Bridget Sullivan testified at the preliminary hearing about sickness in the Borden household before and on the day of the murders, and detailed the movements of family members that morning. The defense tried unsuccessfully to attribute the illness to eaten pears, while both sides awaited Professor Wood's chemical analysis to confirm or refute the poisoning theory.
The Sun · 28 August 1892 · page 3
THE BORDEN MURDER CASE
Monday 1 Prof Woods ovldenco contra dicts that ot Dr Dolan It must necessarily benollt fUlo Borden Furthermore tho establishment or the obliteration ot tho poisoning theory t depends on his report of Ills
At the preliminary hearing, District Attorney Knowlton questions maid Bridget Sullivan about illness in the Borden household the day before the murders, the kitchen fire, and Lizzie's ironing that morning. Lizzie Borden is described entering court scowling, with a handkerchief wrapped around her fingers, as testimony turns toward a disputed note allegedly received by Mrs. Borden.
The Sun · 28 August 1892 · page 3
THE BORDEN MURDER CASE
a barely perceptible nod In hor loft hand she I A carried 1 small white handkerchief I was I Wrapped tightly about the middle and Index i flftgors of hOI hand Judg Dlalsdel opened court bofore the prisoner was fully settled In her seat Dis trict Attorney Knowlton called Bridget Sulli van to the stand I Did you know If there was any sickness In L I the Borden family on Wednesday on Thurs I day the day of the murder he asKed
The report covers day two of testimony in the Borden murder trial, focusing on Bridget Sullivan's account of household illness and Lizzie's movements on the day of the murders. It also highlights details about the family's strained home life despite their wealth, seen as bolstering the prosecution's case.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 28 August 1892 · page 7
BRIDGET ON THE RACK
The Mysterious Cases of Sickness. Bridget Sullivan was examined. Wit ness said somebody was sick at the house Tuesday night Mrs. Borden said she and Mr. Borden were sick all night They had been vomiting and looked sick. When Lizzie came down she said she bad been sick, but Bridget did not notice that she looked poorly. Bridget got wood and coal from the cellar. There was a woodbox in the kitchen. Miss Lizzie had been moving about eight or nine minutes when she went upstairs to her room. When witness came down stairs Miss Lizzie said she told ber she heard her father groaning while she was in the back yard. When she came in she said the
Bridget Sullivan testifies at the inquest about the family's illness before the murders, describing the food eaten and her household duties that morning. She also recounts Lizzie's behavior the day of the murders, including her claim of hearing her father groan and finding the screen door open.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 28 August 1892 · page 7
ON THE DAY OF THE DOUBLE MURDER
her room. When witness came down stairs Miss Lizzie said she told ber she heard her father groaning while she was in the back yard. When she came in she said the screen door was wide open. She recog nized a laugh in the upper hallway as that of Miss Lizzie Boruen. Since the tragedy occurred she never saw Lizzie Borden crying. This ended Mr. Knowlton's questioning. The witness grow a little paler when she
Bridget Sullivan describes the household routine on the morning of the murders, including washing windows, breakfast, and interactions with Lizzie and Mrs. Borden. She recounts hearing someone at the door and the sequence of her chores leading up to the discovery of the crime.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 28 August 1892 · page 7
ON THE DAY OF THE DOUBLE MURDER
A to get water for the windows. All of the windows outside were washed before wit ness vient inside. The dipper she used was in the sink in the kitchen. When she went inside to wash the windows all of the win dows outside were shut. Witness did not see Mr. Borden leaving the house. She went into the kitchen for the dipper after she had used the brush on all the windons. She did not see Lizzie at that lime. She had finished washing the windows nearest the hall when she heard someone at the lront door.
See moreSee less
She could not say that the door bell rang. When Mrs. Borden was in the house she nnsneredthe bell. When Mr. Borden was in he always answered it. When witness went to wash the inside ot the windows she could not say that Miss Lizzie was ironing
At the preliminary hearing in Fall River, testimony revealed Lizzie Borden was upstairs near her mother's room when her father returned home. Witnesses also described the family's frugal daily life, including reheated food, despite their considerable wealth.
The Salt Lake Herald · 28 August 1892 · page 1
> U BOBS The party arrived in Glasgow on it appears have heretofore suffered from 1 Thursday intending to sail for America J discrimination I j t o j was in the upperpart of the bouse near her mothers room when Mr Borden re turned home and entered It was proven beyond question that Bordens home life was not at all what would be expected in a family whose debts were paid and whose wealth was more than half a million Warmed over fruit was fre quently served as fruit Now and then the daughter who did not dine with her father and mother and who thus far has not been seen asked about her mothers health after her dangerous sickness The girls who for the most part lived in their rooms said nothing of their going and coming All these things are being dis cussed and commented on as giving strength to the governments suspicion The Swimming Cbambionshlp PHILADELPHIA Aug 2iTbe twelfth annual meeting of the Amateur Athletic
The examination of servant Bridget Sullivan resumed before Judge Blaisdell in Fall River, with testimony about the Borden family's illness the night before the murders and household habits. Under cross-examination by Mr. Adams, she described her movements the night before, the lack of gas lighting, and a white parcel Mr. Borden carried home the day before the killings.
Richmond Dispatch · 28 August 1892 · page 3
BORDEN MURDER CASE.
Witness said somebody was siek at the house ‘lueszday might. Mrs. Borden sad she and Mr. Borden were sick, [hey had been vomiting and looked sick. When Lizzie came down she eaid she had been sick, but 1 did not notice that she looked unowell. Witness said the family bad mutton soup. She ate some and was also gick, vomiting, Since the tragedy oc curred she wo | pever seen Lizzie Borden crving. A great deal of the testimony re. lated to the daily habits of the Bordens, Witness grew a little paler when she faced Mr.
See moreSee less
Adams to undergo her final ecross-cxamination, She said she had told her story on the inesday after the murder to two or three persons at the inquest, She went out Wednesday night, had a key for the rear door, and returned alone about 10 o'clock. Never bad any man from Fall River visiting her at the Borden house, Two or three months ago an out-of-town man called upon her, The lamp was ht when she returned Wednesday night, I here was no gas in the house, Miss Lizzie said she was sick, but did not appear to have been sick, The witness said Mr. Borden had a white parcel in lus hand when he culered the house the day before the murder. Miss
Servant Bridget Sullivan described household details, the family's illness after eating mutton soup, and the prior burglary of the house and barn. She recounted Lizzie's composed demeanor, the note supposedly summoning Mrs. Borden, and the discovery of the axes in a starch box.
Richmond Dispatch · 28 August 1892 · page 3
BORDEN MURDER CASE.
Lizzie came down she eaid she had been sick, but 1 did not notice that she looked unowell. Witness said the family bad mutton soup. She ate some and was also gick, vomiting, Since the tragedy oc curred she wo | pever seen Lizzie Borden crving. A great deal of the testimony re. lated to the daily habits of the Bordens, Witness grew a little paler when she faced Mr. Adams to undergo her final ecross-cxamination, She said she had told her story on the inesday after the murder to two or three persons at the inquest, She went out Wednesday night, had a key for the rear door, and returned alone about 10 o'clock.
See moreSee less
Never bad any man from Fall River visiting her at the Borden house, Two or three months ago an out-of-town man called upon her, The lamp was ht when she returned Wednesday night, I here was no gas in the house, Miss Lizzie said she was sick, but did not appear to have been sick, The witness said Mr. Borden had a white parcel in lus hand when he culered the house the day before the murder. Miss
Bridget Sullivan's testimony continues at the Borden murder examination, describing the family's illness before the murders, Lizzie's demeanor, and household details on the days surrounding the killings. She recounts specifics about meals, Lizzie's claim of hearing her father groaning, and her own movements the night before the murder.
The Times · 28 August 1892 · page 1
v FALL RIVER TRAGEDY, Continuation of the Trial—Lizzle Porden's suspicious Behavior, Suspicious Behavior, Farr River, Mass, August 27.—Another large audience was present at the Borden murder examination this morning, Bridget | Sullivan resumed her testimony. She said Mrs. Borden said that she and Mr. Borden were sick Tuesday night. They had been vomiting and looked sick. When Lizzie Borden came down stairs the next morning sLe said she had been sick during the night, but witness said sbe did not notice that Lizzie looked unwell. Witness had never goon Lizzie in the barn, When the witness came down stairs after Lizzie bad discovered her father was mur dered, Lizzie said that she heard her father
The maid Bridget Sullivan recounts her movements the morning of the killings, including washing windows, seeing Lizzie ironing, and Mr. Borden returning home with a parcel. She also describes Lizzie's claim that her mother had gone out after receiving a note, and her own trips to fetch Dr. Bowen and neighbors after the bodies were found.
