As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · The full archive

August 1892, part 3

250 articles

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Mrs. Brigham, Lizzie Borden's lifelong close friend, gives an interview denying reports of unhappiness between Lizzie and her father and stepmother. She insists Lizzie described her recent years as her happiest and dismisses as false the claim that Lizzie refused to sit at the table with her father.

Pawtucket Tribune · 20 August 1892 · page 1

MR. BORDEN LOVED LIZZIE

given a publie reception in the pavilion, Coand 7 iof Arthnr skotehed the hetore arlofo(hc lita They weot to the ol nal street primary school together; they weore px.,m.&. ? chjldren, companlons a 8 young girls and close friends as grown womegp. flcxt to Lizzie Borden speaking for her solf, thorefore, Mra. Brigham can best of 81l others now living, speak for her. Thus far she has remalned silent—has spoken to no one for publication; bat yesterday,

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

An anonymous friend of Lizzie Borden gives an interview denying rumors of unhappiness, estrangement, financial stinginess, or insanity in the Borden household. The friend insists Lizzie was generous, even-tempered, well cared for, and loved by her father.

Pawtucket Tribune · 20 August 1892 · page 1

oould be. “Mr. Borden was, as they say, not a demonstrative man, but e Loved Ilis Daughters ond showed {t at such times when they eamo back after being away. He did not like them to be away from home. I oonld ‘g!ve you very many illustrations of this, showing lzzle's kind conaideration for her tother and be for her. “Now as to Mrs, Borden. While she was a 8 very good woman, she was not at all affectionate or calculated to draw the ohiliren to her. She was simply mild and goo I,and so long as things went smoothly she would have very little to say about the hoase.

See moreSee less

So that this should not be taken as proof of any bitterness of feeling between them, for there was none. “Lizzie Borden was a kind and generous girl—very generons—who would do any

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

An acquaintance defends Lizzie Borden against rumors that she was financially stinted or mentally unstable, describing her as generous, even-tempered, and well provided for. The speaker also affirms the belief that Mrs. Borden was killed before Mr. Borden, explaining Lizzie's lack of tears as shock rather than guilt.

Pawtucket Tribune · 20 August 1892 · page 1

MR. BORDEN LOVED LIZZIE.

A Girl of Very Even Tompor, Bhe nevor beeame excited. She had ideas, spoke them quietly and clearly. She could not be insane for the instant of commit ting the murder, and then return to her own normal self instantly—and afcer each of the two murders, for {think Mrs. Bor dea was murdered first, as do the others. “Her conduct since the murder has been just what anyone who knew her would expeet. They speak of her dry eyes. 'ls ft not all too awful to cry about? We might weep,ns all of us have, for the death of Mr. and Mra. Borden, but this, this is too terrible; even I cannot weep in fuce of it. Hor pride was touched at the first sign of suspicion being directed against

See the clipping

Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.

The bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden were buried on order of Medical Examiner Dolan, with cemetery employees handling the burial and no family members present. Dolan stated that the bloody clothing had been sent to Boston, though he could not say when it would be returned.

Martinsburg Independent · 20 August 1892 · page 2

The Bordens Buried

day afternoon Judge Biddle appointed Edward H. Clapp and Benjamin F. Dennisson appraisers of the assigned es tate of the Mutual Banking, Surety, Trust and Safe Deposit Company. The application was made on the petition of A. E. Stock well, assignee of the banking company. The petition simply set out the fact that the assignment was made, and asked that the appraisers be appointed. An inventory has not yet been filed. The Bordens Buried.

See the clipping

Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.

Lizzie Borden appeared before Judge Blaisdell and was compelled to personally enter a plea, stating "not guilty" with emphasis. She was remanded without bail and transported to the jail in Taunton.

Martinsburg Independent · 20 August 1892 · page 2

-„ Miss Bordeu Held for Murder. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 13.—Miss Lizzie Borden was given a hearing be fore Judge Blaisdell yesterday morning. The prosecution forced her to plead not guilty personally, which she aid in a distinct voice, jjlaoing emphasis on the word “not." She was then remanded to prison without bail. Miss Borden arrived at the jail in Taunton in the afternoon.___

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

This item compiles editorial reactions from papers across the country on Lizzie Borden's arrest and imprisonment for the Fall River murders. Opinions vary widely, with some questioning the evidence against her and others noting the case remains unsolved despite her arrest.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 21 August 1892 · page 4

THE BORDEN TRAGEDY

Dover (Del.) State SentineL American protection may „be judged by its works. Factories in full opera tion, wages the highest in the world, prices the lowest ever recorded in this country, and a measure of national pros perity that is the marvel of modem civilization. American free trade is known only by its promises; unrestrict ed importations from Europe, a cheap ening of workingmen's labor, the aban donment of American industries and a general derangement and paralysis of business. ■ .. — -■■ fc *•-•■ ;; j THE BORDER TRAGEDY. I Miss Lizzie Borden, being now be i hind prison bars, may thank her stars on having found a sanctuary from the sleuth hounds of the press.— New York Telegram.

See moreSee less

.It is a grave charge to accuse a daugh ter of killing her father because the de tectives cannot find the murderer. — Chicago Inter Ocean.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper

The report says authorities await verification of a witness's account that Lizzie Borden wished her father dead, while public sentiment has shifted from supporting her to backing police. It also notes the preliminary examination begins today, with about 30 witnesses summoned and the defense planning no evidence but to argue insufficient grounds for trial.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 22 August 1892 · page 2

Sentiment In Favor of the Police The Examination Beglna T.o-Dav. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 22. The au thorities are now awaiting with much interest the return of George W. Hatha way from his trip on the cape, for a veri fication of the story he told at Craigville, that Lizzie Borden had said she wished that her father was dead. The sentiment in the city, which early in the week was on the side of the de fendant, has, during the past few days, rapidly drifted to the support of the po lice officials.

See moreSee less

Lizzie's supporters are not doing much talking of late, but are working under cover and In conjunction with Attorney Jennings, in building up a defence. Part of the government's case will go in at the examination to-day, but the best part of it will probably not. The defence will not produce any evi dence, but depend upon an argument that the government s case does not war rant the holding for the grand jury. H.mma Borden and J. U. Morse are now making preparations to leave the old house on Second street where the murder was committed, and will move to a much more modern house 011 June street. It is pleasantly situated on a hill above the main streets; and is much more congenial than the Second street house. lhe old house will be offered for rental, and, if not capable of being let, eventual ly will be torn down. About 3o witnesses have been summon ed for the examination. District-Attorney Knowlton will conduct the case for the State and Andrew J. Jennings will defend the prisoner. The defense has secured the services of Melvin O. Adams, the well known Boston criminal lawyer to assist Mr. Jennings. "

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa. · 22 August 1892

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Lizzie Borden arrived in Fall River from Taunton jail for a preliminary hearing on a murder charge, showing no visible distress. Reports indicate she has assigned her personal property to her counsel to fund her defense, with her sister Emma also pledging support.

Evening Journal · 22 August 1892 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN IN FALL RIVER. Sbe Is Iteturned for a Preliminary Hear ing-Active Measures for Defence. [By Telegraph to the Evening Journal.] Fall River. Mass., Aug. 88.— Miss Lizzie A. Borden arrived here at 10.65 this morning from Taunton jail and will he given a preliminary hearing on n charge of murder this afternoon, Iw ginning at 3 o'clock. She did not show the slightest trace of suffering and did not in any degree mind the attention site was attracting. It is reported here this morning that Miss Borden has made an assignment of all her personal property to her council, wit it instructions to spare no expense in gaining her freedom. Miss Emma Borden has also given orders to spare nothing in the way of labor and expense.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A report describes how miner Lindsay, blamed for unrest at Coal Creek, was seized by a mob and nearly hanged before escaping death by promising to turn state's evidence. The account details his capture, the mob's pursuit, and the tense standoff before a noose was placed around his neck.

Evening Star · 22 August 1892 · page 5

LINDSAY IS ALIVE.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Lizzie Borden arrived in Fall River from Taunton by train and was quietly escorted by police to the matron's room ahead of her afternoon preliminary hearing on murder charges. Crowds gathered early at the courthouse, and it was reported she had given her attorney full authority over her defense, sparing no expense.

Evening Star · 22 August 1892 · page 5

LIZZIE BORDEN IN COURT

escorted to a closed carriage by D~etective Beaver and City Marshal HNttard. The carriage wae driven by a circuitoas route to the Central station, where Miss Borden was handed over to Matron RamAe and taken to the matron's roomn. Her sister, Mrs. Bria, Attorney Jennings and Attorney Adams where in attendanee to re ecive her and they talked tegether for some time. As early as 11 e'eloek prepara-ic== ware ben~ made in the court room for the hern. Insate sallsy occupied by arog crewd oft ilers finely demsed women and sem began to gather as early asell o'elock, and at 122:Mnln reom eseM net be ha. It is reported here this morning that Miss Bode bee amad. an as.m e t an af her personal prgry to her comel, with

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The report states authorities have made no further progress beyond Lizzie Borden's arrest, though minor details seem to support it. Newspapers are filled with stories of family discord, suggesting Lizzie was capable of the crime, including claims she refused to eat with her father and cursed him.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 22 August 1892 · page 1

Das Mordgeheimniß von Fall River

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Lizzie Borden was to appear before the district court in Fall River on a complaint charging her with the murder of her father, Andrew J. Borden, on August 4. Defense attorney Jennings was preparing his case and had summoned witnesses, while prosecution officials were confident in their evidence.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 August 1892 · page 4

ill par i b lm Washington »n S« pt. -»• will | roil'd*' of 1“ brigade LIZZIE BORDEN Nhil? Have d Hearing Today In the District Court at Fall River. ! } IU n i i. \ ugu>t If!At 2 oYloek oil ;

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The World discusses Lizzie Borden's arraignment at Fall River, charged with murdering her father and mother. The piece reflects on the case's immense public interest and the high stakes for both prosecution and accused as proceedings begin.

The Evening World · 22 August 1892 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN TO THE BAR

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden arrived at Fall River from Taunton Jail for a preliminary hearing on the murder charge, drawing large crowds of spectators, officials, and reporters. The hearing was adjourned until Thursday, with reports that she had assigned her property to her lawyer and her sister vowing to spare no expense for her defense.

The Evening World · 22 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN IN COURT.

LIZZIE BORDEN III GDURJ. But Her Hearing at Fall Eiver Adjourned Till Thursday. fBV AfROf tATEIl rRKM.l Fam. Hivkf, Mass., Aug. I!'.'. Miss Llzlo A. llordcn arrived hero from Tauntou Jail at

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A correspondent reports on a man who claims acquaintance with the person who committed the Borden murders but refuses to give names out of fear of assassination. The account describes a weapon, a telegram coincidence, and alleges a gang of thugs framed the dead couple or their relatives, a theory being investigated by Pittsburg police.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pittsburg Dispatch · 22 August 1892 · page 1

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A Pittsburgh newspaper received an unsigned letter claiming Lizzie Borden is innocent and that a serial killer from St. Louis actually murdered her parents. The anonymous writer refused to name the killer, citing fear for his life, and said he wanted to help Lizzie amid mounting circumstantial evidence against her.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 22 August 1892 · page 1

The Pittsburger furnishes this informa tion, he says, to help Miss Borden, who is the victim of a chain of circumstantial evi dence being woven about her bv the officers,

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A letter writer describes an anonymous confession in which an unnamed man allegedly admitted to killing the Bordens and other murders, including a case in Georgia where an innocent man was hanged. Police and newspaper editors investigate the letter's claims, verifying the Woolfolk case details and attempting to trace the author through handwriting comparison.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 22 August 1892 · page 1

was arrested, tried and banged. Now I know this and many other things of this nature to be true, that they have done. I have known them to shoot men and leave their gun by the dead man's side and when they were found it would he pro nounced suicide. Tbe man who killed the Bordens lives in St. Louis and ho told me bororo he lett for the west that he was going to write a letter and send it back to Fall River and let them know that the daughter did not kill her parents.

See moreSee less

But I know that he did not do that br Ivould have heard of it To try to help that poor. Innocent girl out, whom they are trying so nura to nua gunty oi sometmng sue aia not do, I have risked my life and writteu this letter.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A roundup of brief national and local news items includes a one-line note that public sentiment is again turning against Lizzie Borden. No details or reasons are given for this shift in opinion.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 22 August 1892 · page 5

Gener.i'. An Erie passenger locomotive was aeralled, possibly by strikers Governor flower left Albany.. ..Soldiers protected a train at Waverly Prosecution or strikers has begun. ...The Tennessee war Is oyer; another skirmish was fought Sentiment Is again turning against Lizzie Borden..., An Oil City flood victim committed, suicide ....A California murderer was lynched and

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The preliminary hearing in the Borden murder case began in Fall River, with crowds filling the courtroom hours before proceedings started. Lizzie Borden arrived early from Taunton jail accompanied by Rev. E. A. Buck, appearing composed and unaffected by her confinement.

The Providence News · 22 August 1892 · page 1

ISPECIAL TO THE NEWS.| FALL RIVER, Aug. 22.—The court room in which Miss Lizzie Borden is to under go the preliminary hearing on the charge of murdering her father, Andrew J. Borden, began to fill at half-past ten o'clock this morning, although the pro ceedings were not expected to open until two this afternoon. Miss Borden was brought to this city from Taunton jail, arriving on the 10:55 train, some hours earlier than had been expected. She was in charge of City Marshal Hilliard and State Detective Seaver who went to Taunton for that purpose this morning.

See moreSee less

Pastor Buck, who has been her staunch friend from the start, accompanied the accused young woman and as she stepped from the train he gave Ler his arm. Miss Borden wore a blue serge tailor gown, with a white tie and black hat, and showed no ill eflects from her confine ment. Indeed she looked as a bystander exclaimed, ** better than ever.” She was ushered into a closed carriage and driven rapidly to the Central Police Station. Here police guarded the doors and refused entrance to all. Miss Borden went immediately up stairs to the matron’s room, still leaning on the arm of the Rev, E. A, Buck, who carried for her a small satchel. Lizzie's face was set and absolutely ex pressionless. She walked with a firm step and looked neither to the right nor the left. The number of spectators was reduced by the fact that she got to Fall River two hours before she was expected to leave Taunton. Word had been given out that she would come on the 1 o’clock train, The gossip of to-day is that Emma and Lizzie Borden have given Lawyer Jen nings a drpft covering their entire bank account and their whole property, per sonal and real. They mean to fight the case at every point and to the bitter end. The news of Lizzie's arrival quickly spread through the town. A crowd began to gather about the station but officers guarded the stairway and refused en trance to all but reporters, Emma Borden arrived soon after Lizzie. At 12:15 John V., Morse appeared with lunch for Lizzle, which was at once spread before her, BShe had scarcely seated herself when Lawyers Jennings and Adams entered. Emma, Morse and the matron were sent from the room and a secret conference was held in the matron’s room. In about fifteen minutes Emma was called in, The police station was originally used as a fire engine station. The court room is up stairs in the rear and was originally used as a hay loft, and refitted a few yoars ago. § It is a room 30x40 feet in extent, plain furnished and finished in stained wood. It has accommodations for twenty re porters. The officers are noticeably courteous to the press representatives, The few spectators who had gained entrance before a strict guard was put on a door, were allowed to remain., At 1 o'clock some of them sent out and ob tained lunch. They had waited three hours already, but sat patiently waiting till the hands of the clock should point to 2. Now and then a reporter entered, or hurried out to discover the latest move in the case. Occasionally police officers dropped in and chatted, but otherwise the minutes rolled slowly by until about 1:30. By balf past one the street around the court house was crowded, but only a few of the most prominent citizens were ad mitted, The lntense interest shown in the case is evidenced by the presence of the most influential business men in the community in the court room. Many of them left important engage meunts to attend the hearing. Among them were seen the Hon. C. A. Cook, Henry Carragher, School Committeman Brady, City Physician Bt. Germain, the Rev. P. W, Lyman and many others. Long before two o’clock every seat in the court room was taken. Thirty-three reporters filled the space within the rail ing, and the noise of conversation filled the room. As the hands of the clock neared the expected hour the buzz died away and silence gradually came upon both audience and reporters.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Lizzie Borden arrived by train at Fall River accompanied by Rev. E. A. Buck and was taken to the Central Police Station, where she waited with family and lawyers before a scheduled court appearance. The report also describes the courtroom's layout and notes that she and her sister Emma had reportedly given their lawyer full control of their finances to fund the defense.

The Providence News · 22 August 1892 · page 1

Weak an Impulse as That of Hunger. ISPECIAL TO THE NEWS.| FALL RIVER, Aug. 22.—The court room in which Miss Lizzie Borden is to under go the preliminary hearing on the charge of murdering her father, Andrew J. Borden, began to fill at half-past ten o'clock this morning, although the pro ceedings were not expected to open until two this afternoon. Miss Borden was brought to this city from Taunton jail, arriving on the 10:55 train, some hours earlier than had been expected. She was in charge of City Marshal Hilliard and State Detective Seaver who went to Taunton for that purpose this morning.

See moreSee less

Pastor Buck, who has been her staunch friend from the start, accompanied the accused young woman and as she stepped from the train he gave Ler his arm. Miss Borden wore a blue serge tailor gown, with a white tie and black hat, and showed no ill eflects from her confine ment. Indeed she looked as a bystander exclaimed, ** better than ever.” She was ushered into a closed carriage and driven rapidly to the Central Police Station. Here police guarded the doors and refused entrance to all. Miss Borden went immediately up stairs to the matron’s room, still leaning on the arm of the Rev, E. A, Buck, who carried for her a small satchel. Lizzie's face was set and absolutely ex pressionless. She walked with a firm step and looked neither to the right nor the left. The number of spectators was reduced by the fact that she got to Fall River two hours before she was expected to leave Taunton. Word had been given out that she would come on the 1 o’clock train, The gossip of to-day is that Emma and Lizzie Borden have given Lawyer Jen nings a drpft covering their entire bank account and their whole property, per sonal and real. They mean to fight the case at every point and to the bitter end. The news of Lizzie's arrival quickly spread through the town. A crowd began to gather about the station but officers guarded the stairway and refused en trance to all but reporters, Emma Borden arrived soon after Lizzie.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Lizzie Borden was escorted from Taunton jail to Fall River by Rev. Mr. Buck, Marshal Hilliard, and a detective to attend her preliminary hearing. Meanwhile in Fall River, prosecutors and police prepared witnesses for the hearing before Judge Blaisdell, as defense counsel Jennings added Melvin O. Adams to the defense team.

The Providence News · 22 August 1892 · page 1

THE START FROM TAUNTON.

PREPARATIONS FOR THE HEARING. The Second Act in the Borden Tragedy is FALL RIVER, Aug. 22.—The prosecution in the Borden murder case will open its

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A brief newspaper editorial complains that Massachusetts law should be changed so Judge Blaisdell cannot preside over the Lizzie Borden proceedings taking place that day. It is embedded among unrelated snippets of commentary on other current events.

The Providence News · 22 August 1892 · page 4

S ——————— i _+ Taz Old Bay State should make haste ‘%O repeal such laws as make it possible w Judge Blaisdell to preside at the M against Lizzie Borden to-day, L Wt el s e

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A newspaper opinion column mentions that mystery novelist Anna Katharine Green has publicly stated her belief in Lizzie Borden's innocence. The editorial dismisses her view, arguing her fiction-writing background undermines the credibility of her assessment of a real case.

The Providence News · 22 August 1892 · page 4

ANNIE KATHERINE GrEEN, the author of a number of * detective” movels, comes before the public with a statement of her belief in Lizzie Borden's inno

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The Borden murder hearing in Fall River was adjourned until Thursday after defense lawyers demanded that all physical evidence, including stomachs and household items, be produced in court. The government downplayed the adjournment as routine rather than a weakening of its case, while noting the hatchet allegedly used in the murders bore blood matching that found on Lizzie Borden's apron.

Morning Journal and Courier · 23 August 1892 · page 3

BORDEN MURDER TRIAL

Crowds of Women Tne Court Honored Adjourned to Thnrsday. Faix Eiveb, Aug. 23. The adjourn ment of the hearing to-day la generally re garded here as a weakening on the part of the government, bat each Is far from the truth. The government consented to an adjournment beoause defendant's lawyer insisted that Professor Wood and Medical Examiner Dolan should produce in court everything taken from the Borden house hold since the tragedy occurred. This wonld include the stomachs of the deceased persons, carpets, sofa, pillows, pillow shams, portions of the panelling about the rooms, also other evidenoes of the crime.

See moreSee less

The government has been attaching great importance to the hatchet said to have been taken from the Borden house, whioh is also said to have blood oorpusels on it similar to those found upon Miss Lizzie Borden's

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The report describes the preliminary hearing in the Borden case, noting the hatchet allegedly used in the murder and its possible blood traces matching those on Lizzie Borden's apron. It also details the crowded courtroom, the roster of witnesses including Bridget Sullivan, and arrangements made for Lizzie Borden's custody at the police station.

Morning Journal and Courier · 23 August 1892 · page 3

BORDEN MURDER TRIAL

V. Morse, Omcers Harrington, Doherty, Medley, Chsce, Miss Emma Borden, C. C. Cook and D-puty Sheriff Frank Wixon were among those summoned. BRIDGET SULLIVAN THE CHIKF WITNESS. Bridget Sullivan, whose testimony will

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The report describes chaotic scenes as crowds, reporters, and curious spectators packed the courtroom for Lizzie Borden's hearing, with extra furniture brought in and police needed to manage the throng. It also notes Lizzie's improved condition in police custody, eating a hearty supper sent from home.

Morning Journal and Courier · 23 August 1892 · page 3

CURIOUS WOMEN CROWD THE COURT ROOM.

clear the crowds after adjonrnment. Miss Lizzie Borden ate a very hearty sapper to night, sent from her home by her sister and brought down by Mr. Morse, her nncie. rihe is in excellent frame of mind

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Lizzie Borden was brought from Taunton jail to Fall River for her preliminary trial, but it was delayed when District Attorney Knowlton announced Prof. Wood's forensic analysis of the hatchet and stomach contents was not yet complete. The hearing was continued until Thursday, August 25, and Borden remained at the Central police station rather than returning to jail.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 23 August 1892 · page 2

The Prosecution Not Keadv and it Goes Over to Thursday. Fall, Kivkr, Mass., Aug. 23. Lizzie Borden was brought to this city from Taunton jail at 11 yesterday forenoon. An extra detail of police was required to

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

At Fall River, the courtroom was crowded for Lizzie Borden's examination, but District Attorney Knowlton requested an adjournment because certain evidence was not yet fully prepared. Judge Blaisdell postponed the examination until Thursday, August 25, with no objection from Borden's counsel.

Evening Journal · 23 August 1892 · page 2

|_— Ml»« Durden's Trial 1'osl(inned. Fall River, Aug. 23.—Tbo courtroom "bere Blaisdell presides was crowded " ith «hen the examination ol Lizzie Borden came op. District Attorney ^owlummu that cerum evidence not yet fuUy prepared necessitated his askim; an adjournment until Thursday. Aug.3,5. There was no objection from Miss Borden t ,. uunte l, and Judge Blaisdell poatponed the examination until Thursday. .....

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The preliminary hearing against Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother, was adjourned at Fall River until Thursday because evidence including clothing and furnishings was still with experts. District Attorney Knowlton requested the delay, and the defense insisted that all items taken from the household, including the victims' stomachs, be produced in court.

Evening Star · 23 August 1892 · page 7

Dolan should produce in court everything taken from the Borden household since the tragedy occurred. This would include the stomachs of the deceased persons, carpets, sofa, pillows. pillow shams, portions of the paneling about the room and other evidences of the crime. The state has been attaching great impor tance to the hatchet said to have been taken from the Borden house, which is also said to have blood corpuscles on it similar to those found upon Miss Idszie Borden's apron. If these statements are true the prisoner's coun eel propose to learn the facts at an early stage of the trial The state oem are not sur prised at the continuance of the case.

See moreSee less

They ONy they expected Prof. Wood would be in readiness to report, but they are not disposed to hurry the expert investigations, while not putting all their faith in the results. The large number of witnesses summoned wao taken as evidence of earnestness on the part of the state. Bridget Sullivan, the servant girl, whose tes timony will probably acquit or convict the prisoner, was the most important person at the hearing. She was deathly pale from the mo ment Sergt. Ekson handed her to a seat until the adjournment was reached. She is greatly frightened because of the prominence she has secured before the public. When the court adjourned Miss Borden's counsel went Into the matron's room to tell her how the case stood. The prisoner will not be removed until Thursday at least. The scenes in the court room yesterday afternoon were ex traordinary. Women, who usually would never think of entering such a place, crowded and actually quarreled for a chance to sit down. There were several ministers, doctors, lawyers and other professional men who insisted on places of honor. About thirty-fire newspaper workers were crowded into the space usually occupied by three. Miss Lizzie Borden ate a very hearty sup per at night, sent her from her home by her sister and brought down by Mr. Morse. her un cle. She is in a hopeful frame of mind.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

District Attorney Knowlton requests an adjournment because clothing, furnishings, and other evidence are still with experts for examination. The report describes courtroom scenes, the anticipated testimony of servant Bridget Sullivan, and details about the hatchet believed to carry blood evidence.

Evening Star · 23 August 1892 · page 7

THE BORDEN CASE

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing on murder charges was postponed until Thursday because evidence, including clothing and room furnishings, was still with experts. Separately, an anonymous letter published in Pittsburgh claims Lizzie is innocent and that the writer knows one of the men who actually committed the murders.

The Indianapolis Journal · 23 August 1892 · page 3

Miss Lizzie's Preliminary fleering for Mar v der Postponed Till Thursday. Fall Rivkr, Mass., Aug. 22. Miss Lizzie A. Borden arrived bere from Taunton jail this morning to be given a preliminary hear ing on a charge of murder this afternoon, but the case was adjourned untilTbursday. Tbe adjournment was granted on the ground that some things used as evidence in thoi case are wanting 'at the present time. Tbey are the clothing and various parts of the furnishings of the room where the murders occurred. They are now iu the hands of experts and tbey, will not be here before Thursday.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The Pittsburg Dispatch reports an anonymous letter received at a local hotel in which the writer claims to know that two strangers, not Lizzie Borden, committed the Fall River murders. The letter describes a detailed but unverified account of the killings, linking the men to a prior unsolved murder in Georgia, though police are skeptical of its truth and are trying to find the author.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 23 August 1892 · page 5

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Lizzie Borden was brought from the Taunton jail to Fall River for her preliminary hearing, appearing calm and unbothered by the crowd of spectators and reporters. District Attorney Knowlton requested a postponement because evidence items were still with experts, and the judge adjourned the hearing until the following Thursday.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 23 August 1892 · page 5

BORDEN'S IRON NERVES

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Amid a column of miscellaneous items, the paper offers a philosophical aside on the Lizzie Borden case in Fall River, Massachusetts. It speculates that if she committed the murder she must have been insane, and if she did not, she will soon go mad from the ordeal.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 23 August 1892 · page 5

Wenn Lizzie Borden ihren Vater nicht ermordet hat, dann muß sie zur Ehre der Menschheit sei es dann muß sie bald verrückt werden! Zwischen der Temperatur

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Lizzie Borden arrived at Fall River from Taunton jail for her preliminary hearing, but it was adjourned until Thursday due to missing evidence including clothing and room furnishings being examined by experts. She showed no sign of distress and has reportedly assigned her property to fund her legal defense, while a separate anonymous letter claims knowledge of the true killer.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 23 August 1892 · page 4

Fight Hard for Liberty. Faix River, Mass., Aug. 22.— Miss Lizzie Borden arrived here this morn ing from Taunton jail, to begin her preliminary hearing on the charge of murder this afternoon, but later the case was adjourned until Thursday. The adjournment was granted on the ground that some things used as evidence in the case are wanting at the present time. They are the clothing and various parts of tlie furnishings of the rooms where the murders occurred. They axe now in the hands of experts, and will not be here tomorrow nor next day, nor prob ably the day following.

See moreSee less

Miss Borden did not show a trace of suffering and did not in any degree mind the attention she was attracting. It is reported that she has made an as signment of all personal property to her counsel, with instructions to spare no expense in gaiuiug her freedom. Miss Emma Borden has also given orders to spar* nothing in the way of labor and expense. OPittsbubg, Aug. 22.— A morning

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Lizzie Borden was brought from Taunton jail to Fall River for her preliminary hearing, which drew large crowds and numerous reporters. District Attorney Knowlton requested a continuance because Professor Wood's analysis of stomach contents and bloody evidence was not yet complete, so the proceeding was postponed to August 25.

The Evening Herald · 23 August 1892 · page 2

Tlifl Protteriittnn Not Ilenriv and It Goes Over tu IhurMdMjr. Fam. Riveu, Mass., Aug. 23. Lizzie Borden was brought to this city from Taunton jail at 11 yesterday forenoon. An extra detail of police was required to

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

An unnamed correspondent claims to know the identity of the Borden family's murderer, asserting the same man killed the Woolfolk family in Georgia using a small ax. The letter writer alleges that in the Woolfolk case, an innocent son was wrongly hanged after the real killer planted bloody clothing in a well, and The Dispatch is investigating to verify these claims.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pittsburg Dispatch · 23 August 1892 · page 1

A MYSTERY DEEPENS

Disfatcb, who claims to know the mur derer ot the Bordens and Woolfolks, still conceals his identity. The only clew to follow up was contained in the following portion of his letter: "This man and one or two of his friends were in the South about four years ago, and wnile they were in Georgia, near Macon, they had a little tronble with a farmer. So they went to his house one night and killed all of them but his son,and he got away. So they took some of his clothes and threw them, with -blood on them, into the welL The clothes were fonnd, and as they could not find any other clew to work on, the son was arrested, tried and hanged."

See moreSee less

He also stated that the murderer invariably carries a small ax, and with it has disposed of numerous victims. The Dispatch confirmed a portion of the statement. namely, that the clothing of the alleged murderer of theWoolfolk family of Georgia was found in a well, and that the evidence which convicted him was circumstantial. An Ax Used to Kill Hie IVoIfolk". In order to obtain more light, the Macon

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

Detectives in Pittsburgh continue searching for the writer of a mysterious letter related to the case, interviewing hotel staff without success, while officials express skepticism about its authenticity. Meanwhile, Lizzie Borden's preliminary examination in Fall River was postponed until Thursday after the District Attorney requested more time for experts to complete analysis of physical evidence taken from the accused.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 23 August 1892 · page 1

the authenticity of the letter, but, like Detective Bobinson, savs there is a possi bility of its being all the writer claims. Unless some new cine turns up it,is not likely that the local officials will give the matter any further attention for the present Lizzie Borden's Case Postponed. A special from Fall Blver says: The court room where Judge Blaisdell'presides

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

A crowd gathered expecting Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing to continue, but it was postponed until the following Monday. The delay was attributed to Professor Wood, the chemistry expert analyzing clothing and the hatchet for blood evidence, who needed two or three more days to complete his report.

Pawtucket Tribune · 23 August 1892 · page 1

THE LIZZIE BORDEN CASE

Yo De An Interesting One. The secret of yesterdayls move % the fact that the doten: summoned fescor Wood of flarvard ocollege wo "?‘? go the stand with what goods and chattels @ holds {n trust for the state while they are undergoin} examination. It is whispered that the government didu’t care much whether this witnees did or did uos appear at the hearing, and that the attornoys for Miss Borden learned b:P“ the blood stains were so far from belng ocomnpleted that Proftdsor Woo&’a .:uw tment on the wlt.uaz stand wou the

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The preliminary hearing was unexpectedly postponed until the following Monday after the defense summoned Professor Wood of Harvard to testify about blood stain evidence he was analyzing for the state. The delay stemmed from a fifty-minute conference between lawyers, as the defense refused to proceed until Wood's examination was complete, while the prosecution had hoped to avoid revealing the analysis's inconclusive state.

Pawtucket Tribune · 23 August 1892 · page 1

EXPERT WOOD'S EVIDENCE

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

At the preliminary hearing, the defense succeeded in restricting Professor Wood's expert testimony, a move seen as shrewdly protecting the prosecution's case while limiting disclosure to the defense. Separately, a Pittsburgh newspaper published an anonymous letter claiming the writer knew the real killer and that Lizzie Borden was entirely innocent, though police there gave the story little credence.

