A sheriff in Fremont, Nebraska arrested an old man and woman traveling on foot who asked about the Bender family manhunt, arousing suspicion. A local man who had known the Benders in Kansas identified both prisoners as John Bender and his wife, though the pair denied the identification.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Chicago Daily Tribune · 1 August 1880 · page 2
The Fremont, Neb., Prisoner identified as the Old Man Bender, And the Woman with Him. Believed Officers in Active Search of the Bender
will hang us. You know that that is John Bender, and there’s no use denying that any longer. I am going to tell the .truth. It that don’t save me from hanging I’ll have to hang too. I ought to have told the truth from the start. I told them we would be caught if we came back this way on the main road. We were going back East; had a hard time among the Indians; hardly saw a white per son.” She was asked Where the other child was ' buried, as only one was found, and she said, after asking iloollan where one was discov ered, that the other was buried in the south east comer of the garden.
See moreSee less
She said they had intended to cross over the Missouri River, and go back East. Young Kate and young John Bender were with a . team taking another road. They were to meet in lowa, and then some one of the party was to go to Kansas and dig up 3700 buried On the old Bender place. , The woman claims she is not a Bender, but siiys Bender’s wife was left in.the Choc taw Kation. being unable to proceed further, and that she died in 1870. , Iloollan’s description of the Bender place agrees with that of other persons who have been there. Officers are endeavoring to get on'the track of the rest of the party. Tlie matter will be thoroughly investi gated,-and the parties will be taken to Kan sas for further identification. The affair is creating intense interest here. 1n1873 State Senator York, of Kansas, brother of Dr.
A man named Hooflan identifies two captured prisoners as John Bender and claims the woman admits their guilt, describing buried victims and escape plans. The report also recounts Senator York's 1873 disappearance and discovery of his body among other victims on the Bender property.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
An Omaha dispatch reports that an old man and woman arrested near Fremont, Nebraska, are believed to be John Bender and his wife, the notorious Kansas murderers, based on their suspicious inquiries and testimony from a former neighbor. The man reportedly broke down and admitted to helping bury two murdered children after being confronted with inconsistencies in his story.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 1 August 1880 · page 1
Their arms as rnam Sebraski Omaha, July 31.—Tbe people at Fre mont, Neb., quite generally believe that Um two immune, an ok] man and old woman, who were arrested * few days ago by Sheriff Gregg, are none other Uian John Bender and wife, tlm notorious murderers of Kup— At least it loots as if Um tdd man prae old Bmuie. They ware traveling os. fust, and Uiada luquinra m 1$ what bar eey thlug had been discovered about the whereabouts of the Bander family, of Kansas. This eacited napicion. aud Sheriff Gragg, who ins' notified, cap tured them thirty miles from Fremout.
See moreSee less
When Gregg rode up to them he laid: “Hello Kate!” aud tlm woman replied, “1 ain’t Kate Bender." Nistof teay l»*e been hi jail, they have made statement* whmb would seem to Mrni dhe to believe tliat the mau is Bender. Hn claims that be has only lived wiUi the Bander family and knew of tbe mordera. Tbe woman Buys that she is not Mrs. Bernier, but tbat tka man is Bender. To day a dispatch was received from Fremont stating that all doubts aa to Um man’s Identity have been removed. Mr. Hoofiaa, a resident as Fremont, and who was a user neighbor of Um Bender family In Kansas, knows ull about their old premise* end arrange ments and murders, interviewed tbe prisoners and identified them both as tbe Benders. He first called on Ben der in his cell, aud Bender acknowl edged Ihi knew hits. Bender said bis name was not Bender, and HuraUn said tliat he called himself Bender in Kan
A woman arrested with a man confirms his identity as John Bender and admits they are caught, offering details about buried money, a missing child's burial spot, and claiming she is not actually Bender's wife. The report notes officers are investigating to track down the rest of the Bender family.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 1 August 1880 · page 1
east; that yoang Kate and young John Bender were with tlm team, taking another road; they were to meet in lows and then eome one of the party was to go to Kansas and iljg up S7OO burled an tbe old Bender place. The woman claim* that the is no t Bender’s wife, but says Bender's wife was left in tlm Choctaw nation, being unable to proceed further, and tliat stu died in 1876. Hooflan’e description of tbe Bender place agrees with tbat of oilier persons who have been there. The officers are endeavoring to ge( on the track of tbe rest of the parly.
See moreSee less
The matter will be thoroughly Investigated. Tbe parties will be taken to Ksiisas for further Identification. Tbe affair is creating intense interest here. In 1873 State Senator York, of Ran som, brother Os Dr. York, myiterinivdy disappeared, and upon investigating Um raygtory, hie dead body was discov ered with ton or twelve others, on Ben der’s . place. > Bender pqd Tamil). nn learning that a vlgorouß scarab was bethf made for Senator York, find lm fore Um terrible discovery was made, and have evereiuce eluded pursuit. •eerelty at Bricklayers la t’hlrag*.
A sheriff in Nebraska arrested an elderly man and woman near Fremont after they asked about the Bender family's whereabouts, raising suspicion they were the fugitive Kansas murderers. A neighbor from Kansas claimed to identify the man as John Bender, who allegedly broke down and admitted helping bury two children.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 2 August 1880 · page 1
Etc •..::......;.... -..Etc....... Etc. ■ -* DOMESTIC NEWS. The Bendrr Murderers In Custody in *"■ Nebrankn.', ■ Omaha (Neb.), July 31st.— P.eople at Fre mont, Nebraska, quite generally believe that the : two prisoners, the old . man and old woman who were arrested a few days ago by Sheriff Gregg, are none ; other than John Bender and his wife, the notorious murder ers of Kansas, at least it looks very much as if the man was old Bender.: They ■. were traveling on foot and made inquiries as to whether anything had been discovered about the whereabouts of - the < Bender family of Kansas.
See moreSee less
This excited suspicion, and Sheriff Gregg, who was notified, arrested them thirty miles from Fremont. When Gregg rode up to them he said, " Hello, Kate," and the woman replied, " I ain't Kate Bender." Since they have been in jail they have made a statement which would seem to lead one to believe that the man is Bender. He claims that he only lived with the Bender family and knew about the murders. : The woman says she is not Mrs. Bender, but that the man is Bender. , To-day a dispatch was re ceived from Fremont hinting that all doubt as to the man's identity had been removed. Mr. Hooflan, a resident of Fremont, and who was
A man named Hooflan who knew the Bender homestead identifies two newly captured prisoners as John Bender and his wife, and under questioning they admit to burying children and other crimes. The woman reveals details about hidden money, missing accomplices, and a planned reunion in Iowa, while claiming the "real" Mrs. Bender died in 1876.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 2 August 1880 · page 1
A NEIGHBOR OF THE BENDEK FAMILY In Kansas, and knows all about the old premises and arrangements, and their mur ders, interviewed the prisoners and identified them both as Benders. - He first called on Bender in his cell, and Bender acknowledged that he knew him. Bender said his name was not Bender, and Hooflan said that he called himself Bender in Kansas at any rate. Hooflan closely questioned him as to his previous statements already published, par ticularly with reference to the two murdered children, and when he saw that he had caught himself in a lie, he finally said that he had helped to put two children under the ground, and then he burst out crying, and exclaimed, " I don't care ; G — — dd m 'em ; let them hang me and be d— d."
See moreSee less
When told that he must go to Kansas, he said he would kill him self rather than go there. Hooflan showed him a plan of the house and surroundings, and he said it was correct. Mr. Hooflan next called on the woman, whosaid she knew him. " I never expected to see you any more, and I don't want to talk to you here. We are captured at last, and they will hang us. You know that that is John Bender, and there's no use denying that any longer. lam going to tell the truth. If that don't save me from hanging, I'll have, te hang, too. I ought to have told the truth from the start. I told them we would be caught if we j came back this way on the main road. We were going back East. We had a hard time among the Indians, and hardly eversawa white person." She was asked where THE OTHER CHILD WAS buried, As only one had been . found, and she said, after asking Hooflan where one child . was discovered, that the other was buried in the southeast corner of the garden. She said they had intended to cross over the Missouri river and go I back East. Young Kate and young John Bender were with the team tak ing another road. They : were to meet in lowa, and then some one of the party was to go to Kansas and dig up some 8700 buried on the old Bender place. The woman claims that she is not Bender's wife, but says Ben der's wife was left in the Choctaw nation, being unable to proceed further, and that she died in 1876. Huoflin's description of the Bender place agrees with that of other per sons who have been there. The officers are endeavoring to get on the track of the rest of the party. The matter will be thoroughly investigated, and the parties will be taken to Kansas for further identification. Thesffair is creating intense interest here. In 1873 State Senator York of Kansas, a brother of Dr. "York, mysteriously disappeared, and upon investigating the mystery, his dead body was discovered, with ten or twelve others, on Bender's place. I The Bender fam
Sheriff Gregg of Dodge County reports capturing an elderly couple believed to be the elder Benders, now jailed in Tremont, while tracking a younger couple thought to be their accomplices toward Iowa. Gregg theorizes the woman in custody may be Bender's mistress rather than Kate Bender, speculating the real Mrs. Bender was murdered by the old man.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 2 August 1880 · page 2
DOMESTIC NEWS. The raptured Benders— or Their ..:■.- ■ Arrc»l. j. : ' .; • ■-•■ ■;.,-■. '■•■ Omaha, i August Ist.— Sheriff Gregg, of Dodge county, who arrested old ; Bender and wife, who are now in the Tremont jail, was in ■ Omaha ' to-day hunting 'up the * trail of young Bender and wife, who were I seen with a team and wagon in company with old Ben der and wife, who were on 'foot, near Schuy ler, and they parted : near i there, shortly be fore Daniel Coonlan informed iiregg of their suspicious inquiries about the Bender family of Kansas.
See moreSee less
Gregg has since learned that the young couple crossed the river at Omaha with a wagon and ; team \ and went into lowa, no doubt en route to the place of meeting agreed upon between them and the old folks, fl They bad a team of one gray and one bay horse, and a covered wagon. . The old people in jail have been heard talking of the young couple. One said, " How do you know the others will be caught "No they will fool ; them. They , are : gone : south, i They will go on the — wrong '•,■•■'. track," .: ■ was the \} : re ply, vlt •;■.;= is cr* understood ->: that Daniel Condan is following on their track. ■- Sheriff Gregg says that when he arrested the old couple he rode up to them and said, " Hello, Kate," and the woman replied, "I ain't Kate Bender." Gregg believes that he ; has got a sure \ thing on the old i man, but thinks the woman is Bender's mistress. His theory is that she (started off . with the Bender outfit when they fled, that the old man killed Mrs. Bender,' and that this woman has been with him ■ through , all the Indian . country, and gives good descriptions of the habits and life of the various Indian tribes. The officer has examined the prisoners separately, and finds that the whole of .their stories are somewhat alike, though they do not agree in a number of important particulars. | The old man claims that he was at Bender's for awhile, and was laid up 'sick for seven and a half weeks.' He says his wife was not there, and that he sent for her, and that she was there with him during the time the murders were committed, and that he , knew all about them. The woman claims that she went to Bender's with him, and that both were sick in bed for seven weeks and a half. The original old Bender is a German, and has a big scar in the center of his head. The prisoner at Fremont swears that he does not know a word of German, but when a German was put in his cell and cursed him in the German language, accord ing to instructions, the prisoner . forgot him self and swore terrifically in German at the man. The prisoner also has a scar on his head answering to the scar on old . Bender's
A sheriff recounts arresting an old couple suspected of being the Benders, noting the man's scar and sudden fluency in German match descriptions of old Bender, while the woman denies being Kate Bender. Their separately taken accounts of being sick together for seven and a half weeks are similar but contain discrepancies, and the man begs for a razor to kill himself rather than be tried in Kansas.
A sheriff holds an elderly prisoner suspected of being Bender patriarch, noting a matching head scar and other identifying features; a store clerk named Hoofman positively identifies him. The prisoner refuses to be extradited to Kansas, threatening suicide and declaring he will never go there alive.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 2 August 1880 · page 2
woman is about 40 years of age, wears No. 11 shoes and has hands as big as the ild man's. She is a large, masculine-looking creature, and says there [ were ten persons killed by old Bender. Two of the bodies have never been found. Mr. Hoofton, who inter viewed the prisoners, as stated in yesterday's dispatches, is clerk in Shed's store at Fre mont, and Mr. Shed induced the Sheriff to allow him to visit the captive?. The moment he saw the old man he said, " That's Bender," and the prisoner dropped his head as if he had been shot.
See moreSee less
Hoi. flan claims that he was well acquainted with him. He says the pris oner has changed hi 3 style of shaving, but that his features are unchanged, that the scar • ■ii his head is positive proof, and that he is the man who must go to Kansas for the mur der of Dr. York and numerous other victims. It is understood that $-5,000 reward is off red for the whole gang, and of this amount there i* $11,000 for old Bender.
The report states that an elderly man and woman suspected of being John and Kate Bender, wanted for the notorious Kansas murders, were identified by a former neighbor in a Fremont, Nebraska jail. It notes they will be sent to Kansas and that capture of the rest of the family is expected.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 2 August 1880 · page 1
Train Collision—John and Kate Bender Arrested—Another Presidential Candidate—A Record of Incidents, Crimes and Casualties.
Train Collision—John and Main Bender Arreeted—another Presi dential Candidate— Lena Beeord of Iueldeuts, Crimea and cde nsities. Two trains on the Long Island Rail road ran into each other near Jamaioa, on Saturday night. Both engines were demolished, but the oars were only slightly damaged. John Walcott, one of the engineers, was fatally injured and died in a short time. Samuel Allen, a conductor, had his ribs broken and was injured internally. Several train bands and passengers were less seriously injured. It is reported that the old man and woman euspeoted of being John and Kate Bender, of tbe notorious Bender family of Kansas, accused of murders, have been identified In the jail at Fre mont, Neb., by a former neighbor.
See moreSee less
The aoonsed will be sent to Kansas. Tbe oapture of tbe rest pf the family is ex pected. Gen. John W. Phelps, of Brattlehoro, Vt., has written a letter formally ac cepting a nomination for President of the United States, which, It appears, has been offered him by the National Anti Masonic Sooiety. He oharges Free Masonry with the corrnption existing In National politics.
The report recounts the background of the infamous Bender family murders at their Kansas inn, including the disappearance of Dr. York and the discovery of victims' bodies after the Benders fled. It then describes the recent arrest of an elderly couple in Dodge County suspected to be John Bender and his wife, with authorities building a chain of evidence to confirm their identity while also searching for the younger Benders reportedly traveling through Iowa.
Omaha Daily Bee · 2 August 1880 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
THE BOSS BUTCHERS. A Chain of Evidence Establishing the Identity of the Dodge County Prisoners.
Old Man Bender Identified by a Man Familiar With His Packing House and Himself.
See moreSee less
Young John With His Wife Children and a Strange Woman,
Passed Through Omaha Last Thursday Morning.
A Description of the Whole Outfit, Now in Iowa.
Some years ago a certain wayside house in a lonely region on Agreese creek, sixteen miles northeast of In- dependence, Kansas, and on the pub- lic road leading from that to Osage, Missouri, was the scene of a series of murders, scarcely equaled in the annals of crime. The house was about 12x16 feet; there were no rooms only as divided by canvass curtains; there was a garret up stairs; there was a small garden and a peach orchard of about three acres near the house—say 100 yards away. There were no cattle, but one cow and two horses. There was no stable or outbuildings on the premises, the horses being picketed out or tied in the wagon road about 200 yards from the house. Such was the home and surroundings of the infamous Bender family, consisting of old John Bender, his wife Kate, and their son John and his wife. It was generally understood in the neighborhood that the Benders' was headquarters for horse thieves and hard characters, and at length suspicions of even worse character were aroused.
In 1873, Dr. York, of Kansas, a brother of State Senator York, mysteriously disappeared while on a business trip through the country, and an investigation of the mystery by the latter resulted in the unearthing of a private burying ground on the Bender place, where a dozen dead bodies, including that of the missing Dr. York, were disinterred. The Benders had fled a few days previously having been alarmed by the threat of one of their visitors to have the house searched, and eluding all search were supposed to have disappeared forever. A few days since it was announced that an aged couple had been arrested by Sheriff Gregg, of Dodge county, on the supposition that they were the iniquitous old John Bender and his wife. They were taken to jail and locked up in separate cells and search begun for the rest of the family, s[a]id to be passing through the state by a d[i]fferent road, and for proof to establish the identity of t[h]e prisoners.
Although the news of the arrest of the Benders was received with considerable incredulity, as num[e]rous persons had been arrested and discharged at intervals for several years, yet a chain of evidence was constructed link by link which now seems to leave no doubt that the inhuman butchers have at last come to the end of their rope, and that the whole outfit will be in the h[a]nds of ju[s]tice [v]ery s[o]on. In addition to the circumstances stated below, a Mr. Hoofman, for the past six years a resident of Fremont, but for two years prior to July 16th 1873, a neighbor of the Bender family, and engaged in heording cattle less than a mile from their house, has indentified the old man as John Bender and got the woman to admit the fact. She however denies that she is Kate Bender and says the latter died in 1876. There are other circumstances pointing to the probability that this is no case of mistaken indenty and that in addition to furthering the ends of justice, somebody will fall heir to about $25,000 the amount of outstanding rewards, $11,000 of which is on old man Bender alone.
Mr. Dan Congdon who was the prime mover and leading actor in the arrest of the alleged John Bender and his wife called at this office Sunday morning, and furnished us the following particulars of the capture which we will give in his own language:
About dark on the night of July 20th an old man and an old woman came to my house at Richland, Colfax county, and asked for lodgings and something to eat. 'If you haven't any supper for us,' said they, 'give us a place to lie down.' I showed them out to the hay-mow. When I opened the barn door the old woman kind of pulled back, as if afraid. I asked her what she was afraid of. She said there might be some trap or hole there. I left them and my neighbor, Wm. Herndon, who lives about 100 yards from the barn, came around shortly and took them home with him. He gave them supper and breakfast next morning.
After supper at Herndon's, the old man said, 'By the way, is there any talk of this Bender murder now?' Herndon said 'No, not much.' The old man said, 'I used to know them Benders; stopped at their house many a time. They killed one man and wife and buried their two children alive.' In saying they, the old man, by a slip of the tongue, said we. Then he went on to describe the canvas wall, from behind which the fatal blow was struck, and how nice Kate used to do the work. Then he talked about the Californian who came there in the evening and asked what smelled so. Kate said it was roast meat. If he had stayed there that night he would have been done for. But he gave them a warning by threatening to have the house searched. If he hadn't threatened they would all have been captured in the house.'
The old man said that he went south with the Benders that night to the railroad, where he and the Benders parted. Next day when I heard this story I started after them and to make a sure thing I went for Sheriff Gregg, of Fremont, knowing he had the sand in him. We lef Fremont at 10 o'clock the night of the 21st. Thinking I'd find them at Rogers' Siding we got off there, searched all around that side track without succers. Took the next train for Schuyler and got there at 3:45 in the morning of the 22d. Hir-d a livery rig of Jim Hughes and got track of the party at old man Dixon's grove. We passed them by there and went on to North Bend. Drove back to Mr. York's. We were going to make the arrest there, but let them walk on agan. Took them up and gave them a r de into North Bend. On the way the old man was cursing the Mormons and pretended he hailed from the Niobrara country. We put our teams in the barn there. They sat a l t le while in front of D lon & Purcell's store and then we walked down the track and they walked down the road to the old ranch, forty rods from town. We marched out on the road and commanded old man Bender to throw up his hands. Sheriff Gregg put irons on him and the old woman. He said he was not old Bender and denied having said anything about the Benders at Richland or ever known them, and said he never was in Kansas in his life. When we asked his name he turned around to his wife and asked 'whats that?' She said 'McGregor' and said she, 'my name is Nancy McGregor.'
We brought them down to Fremont that day, and the next day at Schuyler. I heard there were three more in company with them, supposed to be young John Bender, Kate Bender and a young woman about 22, whose name is unknown. I didn't give that any credit until I went and investigated the matter by secreting myself, four days after the arrest, in the jail where I heard the following conversation between the old man and old woman:
Old Man—Oh Kate!
Three raps on the floor with feet.
Old Man—He's caught again this time. (Meaning John I suppose).
Kate—How do you know he's took? How do you know but he has followed them?
Old Man—That's so! Did that fellow come back that was here this morning? (Meaning the jailor).
Kate—No. I didn't see him since dinner, and the less we have to do with letter writing and lawyers, the better.
Old Man—Do you think he's not taken.
Kate—No, he went south from the railroad the last I seen of him. He did not go west.
Old Man—What are they talking about, Cherry Vale, Montgomery county, Kansas?
Kate—It was not there. I don't know where Montgomery county is in Kansas. Do you!
Old Man—I do. How do you feel? I feel as if I had got to die.
Kate—You feel as if you were going to the slaughter house.
Old Man—Damn the luck! I'll be hanged.
Kate—You had better blame me for being caught.
Old Man—No I don't. Kate, what did he say (meaning the sheriff.) Kate—Why he said we were not married.
Old Man—I wish that letter came from Springfield, Ill.
Kate—It would do you no good as you are detected and he says they will hang you. I will go back to Jacksonville, Ill., when you are hung. If I had stayed in Wisconsin and been buried with my child they would have you but not me.
Old Man—Hell! Hang me and not you? Well, that letter will get me out.
Kate—That letter is no good, you are detected.
Old Man—Not unless you have told them something.
Kate—No, I did not tell them anything.
Old Man—Do you think they will let us go to-morrow when they get that letter?
Kate—No, the reward is too big.
Old Man—What did the sheriff say anyway?
Kate—He said you were solid.
Old Man—In what way.
Kate—That you are Bender.
Old Man—Bender be d—d! I am Alex. McGregor now. The best way is to have the trial here, for it would be a bad job if they took us to Kansas.
Kate—I should say it would.
At this juncture I entered the cell to interview Kate and told her I would start for Kansas the next day and that I was afraid of being mobbed in Kansas City.
Kate—Do you think there is any danger going through Kansas City? I said there was. Kate—I'd like to wait for a letter from Illinois.
Old Man—(to Kate). You are the one at fault for telling so much at Richland the other night.
Kate—No, you gave yourself away. You done all the talking yourself. Old Man—You told something. Kate—I told them nothing; I never told lie in my life.
Old Man—I know you are going back on me, but never mind. You told him you wanted to go to Illinois. You might as well go to Kansas as one is as bad as the other.
Kate—No, I told him I wanted to get a letter from Illinois before starting. Old Man—I feel as if I was going to hang.
Here a conversation took place about the alleged ghost of Dr. St. Louis, who was to have been hung at Wahoo, but who killed himself in the Fremont jail, which his spirit is said to haunt.
On Thursday after getting a meagre description of young John Bender, Kate and the other woman. I started for Omaha. I went to the ferry and the ferryman told me he had seen such an outfit cross at 11 o'clock Thursday, answering all the descriptions except having four or five children. To make sure about the children, I went back to Fremont that night and tried to find Sheriff Gregg but could not find him. I entered the jail and told Bender, I had Kate and John arrested at Omaha and, by the way, I said, to the old man, how many children has this Kate had? The old man said four. Said I to the old man, Kate says that you done all the sleeging in the murders from behind the canvass wall
Old Man—She's a liar she's the one that done it.
I started back to Omaha Friday and crossed to the Bluffs on the transfer but found no traces except that they were seen on Broadway. I went to Neola and found a man there who said he met such an outfit Thursday evening as he was going to the circus at the Bluffs. I went from Neola to Avoca and after informing all the officials there about it. I gave up the search. That ends my fifteen days tramp. My opinion is that they are yet within a radius of 25 miles from Council Bluffs. The description, as near as can be found out, is as follows: An old three spring wagon, not sure whether covered or not. An old gray horse and an old bay, the bay supposed to be on the off side. Two dirty clad women, one of them Kate, about 44, not red headed but with sandy hair. The other can't be described She is of medium size, age about 22. Young John Bender is supposed to have a moutache and light side whiskers When last seen had a cow-boy's hat on. In the wagon were a lot of dirty children, number not known. They are traveling under the name of John McGregor, Maggie McGregor and Mary McGregor. They say they are going to various places, the last they said they were bound for being Central Iowa.
Among the places they are going to are Jacksonville, Ills., Freeport, Ill., Springfield, Ill., McGregor's Landing, Prairie du Chiene, Wis., Springfield, Ill., and sometimes they say York state. They claim they hail from the Niobrara country or Utah and last of all they are Kansas sufferers come away from Northwestern Kansas.
The report describes the arrest of a couple believed to be the fugitive Benders, based on circumstantial evidence and a detailed account from Dan Congdon. It notes skepticism due to previous false arrests, but says the chain of evidence pointing to the Benders seems convincing, with large rewards at stake.
Thtro are other circumstances pointin ; ; to the probabdi y that this is no ewe of mistaken indenty and tint in addition to furthering the ends of justice , somebody will fall heir to about § 25,000 the amount of out standing rewards , $11,000 of which is on old man Bender alone. Sir. Dan Congdon who wai the prime mover and leading actor in the arrest of the allcgod John Bender and 1 his wife culled at this office Sunday morning , and furnished us the follow ing particulars of the capture which wo will give in.
See moreSee less
bis own language : About dark on the nichtofJuly 20th an old man and an old woman citne to my house at llichland , Colfax county , and asked for lodgings and something to cat. 'It you haven't any supper for us , ' said hey , 'give ui v plsce to 1 o down. " I showed them
A man describes tracking and arresting an elderly couple in Nebraska after the old man let slip details about the Bender murders near Richland while staying overnight with neighbor Herndon. The couple was captured near North Bend, but the man denied being Bender and the woman gave the name Nancy McGregor.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Omaha Daily Bee · 2 August 1880 · page 1
20th an old man and an old woman citne to my house at llichland , Colfax county , and asked for lodgings and something to cat. 'It you haven't any supper for us , ' said hey , 'give ui v plsce to 1 o down. " I showed them out to the hay-mow. When I opened , the barn door the old woman kind of i pulled back , as if afraid. I asked hdr what sha was afraid of. She said thtra might be eome trap or hole there.
See moreSee less
I left them and my neichbnr , Wra. Herndon , who lives about 100 yards from the barn , came around shortly and took them home with him. He gave tbom supper and broakfaet next morning. After supper at Herndpn's , the ola man said , 'By the way , is there any talk of this Bend < * r murder now ? ' Hprndon said 'No , not much.1 The old man ra'd'lined to know them Benders ; stopped at their house many a time. They killed one mm and wife and buried their two children alive. ' In saying they , the old man , by a slip of the tongue , stidtrv. Then he went on to describe the canvas wall , from behind which the fital blow was BtrucU , and how nice Kate used to do the woik. Then he talked about the California ! ! who came there in the evening and asked what nmellcd so. Kato said it was roaat meat. If ho had stayed there that night ho would have been done for. But he gave them a warning by threatening to have the house searched. If ho hadn't threatened they would all have teen captured in the honso. ' The old map said that he rent south with the Benders that night to the railroad , where ho and the Benders parted. Next day when I heard this story I started af ter them and to make a sure thing I went for Sheriff Gregg , of Fremont , knowing he had the sand iu him. We lef Fremont at 10 o'clock the night of the2l6t. Thinking I'd find them at Sogera' Siding we got off there , 56arejed. ell around thai eid& trsck trjriout euopefs. Took ths nwt train for Schuyler and got there at 3:45 in the morning of the 22d. Hir-da livery rg of Jim Hughes and got track of tne party at old man Dixou'a grove. Wo patsed them by there and went on to North B nd. Drove back to Mr. Y < rk's. We were going to make thearreat there , but Itt them walk on aga n. Took tnera un and gave them a r de it'lo ' Ni.rt Bend. On the way the old mail CTai curmg iha Mrmona juid prct mod hi hai od f.om the Niubrara c Untry. We put : our teims iu the b-rn th < fo. TLey sat al t le whiic in trout of D Unn te Purceh'a stire and then we vr lKed down the track and thy walked down the road to the eli ranch , forty rods from town.Vemarhtd out on the road and commanded old man Bender to tsrow up his hinds. Sheriff Grfgg put irons on him and the old woman. He said he waa not old Bender r.nd denied hav ing said anything about She Bendera at Kichland or ever kn > wn them , and said he never was in Kansas in his life. When we sskcd his name he turned around to his wife and askoi 'whats that ? ' She sdd 'McGregor' and giid she , * uvy name is Nsncy Me- "We brought them down to Fremont that day , and the next day at Schnyler. I heard there were throe more in company with them , supposed to bo young John Bender , Kate Bender and a young woman about 22 , whose name is unknown. I didn't g < vo tba : any credit until I went and investi gated the matter by secreting myself , f i air davs after the at rest , in the jail where I heard the ft llowing conver sation between the old uitui and old woman :
A dispatch from Fremont, Nebraska claims Mrs. Bender (using the alias Mrs. McGregor) has made a full confession detailing the Bender family's murders, though she denies personal involvement and blames Kate Bender as the ringleader. The account recounts the family's migration from Missouri to Kansas and the killings culminating in the death of Dr. York.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Chicago Daily Tribune · 3 August 1880 · page 1
HORRIBLE DEPRAVITY.
THE inSNDKU FAMILY. Social DUvatth toTht.Chleooo Ititmntf. Fremont, Neb., Ang. ti.— Further startling developments were nindo in the Uender mnt lt»r to-day. -Mrs., Hander, or Mrs. McGregor, made u full nmt complete confession of the whole matter, evihrto the minutest, details' •regardlng-tho butcheries perpetrated on the iJolm ‘Homier ' farm ■ -during . 1ST 1 - and 1878. She denies having had any per-' scmnl hand In the but says Kale, old John’s daughter, was the leader of •all 'the deviltry. S|ie went .ovpr her entire history from the time she beeamo Mrs.
See moreSee less
Alex ander McGregor. 15ho was u widow at the time that she'hmrrlcd. 3lcGregor, aims Ihmder, who was a wldow«V' i wllli four children, two of whom wore Kate and John* Jr. They migrated from Missouri to Labette County, Kas., and became Johnßender and
A woman claimed to be Kate Bender, now in custody, gives a rambling interview describing her family's alias as McGregor and the killing of a sick traveler named Brown. She claims innocence of murder herself and says the sheriff promised she need not return to Kansas with the old man.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 3 August 1880 · page 1
jf'slio would be called' Mrs. McGregor or Mr*. Bender, she replied: ' ‘ “The latter 'will do If yon be satisfied,as you he here,to see MrA. Bender.” , 44 Vow have no'ohjcctlbn to giving a little history of your life?” : / ‘ >' “Oh, no; for the Sheriff has told me that' i am to bo free, aful not to go to Kansas with the ole man, and 1 never did kill no ono any way.” .'■■*' “ Wereyou married to Bender In Kansas?” 41 1 was a widow, and he married mu at Springfield, 111,, at thoclo.su be the War.
See moreSee less
I can’t remember what year„bul Stiulrq Sedar tied'the knot. Ills name (hen was Alex ander McGregor,' and . he had four children, John and Kate being of the num ber; but two of the boys hud run off. Ho was a poorcii.s*. but we lived ohoHl several years, and then were sent by. (he county to Dunklin County, In Southwest .Missouri, where sister lived. All this is true.” 44 Voij went by the name of McGregor?” 44 Wh did to the liumu till the ole man went to Kansas and look up it homestead hi ].eblt Gomily, I believe, when he changed It to John Bender, and, nrtur about a year, John and Kale came along, and tlnjn the devil be gan to bo played.” 44 What do yon mean by that?” 44 Well, there was stealih’, thievin’, and killin’, and all that.” • 44 Who was Uie first person killed by tho family?” 44 He was a sick man named Brown. llu came along ono afternoon. The house was a good-si/'ud one. and on a sign was 4 Grocer ics’ the door,, and seeln’ this hu slopped.) rWu took him In, and tho second nlghtNvb got him up* to cut supper, mid white dented at the table John Bender let lilm'fhlo. the cellar, whHu Kate or John killed him, and tho next day Ihey'burfiul him In the garden.” 44 How long after this before mw one else was killed?” 44 1 don’t quite remember, but not long. Two were klllod, and onu of them, whose name T believe was something tike MeGvtilhy or McGrath, had u good deal of money; ut least John told mo so,” 44 Do'ymi remember about a whole family being killed?” 44 Vcs, Ido.' There was a map and w ife , and two, llttlo girls. They drove up In a covered spring wagon, and wanted to stay all night. Kate Bender said tlmyconld stay. Jt was ahoiit ‘J.o’clock In tho afternoon, and
The passage reports a purported confession from someone claiming association with the Bender family, describing how various victims—including a sick man named Brown, a man with money, a family of four, and a bearded traveler—were murdered. The account includes details of trapdoors, burial, and an editorial correction noting the true victim name (Loncher) and that only one child was found.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
A woman held in Fremont, Nebraska allegedly confessed to being Mrs. Bender and described in detail the murders committed on the Bender farm in Kansas during 1872-73, including the killing of a family with two children. The report hedges that if she is not actually one of the original Benders, this can easily be verified.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Rock Island Argus · 3 August 1880 · page 1
A. Horrible Confeasioa. Fremont, Neb., Aug. 3. There were important development in the Bender matter, to-day. Mrs. Bender made fall confession of ail the horrible murders. committed on the John. Bender farm daring 18 j 2 and 1873. She was a widow when fche married McGregor, alias Bender, wao was a widower with four children. They migrated from Missouri to Labette
A telegraph dispatch reports that Sheriff Gregg of Dodge County, Nebraska has arrested an elderly couple believed to be old Bender and his wife, while separately pursuing young Bender and his wife toward Iowa. The report includes unverified jailhouse talk and a sheriff's theory that old Bender murdered his actual wife and has been traveling with a mistress through Indian Territory.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Eureka Daily Sentinel · 3 August 1880 · page 2
THE OLD MAN KILLS HIS WIFE.
Omaha. Neb , August 2.—Sheriff Gregg, of Dodge county, who arrested old Bender and wife, and who are now in the Fremont jail, was in Omaha to-day hunting np the track of young Bender and wife, who were seen with a team and wagon in company with old Bender and wife, who were on foot, near Schuyler, and th*y parted near there shortly before. Daniel Canden in formed Gregg of their suspicious inquiries about tke Bender family of Kansas. Gregg has learned that the young couple crossed the river at Omaha with the wagon and team, and went into Iowa.
See moreSee less
No doubt they are eu route to a place of meeting agreed upon between them and the old folks. They had a team of one gray and one bay hon-e. and a covered wagon. The old neo people in jail have been heard talking of the young couple. One said : “ Now. do yon think the others will l>e caught?” “ No. they will fool them ; they are gone south; they will goon the wrong track,” was the reply. It is understood that Can dan is following on their track. Sheriff Gregg says that when he arrested the old couple lie rode up to them and s«id: ** Hello, Kate.” and the woman replied. I “ I ain’t Kate Bender.” Gregg believes he has got a sure thing on them. He tliinks ! the woman is Bender’s mistress, his the in nifc mat, i*uc BiBl it'll UU Will! ((It) Bender outfit when they left, and that the old man killed Mr*. Bender and that this woman has been with him through all the Indian country and gives good descrip tions of the habits and life of the various tribe*. An officer ha* examined the pris oners separately, and find* that the whole of their stories are somewhat alike, but they do not agree in a number of import ant particulars. The old man claims that he was at Bnder’s for awhile, and was laid up there for seven and a half weekR. He says his wife was there, and that he sent for her. and that she was there with him during the time the mnrder* were committed and that she knew all about them. The woman claim* that *he went to Bender’s with him. and that both were sick in bed for seven week* and a half. The original old Bender is & Ger man and ha* a big scar in the center of the head. The prisoner at Fremont swears that he doeR not know a word of German, but when a German was put in his cell, and cursed in the German language, ac cording to instructions, the prisoner for got himself and swore terrifically in German at the man. The prisoner "ha* also a *car on hi* head, answering to a sear on old Bender’* head, and iu several other points he answers the description. He account* for the scar by saying that he was kicked by a horse. He is seventy-two year* old. and at time* is perfectly frantic, and yells so that he can be heard two or three blocks away. Mr. Gregg has been sleeping in the cell with the old man. in hopes of heat ing something from him. and ha* not been disappointed. The prisoner wants to commit suicide, and he asks Sheriff Gregg for a raz »r with which to shave himself. Mr. Gregg would not grant his request, blit said he would have a barber come and shave him. “I don’t want any d—d barber to shave me,” said the prisoner. He sava that he doesn’t want to be taken to Kansas, but will go anvwhere else to he tried He swears he will never go to Kansas. Young Bender i* 40 years old, wear* No. 11 shoes, and his hands are as big as the old man’s. He i* a largo muscular looking creature. He *ay* there were ten persons killed by old Bender, and that two of the bodies have never been found. Mr. Hooflan who in terviewed the prisoners, as stared in yes terday’s dispatches, is a clerk in Mr. Shed’s store at Fremont, and Mr. Shed induced the sheriff to allow him to visit the cap tives. The moment he saw the old man he said. “That’s Bender.” The prisoner dropped his head as if he had been shot. Hooflan claim* that he was was well ac quainted with him; he says the prisoner ha* changed hi* style of shaving, but his features are unchanged, and that the scar on his head is positive proof, and that he is the man who must go to Kansas for the murder of Dr. York and numerous other victims. It i* nnder*tood that $25,000 reward is offered for the whole gang, and of tbi* amount there is $11,000 for old Bender. The 4'oufiitlon of rainier. New Yobk, August 2.—For the first time since he commenced hia fast Dr. Tan ner admitted this morning that he felt very weak, and that his stomach was in bad condition, hat he ex pressed confidence in his ability to accomplish his undertak ing. His eyes were lusterless and hia face pinched aud haggard. Btill, his watchers assert that he has somewhat improved since Sunday. He has suffered from nau sea three times since midnight. Small quantities of mineral water were adminis tered during the night and early thia morning. Before going on hia customary drive he swallowed two ounces of very hot water. At noon he was quietly resting. He received the following cable dispatch from Paris, aigned by Dr, Marson Sims: "Don’t waste strength iu driving out. Shut off all spectators; haveonlyyour doc tors and attendants. Your experiment is watched here with great interest hy scientists, and is ridiculed onlv hy fools. Hot weather ft against yon. Save cour age, brave fellow, aud hold on. Wish vou •ueceas.’’ A Spanish Bull Fight. New Yoke. August 2—The widely-ad vertiaed Spanish bull tight came off yes terday, and turned out to be very much of a farce. Four thousand people were pres* i nt. Tw* Ive T-xan steers were in tit. in sloftttf, an4 * 4«wtt »w»fthy Bpwitrd* t« RATIFICATION JIEKTIItt. Arrangements are being made (or a grand ratification meeting by the Democ racy of Eureka at an early day. It is de signed to be one of the grandest rallies ever witnessed in Eastern Nevada. Dis tinguished speakers are expected from abroad, and all of our local talent will participate. The date of the formal opening of the campaign in Eureka has been deferred, trom the fact that a double term of our District Court was in session, w hich so occupied a majority of the Democratic lawyers that few of them cared to give any thought to politics until the profes sional duties in hand bad been discharged. Now that the coast is clear, however, the active work of the campaign is to be taken hold of and prosecuted with energy until the last vote is polled at the elec tion in November. The date agreed upon for the demonstration, a list of the speakers and other particulars will be given in the Sentinel either to-morrow or the day following—just as soon as the necessary arrangements shall have been completed.