The Times · 28 August 1892 · page 1
{runing while she was in the back yard. Vhen Lizzie came in the screen door was wide open, Since the murder witness had pever seen Lizzie crying. Witness went out | Wednesday night; had a key for the rear door and returned alone about 10 o'cloek; never had any man from Fall River visiting ber at the Borden house; two or three mouths ago an out-of-town man called on her. The lamp was lit when she returned Wednesday night. There was no gas in the house. Miss Lizzie said she was sick, but did not appear so.
See moreSee less
Witness then described what the family bad to eat on Wednesday. Imma and Lizzie went away Thursday. I don’t think Lizzie left the house on Saturday sfternoon after the murder, The only rooms which witness had been in that morning before breakfast were the kitchen and dining. room. After the breakfast Mrs. Borden told me to wash the windows outside and inside. Tuat morning I am sure Lizzie had coffee and cakes for breakfast. saw her, but | don’t know whether or pot lizzie gaw Mr. Morse. The night before i ate some of the mutton soup and the pext morning 1 felt a little sick and went out in the yard ta vomit. It was at that
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
Testimony at the Fall River hearing revealed Lizzie Borden was near her mother's room when her father returned home that morning. Reports also detailed strained family relations, including modest meals despite wealth and Lizzie's isolation from her parents.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 28 August 1892 · page 2
The Corden Murder Case. FALL RIVEM, Aug. 27.—The testimony in the Bordeu murder trial continued today before an increasing crowd. The only new fact developed beyond the time of going and coming was that Miss Lizzie Borden was in the upper part of the house near her mother's room when Mr. Borden returned homo and entered. It has been proved beyond question that the Borden home life wan not all that would be ex pected in a family whose debts were paid, and whose wealth is more than $500,000. Warmed-over mutton was frequently served, and fruit now and then.
See moreSee less
The daughter did not dine with the father and mother, and thus far has not been shown to have asked about the mother's health after a dangerout sick ness. The girl for the most part lived in her rooms, said nothing of their going and coming. All these things are being dis cussed and commented on as giving strength to the government's suspicions.
During the Borden preliminary hearing, defense investigators searched Bridget Sullivan's record in Newport but found nothing damaging beyond rumors of a temper. Her former employers describe her as truthful and devoted, strengthening the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden.
Morning Journal and Courier · 29 August 1892 · page 3
ABOVE REPROACH. It isbelleved here that Miss Sullivan's character is above reproach. A search In' to her career while in this city shows that Miss Sullivan Is a very good and truthful woman. Her past employers sieek verv kindly of her and say she was always a de voted church member. Her unshaken tes timony has done much to establish the strength of the government's case. It is generally allowed that the government has a strong case. Enough evidenoe has now been introduced to warrant binding over Miss Lizzie Borden until the next grand j ury. The bearing has by no means ended,
The Borden preliminary hearing resumed with neighbor Mrs. Churchill and Alice D. Russell testifying they saw no blood on Lizzie Borden's clothing or hands after the murder. Lucy Collett testified she was in the yard near the Borden house for over two hours that day and saw no one enter or leave.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 29 August 1892 · page 1
The Borden Murder Case. Fall River, Mass, August 29. The Borden hearing was resumed to-day. Mrs Churchill, a neighbor, testified that when she went into the Borden house
At the resumed Fall River hearing, detectives for Lizzie Borden's defense investigated servant Bridget Sullivan's past employment in Newport to test her reliability as a witness, finding only rumors of a hot temper but otherwise a reputation for truthfulness and church devotion. The report notes her testimony has strengthened the state's case and speculates Lizzie Borden will take the stand this week for a multi-day examination.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 29 August 1892 · page 2
HAS A GOOD CHARACTER
Fall, River, Mass., Aug. 29. The hearing in the Borden case was resumed at 10:45 this morning. The defence has been actively engaged in Newport learn ing something regarding the career of Bridget Sullivan, the servant, whose evi dence seems to be so damaging to Lizzie Borden. Detective Richards and Attorney Phillips looked up her record there, but found nothing of importance except a ru mor that she has a very hot temper. She worked in two places besides the Perry House, as she stated on the witness stand Saturday. ' The purpose of inquiry is to determine how reliable her evidence is, also to learn if she could become so much provoked that she would quarrel seriously with Mr.
See moreSee less
and Mrs. Borden. It is believed here that juiss bullivan s character is above reproach. A search into her career while in this city shows that Miss Sullivan is a very truthful woman. Her past employers speak very good of her, and say she was always a devoted church member. Her unsh aken testimony has done much to establish the strength of the case of the State. The accused will be put on the stand this week and it is believed that her ex amination will consume fully three days. It is hoped that she may be able to greatly aid her case, for although many have been forced to believe ner guilty, they still have a suspicion that possibly she is innocent, and as a consequence or this wavering belief there is really no ani mosity against her, but rather a fueling of sorrow nnd a hope that the authorities may prove themselves asses in the matter. Marshal Jtlilliard has repeated his in structions to the matrons in charge of Miss Borden, cautioning them to obey the police rules. Some reporters have been admitted to Lizzie's cell since her imprisonment here, and other breaches of jai 1, prison and home discipline have been recorded. Mr. Morse, Jliss tmm.1 Horden, Rev. Michael Burnham of Springfield, her father's former pastor, were among her callers during the Sabbath. An official who stands high in the gov ernment's counsels was asked by a reporter his opinion concerning the guilt or inno cence of Lizzie Borden. He said in substance: "I have no hesitation in saying that I believe her guilty of the crime. Being pressed for the ground on which his judgement is based, the official said it was largely founded on the evidence of Bridget Sullivan at the examination Sat urday, although developments at the pri vate examination which resulted in Lizzie's nrrest were strongly condemna tory.
The report states Lizzie Borden is expected to testify for several days this week, with public opinion still wavering between belief in her guilt and hope for her innocence. An unnamed high-ranking official tells a reporter he is convinced of her guilt, citing Bridget Sullivan's testimony and evidence from the private examination that led to her arrest.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 29 August 1892 · page 2
At the Fall River hearing, Mrs. A. B. Churchill testified that Lizzie called her over saying 'somebody has killed father,' and described Lizzie's agitated state and uncertainty about her stepmother's whereabouts. Defense attorney Jennings cross-examined her closely about Lizzie's demeanor at the scene.
Evening Journal · 29 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MORE NEW EVIDENCE.
Sensational Testimony in the Fall River Case.
See moreSee less
TRIED TO BUY PRUSSIC ACID.
Two Witnesses Describe the Scene at the House After the Murder. The Prisoner Was Much Agitated—Details of the Hearing.
[By Telegraph to the Evening Journal.
FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug 29.—The hearing in the Borden case was continued today. Lizzie passed a fairly restful night and at an early hour this morning was visited by her sister, Emma, who stayed with her till the hour for court arrived.
Mrs. A. B. Churchill was the first witness called. She lives next to the Bordens on the north side of the street and she remembered well the first day of the tragedy. She first remembered of her attention being called to the affair when she saw Bridget going for Dr. Bowen. About the same time she saw Lizzie standing against the side of the door, apparently distressed about something.
"Somebody Has Killed Father."
"I opened the window and asked her what was the matter and she said, 'Oh, Mrs. Churchill, do come over, somebody has killed father.'
"I went over and asked her where her father was and she replied, 'in the sitting room.' I asked her where she was when it happened and she said she was in the barn looking for something for sinkers."
The time, as near as witness could recollect, was about 11 o'clock. Witness asked Lizzie where her mother was, and she said her mother had a note to go somewhere, but she did not know but that she had been killed too She wished somebody would go and try to find her, for she thought she had come in since. She said her father must have had an enemy, for everyone in the house had been sick.
Lizzie Was Much Agitated.
Mr. Jennings subjected Mrs. Churchill to a severe cross-examination. Witness said that when she got inside the house Lizzie was so much agitated that she fanned her, fearing that she would faint.
Witness could not remember that there was the least sign of blood on Lizzie's dress, hands or face at the time she first saw her; her hair was "done up" and appeared not to be disarranged in the slightest and there was no indication by anything in her appearance that any changes had been made since she arose.
Sensational Testimony.
