As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

May 1874

11 articles

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

The Salt Lake Tribune reports that a woman arrested in Morgan County, Utah on suspicion of being Kate Bender matches the description circulated by Kansas authorities. She is being transported to Salt Lake City so police can determine whether she is actually the notorious 'she-devil.'

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 1 May 1874 · page 4

Free Lunch at 10 a. m., Star Brew ery. ai>3o-2t The Laramie Sentinel of Wednesday says. “ Marshal Hance is out this afternoon with his police brigade cleaning up the streets hnd alleys.” That is a cheerful Item of news, and wo would like to report a similar one respecting our streets and alleys. The Balt Lake Tribune of Tuesday contains the following: Yesterday Chief of Police Burt, received from Sherltf Saunders of Morgan county, n full description of the woman under arrest in that county on suspicion of being Kate Bender, the she-devil.

See moreSee less

The description l»ears such a striking re semblance to the one published by the Kansas authorities, that, the officer having her in charge has been in structed to bring her to this city, where she will probably arrive to-day. Her sudden and mysterious appearance at Weber, and her answering so closely the description of Katie Bender, will warrant her detention till it dan be definitely ascertained whether she is the veritable she-devil or not.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

A report states that it remains undecided whether individuals arrested near Salt Lake City are the Bender murder family, despite contrary claims in a St. Louis paper. The elderly man believed to be the family patriarch was brought to Topeka and identified by several witnesses and Governor Osborne as old Bender, while a woman thought to be Kate Bender was captured after violent resistance and found with a photograph believed to show the elder Mrs. Bender.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 2 May 1874 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Weekly Caucasian · Lexington, Mo.

The report describes a flurry of unconfirmed Bender sightings, including a man called 'Old Bender' arrested in Topeka who turned out to be someone named Johannes Cook, and an elderly Prussian woman mistakenly held as 'old woman Bender' before being released. Another report claims a man and woman suspected to be John and Kate Bender were arrested near Salt Lake City pending identification.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 42 days later. CorrectionThis set right 6 earlier articles: The New York Herald, 10 April 1874, The New York Herald, 10 April 1874, Der Deutsche Correspondent, 11 April 1874, Der Deutsche Correspondent, 11 April 1874, Der Deutsche Correspondent, 11 April 1874, The Somerset Press, 24 April 1874.

Wrong

The Weekly Caucasian · 2 May 1874 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The Bender excitement is raging in Kansas. Old Bender, as some call him, has reached Topeka, and it is claimed the name of the prisoner is Johannes Cook, and not the notorious cut-throat. An old lady, a Prussian, was arrested near Topeka as old woman Bender, but her capturers were mistaken and she was discharged. It is feared that the guilty wretches are still at large.

And now comes another report from Salt Lake that a girl supposed to be Kate Bender, and a man supposed to be John Bender, have been arrested near there, and will be held for identification.

See the clipping

The Weekly Caucasian · Lexington, Mo.

The item reports that a man identified as 'Old Bender' has been transferred from a Salt Lake jail to a jail in Topeka, Kansas, as part of the ongoing manhunt. The report asserts there is no doubt he is the right man.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 42 days later.

Wrong

The Weekly Caucasian · 2 May 1874 · page 2

RENERAl NEWS. A heavy taow storm prevailed all day st Allentown. Pa.. April Snow fell to the depth of ten Inches. Old Bender hu been broufht from the

See the clipping

The Weekly Caucasian · Lexington, Mo.

The report describes John Bender, patriarch of the murderous family, as finally captured near Salt Lake City and conclusively identified by old acquaintances despite his attempt to disguise himself by cutting off a finger. He is said to have been transferred to Topeka, Kansas to await trial under federal marshal escort.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 42 days later.

Wrong

The Weekly Caucasian · 2 May 1874 · page 2

JOHN BENDER

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Northern Ohio Journal · Painesville, Ohio

A dispatch from Topeka, Kansas reports that old man Bender and his wife, the Cherry Vale butchers, have arrived there. Another note claims Kate Bender, one of the Kansas butchers, is reportedly in British Columbia.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 42 days later.

Wrong

Northern Ohio Journal · 2 May 1874 · page 1

Pomeroy, a boy of fifteen, who had recently been pardoned rat of the Penitentiary, con fessed to the deed. He is believed to be in sane. A. B. Holcomb, of Vicksburg, aged 75 years, committed suicide last week by dis charging his rifle into his head. B. F. O leman, a printer from Chicago, recently committed suicide at Indianapolis. A Topeka (Kansas) dispatch announces the arrival there of old man Bender and his wife, the Cherry Vale butchers. Fbitz Dinkle, a German, killed his wife, an Italian fortune-teller, at Davenport, Iowa, a few days ago, by severing her Jugular vein with a butcher-knife. Kate Bender, one of the Kansas butchers, is said to be in British Columbia.

See the clipping

Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis.

The item claims Kate Bender was identified in Salem, Oregon, then traced to Tacoma, Washington Territory, before escaping into British Columbia where she might be reached via extradition treaty. It also notes uncertainty about whether a man captured in Utah and returned to Kansas is actually old man Bender.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 38 days later.

Wrong

Watertown Republican · 6 May 1874 · page 4

Butchering Benders —lt is as certained that Kate Bender, the Kan sas murderess, was in Salem, Oregon, last March. Sue went to Puget Sound and was recognized at Tacoma, Wash ington Territory. She made her es cape into British Columbia, where she now is, but may reached under the ex tradition treaty. It does not seem al together certain, though probable, that the man caught in Utah and brought back to K nsas is the old man Bender.

See the clipping

Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn.

The item claims Kate Bender, the Kansas murderess, was traced to Salem, Oregon in March, then to Puget Sound, Washington Territory, and finally escaped into British Columbia where she was said to currently be. This represents one of the many speculative sighting reports generated during the extended manhunt for the Bender family.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 37 days later.

Wrong

Mower County Transcript · 7 May 1874 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Democratic Press · Ravenna, Ohio

A girl believed to be Kate Bender and a man believed to be John Bender have been arrested near Salt Lake City. They are being held pending identification.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 37 days later.

Wrong

The Democratic Press · 7 May 1874 · page 2

Leaving out specie, the imports at New York have fallen off $44,500,000, and the exports have risen over $34, 000,000 daring the nine months ending April 1, of the present year. That is not a discouraging showing. Since the beginning of ocean navi gation by steam, thirty-three years ago, fiftyone steamers have found the bottom of the ocean. The first one lost was the President, and the last one L'Amerique. A gibx, supposed to be Kate Bender, and a man, supposed to be John Ben der, have been arrested near Salt Lake City, and will be held for identifica

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

An elderly man arrested near Salt Lake City is believed by some, including Governor Osborne, to be old Bender, though he claims to understand only German and may be feigning madness. A woman matching Kate Bender's description was also captured after fierce resistance, with a photograph in her possession allegedly depicting the elder Mrs. Bender.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 8 May 1874 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

A young woman arrested in Morgan County, Utah on suspicion of being Kate Bender was found to be of Swedish descent and told a consistent account of her recent life. The Salt Lake Herald doubted she was Bender, suggesting instead she was a mentally disturbed woman wandering without purpose.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 8 May 1874 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

The young woman arrested in Morgan county, Utah, a few days ago, on suspicion of being Kate Bender, is of Sweedish blood. She tells a very connected story of her life for the last few years, and seems to be a modest timid lady. The Salt Lake Herald says: "It is scarcely probable that she is Katie Bender, but is a semi-demented young woman who is roaming across the country without definite object."

See the clipping