Sheriff Gregg describes arresting an old man and woman he believes are Bender family members, noting the woman denies being Kate Bender while the old man has a scar matching descriptions of Bender. Their accounts of events at the Bender inn broadly match but diverge on key details, and a young prisoner claims ten people were killed with two bodies still missing.
A sheriff's deputy sleeps in the cell with an old prisoner believed to be elder Bender, who refuses to be taken to Kansas and threatens suicide. A witness named Hooflan positively identifies him by a head scar as the real Bender wanted for Dr. York's murder, while young Bender claims ten victims were killed in total.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
A woman in Fremont, Nebraska reportedly confesses in detail to the Bender murders of 1872-73, describing victims including a family with two children buried alive. The report notes this identification is unconfirmed, stating the facts could easily be verified if these are not the original Benders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Press and Daily Dakotaian · 3 August 1880 · page 1
THE OLD WOMAN'S REMARKABLE CONFESSION WHICH IMPLICATES THE WHOLE BENDER FAMILY
Tlio Sii|i|MtHeil Fiimllv In Umbo— Hlelumlllj Ilrtlllls. Fruuiuut, Neb., August 8.—There were important development in the Bender -matter to-day. Mrs. Bender made a full confession of all the horrible murders committed by John Bender during ]K72 and 73. She was a widow when she married McGregory. Bender was a widower With four children. They migrated from Missouri to Labette county, Kan sas, where, under the leadership of Kate,
A woman in Fremont, Nebraska claims to be the wife of the Bender family and confesses in detail to the murders committed on the Bender farm in Kansas in 1872-73. The report itself notes uncertainty, stating that if she is not the real Mrs. Bender, 'the fact can easily be established.'
THE BENDERS, The Butcher's Wife Makes a Clean Breast of Their Butcheries
FREMONT , Nob. , August 3. There were important developments in the Bender matter to-day. Mrs. Bender made a full confoasion of all the horrible rible murders committt 1 on the John Bender farm during 1872 and 1873. She was a widow when she married McGregor , alias Benderx who was a widower with four children. They migrated from Missouri to Labello county , Kansas , where , un der the leadership ot Kate , old John's daughter , the murderand robberies bo'-an. Mrs. Bender declared she
This 1880 retrospective recounts how Dr. William York vanished near Independence, Kansas in March 1873, triggering a massive but fruitless search. It describes the suspicious Bender family living near Cherryvale, whose odd behavior and sudden flight after being questioned drew suspicion, claiming they were finally caught at Fremont, Nebraska.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Sun · 4 August 1880 · page 4
THE CRIME OF THE CENTURY
that Dr York had boon murdered not a slen I anywhere told how he came tolhls death I In deed death had overtaken him unawares le a traced to Cliermale in Labette County but no further There all track and trace of him ceased
A passerby finds the Bender homestead abandoned with a starved calf and undisturbed furniture, prompting Senator York to investigate his missing brother's disappearance. A search reveals a blood-stained trapdoor pit and the garden yields the body of Dr. York, killed by a skull blow and a cut throat.
The Sun · 4 August 1880 · page 4
THE CRIME OF THE CENTURY
minutely looked Into and subjected to the ap i plication ot rods and levers to see I the floor lug was either hollow or loose Nothing came of I No blood spots appeared Tho floor was solid The walls wore solid Next the party D searched the back room The beds were re I moved In their flight the Benders bad left everythIng untouched t A slight depression wu noticed In the floor which upon closer examination revealed a trap js door Ibis was lilted up and In the gloom pit outlined Itself forblddlrg cavernous un i known Lights WAre procured and some of the men descended They found themselves in an I abyss shaped like a well six feet deep and v loot In diameter Here and there little damp places could be seen a though water had oome up from the bottom or ben poured down from
The article recounts the original 1873 discovery of the Bender murder farm, describing how searchers found the mutilated bodies of ten victims including Dr. York, the Longcor family, and others buried in the garden. It then claims that after seven years of fruitless search across the world, the Benders have at last been caught four days earlier and will soon face justice.
TWO HEN UNKNOWN Tho body of tho second daughter of Mr dlulhter Jlr Longear was not found I was burled In the corner ot the garden that was not carefully probed These victims had probably been attracted to the Bender house by thu conspicu ously displayed grocery sign A stranger was inveigled Into the death trap and Invited to I o glass of wino or something to cut As he sat at the bible In the back room one of his treach erous hosts smote him with n hammer crush ing In his skull and killing him Instantly but
A Kentucky paper reports an interview with H. V. Hoofman, who claims to have known the Bender family in Kansas and describes their house and habits. The piece presents a couple held in jail as possibly being identified members of the Bender family.
Press and Daily Dakotaian · 4 August 1880 · page 2
THE BEN0IR FAMIfcV, yrf the identity of the djUple in jail hore for complicity in the Bender butcheries. H. V. Hooflan, a resident of this oity.who formely resided in Labette county, Kan' sas, near the Benders, interviewed the' •ohlwew and -womnn-in iaiVnnd gnve the following interview to. ,a Fremont Hor aldreporter: Reporter—You knew the Bender fam ily? r,l Mf. Htxiflrtn—Yes I lived-seven and a half miles from their house in 1873. I herded cattle within-three-quarters of a mile of the house on Ageese creek, iboatsuto miles -northeast. of Inde ia^id abqut tlio mdehqe, same distance roui Osage mission, on" tn6 ifnain thor oughfare to the latter from Independ ence.
See moreSee less
I was there about two vears. and left there on the 16th of July, 1873, and went to Fort Scott. liep.-^You llave stfen the Benders fre quently Mr. H.—Yes I saw the old man nearly every day. I talked but very little with any bf. the others. He tried to keep peo ilo: away t'rom the house. I would now Kate Bender-by siglit have talked with her, though at some distance l'rom
A local witness (Mr. H.) describes the layout of the Bender homestead and pre-discovery rumors of the family harboring horse thieves. He then recounts visiting a jailed man who answered to recognition as 'Bender,' denied the surname but admitted witnessing eleven murders and two child burials.
Press and Daily Dakotaian · 4 August 1880 · page 2
der? Mr. H.—The first we heard of anything of the kind was wlieu the wife of a half breed called Captain Ageese was going by on the road, about thvee weeks before the York discovery. She says the old man Bender nud Kate followed her on the road, attempting to get ahead of lier. She got away from them, and reported her suspicions. For a considerable time before this it was generally understood in the neighborhood that the Benders' was the headquarters for horse thieves and hard tiharaoters. Bep.—Since the parties have been un der arrest you have seen aiid talked with them in jail here Mr.
See moreSee less
H.—Yes. When I went in Bender looked at me very close. I asked him if he had ever seen this face before, shovinj back my hat on the back of my heac He~said:-,-'t¥es,-I know you, but I can't place vou." I said: Did you know the man that used to herd near your place in Kansas?" He excliimed, excitedly "My God! yes." He asked me howl came here." I answered: "All Labette countylare tip here to see yon." He said I never done any harm in my life. You know that of me." I said: "If you haven't, they are lying terrible about vou." He said: "Well, my name is not Bender." I said: "Your name may not be Bender, "bnt you told me repeatedly that-was your name in Kansas, and it's
A newspaper correspondent recounts grilling a boy and then a captured woman about the burial locations of victims at the Bender farm, pressing them on inconsistencies in their stories. The woman eventually appears to confirm details about hidden graves and claims she was not actually married to John Bender, describing the family's flight west after the murders.
Press and Daily Dakotaian · 4 August 1880 · page 2
thgy^vfire.goiqg across over,the Missouri. Kate iftdd ,Tt)hn: Bender' were with tlie team, taking another road. They were to meet over in Iowa. Then some of the party would go to Kansas and dig up 3700 they had buried there on the old Bender place. The-womau claims that she not Bender's wife, that the latter was left when they ^wenfc south through tlie Choctaw nation in 1873, because she could not go further, when they aban doned their team, Slie thinks the old woman died in 1876. Bender has a mark over the left eye, extending diagonally
A Chicago Tribune special from Council Bluffs claims John and Kate Bender arrived from Nebraska and are believed to be waiting nearby, unaware of pending arrest. An Omaha dispatch adds a conflicting account from a Nebraska farmer who hosted a similar traveling couple using the alias McGregor.
Public Ledger · 4 August 1880 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
An Omaha Herald report describes how Sheriff Gregg arrested an elderly man and woman near Fremont after suspicious behavior and conflicting stories about their identity. A jailhouse conversation, secretly overheard, allegedly reveals the pair fear being lynched if taken to Kansas, suggesting they are indeed members of the notorious Bender family.
THE BENDER FAMILY - A COUPLE OF THEM CAUGHT AND IN JAIL
JAIL The following is tAken t from tho Omaha Herald of the 30h Borne day ago Sheriff Qrecg of tbis county was called upon by a runu named Daniel Condon ling mar fitchsnd atalion west of Subtly ler about thirty mIl train Freiuot t who aid bo thought he lied got track of the famous Bender family An old man and woman traveling on fool Iud topped at a bouse near there and soon after their ornva they made inquiries as to wh ther anything bad yet been discovered of the Bender family who formerly lived in Kar ap Their talk and actions excited suspicion which WAS further strong bened by their answers to quettious asked them and finally Condon as stated cam down alter Sherifl Gregg They immediately proceeded to that neighborbiod and tbe parties were overhauled on bo road this way They appeared cz cited and told conflicting stories as to who they wero and where they were from suid they had lived fivo or six years among the Indians that they bad been up m tbeNibrara country and that thEY were not the Benders ete They were brought hero and lodged in jail Here ingenious ques tioning was brought to bear on them and the etory finally brought out as published below While they were tcgether in jail a conYenatinn was overheard between them on tIme 27b of July wbicb was taken down by parties who were concealed near by
A man and woman apprehended during the ongoing manhunt are separately questioned, with the woman giving a detailed confession describing the Bender family's murder operation, including the trap-door dining room and graves in the garden. The man, identified as a possible accomplice named McGregor, pleads for a letter proving his identity while the woman implicates the Benders in numerous killings.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Salt Lake Herald · 4 August 1880 · page 4
A COUPLE OF THEM CAUGHT AND IS...
down as given The woman said The Bender had to run away from Illinois Tbe were in the same business there wbai they were afterward in Kansas I was wiffl the old man all the tim he WES with tho Benders I dont
A person claims to have stayed at the Bender house and witnessed multiple murders, describing the trapdoor cellar method and naming the Bender family as killers. The testimony is self-contradictory, with the informant changing details about how long they stayed and what they saw under cross-questioning.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Salt Lake Herald · 4 August 1880 · page 4
money at all We went with the Benders from the place of the mur der to the railroad station I dont know what town there they took the train eoutb they would not take ns along The old man told the Benders that if they would not give them money be the old man would tell on them they didnt aay anything to tbat Ihave seen a good many pea < pie killed at Benders house My husband was sick at Benders bouEo and I was waiting on him I think there were moro than ton persons killed while I was in the house The Benders talked freely of these mur ders in my presence The old man Bender Mrs Bender Kate Benoer and John Bender jr done the mur dering The old man went by the name of John Bonder in Kansas The old man when he was told 1 that she had confessed by degrees told his story as published below I was only ono night at Benders house That day a young man came from California and stopped at Ben dens to get something to eat He asked Kate what made the house smell so She said there was nothing He said hs would not stay over niebt in the bouse he would go and get people to search the houseand when he people came they found eome bodies under the bouse six or seven of them When the Benders saw bat they were found out they went ight off left and then I started for liinoia They put two children in a ole that game night and covered them up with dirt The man from ali oraia was tho one that seen them c uildrtn alive The way I came to Kansas that time was that I Has jminc from the westfrom Fort incoln They killed a man the night I was there be was not a very old man I was not in the rood where he was killed it was dark I I could not see very well the door of the room I was in was open I was at Benders house two and onehalf days but no longer Here the old man was closely crossquestioned and he finally made this further confession I was at the Bender house just six weeks The Benders I dont know i where they went to I went to Jack sonville Illinois traveling on foot called himself McGregor About four weeks after the Bendeis left Kansas I saw Kate Bender between Springfield Illinois and Jackson ville she had mens clothes on she bud her hair cut nfl short I met her on the road I knew her the very minute I saw her I iinov of six people killed while I was at the house There was ono family killed while I was tbslea man hia wife and children two of the children were buried alive I My oie was born in Illinois her folka moved to Missouri she was formerly married to George Ellison her name was Nancy Ellison before I i married her My first wife died at Jacksonville fifteen er sixteen years ago she died two years before the war her name WAS Polly she was old J
The article reports that old man Bender and his wife, long sought for the notorious Kansas murders, have finally been captured and jailed in Fremont, Nebraska. It recounts their alleged confessions of murdering travelers and burying children alive, while authorities pursue the younger Benders, John and Kate.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Wheeling Register · 4 August 1880 · page 1
A LONG LIST OF OTHER VILLAINIES. The gang of fiends in human shape known as the Bender family, whose bloody deeds in Kansas, Missouri and elsewhere* in the West, six or seven years ago, will be readily recalled by the reading public, has at last been unearth ed and old roan Bender and his wife
Sheriff Gregg arrested an elderly couple in Fremont, Nebraska believed to be the elder Benders, while authorities pursued the younger couple toward Iowa. A witness reported the old man confessed to seeing eleven murders, and he was tricked into revealing he spoke German, matching the suspected Bender's background.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Mr. Gregg has since learned that the young couple crossed the river at Omatia with a wagon and team ami went into Iowa, no doubt en route to the place of meeting agreed upon by them and the old folks. Sheriff Gregg says that when he ar rested the old couple he rode up to theiu and said: "Hello, Kate." The woman replied: "I ain't Kate Bender." Gregg believes he 1ms a sure thing on the old man, but thinks the woman Mnn.lxr'a mUlrM*. nn<l tliat they have Killed his wife. The original old Iiender was a German, and had a big scar on the centre of his head. The prisoner at Fremont has a scar, but swears he doesn't know a word of German. A Dutchman was put in the cell with in structions to curse him in his natural tongue. Old Bender forgot himself and swore terrifically at the man in German. Bender asked for a razor to shave, but Gregg, fearing he would commit suicide, refused, anil had the barber to shave him. Sheriff Gregg is determined to capture young Bender, and it is understood 125,000 re ward is offered for the whole gang. Of this amount $11,000 is for the old man. Omaha. August, 3.—A dispatch from Fremont, Neb., says: Further develop ments make almost certain the identity of the couple in jail here for complicity in the Bender butcheries. II. V. lloop lar, of this county, who formerly resided in I^abelle county, Kas., near the Ben ders, interviewed the old man and wo man in jail yesterday. He says: "I asked him if he had seen anybody murdered there. He said he had seen eleven persons murdered. Questioned closely, he admitted having helped to kill and bury them, and exclaimed: "Letthem hang me." "He said he would not go back to Kansas; he would kill himself first." Mr. Hooplar then went ami saw the woman captured with Bender. She commenced laughing when asked if she knew him, and answered, "Yes, I do know you. How do yon do, Mr. Hoop | iin? I the name she called him by]. '! never expected to see you any inoie. I i don't want to talk with >on.' He said: "You are captured at last." ! She answered: "Yes, we are. They will hang us." He a*k»d her what Blie was going 10 do, ami she said: "You know that that's John Bender; there is no use to deny it [ any longer. I am going to tell the truth; if that don't save me from being hung I'll have to hang." Mrs Bender Relates the Infamoua Ex ploits of the (Jang— A Whole Family Murdered—Children Buried Alive.
A man and woman held in Fremont, Nebraska are identified as John Bender and his wife, with the man allegedly confessing to helping murder eleven people. The woman reportedly gives a detailed confession describing the killing of strangers and a family with two children at the Bender farm.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The report claims that two, and possibly all, of the notorious Bender family—infamous for a string of murders at their Kansas wayside inn in 1873—have been found, with a man and woman arrested in Nebraska believed to be John Bender and his daughter Kate. A former neighbor reportedly identified the old man, though was less certain about the woman, and authorities are said to know the whereabouts of the rest of the family.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Litchfield Enquirer · 5 August 1880 · page 2
An additional proof of the old maxim that “murder will Qut” has occurred in the discov ery of two at least, and perhaps all, of the no torious Benders whose murders in Kansas, in 1873 made a great noise at the time. They, had a solitary house on the Osage Mission road, and kept a sort of wayside tavern. Here they committed a great number of mur ders, burying the bodies of their victims in their garden, where the remains of ten persons were found. The Ben.lers, four in number, escaped at the time, and all traces of them were lost.
See moreSee less
Last week a man and woman were arrested in Nebraska who, it is supposed, are John Bender, the father, and his daughter Kate. On Friday a man woo formerly lived in their neighborhood, indentifled the old man as John Bender, but was not so positive as to the woman. It is said that the officers have knowledge of the whereabouts of the rest of the family. The Commissioner of Patents recently made a statement which can hardly be considered encouraging to Inventors. He says that not one patent in fifty pays the cost of obtaining it. The chief of the issue division gives the poor patentee a better showing, estimating that one out of every four patents proves a paying investmeut. We incline to the less favorable estimate. Of course there are a few whose value is simply inestimable; very many more, of great value ; others, whose re turns have proved moderate. We imagine, however, that what Mr. Whitney used to term the “bogus” is the rule; the valuable patent, the exception.
A dispatch from Fremont claims Mrs. Bender (alias McGregor) has been apprehended and made a full confession about the Bender family murders of 1872-73, blaming her stepdaughter Kate as the ringleader while denying her own direct involvement. It describes her appearance and manner in custody alongside her husband.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Evening Star · 5 August 1880 · page 3
BUTCHERED AND THEIR BABES BURIED ALIVE
00 the time that she married Metiregor. alKis Ren. der. who was a widower with four ehlldren.two of whom were Kate and John, lr. They ml?n. grated trom Missouri to Labette county. Kas and became John Bender and famllv. She is
A woman identified as Mrs. Bender (also called McGregor) gives a detailed, rambling account from her jail cell of the murders committed by the Bender family, describing victims including Dr. York and a family with two little girls who were allegedly buried alive. The report includes an editorial correction noting the family's real name was Longcor, not Grackmore/Blackmore as stated.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Evening Star · 5 August 1880 · page 3
...AND THEIR BABES BURIED ALIVE
" Who was the first person killed by the family?" fO. " He was a sick man named Brown. He came alor.g one afternoon. The house was a goodsized one. and on a sign was '<;rooerles' outside the door, and seeln' this he stopped. We '? took him in. and the second night we got him up to eat supper, and while seated at the table J ?hn Bender let him Into the cellar,where Kate or John killed hlm.and the next day they burled t m in the garden." " Ilow long after this before any one else was killed?" p " I don't quite remember, but not long. Two
A woman gives a detailed confession describing Bender family murders, including Kate killing a man in bed and horse-thieves using the house as headquarters, while a separate dispatch reports an unsuccessful search in Iowa for 'young Bender and wife' following an earlier arrest near Fremont. The old man arrested made a slip of the tongue saying 'We' instead of 'They' when describing the killings, suggesting guilt.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Evening Star · 5 August 1880 · page 3
Omaha, Neb., August 2, says: Daniel c'ongdon returned to Omaha last evening after an unsuccessful search in Iowa for young Bender and wife. He Is the man who gave the Information leading to the arrest of old Bender and wire n^ar Fremont. They asked to eat and sleep at his , house near Schuj ler, and he turned them over
Multiple wire dispatches report possible sightings of John and Kate Bender in Iowa and Nebraska, with a Kansas sheriff setting out to bring the old couple back believing them genuine. A competing account claims a similar couple seen were actually named McGregor, casting doubt on the identification.
to affairs. . >^ ■. . . ' BELIEVED GENUINE. . ;.- Osweoo, Kb., Aug. 4.— The sheriff of this county starts for Nebraska to-night to bring the Bender family here, where they made a grave yard of travelers several yean ago. They are believed to be the genuine Bender*. : ['"^\\
Authorities in Nebraska arrest an old man and a young woman believed to be members of the Bender family wanted for the Kansas murders. The man admits involvement in the killings while the woman denies being Kate Bender but hints she may confess to save herself.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Mower County Transcript · 5 August 1880 · page 1
The Render Family Again
Bender family who have committed so many murders in Kansas. The woman denies that they are Benders but the old man admits that he was at Bender's six weeks, and explains his presence there by saying he stopped while en route for the east'from Fort T.innnln. He saw six people murdered when at Bender's house one entire family was killed, two children being buried alive. It is fully believed by all who have seen them that, if the genuine Benders are not captured, at least two im portant witnesses have been secured.
See moreSee less
The sheriff believes he has got the genuine Benders, and thinks he has got a clew to the where abouts of young John Bender. A man who used to know the Benders in Kansas visited the two prisoners in the jail at Fremont, Neb., on the 31st ult. Both of them recognized him, and the man admitted that he wes the senior Bender, and that he assisted at some of the burking that was done at his house. The woman denies that she is Bender's wife, but confesses guilt by saying that she will try to save her neck by telling all she knows. She says the old woman was left in Indian Territory, in 1873. when the Benders abandoned their team. The old man was told that John and
An old man and young woman arrested near Fremont, Nebraska are believed to be members of the notorious Bender family wanted for multiple Kansas murders. The man reportedly admits to being the senior Bender and confesses to witnessing and assisting in killings, while the woman denies being Bender's wife but hints she may confess to save herself.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Mower County Transcript · 5 August 1880 · page 2
The Bender Family Agraln. An old man and a young woman who were arrested neat Fremont, Neb., on the 29th ult., we supposed to be members of the notorious
Two prisoners held in Fremont, Nebraska are questioned about the Bender murders; the man admits being at the Bender homestead and witnessing killings, while the woman denies being Kate Bender but hints she may confess to save herself. The sheriff believes he has captured the genuine Benders and a lead on son John Bender's whereabouts.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Mower County Transcript · 5 August 1880 · page 2
Bender family who have committed BO many murders in Kansas. The woman denies that they arc Benders but the old man admits that lie was at Bender's six weeks, and explains his presence there by saying he stopped while en route for the east "from Fort Lincoln. He saw six people murdered when at Bender's house one entire family was killed, two children being buried alive. It is fnlly believed by all who have seen them that, if the genuine Benders are not captured, at least two im portant witnesses have been sccured.
See moreSee less
The sheriff believes he has got the genuine Benders, and thinks he has got a clew to the where abouts of young John Bender. __ A man who used to know the Benders in Kansas visited the two prisoners in the jail at Fremont, Neb., on the 31st ult. Both of them recognized him, and the man admitted that he was the senior Bender, and that he assisted at some of the burking tnat was done at his house. The woman denies that she is Bender's wife, but confesses guilt by saying that she will try to save her neck by telling all she knows. She says the old woman was left in Indian Territory, in 1873, when the Benders abandoned their team. The old man was told that John and Kate had been caught, and had charged him with being the chief criminal. At this ho be came very angry, and cursed them roundly. Self-Murder. Max Burckliardt, editor and proprietor of The Humorist, a German weekly, suicided at San Francisco, Cal., on the 1st instant, by mor pliine. A Baltimore German, 55 years old, committed at the newlv-made Steuben county, Pa., on the 29th ult., Mrs. William C'rance sot lire to her dwelling. After she had watched her home
Sheriff Gregg captured a middle-aged man and woman in Fremont, Nebraska, believed to be the notorious Kansas murderers Old Man Bender and Kate. Both reportedly gave partial confessions and were held pending identification by parties from Kansas.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Independent Statesman · 5 August 1880 · page 6
CURRENT MENTION
Bender and Kate, the notorious murder ers, of Kansas. Both have made a par tial confession. They will be held until the arrival of parties from Kansas to identify them. Mrs. Brown, the mother of “Artemus Ward,” is mentioned by the Boston Jour nal as 2 bright and busy old lady of 70 years, now living at Waterford, Maine, where her son is buried. She has a great love for gardening. Her pride and affec tion are pleasantly shown when visitors come to look at the house where the mer ry Artemus” was born. 4 The mother of United States Senator Grover, of Oregon, died last week at
A short news note claims the notorious Bender family, the Kansas murderers, have been captured in Nebraska. This item appears among a list of miscellaneous news items of the day.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Jackson Standard · 5 August 1880 · page 2
Tiiey have had frost in Rhode Island, and snow in New Hampshire. The notorious Bender family, the Kansas murder ers, have been captured in Nebraska. Gex. Wahn-eu was nominated by acclamation, for Congress, by the Democrats of the 15th District.
This miscellaneous news roundup includes a brief item stating it seems 'pretty certain' that John and Kate Bender, the notorious Kansas murderers, have been captured in Nebraska. The item appears amid dozens of unrelated snippets of national and international news.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The New Northwest · 5 August 1880 · page 3
GENERAL NEWS.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
The report recalls Dr. William York's 1873 disappearance near Cherryvale, Kansas, as the opening thread in unraveling the Bender family's crimes. It then announces that the Benders have now been arrested in Fremont, accused of murdering eleven people, including two children said to have been buried alive.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Memphis Daily Appeal · 5 August 1880 · page 2
SINCE SAWNEY BEAN And His Incestuous Family of Cannibals Were Hanged In Scotland, the World Has Heard of No Such Gang of Murderers as the Benders, Now Under Arrest in Fremont, Charged with the Murder of Eleven Persons, Two of Them Little Children, Whom the Brutes Buried Alive
Burled Alive. . Kansas Citv Times: The crimes for which a price have been set upon the heads of the Bender family are ot a nendisa ana revolting nature. It seems a strange rt flection upon
The report describes the fruitless search for Dr. York before focusing on the Bender family, who ran a roadside grocery and inn near Cherryvale and vanished suspiciously after being questioned. A passerby's discovery of their abandoned house, with a starved calf and undisturbed furniture, prompted the dead man's brother to alert authorities, leading to their eventual capture in Nebraska.
Memphis Daily Appeal · 5 August 1880 · page 2
THB BENDER FAMILY. There were four ot them; father, mother, son and dnuahter. The mother was a Spirit ualist. She called herself a medium: the neighbors called her a she-devil. She had a wav of boiling herbs and roots that were supposed to have charms and spells about tbem, and she dealt in incantations. She was repulsive in aspect tall, angular and scraw ny, with hard, steel-gray eyes, and thin, ragged gray hair straggling over ber temples, The rest of the family seemed to have been totally under the influence of this ungainly creature.
See moreSee less
- Her word with them was law The Benders ostensibly kept a grocery; a sign to that effect was displayed in front' of their rude dwelling. However, tne only ar tide they dealt in was cheap native wine, which wea served on the spot. There were two rooms in the house one nsed as a kitch en and dining-room, and the other as a sleep ing apartment. While the excitement over the mysterious disappearance of Dr. York wa at itahlaht. a party ot Cherryvale eiti zens caauallyaropped In at the Deader-mm sion and as casually inquired of tbe family if mey nao at any time during the past six weeks seen anything of York. The answer was in the negative and the subject dropped. The visit and the questioning of the Cherry vale party had a strange street upon the Hen' aers. iney -
A man and woman believed to be John Bender and his daughter Kate were arrested in Dodge County, Nebraska after arousing suspicion near Schuyler. The woman initially denies being a Bender but gives a confused, shifting account of having witnessed killings at the Bender homestead.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Manitowoc Pilot · 5 August 1880 · page 4
| woman, supposed to Ih> John Bender and his daughter Kate, the notorious Kansas murderers, have been arrested in Dodge ; County, this {State, and are now in jail at ! From ;it. They were arrested in Colfax, | near Schuyler, coming East. They had j excited suspicion at Richland Station, w, ;-t of Schuyler, This information was conveyed to Sheriff Gregg, of Dodge county, who went out, found, and arrest ( ej them. A conversation was overheard | between them, iu which the old man said ho “Knew if he came back toward Kansas he would be hung.” consequent ly the two were separated, and be is | made to believe she is sent down to Kan !
See moreSee less
sas ahea lof him. She denies that they arc the Benders, but says the old man is her husband, and that he had nothing to do with the murders. She confesses, though, that she stopped for a little while at tho home of the Benders, and says Dr. York’s brother was murdered while she was there. She says they went to the railroad with ilie Benders when they fled. The Benders took a train South, and would not take her or her uusoand along. She saw at least ten people killed at Ben der’s, and says her husband was sick there and she was nursing him. His story was, at first, ihat he was on ly one l ight at Bender’s, aud sa>s ia name is McGregor. He says the night the Benders left Kansas they put the children iu a hole and covered them with dirt. The same nip id they killed a man who stopped there. When closely cross-questioned he admitted he was at Bender’s six weeks, and explains his presence there by say ing he stopp 'd while on route for the East from Fort Lin.-ohi. lie dont know where the I tenders went to when they ieit Kunsis. Ho went to Jacksonville, Hi., traveling on foot, and called himself McGregor. Four weeks after he say
A woman and man captured as possible Bender suspects give contradictory testimony about the murders, claiming to have witnessed multiple killings at the Bender home while fleeing. The man, calling himself McGregor, changes his story under cross-examination, admitting he stayed six weeks at the Benders' and saw people killed including children buried alive.
The Manitowoc Pilot · 5 August 1880 · page 4
Kate Bender between Springfield and Jacksonville, Dl. She had men’s clothes on and her Lair was cat short. He saw six people murdered when at Bender's house, and one entire family was killed, two children being buried alive. He says his wife was born in Illinois, and she was the wife of George Ellison be fore he married her. His lirst wife died at Jacksonville sixteen years ago, and her name was Polly Peasley. They both say they Lave been five or six years among the Indians. An apnli cation for a requisition has been made to the Governor of Kansas.
See moreSee less
It is fuiiy be lieved by all who have seen them that, if the genuine Benders are not captured, at least two important witnesses have been secured. The Sheriff believes he has got the genuine Benders, and thinks he has got a clew to the whereabouts of
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Correspondents report sightings of John and Kate Bender near Council Bluffs and of an older couple believed to be the senior Benders passing through Nebraska in July. The Labette County sheriff departs for Nebraska to bring back a couple believed to be the genuine Bender family wanted for the Kansas murders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 5 August 1880 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A man and woman arrested in Fremont, Nebraska are reported to be members of the Bender family, wanted for the 1873 Kansas murders of York and others. The woman reportedly claims she will confess, says the old man is a genuine Bender, and describes their years hiding among Indians before returning east for hidden money, with two more family members traveling separately to rendezvous in Iowa.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Canton Register · 6 August 1880 · page 2
The news received on the 31st ult. left no doubt that the mau and woman who were recently arrested at Fremont, Neb., are members of the Bender family, on whose farm in Kansas the remains of the murdered York and ten other bodies were discovered in 1873. The woman of the party Baid she would confess all about the murders, and in sisted that, although she is not a Bender, the old man is, and that she knows every thing concerning the murders. A resident of Fremont, who lived near the Benders, recognized the old man.
See moreSee less
It appears from the woman’s statement that the Benders fled from their place in 1873 when it be came apparent that the relatives and friends of Mr. York began to suspect them of having been instrumental in his taking-off. They have since lived among the Indians, and have encountered such great hardships that they determined ou returning •ast, one of the objects being to obtain some money hid away on the Bender farm. With the two persons arrested came two other lembers of the family, who traveled with a team by another route. They were to meet in Iowa. Officers were ou the lookout for them, and there was a good chance that the murderous pair would be arrested. The complete census returns of the State of New Hampshire show a total of 347, 211; a gain of 29,011 since 1870. The six cities of the State stand as follows: Manchester, 32,45S; Concord, 13,841; Nashua, 13,453; Do ver, 11,603; Portsmouth, 9,734; Keene, 6,786.
A dispatch from Fremont, Nebraska reports that a woman calling herself Mrs. McGregor has confessed to being Mrs. Bender, wife of John Bender, and gives details of the Bender farm murders of 1872-73 while blaming daughter Kate as the real leader. She describes her background, appearance, and time living among northern Sioux tribes.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Canton Register · 6 August 1880 · page 2
THE BENDERS. Tfc« hpMwd Mn. Beaier, Arrested At FrcAoot, JleK, Mskei m CooffcaalM—A Horrible and llckealac Story. A Fremont (Neb.) special to the Chi cago Tribune of the 3d says: Further startling developments were made in the Bender matter to-uay. Mr*. Bender, or Mrs. McGregor, made a full and complete confession of the whole matter, even to the minutest details regarding the butcheries perpetrated on the John Bender farm during 1S72 and 1873. She denies having had uny personal hand in the matter, but says Kate, old John’s daughter, was the leader ot all the deviltry.
See moreSee less
She went over her entire history from the time she became Mrs. Alexander McGregor. She was a widow at the time she married McGregor, alias Bender, who was a widower with four children, two of whom were Kate and John, Jr. They migrated from Mis souri to Labette County, Kan., and became John Bender and family. She is under the im pression that Kate has been captured, and,
Canton Register · Canton, Ill. · and 1 other paper
A woman held in custody, identified as Mrs. McGregor/Bender, gives an interview recounting her marriage history and the family's move to Kansas, describing the killing of a sick man named Brown as the gang's first murder. She shifts blame onto others while claiming she never killed anyone, as a reporter presses her for details.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Canton Register · 6 August 1880 · page 2
Being asked if she would be called Mrs. Mc Gregor or Mrs. Bender, she replied: *• i'he latter will do if vou be satisfied, as you be here to see Mrs. jieuder.” “You have no objection to giving a little history of your life f” “Oh, no; for the Sheriff has told me that I am to be free, and not to go to Kansas with the ole man, and I uever did kill no one any “ Were you married to Bender in Kansas I” “I was a widow, and he mariied me at
Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · 12 August 1880
The Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
A dispatch reports that two men held at Fremont, suspected of being Bender family members, were identified by a former Jacksonville, Illinois resident as the McGregors, known hard characters who had traveled west with him. Springfield records showed an Alexander McGregor and Nancy Ellington, both poorhouse inmates, married in 1871 and vanished from the parish rolls that August.
Erisoners at Fremont, supposed to be tbe lenders, as the McGregors, of Jackson ville. The man pays the knew them there as hard characters, and he left Illinois for Kansas with them in a wagon train, and that McGregor, who is thought to be iden tical with the (Bender, went to Labette county, " The Tribune s Springfield, Ills,, says the records of that county show that in 1871 Alexander McGregor obtained a marriage license for himself and Nancy Ellington, both inmates of the poor house. ' They were married and remained a charge upon the parish until the August following when they disappeared.
A miscellany column wryly observes that the Bender murders resurface in newspapers on a regular cycle, comparing this recurrence to other perennial topics like Charlie Ross. It references a separate item headlined 'Mrs. McGregor, alias Bender, Gives Her Account of the Cherryvale Butcheries' as evidence of the story's renewed appearance.
The Emporia News · 6 August 1880 · page 2
HERE AND THERE.
It really seems too bad thut the period. ical Bender should come to tbe front again just asJudge Vrooman's little boom let was fairly netting underway. Tbe Cherryvalc butchers, with all their mul tifarious crimes, never did anythin more utterly heinous than to step in just at this inopportune moment and usnrp the place of thut eminent statesman the public mind.