Miss Alice M. Russell, the next witness said she had known Lizzie about eleven years. She thought on the day of the murder that it was 11.15 o'clock when she first heard of the affair. She went to the house and found Lizzie leaning against the door. Witness could not remember how Lizzie was dressed but did remember Lizzie telling her in answer to a question that she went into the barn to get a piece of iron or tin to fix a window with. This testimony created a sensation.
Witness could not tell which window she wanted to fix. Witness was a frequent visitor at the Borden house and always was received in the guest room. Sometimes she would go three times a week, sometimes two or three weeks would elapse before she would go, and she never remembered seeing Mrs. Borden in that room. It was quite evident that the evidence of Miss Russell had made considerable impression on the defense, and when she had finished her direct examination Lizzie's counsel put their heads together and allowed the witness to sit down for a moment. On cross-examination Miss Russell said she bathed Lizzie's face after she went in and saw no signs of blood on it, nor did she see any on any of her clothing. She could see no signs of any undue exertion about Lizzie, nor was she panting as though exhausted. Witness was positive that Lizzie did not go up stairs before the officers, because she remembered the officers asking her questions.
She remembered the officers going up to Lizzie's room and finding it locked; of their pulling the door open, and of her questioning to be allowed to look in first because she did not know what condition it was in; she looked in and finding it all right she let them in.
The Yard Was Watched.
Miss Lucy Collet testified that she was stopping at Dr. Chagon's house on the day of the murder from 11.10 until 12 o'clock noon; and sat on the piazza all the time because from where she sat she said she could see all the yard of the Bordens. During the time she was there, she saw no one passing in the yard. On cross-examination witness admitted that she was where she could not see the whole of the Borden yard, but she was sure that if anybody had entered the yard she would have heard them. A recess was then taken.
Tried to Buy Prussic Acid.
Bulletin, 3.5.—Eli Bence, a drug clerk, has testified that Lizzie Borden called at his store three times the day before the murder for prussic acid and was refused.
Mrs. Churchill and Alice Russell testify they saw no blood or signs of disarray on Lizzie Borden shortly after the murders, with Russell recounting Lizzie's explanation about fetching iron to fix a window. Another witness, Lucy Collet, testifies she watched the Borden yard during the relevant time and saw no one pass through it.
it happened and site said she was in the ^ ^ for M , lnf . t , ltllK for „inkers." -pj,,, j j me, as near as witness could j recollect, was about 11 o'clock. Witness , asked Lizzie where her mother woe. and "a " 1 mother had a note to go somewhere, hut she did not km)W thttt „p,, i, m i i„. en killed too sh „ w , sllwl »„mebody would go and try t o Hud her, for she t bought she had come in since.
See moreSee less
She said her father must have had an enomy, for overyona in the I house Inul been sick. I Linie W Mllf-ll Atiilntcil. Mr. Jennings suhjccteil Mrs. ChnrchQl to a severe cross examination. Witness I "> at when she got inside the house . IJmuwas so much agitated that «''» her. fearing that ehe would i fal,, ' Wituesi eottlil not remoratter that (hero was tho least sign of blood on Lizzie's dress, liunds or face at the time she first saw her; her hailwas "done up" and appeared not to lie disarranged in the „lightest aud then» was no indication by anything in her ap pearance that any changes hod been Iliade hinre site arose. Nciisat louai Tc»tlni»ny. Miss Alice M. Bussell, the next wit ness said she had known Lizzie about eleven years. She thought on the day of tlie murder that It was 11.Iff o'clock when site first heard of tho affair. She went to the house and found Lizzie leaning against the door. Wit ness could not remember how Linda was dressed but did remember Lizzie telling her lit answer to a question that die went Into tho barn to get a piece of iron or tin to fix a window with. This testimony created a sensation, Willies» could not tell which window she wanted to fix. Witness was a fro quent visitor at the Borden house and always was received lu the guest room, Sometimes »he would go three times a week, HmnetimeN two or three weeks would elapse before she would go, and »'>" never remembered seeing Mrs. Borden in that room. It was quite evident that the 1 « vldence of Miss Bussell had made con «iderable impression on the defense, and ■ when she had flnished her direct examl a nation Lizzie s counsel put their heads together and allowed tho witness to sit down for a moment On cross-examlna lion Mias Bussell said she bathed Lizzie's face after she went in and saw no signa of blood on It, nor did she see any on any of her clothing. Khe could see no sign» of any undue exertion about Lizzie, nor was she panting as though exhausted. Witness was posi t vo that Lizzie did not go up stairs be fore the officers, because she remembered the officers asking her questions, She remembered the officers going up of to Lizzie's room and finding it locked, of their pulling the door open and of her questioning to be allowed to look in first because she did not know what condi t ion it was in; she looked in and finding it all right she let them in. The Yard w*% Watehed. M l.s Lucy Collet testified that .h. was ; ..._, ... „ ; * , '>l l i""g-at r - < hagon s «lay of the murder from 11.10 until 1J o'clock noon ; aud sat on the piazza all the time because front where site sat she said she could see all the yard of tho inBordens. During tho time shew.» there, she saw no one passing In the On cross examination witness yard, be admitted that sits was whore she could bo not see tho whole of the Borden yard, but she was sure that If anybody had entered the yard she would have heard them. A recess was then taken, 1 1 1) ll tn Huy I'ruMlc Acid. Bulletin, S'8.—KB Bence, a drug clerk, lia» testified that Lizzie Borden called at his »tore three times Ihh day before the murder for prussic acid and was refused. Fatal Fight for a Ham-tag Partner, [By Telegraph to the Evening Journal.! deHauoutos La Aug. 29 —la a fight ..rd.v ni^ht at Allen Brothers' mill at unlay mgt.i at ln »d*uce there Manrke MB ir, Moo a W aud John Carter wetvaiiiea. xn u l'. r, 'T„n h,>ll M ""' r _ ' , ,. rlur , j I.Ja Pllkington. whom Bob tarter elatmett my I " nm P artner -__ I j Fold Weather In Winnipeg. in ! IBy Telegraph to the Eroalng Journal.] , . .„„—.i i 39.—The Winnipeo mhu. Ang weather here has been constantly grow
A drug clerk named Eli Bence testified that Lizzie Borden came to his store three times the day before the murders asking to purchase prussic acid, and was refused each time. The testimony was given during ongoing inquest proceedings.
Evening Journal · 29 August 1892 · page 1
TRY TO BUY PRUSSIC ACID
1 1 1) ll tn Huy I'ruMlc Acid. Bulletin, S'8.—KB Bence, a drug clerk, lia» testified that Lizzie Borden called at his »tore three times Ihh day before the murder for prussic acid and was refused. Fatal Fight for a Ham-tag Partner, [By Telegraph to the Evening Journal.! deHauoutos La Aug. 29 —la a fight ..rd.v ni^ht at Allen Brothers' mill at unlay mgt.i at ln »d*uce there Manrke MB ir, Moo a W aud John Carter wetvaiiiea. xn u l'. r, 'T„n h,>ll M ""' r _ ' , ,. rlur , j I.Ja Pllkington. whom Bob tarter elatmett my I " nm P artner -__ I j Fold Weather In Winnipeg. , . .„„—.i i
The report describes cross-examination of servant Bridget Sullivan by defense lawyer Adams, revealing she withheld some details about Lizzie Borden's actions on the murder day. It focuses on a discrepancy over whether District Attorney Knowlton read six words or six questions-and-answers from her inquest testimony.
Evening Journal · 29 August 1892 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN'S FATE
".Six," said Bridget. Tho true answer is six questions and an swers, and not six words. The portion of 1 lur her evidence that the district attorney read to Bridget Sullivan is sufficient, says the ! prosecution, to faeteu on Ltzxio Borden the | murder of lier father. Lawyer Adams knew ,U Ü-1. that the Servant girl knew more than she told and lie struggled to find out what it hu was. Time and again he questioned her about Lizzie's actions and conversation. Again and again be fired questions at Brid get that seemed about, to bring out the de sired information. But ho Worked without result. Bridget Sullivan left the stand with out making known tho most important evi dence against Lizzie Burden. TIioh«' Six Oii. *lioin.
The report describes defense lawyer Adams's attempts to cross-examine servant Bridget Sullivan, who broke down at the inquest over six questions Knowlton had posed. It details questions Adams failed to ask, such as whether Bridget saw a weapon or blood on Lizzie Borden's hands.
