Gunness as potentially surpassing the Benders' death toll.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Amador Ledger, 25 May 1906, Amador Ledger, 25 May 1906.

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 12 May 1908 · page 5

The Bender Cases Recalled. The Chlcafro Tribune, commenting editorially on the tragedy, draws this comparison with the Bender family murders: If Mrs. Gunness was or Is a reincar nation of Kate Bender she has out done the ghastly achievements of her former life. Of the Bender family's known victims there were only seven. The tally of the Gunness woman's crimes may never be made up, but it already has surpassed that of the Beneders* butcheries. The parallelism of the two affairs Is otherwise remarkable. The circum stances of the earlier were as follows In 1871 a family of four came over from Germany and opened a small store on the country road which runs from Independence, Kan., to the Osage mission.

See moreSee less

The members of the family were the father, called both William and John his wife their son, John: and their daughter, Kate a girl of 25. who claimed to be a spirit medium. It was through the machinery of spiritualistic seances tha.t the crimes were committed. The victim was seated In the usual dark room with his head against a curtain. One of the Benders, standing behind the cur tain, then struck him over the head with a hammer. Afterwards, to make certain, the victim's throat was cut he was stripped of his valuables and was burled at night. Discovery came May 1873, through the disappearance of Dr. William York, whose brother traced him as far as the Bender's store. Unable to fol low the trail beyond, the brother re turned to the Benders' plaoe and thert caught sight of something that had belonged to Dr. York. As a result of these suspicious circumstances an in vestigation began, but measures-were not taken, so far as is known, to de tain the Benders, who disapeared and never were heard of again. There was a rumor that Kansas farmers of Labette county lynched them, but Is Is wholly unsupported by evidence and therefore is almost certainly un true. The crimes 6f the Benders were the wonder of a generation and the nam of Kate Bender especially occupies a terrible eminence in the history of crime. Yet if the evidence in the aot modified or in I 1 1 1 f1 t*. mm ,*$$$? T4 Ui^mM

See the clipping

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa

This article recaps the Bender family's spiritualist seance murder method and the 1873 discovery via Dr. York's disappearance, noting the Benders vanished and were never found. It then draws a comparison to the more recent, more horrific crimes of Belle Gunness.

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 12 May 1908 · page 5

It was through the machinery of spiritualistic seances tha.t the crimes were committed. The victim was seated In the usual dark room with his head against a curtain. One of the Benders, standing behind the cur tain, then struck him over the head with a hammer. Afterwards, to make certain, the victim's throat was cut he was stripped of his valuables and was burled at night. Discovery came May 1873, through the disappearance of Dr. William York, whose brother traced him as far as the Bender's store. Unable to fol low the trail beyond, the brother re turned to the Benders' plaoe and thert caught sight of something that had belonged to Dr.

See moreSee less

York. As a result of these suspicious circumstances an in vestigation began, but measures-were not taken, so far as is known, to de tain the Benders, who disapeared and never were heard of again. There was a rumor that Kansas farmers of Labette county lynched them, but Is Is wholly unsupported by evidence and therefore is almost certainly un true. The crimes 6f the Benders were the wonder of a generation and the nam of Kate Bender especially occupies a terrible eminence in the history of crime. Yet if the evidence in the aot modified or in I 1 1 1 f1 t*. mm ,*$$$? T4 Ui^mM

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

The newspaper notes that Kate Bender was never captured after the Bender killings were exposed. It speculates that she could be the same person as Belle Gunness, a woman then in the news for her own murder case.

Rock Island Argus · 13 May 1908 · page 4

So far as known, Kate Bender was never captured after the discoveries of thai notorious nest of murderers. May be Belle (iunness is the same woman. It is solemnly announced by republi cans that Taft is the undisputed choice of the party for the presidential nom innl Ion. It is joyfully acclaimed by dem ocrats that Bryan is the favorite of the party for the same high distinc

See the clipping

The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.

This Chicago Tribune piece draws parallels between the notorious Belle Gunness murders and the earlier Bender family killings in Kansas, recapping the Bender story as background. It describes the family's spiritualist ruse, the method of killing victims, and the 1873 discovery triggered by the search for Dr. York, noting the Benders vanished without being caught.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Morning Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 4

■ENDER FAMILY OUTDONE. Ramaa Poaslbilitfe* lllalt* la Evil a* la Goad. (Emm the <ldeago Tribune ) If Mrs. Gun nee* was or la a reincarna tion of Kata Bandar aha haa outdone the ghastly achievements of her former Ufa. Of the Render family’s known victims there were only seven. The tally of tha Gunnees woman’s crimes may never ba made up, hut ft already has surpassed that of the Bender*’ butcheries. The parallelism of the two Hffalrs is otherwise remarkable. The circumstance of the earlier were aa follows: In I*7l a family of four came over from Germany and opened a small store on th* country road which runs from Independence, Ks..

