As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

August 1880, part 2

10 articles

Batesville Guard · Batesville, Ark.

A self-described vigilante describes how a secret posse of about forty men tracked the fleeing Benders south toward Indian Territory after discovering their abandoned, burned wagon. He claims the group's scouts finally caught sight of the murderers some twenty miles beyond the Territory line.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Batesville Guard · 25 August 1880 · page 1

' ful assistance of suspicious characters was a । thing to be dreaded. The vigilantes did not I number more than one hundred men all told, but they meant business, as the sequel proved. It was my good or bad fortune to be one of the elect. Scouts were sent out in all directions, and within forty-eight hours of the departure of the Benders front their camp in the next county, the fact wax duly reported to us. •* About forty of us organized into a pursu ing party and started after the butchers.

See moreSee less

Once ! on their trail, we had no difliculty in following it. The murderous uuartet had taken to the open country west of the river, but were keep । ing within convenient distance of the thick ; timber that grows in the valley watered by the i stream. They were expecting pursuit, and ■ hoped to escape by losing themselves in this timber if it came to the worst. As we pro cecded the trail freshened, and ere long we came across the haif-consumed ruins of the wagon left by the Benders in their flight. From the direction they were taking, it be came evident to the mind of those acquainted with the country that they were pointing tor that paradise of cutthroats located near the i mouth of the Hol fork of the Arkansas. The country hereabouts is a bleak and desolate region, infest’d by horse-thieves, halt-breed Cn eks, Pawnees and Cherokees. Once there they knew they would be safe from pursuit. Even the United States troops have never been able to penetrate that Un a incog* nita. It I a a safe ret rent for the bolder rullians and is known to be such all through this seo lion of the country. This haven tor the wick ed Is distant about one hundred and forty . miles from the point whore the Verdlxrls I River enters Indian Territory. The murderI era had about forty miles to travel before j

See the clipping

The Pulaski Citizen · Pulaski, Tenn.

This 1880 article retells the history of the Bender family of Labette County, Kansas, and how their murders came to light after the disappearance of William York in 1873. It describes neighbors growing suspicious after finding an abandoned Bender wagon team and a starved calf, leading to the discovery of York's body and other victims buried on the Bender claim.

The Pulaski Citizen · 26 August 1880 · page 1

A History of Their Horrible Crimes. For several years previous to the year 1873 John Bender and his wile and two children, Kate and John, lived in the noi tit west corner of La bette county, Kansas, about ten miles from Thayer, and Ave and a half miles from Cherryvale. 1 he first uiug that led to the dis covery ol ihe uorriole series ot murder committed by the Bender family was the disappearance of William York, of Independence, Kansas, a brother of State Senator York, about the first of April, 1873.

See moreSee less

A diligent search resulted in find ing Mr. York's body buried on the claim of the Bender family, bearing marks of violence. The party, mak ing the discovery were horrified to find tbe remains of several other murdered men.- On Monday. May 5tb, 1873 a brother of the murdered Dr. York learned that the Bender family hid left their claim in Labette countv. where they had been running a store lor the purpose ot supplying trav elers who passed that way. The departure of tl.e family of murder ers was discovered by some one, who, in passing, saw that a calf that had been tied up had starved to death. Closer inspection showed that .ill were gone, witli wuat movable could be carried in a w.Tgnn. The neighbors concluded to look furs Lei into the matter, and learned that a team had been abandoned at Thayer about three weeks before, and some of them going to that point discov ered that the team was one that had belonged to Bender.

See the clipping

The Pulaski Citizen · Pulaski, Tenn.

The report details exhumation and identification of several Bender murder victims, describing burial methods and the ninth victim found in Drum Creek. It also describes the Bender family members physically and claims they were later captured and shot by a citizen posse while fleeing toward Indian Territory.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Pulaski Citizen · 26 August 1880 · page 1

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Milan Exchange · Milan, Tenn.