Evening Journal · 29 August 1892 · page 2
SIX IMPORTANT QUERIES UNASKED.
dence against Lizzie Burden. TIioh«' Six Oii. *lioin. j At the inquest Bridget Sullivan hroko j down. Tins occurred when she was forced nt to answer I ho six questions which District I Attorney Knowlton did not ask lier yester day and which Mr. Adams strove iu vain to have her toll. "Where was Lizzie Borden standing when you came down stairs after hearing her scream(" asked Mr. Adams, "In the doorway of tho dining room," said Bridget Lawyer Adams might have followed that iu , , , , , .
See moreSee less
, , „ question by another asking whether or not at any time, and especially at that time Bridget Sullivan saw Lizzie Borden with , an instrument capable of inflicting the L Wounds on Mr. and Mrs. Borden in her , T hand. And he might have asked her if she saw Lizzie trying to conceal such an instill ment iu the folds of her dress or under a ; ti sofa or any other piece of furniture in ; c either the dining room or silting room or liny place else. He might have a.skeü also if she saw auy |
A newspaper analysis examines why defense attorney Adams did not ask Bridget Sullivan about family tensions between Lizzie and her parents during cross-examination. A legal source argues such questions would have been permissible under evidence law, suggesting Adams' omission was strategic rather than accidental.
Evening Journal · 29 August 1892 · page 2
SIX IMPORTANT QUERIES UNASKED.
in regard to the family relations of the Bor j dens or in regard to any conversât Ion al I leged lo have taken place between Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden iu reference to ! thé reported difference between herself, her father and stepmother. ; A Lawyer*. Theory, It might be argued that Lawyer Adams couhl not ask, under the laws of evidence, auy of those questions. But tho laws of evidence in this bearing aro lax, and a re portr was tola by a lawyer that even under a rigid observance of the laws of evi deuce Mr.
See moreSee less
Adams could have asked fliese questions. Tho lawyer whom the reporter questioned in regard to this said; j "Of course it i» alleged that the cross ex amination should not bring out any new facts save in greater detail of those brought out in the direct examination. Granted that to bo true. District Attorney Knuwl ton asked Bridget whete Lizzie Borden was standing when the witness got down stairs, i after the murder of Mr. Borden, in response to tho prisoner's «ill. Bridget answered
The report describes the ongoing preliminary hearing in Fall River, where Bridget Sullivan's testimony has strengthened the case against Lizzie Borden, enough to warrant binding her over for the grand jury. The defense is investigating Sullivan's background and plans to call expert witnesses to challenge the prosecution's blood evidence testimony.
The Indianapolis Journal · 29 August 1892 · page 1
LOOKS BAD FOR LIZZIE.
Fall River, Mass., Aug. 23L The hear ing in the Borden ease will be resumed at 10.45 o'clock to-morrow morning. The de fense has been actively engaged in learn ing something regarding Bridget Sullivan's career. The purpose, of the Inquiry is to learn how reliable her evidence is. also to learn if eha would become so much pro voked that she woujd quarrel seriously with Mr. and Mrs. Borden. It is believed here that ber oharaoter is above reproach. A search into ber career, while in this city, shows that Miss Sullivan is a very truth fnl woman.
See moreSee less
Her former employers s pea re very kindly of her. Her unshaken testi mony has done much to establish the .strength of tho caso against Lizzie Borden. Enough evidence has been introduced to warrant binding over Mitts Lizzie until the next grand jury. Tho hearing has by no means ended, however, as Professor Wood is yet to heard on the character of the blood spots on the clothing, ax and other articles taken from the Borden house.
This report from the Borden hearing describes testimony revealing strained family relations in the Borden household, including bad food, estranged living arrangements, and Lizzie's lack of concern for her ailing stepmother. Bridget Sullivan's testimony also covers the morning of the murder, including illness in the house, Lizzie's demeanor, and the discovery of her father's body.
The Indianapolis Journal · 29 August 1892 · page 3
From (he Second Edition ojlh Sunday Journal. The llorden Murder Case Fall Rivkr. Mass., Aug. 27. The testi mony in tbe Borden nfUnler trial was con tinued to-day before an increasing crowd, The only now faot developed beyond the time of Bridget Sullivan's going and com ing was that Lizzie Borden was in tho up per part of the house near her mother's room when Mr. Borden returned home and entered. It has been proved beyond ques tion that the Borden home life was not all that would bo expected in a family wnose debts were paid, and whose wealth was more than half a million.
See moreSee less
Warmed-over mutton frequently served, fruit now and then, a daughter who did not dine with her father and mother, and who did not ask as to her mother's health afterS dangerous sickness, girls who for the most part lived in their rooms, and said nothing of their going and coming all these things are be ing discussed and being commented on as giving strength to the prosecutor's side of the case. Bridget Sullivan's examination Was con-' tinned to-day. She said in part: Some body was sick at the bouse ou Tuesday night. Mrs. Borden said she and Mr. Bor den were siek all night They " bad been vomiting and looked sick. When Lizzie came down she said she had been sick, bnt she did not look unwell. Got wood and coal from the cellar. There was a wood box in the kitchen. Miss Lizzie had been moving abont eightor nine minutes when she went up stairs to her room. When wit tuees came down stairs Miss Lizzie eaid she heard her father groaning-while she was in the back yard. When she came in she saw the screen-door was wide open. She recognized a laugh in the upper hallway as that of Mi6s Lizzie Borden. Since 'the tragedy occurred she never saw Lizzie Bor den erring. This ended Mr. Kuowlton's questioning. Counsel for defense was stirred up last night over a recent publication to the efTeet ' that Matron Regau had berd a quarrel be tween the Borden sisters. Attorney Jen nings, at the earnest solicitation of tbe re porter who wrote the article, seconded by a number of prominent citizens, drew up a form of affidavit denying that she made the statements attributed to her, to be sub mitted to Mrs. Regan for her signature. She refused to sign it unless the marshal said so, and the marshal positively refused to allow the matron to do anything of tlfo kind unless she was placed on tho witness
Bridget Sullivan's examination at the inquest continued, describing the sickness in the Borden household, Lizzie's movements, and the open screen door on the morning of the murders. Separately, defense attorney Jennings sought an affidavit from Matron Regan denying she had reported hearing a quarrel between the Borden sisters, but she refused to sign without the marshal's approval.
The Indianapolis Journal · 29 August 1892 · page 3
German-language report notes Lizzie Borden, arrested as the suspected murderer of her parents, has reportedly willed her property to her attorney to fund her defense, with sister Emma also pledging support. It also describes a letter published by defense lawyer Jennings describing an encounter with a blood-spattered stranger near Fall River at the time of the murders.
Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 29 August 1892 · page 6
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A witness describes encountering a stranger with blood on his boots who claimed to be a farm worker, delivered during the resumed Borden inquest. Dr. Dolan then gave graphic testimony about the skull wounds of both victims, visibly disturbing Lizzie Borden and her sister Emma in the courtroom.
Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 29 August 1892 · page 6
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
At the Fall River inquest, maid Bridget Sullivan testified that Mrs. Borden and her husband had been unwell and vomited during the night before the murders, and that Lizzie also said she felt unwell. Sullivan described the household's breakfast routine, chores, and Lizzie's movements that morning in detail.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 29 August 1892 · page 4
Der Doppelmord in Fall-River
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The maid Bridget Sullivan testifies about the morning of August 4, describing her chores, Mr. Borden's arrival home, and Lizzie's activities including ironing. She also mentions past burglaries at the house and discusses the timing of events before going upstairs.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 29 August 1892 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The maid Bridget Sullivan recounts going upstairs, hearing the clock strike eleven, and then hearing Lizzie's cries that their father was dead. She describes being sent for the doctor and notes Lizzie showed no visible signs of distress, while also mentioning that axes were found soon after the murder in a starch box.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 29 August 1892 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report covers Saturday's session of the Borden case hearing, focused on the cross-examination of servant Bridget Sullivan, which concluded that day. It notes her testimony was central to the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden, though the defense calls it weak while the state claims it implicates Lizzie in inconsistencies.
The Portland Daily Press · 29 August 1892 · page 1
BRIDGET SULLIVAN'S STORY.
XnUllUgtl/U) A/UHV1VJ — Itiver and Detective McHenry. What went on in the Borden house that fatal Thursday forenoon and where Lizzie Borden spent the time in the house are the points on which the prose cution must inform itself to support its allegations, and Bridget Sullivan is the only person they have to depend on to give information regarding them. That is what made her testimony of value. By Lizzie’s counsel, Bridget’s Sulli van’s testimony is held to be weak, ad ding little that is new to the case. The prosecution, on the other hand, claim that the servant’s testimony shows that either Lizzie or Bridget Sullivan lied, and that Bridget’s story points to Lizzie as the untruthful one regarding what happened in the Borden house on the day of the murder.