Pawtucket Tribune · 23 August 1892 · page 1

EXPERT WOOD'S EVIDENCE

murder mystery. e sAye an the party who took t:: Itves of r. and Mres, Borden, but through fear of deatl be oannds maake public she name of thely slayer. e aleo u‘v the mucrderer has beon implicated in m mardors, and thet kis home I 8 fu oula e says Mise Borden is entirely innoceat of the Eln\u of her perenta The police of flcinls here 8o not place muoch aredouoe in the story.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report argues that the lack of developments in the Fall River court proceedings actually favors Lizzie Borden, since no poison traces were found and it couldn't be determined who died first. It suggests the prosecution's premeditation theory may collapse without this evidence, and notes public sympathy remains with the accused.

The Providence News · 23 August 1892 · page 4

It is very significant that no traces of poison have been found by the Harvard college expert who has been chemically examining the internal organs of the murdered people, and that it cannot be determined which died first, if these re ports prove to be facts, 1f it cannot be shown that Mrs. Borden died first the prosecution’s theory of a motive falls to the ground. If the poison theory has to be abandoned there is no just ground upon which to rest a charge of premedi tation. It is almost equally hard to prove that Miss Borden did not kill her parents, it is true, but she is not obliged to prove that at present, She must be considered as not having committed the deed until evidence that she did is brought for ward, And it certainly looks now as if the government would have great diffi culty in producing incriminating evi dence of importance, Public sympathy stands firmly by Miss Borden in Fall River, and the pro secution brings forward nothing better than dark hLints relative to important evidence that is to be forthcoming, but after two weeks it could offer no better excuse for delay than that sundry arti cles from the Borden house had not then been sufficiently examined,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report states that traces of poison found by a Harvard chemist cannot establish which Borden parent died first, undermining the prosecution's theory that Lizzie poisoned them before the axe murders for motive. It notes public sympathy favors Lizzie Borden and criticizes the prosecution for lacking solid evidence after two weeks of investigation.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Providence News · 23 August 1892 · page 4

THE BORDEN CASE. The developments in the Borden case resulting from the proceedings in the District Court at Fall River yesterday, shadowy and unsatisfactory as they were, can scarcely fail to still further prejudice the public mind in favor of the young woman accused of murdering her father, and by inference her mother also, Strictly speaking there were no devel opments; and the very fact that there were none discredits the case of the gov ernment and gives golor to the hope that there is not sufficient evidence in the hands of the government to warrant the holding of the accused for trial, It is very significant that no traces of poison have been found by the Harvard college expert who has been chemically examining the internal organs of the murdered people, and that it cannot be determined which died first, if these re ports prove to be facts, 1f it cannot be shown that Mrs.

See moreSee less

Borden died first the prosecution’s theory of a motive falls to the ground. If the poison theory has to be abandoned there is no just ground upon which to rest a charge of premedi tation. It is almost equally hard to prove that Miss Borden did not kill her parents, it is true, but she is not obliged to prove that at present, She must be considered as not having committed the deed until evidence that she did is brought for ward, And it certainly looks now as if the government would have great diffi culty in producing incriminating evi dence of importance, Public sympathy stands firmly by Miss Borden in Fall River, and the pro secution brings forward nothing better than dark hLints relative to important evidence that is to be forthcoming, but after two weeks it could offer no better excuse for delay than that sundry arti cles from the Borden house had not then been sufficiently examined,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The item remarks that the government's case against Lizzie Borden doesn't seem so certain after all. It notes that those who expected no adjournment in the Borden inquiry are not saying so now, implying an unexpected delay occurred.

The Providence News · 23 August 1892 · page 4

Were so very sure, after all, of its case against Lizzie Borden, Tue person who didn't expect an ad journment in the Borden inguiry doesn't say 80 to-day, THE NEWS, TUESDAY, AUGUST 23 per cent. cheaper ; building and miscel THERE WAS A FAIR LAND.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report notes Lizzie Borden's hearing was continued until Thursday pending expert reports. It also prints a letter from G. W. Hathaway correcting a rumor, clarifying that a story about a daughter's hostility toward her father was about an unrelated Plymouth County family, not Lizzie Borden.

The Providence News · 23 August 1892 · page 6

THE GOVERNMENT NOT READY.

FALL RIVER, Mass, Aug. 23.—The case against Lizzie Borden charged with murdering her father and motber was yesterday continued till Thursday by consent of counsel., At that time & re port from the sxperts is expected. The story of Capt. Orrick Smalley of Noew Bedford, concerning G. W. Hatha way’s statement at Craigville on the Sun day after the Borden murder, has drawn out the following communication from Mr. Hathaway: “On Sunday after the Bordem murders I was sitting on the piazza at Hotel Pal mer, Craigsville, discussing with others

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A letter from Mr. Hathaway clarifies that an earlier published story about a daughter's insane hatred of her father referred to a Plymouth County family, not Lizzie Borden, correcting Capt. Smalley's mistaken account. The report also notes the preliminary hearing's adjournment was due to the defense demanding production of all evidence taken from the Borden house, including organs and the hatchet, while the prosecution awaits expert analysis.

The Providence News · 23 August 1892 · page 6

THE GOVERNMENT NOT READY.

Papa—l bave a little timo this morning, and we'll go down town and get the bicycie I promised you for passing the fchool examination suoccessfully. " Little Son-—1 sa™ two or three girls on bieyeles yesicrday, and [ don’t want any thing that girls ¢an ride. Papa—-Well, what can we do about it? Littie Boy—~l was thinkin’' you might get me a triok mule. aminer Dolan should groduco in court ove:lythlng taken from the Borden house hold since the tragedy occurred. This would include the stomachs of the de ceased persons, urrou, sofa, pillows, Yil low sbams, portions of the panelling about the rooms, also other Evidences of the Crime.

See moreSee less

The government has bien attaching great importance to the hatchet said to have been taken from the Borden house, ‘which is also sald to have blood corpus cles on it similar to thoss found upon Miss Lizzie Borden’s apron. If these

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The preliminary hearing continues amid reports that a hatchet with blood corpuscles matching those on Lizzie Borden's apron is central government evidence, though officials await Professor Wood's expert analysis before proceeding. Numerous witnesses, including neighbors, family, and servant Bridget Sullivan, appeared at the crowded District Court as the case was postponed and Lizzie's lodging arrangements were discussed.

The Providence News · 23 August 1892 · page 6

THE GOVERNMENT NOT READY.

Papa—l bave a little timo this morning, and we'll go down town and get the bicycie I promised you for passing the fchool examination suoccessfully. " Little Son-—1 sa™ two or three girls on bieyeles yesicrday, and [ don’t want any thing that girls ¢an ride. Papa—-Well, what can we do about it? Littie Boy—~l was thinkin’' you might get me a triok mule. of whom were the closest neighbors of the grlnonor, and all of whom would much prefer to have no connection with the case. Charles Bawyer, Hiram Har rington, John V. Morse, Officers Har rington Dohor(t:y, Medley, Chace, Miss Emma Borden C. C. Cook and Deputy Sheriff Frank Wixon were among

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Lizzie Borden spent an uneasy night in the matron's room at Fall River's Central station, though her own bedding and food were brought from home. She was visited by Rev. Mr. Buck with flowers, while detectives including McHenry of Providence continued quietly pursuing minor clues.

The Providence News · 23 August 1892 · page 7

HER RESTLESS NIGHT.

Second Time, a ISPECIAL TO THE NEWS.| FALL RIVER, Aug. 23.—Andrew Borden. T | treasurer of the Merchant’s Mill, has been 1 | asked by Lizzie A. and Emma L. Borden

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Lizzie Borden receives a visit and flowers from Rev. Mr. Buck while in custody, and reportedly resents the district attorney's harsh questioning at the inquest. Police continue working minor clues quietly, and there is speculation that Thursday's examination may be postponed, with reporters having dispersed after the prior session.

The Providence News · 23 August 1892 · page 7

LITTLE NEW AT FALL RIVER. Will the Examination Be Postponed a Second Time.

2 overtaken on his way home from the sta tion about half %uc three yesterday after noon, just after he had parted with Miss Borden, said she was enduring the strain

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A Fall River dispatch reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and mother began amid a crowded courtroom full of women. District Attorney Knowlton stated that clothing and other evidence were still with experts, prompting an immediate adjournment until Thursday.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 23 August 1892 · page 1

{OF telegraph WO 08 JISPRWE.) Farr River, Mass., August 22, ~The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and motber began to-day before a crowded eourt-room, (reat numbers of women were present. District-Attorney Knowlton said the clothing and other |

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A brief news item reports that the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother, was called at Fall River and continued until Thursday. It appears amid a roundup of unrelated national and international news items.

Alexandria Gazette · 23 August 1892 · page 2

NEWS OF THE DAY. Many of the Homestead iron strikers have secured work elsewhere and have left their old homes. t'ueen Victoria has conferred a baronetcy upon Sir Julian Pauncefotc, British minister at Washington. The case of Lizzie Borden, charged with tiie nrnrder of her father and

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's arrival for a preliminary hearing on murder charges, noting her calm demeanor and the crowd gathering at the courthouse. It also recounts a sensational, unverified letter claiming a man confessed to the murders of her father and stepmother.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Times · 23 August 1892 · page 1

this morning prints s sensational anony mous latter written at the Monongahels House in this city, in which the writer as serts that Lizzie Borden is innocent of the murder of her father and stepmother. The author of thestrauge communication gays “JI was in New Yerk when the murder took place, and as soon as | learned that one of these men did it I left and eame to this city. The one who did the act said Le went into the house to get something to eat, and ss be found no one in the front room.

See moreSee less

he went up stairs and went into a room. While he was there the lady came in on him. Bhe ballooed and he hit her with # 1arze knife or ax that he carries in a case

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

Lizzie Borden was transported by train from Taunton to Fall River, arriving calm and veiled, to face a preliminary hearing on murder charges that afternoon. She was escorted by detectives and clergy to the police station, where she met her sister and attorneys before the hearing began.

The Times · 23 August 1892 · page 1

- crf — _— LIZZIE BORDEN IN COURT, Taken to Fall River. A singular Statement from Flttsbarg. Fary River, Mass., August 22,—Miss Liz zie A, Borden arrived here from Taunton at

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

Lizzie Borden is brought to the matron's room ahead of her preliminary hearing, with reports that she and her sister Emma have pledged unlimited funds for her defense. Separately, a Pittsburgh newspaper prints an anonymous letter claiming a drifter, not Lizzie, committed the murders during a robbery.

The Times · 23 August 1892 · page 1

A STRANGE STORY FROM PITTSBURG

a I a ———— usually occupied by a rough erowd of idlers finuly dressed women and men began to gother as early as 12 o'clock, and at 12:20 standing room could not be ha®. Its reported Bere this morning that Miss Bor. den has made an assignment of all of her personal property to her counsel, with the 108truetions to spare no expense in gaining ber freedom, Miss Emma Borden has also given orders to spare nothing in the way of

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

A sensational anonymous letter written at a Pittsburgh hotel claims Lizzie Borden is innocent and describes a mysterious man who killed her father to avoid being identified, also linking him to an unrelated Georgia murder case. Police are skeptical of the letter's authenticity but are trying to track down its author.

The Times · 23 August 1892 · page 1

A STRANGE STORY FROM PITTSBURG

Prrrapuna, Pa., August 22.—The Dispatch this morning prints s sensational anony mous latter written at the Monongahels House in this city, in which the writer as serts that Lizzie Borden is innocent of the murder of her father and stepmother. The author of thestrauge communication gays “JI was in New Yerk when the murder took place, and as soon as | learned that one of these men did it I left and eame to this city. The one who did the act said Le went into the house to get something to eat, and ss be found no one in the front room.

See moreSee less

he went up stairs and went into a room. While he was there the lady came in on him. Bhe ballooed and he hit her with # 1arze knife or ax that he carries in a case

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Lizzie Borden passed an uneasy night in the matron's room at the Central Station, sleeping poorly despite having her own bedding and food brought from home. She appeared more contented than a week earlier, though still visibly affected by Monday's events, while heirs of Mrs. Borden hired counsel for the Probate Court proceedings.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 24 August 1892 · page 1

Lizzie Borden Uneasy. Fall River, Mass.. Aug. 24. Lizzie Borden passed an uneasy night in the matron's room at the Central Station. She did not sleep well, although her bed ding and food were brought from her own home. She is in a much happier and more contented frame of mind, however. than when she was here a week ago, but the excitement of Monday has had a vis ible effect upon her. The heirs of Mrs. Borden have hired counsel to look after the interests of the Borden estate when it reaches the Probate Court.

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's restless night in the matron's room at Central Station, noting she ate food brought from her own home and seemed in better spirits than a week earlier. It notes the strain of the preliminary examination was visibly affecting her.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 24 August 1892 · page 1

Lizzie Borden's Condition. Fall River, Maas., Aug. 24.—The interest in tho Borden only by discussio weakness of the The defendant, passed uu uueasy night in the matron'# ia reflected the strength :utor's charges. Lizzie Bor

See the clipping

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

The item reports that banker A. J. Borden and his wife were found murdered with an ax in their Fall River home, with daughter Lizzie Borden under arrest. It notes there is no evidence against her beyond a possible motive to inherit the family estate.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 24 August 1892 · page 4

Y. H. Wilson, of Cynthiana, Ky. A fearful double tragedy was enacted at Fall River, Mass., on the 4th instant. A. J. Borden, a banker and prominent capitalist, and his wife, were found murdered in their rooms in their house, their Heads being split open with an ax. Lizzie Borden, their daughter, is

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report describes the quiet aftermath of a postponed District Court session in the Lizzie Borden case, noting her comfortable treatment in the matron's room and visits from her sister and a pastor. It also mentions a rumor that expert testimony about poison may be introduced to strengthen the prosecution's case.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Portland Daily Press · 24 August 1892 · page 1

A PROFESSOR ON POISON. Testimony Which May Strengthen the Case Against Lizzie Borden.

Fall River, Mass., August 23.—The general disappointment following the failure of the governmont to open its case against Lizzie Borden in the District Court yesterday is very marked here to day. People are getting weary of this prolongation of the agony. Some bene fit has accrued, however, as today people are disposed to turn their attention to something else. For the first time in nearly three weeks the environments of the Central police station have been des titute of anything in the shape of excite ment or striking features. Even the ubi quitous gamin has been invisible, ami tne curious crowd which has been camp ing daily on the curbstones about Court Square has apparently folded its tents, like the Arabs, and disappeared.

See moreSee less

Lizzie Borden spent the night in the matron’s room, with Matron Reagan as her guard. Early this morning her sis ter Emma visited her, as did Parson Buck, who brought a bouquet. They spent considerable time with her. During the rest of the forenoon she sat in a chair near the screened window of the room reading a book. The people about the station sav there is a marked improvement in her looks since she was here a week ago. It is not probable that she will be taken to Taunton now until after the preliminary hearing is con cluded. Contrary to general expectation there have been very few applications from curious people to be allowed to take a

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A Springfield Union report claims Bridget Sullivan testified she heard Lizzie Borden in the cellar and later saw a hatchet lying in the sitting room, evidence allegedly leaked by an inquest official. The account suggests this testimony was the key evidence prompting Lizzie's arrest.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Portland Daily Press · 24 August 1892 · page 2

SHE SAW THE HATCHET. Bridget Sullivan Says tliat Lizzie Borden Had It Ready lor the Awful Crime. [Springfield Union.] Fall River, August 17.—The vital bit of evidence which caused the poliee to arrest Lizzie Borden on the charge of murdering her father and step-mother has at last leaked out. As has been suspected, the evidence was furnished by Bridget Sullivan. The arrest followed immediately after her examination at the inquest. The only intimation that has been made public was the remark credited to Bridget: “I am not surprised that they arrested Liz zie Borden.” Today it was learned why she was not surprised.

See moreSee less

The leak came through one of the officials who was present at the examination. That official said today to an intimate friend: “It was what Bridget saw, not what she heard or what she guessed, that led to Lizzie Borden’s ar rest. There were two important points, and they did not occur to her mind, agitated and shocked as she was at the time of the discovery of the crime, until she had a well defined idea of what the police suspected. Bridget said that she heard Lizzie down cellar hunting for something directly after Mr. Borden went out to go down town, and some time after that she saw what she is posi tive was the hatchet, lying half hidden in the sitting room. She heard Lizzie down cellar Before she went out doors to wash the windows; also saw the hatchet when she came ipside to get some water to complete her work. Whether the hatchet was then covered with blood the official did not state. Bridget saw it, and from certain indicar tions, which she described to the officers, was satisfied that it had been in the hands of Lizzie, whether before or after the murder of the step-mother she was of course unable to state. It was a strong point for the govern ment. It w7as necessary to connect Lizzie with the murderous weapon in some way if possible and Bridget did that for them. With Lizzie down cellar and the hatchet up stairs a conclusive point was estab lished, and according to the theory of the police it is simply this: Either the woman secured the weapon for herself or for an accomplice, and in either case she had such guilty knowledge of the crime as to warrant a charge of murder in the first degree. The police can show, they say, that Lizzie Borden was either the principal in the murder or an ancessory before

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report describes housekeeper Bridget Sullivan's claim that she saw a hatchet in the sitting room while Lizzie was down cellar, which police viewed as key evidence linking Lizzie to the murder weapon. It also discusses the police theory that Lizzie was either the principal killer or an accessory, while noting their reluctance to believe she acted alone given her reputation for piety.

The Portland Daily Press · 24 August 1892 · page 2

SHE SAW THE HATCHET.

•_,. | the fact, and everything they have se, cured thus far indicates the former, al though there are a few loopholes which might admit the fact that she was accessory, although they are few and far between. If, however, she was ac cessory, it will throw out an idea that the woman was insane, and the police at present are strongly inclined to that theory rather than believe that this Christian girl with so strong a reputation for piety and missionary labors, com mitted the heartless, cruel murder that they have shown the kiliing of Andrew and Abby Borden to have been.

See moreSee less

That she cold-bloodedly devised such a crime with another person is almost beyond their credulity, although all police officials follow the principle that nothing is impossible in crime.

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

This report reviews the Fall River tragedy, describing how Andrew and Abby Borden were found hacked to death in their home, Andrew on a sofa and Abby upstairs on the floor. It notes the case remains a mystery weeks later despite Lizzie Borden's arrest.

The Anaconda Standard · 24 August 1892 · page 6

FEW FACTS, MANY THEORIES

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

The report recounts the early investigation into the Borden murders, including the initial burglar theory, a rejected theory about a business dispute over fish market shares, and false arrests that were cleared by alibis. It also details the physician's timeline showing Mrs. Borden died about ninety minutes before her husband, and describes suspicion falling on John Morse, who was questioned but never arrested for lack of evidence.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Anaconda Standard · 24 August 1892 · page 6

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

The report reviews Bridget Sullivan's re-examined testimony about her movements and the time Andrew Borden entered the house, finding no gaps allowing an intruder. It also discusses police theories about a motive involving an unmade will and prior illness possibly caused by poisoning, including an alleged attempt to buy prussic acid.

The Anaconda Standard · 24 August 1892 · page 6

jpose of Lizzie Borden, by killing Borden^and his wife, to inherit one-half of his es-^1 tate. Hearing on this |mtut i n formal ion^1 was furnished the police to ihe effect that^Iff. Honlen was about to make a will.^( The police consider the information re-^i liable. No will has been found since his^' death, and he is liehoveil to haw tlicd 111-^j icstate. It is Haiti that l.ixiio lionliui^l knew he was alsiut to make a wll'.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

Charles H. Peckham walked into the Fall River police station claiming he killed Andrew and Abby Borden out of love for blood, describing his escape route. Police quickly determined he was mentally unstable and acquaintances confirmed he had long been considered crazy, though he was briefly released then locked up again.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Weekly Union · 24 August 1892 · page 1

I'M THE MURDERER.

FALL RIVER, MASS., Aug. 18.—Charles H. Peckham of Central Village, Westport, Mass., walked in central police station this morning and said to Assistant Marshal Fleet, ““Well, Mr. Marshal,l killed Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden and I have come from Lhome to give myself up. I went over the back fence and through the rear door of the Borden house two weeks ago today and I kilied both of these people out of pure love for blood. I went out ofthe rear door and over the back fence and walked over the Ngw Bedford road home.

See moreSee less

I’m the mur derer and want to be locked up.” The marshal searched him and found a pocketbook, with a few receipts in it, and some official communications from the Russian bureau at Washington. Peckbam is 62 years of age, about 5 feet G inches tall,and has an iron gray beard. He suys he leases a furm from Edmund Davis The police have started to hunt up his rela tives or friends. The man Peckham who gave himself up at the station this morning, is crazy,beyond a doubt. He begged several of the officers at the station to hang him. He formerly lived in Middletown, Conn., and has had some trouble withshis family. He was locked up. Nelson Reed of West port states that he knows Peckham very well, and says that he has been crazy for some time.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

Charles Peckham, a Westport farmer with a history of insanity, had walked ten miles to confess to the Borden murder but was later released after authorities determined he was not sane and had no actual connection to the crime. He denied all knowledge of the murder upon release and was taken home by his wife and a constable.

Weekly Union · 24 August 1892 · page 1

BECAME INSANE. Cavsed by Brooding Over Borden Mur der—Subject to Insanity for Years. FALL RIvER, MAss., Aug. 18.—Charles H. Peckham, the man who confessed today having committed the Borden murder, lives two and one-half miles south of Brownell’s corner in Westport on afarm he purchased this spring. He was in this city last Friday and heard a good deal ahout Lizzie Borden’s arrest. He went home and since then has brooded so much over the af fair that he became insane. He left bis house between 6 and 7 o’clock this moerning, despite the protestations of his wife, walled ten miles to the police sta tion to give himself up.

See moreSee less

He is a war veteran and has been subject to fits of insanity for some years. He wiil be cared for by friends. The police returned tonight from an un successful search through Assonet woods after the mythical person who was said to be in the vicinity. None of the oflicers could locate the shadow.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The report describes the postponement of Lizzie Borden's first hearing, noting speculation that the prosecution may be weakening its case. Both sides reportedly agreed to the delay to further prepare, with the prosecution insisting all evidence will be revealed at the hearing.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 24 August 1892 · page 8

SOME RAYS OF LIGHT

sides, in order to fully prepare the case. The hearing, said The Dispatch's inform ant, will partake of the nature of a trial by jury in regard to all the facts being brought out. Protests of the Proseontlon. The prosecution emphatically states that it has no fear of the result and asserts that Lawyer Jennings was fully as desirous as it to nave tne examination postponed. Those who insist that the State has no case atrainst Lizzie Borden, and that it has at last real ized that it has been wrong from the start, say that the clearest evidence of weakness in the case against the accused is the fact that the prosecution considers it absolutely necessary to present the evidence of the

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The hearing against Lizzie Borden was postponed until Thursday, reportedly at the request of both prosecution and defense to prepare their cases. Critics argue the postponement and reliance on medical expert testimony reveal weakness in the State's case, while prosecutor Knowlton insists the case remains as strong as ever.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 24 August 1892 · page 8

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

With Lizzie Borden's lawyers out of town, Marshal Hilliard tells a reporter that her arrest was based on strong circumstantial evidence and that she remains in his custody pending trial. He also notes the warrant only charges her with Andrew Borden's murder, not Abby's, and claims the prosecution is confident despite inconclusive expert testimony.

The Providence News · 24 August 1892 · page 1

NO LIGHT ON THE MYSTERY

wrong. ““The experts are not m;l[. it is true, he said, * but I know that Mr. Knowlito is satisfied to present his case to the court and he was yesterday. Miss Borden wa arrested on strong suspicion, backed b strong circumstautial evidence. If sh cannot be held on that evidence we ar perfectly willing to see her released. *“‘lt was with great reluctance that w were compelled to take her into custod)

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A reporter questions the city marshal about why Lizzie Borden's arrest warrant names only her father's murder, not her stepmother's, and the marshal explains legal strategy similar to charging one burglary among many. A local lawyer also marvels at Lizzie's composure, suggesting she must have some powerful inner certainty sustaining her through the ordeal.

The Providence News · 24 August 1892 · page 1

NO LIGHT ON THE MYSTERY

local lawyer, who has known the Borden: since boyhood, expressed ireat admiratior for the self possession of Lizzie Borden it the {)osmon in which she has been placed ‘“lt seems hardly possible,’”’ he said

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

An unnamed commentator theorizes that Lizzie Borden's calm composure proves she has guilty knowledge of who committed the murders, even if she did not inflict the blows herself, speculating she may have been an accessory who helped conceal the killer. The report also notes the DA consulted a druggist about prussic acid, suggesting investigators still suspected poison was used before the hatchet, and teases a newly discovered letter Lizzie wrote the day before the murders.

The Providence News · 24 August 1892 · page 1

ble buiwark for a secret. ‘“Now, then, why should she want te conceal the slayer of her parents ? Ther we are baffled. She was never known t« have a lover, who might have done the deed to hasten his marrlufio and the pos sassion of her share of the Borden weaith But she never was a demonstrative girl and even if she did love, no one would b likely to know. However, I ain not espec ially partial to the lover story. “There remains her knowledge of th crimes as an insticator. If she was ai accessory only her demeanor is explained If she procured the murder it was the re

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Rev. Walker Jubb visited Lizzie Borden at the Central Station, and the report discusses two unidentified figures tied to the case: the boy who allegedly delivered a note to Mrs. Borden, and a boy named Pierce who first spread word that a Portuguese man committed the murders. A local lawyer also speculates that a property transfer dispute involving Ferry Street may have motivated the killings.

The Providence News · 24 August 1892 · page 7

Station this mornlng. There are two lads who will go into history by their connection with the bloody tragedy of August 4th in this city; one is he, whoever he may prove to be, who was said by Lizzie A. Borden to have handed her a note for her step-mother, that morning, requesting her step mother’s presence with some friend who was represented as being sick. The other is a lad named Pierce, who was the first to get word of the murders upon the street—the one who told John Curn n¢lay toat the Bordens had been killed, and, almost in the same breath added that'it was a Portuguese who killed them.

See moreSee less

This lad, who has since been stay ing in Little Compton, is expected here to-night, and he may afford some lizht

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes a lawyer's theory that a property transfer motivated the murders, and details Andrew Borden's purchase of a Ferry Street property from his daughters just before the killings. It also recounts an alleged letter from Lizzie to her sister Emma describing a suspicious man lurking in the yard the night before the murders, a letter since destroyed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Providence News · 24 August 1892 · page 7

THOSE LETTERS,

examination to-morrow. 3 ¥ A local lawyer said lymterday that he should not be surprised if it turned out that the immediate incentive to the mur ders lay in connection with the transfer of certain property on Ferry streeton the 1641 of last month. As has been stated in other papers, Andrew J. DBorden bought of Emma and Lizzie a cer tain tenement house on Ferry street paying them §2,500 each therefor, and a de:l wa¥ given by the daughters to Mr, Borden (which deed, by the way, was re ceived, for record in the local registry on the very day of the homicides), which has been recorded, and the insurance was duly transferred to him.

See moreSee less

An ipspection of the insurance paper shows that Emma (as was to have been expected from whut has been written of her), is the writer of a weak hand, while Lizzi¢'s is the hand of & much more dom inant character, althou ;o not possessing much individuality.

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

The report describes the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies at their Fall River home, both brutally mutilated about the head with a bladed weapon. It states that their daughter first found her father's body, then went upstairs and discovered her mother's body as well, after which she fainted.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 24 August 1892 · page 2

A COUPLE KILLED. Andrew J. Borden and His Wife Foand Mysteriously Murdered.

See the clipping

Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · and 1 other paper

A national news digest reports that the bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew Borden were buried on the 17th by order of Medical Examiner Dolan. The burial was carried out by cemetery employees, with no family members present.

Iron County Register · 25 August 1892 · page 6

Borden, the victims of the Fall River (Mass.) tragedy, were buried, on the 17th, by order of Medical Examiner Dolan. They were placed in the family lot by the employes at the cemetery, no member of the family being pres

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Osceola Times · Osceola, Ark. · 27 August 1892

Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · and 2 other papers

A news digest reports that Lizzie Borden was arrested for the murder of her father and stepmother based on statements from family servant Bridget Sullivan, which could build a strong circumstantial case. The same item also notes a man named Charles H. Peckham falsely confessed to the murders, claiming he killed out of 'pure love of blood.'

Iron County Register · 25 August 1892 · page 6

River, on the lbih, declaring himself to le the murderer of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, whom he said he killed "out of pure love of blood." He wished some of the officers to accommodate him by hang ing him at once. It transpires that Miss Lizzie Borden was arrested for the murder of her father and step-mother at Fall River, Mass., on the strength of certain state ments made by Bridget Suliivan, a do mestic employed in the family, which, if borne out, will make a strong circum stantial case against Miss Borden.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Bolivar Bulletin · Bolivar, Tenn. · 26 August 1892
  • The Osceola Times · Osceola, Ark. · 27 August 1892

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

District Attorney Knowlton requested an adjournment of Lizzie Borden's examination before Judge Blaisdell due to evidence not yet fully prepared. Her counsel raised no objection, and the hearing was postponed until Thursday, August 25.

Connecticut Western News · 25 August 1892 · page 1

Mis. Borden's Trial Postponed. Faix Rtver, Aug. 23. The courtroom where Judge Blaiadell presides was crowded with witnesses when the examination ot Lizzie Borden came up. District Attorney Knowlton said that certain evidence not yet fully prepared necessitated his asking

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

This is a general telegraph news roundup whose headline block briefly flags 'Both Sides Ready in the Borden Case' among several unrelated stories. The actual body text that follows discusses the resolution of a railroad switchmen's strike in Buffalo, with no substantive content about the Borden case itself.

Morning Journal and Courier · 25 August 1892 · page 3

Both Sides Ready in the Borden Case. THE GLOUCESTER CELEBRATION. A Hunting Party of Four Are Murdered. ENDED AT WIDWIOHT. ' Conference of tne Leaders They Did Not Order a Sympathetic Strike

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

As the Borden preliminary examination approaches, officials and attorneys prepare their cases while speculation grows that the assailant was left-handed based on wound analysis. The report also describes a psychic woman's vision of Lizzie committing the murders and a New Bedford man's claim that Lizzie sought poison before the killings.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Morning Journal and Courier · 25 August 1892 · page 3

XAOBB FOB THE EXAMINATION. Uiss Borden is In very good spirits to night and looks forward eagerly to the examination to morrow. She has perfeot freedom of the matron's room, but oom- -plains a little of the noise made at 1 o'clock in the morning when the polioemen are go ing to and returning from their beats. One of use moat prominent citizens Is quoted to-night as saying that he asked Mr. Borden why he was not spending the summer at his farm in Swansea, receiving the reply: 'Ho. I nave had so muoh almoulty in my family that I hare not felt like going way."

See moreSee less

Xjemay. the Frenchman who reported having seen a suspicious stranger in the vicinity of Thomas Thurston s house, in sists that his story is correct. Two polioe men are stationed at Steep Brook to-night to waton him.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

An unidentified woman visited the police marshal and claimed to have a psychic vision of Lizzie Borden committing both murders, including details of hiding a hatchet and striking her father's skull. The marshal noted she appeared sane but she refused to give her name or register at her hotel.

Morning Journal and Courier · 25 August 1892 · page 3

A WOMAN'S VT8IOW. A woman plainly dressed, with short, dark hair, called at the police station this afternoon in searoh of Marshal Hillard. Failing to find him she returned to-night and waa closeted with him for half an hour. She refused to give her name and also declined to register at the Wilbur house, where she was stopping. She told the marshal that the was peculiarly gifted from infancy and went on to say that she saw in a vision Uiss Lizzie Borden mur dering her mother at 10:30 o'clock Thurs day, August 4.

See moreSee less

Later, she saw Miss Lizzie pass down stairs witn a hatchet in her hand, go towards her father, putting the hatohet in a corner, while she smoothed the sola pillow for her father to rest on. Still later she saw Lizzie standing at the head of the sofa haoking mercilessly at her lather's skull. Marshal uiuard says that the woman appears to be sane. Life-sized photographs have been taken of the skulls of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, showing the position of the wounds, and they will be used at the trial. One-half of Mrs. Borden's skull is broken in.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The report describes the crowded opening of the preliminary hearing before Judge Blaisdell, with Lizzie Borden and her sister Emma attending alongside family and clergy. Medical Examiner Dolan testifies about the condition and positioning of the bodies, followed by Surveyor Kieran taking the stand.

