A dispatch from Alma, Crawford County, Arkansas reports that George Keifer and his family, believed to be the original Bender family wanted for murders in Kansas, were arrested by Kansas detectives who had been posing as farm laborers to watch them. The detectives express confidence they have captured the right parties.
ARKANSAS. CHE BENDER FAMILY ARRESTED. Little Rock , April 4. A special i the Gazette from Alma , Crawford tuntyj jrives the latest in regard to ie Bender family. George Keifer id family , supposed to be the origal family of Benders , of murderis fame in Kansas , were arrested are to-day by Kaunas detectives bo have been shadowing tin eifer family , and are confiden tat they have captured the rig > > irties Detectives have been fo me time past working as farm borers in this county , quietly atoning the movements of their larry , upon whom they sprang the ip to-day.
The report claims that the mystery of the Bender family, who vanished from Kansas in 1872 after multiple murders, has been solved with the arrest of four people believed to be the Benders in Crawford County, Arkansas. They are said to be extradited to Kansas to face trial for the killings.
The mystery attending the Bender family, who disappeared from Kansas in 1872, after the murder of several persons and tbo burial of the bodies on their form, seems to have Leon solved by tbo arrest iu Arkansas of a family of four persona who are believed to bo tbo Identical Benders. For yean they bad succeeded in defying tbo efforts of tbo
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A news digest headline announces the arrest of the notorious Bender family and their return to Kansas, the scene of their murders. No further narrative details are given in this fragment beyond the headline line itself.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 6 April 1877 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Kansas detectives escorted a family believed to be the notorious Benders, using the alias Keofer, through Fort Smith en route to Kansas after their arrest in Crawford County, Arkansas. The family was tracked by private detective Beard, who had earlier discovered the murdered bodies at the Bender farm in Kansas in 1872, and local circumstantial evidence strongly suggested their identity despite their denials.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 6 April 1877 · page 1
THE MURDEROUS BENDERS
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Kansas detectives escorted a family believed to be the Benders, traveling under the alias Keofer, through Fort Smith after their arrest in Crawford County, Arkansas on a Kansas governor's requisition. The detective who arrested them, Beard, had earlier discovered the murder victims' bodies on the Bender property in 1872 and tracked the family for years before identifying them.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Wheeling Daily Register · 6 April 1877 · page 1
After satisfying himself as to the idantitv of the family, the detective went to Kansas. The governor offered a reward of 92^00, and a requisition was obtained for Goo. Keofer, aluu John Bender; Less Keofer, aluu Kate Bender; Mrs. Keoter, aluu Mrs. Bender, Phillip Keofer, aliat John Bender, jr. The arrests were mads terv quietly by the sheriff, the only resistance being by Kate, wbo drew a shovel on the detective and attempted to get a put*... but was prevented from doing anything. Tke u. k/in l4hJt? iksaf 1 KhV MM* (Km I t WMVIV ym* 9J vaaarv *?
See moreSee less
j v. v ' | Benders. Ail tbe circumstances ere so strong thai every one in the locality ! wbere the arresU were made believe they iri tbe Ber.dcrs Keofer made a jjood
The report claims a detective named Beard, who discovered the victims' bodies in 1872, successfully tracked down and arrested the entire Bender family near Crawford. It states the family denied their identity but that evidence against them was overwhelming.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 6 April 1877 · page 2
Binder Jam®’, thr6ugh Pl> b*re yesterday. The family beat the natne senior and junior, Kate Bender and Mrs. Bender. A detective named Beard, who, in 1872, discovered the bodies of their victims, has long teen ■working up the case, and effected their arreat without, extraordinary trouble. The whole patty deny their .Identity, but tbu evidence is overwhelming. They were good citizens but rested under suspicion from the fact that they
A dispatch from Crawford county reports that detectives have arrested George Keafer and his family, believed to be the notorious Bender family wanted for murder. The suspects had reportedly been working undisclosed as farm laborers while being secretly watched before the arrest.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
Dodge City Times · 7 April 1877 · page 5
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A private detective named Beard, acting on a Kansas governor's requisition, is reported to have tracked the Bender family from Kansas through Missouri to Arkansas and arrested them there with Kate Bender briefly resisting with a shovel. The report names the family under aliases (Keafer) and credits Beard with having originally discovered the murder victims' bodies on the Bender property in 1872.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 7 April 1877 · page 2
THE BENDER BUTCHERS. Their Pursuit and Capture. Little Rock, Ark., April o.—The Benders were arrested by a Mr. Beard, of Kansas, a private detective, on a requisition from the governor of Kan sas. Beard is the man who discovered the bodies of the murdered Y'ork and others on Bender’s place, in Kansas, in 1872. He followed the family down the Atlantic & Pacific road to Pierce City, Missouri, thence to Fayetteville, in this state. The family separated at Fayetteville, but re-united at the house of a son of old man Bender, on Cedar creek, where they engaged in agricul tural pursuits.
