As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

Lizzie Borden Arrested

August – September 1892

After an inquest held behind closed doors, Lizzie Borden was arrested, pleaded not guilty and was committed to Taunton jail to await her trial. At the hearing in Fall River the state’s physical evidence came apart: Professor Wood found no poison, no blood on the hatchet, and one spot of blood the size of a pin head. The judge held her for the grand jury anyway. Rumour ran ahead of the evidence: a quarrel in the police matron’s room, a madman’s confession, a man seen jumping the back fence.

The daughter is taken to jail

A Fall River dispatch reports that the inquest resumed behind closed doors and that Lizzie Borden has been arrested and jailed, held as at least an accessory before the fact. A second autopsy at Oak Grove cemetery found a bruise on Mrs. Borden’s back, near the left shoulder. By the next day’s report she was answering to a charge of murder.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 12 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED. Held as an Accessory in the Murder of Her Parents.

Fall River, Mass., Aug. 12.—The inquest in the Borden murder case was resumed yesterday behind closed doors. Just what was developed at the hearing it is impossible to learn at present, but from the fact that Miss Lizzie Borden has been placed under arrest it is evident that facts have been developed which point to her as at least an accessory before the fact in the murder of her father and stepmother. Miss Borden was taken to jail at once.

See moreSee less

A second autopsy was held in the ladies' waiting room at the Oak Grove cemetery. Mrs. Borden's body was exhumed first. The new fact discovered was a bruise on the back, near the left shoulder, about the width of an ax and shaped like the head of an ax. It gives another clew to the exact position held by Mrs. Borden when the deed was committed.

See the clipping

The people around the Borden house

A Providence paper sketches the people in the case. Dr. Seabury W. Bowen, the family physician from across the street, is said to have found Mrs. Borden and cried ‘Why, she’s fainted at the sight of Mr. Borden’. At the trial the prosecutor told it differently: Mrs. Churchill, the next-door neighbor, saw the body first. Hiram P. Harrington, a brother-in-law, admits business differences with Andrew Borden.

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Providence News · 12 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE DRAMATIS PERSONAE. Some of the People Who Figure in the Great Borden Tragedy. FALL RIVER, Aug. 12--Dr. Seabury W. Bowen is the Borden family physician, and lives opposite their house. He is a gray, churchly looking gentleman, tall and dignified, and has always had a good name and been connected with the First Baptist church. His standing as a physician is good and he is liked by the public. Insinuations against him early in this case were promptly and properly frowned down. It was he who, in company with Officer Doherty, first discovered Mrs.

See moreSee less

Borden lying dead in her room. The doctor proceeding to the upper floor to try to find Mrs. Borden, saw her lying on the floor and exclaimed, "Why, she's fainted at the sight of Mr. Borden!" When a step nearer showed him what had actually befallen her. Adelaide Churchill is the widow of Charles H. Churchill and next door neighbor of the Borden family. She is a light-complexioned, fleshy lady of about 50 years; has long been a singer in the First Congregational Church and has a high personal reputation. Hiram P. Harrington is a brother-in-law of Andrew J. Borden, an old resident and a well-meaning man, who says he had business differences with the old man. The older citizens everywhere recall the murder, many years ago, by a Borden related to this very family, of her three children and her own suicide in a well, on the premises adjoining those of the late Andrew J. Borden. Lizzie Borden is said to have been very friendly with, if not engaged to, a worthy young man of Westport. MISS LIZZIE BORDEN.

See the clipping

Committed to Taunton jail without bail

Arraigned on a charge of murder, Lizzie Borden pleads not guilty in a firm voice and is committed without bail to Taunton jail. The same dispatch announces the weapon found: a claw hatchet from the cellar said to show ‘many spots of human blood’ and hairs matching Mrs. Borden’s. Seventeen days later Professor Wood testified that the hatchet bore no blood and the hair was not human.

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Vermont Phœnix, 12 August 1892, The United Opinion, 12 August 1892.

Evening Journal · 13 August 1892 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LIGHT ON THE MYSTERY.

The Bloody Ax That Killed the Bordens Has Been Found.

See moreSee less

LIZZIE BORDEN PLEADS NOT GUILTY.

She Is Remanded for Trial Without Bail and Taken to Taunton and Locked Up in a Cell—The Accused Woman Preserves Her Air of Indifference.

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 13.—The ax with which Mrs. Borden was killed has been found. That is the sensation of the day in the mysterious double murder case. The formal commitment of Miss Lizzie as the assassin of her father and stepmother ranks second in interest to the discovery of the murderous weapon.

It did not leak out till now that one of the four hatchets found in the cellar of the Borden homestead soon after the murder was the instrument with which the butchery was committed. Under the microscope it shows many spots of human blood. That it was carefully washed there is no doubt, for a bucket of water was found near it, and also three new towels, partially covered with blood. The water had been splashed over the cellar floor. The weapon also showed some long hairs, which matched those in Mrs. Borden's head.

No hatchet like the one in custody can be found in the local hardware stores, its greatest peculiarity is the claw on the side of the head nearest the handle. The handle is about 2½ feet long and the top of the head is about 1¼ by 4 inches.

It Fits Into the Cuts.

It is said that the head of the hatchet fits into the murderous wounds in Mr. Borden's head. The blade of the implement is represented as being very thin and very sharp, measuring about 5½ inches in the widest part. It is what is known among farmers as an oldfashioned thrashwood hatchet, except for the strange claw. A hardware man says that such hatchets are probably used in trimming heavy planking where spikes are driven, the claw being used in pulling out spikes.

When the police authorities were asked if such a hatchet was in their custody they would neither admit nor deny it. The matter with all other evidence is now in control of District Attorney Knowlton.

Certain clothes covered with blood, found in the cellar where the hatchet was found, are said to have an important bearing on this part of the case.

Marshal Hilliard said there was a great deal yet to be proven before the crime could be finally fastened upon Miss Borden. Much had been learned, but for all that he could see the trial would be long and tedious. Medical Examiner Dolan says that a great deal will depend upon the accuracy of the medical examination of the bloody body and the analysis of the parts sent to Boston. Affairs are more quiet in police circles than for many hours. There is the report of an unsuccessful search made in the Chace hill woods ponds, which, according to the statement of a man named Ward, contained evidence of the crime. Officers Doherty and Harrington found nothing suspicious there.

Lizzie Borden Arraigned.

When court was opened Lizzie Borden came in on the arm of Rev. A. E. Buck, the white haired missionary of Central church. She wore a tailor made gown of dark blue and a black hat trimmed with black polka dot crape. She had no veil. She was more self possessed than at any previous time, and her steellike and almost painful severity of countenance betrayed no emotion. She was careless and indifferent to her surroundings and whispered leisurely to her counsel, A. J. Jennings. The latter filed a motion to dismiss the complaint upon the grounds that the judge, being the same person who presided at the inquest, was not competent to pass an unbiased opinion at the preliminary trial; further, that the inquest was still in session.

District Attorney Knowlton offered a demurrer, which was sustained, and then he asked that the prisoner be called upon to make her plea to the complaint. Her lawyer offered a plea of not guilty, but the judge would not accept it, and ordered the clerk to proceed with the usual custom of the court. The clerk asked Lizzie to stand up and answer to the charge of murder.

She Pleads Not Guilty.

She did so in a firm tone of voice and with stress upon the "not." Mr. Jennings arraigned the police for conducting the inquest in private and for denying him the right to attend and protect her from useless questions. A wordy war between the two lawyers lasted for half an hour. Jennings announced that his client was ready and anxious to proceed to trial at once. The state asked for a continuance until Aug. 22, which was granted.

The district attorney informed the court that he wished John V. Morse and Bridget Sullivan placed under bonds to secure their attendance at the trial, as he looked upon them as valuable witnesses. They were ordered to give security in $500 each, which they did, with Almy & Milne, proprietors of The Daily News, as their bondsmen.