Evening Journal · 25 August 1892 · page 1

EXPERTS ON THE WITNESS STAND, H. .I1 lAiunlfier and Surveyor Kin TeHtif) Ml»« Itonln Given Kvlilcno® Th® Ainued a Srverr Nerv Strali anil II* r Sint«*!* Don't Sp* uk The <'« irt llooni 4'ro wilt'd. Faix Biveh, Mass., Aug. 2ft.— The seeoiul district court room never before held such a crowd us that which greeted Judge Blnlsdell tills morning at 10 it was tho second day agreed o'clock. upon for the hearuig of Miss Lizzie A. Borden on the charge of killing her father with an axe. Clergymen, laymen, physicians and more than IftO ladies, who wore not directly connected with the case, were seated and standing in oil parts of tho room, while inside tho rail was an extraordinary crowd of reporters and other newspaper workers.

See moreSee less

Ladies occupied more than two-thirds of the seats usually occupied by the curious gang who usually Hock into the lower courts. At 10.30 Mr. Charles J. Holmes appeared with Miss Fnnma Borden on his arm. Following them came Mrs. Brjgham, Mrs. Holmes and the Bev.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Dr. Dolan described the wounds on Mr. and Mrs. Borden's bodies in graphic detail, stating Mr. Borden died from shock due to massive head trauma. Surveyor Kieran presented diagrams of the Borden home showing blood spot locations and measurements.

Evening Journal · 25 August 1892 · page 1

EXPERTS ON THE WITNESS STAND

the stand. IMkut Kxainim'r iminii Texlltle». The witness testified to tho position of the bodies of the murdered couple when found, and to sending their stomachs to Professor Wood of Harvatd college, for analyzatiou. "Mrs. Borden's body was »iressed os you would I expect a housewife to he at that time of | day. it hail an old handkerchief about the neck that was bloody." Witness did not believe it was tied in a knot and diil not remember whether it was cut or not. Nurveyor Kii-iiiaii ou tbo SI anil.

See moreSee less

Surveyor Kieruan then took the stand. Kieruan submitted plans sln^i iug the interior and exterior of tho Borden homestead witli measurements of Hie rooms, descript ion and measure ments of tho land, height of fences, lo cation of Hie barn, etc. He saw blood spnts und (Waited them in the plans. A place in the plans showed where a piece of isiard had been taken from the kitchen. Witness then described position of the blood spots. Lizzie bora an expressionless countenance and bit at the edge of a palm leaf fan while Emma hid her face behind a similar article. Dolan Recall®«!.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A medical witness describes in graphic detail the ten parallel wounds to Andrew Borden's head and face, stating death resulted from shock. Testimony also covers blood spot patterns on a door casing and a damaged section of wood matching evidence held by the marshal.

Evening Journal · 25 August 1892 · page 1

EXPERTS ON THE WITNESS STAND

Th „ witaPlj8 thell toM tt story of ,] 10 ., . , * f ........ bl^spots fo tn. in the reom saytug Hu side of Mr. Bordens head and fact* was covered with blood. The shirt was bloody h»>d the back of h.s clot 1,,-s soak»d His

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

This report describes testimony from the Borden household servant, Bridget Sullivan, suggesting ongoing conflict between Lizzie and her stepmother, which investigators saw as evidence of motive. It also reveals a letter Lizzie wrote to her sister Emma before the murder, mentioning an unspecified anxious incident.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Portland Daily Press, 24 August 1892, The Abbeville Press and Banner, 24 August 1892.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 25 August 1892 · page 1

tri PRICE ONE CENT, I THE BORDEN MURDER Miss Lizzie's Story of a Myste rious Stranger, DNPLEA3ANT FAMILY RELATION! Bridget Sullivan, the Servant Girl, Tells of tho Stepmother's Futile lOlforts to Establish Domestic Hj ninny — Important Letters That Have Ileen Destroyed. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 23.—It has come to the knowledge of the public that Bridget Sulli had long before the tragedy at the Borden home con fided to intimate friends certain facts which leave little doubt that there had been a constant warfare going in the Second street house.

See moreSee less

Mrs. Borden and her stepdaughters were on anything but pleasant terms with each other, al though the former tried in every way to establish pleasant relations. Lizzie showed more autipathy toward the elder woman than did her sisterIt is supposed that at the inquest Bridget Bullivan delivered a great deal of im portant information of this character, and furnished the government with broad grounds on which to base the theory of a motive. A Mysterious Stranger. Another new feature of the case Is a letter which Lizzie wrote to her sister Emma the Tuesday before the murder. The first knowledge of this letter caine out at Lizzie's examination at the in quest in reply to the question: ''Had you noticed any suspici persons about the house the day of the trag edy?" Sho'said she had not that day, but bad on the Monday night before this, •ud had written an account of the inci dent to her sister Emma. Inquiry de velops the fact that on Wednesday Emma did get a letter from Lizzie, in which the latter refers to her anxiety over something which happened Monday night. When she was return ing home from a call she noticed a iu the back yard just as she opened the aide gate. He disappeared on discover ing her. Afl entering the house, Lizzie disturbed over what wrote, she w< that she went to •he had of the windows in her room commanding the vurd and watched. Shu a man who already looked like the • sho hud se moving about, but it unite dark and she could not gi description any of him. The Lctt.i Destroyed. Emma Borden showed this letter to friends in F Haven, with whom she was visiting when sho received it, and then destroyed it, she says. It also turns out that tho letter which Lizzie Borden sent toher Marion friends, and which received by them on the day of the murder. also destroyed, be cause it contained reference to some thing which in the opinion of the young woman to whom it sent might iu the light of subsequent, events ba mis construed. Some of the Bpeculating during if that Boine ones thing t the story of the suspicii Lizzie told her sister v ■ about the Borden house Monday night. Bandits Make a Good Haul. Van Burkn, Ark., Aug. 25.—James

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

At the inquest, Lizzie Borden testified she wrote to her sister Emma about a man she saw lurking in the yard the Monday night before the murders. Both that letter and another sent to Marion friends were destroyed by their recipients, reportedly because of contents that might be misconstrued in light of later events.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 25 August 1892 · page 1

UNPLEASANT FAMILY RELATIONS

which received by them on the day of the murder. also destroyed, be cause it contained reference to some thing which in the opinion of the young woman to whom it sent might iu the light of subsequent, events ba mis construed. Some of the Bpeculating during if that Boine ones thing t the story of the suspicii Lizzie told her sister v about the Borden house Monday night. Bandits Make a Good Haul. ■

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

An anonymous letter sent to a Pittsburgh newspaper claims a mysterious man, not Lizzie Borden, confessed to the axe murders, though police are skeptical of its authenticity. Separately, the report notes Lizzie Borden was brought from Taunton jail for a preliminary hearing, with crowded courtrooms and news that she and her sister Emma have assigned their property to pay defense costs.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 25 August 1892 · page 6

WOMEN FIGHT FOR A PLACE

■»lie ArcuNOd Woman Jlravely F Hi ! Terr!Itle Ordeal. Pittbiiuuo, Pa., Aug. 22.—The Dit •nsational patch this morning prints anonymous letter, written at the Motion* gahela House, in this city, in which the writer asserts that Lizzie E. Borden is innocent of the murder of lier father

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

District Attorney Knowlton requested a postponement of the preliminary hearing because key evidence—including the victims' stomachs, bloodstained furnishings, and expert analysis of a hatchet—was not yet ready for presentation. The adjournment, though seen by some as government weakness, was explained as necessary to allow Professor Wood and Medical Examiner Dolan time to complete their investigations, with Bridget Sullivan present but visibly frightened.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 25 August 1892 · page 6

EVIDENCE TO BE SUBMITTED

household since the tragedy occurred. | This would include the stomachs of the ! deceased persons, carpets, sofa, pillows, ' pill shams, portions of the panelist about the room, also other cvideuuar uS* the ci inn-. The government lms been attaching great importance to the hatchet said to have been taken from the Borden house which is also s.ud to have blood corpus cles on it similar to those found upon Miss Lizzie Borden's apron. If these statements are true, the prisoners coun sel proposes to learn the facts at an early »tage ot th«; trial.

See moreSee less

The government officials are not surprised at the contiu uunce <»f the ease. They say that tlioy expeet««l that Professor Wood would bo in readiness to report, but they are not disposed to hurry the expert investie*- ,

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The preliminary hearing for Lizzie Borden was set for Fall River, with new details emerging from the inquest testimony. Bridget Sullivan reportedly described tension between Lizzie and her stepmother, while a letter Lizzie wrote to her sister Emma describing a mysterious man seen near the house on the Monday night before the murders was revealed.

Evening Star · 25 August 1892 · page 7

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The report reveals previously unknown letters Lizzie Borden wrote to her sister Emma and Marion friends, describing a suspicious man she saw near the house the night before the murders. It also includes Marshal Hilliard's defense of her arrest, insisting strong circumstantial evidence justified holding her in custody.

Evening Star · 25 August 1892 · page 7

WHY LIZZIE BORDEN IS HELD

notgive an desecription of him. Emma Borden showed the lbtter to fuisade in Fair Haven whom she was Visiting when she received it, and thee she destroyed it. e raye is also tarns out that the letter which Ls=ie Borden seat to Marion friends, and was received by them on the day of the ,mdsr, was aloe destroyed. becanse it con msined reference to something which, in the opinion of the young woman to whom it was mt, might. in the light of subsequent events, he misconstrued. w1a1 uzzt nonax is nULD. A special dispatch to the New York World frem Fal River, Ease=. in regard to the case of Lizzie Borden saws that Marshal Hilliard de

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper interview explains that Lizzie Borden was charged only with her father's murder because she discovered his body and was the last person seen with him, though prosecutors believe one killer committed both murders. A local lawyer who has known the Bordens since childhood theorizes that her calm demeanor stems from guilty knowledge of the murderer's identity, possibly as an accessory rather than the killer herself.

Evening Star · 25 August 1892 · page 7

In discusng the strange afair today a local lawyer. who has known the Bordens since boy heed, expressed great admiration for the self pesaseion of LisMie Borden in the position in which she has been placed. "It sees hardly poisible." he said. "that a waumn who had committed such crimes could maamin the demeanor borne by Liszie alle asng. If Guilty an ordinary woman would her innocence and show sign. of her te beingaecused. If innocent she should scarcely bear up under the weight of the out ra upon her. "An ordianrv person would appeal to some one for help.

See moreSee less

ifies Borden has done none of this. She he.. shown no fear; ehe has never ap peared to reient asuppoeed outrage; she has net el to her fraenda. - isr some reason for her marvelous cemsuare, for Lizzie Borden is not insane. Tha sl, I cannot think her so. The reason mee he en aRl-powerfual one. "The rock that sustains Lizzie Borden Is her knowledge of the ~gderer. She knows who butchered her pamen That guilty knouledge is her strength. --Vieriene guilt, borne with the conviction that the persons guilt cannot be proved ad bedon some istrong personal motave for eon esahent, is en iempregnable bulwark for a asert "Now. then, why should should she went to e.eal the siayer of her perents? There we se ba.=- Mbe was nerer known to have a lover, who might have done the deed to hasten his marriage and the possion of her ehere of the Borden wealtic But she was er a desmoustratste girl. end even if she ddlove, no one woul be aikely to know it. Hlowever, I am not e 4pcially partial to the love theory. "There reman, her knon ledge of the crimeo as an instigatoer. If -he wea en accessory only her dm..caor ise exp lained. If she procured the murder it wa' the result of a long consid erved plan and when it was done she ws eati'. Sedl. ilhe cookd essily have conealed the mur derer in the houce. sent Bridget out of the way end co)veredl hi' retreat. -.There ine my theory: I don't think any woman could keep up as ILizzie Borden has done if she heel kfled those old people with her

See the clipping

Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

Police report that Lizzie Borden, speaking before the police matron, accused her sister of 'giving her away.' Authorities view this slip of the tongue as nearly a confession in the murder case.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Rock Island Daily Argus · 25 August 1892 · page 4

London, Aug. 25. The election at Derby, component upon Sir William Har court's entering the cabinet, was held yesterday mid Sir William was elecud over Farmer Atliius, nis erratic conservactive opponent.by a vote of 6,508 to 1,019. The result was a goiegoue conclusion. Uzsio' Rordeu'a Slip of the Tongue. Boston, Aug. 2o. Lizzie Borden, in the presence of the police matron, yesterday accused her sister of "giving her away." The police look upou this slip of the tongue as almost a confession. Lizzie is accused of the murder of her aged father and mother.

See the clipping

The Somerset Reporter · Skowhegan, Me.

The preliminary hearing for Lizzie Borden, expected to draw a large crowd, was postponed until Thursday because expert Professor Wood needed more time to test the hatchet, clothing, and wood for blood evidence. Both prosecution and defense attorneys agreed to the delay, surprising observers including Judge Blaisdell.

The Somerset Reporter · 25 August 1892 · page 8

AN ADJOURNMENT TAKEN UNTIL THURSDAY IN THE BORDEN MURDER CASE. K Xpert Wnoil'n Test liiiitny Consiilered Important Rnmigli tu Grunt the Delay. Mote l»y Mis* Holden's Attorneys

See the clipping

The Somerset Reporter · Skowhegan, Me.

The preliminary hearing in the Borden case was unexpectedly postponed until Thursday after defense attorneys insisted on access to Professor Wood's forensic findings before proceeding. The delay arose because the defense had summoned Wood to testify about evidence in his possession, but his blood analysis was not yet complete, forcing the state to agree to the postponement.

The Somerset Reporter · 25 August 1892 · page 8

BORDEN MURDER CASE.

ire undergoing examination. It is whispered that the government li.ln’t care much whether this witness did ir did not appear at t he hearing, and th.it he attorneys for Mis* Borden learned that lie blood "f ;tinswere so far from being

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Bridget Sullivan testified about frequent family quarrels, which prosecutors believe establishes a motive for Lizzie Borden. Separately, Rev. Mr. Jubb was turned away by the matron when he tried to visit Lizzie Borden at the police station without proper permission.

The Portland Daily Press · 25 August 1892 · page 1

FOR AND AGAINST HER.

Faix Rivbb, Mass., August 24.—Rev. Mr. Jubb, Lizzie Borden’s pastor, strode into the police station this morning and without further ado ascended the stairs leading to the matron’s room. It was'

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A minister was turned away from Lizzie Borden's jail room by the matron for lacking proper authorization. The report also reveals that servant Bridget Sullivan had spoken of discord between Mrs. Borden and her stepdaughters, and discusses a letter Lizzie wrote to her sister Emma about a suspicious man seen near the house before the murders.

The Portland Daily Press · 25 August 1892 · page 1

FAMILY SKELETON

office to report the affair. Mr. Jnbb didn’t appear to relish : the situation. He finally started down'the stairs, and meeting the Bev. Mr. Buck on» his way to call on Miss Borden, expressed his opinion of This Sort of Business, declaring that he was so upset by thv incident that he didn’t think he would! bother the City Marshal today for an - order to see the prisoner. It has come to the knowledge of the public today that Bridget Sullivan, long before the tragedy at the Borden homa, confided to intimate friends certain facts which leave little doubt that there had been a constant warfare going on in tho Second street house. Mrs. Borden and

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

At the inquest Lizzie Borden testified she saw a suspicious man in the yard on the Monday night before the murders and wrote to her sister Emma about it, a letter Emma later destroyed. Another letter Lizzie sent to friends, received the day of the murder, was also destroyed because it reportedly contained details that might be misconstrued in light of later events.

The Portland Daily Press · 25 August 1892 · page 1

FAMILY SKELETON

could not give any description of him. Emma Borden snowed this letter to friends in Fairhaven with whom she was visiting when she received it and then destroyed it, she says. It also turns out that the letter which Lizzie Borden sent to her Marion friends and which was received by them on the day of the murder, was also destroyed, because it contained reference to some thing which in the opinion of the young woman to whom it was sent might m the light of subsequent events be miscon strued. Some of the speculating o<ies are now wondering if that something was not this story of the suspicious man whom Lizzie told her sister was about the Borden house Monday night.

See the clipping

Courier Democrat · Langdon, N.D.

The New Bedford Standard reports a story from Capt. Orrick Smalley about traveling agent George W. Hathaway, who claimed Andrew Borden told him Lizzie would not eat with him and once said she hoped he would come home a corpse. The account is presented as secondhand but credible, intended to suggest tension between Lizzie and her father before the murders.

Courier Democrat · 25 August 1892 · page 3

WISHED HIM DEAD.

Suspected Mnrdera sa. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., Aug. 20.—This afternoou llie Standard prints the follow ing story which it states is worthy of more than usual credence, as it comes irom Capt. Orrick Suialley, chairman of the overseers ofthe poor. Capt. Smallev was enjoying his vacation at Craigville when the Borden murders were comm.tted, and the next day alter, while discussing the news from Fall River he made the remark that it was im possible for the daughter to have carried out such a horrible deed. There were those on the piazza, said Capt.

See moreSee less

Smalley, who did not agree with him. A stranger to whom the captain was talking was the one who related a conversation with An drew J. Borden, which has since opened the eyes ot those who have heard it. This gentleman, who is George W. Hathaway a traveling agent, said that not long since while he was out on one of Mr. Borden's farms, the old gentleman came out very much dis turbed. Upon being questioned he re marked that did not take much comfort at home with Lizzie that she would not eat at the same table with him, and that only that morning when he accidentally went into the room where she was eating she got up irom the table and left the room. Hath away also said that Mr. Borden told him this with tears in his eyes, and remarked that when he le:t the bouse Lizzie said she hoped he would come home a corpse, and that probably he would be belore long. Smalley said he was thunderstruck, and not lieinie acquainted with Hathaway he made inquiries concerning him. The cap tain learned lhat he Was reliable man re siding in Fall River. His business is that of a traveling man, and he is prominently connected with one ot the Fall River churches.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report describes the second day of Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing in Fall River, where over 100 women and many reporters crowded into the courtroom. Lizzie Borden entered with her sister Emma and supporters, appearing strained, as the district attorney announced readiness to proceed and the first witness was called.

The Evening World · 25 August 1892 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report describes the scene at the Second District Court in Fall River as Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing resumes, noting the large crowd including clergymen, lawyers, physicians, and over 160 women. It details the arrival of Borden with her sister Emma and legal counsel, and the start of testimony with Medical Examiner Dolan called to the stand.

The Evening World · 25 August 1892 · page 1

la. K. -!" LIZZIE BORDEN'S HEARING. 'f : More Than 160 Woman Attend tt at ,(f Fall Blvar. , '?, lT ASIOCliTTO . I ,ys Fall ItiTEB, Mass.) Aug. 23. The Second .ft District court-room never beiore held such a M crowd as that which greeted Judge BUISdeU this morning at 10 o'clock. ''. It was tbe second date agreed upon for the fi hearing of Miss Lizzie A. Borden on tba Q charge of killing ber father with an axe. clergymen, law men, physicians and more T tban ICO ladles, wbo were not directly con- ,!j: nected with tbe case, were seated abd stand- 'sj'i; tog In all parts of the room, whlld Inside tba rail was an extraordinary crowd ot reporters H and other newspaper workers.

See moreSee less

. r'.fl At 10.30 o'clock and Charles j. Holmes $U appealed with Miss Emtna Borden on bla v,TB arm, following them came sirs. Brlgham, ""jjU Mrs. Humes and the Hev. Mr. Buck. M Miss Lizzie Borden cams In last with MarU:M shall Ulllalrd. Her lace gave evidence ot an ' VtjH extreme strain. She was handed to a seat rH between ber two legal advisers and near a J'H settee on wblch ber sister was seated. Tba jB two women sat elbow to elbow, alias Lizzie )M was at ber sister's right band, not a word M passed between them. l?m "Wo are ready to prjeeed, your Honor," 'M said District-Attorney Knowtton. of uM At 10.31, Medical Examiner Dolan waa VrSa called to the stand. A. WjSB

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

At Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing in Fall River, crowds packed the courtroom as Medical Examiner Dolan testified about the positions of the bodies and sent stomach samples to Harvard for analysis. Surveyor Kieran then presented diagrams of the Borden home showing blood spot locations and property measurements.

The Evening World · 25 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN'S HEARING

arm, following them came Mrs. Drlgbam, Mrs. Humes and the Iter. Mr. Iluck. Miss Llrrle Borden came In list with Mar shall HUlatrd. Her face eave evidence ot an extreme atraln. She was handed to a seat between ber two legal advisers and near a Settee on Which her sister was seated. The two women sat elbow to elbow. Miss Llrrle wa at her sister's right band. Not a word pasvd between them. At ia:it Medical Examiner Dolan was called to the stand. lb witness testified to the position of the bodies ot the murdered couple when found and to sending tbelr stomach to Prof.

See moreSee less

Wood, ot Harvard college, for analysis. surveyor Kelrnan then took the stand and submitted plans showing tbe Interior and exterior ot tbe Borden homestead, with meas

See the clipping

In the story →

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

A sensational special dispatch describes a dramatic jail scene in which Lizzie Borden allegedly accused her sister Emma of giving her away to lawyer Jennings, ending in tears and collapse. The matron Mrs. Reagan is cited as a witness to this emotional confrontation.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pawtucket Tribune · 25 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

"YOU GAVE ME AWAY."

Lizzie Borden Turns Against Her Sister.

See moreSee less

AN OUTBURST OF ANGER.

Belief That Emma is in Possession of a Secret.

BOSTON, Aug. 25.—The Globe this morning has the following special:

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 24—"You gave me away, Emma, did you not?"

"No, Lizzie, I only told Mr. Jennings what he ought to know for your defense."

"That is false. You have given me away and I know it; but remember! I will not give in jone inch, never! never? That is all I have to say to you."

In a voice embittered with suppressed passion, Lizzie A. Borden this afternoon, in the presence of her attendant, Mrs. Reagan, the police matron, thus addressed her nearest and dearest relative, as with a violent wave of the hand she turned her back upon her sister, with whom the conversation just narrated had taken place.

With tears in her eyes and voice choked with sobs, Miss Emma left the room, and then the accused, overcome with emotion, fell prostrate on her bed. Another chapter in the Borden tragedy was ended.

Cast off by the sister to whom she had come with words of comfort and hope, Emma Borden returned to her home, on Second street, with Lizzie's denunciation ringing in her ears.

Mrs. Reagan, speechless and horrified, watched the prisoner intently.

The Significance of the Scene she had witnessed was fully realized, but the compromising words of the suspected murderess, her unstrung nerves and wretched condition were a revelation. Previously she had been stoical and reserved, even in disposition, and self controlled. But in one brief minute, as Emma Borden was entering the room, a transformation had taken place and passion reigned within her where indifference had before been.

The above information that The Globe has secured comes from a source that is thoroughly reliable.

It is Not Exaggerated and is published entirely as secured by the writer from a person in authority, who, while not himself present in the matron's room during the interview, had positive assurance from Mrs. Reagan that such occurrences took place.

In an interview with the writer, a member of the police department said: "Yes, Mrs. Reagan saw and heard all that she has been credited with. She is very reliable and truthful. She is likewise discreet, and you may depend that she will say nothing to newspaper men. If approached I have no doubt she would absolutely refuse to talk and, perhaps, in self protection, would deny the story. But it is true. She reported it to the city marshal almost immediately after Emma's departure, and he in turn told Mr. Hilliard. The marshal was very much surprised.

"If Miss Lizzie were innocent of the murder of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, how would it be possible in any manner for Miss Emma to 'give her away?' Unless Lizzie had confided something to Emma that the latter had repeated to Mr. Jennings, there would have been no cause or reason for that conversation.

"That there has taken place

Some Violation of Confidence, or some revelation or fact that Emma was cognizant of, is apparent to the most devoted believer in Miss Borden's innocence. That so-called betrayal was great enough to cause anger on Miss Lizzie's part and make her turn back on her sister and wholly ignore her.

"It was important enough, if Mrs. Reagan speaks the truth, for Lizzie to say she 'would not give in a single inch,' and as Mrs. Reagan says, to emphasize her words, with a gesture in which she designated a portion of her little finger as being less than she would admit. I think this is the most important development in the Borden case since the arrest was made.

"I also think it may be possible after Bridget Sullivan gives her testimony on the stand for the state to proceed in other directions. It is understood among the subordinates in the police department that Bridget has said she

Saw Lizzie in the Cellar of the Borden house at the place where the axes were kept just prior to the murders. There are other important things that she will tell about, notably the girl's relations with the old folks. She tells a story of domestic discord among the Bordens, the like of which has not been printed in the newspapers as yet."

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The Globe reports secondhand claims that matron Mrs. Reagan overheard a bitter confrontation between Lizzie and Emma Borden in the jail, with Lizzie reportedly refusing to give any ground. The article also previews anticipated testimony from Bridget Sullivan about seeing Lizzie near the axes and domestic discord in the Borden household.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Pawtucket Tribune · 25 August 1892 · page 1

AN OUTBURST OF ANGER.

Miss Emma to ‘give her away? Unless Lizzle had mnflsw something to Emma that the latter had repeated to Mr. Jen nings, there would aave been no oause ox reason for that conversation “That there has taken place Some Violatien of Confldence, or some revelation or fact that Emma wase cognizant of, i appareot to the most de voted believer in {;lu Borden’s innocence. That so-called betrayal waa great enough to canuse auger on Miss Lizzie's part and make her turn back on her sister and wholly lgnore her. “It was lmportant enough, if Mrs. Rea

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes the opening of the second day of Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing in Fall River, with Dr. Dolan called as the first witness. It notes public anxiety over the case, denies rumors of a quarrel between Lizzie and her sister Emma, and suggests sentiment is shifting toward the prosecution.

The Providence News · 25 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN. THE ACCUSED WOMAN FACES A CURIOUS THRONG. HER ORDEAL HAS BEGUN. DR. DOLAN THE FIRST WITNESS CALLED TO TESTIFY. THE SISTERS' QUARREL DENIED.

JUDGE BLAISDELL. probably settle the fate of the unfortu nate woman who is accused must be made. Will the testimony to be given in the next five days sustain the government in its position or will it show Attorney Knowiton to have been lacking in judg ment? One week ago the verdict would have been against the authorities, To day sentiment has either changed or is re luctantly confessing that the winning cards have thus far appeared to be in the hands of the prosecution. The examination of Lizzie Borden to day created as much excitement as on Monday.

See moreSee less

The beginning of the hearing was set for 10 o’clock, but almost by daylight, eager and excited people thronged the ap proaches to the court honse. It was freely gossiped among the wait ing towns people that to-day’s proceeed ings would be but a repetition of Mon day’s and another adjournment would be in order. It was also insisted by the knowing ones that there would be no

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes the second day of Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, with large crowds gathering early and witnesses including Bridget Sullivan arriving at the courthouse. It also mentions gossip about a reported confrontation between Lizzie and her sister, though the paper notes this was likely exaggerated.

The Providence News · 25 August 1892 · page 1

for seats as soon as the court opened at 9 o'clock. Judge Blaisdell arrived earl¥ and at 9 o’cloek sharp began to dispose o a number of minor cases, These cases were all out of the way at 10 o’clock and then the witnesses in the Borden case bogan to arrive, Bridget Sullivan eame first., She was unaccompanied by anv friends to-day and was escorted to a seat by a cour. officer. Her appearance caused a great stir in court and all eyes were bent in her diree tion. Bank Treasurer Harb of the Union Savings Bank came next aud was followed

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes the courtroom scene as Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing begins, noting her composed demeanor and the arrival of counsel, officials, and family members. Medical Examiner Dr. Dolan takes the stand and begins describing the position of Andrew Borden's body on the sofa and his initial examination of the wounds.

The Providence News · 25 August 1892 · page 1

yesterday afternoon. Lizzie was followed by Mrs, Charles J. Holmes and Mrs, Brigham, and then came Miss Emma Borden, escorted by C. J. Holmes. A o 8 7

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Dr. Dolan, the medical examiner, testifies about the wounds, evidence collected including shoes and stockings sent to Prof. Wood, and details of entering the Borden house. Cross-examination by defense attorney Adams probes his experience with homicide cases and the specifics of the crime scene layout.

The Providence News · 25 August 1892 · page 7

LIZZIE BORDEN. The Examination of Dr. Dolan Is Continued.

and bed about three feet, “Did you hear the engineer say this morning that this spuce was 2 {eet. 10 inches.’ ¥ 3 3 “No, sir, there was about one foot space on either side of her.” “Are you aware that that would make Mrs. Borden not over eleven inches across, and yet you say she was a fau woman weighing 200 pounds and over " “Did you or any other persou move the

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Dr. Dolan testifies about entering the Borden house, the position of Abby Borden's body, and the blood flow near the bed. Cross-examination reveals discrepancies in room measurements and irregularities in the handling and timing of the autopsy reports.

The Providence News · 25 August 1892 · page 7

stairs "’ ; , Mr. Dolan further stated in reply—*‘l found the blood runnh}n{g fromn tue sofa under Mr. Borden. aircloth would offer resistence t» flow of blood by coagu lation. The amount of blood in the hu man body is almost one-theifth to one thirteenth of the weight of the body.” - “How much bloed would run out of a dead body?”’

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Testimony at the inquest revealed confusion and irregularities over the Borden autopsy reports, with dates and filings disputed and some records apparently not properly submitted to the court. Separately, the defense released a letter from a peddler named Samuel Robinsky claiming he encountered a blood-covered stranger near Fall River on the day of the murders who paid him for cleaning supplies and fled toward Boston.

The Providence News · 25 August 1892 · page 7

ANOTHER QUEER STRANGER.

One---An Interesting Letter, FALL RIVER, Aug. 25.—After the ad jourument of the court this noon, Mr. Adams of the counsel for the defense, furnished for publication a copy of a let ter received by Emma Borden, and pro duced the original copy and the envelope. According to the latter it was mailed in Waltham, Mass,, Aug. 18 at 1130 A, M. and received in Fall River on the same day at 4:30 P, M, The letter is as follows: WALTHAM, Mass., Aug. 17, 1802, Miss Emma Borden, Dear Madam: You must excuse that, | take the liberty in sending you these few lines. 1 ought to have written to you before this, but [ was unable todoso, as | was travling every day.

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

At the Fall River courthouse, a packed crowd watched as Judge Blaisdell opened the second day of hearings on Lizzie Borden's murder charge. Medical Examiner Dolan and other witnesses testified, though nothing of importance was revealed, and rumors circulated of a tense exchange between Lizzie and her sister Emma at the station house.

Alexandria Gazette · 25 August 1892 · page 2

Tlie Borden Trial. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 25.?Tho court room never before held such a crowd as that which greeted Judge Blaisdell this morning at 10 o'clock.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

At the inquest, Lizzie Borden testified she saw a suspicious man in the yard Monday night before the murders and wrote to her sister Emma about it; Emma reportedly destroyed the letter after showing it to friends. A second letter Lizzie sent to Marion friends, received the day of the murder, was also destroyed over fears its contents could be misconstrued.

The Times · 25 August 1892 · page 1

THE FALL RIVER TRAGEDY.

Emma. Inquiry develops the fact that on Wednesday Emma did get a letter from Liz zie. in which the latter refers to her anxiety over something which happened on Monday pight., When she was returning home from a call she noticed a man in the back yard just as she opened the side gate. He disap peared on discovering her, After entering the house Lizzie wrote she was so disturbed over what she had seen that she went to one of the windows in her room commanding the yard and watched.

See moreSee less

She saw a man who looked like the ono she had seen already moving about, but it was quite dark and she could not give any de scription of him. Emma Borden showed this letter to friends in Fair Haven with whom she was visiting when she received it, and then destroyed it, She says it also turns out that the letter which Lizzie Borden sent to her Marion friends, and which was received by them on the day of the murder, was also de stroyed because it contained reference to something, whieh, in the opinion of the young woman to whom it was sent, might in the light of subsequent events be miscon strued. Bome of the speculating ones sre pow wondering if that something was not this story of the suspicious man whom Lizzie told her sister was about the Borden house Monday night. — I a. hk. Brunswiek Demoeratiec Delegates,

See the clipping

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.

Charles H. Peckham walked into the Fall River police station and confessed to killing Andrew and Mrs. Borden, claiming he did it 'out of pure love for blood.' Police searched him, found odd personal effects, and began looking into his background while noting his claims seemed dubious.