See moreSee less

to the Osar* mission. The members of the family were the father, called both William and John, his wife, their son, John, and their daughter, Kate, a giri of twenty-five, who claimed to be a spirit medium. It Vas through th* machinery of spiritualistic seances that the crimes were committed. The victim was seated in ths usual dark mom with his head against a curtain. One of the Benders, standing be hind the curtain, then struck him over the head with a hammer. Afterward, to make certain, the victim’s throat was cut, he waa stripped of hie valuables and was burled at night. Discovery came May 4, 1*73, through the disappearance of Dr. William H. Tork, whose brother traced him as far as the Benders’ store. Unable to follow the trail beyond, the brother returned to the Benders’ place and there caught sight of something that belonged to Dr. York. As a result of these suspicious circum stances an investigation began, but meas ures were not takon, wo far as is known, to detain the Benders, who disappeared and never were heard of again. There was a rumor that the Kansas farmers of Eabette county lynched them, but it is wholly unsupported by evidence and therefore is almost certainly untrue. The crimes of the Benders were the wonder of a generation and the name of Kate Bender especially occupies a terrible eminence In the history of crime. Yet if the evidence in the Import* affair is not modified or in part belied, the oaae of Mrs. Gninness la more plngular and horrific. The Benders had the moral (or Immoral) support of one another—the terrible relief which comes to those who share a fatal secret. Mrs. Gunness may have had an accomplice in laimpher* or another, hut that has not yet been established, and it Is not Improbable that many if not most of her crime® were committed by her alone. In any event, she achieved a terrible Im mortality, leaving a name at which the world may well grow pale. The possibili ties of the human soul seem Infinite in evil as in good.

See the clipping

The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.

The article recaps the Bender murders of 1873, describing how Dr. York's disappearance led his brother to the Benders' store and triggered the investigation, after which the family vanished without a trace. It then contrasts the Benders' crimes with the more recent and arguably more horrific case of Belle Gunness, noting she may have acted largely alone.

The Morning Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 4

BENDER FAMILY OUTDONE

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Idaho Republican · Blackfoot, Idaho

The report describes Belle Gunness's Indiana farm, where multiple bodies were found after a house fire, comparing her methods to the Bender family's killings in Kansas decades earlier. It adds a circulating rumor that Gunness was actually a cousin of Kate Bender and may have escaped the fire to hide in Chicago.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

The Idaho Republican · 15 May 1908 · page 1

A MATCH FOR KATE BENDER

They were supposed to be ruins. Mrs. Gunness and two adopted chil-j to[dren, but,on investigation there is some reason to believe that it was some of her victims that burned, and that she escaped to Chicago, and is now in hiding there among friends for whom she has put troublesome people out of the way. A ofnrv ic plrDiilntprl tn thp pffppt that Mrs. Gunness is a cousin of Kate Bender, one of the family that had a stage sta ion n ansas many years

See the clipping

Freie Presse Für Texas · San Antonio, Tex.

Prompted by the discovery of murders on the Gunness farm near La Porte, Indiana, this German-language report recalls the notorious Bender family killings in Kansas 35 years earlier. It describes the family's 1871 arrival, their roadside store and inn in Labette County, and daughter Kate's use of spiritualist mediumship to lure victims to their deaths.

Freie Presse Für Texas · 15 May 1908 · page 2

Die Benders

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Freie Presse Für Texas · San Antonio, Tex.

The article recounts how neighbors grew suspicious of the Benders when guests vanished, then found the inn abandoned and several corpses buried beneath and near the house, including a child's body. It notes the Benders' method of luring guests before bludgeoning them, and states their ultimate fate was never discovered despite rewards and rumors.

Freie Presse Für Texas · 15 May 1908 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

This 1908 feature recounts the legend of Kate Bender, describing how she lured travelers with promises of spiritualist seances before bludgeoning them with a hammer. It frames the Bender killings as a notorious tale from Kansas's past, emphasizing Kate's role as the beguiling lure rather than an active hunter of victims.

