As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

May 1876

4 articles

Der Westbote · Columbus, Ohio

The sheriff of Laramie City, Wyoming Territory, has arrested two women he believes are Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender of the Kansas murder family, based on a telegraphed description from Sheriff Parsons of Kansas that closely matches them. The women are being held for further investigation.

Der Westbote · 4 May 1876 · page 4

Die Bender'sche Mordfamilie.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Superior Times · Superior, Wis.

The report states that two women arrested in Laramie City, Wyoming, matched the telegraphed description of Kate Bender and her mother, wanted for the Kansas murders. Authorities believed they had captured the infamous fugitives based on this matching description.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Superior Times · 5 May 1876 · page 2

CRIMES AND CASUALTIES.

The sheriff of Laramie City has arrested and confined in jail, two women supposed to be the old woman Kate Bender, of Kansas murder-fame, as a description of Kate and Mrs. Bender was sent by telegraph from the

See the clipping

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

Two women arrested in Laramie City on suspicion of being Kate Bender and her mother were found to be unrelated Missouri women traveling to California. The item briefly notes the false alarm amid the ongoing search for the fugitive Benders.

CorrectionThis set right 12 earlier articles: Chicago Daily Tribune, 25 April 1876, The Portland Daily Press, 25 April 1876, Omaha Daily Bee, 25 April 1876, The Cincinnati Daily Star, 25 April 1876, Daily Press and Dakotaian, 25 April 1876, Public Ledger, 25 April 1876, The Cheyenne Daily Leader, 25 April 1876, Memphis Daily Appeal, 27 April 1876, The Cambria Freeman, 28 April 1876, Northern Ohio Journal, 29 April 1876, The Weekly Elko Independent, 30 April 1876, The Superior Times, 5 May 1876.

The Iola Register · 6 May 1876 · page 2

The two women recently arrested at JLaramie City on the supposition that tbey were Kate Bender and her mother, 'turn out to be a couple of women from Missouri on their way to .California to reside. 1 n - MA8SACH u sk it's delegation to tbe Cincinnati convention are said to be equally divided -between Blaine and Bristow, but the California delegation selected tho same day js unanimous for Hume. - The Chinese Government in order, to check official corruption, has ordered that in the future bribery will bo pun ished by decapitation. Wouldn't such an order as that create consternation in .this country ?

See the clipping

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A short item reports that two women, believed to be the elder Bender woman and Katie Bender of the notorious Kansas murders, have been arrested at Laramie. The claim is presented as supposition rather than confirmed fact.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 10 May 1876 · page 1

Two women, supposed to be the old woman and Katie Bender, of Kansas murder fame, have been arrested at LarĀ­ amie. The Pope had $3,190,000 left to him

See the clipping