Then Lizzie Borden was ordered to be committed without bond to await the trial. She arose, and with ever faithful Minister Buck passed out under police guard. A closed carriage conveyed her and her sister Emma to the depot, where a train was boarded for Taunton. She was in custody of the chief of police. This closed the first legal act in this stirring tragedy.

In Jail at Taunton.

TAUNTON, Mass., Aug. 13.—Miss Lizzie Borden's entry into the city took the form of a public ceremonial. The excitement was high. Arriving at the Central Passenger station, Miss Borden was conducted to a curtained hack by Mr. Buck and City Marshal Hilliard, Detective Seaver acting as guard and clearing the way. The only sign of interest she manifested on the trip from Fall River was when Taunton was reached, when she aroused from her lethargy for a second, then dropped her head on her hand and closed her eyes.

Arriving at the jail, she was at once placed in a cell, the minister conducting her to the door and Marshal Hilliard seeing that the door was properly secured.

Mrs. Wright, wife of Sheriff Wright, an old friend of the Borden family, hurried to the cell with a glass of water, which the prisoner eagerly drank. When Miss Borden entered the jail office her face was composed and there was no sign of consciousness given as she passed toward the corridor, apparently seeing nothing and noticing no one.

The sheriff stood by the inner door, and he was affected almost to tears as he saw the daughter of his old friend passing to apartments usually occupied by the most degraded females. Minister Buck emerged from the cellroom white and agitated and not disposed to talk.

See the clipping

The mutineers were still in prison

A Lynn paper offered revenge as a motive: Andrew Borden’s testimony had convicted mutineers of the schooner Jefferson Borden, who vowed vengeance. A Thomaston dispatch ends it: the two men sent to the Maine State Prison in 1875 for life have ‘never been pardoned’. From Fall River, Bridget Sullivan is quoted saying ‘don't wonder that they arrested Lizzie Borden’.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

New-York Tribune · 14 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A THEORY THAT FAILED.

REVENGE OF CONVICTED MEN AS A MOTIVE FOR THE BORDEN MURDER.

See moreSee less

BUT THE CONVICTS ARE STILL IN A MAINE PRISON--MISS BORDEN'S LIFE IN JAIL.

Lynn, Mass., Aug. 13.--"The Lynn Item" to-day published a story stating that Andrew J. Borden, of Fall River, gave the principal testimony that convicted the ringleaders in the mutiny on the schooner Jefferson Borden, while on a voyage from a foreign port to this country; that he and his wife were on the vessel; that his testimony in the courts was declared by the sailors to be false and exaggerated, and that the men who suffered by it vowed vengeance against him. The ringleaders of the mutiny, five in number, were overpowered and placed in irons, and when the vessel arrived in port they were brought before the courts for trial. Two of them were Americans, two were British subjects and one a Portuguese, who claimed to be a subject of Queen Victoria. By the aid of the English Government the three foreigners were either released or escaped with light terms of imprisonment. The two Americans were declared guilty by the courts and sentenced to death, but later President Cleveland commuted their sentences to imprisonment for life in the State Prison at Thomaston, Me. The principal testimony which the courts took under consideration and acted upon was given by Andrew J. Borden.

Thomaston, Me., Aug. 13.--George Miller and William Clark, the Jefferson Borden mutineers, were sent to the Maine State Prison on October 4, 1875, and have never been pardoned. They were sentenced for life.

Taunton, Mass., Aug. 13.--Sheriff Wright declined to ask or have Lizzie A. Borden asked, or her sister Emma, who is visiting her at the jail, whether their parents were on the schooner Jefferson Borden, or whether either of them knew anything about "The Lynn Item's" story. He declares that no questions are to be asked of people in jail, whether visitors or not.

Miss Borden passed a comfortable night, and this morning was cheerful to an unusal degree, brought about perhaps by the prospect of a visit from her sister. Mr. Jennings and Miss Emma Borden came up this morning, and the former, after a brief conversation, went away, leaving Emma in the cell with her sister. The two conversed in low tones for some time. During part of the time, Lizzie was occupied with some sewing which she had brought with her. It is understood that under no circumstances will she open her mouth, and Mr. Jennings, her counsel, will do all the talking necessary.

Fall River, Mass., Aug. 13.--The reaction in the Borden cases has set in, and to-day the popular feeling is noticeably quiet. There is now but one policeman at the Borden homestead, and he is doing patrol duty in the street to prevent curious people from annoying the family. The police have resumed their regular patrol duty, and only three men are hunting up further evidence of the murder.

The City Marshal said this morning that he was confident that the evidence to be submitted at the hearing, on August 22, would be strong enough to warrant the holding of Miss Borden for the Grand Jury. That body will not convene until November, and the time of the special session of the Superior Court that must be held, will be decided on afterward. While direct police surveillance has been removed from Mr. Morse and Miss Sullivan, yet their whole connection with the case will be gone over by the police again within the next few days, and they will not be far away should the police need them. There will not be many witnesses summoned for the preliminary hearing, unless the present plans are changed. The proceedings will be open to reporters. The marshal again denies the statements in many papers to the effect that no search was made until after the funeral. A search was made three times during the afternoon of the day of the murders, and Miss Lizzie's room was searched as thoroughly as other portions of the building. Police inquiry is being made again into the details of a mysterious robbery, which took place at the Borden homestead about a year ago. A lady's watch and several articles of jewelry were taken from a dressing case in one of the upper rooms, and to this day the police have been unable to trace the thief.

The most noticeable feature in the Borden case to-day was an expression made by Bridget Sullivan during an interview this afternoon. She remarked: "Well, I don't wonder that they arrested Lizzie Borden." As the Sullivan woman is the most important Government witness, her statement has startled the friends of the imprisoned girl. It is reported that the prosecution will present but little of its case at the preliminary hearing, keeping back, if possible, the most important evidence.

To-night's "News" says: "Mrs. Holmes has been one of the most intimate friends of the family. She admits that the family relations have not been as pleasant as they are in many families; that in years past they were decidedly unpleasant, at times, but she pronounces foolish all talk of an open rupture between Lizzie and her father and stepmother. She says that, as a matter of fact, Lizzie had been on much more friendly terms with her father and Mrs. Borden during the last year or two than she had been for a long time previously--probably since her father's second marriage."

See the clipping

The first talk of insanity

State officers are said to believe that if Lizzie Borden killed her parents she was insane, while her lawyer, Jennings, is turning opinion: ‘She is finding supporters and friends in unexpected places’. Robert Pinkerton thinks the arrest justified but says the killer ‘must have been insane’. In November a New Bedford paper would say the grand jury was adjourned so her sanity could be examined.

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The Indianapolis Journal · 15 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

IF GUILTY SHE WAS INSANE

Opinion of Leading Police Officials and Friends of Miss Lizzie Borden.

See moreSee less

Evidence Relating to Her Private Life Said to Furnish a Basis for the Belief that Her Mind Was Unbalanced.

Robert Pinkerton Also Thinks the Perpetrator of the Crime Was a Lunatic.

Madman Kills His Companion and Throws Himself in Front of a Locomotive—Deadly Free Fight Follows a Dog Fight.

WAS MISS BORDEN INSANE?

Opinion Gaining Ground that She Was Ill She Committed the Double Crime.

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 14.—The Borden murders are the great topic here yet. At the Central Congregation Church, of which the Borden family were members, union services were held to-day, attended by the members of the First and Central Churches.

City Marshal Hilliard has heard nothing from Prof. Wood, who is analyzing the stomach of the victims and comparing the spots of blood on the axe and carpet. He says if there is any truth in the reports that Wood has discovered that the blood upon the axe and carpet is the same it is very strange he has not heard it officially. The police to-day have been engaged in chasing down clews and testing statements made in many letters sent to the marshal.