Eagle River Review · 25 August 1892 · page 6

SAYS HE KILLED THE BORDENS

I want to be locked up.” The marshal took Peckham to the cell room and searched him.Hefound adpock et book with a few receiptsin it,and also unearthed some official communications from the Russian bureauat Washington. Peckham is 62 years ot age, about 5 feet 8 inches tall and has thin, grav beard. He says he leases a farm from Ildmund Davis. The police have started to hunt up his relatives or friends. The circumstances surrounding the assaesination of Borden and his wife were sach as to astound those who would pounce, off-hand, upou a motive.

See moreSee less

Borden was a rich and pious skinflint, aged 76 years, whose probity was equal to his thrift. He had mnot led a public life, he had no known enemy who, it could be conjectured, would go to the extent of killing him, much less his wife, and when the mu tilated bodies of the couple were dis covered, in their own Louse, shortly be fore noon on August 4, the police and the public were utterly at a loss for a motive, and in the intense excitement that overwhelmed the community they turned to one another in helpless astone isment and horrer. The body of Borden was found on a velvet sofa in the parlor of the house. His head had been literally hacked to pieces. There were seven long gashes on his face and skull, some of them an inch and a half deep through the flesh and bone. In the ‘‘spare’” bedcham ber on the second floor was dis:overed the body of Mrs. Borden, who was 67 vears old. There was at first no sight of blond, and the mementary supposi tion was that heart failure had occurred. Mrs. Borden was lying prone on the floor on her face with her arms out stretched and the toes of her shoes resting on the carpet. On raising the body there was seen a pool ot blood, and an examination disclosed the iact that death had been caused, as in the cace of the husband, by repeated blows of some heavy sharp lustrument on the face, neck and head. 1n the case of both there was found a deep cut into the brain. The first alarm was given by Lizzie Borden, who ran out into the yard and called for help. [Half of the police force of Fall River were off on a picnic when the murder occurred, and for that reason a strong guard of the premises was not furnished immediately, but sev eral ofticers were quickly in the house atter the alarm was given, and they learned enough to make it plain that robbery had not been the purpose of the killing. No plate or money or any of the valuables of the mansion were missing, nor had a single thing been removed irom the bodies. Borden’s watch and money and Mrs. Borden’s money and jewels were undisturbed. Miss Borden, a daughter of the mur dered couple, was put under poiice surveillance two days after the crime, but was not arrested until the week tol lowing. She was suspected chiefly by reason of certain discrepancies between her statements to the police as to the circumstances under which the bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Borden were found. The suspicion against her was ren dered stronger by a statement made to the police by Eli Bence, a clerk at D. R. Smith’s drug store, to the etlect that Miss Borden had been in his store two days before the murders inquiring for prussic acid or hydrocyanic acid. She failed to secure either. The drug clerk made a partial identification of Miss Borden, but later the ac curacy of his identification was denied. Miss Borden denied that she had bought or tried to buy either poison. Hydrocvanic acid leaves no outward trace on the body, and it was the con jecture of the physicians for the prose tion that this was the drug that had been used.

See the clipping

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.

A man named Peckham, found with a pocketbook and Russian bureau papers, is searched and questioned by police after claiming involvement in the Borden killings. The report recaps the original discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's hacked bodies, noting robbery was ruled out and Lizzie Borden raised the alarm.

Eagle River Review · 25 August 1892 · page 6

SAYS HE KILLED THE BORDENS

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.

The report describes the murder weapon wounds and notes robbery was ruled out since valuables were untouched. It details why Lizzie Borden became a suspect, including inconsistent statements and a drug clerk's claim she sought prussic acid before the killings.

Eagle River Review · 25 August 1892 · page 6

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · and 1 other paper

Lizzie Borden arrived from Taunton jail and had a preliminary hearing on murder charges, showing no visible distress. She reportedly assigned her personal property to her counsel, and her sister Emma vowed to spare no expense in her defense.

Wood County Reporter · 25 August 1892 · page 6

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRAIGNED. She Assigns Her .Personal Property to Pay for Counsel Fees. Falls River, Mass., Aug-. 22. —Miss Lizzie A. Borden arrived here from

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis. · 26 August 1892

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The preliminary hearing in the Borden case opened with Dr. Dolan, the medical examiner, undergoing lengthy cross-examination by defense attorney Adams, which exposed sloppy police and medical procedures. The official autopsy report was read, describing Andrew Borden's death from axe blows to the head.

Morning Journal and Courier · 26 August 1892 · page 3

Days' Proceeding. Pleasing to tne Defence Adjourned Till Tnls Bora. Inc. Fall Bitkb, Aug. 25. The. first day's hearing of the Borden case wm brought to a close at 5:80 this afternoon. Dr. Dolan who was first called to testify was still on the stand at adjournment. The principal things developed by Attorney Adams' long examination was the exposure of the slip-shod methods of the polios foroe and medioal examiner, one of the results of whioh ia the imprisonment of Miss Lizzie Borden. The principal government witness made a confession to this foot, allowing that his final searoh was delayed and that only a partial autopsy was held shortly after the bodies were discovered. The official reports eliminated of teohniealities were as follows:

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

This report details the official medical examiner's findings on the Borden murders, describing the wounds found on Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies during autopsy. It also includes courtroom testimony from Dr. Dolan explaining why his initial autopsy was only partial, with a complete report following a second examination weeks later.

Morning Journal and Courier · 26 August 1892 · page 3

THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

signed W. A. DOLAN. Medioal Examiner. Dated at Fall River, August 8, 1893. This was the report of the examination made August 4 of the body of Andrew J. Borden, seventy years of age. rne report on Mrs. Andrew j. Borden. sixty-seven years of age, says: rne autopsy proceeded as follows: On the left side of the head, over the ear, was a wound two and one-half inohes long, one quarter inch wide. On the right side of her head was a number of cuts pen etrating the brain, so intermingled as to be practically impossible to count.

See moreSee less

Tnls "partial report," upon which, coun sel for the defense dwelt sarcastically at some length, was not sent to Judge Blais dell until August 8. This portion of the government's case is most'clearly given in tne actual testimony.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Dr. Dolan testifies about his partial autopsy report submitted to the district attorney, describing wounds to Mrs. Borden's head and his examination of a hatchet with bloodstains. Defense attorney Adams presses him on whether he washed his hands after touching the bodies before handling the hatchet, and Dolan admits he initially forgot he had washed them.

Morning Journal and Courier · 26 August 1892 · page 3

Dr. Dolan's statements. It appeared to Dr. Dolan that all the wounds except one could have been infiioted while the body lay on the floor. Mrs. Borden's hair was 'down," that Is, not knotted up. and was slightly inclined to gray. One of the blows out the hair as smoothly as a razor would, but by the other wounds the hair was matted. Mr. Adams pressed witness about putting his fingers into the wounds in Mrs. Borden's head, then asked him if he washed his hands after he had handled the dead bodies. To this Dr. Dolan said:

See the clipping

The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn.

A brief notice states that Miss Collins of the Penny Press will report on the Lizzie Borden case at Fall River for the Connecticut Associated Press. This item appears amid a list of unrelated local social and sporting notes.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Willimantic Journal · 26 August 1892 · page 5

Howard Kite, C. Loomis and J. T. Byrnes. —A shooting match between a well known dentiBt and one of our big furni ture dealers at the Gun club’s grounds Wednesday resulted: 10 out of 25 for one and 7 out of 25 for the other. Other in formation about the match can be ob tained of the marksmen who are proud of their skill. —County Commissioners Kelly, Hall and Morse attended the state annual meeting of the boards at Rockville Wed nesday. The next meeting will be held in this city.

See moreSee less

—Miss Collins of the Penny Press will report the Lizzie Borden trial at Fall River for the Connecticut Associated Press. — Six car loads of Block Island excur sionists came down from Hartford, Thurs day morning. Be sure and put a box of Ayer’s Pills in your satchel before traveling, either by land or sea. You will find them conven ient, efficacious, and safe. The best rem edy for costiveness, indigestion, and sick headache, and adapted to any olimate. Republican Caucus. \ The Republican town committee will probably call the caucus for choosing dele gates to the state convention for Monday evening, Sept. 1. Reception at the Windham Wednesday evening Miss Gertie Turner gave a reception in honor of Miss Flor ence Abel of Brooklyn, N. Y., who is her guest at the Windham. There were so cial games, music and danciDg and a fine spread.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Lizzie Borden's lawyer released a letter from a Jewish peddler claiming he encountered a blood-covered man near Fall River on the day of the murders. The man told him he had fought with a farmer over unpaid wages and bought items to clean himself up, including boot blacking to cover bloodstains.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 26 August 1892 · page 2

Stand Nearly All Day. Fall Kiver, Mass., Aug. 20. Lawyer Jennings, counsel for Lizzie Borden, has given out the following letter, which is considered by the defense to be a most important clue in the murder mystery. It was mailed on Aug. 18, and received the same day: "Waltham, Mass., Aug. 17, 1S93. Miss Emma Borden: Dear Madam You must excuse that

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

A letter writer named Rebinsky describes a nervous stranger peddler he encountered near Fall River, which defense counsel is investigating. The report also covers the crowded second day of Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, including Dr. Dolan's testimony about the axe wounds and bloody hatchet found in the cellar.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 26 August 1892 · page 2

Borden on the charge oi killing her lather with an axe. Clergymen, laymen, physicians and more than lo0 ladies who were not direct ly connected with the case were seated and standing in all parts of the room while inside tho rail was an extraordinary crowd of reporters and other newspaxter workers. Ladies occupied morn than two-thinh of the seats usually occupied by the curi ous gang who usually llock into the lower courts. At 10:o0 o'clock Charles J. Holmes ap peared with Miss Emma Borden on his arm. Following them came Mrs, Hrighom. Mrs. Holmes and Kev. Mr.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Defense counsel in the Borden case released a letter from a peddler named Samuel Robbins claiming he encountered a bloodstained stranger on the day of the murder, though the man could not be located. The first day of preliminary hearings closed with little new revealed except criticism of police and medical examiner methods that led to Lizzie Borden's imprisonment.

The Morning Call · 26 August 1892 · page 1

THK BOItOKN MURDER& A Peddler Claims to Have Been the Alleged Murderer. FALL River, Mass., An?. 25.— 1n the Bordcn murder eaaa counsel for tho de fense has given out a letter signed by one Samuel Robbins, telling in a rambling way ol Ihe writer's interview with a blood stained stranger on the day of the murder. The writer of the letter la' known in Walton as a peddler, but he cannal now be found. The first day's hcarine In the Bordeu case closed this evening. Nothing new was de veloped except, perhaps, the peculiar methods of the police force and the medical examiner, one of the results of which Is the Imprisonment of Mis* Lizzie Borden.

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

During the Borden preliminary hearing, the defense was given a letter from a man named Samuel Robbins describing an encounter with a blood-stained stranger on the day of the murders. The letter writer, known locally as a peddler, could not be located, and the report notes the hearing otherwise revealed mainly the sloppy work of police and the medical examiner.

Los Angeles Herald · 26 August 1892 · page 5

A BLOOD-STAINED STRANGER. New Evidence in the Borden Murder Case. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 25. —In the Borden murder case, today, counsel for the defense was given a letter signed by Samuel Robbins, telling in a rambling way, of the writer's .interview with a blood-stained stranger the day of the murder. The writer of the letter I Is known in Walton as a peddler, but cannot now be found. The first day's bearing in the Borden case closed this evening. Noth ing new developed except, perhaps, the slip-shod methods of tbe police force ami medical examiner, one of the re sults of which is the imprisonment of Miss Lizzie Borden.

See the clipping

In the story →

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

On the first day of the preliminary hearing in the Borden case, Dr. Dolan testified about the condition of the bodies, the wounds, and bloodstains on the hatchet, suggesting police and medical examiners used sloppy methods. Lizzie Borden showed little emotion except when the wounds to her father were described.

Evening Journal · 26 August 1892 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN'S ORDEAL.

The First Day's Hearing Develops Official Slipshod Methods.

See moreSee less

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 26.—The first day's hearing of the Borden case was brought to a close while Dr. Dolan, who was first called to testify, was still on the stand. The principal thing developed by Attorney Adams' long examination was the exposure of the slipshod methods of the police force and medical examiner, one of the results of which is the imprisonment of Miss Lizzie A. Borden. The principal government witness made a confession to this fact, saying that his final search was delayed and that only a partial autopsy was held shortly after the bodies were discovered.

The witness, after describing the condition of the bodies when found, said that in his opinion the wounds were made by the same instrument. The edge would not necessarily be dulled by the successive blows.

Continuing his testimony, the medical examiner told of examining the clothing of the Borden girls and described the stains and hairs found on the hatchet. He thought Mr. Borden's assailant stood between the head of Mr. Borden and the dining room door. From the position of the assailant and Mr. Borden, he thought the former would have received more blood above the waist than below.

He thought the deed could have been done and the person doing it not have more than ten spots on his clothing.

Miss Lizzie Borden did not betray any noticeable feeling during the whole day, except possibly in three or four instances. One was when Dr. Dolan described the ghastly wounds on her father. Then she flushed and tears came into her eyes. She closed her eyes and hid her face behind a palmleaf fan and leaned toward her sister, who also remained with closed eyes until the dreadful tale was ended.

Miss Lizzie and her attorneys are well pleased with the result of the first day's proceedings. They see nothing which attaches the crime to the house, but see a great deal to show careless and even shiftless methods on the part of the prosecution.

Lawyer Jennings, counsel for the defense, gave out a letter purporting to be from Samuel Robinsky, a Jew peddler, who said that on the day of the murder a man whose clothing was covered with blood bought from him four handkerchiefs, a looking glass, collar, necktie and some shoe blacking. The peddler did not then know of the murder and helped the man to "fix up." The defense claim to know that there was a peddler named Robinsky about Fall River on the day of the murder and are making a search for him.

See the clipping

Milford Chronicle · Milford, Del.

This report recaps the Fall River murders of Andrew and Abby Borden, noting Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony, arrest, and imprisonment. It adds that Bridget Sullivan, the family's servant, may hold knowledge that could implicate Lizzie, and that the murder weapon was a hatchet.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Rock Island Daily Argus, 25 August 1892, Pawtucket Tribune, 25 August 1892.

Milford Chronicle · 26 August 1892 · page 2

possessed of a magnetic I erne and charming address. ia true to his friend*», loyal to h )j party, firm in his convictions,and tiff intelligence, eourugc.iuid tact to de fend the measures of bis platform und the principles of the Republican party against assaults of competi tion. The Republican party recog I nizes in him a leader fit to follow, and will triumphantly elect him,feel ing that in elevating him, ho will re flect honor alike on his State and himself. Although the weather looked un propitious on Tuesday, the Demo cratic delegates of Kent assembled at Dover all the same, and went through the form of making out their ticket; which labor had been prac tically accomplished on the Saturday previous at the primaries—when the men were named to carry out the slate already fixed by the leaders.

See moreSee less

The ticket made out is not near so strong as that they placed before the people two years ago—when James Williams an<^ Governor Hall were named jis Senators. In nominating Willi«! T. Watson for Senator,they bayer" probably put forward their bestand most available man,but Mr. Watson and his colleague—Mr. Lacy represent the Reynolds Stockley-Gray ring of their -party, and it is against that branch the conservative Democrats are kicking, and possibly bolt the ticket. Fall Rivkr, Mar«., was lately the scene of two atrocious murders— Andrew J. Borden and his wife— aged and wealthy people. For some mu days the authorities were at a loss to find a clue to the perpetrator, but at last suspicion fell on Lizzie Borden, one of the two daughters of the mur dered man. She was examined at the inqucst.and her arrest and com mitment to prison followed. The public believed her innocent of the unnatural, fiendish crime; but still, > the detectives were supposed to have some incriminating evidence which they withheld. It now trans pires that Bridget Sullivan, a hired girl in the Borden family, may be possessed of a knowledge of facts that will fasten the crime on Lizzie Borden, the daughter of the mur dered man. It is alleged that the murder was done with a hatchet. Her friends were ill prepared for this revelation,and say that if she did it, she was crazy at the time. For the sak< of the veneration we all feel for I, it is hoped the girl may yet worn escape' com pHcity in the crime. T'mAUsastrons. fi-cs on the lower part of the Peninsula, wont,. . 1 ^. ; sufficient warning to every town of 2,000 inhabitants to provide water works. The cost to Milford of the light and »rater works was about 140,000, and wc feel reasonably pre combat an only half our population,without any means of putting out fire except well water, which was soon exhausted, loses $100,000 above insurance in a single night; twice and a-half as much as the entire light and water plant at Milford cost,and they have nothing to show for it but ashes and misery. A standpipe and water mains extending only in front of the most compactly built parts of the town could have been put in place at a cost of less than $10,000, which a prosperous town like Delumr could well and safely afford, and it would in all probability have saved valua ble human lives,and property aggre gating $100,000. The advantages of water works are many. Rates of insurance would be much reduced; comfort,cleanliness and health would be promoted; the consciousness of reasonable safeguards against lire would induce the erection of new buildings and the expansiou of busi ness enterprises. And when a fire broke out a means for its speedy ex tinction would be at jiand—exceed ing in celerity and efficacy all the water that five limes the population could effectually bring to boar with water buckets, because of the power to force the water through heated space that no man could endure anil live. For the credit of the Slate of Del aware and the Chief Executive of the State,we earnestly hoped on reading the letter below,alleged lo have been son. written hy Governor Robert J Rey nolds to John T. Dickey, receiver of taxes at Wilmington, that it was not sustained by facts; but further news from Wilmington bears corrobora tive evidence that it is genuine, ft is as follows : ExbcutiveDepartmbnt } DovrvR. Du,., July 27, 1892

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Dr. Dolan testifies about the ghastly wounds on Mr. Borden's body and the location of bloodstains, while a witness named Adams describes finding hatchets in the cellar, one of which may have matched the fatal wounds. Lizzie Borden reacts emotionally during the graphic testimony, hiding her face behind a fan.

New-York Tribune · 26 August 1892 · page 3

SLIPSHOD METHODS OF THE POLICE

the successive blows. sarily be dulled by The Medical Examiner told of examining the cloth the stadns described and girls, Borden of the ing thought the He hatchet, the Jirs found on and person doing the and done, heen cond have deed hie clothing. not have had more than ten spots ou It District Atthis tedious examination, All through objection. Miss hamly ralsed an torney Knowlton potlceable feeling not betray any Lizzie Borden did three or four in day, except In during the whole when Dr. Dolan described the (me Wis shane s, her father. Then «he flushed wounds Oh ghastly She closed her eyes into her eves, and tears came

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At the second day of Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing before Judge Blaisdell, Medical Examiner Dolan described the wounds on the victims' bodies, stating they were made by a sharp instrument like an axe or hatchet. The report also mentions a surveyor's testimony on the house layout and a strange story from a peddler about a man seen with bloody clothing.

New-York Tribune · 26 August 1892 · page 3

Mr. Knowlton is not on In case 4 to show where Mr. Borden was the mornbe calle w the murder. ing previous connsel for the defence, has gdven out Mr. Jennings, publication, a letter for named Samuel Robipsky, Hebrew pedler witnesses will han Waltham, from dated written

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At the preliminary hearing, Dr. Dolan testified about the wounds, the hatchet, and bloodstains found during the autopsy, while defense attorney Adams aggressively challenged inconsistencies in his account, including claims about washing his hands and handling the hatchet. The report also notes only a partial autopsy was initially done, with a second examination conducted a week later.

New-York Tribune · 26 August 1892 · page 3

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A roundup of news briefly notes that on the second day of proceedings against Lizzie Borden in Fall River, testimony revealed slipshod methods by police and the medical examiner. The item is one line among many unrelated domestic and foreign news items in the day's digest.

New-York Tribune · 26 August 1892 · page 6

THE NEWS THIS MORNING

Berlin and Vienna have established a rigid quarantine against Hamburg: there were 2,743 deaths — A heavy vote | from the disease in Russia, = was polled in Newcastle, where John Morely stood for re-election to the Commons; the result will be annonnced to-day. === Another revolt against the Ameer of Afghanistan has broken out. ——= There were two dynamite explosions in Trieste: little damage was done. Domestic. —Grand Master Sweeney was beaten by a striking gwitchman at Buffalo: a boy who was throwing stones was shot hy a soldier of the 224 Regiment: about 1,500 soldiers left Buffalo for their homes.

See moreSee less

—— = Chancellor McGill, at Trenton, rendered a decision against the coal combine. == At the secon day’s trial of Lizzie Borden, at Fall River, elipshod methods on the part of the police and medieal examiner were shown, —= More than 200 men employed in the Carnegie Twenty-ninth-st. mill, Pittsburg, began a sympathy strike. Additional corresponlence between Seerctary J. W. Foster and Mr. Herbert concerning Canadian discrimination in coal tolls way mad: public. John Randolph Tucker, of Virginia, delivered the annual address before the American Bar Association; reports of standing committees were read. City and Suburban.—Immigrants suspected of cholera had their baggage thoroughly fumigated: the Hamburg-American Line, on account of the cholera, discontinued its cabin passenger service

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The report notes that Bridget Sullivan, the Borden family's servant, is not staying silent like a past witness but is instead sharing sensational stories about family quarrels at the Borden home while Lizzie Borden undergoes examination for the murders. It speculates that Sullivan's accounts could be decisive in a case built on circumstantial evidence.

The Morning News · 26 August 1892 · page 4

It seems that Bridget Sullivan, the ser vant of the Bordens, at Fall River, Mas*., is uot another Becky Jones. The Jones woman, it will be remembered, suffered long confinement in prison for refusing to divulge in court the family secrets of the Hamersleys; but the Hulllvan woman is regaling her friends at Fall River, where Lizzie Borden is undergoing examination on the charge of having murdered her father aud etep-mother, with sensational stories of family rows at the Borden resideuoe. Lizzie Borden's fate, which bangs nn circumstan tial evidence, may be decided by tbe Sulli van vomsn'i stories.

See moreSee less

A convention of the “ex-jaggers,” other wise Keeiey institute graduates of South Carolina, is to be held iu the near future. Jt is not stated what relation the meeting will bear to tbe political situation. But if tbe opposition, whichever party that may hap pen to be, should wish to get up an over shadowing counter demonstration, a con vention of the unterrified regulars would be tbe proper thing. George Gould deuiee the story that his father, Jay Gould, contemplates “unload ing” bis Western Union stock and giviug up control of that concern. However, if Mr. Gould bad any such idea he would Laidiy advertise U in tho uewipoit Our Military Organizations. Some of our rural statesmen are inclined to think that the money appropriated by the legislature for the militia is money i wasted. Many of them object to taking any part of the people’s money for military organisations. These statesmen do not look ahead. From their point of view the state will never have any reason to call on the state troops for help. Those of them who are candidates for the legislature should notioe particularly the labor troubles that have occurred in several states within the last month or two. If It ha.l not been for the presence of state troops at Homestead there would have been, in ail probability, a very great loss of property and a very considerable loss of life. At Buffalo the presence of the state troops checked what promised to be a very disastrous strike, and In Tennessee the free miners would have overridden the law and humil iated the state, besides costing the state many thousands of dollars for damage to state. property, if the state troops had not been sent to the soene of the trouble quickly. In this state apprehensions were felt on Wednesday by the state authorities that an attempt would be made to liberate the oonviots in the Dade county coal mines. The services of state troops may not be needed by the state often, but when they are needed the demand for them is impera tive. A condition of affairs llikely to arise at any time in which the civil authorities would not be able to restore order or pre vent the destruotion of property worth more than the amount likely to be ap propriated by the state In half a duxen years for military purposes. It has not been vary long since the military rendered great service In this city. A strike that might have culminated in a riot was settled poaceably. It is impossible to say how the strike would have terminated if all tendency toward lawlessness had not been cbeoked by the troops. The legislature would make a great mis take if It should omit in its budgot an ap propriation for the militia. The need In every state for a good militia force is steadily becoming more apparent. Where Did the Money Qo? Now that parties Interested in Richmond Terminal are making charges and counter charges, bssed upon the belief that there was crooked work of some sort in the man agement of Its affairs, a very general desire is cropping out here to know whether the large floating debt and cither obligations of the Georgia Central were legitimately accu mulated. A few days ago the Macon Telegraph pub lished a special from New iu which it waa stated that in ISBB Gen. Alexander, as president of the Central, gave a certifi cate to the efTect that the Central was pay- ■ ing all its fixed charges, Interest on its float ing debt, providing for Its sinking fund and earning 14 per cent. on its stock. What those who are interested in Central’s securities now want to know is, how It was that a railroad with such splendid earning power became bankrupt in less than four years from the time that certiflcate was given. Receiver Comer Is having the financial affairs of the Central inquired into thor oughly by an expert with the view of re organizing the property. He ought also to have a statement prepared showing what be came of the Central's earnings from the time the Raoul management was ousted to the time of the appointment of a recelvor, and alio the money that is represented by new obligations and the floating debt. If the money was properly spent and the debt was accumulated legitimately the facts ought to be made public in justice to those who were rosp insible for the road's Berlin. management, and if the Wall street in fluences wnioh controlled the road diverted its property from its legitimate uses that fact ought to he known. What is wanted is a history of the road’s financial affairs for the last five or six years. It would be an interesting history to many people.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

At Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing in Fall River, Medical Examiner Dolan testified about the position of the murdered couple and sending their stomachs to Harvard for analysis. Surveyor Kernan then testified about a blood spot on a door-casing, suggesting its trajectory.

The Indianapolis Journal · 26 August 1892 · page 1

WHEN LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL

' Stained Hatchet and Clothing The Ac cused's Demeanor During the Day. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 25. The Sec ond District Court-room never before held such a crowd as that which greeted Judge lilaisdol this morning. It was the second date agreed upon for the hearing of Miss Lizzie A. Borden on the charge oi killing her father with an ax. Clergymen, lay men, lawyers, physicians, and more than 150 women, who were'not directly connect ed with the case, were seated and standing in all parts of the room, "while inside tho rail was an extraordinary number of report ers.

See moreSee less

Women occupied more tban two-thirds of tho sears usually occupied by the curious people who usually frequent the lower courts. At 10:30 Mr. Charles J. Holmes ap peared with Miss Emma Borden on his arm. Miss Lizzie Borden came in last with Marshal Hilllard. 8he was handed to a seat between her two legal advisers and near a sottee on which her sister was seated. The two women sat elbow to elbow. Miss Lizzie was at her sister's right hand. Not a word passed between them. ' "We are ready to proceed your honor." said District-attorney Knowlton. At 10:S0 Medical Examiner Dolan was called to the stand. The witness testified to tho posi tion of the murdered couple when found, nnd to sending their stomachs to Professor Wood, -of Harvard College, for analysis. Surveyor Kernan was the next witness, lie thought from the appearance of a spot of blood on the door-casing that it was thrown from the sitting room toward the ki tchen. Dr. Dolan was called back to the stand. "What caused Mr. Borden's death!" was asked. . Witness Ho died from shock, and tho body was still warm when witness arrived at the house. A question as to the force required was. o bice ted to, but the objection wan over-" ruled. Witness eaid the wounds could be' made by any person of ordinary strength using moderate force. Jn the witness's opinion Mrs. Borden had been dead about au hour ana a half when he saw ber. ttne died of shock. Witness saw four axes in the cellar of the house. He examined one and found it had been scraped and washed. Under the glass it showed stains which looked like blood. There was some hair on it, also. He took some dress-skirts and un derskirts from the house, the property of Miss Borden, the defendant. Dr. Dolan's examination lasted all day. The principal things developed by attorney Adams was tho exposure of the slip-shod methods of the polioe force and medical ex aminer, one of the results of which was the

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

At the probable-cause hearing, Medical Examiner Dolan testified about the victims' wounds, time of death, and a hatchet found in the cellar with apparent blood and hair. Defense attorney Adams challenged the thoroughness of the police and medical investigation.

The Indianapolis Journal · 26 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Defense attorney Adams questioned Dr. Dolan about the murder weapon and blood evidence, highlighting sloppy police and medical examiner methods. Lizzie Borden showed little emotion except when wounds were described, and the defense expressed satisfaction with the day's proceedings.

The Indianapolis Journal · 26 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL

Adams was tho exposure of the slip-shod methods of the polioe force and medical ex aminer, one of the results of which was the imprisonment of Miss Lizzie Borden. Mr. Adams wanted to know if Dr. Dolan thought that the hatchet with the peculiar clay head was the identical one which pro duced the crushed wound in Mrs.. Bor den's head. He thought it could have done it. Continuing his testimony, tho medical examiner told of examining the clothing of the Borden girls aud described the stains and hair found oa the hatchet.

See moreSee less

Ho thought Mr. Borden's assailant stood behind the head of Mr. Borden and the dining-room door, perhaps midway of the opening. From the position of the assailant and Mr. Borden he tnought the former would have received more blood about the waist than below. He thought the person doing tho deed could have not more than ten spots of blood on his clothing. All through this exhaustive and tedious examination District Attorney Knowhou hardly raised an objection. Miss Lizzie Borden did not botray any noticeablo feel

See the clipping

Dziennik Chicagoski · Chicago, Ill.

The report describes the ongoing Fall River proceedings against Lizzie Borden, noting that her defense submitted a letter from peddler Samuel Robinsky claiming he met a blood-stained stranger near the farm on the day of the murders. It also notes Lizzie's calmer demeanor in court and claims general opinion now favors her innocence.

Dziennik Chicagoski · 26 August 1892 · page 1

Morderstwo w Fall River

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A short wire-service item among several unrelated news briefs states that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother is proceeding at Fall River, Massachusetts. It notes that the testimony presented is entirely circumstantial.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Rock Island Daily Argus · 26 August 1892 · page 4

ABBREVIATED TELEGRAMS.

W. Maddox; Eighth Georgia, Thomas G. Lawson. Thomas Smith shot and killed his wife and himself at the home of a friend near Denver, Colo. The couple had been separ ated for some time, and jealousy is as signed as the cause. Enoch May, the oldest printer iu the west, died in Burlmgtcn, la., aged 91 years. He was born in Boston, and bad lived in Burlington since 1840. The trial of Lizzie Borden for the mur

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report summarizes the double murder of Andrew and Abby Borden, describing the wounds, body locations, and the discovery that Mrs. Borden died well before her husband. It notes Lizzie Borden's arrest after a week of investigation, with the formal complaint naming her only in her father's murder.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 August 1892 · page 2

THE FACTS OF THE~BORDEN CASE. Andrew J. Borden, a rich man of Fall River, and his wife, were found murdered in their home about 11 o’clock on the morning of Friday, August 5. Both had been killed, it appeared, by a hatchet or au ax, or some such weapon, for their heads were frightfully hacked, no less than 12 distinct wounds being counted on Mr Borden alone. When found Mrs Borden was lying face down on the floor in a spare bedroom on the second story, while Mr Borden was seated on the sofa in the sitting-room on the first floor.

