Butler Citizen · Butler, Pa.
A newspaper item reports a claim that the notorious Bender family was secretly lynched by vigilantes shortly after their murders were discovered in 1873. An alleged eyewitness describes four Benders, including a defiant Kate, being shot by nine riflemen and buried at a county corner.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 29 days later.
Butler Citizen · 1 September 1880 · page 3
—The Benders are now believed to have been lynched at the time of the dis covery of their last murder in 1873. One who witnessed the lynching says that the notorious Bender family, "four in number, were captured soon after the discovery of the murder of Col. York's brother. He says the four were stood up in a row, facing nine riflemen, and were told their fate, that Kate was pluck to the last, and called upon her captors to "shoot and be d—d," and that the four bodies were buried at thu corner of" the counties of JLabette, Wilson, Neosho and Montgomery.