It is Lizzie Borden's side of the case that is now attracting the whole attention of the police. It is not thought that the preliminary hearing set down for the 22d inst. will be of long duration. It has been the policy of District Attorney Knowlton in handling capital crimes to give as little evidence as possible until the trial takes place. Attorney Jennings, who beyond question believes in the innocence of Miss Borden, will do everything in his power to have a full examination at the earliest date. His work at the time of the arraignment has done much to change public opinion concerning the girl; more particularly that position referring to a fair trial by an impartial judge. Although Miss Borden is under arrest charged with perhaps the most heinious crime committed here in recent years, there is little talk about the punishment that should be meted out to her. She is finding supporters and friends in unexpected places. The talk is almost entirely regarding her chances of proving her innocence. This fact gives the police authorities reason to think that much of the strongest evidence will have to be given before attorney Jennings will consent to an order for holding his client until November. It is an open secret in police circles that the leading officers of the State believe that Miss Borden was insane at the time of the murders, if she committed them. It is well known in this city that Judge Blaisdell and District Attorney Knowlton were prejudiced in Miss Borden's favor, and they must have had the strongest possible reasons for ordering her arrest. Some evidence relating to the private life of Miss Borden, now in the hands of the police, bear directly on this side of the case, and strengthens the opinion of the high police authorities who have said that Miss Borden was not conscious of her deeds if she was implicated.

Views of Robert Pinkerton.

NEW YORK, Aug. 14.—Robert Pinkerton gave his views on the Borden murders to a reporter to-day. He said he had not studied the case from a detective's stand-point, but only through the newspapers. He said, in reply to a question whether Lizzie Borden's arrest was justified by the facts, that he thought it was, but that such an action did not necessarily imply that she was guilty. It would be quite possible for a person to enter the house by stealth and commit the crime without being seen, and to prove the point Mr. Pinkerton mentioned several cases where large sums of money had been stolen by expert thieves in broad daylight. When asked if he thought the murderer an insane perso[n], he said: "Judging from what I have read about the case it seems to me that the person who killed Mr. and Mrs. Borden must have been insane, but I would not care to be quoted as advancing an insanity theory." Continuing, he said: "It seems strange that there are no more conclusive clews to be followed, if the reports of blood-stained walls and ceiling are true. If they were in such a condition the murderer must have gone away with blood stains on his clothing. Now where are these bloody clothes? The mere fact that Miss Borden has told conflicting stories is more in her favor than if she had unhesitatingly stuck to the same tale, as an innocent person is more likely to make conflicting statements than a guilty one."

Concerning the Pinkerton detective who was placed on the case and who was severely criticised by the Fall River authorities, he said: "The authorities seemed to have thought that our detective was brought into the case for the purpose of protecting Lizzie Borden. Such was not the case. He was wired by the family to follow any clews that might lead to the detection of the criminal. He has been removed from the case at my suggestion, as I thought it unwise to have a private detective on the case until the authorities had reached some decision." The lawyer who has charge of Miss Borden's interests Mr. Pinkerton considers a very clever man, and thinks her interests will not suffer while under his care.

See the clipping

New England papers take her side

City Marshal Hilliard is shown about fifty New England editorials, most of them sure of Lizzie Borden’s innocence and hard on the police. He answers that he started on an outside clue ‘within a half hour of the discovery of the tragedy’ and that the papers do not know what the inquest heard. Her Christian Endeavor society sends its sympathy to the jail.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 16 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THE BORDEN MURDER

City Marshall Hilliard Sustains His Action.

See moreSee less

SYMPATHY FOR THE PRISONER.

A Large Number of New England Newspapers Assail the Authorities for Imprisoning the Murdered Man's Daughter—Sympathy of the Young People's Society.

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 16.—City Marshall Hilliard was yesterday morning shown about fifty editorials clipped from various papers published in New England during the past few days. Most of them reflect a belief in Miss Lizzie Borden's entire innocence of the crime charged against her and assail the Fall River police for prolonged delay in the case and for directing their efforts wholly toward proving Miss Borden guilty.

Marshal Hilliard read most of the editorials carefully and flushed once or twice when his actions were criticised pointedly. He spoke warmly and said it was about time out of town people suspended judgment on Lizzie Borden and her arrest by the Fall River police. "I started," he said, "on an outside clew within a half hour of the discovery of the tragedy on information furnished by members of the family. I have chased down more than a hundred outside clews within ten days. You and every other citizen must remember that the newspapers have not given anything near the facts disclosed at the inquest. You and the public may rest assured of this fact. The district attorney and myself are satisfied that the public authorities have ample cause for holding this girl, and she has not been imprisoned in haste nor without a full understanding of what her arrest means."

A great deal has been said in and out of town papers about the cruelty of detaining a finely bred and sensitive woman as Miss Borden is. One of the greatest complaints that has been made against the administrator of police affairs has been that he was too easily moved by his feelings, too sentimental to be a police officer. That he has a very kind heart and a courteous manner is acknowledged by all the members of the Borden family, and they do not blame the authorities for the harshness of the arrest. A great deal of nonsense is being published in connection with the case about the Borden family honor. On this point the most important member of the Borden said for publication yesterday morning:

"The honor of the Bordens, whose names are so closely allied with the prosperity of the town, is not to be affected by a police suspicion perhaps resting justly on Miss Lizzie Borden. No true Borden has ever placed a stumbling block in the way of the law, and no member of my family will in any way hamper the police in their investigation. The statement that $15,000,000 of Borden money will be used in balking the authorities, is untrue and ill advised."

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 16.—The following was sent to Taunton jail yesterday morning: "We, the members of the Young People's Society of Christian Endeavor, desire to extend to our fellow member, Miss Lizzie A. Borden, our sincere sympathy with her in her present hour of trial and our confident belief that she will soon be returned to her place of usefulness among us."

TAUNTON, Mass., Aug. 16.—A Taunton Gazette reporter learned from Bridget Sullivan on Sunday that the reason she lay down on the day of the Borden murders was because she was troubled with naseau that morning and vomited several times while washing windows. Previous statements from the police have been to the effect that she laid down because she was tired with the work. It is probable that this statement was held back if made known at the inquest, as bearing upon the theory that the victims may have been dosed with poison.

See the clipping

A man walks in and confesses

Charles H. Peckham of Westport walks 10 miles to the Fall River police station and tells Assistant Marshal Fleet he killed both Bordens ‘out of pure love for blood’. The dispatch calls him ‘crazy beyond doubt’, a war veteran who had brooded over Lizzie Borden’s arrest. Others would follow: a year later a letter found in a bottle in Michigan claimed the killings.

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The Portland Daily Press · 19 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

"I KILLED MR. BORDEN."

Startling Confession of a Supposed Crank.

See moreSee less

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 18.—Charles H. Peckham, of Central Village, Westport, Mass., walked into the central police station this morning and said to Assistant Marshal Fleet; "Well, Mr. Marshal, I killed Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden and I have come from home to give myself up. I went over the back fence and through the rear door of the Borden house, two weeks ago today, and I killed both of these people out of pure love for blood, went out of the rear door and over the back fence and walked over the New Bedford road home. I'm the murderer and I walked to be locked up."

The marshal searched him and found a pocket book with a few receipts in it, also some official communications from the Pension Bureau at Washington.

Peckham is 62 years of age, about five feet six inches tall, and has a thin, gray beard. He says he leases a farm from Edmund Davis.

The police have started to hunt up his relatives or friends.

Peckham Crazy.

FALL RIVER, August 18.—The man Peckham, who gave himself up at the station this morning, is crazy beyond doubt. He begged several of the officers at the station to hang him. He formerly lived in Middletown, Ct., and, it is said, has had some trouble with his family. He was locked up.

Nelson Reed of Westport states that he knows Peckham very well, and says he has been crazy for some time.

Charles H. Peckham was in this city Friday and heard a great deal about Lizzie Borden's arrest. He went home and since then has been brooding so much over the affair that he became insane. He left home between 6 and 7 this morning, despite the protestations of his wife, and walked 10 miles to the police station to give himself up. He is a war veteran, subject to fits of insanity for some years He will be cared for by friends.