A man who once lived near the Benders in Kansas identifies an elderly prisoner at Fremont, Nebraska as 'old man Bender,' though he is less certain about the woman, who denies being Kate Bender. Sheriff Gregg describes tracking and arresting the pair near Schuyler, and says the old man refuses to be taken back to Kansas alive.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Emporia News · 6 August 1880 · page 2
march of human piagretm. I am, wi!l great resjiect, very truly yours, Wru-IAM H. English. The Binder. TTi Party Airetwl at Pr munt ldc utided as the Old Hon. Fkemost, Xtb., July 31. To-day a man named Hootlan, who formerly re sided in the Bender's neighborhood in Kansas, and who knew the old man per sonally, was admitted to the prisoner's presence, and ideptified the man as being actually old man Bender. He is not so positive as to the woman. The woman claims that Mrs. Bender died in lt76. Tbe whereabouts of Kate and John Bender, Jr, have been disclosed, and of. fleers are en route to capture them. The prisoners were to have met Jobn Bender to-day In thistat. Omaha. Neb., August 1. Sheriff
The item reports that two prisoners recently arrested in Nebraska are believed to be 'Old Man' Bender and his wife of Kansas, who had made murdering and robbing their guests a business. It notes that in 1873 ten or twelve bodies were found buried in their garden.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Aegis & Intelligencer · 6 August 1880 · page 3
—Two prisoners arrested a few days ago in Nebraska, are believed to be the notorious John or Old Man Bender and his wife, of Kansas, who several years ago made robbery and murder of their guests a regular business. After their ilgli 1
An old man and woman have been arrested in Nebraska who are claimed to be the original Benders, the family accused of numerous murders in Kansas years earlier. The report states they fled after suspicions were raised against them.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Weekly Visitor · 6 August 1880 · page 2
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Weekly Arizona Citizen · Tucson, Ariz.
A telegraphic dispatch from Omaha reports that a woman held in Fremont jail, claiming to be the elder Mrs. Bender, continues giving detailed confessions of the family's killings, starting with a murder in Jacksonville, Illinois, and continuing through their time in Kansas. She describes the trapdoor method used to kill victims and claims ignorance of murders committed solely by the younger Benders.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Weekly Arizona Citizen · 7 August 1880 · page 2
THE BENDERS AGAIN.
More Confension of Crime by the Ken dew. OMArtA, August 7. Old Mrs. Ben der "continues to bold receptions In the jail in Fremont, and continues to confers in her talks. She occasionally throws additional light on the past life and crimes of tbe Bender family To-day, among other things, she said that when she married Bender, alias McGregor, at Springfield, Illinois, his two children John and Kale were in Kansas Tho first murder wa3 com mittcd by old Bender and his wife
A reporter interviews an old woman and old man separately, each giving matching but elaborate confessions claiming to be members of the Bender family, describing a trapdoor murder method and various killings in Illinois and Kansas. The man, calling himself 'Alexander McGregor,' gives a convoluted family history and openly admits to being Bender while his wife is said to believe she escaped detection.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Weekly Arizona Citizen · 7 August 1880 · page 2
THE BENDERS AGAIN.
Kate and Maggie, but were never harmed. She then related the adven tures during their flight from Labette count-. Tho reporter who spent the afternoon witb Mrs. Bender, also call ed on the old man, who was under the delusion that his wife had escaped and told the complete history of his life. He corroborated ihc old woman's con fession nnd described tbo killing of the man in Illinois and the murders in Kansas exactly as the old woman told it. He makes no secret of being Bender, and gives a complete history
This report recounts a purported confession describing the Bender family's killing methods, including stabbings, a hammer attack on a peddler, and the burial of two young children alive. It also notes that a Kansas sheriff has arrived with a requisition for the Benders but admits he has never seen them.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Weekly Arizona Citizen · 7 August 1880 · page 2
wagon. Sheriff D-tnlel M. Bender, from Kan sas, has arrived at Fremont with a re quisition from the Governor of Kansas, be does not know tbe Benders, has never seen them before.
This report says the Kansas sheriff is expected to take custody of John and Kate Bender, who were reportedly only a few miles ahead of pursuers near Avoca, Iowa. It also claims confessions that another victim, Holbrook, was murdered with $2,000 on him, and alleges John and Kate were siblings living as man and wife with four children.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Morning Journal and Courier · 7 August 1880 · page 3
THEWESTi Nebraska. The Benders Further Details of their Sickening Exploits. Fbemont, Aug. G. The sheriff of Habbe tite county, Kansas, is expected to-day to take
Old Mrs. Bender, held at Fremont jail, confesses details of the family's crimes, describing the first murder committed near Jacksonville, Illinois by herself and her husband using a trap-door and hatchet. She also recounts their travels through Iowa, Indiana, and Kansas, where the notorious Bender inn operated with Kate, John, and a cousin Maggie.
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 7 August 1880 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
THE BENDER FIENDS. Ho,rrifying Confessions of the Monsters.
The Bender Fiends—Horrifying Recitals. THE OLD WOMAN'S STORY.
See moreSee less
OMAHA, August 6th.—Old Mrs. Bender continues to hold receptions in the jail at Fremont, and continues to confess. In her talks she occasionally throws additional light on the past life and crimes of the Bender family. To-day, among other things, she said that when she married Bender, alias McGregor, at Springfield, Ill., his children, John and Kate, were in Kansas. The first murder committed by old Bender and wife was at their place near Jacksonville, Ill. One afternoon a man rode up to their house and asked to stay all night, and she made him pay in advance. He exhibited a large roll of money. Her husband had fixed a trap-door, and when this man was sitting at supper he stepped up behind him and split his head in two with a hatchet. The murdered man was short, thick-set, had black hair and whiskers, his chin being shaved. The body was thrown into the cellar temporarily, and afterwards buried back of the house. She did not get any of the money. The old man must have got it. They remained on the farm only a few weeks after that, and moved to Iowa City. They lived on the money obtained from the murdered man. They went to Indiana, lived there eight months; then moved to Kansas, where Kate and John were, and also Maggie, a cousin. These three had been keeping a tavern, and called it Bender's Hotel. The old woman does not know of any murders committed by John, Kate and Maggie before she and the old man came there. The old man said he would fix a trap-door like that in Illinois, to let men into the cellar to be chopped to death with hatchets by Kate and Maggie. The old woman then described at length the modus operandi of the various murders. They always found what customers had money. She also states that Kate allowed men to sleep with her and then cut their throats and slept soundly afterwards till morning. She told of one such case in detail, and said the man's money was divided between them. Kate had a lover who would "steer" men to the place. Horse thieves and cut-throats used to be entertained by Katie and Maggie, but were never harmed. She then related their adventures during their flight from Labette county.
Your reporter, who spent the afternoon with Mrs. Bender, also called on the old man, who, under the delusion that his wife had escaped, told the complete story of his life, corroborating the old woman's confession. He describes the killing of the man in Illinois and the murders in Kansas exactly as the woman told it. He makes no secret of being Bender, and gives a complete history of Kate, John and Maggie.
CONFESSION OF THE OLD MAN.
OMAHA, August 6th.—Bender has made the following statement: My name is Alex. McGregor; was born in the State of New York; lived there till married to my first wife, who when married had one child called William Houck, begotten in adultery; after being married two weeks John Bender, my son, was born; then moved to Illinois, where Kate was born; Kate and John were good children, but ran away when 17 years old and went to Kansas; my first wife died in Illinois with consumption; after two years I married my second wife; she had three children; her name was Nancy Peasley; the children all died; had no children by my second wife; while living in Illinois I committed my first murder; killed a short, dark-haired man, and sent him down cellar through a trap door; got some money from him; buried him back of the house two rods; the old woman helped bury him; went to Independence, Ia.; worked on a farm at my trade (blacksmithing) there; after a while went to Kansas; had heard from Kate and John, who wrote for me to come on; went to Kansas to live with John and Kate; Maggie, his cousin, was there, at a place called Bender's Hotel; after being there a few days helped John make a trap door the same as I had in Illinois; the first man killed wouldn't get on the trap door; he and Kate slept together, and she killed him with a butcher knife; she showed me the knife; we burned him near the house; the only man I ever killed alone in Kansas was a peddler; I hit him on the back of the head with a stone-hammer; hit him once; got a good deal of money from him; don't know how much; I remember others that were killed; one man John killed and put him under the ice; two little children, both girls, were buried alive; the children were seven or eight years old; their parents were killed the day before; I used to stand behind a curtain and push the trap-door; Kate and Maggie were always down cellar to cut the victims' throats; I often heard them whetting their knives; John and Kate used to sleep together; Leander Smith was Kate's lover; Justice Grimshaw used to be Maggie's man; after leaving Kansas we went with the Indians; we thought this spring we must go to Illinois to die; started with old Kate, John, Maggie and four children; the old woman and I left them at Schuyler; they had a team of old horses, one bay and one gray, and an old wagon.
Sheriff Daniel M. Bender, from Kansas, has arrived from Fremont with a requisition. He does not know the Benders and has never seen them before.
A reporter claims to have interviewed an old woman and old man in custody, each independently confessing to the Bender murders and corroborating details about trapdoors, throat-cutting, and victims' money. The old man, giving his name as Alex McGregor, details a lifetime of murders starting in Illinois and continuing in Kansas with his children John and Kate and niece Maggie.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 7 August 1880 · page 8
THE OLD WOMAN'S STORY.
("dteer" mentotha placo. Horse thieves and c it-throats use i to be entertained by Katie and Maggie, but were never harmed. She then related their adventures during their " flight from Labette county. Your reporter, who spent the afternoon with Mrs. Bender, also called on the old man, who, under the delusion that his wife had escaped, told the complete story of his life, corroborating the old woman's confession. He describes the killint: of the man in Illi nois and the murders in Kansas exactly as the woman told it. He makes no secret of being Bender, and gives a complete history
A man claiming to be the elder Bender gives a gruesome confession detailing murders by stone hammer, knife, and burial alive, implicating Kate, Maggie and John Bender. The report notes a Kansas sheriff who has come to collect him admits he does not actually know the Benders and has never seen them before.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 7 August 1880 · page 8
CONFESSION OF THE OLD MAN
wagon. . Sheriff Daniel M. : Bender, from Kansas, has arrived from Fremont with a requisition. He does not know the Benders an J has never teen them before. Krri'iuiitn and ISrrennite to «.< n< i al l.;\r Held. New York, August 6th.— A reception and serenade was tendered to-night to General Garfield at the headquarters of the RepnMi can National '-■ Committee, Fifth avenue, which turned " out to be a brilliant succeev the . avenue and .' surrounding streets being thronged . with , an enthusiastic crowd. 1, The .rooms of the committee Were early thronged j I with prominent men of the Republican party.
See moreSee less
I Shortly | after ,' 8 > o'clock ~ a squad ' of «, police opened a passage in the throng, estimated to be 10,000 strong,' and escorted General Gar field to the rooms of the committee. 7As the Presidential candidate was re cognized cheer after j cheer rent the | air ; and even after he disappeared { the f crowd \ continued shouting until the General appeared on the balcony to review the precession, when a scene of great enthusiasm ■ endued. Hats i flew ; in ■ the • air, and it was with f the ; greatest | difficulty that I the police ; were able to keep a clear passage. way for the " Boys in Blue " to pass..;; First was*the colored organization, and ; then came the • G^rtield {and Arthur Clubs of different Assembly districts. - General ' Sharpe. intro duced ■ General GarfiVld, who was received with enthusiastic applause, when it subsided he said : <■■ "■■■• ■-:"• T '( Comrades and Boys in Bliri, and Fellow-citizens of New Yoik: I cannot look up n this great as.em lil-ee, an! these old veterans that have marched past us, and listen to , the welcome from our ccm ade who has just spoken,: without remembering how great a thing it is to live in the Union aud be a part of it. ■ This is New York, and yonder toward the Battery more thin 100 .years »go a young stuI dent of Columbia was arguing the idea-* of the I American Union against hid college President and ! Profeßsora. By and r by ' he .; went :to the patriot army, was ; placed' on - the ■ staff >of ■ Washington I to j fight the battles of his country, and there, before Ihe I was 21 . years old, upon a drum-head I he wrote a letter which contained the very germ of ' the Constitution of the ': United States. That student, soldier, statesman ■ and great leader of thought, Alexander Hamilton, of New York, made the republit glorious by his thir.king, and left his I last imprassi n upon New York.the foremost State of the Union ; and here, on this i.-hind, the scene cf hi? early triumphs, we gather to-night, soldiers hi? early triumphs, we gather tonight, soldiers
The item claims 'Old Bender' is jailed at Fremont and has confessed to the family's crimes, with his wife providing lurid details including an earlier murder in Jacksonville and Kate Bender's alleged killing of a roommate. It states officers are now searching for Kate Bender specifically.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 7 August 1880 · page 4
Oi.d Bender, now lu Jail nt Fremont, has confessed to bis crimes, ills wife, who Is more loquacious, says that Boodor committed bis Urst murdur at Jacksonville, lu this State. Tbo fam ily then removed to Kansas, and for a series of years committed tbo most horrible atrocities. Kate Bender, for whom tbo oflloors ore now on tbo look-out, Is said to have out iho throat of a
A brief news item states that two people believed to be old man Bender and Kate Bender, the notorious Kansas murderers, were arrested at Fremont, Nebraska. No further detail or confirmation is given in this report.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Northern Tribune · 7 August 1880 · page 1
Gen. Weaver orated at Wheeling, W. Va., Saturday, and took a decided stand in favor of the Republican party as against the Democrats. - Two old parties, supposed to be the old man Bender and Kate Bender, the no
Lawmen from Labette County, Kansas traveled to Fremont to verify whether two prisoners there are the fugitive Benders, John and Kate, while a separate telegram reports that deputies tracking the outlaws lost their trail near Coon Rapids, Iowa. The report also claims an elderly female suspect has confessed to the murder of a victim named Holbrook and described how his body was disposed of under ice.
A day or l ro more will , in all prob ability , settle the question of thi identity of the prisoners at Fremont ono way or the other. The sheriff of Labette county , to gether with several other persons , kf Oawogo , Kan. , Thursday for Fremont where thej.were expected y ; sterdaj Tfioy will of courto'atonce pass upon th identity of the prisoners , and if prc nounced genuine they will ba immc diately transported to Labette countj
A dispatch reports that the pursuit of a couple believed to be John and Kate Bender was abandoned after the trail was lost near Coon Rapids, Iowa, though officers still thought capture likely. It also relays sensational claims that the woman in custody confessed to the Benders' murder of Dr. York and admitted incest between 'John' and 'Kate,' while raising doubts about identification based on a missing thumb mark.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Omaha Daily Bee · 7 August 1880 · page 4
THE TRAIL LOST
O.d Mis. Bender has confessed tha young John and K-io are brother an sister , and they ara living together a man and wife , thus adding incest t their other crimes. John is the fathe of Kate's four children , the oldest c whom is fcven or eight years , all c them having been born while the have been wandericsr about the weal orn cruntry from place to place. Th old lady beems detcrmircd to make clean breast of everything and has n hpsicancy in tellinri anything thj cornea uppermost in her mind.
See moreSee less
Ono J. F. Hopper , of Leavenwortr having written to The Times , of tlu city , that the thumb of the genuin Bender , on the right hand , wss cut o between the hrst and second joint : a tsl-'gram wns last night sent froi this city lo Fremont to know if Mi Gregor wan thus maimed. A reply wi received that ho had both thuml all right. At first this weakem the belief in 'the old man's identit ; but on examination it was fuiind th the description furnished by the sla authorities made no mention of at such marks und It is believed th Mr. Hopper was mistaken althouj ho says that several years ago a nv was captured in Utah , and brought ! Topek * , Kan-5-s. In many respec he resembled Bender and even hi this discriptivo mark upon his han but upon examination it was provi that ho was not the Bender , but countryman of his. It is hirdly lik ly that BO important a mark could omitted in the description. A travtllina man from Kansas w in the city last n-ght and had a ta with a friend on the subject of t capture. Ha said in pcsitive ten that the genuine Benders wou
A Fremont news report describes skepticism among locals that the McGregor family held as prisoners are actually the fugitive Bender family, with some suggesting they may be impostors seeking a false-imprisonment lawsuit. It also notes contradictory statements from relatives of victim Dr. York and from Mr. Hoeflin, plus a Bender admission about a murdered man named Hodbrock and newly found marriage records.
Omaha Daily Bee · 7 August 1880 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A dispatch from Fremont, Nebraska describes an elderly woman, claimed to be part of the Bender family, confessing to additional murders including a detailed account of the first killing in Illinois. The report includes graphic descriptions of the murder method and claims other family members, including Kate, participated in luring and killing victims.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Gold Hill Daily News · 7 August 1880 · page 3
$3200 on bis person. Kate and John, the old woman aaya, are full brother and aiater and hare four ohlldren. They are in the timber near Avoce, Iowa, and will continue a to bold reoeptiona in jail and oonleae. In her talka »he ocoaaionally throw* additional light on the put lll« and Crimea ot the Bender family. Today, among other thing., aheaaid that when she married Bender, allee Mo\x=req-\ Qregor. at Springfield, Illlnola. and hie children. John and Kate. w.reinKan\x=req-\ aaa. the first murder committed by old Bender and hia wile wea at their place in Illlnole.
See moreSee less
One afternoon a man rode up to their hoaae and a«ked to atay all night, and aha made him pay In advance and he exhibited a large roll of money. Her hntband bad fixed a trap-door, and when tbla man wea altting at "PP"'h* slipped np behind him and split hie head in two with a hatchet. The
A newspaper reports an elderly man and woman in custody giving detailed confessions to the Bender murders, with the man identifying himself as 'Alexander McGregor,' the family patriarch, describing the trap-door killings in Illinois and Kansas. The woman separately corroborates the account, describing the gang's methods of robbing and killing travelers.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Gold Hill Daily News · 7 August 1880 · page 3
,uch oaae in detail, and said the man s money was dWlded between them. Kate had a lover who used to steer men, to the place. Horss-tbi.vss aiid cuUbrosU need to be entertained by Kate ^ Maggie, but were never harmed. She then related their adventures during tbeu reiaw — : » ~ their flight from Lebelte county. A re\x=req-\ nnrtAr who spout th6 afternoon with Si,a. Bender, alw called on the old man Sin. Bender, also oalled on the old man
A first-person account describes how the Benders used a trap door, knives, and a stone hammer to kill victims including a peddler and two young children buried alive. The passage ends by noting a man claiming to be 'M. Bender' arrived with a requisition but admitted he did not know or recognize the actual Benders.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Gold Hill Daily News · 7 August 1880 · page 3
Indiana. We thought thle sprlng we must go to Illinois to die. I started with Kate, John, Maggie and our children. The old women and I lett tbsm at Schuyler. They had a team of old horses-one a bay and one a gray "bS&Rm M. Bender, from Kan\x=req-\ aae. baa arriyed at Fremont with a requisition. He doee not know the
A report describes the capture near Fremont, Nebraska, of an old man and woman suspected of being John Bender and his wife, the notorious Kansas murderers. An old Kansas neighbor identifies them, and the man reportedly breaks down and admits to burying two children, though his identity remains disputed.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Douglas Independent · 7 August 1880 · page 1
AN OLD MYSTERY SOLVED
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Douglas Independent · Roseburg, Or.
A newspaper reports that captured suspects have confessed to being members of the Bender family, with the male prisoner admitting to burying children and the woman detailing their flight plans. Officers are investigating further to locate other family members and confirm identities in Kansas.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Douglas Independent · 7 August 1880 · page 1
AN OLD MYSTERY SOLVED
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Douglas Independent · Roseburg, Or.
A woman arrested with a man claimed to be old John Bender in Omaha gives a partial confession, claiming Mrs. Bender died in the Choctaw Nation in 1876 and that a young couple (Kate and John Bender Jr.) fled toward Iowa with buried money hidden in Kansas. Sheriff Gregg of Nebraska is pursuing leads on the fleeing relatives while officials prepare to transport the captured pair to Kansas for further identification.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Douglas Independent · 7 August 1880 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Grant County Herald · Big Stone City, S.D.
A report claims John and Kate Bender arrived in Council Bluffs from Nebraska, unaware that an older couple believed to be the senior Benders had been traced through Clarksville, Nebraska. The Oswego County, Kansas sheriff is said to have set out to apprehend the family and return them to the scene of their infamous murders.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Grant County Herald · 7 August 1880 · page 4
Indiana Thk notorious Bender family, »,vnu a few years ago created such a sensa tion by the numerous and bloody murders they committed in Kansas, have been discovered in Nebraska. A late telegram says that John and Kate Bender arrived in Council Bluffs from Nebraska Thursday, last. .They are supposed to be wait'ug for the old folks, of whoso arrest they are not aware. The old couple supposed to be Bender and if passed ClarksAY ville, Neb., July 12tll, saying they were going to Nebraska to take up a land claim,.
See moreSee less
The sheriff, of, Oswego county, Kansas, started Wednes day night to take the family to where they made a graveyard of travellers a few years ago. '.I'lte Sioux Falls Pantagraph con tains the following account the S. fall and miraculous escape of Win.
A Chicago Times dispatch from Fremont, Nebraska reports that an elderly man and woman believed to be the Benders are in custody, with the woman said to be freely confessing details implicating herself and 'the old man.' It also mentions a telegram claiming a wagon thought to carry John Bender Jr. and family was traced near Owaukee, Iowa.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Daily Dispatch · 7 August 1880 · page 4
A Family of Cold-Blooded Murderers OLD BENDER AND HIS WIFE UNDER ARREST THE WOMAN TALKATIVE—THE CRIMES CHARGED TO THEIR ACCOUNT—A RARE RECORD OF DESPERATE VILLAINIES
thinks ber in Kansas, and has been led to believe that she will be back in a day or two. Parties have been telegraphed to who are expected to-morrow to make more posi tive fhe identificaticn, if any is needed, Mr. H. W, Harrington is bere looking up turther details. A telegram was received here to-day stating that traces of the wagon supposed to contain Joho Bender, Jr, and family, which was lost sight of near Coun cil Binfis, has been discovered near Owau kee, Towa, and (hat parties were on the trail.
See moreSee less
The old man bas taken no steps to effect his release, but seems much worried over his situation. He declares be will never enter the State of Kansas alive. The wo man gives very minute details of the con dition and surroundings of the Bender bouse when they left it, which exactly cor responds with the description by parties who were there immediately after the ex posure. , The old man claims that he was at the house at the time, and that he crawled away on his bands and Knees; that he was there tive montbs, but bad nothing to do with the murders, Confidence has not at all weakened here that they are the original Benders now in custody.
A woman held in custody speaks freely about her and an old man's connection to the Bender case, giving details of the Bender house that match earlier accounts, while the old man denies involvement in the murders. The report also recounts the original 1873 discovery of the Bender killings in Labette County, Kansas, triggered by the disappearance of William York.
The report recounts how the disappearance of William York led neighbors to investigate the abandoned Bender homestead, where a buried, mutilated body was found in a garden plot. It describes the crude probing method used to locate graves and the gruesome wounds found on Dr. York's corpse.
The Daily Dispatch · 7 August 1880 · page 4
ALL WERE GONE
HISTORY OF THEIR CRIMES, For several years previous to the year 1872 John Bender and hs wife and two children, Kate and John, lived in the north. west corner of Labette county, Kansas, about ten miles from Thayerand five anda half miles from Cherryvale. The first thing that led to the discovery of the horrible series of murders committed by the Bender family was the disappearance of William York. of Independence, Kan., a brother of State Senator York, about the 1st of April, 1873. A diligent search resulted in finding Mr.
See moreSee less
York's body buried on the claim of the Bender family, bearing marks of violence. The party making the discove ry were horrified to find the remains of several other murdered men. On Monday, May 5, 1873, a brother of the murdered Dr. York learned that the Bender family had left their claim in Kabette cone. ty, where they had been rupning a store for the purpose of supplying travellers who passed that way. The departure of the family of murderers was discovered by some one, who in passing saw that a calf that bad been tied up had starved to death, Closer inspection showed that
A dispatch from Fremont, Nebraska reports an old man and woman in custody believed to be John Bender Sr. and his wife, with the woman talkative and cooperative while the old man denies involvement in the murders. Authorities express confidence in the identification and await witnesses to confirm it, while also tracing a wagon thought to carry other Bender family members.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Daily Dispatch · 7 August 1880 · page 4
OLD BENDER AND HIS WIFE UNDER ARREST THE WOMAN TALKATIVE THE CRIMES CHARGED TO THEIR ACCOUNT A RARE RECORD OF DESPERATE VILLAINIES
Investigators describe the murder method used at the Bender homestead, where victims were struck with a hammer through a curtain and then had their throats cut before being dropped through a trap door. The search uncovers William York's body, identified by distinctive marks, followed by seven more victims exhumed from graves on the property.
The Daily Dispatch · 7 August 1880 · page 4
THE BODY OF WILLIAM YORK was immediately recognized by Elwooc York by the general features, and by ¢ pandage on one knee, where Le had a run ning sore, and by a bandage on one finger which bad been mashed just before he hac started on his journey. The location of the place was in the north west corner of Labette county, on the roac to Osage Mission and Fort Scott, about ter miles from Thayer, and five miles and a hal from Cherryvale. Tbe building was out o view from every other house, and seems tc have been chosen expressly for the murder ous purpose to which it had been dedicated It was in the hollow of a prairie, far fron timber, where the occupants couldgsee mile in either direction, and be in no dan ger of interruption for at least balf an hour There was a stone stable on the premises where horses could be hidden until sue time as they could be run off or disposed of After the finding of York it was dcter mined to make a further search next day This was done, und the horrible diselosur made that there were at least seven othe graves on the same piece of ground.
See moreSee less
Will ing hands were soon engaged in exhuming them, and during the day the bodies of
A woman held in jail near Fremont continues giving detailed confessions about the Bender family's crimes, describing an early hatchet murder of a wealthy traveler in Illinois before the family's Kansas killings. She claims not to know of murders committed by the younger Benders before she and her husband joined them in Kansas.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 7 August 1880 · page 1
BENDERS' VICTIMS
■KXOKIS' WTOKIKM. They Tell s PvwfW SAtory »r Crime— Omaha, Aug. C.—Old Mrs. Bender continues to hold reoagUona in jail at ftPcomont, hod continues to confess. In her talks she occasionally throws addi tional light on tbo past life and crimes of the 1 tender family. Ou Friday,among other things, she said that when she married Bender, alias McGregor, at •Spriugfield, Ills., his children, John aud Kate, were in Kausas. The tlrst murder committed by old Bender and
A newspaper account claims to report a detailed confession from the elderly Bender woman and man, describing their method of luring and murdering victims with trapdoors and hatchets, and recounting the family's flight from Kansas. It also notes a Kansas sheriff's arrival with a requisition, claiming no knowledge of the suspects.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 7 August 1880 · page 1
their advontaree during the flight from Labette oouuty. The reporter, who spent the after noon with Mrs. Bender, also called ou the old man, whe, under the delusion that bis wife has escaped, told the complete story of his life, corroborating the old womau’s confession. He do described the killing of tbe man in lOinois sad tbe murders in Kansas, exactly as the old woman told It. Ho makes no secret of being Bender, nnd gives a complete history of Kate, John and Haggle. After leaving Kansas, he rays, we went with the Indians.
See moreSee less
lie thought this spring be moat go to Illinois to die; started with Kate, John end Mag gie and four ebildren. Tbo old woman and I left them at Schuyler; they had a team of old horses, one hay and one gray and an old wagon. Sheriff Daniel M. Ilender, from Kanaaa, haa arrived at Fremont with a requisition. He says lie doos not know the Benders and has never seen them before.
Sheriff Bender of Labette County, Kansas, arrived with a requisition for two suspects believed to be the fugitive John Bender and his wife, based on their resemblance and admissions made by the woman. The sheriff departed with the pair that afternoon, while the old man vowed he would not be taken there alive.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
New-York Tribune · 8 August 1880 · page 2
\THE BENDERS SENT T0 K.INSAS, Fremoxt, Neb, Aug. 7.—Sheriff’ Bender, of ‘Labette County, Kansas, arrived kere last might with & reguisiton for the return of the supposed Benders here in custody. He 1s confident from conversation with the old man and admissions of the woman, and from Lis close resemblance to the description, that he 1s the original Johu Bender, The Shenfl started with the pair this after- : (ah ii 4 & § Sah i 4 v . y 3 ii ki y - . . i id i eh Rl pa JE “J all this country, 4,000, or perhaps 5.000, of his horny Landed depot was alive with men; the tops of adjoining joy of ifs people, and in that (qual freedom that blesses Williams.
A man claimed to be Bender, handcuffed and guarded during transport, denies and then half-admits his identity under interrogation, mentioning Kansas victims and a self-defense killing in Jacksonville. His wife reaffirms her earlier confession, while the sheriff vows due process and reports no trace yet of the younger Benders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Chicago Daily Tribune · 8 August 1880 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
THE BENDER BUTCHERS
The Old Reprobate, John, and His Wife on Their Way to Kansas.
See moreSee less
Intense Excitement in Labette County Pending Their Arrival.
THE BENDERS. Special Dispatch to The Chicago Tribune.
OMAHA, Neb., July 7.—Old Bender and wife passed through Omaha this afternoon en route from Fremont to Oswego, Labette County, Kas. They will arrive in Kansas City at 8 o'clock Saturday morning by the Wabash route, via Brunswick. They are in charge of Sheriff Daniel M. Bender, of Labette County, who does not claim relationship to the prisoners. He is accompanied by Daniel Condon, of Colfax County, Nebraska, who assisted Sheriff Gregg in their capture. Bender was handcuffed, and he thought it an outrage. He didn't have much to say to the passengers, who tried to talk him to death. With your reporter, however, he conversed more freely. He at times denied being Bender, but said he was McGregor, and that he was sick at Bender's while the murdering was going on. In talking, he carelessly made admissions which corroborated his confession last night, and which tallied with his wife's confession, as published in THE TRIBUNE this morning. He said he killed a drunken man in Jacksonville, Ill., in self-defense, and hopes to be acquitted. He imagines that he is being taken to Jacksonville. He was told this in order to keep him calm, as he becomes excited whenever Kansas is mentioned. He wants to commit suicide, and asked for a pair of scissors several times, pretending that he wanted to cut his hair. He mentioned the names of several persons living at Jacksonville, but didn't seem to know any persons by name in Labette County. He says the Benders were bad people. He knew what was going on at their house, but could not get away, as he was sick. He was afraid they would kill him. Shortly after this he spoke of the Benders in such a way as to include himself among the family. He made several such bad breaks, showing that while he was trying to conceal his identity he was unable to do so at times. The old woman unhesitatingly confirmed all her previous confessions. She believes she is going to get off free by acknowledging everything. This morning at Fremont she was allowed to see her husband for the first time since their confinement. She was surprised, as she thought he had escaped. When she told him she had told everything he flew into a passion and cursed her frantically, and she had to be taken away. He says he changed his name to Bender because his children went under that name in Kansas. He remembers Dr. York, and called him the brother of Col. York. He also spoke of other Kansas victims, and again told of the murder at Jacksonville. Sheriff Bender says that, while excitement will surely run high in Labette County upon the arrival of the prisoners, they shall be protected, and if they are the real Benders they will be dealt with by due process of law. No news has yet been received concerning the whereabouts of young John, Kate, and Maggie. It is thought by some that, while the old man may really be Bender, he is not exactly of sound mind, owing to the brooding over past crimes and dark prospects.
To the Western Associated Press.
FREMONT, Neb., Aug. 7.—Sheriff Bender, of Labette County, Kansas, arrived last night with a requisition for the supposed Benders. He is confident, from conversations with the old man and the admissions of the woman (which have been uniformly positive for the past two weeks), and from his close answering to the descriptions, that he is the original John Bender. The latter confessed to killing a peddler at the former's ranch, and also a man near Jacksonville, Ill., before he left for Kansas, seventeen years ago. The Sheriff started with the pair this afternoon. The old man declares he will not be taken to Kansas alive. Nothing has been received here from the rest of the gang.
A sheriff from Labette County, Kansas arrives in Fremont, Nebraska with a requisition for a couple believed to be John Bender and his wife, confident based on their confessions and matching descriptions. The old man reportedly confessed to murders in Kansas and near Jacksonville, Illinois, while vowing he would not be taken to Kansas alive; no word yet on the whereabouts of the younger Benders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Chicago Daily Tribune · 8 August 1880 · page 2
Case at Americas, Ga. THE BENDERS. •Special Dispatch to The Chicago Tribune, Omaha, Neb., July 7.—01 d Bender and •wife passed through Omaha'this afternoon eh route from Fremont to Oswego, Labette County.- Kas. They will arrive in Kansas City at 8 o’clock Saturday morning by the Wabash route, via Brunswick. They are in charge of Sheriff Daniel' 31. Bender, of La - Bette County, who does not claim relation ship to the prisoners. He is accompanied by Daniel Condon; of Colfax County, Nebraska, who assisted Sheriff Gregg in their capture. Bender was handcuffed, ana lie thought it an.
See moreSee less
outrage. He didn’t have much to say to the passengers, who tried to talk him to death. With ydnr reporter, however, he conversed more freely. Heat times denied being Bender, but said ho was McGregor, and that he was sick at Bender’s while the murdering was go ing on. In talking, he oarelesly made ad mis&ms'wbicb corroborated his confession last night, and which tallied with his wife’s confession, as published in The Truiune this morning. He said he killed a drunken man in Jacksonville, 111., in self-defense, and hopes to be acquitted. He Imagines that he Is being taken to Jacksonville. He was told ffais in order to keep him calm, as be be comes excited whenever Kansas is men tioned. He wants to commit suicide, and asked for a pair of scissors several times, pretending that he wanted to cut his hair. He mentioned the names of sever al persons living at Jacksonville, but didn’t teem to know any persons by name in La bette County. He says the Benders were bad people. He knew what 'was going on at their house, but could not get away, as be was sick. He was afraid they would kill him. Shortly after this be spoke of the Benders in such a way as to include himself among the family. He made several such bad breaks, showing that while be was trying to conceal, his identity he was un able to do so at times. . The old woman . unhesitatingly confirmed all her previous confessions. She believes she is going te get off free by acknowledg ing everything. This morning at Fremont she was allowed to see her liusbandfor the fint time since their confinement. Site was surprised, as she thought he had escaped.. When she told him she had told everything he flew into a passion and cursed her fran tically, and she had to be taken away. ' He says lie changed his name to Bender because his children went under that , name in Kan sas. He remembers Dl .York, and called him the brother of 061; ' York. He also spoke of other. -Kansas • victims, and . again told of -the murder at Jack /sonville. Sheriff Bender says that, while excitement will surely run high in Labette' County upon the arrival" of the prison ers, they shall be protected, and if they are the real Benders they will be dealt with by due process of law. No news has yet been received concerning the whereabouts of . young John, Kate, and Maggie. It is thought by some that, while the old man may really bo Bender, he Is not exactly of sound mind, owing te the brooding, over .past crimes and . dark prospects. , v. To the I yistem Associated Press,* • Fremont. Neb.. Aug. 7.—Sheriff Bender, of Labette CountyiKansas, arrived last night With a requisition for the supposed Benders. He is confident, from conversations with the old man and the admissions of the woman (which have been uniformly positive for the past two weeks), and from his close answer ing to the descriptions, that he is the original John Bender. The latter confessed to killing a peddler at the former’s ranch, and also a man near Jacksonville, HI., before he left for Kansas, seventeen years ago. The Sheriff started with thepair this -.afternoon. -The old man declares lie will -"not be taken to Kansas alive. Nothing has been received here from thereat of the gang.
The report claims Sheriff Bender apprehended 'Old John Bender' and his wife Nancy at Fremont and were being transported back to Labette County, Kansas, amid talk of lynching. It notes the younger Bender family members remained at large.
Old John Bender, alias McGregor, and his wife Nancy, were taken in charge by Sheriff Bender, of Labette County, Kansas, at Fremont yesterday, ana ore now on their way to the scene of their fiendish atrocities. The younger members
An elderly man and woman, identified as the notorious Benders, are transported by train under guard to face justice, drawing large crowds at every stop. The husband denies being Bender even as his wife reiterates her prior confessions, and he admits to having been near the Bender property during several murders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 8 August 1880 · page 1
BUSY BENDERS
tioned. Vour reporter took a seat beside him on the train, and Bender, while deny ing to-day that lie is Bender, sgsin admitted that lie was sick at Bander’s live or six weeks, during which time live or six murders were committed. He talked quite freely about the bad headers, their misdeeds and their piemiscs. He admitted tire murder at Jacksonville, and lays he killed n drunken man in self-defense; says lie will get off free. Aflhough contradict ing .himself several times he virtually corroborated his confession of last even ing and published to-day.
See moreSee less
My impres sion is that be is not of sound mind owing to his wanderings and the con tinual thought of his crimes. He has a terrible fear of Kanra and .frequently makes a slip and catches himself refer ring to himself at Bender and then correcting himself. The ides of sulcido still prevails In liu mind and he frequently asked for a pairof scissors with which to cut his hair, ilo said if they took him down below, moaning Kanina, lie would teU things that would give several people away; •ays he will make somebody pay for making him trouble; claims to be the brother of MoGregor. after whom Mediator, es lowa, Is named. He mentioned the names of several persons whom be knew In JaekaonvHle. Sheriff Bender mys that If the pris oners are the genuine Benders there are parties In Labette county who can positively identify them, and thus set tle the matter. The party left for Kansas City over the Wabash route, and w>U arrive there at Ha. m. to-morrow. It is intimated that if they are the real Benders they will be lynched by the people of La bette county, but the sheriff says they will be protected. »■* »w gpccanian.
A prisoner claiming confused identity as Bender is being transported by train, alternately denying and admitting to the Bender killings while contradicting himself. The sheriff says Labette County residents could identify the real Benders, and rumors circulate that mob lynching awaits if they are confirmed genuine.
