The Milan Exchange · Milan, Tenn. · and 1 other paper
A source recounts how suspicion fell on the Benders after Dr. York's disappearance and a vigilance committee's investigation, including Senator York's dramatic discovery of his brother's spectacles and grave at the Bender homestead. He theorizes that before the family vanished, vigilantes seized them, extracted a confession, and killed them, hiding the bodies forever.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 119 days later.
The Milan Exchange · 7 December 1876 · page 2
Senator York walked directly to a spot where the earth was slightly shaken, and said : 4 Here is a grave ; here my brother is buried.1 This proved to be trie. The unhesitating cond uct of Sen ator York.in placing his hand upon his brother's spectacles and going to the exact spot where his brother's remains had been buried, proves conclusively that he had been informed beforehand, and knew exactly where to look to make the discoveries that he did. This con viction i3 also strengthened by a great many other incidents that took place about this time.
See moreSee less
I am satisfied also that Governor Osborn was secretly apprised of all these facts, which will account for the fact that, on the part of the Kansas authorities, no systematic effort has ever been made to apprehend the Benders, and stories of their capture elsewhere has only excited an incredulous smile at the State Cap itol. Whether I am right or wrong," concluded my informant, "you must admit that my theory is a plausible one," and with a significant smile he said, " I know that I am right." We, of Kansas, will be glad to accept the above theory as reliable, if for no other reason than that it so happily tones down the feeling of chagrin over the idea that Gabriel will get the start of us in bringing the Benders to judg
Also printed in 1 paper
- American Citizen · Canton, Miss. · 9 December 1876