See the clipping

A sisters’ quarrel in the matron’s room

A Boston Globe special, reprinted here, says Lizzie turned on Emma in the police matron’s room, ‘You gave me away, Emma’, and that Emma left in tears. The Globe’s informant was not in the room; he had it from the matron, Mrs. Reagan. At the trial in June 1893 the New-York Tribune reported the story contradicted.

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pawtucket Tribune · 25 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

"YOU GAVE ME AWAY."

Lizzie Borden Turns Against Her Sister.

See moreSee less

AN OUTBURST OF ANGER.

Belief That Emma is in Possession of a Secret.

BOSTON, Aug. 25.—The Globe this morning has the following special:

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 24—"You gave me away, Emma, did you not?"

"No, Lizzie, I only told Mr. Jennings what he ought to know for your defense."

"That is false. You have given me away and I know it; but remember! I will not give in jone inch, never! never? That is all I have to say to you."

In a voice embittered with suppressed passion, Lizzie A. Borden this afternoon, in the presence of her attendant, Mrs. Reagan, the police matron, thus addressed her nearest and dearest relative, as with a violent wave of the hand she turned her back upon her sister, with whom the conversation just narrated had taken place.

With tears in her eyes and voice choked with sobs, Miss Emma left the room, and then the accused, overcome with emotion, fell prostrate on her bed. Another chapter in the Borden tragedy was ended.

Cast off by the sister to whom she had come with words of comfort and hope, Emma Borden returned to her home, on Second street, with Lizzie's denunciation ringing in her ears.

Mrs. Reagan, speechless and horrified, watched the prisoner intently.

The Significance of the Scene she had witnessed was fully realized, but the compromising words of the suspected murderess, her unstrung nerves and wretched condition were a revelation. Previously she had been stoical and reserved, even in disposition, and self controlled. But in one brief minute, as Emma Borden was entering the room, a transformation had taken place and passion reigned within her where indifference had before been.

The above information that The Globe has secured comes from a source that is thoroughly reliable.

It is Not Exaggerated and is published entirely as secured by the writer from a person in authority, who, while not himself present in the matron's room during the interview, had positive assurance from Mrs. Reagan that such occurrences took place.

In an interview with the writer, a member of the police department said: "Yes, Mrs. Reagan saw and heard all that she has been credited with. She is very reliable and truthful. She is likewise discreet, and you may depend that she will say nothing to newspaper men. If approached I have no doubt she would absolutely refuse to talk and, perhaps, in self protection, would deny the story. But it is true. She reported it to the city marshal almost immediately after Emma's departure, and he in turn told Mr. Hilliard. The marshal was very much surprised.

"If Miss Lizzie were innocent of the murder of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, how would it be possible in any manner for Miss Emma to 'give her away?' Unless Lizzie had confided something to Emma that the latter had repeated to Mr. Jennings, there would have been no cause or reason for that conversation.

"That there has taken place

Some Violation of Confidence, or some revelation or fact that Emma was cognizant of, is apparent to the most devoted believer in Miss Borden's innocence. That so-called betrayal was great enough to cause anger on Miss Lizzie's part and make her turn back on her sister and wholly ignore her.

"It was important enough, if Mrs. Reagan speaks the truth, for Lizzie to say she 'would not give in a single inch,' and as Mrs. Reagan says, to emphasize her words, with a gesture in which she designated a portion of her little finger as being less than she would admit. I think this is the most important development in the Borden case since the arrest was made.

"I also think it may be possible after Bridget Sullivan gives her testimony on the stand for the state to proceed in other directions. It is understood among the subordinates in the police department that Bridget has said she

Saw Lizzie in the Cellar of the Borden house at the place where the axes were kept just prior to the murders. There are other important things that she will tell about, notably the girl's relations with the old folks. She tells a story of domestic discord among the Bordens, the like of which has not been printed in the newspapers as yet."

See the clipping

The medical examiner takes the stand

On the first day of the hearing, Medical Examiner Dolan admits his final search was delayed and only a partial autopsy was held at first, which the paper calls ‘slipshod methods’. Lizzie Borden shows feeling only three or four times, once when he describes her father’s wounds, hiding her face behind a fan. Jennings gives out a letter from a peddler about a man with blood on his clothes.

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Evening Journal · 26 August 1892 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN'S ORDEAL.

The First Day's Hearing Develops Official Slipshod Methods.

See moreSee less

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 26.—The first day's hearing of the Borden case was brought to a close while Dr. Dolan, who was first called to testify, was still on the stand. The principal thing developed by Attorney Adams' long examination was the exposure of the slipshod methods of the police force and medical examiner, one of the results of which is the imprisonment of Miss Lizzie A. Borden. The principal government witness made a confession to this fact, saying that his final search was delayed and that only a partial autopsy was held shortly after the bodies were discovered.

The witness, after describing the condition of the bodies when found, said that in his opinion the wounds were made by the same instrument. The edge would not necessarily be dulled by the successive blows.

Continuing his testimony, the medical examiner told of examining the clothing of the Borden girls and described the stains and hairs found on the hatchet. He thought Mr. Borden's assailant stood between the head of Mr. Borden and the dining room door. From the position of the assailant and Mr. Borden, he thought the former would have received more blood above the waist than below.

He thought the deed could have been done and the person doing it not have more than ten spots on his clothing.

Miss Lizzie Borden did not betray any noticeable feeling during the whole day, except possibly in three or four instances. One was when Dr. Dolan described the ghastly wounds on her father. Then she flushed and tears came into her eyes. She closed her eyes and hid her face behind a palmleaf fan and leaned toward her sister, who also remained with closed eyes until the dreadful tale was ended.

Miss Lizzie and her attorneys are well pleased with the result of the first day's proceedings. They see nothing which attaches the crime to the house, but see a great deal to show careless and even shiftless methods on the part of the prosecution.

Lawyer Jennings, counsel for the defense, gave out a letter purporting to be from Samuel Robinsky, a Jew peddler, who said that on the day of the murder a man whose clothing was covered with blood bought from him four handkerchiefs, a looking glass, collar, necktie and some shoe blacking. The peddler did not then know of the murder and helped the man to "fix up." The defense claim to know that there was a peddler named Robinsky about Fall River on the day of the murder and are making a search for him.

See the clipping

The matron will not sign a denial

After the day’s hearing the defense disputes the quarrel story. Jennings drafts an affidavit for the matron, Mrs. Regan, to sign; she will not without the marshal’s leave, and the marshal refuses unless she takes the witness stand, which Jennings calls ‘the meanest thing he had ever heard’. In court, Dr. Dolan tells how the victims’ skulls were removed, cleaned and photographed.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

New-York Tribune · 27 August 1892 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL.

DID SHE REPROACH HER SISTER WITH "GIVING HER AWAY"?

See moreSee less

ALLEGED STATEMENT OF THE JAIL MATRON—HOT WORDS IN THE COURTROOM—TESTIMONY ABOUT FINDING THE BODIES.

Fall River, Mass., Aug. 26.—The most extraordinary occurrence since the Borden murder three weeks ago, occurred to-night just after the adjournment of the hearing. Several reporters crowded around the attorneys for the defence, who showed the following clipping from "The Fall River Globe":

"Wednesday afternoon a reporter of "The Globe" learned that Matron Regan had heard Lizzie Borden quarrelling with Emma, accusing the latter of giving her away. He went to Mrs. Regan to have the story corroborated. The question was put to the matron: "How is Miss Lizzie conducting herself now?" She replied: "She is very much agitated, and has been since her sister called to-day. She is wringing her hands and walking up and down like a crazy person." The reporter then asked what happened when Emma called, and the story, which the reporter had already heard from other sources, was corroborated in detail by the matron. Matron Regan told this story to other persons."