A dispatch reports that the Bender family, infamous for a string of murders, are believed to be returning to the scene of their crimes, with passengers said to be coming west by rail. The brief item offers no confirmation, only a rumor circulating amid the ongoing manhunt.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 9 August 1880 · page 1
THE BENDERS RETURNING TO THE SCENE OF THEIR CRIMES
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
An old man and woman identified as the Benders are being transported by train from Nebraska toward Kansas, escorted by a sheriff and an informant named Dan Condon. The woman reportedly reiterates a confession to the crimes, enraging her husband when he learns she had not escaped as he believed.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 9 August 1880 · page 1
The Kansas Fiends - The Benders on the Way to the Scene of their Crimes
HER TESTKItDAVS CONFESSIONS^ As well as the previous ones. When leaving Fremont the prisoners were given to under stand tbat they were being taken to Jack sonville, 111., as the old man becomes very ex citable when Kansas is mentioned. ... Your reporter took a seat behind him on the train, and Bender, while defying to-day that he is Bender, again admitted that he was sick by chance at Bender's for five or six weeks, dur ing which several murders were committed. He talked quite j freely about | the bad Ben ders, their misdeeds and their premises.
See moreSee less
He admitttd the murder at Jacksonville, and says he killed a drunken man in self-defense, and says he will get off free. \-> Although con tradicting himself several times, he virtually corroboiated the confession of . last evening and published to-day. The impression of your correspondent is that he is not of • a sound mind, owing to his wanderings and his continual thought of his crimes. ■: He has a terrible fear of Kansas, and frequently makes a slip and ! catches himself, referring to him self as Bender and \ then correcting him£«lf. The idea of suicide still prevails in his mind, and -he frequently asks for scissors with which to cut his hair. He said that if they took him down below, meaning Kansas, he would tell things that would give several peo ple away. : He says he will make somebody pay for making him trouble, % He claims to be a brother of ' the McGregor after whom McGregor, la., is named. He mentioned the
An elderly couple claimed to be the Benders are transported by train while reporters and crowds question them relentlessly. The old man grows frantic learning his wife remains jailed, both reiterate confused, contradictory confessions amid doubts about the man's sanity.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 9 August 1880 · page 1
HER YESTERDAY'S CONFESSIONS
;. ■_ ■':: - ■.. OPINION IN FRANCE. ... - Paris, August 7th.— -French :. opinion .on Tanner's experiment is pithily summed up in this evening's Francois. "This prodigious fast," it says, "will not fill the stomachs of the starving. There is no need to be a great doctor to make such experiments.' All the wretched make them each winter. Tanner has done the poor a great deal of harm. The familiar appeal, ,' My good sir, pity me, I've eaten nothing for two days,' will nevermore have any effect on us."
See moreSee less
■:::..:. :, ; ff<f f: ; Tbe Kansas Fiends -The Benders on the .;'- : Way to the Scene of their Crimes, Omaha, August 7th. — afternoon your correspondent met the East-bound Union Pa- , cific train at the Valley and rode into Omaha with old Bender and bis wife, who were in charge of Sheriff Bender (no relation) of Os wego, ' Labette county, : Kansas, and . Dan Condon of Schuyler county, Nebraska, who was the man who gave the information lead ing to their arrest. . Condon sat beside old Bender, who was handcuffed, and the Sheriff
A reporter visiting Mrs. Bender in an Omaha jail reports her account of the family's first murder, claimed to have occurred at a farm near Jacksonville, Illinois, before they moved through Iowa and Indiana to Kansas. She describes subsequent murders at the Kansas inn run with stepchildren John and Kate, including throat-slashings and money divided among the family.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 9 August 1880 · page 1
Die Mörderfamilie Bender. Geständnisse der Gefangenen.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report claims old man Bender and his wife confessed in detail to multiple murders in Kansas, describing the family's crimes, hideouts, and victims. It then describes their alleged capture, a near-lynching, their public exhibition for 25 cents in Kansas City, and transport toward Oswego, Kansas for extradition.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 9 August 1880 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
An Omaha reporter claims Mrs. Bender, held in jail at Tremont, confessed that the family's first murder occurred near Jacksonville, Illinois, with a trap door used to kill a lodger for his money. The account traces the family's subsequent moves through Iowa, Indiana, and Kansas before they set up their infamous 'hotel.'
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Portland Daily Press · 9 August 1880 · page 2
Δ HORRIBLE STORY. Confessions of the Bender Family. Omaha, Neb. Aug. 7.—On Friday Mrs. Ben der was visited in jail at Tremont by an Oma ha reporter, to whom she said the first murder
This report describes the alleged confessions of old Bender and his wife, detailing the family's movements and murders at their roadside inn in Kansas. It also covers the sheriff's transport of two Bender prisoners through Kansas City amid hostile crowds, with prisoners exhibited publicly for admission.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Portland Daily Press · 9 August 1880 · page 2
Δ HORRIBLE STORY. Confessions of the Bender Family. Omaha, Neb. Aug. 7.—On Friday Mrs. Ben der was visited in jail at Tremont by an Oma ha reporter, to whom she said the first murder ever committed by her and her husband was in Illinois, on a farm near Jacksonville. The victim asked for lodging and supper, and in paying for the same in advance exhibited con siderable money. While eating supper Bender cut his head in two from behind, and he was dumped into the cellar through a trap door arranged by Bender, who got the money.
See moreSee less
The corpse was buried the next morning baci* of the bouse. A few weeks after this they went to Iowa, remaining eight months. They then went to Indiana, living on the murdered man's money; then went to Kansas, where Bender's children by his first wife (John and Kate) were living with cousin Maggie. They kept a re sort for travellers and called it "Bender's Ho tel." They had committed no murders prior to the old folks arrival, but in the course of time old Bender arrangd a trap door, and then murdering operations began. Kate at one time had a man in bed with her and she cut his throat and slept till morning beside the corpse. His monoy was divided. She never injured horse thievesand cut throats who came ιυ liui uuuoc, uuu ouwnaïucU tllCUl well WliQ her cousin Maggie. No murders were com mitted after they fled from Kansas. Old Ben der has confessed, believing the old woman bas escaped. His story tallies with his wife's ex actly. He relates the history of the whole family and their crimes. A sheriff from Kan gas is now probably at Lincoln, obtaining a requisition from the Governor, and will be at Fremont to-morrow. Chicago, 111., Aug. 8.—A Kansas City special sa>8 Sheriff Bender, of Labette county, Kan sas. arrived there this morning with the two Bcudor prisoners and remained during the day, fearing to proceed on account of a crowd said to have gathered at Cherryvale with in tentions hostile to the prisoners. In the after noon the prisoners were exhibited at the Thea tre Comique, twenty-five cents admission be ing charged. At 5 o'clock the sheriff left with the prisoners for Oswego, Kansas.
A sheriff and deputy escort a man and woman identified as Bender and his wife from Fremont through Omaha toward Labette County, Kansas, where the Bender murders occurred. The man, handcuffed and agitated, denies being Bender at times, claims the name McGregor, and makes statements that reportedly corroborate a confession attributed to him and his wife.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Gold Hill Daily News · 9 August 1880 · page 2
THE BENDERS.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A man and woman held as suspected Benders give shifting, contradictory statements, with the woman confessing fully while the man denies his identity before breaking down and cursing her. Authorities await confirmation of whether the captives are truly the fugitive Bender family.
He waa aurpriaed, aa he tbonght aha had eecaped. When aha told him aha had told everything, he flew into a paaalon and curaed bar frantically, and aba had to be taken away. Ha aaya he ohangad hia name to Bender beoauae the children went under that name in Kanaaa. Ha remembere Dr. Tork. Ha aleo apoke of other Kanaaa vlotima, and again told of the murder at Jeokaonville. what in aHxaorr aaxa. Sheriff Bender aaya that while the excitement may ran high In Labette oonnty upon the arrival of the priaonara they ehall be proteoted, and if they
Sheriff Bender of Labette County, Kansas, arrives in Fremont, Nebraska, claiming the man in custody is John Bender based on resemblance and admissions. The suspect, giving his name as Alexander McGregor, confesses to a series of murders including one committed in Illinois before moving to Kansas to join Kate and John.
The riicneiiK'iiiil Joint Mender Tells or Ills Oark Deeds. Sheriff Bender, of Labette county, Kan sas, airivcd in Fremont, Neb., en Friday night with a requisition for the return of the supposed Benders new in custody. He is confident from conversation with the old man and admissions of the woman and from his close lcscmblauce te the descrip tions that he is the original Jehn Bender. The sheriff started with the pair. The obi man declares he will net be taken te Kansas alive. Ne news has been received in legard te the rest of the gang. Jehn Bender makes the following statement:
A man identifying himself as Alexander McGregor, claimed to be the elder Bender, gives a detailed confession describing multiple murders committed with his family in Illinois and Kansas, including trapdoor killings and burying children alive. The account describes the family's methods and eventual flight with Indians before splitting up near Schuyler.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 9 August 1880 · page 2
A FIEND'S CONFESSION
Kate and Jehn, who wrote for me te come en. I went te Kansas te live with Jehn and Kate. Maggie, Kate's cousin, was there at the place called Bender's hotel.
A dispatch reports that the elderly couple arrested in Dodge County, Nebraska by Sheriff Gregg and brought to Oswego, Kansas were examined by locals who knew the real Benders and pronounced them frauds. Despite their detailed and convincing stories closely matching the Bender case, no one could identify the man as old Bender or the woman as his wife, and the Sheriff planned to release them.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 10 August 1880 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
The Alleged Benders Now Believed to Be a Bogus Pair.
IMPOSTORS.
See moreSee less
Special Dispatch to The Chicago Tribune.
KANSAS CITY, Mo., Aug. 9.—Dispatches have been received all day from Oswego, Kas., regarding the identification of the supposed Benders, who were arrested in Dodge County, Nebraska, some days ago by Sheriff Gregg. Last night as the train neared Oswego a crowd gathered at every station for a glimpse of the prisoners, and at various points facts were obtained which went to show that the couple were frauds of the grossest kind. Upon arriving at the county seat of Labette County, no one could identify the man as old Bender, or the woman as his wife, and when the train from Cherryvale reached that point the point was settled, and the two would-be Benders pronounced frauds. They refused to give any reason for assuming that they knew so much about the noted butchers and their perpetrations, and no motive for such action has yet shown itself. In all their talk and would-be confessions both man and woman have told the same story, and it was so near the actual truth that even the Sheriff who brought the prisoners from Nebraska thought he had the right parties. There has been great excitement over the matter at Oswego since the arrival of the parties, and it is not yet known what action will be taken in the premises.
OSWEGO, Kas., Aug. 9.—The old couple supposed to be Bender and wife arrived here from Nebraska this morning, and were exposed in the Court-House for some hours. Many persons went to see them, and a dozen who knew the real Benders pronounce these people impostors. The Sheriff thinks they will be discharged to-morrow.
An elderly couple captured in Nebraska are claimed to be the long-sought Benders, with the woman reportedly confessing to an Omaha reporter in the Fremont jail. She describes murders beginning in Illinois and detailing the family's operations at Bender's Hotel in Kansas, including Kate's killing of a man and the old man's own confession.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Weekly Floridian · 10 August 1880 · page 2
The Benders. The old man and woman captured in Nebraska the other day have really turned out to be the Benders. The old woman has made a confession and gives many particulars of the doings of the family. Mrs. Bender was visited in jail at Free mont by an Omaha reporter, to whom she said tbe first murder ever committed by her and her husband wa* in Illinois, on their farm, near Jacksonville. The victim asked for lodging and supper. On paying for tbe same in advance, he exhibited con siderable money.
See moreSee less
While eating his sup per, Bender cut his head in two from be hind, and he was dumped into the cellar through a trap-door arranged by Bender, who got his money. The corpse was bur ied the next day back of the house. A few weeks after this they went to lowa, remaining there eight months. They then went to Indiana, living on the murdered man’s money, and then went to Kansas, where Bender’s children, John and Kate, by his first wife, were living with her cousin, Maggie. They kept a resort for travelers there and called it Bender’s Ho tel. They had committed no murder prior to the old folks’ arrival, but in the course of time old Bender arranged a trap-door, and then the murdering operations began. Kate at one time had a man in bed with her, and she cut his throat and slept till morning beside the corpse. His money was divided. She never injured horse thieves and cut-throat* who came to the house, but entertained them well with her cousin Maggie. No murders were com mitted by the family after they fled from Kansas. Old Bender has confessed, be
A sheriff in Fremont, Nebraska has arrested an elderly couple believed to be the elder Benders, while continuing to pursue the younger Bender couple reportedly seen near Schuyler. A reward of $25,000 is said to be offered for the capture of the entire Bender gang.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Spirit of Democracy · 10 August 1880 · page 2
Omaha, August 3 -Sheriff Gregg, of Dodge County, who arrested old Bender and his wife, now in Fremont jail, is in Omaha hunting up tbe trail of young Bender and wife. The latter were seen itb a team and wagon with old Bender and wife, who were on foot, near Schuy ler, and they parted near there. Shortly before Daniel Condon informed Gregz of their auspicious inquiries about the Ben der family of Kna. Mr. Gregg has since learned that ' the young couple crossed the river at Omaha wiih a tenn and wagon and went into Iowa, no doubt en route to the place of meeting agreed upon by them and the old folks.
See moreSee less
Sheriff Gregg says that when he ar rested tbe old couple he rode np to them and said, "Hello. Kate!" The woman replied, "I ain't Kate Bender." Gregg believes that he has a sure thing on the old man, but thinks the woman Bender's mistress, and that they have killed his wire, lue original old Bender was a German, and had a big scar on the cen ter ot bis head. The prisoner at t re mont has a scar, but swears he doesn't know a word of German. A Dutchman was put in the cell wi h instructions to curse btm in bis natural tongue. ( Old Bender forgot himself and swore terrfically at the man in German. Bender asked for a razor to shave, but Gregg. fearing be would commit suicide, refus ed, and bad the barber to shave him Sheriff Gregg.. Is , determined 10 captnre vounz Bender, as it is understood $25,- 000 reward is offered for the whole gang. Of this amount $11,000 is for tbe old man. Omaha, Auzust 3. A dispacb from Fremont, Nebrasxa, says: Further de velopments make almost certain the iden tity of the couple in jail here for com plicity in the Bender butcheries. " H. v. Hooplar, of Una county, who lormeny resided in Libelle County, Kansas near tbe Bender's interviewed the old man
Sheriff Gregg's prisoners in Fremont, Nebraska, are tested for signs of being 'old Bender' and his wife, including a ruse involving a German-speaking cellmate. The woman allegedly confesses to being linked to Bender and admits to knowledge of the murders, including children buried alive.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
A woman, possibly connected to the Bender family, gives a detailed account of the murders under Kate Bender's leadership, including the killing of a man named Brown and a family of four, with two children buried alive. The report notes uncertainty about whether this woman is truly linked to the original Benders, stating the fact could easily be verified.
The Spirit of Democracy · 10 August 1880 · page 2
Choctaw nation. Many further details were obtained from this woman, and if these are not -the original Benders, the fact can easily be established. : CLARENGTON, OHIO, i
The New Bloomfield, Pa. Times · New Bloomfield, Pa.
A sheriff in Fremont, Nebraska, arrests two travelers suspected of being Old Man Bender and his wife after suspicious questions about the Bender family's whereabouts. A former neighbor identifies the male prisoner using a hand-drawn plan of the Kansas farmhouse, while the woman denies being Kate Bender but claims her companion is indeed Bender.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The New Bloomfield, Pa. Times · 10 August 1880 · page 8
The Benders Identified. Fremont, Neb., August 2. It Is gener ally believed her tbnt the two prison- , erg, arretted a few dixy s bro and beld by ( Sheriff Gregg, are the notorious John or Old Man Bender and bin wire, of Kansas, who 'several years ago made robbery and murder of tbelr gueBts a regular business. Busplclon was first aroused by their Inquir ies as to whether the whereabouts of the ltendor family bad jet been discovered. They were traveling on foot through the country and were overtaken thirty miles west of here.
See moreSee less
Gregg accosted tbera with 'Hello, Kate." The woman at onoe replied My name alnt Kate Bender." In jail they were Interviewed by a Mr. Ilooflan, wh6 once lived near them in Kansas. He fully identified thnm. The woman denied that she is Mrs. Bender, 'but says her male corn pan ion Is Old Man Bender. Ilooflan showed the male prisoner a plau of Bender's Kan sas house, adjoiulng the graveyard ' which the old man acknowledged was a correct drawing. The woman was then inter viewed alono. She recognized Ilooflan, but said she never expected to see him again. She expeots that telling the truth now will save her, but acknowledges the possibility of hanging. The woman insists that Bender's wife was left In the Chootaw Nation in 1870, three years after the flight of the family from Kansas, and died in the Territory in that year. The couple will be taken to Kansas for further identifi cation. The Bender family fled from Kansas In 1873. Shortly after that time ten or twelve bodies were found in the garden of their place, among others that of State .Senator York, of Kansas.
A newspaper account describes the arrest of an elderly man and woman near Richland, suspected of being the fugitive Bender patriarch and his wife, based on suspicious behavior and conflicting stories. An overheard jailhouse conversation seemingly confirms their guilt and fear of being hanged in Kansas.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Connecticut Western News · 11 August 1880 · page 4
THE BENDER MURDERERS. How the Capture of the Elder Bender and. his Wife was Effected,. The Omaha Herald says : A man was arrested by Sheriff Gregg at Richland a few days ago, and he is now lodged in jail at Fremont. He was with a woman traveling eastward on foot. They had stopped at a house near there. Soon after their arrival they made inquiries as to whether anything had yet been dis covered of the Bender family, who for merly lived in Kansas. Their talk and actions excited suspi cion, which was iurtner strengthened bv their answers to questions asked them.
See moreSee less
They appeared excited, and told conflicting stories as to who they were and where they were from ; said they had lived five or six years among the In dians; that they had been up in the Niobrara country, and that they were not the Benders. Ingenious question
A newspaper reproduces a secretly recorded conversation between an elderly captured man and woman, in which he frets about being hanged in Kansas and speaks of his dying wish. The woman then gives a detailed confession claiming she and her husband traveled with the Benders, witnessed over ten murders including a trapdoor killing method, and names the four Benders as the killers.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Connecticut Western News · 11 August 1880 · page 4
THE BENDER MURDERERS. How the Capture of the Elder Bender and. his Wife was Effected,. The Omaha Herald says : A man was arrested by Sheriff Gregg at Richland a few days ago, and he is now lodged in jail at Fremont. He was with a woman traveling eastward on foot. They had stopped at a house near there. Soon after their arrival they made inquiries as to whether anything had yet been dis covered of the Bender family, who for merly lived in Kansas. Their talk and actions excited suspi cion, which was iurtner strengthened bv their answers to questions asked them.
See moreSee less
They appeared excited, and told conflicting stories as to who they were and where they were from ; said they had lived five or six years among the In dians; that they had been up in the Niobrara country, and that they were not the Benders. Ingenious question ing was brought to bear on them, and the story finally came out. While they were together in jail a con versation was overheard between them on the 27th of July, which was taken down by parties who were concealed near by. The old man, who is apparently over sixty years of age, said to her : "I knew if we came to Kansas that they would hang us before we would be there two hours. We would not stand a ghost of a show. If I have to die, I want to die with you and be buried with you. I am going crazy. I know I have to die. I want that razor in here before I start for Kansas." "They would not let you have it. They are afraid of losing their reward," she said. He continued: "I know you'll give me away, but you cannot save yourself. Oh! my first wife. She was a good woman. You don't care for me. You musn't think you can escape by giving me away. Don't you cry." Here they were interrupted by some noise, and would say no more. The par ties were afterward separated, and the old man was told that she had been taken to Kansas. He appeared to feel very bad, but said little. , She was then questioned and asked to give the whole story, which was finally got out of her, as appears in the answers given to the questions put to her. The old woman said the Benders had to run away from Illinois. They were in the same busi ness there that they were afterward in in Kansas. "I was with the old man," the woman said, "all the time he was with the Benders. I don't know if he had any thing to do with the murders. I think he had. The money taken from persons murdered was always divided among the Benders. I think my husband never got any of it. The garden was full of graves, and the cellar full of dead bodies. Dr, York's brother was murdered while was there. He was a single man, I think about 35 years old. The dining-room of the house was the room which the shding trap was under. A person would sit down at the table to eat, and the slides -were njoved and the person would fall into a dee'p' cellar. .1 don't know how deep the cellar was.' They would kill anybody who would come to the house, rich or poor, for fear they might inform on them. They killed some persons that had no money at alt. We went with the Benders from the place 6f therhiiirder to the railroad station. I don't know what town. There they took the train south. They would not take us along. . The old man told the Benders that if they would not give them money he and the old man would tell on them. They didn't "say anything to that. I havevseen" a good many people killed at Bender's house. My husband was sick at Bender's house, and I was waiting on him. I think there were more than ten persons killed while I was in the house. The Benders talked freely about these murders in jny pres ence. The old man Bender, Mrs; BenI der, Kate Bender, and John Bender, Jr., done the murdering. The old. man went bv the name of John Bender in Kansas." - The old man when he was told that she had confessed by degrees, told his story: "I was -only one night at Ben der's house," he said. "That day youug man came from California, and stopped at Bender's .to get something to eat. He asked Kate what tnade the house smell so. She said it was nothing. He said he would not stay over night in the house ; he would go and got people to search the house, and when the people came they found some bodies under the house, six or seven of 'them. When the Benders saw that they were found out they went right off, and then'1 1 started for Illinois. They put two children in a hole that same night and covered them with dirt. The man from California was the one that saw these children alive. The reason why I came to Kansas that time was that I was coming from the West from Fort Lincoln. ; They killed a man the night I was therei He was not a very old man. I was not jin the room where ho was killed. It Ttas dark. I could not see very well. The door of the room I was in was open. Ijwas at Ben der's house two and a half (lays, but no longer." . Here the old man was, dosely cross questioned, and he hnauyaia : -1 was at the Bender house lust sixweeKS. The Benders, I don't know whfSthey went, I went to Jacksonville, -JJ1., traveling on foot, calling myself McGregor. About four weeks after the Benders left Kansas I saw Kate Bender between Springfield, 111., and Jacksonville, fele had mens clothes on. She had hai her hair cut short. I met her on the Joad. I knew her the minute I saw her.l I know of six "I 1 -11 . T 1 ! "1- . 1 I 11 people Kuiea wnne-j. waj at tne house. There was one family kilfed whila f was there a man, his wife, and children. Two of the children weie buried alive. My wife was born in Hliiois. - Her folks moved to Missouri. Slje was formerly married to George Ellionl Her name was Nancy Ellison before I married her." . S
A woman describes the trapdoor cellar method of murder and claims over ten people were killed while she was present, while a man's confession changes under cross-examination about how long he stayed at Bender's house. The accounts are inconsistent with each other and with established facts about the case.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Connecticut Western News · 11 August 1880 · page 4
The report describes a man and woman arrested in Fremont, Dodge County, Nebraska, believed to be John Bender and his mother, wanted since 1873 for the notorious Kansas murders. It recounts the Benders' background near Cherryvale and the old woman's reputation as a sinister medium.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Smyrna Times · 11 August 1880 · page 1
THE HOUSE, THROWING THEM INTO A DUNGEON AND MURDERING THEM FOR THEIR MONEY. Omaha, Nib., A a ft list 2. Tho story of tho crimes of tho Bender family is upon everybody's lips. The great est crime of the century is likely, in a small measure at leimt, to bo attoued for. But tho most horrible death that old John Bander could bo put to would hut in a slight degree avenge the sufferings of his many victims. In tho jail at Fremont, in Dodge county, a man is locked up who is supposed to be tho fiend that the authori ties of Kansas have been looking for for seven years.
See moreSee less
There hardly seems a doubt of his identity. With him is a woman — repulsive, hard-fisted and old. She may bo the original Mrs. Bender or she may be his mistress. Opinions differ on this point. When they roach Kansas tho authorities will have hard work to guard the couple from the attacks of the populace, who are thirsting for their blood. In 1873 old Bender and his wife and their son John and his wife lived near Cherry vale, Labette county, Kansas. Their house was about two miles out of town. It was a rude frame structure, standing in a lot of two acres. The old woman called herself a medium. She had a way of boiling herbs of roots that were supposed to have charms and spoils about them and she dealt in incantations. She was repulsive in aspect—tall, angular and scrawny, with hard, steel-gray eyes and thin, ragged gray hair straggling over her temples. Tho family seem to have been totally under tho influence of this ungainly creature. Her word with them was law. The Benders ostensibly kept a grocery. A sign was displayed in front of their rude dwelling to attract visitors, but the stock in tradb consisted principally of a sort of cheap wine. There were only two rooms in tho house. One was a dining room and kitchen combined. In tho other the four Benders slept.
A newspaper reports that a man believed to be one of the Bender murder family has been captured along with a woman who may be the original Mrs. Bender, after seven years of searching since the 1873 Kansas disappearances. It then recounts the background of the Bender family's grocery/inn near Cherryvale and the mysterious vanishing of travelers, including Dr. William York.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Dr. William York vanished while investigating an earlier disappearance traced to a wagon sold near Cherryvale; after his brother Senator York organized a search, the abandoned Bender homestead was found deserted and searched, revealing a hidden trap door. Extensive efforts including rewards and river dragging had failed to locate York until suspicion fell on the fled Bender family.
Smyrna Times · 11 August 1880 · page 1
MANY SUDDEN DISAPPEARANCES. In 1873 a number of persons traveling in tho direction of Cherryvale mysteriously disappeared. No traces of then could bo found. The first disappearance that attrac ted attention was that of an old man and his granddaughter, who left Cherryvale iu February, 1873, in a two-horso wagon to go to Fort Scott, but who never reached that place. All inquiries failed to elecit a clue to their disappearance until about the beginning of March, Dr. William II. York recognized the wagon and team at Fort Scott. He ascertained that tho wagon had been purchased at the Fort from some person who had come from Cherryvale, and he determined to ferret out tiie mystery.
See moreSee less
He loft Fort Scott on March 9, and he too dis appeared. Dr. York was well known and tho greatest efforts wore made to discover traces of him. A large reward was offerred, rivers were dragged, spots fit for ambush wore probed foot by foot, lonesome places were quested as a keen hound scents a trail that is cold, and still no traces of the lost man were discovered. Not a shadow of evidence rested anywhere to say that Dr. York had been murdered—not a sign any where told how he came to his death, if indeed, death had overtaken him unawares. He was traced to Cherryvale, in Labette county, but no further. There all track and trace of him ceased. The excitement was at a high pitch. Ono day an explor ing party stopped at the house of the Benders. Had they seen anything of Dr. York ? No, the answer came, they had not. They knew nothing whatever concerning him. But this visit had a strange effect, 1 'he next «lay tho Bender family disap peared, and almost as mysteriously as had Dr. York. This suspicious circumstance aroused curiosity. A man riding into Cherryvale from the country one day was impressed hy tho deserted appearance of the Bender place. He entered the yard. In tho stable lie found a dead calf. There was every indication from the appearance of the miserable creature that it had starved to tleath. Tho man walked up to the house, openeil the door and iookeil in. Not an article of household furniture had been removed, but the dust lay heavy on everything. The man went to Cherryvale and told Ids story. Senator A. M. York the brother of the missing man was there. To bis suspicious mind the sudden and strange flight of the Bender family was a revelation. He hud found the first clue to his lost brother. He divulged his suspi cions and a band of men accompanied him him to the Bender farm. The front room of the house was carefully searched, every crack and crevice being minutely looked into and subjected to the application of rods and levers to see if the flooring was either hollow or loose. Nothing came of it. No blood spots appeared. The floor wps solid, the walls were solid. Next the party searched the back room. The beds were removed. In their flight the Benders had left everything untouched.
The Anderson Intelligencer · Anderson Court House, S.C. · 19 August 1880
Decorah-Posten · Decorah, Iowa
This Danish-language report says accounts of the Bender family's capture are wavering and uncertain, with some claiming only the old couple was caught while the young ones remain at large. It also reports that the old couple confessed in detail, implicating daughter Kate as the one who killed victims with an axe after they fell through a trapdoor.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Decorah-Posten · 11 August 1880 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
An elderly couple arrived in Oswego, Kansas from Nebraska, suspected of being the fugitive Benders, and were displayed at the courthouse for public identification. People who knew the real Benders declared the pair imposters, and the sheriff expected to release them.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 11 August 1880 · page 1
NOT THE BENDERS.
HOERIBLE C RIM KS COMMITTED ON ' "THAT FARM." Fremont, Neb., August 3. There were Im portant devolopments in the Bender matters to-day. Mrs. Bender made a tu. I confession of all tbe horrible murders committed on Ben der's latzn in l.TC and 1870. She was a widow when she married McGregor, alias Lender, who was a widower with four children. Tbey migrated from Mlasonrl to Labette County, Kansas, where, under the leadership of Kate. old John's dsugbter, the murders aud robber ies began. Mrs. Bender declares she had no
A woman claiming Bender family ties confesses details of murders, including burying children alive, but the report admits identity is unverified. Multiple contradictory sightings and arrests of supposed Benders (also called McGregors) are reported from Nebraska, Illinois, and Kansas simultaneously.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 11 August 1880 · page 1
HORRIBLE CRIMES COMMITTED ON
Cherokee or Choctaw Nation. Many further details were obtained from tbe woman, and If these are not the original Benders the fact can easily be established.
A report claims the elderly couple held in Fremont, Nebraska have confessed to being the Bloody Benders, with the wife detailing murders in Illinois and Kansas including a trap-door killing method. The same dispatch simultaneously carries a conflicting identification claiming the prisoners are actually a couple named McGregor from Jacksonville, Illinois.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Indiana State Sentinel · 11 August 1880 · page 1
CLD MAN BENbF.U AND HIS WIFE CONFESS Chicago, Augnst C An Omaha special to the Tribune says: "A former resident of Jacksonville, IU., has identified the two pris oners at Fremont, supposed to be Benders, as McGregors, of Jack&onvi l. Tbe man says he knew tbem there as hard characters, aud that he left Illinois for Kansas with them in a wagon team, and that McGregrcr who It is thouaht to be Identical with Benders, went to Labette Connty." The Tribune's Spring field, 111., specta:, says: "The records of the County show that in 1871 Alexander McGregor obtained a marriage license for himself and Nancy Ellington, both of them inmates of the Poor House.
See moreSee less
They were married and remained a charge upon the Parish nntil the August fol lowing, when they disappeared." Chicago, 111., August 8. An Omaha (Neb) Rpeclal to the Trluune says: "To day Mrs. Bender was visited In the jail at Fremont by an Omaha reporter, to whom she said: The first murder ever committed by her and her husband was In Illinois, on their farm near Jacksonville. The victim asked for lodging and supper, and In paying lor the same in advance, exhibited considerable money. While eating supper Bender cut his head in two from be hind, and he was dumped into the cellar through a trap door, arranged by Bender, who got the money. Tbe corpse was buried next morning back of the house. A few weeks alter this they went to Iowa, remaining eight months. They then went to Indiana living on the murdered man's money. They went to Kansas, where Binder's children by the first wife, John and Kate, were living together with a cousin, Maegie They kept a resort lor travelers, and called It "Bender's Hotel." They had committed no murders prior to the old folks' arrival, but in the course of time old Bender arranged a trap-door, ad then the murdering operations began. Kate, at one time had a man In bed with her, aDd she cut his throat and sl-pt until morning beside tbe corpse. His money was divided. She never lDjured horse thieves and cut-throats who came to her bouse, hut entertained them well with her cousin Maggie. No murders were committed by the family alter they fled from Kansas." Old Bender has confessed, believing that the old woman has escaped. His story tallies with hla wife's exactly. He relates the history of tbe whole family, and their crimes. A Sheriff from Kan sas la now probably at Lincoln obtaining a requisition from the Governor, and will be at Fremont to-morrow." -? v i.
A sheriff claims to have arrested old man Bender and his wife, now jailed in Fremont, while tracking young Bender and his wife believed en route to the Indian Territory to meet them. The report includes anecdotes of jailhouse remarks and a theory that the female suspect may be connected to Bender's family, though identification remains uncertain.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Indiana State Sentinel · 11 August 1880 · page 3
Iparted near ttere. Shortly before DaoLoodoD informed Gregg of their suspl i inquiries about the Bender family of ;aa. Mr. uregg ras since iearnea mat ouDg cod pie crossed the river at Omaha the wagon and team and went Into , no doubt en route to the place of meet agreed upon between them and the old A. rney oaa a team oi one gray auu one horse, aod a colored wagon. The people
A sheriff and detective interrogate an elderly man and woman arrested on suspicion of being the fugitive Benders, noting the man's scar matching Bender's description and his unexpected fluency in German. Their accounts of being sick in bed for seven and a half weeks at the Bender place conflict on key details, and the woman is suspected to be an associate who joined the family's flight.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 11 August 1880 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
"HALLOO, KATE!" Capture of the Benders—How the Old Man Swears in German.
[Chicago Times Special.]
See moreSee less
[Om]aha, Neb., August 1.—Sheriff Gregg, of [Dodg]e County, who arrested old Bender and [his wife,] who are now in Fremont Jail, was in [Oma]ha to day, hunting up the trail of young [Ben]der and wife, who were seen with a team [and] wagon in company with old Bender and [wif]e, who were on foot, near Schuyler, and [they] parted near there. Shortly before Dan[t] Condon informed Gregg of their suspi[cious] inquiries about the Bender family of [Kan]sas. Mr. Gregg has since learned that [the y]oung couple crossed the river at Omaha [with] the wagon and team and went into [Iowa], no doubt en route to the place of meet[ing] agreed upon between them and the old [folk]s. They had a team of one gray and one horse, and a colored wagon. The people [about] the jail have been heard talking of the [you]ng couple. One said: "How do you [kno]w the others will be caught!" "No, [we] will fool them. They are gone South, [and I] will go on the wrong track," was the [repl]y. It is understood that Condon is fol[low]ing on their track. Sheriff Gregg says [tha]t when he arrested the old couple he rode [up] to them and said, "Halloo, Kate!" and the man replied: "I AIN'T KATE BENDER." [Gre]gg believes he has got a sure thing on the
[wo]man, but thinks the woman is Bender's
[mis]tress, his theory being that she started off wi[t]h the Bender outfit when they fled, and
[t]hat she and the old man killed Mrs. Bender, and this woman has been living with Bender ever since. She has been with him through all the Indian country, and gives good descriptions of the habits and life of various Indian tribes. The officer has examined the prisoners separately, and finds that while their stories are somewhat alike, they do not [a]gree on a number of important particulars [t]he old man claims that he was at Bender's [fo]r awhile, and was laid up sick for seven [an]d a half weeks. He says his wife was not [the]re, and that he sent for her, and that she [was] there with him during the times that murders were committed, and that he [kne]w all about them. The woman claims she went to Bender's with him, and [and] both were sick in bed for seven weeks and a half. The original old Bender is a man, and has a big scar in the center of head. The prisoner at Fremont swears [he d]oes not know a word of German, but wh[e]n a German was put in a cell and cursed im in the German language, according to structions, the prisoner forgot himself and SWORE TERRIFICALLY IN GERMAN he man. The prisoner also has a scar his head answering to the scar on old nder's head, and in several other points answers the description. He accounts for e scar by saying he was kicked by a horse. e is seventy-two years old. At times he is rfectly frantic and yells so that he can be ard two or three blocks away. Mr. Gregg as been sleeping in the cell under the old an, in hopes of hearing something from m, and he has not been disappointed. The isoner wants to commit suicide, and he ked Sheriff Gregg for a razor with which shave himself. Mr. Gregg would not nt his request, but said he would have a ber come and shave him. "I don't want damned barber to shave me," said the oner. He says that he doesn't want to aken to Kansas, but he will go anywhere to be tried. He swears he will NEVER GO TO KANSAS ALIVE. he is a woman of forty years of age, wears 11 shoes, and has hands as big as the old n's. She is a large, masculine looking ature. She says there were ten persons killed by old Bender, two of the bodies never having been found. Mr. Hooflan, who interviewed the prisoners as stated in yesterday's dispatches, is a clerk in Mr. Shed's store, at Fremont, and Mr. Shed induced the Sheriff to allow him to visit the captives. The moment he saw the old man he said, "that's Bender." The prisoner dropped his head as if shot. Hooflan claims that he was well acquainted with him. He says the prisoner has changed his style of shaving, but that his features are unchanged, and that the scar on his head is positive proof that he is the man who must go to Kansas to answer for the murder of Dr. York and his numerous other victims. It is understood that $25,000 is offered for the whole gang, and of this amount there is $1,000 for old Bender. [Special to the Chicago Tribune.
Fremont, Neb., August 1—The knowledge of the arrest of old man Bender and wife has been telegraphed all over the country, and this morning when the Tribune correspondent reached Fremont he set about obtaining an interview with the famous murderers. At last the desired end was reached, and a long talk had with the prisoner, who declares that his name is John McGregor. He admits having been a member of the famous John Bender family during five months just previous to March, '73, but says he was compelled to remain here by sickness, and that his wife, who is supposed to be Mrs. Bender, was her nurse; while on the other hand the old woman, not half an hour ago, swore that the old man was the original John Bender, but that she was not his wife, but had been traveling with him during the past seven years. As your correspondent came to the door which leads to the prisoner he rose and at once began talking about the trouble which had overtaken him. He said he was not John Bender, but was John McGregor, from Jacksonville, Ill., which place he left last fall.
