A ragged, dirty man arrested in Sevier County, Utah, who claimed to have traveled from Montana, was suspected of being the fugitive Kansas murderer Bender due to strong physical resemblance, including maimed hands. He was jailed in Manti while a photograph was sent to Kansas authorities for confirmation, and a woman thought to be Kate Bender had reportedly been seen near Provo.
Iowa Voter · 2 April 1874 · page 2
Bender, in all particulars. He was then San ut for safe keeping in the jail at Manti, Pete County. There is a most strik ing similarity between the description of the accused old man and Bender, even to the maimed hands with the large, promi nent cords on the back, color and quanti ty of hair, beard, etc. There appears to be a scowl the face, the brows being OH habitually knit. A portrait was taken at
A man arrested in Utah was suspected of being the elder Bender, one of the Kansas murderers. His photograph was reportedly recognized by former neighbors back in Kansas as that of old Bender himself.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 28 days later.
Wrong
The Idaho World · 2 April 1874 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A dirty, ragged old man arrested in Sevier County, Utah, was suspected of being the fugitive Kansas murderer Ben Bender based on matching physical descriptions, including maimed hands with prominent cords. He was held in Manti jail while a portrait was sent to Kansas authorities for confirmation, and a woman near Provo was similarly suspected of being Kate Bender.
The Redwood Gazette · 2 April 1874 · page 3
Richfield. He stated that ht had traveled over the mountains from Montana. His conduct was exceedingly strange, appear ing most uninviting, and people wiio had read the description of old Bender sus pected that this was the identical Kansas murderer. The suspicion was so strong that he was placed under arrest, and the Sheriff wrote to Salt Lake for a de tailed description of the individual in question. When the reply was received the supposed murderer haaa preliminary examination before a Justice of the Peace, when it was clearly indicated that the man answered the description given of Bender, in all particulars.
See moreSee less
He was their put for safe keeping in the jail at Manti, San Pete County. There is a most strik ing similarity between the description of the accused old man and Bender, even to the maimed hands with the large, promi nent cords on the back, color and quanti ty of hair, beard, etc. There appears to be a scowl OH the face, the brows being habitually knit. A portrait was taken at Manti and sent to the authorities in Kan sas for recognition. Some months ago a woman came out of the mountains and sojourned awhile at Provo, supposed to be the murderess, Kate Bender.
A Salt Lake City dispatch reports that an old man resembling Bender, the notorious Kansas murderer, emerged from the Wahsatch Mountains and was captured, with witnesses identifying him from a photograph. The report also claims a woman matching Katherine Bender's description appeared starving in a southern settlement, suggesting the whole family had been hiding in the mountains.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.
Wrong
The New York Herald · 10 April 1874 · page 7
OLD BENDER AT SALT LAKE.
Salt L.akk, Utah, April 9, 1874. Some weeks ago an old man emerged from the Wahsatch Mountains, iso miles south or this city, i ai^tl, from Ills appearance and conduct, tie was j believed to be old Bender, the Kansas murderer. Ills photograph was taken and sent to the Gov ernor of Kansas, and it has slnco been returned, with statements Irom Senator York, brother of Bonder's last victim, and other persons, all agree ing that tho photograph greatly resembled the murderer. He was brought here last night. So intense tias been tho excltcuient that the jailer brought tilm twlcu out of prison, in order to satisfy the crowds of people who wanted to see him.
See moreSee less
He answers tally to the published descriptions, but he will give'no account of ais pasc whereabouts. THE CAPTIVE RKOOONIZBD AS BENDElt.
The report recaps how the Bender family's house near Cherryvale, Kansas, was found to conceal the bodies of victims, with the discovery of a murdered man identified as Dr. York's brother triggering the family's flight. It describes the subsequent search for the fugitives, believed to be fleeing south toward Texas, and recounts the gruesome details of the killings discovered in their cellar.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The New York Herald · 10 April 1874 · page 7
THE CAPTIVE RKOOONIZBD AS BENDElt. I have seen him three times to-day. The last time I was accompanied by two gentlemen wtio identified him as Bender. One knew him In Pike county, 111., for soven years; the other had seen htm at least fifty times at different ranches in Kansas about two years back, lie looks mean enough to have done all that is charged against Bender without realizing any mental compunc tions. The officers will brinar up from the South in a few days a young man who answers to the de scription of young Bender.
See moreSee less
A woman, who an swers the description of Kathertne Bender, came into the Southern settlements some inouims siuce almost naked. After obtaining ioocf and clothimr she disappeared, and it is now thought the whole family have been in the mountains all winter, and have been driven out by starvation into the set tlements. Heuce their capture. The Crimes of the Bender Family?A
The report describes the discovery of five murdered men and an infant in the Benders' cellar, each killed by a hammer blow and cut throat, suggesting organized serial murder of travelers. It also recounts the pursuit of suspects, the capture and suicide of accomplice Nicholas Morrin, and claims the capture of 'old man Bender' himself.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.