See moreSee less
After satisfying him self as to the identity of the family, Ji.-aid proceeded to Kansas, and tue governor offered a reward of $2,500 and a requisition for George Keafer alias John Bender, Lena Keafer alias Kate Bender, Mrs. Keafer alias Mrs.
Kansas detectives, led by a private detective named Beard, arrested a family going by the name Keeler/Kealer in Crawford County, Arkansas, believing them to be the notorious Bender family wanted for the Kansas murders. The family denied being the Benders, though circumstantial evidence and local belief suggested otherwise, and Kate reportedly resisted arrest with a shovel.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Dallas Daily Herald · 10 April 1877 · page 3
THE ORIGINAL BENDERS
T11K OUICilXAL 1U:XI)KHS, The 14 annul nurilorcm Oiptnrotl lu ArknnmiH. Litti.k KtK'K, April 5. The Kniisas detectives pnssetl through Port Smith yesterday, en route for Kansas, with tho supp'osed Bender family arrested in Crawford county Tuesday. The family went under the name of Keulor. They were arrested by a Mr. Beard of Kansas, a private detective, upon a requisition from the governor of Kansas upon the governor of Arkansas. Beard is tho man who discovered the bodies of the murdered York and others on Bender's ilaee in Kansas in 172, He followed the family down tho Atlantic and Pa cific road to Pierce City, Missouri, thence to Kayetteville, but reunited at the houso of a son of obi man Bender on Cedar Creek, where they engaged in agricultural nursuits.
See moreSee less
After satisfying himself as to the identity of the family, the deteo live, Heard, proceeuen to ivansns. me KOTcrnor ntl'ereil a reward of $-J' and a requisition was issued for lieorge Keafer alias John Bender, Lena Kealer alias Kate Bender, Mrs. Kealer alias r.emler, and rhilinalia John Bender, Jr. The arrests were made uuittly by the sheriff, the only resistance leing made by Kate, who drew a shovel on the detective ami attempted to net a pistol, but was prevented from doing anything. The whole party deny they are the Benders. All the circumstances are so strong that every one in the lo cality where the arrests were made behere they are the real Bentler family. Keafer made a good citiien, but rested tinder suspicion ever since his residence In Cii furl. They canu into ibecouuly oil IimI, nil. 1 ill a lil'le, bill ill" ol I Until ml III I I. II, III In . ' l'l iilj I ll llli, .III' I It!- 1 1 1c11l1ur.il 1 in i Ii'iiii'iiin, nlw ,iy 1 1 .1 v in;; I'lelll y ul' lii "In y In I it lu. ii.iv. .vilu'.i liny lill K ill., i'. I 11I1' I, in- !,, une llle luolhei' i,l Inn 1 hil'llell.
