As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

November 1876

3 articles

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

The report presents an unconfirmed theory from a Topeka gentleman suggesting the entire Bender family was secretly lynched by vigilantes after their crimes were discovered, with their bodies disposed of so as to never be found. It recaps the known background of the Bender murders before introducing this new speculative explanation for their disappearance.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Chicago Daily Tribune · 28 November 1876 · page 5

REMARKABLE NOVEL

Tried Until February. nUMARXAIII.V NOVEI,. Special Dltpateh to The TWftuw. Lawubncb, Kan., Nov. 37.—One of the black est of alt black crimes ever spread upon tho rec ords of man’s worse than Inhumanity to man is known to the reading public of this country, and perhaps other countries, ns the bender tragedy of Kansas. - Renders of Tns Tridu.se will remember at least so many of the terrible details of tho affair as aro essential to an easy understanding of the story presented below. They will remember that tiic Bender family was resident In Montgomery County, Kan.; that tho family consisted of “Old Man ” Bernier, his wife, h!s daughter Kate, and his eon, a young man who is to some considerable extent ac quitted In the public mind of much that is charged without distinction to his -father, mother, and sister; that the crime of tho crowd consisted of murdering, from mercenary mo tives, aud-Unrying upon their wayside premises, MOT FEWER THAN MINE PERSONS,

See the clipping

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

A Topeka man recounts a conversation with a stranger on a steamer who claimed intimate knowledge of the Bender case, suggesting a vigilance committee near Cherryvale had tracked the family down before their official disappearance became known. The account is explicitly presented as an unverified rumor that 'must not be accepted as conclusive.'

Chicago Daily Tribune · 28 November 1876 · page 5

mains yet to be removed. THE STORY Is this: A gentleman residing In Topeka .has traveled much In the far Western States, and was, about one year ago. a passenger on hoard the steamer plying between San Francisco and Portland. Concerning this voyage, in a letter to the Topeka Couunomeealth , he says: I met n man on (bo steamer, apparently about 50 years of ago, of One appearance, gentlemanly de portment. and Intelligent address. Upon enterin'; into a conversation with him, (in Informed mo that he was from Montgomery Comity, Kan., where be had lived for several years, and was now on his way with his family to Washington Territory, which ho expected to make his permanent home.

See moreSee less

During the conversation, knowing that ho was from Ibo vicini ty of the Bender murders, I expressed' my aston ishment that these people, Ignorant of ami unfa miliar with the geography of tills country ns they must have bean, had been so successful In making their escape from the officer* of the law, especially as n large reward bad been offered for their appre hension. IK A HALF CONFIDENTIAL TONE,

See the clipping

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

An informant argues that Senator York's confident identification of his brother's spectacles and immediate location of the grave prove he had been secretly informed beforehand. The theory further speculates that Kansas Governor Osborn was also informed, explaining the lack of official effort to capture the Benders.

Chicago Daily Tribune · 28 November 1876 · page 5

KNEW EXACTLY WHERE TO LOOK

hension. IK A HALF CONFIDENTIAL TONE, and la a manner which lent credence to bis state ment and Impressed me with a belief of his hon esty, ho said that so far as ho wan concerned there was no mystcryabout It. *‘ 1 am well acquainted." said he, “with the whole history of the matter. I know cx-Scnator A. At. York very well, ana also knew his brother, Dr. York, whose murder led to the developments which have been made In con nection with the Bender family. Some lime before the murder of Dr.

See moreSee less

York, a vigilance committee was organized In the neighborhood of C'licrryvnle for the protection of the people against horse thieves. Prior to this no well-donned suspicion had rested upon the Bender family. The sudden and unaccountablo disappearance of Dr. York, however, who was well known and highly respected throughout that country, cansuri a great commo tion among the people. Search wan Instituted, led principally by this vigilance committee and Sen ator York. Upon conferring together several other Instances in which persons had mysteriously dis appeared, and had never been beard of, came to light. A comparison of notes In these coses pointed In ono direction, nud fixed suspicion upon the Benders. IT 18 SIT OPINION

See the clipping