See moreSee less

The location of Mrs Borden’s wounds seemed to show that she had been struck by some one who had crept up behind, while Mr Bor den, it appeared, had been struck while asleep or unconscious of impending danger. Later investigation by the police authorities has established ♦re fact that Mrs Borden died at least an hour, perhaps 1% hours, be fore her husband did. The first alarm was given by Miss Lizzie Borden, daughter of Mr Borden and step-daughter of Mrs Borden, within 15 minutes after Mr Borden was known to be alive. After a week’s assiduous investigation and patient chasing of fruitless clews that had seemed to implicate outsiders as the guilty ones, the Fall River police c harged Miss Liz zie Borden with having murdered her father with a hatchet, and they arrested her for the crime. The exact text of the complaint does not charge Miss Dizzie with having murdered her step-mother, so we may infer that such evidence as the police have gathered impli cates her more directly with the murder of her own parent than with the murder of one who was not her parent at all. Now Miss Lizzie Borden denies having committed either crime or having any knowledge what ever concerning them. Her story is that she arose from her bed and walked down stairs late in the forenoon. She saw her father in the sitting-room, spoke to him and then went to the barn where she remained about 30 minutes. There she heard a cry of distress from the house. Running in she found her father just as he was found by the police after she had shrieked an alarm. Her cries aroused the servant, Bridget O’Sullivan, and a neighbor. Then she and Bridget searched for Mrs Bor den and found her upstairs as already de scribed. Bridget O’Sullivan and Miss Borden were the only members of the household in the house or on the premises at the time of the murders. This servant, according to her own story, was sent to w'ash the windows on the third floor at about 9.30 o'clock. When Mr Borden came in from the street she went to the door and admitted him, between 10.45 and 11 o’clock. Then she went upstairs tv wash the windows, and did not come down again until the alarm was given. The move ments of Mr and Mfb Borden, so far as can be determined, were simple enough. The wife left the house soon after breakfast to visit some one, and the husband followed within a short time. Mrs Borden, it is alleged, went out in response to a note from a friend, but thus far, according to the evidence as known to the public, the identity of that Jriend is a mystery. At any rate, Mrs Bor den must have returned home within a com paratively short time. Mr Borden went down street. Charles M. Horton swears that at 10.30 o’clock he talked with him aboard the Chace mill car. Mr Borden alighted from the car and walked up South Main street, stopped for a moment at his block and then went to bis home,where the servant says she admitted him between 10.45 and 11 o’clock. Some one killed Mrand Mrs Borden. What ground have the police for charging the daughter with the crime? They have been utterly baffled in their attempt to connect any other person with the double butchery, $o if r Miss Lizzie be innocent^ this from this state who spoke on the bill. But he said nothing about the prostration of Massachusetts industry. Be claimed to be a protectionist and gave the Bouse in a gen eral way a few of his opinions as to that pol icy. And then—ho proceeded to attack that part of the Morrill bill which restored the duties on certain cheaper grades of wool which had been coining in free under the 1857 tarilf. Mr Dawes spoke on May 9, 1860. We call the attention of his present constit uents to what he then said about taxing raw wool:— If the object (of these proposed duties on raw wool), on the other hand, be to protect, the wool-grower, it has been demonstrated very clearly, I think, that the wool-grower receives advantage from the introduction of i this kind of wool. It enlarges the range of manufacture. It calls for a greater demand for American wool in connection with the manufacture of this wool. There is, there fore, no occasion for this duty. It injures the wool-grower. The gentleman (Stanton of Ohio),I think, does not understand the man ner in which wool is manufactured, and the necessity there is to have the loreign wool to mix with the American wool. He is mis taken when he thinks that so much fine wool introduced into the country supplants so much American wool. It aids the manu facture of American wool and all the statis tics since the tariff of 1857 show that to be so. If, therefore, the gentleman desires to in crease the product of American wool he must make a larger market here, at home, and a larger range of manufacture. If he stimu lates the introduction of such foreign wool as is mixed with American wool, he will stimulate and enlarge the manufacture of all kinds of wool grown in this country. Here is the argument for free wool just as it stands 32 years from that date. It is as unassailable to-day as it was then. We have been urging it in season and out. And for ibis the senator says we are free traders. Did it make him out a free trader in 1860? It is the senator who has gone awry. It is he, and not The Republican, who has repudiated the original republican protective policy. He has developed into a type of protectionist he would never have recognized as such in that day: it is not The Republicanthat has developed into a free trader. No talk then from Mr Dawes about “proter non” through high duties on raw material or about the need of 100 per cent duties on manufactured goods. Give the manufacturers free wool, he said then, and they will prosper under duties of 15 to 30 per cent on manufactured goods and will give the domestic wool-grower a better market than he could otherwise hope to have. Now republicans cry havoc and go into spasms of fear when democrats propose free wool and duties of 30 to 40 per cent on woolens. And Mr Dawes, too, seemed to think, with Sena tor Wilson, that that “free trade tariff” of 1857 was a splendid thing for Massachusetts— “the best tariff ever put upon the statute ‘books of this country.”

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

This report summarizes the medical findings on time of death, the arrest of Lizzie Borden for her father's murder, and her own account of events that morning. It also describes Bridget O'Sullivan's movements and claims about Mr. and Mrs. Borden's whereabouts before the murders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 August 1892 · page 2

of Friday, August 5. Both had been killed, it appeared, by a hatchet or au ax, or some such weapon, for their heads were frightfully hacked, no less than 12 distinct wounds being counted on Mr Borden alone. When found Mrs Borden was lying face down on the floor in a spare bedroom on the second story, while Mr Borden was seated on the sofa in the sitting-room on the first floor. The location of Mrs Borden’s wounds seemed to show that she had been struck by some one who had crept up behind, while Mr Bor den, it appeared, had been struck while asleep or unconscious of impending danger.

See moreSee less

Later investigation by the police authorities has established ♦re fact that Mrs Borden died at least an hour, perhaps 1% hours, be fore her husband did. The first alarm was given by Miss Lizzie Borden, daughter of Mr Borden and step-daughter of Mrs Borden, within 15 minutes after Mr Borden was known to be alive. After a week’s assiduous investigation and patient chasing of fruitless clews that had seemed to implicate outsiders as the guilty ones, the Fall River police c harged Miss Liz zie Borden with having murdered her father with a hatchet, and they arrested her for the crime. The exact text of the complaint does not charge Miss Dizzie with having murdered her step-mother, so we may infer that such evidence as the police have gathered impli cates her more directly with the murder of her own parent than with the murder of one who was not her parent at all. Now Miss Lizzie Borden denies having committed either crime or having any knowledge what ever concerning them. Her story is that she arose from her bed and walked down stairs late in the forenoon. She saw her father in the sitting-room, spoke to him and then went to the barn where she remained about 30 minutes. There she heard a cry of distress from the house. Running in she found her father just as he was found by the police after she had shrieked an alarm. Her cries aroused the servant, Bridget O’Sullivan, and a neighbor. Then she and Bridget searched for Mrs Bor den and found her upstairs as already de scribed. Bridget O’Sullivan and Miss Borden were the only members of the household in the house or on the premises at the time of the murders. This servant, according to her own story, was sent to w'ash the windows on the third floor at about 9.30 o'clock. When Mr Borden came in from the street she went to the door and admitted him, between 10.45 and 11 o’clock. Then she went upstairs tv wash the windows, and did not come down again until the alarm was given. The move ments of Mr and Mfb Borden, so far as can be determined, were simple enough. The wife left the house soon after breakfast to visit some one, and the husband followed within a short time. Mrs Borden, it is alleged, went out in response to a note from a friend, but thus far, according to the evidence as known to the public, the identity of that Jriend is a mystery. At any rate, Mrs Bor den must have returned home within a com paratively short time. Mr Borden went down street. Charles M. Horton swears that at 10.30 o’clock he talked with him aboard the Chace mill car. Mr Borden alighted from the car and walked up South Main street, stopped for a moment at his block and then went to bis home,where the servant says she admitted him between 10.45 and 11 o’clock. Some one killed Mrand Mrs Borden. What ground have the police for charging the daughter with the crime? They have been utterly baffled in their attempt to connect any other person with the double butchery, $o if r Miss Lizzie be innocent^ this from this state who spoke on the bill. But he said nothing about the prostration of Massachusetts industry. Be claimed to be a protectionist and gave the Bouse in a gen eral way a few of his opinions as to that pol icy. And then—ho proceeded to attack that part of the Morrill bill which restored the duties on certain cheaper grades of wool which had been coining in free under the 1857 tarilf. Mr Dawes spoke on May 9, 1860. We call the attention of his present constit uents to what he then said about taxing raw wool:— If the object (of these proposed duties on raw wool), on the other hand, be to protect, the wool-grower, it has been demonstrated very clearly, I think, that the wool-grower receives advantage from the introduction of i this kind of wool. It enlarges the range of manufacture. It calls for a greater demand for American wool in connection with the manufacture of this wool. There is, there fore, no occasion for this duty. It injures the wool-grower. The gentleman (Stanton of Ohio),I think, does not understand the man ner in which wool is manufactured, and the necessity there is to have the loreign wool to mix with the American wool. He is mis taken when he thinks that so much fine wool introduced into the country supplants so much American wool. It aids the manu facture of American wool and all the statis tics since the tariff of 1857 show that to be so. If, therefore, the gentleman desires to in crease the product of American wool he must make a larger market here, at home, and a larger range of manufacture. If he stimu lates the introduction of such foreign wool as is mixed with American wool, he will stimulate and enlarge the manufacture of all kinds of wool grown in this country. Here is the argument for free wool just as it stands 32 years from that date. It is as unassailable to-day as it was then. We have been urging it in season and out. And for ibis the senator says we are free traders. Did it make him out a free trader in 1860? It is the senator who has gone awry. It is he, and not The Republican, who has repudiated the original republican protective policy. He has developed into a type of protectionist he would never have recognized as such in that day: it is not The Republicanthat has developed into a free trader. No talk then from Mr Dawes about “proter non” through high duties on raw material or about the need of 100 per cent duties on manufactured goods. Give the manufacturers free wool, he said then, and they will prosper under duties of 15 to 30 per cent on manufactured goods and will give the domestic wool-grower a better market than he could otherwise hope to have. Now republicans cry havoc and go into spasms of fear when democrats propose free wool and duties of 30 to 40 per cent on woolens. And Mr Dawes, too, seemed to think, with Sena tor Wilson, that that “free trade tariff” of 1857 was a splendid thing for Massachusetts— “the best tariff ever put upon the statute ‘books of this country.”

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report recaps the movements of Mr. and Mrs. Borden and the servant Bridget on the morning of the murders, noting Mrs. Borden left after receiving an unidentified note. It also questions the state's case against Lizzie Borden, noting the secret inquest and the difficulty of establishing a motive for a woman of her reputation.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 August 1892 · page 2

terest in the case. Before, it had been de scribing to its readers with great volubility the terrible effects of this “free trade tariff” on Massachusetts manufactures. Several columns a week were being devoted to this purpose, and finally we were told that every one of the Massachusetts representatives in Congress voted for the Morrill tariff of 1861 because of the disastrous effects of the “free ‘trade tariff” on the industries of the state. But since learing that Senator Wilson for one declared that he voted for tlie Morrill tariff merely as a measure to increase the revenue and that as for protection “the tariff of 1857, ‘precisely and exactly as it stands upon your •statute book to-day, so far as the productive ‘industry of Massachusetts is concerned, is scribed.

See moreSee less

•the best tariff ever put upon the statute ‘books of this country,”—since hearing this the Journal dropped the subject just as quick as ever it could and has not returned to it Jong enough even to tell its readers that it had been hoodwinking them. This was where Henry Wilson stood. How about the other representatives of Massachu setts in the 36th Congress ? Did they vote for the Morrill tariff to relieve Massachu setts manufacturers from the alleged dis tressful conditions of the “free trade tariff” of 1857? Will the Journal name any of the 13 representatives and senators from Massa chusetts in that Congress who did? We have searched the records carefully and can not find even one. Senator Sumner’s inter est in the Morrill bill was confined—quite characteristically—chiefly to assailing its pro posed taxes on books and the paper which is a means of spreading knowledge. Going into the lower branch of Congress we find the Massachusetts representatives there singularly indifferent as to this measure which was to restore the protected indus tries of the state. Indeed, very few of them spoke on the bill at all. And the few who did speak, as in the case of Senator Sumner, confined tbemselves to attackingfthe more re strictive or highly “protective^” features of the bill. They said nothing about! this o’clock. alleged prostration of Massachusetts indus tries under a low tariff. We should not dream, from their remarks, that any such condition existed. And it did not exist. The present senior senator of Massachu setts, Mr Dawes, was then in th* Mouse, and Jte wa* uuo es th* two ox Uirtv members thirsty atrocity, committed almost at high noon in the heart of a city, remains to this day an impenetrable mystery. But that in itself is no evidence that the girl did it. In order to convict her the state must weave a web of incontrovertible facts demonstrating to the satisfaction of 12 men that she really struck the fatal blows. The public are not thoroughly acquainted with the evi dence the district attorney has succeeded in gathering, because the inquest at which Miss Borden was examined was held in secret, admission even being denied, and lawfully, to the attorney who will defend her in open court. But from such tacts as the public possess one van measure to some extent the probable strength and weakness of the prosecution’s case. At the start the state meets an obstacle that may prove insuperable. A sufficient motive must be found. Here was a young woman of wealth, education and refinement, whose church and religious surroundings were very congenial and whose activity in religious and temperance work was more than ordinary. Every effect must have a sufficient cause. Tell us, now, what motive such a woman could have had sufficient to make a wild beast of her for a brief hour or two? Was Mr Borden about to make a will disinheriting her, or leaving to the step mother more than au ordinary share of his property? Luckily for this girl, her at torney was Mr Borden’s family lawyer and he, it is reported, stands ready to swear that Mr Borden had not consul ted with him about the making of a will. Weare told that Miss Lizzie and her stepmother were not on pleas ant terms. Was Lizzie Borden the first one

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The preliminary hearing against Lizzie Borden began in Fall River district court but was quickly adjourned until Thursday because expert witnesses were not ready. A large crowd, including many notable attendees and 32 newspaper workers, packed the courtroom to observe the proceedings.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 August 1892 · page 3

THE EXPERT WITNESSES NOT READY. A Big Crowd Gather* in the Fnll River OiMirict ( ourt Room—lla u> Witneanea Stiiumoufd. The preliminary hearing of Lizzie A Bor den, charged with the murder of her father, was began in the Fall River district court Monday, but soon after opening was adjourned till Thursday. Miss Borden

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The district court hearing for Lizzie Borden opened with a packed courtroom, but was immediately adjourned until Thursday at the defense's request, consented to by the government. The delay reportedly stemmed from demands that Prof. Wood and Medical Examiner Dolan produce all physical evidence, including organs and household items, while government officials said they were not surprised since expert analysis was not yet complete.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 August 1892 · page 3

THE EXPERT WITNESSES NOT READY.

consented, and the hearing was put over till Thursday. The adjournment of the hearing is generally regarded at Fall River as a weakening on the part of the govern eminent, bur such, they claim, is far from the truth. The government consented to an adjournment presumably liecause de fendant’s lawyer insisted that Prof Wood and Medical Examiner Dolan should produce in court everything taken from the Borden household since the tragedy occurred. This would include the stomachs of the dead per sons, carpets, sofa, pillows, pillow-shams, pieces o' the paneling about the rooms and all other evidences of the crime.

See moreSee less

The government has been attaching great importance to the hatchet said to have been taken from the Borden house, which is said to have blood corpuscles on it similar to those found * upon Lizzie Borden’s apron. If these statements are true the prisoner’s counsel propose to learn the facts at an early stage of the trial. The government officials are not surprised at the continuance of the case. They say they expected Prof Wood would be in readiness to report, but they are not disposed to hurry the expert investigations, while not putting all their faith in their results. The large number of witnesses summoned Mon day was taken as evidence of earnestness on the part of the government. Among those who appeared were Dr Bowen and wife, Mrs Churchill, Dr and Mrs Kelley, Miss Russell, all of whom are the closest neigh bors of the prisoner, and all of whom would much prefer to have no connection with the case. Charles Sawyer, Hiram Harrington, John V. Morse, Officers Harrington, Doherty, Medley, Chace, Miss Emma Borden, C. C.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Witnesses including neighbors, family, and police were summoned to the preliminary hearing, with servant Bridget Sullivan appearing pale and frightened as a key witness. The city marshal denied the adjournment signaled government weakness, and rumors suggested the medical expert might not be able to pinpoint the time gap between the two murders.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 August 1892 · page 3

John V. Morse, Officers Harrington, Doherty, Medley, Chace, Miss Emma Borden, C. C. Cook and Deputy Sheriff Frank Wixon were also among those who were summoned. Bridget Sullivan, the servant girl, whose testimony will probably acquit or convict the prisoner, was the most important person present at the hearing. She was deathly pale from the moment Sergeant Ed son handed her to a seat till the adjournment was reached. She was greatly frightened be cause of the prominence she has secured be fore the public. Lawyer James Cumming ap peared in court and sat beside her, advising her as to her duties should she be called early in the hearing.

See moreSee less

She was dressed neatly, but shows in her countenance the effects of the great, strain under which she has been placed. When the court adjourned Miss Borden’s counsel went into the matron’s room to tell her how the case stood. The prisoner will not be removed till Thursday at least, Rev Mr Back, her pastor, selected a substantial iron bedstead for her from among those in the night, patrolmen’s room and a large quantity of suit able bedding was taken down to the station from the Borden homestead. For some days Miss Lizzie will be under the care of Ms* Russell aud Mrs Reagan, the matrons of the police stations. Outside the building the sight presented can never be forgotten. Men, women and children surged to and fro as if their brothers’ and sisters' lives were at stake. A stopping hack containing distinguished passengers was always the signal for a grand rush and crush. It took 14 police men to clear the crowds after adjourn ment. Miss Lizzie Borden ate a very heart-y supper last night, sent from her home by her sister and taken down by Mr Morse, her uncle. Iu an interview with the city marshal Monday night he said that the adjournment was very far from a oonfesmon of weakness on the part of the government. He was will ing, indeed anxious, to place all the testi mony in bis bauds before the judge of the second district court or any other properly constituted official. If the evidence pre sented did not convince the public generally that this case was one worthy of further in vestigation, then be wanted to know it, and wanted to have Miss Borden liberated at once. It was rumored Monday that Prof Wood, tiie expert, would be unable to testify posi tively that Mrs Borden died any great length of time before her husband. If this rumor be true it will greatly weaken the state’s case, as the fact that, or what was claimed to be a .

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The report claims Lizzie Borden wrote letters to her sister and friends describing a suspicious man lurking near the Borden house, but both letters were allegedly destroyed. It also mentions investigators discussing whether the killer was left-handed and references a poisoning theory involving a witness named E. E. Wright.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 26 August 1892 · page 4

Der Doppelmord von Fall River

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The report discusses several investigative threads: a destroyed letter mentioning a suspicious man seen near the Borden house, the theory that the killer was left-handed, and a witness (Lemay) maintaining he saw a stranger near the Thurston property before the murders. It also notes a woman who claims to have had a vision of Andrew Borden himself killing his wife and parents, and mentions life-size photographs taken of the victims' skulls to help determine the angle of the blows.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 26 August 1892 · page 4

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The preliminary hearing against Lizzie Borden began before Judge Blaisdell, with witnesses Dr. Dolan and another describing the discovery of the bodies and the house layout, though nothing new was revealed. The report also notes a woman claiming a vivid vision of Lizzie committing the murders, photographs of the victims' skulls to determine the killer's stance, and a letter from attorney Jennings released to the press.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 26 August 1892 · page 4

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report describes the opening day of Lizzie Borden's hearing in Fall River, noting blunders by police and officials and growing belief in her innocence. It details testimony from Medical Examiner Dolan and Civil Engineer Kiernan about the crime scene, including evidence that bloodstained woodwork had been washed and later sawed off.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 26 August 1892 · page 1

Will Now .Crow. F vi i. Kivek, Mass.. Aug. 5f’».—The sec ond district court room was crowded to the utmost capacity this morning when the hear ing in the ease of l.i/zie A. Borden, charged with the murder of her father and step mother was begun. Miss Borden sat with her counsel and be side her. her sister. Her face gave evi dence of grief. There are between d.*» and 40 witnesses for the State, who will lie ex amined at great length. The government has evidence w hich goes to show that the woodwork m the rooms where the murders were committed was washed after the tragedy.

See moreSee less

The photographs taken soon after the killing plainly show blood stains on certain portions of the room which carpenters have sawed off. and which are now clean. The district attorney announced at 10.:'.t> that he was ready to proceed, and immed iately Medical F.xaminer Dolan w as called to the w itness stand. He testified to view - ing the bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Borden on the day of the munler and to Ike appear ance of the rooms at the time. Civil Fnginecr kiernan then took the stand and submitted plans of the Borden homestead, and measurements of the rooms in which the victims were found, and testi fied to seeing blood spots about the rooms. Dr. Dolan w as recalled and describ'd the appearance of Mr. Borden's body after the murder. The first day's hearing was brought to a close at this afternoon. Dr. Dolan, first culled to testify, w as still on the stand at adjournment. The principal things developed by Attor ney Adams' long examination was the slip shod methods of the police force and medi cal examiner, one of tin* results of which is the imprisonment of Miss l.izzie A. Bor den. The principal witness for the government made a confession to this fact, allowing that his Jinal search was delayed and only a partial autopsy held shortly after the bod ies were discovered.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Medical examiner Dolan and civil engineer Kiernan testified at the preliminary hearing about the crime scene, blood spots, and body conditions, with defense attorney Adams highlighting sloppy police and medical examination methods. The report also describes an emotional clash between Lizzie and Emma Borden at the police station, plus a peddler's letter claiming he aided a bloodied stranger near Fall River on the day of the murder.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 26 August 1892 · page 1

YOU GAVE ME AWAY

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

At the preliminary hearing in Fall River, Medical Examiner Dolan testified in graphic detail about the wounds found on Andrew Borden's body, describing cuts to the face and head. The courtroom was crowded with spectators eager to see Lizzie Borden, who appeared flushed and leaned on Rev. Mr. Buck's arm.

The Portland Daily Press · 26 August 1892 · page 1

PEOPLE SHUDDERED

Charles J. Holmes, Bank Commissioner. Behind them came Lizzie A. Borden wearing her blue dress and tocque. • She was quite flushed and leaned heavily on the arm of Rev. Mr. Buck. She took a seat directly behind her counsel. Medical Examiner Dolan was the first witness. He told of going to the Bor den house after the murder and examin ing the bodies. When he went into Mr. Borden’s sitting room there was a sheet over the body. He said: “I took off the sheet. It was the most ghastly sight I ever saw.” “Well, we object to that,” said Col.

See moreSee less

Adams. “Describe the wounas, Doctor," saia the district attorney. “As he lay on the right side, there was one wound on the nose, cutting through the lower lip; there was another cut from the angle of the eye running down to within an inch of the lower jaw; there was another one and one-half inches to two inches in length running to the side of the head.” ,‘Where were those spots, doctor?” asked Mr. Jennings.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Dr. Dolan testifies about the number and nature of wounds on Andrew and Abby Borden's heads, describing blood spatter patterns on walls, doors, and ceiling. He also discusses axes found at the scene and the physical state of the bodies.

The Portland Daily Press · 26 August 1892 · page 1

BORDEN CASE.

Tlie Evidence Was So Horrible that there was a palpable shudder throughout the court room. ! The doctor said radiating in the arc of a circle back of the sofa in the wall paper were eighty-six blood specs. There were two pools of blood under the sofa on the floor. There were seven blood spots on the Darlor door about five feet from the head. Five or six feet from the floor there was a large spot. There were two spots on the ceiling, but the witness did not think they were blood.

See moreSee less

They were probably made by some insect. There was an other spot further along the ceiling. While all the other spots were with a neck as it were, the spot on the door jam was more of a stain, being long, as though it came from a swinging instru ment used in murdering a body. These wounds on Mr. Borden were all sharp in cised wounds. They were bleeding freshly and there was no clotted blood. Dr. Dolan said that he believed it was possible for an ordinary healthy person to crush the skull with a five or six pound hatchet. Mr. Borden was 70 years of age. The witness could not tell his exact height. His general health appeared to b© excellent. The defence objected to the question whether there was anything inconsistent in what he saw with the assumed fact that Mrs. Borden might have been dead two hours. It was ruled in, however. The doctor did not think so. The doctor testified to seeing the four axes at the foot of the stairs. One which migm De canea a large uareuet uau <* claw in which were two hairs and there was blood on the handle. He sent it to Prof. Wood as he did the stomachs and bloody clothing. The highest blood spots on the wall were 6 feet If inches, and next 6 feet H inches. On the picture there were in all forty spots. The highest spot was 5 feet S inches above the floor. There were beside seven or eight spots on the mould ing. Coining to Mrs. Borden, Dr. Dolan said that she had 18 distinct wounds, all on the head. Four were on the right side. Taking the medial line of the head from the nape of the neck up over the ear and wound down the back, there were 14 wounds in that section alone. There were seven or eight wounds through the bone, penetrating the brain. Mrs. Borden lay in a pool of clotted blood. It was not in the fluid condition that Mr. Borden’s was. The front of her clothing was much soaked. There was a flat scalp wound and a wound found sub sequently cutting in over the spine 2i inches long by 2% inches deep. There was blood on the drawers of the dressing case, three spots on the rail of the bed and thirty to forty on the bed clothing. Taking everything as he saw it, it was his impression that Mrs. Borden had been dead anywhere from an hour to an hour and a half. There was not the pos terior warmth in her body that there was in Mr. Borden’s.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Medical examiner Dr. Dolan testified that Mrs. Borden suffered 18 distinct head wounds, with blood spots mapped across the walls, moulding, and bedding of the murder room. Cross-examination by defense counsel exposed sloppy police and medical procedures, including a delayed, only partial autopsy.

The Portland Daily Press · 26 August 1892 · page 1

Tlie Evidence Was So Horrible that there was a palpable shudder throughout the court room. ! The doctor said radiating in the arc of a circle back of the sofa in the wall paper were eighty-six blood specs. There were two pools of blood under the sofa on the floor. There were seven blood spots on the Darlor door about five feet from the head. Five or six feet from the floor there was a large spot. There were two spots on the ceiling, but the witness did not think they were blood.

See moreSee less

They were probably made by some insect. There was an other spot further along the ceiling. While all the other spots were with a neck as it were, the spot on the door jam was more of a stain, being long, as though it came from a swinging instru ment used in murdering a body. These wounds on Mr. Borden were all sharp in cised wounds. They were bleeding freshly and there was no clotted blood. Dr. Dolan said that he believed it was possible for an ordinary healthy person to crush the skull with a five or six pound hatchet. Mr. Borden was 70 years of age. The witness could not tell his exact height. His general health appeared to b© excellent. The defence objected to the question whether there was anything inconsistent in what he saw with the assumed fact that Mrs. Borden might have been dead two hours. It was ruled in, however. The doctor did not think so. The doctor testified to seeing the four axes at the foot of the stairs. One which migm De canea a large uareuet uau <* claw in which were two hairs and there was blood on the handle. He sent it to Prof. Wood as he did the stomachs and bloody clothing. The highest blood spots on the wall were 6 feet If inches, and next 6 feet H inches. On the picture there were in all forty spots. The highest spot was 5 feet S inches above the floor. There were beside seven or eight spots on the mould ing. Coining to Mrs. Borden, Dr. Dolan said that she had 18 distinct wounds, all on the head. Four were on the right side. Taking the medial line of the head from the nape of the neck up over the ear and wound down the back, there were 14 wounds in that section alone. There were seven or eight wounds through the bone, penetrating the brain. Mrs. Borden lay in a pool of clotted blood. It was not in the fluid condition that Mr. Borden’s was. The front of her clothing was much soaked. There was a flat scalp wound and a wound found sub sequently cutting in over the spine 2i inches long by 2% inches deep. There was blood on the drawers of the dressing case, three spots on the rail of the bed and thirty to forty on the bed clothing. Taking everything as he saw it, it was his impression that Mrs. Borden had been dead anywhere from an hour to an hour and a half. There was not the pos terior warmth in her body that there was in Mr. Borden’s. Civil Engineer Kiernan then took the stand and submitted the plans of the Borden homestead and measurements of the rooms in which the victims were found. He testified to seeing blood spots about the rooms. Dr. Dolan was crossed examined by Col. Adams at the afternoon session. The principal point developed was the exposure of slip shod methods of the po lice force and medical examiner, one of the results of which is the imprisonment of Miss Lizzie A. Borden. The princi pal government witness made a confess ion to this fact, all because his final search was delayed and only a partial PORTLAND DAILY PRESS.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The second district court room was packed as Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing resumed before Judge Blaisdell, with Medical Examiner Dolan testifying about the position of the bodies and sending stomach samples to Harvard for analysis. Lizzie sat composed between her lawyers near her sister Emma as the proceedings began.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 26 August 1892 · page 5

Fall River. Mass., Aug. 25.— The second district court room never held such a crowd as that which greeted Judge Blaisdell this morning. It was the second date agreed up<in for the hearing of Miss Lizzie A. Borden. on the charge of killing her father with an ax. Clergymeu, lawyers, physicians, and more than 150 ladies, who were not directly connected with the case, wpre seated and standing in all parts of the room, while inside the rail was an ex traordinary crowd of reporters and other newspaper workers. Ladies oc cupied more than two-thirds of the seats usually occupied by the curious gang w ho frequent the lower courts.

See moreSee less

At 10:30 o'clock Charles.). Holmes ap peared with Miss Emma Borden on his arm. Miss Lizzie Border, came in last with Marshal Hiliard. She was handed to a seat between her two legal advisers and near a settee on which her sister was seated. The two women sat elbow to elbow. Miss Lizzie was at her sister's right hand, but not a word passed be tween them.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Medical examiner Dr. Dolan testified about the condition and timing of the Borden deaths, the bloody hatchet, and bloodstained clothing taken from Lizzie Borden. Surveyor Kiernan also testified about blood spatter direction, while defense attorney Adams' cross-examination exposed sloppy police and medical procedures.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 26 August 1892 · page 5

THE BORDEN TRIAL.

Openins Eridonre. "T\ c are ready to proceed, your hon or.*' said District Attorney Knowlton. and Medical Examiner Dolan was calied to the stand. The witness testified as to the position of the bodies of the mur dered coupie when found and to send iug their stomachs to Prof. Weod, of Harvard eolleee, for analysis. Surveyor Kiernan then took the stand, lie thought from the appear ance of a spot of bloo:i on the door cas ing that it was thrown from the sitting room toward the kitchen. Lizzie bore ;$n expressionless countenance ami bit tlie wlge of a palm leaf fan, while Emma had her face, behind her fan.

See moreSee less

Dr. Dolan was called back to the stanJ, and said Mr. Borden's death was caased by shock, aud the body was still warm when witness ar rived at the house. Witness said the wounds could De made by any person of ordinary strength mine moderate force. In the witness" opinion Mrs. Borden had been dead aoout an hour and a half when he saw her. She died ot shock. V\ itness saw Fonr Alps in the Cellar of the house: examined one. and found it had been scraped and washed. Un der the glass it showed stains which looked like blood. Saw some hair oil it also. Took some dress skirts and ■un derskirts from the house, the property Of Miss Borden. the defendant.* Dr. Dolan was still on the stand at adjournment. The principal thiccs disciosea by Attorney Adams' long ex amination wns the slip-shod methods ot the police force and medical examiner, one of the results of which is the im prisonment of Miss Lizzie Borden. The principal government witness made a confession to this fact. Mr. Adams wanted to know if Dr. Dolan thought that th<s hate.net with the peculiar claw head was the identical one which produced the crushed wound in Mrs. Bordens head. H« thought it could have done it. Continuing his tes tiinuny. the medical examiner told of examining toe clothing of the Borden girls, and described the stains and hairs round on the hatchet, lie thought Mr. Borden's assailant stood between the head of Mr. Borden ar.d the dinintr room door, perhaps midway of the open insr. From the position of the assailant and Mr. Borden he thousht the former would have had more blood above the waist than below it. All through this exhaustive and tedious examination District Attornew kaowltoti hardly raised an objection.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Dr. Dolan testified about the hatchet, wounds, and blood evidence while defense attorney Adams highlighted sloppy police and medical procedures. Lizzie Borden showed little emotion except when wounds were described, and was reportedly later accused by her own sister of betrayal.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 26 August 1892 · page 5

Lizzie Is Nervy. Miss Lizzie Borden did not betray any noticeable feeling dunng the whole day. except possibly in tiiree instances. One was when Dr. Oolan described tlie ghastly wounds on her father. Then

See the clipping

The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.

The report describes the crowded second day of Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing in Fall River, with family members and spectators present. Medical examiner Dolan testified about the eighteen wounds on Mrs. Borden's body and the discovery of axes in the cellar, one of which appeared cleaned.

The State Chronicle · 26 August 1892 · page 1

MIsm Lizzies Ho r den in Court Yester day Charged With the Crime. By Telegraph to the Slate Chronicle. Fall River, Mass., Aug 25. The second distsict court room never before held such a crowd as that which greeted Judge Blaisdell this morning at 10 a. in. It was the second day agreed upon for the hearing of Miss Lizzie A. Borden on the charge of killing her fathrand moth er with an exe. Clergyman, Laymen, physicians and more than 150 "ladies who were not directly connected with the case, were seated and standing in all parts of the room.