This article stirred counsel for defence and its correctness is denied. "The Globe" representative, however, will make affidavit that Mrs. Regan corroborated this account, and another newspaper correspondent will make oath that a person in a position to know whereof he speaks, told him the same facts, and said they came directly from Mrs. Regan. Attorney Jennings was much worked up over the matter, and at the earnest solicitation of the reporter, seconded by a number of prominent citizens, the lawyer drew up a form of affidavit, denying that she made the statements attributed to her, to be submitted to Mrs. Regan for her signature.

The Rev. Mr. Buck was delegated to take the document to the matron, but soon returned, saying that she refused to sign it unless the marshal said so. Mr. Buck went to the marshal, who positively refused to allow the matron to do anything of the kind unless she was placed on the witness stand. Mr. Jennings, who had followed Mr. Buck into the office, grew very indignant, and told the marshal it was the meanest thing he had ever heard. The marshal thanked him and hot words passed between the two.

There was a great deal of warm talk over these occurrences to-night, and they are being discussed in all circles. Marshal Hilliard says he has been making an investigation of the case.

There were fewer women in the District Court room to-day. This was probably due to a dreary rain. The prisoner and her friends came in unattended except by the City Marshal. Lizzie walked firmly after her sister and took her usual seat. She busied herself reading a letter written on a sheet of foolscap paper.

The examination was resumed a few minutes before 10 o'clock. Mr. Adams called Dr. Dolan to the stand. He thought the murderer stood just behind Mr. Borden's head; but could not say he struck with both hands. The person who killed Mrs. Borden struck a blow, perhaps, while she was standing up and the others were struck after she had fallen. He must necessarily have been spattered with blood. The hands of the murderer may or may not have been covered with blood. Witness did not give any one permission to clean the wood-work in the house. In fact, he told the family not to disturb the blood spots. No one handled the axe except himself, as far as he knew.

Search of Mr. Borden's clothes was conducted by the undertaker. Keys, some silver money, a pocket-book and some documents were found tied in a handkerchief, and were locked in the examiner's safe. The wound in Mrs. Borden's back was first discovered at the autopsy held in Oak Grove Cemetery. Then came the most grewsome part of the testimony yet given, and while it was going on Miss Lizzie and Miss Emma closed their eyes and flushed and showed much feeling. The witness said the bodies had been buried. The skulls were removed from the bodies, by instruction of the Attorney-General, and cleaned. They were photographed, and are now in the witness's possession. No member of the Borden family was informed of the removal and photographing of the skulls, as far as witness knew.

Here followed a discussion on the pronunciation of the word "photographer," the question being on which syllable the accent should be placed. The diversion had the effect of relieving the tension on the minds of the prisoner and her friends. The witness resuming, said he saw the contents of the safe, but saw no will. He saw a pail and some towels in the cellar, but was satisfied they had no connection with the case; the clothes were buried in a box in the rear of the house. The axe is now in possession of the marshal; the axes and hatchets were given to Professor Wood, but were never fitted to the wounds. In his opinion, Mrs. Borden died from one hour to two hours before Mr. Borden.

A. G. Hart, treasurer of the Union Savings Bank, Cashier Burrill and Everett Cook, of the First National Bank, all testified to seeing Mr. Borden between 9:30 and 9:45 o'clock, the morning of the murder.

Charles C. Cook, real estate broker and agent for Mr. Borden's new business block, had a long talk with him a few days before the tragedy. Mr. Borden said that he had made no will.

Mrs. Caroline Kelly testified to living in the house next south to the Borden homestead. On the day of the murder she saw Mr. Borden coming around the house from the north side and going toward the front door. She thought he had a small white package in his hand. At the time she saw him it was 27 or 25 minutes to 1 o'clock; she could not say that he entered the house.

Dr. Dolan was recalled and produced the property taken from Mr. Borden's pockets, by the undertaker. Among the effects was a package of tobacco.

The photographs taken in the house soon after the murder were placed in evidence. There are five of them, showing the various positions of the bodies in the various rooms. On a second cross-examination witness said when an artery was cut the direction of the spurt would be dependent on the direction from which it was cut. He saw no yard stick when he first saw the body, but he did see one later.

John Cunningham, newsdealer, was sworn. He was passing the Borden house, on the morning of August 4, and heard of the murder. When he reached Hall's stable, two or three houses below, he noticed four or five men standing in front of the house, and saw Mrs. Churchill running excitedly across the street. A boy told him he was looking for a policeman. He stepped into a store and called up the city marshal's office, at 10:50 o'clock. He saw the police officer, Allen, going toward the house, four or five minutes after he had informed the marshal. He went around the house with two reporters, but they could find no trace of footprints on the grass or the fence.

Deputy Sheriff Frank H. Wixon was sworn. He saw the officers make a search of the house; he could not say he saw anybody go into the barn; he was in the yard after 12 o'clock and crawled up on a pile of lumber and into the next yard. He thought the next yard extended to Third-st. The other men were so standing that they could not see the Borden house, but the first man could have seen any man who crossed the back Borden fence; he could not talk to this first man, as he was a foreigner.

The first witness this afternoon was Joseph Shortsleeves, a carpenter who had worked for Mr. Borden. He was at the store, 92 South Main-st., but was not working, when Mr. Borden stopped there on his way home on the morning of the murder. He fixed the time at 10:40 as nearly as possible.

Miss Lizzie Borden appeared to be using more than an ordinary effort to maintain her composure, and it was evident that the strain was beginning to tell on her wonderful nerve. As she caught Mrs. Holmes's eye her face brightened in an instant.

See the clipping

Neighbors, a friend and a drug clerk testify

Mrs. Churchill, the neighbor, tells how Lizzie called to her, ‘do come over, somebody has killed father’, and saw no blood on her. Alice Russell, who later told the grand jury of a burned dress, says Lizzie said she went to the barn for iron or tin to mend a window. Drug clerk Eli Bence testifies she asked him for prussic acid and was refused.

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Evening Journal · 29 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

MORE NEW EVIDENCE.

Sensational Testimony in the Fall River Case.

See moreSee less

TRIED TO BUY PRUSSIC ACID.

Two Witnesses Describe the Scene at the House After the Murder. The Prisoner Was Much Agitated—Details of the Hearing.

[By Telegraph to the Evening Journal.

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug 29.—The hearing in the Borden case was continued today. Lizzie passed a fairly restful night and at an early hour this morning was visited by her sister, Emma, who stayed with her till the hour for court arrived.

Mrs. A. B. Churchill was the first witness called. She lives next to the Bordens on the north side of the street and she remembered well the first day of the tragedy. She first remembered of her attention being called to the affair when she saw Bridget going for Dr. Bowen. About the same time she saw Lizzie standing against the side of the door, apparently distressed about something.

"Somebody Has Killed Father."

"I opened the window and asked her what was the matter and she said, 'Oh, Mrs. Churchill, do come over, somebody has killed father.'

"I went over and asked her where her father was and she replied, 'in the sitting room.' I asked her where she was when it happened and she said she was in the barn looking for something for sinkers."

The time, as near as witness could recollect, was about 11 o'clock. Witness asked Lizzie where her mother was, and she said her mother had a note to go somewhere, but she did not know but that she had been killed too She wished somebody would go and try to find her, for she thought she had come in since. She said her father must have had an enemy, for everyone in the house had been sick.

Lizzie Was Much Agitated.

Mr. Jennings subjected Mrs. Churchill to a severe cross-examination. Witness said that when she got inside the house Lizzie was so much agitated that she fanned her, fearing that she would faint.

Witness could not remember that there was the least sign of blood on Lizzie's dress, hands or face at the time she first saw her; her hair was "done up" and appeared not to be disarranged in the slightest and there was no indication by anything in her appearance that any changes had been made since she arose.

Sensational Testimony.

Miss Alice M. Russell, the next witness said she had known Lizzie about eleven years. She thought on the day of the murder that it was 11.15 o'clock when she first heard of the affair. She went to the house and found Lizzie leaning against the door. Witness could not remember how Lizzie was dressed but did remember Lizzie telling her in answer to a question that she went into the barn to get a piece of iron or tin to fix a window with. This testimony created a sensation.