A correspondent writing from Labette County, Kansas, asserts flatly that the Benders are dead, dismissing recent claims by captured McGregor tramps to be Bender family members. He begins describing the family's wayside tavern and Kate Bender's reputation as a 'spiritualistic doctor' whose cures were in fact murders by hammer.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 35 days later.

Wrong

The Milan Exchange · 26 August 1880 · page 2

WHAT BECAME OF THE BENDERS

found on their persons. Duprez was travel ing south alone, and stopped in a tent over night. ( ne of the Mexicans shot him while asleep, while the other stood by with an ax ready to afford assistance if necessary. A party of Russian emigrants, sixty seven in number, the sole survivors of a par ty of three hundred and thirty, which left Russia in 1877 for Brazil, have arrived at New York sick and destitute. They found the South American climate unsuited to them, and after losing nearly all their funds decided to leave the country where they had experienced so many hardships.

See moreSee less

Dr. Turner, Secretary of the Na tional Board of Health, says that from of ficial reports received from what are known as the yellow fever districts, h does not an ticipate that there will be any yellow fever in this country this season in an epidemic form. There may be sporadic cases, but the disease would then be confined and would not spread. He said the most dangerous part of the season is already over, and noth ing that could indicate the breaking out of a yellow fever epidemic has been reported. He attributes the freedom of Memphis from the fever this year to her establishment of sewerage and other sanitary precautions against the engenderment of the disease. The officers of the Board in the different sections are ready to act at a moment's no tice to the extent of the power conferred upon them by law. The Indian Agent at Poplar River, D. T., has abandoned his post in conse quence of the threatening aspect of the In dians in that vicinity. He reports Sitting Bull within twenty miles of the Agency. Troops have been dispatched to that point from Bismarck. The naked and terribly mutilated body of Mary Cassiday, aged ten years, was found in a brush heap in the woods near Barnstable, Mass., on the 18th. The head was nearly severed from the body and in the child's side was a large butcher-knife. The ground about bore evidence of the struggle of the little girl to free herself from the vil lain who so fearfully assaulted and cruelly murdered her. Senator Conkling, it is said, is booked for several speeches in Ohio and In diana. Wadkins, a horse thief, was taken from the Jail at Fort Scott, Kansas, by a mob, and hanged to the limb of a tree. of the McGregor tramps and their claim to be members of the murderous Bender family, says: The Benders are dead. I speak thus de cisively because 1 know whereof 1 speak. It is not customary lor one to boast of acts of lawlessness!, am! it is not in that spirit that 1 enter upon the recital of the last chapter of the Mix nly career of the brutish Benders. "It is not necessary tojro into a detailed account of the munlcrs. In point of fact, very little is actually known on that point. No one in the ittml ol the living will nave me nani ihood to say that ho saw the denii done, and the Benders themselves never made a con fession that I know of. The Mctireg-or Mars

See the clipping

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas · and 1 other paper

The report corrects earlier accounts, stating victims were killed with a hammer and throat-cutting rather than hatchets, and describes the Benders' tavern operations and reputation. It also corrects the escape route, saying they fled by wagon toward Indian Territory rather than by train through Humboldt to Texas.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Sacramento Daily Record-Union, 21 August 1880, Sacramento Daily Record-Union, 21 August 1880, Batesville Guard, 25 August 1880.

The Iola Register · 27 August 1880 · page 2

County, Kan., in reference to the arrest oftheMcGregortrampaand their claim to be members of the murderous Bender family, says: . "The Benders are dead. I speak Urns de cisively because I know whereof r speak. It is not customary ior one to boast of acts or lawlessness, and it is not In that spirit that J enter upon the recital of the last chaster or the bloody career of the brutish Benders. "It is not necessary to go into a detailed account of the murders. In point of fact, very llttlo Is actually known on that point.