BUT ALMOST IN THE SAME BREATH
said he had been among Northern tribes of Indians for five years.
"But you knew the Benders?"
"Yes; and they were a bad lot."
"Were you there when any persons were killed?"
"Oh, yes; they killed at least a dozen during the five or six weeks that I was in their house."
"How did they kill them?"
"First by letting them through a trapdoor, and then by knocking out their [br]ains." "Who did this?" "Well, the old man. John sometimes [p]ulled the lever and let them fall into the [c]ellar. Then Kate would knock their brains [o]ut."
"Did Kate Bender do this? She must have been a perfect devil."
"She was terrible bad, and most of the time she was dressed as a man." "What did she kill them with?"
"With a short-handled ax or hatchet, and sometimes she had to strike three or four times before they died."
"How do you know all this?"
"I was sick in the house, you know, and they told me."
"Who do you mean by 'they?'" "Old John and Kate; tney told me all about it." "Were you there when Dr. York was killed?"
"I don't know who Dr. York was."
"How many dead bodies did you see?"
"I saw them bury six or seven; it was after dark."
"Did you
SEE THEM KILL ANY LITTLE CHILDREN?"
"They killed a whole family. Mr. and Mrs. Louchere and two children, I think their names were."
"How did they kill them?"
"They killed the old folks by dropping them into the cellar, where Kate hit them on the head."
"How about the two children?"
"They dug two holes and threw them in alive, and then covered them with the dirt.'
"You did not see them, you say?"
"It was after dark, but I heard the little girls scream and scream. Oh, it was horrible, but I did not do it. They say I am John Bender, but I am not."
"Why didn't you try and save the children?"
"I was afraid they would kill me, too."
"When did you leave Bender's house?"
"About the last of March, 1873. I left the
Benders at a railroad station, and have never seen them since."
During all the time the old man continually said he was not John Bender, and that he wanted to see his wife (she is in a separate part of the jail, but he thinks she has been taken to Kansas). He vows he will never be taken back to Kansas alive,
BUT WILL GO ANYWHERE else for identification. Especially has he an aversion for Labette County, where he says everything is so horrible. All this he said to the Tribune correspondent during an hour's interview, and the impression on my mind is that his brain is weakening. He has thought so much and talked so much on the Bender subject that he can not converse about anything else.
"I was arrested about four years ago in Iowa for being John Bender, but talked them out of putting me in jail," said he, during the interview, "and once in Kansas I go into trouble on the same question."
A man arrested in Fremont swears he will never be taken alive to Kansas, while witnesses positively identify him as old man Bender despite his claim to be John McGregor. A woman with him first confirms he is Bender but then says she is not his wife, only a travel companion of seven years.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 11 August 1880 · page 3
NEVER GO TO KANSAS ALIVE
11 ihnca anrl haa hands an bi? ad the old fa's. She'is a large, maeculine looking turs. She says there were ten persons led by old Bander, two of the bodies I . - . j r tr a ver navirjg oeen iuuuu. air. auuuiu, ho Interviewed the prisoners as stated in sterday's dispatch", Is a clerk in Air. bed's store, at Fremont, and Mr. Shed In iced the Sheriff to allow him to visit the .ptives. The moment he taw toe oia man 9. said. "taafa Bender." The prisoner roppfcd his bead as if shot.
See moreSee less
Hoo3n claims hat he wbs well acquainted with him. He nyi the prisoner has changed his style of Ving, out mat nis leaiures are uncuaugeu. dthat the scar on his head la positive roof that he is the man who must go to anas to answer for the murder ot Dr. k and his numerous other victims. It is derstood that $25,000 is oöered for the hale gang, and of this amount there is LOCO for oid Bender. lSr.eciil to the Chicago Tribune. 1 The know! L .. " V . a . . r i . : 1 ' uie arrest Ol Old man ivnuor uuu wue um en tilegraphed all over the country, and this morning wnen me lnuune corremdent reached Fremont he set about inine an Interview with the famous rderers. At last the desired end was hed, and a long talk had with the i-iarmar. who declares that bis name is ihn McGregor. He admits having been a
The report summarizes alleged jailhouse confessions from old woman Bender and old man Bender describing the family's murders in Illinois and Kansas, including the killing of a family with two children. The accounts describe trap-door killings and an eventual flight to join Cherokee or Choctaw Indians.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Columbus Journal · 11 August 1880 · page 2
The main sensation of the week aud'old woman Bender, their deten tion at the Fremont jail and their numerous confessions and inter views with -newspaper correspond ents. From these we eummacjzc the following. The old woman says that she was a widow wbeh""ShG married McGregor, alias Bender, who:wtt-a:widower with -four chil dren. They moved from Illinois to Labette county, Kansas', where under the leadership of Kate, old John's daughter, tho murders and robberies began. Mrs. Bender declares she
The report recounts a gruesome confession attributed to the Bender family, describing murders via trap-door and hidden cellar, and states that an elderly couple matching their description was arrested and extradited to Kansas as the Benders. However, it also notes that many who knew the real Benders viewed the prisoners at Oswego and declared them impostors.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Columbus Journal · 11 August 1880 · page 2
6ayB :"Tho old couple, supposed to be Bender and wife, arrived here from Nebraska this morning, and were exposed in the court house for somo hours. Many persons went to see them and dozens who knew the real Benders pronounce these people
A report states that the Sheriff of Oswego, Kansas left for Fremont to apprehend a man and woman believed to be Bender and his wife, intending to return them to Kansas where the Benders had murdered travelers. The public reportedly believes these are the genuine fugitives.
The Columbus Journal · 11 August 1880 · page 2
Bender aud his wife and take them back to Kansas, where they made a graveyard of travelers several years ago. The public believe they are the genuine Benders.
A dilapidated family claiming to be emigrating from Oregon was reportedly identified as the real John and Kate Bender by a Fremont sheriff and a Colfax County citizen. A requisition was being sought to extradite them to Kansas to face charges for the notorious Bender murders.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Columbus Journal · 11 August 1880 · page 3
State of Illinois. From all tho recent devclope montfi, it looks as if the real Mr. and Mrs. Bender, formerly of Kansas, and of murderous notriety have really been captured by the Sheriff of Fremont and a citizen of Colfax co., our Dan. Condon, who first dis covered them. A requisition has been asked for, which has been asked for, which is expected to be received in a few days, when these suppos ed wicked criminals will be remov ed to Kansas, where they commit ted several horrible murders. The former charges against John Beqder and his wife wbilo liviug in Kansas were the murders and robbery of the following persons, so far as
Dispatches from Kansas report that old settlers and locals in Labette and LaCygnes do not recognize the arrested Fremont couple as the real Benders, with witnesses identifying them as known tramps instead. The general belief is that the actual Bender family was killed by vigilantes long ago, and the arrest is dismissed as a hoax.
Omaha Daily Bee · 11 August 1880 · page 4
NOTORIOUS LIARS, The Bender Boom Exploded and Everybody Disgusted.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Juniata Sentinel and Republican · Mifflintown, Pa.
An elderly man and an unusually tall woman were arrested in Nebraska on suspicion of being the notorious Bender family, wanted for murders committed at their Kansas inn in 1873. A reporter visiting the jailed woman at Fremont claimed she confessed to an earlier murder in Illinois and described the family's subsequent movements through Iowa, Indiana, and Kansas.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Juniata Sentinel and Republican · 11 August 1880 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
An old man and young woman arrested near Fremont, Nebraska are suspected of being members of the Bender family; the man admits being present during the murders and implicates himself, while the woman denies being Mrs. Bender but hints she knows details. The sheriff believes he may have captured the genuine Benders and a clue to young John Bender's whereabouts.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Union County Courier · 11 August 1880 · page 1
CTTFES. The Bender Family Araln. An old man and a young woman who were arrested nem Fremout, Neb., on the 39tli nit., are supposed to be members of the notorious Bender family who have committed so many murders in Kansas. The womau denies that they are Benders but the old man admits that he was at Bender's six weeks, and explains his presence there by saving he stopped while en route for the east "from J-ort Lincoln. He saw six people murdered when at Bender's house one entire family was killed, two children being buried alive.
See moreSee less
It is fully lelievcd by all who have seen them that, if tho genuine Benders are not e.ipttircl, at least two iln lortaiit witnesses have been secured. The sheriff believes he has got the genuine Benders, and thinks he has got a clew to the where abouts of young John lieuder. A man" who used to know the Benders in Kansas visited the two prisoners in the jail at Fremont, Neb., on the Slst ult Both of them recognized him, and the man admitted that he wos tho senior Bender, and that he assisted at some of the burking that was done at his house. The woman denies that she is Bonder's wife, but confesses guilt by sayiug that she will try to save her neck by telling all she knows. She says the old woman was left in Indian Territory, in* 1873, when the Benders abandoned their team. The old man was told that John and Kate had been caught, and had charged him with being the chief criminal. At this he be came very angry, and cursed than roundly.
A correspondent reports that a man believed to be fugitive Bender family patriarch John Bender has been jailed in Fremont, Dodge county, Nebraska, with a woman possibly his wife or mistress. The report recounts the Benders' 1873 crimes near Cherryvale, Kansas, describing their roadside inn, the mother's fortune-telling, and warns of mob violence when the suspects are returned to Kansas.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Public Ledger · 11 August 1880 · page 2
THE OLD MAN SAFE BEHIND IRON BARS
Special Correspondence to the P'oila, Times. Omaha, Neb., August 2. The story of the crimes of the Ben der family is upon everybody's lips. The greatest crime of the century is likely, in a small measure at least, to be atoned for. But the most horrible death that old John Bender could be put to would but in a slight degree avenge the Bufferings of his many vic tims. In the jail at Fremont, in Dodge county, a man is locked up who is supposed to be the fiend that the au thorities of Kansas have been looking for for seven years.
See moreSee less
Thero hardly seems a doubt of his identity. Vith him is a woman repulsive hard-fisted and old. She may be the original Mrs. Bender or she may bo his mis tress. Opinions differ on this point. AVhen they reach Kansas the authori ties will have hard work to guard the couple from the attacks of the popu laoe, who are thirsting for their blood. In 1873 old Bender and his wife and their son John and his wife lived near
A passerby's report of the deserted Bender farm leads Senator York and a search party to investigate the house, where they discover a hidden trapdoor over a blood-stained pit. Digging in the garden, they unearth the decomposing body of York's missing brother, his skull crushed and throat cut.
Public Ledger · 11 August 1880 · page 2
Dr. York was well known and the greatest efforts were made to discover traces of him. A large reward was offered, rivers were dragged, spots fit tor ambush were probed toot by toot, lonesome places wre quested as a keen hound scents a trail that is oold, and still no traces of the lost man were discovered. Not a shadow of evidence rested anywhere to say that Dr. York had been murdered not a sign any where told how he came to his death, if, indeed, death had overtaken him unawares.
See moreSee less
He was traced to Cherry ryvale, in Labette county, but no further. There all track and trace of him oeased The excitement was at a Inch Ditch, One day an exploring party stopped at tne bouse ot the lsenders. Had they seen anything of Dr. York ? No, the answer came, they had not. They knew nothing, whatever, con cerning him. But this visit had a strange effect. The next day the Bender family disappeared, and al most as mysteriously as had Dr. York. This suspicious circumstance aroused curiosity. A man riding into Cherry vale from the country one dav. im pressed by the deserted appearance of tbe liender place, he entered the yard. In the stable he found a dead calf. There was every indication from the appearance of the miserable creature, that it had starved to death. The man walked up to the house, opened the door and looked in. Not an article of household furniture had been removed, but the dust lay heavy on everything. The man went to Cherryvale and told his story. Sena tor A. M. York, the brother of the missing man, Was there. To his sus picious mind the sudden and strpnge flight of the Bender family was a rev elation. He had found the first clue to his lost brother. He divulged hia suspicions and a band of men accom panied him to the Bender farm. The front room of the house was carefully searched, every crack and crevice be ing minutely looked into and subject ed to the application of rods and le vers to see if the flooring was either hollow or loose. Nothing came of it. No blood spots appeared. The floor was solid. The walls were solid. Next the party searched the back room. The beds were removed. In their flight the Benders had left everything untouched.
A correspondent reports that an old man believed to be John Bender has been captured and jailed in Fremont, Dodge County, Nebraska, with a woman thought to be his wife or mistress. The piece recounts the Benders' history in Kansas, describing their roadside inn, the old woman's claims of mediumship, and the family's reputation for murder.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Delaware State Journal · 12 August 1880 · page 1
THE BENDERS.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Delaware State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
The report narrates the 1870s disappearances near Cherryvale, including Dr. York's doomed investigation into his missing relatives and the Benders' sudden flight after his visit. It describes the subsequent discovery of the abandoned, dust-covered Bender house and a thorough but initially fruitless search of its floors and walls for evidence.
Delaware State Journal · 12 August 1880 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Delaware State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
Searchers at the abandoned Bender farm find a hidden trap door leading to a blood-stained pit, then uncover a shallow grave containing a body identified as Dr. York, his skull crushed and throat cut. Continued digging in the orchard area reveals the graves of ten murdered people, including two children.
solid. solid. Next tho party searched the back The beds were removed. In their flight the Benders had left everything un touched. Tbe explorers were about to retiro when they noticed a depression in tho floor. A they trap door was revealed. It was lifted up. trap
A dispatch from Fremont, Nebraska reports that a woman identifying herself as Mrs. Bender confessed to the Bender farm murders of 1872-73, describing victims including a family with two children buried alive. The report notes skepticism, stating that if this is not the original Bender woman, that fact could easily be verified.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Topeka Tribune · 12 August 1880 · page 1
CRIMINALITIES MRS BEND&B MAKES A CONFESSION. A dispatch from Fremont, Neb., dated the 3 1. says: There were important develop ments in the Bender matter to-day. Mrs. Ben der ma^e a full confession of all the horrible murders committed on John Bender's farm during 1872 and 1873. She was a widow when she married McGregor, alias Bender, who was a widower with four children. They migrated from Missouri to Labette county, Kan - , where, under the leadership of K‘>p, old John’s daughter, the murders and robberies began. Mrs. Bender declares that sho had no personal
A witness named Hooflin who had known the Bender family in Kansas was brought to view a prisoner in Fremont, Nebraska, and identified him as old man Bender, though less certain about the woman. Officers reportedly knew the whereabouts of Kate and John Bender Jr. and were setting out to capture them, with a meeting with John Bender expected that day.
OLD MAN BENDER IDENTIFIED. A dispatch from Fremont, Neb., dated the 30 ;h, says: To-day a man named Hooflm, who formerly resided in the Bender neighbor hood in Kansas, and who knew the old man personally, was admitted to the prisoner’s presence, and identified the man as actually old man Bender. De is not so positive as to the woman. The we man claims that Mrs. Ben der died in 1876. The whereabouts of Kate avd John Bender, jr., has been disclosed, and the officers are en route to capture them. The prisoners were to have met John Bender to-day in this state.
Two people suspected of being the Benders were arrested in Dodge County, Nebraska, after suspicious behavior and overheard conversation. Under interrogation, the male suspect, calling himself McGregor, gave shifting and contradictory accounts of his time at the Bender house, eventually admitting he witnessed multiple murders there.
mont. Dodge county, in Nebraska. At Hicbland Station, Just west of Schuvler. their actions and some conversation overheard between them led to a sus picion of their Identity, and informa tion or their whereabouts was con veyed to Sheriff Gregg of Dodge coun ty, - who ' found and arrested them. After being lodged in jail they were watcned by persons concealed from them, and the old; man was heard to say that he knew if he came back to ward Kansas he would be banged." The woman was afterward removed from the cell in, which the two were at first confined, and the old man was told that she had been sent to Kansas in ad vance of him.
See moreSee less
He said at first that he only passed - one night ' at Bender's house, near Cherryvale. His name, he said, was McGregor. On the night wnen the uenders left Kansas, he saw them put two children in a hole in the garden and cover them with dirt. On the same night they killed a man who stopped at the house for entertainment. When closely cross-examined the pris oner admitted that he had stopped with tne uenaers ror - six weeks, and ' ex plained his presence there by saying ne naa scoppea on nis way east from Fort Lincoln. He said that during nis six weeKs stay at uenuer s house he saw six people murdered there. One entire family was killed, two children
A woman interrogated in 1880 gives a detailed account of the Bender murders near Labette County, Kansas, describing the killing of a man named Brown, two strangers, and a family with two young girls who were buried alive. The report notes uncertainty about whether this woman is connected to the actual Bender family, stating the fact could easily be established.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Lake County Star · 12 August 1880 · page 3
1873. ' She was a widow and 1873. ' Bhe when she married McGregor, alias Bender, who was a widower with four children. They migrated from Missouri to Labette county, Kansas, where, under the leadership of Kate, old John's daughter, the murders and robberies began. Mrs. Bender declares
A newspaper report claims that an elderly man identified as John Bender, held in jail at Fremont, Nebraska, confessed his crimes to a reporter and a man named Shedd who posed as helping him escape. The account states he corroborated his wife's earlier confession and for the first time admitted his identity as the notorious Kansas murderer.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Redwood Gazette · 12 August 1880 · page 2
IT was reported on the 6th that old man Bender, in jail at Fremont, Neb., had made a full confession of his many crimes. A man named Shedd and a reporter of the Omaha Republican had a long interview with him under the pretense of assisting him to escape. He corroborated every important particular of the confession of his wife. He made no secret of his Identity as Bender, and gave a complete history of Kate, John and Maggie. This was the first time he had talked freely, and the first time he had ad mitted that he was John Bender, of Kansas notoriety.
See moreSee less
DR. TANNER entered on the fortieth and last day of his fast on the 6th. He was very feeble, but still persistent and courage ous. His weight was 198 pounds, pulse 88 and temperature 99. MR. J. LLOYD HAIGB, a contractor and manufacturer of New York, has been con victed of the forgery of bank acceptances on the Grocers' Bank of New York, and sen tenced to four years' hard labor In the State Prison. THE population of California is 863, 000, a gain of 8118,000 since 1870. The census gives Nebraska a population of 453,443, tohis head and« revolver lying by his side, ww »t is supposed that after the accident, despairing of recovery, he shot himself. THE following Congressional nomi nations were announced on the 5th: First Ohio District, B. A. Butterworth, Repub lican (renominated) Second Ohio, Thomas
A Fremont, Nebraska dispatch reports that a woman identified as Mrs. Bender (also known as Mrs. McGregor) gave a full confession about the Bender farm murders of 1872-1873, claiming Kate Bender was the true leader of the killings. She described her marriage to John Bender/McGregor and life among Sioux tribes, while distancing herself from direct involvement in the murders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Redwood Gazette · 12 August 1880 · page 2
A HORRIBLE STORY. The Wnui A rrr.trd at Vremoat, tawMiJ til fife Stri. John Header, SlekrMlBa •W Work ^tke lakaaaa n«4i. ^.Fremont (Neb.) special to the Chi ciago Tribune of the 3a says: Further startling developments were made in the Bender matter to-day. Mrs. Bender, or Mrs. McGregor, made a full and complete confession of the whole matter, even to the minutest details regarding the butcheries perpetrated on the John Bender farm during 1872 and 1873. She denies having had any personal hand in the matter, but says Kate, old John's daughter, was the leader ol all tbe deviltry.
See moreSee less
She went over her entire history from the time she became Mrs. Alexander McUregor. She was a widow at the time she married McUregor, alias Bender, who was a widower with four children, two of whom were Kate add John, Jr. They migrated from Mis* Souri to Labette County, Kan., aud became Johb Bender and family: She is under the im pression tbat Kate has been captured, and,
A dispatch from Fremont, Nebraska reports that a woman claiming to be Mrs. Bender gave a full confession detailing the murders committed on the Bender farm in 1872-1873, including the killing of a family of four whose children were buried alive. The report itself notes uncertainty about whether she is truly one of the original Benders, saying this could 'easily be established.'
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Weekly Chillicothe Crisis · 12 August 1880 · page 4
CRIME.
CKIMK. A dispatch from Fremont, Nob., dated the 3d, says: There wero important develop ments in the Bender matter to-dny. Mm. Ben der made ft full confession of all the borriblt murders committed on John lender's farm during 1872 and 1873. tilie was a widow when be married McGregor, alias Bender, who was a widower with four children. Tuey migra ted from olissourl to Labette county, Kaunas, where, under the leadership of Kate, old John's daughter, the murders and robberies began Irs, Bender declares that she bad no personal hand in these crimes. The first pernor, killed
Sheriff Greffir of Dodge County, Nebraska, arrived in Omaha pursuing John and Kate Bender, claiming he already held old man Bender captive in the Fremont jail. He expressed confidence that locating the rest of the family would be easy, motivated by a $16,000 reward for the entire gang.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Weekly Chillicothe Crisis · 12 August 1880 · page 4
will now go to tbo criminal court. -1? Sheriff Greffir. of Dodtro county, N braska, the raptor of oil Bender, airivcl in Omaha, on the Int. on the trail of young John and Kate. Tho ntlionr is confident that ho ha
A railroad contractor named Stewart identifies an old man jailed in Fremont, Nebraska as the original Bender, claiming prior familiarity with the family. A Kansas sheriff travels to Fremont to retrieve the prisoners in connection with the Bender murders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Weekly Chillicothe Crisis · 12 August 1880 · page 4
off into the shank of an unsuspecting yonth T near by. Amputation will bo necessary in the com ot tne latter. Mr. Stewart, a railroail contractor, haw Identified the old man In ail at Fremont, Neb., as the original Bender. Htewart was once well acquainted with the family, and is or undent that ho is not mistaken. A Ktiisas sheriff hot gone to Fremont for the purpose of removing the prisoners to tho scece of their on met. A burtrlar from Chicago who arrived in Horrtion, III, on Sunday, was found late that mgnt ptowiing around a private residence, and in endeavoring to escape was shot by an officer. Ho dioii on tho following cvenina. stating jost before dissulnllon that bis name was Henry Moore.
A Chicago Tribune special from Fremont, Nebraska reports that a woman identified as Mrs. Bender (also called Mrs. McGregor) has made a complete confession detailing the Bender farm murders of 1872-1873, though she denies personal involvement and blames Kate Bender as the ringleader. The report describes her physical appearance and demeanor while in custody, comparing her to Jesse James's mother.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Iron County Register · 12 August 1880 · page 2
A Fremont fNeb.) special to tbe Chi cago Tribune ol the 3d says: Further startling developments were made ia the bender matter to-uy. Mrs. Bender, or Mrs. McUregor, made a full and complete confeaaioa of the hole matter, even to the minutest details regardiag the butcheries perpetrated on the John Bender farm during loTi aad 1873. bhe denies having had any personal hand la the matter, bat says Kate, old John's daughter, was She leader ot all the deviltry. She went over ber entire history from tne time she became Mrs.
See moreSee less
Aleiaoder McUregor. bhe was a w.dow at the time she,, married McUregor, alias Bender, who was s widower with four children, two of whom were Kale and John, Jr. Tbey migrated Irota Mis souri to Labette Ooauty, Kan., and became John Bender and family, bbe Is under the Im pression that Kate has been captured, and,
A newspaper interview presents a confession-style account from someone claiming to have lived with the Benders, describing the killings of Brown, the Longcor family, and Dr. York, including the live burial of the two children. The text includes an editorial correction noting the family's true surname was Loncore, not Blackmore as the confessor stated.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Iron County Register · 12 August 1880 · page 2
Uregor or Mr. Bender, she replied I 1 he latter will do If too be satis fled, as you be here to see Mrs. Bender." 'You have no objection to giving a Little history of your life I" On, no; for the Sheriff batold me that I am to be free, and not to go to Kansas with the ole man. and I never did kill no one any way." - Were you married to Bender in Kansas I" MI was a widow, aud he man led me at Springfield, lit, at the close of the war.
See moreSee less
I can't remember what year, but 'Squire Sedar tied the knot. Hi name then was Alexander McGregor, and he had four chlmren, John and Kate neiiig of tbe number; but two of the boy had run ofL He wa a poor cus, but we lived about several years, and then were sent by the county to Dunkirk County. In Southwest Missouri, where sister lived. All this fa true." .... You went by the name of McGregor!" 'We did to the name till the ole mau went to Kansas and took up a homestead In Leblt County, I believe, when he changed it to John Bender, and, arter about a year, John and Kate came along, and then the devil began to be played." "What do you mean by thatl" 'Well, there was stealia', th levin' and kill in, and all that." . , "Who was the first person killed by the family I" "He was a sick man named Brown. He came along one afternoon. Tbe house was a good-sisedone, and ou a sign was tirocerles outside the door, and seelu' thl he stopped. We took him in, and tbe second night we got him up to eat unper, and while seated st tho table John Bender let him Into the cellar, where Kate or John killed him, and tbe next day tbey buried him in tbe garden. " How long after this before any one else was killed!" "I don't quite remember, but not long. Two were killed, and one of them, whose name I believe was someming line mo Gruthy or McGrath, had a cood deal of money; at least Jonn iota me so." "Do you remember about a whole family being killed 1" "Ye, I do. There was a man and wife and two little girls. They drove up In a covered spring wagon, and wanted toStay all night. Kate Bender raid ther oould slay. It was about two o'clock In the afternoon,
Dispatches from Omaha and Fremont claim members of the Bender family have been arrested, with 'Old Bender' confessing to murders including the first killing in Illinois. The account details the family's claimed history of murder for money across Illinois, Iowa, Indiana, and Kansas, including grisly specifics from Kate Bender.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Helena Weekly Herald · 12 August 1880 · page 5
Bender Arrested Omaha, August 3. —A sensation was crea ated here by the arrest of a party supposed to be John Bender jr. and family. to Fkkmont, Neb, August 6.—Old Bender has has confessed another murder to a relative of the the victim, saying that he had $2,200 on his person. The old woman says Kate and John are full brother and sister and have four children. They are in the timber near Avoca, Iowa, and will soon be captured. Omaha, August 6.—To-day Mrs. Bender was visited at the jail at Fremont.
See moreSee less
She said the first murder ever committed by her and her husband was in Illinois, on their farm near Jacksonville. The victim asked for lodging and supper, and in paying for the same in advance exhibited considerable money. While he was eating supper Bender cut his head in two from behind, and he was dumped into the cellar through a trap door arranged by Bender. The corpse was buried the next morning back of the house. A few weeks after this they went to Iowa and re mained eight months. They then went to Indiana, living on the murdered man's money, and then to Kansas, where Bender's children by his first wife—John and Kate—were liv ing, together with their cousin Maggie. They kept a resort for travellers and called it Bender's Hotel, and had committed no mur ders prior to the old folk's arrival, but in the course of time old Bender arranged a trap door, and then the murdering operations began. Kate at one time had a man in bed with her and she cut his throat and slept till morning beside the corpse. His money was divided. She never injured horse thieves and cut the throats of those that came to the house, but entertained them well with her cousin Maggie. No murders were committed by the family after they fled from Kansas. Old Bender has confessed, believing that the old woman has escaped. His story tallies with his wife's exactly. He relates the story of their whole family and their crimes. The Sheriff from Kansas is now at Lincoln ob taining a requisition from the Governor, and will be at Fremont to-morrow.
The report describes a man allegedly confessing to being Old Man Bender, giving a detailed account of the family's murders in Kansas and their escape to Iowa and Indiana. A Kansas sheriff is said to be en route to obtain a requisition for the suspect's extradition.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
A Nebraska farmer, Daniel Congdon, tipped off Sheriff Gregg after an old man and woman staying at his house let slip details about the Bender murders, including the canvas wall trick and the California victim. The pair were arrested, gave conflicting stories about their identity, and were overheard discussing their fear of being hanged if taken to Kansas.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Nebraska Advertiser · 12 August 1880 · page 1
ECHOES OF SORROWS
T7nioL -Hotel. t ped at his house for food and lodging. and as he was about to let them sleep in the stable, the oM woman objected to entering the place, as she was afraid of soaae trap door or hole, and thereup on he turned them over to his neigh bor, Mr. Herndoo. After swpper at Hemdon's, the old ffian said. By the way, is there any talk of this "Bender murder now?" Hera said -No, not efa." The aki rata said. '"I used to know them Benders ; stepped at their house many i Thev killed oee man and wire i a time. aad buried their two ehUdren alive." j T i!vr tW old man. bT a slin . -j'-S T ' W XT I
Two prisoners believed to be Bender family members have a tense jailhouse conversation about fear of being hanged in Kansas and distrust of each other, then are questioned separately and deny being Benders. A longtime Kansas neighbor named Hoodan confronts the old man in his cell and insists he recognizes him as Bender despite the man's denials.
Nebraska Advertiser · 12 August 1880 · page 1
BEOW!STyiLLE, NEBRASKA, i Hooflaa Xour name may not be Bender, bat yoa toJd me repeatedly, that was veor name inisas, anditrs no use for vou. to denv it here.' Bender "I was there, and remem ber you distinctly. I had nothing to do with any of those murders." Hoodan "Bid you ever see anybody murdered there?" Bender "I saw eleven persons mur dered thersr. Hoofess -"VGas there more than one child faurietf "i-sure?" BeEo-"XIere were two " Hoouarr -How do you know there were two?" Bender 1 saw them take them out of the room, asleep and put them in the graves.
See moreSee less
I was in the out bedroom." Hooflan "There is no use saying that. There was no bedroom in. the house." Bender "I was in the back room." Hoofian "You couldn't see into the peach orchard from the biek room." Bender "I saw them in the grave next day." Hooflan "Hot did you see them? Were thev covered up? Did you take the dirt off of them?" Bender "They were oaly buried st inches under the ground." Mr. Shed, who was present at the in terview, said to the old man, -That's a lie. You can't see six inches under the ground." Bender thereupon confessed that he helped to put them under the ground, etc. and he burst out crying, and exclaim ed, "I doa't care a G d d n. Let 'em hane me and be d d." On being tokl that he would have to go to Kansas, he swore most emphatij ealty that he would not go there, but , he was willing to go anywhere else, i and that he would kill himself before he would be taken to Kansas. Hoodan showed him a plan of the old house and surrouadin-s, which he acknowledged was correct. Hooflan then left him and called up on the woman, who eommeueed laugh ing when she saw him. and when asked if she knew him she replied : "Yes, I know you. How do you do, 1 1 ILr. Huff an? (as she called Mieu)
A detective named Hoodan confronts an elderly prisoner and a woman claimed to be the Benders, pressing them with details about the murder house. The old man eventually breaks down, admitting to seeing bodies buried and helping cover them, while the woman acknowledges they have been caught and will hang.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Nebraska Advertiser · 12 August 1880 · page 1
IDENTITY OF THE PRISONERS
T7nioL -Hotel. t selves of that family. rDENTTTY OF THE FEISONEES. A Mr. Hoodan. who for the post six years has been a resident of Fremont. y loth, was for two years, prior to July "faaifly is 3, a neighbor of the Bender in Kansas, and herded cattle within three-quarters of a mile of their house on Agerese creek, sixteen miles northeast of iEdependeace. aad about the same distance from Osage mission, on the saaie thoroughfare from ladepen - denee to the latter place. He saw the Benders quite oftea durhg his residence there, and became!
See moreSee less
quite well actiuainted with them. Hear- ; i . U J in 5 w. fcue attest, m lbc wu ukiii ami woman, he went to the jail at Fremont to see them. As he entered the eell ia I which the old man is confined, the at - I - tl I t-i , -r-T- ., i kci iuue. at, nun. very aoseiy. iioooan. i shoved his hat to "the back of bis ' head, and the foowit co.versation then took place: Hoodan Did yoa ever see this face before?" j Bender "Yes, I know you, bet I i can t place you. TTnvu . TXT.
The paper reports that it is reprinting an account of the capture, interviews, and confessions of the elder Benders, compiled from Omaha and Kansas City dailies, claiming their guilt is now certain. It further states that John and Kate Bender have also been located and will be produced when needed, with full details promised in the next issue.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Nebraska Advertiser · 12 August 1880 · page 3
Schick, Esq., Col. Sam Ricb and Hon. Church Howe. "We warrant they will do justice to the cause. The Guards of Brownville and a number of others will go to Sheridan on that occasion. Let tlie people of tlie center of the county turn out en masse and have a big meeting. On the outside of this issue we have thestoryofthecapture interviews and parts of confessions of old Bender and wife, compiled from tlie elaborate statements made through the Omaha Kansas City and other dailies, believ ing it will be interesting reading to many of our readers wbo have not ac cess to the daily general news.
See moreSee less
Old man Bender as well as the obi woman has made confessions which leave not the least doubt that two of the fiends of Cherryvale are at last in a fair way of meeting their just deserts. We learn that John and Kate Bender have been found and will be forth coming when wanted. In our next issue Ave will give further full particulars cov ering every, feature ot interest.
A telegram reports that Sheriff Gregg of Fremont County has arrested a couple believed to be old Bender and his wife, with the woman denying she is Kate Bender. The sheriff is still hunting young Bender and his wife, with a large reward offered for their capture.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Eaton Democrat · 12 August 1880 · page 4
The Bender Fiends. The Bender famfly; notorious murderers, well known throughout the country,, are at last tomeeij .their .just retribution. A telegram I rum umuuL hvb uum, onerm vjreKK, Ul XKKiro uonnty, arrested oia enaer ana nis wire, who) are now in rremont jau, and is hunting m the trail of young Bender and wife; wha, were seen., with a team and wagon in -company with old Bender and wife,' who were on foot near SchujS ler, and they parted near there. ' Sheriff Gregg savs that whenhe arrested tne old couple he rode up to them and said: "Hello, Kate.",.
See moreSee less
The woman replied; "I ain't Kate Bender.". Gregg believes he has a sure thing on the old man, but thinks the woman is Bender's mistress, and that they have' killed his wife. . .The original old Bender was a German, and had a big sear on the center of the bead. . The prisoner at Tremont has a scar, but swears he does' not know a word of German. 'A' Dutchman put Into the sell' with instructions to curse bint in his mother tongue. ' ' Old Bender forgot him self and swore terrifically, at the man -in Ger- ;ina! Bender asked for a razor to shave, but Gregg, fearmg- .h would' commit suidai; .reV fnsad, snd hid t "-t""- n t.i ciriff Gregg is determined to capture .young Bender, aji it is rnidere6od-4V25, 000 Kwardis'oSrered for ihe whole gang. Of tins-amount 811, ( 11,000 is for
Authorities in Fremont, Nebraska have arrested an elderly man and woman believed to be the parents from the notorious Bender murder family, who allegedly gave a partial confession and named the whereabouts of the younger Bender son and daughter Kate. The report recounts the original Bender horrors at their roadside inn near Cherry Valley, Kansas, while cautioning this could again be a hoax.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Der Westbote · 12 August 1880 · page 1
Die Mörderfamilie Bender.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The article retells the Bender family's murders in their Kansas roadside inn, describing how victims were lured, killed, and buried, and how Dr. York's disappearance led his brother to investigate and ultimately expose the killings. It notes that since the Benders' flight, numerous people have been wrongly arrested across the states on suspicion of being family members.
Der Westbote · 12 August 1880 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes how suspicion against the Bender family arose only after their flight, following which their house and garden were searched and confirmed horrific crimes. It details the ongoing manhunt, numerous wrongful arrests of innocent people mistaken for Benders, and current detained suspects whose identities remain unconfirmed as the sheriff travels to verify them.
Der Westbote · 12 August 1880 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
This article announces that one of the notorious Bender killers has been positively identified and safely imprisoned, then recounts the original 1873 case background: Dr. William H. York's disappearance near the Bender family's roadside inn in Labette County, Kansas, and the family's sudden flight once neighbors grew suspicious. It frames this as the resolution of the long manhunt following the Bender butchers' crimes.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Stark County Democrat · 12 August 1880 · page 6
STORY OF THE BENDER BUTCHERS.
Pomeroy had at that time made him fa mous. The story of York's disappear ance was now in every mouth, and every effort w.tu put forth to solve the mystery of his absence. Rivers were dragged, spots fit for an ambush were probed foot by foot, lonesome places were quested aa keen hot) id scents a trail that is cpld, a and still no traces of the lost man were discovered. Not a shadow of evidence rested any where to say that Dr. York had been murdered not a sign anywhere told how he came to his death, if indeed death had overtaken him unawares..
See moreSee less
He was traced to Ciierry vale, in Labette Co., but no further. There all track and trace him ended, About two miles south of Cherryvale, in a rude frame house s'anding in a lot of two acres in dimensions lived the Ben der family. There were four of them father, mother, son and daughter. The mother was a Spiritualist. She called herself a medium; the neighbors called hera8b9-devil. She had a way of boil ing herbs and roots that were supposed to have charms and spells about them, and she dealt in incantations. She was repulsive in aspect tall, angular and scrawny, with hard, steel gray eyes, and thin, ragged gray hair straggling over her templaa. The family seem to have been totally under the influence of this ungain ly creature. Her word with them was law. The Benders ostensibly kept a gro eery. A sign was displayed in front of their rude dwelling. The only articles they dealt in was cheap native wine which they served on the spot. There were two rooms in the house, one used a kitchen and dining room, and the aa uumr hb n nieuping apartment. While the excitement over the mvsterious disappearance of Dr. York wan at its height a party of Uherrvva e citizurm dropped in at the Bender mansion and casually inquired of the family if they had at any time during the oast, six weeks anything of York. The answer was the negative and the suhient w in dropped. The visit and the questioning of the Cherryvale party had astranee ef. . . n n . V r ieci upon me ijenaers. They anddenly disappeared ; nor were they seen again ' " T ' , .