Kansas detectives, led by private detective Beard who first discovered the Bender murder victims in 1872, tracked a family calling themselves Keafer through Missouri and Arkansas before arresting them on suspicion of being the notorious Bender family. The family denied being the Benders, though locals and investigators believed strong circumstantial evidence pointed to their true identity.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Watertown Republican · 11 April 1877 · page 1
The Kansas detectives passed through Fort Smith, Ark., Wednesday, en route for Kansas, with the supposed Bender family, arrested in Crawford county, last week. The family went under the name of Keafer. They were arrested by Mr. Beard of Kansas, a private detective, upon a requisition from the Governor oi Kansas. Beard is the man who'discovered the bodies of the murdered York and others on Bender’s place, in Kansas, in 1872. He followed the family down the At lantic and Pacific road to Pierce City,
Kansas detectives, aided by a private detective named Beard who had found the Bender murder victims in 1872, arrested a family going by the name Keafer in Crawford County, Arkansas, believing them to be the Bender family. Local residents strongly suspected the family's true identity despite their denials, and the suspects were being returned to Kansas under a governor's requisition.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Fair Play · 12 April 1877 · page 1
The Original Benders. The Kan sas Murderers Captured in Arkansas. Little Rock, April ; The' Kan sas detectives pitssed through Fort Smith yesterday, enroute for Kansas, with tho supposed Uonder family arrosted in Crawford county Tuesday. Tho family went under tho name of Keafer. They were arrested by a Mr. Beard of Kansas, a private de Uctive, upon a requisition from tbo governor of Kansas upon the governor of Arkansas. Heard is tho man who discovered the bodies of the murder ed York and others on Bender's place in Kansas in 1872.
See moreSee less
He lb I lowed the family down tho Atlantic and Pacific road to Fiorco City, Mo., thence to Faycttoville in this stato. Tho family separated at Fayette villo, but reunited at tho bouso of a son of old man Lender on Cedar creek, where thoy engaged in agri cultural pursuits. After satisfying himself as to tho idontity of the de tective, Beard, proceeded to Kansas. 'be governor offered a reward of f 2,- 500, and a requisition was issued for George Keafer alias John Uender,
A Cherokee man named Tom Williams was reportedly assassinated in Tahlequah, and Kansas detectives passed through Fort Smith with a family suspected to be the Benders, traveling under the name Keoffer. The family denied their identity, but authorities cited suspicious circumstances and claimed the evidence against them was overwhelming.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Helena Weekly Herald · 12 April 1877 · page 5
Gen. Hawley, Secretary. Assassination—The Bender Family. Fort Smith, (Ark.) April 5. —A Cherokee named Tom Williams was assassinated at his home in Tahlequash, Saturday night. Kansas detectives, with the Supposed Ben der family, passed through here yesterday. The family bore the name of Keoffer, and consists of John Bender, sr., John Bender, ;jr., Kate Bender and Mrs. Bender. A detec tive named Beard, who in 1872 discovered the bodies of their victims, has long been working up the case, and effected their ar rest without extraordinary trouble. The whole party deny their identity, but the evi dence is overwhelming. They were good citizens, but rested under suspicion from the fact that they came to Crawford one by one afoot, but always had plenty of money to buy farms, etc.
Kansas detectives are reported to have arrested parties believed to be John Bender Sr., John Bender Jr., Mrs. Bender, and Kate Bender. This brief item appears amid a roundup of unrelated national and international news.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 12 April 1877 · page 7
GENERAL NEWS.
Were killed inl the Cherokee nation last week. ý,Kansas detectives have arrested some parties supposed to be John Bender senior Sidjunior, Mrs. Bender and Kate Bender.
A special dispatch from Alma, Crawford County, Arkansas reports that George Keafor and his family were arrested by a detective from Kansas who believed them to be the murderous Bender family. The detective claimed to have been observing them for some time before the arrest.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Der Westbote · 12 April 1877 · page 2
Bei der Verhaftung einer verdächtigen Familie
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Der Westbote · Columbus, Ohio
The report claims a private detective traced the Bender family, living under the name Keofer, to Crawford County, Missouri, leading the Kansas governor to offer a $2,500 reward and issue a warrant for their arrest. It describes the sheriff's quiet arrest of the family, with Kate Bender resisting by grabbing a shovel and trying to seize a pistol, though the family denied being the Benders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Der Westbote · 12 April 1877 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes Deputy Sheriff Thomas Beers, a former acquaintance of the Benders, finally tracking the family to Arkansas with Governor Anthony's backing. A telegram confirms the arrest near Boston Mountain, Crawford County, of George, Mrs., Phillip, and Tena Keafer, alias the Bender family.