Witness could not tell which window she wanted to fix. Witness was a frequent visitor at the Borden house and always was received in the guest room. Sometimes she would go three times a week, sometimes two or three weeks would elapse before she would go, and she never remembered seeing Mrs. Borden in that room. It was quite evident that the evidence of Miss Russell had made considerable impression on the defense, and when she had finished her direct examination Lizzie's counsel put their heads together and allowed the witness to sit down for a moment. On cross-examination Miss Russell said she bathed Lizzie's face after she went in and saw no signs of blood on it, nor did she see any on any of her clothing. She could see no signs of any undue exertion about Lizzie, nor was she panting as though exhausted. Witness was positive that Lizzie did not go up stairs before the officers, because she remembered the officers asking her questions.

She remembered the officers going up to Lizzie's room and finding it locked; of their pulling the door open, and of her questioning to be allowed to look in first because she did not know what condition it was in; she looked in and finding it all right she let them in.

The Yard Was Watched.

Miss Lucy Collet testified that she was stopping at Dr. Chagon's house on the day of the murder from 11.10 until 12 o'clock noon; and sat on the piazza all the time because from where she sat she said she could see all the yard of the Bordens. During the time she was there, she saw no one passing in the yard. On cross-examination witness admitted that she was where she could not see the whole of the Borden yard, but she was sure that if anybody had entered the yard she would have heard them. A recess was then taken.

Tried to Buy Prussic Acid.

Bulletin, 3.5.—Eli Bence, a drug clerk, has testified that Lizzie Borden called at his store three times the day before the murder for prussic acid and was refused.

See the clipping

The chemist finds no poison and little blood

Professor Wood’s report gives the prosecution little: no poison in the stomachs, no blood on the hatchet or the axes, and the hair on the hatchet ‘not human hair’. One spot of blood on a white skirt was ‘about the size of a pin head’. The defense adds that Lizzie denies ever being at the drug store. Wood told the trial jury the same.

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The Evening World · 30 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A PIN-SPOT OF BLOOD.

All That the Experts Found on Lizzie Borden's Clothes.

See moreSee less

Axes Not Bloodstained — Hair on the Hatchet Not Human.

And No Poison Found in the Stomachs of the Murdered Pair.

[BY ASSOCIATED PRESS.]

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 30.—Defendant's lawyers, who are preparing many arguments showing plausible reasons for believing in Miss Lizzie Borden's innocence of murder, are given as authorities for the following:

Miss Lizzie Borden probably heard her mother struck down, perhaps heard her fall. She (Miss Lizzie) was busy clattering about the house, putting irons on the fire and pounding them on her ironing board. Hearing her mother fall would readily account for readiness to say that Miss Borden had entered the house, slammed the front door and gone directly to her room.

Bridget Sullivan did not see Mr. Borden leave the house or yard, and it does not seem improbable that the others should not have seen any stranger or peddler enter or leave through the back screen door.

Miss Lizzie Borden denies positively that she was ever at D. R. Smith's drug store, where Eli Bence is clerk.

Court opened at 10.30 precisely this morning and the first witness called was Prof. Edward S. Wood, the man for whom everybody has been looking for days.

He said he had received a package containing two stomachs on the 5th of August and two jars containing milk used on the 4th and 5th of August.

The stomachs were labelled "Mr." and "Mrs." Borden. They appeared to be perfectly natural. Mrs. Borden's stomach contained about eleven ounces of solid food; the food was partially digested and showed wheat, starch and meat. The digestion seemed to be advanced in the neighborhood of two and a half hours, more or less. The stomach was tested for prussic acid, but with a negative result.

The stomach of Mr. Borden contained only six ounces, chiefly water. In Mr. Borden's stomach there was only a small portion of starch. The digestion in his case, the contents being nearly all water, was much further advanced than in the case of Mrs. Borden. There were a few threads of vegetable tissue in his stomach which might have been apple, but could have been pears.

Witness had not analyzed the milk and could not report on that.

On the 10th of August he received from Dr. Dolan a hatchet, two axes, a blue dress skirt, dress waist, white starched skirt, lounge cover and three small envelopes in which were hair taken from Mr. and Mrs. Borden and hair taken from the hatchet.

On Aug. 16 witness received a pair of black stockings.

The hatchet contained a number of suspicious looking spots, but careful examination showed no traces of blood. Every spot which looked like blood was examined, but no traces of blood were seen.

A big smooch on the blue skirt looked like blood, but was found not to be. The white skirt had one spot which looked like blood and was found to be. It was directly in front, about six inches from the bottom. The carpet was blood-stained (this was the sitting-room carpet) and there was blood, of course, on that. There was no blood on the lounge cover.

The envelope marked "Hair from A. J. Borden" was simply white hair; Mrs. Borden's was dark.

The hair on the hatchet was not human hair. (Sensation.) Was more like that taken from an animal.

The spot on the right shoe was not blood and there was no blood on either shoes or stockings.

There was nothing on the two axes. Near the edge of the hatchet were spots which seemed to be blood, but were found not to be. There was a spatter on the blade, but it was not blood, and there were spots on the side of the head of the hatchet which looked like blood, but were not. (Hatchet produced in court and Lizzie examined it with as much interest as did her counsel.)

One paper was produced by witness on which was written "Hair," placed at (time mentioned), but no hair was there.

On cross-examination Prof. Wood said that the spot on the white skirt looked larger on the outside than on the inside. The size of the spot was about the size of a pin head.

Q. This you say was human blood? A. I don't know; I did not say so. I have not examined it.

Q. Could you tell in what direction this blood came when it struck the skirt? A. I could not.

After some general testimony about the bloodspots on the wall in the room where Mr. Borden lay, and about bloodspurts from arteries, Prof. Wood said it appeared to him that the murderer stood in the dining-room when the first blow was given; this because of the spot found on the frame of the dining-room door.

(Here witness was allowed to look at the stain on the piece of door frame, under his glass, and resuming the stand, said it was not blood.)

A smaller hatchet was handed to the witness, but he said he could not examine it in so short a time as was allowed him. He had spent six or eight hours on the other one. He said there was rust on this one, and rust spots might always be taken for blood until examined. The hatchet was put in his care for full examination.

Witness said it would be impossible for the murderer to escape getting blood on his body in some way. The stains on the sitting-room door might have gone over the head of the assailant as the instrument was lifted. The blood would hit the assailant from the knees up, and the blood on the assailant in the case of Mrs. Borden would be shown anywhere above the feet.

Some controversy arose over a piece of plaster on which a spot of blood was; the plaster was handed over to Prof. Wood for examination, but Mr. Jennings objected, saying that he would not allow it to go out of his possession unless he could be assured that the blood stain would be left where it was. He was willing to admit it was human blood and leave the plaster in the possession of the Court.

The District-Attorney then requested Marshal Hilliard, since it appeared to have come to a matter of physical force, to remove the piece of wood shown on which were blood-stains before they were taken away.

Mr. Jennings asked the Court if he could have the assurance that the plaster would be retained in the custody of the Court, and the Court refused to give that assurance. Then Mr. Jennings quietly put the plaster in his pocket.

See the clipping

Held for the grand jury

At the close of the hearing the judge, his voice choked and his eyes wet, tells Lizzie Borden ‘you are probably guilty’. She stands without help to hear the order, and tells Mr. Buck it is for the best, since an exoneration in a higher court would be complete. The grand jury indicted her in December; the trial jury acquitted her in June 1893.

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Providence News · 2 September 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN STANDS UP TO BE COMMITTED.

IN TAUNTON JAIL.

The Courtain Drops on the Borden Tragedy.

See moreSee less

TO RAISE IN NOVEMBER

Two Acts Have Been Played Out to Their Close.

IS SHE GUILTY OR INNOCENT.

Public Opinion is Still Fluctuating -- Lizzie Borden Takes the Prospect of two Months in Jail Very Calmly --"It is Best," She Says, "That Exhoneration Should Come From the Higher Court."