See moreSee less
Attorney. General Pillsbury’s questions to the girl were so framed that it is believed much of what she knows was not drawn out, especially as to the domestic troubles in the Bor den household. In his cross-examination today Colonel Adams asked Miss Sulli'van many ques tions as to her life in this country, where she had worked, etc. He also asked whether she had men visitors at the Borden house. To this the girl gave a negative answer. Another point made by the defence was that to Bridget Sullivan at least Miss Borden said nothing about going to the barn to get lead to make sinkers when the murder was committed. She simply said that she was out in the yard. Light was thrown on the home life of the Bordens by the servant’s testimony as to the way the family lived. In the daily bill of fare, warmed over soup and like dishes had a prominent place even when visitors like Uncle John Y. Morse wore present.
At the inquest, Bridget Sullivan's testimony about the morning of the murders is examined by both prosecution and defense, with disagreement over its significance. The defense challenges her account of Lizzie's whereabouts, while details of the family's domestic life and diet are also revealed.
The Portland Daily Press · 29 August 1892 · page 1
A newspaper bulletin list mentions 'Dark for Lizzie Borden' among other brief headlines of the day, including a mine disaster and various deaths. No further detail on the Borden case is given in this item.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 29 August 1892 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes the ongoing preliminary hearing in Fall River, noting that Bridget Sullivan's unshaken testimony has strengthened the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden, enough to warrant binding her over to the grand jury. The defense is preparing to challenge Dr. Dolan's medical testimony about blood spots on evidence, with Dr. Ely expected to testify as an expert witness for the defense.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 29 August 1892 · page 7
HAS A STRONG CASE.
Forger Who Had Out witted One Detective. Fall River, Mass. Aug. 28.— The hearing in the Borden ease will be re sumed at 19:45 tomorrow morning. The defense has been actively engaged in Newport today learning something re garding Bridget Sullivan's career in that city. Her past employers speak very highly of her and say she was a devoted chui>ch member. Her unshakeu testimony has done much to establish the strength of the case of the government. It seems to be generally allowed that the government has a strong case. Enough evidence has now been introduced to warrant binding over Miss Lizzie until the grand jury.
See moreSee less
The hearing has been by no ineaus ended, as Prof. Wood is yet to be heard on the character of blood spots on the linen, ax aud other articles taken from the Borden house. The defense now proposes to call witnesses who will show that much of Dr. Dolaifs testimony is unreliable. Ex-Medical Examiner D.
A government official states he believes Lizzie Borden is guilty, basing this largely on Bridget Sullivan's testimony and the timeline of her movements the morning of the murders. The defense is preparing to challenge medical testimony by calling former Medical Examiner Dr. Ely to dispute inconsistencies in the prosecution's evidence.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 29 August 1892 · page 7
HAS A STRONG CASE
An official who stands high in the government counsels was "asked this morning his opinion concerning the guilt or innocence of Lizzie Borden. He said in substance: -1 have no hesi tation in saying that 1 believe her guilty of the crime." Being pressed lor the ground on which his judgment was based, the official said it was largely founded on the evi dence of Bridget Sullivan at the exam ination yesterday afternoon, although developments at tiie private examina tion which resulted in Lizzie's arrest were strongly condemnatory. The official said the crime must have been committed by some one who was familiar with the ar rangements of the house,wilh the move ments of Mr.
See moreSee less
and Mrs. Borden and of Lizzie on the day of the murder. The appearance of Lizzie at the back door when Bridget Sullivan went into the back yard in the morn ing, and her Inquiry of the ser vant, were suspicious circumstances against her. After this inquiry Lizzie disappeared from sight and sound, while Bridget was washing the outside windows of the house. She was not oeen by Bridget again around the rear ot the house, and this would Give Tinie for the lUurder of Mrs. Borden to have been committed. The noise made by Bridget in washing the windows would have deadened to her ears any sound which came from the upper rooms of the house. The de pal ture of Bridget to the upper rooms soon afterward placed her out of the way while the mur der of Mr. Borden was ac complished. It is now tl-ought that the.
Neighbor Adelaide Churchill testifies at Lizzie Borden's trial, describing how Lizzie called her over on the day of the murder, saying someone had killed her father. Churchill recounts Lizzie's claim she had been in the barn looking for sinkers when the murder occurred.
The Evening World · 29 August 1892 · page 3
MISS BORDEN'S CONTRADICTION. New Reason for Going to tbe Barn tbe Day or tbe Murder. IDT AtaOCIATED rlISS.1 Fall llirxn, Mass., Aug.'.'U Court opened In tbe liorden case at 10,43 sharp. Lizzie
Mrs. Churchill testifies about Lizzie's reactions and statements immediately after the murders were discovered, including her request to notify sister Emma gently. A bulletin reveals Alice Russell's testimony that Lizzie gave a different reason for her barn visit than she later stated at inquest.
The Evening World · 29 August 1892 · page 3
MISS BORDEN'S CONTRADICTION
Sbo said bar lather must have an enemy, for I every one la the home had been alck. After the neighbors bad commenced to come In Llzzlo said again that she wished borne one would go and try to find Mrs. Bor den, for she was sure she bad beard her como In, and here witness doscrlbed finding Mrs. Borden. Witness said she heard Llzzlo ask Dr. Bowen to telegraph to her sister Emma, but to be carerta and not Bay the worst, as tbe lady with whom she was stopping was old, nnd It might affect her.
See moreSee less
Witness described tbe dress which Lizzie wore on that day as a dark blue cloth dress. Mr. Jennings subjected Mrs. churchUltoa Bevere croES-eiamlnattoD, dwelling particu larly ou the excited condition or Llzzlo when witness was llrsi called to ths scene. Later Bullbtin.-MIss Alice Itussell has created a sensation by testifying that Im mediately at ler the discovery of the murder Lizzie Borden told ber that ber alleged visit to tbe barn was to procure a piece ot Iron or tin with which to tlx a window. This contradicts subsequent statements ot Miss Llrzlo tbat sho went there tor lead-sinkers.
Mrs. Adelaide Churchill testifies about Lizzie Borden's behavior and statements immediately after discovering her father's body, including inconsistent accounts of her whereabouts. The report also notes no blood was found on Lizzie and references a drug clerk's claim she tried twice to buy prussic acid.
The Evening World · 29 August 1892 · page 1
NO BLOOD UPON HER.
Twloo to Uuy I'rusalc Acltl. inr AiaoeiATxn rarm. I 1'ailHivkk, Mass., Aug.'.'u court opened In the Uoiden caso at 10.43 sharp. Llzrld Borden bad passed a fairly icstful night and at an early hour this morning was Mstlud by
Mrs. Churchill and Alice Russell testify at the inquest about Lizzie's composed appearance and lack of blood on her clothes or person immediately after the murders were discovered. Russell also reveals a contradiction in Lizzie's account of why she was in the barn—fixing a window versus looking for sinkers.
The Evening World · 29 August 1892 · page 1
NO BLOOD UPON HER.
In, and hero witness described finding Mrs. Borden. Witness sola sha, heard Lizzio ask Dr. Bon on to telegraph to her sister Emma, but tn bo caratul and not say tba worst, as tho
At the inquest, Alice Russell testified Lizzie Borden gave a different reason for visiting the barn than she later stated, and said she saw no blood on Lizzie afterward. Drug clerk Eli Bence and others testified Lizzie had tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murder but was refused.
The Evening World · 29 August 1892 · page 1
Ibis contradicts subsequent statements ot Miss 1.1771c that sho went thero lor lead sinkers. on cross-examination Miss ltusscll said she bathed Lizzie's face alter she went In and saw no signs of blood on It, nor did bhe see any on any of her clothing. It was the nlt'icss who persuaded Lizzio to go In tho dining-room and He down, bho could see no signs ot any undue exertion about Lizzie, nor was she panting, as though exhausted. Ell Bence, a drug clerk, testified that Lizzie Borden called at his store three times the day before tho murder for prusslc acid, ana was re used.
See moreSee less
l'rank II. Kllroy, medical Htudont, testified to conversing with Mr. Bcnce In his storo on Wednesday morning, but could not state tho exact time. Know Miss Borden ; saw her that morning.