Wrong
The New York Herald · 10 April 1874 · page 7
THE CAPTIVE RECOGNIZED AS BENDER
i than they did. But they lost thoir caution, ana let | the body of one of their victims be found in the ' vicinity of their dwelling. The murdered man was I identified as a brother of Colonel A. M. York, the legislator who exposed the attempt of Senator Pomeroy at bribery; tho Bender lamlly becamo panic-stricken, and precipitately left their honso near Cherryvale, Labette county, Kansas. Suspi cion had pointed at them, but not definitely enough for them to be urrested. Their flight was a good in dication of guilt, and endeavors were iinmadiaiely made to procure other and more certain evidence against the mgittvos.
See moreSee less
When the Benders had been none from their house about two weeks the building was examined carciully, and in its I cellar were tound prools that its occupants hud i beeu criminals of the most horrid class. There I were tound the bodies of live men and the body of j an infant. The manner of murdering was the same In evfery instance. The victim seemed ilrst to have been struck upon the head witn a hammer, and I then to have had his throat cut. The unltornnty in tills respect argacd strongly that the Benders and coniederates were associated lor the defined purpose of Killing and plundering whatever trav ellers chinced into their vicinity. When their murderous doings were fully knowu they were im mediately sought lor. The Western country was scoured by excited people, ami It was soon de cided that the murderers had gone to tho ! South, and were trvmg to get through I Texas into Mexico. i'nis idea was con firmed by the capture In the Indian Teiritory, alter a week's chase, of Nicholas Morrin, or Marlon, a coniederate of the Benders. Marion made some important disclosures, and promised to tell the story of the crimes of himseli and accomplices when he should reach Parson", Kansas. He niter wards becamc atraid of tieinir lynched, and while on the way to Kansas with his captors committed , suicide by shootiug himself. Several other per i sons were arrested subsequently in different lo calities of the West, but uone of tiiem were proven to have been In couiederacy with the ilentons. The capture of the old man Bender is very grati fying. It Insures that he will ue punished for his enormon* crimes, and protects tne people of some ! new locality irom a repetition of them.
A report from Salt Lake City says an old man resembling the elder Bender, the notorious Kansas murderer, was arrested after being spotted near the Wasatch Mountains and identified by a photograph sent from Kansas. Two men who claimed to know him from Illinois and Kansas identified him as Bender, and police expected to soon bring in a young man matching the description of Bender's son.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 21 days later.
Wrong
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 11 April 1874 · page 1
Die berüchtigte Mörder-Familie Bender aus Kansas in Utah verhaftet. Vater und Sohn identifizirt. Ihre Abführung nach Kansas steht bevor.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A man resembling published descriptions of Bender was brought to jail amid great public excitement, and two witnesses claimed to recognize him from past years, though he denied any recent whereabouts. The report also recaps the Bender family's murders near Cherryvale, Kansas, including the discovery of Colonel York's brother's body that prompted their flight.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 21 days later.
Wrong
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 11 April 1874 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes how suspicion forced the Bender family to flee their home near Cherryvale, Kansas, and how authorities then found the bodies of five men and an infant in the cellar, all killed by hammer blows and throat-cutting. It also recounts the pursuit of the fugitives, the capture and suicide of an alleged accomplice named Marion, and claims the elder Bender himself has been captured.
The report states that "Old Bender," the Kansas murderer, has been arrested and identified, and is currently held in jail in Salt Lake City. It notes his presence is desired in Kansas, where he will likely be extradited.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.
Wrong
The Somerset Press · 24 April 1874 · page 2
Governor Washburn has been chosen as the successor of Sumner in the U. S. Senate. He is not gen erally looked upon as the kind of man that Commonwealth should have selected for the place. But it appears that his election was the best thing that could be done under the circumstances. Old Bender, the Kansas murder erer, has been arrested and identi fied, and is now in jail in Salt Lake City. His presence is greatly de sired in Kansas, to which State, he will doubtless shortly be removed. The Legislature adjourned on Monday last, without having ac complished much legislation of gen eral importance. The re-di.tricting measure was not passed.
A disheveled old man captured by a workman in Sevier County, Utah, and sent to Topeka under guard is being viewed by crowds who dispute whether he is the fugitive Bender patriarch. Witnesses disagree, with one key detail—missing fingers—casting doubt, though many still believe him to be the wanted man.
Bender, who only had one missinc. Nev ertheless, he is generally believed to be the man wanted. He was captured bv a workman on the road in Seveir Conntv Utah ; was taken to Salt L&ke City by Sheriff Fouty, and, on the expressed belief of parties who knew Bender, was sent here. Other parties will be here to morrow to identify him.
A dispatch from Salem, Oregon states it has been ascertained that Kate Bender, the Kansas murderer, was in the city in March before going to Puget Sound, where she was recognized at Tacoma. This is one of many reported sightings during the ongoing search for the Bender family.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Daily Argus · 30 April 1874 · page 1
Salem. Ore., April 28. It is ascertaini ed that Kate Bender, the Kansas murder er, was in this city last March. She went ' to Puget Sound, and was recognized at Tacoma, V ashmgton Territotv. She made er escape into British Columbia, where lie jnow is. The Record publishes to dav an account ol the pursuit and escape.