Kansas if they prove to . he the genuine original Benders. Gojrge Kaefcr claims to have Lien a member of tbe legislature of Wis consin in 1860, trom West "Bend, Washington county, and to have resided there until 1873. Wheth er they are the Benders is still an open question. Milwaukee, April 6th. The Sentinel has a special from West Bend showing that George Keafer, arrested in Crawford county, Ark., on suspicion of being a Bender, resided for many years in Wash ington county in this State, and was a member of the legislature in 1860.
See moreSee less
He removed to Arkansas 1873. The story published in the Commonwealth some time ago and repeated in last Sunday's Kansas City Journal, to the effect that the Benders had been caught and lynched a short time after their escape, is entirely too thin to go down, and is not believed by any one. It is not sustained by one particle of creditable proof. It seems to have been an after thought, gotten up by some would be hero or heroes, who loved a sort of mysterious fame more than the truth. Had the lynching taken place it could not, amidst all tbe excitement of tbe time, have been kept a secret. There was no pos sibility that any one engaged in the lynching would have been dis turbed even if found out, There was no object at all in keeping tbe matter a secret if the lynching had really taken place.
A woman and man arrested in Arkansas as suspected Bender family members resist detectives, while legal maneuvering over habeas corpus delays their transfer to Kansas. The report also debunks an earlier rumor that the Benders had been lynched, calling it unsubstantiated, while leaving open whether the arrested pair are truly the Benders.
The Emporia News · 13 April 1877 · page 2
Not tbe Benders after all, as tbe following shows : Little Rock, Apr11. A dis patch from Fort Smith says the Keafer family, arretted on tbe charge of being the Kansas Bend ers, after an examination before United States Judge Parker, were released. Tbe parties from Kansas failed to identify them. On Sunday, berglars robbed the Sixth national bank of New York, of $200 in silver, or all that five men conld carry away at one load. This might be called s heavy robbery.
A dispatch reports that the Keafer family arrested in Arkansas on suspicion of being the Benders was released after Kansas witnesses failed to identify them at a habeas corpus hearing before Judge Parker. The report clarifies earlier confusion, confirming the family came from Wisconsin in 1873 and was not connected to the Benders.
Judge B. W. Pernios, of Oswego. He states that the Benders, or tbe Keafers, as the case might be, had not yet arrived in Labette county, but, on the contrary, parties from Kansas bad gone to Arkansas as witnesses before tbe habeas corpus case before U. S. Judge Park er. Judge Perkins also stated in bis dispatch that there 'was no danger of viol.nce to the ac cused parties in case they were brought back to Kansas. Gov. Anthony is in receipt of letters from Van Baren, Arkansas, which go to confirm the statement !
See moreSee less
made by telegraph that the fami v . arrested is named Keafer lot uuicu jkciicr , came to Arkansas from Wiscon-1 sin in 1873. It would seem that Gov. Miller, of Arkansas, at the time of his dispatch mentioned yeste. i?.r, had not been advised that the ax rested parties had been taken cck from Muscogee on a writ of habeas corpus. Commonwealth, 11th. Not tbe Benders after all, as tbe following shows : Little Rock, Apr11. A dis patch from Fort Smith says the Keafer family, arretted on tbe charge of being the Kansas Bend ers, after an examination before United States Judge Parker, were released. Tbe parties from Kansas failed to identify them. On Sunday, berglars robbed the Sixth national bank of New York, of $200 in silver, or all that five men conld carry away at one load. This might be called s heavy robbery.
The report states that Bender family members, the notorious Kansas murderers long sought, were reportedly captured and lynched by a vigilance committee while trying to flee the state. It adds that one of the lynching party supposedly made a confession.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 21 days later.
Wrong
The Aegis & Intelligencer · 13 April 1877 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
—It is stated that Bender, his wife, son and daughter, the notorious Kansas murderers, who have been searched for during the last several years, were captured and lynched by a vigilance committee, whi'e attempting to leave the State. One of the lynching party, it appears, has made the confession.
A dispatch from Fort Smith, Arkansas reports that detectives have arrested a family using the name Koeffer, believed to be the notorious Bender family, after years of investigation by a detective named Beard who discovered the victims' bodies in 1872. The family denies their identity, but authorities claim the evidence against them is overwhelming.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 21 days later.
Wrong
The New North-West · 13 April 1877 · page 2
The Bender Family Again Found
The Bender Pamily Again FouT SMITH, Ark., April 5.-The Chero kee. Tom Williams, was assassinated at his home in Tahlequah on Saturday night last. Citizens of this place pursued into the
Detectives passed through Fort Smith, Arkansas, escorting a family arrested under the name Keofer, suspected to be the Benders. Kansas's Governor had offered a $2,500 reward and issued a requisition for them; Kate Keofer/Bender reportedly resisted arrest with a shovel, and the whole family denied being the Benders.
The Workingman's Advocate · 21 April 1877 · page 1
Lmt-c K «i, April 5—The Kansas deI tcctives fowJ through Fort Smith, Ark., yesterday en route ?•»r Kansas with the supposed Bender family, arrested in Craw- , ford eouuty on Tuesday. The family went under the name of Keofer The Governor offered a reward of $2,500. and issued s requisition for George Keofer, alias John Bender ; Lena Keofer, alias Kate Bender ; Mrs. Keofer, alias Mrs. Bender, and Philip, alias John Bender. Jr. The arrests were made quietly by the Sheriff, the only re1 sistauce being by Kate, who drew a shovel on the detective and attempted to get e pistol, but was prevented from doing any thing. The whole imrty deny they are the Benders.
The Highland Weekly News · Hillsborough Hillsboro, Ohio
A Kansas detective named Beard, who had earlier discovered the Bender murder victims in 1872, tracked a family calling itself Keofer through Missouri to Arkansas and had them arrested under a Kansas governor's requisition, believing them to be the fugitive Benders. The family denied being the Benders, but local residents reportedly believed the identification was correct, and Kate (believed to be Kate Bender) resisted arrest with a shovel.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.
Wrong
The Highland Weekly News · 26 April 1877 · page 2
The Bender Family. A Southern letter saya that on March 4, Kansas detectives passed through Ft. Smith en route for Kansas, with the sup posed Bender lamily, arrested in Craw ford County. The family went under the name of Keofer. They were arrested by a Mr. Beafd, of Kansas, a private de tective, upon a requisition from the Gov ernor of Kansas upon the Governor of Arkansas. Beard is the man who dis covered the bodies of the murdered York and others, on Bender's place, in KaLsas, in 1872. He followed the family iown the Atlantic and Pacific Railroad to Pierce City, Missouri, and thence to Fayetteville, but reunited at the houso of old man Bender on Cedar Creek, where they engaged in agricultural pur suits.
See moreSee less
After aatistying himself as to the identity of the family, the detective pro ceeded to Kansas, the Governor offered arewardof $2,500, and requisition for George Keofer alias John Bender, Lena Keofer, alias Kate Bender, Mrs. Keofer, alias Mrs. Bender, and Philip Keofer, alius John Bender, jun. The arrests were made quietly by the Sheriff, the only resistance being by Kate who drew a shovel on the detective and attempted to get a pistol, but was prevented from doing anything. The whole party deny they are the Benders. All the circum stances are so strong that every oce in that locality where tbe arrests were made believe they are the real Bender family. Keofer made a good citizen, but has rested under suspicion ever since his residence in Crawford. They came into the country on loot, one at a time, but the old man soon commenced buvine farms and agricultural imple ments7al ways having plenty money to pay his way. Since they left Kansas Kate has become the mother of two child ren.