[SPECIAL TO THE NEWS.]

FALL RIVER, Sept. 2.--There are still various shades of opinion on the Borden case ranging from the inspired believer in Lizzie's innocence to those who are confident that she is the one described by Mr. Jennings as either "Insane" or inspired by "hatred as black as hell itself."

Whichever may be the true view, and undoubtedly one or the other is true, for there is no middle ground in a case like this, may never be known, but the final judgment of the highest tribunal is still some months away and the public must accept what it has as the full evidence until more is shown.

It is the office of the reporter to portray facts and describe public opinion of them. That has been the aim of this column, and the fact that in neither of the arguments presented yesterday was there any new thought developed is conclusive evidence that the readers of the NEWS have had access to all the evidence that has been available.

The pleas of the opposing attorneys yesterday were as different as it was possible to conceive. Both were specimens of keen logic and each made the best possible presentation of his view of the case. Of the two that of Mr. Jennings was the more eloquent and effective on the audience.

It was an address wherein the array of facts in his client's favor, the disproof of all the theories of the prosecution, and the appeals to humanity and mercy were blended with the nicest precision and voiced by a man whose inspiration was his soulful conviction that the defendant is innocent.

The points that he made have already been detailed the possibilities of someone else being there, as shown by the unsolved burglaries. The absence of blood and the failure to find a weapon were emphasized yesterday by the obvious fact that Miss Borden was ill on Wednesday morning. Her mother said so, she said so and Bridget said so. On that morning she was in her room and hence she did not go out and try to buy prussic acid on that day Mr. Bence said. This somewhat effectually disposes of the prussic acid motive theory, so far at least as present evidence goes. It leaves the government with absolutely nothing in the way of fact to prove Lizzie's guilt, except her presence at the house, her opportunity to commit the murder and her own unintelligible account of her acts and statements.

Unfortunately for her, while these are plainly inadequate as positive evidence of guilt, they are adequate ground for suspicion--and that is the ground which Mr. Knowlton took in his plea for the prosecution. It was repeated again and again and emphasized forcibly that he at no time considered that he had proofs of her guilt. He would be prepared to prove that when it became necessary. All that he wished to do at that hearing was to establish good evidence for strong suspicion and he claimed to have done it.

He claimed that the wounds were not those caused by great force and they were not. He stated that they were those of a timid irresolute hand and the evidence of Dr. Draper was convincing that no one of the first eight wounds were "necessarily fatal."

It was this damaging evidence that Mr. Adams very thoughtlessly brought out in his cross-questioning. It had been claimed by the prosecution that the blows were crushing, heavy blows. Dr. Dolan had testified to that fact and it was of material advantage to the defence that that fact should be established.

But it was entirely refuted by Dr. Draper. The blows were light. Only in one instance in Mr. Borden's case was there a blow sufficiently strong to cut through bone one-sixteenth of an inch in thickness.

Such blows were possible by a woman, and Attorney Knowlton was shrewd enough to make a strong point of this fact, that the nature of the wounds was such as to warrant the statement that they must have been made by a feminine hand: that being struck in the back, they were the work of a moral coward who did not dare face the unfortunate victim.

Mr. Knowlton also made it plain that the front door at least was locked until Mr. Borden returned at about half past nine. Bridget was out washing windows and Lizzie was alone with her mother upstairs. And that was the time when her mother was killed.

It is extremely improbable that anyone could have entered the house while Bridget was washing windows. This more than gives Lizzie "opportunity;" it gives her the only opportunity thus far known and she does not attempt to prove an alibi at that time. Her alibi only applies to the time when her father was killed, and that is such a halting one that it surpasses credulity to use the words of Mr. Knowlton.

That these circumstances are sufficient to prove suspicion there can be little doubt, and having proved suspicion the case of the government is finished.

Side Lights on the Case--Insanity.

Of the side lights yesterday let in on the case two are important. One applies to Mr. Knowlton's public admission that the government had a great deal more evidence than it had used, and that is undoubtedly true. There is evidence in this case which has been given to parties in confidence that is very strong, though entirely circumstantial and indirect in its character. It will be used when necessary and not before.

The second side light, so to speak, relates to Mr. Jennings statement that the murderer "must be insane." That is not a meaningless phrase. It is a statement of fact as it exists. But it is more than that. It is the utterance of an inspired prophet. It is in short the prophecy of the line which the defence will adopt should convicting evidence be shown against Lizzie. Bear in mind that Mr. Jennings was not called upon to make this statement. It had little to do with his argument. It neither aided nor hindered his plea at the hearing. It was a gratuitous admission on his part, and it shows, perhaps, stronger than anything else the turn which his mind is taking in the case.

His plea will be insanity. In this he has but confirmed the presentation of the facts made in Saturday's NEWS that Miss Borden has those characteristics, not only of action but of feature and expression, that give the strongest grounds for doubting her entire sanity under all circumstances.

How Lizzie Received the News.

The scene in the court room was affecting yesterday afternoon when the end of the hearing was reached. The judge's voice was choked with grief and his eyes were filled with tears as he uttered the words "you are probably guilty."

The words were received by the prisoner without a movement. She sat quietly in her seat until called upon to stand while the clerk read the order of the court. Then she stood without assistance and as quietly received the decision of the judge. Words of sympathy were heard on all sides, and when Mr. Buck spoke to her she interrupted him by saying:

"It is for the best, I think. It is better that I should get my exoneration in a higher court, for then it will be complete."

John V. Morse and Bridget Sullivan were ordered to furnish bonds to the amount of $500 each for appearance at the November term of the grand jury. They readily obtained the amounts, John C. Milne and Frank Almy going bail for both.

There being nothing further to do, Miss Lizzie arose, took the proffered arm of the Rev. Mr. Buck and walked resolutely along the corridor to the matron's room, followed by Mrs. Brigham, who was on the border of hysteria, so grief-stricken was she.

Miss Emma awaited her sister in the matron's room and Mr. Buck soon left them together.

The Inquest Not Ended.

It has been stated in the morning papers that the first act in the Borden case is finished. The statement is misleading, for it conveys the idea that the prosecuting authorities will rest. Such, however, is not the case.

The inquest is not yet finished, and no time has been set for its end. It will be continued so long as any suspicious circumstances or characters can be found and examined.

LIZZIE BORDEN STANDS UP TO BE COMMITTED.

See the clipping

A man seen jumping the back fence

A Taunton dispatch names the defense’s most important witnesses: Mrs. Marshall and her daughter, who say that on the day of the murders they saw a ‘villainous looking man’ jump the Bordens’ back fence and drive off in a waiting buggy. In mourning for her husband, she had not come forward at the hearing. The police, it says, treated her clue as from an ‘untrustworthy source’.

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The Sun · 6 September 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

IN LIZZIE BORDEN'S DEFENCE.

A Woman Who Says She Saw a Villainous Looking Man on the Premises.

See moreSee less

TAUNTON, Sept. 5.—Mrs. Marshall and her daughter will be the most important witnesses for the defence of Lizzie Borden.

She said to-day that on the morning of the tragedy she and her daughter drove down Third street shortly after 11 o'clock and saw a villainous looking man jump over the Borden back fence, hurry through Dr. Chagnon's yard, jump into a buggy that was in waiting and drive away.

They paid no attention to it at the time, but half an hour later they drove through Second street and saw a crowd in front of the house, and heard that a murder had been committed.

Before any suspicion had rested on Lizzie Borden, Mrs. Marshall had told friends about the man she had seen jump over the back fence. Mrs. Marshall is a woman of unquestioned veracity, and her daughter's word will have equal weight.

She was asked to-night why she had not appeared at the preliminary hearing in the case, and her deep mourning, together with the statement that she had just buried her husbahd, was an explanation of her ignorance of the course events had taken. She did not know how important her testimony would have been at the hearing.

The police at Fall River were informed of the nature of Mrs. Marshall's statements a few days ago, but they apparently ignored the clue which, she gave them and intimated that it was from an untrustworthy source.

