The Providence News · 2 September 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
LIZZIE BORDEN STANDS UP TO BE COMMITTED.
IN TAUNTON JAIL.
The Courtain Drops on the Borden Tragedy.
See moreSee less
TO RAISE IN NOVEMBER
Two Acts Have Been Played Out to Their Close.
IS SHE GUILTY OR INNOCENT.
Public Opinion is Still Fluctuating -- Lizzie Borden Takes the Prospect of two Months in Jail Very Calmly --"It is Best," She Says, "That Exhoneration Should Come From the Higher Court."
[SPECIAL TO THE NEWS.]
FALL RIVER, Sept. 2.--There are still various shades of opinion on the Borden case ranging from the inspired believer in Lizzie's innocence to those who are confident that she is the one described by Mr. Jennings as either "Insane" or inspired by "hatred as black as hell itself."
Whichever may be the true view, and undoubtedly one or the other is true, for there is no middle ground in a case like this, may never be known, but the final judgment of the highest tribunal is still some months away and the public must accept what it has as the full evidence until more is shown.
It is the office of the reporter to portray facts and describe public opinion of them. That has been the aim of this column, and the fact that in neither of the arguments presented yesterday was there any new thought developed is conclusive evidence that the readers of the NEWS have had access to all the evidence that has been available.
The pleas of the opposing attorneys yesterday were as different as it was possible to conceive. Both were specimens of keen logic and each made the best possible presentation of his view of the case. Of the two that of Mr. Jennings was the more eloquent and effective on the audience.
It was an address wherein the array of facts in his client's favor, the disproof of all the theories of the prosecution, and the appeals to humanity and mercy were blended with the nicest precision and voiced by a man whose inspiration was his soulful conviction that the defendant is innocent.
The points that he made have already been detailed the possibilities of someone else being there, as shown by the unsolved burglaries. The absence of blood and the failure to find a weapon were emphasized yesterday by the obvious fact that Miss Borden was ill on Wednesday morning. Her mother said so, she said so and Bridget said so. On that morning she was in her room and hence she did not go out and try to buy prussic acid on that day Mr. Bence said. This somewhat effectually disposes of the prussic acid motive theory, so far at least as present evidence goes. It leaves the government with absolutely nothing in the way of fact to prove Lizzie's guilt, except her presence at the house, her opportunity to commit the murder and her own unintelligible account of her acts and statements.
Unfortunately for her, while these are plainly inadequate as positive evidence of guilt, they are adequate ground for suspicion--and that is the ground which Mr. Knowlton took in his plea for the prosecution. It was repeated again and again and emphasized forcibly that he at no time considered that he had proofs of her guilt. He would be prepared to prove that when it became necessary. All that he wished to do at that hearing was to establish good evidence for strong suspicion and he claimed to have done it.
He claimed that the wounds were not those caused by great force and they were not. He stated that they were those of a timid irresolute hand and the evidence of Dr. Draper was convincing that no one of the first eight wounds were "necessarily fatal."
It was this damaging evidence that Mr. Adams very thoughtlessly brought out in his cross-questioning. It had been claimed by the prosecution that the blows were crushing, heavy blows. Dr. Dolan had testified to that fact and it was of material advantage to the defence that that fact should be established.
But it was entirely refuted by Dr. Draper. The blows were light. Only in one instance in Mr. Borden's case was there a blow sufficiently strong to cut through bone one-sixteenth of an inch in thickness.
Such blows were possible by a woman, and Attorney Knowlton was shrewd enough to make a strong point of this fact, that the nature of the wounds was such as to warrant the statement that they must have been made by a feminine hand: that being struck in the back, they were the work of a moral coward who did not dare face the unfortunate victim.
Mr. Knowlton also made it plain that the front door at least was locked until Mr. Borden returned at about half past nine. Bridget was out washing windows and Lizzie was alone with her mother upstairs. And that was the time when her mother was killed.
It is extremely improbable that anyone could have entered the house while Bridget was washing windows. This more than gives Lizzie "opportunity;" it gives her the only opportunity thus far known and she does not attempt to prove an alibi at that time. Her alibi only applies to the time when her father was killed, and that is such a halting one that it surpasses credulity to use the words of Mr. Knowlton.
That these circumstances are sufficient to prove suspicion there can be little doubt, and having proved suspicion the case of the government is finished.
Side Lights on the Case--Insanity.
Of the side lights yesterday let in on the case two are important. One applies to Mr. Knowlton's public admission that the government had a great deal more evidence than it had used, and that is undoubtedly true. There is evidence in this case which has been given to parties in confidence that is very strong, though entirely circumstantial and indirect in its character. It will be used when necessary and not before.
The second side light, so to speak, relates to Mr. Jennings statement that the murderer "must be insane." That is not a meaningless phrase. It is a statement of fact as it exists. But it is more than that. It is the utterance of an inspired prophet. It is in short the prophecy of the line which the defence will adopt should convicting evidence be shown against Lizzie. Bear in mind that Mr. Jennings was not called upon to make this statement. It had little to do with his argument. It neither aided nor hindered his plea at the hearing. It was a gratuitous admission on his part, and it shows, perhaps, stronger than anything else the turn which his mind is taking in the case.
His plea will be insanity. In this he has but confirmed the presentation of the facts made in Saturday's NEWS that Miss Borden has those characteristics, not only of action but of feature and expression, that give the strongest grounds for doubting her entire sanity under all circumstances.
How Lizzie Received the News.
The scene in the court room was affecting yesterday afternoon when the end of the hearing was reached. The judge's voice was choked with grief and his eyes were filled with tears as he uttered the words "you are probably guilty."
The words were received by the prisoner without a movement. She sat quietly in her seat until called upon to stand while the clerk read the order of the court. Then she stood without assistance and as quietly received the decision of the judge. Words of sympathy were heard on all sides, and when Mr. Buck spoke to her she interrupted him by saying:
"It is for the best, I think. It is better that I should get my exoneration in a higher court, for then it will be complete."
John V. Morse and Bridget Sullivan were ordered to furnish bonds to the amount of $500 each for appearance at the November term of the grand jury. They readily obtained the amounts, John C. Milne and Frank Almy going bail for both.
There being nothing further to do, Miss Lizzie arose, took the proffered arm of the Rev. Mr. Buck and walked resolutely along the corridor to the matron's room, followed by Mrs. Brigham, who was on the border of hysteria, so grief-stricken was she.
Miss Emma awaited her sister in the matron's room and Mr. Buck soon left them together.
The Inquest Not Ended.
It has been stated in the morning papers that the first act in the Borden case is finished. The statement is misleading, for it conveys the idea that the prosecuting authorities will rest. Such, however, is not the case.
The inquest is not yet finished, and no time has been set for its end. It will be continued so long as any suspicious circumstances or characters can be found and examined.
LIZZIE BORDEN STANDS UP TO BE COMMITTED.