See moreSee less

No one in the land or the living will have the hard ihood to say that he saw the deeds done, and the Benders themselves never made a con fession that I know of. The McGregor liars were a little off in their description of the mur ders. They always had Kate, or Maggie, her cousin, or John, cutting the heads of the vic tims to pieces with hatchets, whereas they were invariably brained with a hammer and theirthroats cut. " The Benders, John and his wife, and their two children, Kate and John, kept & wayside tavern about a mile and a half southeast or Morehead Station on the road leading from In dependence to the Osage Mission. They were there when I moved into the county two years before the discovery of the butcheries, and were well known then. Kate was a red-faced, low-browed, square-shouldered amazon, strong enough to throw a bull by the tail, and every body stood in awe of her. She made a pre tense of practicing the healing art, and was known far and wide as a "spiritualistic doctor." Her" cures were petmanent, and her remedy was a hammer. Decent people avoided the Bender tavern. As the country hereabouts harbored a good many des peradoes about this time, no one cared to raise a row, and the protest went no further than avoidance. When search was instituted for the body of Dr. York, in April, 1STJ, sus picion was directed against the Benders, and contrary to the general belief a close watch was kept on them for a while. They must have been aware of the surveillance, for at the first opportunity they decamped. 1 ho re port that they took the train at Thayer, a sta tion a few miles north of Cherry ale, and went to Humboldt, from which place they took

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Batesville Guard · Batesville, Ark. · 25 August 1880

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

A Chicago Times correspondent from Kansas asserts confidently that the Benders are dead and dismisses the McGregor tramps' claims to be the murderous family as lies. He also corrects the McGregors' description of the murder method, stating victims were killed with a hammer and throat-cutting rather than hatchet mutilation.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 34 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Iola Register · 27 August 1880 · page 2

THE BENDERS

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

A self-described vigilante recounts organizing a secret posse that tracked the fleeing Bender family after their crimes were discovered, claiming to have captured all four near a riverside forest after a chase. The account describes the posse debating whether to hand them to the law or exact instant vengeance.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 34 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Wrong

The Iola Register · 27 August 1880 · page 2

what was left, set lire to it, and hurried on. "In the meantime a vigilaneo committee had been formed. This move wa taken -vv ith the greatest secrecy, and none but trusty men were admitted to the organization. The ut most circumspection was uted, for the reason that in a new community like this the doubt ful assistance of suspicious characters was a thing to be dreaded. The xigilintes did not number more than one hundred men all told, but they meant business, as the sequel proved. It was my good or bad fortune to be one of the elect. Scouts were sent out in all directions, and within forty-eight hours of the departure of the Benders from their camp in the next county, the fact was duly reported

See the clipping

The Weekly Thibodaux Sentinel and Journal of the 8th Senatorial District · Thibodaux, La.

A notable citizen of Sigourney reports to an Iowa newspaper, citing an eyewitness, that the four Benders were captured after the murder of Colonel Yorke and shot dead by nine armed men, then buried at the junction of four counties. The item itself questions whether this account is true or merely a story spread to mislead police.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 33 days later.

Wrong

The Weekly Thibodaux Sentinel and Journal of the 8th Senatorial District · 28 August 1880 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Weekly Thibodaux Sentinel and Journal of the 8th Senatorial District · Thibodaux, La.

A Chicago Times report, relayed via Oswego, Kansas, quotes an anonymous vigilante who claims the Bender family was tracked down and killed in 1873 near the Verdigris River in Montgomery County. The informant insists the Benders are dead, their bones bleaching in the open, and describes a forty-man posse capturing all four after a brief struggle.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 33 days later.

Wrong

The Weekly Thibodaux Sentinel and Journal of the 8th Senatorial District · 28 August 1880 · page 1

LES BENDER

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Weekly Thibodaux Sentinel and Journal of the 8th Senatorial District · Thibodaux, La.

A self-described vigilante describes joining a 40-man posse that tracked down the Bender family as they fled south, capturing all four after a brief gunfight. He recounts their interrogation, curses from Kate Bender, a death sentence, and their execution by firing squad tied to trees.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 33 days later.

Wrong

The Weekly Thibodaux Sentinel and Journal of the 8th Senatorial District · 28 August 1880 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping