As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

December 1876

3 articles

The Milan Exchange · Milan, Tenn. · and 1 other paper

A source recounts how suspicion fell on the Benders after Dr. York's disappearance and a vigilance committee's investigation, including Senator York's dramatic discovery of his brother's spectacles and grave at the Bender homestead. He theorizes that before the family vanished, vigilantes seized them, extracted a confession, and killed them, hiding the bodies forever.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 119 days later.

Wrong

The Milan Exchange · 7 December 1876 · page 2

Senator York walked directly to a spot where the earth was slightly shaken, and said : 4 Here is a grave ; here my brother is buried.1 This proved to be trie. The unhesitating cond uct of Sen ator York.in placing his hand upon his brother's spectacles and going to the exact spot where his brother's remains had been buried, proves conclusively that he had been informed beforehand, and knew exactly where to look to make the discoveries that he did. This con viction i3 also strengthened by a great many other incidents that took place about this time.

See moreSee less

I am satisfied also that Governor Osborn was secretly apprised of all these facts, which will account for the fact that, on the part of the Kansas authorities, no systematic effort has ever been made to apprehend the Benders, and stories of their capture elsewhere has only excited an incredulous smile at the State Cap itol. Whether I am right or wrong," concluded my informant, "you must admit that my theory is a plausible one," and with a significant smile he said, " I know that I am right." We, of Kansas, will be glad to accept the above theory as reliable, if for no other reason than that it so happily tones down the feeling of chagrin over the idea that Gabriel will get the start of us in bringing the Benders to judg

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • American Citizen · Canton, Miss. · 9 December 1876

The Milan Exchange · Milan, Tenn. · and 1 other paper

An unnamed informant speculates that Senator York had prior knowledge of the location of his brother's remains and spectacles, suggesting a cover-up involving Kansas authorities and Governor Osborn. The newspaper presents this as unproven gossip while noting it would explain the lack of a serious hunt for the Benders.

The Milan Exchange · 7 December 1876 · page 2

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Also printed in 1 paper
  • American Citizen · Canton, Miss. · 9 December 1876

American Citizen · Canton, Miss. · and 1 other paper

A traveler claims to know the inside story that a Montgomery County vigilance committee, formed against horse-thieves, grew suspicious of the Benders after Dr. York's disappearance and other mysterious cases. He suggests the committee secretly dealt with the Benders themselves before authorities could.

American Citizen · 9 December 1876 · page 1

A Belief That the Members of That Tribe of Murderers were Xsjrnehed . - Special Cor. Topeka Commonwealth.) , , I met a man on the steamer, appar ently about fifty years of age. of fine appearance, gentlemanly deportment and intelligent address. Upon enter ing into a conversation with him he in formed me that he was from Montgom ery County, Kansas, where he had lived for several years, and was now on his way with his family . to Washington Territory, which he expected to make his permanent home. During the con versation, knowing that he was from the vicinity of the Bender murders, I expressed my astonishment that these people, ignorant of and unfamiliar with the geography of this country, as they must have been, had been so successful in making their escape from the officers of the law, especially as a large' reT ward had been offered for their appre hension.

See moreSee less

In a half -confidential tone, and in a manner which lent credence to his statement, and impressed me with a belief of his honesty, he said that, so far as he was concerned, there was no mystery about it. . "I am.; well acquainted," said he, "with. the. whple history of the matter. I know ex-Senator A. M. York very well, and also knew his brother. Dr. York, whose murder led to the developments which have been made in connection with the Bender family; Some time before the murder of Dr. York, a vigilance com mittee was organized in the neighbor hood of -Cherry vale for the protection of the people against horse-thieves. Prior to this no weirdefined suspicion had rested upon the Bender family. The sudden and; unaccountable disap pearance of Dr. York, however, who was well known aud highly respected throughout that country, caused a great commotion among the people. Search was instituted, led principally by this vigilance committee and Senator York. Upon conferring together several other instances in which persons had mys teriously disappeared,- and had never been heard of, came to light. A com parison of notes in these cases pointed in one direction, and fixed suspicion upon the Benders., k . , . f " It is my opinion that a detachment of this vigilance committee, a few nights before the discovery was. made that the Benders had disappeared. went to their house, placed them in their own ; wagon, . drawn &y tneir ..own horses; and conveyed them to a seclud ed spot, not far off, on the edge of a large pond, and there extorted a fall confession from them of all their crimes down to the smallest details. After this the Benders were never heard of, and it is more than probable that their bo dies were so carefully concealed that they will never be discovered until Gabriel does it. ' It will be remembered, if I am right in my theory, that a few days after this a wagon was discovered near this point, in which a pair of horses was tied, which was known to be Bender's property. This was soon followed by the announcement that the home of the Benders bad been dissolved, and some

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Milan Exchange · Milan, Tenn. · 7 December 1876