As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

June 1873

18 articles

In the story →

Memphis Daily Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.

A young man believed to be a son of the Kansas Bender murderer was arrested at West Liberty, Iowa, and a woman thought to be Mrs. Bender was arrested at Oxford. The report states there is little doubt as to their identity and that both are held for further investigation.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Memphis Daily Appeal · 1 June 1873 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Arrest of Two of the Benders. DUBURUE, IOWA, May 31.—A young man, supposed to be a young Bender, son of the well-known Kansas murderer, was arrested at West Liberty, Iowa, to-day, and a woman, thought to be Mrs. Bender, was arrested at Oxford. There seems to be little doubt as to their identity. Both parties are being held for further developements.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Authorities in Iowa arrested a man and woman believed to be young Bender and his mother, while a suspected Bender accomplice named Nicholas Mouin shot himself before he could confess fully. Officials claimed the real Benders were fleeing toward Mexico via Texas.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 2 June 1873 · page 8

ARREST OF TWO OF THE BENDER FAMILY, DusuQue, May 3lL.—A man, supposed to be young Bender, a son of the well-known Kausas murderer, was arrested in West Liberty, lowa, to-day, and a worsan, thonght to he Mra, Bender, was arrested at Oxford, Iowa. There seems to be little donot as to their went y. Both are Leld tor further developments,

See the clipping

The Van Buren Press · Van Buren, Ark.

A man matching the description of Bender family patriarch John Bender was arrested in Ely, Iowa, and jailed, giving contradictory statements about his identity. He claimed his name was John Bender from Independence, Kansas, and bitterly denounced Kate Bender as his daughter, while several people who knew the family believed the identification was correct.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Van Buren Press · 3 June 1873 · page 3

Dubuque, May 26. A man answering the description of Mr. Bender, senior, a member of the no torious Bender family, was arrested Sunday night at Ely, lowa,a small village ten miles from Cedar Rapids, lowa, to which he was taken and confined in jail. In conversation lie i i very eontradlcto

See the clipping

Little Rock Daily Republican · Little Rock, Ark.

This article reprints the Kansas governor's proclamation describing the Bender family as the perpetrators of recent atrocious murders in Labette County and offering a $500 reward for their capture. It includes a physical description of John Bender, noting his age, height, and German origin.

Little Rock Daily Republican · 3 June 1873 · page 4

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Little Rock Daily Republican · Little Rock, Ark.

The Kansas governor Thomas A. Osborn issues a proclamation describing the Bender family members in detail, offering a $500 reward for the capture of each fugitive. The description covers John Bender, Mrs. Bender, John Bender Jr. (alias John Gebhardt), and Kate Bender, detailing their ages, appearances, and speech patterns.

Little Rock Daily Republican · 3 June 1873 · page 4

THE BLOODY BENDERS.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Little Rock Daily Republican · Little Rock, Ark.

This report describes how the Bender family allegedly murdered travelers at their Kansas cabin: a guest was seated against a hanging sheet, struck from behind with a hammer when his head pressed the fabric, then dropped through a trapdoor into the cellar where the wife waited with a knife. It frames this gruesome system as unusually 'merciful' among methods of murder.

Little Rock Daily Republican · 4 June 1873 · page 3

Eumanizing Murder. I Th* Bender family, of Kansas, has discovered, perhaps, the most merciful system of murder, and if we must hirve: murderv. let ua by all means baveasys- ‘ tem which we have not yet seen no tioed. It is this: The cabin was ar-i

See the clipping

Delaware Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The report describes the Benders' alleged trap-door and hammer murder system used against lone travelers, with the wife finishing victims with a knife. It also claims an accomplice named Nichols was arrested in Texas and committed suicide, and that two Bender family members were arrested in Iowa.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Delaware Republican · 5 June 1873 · page 2

THE BENDER MURDERS

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The State Rights Democrat · Albany, Oregon

A newspaper correspondent describes visiting the Bender property near Independence, Kansas, where Dr. York's body was discovered, detailing the house's trap door, bullet holes, and outbuildings. The small orchard on the property is revealed to be the burial site of eight murder victims.

The State Rights Democrat · 6 June 1873 · page 1

For a year or more past, bodies have been found in' the creeks and on the prairies -within a radius of twenty miles of thi place. The Bender family have been residing on the claim about three years and it is not improbable, " from the wholesale slaughter recently discovered that they, or as a party by an extensive gang of marauders .bad something to do with these mysterious murders. The claim is an old section of rail road land. Some one with an eye to business : under the most trying circumstances stuck op a board near the well on which is written; "This claim taken May Ctb, 1873, R.