See moreSee less

The ladies occupied more than two-thirds of the seats usually occupieu uy me curious gang who usu ally tlock into the lower courts. At 10:30 o'clock Mr. Charles J. Holmes ap peared with Miss Emma Borden on his arm. Following came Mrs. Brigham, Mrs. Holmes and the Rev. Mr. Buck' Miss Lizzie Borden came in last with Marshal Hilliard. Miss Borden's face gave evidence of an extreme strain. She was handed a seat between her two legal advisors and near a settee on which her sister was seated. The two women sat elbow to elbow, Miss Lizzie at her sisters right hand. Not a word passed between them. Medical exam iner Dolan was called to the stand. Dr. Dolan said: "There were eighteen wounds on Mrs. Borden's person. Four teen of them were in a small space back of her head over her ear. Pieces of the skull were driven into the brain. All these wounds were made w ith a sharp instrument." In witness' opinion Mrs. Borden had been dead an hour and a half when he saw her. Witness saw four exes in the cellar of the house. Examined one with a claw on it, and found that it had been scraped and washed.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

This report accuses the World newspaper of fabricating a story about a quarrel between Lizzie Borden and her sister, calling it a reckless fake made purely for sensation. It likens this fraudulent reporting to the World's forged Bismarck cable scandal and its earlier reckless accusations in the Amboy murder case.

The Jersey City News · 26 August 1892 · page 2

Borden’s alleged quarrel with her sister shows that it is not with repu- (

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

During Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, a sensational New York Herald story claimed Lizzie confronted her sister Emma over betraying her to defense counsel. The report reveals this story was invented by a reporter who hadn't even arrived in Fall River when the alleged interview supposedly took place.

The Sun · 26 August 1892 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The report exposes a rival paper's fabricated interview claiming a Mrs. Reagan overheard a damaging conversation between Lizzie and Emma Borden, which both sisters and their lawyers denied. It then describes the packed courthouse scene in Fall River as the preliminary hearing began, with crowds filling the streets and Bridget Sullivan arriving to testify.

The Sun · 26 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN IN COURT

EmmA Bordon dtniec ts did Ie stan her liter Lizzie Lawyer Jennings says tho tan la a le Lawyer Adam denied It When Emma and Lizzie Borden met this morning Emma Borden mentioned the storyand told i

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Dr. Dolan describes finding Mr. Borden's body on the sofa and Mrs. Borden's body upstairs, detailing wounds and room measurements. Cross-examination by lawyer Jennings challenges the accuracy of the sofa's position as reconstructed for testimony.

The Sun · 26 August 1892 · page 1

DR. DOLAN ON THE STAND

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Morning Appeal · Carson City, Nev.

Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, appeared in court for examination and showed no signs of nervousness, walking firmly and defiantly. The case was postponed until Thursday due to the absence of important documents.

Morning Appeal · 26 August 1892 · page 3

Director Mint. Mr. Whitelaw Held is quoted as saying "We must keep down this feeling of over-confidence which Republicans are manifesting. We lave got a hard tight on hand, but we will certainly win. " Paradox al as this sounds, it fairly expresses the situation for either Republicans or Democrats. They must bo sure of winning in order to keep up their enthusiasm, but they must not be over-conhdent, lest that should make them careless about briiiirin" out the vote. Lizzie Borden, who is accused of murdering her father and stepmother at Fall River, appeared in court yes terday for examination.

See moreSee less

There was not a tremor in her action and her walk was firm and defiant. Owing to the absence of importaut documeuts the case was postponed until Thurs day. A search-light was operated from the summit of Mount Washington for the first time on Saturday night eek before last, and the surroud ings of hotels seven miles distant are said to have been made as light as day, If your watch is out of order" in any way you can get it repaired at Golden's by skilled workmen from the best institutions in Europe. The work turned out in jewelry repairiDcr is always finished in the best style and the assortment of goods has no qual anywhere in Nevada. 4tf. ;

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Lizzie Borden's lawyer released a letter signed by a Jewish peddler named Samuel Robinsky, claiming he encountered a blood-covered man near Fall River on the day of the murders who said he'd fought his farm employer over wages. The defense presented this as a potentially important clue pointing to an alternate suspect in the case.

The Evening Herald · 26 August 1892 · page 3

WHERE IS THE PEDDLER

"Waltham, Mass., Aug. 17, 1802. Hiss Emma Borden: Dkau Madam Vou must excuse that I tako the liberty in sending you those few lines. I ought to have written to you beforo this, but I was unablo to do

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

A letter writer named Robinsky describes a nervous stranger he saw near the Borden house and expresses fear of involving police, prompting defense counsel to search for the man. The report also covers the second day of Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, including Dr. Dolan's testimony about the axe wounds and a bloodstained hatchet found in the cellar.

The Evening Herald · 26 August 1892 · page 3

upon for the hoaring of Miss Lizzlo A. Borden on tho chares of killinir h wiiu un axe. Clergymen, laymen, physicians and more than 150 ladies who were not direct ! v tuimcuucu wiiii me case were seated anil standing in all parts of tho room while insldo the roll was an extraml iiinroui tepuriera ana-otner newspaper Xadlos occunled mora than twn-tnlrila oi me seats usually occupied by the curl ous gang who usually flock into the lower courts. At 10:80 o'clock Charles J. Holmes nn pearea with Miss Emma Borden on his arm. foilowlne them camn Mm Brighom, Mrs. Holmes and T?nv rr uucK. Miss .Lizzie Borden came in last witn aiarsual iillllard. Miss Hnr.lr.n'

See the clipping

Scranton Wochenblatt · Scranton, Pa.

The report notes that the mystery of the Fall River double murder remains unsolved, though a man named Frank Peckham, described as an apparent crank, has turned himself in claiming to be the murderer of Andrew and Abby Borden. It adds that many people are now beginning to doubt the guilt of Lizzie Borden, who remains jailed in Taunton.

Scranton Wochenblatt · 26 August 1892 · page 4

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The Fall River preliminary hearing against Lizzie Borden began, with Medical Examiner Dr. Dolan testifying about the victims' wounds, body positions, and blood stains, and sending stomach samples to Harvard for analysis. Separately, defense counsel Jennings released a letter from a self-described peddler describing a blood-covered stranger he met near the time of the murders, which the defense is pursuing as an alternate lead.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 26 August 1892 · page 9

THE PRISONER SMILES AT LAWYERS

thought he was a Poor Farm hand, and so took pltv on him, as I know, as a rule, farm ers seldom pay their hands during the sum mer. The Preliminary Trial Begins. After much delay the preliminary-trial of Miss Lizzie Borden began here in earne st at 10:30 A. 31. Tbe first witness called to the stand was Medical Examiner Dolan. The witness testified to the position of the bodies ot the murdered couple when found, and to sending their stomachs to Prof. Wood, of Harvard 'College, for analysis. Mrs. Borden's body was dressed as you would expect housewife to be at that time of the day; it had au old handkerchief about tbe neck that was bloody. Witness did not believe it was

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

Lizzie Borden's preliminary trial began with testimony from Medical Examiner Dolan describing the bodies' condition and sending stomach samples to Harvard for analysis. A surveyor presented house diagrams, and Dolan admitted to sloppy police procedures, including a scraped, blood-stained axe found in the cellar.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 26 August 1892 · page 9

found, and to sending their stomachs to Prof. Wood, of Harvard 'College, for analysis. Mrs. Borden's body was dressed as you would expect housewife to be at that time of the day; it had au old handkerchief about tbe neck that was bloody. Witness did not believe it was tied in a knot, and did not remember wheth er it was cut or not. Surveyor Kiernan then took the stand and submitted plans showing the interior and exterior of the Borden homestead, with measurements of the rooms, etc He thought from the appearance of a spot of blood on the door casing that' it was thrown from the sitting room toward the Kitchen.

See moreSee less

During his evidence Lizzie bore an expressionless countenance and bit the" edze of a palm-leaf tan, while Emma hid her face behind her fan. Dr. Dolan was called back to the stand. What caused Mr. Borden's death? was asked. Witness He died from shock, and the body was still warm when I arrived at the house. A question as to the force required was objected-to. The objection was overruled. Witness said the wounds could be made by

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

At the preliminary hearing, Dr. Dolan testified under cross-examination by Attorney Adams about the wounds, estimating they required only ordinary strength and that both victims died of shock. He also described finding axes in the cellar, one with apparent blood and hair, while Adams highlighted flaws in the police and medical examiner's methods; Lizzie Borden smiled or showed emotion at several points during testimony.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 26 August 1892 · page 9

THE PRISONER SMILES AT LAWYERS

Large Pools or Blood Unnecessary. From the position of the assailant and Mr. Borden, he thought tbe former would have received more blood above the waist than below. He thought the deed could have been done and the person doing it not have had more than ten spots on his clothing. All through this exhaustive and tedious examination, District Attorney Knowlton hardly raised an objection. Miss Lizzie Borden did not betray any noticeable feel ing during the whole day, except possibly in three or four instances. One was when Dr. Dolan described the ghastly wounds on her father. Then she flushed and tears came into her eves. When Mr. Adams asked If the report of

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

At the preliminary hearing in Fall River, Dr. Dolan the medical examiner gave gruesome testimony about Mrs. Borden's wounds and body position, prompting horror from spectators. Lizzie Borden reportedly showed almost no emotion, only briefly lowering her head and once laughing nervously during cross-examination.

Pawtucket Tribune · 26 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN. Appears Unmoved in the Court Room. FAMOUS CASE HAS BEGUN. State Responsible for the Further Mutilation of the Body.

Fauh Juvin, Mass, Aung #2\ I'n battle for Lizzie Borden's life ts oo I promises to b long and bivter, evea in 1w preiminaey stage. Yesterduy, though much of the timw ws oocupled In the routine business of stablishing the fact of murder, the hoar ina was of tragle interest throughout. 'l River—New Eagland oune migh. my-—~has witnessed no such scene a 8 tha o yooterday, when Andrew Borden's lnughter henrd without the movement o A mus cle a recital 8o ghastly in its de

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Medical Examiner Dolan testified that the Bordens died from shock due to hatchet wounds, and described finding hairs on a cellar hatchet believed to be the murder weapon. The report also reveals that the victims' heads were later severed from their bodies during a secret autopsy at the cemetery, provoking public outrage.

Pawtucket Tribune · 26 August 1892 · page 1

FAMOUS CASE HAS BEGUN.

by the weatimony of Modical Examiner Dolan. It tuched the accused only at intervale. D Dolan awears that the eanse of Adenth was shock from the wounds. The Bordens, then, were not mutilnted after havine &lnd from polson Agenin, the nature of the ataln on the hatchet and axe and on Lizzle™ clothing wna not dotecinined by the doctor’s testi mony. He bellevea the blows wera given by o hatchet found in the cellar. It was stnined, and npon it two short hairs—one gray anll one dark browu—were found. Buch blows could casily have been doHvered by a porson of moderate strength.

See moreSee less

That was the pubstance of yesterday’s testimony. The motive, the prisoner’® movements on the day ol the tragedy, the letter to Mra Borden, the astatements of the ao cused when qunestioaed jnst after the

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The report describes how the skulls of the victims were cleaned and photographed, with images possibly to be introduced at the hearing or trial later. It also addresses a rumor that Lizzie Borden said "You gave me away, Emma" during a private conversation with her sister, a claim denied by her intimates and the defense.

Pawtucket Tribune · 26 August 1892 · page 1

sure Care For Malaria, Murray's Maiaria Mixtuare, 91 Main streeg, PR tneket Advertise your wants in the 1T RIRTNR, there was nobody present to bhéar whal wis sakil 3 wad trae sbn:r T W sisters woerd together ane rooon, or two aga, and the matron was aud of th room. When she retarned the dwo sister, had apparently had g somewhat oullo‘ von’erence, but of what it was abous iy one besldes themselves bas any kbowd edge, That lAzete Borden evey sald, “¥o

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

At the preliminary hearing, gruesome photographs of the hacked skulls were displayed in court, visibly distressing Emma Borden and startling Lizzie. The report also details cross-examination of Dr. Dolan and speculates on an alleged quarrel between the sisters as evidence of Lizzie's vindictive character.

The Providence News · 26 August 1892 · page 1

A SENSATION. Ghastly Photographs Shown in Court. HACKED SKULLS.

J A and P-~Messrs. Jennings, Adams and Pmm{», counsel for the defense, L~ Lizzie Borden, E-—~Emma Borden M-—Minister Buck. N N NFriends of the Borden sisters. W--Two lotg;es for witnesses, B-—-Witness box. O~ Crier Wyatt,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report covers the preliminary hearing where Dr. Dolan testified about the wounds and body measurements of Mrs. Borden, with defense attorney Adams cross-examining him on inconsistencies. It also speculates on a possible insanity plea and notes Lizzie Borden's composed demeanor, including a brief lapse into laughter during testimony.

The Providence News · 26 August 1892 · page 1

DR. DOLAN DESCRIBING THE WOUNDS

shown during the cross-examination of Dr. Dolan ugurdm the ‘eo-mon and size of Mrs. Borden’s y. hen Mr. Adams had reduced the Doctor’s statements to flFum. and had shown that according to the Doctor’s calculation of distances the

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes the cramped courtroom scene during the Borden preliminary examination, detailing the physical layout and the crowd of reporters, officials, and spectators packed into the small space. It identifies key figures present including Judge Blaisdell, the court stenographer, Lizzie Borden, her sister Emma, and various attorneys and witnesses.

The Providence News · 26 August 1892 · page 1

THE COURT ROOM, The Scene of the Borden ExaminationThe Setting of the Stage. ISPECIAL TO THE NEWS.| FALL RIVER, Aug. 26.—The scene as set

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Providence News comments on suspicions of prosecutorial favoritism at the Borden hearing, warning this could prejudice the case, while also promoting itself as the best source for daily Borden case coverage. The piece is part of a miscellany column mixing editorial opinions on various topics.

The Providence News · 26 August 1892 · page 4

Protection’s banner guards our land Andow] m':}:'fl;fi:‘; 7%:‘;"!#1'&'@':?&?" E Please take me for a blooming jay. The sentiment is all right, but can’t Carter lend 'em a better campaign poet ? Tue suspicion of favoritism to the prosecution should be cleared away from the Borden hearing, both as a matter of fairness to the accused and because it might have influence in de feating the ends of justice, by awaken ing prejudice against the State's cause, MRr. SAMUEL ROBINSKY'S sapient ob servation that ‘‘farmers seldom pay their hands during summer” leads one to query whether farm hands are rot long suffering individuals.

See moreSee less

But pethaps Mr. Robinsky's imperfect English is at fault, Or perhaps there isn't any Mr, Robinsky. Trose who wish to follow the Borden case day by day in its fullest details and to read the most careful and accurate review of the ebb and flow of the legal battie are advised to purchase the ProvIDENCE NEWS every evening, It will

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report notes a change in public sentiment in Fall River, with more people now suspecting Lizzie Borden's guilt amid rumors of a sisterly quarrel and speculation that an insanity defense may be used. It also criticizes the medical examiner's irregular autopsy record and the defense's focus on blood spot details during the preliminary proceedings.

The Providence News · 26 August 1892 · page 4

THE BORDEN CASE, A subtle change of sentiment is noted in Fall River, From believing Lizzie Borden innocent most people have come to suspect that she may be guilty. The

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Witnesses testify about the Borden murder scene, including a blood-covered camp chair and work basket near Mrs. Borden's body. Multiple witnesses describe hearing of the murder, arriving at the house, and the sequence of events that morning.

The Providence News · 26 August 1892 · page 7

John Clegy, a hatter, was called. He had talked with Mr. Borden that morn ing in his store in ugrd to A new store, He left the store at 29 minutes pasu 10, He was not certain what direction he went, but thought he went south. He didn’t see him afterward. Mr, Borden had been in his store on Tuesday before, John Cunniogham, newsdealer. He had heard of the murder when in front of Mr. Hall’s stable. Noticed Mrs. Church ill run out of the house across the street,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Deputy sheriff Francis Wixon testifies about arriving at the Borden house shortly after the murder was discovered, describing what he found including Mr. Borden's body and removing his watch. Cross-examination covers whether the barn was searched and who was present at the scene.

The Providence News · 26 August 1892 · page 7

“Did you take m:yt.blni( #" “Yes, I re moved the watch from Mr. Borden’s vest pocket., It was a silver watch, [ went upstairs with Dr. Bowen. I could unot say positive whether I saw Dr. Dolan up stairs ordown, I went out and exam

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The inquest continues with witnesses Shortsleeve and Mather placing Andrew Borden at his Main Street store mid-morning, then John V. Morse takes the stand. Morse describes his family relationship to the Bordens, his arrival on August 3rd, and details of the household's sleeping arrangements and his activities the day before the murders.

The Providence News · 26 August 1892 · page 7

THIS AFTERNOON'S SESSION

Jomes Mather, a fellow-workman of Shortsleeve, saw Borden at the same time us Shortsleeve and watehed him iurn u toward Spring street.” Further mtfi mony corroborated Shortsleeve’s story, Then came the sensation. Knowlton called Bridget Sullivan. Not present and Johu V., Morse was calleq, He is 50 years of age and has lived in tne West and returned three years ago. Lived in Warren, also in Dartmouth. Since the murder has lived in the Borden house. He is a brother of Mr. Borden's last wife. “When did she die?”’ *I think about 18632" “How old was Lizzie at that time?" “Two years old.” “*Where aid you live at that time?”’ *'ln the West,” ~ “How long had the porden’s lived in

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

A one-line news digest item reports that Lizzie Borden's trial has begun at Fall River, Massachusetts. It notes that early testimony is favorable to the accused.

San Antonio Daily Light · 26 August 1892 · page 1

Autumnal Festivities association. Austria has medical examination of all persons from Hamburg cross ing the frontier. Railways running steamships from European ports are taking no pre cautions against cholera. Lizzie Borden’s trial begins at Fall River, Mase. Testimony favorable to accused. t New York health officers are ready to care for 5000 cholera patients at a movements notice. The streets of Hamburg are filled with ambulances removing cholera patients to the hospitals. Randolph Tucker, Va . delivers annual address to Bar Association, Saratoga.

See the clipping

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

Charles H. Peckham, a 62-year-old man, walked into a Fall River police station and declared he had killed Mr. and Mrs. Borden, the murder for which Lizzie Borden had been arrested. The report notes Peckham was evidently insane and his confession was not believed.

Shenandoah Herald · 26 August 1892 · page 1

Trust millionaire, met with an accident dur ing the burninz of the stables at his summer residences at Mamaronect, N. Y., and died in ten minutes, Two stablemen were burnei to death in Mr. Constable's aa oiling stable, which was also destroyed by Tae Republican State Convention of De!l aware met in Dover and nominated Rav. Jonathan 8. Weller, a Methodist clergy man, for Congress by acclamation, and also Presidential electors, CrArLES H. PECKHAM, sixty-two years old, walked int> the station houses at Fall River, Mass., anil declarei that hs had killed Mr. and Mrs, Borden, for whoss mys terious murder Miss Lizzie Borden has baen arrestel. Packham was evidently insane, and little stock was taken in his story.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

A crowded Fall River courtroom saw the start of proceedings against Lizzie Borden, accused of killing her father with an axe. Medical Examiner Dolan took the stand to describe the condition of the murdered couple's bodies.

The Times · 26 August 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN TRAGEDY, Beginning of the Trial of Lizzie Borden, of Fall River

said ha would be ready to commence. Sr At 10:30 o'clock Mr. Charles J. Holmes appeared with Miss Fmma Borden on his arm. Following came Mrs. Brigham, Mrs, Holmes and the Rev. Mr. Buek. Mise lizzie s+ Borden came in last with Marshal Hilliard. Miss © Borden's face gave evidence of an extreme strain. She was handed a seat between her two legal advisers and near a settee on which her sister was seated. The two women sat elbow to elbow, Miss Lizzie at her sister's right hand. Not a word passed between them. » THE TESTIMONY BEGUN.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

Medical Examiner Dolan testified about the condition of the bodies, describing eighteen wounds on Mrs. Borden's head and stating she died of shock about an hour and a half before he examined her. He also described finding four axes in the cellar, one of which showed signs of having been scraped and washed with possible bloodstains.

The Times · 26 August 1892 · page 1

THE TESTIMONY BEGUN.

Medical Examiner Dolan was called to the ie atand. ‘The witness testified to the position of the bodies of the murdered couple when found and to sending their stomachs to Pro fessor Wood, of Harvard College. for analysis. gE: Ur. Dolan said: There were eighteen wounds : on Mrs. Borden's person. Fourteen of them = were in a small space back of her head over her ear. Pieces of the skull were driven into the brain. All these wounds were made with a sharp instrument, In witness’ opin. jon Mrs. Borden had been dead an hour 8 and a balf when he saw her.

See moreSee less

. - Mrs. Borden weighed 210 or 245 pounds, She died of shock, Witness saw four axes in the cellar of the houses, Examined one with a olaw on it sud found that it had been gsoraped and washed. The head-cutting sur. face of about five inohes, weighed from thres to tive pounds. Under the glass it showed stains which looked like blood, Saw some Lar on it also. Took some dress skirts and ' nnderskirts from the house, the property of a Miss Borden, the defendant.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

This short notice announces that testimony has begun in the Borden tragedy case. It appears as a brief item amid other unrelated local news snippets.

The Times · 26 August 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN TRAGEDY, THE TESTIMONY BEGUN

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Londonderry Sifter · South Londonderry, Vt.

A brief item reports that the Lizzie Borden trial at Fall River, Massachusetts, originally scheduled for the previous Monday, was postponed on motion of the prosecuting officer until the following day. The notice appears amid unrelated local political commentary and miscellaneous news items.

The Londonderry Sifter · 26 August 1892 · page 1

this nurnose in everv case. Remem- " if yow f rite a name in you must; marking an X after the name. w nere mere is no mam mere is no vole.' Make no mark after Levi Fuller's name. Don't touch it. Write in Henry A. Fletcher and make an X after it. The Lizzie Borden trial at Fall

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

The preliminary examination of Lizzie Borden, expected to occur on August 22, was postponed until Thursday at the request of both prosecution and defense attorneys. The delay was granted because Professor Wood, the expert analyzing clothing, a hatchet, and wood samples for blood evidence, needed two or three more days to complete his report.

The United Opinion · 26 August 1892 · page 1

AGAIN ADJOURNMENT TAKEN UNTIL THURSDAY IN THE BORDEN MURDER CASE

Important Enough to Grant the Delay. Move by Miss Borden's Attorney! Promptly Met by the Government.' Fau RrVEK. Mass., Aug. 23. Two hun dred expectant residents of this city were unable yesterday to gratify their desire to see Lizzie A. Borden in court. The noted

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

The Borden preliminary hearing was unexpectedly postponed until Thursday after defense attorneys demanded that Professor Wood of Harvard, who was analyzing bloodstain evidence for the prosecution, be made available for cross-examination. The prosecution had hoped to proceed without revealing Wood's findings, but the defense forced a delay until his analysis was complete.

The United Opinion · 26 August 1892 · page 1

BORDEN MURDER CASE.

It is whispered that the government didn't care nim li whether this witness did or did uot appear at the hearing, and that the attorneys for Miss Borden learned that

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

At the Borden murder hearing in Fall River, defense counsel produced a letter from Samuel Robbins describing his encounter with a blood-stained stranger on the day of the murder, though the letter's author cannot be located. The first day's hearing closed with little new revealed except criticism of the sloppy investigative methods used by police and the medical examiner.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 26 August 1892 · page 1

The Borden Murder Ca<«. F ». r i. RIVER. Mass., Aug. 25.—1n the Borden rauraer counsel for defense his given ont a letter signed by Samuel Robhina, teding him in a rambling way of the writer's interview with a b'ood stained stranger on the day of the murder. The writer of the letter ia known in Walton as a peddler, but cannot be found. The first day's hearing in the Borden case closei this evening. Nothing new de veioped except, perhaps, the slip-shod

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The passage reports on the opening day of Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing on charges of murdering her father and mother in Fall River. It notes little new evidence emerged, Borden wept when her parents' wounds were described, and includes a dubious letter about a bloody stranger circulated by defense counsel.

Wheeling Register · 26 August 1892 · page 1

Fall River, Miss., August :I5.-In the Borden murder case Mr. Jennings, coun sel for the defense, has giveu out a letter for publication which tell# in a rambling wav of the writer's interview with u

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The report describes the first days of Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, including testimony from Medical Examiner Dr. Dolan about the bodies' positions and handling of evidence, and cross-examination revealing sloppy police and medical procedures. It also includes an unrelated anecdote from a peddler claiming to have encountered a bloody stranger claiming to be a farmhand.

Wheeling Register · 26 August 1892 · page 1

d wing the summer.” The first day’s hearing of the Borden (Use was closed at 31:90 this afternoon. Hr. Dolan, who was l.rst called to testify w is still on the stand at adjournment. The principal things developed by Attorney Adams' longexamiuation was the exposure of the slip shod methods of the police force and medical examiner, one of the results of which is the imprisonment of Miss Little Borden. The principal witness made a confession to this fact, allowing that his final search was delayed and that only a partial autopsy was held shortly after the bodies were re covered.

See moreSee less

Miss Li/zie Borden did not be tray any noticeable feeling duriug the’whole day, except possibly In three or four instances One was when Dr. Dolan described the ghastly wounds on her father. Then she Hushed, aud tears came into her eyes. Miss Lizzie and her attorneys are well pleased with the result of tho first day’s proceedings. The hearing will he resumed to-morrow morning at 10 o'clock. The Second District Court room never before held such a ermd as that which greeted Judge Blaisdgll this morning. It was tho second date agreed upon for the hearing of Miss Lizzie A. Borden on the charge of kllliug her father with an axe. At 10:30 Mr. Charles J. Holme* ap peared with Mis* hrama Hordun, on h>* arm. Mi*s Lizzie Borden came In last

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

At Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, Medical Examiner Dolan testified about the positions of the bodies, the cause of death by shock, and the condition of axes found in the cellar, including one with blood-like stains and hair. Surveyor Kalman also testified about blood spatter patterns found near the kitchen door.

Wheeling Register · 26 August 1892 · page 1

OF HER FATHER AND MOTHER

her fan. Dr. Dolan was railed hack to the stand. What caused Mr. Borden's death? was asked. Witness—He died from shock, and the body was still warm whan witness

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

During the preliminary hearing in Fall River, controversy erupted over a Globe newspaper report claiming Matron Reagan overheard Lizzie accusing Emma of 'giving her away.' Defense counsel denied the story's accuracy, while reporters prepared to make sworn affidavits backing its truth.

Morning Journal and Courier · 27 August 1892 · page 3

Some Light on the Methods of the Iron Hall. THE BORDEN TRIAL. Tbe Examination Resumed Excite ment Over tbe Assertion tbat m.a Lizzie Reproached HerSister With "GIvlns Her Away" Newspaper men to Slake Affidavit. Various Witnesses. Fall Eivkr, Mass., Aug. 26. The most extraordinary event Blnce the Borden tragedies three weeks agot oooarred to night just after the adjournment of the hearing. Several reporters crowded around the attorneys for the defence, who showed the following clipping from the Fall Htver Globe: Wednesday afternoon a reporter of the Globe learned that Matron Reagan had heard Lizzie Borden qnarreling with Emma, accusing the latter of giving her away.

See moreSee less

He went to Mrs. Eeagan to have the Btory corroborated. The question was put to the matron: How is Miss Lizzie condnotiDg herself now! She replied: 'She is very much agitated and has been since her sister called to day. She is wringing her hands and walking np and down like a crazy person.' Tbe reporter then asked what transpired when Emma called, and the story which the reporter had already heard from other sources was corioborated in detail by the matron. Matron Eeagan told this story to other persons." THE 8T0BT CORROBORATED.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A dispute arose over matron Mrs. Reagan's refusal to sign a denial without the marshal's approval, leading to heated words between Mr. Jennings and the marshal; the controversy over her alleged quarrel statement was widely discussed. Meanwhile, the inquest continued with testimony from Joseph Shortsleves, Joseph Mather, and John V. Morse, who detailed timing of Andrew Borden's movements and his own activities before the murder.

Morning Journal and Courier · 27 August 1892 · page 3

PROVOKES CONSIDERABLE DISCUSSION. There was a great deal of warm talk over these occurrences to-night, and they are being discussed in all circles. Marshal Hilltard says he has been making an in vestigation of the case to determine the merits of the case, and has yet to examine one officer. As' the matter now stands Mrs. Beagan has made fonr denials at dif ferent times. Two policemen and one re porter will make affidavit that what has Deen puoiisnea is suostantiaiiy true, not one of the Misses Borden's friends, how ever, believe that the quarrel occurred.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A witness describes bloodstains on a door and police removing axes, plus details about Andrew Borden's will plans. Bridget Sullivan resumes testimony about the household's movements on the morning of the murders.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Rock Island Daily Argus, 26 August 1892, Springfield Weekly Republican, 26 August 1892.

Morning Journal and Courier · 27 August 1892 · page 3

BRIDGET SULLIVAN AGAIN. Bridget Sullivan, the servant girl, was called and was still on the stand when the court adjourned at 5 p. m. She said she came down to tne citcnentnat morning and found the doors as she had left them the night before. Opened the doors to let ice man in and to get the milk can; closed and locked the soreen door. Mrs. Borden eame down stairs by the back way and went into the sitting room, and I commenced to set breakfast. Mr. Borden came down and went into the yard with a pall of slops, washed the pail and came back into the bouse.

See moreSee less

After breakfast saw Mr. Borden let Morse out the outside door. He then went upstairs and put on his tie and came down. I did not fel well and was sick at the stomach and went ont into the yard to vomit. Came in at 9 o'clock, saw Mrs. Borden in the dining room; she told me to wash the windows, as they were very dirty. Typhoid In Springfield. Sprikgfikld, Mass., Ang. 26. There are an unusual number of typhoid fever eases in the city, and tbe disease baa been epidemic in one locaUty.embracloff several streets on the bill At one time forty-eU eases were reported In a short radius, while there were sixty or more in an.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper

At the Borden preliminary hearing, Marshal Hilliard blocked Matron Reagan from signing a retraction regarding an alleged quarrel between Lizzie and Emma Borden in jail, prompting defense counsel to denounce the action. Testimony continued from Dr. Dolan, John V. Morse, and Bridget Sullivan about the household's movements on the day of the murder.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 27 August 1892 · page 1

Marshal Milliard Will Not Allow Matron Reagan Retract. Faix. River, Mass., Aug. 27. A sen sational incident of the Borden hearing was when City Marshal Hilliurd refused to allow Matron Reagan to sign a paper which mwyer Jennings had drawn up. The paper was a denial of the informa tion which she hod been alleged to give to a newspaper man as to a quarrel be tween Lizzie and her sister Emma in the jail. The marshal refused to allow the ma tron to sign the paper, whereupon the counsel for the defense in a loud tone do nounced his action as an outrage, and asked all tho newspaper men present to give the facts publicity.

See moreSee less

The examination of JJr. Dolan in the hearing of Lizzie Borden was concluded. Several witnesses were examined to show Mr. Borden's wheroabouts before his re turn to his house on the morning of the murder, and then John B. Morse was placed on the stand. Ho told of his visits to the family, his relations with Mr. Borden, aud his own whereabouts on the morning of the murder. He was fol lowed by Bridget Sullivan, who described so far as possible the actions and where abouts of herself, Lizzie Borden, and Mr. and Mrs. Borden on the day of the mur der. The direct examination of Bridget is not yet finished.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa. · 27 August 1892

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

At Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, Medical Examiner Dolan testified about the hatchet wounds to Andrew and Abby Borden's skulls, stating Abby was killed at least an hour before her husband. He then revealed he had exhumed and removed the heads of both victims from their graves for further examination, shocking Lizzie Borden in the courtroom.

Evening Journal · 27 August 1892 · page 2

THE BORDEN TRAGEDIES

must have been done with a hatchet, how Mr . Borden must have been struck from . • . . . , , . a l * 10 Sttt ou tlle nIH * ^ ,rB "° r " rn must have be»*u «mitten while »ho was standing up and inutlbited nfti r (.lie fell. Ho had also t .tlfied that Mrs. Bor wn must have boon killed at l«iwt tw °l heart before her hufcbaml. Then he laid calmly; "I havo the head» of both the deceased. 1 removed them from the bodies in the «raves in Oak (irove come tefj on Au«, ll by order of tho attorney , hvy m iu w , Pu «j.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A medical examiner testifies he removed the heads of both victims from their graves for examination, shocking Lizzie Borden in the courtroom. Bridget Sullivan then testifies that Lizzie laughed from upstairs shortly before the murders, while another witness recounts his movements on the day of the killings.

