Paper unidentified
A federal prisoner named J. J. Burns claims to have solved the Bender mystery, alleging Kate Bender is alive under a new identity and had him arrested after he tried to court her daughter. He says he was jailed for mailing obscene material but frames the arrest as Kate Bender's revenge for his romantic pursuit.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 377 days earlier.
Paper unidentified · 6 June 1907 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image
KATE BENDER IS ALIVE SAYS PROF.
J. J. BURNS ASSERTS WOMAN CAUSED ARREST.
See moreSee less
Seeks to Wed Daughter and Okla homan Tells of Wandering of Out law From Kansas—Fate of Atrocious
Guthrie, Okla., June 6.—If the story related by J. J. Burns is correct, he has succeeded in unraveling one of the most interesting mysteries connected with early-day border events in Kansas—the fate of the Bender family, whose atrocious murders astounded the country.
J. J. Burns is a prisoner here in the federal jail, having been brought in yesterday by Deputy United States Marshal John Dossett. He is charged with sending obscene matter through the United States mail, and had succeeded admirably in eluding the officers and arrest for several months.
Burns made the same statements to Dossett following his arrest, that the warrant for him was sworn out by Kate Bender, a member of the Bender family. Burns says that he is in love with Kate Bender's daughter, and desired to marry her, but that the match was frowned upon by Kate. Notwithstanding opposition, Burns says he went to the home of Kate Bender to pay court to her daughter, and that she had made threats and attempts to kill him. Following these threats he returned home, and is said to have written her some letters, in which he took her to task pretty severely for her interrupting his love affairs, and upon these letters she had him arrested.
Burns is himself something of an unusual character. He lives on a homesteaded claim, near Bessie, in a home. He has tunnels running from his dugout home to the well and also to his barn shed, and by means of these tunnels he succeeded several t[imes] in eluding the officers which were sent to arrest him. These underground channels gave him an excellent means of escape whenever officers came to his dugout.
John Dossett finally trapped Burns in the town of Bessie, however. It is claimed that friends of Burns, whenever an officer reached that locality, would tip the matter off to Burns, and he would elude the officer, but Dossett went to the hotel and remained there, keeping an outlook on the street, however, for Burns. Finally he saw Burns enter a hardware store, and he followed him. Walking up behind him, Dossett asked him: "Is your name Burns?" and received an affirmative reply. Burns turned around and extended his hand to shake hands, when Dossett gripped him around the wrist to prevent Burns from pulling a gun. Dossett said: "I have a warrant for you," and Burns' only answer was: "Well, I guess you've got me at last." He made no resistance whatever. Burns was in his shirt sleeves and had no gun, having left his Winchester at a place not far distant. On him, however, Dossett found three boxes of steel bullets.
Burns talks intelligently. When a newspaper reporter called on him in jail he made no hesitancy regarding the charges that the woman who caused his arrest was Kate Bender. He said:
"Following their departure from Cherryvale, Kan., they went northeast through the country, arriving at Creston, Ia., where they lived for a number of years, ten miles below Creston. While living there Kate Bender married George Boggs, who shortly afterward disappeared. In the meantime John Bender, the father, had become old and childish, and his wife and daughter thought he was talking too much. Shortly thereafter he disappeared.
"In Iowa the Benders went under the name of Wilson. Following the disappearance of Boggs, Kate married Robert Lowe. The Wilsons, or Benders, left Iowa after a number of years and settled for a time in Chautauqua county, Kan., but later came to Oklahoma, where they located on a claim.
"During the residence there Mrs. Sarah Jane Lowe's two sweethearts quarreled and one killed the other. The killing was laid to Lowe, who was arrested and convicted and actually served a term in the penitentiary for Miller's murder."
Burns got mixed up with the family by renting them his claim near Bessie, and to this claim came Mrs. Lowe, an adopted daughter, Cora Lowe, aged about 19, and Grandmother Wilson, or Bender, aged now about 87.
"I discovered after I had rented the claim to the family," Burns said, "that a conspiracy had been entered into for me to marry either the adopted daughter or her mother, and that afterward I would be got out of the way and they would secure my land.
"I want to say that I did not write the letters which it is claimed I sent through the mails. They are forgeries and were fixed up to get me into trouble. Following my quarrel with them they did have me arrested, but I was acquitted. Mrs. Lowe then left that portion of the country and went, I think, to Oklahoma City, where, to the best of my knowledge, she is still living."
Following the disappearance of Dr. York, his brother began an investigation and tracked him to the Bender home. When the party, led by York, reached the home they were told by Kate Bender that her mother was critically ill and that they must not enter. Unsuspecting, the party withdrew, and that night, according to those who believe that the Benders did escape, the family left their farm. Their absence was not noticed until the bawling of starving calves on the farm attracted attention. The searching party later found the numerous graves of the Bender victims.
Dossett was once convicted of murder, but got a new trial and was acquitted.