See moreSee less

Eider." Fiction founded upon the annals of crime baa failed to furnish mys tery so astounding as this revelation of horrible facts. It is with this feeling that a visitor wrote on the door of the murderer's den, "John Bender, special agent for Hell." " As this house was a seeminjr plaee of entertainment for , . wayfarers,! it forces to the mind that startling old Russian romance. "The Traveler's Last Inn." - - We are unable to see the financial speculation in ' this octave of mur ders. ' ' borne or the killed were known to be almost penniless, though three of the number possibly bad larxre sums of money. Doubtless York ,-(was"- murdered because of the interest be was tak ing in endeavoring to trace ups the missing Loogcor aud child. " He had identified the wagon found at Longcor 8 and in case the murder was re vealed would become an important witness. ' ' - - . .. ... The Bender family left about the sixth of April, left their team and dog on the streets at Thayer, and bought tickets for Hamboldt. -The horses attracted attention when driv en by hunger they bad nearly ..de voured the wasron bed lhe dog at tempted to jump on every passin train coins north. ' Benders left the

See the clipping

The State Rights Democrat · Albany, Oregon

A neighbor noticed the Bender homestead abandoned with livestock untended, leading township officials and Dr. York's brother to investigate the premises. They found a trap door leading to a blood-soaked pit, and upon probing the garden, discovered York's body buried head-down with his throat cut.

The State Rights Democrat · 6 June 1873 · page 1

Bender (or Benter, as written in pencil over the house). The family consists of John Bender, CO years of age, his daughter a young woman, Mrs. Bender and her son, a youug man. At times the young people claimed to . be man and wife, but publicly and when on a' tour a a Hpirtual lecturer, she passed oil as

See the clipping

The State Rights Democrat · Albany, Oregon

The report describes identification of several Bender murder victims—including a child, McKinzie, Brown, Boyle, Boley, and Scouce—through personal effects like clothing, rings, and physical features. It also details the ongoing inquest, mass arrests, and the near-lynching of neighbor Thomas Tyack during the investigation.

The State Rights Democrat · 6 June 1873 · page 1

NO.' 43 j ersonn at Independence.. Thui was same time during the winter, , r, Wm., Boyle of Independence left that place on the 25th of October, for Osage Mission. He 'was recog

See the clipping

The Donaldsonville Chief · Donaldsonville, La.

The report describes the unearthing of nine murdered bodies on the former Bender family farm in Labette County, Kansas, including Dr. William York. It recounts the family's background, their flight weeks earlier, and Kate Bender's advertised work as a 'spiritual physician.'

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The Donaldsonville Chief · 7 June 1873 · page 1

The Kansas Horror.

had started out afew days previously. 1)r. York expressedl great iiterest in the discovery, and when lie started out on Li. rettun hoime, declared his intWetiont of hunting up thgl details of the su pposed 'crime. About March 10 he left Fort Scott, mounted on a val uable horse, but never reached his home ; his family becoming alarmled at his absence his brother, the Senator, proceeded to Fort Scott to inquire after him. Learning thie facts of the case, lie returned over the road, ac compainei by another brother who lived in that city and sonime other per sons and they traced the missing man to Osage Mission and thence to Drum Creek, and here all trace of him was lost.

See moreSee less

It was at once supl)osed that the doctor hIad been waylaid and mnur dered, the recent disappearance of other persons in the same locality giv ing color to the suspicion. OHlicers were set to work to ferret out the murderers, and Governor (Osborne offered a reward of '50() for the alp prehensioa of every person concerned in the crime. This stimulated inquiry, and on the 6thi inst. the body of the murdered man was discovered by his brother JEdward in a plowed tield

See the clipping

The Donaldsonville Chief · Donaldsonville, La.

The report recounts how Dr. York's disappearance while investigating a suspicious abandoned wagon led his brothers to search for him, culminating in the discovery of his battered body buried near the Bender house. This find prompted further search of the property, uncovering eight more murdered victims buried beneath the building, all killed by hammer blows and cut throats.

The Donaldsonville Chief · 7 June 1873 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Donaldsonville Chief · Donaldsonville, La.