Evening Journal · 27 August 1892 · page 2

GHASTLY EVIDENCE IS IN STORE

ess, if the licensed h. a inurder««*». She testified that the daughter went to the murder of her father with a light heart for when Andrew J Borden cam« home on the morning of that fatal day Bridget let hm ,' " ,to th » h " UM '- ' nu rd to open. Bridget node j use of some forcible national exclamation at tbo obduracy of the door, and after she i had done so heard Mis» Lizzie up stairs laugh outright nt her warmth, so that, ac c-mling to the witness' It stimuli)-, Lizzie Borden premeditated parricide nnd laughed ; I at a servant's struggle with a sticky door in one and the unie instant.

See moreSee less

Less than au i hour passed between the time that Lizzie 1 laughed at the servant's encounter with tho door and the time at which she an it tranced her father's murder. The witness ! then deluded the events of the fatal morn ling, ^I«»r*«* ibo m id. The Borden« had a visitor on the day of I their awful visitation. ilis name in John V. Morne. Ho is an uncle of the .

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

John Morse testified about his movements the morning of the murders, never seeing Lizzie until afterward, and described helping wash blood from the cellar floor days later. The report also covers a dispute over whether Matron Reagan told reporters she heard Lizzie quarreling with Emma, accusing her of 'giving her away,' which the matron denied under pressure from the marshal.

Evening Journal · 27 August 1892 · page 2

vau* un.t^. t was recalled and the exami ° ^ «I - ,i . • ^ mo| d extraordinary event since the Borden tragedies I tire,i weeks ago occurred Just aft. r the adjournment of the hearing. Several reporters crowd««! around tbo at top'ieva f«*i tho defense who ahnwi-d • Sing extrlet omThe IMll U vèr Gl.d* "om tut Fall River Globe.

See the clipping

In the story →

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A newspaper clipping claiming jail matron Mrs. Regan overheard Lizzie accusing Emma of 'giving her away' causes uproar among defence attorneys, who deny its accuracy. Multiple reporters prepare to swear affidavits supporting the story while Attorney Jennings drafts a denial for the matron to sign.

New-York Tribune · 27 August 1892 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL.

DID SHE REPROACH HER SISTER WITH "GIVING HER AWAY"?

See moreSee less

ALLEGED STATEMENT OF THE JAIL MATRON—HOT WORDS IN THE COURTROOM—TESTIMONY ABOUT FINDING THE BODIES.

Fall River, Mass., Aug. 26.—The most extraordinary occurrence since the Borden murder three weeks ago, occurred to-night just after the adjournment of the hearing. Several reporters crowded around the attorneys for the defence, who showed the following clipping from "The Fall River Globe":

"Wednesday afternoon a reporter of "The Globe" learned that Matron Regan had heard Lizzie Borden quarrelling with Emma, accusing the latter of giving her away. He went to Mrs. Regan to have the story corroborated. The question was put to the matron: "How is Miss Lizzie conducting herself now?" She replied: "She is very much agitated, and has been since her sister called to-day. She is wringing her hands and walking up and down like a crazy person." The reporter then asked what happened when Emma called, and the story, which the reporter had already heard from other sources, was corroborated in detail by the matron. Matron Regan told this story to other persons."

This article stirred counsel for defence and its correctness is denied. "The Globe" representative, however, will make affidavit that Mrs. Regan corroborated this account, and another newspaper correspondent will make oath that a person in a position to know whereof he speaks, told him the same facts, and said they came directly from Mrs. Regan. Attorney Jennings was much worked up over the matter, and at the earnest solicitation of the reporter, seconded by a number of prominent citizens, the lawyer drew up a form of affidavit, denying that she made the statements attributed to her, to be submitted to Mrs. Regan for her signature.

The Rev. Mr. Buck was delegated to take the document to the matron, but soon returned, saying that she refused to sign it unless the marshal said so. Mr. Buck went to the marshal, who positively refused to allow the matron to do anything of the kind unless she was placed on the witness stand. Mr. Jennings, who had followed Mr. Buck into the office, grew very indignant, and told the marshal it was the meanest thing he had ever heard. The marshal thanked him and hot words passed between the two.

There was a great deal of warm talk over these occurrences to-night, and they are being discussed in all circles. Marshal Hilliard says he has been making an investigation of the case.

There were fewer women in the District Court room to-day. This was probably due to a dreary rain. The prisoner and her friends came in unattended except by the City Marshal. Lizzie walked firmly after her sister and took her usual seat. She busied herself reading a letter written on a sheet of foolscap paper.

The examination was resumed a few minutes before 10 o'clock. Mr. Adams called Dr. Dolan to the stand. He thought the murderer stood just behind Mr. Borden's head; but could not say he struck with both hands. The person who killed Mrs. Borden struck a blow, perhaps, while she was standing up and the others were struck after she had fallen. He must necessarily have been spattered with blood. The hands of the murderer may or may not have been covered with blood. Witness did not give any one permission to clean the wood-work in the house. In fact, he told the family not to disturb the blood spots. No one handled the axe except himself, as far as he knew.

Search of Mr. Borden's clothes was conducted by the undertaker. Keys, some silver money, a pocket-book and some documents were found tied in a handkerchief, and were locked in the examiner's safe. The wound in Mrs. Borden's back was first discovered at the autopsy held in Oak Grove Cemetery. Then came the most grewsome part of the testimony yet given, and while it was going on Miss Lizzie and Miss Emma closed their eyes and flushed and showed much feeling. The witness said the bodies had been buried. The skulls were removed from the bodies, by instruction of the Attorney-General, and cleaned. They were photographed, and are now in the witness's possession. No member of the Borden family was informed of the removal and photographing of the skulls, as far as witness knew.

Here followed a discussion on the pronunciation of the word "photographer," the question being on which syllable the accent should be placed. The diversion had the effect of relieving the tension on the minds of the prisoner and her friends. The witness resuming, said he saw the contents of the safe, but saw no will. He saw a pail and some towels in the cellar, but was satisfied they had no connection with the case; the clothes were buried in a box in the rear of the house. The axe is now in possession of the marshal; the axes and hatchets were given to Professor Wood, but were never fitted to the wounds. In his opinion, Mrs. Borden died from one hour to two hours before Mr. Borden.

A. G. Hart, treasurer of the Union Savings Bank, Cashier Burrill and Everett Cook, of the First National Bank, all testified to seeing Mr. Borden between 9:30 and 9:45 o'clock, the morning of the murder.

Charles C. Cook, real estate broker and agent for Mr. Borden's new business block, had a long talk with him a few days before the tragedy. Mr. Borden said that he had made no will.

Mrs. Caroline Kelly testified to living in the house next south to the Borden homestead. On the day of the murder she saw Mr. Borden coming around the house from the north side and going toward the front door. She thought he had a small white package in his hand. At the time she saw him it was 27 or 25 minutes to 1 o'clock; she could not say that he entered the house.

Dr. Dolan was recalled and produced the property taken from Mr. Borden's pockets, by the undertaker. Among the effects was a package of tobacco.

The photographs taken in the house soon after the murder were placed in evidence. There are five of them, showing the various positions of the bodies in the various rooms. On a second cross-examination witness said when an artery was cut the direction of the spurt would be dependent on the direction from which it was cut. He saw no yard stick when he first saw the body, but he did see one later.

John Cunningham, newsdealer, was sworn. He was passing the Borden house, on the morning of August 4, and heard of the murder. When he reached Hall's stable, two or three houses below, he noticed four or five men standing in front of the house, and saw Mrs. Churchill running excitedly across the street. A boy told him he was looking for a policeman. He stepped into a store and called up the city marshal's office, at 10:50 o'clock. He saw the police officer, Allen, going toward the house, four or five minutes after he had informed the marshal. He went around the house with two reporters, but they could find no trace of footprints on the grass or the fence.

Deputy Sheriff Frank H. Wixon was sworn. He saw the officers make a search of the house; he could not say he saw anybody go into the barn; he was in the yard after 12 o'clock and crawled up on a pile of lumber and into the next yard. He thought the next yard extended to Third-st. The other men were so standing that they could not see the Borden house, but the first man could have seen any man who crossed the back Borden fence; he could not talk to this first man, as he was a foreigner.

The first witness this afternoon was Joseph Shortsleeves, a carpenter who had worked for Mr. Borden. He was at the store, 92 South Main-st., but was not working, when Mr. Borden stopped there on his way home on the morning of the murder. He fixed the time at 10:40 as nearly as possible.

Miss Lizzie Borden appeared to be using more than an ordinary effort to maintain her composure, and it was evident that the strain was beginning to tell on her wonderful nerve. As she caught Mrs. Holmes's eye her face brightened in an instant.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At the preliminary examination, Dr. Dolan testified about the likely position of the murderer during the attacks and the nature of the wounds, noting the killer would likely have been spattered with blood. He also revealed that the victims' skulls had been removed, cleaned, and photographed without the family's knowledge, causing visible distress to Lizzie and Emma Borden in court.

New-York Tribune · 27 August 1892 · page 5

TESTIMONY ABOUT FINDING THE BODIES.

He thought the murderer stood just behind Mr. Bor den’s head; but could not say he struck with both hands, The person who killed Mrs, Borden struck a

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A witness describes how the skulls were removed from the buried bodies, cleaned, and photographed without informing the Borden family, and gives a medical opinion that Mrs. Borden died one to two hours before Mr. Borden. Additional witnesses testify about seeing Mr. Borden on the morning of the murder, a neighbor's sighting of him near the house, and evidence including photographs and personal effects taken from the scene.

New-York Tribune · 27 August 1892 · page 5

Borden dled from one hour to two hours before Mr. Lorden, A. G. Hart, treasurer of the Unton Bavings Bank, Cashier Burrill and Everett Cook, of the First Na. tlonal Bank, all testified to seeing Mr. Borden between 9:30 and LV:45 o'clock, the morning of the murder, Charles (. Cook, real estate broker and agent for Mr. Lorden's new business block, had a long talk with im a few days before the tmmgedy. Mr, Borden said that he had made no will, Mrs, Caroline Kelly testified to ving In the house pext south to the Borden homestead.

See moreSee less

On the day of the murder she saw Mr. Borden coming around the house from the north side and going toward the front door. She thonght he had a small white pack. age In Ws hand, At the time she saw hm It wits 27 or 25 minutes to 1 o'clock; she could not say that he entered the house, Dr. Dolan vas recalled and produced the property taken from Mr, Borden's pockets, by the andertaker, Among the effects was a package of tobacco, I'he photographs taken In the house goon afier the murder were placed In evidence, There are five of them, showing the various positions of the hodies In the various rooms, cross oxamina on a second tlon witness sald when nn artery was cut the direction of the spurt would be dependent on the direction from which It was cut. lle saw no yard stiek when he first saw the body, but he did see one later, John Cunningham, newsdeal r, was sworn, He was, passing the Borden house, on the morning of August 4. and heard of the murder. When he reached Hall's stable, two or three houses below, he noticed four or five men standing in front of the house, and saw Mrs, Churchill running excitedly across the street, A boy told him he was I oking for a pollceman, He stepped nto a store and called up the city marshal’s office, at 10:50 o'clock, He saw the police officer, Allen, going toward the house, four op five minutes after he had in formed the marshal, He went around the house with two reporters, but they could find no trace of foot prints on the grass or the fence. Deputy sheritt Frank 1H. Wixon was sworn, He saw the officers make a search of the house; he could not say he saw anybody go into the barn, he was In the yard after 12 o'clock and crawled up on a pile of lumber and Into the next yam. He thought {Ne next va extended ™ Third-st, The other men were so standing that they could not see the Lorden honse, but the first man could have seen any man who crossed the back Borden fence; he conld not talk to this first man, as he was a foreigner The first witness this afternoon was Joseph Shortsleeves, a carpenter who had worked for Mr. Borden. He was at the store, 92 South Maln-st., but was not working, when Mr. Borden stopped there on his way home on the morning of the murder, He fixed the time at 10:40 as nearly as possible, Miss Lizzie Borden appeared to be using more than an ordinary effort to maintain her composurs, and It was evident that the struiy was beginuing to tell on ler wonderful nerve. A. she eang'® Mrs, Holmes's eve her fue Leghtoned inoan Instance, ——

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

German-language report from Baltimore describes continued preliminary hearing testimony in the Lizzie Borden case, focusing on defense attorney Adams's cross-examination of Dr. Dolan. Dolan admitted the initial autopsy was incomplete, that he lacked authority at the time for a full examination, and that his report to Judge Blaisdell was delayed, with contradictions emerging between his first and second autopsy reports.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 27 August 1892 · page 1

Der Doppelmord von Fall-River. Fortsetzung der Verhör im Fall Lizzie Borden

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

At the preliminary hearing, Dr. Dolan's cross-examination revealed contradictions between his first and second autopsy reports, including confusion over whether he washed his hands after handling the bodies and the bloody axe. He also testified that the skulls of both victims had been removed, cleaned, and photographed during a second exhumation, with the bodies reburied headless without family notification, causing visible distress to Lizzie and Emma Borden.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 27 August 1892 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

German-language newspaper reports on the Fall River preliminary hearing, where Dr. Dolan testified under cross-examination about exhuming the Borden bodies, removing and photographing the skulls, and his belief that Mrs. Borden died one to two hours before her husband. Other witnesses testified about Andrew Borden's bank visit and appearance that morning, the absence of any will, and sightings of Borden near the house shortly before the murders.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 27 August 1892 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

At the Fall River preliminary hearing, defense attorney Adams cross-examined Dr. Dolan at length, highlighting the police and medical examiner's negligence. Dolan admitted the initial autopsy was incomplete and his report to Judge Blaisdell was delayed, with contradictions emerging between his first and second autopsy reports.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 27 August 1892 · page 2

Der Doppelmord von Fall River. Fortsetzung der Verhör im Falle Lizzie Borden

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Dr. Dolan testifies about the second autopsy conducted after the bodies were exhumed, describing how the skulls were removed, cleaned, and photographed without family notification. He contradicts himself about washing blood from his hands before handling the murder weapon, and the defense expresses satisfaction that no evidence has linked the murders to anyone in the household.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 27 August 1892 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The cross-examination of Dr. Dolan concluded, revealing he had exhumed the victims' bodies on the Attorney General's orders, removing and photographing the skulls without notifying the Borden family; this news visibly distressed Emma and Lizzie Borden in court. Additional witnesses testified about Andrew Borden's bank visit on the morning of the murder, his denial of having made a will, and a neighbor's sighting of him returning home shortly before the murders.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 27 August 1892 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The passage recounts servant Bridget Sullivan's preliminary hearing testimony describing the morning of the murders and discovery of the bodies. It also reports that the skulls of Andrew and Abby Borden were removed from their bodies five days after burial for medical examination, shocking the public.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 27 August 1892 · page 4

REVOLTING

After Death. The people are still agitated over the | horrors of the testimony given in tin* pre j litninary hearing in the ease of Miss Lizzie i A. Borden, charged with the murder of her J father and stepmother, j It appears that hrutal as was the hacking j of the heads and faces' of Mr. and Mr-. ! \ndrev J. Borden, there had been still further mutilation of the bodies. The heads of both murdered persons were cut from the trunks, and the bleached -kulls now occupy a strong box in the office of Medical Kxanilner Dolan.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Nearly a dozen doctors examined the Borden bodies in autopsies, removing stomachs for analysis and the skulls themselves, which were later photographed after flesh was stripped away. The photographs reveal extensive wounds, with Mrs. Borden's skull showing a large hole and fourteen distinct marks, while Mr. Borden's head shows nine marks including a gash through his eye and cheek.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 27 August 1892 · page 4

A HORRIBLE STORY

terrible tragedy. i Then came, the crowning act. cutting off j tinheads, a desecration that murderer have been known to commit, but never | before in the opinion of several lawyers ; who have been seen, undertaken with like I circumstances by a state, and especially the (’ommoMwealth of Massachusetts. Two davs ago the skulls were photo* 1 graphed. \ Ii traceof flesh have been ! removed. This is probably why the pic turewere not taken for eleven day s after [ the heads were cut off. the flesh ill the | meantime having been removed.

See moreSee less

Two more ghastly pictures it would. 1 indeed, he hard to tigd than are the plioto | graphs. I The back part of Mrs. Borden's skull is shown on one photograph. It reveals an ! even greater amount of brutality than ! could be imagined Irom the description# given from time to time -if the wounds. The photograph is 7xlo inches, and i show# that tin* hack part of the murdered : woman'- head was literally rut away. A j hole If 1 A! inches wide, extending from the ; erown almost h* the ne.-k, -how# where the : ax or hatchet tore away the skull. Fourteen black marks, varying in length j from an inch to three inches, are notable on the surface, and indicate where the as sassin's implement made the horrible gashes which Medical F.xaminer Dolan told of at ; tinhearing. Pieces of the skull were : drivell into the brain. Another photograph shows a front view ; uf Mr Borden's head and face. and. though ! not as shockingly mutilated as that of his ! wife, it is still a gha-tly tiling to look at. ; The camera has truly reproduced the awful gashes that ran from the left side of Mr. Borden's head, through the eyeball and j cheek bone to the chin. I Nine black marks on the photograph *ig ! nified the other places on the head and face j where the ax-- or hatchet struck.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

At the preliminary hearing in Fall River, Dr. Dolan testified about his examination of the hatchet and his earlier secret decapitation of Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies, shocking Lizzie and Emma Borden in court. The report also covers servant Bridget Sullivan's account of Lizzie's movements and demeanor on the morning of the murders, including her laughing in the hall around 10:30 a.m.

The Portland Daily Press · 27 August 1892 · page 1

John V. Morse’s Story. Fall River, August 26.—The testimo ny of Dr. Dolan today as to his decapitar tion of the bodies of Andrew J. Borden and his wife came as a sad and terrible shock to the sensitiveness of the Misses Borden, and for the first time during the trial Lizzie Borden gave way to emotion.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A medical examiner testifies at the inquest that he removed the skulls of both victims during autopsy on instructions from the Attorney General, and that the bodies were buried without their heads. He also describes cleaned bloodstains, a false blood spot later identified as dirt, and confirms Mrs. Borden's body was moved and replaced during examination.

The Portland Daily Press · 27 August 1892 · page 1

Witness went on to say that he caused Mr. Borden’s body to be searched; he re ceived a bunch of keys from his pockets; he had them now; they were given him by the undertaker. Tbe wound in the back was not discovered until the autop

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Dr. testifies at inquest that the victims' bodies were buried without their heads, which he removed on instruction from the Attorney General and kept at his office after having them photographed. Insurance agent Charles Cook also testifies about Andrew Borden's lack of a will, contradicting an officer's earlier account of a conversation.

The Portland Daily Press · 27 August 1892 · page 1

Charles C. Cook, Insurance Agent, testified to his business relations with Mr. Borden. He had charge of his busi ness block at the corner of Anawan and South Main streets; saw him three or four times a week. Witness did not see him on the day of the murder. Saw him pass along the street on the day before. Witness talked with Mr. Borden on the day before the murder, “Did he say anything about mak ing a will?” asked the district attorney. “No, sir.” “Had he ever said anything to you about his will?” “Not about making one, He said he hadn’t one.” “Were you drawing a will when he came?” “I was preparing a draft for somebody else?” “Did he notice your work, and say ‘that is something I ought to do’?” “He did not; he simply said in noticing it that he hadn’t any will of his own.” “Do you remember Officer Medley coming to you two days after the mur der?” “Yes.

See moreSee less

sir.” “Do you remembei the officer asking you about what Mr. Borden said to you that morning?” “He asked me a great many ques tions.” “Do you remember telling Mr. Medley that Mr. Borden said to you, ‘What are you doing?’ Objected to bv Mr. Jen nings, but subsequsw Uy withdrawn. “Do you remember telling Officer Medley that Mr. Borden said to you that what you were doing was something he hadn’t done, and that he ought to do?” Witness—“I never said anything of the kind, sir,” with emphasis. This was a sharp blow at the govern ment’s theory of mo' ve and is of great interest to the defence. Mr. Cook was told that he might leave the stand. The defence made no cross examination.

See the clipping

Daily Yellowstone Journal · Miles City, Mont.

A report describes a jail visit by Emma Borden to her sister Lizzie, witnessed by police matron Mrs. Reagan. Lizzie accuses Emma of giving her away, while Emma insists she only told attorney Jennings what he needed to know for the defense.

Daily Yellowstone Journal · 27 August 1892 · page 1

SBie GOve!ilerself.Away. N1,rw Yostu, Aug. 25.-A special to the World from Fall River says that Miss Lizzie Borden was visted by her sister Emma yesterday afternoon. Mas. Regan, the police matron, was present during the interview. When Lizzie saw her sister she waved her away, sayinug: 'You gave me away, Emma, did you not?" and turned her back upon her sister. "No, Lizzie, I only told Mr. Jen nlngs what he ought to know for your defense," answered the girl. Lizzie turned and replied in a voice emblttted with suppressed passion: "Tlhat is false.

See moreSee less

Yu ihave given tile away and I know it, but remem her, I will inot give in oone inchl, neve r, never. Thait is all f care to say to you." With tears in her eyes and a volce HEI AILY ELI OWSTONE TIRINAI

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

At the preliminary hearing in Fall River, Dr. Dolan's cross-examination covered details such as the axe handle's length and how Abby Borden was struck while lying on the floor. John V. Morse and Bridget Sullivan then testified about their own whereabouts and the movements of Lizzie and the Bordens on the morning of the murders.

The Sun · 27 August 1892 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Lawyer Adams cross-examines Dr. Dolan at the preliminary hearing about the murder weapon, the killer's position over Mrs. Borden's body, and bloodstains. Dolan also describes the Oak Grove Cemetery autopsy, revealing that he had decapitated both victims to examine and photograph the skulls.

The Sun · 27 August 1892 · page 1

THE MURDERER STOOD OVER MRS BORDEN

Probably but not necessarily sold Dr Dolan 3 DolanWould Would there not have been blood on the upper part of the body ot the murderer tool Possibly but not probably was the an swer Did you give anyone permission to wash the blood stains from the parlor door asked Mr Adams No sir said Dr Dolan While I am no I ° absolutely certain that any member of the 4 Borden family washed them off yet I think thoy did It was done I think on the day after tho murder and without my consent Turning once moro to the axes found In th cellar Mr Adams spent some time In trying to confuse the witness as to whether the axes were damp or dry and exactly how dry they were He asked if they wore bone dry Leaving the axes Mr Adams asked what was found on tile body ot Mr Borden Dr Dolan testified that a bunch of keys some money s > C note book and one big key were given to him by the undertaker who said he had taken them from Mr Bordons clothing Dr Dolan next reviewed the Oak Grove Cem etery autopsy held on Aug 11 Ho told ot the additional wound discovered in Mrs Bordens back

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

During cross-examination at the preliminary hearing, Dr. Dolan testified that he had removed the heads of both victims during the Aug. 11 autopsy to scrape and photograph the skulls, shocking the Borden family who had not known. He also described blood-stained rags found in a cellar pail that were human blood but not from either victim, and recounted the burial and search of clothing and the house safe.

The Sun · 27 August 1892 · page 1

THE HEADS OF THE BODIES CUT OW Then one week later ho said the bodies i were Interred Thnt Is parts of them were On the 4ay of the autopsy I cut off the heads of Mr and Mrs BOrden scraped the skull and had them photographed You what roared Mr Adams Ton burled those bodies headless and have those broken skulls now I havo sir said Dr Dolan Emma Borden began to cry For time first tIme Lizzie Borden showed evidences of fooling The muscles ot her face twitched and her lips trembled Did any of tho family know of this 1 asked Mr Adams They did not sir and probably this Is the A first they hove heard ot It When were Urn skulls photographed On Monday or Tuesday of this week said Dr Dolan The witness then produced photo a graphs of tile bodies of Mr and Mrs Borden as they lay tho ono iu the sitting room the other In tine spare bedroom when discovered after tho murdor Next Dr Dolan told of the mrummmim s scarcii lor a win wets oy nimseif lawyer Jennings and District Attorney Knowlton In the safe of Mr Borden Tho District Attorney Interrupted the wit ness to stats that ho had had two facts to offer which if accepted by the defence would enublo the prosecution to dispense With sev eral witnesses The first was that Mr Borden was a man of means at the time ot his death and tho second was that he died without will or was Intestate The defines acreet that these two facts should stand as It alwadf proved Was there a pall discovered la the cellar of the Borden house asked Lawyer Adams after the District Attorney finished Thore was said Dr Dolun ct Woro timer any clothes In the pallf t es eir IVns there blood on these clothes ° Yesslr Was It human blood I os sir hut It was not blood of either Mr or Mrs Borden slId the finding of the bloody rags will not be used In this case1 Dr Dolan then described how the plothlng taken from it the bodies of Mr and Mrs Borden was first burled back of the house then was taken UP examined and buried again Ina box and then was again taken up and sent to Marshal Hllllnrd In a box The axes found In the cellar said time witness wore not fitted to tho wounds In the heads of the murdered couple He swore positively that Mr Bordon died before 1116 oclock and at least from an haur to an hour and a half before Mr Jiorulen was k Hod Ho said the coagulated condition of the blood proved that ashio from time dllloronou ot temperature In the two bodies Thioughout tholr testimony the defendant leaned forward and listened Intently Dr Dolan repeated that the firmness anti color of the condiulatlon of the blood of Mrs Borden showed that Itwas out of living tissue nnd cxpoiml to the air from one and a half lo two hours Dr Dolan was directed to produce In court as soon as possible time various articles given him by the undertaker who took thorn from Mr Borden s body TIUCINO MR 80RDEN

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Several bank cashiers testified about Andrew Borden's visits to their banks on the morning of his murder, noting his unusual appearance and brief stays. Testimony also touched on a conversation in which Borden reportedly said he had made no will, contradicting prosecution claims.

The Sun · 27 August 1892 · page 2

murder when he came In I asked him whern Ju I had been the day before I was not hero I 0 lie saidbecause 1 wns not well He was far I from well I then John O Hurrough cashier the National l Union lank said that Mr Borden was a stock holder in tho bank and came into thn bank the morning ot the murder hotwoon 111 Hand U4 > and remained from live to ton minutes Ever ett Cook cashier of tho First National Hank

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Bank cashiers testify about Andrew Borden's visits to their banks on the morning of the murder, and neighbor Mrs. Kelly describes seeing him return home carrying a small white package around 10:40. The report also lists items found in Borden's pockets and resumes medical testimony about the fatal wounds.

The Sun · 27 August 1892 · page 2

by Mr Cook thnt Mr llorden had said ho was 1 Z about to make 1 s will Mrs Caroline Kelly wife ot Ir Kelly who lives about thirty foot south of tho Borden house then Mild I 1 live next to tho llordons on tho sitting room side of their houxo Un the morning of the murder I saw Mr llordcn eo up tho front IO steps of his house and try tho door Ho had a

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A medical expert testifies about blood spatter patterns in the Borden house, describing how spurts from Mrs. Borden's wounds marked the wall and furniture, and stating the fatal blow was struck while she was alive, probably not while standing. Additional witnesses testify to seeing Andrew Borden at local shops shortly before the murders, establishing a timeline of his movements that morning.

The Sun · 27 August 1892 · page 2

I mt I saw Mr Borden on the mon1n of the I oclock and hlnyod until 111211 > oclock Ho r murder In my store Ho coma In at lOiO t t went south after lonUrig my store I am pool eW the about tho time as I looked ut the clock

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Maid Bridget Sullivan testified that Mr. and Mrs. Borden had been sick the night before the murders, and that Lizzie also said she'd been sick. She also stated she recognized Lizzie's laugh on the stairs and had never seen her crying since the tragedy.

The Evening World · 27 August 1892 · page 2

HADN'T SEEN LIZZIE CRY.

More of Drldtjitt Sullivan's Tesstlmon. In tba Borden Murder Cms. 1st AsrociATiD rate... I FallKitek, Aug. 27. At tho Borden hear, lng this morning tbe examination of Bridget Sullivan was continued. Witness said: "Somebody was sick at tkt house the night before tbe murder. Mrs. Boiden said ehe and Mr. Borden wero sick ut night. They hud been vomiting and looked sick. " Wben Unto came down sbe said the hat) been sick, but I did not hotlce that aha looked so. "Miss Lizzie bad been moving about eight et nlno minutes when sbe went upstairs to her room.

See moreSee less

Tbe District-Attorney asked the witness te tell them again about tho words used by Lis, zlo about going out, locking tba door and, Mrs. Borden rccolvlng a note. Objections were ralsod, but were over, ruled. Witness said wben sbe came downstairs Miss Lizzie told her she beard her father , groaning wnllo be was In the back yard. W hen she csmo In the screen-door was wide open. She recognized tho laugh In tbe upper balk way spoken of yesterday as that ol Miss Lizzie Borden. Slnco tbe tragedy occurred sbe had nevaf seen Lizzie Borden crying.

See the clipping

Eureka Weekly Sentinel · Eureka, Nev.

Embedded in a report of a political rally speech, a passing joke suggests that if Lizzie Borden killed her father she must have been insane, and if she didn't she must be nearly insane by now. The remark reflects ongoing public uncertainty about her guilt rather than reporting new facts.

Eureka Weekly Sentinel · 27 August 1892 · page 2

Four daily papers—the Detroit Flven ing News, the SI. Louis Chroniole, the Cincinnati Post and the Cleveland Press —combined circulation ICO,000 copies, have joined the People's party within the past three weeks. 111 —1 - _ Colonel Ingersoll says that there are just two things in the world very hard to bear. " One is to be hated by the publio, and the other to be loved by it. The ideal thing ie to be ignored. ” If Lizzie Borden killed her father she must have been insane at the time. If Lizzie Borden did not kill her father she must be pretty nearly Insane by this time. Keep cool, don't lose your head, silver #2.—State.

See the clipping

The Ohio Democrat · Logan, Ohio

Charles H. Peckham of Westport walked into the Fall River police station and confessed to killing Andrew and Abby Borden, claiming he did it 'out of pure love for blood.' He described entering through the back fence and rear door, striking multiple blows, and leaving the same way, though police began investigating his background and relatives.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Ohio Democrat · 27 August 1892 · page 2

LOVED BLOOD.

II. Peckham, of Central Villa, West port, Mass., walked into tho Central po llco btation Thursday morning nnd said to Assistant Marshal Fleet: "Well, Mr. Marshal, I killed Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden, and I havo como from homo to give myself up. I went over tho back fonco nnd through tho rear door of tho Borden house two weeks ago to day nnd I killed both of those peoplo out of puro lovo for blood. I went out the rear door and over the back fenco nnd walked over tho Now Bedford road home. I'm tho murderer, nnd I want to bo locked up."

See the clipping

The Ohio Democrat · Logan, Ohio

A man named Peckham confessed to Deputy Marshal Fleet, explaining he struck extra blows as a precaution though the first blow killed instantly, and that he wanted to be held after bearing the guilt alone. Fleet telephoned New Bedford's mayor about Peckham's character and also contacted Andrew Jennings, Lizzie Borden's attorney.

The Ohio Democrat · 27 August 1892 · page 2

LOVED BLOOD.

Mr. Fleet also communicated by tele phone v itli Andrew J. Jennings, at torney for Lizzie Borden. Mr. Jen nings replied that ho wished to see tho prisoner.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The Borden murder hearing resumed in district court with Lizzie Borden present, and Dr. Dolan testified about the victims' wounds, noting their skulls had been removed and photographed. A bank treasurer also testified that Andrew Borden had complained of feeling unwell the morning of the murders.