After the Bender family vanished amid suspicion over Dr. York's disappearance, a passerby found their homestead abandoned with a starved calf and undisturbed furniture. Searchers led by Senator York then discovered a concealed trap door in the back room leading to a deep pit beneath the house.
The Stark County Democrat · 12 August 1880 · page 6
The report describes the exhumation of multiple bodies from the Bender farm property, including the corpse of Dr. York showing a crushed skull and cut throat. It identifies several victims by name and describes the method of murder, while claiming authorities are now close to capturing the fugitive Bender family.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Stark County Democrat · 12 August 1880 · page 6
Mr. Loncar was not found. It was bn ried in toe corner of the garden that was not careiully probed. Tne victims had probably been attracted to the Bender house by the conspicuously displayed grocery sign. A stranger waB inveigled into the death trap and invited to a glass of wine or something to eat. As he sat at the table in the back room one of his treacherous hosts smote him with a ham mer, crushing his skull and killing him instantly, but to insure death his throat was ripped from ear to ear, and he was hurriedly dropped through the trapdoor into the bloody cavern beneath.
See moreSee less
Id the dead of night the body was removed to the garden and buried. These ghastly crimes were committed solely for gold. Whoever entered the Bender mansion alone and with money, it mattered not how little, died like a brute. Loncar was one of Dr. York's neighbors and had started for Iowa with a view to locating permanently. Casually stopping at the bender place be was brutally mur dered. His skull was smashed to a jelly, his throat cut and his body mutilated. His little child had evidently been tossed into the grave upon the mangled corpse and buried alive. The discovery of the inhuman butcher ies perpetrated by the Bender family was made seven years ago. For seven years dilligent search tor the bloody murderers has been pursued in every land bn the face of the earth. Up to four days ago the search was unavailing. But justice, though tardy, is sure, and once in the hands of the grossly outraged law, the Benders will speedily suffer the penalty of the fhndish atrocities. The gallows upon which they die should be built bo high as all the world might see and en joy ths death throes of these most inhu man wretches with which civilization has been cursed since the days of Saw ney Bean and his incestuous family of canniDale.
A Nebraska dispatch claims Mrs. Bender (also called Mrs. McGregor) has been captured and made a full confession detailing the murders at the Bender farm, blaming daughter Kate as the ringleader. The report describes her physical appearance and background, comparing her to outlaw Jesse James's mother.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Milan Exchange · 12 August 1880 · page 7
Capture of the Benders.
A Fremont (Neb.) special to the Chi cago Tribune of the M says: lurtberiiirtlinsr tlevelupmeots were made in i lie bender mailer to-iijy. Mrs. Bender, or .Vr. MeUregur, made a luil and Cumjileus
A newspaper report presents an interview with a woman identified as Mrs. Bender (also known as Mrs. McGregor), who gives her life history and describes the family's killings, including the murder of a sick traveler named Brown. She claims innocence of direct killing while implicating her husband and children in the crimes.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Milan Exchange · 12 August 1880 · page 7
Being asked it she would be called Mrs. Mc Gregor or Mrs. Bender, she replied: - 1 he latter will do if vou be satisfied, as you be here to see Mrs. Beuder." "You have no objection to ftivtng a little history of your lilef ' "Oh, no; for the Sheriff has told me that I r.m to lie free, and not to go to Kausas with the ole man, aud I never did kill no one any way." ' Were you married to Bender in Kansas i" " I was a widow, and he married me at
The report notes that nearly seven years after fleeing, the Bloody Benders remain at large, and that if the people of Labette County, Kansas get hold of them first, little mercy will be shown. It recalls the horror of their murder house and the impunity with which the family operated.
The Weekly Democratic Statesman · 12 August 1880 · page 1
The people of Labette, county Kansas, will claim the right of first dealing with the Benders, and when they, get through with them there will not, probably, be anything more of the Bender family on this earth. It was in Labette county they lived in. a home that was a death-trap to every one who entered it, and in which . they pursued their horrid avocatiou of murder with a secrecy and impunity that surprises us; and we may take it for granted that that community will show (hem as little mercy as they were accustomed to xtend to their ill-fated victims. It is nearly seven years since this fam ily of murderers fled from their home and began a series of wander ings that, perhaps, has no parallel.
A report states that an elderly man and woman suspected of being John and Kate Bender, members of the notorious Kansas murder family, have been identified at a jail in Fremont, Nebraska by a former neighbor. The article states they will be sent to Kansas and that capture of the rest of the family is expected.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Weekly Democratic Statesman · 12 August 1880 · page 4
It is reported that the old man aud woman suspected ot being John aud Kate Bender, of the notorious Bender family of Kansas accused of
Two people claimed to be Bender family members were transported to Oswego, Kansas, and questioned by the prosecuting attorney, but denied making any confession and claimed their name was McGregor. Authorities and witnesses expected to identify them had not yet arrived, and officials doubted these were the actual wanted Benders.
The Dallas Daily Herald · 12 August 1880 · page 1
THE ALLEGED BENDERS TAKEN TO KANSAS NOT IDENTIFIED
Dal Not Identified. Oswego, Kan., Aug. 11. Sheriff Bender of this county, accompanied by Daniel Condon, of Fremont, Nebraska, arrived here at one o'clock this morning with the so-called Ben ders. The party lift Kansas City at 6:40 o'clock yesterday afternoon, and at every station along the lint of the Gulf road there wsre imtueus crowds to catch a glimpse of tho notorious prisoners. On arrival here the old man and woman were locked up, and at ton o'clock this morning they were takon Into the court-roam whore they were interrogated by' prosecuting attorney Waters and others.
See moreSee less
They denied that they bad ever made a confession, but the old man admitted that he was an inmato of Bender's house for six weeks, he being sick and unable to got away. It is generally be lieved that theso are not the parti s wanted, although the old man is thought to hnvo been at Bender's. They claim that their namo is McGregor, and that they were on thoir way to Jaeksoi.ville, III., when arrested. They did not know they were being takej to Kan nt until Parsons was reached, and then the old nuin raved and swore in a frightful man ner. To-dav both appeared uuconcerned, and they will be liborattd in a day or two. McGregor says that whilo ho wa at Bonder's Kate and John threw a man through the fatal trap-door, letting him fall Into the cellar, where ha wis afterwards murdered. CM man Bonder then secured the victim's money, which he kept, refusing ti divide with his children. Parties were expected here this afternoon from Cherryvale to iden tify them, but they fuilvd to come, and will not bo here until to-morrow af.ernoon. Colonel Waters thinks neither of them is of sound mind, but informed your repoi ter that tney woull bo held for a fow days to await developments. No oio except the party nuking .the arrest thinks the prisoners ar the Benders, although they are cerlain that the old man is cognisant of some of tho crimes committed by them. Both art notorious prevaricators.and but little reliance Ckn be placed lanything they say. The gen eral opinion in this community is that old man Bender and fanily were killed by a u ob before they wore able to got out of Labette county. After an interview of an hour the par ties under arrest were again remanded"to jail, and at 5 o'clock this afternoon another interview was held with them by prominent citi.ens and reporters, when it was ascer tained beyond the possibility of a doubt that the prisoners were not tho Bonders.and there aro many who doubt whether they over saw them. Wn It Murder or niddeT
Two men arrested as suspected Benders, claiming to be a McGregor father and son headed to Jacksonville, Illinois, were questioned at length and eventually confirmed not to be the Benders. The old man made claims about witnessing Kate and John Bender murder a victim via the trap-door, but officials doubted the prisoners' reliability and the general belief was that the Bender family had already been killed by a mob.
Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio · and 1 other paper
This is an interview-style account in which a witness describes how the Benders murdered various travelers, including a sick man named Brown, a man with money, a family with children, and Dr. York. The newspaper interjects its own correction, noting the family's name was actually Longhor and only one child's body was recovered.
outside the door, and seein' this he stopped. We took him in, and the second night we got him up to cut supper, and while sealed at the table John Bender let him Into the cellar, w here Kate or John killed him, und the next day they buried him in the garden. " How long alter this before any one else was killed!" "1 don't quite remember, but not long. Two were killed, and one of them, whoso name I believe was something like Mc Cruthy or MeOtath, had a good deal of money; at least John told me so."
See moreSee less
" Do you remember about a whole family being killed!" "Yes, I do. Thero wa a man and wife and two little girls. They drove up In a covered spring wagon, and wanted to stay all night. Kate Bender said thev could stay. It was about two o'clock In tho afternoon,
The Milan Exchange · Milan, Tenn. · 12 August 1880
The Emporia News · Emporia, Kan.
The Kansas City Times published images of the McGregors, who have caused a sensation with unverified claims connecting them to the 1872 Cherryvale Bender murders. This paper mocks their appearance and suggests they are likely impostors who should drop the pretense.
The Emporia News · 13 August 1880 · page 2
The Kansas City Times of Tuesday publishes wood-cuts of the McGregors, who have created such a sensation by their unaccountable stories in relation to tho Cherryvale butchers of '72. Tiny
A sheriff reportedly sold custody of alleged Bender family members to a showman in Kansas City for $25, who charged the public twenty-five cents to view them. The report then reveals this was likely false, as the supposed Benders could not be identified by anyone from their former neighborhood.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Emporia News · 13 August 1880 · page 2
An outrage which call-for a summary find sweeping reprimand was committed when the sheriff having in custody the alleged Benders, gave the prisoners, fur the sum of f 2.1, into the hands of a show man
The report calls the Bender murders the most horrible crimes of modern times, surpassing even De Quincey's famous accounts. It notes the bizarre recent attempt by an elderly couple to falsely connect themselves to the Bender crimes, a phenomenon the writer finds inexplicable.
The Hickman Courier · 13 August 1880 · page 2
Tho most horrible cases of murder reported iu modern times have been those of the Benders in Kansas Iu horrible details and in unrelieved biu
An elderly couple arrested in Dodge County, Nebraska, and believed to be the notorious Bender murderers, were brought to Labette County, Kansas, but found not to resemble the real Benders at all. They were revealed to be tramps who had impersonated the killers in order to get a free train ride.
Ohio, carrying 150 people to the bottom. Ono man was killed and many others severely in jured. Threo men wero killed and several seriously injured by a threshing-machine explo sion at Lakeland, Minn. Tho old couple, supposed to bo the bloodthirsty Bender and his wife, lately ar rested in Dodge county, Neb., turn out to bo gross impostors. When they arrived at tho sceno of tho Bender atrocities in Labette coun ty, Kansas, they wero found to bear no rc-em-blauco to tho original Benders. They aro tramps, and undoubtedly personated tho Cher ryvalo butchers with a view of obtaining a free railroad ride, in which they succeeded.
A dispatch reports that a former Jacksonville, Illinois resident identified two prisoners held at Fremont, Nebraska—believed to be the Benders—as the McGregors, a family he had known as having bad character. The report also notes that "Old Bender" confessed, believing his wife had escaped custody, and that his account matched hers exactly.
Tribnn; on the 0th, stated that, a former res ilient of Jacksonville, 111., had identified the two prisoners at Fremont, Neb., supposed to be the Benders, as the MeGrcgors, of Jack sonville. The man savs he knew them there as hardcharacter and he left Illinois forKansa with them In a wagon train, and that Mc Gregor, who is thought to bo Identical with Bender, went to Labette County. Old Bender
A Chicago Tribune dispatch from Fremont, Nebraska reports that a woman arrested there and believed to be Mrs. John Bender has given a full confession detailing the Bender farm murders of 1872-73, naming Kate Bender as the ringleader while denying her own direct involvement. The report describes her appearance and notes she believes Kate has also been captured, which may explain her willingness to talk.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Perrysburg Journal · 13 August 1880 · page 4
A HORRIBLE STORY. The Woman Arrested at Fremont, Neb., and Supposed to Be Mrs. John Bender, Makes a Full Confession-Sickening Details of the Work of the Inhuman Fiends. A Fremont (Neb.) special to tho Chi cago Tribune of (ho 3d snys: FurtliiT Mnrtlinn ilcvolopmeuts were made In the Homier inattur to-nny. Mrs. Hcndor, or Mrs. McHipjror, mailc a lull ami c'ompleK confession of llio Klinle matter, even. ti tin numiti'st cli-talla rncarilliiK the butchcrlei
A reporter describes a woman in custody, alleged to be Mrs. Bender, who gives a physical description and recounts the family's history under the alias McGregor before becoming the Benders in Kansas. She describes the first murder victim, a sick traveler named Brown, lured in and killed in the cellar by John and Kate.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Perrysburg Journal · 13 August 1880 · page 4
A HORRIBLE STORY.
lleini; asked il the w ould bo called Mrs. Alc Orejjuror Mrs. Uender, she replieJ: ' 1 he hit ter will do it vou be satisfied, at you be here to see Mrs. Bender." " l'ou have no objection to Riving a little history of your life!'' "On, no; for the bherlH has told mo that I am to t,e free, and not to ro to Kaunas with the ole niu.il, and I never did kill nil one an; way." ' Were you married to Bender In Kansas!" "I was a widow, and he tnariicd me at
A Fremont, Nebraska dispatch claims that old Mrs. Bender confessed fully to the murders committed on the Bender farm in Labette County, Kansas, during 1872-1873. It describes her as a widow who married John Bender (alias McGregor), with the killings allegedly led by daughter Kate, while Mrs. Bender denied any personal hand in the crimes.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 13 August 1880 · page 2
WEST AND SOUTH. A Fremont, Neb., dispatch, on the 8d, stuted that old Mrs. Bender mado a full confession of all the horrible murders com mitted on the John Bender farm during 1872 and 1873. She was a widow when she married McGregor, allot Bender, who was a widower with four children. They migrated from Mis souri to Labette County, Kansas, where, un der the leadership or Kate, old John's daugh ter, the murders and robberies began. Mrs. Bender declares that she had no personal hand lu these crimes.
A Chicago Tribune special from Omaha reported that two prisoners held at Fremont, Nebraska, believed to be the Benders, were identified by a former Jacksonville, Illinois resident as the McGregors, a family of 'hard characters.' The report also claimed that 'Old Bender' made a confession matching his wife's story, believing she had escaped from prison.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Paper unidentified · 13 August 1880 · page 2
An Omaha special to the Chicago Tribune, on the 6th, stated that a former res ident of Jacksonville, III., hsd Identified the two prisoners at Fremont, Neb., supposed to be the Benders, as the McGregors, of Jack sonville. The man says be knew them there as hard characters and he left Illinois for Kan sas with them In a wagon train, and that Mc Gregor, who Is thought to be ldcntlcsl with Bender, went to Labette County. Old Bender made a confession, believing that his wife had escaped from prison. Ills story tallies with his wife's exactly.
See moreSee less
In Wobstor County, Ga., on the 5th, Mrs. Woodson L. Gunnel Is, wife of a well-to-do farmer, poisoned herself, four of her chil dren and live of her step-children. Mrs. Gun nells died, and no hopes of recovery were en tertained for threeof the children. The others were believed to be out of danger. A note In tho handwriting of Mrs. Gunnclls was found under some morphia on the tubte, in which she stated that she had deliberately adminis tered morphia to tho children and herself with the Intention of destroying them all, and that Bhe was not actuated by any domea tic trouble.
A Nebraska newspaper report claims a woman identified as Mrs. Bender (alias Mrs. McGregor) has confessed in detail to the Bender farm murders of 1872-73, blaming daughter Kate as the ringleader. The account describes her appearance and background, suggesting she will be returned to Kansas to face justice.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 13 August 1880 · page 2
Capture of the Benders. A Fremont (Nob.) special to the Chi. cago Tribune of the 3d says: Further startling developments were nsd In the Bender matter Uxlsv. Mrs. Bender, or Mrs. McGregor, made a lull and complete confession of the whole matter, even to ths minutest details regarding the butcheries periietrated on the John Bender farm during 1H72 and 187H. She denies having had any personal hand In the matter, but says Kate, old John's daughter, was the leader ot all ttis deviltry. She went over her entire history from the time she became Mrs.
See moreSee less
Alexsnder McGregor. She was a widow at the time sua married McGregor, alias Bender, who was widower wit h four children, two of whom were Kate and John, Jr. They migrated from Mis souri to Labette County, Kan., and becanis John Bender and family. She Is under the Im pression that Kate has been captured, and,
This article revisits the 1876 disappearance of Dr. William H. York near Cherryvale, Kansas, and the subsequent discovery of the murderous Bender family living nearby. It recounts the fruitless early search efforts before the Benders' crimes came to light, tying the story to their recent 1880 arrest in Nebraska on charges of ten murders.
Staunton Vindicator · 13 August 1880 · page 2
A Wonderful Family of Criminals
ow of evidence rested anywhere to say that Dr. ioik had been murdered—not a sign anywhere told how he came to his death, if indeed death had overtaken him una wares. He was traced to Cherryvale, in Labette county, but no further. There all track and trace of him ceased.
An elderly couple arrested in Dodge County, Nebraska, suspected of being the notorious Bloody Benders, were proven to be impostors. Upon being brought to Labette County, Kansas, they bore no resemblance to the real fugitives and were identified as tramps seeking a free train ride.
The Kenosha Telegraph · 13 August 1880 · page 1
DOMESTIC INTELLIGENCE.
Tlfo® men vjoFft killed uik several s( noiisly injured tiy a threshing-machine explo sion at Lakeland. Minn. The old couple, supposed to be the bloodthirsty Bender and his wife, lately ar rested in Dodge county,. Neb., turn ont to bo gross impostors. When they arrived at the set ne of (he Bender atrocities in Labette coun ty, Kansas, they were found to bear no resem blance) to tho original Benders. They are tramps, and undoubtedly personated tho Cher ryvale butchers with a view of obtaining a free railroad ride, ih which they succeeded.
See moreSee less
The dreaded Spjuiish fever has broken out among Texas in the vicinity of Mo bcrly, Mo. Gol, Grierson is still pursuing and fighting Aiclbfia's band of savages in Arizona and Now'Mexieo. , South. A horrible crime is reported from Americus, Ga. Mi’s. Webster Gunnells put some morphia into lemonade, which she then gayp her ten children to drink, and of which she herself partook. Three of the children and Mrs. Gunnells will die. No cause is assigned for the rash act.
The article ridicules as a "farce" the repeated false reports of old man Bender being captured in Nebraska, Minnesota, Utah, Arizona and elsewhere, noting Kansas and Labette County keep paying expenses for pursuing imposters. It then relays a letter from Iowa claiming a witness says the real Bender family of four was captured and stood before a firing squad of nine riflemen.
This report describes how neighbors grew suspicious after the Bender family abandoned their homestead, finding their wagon at a nearby town and a neglected calf left to starve. A search party used a wagon tongue to probe the ground and discovered York's grave, finding he had been killed by blows to the head with a blunt instrument.
Arizona Silver Belt · 14 August 1880 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes the discovery and exhumation of victims' graves near the Bender property, noting peculiarities such as crossed arms and skulls crushed by an axe. It also gives physical descriptions of the Bender family members and details a reward offered for their capture.
A letter from Iowa claims the Bender family of four was captured after the murder of Colonel York's brother was discovered, and were shot by nine riflemen after Kate defiantly taunted her executioners. The bodies were allegedly buried at the junction of four Kansas counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 14 August 1880 · page 8
The Benders — Another Account of their Extinction
Bender family, four in number, were cap tured soon after the discovery of the murder of Colonel York's brother. He says the four were stood up in a row facing nine riflemen, and were told ; their fate ; that Kate was pluck to the last, and called upon the cap tors to shoot and be d — and the four bodies were buried at th» corner of the four counties of Labette, Wilson, Neosho and Mont gomery. The I'sual Railroad Accident.
A letter reprinted from the Iowa State Register claims the four members of the notorious Bender family were captured by nine riflemen shortly after the murder of Col. Yorke was discovered. It alleges Kate Bender defiantly told her captors to "shoot and be damned," and that all four were executed and buried at the junction of four Kansas counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Evening Star · 14 August 1880 · page 4
Atwictwh, Knights.?The grand pi 'ate or th' Knights of St. George takes place oa Monday, ti>^ l^tA iLbtant. at Geo. Jagnflninn^ garden, ah ihos* w Nnir i; to enl jy tbemselvei are cordially invited to attend. t the information, on the authority ot an eyewitness. w ho is also a rcsponsiOle man. that the rctorlous Bender family, four in number, were captured soon alter the discovery of the murder of Col. Yorke. The eye-witness says that the lour were stood up in a row facing nine riilewen and were told their fate; that Kate was plucky to the last, and called upon the captors to " shoot and be damned," and that the four bodies were burled at the corner of the four counties of Labette, Wilson, Neosho and Montgomery.
A letter relayed secondhand claims that the four Benders were captured shortly after the murder was discovered, stood before riflemen, and executed, with Kate reportedly defiant to the end. The bodies were allegedly buried at the junction of four counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Rock Island Argus · 14 August 1880 · page 1
The Bandars. Des Moines. An. 13. A letter to ths State ReaisUr, from a responsible citizen of this state, Mr. 8. A James, of Sigour uey, gives information, on authority of an eye witness, also a responsible man, that the notorious Bender family, four in num ber, were captured soon after the discov ery of the murder of Col. lorke's brother. le says the four were stood un fnn?r. cine riflemen and were told their fate that Kate was pluck to the last and called upon tne captors to snoot and be damn. ed," and that tbe four todies were buried at the corner ot the tour counties of Labet-
A man and woman suspected of being John Bender and his daughter Kate were arrested near Schuyler in Dodge County, Nebraska, after acting suspiciously. The woman denies being a Bender but admits staying at the Bender house and witnessing multiple murders, while the man's story shifts under questioning.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
St. Landry Democrat · 14 August 1880 · page 2
THE BENDERS. PROBABLE CAPTURE OF THE MURDEROUS GANG.
East. They had excited suspicion at Richland Station, west of Schuyler. This information was conveyed to Sheriff Gregg, of Dodge county, who went out, found and arrested them. A conversation was overheard between them, in which the aid man said he "knew if he came back to Kansas he would he hung," consequently the two were separated, and he is made to be lieve she is sent down to Kansas ahead of him. She denies that they are the Benders, but says the old man is her husbaud, and that she had nothing to do with the murders.
See moreSee less
She confesses, though, that she stopped for a little while though at the house of the Ben ders, and says Dr. York's brother was murdered while she was there. She says they went to the railroad with the Benders when they tied. The Beuders took a train South, and would not take' her husbaud along. She saw at least ten people killed at Bender's, and says lier husbaud was sick there and she was nursing him. His story was, at first, that he was only one night at Bender's, and says his name is McGregor. lie says the night the Benders left Kansas they put the children in a hole and covered them with dirt. The same night they killed a man who stopped there. When closely cross-questioned he admitted he was at Bender's six weeks, and explains his presence there by saying he stopped while en route for the East from Fort Lincoln. He don't know where the Benders went to when they left Kansas, He went to Jackson ville, 111., traveling on foot, and called himself McGregor. Four weeks after lie saw Kate Bender between Springfield and Jacksonville, 111. She had men's clothes on, and her hair was cut short. He saw six people murdered when at Bender's house, and one entire family was killed, two childreu buried alive. He says his wife was born in Illinois, and she was the wife of George Ellison before he married her. His first wife died at Jacksonville sixteen years ago, and her name was Polly Peasley. They both say they have been five or six years among the Indians. An ap plication for a requisition lias been made to the Governor of Kansas. It is fully believed by all who have seen them that, if the genuine Benders are not captured, at least two important witnesses have been secured. The sheriff believes he has got the genuine Benders, and thinks he has got a clue to the whereabouts of young John Bender.
A woman and man arrested as suspected Benders give contradictory, shifting accounts of events at the Bender house, including witnessing multiple murders and children buried alive. Authorities seek a requisition from the Kansas governor while uncertain whether they have captured the real Benders or merely witnesses.
The report recaps the 1873 disappearance of Dr. William York and the subsequent discovery of the murderous Bender family near Cherryvale, Kansas. It then claims a man apprehended in Fremont, Nebraska has been positively identified as a Bender after years living among Indians, with Kate Bender said to be roaming disguised as a man.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
St. Landry Democrat · 14 August 1880 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
The Crime of the Century. THE WHOLESALE KANSAS MURDERER, BENDER, RUN TO THE EARTH.
HIS POSITIVE IDENTIFICATION; SIX YEARS AMONG THE INDIANS—CONVERSATION IN HIS CELL—KATE BENDER ROAMING THE COUNTRY IN MAN'S CLOTHES—THE STORY OF THE BENDER BUTCHERIES.
See moreSee less
[Kansas City Times.]
On the 9th of March 1873, Dr. William H. York left Fort Scott on horseback for his home in Independence, Kansas. He never arrived at home. On the 28th of March the Lawrence Tribune gave a brief account of his disappearance and hinted at foul play. York was well known throughout the State—a brother of Col. A. M. York, whose expose of old Senator Pomeroy had at that time made famous. The story of York's disappearance was now in every mouth, and every effort was put forth to solve the mystery of his absence. Rivers were dragged, spots fit for an ambush were probed foot by foot, lonesome places were quested as a keen hound scents a trail that is cold, and still no traces of the lost man were discovered. Not a shadow of evidence* rested anywhere to say that Dr. York had been murdered—not a sign anywhere told how he came to his death, if indeed death had overtaken him unawares. He was traced to Cherryvale, in Labette County, but no further. There all track and trace of him ceased.
About two miles south of Cherryvale, in a rude frame house standing in a lot of two acres in dimension, lived the Bender family. There were four of them—father, mother, son, and daughter. The mother was a spiritualist. She called herself a medium; the neighbors called her a she-devil. She had a way of boiling herbs and roots that were supposed to have charms and spells about them, and she dealt in incantations. She was repulsive in aspect—tall, angular, and scrawny, with hard, steel-gray eyes, and thin, ragged gray hair straggling over her temples. The family seem to have been totally under the influence of this ungainly creature. Her word with them was law. The Benders ostensibly kept a grocery. A sign was displayed in front of their rude dwelling. The only article they dealt in was cheap native wine, which was served on the spot. There were two rooms in the house, one used as a kitchen and dining room, and the other as a sleeping apartment.
While the excitement over the mysterious disappearance of Dr. York was at its height a party of Cherryvale citizens dropped in at the Bender mansion and casually inquired of the family if they had at any time during the past week seen anything of Dr. York. The visit and the questioning of the Cherryvale party had a strange effect upon the Benders. They suddenly disappeared; nor were they seen again till their apprehedsion at Fremont, Neb., last week. A man riding into Cherryvale from the country one day was impressed by the deserted appearance of the Bender place. He entered the yard. In the stable he found a dead calf. There was every indication from the appearance of the miserable creature that it had starved to death. The man walked up to the house, opened the door and looked in. Not an article of household furniture had been removed, but the dust lay heavy on everything. It was suspicious. The man went to Cherryvale and told his story. Senator A. M. York, the brother of the missing man, was there. To his suspicious mind the sudden and strange flight of the Bender family was a revelation. He had found the first clue to his lost brother. He divulged his suspicions, and a band of men accompanied him to the Bender farm. The front room of the house was carefully searched, every crack and crevice being minutely looked into and subjected to the application of rods and levers to see if the flooring was either hollow or loose. Nothing came of it. No blood spots appeared. The floor was solid. The walls were solid. Next the party searched the back room. The beds were removed, In their flight the Benders had left everything untouched.
A slight depression was noticed in the floor, which upon closer examination revealed a trap door. This was lifted up, and in the gloom a pit outlined itself, forbidding, cavernous, unknown. Lights were procured and some of the men decended. They found themselves in an abyss shaped like a well, six feet deep and five feet in diameter. Here and there little damp places could be seen, as though water had come up from the bottom or been poured down from above. They groped around over these splotches and held a handful to the light. The ooze smeared itself over their palms and *dribbled through their fingers. It was blood.
Every suspicion was realized. The murderers had fled, leaving behind damning evidences of their hideous guilt. But where were the bodies of the victims? For an hour the party of excited people traversed the lonely garden in the rear of the human slaughter pen, prodding the earth with a long iron rod. All at once the iron seemed to strike a fleshy matter. In a moment's time a dozen eager spades had resurrected from its shallow grave the decaying body of a human being. It had been buried face down. They turned it to the sunlight. A cry of terror went up from the crowd. It was York's corpse. Although far advanced in the stage of decomposition, the features were plainly recognizable. How the murderous deed had been done was speedily and easily learned. A terrible blow on the back of the head had crushed the skull upon the brain and the throat had been cut from ear to ear.
The work of discovery went on. One after another was laid bare the graves of ten murdered people. Most of the bodies were identified and the roster of recognized victims were as follows:
W. H. York, Geo. W. Longcar,
L. G. Brown, Miss Longcar,
W. F. McCrotty, Henry F. McKenzie,
Peter Boyle, John Bogert,
Two men unknown.
The body of the second daughter of Mr. Longcar was not found. It was buried in the corner of the garden that was not carefully probed. These victims had probably been attracted to the Bender house by the conspicuously displayed grocery sign. A stranger was inveigled into the death trap, invited to a glass of wine or something to eat. As he sat at the table in the back room one of his treacherous hosts smote him with a hammer, crushsng in the skull, and killing him instantly. But to insure death his throat was ripped from ear to ear, and he was hurriedly dropped throgh the trap door into the bloody cavern beneath. In the dead of night the body was removed to the garden and buried.
These ghastly crimes were committed solely for gold. Whoever entered the Bender mansion alone and with money, it mattered not how little, died like a brute.
Longcar was one of Dr. York's neighbors, and had started for Iowa with a view to locating permanently. Casually stopping in at the Bender place he was brutally murdered. His skull was mashed to a jelly, his throat cut and his body mutilated. His little child had evidently been tossed into the grave upon the mangled corpse and buried alive.
The discovery of the inhuman butcheries perpetrated by the Bender family was made seven years ago. For seven years diligent search for the bloody murderers has been pursued in every land upon the face of the earth. Up to four days ago the search was unavailing. But Justice, though tardy, is sure, and once in the toils of a grossly outraged law, the Benders will speedily suffer the penalty of their fiendish atrocities. The gallows upon which they die should be built so high that all the world might see and enjoy the death throes of the most inhuman wretches with which civilization has been cursed since the days of Sawney Bean and his incestuous family of cannibals.
HOW THE CAPTURE OF THE ELDER BENDER AND HIS WIFE WAS EFFECTED.
[Omaha Herald.]
A man was arrested by Sheriff Gregg at Richland three days ago, and he is now lodged in jail at Fremont. He was with a woman traveling eastward on foot. They had stopped at a house near there. Soon after their arrival they made inquiries as to whether anything had yet been discovered of the Bender family who formerly lived in Kansas. Their talk and actions excited suspicion, which was further strengthened by their answers to questions asked them. They appeared excited and told conflicting stories as to who they were and where they were from; said they had lived five or six years among the Indians; that they had been up in the Niobrara country, and that they were not the Benders. Ingenious questioning was brought to bear upon them, and the story came out.
While they were together in jail a conversation was overheard between them on the 27th of July, which was taken down by parties concealed near by. The old man who is apparently over 60 years of age, said to her: "I knew if we came to Kansas that they would hang us before we were there two hours. We would not stand a ghost of a show. If I have to die I want to die with you and be buried with you. I am going crazy. I know I am going to die. I want that razor in here before I start for Kansas."
"They would not let you have it. They are afraid of losing their reward," she said.
He continued: I know you'll give me away, but you cannot save yourself. Oh! my first wife. She was a good woman. You don't care for me. You mustn't think you can escape by giving me away. Don't you cry."
Here they were interrupted by some noise, and would say no more. The parties were afterward seperated, and the old man was told that she had been taken to Kansas. He appeared to feel very bad, but said little. She was then questioned and asked to give the whole story, which was finally got out of her, as appears in the answers given to the questions put to her. The old woman said the Benders had to run away from Illinois. They were in the same business there that they were afterward in Kansas.
"I was with the old man," the woman said, "all the time he was with the Benders. I don't know if he had anything to do with the murders. I think he had. The money taken from persons murdered was always divided among the Benders. I think my husband never got any of it. The garden was full of graves, and the cellar full of dead bodies. Dr. York's brother was murdered while I was there. He was a single man, I think about 35 years old. The dining room of the house was the room the sliding trap was under. A person would sit down at the table to eat, and the slides were moved and the person would fall into a deep cellar. I don't know how deep the cellar was. They would kill anybody then who would come into the house, rich or poor, for fear they might inform on them. They killed some persons that had no money at all. We went with the Benders from the place of the murder to the railroad Station I don't know what town. There they took the train South.
They would not take us along. The old man told the Benders that if they would not give them money he and the old man would tell on them. They didn't say anything to that. I have seen a good many people killed at Bender's house. My husband was sick at Bender's house, and I was waiting on him. I think there was more than ten persons killed while I was in the house. The Benders talked freely about these murders in my presence. The old man Bender, Mrs. Bender, and John Bender Jr., done the murdering. The old man went by the name of John Bender in Kansas."
The old man when he was told that she had confessed by degrees, told his story: "I was only one night at Bender's house," he said. "That day a young man came from California, and stopped at Bender's to get something to eat. He asked Kate what made the house smell so. She said it was nothing. He said he would not stay over night in the house; he would go and get people to search the house, and when the people came they found some bodies under the house, six or seven of them. When the Benders saw that they were found out they went right off, and I then started for Illinois. They put two children in a hole that same night and covered them with dirt. The man from California was the one that saw these children alive. The reason that I came to Kansas that time was that I was coming from the West from Fort Lincoln. They killed a man the night I was there. He was not a very old man. I was not in the room where he was killed. It was dark. I could not see very well. The door of the room I was in was open. I was at Bender's house two and a half days no longer."
Here the old man was closely cross-questioned, and he finally said: "I was at the Bender house just six weeks. The Benders I don't know where they went. I went to Jacksonville, Ill., travelling on foot, calling myself McCregor. About four weeks after the Benders left Kansas I saw Kate Bender between Springfield, Ill., and Jacksonville. She had men's clothes on. She had her hair cut short. I met her on the road. I knew her the minute I saw her. I know of six people killed while I was at the house. There was one family killed while I was there—a man, his wife, and children were buried alive. My wife was born in Illinois. Her folks moved to Missouri. She was formerly married to George Ellison. Her name was Nancy Ellison before I married her."
A CONFESSION.
[Kansas City Times.]
OMAHA, Neb., July 31—All doubt is now removed. The original John Bender and wife are now in the grasp of the law. Further developments in the case of the old man and woman lately captured and now in jail in Fremont, Neb., show that they are undoubtedly the Kansas butchers whose crimes gave them a world-wide notoriety a few year ago. A Mr. Hooflan, who for the past six years has been a resident of Fremont, was for two years prior to July 16, 1873, a neighbor of the Bender family, and herded cattle within three-quarters of a mile of their house on Agreese Creek, a few miles northeast of Independence, and about the same distance from the Osage Mission, on the main thoroughfare from Independence to the latter place. He had seen the Benders quite often in that time, and had become quite well acquainted. Hearing of the arrest of the old man and woman, he went to the jail to see them, and, if possible, identify them. As he entered the room in which the old man was confined, the latter looked at him very closely. Hooflan shoved his hat to the back of his head.
"Did you ever see this face before?" Hoofland asked.
"Yes," replied the old man. "I know you, but I can't place you." "Don't you know the man that used to herd near your place in Kansas?" Mr. Hooflan inquired.
The old man became excited. "My God, yes," he answered. "How did you come here?"
"Why, all of Labette County are up here to see you," the herder said.
The old man's voice dropped. He furtively eyed Mr. Hooflan. "You know I never done any harm in my life," he said in a plaintive tone.
"Well, if you haven't," returned the drover, "they're lying terribly about you."
The old man moistened his lips, and drew a long breath. "Well," he said, "my name is not Bender."
"Your name may not be Bender," said the herder, "but you told me repeatedly that was your name in Kansas, and its no use for you to deny it here."
"I was there," said the old man, "and remember you distinctly, but I had nothing to do with any of these murders." "Did you ever see any body murdered there?" Mr. Hooflan asked.
"I saw eleven persons murdered there," the old man coolly replied.
"Was there more than one child murdered?" the herder inquired.
"There were two buried," the old man answered.
"How do you know?"
Why, I saw them taken out of the room asleep and put in the grave. It was in an out bedroom."
"There is no use saying that there was no bedroom in the house." Mr. Hoofland remarked.
"I was in the back room," said the old man.
"You couldn't see into the peach orchard from the back room."
"But I seen them in the grave the next day," the old man said.
"How could you see them?" the herder asked. "They were covered up. Did you take the dirt off of them?"
"They were only buried six inches under the ground," the old man replied.
"That's a lie," exclaimed a Mr. Shed, who was listening to the conversation. "You can't see six inches under the ground."
The old man then confessed that he helped to bury them, burst out crying and exclaimed, "I don't care a ——; let them hang me and be damned."
On being told that he would have to go to Kansas he swore that he would not go. He said that he would go anywhere else, and would kill himself before he would go there. Hooflan showed him a plan of the house and surroundings, whith he acknowledged was correct.
Hooflan then went and saw the woman. She began laughiug when she saw him. When asked if she knew him she answered, "Yes, I do know him. How do you do, Mr. Huffan ?" (the name she was wont to use.) I nev-
er expected to see you any more. I don't want to talk to you here. We are captured last, and they will hang us. You know that. That's John Bender. There's no use denying that any longer. I'm going to tell the truth. If that don't save me from being hung, I'll have to hang, too. I ought to have told the truth from the start. I told them that we would be caught if we came back this way on the main road. We were going back East. We had a hard time among the Indians; very seldom saw a white person."