Searchers at the Bender property uncover eight additional bodies beneath the house, all killed by hammer blows and throat-cutting, with several victims identified by relatives. A mob seizes a man named Brockman, repeatedly hanging and reviving him to force a confession, while a detective from Kansas pursues the fleeing Bender family.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Donaldsonville Chief · 7 June 1873 · page 1

The latest horror has just been un earthed in Labette County, Kansas, where nine murdered bodies have already been discovered, and a search is being prosecuted for more. Amuong the victims found is Dr. William York, brother of State Senator York (who gained such extended notriety during the late Senatorial election). The scene of these wholesale murders lies one and a half niles southeast of More head Station, on the road leading from Osage Mission to Independence. The bodies were found under a frame house recently occupied by a German family named Bender, who left the place some two or three weeks since.

See moreSee less

This fiunly consisted of four adults, Bender and his wife, and a son and daughter. They had settled upon a railroad claim ten years ago, and although they were not regarded tavorably by their neigh

See the clipping

Sunbury American · Sunbury, Pa.

The report details the alleged method the Bender family used to murder travelers—trapping them behind a sheet, striking them with a hammer, and dropping them through a trap door to be finished off with a knife. It also reports the suicide of a supposed accomplice, Nicholas Mindon, in Texas, and the arrest of two Bender family members in Iowa.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

Sunbury American · 7 June 1873 · page 2

HOW THE BENDER MURDERS WERE COMMITTED

It is this : Their cabin was arranged as a place bf entertainment for travelers. , A sheet hung Across it, dividing it into two compartments. When a single traveler arrived, he was seated at a table so that the outline of his lorm was defined upou the sheet, and in case he leaned back, his head pressed against Uils clastic as well as transparent bulkhead. Under his chair unknown to Him, was a trap-door. Tho mail fiend, stationed on the outer side of the sheet, watched for tho pressure of the victim's head against it,and striking a stun nine blow with a hammer on the back of tho skull, slipped the spring of tho trap-door, thus dumping the body into tho cellar, whore his wife, knife in hand, stood ready to end tho work..

See moreSee less

Nicholas Mindou, a supposed accomplice of tho Bender lUmily, was arrested in Texas," but oonwutted Bui cide before rcachiug the Stale where the atrocities, in which he no doubt bora a part, were committed. He promised to make a confession, but ho was allowed to have a pistol in his possession, strango enough, with which . ho shot himself. There seems to be no doubt but that tho Benders were in Texas where Miudou was

See the clipping

The Elk County Advocate · Ridgway, Pa.

This brief item recounts how the Bender family of Kansas allegedly killed travelers by seating them against a hanging sheet, clubbing them through it when their heads pressed the fabric, then dropping them through a trapdoor to a cellar where the wife finished them with a knife. The tone is darkly sardonic, framing it as a 'merciful system of murder.'

The Elk County Advocate · 12 June 1873 · page 1

Kansas Murdering. The Bender family, of Kansas, have discovered perhaps the most merciful system of murder, and, if we must have murders, let us by all means have a

See the clipping

The Weekly Caucasian · Lexington, Mo.

A short local item claims a person using the alias 'Kate Bender' was spotted near Tallerville, with a township constable reportedly in close pursuit. No outcome of the chase is given.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 7 days earlier.

The Weekly Caucasian · 14 June 1873 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Weekly Kansas Chief · Troy, Kan.

An Indiana newspaper reports that the Bender family, before fleeing to Kansas, may have been responsible for the unsolved 1871 murder of a German couple named Brandle near New Albany. It claims the men worked on the same farm where the killing occurred and left for Kansas soon after, suggesting their guilt.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Weekly Kansas Chief · 19 June 1873 · page 2

A BLOODY TRAIL.

1. Tim identity of I he names. S. The description of the Kansas murderers answers exactly to the Benders who lived here. 3 Their mnniier of living in Kansas-the two men aud the two woman living as one family, U exactlv as they lived here. 4. The Benders left this city for Kansas, the place where we find them now. 5. The time of their departure from this point corresponds with their arrival in Kansas. 6. The residence oftlie Benders on the farm on which Handle and his wife were murdered, nud their immediate departure from the scene.

See moreSee less

The Benders tied from Kansas when they dis covered the suspicion of the people there; bnt, we predict Hut, before they nil swing from the sratlold, somo one of them will confess their com plicity with tho Baudle tragedy near this city.

See the clipping

The Weekly Kansas Chief · Troy, Kan.

The report describes how the Benders used a curtained table and hidden accomplice to bludgeon and slit the throats of boarders, then buried them in the garden, including one man buried alive with his infant child. It also lists six points of circumstantial evidence linking the Kansas Benders to the earlier murder of Boadle and his wife in another city.

The Weekly Kansas Chief · 19 June 1873 · page 2

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page