Paper unidentified · 27 August 1892 · page 2

Tho Borden Murder Oaso. Fall ill visit, Mass., Aug. 27. The Borden murder hearing was re sumed la tho district court. Lizzie Borden, the prisoner, walked firmly uud took her usual seat. Dr. Dolan resumed his testimony. He de scribed tho wounds und how he supposed they were inlhoted. Wit ness said the Indies hud been in terred, aud skulls removed from tlio bodies by instruction of tlio utioruoy-geiiorul. Tlio skulls were photographed uud were now lu wluiraa' possession. Ill the doctor's opinion Mrs. Bordeu was dead two hours before her husband. Treasurer Hart, of tlie Union savings batik, testllled he had seen Mr. Borden lu tlio bank tiie morulug of the mur ders, und that he complained of feeling unwell.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

On the second day of the preliminary hearing in Fall River, witnesses detailed Andrew Borden's whereabouts before his death, and John Vinnicum Morse described his visits and movements that morning. Bridget Sullivan then testified about the household's activities, with cross-examination touching on how Mrs. Borden was killed while lying down.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 27 August 1892 · page 6

WEAVING THE WEB

rsrZCXSX TELtORAM TO THE DISPATCH.J Faia Eivee, Mass., Aug 2a "Wet and chilly dawned the second day of the hearing of Lizzie Borden. The examination of Dr. Solan was concluded, sevetal Witnesses were examined to vbow Mr. Borden's whereabouts previous to his return to his house on the morning of the murder, and then John Vinnicum Morse was placed on the stand. Mr. Morse told of his visits to the family, his relations with Mr. Borden, and his own whereabouts on the morning of the murder. He was followed by Bridget Sullivan, who described the actions and the whereabouts of herself, Lizzie Borden, and Mr. aud Mrs. Borden on the day of the murder. TJie direct examination of Bridget was not concluded. Judge BlaUdell opened court promptly.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

At the preliminary hearing, Dr. Dolan testified under cross-examination that the Bordens were struck while lying down and described how he removed and scraped the skulls during autopsy before burial, shocking the Borden sisters. He also stated Mrs. Borden died 1 to 1.5 hours before Mr. Borden, and testimony covered the fruitless search for a will and witnesses tracing Andrew Borden's movements that morning.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 27 August 1892 · page 6

of them were, lor on the day of the autopsy I cut off the heads of Mr. aud Mrs. Borden, scraped the skulls, and had them photo graphed." "You what?" roare 1 Mr. Adams. "You buried these bodies headless, and have those broken skulls now?" "I have, sir," said Dr. Dolan. Emma Borden beian to cry softly. -For

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

John Vinnicum Morse testified about his overnight stay at the Borden house, his morning errands, and his return just after the murders. Under cross-examination he recounted that Mr. and Mrs. Borden had complained of sickness the morning of the murder, with Mrs. Borden suspecting poisoning from bread.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 27 August 1892 · page 6

SPECIAL TELEGRAM TO THE DISPATCH

alternoon." Mr. Knowlton asked him first of his rela tionship to Mr. Borden, and Mr. Morse, in , a low, almost inaudible voice, said: "I am C9 years old, and live now at the Borden house."

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The second day of the Borden preliminary hearing featured testimony from Bridget Sullivan and John Morse, but produced accusation without proof. Sullivan's account covered the night before the murder through her discovery of the crime, while Morse's testimony touched on establishing a motive.

Pawtucket Tribune · 27 August 1892 · page 1

STILL UNANSWERED.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The report describes courtroom testimony from Bridget (the surviving servant) about events on the morning of the murders, including details about washing windows and when Mrs. Borden's body was found. It also notes Lizzie Borden's calm, self-possessed demeanor in court, though she showed visible strain during Dr. Dolan's testimony about the trunks.

Pawtucket Tribune · 27 August 1892 · page 1

POINTS IN HER FAVOR

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report covers the third day of the preliminary hearing, noting that Bridget Sullivan's testimony remained unshaken under cross-examination. It also reveals that the insurance agent's testimony discredited rumors about a will, while John Morse's account left open the possibility the cellar door was unlocked, and mentions a previously secret burglary at the Borden house in July.

The Providence News · 27 August 1892 · page 1

STRANGE BURGLARIES.

Journment Untill 11 O'clock Monday. ISPECIAL TO THE NEWS.| FALL RIVER, Aug. 27.—The second and third days have been fateful for the ac cused. The strenuous efforts made by the de fence to find some flaws of importance in the testimony has proved of no avail. Slowly but surely the prosecution is drawing the cordon of facts down to a point where the friends of Miss Borden must cease to claim that there was not evidence enough to justify her detention. Meanwhile the defence has added two ifmportant points to its claims one of them almost positively settied, and the other still floating.

See moreSee less

The first relates to the motive, In the testimony of the in surance agent yesterday it appeared that the reports concerning his remarks about Mr. Borden’s will and his intention to make one were entirely unfounded. He said Mr. Borden never said anything of that kind nor did he say that Mr. Burgen

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report examines conflicting testimony from John Morse about the cellar door and Bridget Sullivan's detailed account of the morning of the murders, noting no one else could have committed the crime without detection. It argues the circumstantial evidence against Lizzie Borden is strong and speculates that only insanity could explain such a calculated, nerve-wracking crime.

The Providence News · 27 August 1892 · page 1

position is very strong. Grant the probable ruilt. and the out come of the case is evident. Many have been the guesses that Miss Borden is in sane, but unone have given conclusive reasons such as the NEws of yesterday preseyted for the belief that the insanity plea could be well founded, The shape of the head and the expression of the race as minutely described yesterday are strong evidence, but a careful analysis of her acts adds lnaurlalh to the thought. Here is a case not only of pre meditated murder but of Jprobable deliberation for months. “Uhe or dinary assassin is cunning too cunuing to risk his chances of detection

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A Providence News editorial argues that Lizzie Borden's calm, calculated behavior during and after the murders—such as laughing and ironing while blood still oozed from the victims—proves she must be insane rather than a cunning criminal. It predicts the case will ultimately resolve with a verdict that the killings were committed by an insane, and thus irresponsible, person, supported by unanimous expert medical testimony.

The Providence News · 27 August 1892 · page 1

thought of his escaping from the sight of Bridget or Lizzie for two hours is impos gible. Only an insane person of abuor mulld developed cunning and the spirit of afiend could have endured such a ner vous strain, No sane person would have thought of escaping notice on the publie streets at that time of day., The act is one thut resulted from lonz study and it was consummated under conditions that exelude all elements ‘of chance. Grant again the probable guilt of Miss Borden. Think of her laughing at the basty remarks of Miss Bridget when the door refused to open—laughing when the life Dblood was oozing from

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A brief sarcastic filler note remarks that Lizzie Borden must be pleased with the various comments being made about her personal appearance. It reflects the intense press scrutiny of her looks during the ongoing case.

The Providence News · 27 August 1892 · page 4

8 | part in this campaign. e | Miss Lizzie BORDEN must be pleas o | at the various comments on her persol 't appearance. == 0 0 t | Daxa smites Pulitzer hip and thij n —_—

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Bridget Sullivan resumes testimony about the morning of the murders, describing Lizzie's statements about her mother's note, a groan she heard, and the household's illness the night before. Defense attorney Adams begins cross-examination, establishing Sullivan's employment history and background.

The Providence News · 27 August 1892 · page 7

THE THIRD DAY

torney Knowlton questioning her. There had been some sickness in the family Tuesday n!fiu.. Mrs. Borden told her that she and Mr. Borden had been vommng all nltht. Lizzie also said she had beeh sick that night.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This passage details inquest testimony from Bridget Sullivan, the Borden household maid, being closely cross-examined about a mysterious note, her whereabouts, and household meals in the days before the murders. The questioning highlights inconsistencies in her account of how long Lizzie and Emma were away, and details the family's food and routines leading up to the murders.

The Providence News · 27 August 1892 · page 7

gentleman callers?’ “No, sir. Came in Wednesday night about five minutes past ten, locked the door, got a lamp. Every on%:las gone to bed. She weat up-stairs to o 7 Her testimony here repeated the story of Mrs. Borden and Mr, Borden and Laz

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This passage reports detailed questioning of maid Bridget Sullivan about the Borden household's meals, routines, and movements in the days before the murders. It covers topics like Lizzie's illness, breakfast habits, household chores, and the layout of the house including the entryway and pantry.

The Providence News · 27 August 1892 · page 7

couldn’t say.” Thursday morning Bridget Sullivan® came down stairs; got her wood first then got coal from the cellar; started fire; weunt into dlnlni room and opeued the window: went back to kitchen to get breakfast; got can of milk from steps; Mrs. Borden came down and told her to get mutton soup, cold mutton, johuny cakes and coffee. She didu't know any

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

Fall River court resumed testimony from Bridget Sullivan, the Borden household servant, about events on the morning of the murders including illness in the house and Lizzie's movements. She also described hearing Lizzie's laugh upstairs and noted she never saw Lizzie crying after the tragedy.

Alexandria Gazette · 27 August 1892 · page 2

The Borden Trial. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 27.?The famous Borden trial was resumed this morning. The examination of Bridget Sullivan was resumed. Witness said: Somebody was sick at the house Tues? day night. Air.-. Borden said she aud Mr. Borden were sick. They had been vomiting and looked sick. When Liz? zie came down she said she had been sick, but I didn't notice she looked un? well. I got wood and coal from the cellar. There was a wood box in the kitchen. Miss Lizzie bad been moving about eight or nine minutes when she went up stairs to her room.

See moreSee less

Mr. Bor? den used the sofa a great deal, bul witness never saw tho girls using it. Had never seen Lizzie in the barn. The attorneys asked the witness to tell them again about the words used by Lizzie Borden about goiug out, locking the door and Mrs. Borden receiving a note. Objections were raised, but they were overruled. When witness came down stairs, Miss Lizzie said she told her she heard her father groaning while she was in the yard. When she came in she said the screen door was wide open. She recognized the laugh in the upper hall-way spokeu of yes? terday as that of Miss Lizzie Borden. Since the tragedy occurred she never s.tw Lizzie Borden crying.

See the clipping

The Superior Times · Superior, Wis.

Charles H. Peckham of Westport walked into the Fall River police station claiming he killed Andrew and Abby Borden out of 'pure love of blood,' describing his escape route over the back fence. Police searched him, found only a pocketbook and some papers, and began trying to locate his relatives or friends, treating his confession with suspicion.

The Superior Times · 27 August 1892 · page 4

SAYS HE KILLED THE BORDENS

A Men Named Cliurlen 11. Peckliam Con lenaem the IJloodj lee<. Fail Eiveß, Mass., A tip. IS.—Charle* 11. Peckham, of Central ' illatre, West port, Mass., walked into the central po lice station this morning and said to As sistant Marshal Fleet; “ Well, Marshal, I killed Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Bor den, and 1 Lave come from horn© to give myself up. I went 076f the Lack fence and through the rent door of the Holden House two weeks ago to-day, nod I killed both of those people out of pure love biood, 1 went out the rear door and oterthe hack fence, and walked over the Ae* Bedford road.

See moreSee less

I’m the murderer, and I want to be locked up.” . The marshal took Beckham to tneced room nr.d searched him. He found a pock et hock with a few receipts in it,and linear! Led conle n IJlcial c* on mu ni* ali ons from Kdssiaft bureattal Washington, J-eckham is years of age, about - feet s im lies tall and ha'a thin, gray beard* Ho savs he leases a farm ffom Fdmund Ha vis. The police have started to hunt up his relatives or friends. The circumstances surrounding the assassination "1 Borden and hie wile well' such as to astound those who would pounce, olf’-haiicl, upon a motive. Borden was a rich and pious skinflint, aged 7i years, whose probity I*“* (ipial to" liis thrift. He had not i a puiilic lift*, he had no known enemv who, it could he conjectured, would l'. to the extent of hiding him. miwh less Ins wile, and when the mi. tilatcd bodies of the couple were dis covered, 'M theirown 1 ;ouse, shortly be fore noon on August 4, the police and tlie public were utterly >* a loss for a motive, and in the intense excitement that overwl elmed the community they turned to one another in helpless astute* isment and horror. The body of Borden was found on a velvet sofa in the parlor ol the house. His head had been literally hacked to piece?. There were seven long ga-hes mi hif face and skull, some •>! them an in and a half dt ep through tin flesh and hone. In tin* “spare leil<di"in h r on tla second floor was dis own'd liie body ol Mrs. Borden, who was 07 t ears old. There was at first no sight of olood. and the n.<ui eutary suj posi tion was that heart failure had oci urred. Mrs. Borden was lying prone on the floor on her face with her arms out sdreiched and the toes ol her shoes resting <m the carpet. On raising the body tiiere was seen ft pool ol blood, and an examination disclosed the ‘act that death had 1 con caused, as in the ea-e of the husband, by repeated blows *f some heavy sharp instrument <m the face, neck and bead. In the ease of both there win ftund a deep cut into the brain. The tirs I alarm was given by Lizzie Borden, who ran out into the yard and called for help. Half of the police force of ball liivvr were oil on a picnic when the murder occurred, and 'or that reason a strung guard ol the premises was not furnished immediately, hut sev eral officers were quickly in the house a ter the alarm was given, and tin y leaned enough to make it plain that robbery had not 1 eon the purpose of the killing. .No plate or money or any of the valuables of the mansion were missing, nor had a single thing been removed Iroia the bodies. Borden’s wati h and money and Mrs. Borden’s m-ney and jewels were undisturbed. Miss Borden, a daughter of the mur dered couple, was put under pie ice surveillance two davs after the crime, hut wa u m>t arreted until the a* ok :ol iowing. she was suspected chiefly by rea-o.'i of certain discrepancies between her statements *. the police as to the circumstances under V. inch the bodies ol dr. ami Mrs. Borden were found. The suspicion against her was ren der* 5 s -ongi i y a stun :acnt made to tin- ! oil ■ . . B nee, a clerk at I*. B. ."smith's drug store, to the client that Mi-s Borden had been in his st**rtwo days before the murders inquiring tor prussic a< i<i or hydrocyanic acid. She failed to secure either. The drug clerk made a partial identification ot Miss Borden, but later the ac curacy of his identification was denied. Miss Borden denied that she had bought or tried to buy either poison. Hydrocyanic acd leaves no outward race on the body, and it was the con jecture id' the physicians for (he pro.-e --tlon that this was the drug that hud been ns<M

See the clipping

The Superior Times · Superior, Wis.

A man named Beckham was searched by the marshal after claiming to have killed the Bordens, with police checking his background and papers. The report also recaps the original August 4 murders, describing the brutal wounds, lack of robbery motive, and Lizzie Borden's discovery of the bodies.

The Superior Times · 27 August 1892 · page 4

SAYS HE KILLED THE BORDENS

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Superior Times · Superior, Wis.

The report describes the brutal wounds to both victims and notes robbery was ruled out since nothing was missing. It details how suspicion fell on Lizzie Borden due to inconsistent statements and a drugstore clerk's claim she tried to buy prussic acid before the murders.

The Superior Times · 27 August 1892 · page 4

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The report describes ongoing testimony in the Borden case, noting Lizzie Borden was in the upper part of the house near her mother's room when Mr. Borden returned home. It highlights strained family relations and odd household habits as details reinforcing the prosecution's suspicions.

Los Angeles Herald · 28 August 1892 · page 1

Snspiclon Points Strongly Toward the Danelitcr'n Guilt. Fall River, Masa., Aug. 27. —The tes timony in the Borden murder trial, waß continued today before an increasing crowd. The only new fact developed beyond the time of Bridget Sullivan's going and coming, was that Miss Lizzie Borden wae in the upper part of the houee, near her mother's room, when Mr. Borden returned borne and entered. It has been proved be yond question that the Borden home life was not all that would be expected in a family whoee debts were paid, and whose wealth was more than half a million dollars.

See moreSee less

Warmed-over mut ton was frequently served; fruit was had only now and then. The daughter, who did not difle with ber father and mother, and who thus far has not been shown to have aeked about her mother's health after a dangerous aicknese; the girls, who, for the most part, lived in their rooms and said noth ing of their going and coming—all these things are being discussed and com mented on, aa giving strength to the proaecution's suspicions.-

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At the District Court preliminary hearing in Fall River, Bridget Sullivan continued testifying about the household's illness, Lizzie's movements, and the back door and screen door on the morning of the murders. District Attorney Knowlton questioned her about Lizzie's statements regarding locking the door and Mrs. Borden receiving a note.

New-York Tribune · 28 August 1892 · page 13

THE BORDEN MURDER TRIAL BRIDGET SULLIVAN CONTINUES HER TESTIMONY

LIZZIT. MORNING BORDEN ON THE THE MURDERS WERE COMMITTED. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 27~The District Court room was not so densely erowded this morning when Judge Blaisdell took his seat at 10 o'clock in the Borden murder trial, There wae delay of a few minutes while District-Attorney Knowlton was consulting with the attorney for the defence regarding the length of the trial, The examination of Bridget Sullivan was continued. The witness said fn substance: Somebody was sick at the house Tuesday night. Mrs. Borden said she and Mr. Borden were sick all night.

See moreSee less

They had been vomiting and looked sick. When Lizzie cams down she said she had Leen sick, but the witness did not notice that she looked unwell, The witness got wood and coal from the cellar. There was , wood-box in the kitchen. Miss Lizzie had been moving about eight or nine minutes, when she went upstalrs to her room. Mr. Borden used the sofa a great deal, but the witness never saw the girls using it. lad never seen Lizzie in the barn. The District Attorney asked the witness to tell them again about the words used by Lizzie, about going out, lock sg the door, and Mrs. Borden rece!v. ing a note, Objections were raised but were overruled. When witness came down stairs "she said, Miss Lizzie told her she heard her father groaning while she was In the back yard. When she came in she said the screen door was wide open. She recognized the laugh in the upper hallway, spoken of yesterday, as that of Miss Lizzie Borden. Since the tragedy ocenrred she never saw Lizzia Borden crying. The witness grew a ttle paler when she faced Mr. Adams to undergo her final erossexamination. She <add she had told her story on the Tuesday after the murder to two or three persons at the inquest, After the hearing yesterday the witness went to the Marshal’s office to walt for a carriage. While there Mr. Knowlton read a few words from a paper. she conld not remember what the words were] went home to supper, did not any Sop paper before the examination this morning. elr, Knowlton had the paper, but suid nothing. she wont out Wednesday night: had a key for the rear door, and returned alone about 10 o'clock. She never had any man from Fall River visiting her at the Borden Two or three months ago an out-of-town man house, The lamp was lt when'she returned { called upon her, There was no gas in the house, Wednesday night. Miss Lizzie said she was sick, but did not appear to have been sick. Witness then described what the family had to eat wWedne<day. ¥mma and Lizzie wen! away the Thurs dav before the murder, and Lizade came back the fol lowing Tuesday. “1 don’t think Lizzie left the house on the saturday after the murder,” sald the witness. “The day before they were slek, they hud fried fish for dinner, which were warmed over for supper. On Wednesday morning, 1 warmed over the mutton soup whliich we had the day before, It was the next day they complained of being sick. Thursday morning Mrs. Borden came down and asked me what I had for breakfast. I told her, and then she sald that Mr. Morse was In the house, but he guessed 1 had better warm over the mutton sotp, ind 1 did so and made some johnny-cakes. If we had fruit for breakfast that morning I don’t remember 11. Mr. Borden brought in a basketful of ripe pears

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Maid Bridget Sullivan testified at the inquest about the family's illness before the murders, Lizzie's claims of sickness, and the timeline of events on the day of the killings. She also described her own movements, the locked doors, and her cross-examination by defense counsel Adams.

New-York Tribune · 28 August 1892 · page 13

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The servant Bridget (called 'Maggie') describes the Borden household's meals and morning routine on the day of the murders, including breakfast, chores, and interactions with Lizzie and Mr. Morse. She recounts feeling ill from the mutton soup and the sequence of her tasks that led her to the barn and back.

New-York Tribune · 28 August 1892 · page 13

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

At the resumed hearing before Judge Blaisdell, servant Bridget Sullivan described the Borden family's illness the night before the murders and the household's daily routines. Under cross-examination she detailed her movements on the night before the killings and recalled Lizzie's odd remark about her mother receiving a note.

The Morning News · 28 August 1892 · page 1

FALL RIVER'S DARK CRIME.

A Servant Tel's of the Movements of Lizzie Borden. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 27.—The famous Borden trial was resumed this morulng. The oourt room was not so densely crowded when Judge Blaisdell took his test at 10 o'clock. The examination of Bridget Sullivan, the servant, was then oontinued. The witness teld: “Somebody wes siok et the bouse Tuesday night. Mrs. Borden said the and Mr. Borden were sick. They had been vomiting and looked sick When Miss Liz zie came down she said she bed beeu sick, but I did act notice thet she looked un well.

See moreSee less

“The witness said the family had mutton soup. She ata some and was al -o siok, vomiting. Since the tragedy occurred •he never saw Lizzie Borden crying. A groat deal of her testimony related to the daily habits of the Bordens. The witness grew a little paler when she faced Mr. Adams to undergo her final urnss-examtna tion. She said she had told her story on Tueeday after the murder to two or three persona at the Inquest. She went out Wednesday night; she had a key for the rear door and returned alone about 10 o’clock. She never had any man from Fall River visiting her at the Borden house. Two or three months ago an out-of-town man oalled upon her. A lamp was lit when the returned Wednesday night. Thers was no gas in tho house. Miss Lizzie said she was siok, but she did not appear to have been sick. The witness saw that Mr. Bordou had a white parcel lu his band when he entered the house the day before the murder. Miss Lizzie said very slowly to her father that her mother had gone out in response to a note received early In the morning. THE HOUSE HAD BEEN ROBBED.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

This piece reports that inquest testimony in the Borden case described how the victims' heads had been severed from their bodies and photographed, and draws a comparison to Inspector Byrnes' intimidating interrogation technique known as the 'third degree'. It recounts an anecdote of Byrnes staging a crime scene reconstruction to psychologically break a murder suspect.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Morning News · 28 August 1892 · page 4

A Famous Criminal Casa Recalled. The testimony taken in the Borden case at Fall River day before yesterday in the presence of Lizzie Borden, the acoused

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The report describes Inspector Byrnes recreating the murder scene in his office, complete with hatchet, lounge, saw, and trunk, to psychologically pressure a suspect into confessing. It claims the suspect broke down and confessed after being shown gruesome details, including photographs of the victims' skulls, in Lizzie Borden's presence.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Morning News · 28 August 1892 · page 4

And in this strain he went on to describe the whole scene of the murder, as he con ceived it to lie from the clews in bis posses slon, the suspect in the meantime growing more and more nervous. Finally the wretch broke down and confessed the crime. The telling in the presence of Lizzie Borden of the photographing of the skulls of the Bor dens. with the horrid details of cutting off the heads and cleaning them, was evidently dote for the purpose of shaking her nerves and influencing a confession, if she really oommitted the crime.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Bridget Sullivan, the Borden household servant, testified about events on the day of the murders, including family illness the night before and Lizzie's movements that morning. The report also details domestic habits of the Borden family, such as reused meals and distant relationships, which were seen as supporting the prosecution's case.

The Indianapolis Journal · 28 August 1892 · page 2

Fall River, Mass., Aug. 27,The testi mony in the llorden murder trial was con tinued to-day before an increasing crowd. The only new fact developed beyond , the timo of Bridget Sullivan's going and com ing was that Lizzie Iiorden was in the up per part of the house near her mother's room When Mr. Borden returned home and entered. It has been proved beyond ques tion that the Borden home life was not all that would bo expected in a family whose debts were paid, and whose wealth was more than half a million.

See moreSee less

Warmed-over mutton frequently served, fruit now and then, a daughter who did not diue with her father and mother, and who did not ask as to her mother's health after a dangerous sickness, girls who for the most part lived in their rooms, and said nothing of their going and coming all these things are be ing discussed and being commented on us giving strength to the prosecutor's side of the case. Bridget Sullivan's examination was con tinued to-day. She said in part: Some body was sick at the bouse on Tuesday night, Mrs. Borden said she and Mr. Bor den were sick all night. They had been, vomiting and looked sick. When Lizzie came down she said she had been sick, but she did not look unwell. Got wood and coal from the cellar, There was a wood box in the kitchen. Miss Lizzie had been moving about eight or nine minutes when she went up stairs to berroom. When wit ness came down stairs Miss Lizzie said she heard her father groaning while she was in the back yard. When slie came in she saw the screen-door wan wide open. She recognized a laugh in the upper hallway as that of Miss Lizzie Borden. Since the tragedy occurred she never saw Lizzie Bor den crying. This ended Mr. Knowlton's qnestioniug. . The witness grew a little paler when she faced Mr. Adams to undergo her final cross examination. She said he bad told her story on the Tuesday after the murder to two or three persona at the inquest. After the hearing yesterday the witness went to the marshal's office to wait for a carriage. While there Mr. Knowlton read a few w ords from a paper. She could not re member what the words were. Went borne to supper. Was not shown any paper be fore the examination this morning. Olr. Knowlton had the paper, but said nothing. She went out Wednesday night, had a key for the rear door, and returned alone about 10 o'clock. Never had any man from Fall River visiting her at the Borden bouse. Two or three months ago an out-of-town man called upon her. The lamp was lit when she returned Wednesday; there was no gas in the house. Miss Lizzie said she was sick, but did not appear to have been sick. Witness then described what the family had to eat on Wednesday. Emm and Lizzie went away the Thursday be fore the murder, and Lizzie came back tho following Tuesday. She did not think Lizzie left the house on the Saturday after tho murder.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Bridget Sullivan continued her testimony about the Borden household's meals, the family's illness the night before the murders, and Lizzie's behavior that morning. Cross-examination by defense attorney Adams probed her prior statements and a note Knowlton read to her at the marshal's office.

The Indianapolis Journal · 28 August 1892 · page 2

BRIDGET SULLIVAN'S STORY

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Bridget (Maggie) Sullivan describes the family's meals in the days before the murders, including warmed-over fish and mutton soup that made several household members ill. She also details the morning of the murders, including Lizzie's breakfast, Mr. Borden's pears, and her own task of washing windows.

The Indianapolis Journal · 28 August 1892 · page 2

It was the next day they complained of be ing sick. '"On Thursday,' j continued Bridget, "Mrs. Borden came down - and asked me what tho family had for break-, fast, 1 told her. and then she said that Mr. Morse was in the house, but she guessed I had better warm over the mutton soup, and 1 did so. and made, some Johnny cakes. If we had fruit for breakfast that morning 1 don't remember. Mr. Iiorden brought in a basket fall of ripe pears and put them on the table.

See moreSee less

They were not put on the table in the dining-room. He was in the habit of bringing in pears and putting them on the table, aud then throwing them under the barn. The only rooms which I had been in that morning before breakfast were the kitchen aud dining-room. After breakfast Mrs. Borden said to me, 'Maggie,

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The report describes inquest testimony from Fall River detailing the Borden family's strained home life and Lizzie Borden's movements on the morning of the murders. Bridget Sullivan testified about sickness in the household and her interactions with Lizzie before discovering Andrew Borden's body.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 28 August 1892 · page 2

THE BORDEN MURDER. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 27. -The testi mony in the Borden murder trial was con tinued today before increasing crowds of spectators. The only fact developed be yound the time of Bridget Sullivan's going and coming during the time the murder was committed was that Miss Lizzie Bor den was iu the upper part of the house, near her mother's room, when Mr. Borden returned home. So far, also, it has been proven beyond question that the Bordens' home life was not all that would be ex pected in a family whose wealth was esti mated at half a-million.

See moreSee less

It was also de veloped that Lizzie did not dine with her father and mother, aud thus far sho has not been shown to havo asked about her mother's health after her dangerous sick ness The daughters, tor the most part, lived in their rooms aud said nothing of their going and coming. All these things are being commented ou and discussed and are givingstreugth to the government's suspicions. Bridget Sullivan was examined. The witness said that everybody was sick at the house on Tuesday night. Mrs. Borden said that she and Mr. Borden were sick all night. They had been vomiting aud looked sick. When Lizzie came down she said that she had been sick, but the wit ness did not notice that she looked ill. Miss Lizzie had been moving about eight for nine mitiutes, wheu she went up stairs to her room. V lien the witness came down stairs and saw Mi3s Lizzie she told her that sho had heard her father groauing while she was in the back yard. When she came in she saw that the screen door was wido open. She recoguized a laugh in the upper liallway as that of Miss Lizzie Borden. Since the tragedy occurred sho had never seen Lizzie Boiden crying. This ended the direct examination. On the final cross-examination the witness said: "Emma and Lizzie went away on Thurs day before the murder, and Lizzie came back tho following Friday. I don't think" continued tho witness, "that Lizzie left the house on Saturday after tho murder. The day before they were sick we had fried fish for dinner aud warmed over for sup per. On Thursday morning Mrs. Borden come down and asked me what I had for breakfast. I told her, aud then she said that Mrs. Morse was in the house. Sho told me that I had better warm ovdr the mutton soup, and I did so, aud made some johnny cakes. Mr. Borden biought in a basketful of ripe pears and put them ou the table. He was in the habit of bring ing in pears and putting them on the table, and then throwing them under the barn. After breakfast Mrs. Borden told me to wash the windows. I am sure that Lizz.e had coffee -and cakes for breakTiist. The night before I ate some of tho mutton soup and the next morning 1 felt a little sick and went out iu tho back yard to vomit. It was at that time that Lizzie wa eating her breakfast. I do not know whether Mrs. Morse pass ed out while Lizzie was eatiug or not. I did not see Mrs. Morse or Mrs. Borden go out. Mrs. Borden was dusting the sitting room. When she told me .o wash the windows I went to tho barn to get a pail. Coming back from tho barn 1 saw Miss Lizzie at the screen door. She spoke to me about hookinc the door. I told her that she did not need to hook the door, as I would be in the yard." The witness went several times to the barn to get water for the windows. Alt the windows were washed ouf-ide before the witness went inside. hen she went in side to wash the windows all were shut. She had finished washing the windows nearest the hall when she heard some one at the front door. She could not say that the door bell raug. Mr. Borden passed through the hall into the sitting room, and thence into the dining room, where he sat dowu. The witness continued wahing the inside of the sitting room windows.and saw Miss Lizzie come from the hall and pass her father. Mr. Borden had a white parcel in his hands when he entered the hou-se. Lizzie satd very slowly to her lather that her mother had gone out in response to a note received early iu the morning. Mr. Borden's safe was kept in a room leading from his bedroom. The witness knew that the house had been entered and money and watches taken. Miss Lizzre. wa cleaning handkerchiefs She saw them on the table Miss Lfz.e asked her if she was going out, and, if s J. to be snre and fnsten the door, as htr mother had been called to see a sick friend. The de fense took unusual ; notice of ihi. .state ment. It was 10 o'clock when the witne-s went uptairs. She said that she couid not have been m her room more than thirty minutes when the city hall bell ransr. She was there about ken rainotrs when L'zzte shouted to her, Lizzie was standing neir the Mrreea door loading into the yard when the witness went down sUtirs, and was not -wringing her hands nor giving any other sign ot great grief. Tba witness weot down stairs shortly alt er the tragedy. An axe was found la a starch box back of the furnaceSue ceultf not say wnat kind of a dres Lfzzie had imi. fcoe saw no blood except that alrsady spoken of. Adjourned until Monday.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

Servant Bridget Sullivan describes the Borden household's illness the night before the murders, including meals and symptoms, and recounts seeing Lizzie near the screen door. She also notes Lizzie's apparent lack of distress and that she had not heard her ask after her sick mother.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 28 August 1892 · page 2

THE BORDEN MURDER.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The maid Bridget Sullivan recounts washing windows inside and outside the Borden house, Mr. Borden's return home, and Lizzie's statement that her mother had left after receiving a note. She also describes going upstairs, hearing Lizzie's cries, and the later discovery of an axe in a box behind the furnace.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 28 August 1892 · page 2

THE BORDEN MURDER.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Testimony in the Borden case reveals a strained household: cold leftovers served repeatedly, Lizzie dining apart from her parents, and secretive comings and goings among the household's women. The new detail is that Lizzie was upstairs near her mother's room when Andrew Borden returned home, and commentators say the evidence is strengthening suspicion against her.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 28 August 1892 · page 8

A DIVIDED FAMILY.

_ ... .... . „_ Fall River, Mass.. Aus. 27.— The testimony in the Borden murder trial was continued today before an increas iug crowd. The only new fact devel oped beyond the time of Bridget Sulli van's going and coming was that Miss Lizzie Borden was in the upper part of the house, near her mother's room, when Mr. Borden returned home and entered. It has been proved beyond question that the Borden home life was uot all that

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

At Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, maid Bridget Sullivan testified in detail about the movements of the household on the morning of the murders and described illness among the Bordens the day before and on the day of the killings. The prosecution's questioning suggested they were building a theory that Mr. and Mrs. Borden had been poisoned prior to being murdered, while the defense tried unsuccessfully to attribute the sickness to spoiled pears.

The Sun · 28 August 1892 · page 3

t Ft > mllr on the Dnjr nero lha Murder t FALL IttTn Aug 27 Bridget Sullivan was j on Ihn witness stand tho entire morning nt the hearing of Lizzie Borden fiho gave somo 1 Important testimony In regard to slcknoss In

See the clipping