She was asked where the other child was buried, as only one of the two children was found. She asked Hooflan if he remembered where they dug up Dr. York's body, and which way from him the child was found. He told her "Yes," She said the other child was buried in the southeast corner of the garden. She said they had come back from the Indian country, and that they were going over the Missouri. Kate and young John Bender were with the teams taking another road. They were to meet in Iowa, and then some of the party was to go to Kansas and dig up $700 they had buried there on the old Bender place.
There would seem to be no further reason for doubt as to the identity of the prisoners, and that they are members of the only original Bender family. No legal investigation has yet been had, and this must be awaited before the world will be satisfied that the monster butchers of the age are at last in custody. The woman claims that she is not Bender's wife; that the latter was left when they went south through the Choctaw nation, in 1873, because she could not go further when they abandoned the team. She thinks the old woman died in 1876. Hoofland's description of the old Bender place agrees perfectly with that of other persons who have been there.
AFTER KATE AND YOUNG JOHN.
OMAHA, Neb., Aug. 2.—Sheriff Gregg of Dodge County, who arrested old Bender (the outlaw) and his wife, who are now in Fremont jail, was in this city yesterday hunting up the trail of young Bender and his wife. They were seen with a team and wagon in company with old Bender and his wife, who were on foot, near Schuyler, and they parted near there shortly before Daniel Condon informed Gregg of their suspicious inquiries about the Bender family of Kansas. Mr. Gregg has since learned that the young couple crossed the river at Omaha, with a wagon and team, and went into Iowa, no doubt en route for a place of meeting agreed upon by them and the old folks. They had a team of one gray and one bay horse, and a colored wagon. It is understood that Condon is following on their track.
Sheriff Gregg says that when he arrested the old couple he rode up to them and said: "Hello, Kate." The woman replied, "I ain't Kate Bender." Gregg believes he has a sure thing on the old man, but thinks the woman is Bender's mistress, and that they have killed his wife. Old Bender was German, and had a big scar on the centre of his forehead. The prisoner at Fremont has a scar, but swears he does not know a word of German. A German was put into a sell with instructions to curse him in his native tongue. Old Bender forgot himself, and swore terrifically at the man in German. Bender asked for a razor to shave, but Gregg, fearing he would commit suicide, refused, and had a barber shave him.
Sheriff Gregg is determined to capture young Bender, and it is understood $25,000 reward is offered for the whole gang. Of this amount $11,000 is offered for the old man.
After the Benders fled following inquiries about missing Dr. York, a passerby found their farm deserted with a starved calf and undisturbed furniture. A search party, led by the missing man's brother, discovered a hidden trapdoor beneath the back room leading to a mysterious six-foot pit.
St. Landry Democrat · 14 August 1880 · page 3
STORY OF THE BENDER BUTCHERIES.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
St. Landry Democrat · Opelousas, La.
The report re-describes the gruesome 1873 exhumation of ten victims from the Bender farm, detailing how guests were killed with a hammer blow and throat-cutting for robbery. It then claims that after seven years of fruitless search, the Benders have finally been caught and will soon face the gallows.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
St. Landry Democrat · 14 August 1880 · page 3
tims had probably been attracted to the Bender house by the conspicuously dis played grocery sign. A stranger was inveigled into the death trap, invited to a glass of wine or something to eat. As he sat at the table in the back room one of his treacherous hosts smote him with a hammer, crushsug iu the skull, and killing him instantly. But to in sure death his throat was ripped from ear to ear, and he was hurriedly drop ped throgh the trap door into the bloody cavern beneath. In the dead of uight the body was removed to the garden and buried.
See moreSee less
These ghastly crimes were committed solely for gold. Whoever entered the Bender mansion alone and with money, it mattered not how little, died like a brute. Longcar was one of Dr. York's neigh bors, and had started for Iowa with a view to locating permanently. Cas ually stopping in at the Bender place he was brutally murdered. His skull was mashed to a jelly, his throat cut and his body mutilated. His little child had evidently been tossed into the grave upon the mangled corpse and buried alive. The discovery of the inhuman butch eries perpetrated by the Bender family was made seven years ago. For seven years diligent search for the bloody murderers has been pursued in every land upon the face of the earth. Up to four days ago the search was unavail ing. But Justice, though tardy, is sure, and once in the toils of a grossly out raged law, the Benders will speedily suf fer the penalty of their fiendish atroci ties. The gallows upon which they die should be built so high that all the world might see and enjoy the death throes of the most inhuman wretches with which civilization has been cursed since tlie days of Sawney Bean and his in cestuous faiyiJy of cannibals.
An Iowa newspaper relays a letter claiming the four Bender family members were caught shortly after Dr. York's murder, tied to a fence, and shot dead by nine armed citizens at the junction of four counties. Kate Bender reportedly remained defiant, daring the men to shoot her, and the bodies were buried on the spot.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 14 August 1880 · page 1
Das Schicksal der Mörderfamilie Bender
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A letter relayed secondhand claims that the Bender family of four was captured and executed by nine riflemen after the murder of Col. York's brother, with Kate reportedly defiant to the end. The bodies were allegedly buried at the junction of four counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Daily Globe · 14 August 1880 · page 1
THE BENDERS. More Authority to the Killing of the CutThreat*— The Four Buried in One Grave. Dcs Moisb, Aug. 13.— A letter to the SiaU Register from a responsible citizen of this State, Mr. G. A. Jones, of Sigoorney, gives in formation, on the authority of an eye witness, also a reeponsibte man, that the notorious Bender family, four in number, were captured soon after the discovery of the murder of Col. York'a brother. He says the four were stood up ia a row facing nine riflemen, and were told their fate; that Kate was plucky to the last, and called noon their captor* to shoot ud be damned, and that the four b xlies were buried at toe corner of the four counties of Labelle, Wilson, Neinshe and Montgomery;
A correspondent relays a secondhand account claiming the four Benders were captured shortly after Colonel York's murder was discovered and executed by a firing squad of nine riflemen. Kate Bender reportedly taunted her captors before all four were buried at the junction of four Kansas counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 14 August 1880 · page 2
The Bloody Benders. S. A. James, of Sigeurncy, gives the in formation en' the authority of an eye witness, who is also a responsible man, that the notorious Bender family, four in number, were captured seen after the dis covery of the murder of Colonel Yerk. The eyc-witness says that the four were steed up in a row, facing nine riflemen, and were told their fate ; that Kate was plucky te the last and called upon the captors te "sheet and be damned," and that the four bodies were buried at the corner of the four counties of Labette, Wilsen,
A news brief claims the Bender family was captured in Nebraska and gave a full confession detailing murders committed in Illinois and Kansas, including the killing of State Senator York. It states they were being returned to Kansas under requisition to face justice.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Narragansett Herald · 14 August 1880 · page 4
perzons were killed and about fourteen others D - “At six o’clock ia the evening Woodson L. Gunnells, a well to do farmer, living in Webster county, Ga., left home to visit a sick neighbor, and returning at ten o'clock at night tound his wife and nine of her ten small chi‘dren in a sleep from the effects of mor phine administered in lemonade by Mrs. Gun nells. Six of the children at last accounts bad recovered, but the woman had died, and it was feared that three of the children would not recover.
See moreSee less
The cause of the strange act is unknown, as Mrs. Gunnells had shown no signs of insanity, and had been a kind-hearted mother. - The notorious Bender murderers, recently arrested in Nebraska, have made a full confes. sion of their many murders in Kansas, and have been taken back to that State on a requi sition. Mras. Bender confessed that their first
A letter relayed secondhand claims that the Bender family was captured shortly after a murder discovery, lined up before nine riflemen, and executed, with Kate defiantly taunting her captors. The bodies were allegedly buried at the junction of four Kansas counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Salt Lake Herald · 14 August 1880 · page 2
THE BENDERS
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.
A dispatch reports that a woman identified as Mrs. Bender, alias Mrs. McGregor, made a full confession about the Bender farm murders of 1872-73, claiming Kate Bender was the true leader of the killings. She recounts her marital history with Bender/McGregor and the family's move from Missouri to Kansas.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Shepherdstown Register · 14 August 1880 · page 3
THE ClilME WAS COMMITTED, ETC. I A Fremont (Xeb.) dispatch to the Chicago Tribune says further startling i dcvelopements were made in the Ben1 der matter Monday. Mrs. Bender, or Mrs. McGregor, made a full and com plete confession of the whole matter, even to the minutest details, regarding the butcheries perpetrated on the Johu Bender farm during 1S72 and 1878. She deneis having had any personal hand in the matter, but says Kate, old John's daughter, was the leader of all the deviltry. She went over her entire history from the time she became Mrs.
See moreSee less
Alexander McGregor. Sho was a wid ow at the time she married McGregor, alias Bender, who was a widower with four children, two of whom were Kate i anil John, Jr. They migrated from Missouri to Labette county, Kansas, and became John Bender and family. Be ing asked if she would be called Mis. McGregor or Mrs. Bender, &ho replied: "The latter will do if roil be satisfied, as you are here to see Mrs. Bender, i "Were you married to Bender in Kan sas? ' I was a widow, and he married me at Springfield; 111., at the close of the war. I can't remember what year, but j Squire Sedar tied the knot. His name then was Alexander McGregor, and he had four children, John and Kate being of the number, but two of the boys had ; run of)', lie was a poor cuss, but we lived about several years and then were sent by ttiw county to Dunklin county, in southwest Missouri, where sister lived. All l! lis is true." "Vou went by the namo of McGre ? goi? " "We did to the name until the f ole man went to Kansas and took up a j homestead in Labette county, I believe, ? when he ehanged it to John Bender, ' and, arter ubout a year, John and Kate came along, and then the devil began to be played. "What do you mean by that?" "Well, there was stealin', tiiieviif and killin", and all that." ?'Who was the first person killed by the family?" "lie was a siek man named Brown, lie came along one aJternoon.
Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.
An interview presents a supposed confession from a Bender family associate, describing the killings of a sick traveler named Brown, a man with money, a family of four including two little girls, and Dr. York. The account claims victims were drugged or trapped through a hidden trapdoor, robbed, and buried, with children allegedly buried alive.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
A letter from Sigourney, Iowa claims the notorious Bender family of four were captured soon after the murder of Col. York's brother was discovered, facing nine riflemen who told them their fate. It alleges the group was defiant to the end and their bodies were buried at the junction of Labette, Wilson, Neosho and Montgomery counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 14 August 1880 · page 1
Bender family, four in number, were captured soon after the discovery of tho murder of Col. York’s brother. lie says fee tour were up in a raw facing nine riflemen and were told their fate; tbutKals was pluck to the last end called upon the captors to shoot and be d—d, and that the bodies were buried at the corner of the four counties of Labette, Wilson, Neosho and Mont gomery. Engraving in all its branches is done at ZmuNxit, Jackson A Uuxcukek’s.
A dispatch describes a woman in male attire arrested in Grand Island, Nebraska, whom a sheriff suspects might be Kate Bender; the writer mocks the rush to assume every suspicious woman is Bender. The tone is heavily sarcastic, doubting the identification while reporting it anyway.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 14 August 1880 · page 4
Ths Bender ssnaaUou is still the sub ject of eonversaLoe to a great erlsul. and many people aria yet disposed to batiove that ths old couple are Band ers any way. And Dow cornea the (uUowiag dispatch, which adds further mystery to the affair: Grand Island, Nab., Aug. lL Shariff Killian baa arrested a woman in male attire, whom be thinks laKata Bender. She had beau sleeping around town for a few days The sheriff doesn’t have much to aay about her. C. A wumaa In male attire oertaiuly teaks suspicious, as doss also her set of sleeping around town for a tew days i Nobody hut Kate Beuder would be i likely to do either of the above acta, l She has probably heard of the arrest of , her loving par sots, end thereupon she stole s suit of clollies from young John , Beuder, her brother, with whom she was traveling, nnd then separating 1 from him alia stole sway and took s .
See moreSee less
hack track. The sheriff, it seems, is a , very discreet officer and does not say much about ths woman, though lie oould probably tell something startling If be should feel like It. ! We have not the shadow of a doubt about the woman being Kate Bender. She will probably begin her confessions to-day or as soon a* soma of the Omaha 1 reporters can reach her. We hope to ' hear, however, that she has been hung 1 to a telegraph pote before she is twenty - ' four hours older. It la reported that great excitement prevails at (trend Island over the arrest. That she Is a genuine Bender is evident, as already Intimated, from her sleeping around ' town. Headers Invariably do that. Notwithstanding the fact that the dispatches announce that the people of Labette county, Kansas, have failed to identify the Fremont prisoners as the Benders, we are yet inclined to think that they are tlie real Benders. We bate to gu back on the aged couple and call them frauds. Newspapers have been sued for libel la calling people frauds, and therefore we do not propose to subject the JfrpuMtcun to any such possibility. Tlie Deuders lived a secluded life, and kept away from tlieir neighbors, If they had nay. The only persona at their house were transients. We do not believe there are any persons in 1-sbelte county that can puesltily Identify a Bender anyway. The citizens hod but little if any acquaintance with them, and seven years have passed since the Iraglo events occurred at Uherryvale. In that length of time the Deuders have changed their appearance, awl their original appearance had no doubt to a great extent passed from the minds of their tew slight acquaintances, wlhi possibly might have positively Identified them a year or two after the murders, but who cannot do so now with suffi cient certainty to swear to it. To Illustrate this point, we will men tion the fact that Mr. Dick Kitchen, landlord of the Witlinell houae of this city, stopped over night at Bender's hotel in 1873, during tlie murdering period, lie had a drove of cattle and several men In tlis vicinity, end, think ing the place looked very rough, he borrowed a pistol from uue of his men aud put It In his pocket. He slept soundly that night on a plank bench in the Bender hotel, with $3,000 in money on his person. The Benders did not kill him because If they had they would have been soon detected by Mr. Kitch en's men, If they had tniaaod him. A short time nrter this Kitchen heard of the murders which had been discovered there, aud he felt thankful that the proximity of hta men had saved him from filling a grave in the Bender graveyard. Yet Mr. Kitclien says that be would he unable to identify the Benders now, because whan he stopped st their house lie did not teku particular pains to Impress their features upon his memory. No two persons as ignorant as the prisoners could have possibly oonoocted and told such strange but similar sto ries, while confined in separate cells. There Is truth in mast of their state menu, and we are confident that time will prove it. It they are not the Ben ders, then they are certainly two very mysterious character*. The story that the Benders were kilted before they left Labette county u too thin. If they had been captured and kilted, why wan the heavy reward offered? Would not some one have come forward nnd told all about It, nnd endeavored to secure the reward? Couldn’t their bodies be produced? Home one certainly would have put in claims for the reward, and hacked up his claims by exhuming the bodies, bad the Benders been killed. W. A. Htarr, of Oswego, who was chief of the vigilantes to investigate the mysterious disappearances In that local ity, says that the Benders were not kilted by the vigilantes, ns has been re ported. “My reasons are these: Our committee dkl not lynch them; that I know. lam equally confident that no body of citisens did, for if they had bean kilted, no man would be afraid or aahamsd to acknowledge having kilted them. ffSere la a possibility, but sot a probability, that they wen killed by their horse-thtef companions, who might have committed the murders with the double purpoes at preventing Um Bandars from Imp! testing thorn. If caught, and of seouring what moaay
The report speculates that an arrested woman is Kate Bender, based on her suspicious behavior of sleeping around town, and hopes she will be lynched. It also insists the arrested elderly couple must be the real Benders despite Labette County residents failing to identify them, arguing memories have faded over seven years.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 14 August 1880 · page 4
The report argues that two jailed suspects might be the Benders, noting it would be hard for old acquaintances to positively identify them years later. It also rebuts rumors that the Benders were secretly killed by vigilantes or Labette County citizens, citing the lack of any reward claims or body as proof they survived.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 14 August 1880 · page 4
A letter relayed through the Iowa State Register claims the Bender family of four was captured shortly after Colonel York's brother's murder was discovered, then executed by nine riflemen and buried at a four-county corner. The account, attributed to an unnamed eyewitness via a 'responsible citizen,' describes Kate Bender's defiant final words.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Eureka Daily Sentinel · 15 August 1880 · page 2
Another Bender Story. Dxsxoixxs, August 14.—A letter to the State Register, from a responsible citizen of this State, Mr. S. A. James, of Sigour ney, gives information, on the authority of an eye-witness, also a responsible man,
A letter relayed through an Iowa citizen claims the notorious Bender family was captured shortly after the discovery of Col. Corke's murder, with an eyewitness describing their execution by nine riflemen. The account states Kate Bender defiantly told her captors to shoot her, and that the bodies were buried at a county-line marker.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Knoxville Daily Chronicle · 15 August 1880 · page 1
THE BENDER FAMILYDesmoins, Iowa, Aug. 14. A let ter to the state register from a re sponsible citizen. S. A James," of Siourney, gives information on au thority of an eye-witness, who is also a responsible man, that the no torious Bender family, four in num ber, were captured soon after the discovery of the murder of Col. Corke. The eye-witness says that the four were stood up in a row, facing nine riflemen, and were told their fate, and that Kate was plucky to the last, and called upon their captors to "shoot and be damned," and that the four bodies were buried at the corner of four counteis, La Belle, Wilson, Nessbo and Montgom
An Iowa newspaper letter claims an eyewitness saw the four Bender family members captured, lined up before nine riflemen, and shot, with Kate defiant to the end. Their bodies were allegedly buried at the junction of four Kansas counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Daily Dispatch · 15 August 1880 · page 2
ENTIRE FAMILY YEARS AGO CAPTURED
sinking fund, and ealled upon the captors to “ shoot and be d—d,” and that the four bodies were buried at the corner of the four counties of Labette. Wilson, Neosho, and Monigomery.
A letter relayed from an Iowa citizen claims an eyewitness saw the four Bender family members captured soon after Colonel Yorke's murder was discovered and executed by nine riflemen. The account states Kate defied her captors and that the bodies were buried at the junction of four Kansas counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
A Des Moines dispatch relays a secondhand account claiming the four Benders were captured, lined up before nine riflemen, and shot, with Kate defiantly cursing her executioners. The report also dismisses an elderly couple recently detained in Nebraska as impostors falsely claiming to be the senior Benders.
Gold Hill Daily News · 16 August 1880 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
THE TRUE BENDER STORY. A telegram from Des Moines, Iowa, under date of the 13th instant, says: A responsible citizen of this place, S. James Sigourney, gives information on the authority of a witness, also a responsible man, that the notorious Bender family, four in number, were captured soon after the discovery of the murder of Colonel York's brother. He says the four were stood up in a row facing nine riflemen, and were told their fate; that Kate was plucky to the last, and called upon the captors to "shoot and be d—d;" and the four bodies were buried at the corner of the four counties of Labette, Wilson, Nooshoe and Montgomery.
See moreSee less
This is probably the true story relative to the fate and whereabouts of the Benders. A story to the same effect, given upon the authority of a participant in the retribution, went the rounds of the press some months ago, and was generally received as true. The old man and woman purporting to be old Bender and wife, recently captured in Nebraska, were evidently impostors, desirous of traveling to Kansas at public expense.
A Kansas correspondent mocks two tramps who falsely claimed to be the original Bender murderers, noting such impostures recur regularly. He hints that he knows the Benders' true fate, implying they were killed by vigilantes who held 'the last sad rites,' but withholds full details.
Press and Daily Dakotaian · 16 August 1880 · page 2
THOSE BENDERS.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No page image survives for this article
Press and Daily Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D.
A correspondent dismisses the recent M'Gregor tramp hoax but then claims special inside knowledge that the actual Benders are dead, implying he participated in or witnessed vigilante justice against them. He refuses to give details of the killings themselves, only asserting with certainty that the family is beyond the reach of the law.
Press and Daily Dakotaian · 16 August 1880 · page 2
THESE BENDERS
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No page image survives for this article
Press and Daily Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D.
A correspondent recalls the Benders' tavern and reputation before recounting their flight after suspicion arose from the Dr. York search in 1873. He corrects the widely reported claim that they fled by train via Thayer and Humboldt to Texas, stating instead they left by wagon toward Indian Territory before camping near the Verdigris River.
Press and Daily Dakotaian · 16 August 1880 · page 2
THOSE BENDERS.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No page image survives for this article
The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · Sedalia, Mo.
A correspondent describes visiting the Bender farm, noting how much the surroundings have changed since 1874 so that someone familiar with the place then would not recognize it. The passage also includes a fragment of narrative involving a character named Alice finding a note, seemingly unrelated serialized fiction mixed in with the news item.
The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 17 August 1880 · page 2
The Old Bender Farm. Alice, i Che rry vn'. Ka-.) V.r. Ctttagn Tim .. The Times enrresnondent visited the BenIer farm tlm morning, lhe snirrounding-; of the old place have changed so Miice 1874 that onu who was familiar with the faim and hopf.ehold premises then could not recognize
A visitor to the Bender farm describes the excavation site, correcting the widely published story that a man and two little girls were found in the grave—actually a man and one little girl were recovered. The report also describes mutilation of male bodies, possibly to prevent identification, and notes evidence suggesting the child was buried alive.
The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 17 August 1880 · page 2
The story so generally published that the lodies of a mau and two little girls were found in the grave is false. The bodies of a man aud one little girl were taken out of the bole. The child had on red mits, and lay face dovvn aud its hands on the top of its father. There was every indication to substantiate a report that the child was buried alive. With the exhuming of the bodies the evidence of the com inision of the most ghoulish deeds was brought to light, but for some un accountable reason never found its way into print.
See moreSee less
The body of every man taken up was found to be mutilated in such a way that the supposition is that the Benders did it to prevent the identification of the dead person's sex. No other reason can be ascribed, unless it is attributed to pure fiendishness on the part of Kate Bender. Physicians, however, and even men who were not physicians, could after the lapse of years readily recognixe that the bodies had been those of men.
A reporter accompanies a sheriff and two prisoners—believed to be the elder Benders—from Fort Scott to Oswego amid threats of lynching from angry crowds. The suspects deny any confession, and witnesses who knew the actual Bender family fail to identify them, with evidence mounting that the prisoners are impostors.
The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 17 August 1880 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
NOT THE BENDERS.
A "Bazoo" Reporter Meets the Prisoners at Fort Scott and Accompanies them to Oswego.
See moreSee less
The Prisoners Deny Having Ever Made any Confession.
Shouts of "Hang Him," "Bring a Rope," Etc., at Fort Scott.
Former Neighbors and Acquaintances of the Benders at Parsons Fail to Identify Them.
Arrival at Oswego—Lodged in Jail—Visitors—Interviews--Threats of Lynching, Etc.
Almost Conclusive Evidence that the Prisoners are not the Benders.
Special dispatch to the Bazoo. Oswego, August 9.
About the only topic of conversation in Oswego, and, in fact, all through Labette county, is the parties arrested a few days since by the authorities of Fremont, Nebraska.
Sheriff Bender, of this county, who went after the prisoners, arrived here on the M., K. & T. train this morning, at one o'clock, and notwithstanding the hour, some were present to catch a glimpse of
THE NOTORIOUS PERSONAGES.
The BAZOO's representative met the party at Fort Scott and accompanied them to this point, and on the trip down learned considerable of interest. The man whom they claim is old man Bender, is in the neighborhood of sixty years of age, wears a shaggy gray beard, unkempt hair, and has the stiff finger the original Bender is said to have had. He looks as though he had seen hard times. He is sullen and morose, and is averse to being interviewed. When he can be engaged in conversation, he intersperses oaths quite freely, and is most bitter in his denunciation of mankind in general and the authorities of Labette county in particular. He is a man whom you would, from his looks, feel like charging with
ALMOST ANY CRIME.
The woman is probably forty five years of age, is large and masculine, having the appearance of an old hag who would stoop to crime of any description.
Sheriff Bender informed me that he arrived in Fremont Friday evening, and immediately visited the prisoners in the jail. When he informed them that he had come for the purpose of removing them to Kansas, the old man raved, and swore he would never be taken there alive. To prevent trouble, he was then informed that he was to be removed to Jacksonville, Ill., to answer the charge of murder committed there years ago. This seemed to pacify him, and
FOR THE TIME BEING HE WAS QUIET.
Saturday afternoon at one o'clock, Sheriff Bender and Daniel Condon, the latter being the gentleman who made the arrest on the 22d of July, took the prisoners from the Fremont jail, and placing them in a Union Pacific train, went to Omaha. There they crossed over to Council Bluffs, and at five o'clock they boarded the Wabash fast express and started for Kansas City, where they arrived at eight o'clock yesterday morning.
Their coming had been anticipated, and when the train pulled up at the depot the crowd of spectators was simply immense. They crowded and jammed until it was almost impossible to make a way through. They were finally
TAKEN TO THE STATION, where they were visited by hundreds, and interviewed at the hands of the Kansas City reporters. At 5:40 yesterday afternoon, Messrs. Bender and Condon placed their charges on the Gulf train and started for Fort Scott. At every station the platform and adjoining space was packed with humanity, and when Fort Scott junction was reached there were hundreds of citizens present. The prisoners were placed in the smoking car, and almost in an instant it was filled with those anxious to see, until it was impossible to get through the aisle. Boys and men climbed upon seats, and such a shoving and surging has seldom been witnessed. They all remained in the car until the down town depot was reached where
A STILL LARGER NUMBER WAS PRESENT.
After a brief period, Conductor Fuller shouted "all aboard," and the car was cleared as if by magic.
The BAZOO representative then proceeded to get in his work, and dropped into a seat by the side of the old woman. She was dressed quite commonly, and sported a large sun bonnet, with which she tried to conceal her face. She was not handcuffed, but the old man, who occupied the next seat back, wore a pair of bracelets, and was closely watched by Condon. Both were still laboring under the impression that they were being taken to Illinois. When the old man was asked if he did not want to go to Kansas, he replied:
"NO, I'LL NEVER GO THERE ALIVE."
He had been informed that Kate and John Bender had been arrested by Mr. Condon, and it was this circumstance that made him afraid to visit Labette county. He said Kate had told a lot of d—d lies about him, and the people there would hang him in five minutes.
In conversation with your reporter the woman stated that her husband's name was Alex. McGregor, and her's Nancy McGregor. He was born in New York state, while she first saw the light of day in southern Illinois, in what is known as Egypt. She lived there until she was fifteen years old, and
THEN REMOVED TO MISSOURI.
She subsequently removed back to Illinois, and was married to McGregor in that state, but in what year she did not know. This is the story she told your reporter, but to others she stated it differently. Condon says she is the d—dest liar he ever met.
When asked about the confession both were reported to have made, the old woman denied most emphatically that they ever did make anything of the kind, and in this assertion she was corroborated by her husband.
McGregor does not deny that
HE KILLED A MAN
at Jacksonville, and also a peddlar in Kansas, but says both were in self-defense.
The woman says they stopped with the Bender family three weeks at their place near Cherryvale, on account of the old man's sickness. She knew of a number of murders committed by the family, but said they were in no wise implicated in any of them.
When asked where they were bound for when arrested, McGregor replied that he was on his way to New York state. On his arrival there he had intended
GOING TO THE POOR HOUSE
until cured of a bad rupture he now suffers with, after which it was the intention of himself and wife to make their home with his son, who resides at some point in the state, but exactly where he does not know.
Nearly every one in the coach had something to say to the old man, or some question to ask, and to all he was most positive in his assertion that he would not return to Labette county for any consideration. His profanity was as if by note. The woman, however, was more mild, and would have
ANSWERED QUESTIONS PROMPTLY
if McGregor had permitted her. She has a habit of addressing everyone as "uncle," and called your reporter by no other name during the trip.
All of the Kansas City papers have representatives here, they being Will Baker, of the Journal; W. L. Campbell, of the Mail, and John P. Coffin, of the Times.
Second Dispatch. Special Dispatch to the Bazoo. Oswego, August 9.
When the train arrived at Parsons, fifteen miles north of this place, another grand rush was made for the car containing the prisoners, and in a minute it was filled with spectators. Several persons who had known Bender, whose home was only thirteen miles from Parsons, took a good look at the old man, and all shook their heads and said:
"THAT'S NO MORE HIM THAN I AM.
Among the number so expressing themselves was Leroy Dick, a prominent real estate agent of that city, who was sure it was not the man wanted.
While the train was standing at the depot the old fellow learned for the first time where he was, and he heaped down abuse upon the head of his captor in a style becoming a thoroughbred. He stood up in the aisle and
DEMANDED THAT HE BE RELEASED, saying he desired to go to Jacksonville, and he'd be d—d if he didn't go. He threatened the whole state with a suit for damages, and made things exceedingly lively for a short time. The positiveness with which the gentleman said it was not Bender, came pretty near convincing all in the car that such was the case.
Third Dispatch. Special to the Bazoo. Oswego, August 9.
When the train arrived here there was no crowd in attendance, as the officers were not expected until the afternoon train. The prisoners were in anything but a pleasant frame of mind, as they were taken from the train, but when no demonstrations were made, they seemed to feel as if a great load had been lifted from their minds.
Fort Scott was the only place on the trip where the crowd expressed themselves, and there were a number of shouts of "hang 'em" "bring a rope," etc.
The prisoners were remanded to jail and will be identified to-day or discharged.
Fourth Dispatch Special Dispatch to the Bazoo. Oswego, August 9, 11:50 a. m.
At 10:30 this morning the prisoners were removed from the jail and taken to the court room. Notwithstanding a drizzling rain, the place was filled in a very few minutes and all crowded around anxious to catch every word. Prosecuting Attorney Watters occupied a seat
BESIDE THE OLD WOMAN, and put to her numerous questions, all of which were answered in nearly the same language telegraphed in former dispatches.
Mr. Mat Miller, who resided near the Benders at the time the butcheries were committed, was called upon to identify them, but as soon as he had obtained a glance he said
THEY WERE NOT THE BENDERS, and such seemed to be the opinion of all present. It is now definitely known that McGregor was an inmate of the Bender house for six weeks, but it is almost as certain that the old woman was never there.
McGregor, as he calls himself, says he was present when one man was dropped through the trap door and killed by Kate and John in the cellar below. He claims that this was the only murder he ever witnessed. Parties here who knew old Bender says there is not
THE LEAST RESEMBLANCE
between this man and Bender. Parties are expected from Cherryvale at two o'clock this evening, when the question of identity will be finally settled. It has been learned that the prisoners passed up the Gulf road going to Nebraska about six weeks ago. This is reliable. There is no excitement and the general impression at this writing is that the right parties have not been captured.
Fifth Dispatch Special to the Bazoo. Oswego, Kas., July 9, 2:32 p. m.
The train from Cherryvale did not bring any of the old neighbors of the Bender family, and things stand as they did in my last dispatch. Prosecuting Attorney Waters is convinced that the prisoners
ARE NOT THE BENDERS, but a half crazy old couple who have been tramping for months. He says they will be held for a few days to await developments, but he expects nothing new to be unearthed. There is not the least excitement and even if the old man should be identified as Bender there would be
NO DANGER OF LYNCHING
at least not for the present. You may set it down for almost a certainty that the so called Benders are a myth.
A couple arrested as suspected members of the Bender family were brought before a judge and townspeople for questioning and identification, with witnesses examining the old man and some saying he resembled Bender. The report suggests the arrest may actually be part of a scheme to collect the reward money rather than a genuine capture.
The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 17 August 1880 · page 3
Hfwcsa. Dipatch to the Bazoo. Oswego, August 9. When the train arrived at Parsons, fif teen miles north of this place, another grand rush was made for the car coutaining the prisoners, and in a minute it was filled with spectators. Several persons who bad known Bender, whore home was only thirteen miles from Paron, took a good look at the old man, and all shook their heads and said:
An elderly prisoner believed to be one of the Benders is transported by train through Kansas and Nebraska toward identification, with onlookers divided over whether he is truly Bender. The prisoner protests his innocence and threatens legal action, while crowds at some stops shout for his lynching before he is finally jailed pending identification or discharge.
The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 17 August 1880 · page 3
DEMANDED THAT HE BE RELEASED
FOR THE TIME SEIKO HE WAS QCIET. Saturday afternoon at one o'clock. Sher iff Bender and Daniel Condon, the latter hrlnr the centleman who made tbe arrest ww on tbe 22d of July, took the prisoners from the Fremont jdl, and placing them in n Union Pacific train, went to Omaha. There they crossed over to Council Bluffs, and at fi AVtnelr tbev boarded the Wabash fast they arrived at eight o'clock yesterday morning. Their coming had been anticipated, and when the train pulled up at the depot the crowd of spectators was simply immense. Thev crowded and iammed until it was al-
Two men arrested near Fremont, Nebraska as the Bender family turned out to be impostors and were released. The report repeats a secondhand rumor that the real Benders had been captured and summarily executed by vigilantes shortly after fleeing Kansas, their bodies buried at a county corner.
THE two stragglers recently arrested at Fremont, Neb., as the original Benders, have turned out to be frauds, and have been discharged. It is a common theory now that these noted cut-throats were cap tured and killed very soon alter their es cape from their, old camping grounds in Kansas. A. letter to the Des Moines Reg inter from a responsible citizen of Iowa, L. A. James, of Si journey, gives informa tion on the authority of an eye-witness, also a responsible man, that the Bender family, four in number, were captured soon after tbe discovery of the murder of Col.
See moreSee less
York's brother. He says the four were stood up in a row facing nine rifle men and were told their fate that Kate was plucky to tbe last and called upon her captors to "shoot and be damned," and that the four bodies were buried at tbe corner of the four counties of La
A circulating story claims that shortly after killing Col. York, the Benders were captured, lined up before nine riflemen, told their fate, and executed, with bodies buried at the junction of four Kansas counties. The report is presented as an unverified rumor rather than confirmed fact.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Columbus Journal · 18 August 1880 · page 2
Kausan, Missouri, Iowa and Illinois. All information goes to show that i he English government is very active, as it Is in possession of infor mation going to show that in Ireland secret agitators have thus far been very successful In organizing sedi tion. Conviction daily increase that the whole Island is ripe for revolution. The last Bender story runs in this wise : That shortly after thpy killed Col. York, the Benders were cap tured, placed in a row facing nine riflemen, wore told their fate, and that the bodies were buried at the corner of the four counties of La
At Grand Island, Nebraska, Sheriff Killan arrested a woman dressed in male attire who had been sleeping around town, suspecting she might be Kate Bender. The report notes the sheriff was tight-lipped about the suspect's identity.
The Columbus Journal · 18 August 1880 · page 2
Ax other Bender excitement was created at Grand 'island, this State, on the 11th by Sheriff Killan arrest ing a woman in male attire whom he thinks is Kate Bender. She has been sleeping about town for a few days. The sheriff don't have much to say about ber.
The Canton Advocate · Canton, S.D. · and 2 other papers
After suspicious neighbors investigate the abandoned Bender homestead, searchers find a blood-soaked trapdoor pit beneath the floor and then unearth a human body buried in the garden. The report also claims the Benders had just been apprehended in Fremont, Nebraska.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Canton Advocate · 19 August 1880 · page 4
SUDDENLY DISAPPEARED from their former home, nor were they seen again till their apprehension at Fremont, Neb., was accomplished last week. A man riding into Cherryvale from the country one day was impressed by the deserted appearance of the Bender place. He entered the yard. In the stable he found a dead calf. There was every indication from the appear ance of the miserable creature that it had starved to death. The man walked up to the house opened the door and looked in. Not an article of house hold had been removed, but the dust lay heavy on everything.
See moreSee less
It was sus picions. The man went to Cherryvale and lold his story. Senator A. M. York, the brother of the missing man, was there. To his suspicious mind the sudden and strange flight of the Ben der family was a revelation. He had found the first clue to his lost brother. He divulged his suspicions, and a band of men accompanied him to the Bender farm. The front room of the house was carefully searched, every crack and crevice being minutely looked into and subjected to the application of rods and level's to see if the flooring was either hollow or loose. Nothing came of it. No blood spots appeared. The floor was solid. The walls were solid. Next the party searched the back room. The beds were removed. In their flight the Benders had left everything
Memphis Daily Appeal · Memphis, Tenn. · 5 August 1880
Staunton Vindicator · Staunton, Va. · 13 August 1880
The Canton Advocate · Canton, S.D. · and 1 other paper
The report describes the Bender family and their roadside house near Cherryvale, noting the mother's reputation as a sinister 'medium'. It recounts how the family vanished after being questioned about Dr. York's disappearance, and claims they were later apprehended in Fremont, Nebraska.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Canton Advocate · 19 August 1880 · page 4
THE liENDER FAMILY. There were four of them father, mother, son and daughter. The moth er was a Spiritualist. She called her self a medium the neighbors called her a she-devil. She had a way of boiling herbs and roots that were sup posed to have charms and and spells about them, and she dealt in incanta tions. She was repulsive in aspect— tall, angular and scrawny, with hard, steel-gray eyes, and thin, ragged gray hair straggling over her temples. The rest of the family seem to have been totally under the influence of this un gainly creature.
See moreSee less
Her word with them wits "law. The Benders ostensibly kept a grocery a sign to that effect was dis played in front of their rude dwelling. However, the only article they dealt in was cheap native wine, which was served on the spot. There were two rooms in the house—one used as a kitchen and dining room, and the other as a sleeping apartment. While the excitement over the mys terious disappearance of Dr. York was at its height, a party of Cherryvale citizens casually dropped in at the Ben der mansion and as casually inquired of the famil}* if they had any time dur ing the past six weeks seen anything of York. The answer was in the negative and the subject was dropped. The visit and the questioning of the Cherry vale party had a strange effect upon the Benders. They
Staunton Vindicator · Staunton, Va. · 13 August 1880
The Topeka Tribune · Topeka, Kan.