See the clipping

A Providence lawyer and her father’s property

Summarizing a Globe story, this dispatch says the state can prove Lizzie Borden twice went to Providence by way of New Bedford, six months and then two weeks before the murders, to ask a lawyer how her father’s property would pass at his death. Shipping tags are said to place her there. The paper reads it as another link in the state’s case for a motive.

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Evening Journal · 21 September 1892 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

THE BORDEN MURDERS.

New Evidence That the Prosecution Will Introduce Against Lizzie.

See moreSee less

FALL RIVER, Mass., Sept. 21.—The Globe publishes an array of facts bearing on the Borden case, of which the following is a summary: The state is ready to prove that six months before the murders Lizzie Borden went to Providence by way of New Bedford, and there consulted with a lawyer as to the possible disposition of her father's property in the event of his death, and more particularly as to its disposition as affecting her. This man is one of the best known lawyers in Rhode Island and has held several political offices.

He asked Miss Borden where she lived. When she said Fall River he told her he would not be able to give her an answer at once, but if she would call again later he would have looked up Massachusetts' law and would be able to advise her. Two weeks before the murder she again went to Providence via New Bedford and received all the information the lawyer could give her. Then she went to several stores in Providence and made purchases, directing that they be shipped to her home. The police are in possession of shipping tags showing that Miss Borden was in Providence on the day indicated.

When the story of the murders was published the lawyer recalled his client of two weeks previous. On the last day of the preliminary hearing he was in the district courtroom and stood face to face with the prisoner. Recognition was mutual, and the lawyer determined then to go on the witness stand and testify as to the interviews when the proper time arrived. These facts are construed to mean that the state has discovered another link in bolstering up their construction of a motive for the crimes.

See the clipping

The police stand by the lawyer story

Despite positive denials and sharp criticism from the press, the Fall River police say the published account of the Providence lawyer is ‘substantially correct’, and the city marshal promises to deal severely with whoever leaked it. Local papers name the lawyer as Lycurgus Sales, though it is doubted that he can be called to testify.

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Morning Journal and Courier · 23 September 1892 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

THE STORY RE-AFFIRMED. The Police Say That Lizzie Borden Did Consult a Lawyer About the Division of Her Father's Estate. FALL RIVER, Mass., Sept. 22.—Despite positive denials of the Providence lawyer episode in the Lizzie Borden case, also the severe criticism made by local and out-of-town papers, the police authorities say tonight that the statements already published are substantially correct. They cannot account for the leak of a party of the investigation by the officers and the city marshal has said that he will deal severely with the person who gave out the information, should he be found.

See moreSee less

There is much doubt here as to whether the lawyer consulted by Miss Borden can be called to testify. It is currently rumored and was published in the local papers tonight that Lycurgus Sales was the lawyer consulted.

See the clipping

A writer’s theory of how she did it

Reprinted from the New York Herald, A. Curtis Bond says the question among those who study the case is not whether Lizzie Borden is guilty but how she did it. He thinks the prussic acid story, if of any value, has that value ‘in clearing rather than in condemning Lizzie’, and finds a reason in her father’s ‘grinding parsimony’. The jury acquitted her nine months later.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 29 September 1892 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

DID SHE STRIP TO STRIKE?

One Presumption That Points to Lizzie Borden's Guilt.

See moreSee less

She May Have Removed Her Clothing and Thus Avoided All Suspicious Blood Stains While Perpetrating the Double Crime.

A. Curtis Bond in N. Y. Herald.

The speculation among those who have looked at the credible side of the Borden mystery is not whether Lizzie Borden is guilty, but how she committed the crime and how she did it so cleverly as to escape thus far absolute detection.

Up to this time there has been no attempt to show how the murder was done, but merely to demonstrate that no one other than Lizzie Borden was in a position to do it, and yet the strongest points that have thus far been made against the girl are not strong at all when dissected, and the plausible explanation has been overlooked altogether.

The importance attached to the attempted purchase of prussic acid is entirely misplaced, and if of any value whatsoever, has that value in clearing rather than in condemning Lizzie. The district attorney claims that Lizzie's first idea was to destroy her father and step-mother by poison, but when she discovered on Wednesday afternoon the impossibility of procuring the poison, she then changed her plans and resolved to use an axe.

This is incredible and impossible. Whoever did that murder arranged for it further ahead than from Wednesday afternoon to Thursday morning. If Lizzie did it, she had long before settled on the means with which to do it, the disposition to be made of her blood-stained clothing and the weapon used, so as to battle the closest search of shrewd officers. This required much more time than from Wednesday afternoon till Thursday morning at 9.30 o'clock to provide for.

PRECEDENTS.

The sentimental argument against a woman indulging in such butchery will not hold—we are dealing with an extraordinary woman. And even with the commonplace woman there are precedents to prove the instability of this sentiment. Mrs. Druse was hanged in New York state a few years ago for murdering her husband in precisely this same manner, Governor Hill declining to commute her sentence.

How, then, did Lizzie Borden kill her father and stepmother and what led to it?

That Mr. Borden deserved some such summary removal may be no excuse for the deed, but it furnishes a reason. His grinding parsimony and brutal selfishness had ruined the life of his two daughters, had deprived them of all opportunities for pleasure and had interfered forever with their chances of marriage. Lizzie Borden in all probability wished to enjoy life. She had seen Europe once; she realized what living is and what there was beyond the confines of Fall River. But her father was immovable; he could find no reason why she should have anything, see anything, do anything, other than what suited his narrow views. This unnecessary restraint finally so affected her, her mind became so fevered over its mental imprisonment, that she became irresponsible and sought relief by breaking down the iron selfishness that held her just as an every day prisoner would break down the stone walls that hold him.

That was the reason.

An having the reason Lizzie planned accordingly.

THE METHOD.

When Mrs. Borden went to the room that had been occupied by their guest the night before in order to make the bed and otherwise put it in order, Lizzie followed and proceeded to her own apartment, where she already had the axe selected for the deed. Reaching here she removed her clothing, even to her shoes and stockings, for it will be remembered Dr. Wood examined these latter with the same care he did her dress, seeking blood stains. Thus prepared she stepped noiselessly into the guest's room and struck Mrs. Borden on the head with the axe, felling her to the floor.

All the suppressed resentment against her stepmother's symathetic selfishness with her father that had helped to make Lizzie's life miserable then broke forth, and she buried the weapon again and again in the unresisting body that lay before her.

During this time she stood with her foot on either side of the body, as the physicians' evidence at the inquest showed was necessary in order that the blows be delivered as they were, and before the blood had coursed along the carpet sufficiently to stain her feet and thus leave footprints as she left the room she had concluded her work and withdrew.

THREW OUT THE WATER.

She then returned to her room, washed the spattering blood stains from her flesh, dressed again and went down stairs. According to the testimony of the neighbors and others familiar with the household arrangements there it was customary for the Bordens to throw their waste water on the grass, and the porous earth would quickly absorb the reddened basinful Lizzie had removed from her limbs and body.

It is a significant fact that whoever committed this deed, conceding that a doubt may exist in some minds as to the integrity of my conclusions, left no footprints behind when he or she stepped from the room whose floor was saturated with the life blood of Mrs. Borden.

When Mr. Borden entered and took his place upon the lounge it was no more difficult matter for Lizzie to disrobe a second time in the dining room or kitchen adjoining the parlor where her father lay, and repeat upon her father the deed that had already taken place above.

The weapon was then either dropped in a hole already prepared for its reception in the yard, the earth thrown back and a sod neatly placed above it, or else a loosened board was lifted in the floor, and there the axe rests to-day.

Accepting this solution of the mystery, Bridget Sullivan's puzzling evidence that Lizzie wore the same dress immediately after the murders that she did immediately before becomes less puzzling, and the strained explanation by the prosecution that Lizzie indulged in the folly of a duplicate dress of the same pattern becomes useless.

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: Husband and Wife Butchered