During the Borden preliminary hearing, defense investigators checked Bridget Sullivan's past employment in Newport and found her reputation for truthfulness intact, despite a rumor of a hot temper. The report also predicts Lizzie Borden will testify for about three days later in the week.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Evening Herald · 29 August 1892 · page 2
HAS A GOOD CHARACTER.
Fail RivEn, Mass., Aug. 29. The hcnrlng in tho Bordon case was rosumed at 10:15 this morning. Tho defenco has been actively engaged In Newport learn ing something regarding the - career of Bridget Sullivan, tho servant, whose evi dence seems to be so damaging to Lizzie Borden. Detective Richards and Attorney Phillips looked up hor record there, but found nothing of Importance except a ru mor that slio has a very hot temper. She worked in two places besides the Perry House, as she stated on the witness stand Saturday.
See moreSee less
The purpose of inquiry is toilutermtne bow reliable hor evidence is, also to learn If she could become so much provoked that she would quarrel seriously with Mr. nnd Mrs. Borden. It is believed hero that Miss Sullivan's chnrncter is above reproach. A search into hor career while In this city shows that Miss Sullivan is very truthful woman. Her past employers speak very good of her, nnd say she was always a devoted church member, ner unshaken testimony hns done much to establish the strength of the case of the Stato. Tho accused will bo put on the stand this week and it is believed thnt hor ex amination will consume fully three days. It is hoped that she may bo able to greatly aid her case, for although many hove been forced to believe her guilty, thoy still have a suspicion that possibly she is Innocent, and as a consequence of this wavering belief there Is really no nnl mosity against her, but rather a feeling of sorrow and n hope that the authorities may prove themselves asses in tho matter. Marshal Hilliard has repeated his In structions to tho matrons in chnrge of Miss Borden, cautioning them to obey the police rules. Some reporters have been admitted to Lizzie's cell since her Imprisonment here, and other breaches of jail, prison and home discipline have been recorded. Mr. Morse, Miss Emma Borden, Rev. Michael Burnham of Springfield, her father's former pastor, were among her callers during the Sabbath. An official who stands high in the gov ernment's counsels was asked by a reporter his opinion concerning the guilt or inno cence of Lizzie Borden. Ho said in substancos "I buve no hesitation In saying that I believe her guilty of tho crime." Being pressed for the ground on which his judgement is based, the official said it was largely founded on the cvldenco of Bridget Sullivan at the examination Sat urday, ulthough developments at the pri vate examination whicli resulted in Lizzie's arrest were strongly condemna
The report says Lizzie Borden is expected to testify for several days to strengthen her defense, amid public sympathy and doubt about her guilt. A high-ranking government official tells a reporter he believes her guilty, citing Bridget Sullivan's testimony and evidence from the private examination that led to her arrest.
The Evening Herald · 29 August 1892 · page 2
structions to tho matrons in chnrge of Miss Borden, cautioning them to obey the police rules. Some reporters have been admitted to Lizzie's cell since her Imprisonment here, and other breaches of jail, prison and home discipline have been recorded. Mr. Morse, Miss Emma Borden, Rev. Michael Burnham of Springfield, her father's former pastor, were among her callers during the Sabbath. An official who stands high in the gov ernment's counsels was asked by a reporter his opinion concerning the guilt or inno cence of Lizzie Borden. Ho said in substancos "I buve no hesitation In saying that I believe her guilty of tho crime."
See moreSee less
Being pressed for the ground on which his judgement is based, the official said it was largely founded on the cvldenco of Bridget Sullivan at the examination Sat urday, ulthough developments at the pri vate examination whicli resulted in Lizzie's arrest were strongly condemna
A wire-service style roundup of miscellaneous news items includes a single line noting that Bridget Sullivan testified in what it calls the Lizzie Borden murder trial. In reality, in August 1892 the Borden case was still at the inquest stage, with the actual trial not occurring until June 1893.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 29 August 1892 · page 7
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
With most reporters having left Fall River after Saturday's hearing, the case against Lizzie Borden awaits testimony from Professor Wood and a drug clerk regarding poison. Bridget Sullivan's testimony is said to show only opportunity, not proof, and her account largely does not contradict Lizzie's own story.
Pawtucket Tribune · 29 August 1892 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE. Government Has Two More Witnesses. TESTIMONY OF PROF. WOOD Will Play an Important Part in the Trial of the Accused.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.
The report examines Bridget Sullivan's testimony, noting it contradicts officers' claims and does not directly implicate Lizzie, while highlighting that blood evidence from Professor Wood's tests on the hatchet will be crucial. It also describes the Borden sisters' theory that an unknown man, possibly seeking Mr. Borden on business, committed the murders.
Pawtucket Tribune · 29 August 1892 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.
The report describes a theory held by Lizzie, Emma, and Mr. Morse that an unknown man entered the Borden house searching for Mr. Borden, hid in an upstairs closet, and later escaped after killing both victims. The family cannot explain when or how Mrs. Borden was killed, nor offer a motive for the murders.
Pawtucket Tribune · 29 August 1892 · page 1
THE SISTERS' THEORY.
The members of the bo d do at tempt %o explain how or when Mm. Bor den was killed; neither can they offer n? reason wh{ Mz. Borden was murdered. They say, however, that they think the
Witnesses Mrs. Churchill and Mrs. Russell testified that Lizzie's face and hands were clean, her hair neat, and she did not appear to have exerted herself physically. The reporter notes the prosecution need only show enough to hold Lizzie for the grand jury, not prove guilt, and calls the case marvelous and seemingly motiveless.
The Providence News · 29 August 1892 · page 1
NEIGHBORS GIVE TESTIMONY.
be{ond what is necessary to hold lLizzie, If is not intended to show her guilt nor even to show her probable guilt very strongly. All that is necessary is to show a stroug lmprobubll‘l:s that anyone else could bave committed the deed. the evidence, therefore, must not be weighed in the scale of prejudice, nor must anything buv the facts be consider ed. With these before them the public can hardly fail to see that the judge is almost certain to hold Miss Borden until
This opinion piece examines the puzzling, seemingly motiveless nature of the Borden murders and questions the reliability of evidence presented against Lizzie Borden. It highlights contradictions, such as conflicting testimony about where bloody hatchets were found and skepticism about blood drying quickly in a damp cellar, arguing the case against her remains weak and circumstantial.
The Providence News · 29 August 1892 · page 1
rosecution has simply shown that it was Sumcult for anvone else to have com mitted the deed. They have shown that there is a note mentioned by Lizzie that must beoxglnined away, That is the substance of the prosecution. The aefence has done scarcely more, It has shown that the front door did not fasten readily. It has shown that, so far as anyone Kknowns, it was not fastened that morning after Mr. Borden entered. It has been shown that the cellar door may have been open and probably was, It has shown that a burguiary was com
The report scrutinizes the physical evidence, arguing it would have been nearly impossible for Lizzie to commit both murders, clean herself and the hatchet, and still call Bridget within the brief window of time. It details the extensive blood spatter from Andrew Borden's wounds versus the seemingly staged, clean hatchet found pointing downward in the basement.
The Providence News · 29 August 1892 · page 1
concerned. The murderous blows upon Mrs, Boruen sgntwm the blood ugnffn the bureau and the wall three feet away, and even up on the pillow shams. But it an hour elapsed betors Lizzie was seen she had time to remove the stiins from herself and her ¢lo hing Misut the ease of Mr. Borden’s death is nout 80 easily explained. The blood from his wounds was thrown five or six feet; furown through the dining room door onto the casement in the dining room: thrown on a piciure above his head;
At the preliminary hearing, witness Miss Collet testified she saw no one pass by during the critical time window. Druggist Eli Bence then testified that Lizzie Borden had come to his store the day before the murders asking to buy prussic acid, which he refused to sell without a prescription.
Druggist Eli Bence testified that the day before the murders, Lizzie Borden asked him for 10 cents worth of prussic acid, claiming she wanted it for a sealskin cape. He refused to sell it without a prescription, and was cross-examined about details of her appearance, the time, and witnesses present.
The Providence News · 29 August 1892 · page 7
“When did }'od'soe this lady bafore this morning?’’ re orriug to Miss Borden. *‘l h‘ad seen her on the street a number of times, { T
Drug store clerks and a witness testify about a woman who tried to buy prussic acid, with some identifying her as Lizzie Borden. Defense attorney Adams cross-examines witnesses on the reliability of their identification by voice and appearance.