A couple suspected to be John Bender and his wife were brought through Kansas City in the custody of a Kansas sheriff, en route to Oswego for identification. Fearing mob violence, the sheriff delayed travel and controversially allowed the prisoners to be exhibited on a theater stage for paying crowds.
THE BENDERS IN KANSAS CITY . The notorious couple, supposed to be old John Bender and wife, arrived in Kannas City, on the morring of the Bth, in the custody of the sheriff of Labette county, Kan., being en route to Oswego, where they are to be identified. They were transferred to the Fort Scott train, but, after waiting seme time, Sheriff Bender, who had the prisoners io charge, concluded to \ait for the evening train, as he was fearful of a mob at Cherry vale. In the meantime the prisoners were locked up in the Kansas City po’ice station.
See moreSee less
Soon after they had been placed in the police station, the proprietor of a variety theater offered the sheriff $25 for permission to exhibit them during the afternoon on the stage of his theater. Much to the surprise of everyone, the proposi'ion was accepted by the sheriff, and the prisoners were conducted to thetheater, where they remained on exhibition until their departure for the evening train, the proprietor of the theater reaping a hand soma profit by admitting the crowds that had collected, at twenty-five cents a head.
This 1880 article revisits older claims that the Bender family was killed by vigilantes while fleeing Kansas in 1873, citing a May 1877 correspondence from Labette County as supposed proof. It recounts how the discovery of a murdered man's body allegedly triggered an inquest and vigilante justice against the Benders themselves.
The Topeka Tribune · 19 August 1880 · page 4
May, 1877, ventured to give all the details ot the affair upon the authority of citizens of Labette county. This statement is given to the public in 'the form of corre spondence from that vicinity. The corre spondent alleges that the facts in regard to the tragic end of the Benders are no secret to the people of that county and he pretends to give the statement of one of the persons concerned in the massacre of the murderers. According .to this version of the tale, the discovery of the body of a man named Jones in a creek some miles away from the Bender tavern was the signal for the dis closure of the dark practices of that place.
See moreSee less
Some hunters, it is said, came upon the body lodged in the brush against the bank, and as there were indications of violence, a body of twelve persons was hastily called together and an inquest be gun. All the facts being noted, the broken skull, the gaping throat wound, the color and nature of the garments, etc., they buried the body, agreed to keep quiet and hold another meeting the following day. The next day they came together, and after talking over the matter arrived at the conclusion that the Benders who had always been looked upon with suspicion, knew something about the death of this man. It became known that a man of that description had been seen in the vicinity with a horse and wagon, which could not be traced beyond the tavern of the Benders. A party of men visited the tavern and discovered a wagon trail lead ing in the direction of the bayou. They followed it over hill and valley for ten or fifteen miles, and finally came to the creek several miles above where the body bad been found. Here they discovered that something had been dragged through the brush and thrown into the creek. They also noticed that one of the hind wheels of the wagon did not track with the front wheel. Bender had just such a wagon. Having learned these facts the party went to their homes, having ar ranged to meet again next day at a cer tain point. That night, it is claimed by the same au thority, a tramp came to the house of one of the men engaged in the investigation and asked for shelter. In the course of a onversation he said that he had slept the night before in a haystack on the Bender place, and that about midnight he saw them bury some one in the field. He indicated what part of the field it was, and the next day a party of men called there to investi gate. They found the Bender house abandoned, and there was a fresh wagon trail leading over the prairie towards the southwest. In a freshly plowed field they unearthed the body said to have been seen buried there by the tramp. It proved to be the body of Dr. York. Other bodies, the deadly hammers, the trap door, the coal cellar and its ghastly store were also discovered. It is claimed that as soon a« these matters became public it was decided to pursue the Benders and treat them as they had treated their victims. They had thirty-six hours the start, it is said, but the-vigilantes followed with fresh horses, overtaking them after a ride of forty odd miles. All four were killed there and then, and all died cursing God and man. Kate Bender was the only one who would
A correspondent from Labette County relays a secondhand story claiming to reveal secret local knowledge of the Benders' downfall. It describes hunters finding a murdered man's body, a citizen inquest tracing wagon tracks to the Bender tavern, and a tramp's tip leading to the discovery of Dr. York's body buried in a field, implying local men later killed the Benders themselves.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
The article retells a widely circulated secondhand tale that a tramp witnessed the Benders burying Dr. York, leading to discovery of the murder house and a vigilante posse hunting down and killing all four Benders, with Kate confessing to the killings. The paper notes this account, found in a police scrapbook, is likely false given new suspects now under arrest at Fremont.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
A secondhand account claims the four Benders were captured shortly after the murder of Col. York's brother was discovered, stood before nine riflemen, and executed, with Kate defiantly daring her captors to shoot. The report claims their bodies were buried at the corner of four counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Morris Tribune · 19 August 1880 · page 2
I It appears that thTtwo old tramps who claimed to be the Benders, were frauds, and have been discharged from custody. The general impression with regard to the mysterious disappearance of the Bender family, is that they were killed by their pursuers. It is stated on the authority of an eye witness, a responsible man, "that the notorious Bender family, four in num ber, were captured soon after the discovery I of the murder of Col. York's brother. He
This Kansas City Sunday Times account claims the Bender patriarch has been run to earth after six years among the Indians, with positive identification and an interview conducted through his cell bars. It also recounts Dr. York's 1873 disappearance and the fruitless search for his body as background to the Bender butcheries.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Canton Advocate · 19 August 1880 · page 4
CRIME OF THE CENTURY.
the 4'ountry in Nan'** Clothes---The Story of the Bender Butcheries. Kansas City Sunday Tunes'. The crimes for wliich'a price lias been set upon the heads of the Bender family are of a fiendish and revolting nature.
A letter relayed secondhand claims that the four Benders were captured after the murder of Colonel York's brother and summarily executed by nine riflemen. It further alleges their bodies were buried at the junction of four Kansas counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 19 August 1880 · page 7
-A letter to the Iowa State Register from a responsible citizen in that State gives in formation on the authority of an eye wit ness, also a responsible man, that the noto rious Bender family, four in number, were captured soon after the discovery of the murder of Colonel York's brother. He says the four were stood up in a row facing nine riflemen and were told their fate; that Kate was plucky to the last and called upon their captors to shoot and be d-d, and that the four bodies were buried at the four cor ners of the counties of Labelle, Wilson,
A Chicago reporter interviews a woman calling herself Mrs. Bender in a Fremont jail, who describes the family's first murder in Illinois before detailing their move to Kansas and the killings at their roadside inn. Old Bender reportedly confesses separately, with his account matching hers exactly.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 19 August 1880 · page 1
Art Departments. Complete course, high standard and moderate cnarges. Accommodations for over one hundred boarding pupils. Board 10 per month. For catalogue address july -t. II. W REJNIIART, Principal. Chicago, August 7. Mrs. Mender was visited in jail at Frecmont by an OukiIju re porter to whom she said that the tirtt mur der ever committed by her and her husband was in Illinois, on their farm near Jackson ville. The victim ased for lodj;in and supper and n paying for the same in ad vance exhibited considerable money. While he was eating supper Bender cut his head into from behind, and lie was dumped into the cellar through a drap-door arranged by Bender, who tzot his money.
See moreSee less
The corpse was buried next morning back of the house. They then went to Indiana, living on the murdered man's money, and then went to Kansas where Bender's children John and Kate, by his first wife were living with her cousin Maggie. They kept a resort for travellers there, and called it Bender's ho tel. They had committed no murder prior to the old folks' arrival, buf in couise of time old Bender arranged a trap door, and then murdering operations begau. Kate at one time had a man in bed with her, and she cut his throat and slept till morning be side the corpse. Ilis money was divided. She never injured horse thieves and cut throats who came to the hous-.e, but enter tained them well in company with her cousin Maggie. No murders were commit ted by the family after they lied from Kan sas. Old Bender lias confessed, believing that the old woman has escaped. His story tallies with his wife's exactly. He relates the history cf the whole family and their crimes. In J 873, old Bender and his wife and their son John and his wife lived near Gher ryvale, Labette County, Kansas. Their house was about two miles out of town. It wasa rude frame structure, standing in a lot of two acres. The old woman called hers2lf a medium. She had a way of boiling herbs and roots that were supposed to have ( harms and spells about them and she dealt in incantatio-s. She was repulsive in as pect tall, angular and scrawny, with hard, steel-iiray eyes, and thin, ragged gray hair st:aggglm govcr her temples. The family seem to have been totally under the influ ence of this ungainly creature. Her word with them was law. The Benders ostensi blv kept a grocery. A sign was displayed iifront of their rude dwelling to attract visitors, but the stock in trade consisted principally of a sort of cheap wine. There were only" two rooms in the house. One was a dining room and kitchen combined. In the other the four Benders slept.
The article claims that Old Bender has confessed to the family's crimes, with his account matching his wife's story exactly, and recounts the family's history near Cherryvale, Kansas, including the mysterious disappearances of travelers like the old man and his granddaughter and Dr. William H. York. It describes the Bender household, the mother's role as a medium, and the fruitless search efforts following York's vanishing.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 19 August 1880 · page 1
MANY SUDDEN DISAPPEARANCES. In 187o a number of persons traveling in the direction of Cherryvale mysteriously dis appeared. No traces of them could be found. The first disappearance that at tracted public attention was that of an old man and his granddaughter, who left Cher ryvale in February, 1873. in a two-horse wagon, to go to Fort Scott, but who never leached that place. All inquiries failed to elicit a clue to their disappearance until, about the beginning of March, Dr. William H York recognized the wagon and team at Fort Scott. He ascertained that the wagon had been purchased at the fort from some
The report says a couple impersonating the elder Benders were examined and discharged from custody after neighbors called them frauds. A separate secondhand account claims the actual four Benders were captured, executed by riflemen, and buried at the junction of four Kansas counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Gloucester County Democrat · 19 August 1880 · page 4
Western and Southern States* Mr. William Jones, a prominent farmer ol Campbell county, Va., had just completed thrashing his wheat crop and was attempting to jump on the thrasher-box while in motion when he slipped and fell upon the cylinder. One foot was crushed so badiy that amputation was rendered necessaiy, from the effects of which he died a few minutes afterward. 1 ae dispatches say that when the s .pposeri Bender murderers were taken to their old home in Kansas many former neighbors ot the Bonder family declared that the old man and woman were frauds; and alter a thorough examination the pair were discharged from custody.
See moreSee less
What their object was in counter feiting the Bender murderers is unknown. The Texas Democrats have nominated 0. Al. Roberts for gove rnor. President Hayes, Governor Foster and General Sherman were present at a reunion ol Ohio soldiers at Columbus. There is a split among the Georgia Demo crats, and ex-United States Senator Norwood, nt the request ot a number of delegates to the late State convention, has consented to run tor governor. There are at present fifteen persons in jail it Chicago charged with murder. Two ot the fifteen are women. A letter to the Des Moines (la.) State Register from a responsible citizen, S. A. •James, ot Sigourney, gives the information, oh the authority ol an eye-witness, also a re sponsible man, that the notorious Bender family, four in number, were captured soon after the discovery of the murder ot Colonel Yoik. The eye-witness says that the lour were stood up in a row lacing nine riflemen, and were told their late; that Kate was plucky to the last and called upon the captain 10 “ shoot and be —and thst the tour bodies were buried at the corner ot the lour counties
A preliminary examination at Oswego, Kansas resulted in the discharge of an old man and woman arrested as the Benders, with old settlers and a justice saying they did not match the real family. Locals called the pair notorious liars and speculated that the actual Bender family had already been killed by vigilantes before leaving the county.
The Eaton Democrat · 19 August 1880 · page 4
Mexican Border Difficulty. The Bender Room Exploded. At a preliminary exam'nation of the Benders at Oswego, Kas., on the 10th inst, they were discharged. A telegram says: "Old settler say tbe old man and woman do not resemble the original Benders in the least. Justice Hughey says he knew the woman at Cape Gerard. Everybody is disgusted, and thinks these persons are a couple of crazy tramps. Both are notorious liars, and no reliance can be placed on their word. The general impression in this community is that the whole Bender family were killed by vigilante before they were able to get out of this (Labette) county. The whole Bender boom is exploded."
The Anderson Intelligencer · Anderson Court House, S.C.
A dispatch from Omaha reports that a man believed to be John Bender Sr. and a woman, possibly his wife, have been arrested and jailed in Fremont, Dodge County, Nebraska. The article recounts the Benders' 1873 Kansas murders, describing their roadside inn, the mother's claims of being a spiritual medium, and the family's scheme of luring and killing travelers for money.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Anderson Intelligencer · 19 August 1880 · page 1
ARREST OF OLD MAN BENDER AND A WOMAN
Omaha, Neb., Aug. 2,1880. The story of the crimes of tho Bender family is upon everybody's lips. The greatest crimp of the century is likely, in a small measure at least, to be atoned for. But the most horrible death that old John Bender could be put to would but in a slight degree.avenge the suffer? ings of his many victims, lu the jail at Fremont, in Dodge County, a man is locked up who is supposed to be the fiend that the authorities of Kansas have been looking for for seven years.
See moreSee less
There hard? ly seems a doubt of his identity. With him is a woman?repulsive, hard-fisted and old. She nuy be the original Mrs. - Bender or she may be his mistress. Opinions differ on this point. When they reach Kansas the authorities will have hard work to guard the couple from the attacks of the populace, who are thirsting for their blood. In 1873, old Bender andhis wife and their son John and his wife lived -near Cherryvale, Labette County, Kansas. Their house was about two miles trat of town. It was a rude frame structure, standing in a lot of two acres. The old woman called herself a medium. She had a way of boiling herbs Jind roots, that were sup? posed to have charms and'spells about them, and she dealt in incantations. She was repulsive in aspect?tall, angular and scrawny, with hard, steel-gray eyes, and thin, ragged gray hair struggling over Lertemples. The family seem to have been totally under the influence of this ungainly creature. Her word with them was law. The Benders ostensibly kept a grocery. A sign was displayed in front of their rude dwelling to attract visitors, but the stc-k in trade consisted principally of a sort of cheap wine. There were only two rooms in the house. One was a dining room and kitchen combined. In the other the four Ben? ders slept.
The Anderson Intelligencer · Anderson Court House, S.C.
The report describes the Bender family's household near Cherryvale, Kansas, and the strange disappearances of travelers in 1873, including Dr. William H. York who vanished while investigating an earlier disappearance. It notes the Benders fled the day after being questioned by a search party.
The Anderson Intelligencer · 19 August 1880 · page 1
MANY SUDDEN DISAPPEARANCES. In 1873 a number of persons travelling in the direction of Cherryvale. myste? riously disappeared. No traces of them - could bs found. The first disappearance that attracted public attention was that of an old man and his granddaughter, who left Cherryvale in February, 1873, in a two-horse wagon, to go to Fort Scott, bet who never reached that place. All inquiries failed to elicit a cine to their disappearance until, about the beginning of March, Dr. William H. York recog? nized the wagon and team at Fort Scott.
See moreSee less
He ascertained that the wagon bad been purchased at the fort from some person who had come from Cherryvale, and he determined to ferret out the mystery. He left Fort Scott on March 9, and he, too, disappeared. Dr. York was well known, and the greatest efforts were made to discover traces of him. A large, reward was offered, rivers were dragged, spots fit for ambush were probed foot by foot, lonesome places were quested as a keen hound scents a trail that is cold, and still no traces of the lost man were discovered. Not a shadow of evidence rested anywhere to say that Dr. York bad been murdered?not a sign anywhere told how he came to his death, if, indeed, deathhad overtaken him unawares. He was traced to' Cherryvale, in Labette County, but no further. There all track and trace of him ceased. The excite? ment was at a high pitch. One day an exploring party stopped at the house of the Benders. Had they seen anything of Dr. York? No, the answer came, they had not. They knew nothing what? ever concerning him. But this visit had a strange effect. The next day the Ben? der family disappeared, and almost ns mysteriously as liad Dr. York. This suspicious circumstance aroused curios? ity. A man riding into Cherryvale from the country one day was impressed by the deserted appearance of the Bender place. He entered the yard. In the stable he found n dead calf. There was every indication from the appearance of the miserable creature that it had starved to death. The man walked up to the house, opened the door and looked in. Not an article of household furniture had been removed, but the dust k.y heavy on everything. The man went to Cherryvale and told his story. Senator A. M. York, the brother of the missing man, was there. To his suspicious mind the sudden and strange flight of the Bender family was a revelation. He had found the first clue to his lost brother. He divulged-his suspicions, and a band of men accompanied him to the Bender farm. The front room of the bouse was carefully searched, every crack and crev? ice being minutely looked into and sub? jected to the application of rods and levers to see if the flooring was either hollow or loose. Nothing came of it. No blood spots appeared. The floor was solid. The walls were solid. Next the party searched the back room. The beds were removed. In their flight the Ben? ders had left everything untouched.
A letter relayed secondhand from an alleged eyewitness claims the four Benders were captured after Colonel Yorke's murder was discovered and were executed by firing squad at the junction of four Kansas counties. Kate Bender is quoted as defiantly daring her captors to shoot her.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Yorkville Enquirer · 19 August 1880 · page 2
Sigourney, gives the information, on the authority of an eye-witness, who is also a responsible man, that the notorious Bender family, four in number, were captured soon after the discovery of the murder of Colonel Yorke. The eye witness says that the four were stood in a row facing nine riflemen and were told their fate ; that Kate was plucky to the last, and called upon their captors to "shoot and be damned," and that the four were buried at the comer of the four counties of Labette,
A letter from S. A. James relays a secondhand account claiming the four Benders were captured shortly after Colonel Yorke's murder was discovered and executed by nine riflemen, with Kate defiantly taunting her captors. The letter states they were buried at the junction of four Kansas counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The News and Herald · 19 August 1880 · page 3
THOSE BLOODY BENDERS.
SECRETARY. ,TirOSE BLOODY hiENDERs.--A letter to the Des Moines Btate Recgistsr from a responsible citizen, S. A. James, of1 Sigouney,gives thme inforraation, on th uhrty efa ye-witness, woi also a responsible man, that the noto rious Bender family, four in number, were captured 800on after thme discovery of the murder otf Colonel Yorke. The eye-witness says that the four were stood in a rowv facing nine riflemen and told -their fate; that IKate was pluck y to the last'and called u pon their captors to ''shoot and be damned," and that the four wvere buried at the corner of the four conuties of Labette,
The Anderson Intelligencer · Anderson Court House, S.C.
This Omaha dispatch claims a man believed to be old John Bender has been jailed in Fremont, Nebraska, along with a woman who may be his wife or mistress. It recounts the Benders' history near Cherryvale, Kansas, where the family ran a roadside inn and the mother posed as a spiritualist medium before being linked to disappearances.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Anderson Intelligencer · 19 August 1880 · page 1
THE BENDERS AS MURDERERS, ARREST OF OLD MAN BENDER AND A WOMAN
OMAHA, NEU., Aug. 2, 1880. Tue story of the crimes cf t!-.o Bonder family ia upon everybody'/- lipo. The f;rcate%t crime of the century ia likely, n a small measure at least, to be atoned for. But the most horrible death tbat old Jobu Bender could bo put to would but in a slight degree avenge the suffer ings of his many victims, lu the jail at Fremont,, in Dodge Con..ty, a man is locked up who is supposed to bo tho fiend thnt the authorities of Kansas have been looking for for seven years.
See moreSee less
There hard ly seems a doubt of his identity. With bim ?. '" woman-repulsive, hard-hVed and old. Sbe mny bo tho original .Mrs. Bender or she may bo bis mistress. Opinions differ on this point. Whrn they rer.eh Kansas the authorities will have bard work to guard tho couple from tho attacks of tho populace, who are thirsting for their blood. In 1878, old Bender and bin wifo and their'son John and his wifo lived -near Cherryvale, Lnbetto County, Kansas. Their house was about two miles ont-of town. It was a rude framo structure, standing in a lot of two acres. The old woman called herself a medium. She had a way o! boiling berhs and roots.that were sup posed to b"..rc charms and spells aboul thom, and tho dealt in incantations. She was repulsive in aspect-tall, nngulai and scrawny, with hard, steel-gray eves, and lh\pi ragged gray hair struggling over her-tempies. Tho family'seem tx havo been totally under the influence o: this ungainly creature. Her word witt thom was law. Tho Benders ostensibly kept a grocery. A sign was displayed lr front ot their rude dwelling to attrnc I visit?n, but tho s tock in trade - cousiatet principally of a Eort of cheap wine Th'tre wero only two rooms in the bouso Ono was a dining room and kitcho* combined. In the other tho four Ben dcrs slept.
The Anderson Intelligencer · Anderson Court House, S.C.
This report describes the Bender family's rude house and the old woman's reputation as a sinister medium, then recounts the 1873 disappearances near Cherryvale, including the old man and granddaughter and Dr. William H. York, who vanished while investigating. It notes that after a search party questioned the Benders, the family fled, and a passerby later found the abandoned house with a dead animal in the stable.
The Anderson Intelligencer · 19 August 1880 · page 1
The Anderson Intelligencer · Anderson Court House, S.C.
Searchers investigating Dr. York's disappearance find the Bender family mysteriously fled, their farm abandoned with a starved calf and thick dust. A hidden trap door in the floor reveals a pit stained with blood, confirming suspicions of murder though the victims' bodies are not yet found.
The Anderson Intelligencer · 19 August 1880 · page 1
MANY BODDEN DISAPPEARANCES. In 1873 n number of persons traveUinj in ibu uireciiuu of Cucrryvuiu mysie riou8ly d?sappoared. No traces of theo could be found. The first disappearance that attracted public attention was tba of an old man and bis granddaughtei who left Cherryvale in February, 187S in a two-horse wagon, to go to Fort Scotl but wh? never reached that place. Al inquiries failed to elicit a clue to thci disappearance until, about the beginning of March, Dr. William II. York recog ni zed the wagon and team at Fort Scot!
See moreSee less
He ascertained that tho wagon bad bee: purchased at the fort from some pcreo: who had come from Cherryvale, and h determined to ferret out the myster* He left Fort Scott on March 9, and hi too, disappeared. Dr. York wns wei known, and tho greatest efforts wer made IO discover traeos of him. A larg reward was offered, rivers were draggee spots fit for ambush wore probed foot b foot, lonesome places were quested as keen bound scents a trail tbat is colt and still no traces of the lost mah wet discovered, . Not a shadow af eridenc rested anywhere to say that Dr. Yor had been murdered--notasignanywhei told how bo carno to bis death, if, indeei death-had overtaken him unawares. B was traced toCherryvale, in Labetl Couuty, but no further. There all trac and trace of him ceased. The excib ment was at a high pitch. One day a .jxploring party stopped at tho houso < tho Bcuucrd. Had they seen nnythir of Dr. York? No, the answer cam . they had not. They knew nothing wha ever concerning him. But this visit hi a strango effect. The next day the Bei der family disappeared, and almost ; mysteriously as bad Dr. York. Th suspicious circumstance aroused curie ity. A man riding into Cherryvale frc tho country ono day was Impressed 1 tho deserted appearance of tho Bend place. - Ho entered the ynrd. In tl stable ho found a dead calf. There w every indication from tho appearcace tho miserable creature that it had starvi to death; Tho man walked up to t! bouse, opened tho door and looked i Not an article of household furnltu had boen removed, but tho dust 1 heavy pn everything. Tho man went Cherryvale and 'told, his story. Sonni A.>Mi York, the; brother of tho miss! man, was there. To his suspicious mi tho sudden and strange flight of t Bender family was n-revolution. Ho h found tho'first cluo to bis lost broth He divulged<his suspicions, and a ba of men accompanied bim to tho Bent farm. Tho front ruom of the hoi'te ** carefully searched, every crack and cn icc being minute'y looked into and st jeeted to tho application of rods a lorers to seo if Inti flooring was cltl hoiiow or loose. . Nothing: came of No blood spots'appeared. Tho floor v Bolid. Tbs walls wero solid. Next I party, searched ibo back room. The b< ' were removed. In their flight the P. dors had left everything untouched. A HOItlUBliE DI8COVEB.Y.
A letter relayed through an Iowa newspaper claims the four Benders were captured shortly after Col. Yorke's murder was discovered and were executed by nine riflemen, with Kate defiantly daring them to shoot. The bodies were allegedly buried at the junction of Labette, Wilson, Neosho and Montgomery counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Weekly Democratic Statesman · 19 August 1880 · page 1
Des Moines, la, August 14. A letter to the Stale JleyiMer from a responsible citizen, S. N. J. James of Sigoruey, gives information on the authority of an eye witness,who is also a responsible man, that the notorious Bender family, four iu number, were captured, "soon after the discovery of the murder of Col. Yorke. Tho witness says that the four were stood up in a row, facing nine riflemen and were told their fate, that Kate was plucky to the last and called up to her captors 'to "Shoot aud be damucd".and that the lour bodies were burled at tlie. cor ner of tho four counties. Labette,
A couple captured in Nebraska and suspected of being the Bender murderers were taken to Oswego, Kansas for identification. They were not recognized as the genuine Benders, debunking the earlier capture claims.
The Valley Virginian · 19 August 1880 · page 1
The parties captured in Nebraska, and sup posed to he old man Bender and his wife, who committed a number of murders upon travel ers while living in Kansas, are not the genu ine Benders. They were taken to Oswego,
An Iowa correspondent relays a secondhand account claiming the four Benders were caught after the York murder was discovered and shot by nine riflemen, with Kate defiantly daring them to fire. The bodies were allegedly buried at the junction of four Kansas counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Grant County Herald · 19 August 1880 · page 2
The latest Bender story is related by Mr. S. A. James, of Sigourney, lowa, who gives information on the authority of an eye witness, a re sponsible man, that the notorious Bender family, four in number, were captured soon after the discovery of the murder of Col. York’s brother, and shot He says the four were stood up in a row facing nine rifle men and were told of their fate; that Kate was pluck to the last and called on her captors to “shoot and be damned,’ and that the four bodies were buried at the corner of the four counties of Labette, Wilson, Neosho and Montgomery.
A letter relayed via the Des Moines State Register claims the four Benders were captured shortly after Col. York's murder was discovered and were lined up before nine riflemen and shot, with Kate defiantly taunting her executioners. The account is attributed to an unnamed 'responsible' eyewitness relayed secondhand.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Weekly Floridian · 20 August 1880 · page 4
(J. A. James, of Sigourney), give# infor mation, on the authority of an eye-witaees, who is also a responsible man, that the notorious Bender family, four in number, were captured soon after the discovery of the murder of Col. York. The eye witness says that the four were placed in a row, facing nine riflemen, and wen told their fate; that Kate was plucky to the last, and called upon their oapfpm to u shoot aad t d—d* and that #four fear oountMs of Labette, WUsou, Neosho ■ w. .a L ■ i tern mu; ana Montgomery. _ * :'i ! -
A letter from an Iowa citizen, citing an eyewitness, claims the notorious Bender family of four was captured and shot soon after the murder of Colonel York's brother was discovered. The report is presented as secondhand information within a general news summary digest.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Canton Register · 20 August 1880 · page 2
Register from a responsible citizen of the j 8tate, Mr. 8. A. James, of Sigourney, gives the information on the authority of au eyej witness, also a responsible man, that the no- , torious Bender family, four in number, were captured soon after the discovery of the murder of Colonel York’s brother, and shot. It wits announced on the loth that
An elderly couple arrested in Fremont, Nebraska as members of the Bender family were brought to Labette County courthouse in Oswego, Kansas and put on public display. Neighbors who had known the real Benders unanimously declared the pair were impostors, though the report notes they seemed to have some knowledge of the murderous gang.
The oldeouple who were arrested at Fremont, Neb., ax members of the Bender family, were exhibited in the Labette county courthouse, at Oxwego, Kax., on the loth inst. The person* who lived in the neighborhood of the Bender*, and who knew them well, were unanimously of the opinion t hat the aged pair were not’the Benders. What tbe motive of the woman wax in stating what she did it is difficult to ascertain. Even the old man at times seeme.l to confess that he wax a Bender. They probably wanted a free ride to Kansas.
See moreSee less
It is quite evident, how ever, that the pair have some knowledge of the murderous gang. Col. Fred IJi*kti.ey, officer in charge of the National cemetery nt Little Rock, Ark., died suddenly of heart disease* at the cemetery lodge, on the Btli mat. An Owego, K*., dispatch of tlie 9th says: “ The old couple supposed to bo Bender mid wife arrived here from Nebraska tins morning, and wire ex|4>sed in the court house for some hours. Many peraou* went to see them, and dozens who know the real Benders prouoiuiccd these people inqsixtors. The sheriff think* thej’
A letter relayed secondhand claims the Bender family was captured by a posse after the murder of Col. York's brother and executed by nine riflemen, with Kate defiantly taunting her captors. The bodies were supposedly buried at the corners of four counties, though the account is unverified and based on an unnamed 'eye witness.'
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The New North-West · 20 August 1880 · page 2
Another Bender Story. Das MOINES, Ia., Aug. 13.-A letter to the State Regiser from a responsible citizen in this State gives information on the au
The sheriff of Labette County, Kansas, has taken an old man identified as John Bender back to that state, believing him to be the long-sought murderer. The item closes with the proverb 'Murder will out,' suggesting confidence that justice is finally catching up to the Bender family.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
Bismarck Tribune · 20 August 1880 · page 1
Hon. J. G. Thorp, Madison, Wis. —Maud S. and St. Julien each trotted a mile in 2:ll?i at Rochester, New York, last -week. Yanderbilt now owns both and Bonner proposes a match with his fast team. —The sheriff of Labette county, Kan sas, has taken old John Bender back to that
A letter from Des Moines cites an eyewitness claiming the four Benders were captured after the discovery of Colonel York's brother's murder. The account says they were lined up and shot by nine riflemen, then buried at the junction of four Kansas counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Perrysburg Journal · 20 August 1880 · page 1
VOL. XXVIII -NO. 10. trict Convention, hold at Toledo, Hon. Frank Hurd was nominated. Tuk complete census returns of Ar kansas, less nine small districts, four of which are estimated, show tho population of that Stato to be 81(1, 147. ' A letter to tho Des Mojnes Stale Jtttlitfr from a responsible citizen of that State gives Information on the authority of an eye witness, also a responsible man, that the notorious Bender family, four In num ber, were captured soon after the discovery of the murder of Colonel York's brother. They were Htood up In a row faciug nine rifle men, were told their fate and then shot. Tho bodies were burled at the corner of tho four counties of Labette, Wilson, Ncosha and
A Chicago Times correspondent from Kansas claims to know for certain that the Bender family is dead, dismissing an earlier account by captured 'McGregor tramps' who falsely claimed to be Benders. He promises the true story of their pursuit, capture, and death, while noting no one ever witnessed the murders or heard a confession.
WHAT BECAME OF THE BENDERS. A True Account of How the Notorious Benders Were Disposed of - Their Pursuit, Capture and Death.
County, Kan., in referenco to tho arrest of tho McGregor tramps and their claim v be members of the murderous Bender family, says: " The lleiidem are dead. 1 sneak thin dootsivnly because I know whereof i speak.' It
A letter to the Des Moines State Register, citing an eyewitness, claims the notorious Bender family was captured shortly after the murder of Colonel York's brother was discovered. The report states the four were lined up before nine riflemen, told their fate, shot, and buried at the junction of four Kansas counties.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 20 August 1880 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
This sensational account describes the Benders being tied to trees, forced to pray before being killed, and their bodies dumped in a hole dug beneath a fallen cottonwood's roots. The narrator claims their belongings were burned as an offering and warns that any future claims of a Bender's capture should be considered false.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 20 August 1880 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A correspondent recounts a Chicago Times story in which a man claiming to have been part of a vigilante party asserts he knows what really happened to the Bender family, dismissing recent impostors who falsely claimed to be the Benders. He frames this as finally setting the historical record straight after years of recurring sensational claims.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 21 August 1880 · page 6
A VIGILANTE TELLS HOW THE BENDERS WERE BLOTTED OUT
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
The author explains that professional tramps often absorb lurid criminal lore and sometimes fabricate elaborate confessions to famous crimes like the Bender murders for amusement or notoriety, as apparently happened with the 'McGregors.' He urges the public to accept that the real Benders can never be arrested, asserting as settled fact that they are already dead and in hell.
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 21 August 1880 · page 6
She-Devil Kata. (Chicago Times, August 12th.J Oswego (Labette county, Kan.), August 9th. — The attempt on the . part of ' two weather old tramps to palm them selves off on a credulous public pas the only and original Bender butchers, has occa sioned a good deal of quiet amusement in these parts, where the truth is very gener ally known or shrewdly surmised. Every time the story of the Bender murders is re vived, and it has been revived . a dozen times almost within the last six or. seven years, I am tempted to come forward and tell what I know.
See moreSee less
Were it not for the en joyment that comes of watching the birth, growth and sudden subsidence of each suc cessive sensation I should . long ago have made a statement of facts, for the vindica tion of history if for no other reason. This last sensation has proved a "corker" in its way, and under the circumstances the I public can not be blamed for being taken lin by the imposture. The knowledge of j the Kansas tragedies displayed by
A self-described vigilante writes to the paper claiming he and associates killed the Bender family in revenge for the murders, insisting they are certainly dead and beyond legal justice. He disputes earlier published details (the 'McGregor' account) about hatchet decapitations and a girl named Maggie, saying the victims were actually killed with a hammer and had their throats cut.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 21 August 1880 · page 6
They are awfully dead, and their bones tomary for awfully boast of acts lawless arc whitened by the processes of nature i whitened by the processes of nature ere this. I speak thus decisively because s this. I speak thus decisively because I know whereof I speak. It is not cus ;now whereof I speak. It is not cua rary for one to boast of acts of lawless ness, and it is not in that spirit that I enter upon the recital of the last chapter of the bloody career of the brutal Benders, I am prudent enough, too, to wish to hedge myself against possible annoyance, ; and had I not your solemn assurance that !
See moreSee less
you will not divulge my name, it is not un , likely I should leave the writing of this ' scrap of history to other hands. I will ' not consume your valuable space by at r tempting to defend myself or my asso i ciates for the part we took in purifying the p atmosphere of Southern Kansas by aveng ; ing the wholesale murders that were comI mitted by the Benders. Suffice it to say, I our consciences are not troubled in the ; least by recollections of the exciting occurI rences which followed the discovery of the slaughter of ten human beings in that lonely tavern, and if we had it to do over again I doubt if the programme would be varied an iota. It is not necessary to go into a detailed account of the murders. In point of fact, very little is actually known on that point. No one in the land of the living will have the hardihood to say that he saw the deeds done, and the Benders themselves
Batesville Guard · Batesville, Ark. · and 1 other paper
A Chicago Times correspondent from Kansas asserts the Benders are dead, disputing claims by captured tramps (the McGregors) who falsely claimed to be Bender family members. He describes the family's background and methods but promises the 'last chapter' of their story without yet detailing the claimed capture.
Times, writing from Oswego, Labette County, Kan., in reference to the arrest of the McGregor tramps and their claim to be members of the murderous Bender family, says: “ The Benders are dead. I speak thus de cisively because I know whereof I speak. It is not customary lor one to boast of ads of lawlessness, and it is not in that spirit that I enter upon the recital of the last chapter of the bloody career of the brutish Benders. “It is not necessary to go into a detailed account of the murders.
See moreSee less
In point of fact, very little is actually known on that point. No one in the land of the living will have the hard ihood to say that he saw the deeds done, and the Benders themselves never made a con fession that I know of. The McGregor liars were a little off in their description of the niur ders. They always had Kate, or Maggie, her cousin, or John, cutting the heads of the vic tims to pieces with hatchets, whereas they were invariably brained with a hammer and their throats cut. “ The Benders, John and his wife, and their two children, Kate and John, kept a wayside tavern about a mile and a half southeast of Morehead Station on the road leading from In dependence to the Osage Mission. They were there when I moved into the county two years before the discovery of the butcheries, and were well known then. Kate was a red-faced, low-browed, square-shouldered amazon, strong enough to throw a bull by the tail, and every body stood in awe of her. She made a pre tense of practicing the healing art, and was known far and wide as a “spiritualistic doctor.” Her cures were permanent, and her remedy was a hammer. Decent people avoided the Bender tavern. As the country hereabouts harbored a good many des peradoes about this time, no one cared to raise a row. and the protest went no further than avoidance. When search was instituted for the body of Dr. York, in April, 1873, sus picion was directed against the Benders, and contrary to the general belief a close watch was kept on them for a while. They must have been aware of the surveillance, for at the first opportunity they decamped. The re port that they took the train at Thayer, a sta tion a few miles north of Cherryvale, and went to Humboldt, from which place they took passage for Texas, is a mistake, 'rhey simply bundled their goods intotwo wagonsand start ed for Indlon Territory. I'hey did not pro ceed at once to their destination, if, indeed, they had any destination marked out, but crossed over into Montgomery County, and squatted near Verdigris River to await devel opments. The distance from their farm was something like twenty miles. John, Jr., or John, Sr., made daily trips back to the vicinity of Cherry vale and took observations. It was their intention to return if the excitement should blow over, but*ir it continued warm । they would go on as originally planned. They j knew of the discovery of their crime within