As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

May 1875

2 articles

In the story →

The Andrew County Republican · Savannah, Mo.

A woman long suspected of being Kate Bender was taken into custody near the Douglass county line after offering a man money to help her flee the country by traveling only at night. Parties arrived and telegraphed for a correct description to confirm her identity.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

The Andrew County Republican · 7 May 1875 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Kate Bender. A woman upon whom suspicion has rested for some time, was taken into custody one day this week near the Douglass county line. It has been thought by many for severl months that she is the genuine Kate Bender, the genuine maiden, and heroine of the Kansas murders. Parties arrived here Tuesday and telegraphed for correct description. This woman of whom we speak, we are informed, has been in Douglass county some five monts. She has been known to hide herself on the approach of strangers, but we believe the direct cause for suspecting her consists in the fact that she offered a certain man $500 if he would travel with and take her out of the country.

See moreSee less

She mentioned that it would be her plan to travel by night and rest during the day. —Marshall (Mo.) Democrat.

See the clipping

The Holt County Sentinel · Oregon, Missouri.

A woman who had aroused suspicion for months near the Douglas county line was taken into custody, believed by many locals to be the real Kate Bender of the Kansas murders. She had reportedly hidden from strangers and offered a man $500 to help her flee the country by traveling at night.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 7 days earlier.

The Holt County Sentinel · 14 May 1875 · page 2

Kale Bender. A women upon whom suspicion, hlw rested for some time, was taken Into custody one day this week near the Douglass county line. It has been thought by many for severel months that she is the gcnulno Kate Bender, the genuine raaiden.nnd heroino of the Kansas murders. Pal ties arrived here Tuesday and telegraphed for correct description. This woman of whom wc speak, we are informed, has "been Jn TintirrlnKa nnnnfv soma five mo'nthg. Sho Sas been known to hide herself on tho approach of strangers, but wo be lieve tno Uirect. cause iur suspecting her consists in tno iact mat sne offered u certain man 8500 if he wojild travel with and take her out of 'tho country. She mentioned that it would be her plan

See the clipping