The Providence News · 29 August 1892 · page 7
Smith, was called, He did not know Miss bonlen. IHe was there between 10 and 11:30. He was behind the counter. He said & woman came in and askedfor 10 cents’ worth of prussic acid, Bence refused her. She said something about a sealskin garment. He was sure the defendant was the woman, Adams cross-examined, Hardt had worked for Smith about a year, He never had seen Miss Borden before, saw her Thursday the week following here in the court room, His attention was called to ber by Knowliton. Saw her sitting down in the corridor alterwards.
See moreSee less
No one called his att:ntion to her then. The corridor muy have been lighted, “How was ste dressed !’ 1 think in black. She was with the marshal.” “How was she dressed in the store ! “In dark clothes; she had & sack on her arm, & purse in ber hand.” “Is your store light?’ *‘Yes sir, it ison a corner.” “You said she wante! prussic acid to go on the edges of her sack?”’ *“*Yeo, sir,”
Mrs. Adelaide Churchill testified about seeing Bridget fetch the doctor and Lizzie's distress on the day of the murders, and described finding Mrs. Borden's body. Alice Russell testified that Lizzie first said she went to the barn for iron or tin, contradicting her later claim of searching for lead sinkers.
Alexandria Gazette · 29 August 1892 · page 3
The Korden Trial. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 29.?Court was called lo order in the mysterious Borden case at 10:45 sharp. Mrs. Ade laidc B. Churchill testified that she lived next to the Bordens. The first she remembered of her attention being called to the affair was when she saw Bridget going for Dr. Bowen. About the same time she saw Lizzie standing against the side of the side door, appar? ently distressed about something; open? ed the window and asked her what was the matter, and she said, "Oh, Mrs. Churchill, do come over ; somebody has kj'.led father," Witness described finding Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden's body. Miss Alice M. Russell has created a sensation by testifying that immediate? ly after the discovery of the murder Miss Lizzie Borden told her that her alleged visit to the barn was to procure a piece of iron or tin with which; to, fix a window. This contradicts sqhsequent statements or Miss Lizzie that she went there for lead sinkers.
At the Fall River preliminary hearing, Mrs. Churchill testified that Lizzie said she worried her mother might have been killed too, which prosecutors found suspicious given the timeline. The defense countered with testimony from Miss Russell that she saw no blood on Lizzie shortly after the alarm was raised.
Morning Journal and Courier · 30 August 1892 · page 3
Tournament. THE BORDER TRIAL. The Government's Case Appears to be Somewhat Stronger Lizzie's Friend, Mrs. Cburcb.Ul, Gives Kvl' dence Against tbe Girl A. New Version of the Canse ot the Sis. tern' 0.narrel In the matron's Room. Fall Eivbb, Aug. 29. The court has adjonrned until 10:15 a. m. to-morrow. The strongest point brought out by this morning's testimony in the Borden murder investigation, the state's officials say, was Lizzie's remark, speaking of her mother to Mrs. Chnrohill, according to that lady's testimony: "I don't know bat she has been killed, too."
See moreSee less
Lizzie made this remark while telling that she thought she heard her mother oome in. What reason, ask the officials, did Lizzie have for believing that her mother had been killed, considering the circumstances already brought out. viz., that Lizzie was upstairs when her father came in, when Mrs. Borden had been dead abont one honr, and went down stairs and told him that his wife was ont, bat failed to say anything abont thinking she heard Mrs. Borden come in. On the other hand an imDortaut faot was brought out by Lawyer Jennings in his orocs-examination of Miss Russell. That lady bathed Lizzie Borden's face and fan ned her, and did not notioe any signs ot blood whatever abont the accused. That was only ten or fifteen minutes after Liz zie oalled for Bridget to oome down stairs.
This report covers testimony from Mrs. Addie Churchill and Miss Russell at the preliminary hearing, noting discrepancies in Lizzie Borden's statements about her stepmother's whereabouts and the open bedroom door. Witnesses confirmed no blood was found on Lizzie's clothing or person shortly after the murders, even as other details raised suspicion among her former supporters.
Morning Journal and Courier · 30 August 1892 · page 3
A CHANGE OF OPINION. The testimony brought oat in the Bor den hearing to-day has caused a change of opinion among many of her friends who have heretofore stoutly maintained her innocence. They consider the strongest evidenoe given against her to be that of Mrs. Addie Chnrohill, the neighbor whom she has known and loved sinoe childhood. Mrs. Churchill is a sister of City Auditor BufEngton and daughter of the late Mayor Buffiogton, and owing to her standing in social ciroles her testimony has caused a profound sensation. She stated positively that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden's room door was opened when she and Bridget Sullivan discovered the body of the mur dered woman. It has already been stated that Lizzie Borden was in the hallway near this open door when Bridget Sullivan was opening the front door at 10:35. Again, Mrs. Churchill stated positively that Miss Lizzie told her Mrs. Borden had received a note to call on a sick friend, but it has not yet been proven that any person in this city or elsewhere sent suoh note or that Mrs. Borden left the house at any time during the day. Like all the rest of the witnesses for the government she failed to find any traces of blood on Miss Lizzie's olothing or her person. Miss Lizzie was in distress and greatly agitated when her life-long friend came to her assistance, bat she was not obtrusively sorrowful nor did she show palntul emotion. When Mrs. Churchill asked her where her mother was she did not say she was out. Her answer was: Go and see if yon can find her. I don't know bat she is killed, too." SHE FBARBD TO OBKY.
Testimony from drugstore clerks and witnesses at the hearing appears damaging to Lizzie Borden, while questions arise about her unexplained visit to the barn. Meanwhile, defense detectives are shadowing a suspicious man matching Dr. Handy's description, and a new account disputes rumors of a quarrel between Lizzie and her sister Emma.
Morning Journal and Courier · 30 August 1892 · page 3
A SUSPICIOUS MAN LOCATED. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 29. Counsel for the defense have been apprised of the location of a suspicious man, said to an swer the description given by Dr. Handy and he is being shadowed by detectives in the employ of the Misses Borden until he is needed.
At the preliminary hearing, neighbor Mrs. Addie Churchill testified that Mrs. Borden's door was open when the body was found and that Lizzie claimed her stepmother had left to visit a sick friend, a claim never corroborated. The testimony, along with earlier reports of Lizzie trying to buy prussic acid, is causing even her longtime friends to doubt her innocence.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 30 August 1892 · page 1
FRIENDS ARE DOUBTING
Opinion In Many Quarters HIm Bor den Denies the Drue Clerk's Story. Faix River, Mass., Aug. 80. Long be fore the hearing la the Borden murder case was continued this morning the court room was crowded to suffocation. The examination was resumed at 10:15. The testimony brought out in the hear ing yesterday has caused a change of opinion among many of Lizzie Borden's friends, who have heretofore stoutly maintained her innocence. They consider the strongest evidence given against her to be that of Mrs. Addie Churchill, the neighbor whom she has known and loved since childhood.
See moreSee less
Mrs. Churchill is a Bister of City Audi tor Buffington and daughter of the late Mayor Buffington, and her testimony has caused a profound sensation. She stated positively that Mrs. Borden's door was open when she and Bridget Sul livan first discovered the body of the murdered woman. Again, Mrs. Churchill stated positively that Miss Lizzie told her that Mrs. .Bor den had received a note to call on a sick friend. It has not been proven that any person in this city or elsewhere sent such a note or that Mrs. Borden left the house
Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper
This report details testimony from the Borden preliminary hearing, including Mrs. Churchill's account of finding Lizzie distressed and Lizzie's cryptic remark about her mother being killed too. It also covers Miss Russell's testimony hinting at family tension and the damaging drugstore testimony regarding Lizzie's alleged attempt to purchase poison, which she denies.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 30 August 1892 · page 1
flushed and bent toward Attorney Adams. Following Mrs. Churchill's testimony came that of Miss Russell, the friend for whom Miss Lizzie sent at once. Uncon sciously, perhaps, Miss Russell gave an other insight into the unhappy domestic life of the Borden family. Mrs. Borden,
The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa. · 30 August 1892
Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.
Mrs. Churchill describes being called by Lizzie Borden on the day of the murders, recounting Lizzie's statements about her father, missing mother, and her barn visit, and noting no blood or disarray on Lizzie's person. Alice Russell then testifies that Lizzie told her the barn visit was to find a piece of iron or tin to fix a window.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 30 August 1892 · page 1
bors had commenced to come in Lizzie said again that she wished some one would go and try to find Mrs. Borden, for Bhe was sure she had heard her come in, and here witness described finding Mrs. Borden. itness had seen Mr. Borden that
At the probable cause hearing, neighbor Mrs. Addie Churchill testified that Mrs. Borden's door was open when the body was found and that Lizzie claimed her stepmother had left for a sick friend's house, though no such note was ever confirmed. Druggist witnesses also gave testimony considered damaging to Lizzie, who reacted visibly in court.