The Topeka State Journal · 16 May 1908 · page 4

KANSAS COMMENT: KATE BENDER

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Paper unidentified

This report on Belle Gunness's murders claims she surpasses other infamous killers, including the Bender family of Kansas, in victim count. It notes that no accurate death toll for the Benders' mostly male victims was ever established.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Paper unidentified · 17 May 1908 · page 21

Of the victims of the notorious Ben der family of Kansas, most of whom were men inveigled by Kate Bender no accurate account has ever been obtained. It is safe to say. however that in tho light of the disclosures of the past few days Mrs Belle Gun ness. the Laporte widow, has eclipsec the record of the prairie vixen ol Kansas, and that she undoubtedly holds the palm as the most extensive slayer, man or woman, ot the age.

See the clipping

Luxemburger Gazette · Dubuque, Iowa

The article reports on gruesome discoveries at Belle Gunness's murder farm in Indiana and compares them to the Bender family killings in Kansas some 35 years earlier. It recounts how the Benders ran a roadside store and used daughter Kate's fake spiritualist mediumship to lure and murder travelers.

Luxemburger Gazette · 19 May 1908 · page 6

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Luxemburger Gazette · Dubuque, Iowa

Reporting on the Belle Gunness murder farm discoveries, the article draws a parallel to the Bender family killings in Kansas some 35 years earlier. It recounts how the Benders ran a roadside store as a front for robbery and murder, with daughter Kate posing as a spiritualist medium to lure victims.

Luxemburger Gazette · 19 May 1908 · page 6

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Luxemburger Gazette · Dubuque, Iowa

The article recounts how neighbors grew suspicious of missing guests at the Bender house, found it abandoned, and uncovered buried bodies revealing the family's hammer-and-robbery murder method. It notes the Benders' ultimate fate was never discovered, drawing a comparison to the contemporary Belle Gunness murders.

Luxemburger Gazette · 19 May 1908 · page 6

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Dawson News · Dawson, Ga.

The report describes the discovery of multiple murders at the Gunness farm near LaPorte, Indiana, with uncertainty over whether Mrs. Gunness died in the fire. It claims she was a grandniece of the notorious Bender family of Kansas, whose crimes had shocked America thirty years earlier.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

The Dawson News · 20 May 1908 · page 2

“Moth(;r‘s Day,”” and make it sacred. The story of the Guinness farm, in the suburbs of LaPorte, Ind., where so many murders have been committed, has horrified the coun try. The problem now is: Is Mrs. Guinness alive, or did she die in the fire? And a further gruesome feat ure is the story that toe woman is a grandniece of the Benders of Kan sas fame. The old readers of today will recall how the ghastly story of the Bender family’'s crimes—and most of the murders committed by Kate Bender, a young woman— shocked the American people thirty years ago.

See moreSee less

No, Erastus, there are few people who want this thing to degenerate into a mere political fued. There are good people on both sides, re member. But you can hold your principles as firm as ever, and stand up for them when occasion requires. Things political have changed, in deed. In this campaign the Atlanta Journal is leading the Sunshine Bri gade, and giving ‘‘some cheerful facts and figures” about the prosperity of the country.

See the clipping

Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho

A 1908 article about accused murderer Belle Gunness of Laporte draws comparisons to the earlier Bender family murders in Kansas. It recaps the Bender case decades later, describing the family's disappearance, rumors of vigilante justice, and the failed attempts to capture them.

Lewiston Evening Teller · 27 May 1908 · page 5

The murder farm run at Laporte. Ind.. by Mrs. Belle Gunness. or Guin ness, recalls a similar place, the Ben der farm, in Montgomery county, Kan. The Bender family consisted of old man Bender, his wife, a daughter. Kate, and a son. They are supposed to have murdered nine or ten persons on their premises, the bodies being buried in the immediate vicinity of the house. Robbery was the motive in each case. It was not until Dr. York was mur dered that suspicion was directed against the Benders. They almost im mediately disappeared, and there were all kinds of stories as to what became of them.

See moreSee less

One was that members of the York family waylaid and murdered them, that a vigilance committee forced a confession from them and then dis posed of their bodies after killing them, but each of these has been deuled. Two women were arrested at one time who were supposed to be Mrs, Bender and Kate Bender, but they suc ceeded in clearing themselves. A large reward was offered at the time of the Bender family's disappearance for their capture. Like the "Benders, Mrs. Gunness bur led her victims In the yard near her house. They included two men she had married, her three children and other men and women lured to the farm and murdered or slain In Chica go, forty-five miles distant, and ship

See the clipping