Los Angeles Herald · 30 August 1892 · page 1
THE COILS TIGHTENING. A Change of Opinion in the Lizzie Bor den Case. Fall Riveb, Mass., Aug. 29.—The testimony brought cut in the Lizzie Borden hearing, today, caueed a change of opinion among her friends, who here tofore stoutly maintained her innocence. They consider the strongest evidence against her to be that of Mrs. Addie Churchill, a neighbor, whom she has known and loved since childhood. Mrs. Churchill stated positively that Mrs. Borden's room door was open when she and Bridget Sullivan first discovered the body of the murdered woman. It has already been stated that Lizzie Borden was in the hallway, near the open door, when Bridget Sullivan onened the front door, at 1.35 o'clock.
See moreSee less
Again, Mrs. Churchill stated posi tively that Lizzie told her Mrs. Borden had received a note to call on a sick friend, but it has not yet been proven that any person in the city or elsewhere sent such a note, or that Mrs. Borden left the house at any time dur ing the day. Like all the rest of the witnesses for tbe government, she failed to find any traces of blood on Miss Liz zie's clothing or person. During the testimony the prisoner bit her lip, flushed, and bent toward Attorney Adams. Toe testimony also of E. H. Pence, a drug clerk, Frank Kilroy, a Harvard medical student, and Fred Hart, an assistant drug clerk, all of whom were in Smith's drug store when Lizzie was there, seems very damaging to the defendant. Tbe building boom has caused tbe re moval of H. A. Getz'e fine tailoring
Mrs. Churchill testified that Mrs. Borden's bedroom door was open when the body was discovered and that Lizzie mentioned a note calling her mother to a sick friend's house, though no such note was ever found. The report also notes no blood was found on Lizzie's clothing, but mentions she reportedly tried to buy prussic acid beforehand.
Evening Journal · 30 August 1892 · page 2
BAD FOR LIZZIE BORDEN
murdered woman. It has already been stated that Lizzie Borden whs in tlia hull. SS™ lu Ï ia . . « . uav near this opeu door when Bridget bul livnn was opening the front door at 10:35 o'clock. Again, Mrs. Churchill stated po*i tively that Miss Lizzie told her Mrs. Borden had received a note to call on a sick friend It has not yel beeu proven that any person in this city or elsewhere sent such a note or that Mrs. Borden lott the house at any tune during the day L,ke ail the rest of the witnesses for the government she failed to find any traces of blood on Miss Lizzie's clothing or her per son.
See moreSee less
Miss Lizzie wus in distress and great ly agitated when her lifelong friend run to her assistance, but she was not obtrusively sorrow tul nor did she show painful emotion i «» , a. . ... , » ' When Mn». Churchill aaked her where her mother was ahe did not say she was out. Her answar was- 'Hin se« if von ran find tier answer was. Gosse if you can find her. I don t know but sho is killed too. Bridget Sullivan a'as intuitively fearful of obovmir Mis« Limai* and refused r.nfriirht obeying Miss Mizzle, ana rerused outright to go up stairs uuless Airs. Churchill accom* panied her. Lizzie Hit Her I.ips and Fluslied.
At the Lizzie Borden hearing, Mrs. Addie Churchill testified that no blood was found on Lizzie's clothing or person, though her account of Lizzie's reaction to the murders was seen as damaging. Drug clerk Eli Bence and others testified that Lizzie had tried to purchase prussic acid from Smith's drug store the day before the killings.
Evening Journal · 30 August 1892 · page 2
SHE TRIED TO BUY PRUSSIC ACID.
panied her. Lizzie Hit Her I.ips and Fluslied. During this testimony ttie prisoner bit her lips. Bushed and beat tuwurd Attoruey Ad ams. Following Mrs. Churchill's testimony came that of Mias Russell, the friend for whom Miss Lizzie sent at once. Uucon sciously, perliapa, Miss Russell gave another insight into the unhappy domestic life of the Borden family. Mra. Borden, the step mother, was se dom seen in the guest»' chamber, although witness wits a trequeut visitor. * Coupled with Miss Lizzie's own words that she always locked her room door when going out, it was apparent that the pleas untest relations did not exist.
See moreSee less
Miss Russell was a stubborn witness in the opii.ion of a government official, while Mrs. Churchill, who was reluctant and tearful at first, told freelv all she 1-new witliont lliutinir at fem. ireeiy an sne knew, without muting at tarn lly relations. The testimony also of E. H. Berce, the drug clerk; Frank Kilroy, the Harvard med icAl BtUflent, and Fred Hart, töe «««i^tant drug clerk, all of whom were in Smith'« drug store when Lizzie was there, seems very dnmaging to the defendant. Eli Bence, diug clerk, testified that he re membered tho «lay of the tragedy and w.is acquaisted with Lizzie Borden. Witness «aw her in his «tore the day before aud she u«ked him for ten cents'worth of prussic acid to put on a sealskiu cape, but he told her he could not hell it without a physician's prescription. His attention was called to the fact that -he was in the store on Thurs day evening and soon after that agaiu, oi about 6 o'clock. His uttention was called to the fact that she was the daughter ot Audrew Borden.
At the preliminary hearing, druggist Eli Bence testified that Lizzie Borden asked to buy prussic acid the day before the killings, a claim corroborated by other clerks present. Lizzie denied ever being in the drug store, while other witnesses' testimony and barn-visit discrepancies were also detailed.
Evening Journal · 30 August 1892 · page 2
very dnmaging to the defendant. Eli Bence, diug clerk, testified that he re membered tho «lay of the tragedy and w.is acquaisted with Lizzie Borden. Witness «aw her in his «tore the day before aud she u«ked him for ten cents'worth of prussic acid to put on a sealskiu cape, but he told her he could not hell it without a physician's prescription. His attention was called to the fact that -he was in the store on Thurs day evening and soon after that agaiu, oi about 6 o'clock. His uttention was called to the fact that she was the daughter ot Audrew Borden.
See moreSee less
The other witnesses who were present in the drug store at the time corroborated Bence's testimony. Miss Lizzie Borden denies positively that she was ever at Dr. Smith's drug store,
The report argues it is morally certain that either Lizzie Borden or Bridget Sullivan committed the Fall River murders, and that both have guilty knowledge. It notes the only testimony comes from the two women and predicts a jury will find circumstantial evidence unconvincing.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Evening Journal · 30 August 1892 · page 4
Fhom the evidence it appears morally certain that either Lizzie Borden or Bridget Sullivan committed the horrible murders at Fail Rfver. Mass., and that both of them have guilty knowledge of it. The difficulty will be to prove it.
At the Fall River hearing, a drug clerk testified that Lizzie Borden tried three times to buy prussic acid the day before the murders. Alice Russell and others gave testimony about Lizzie's shifting explanations for her barn visit and an odd remark suggesting she feared her mother was also killed.
New-York Tribune · 30 August 1892 · page 1
MURDER—NO BLOOD FOUND ON HER AFTER THE DIICOVERY. Fall River, Mass.,, Aug, 20.—In the Borden trial today noteworthy testimony was given by several witnesses. EN Bence, a drug clerk, testified that Miss 1izzie Borden called at his store at three different times, the day before the murders, for prussic acld, ostensibly to use in cleaning a sealskin cape, and that he refused to sell it to her without a physician's prescription. Miss Alice Russell created a sensation by testifying that immediately after the discovery of the murder Miss Lizzie Borden told her that her alleged visit to the barn was to procure a piece of fron or tin with which to fix a window.
See moreSee less
This contradicts subsequent statements of Miss Lizzie that she went there for lead sinkers. Th. strongest point brought out by this morning's testimony, the State's officials say, was 14zzie’s remark, speaking of her mother to Mrs. Churchill, according to that lady’s testimony: “I don't know but she has been killed, too.” Lizzie made this remark while telling that she thought she heard her mother come in. What reason, ask the officials, did I4zzie have for believing that her mother had been Killed, considering the clrenmstances already brought out: that Lizzie was upstairs when her father came in, when Mrs. Borden had been dead about an hour, and went downstairs and told him that his wife was ont, but failed to say anything about thinking she henrd Mrs! Borden come in. On the other hand, an important fact was brought out by Mr. Jennings, in hls cross-examination of Mrs. Russell. That lady bathed Lizzie’s face and fanned her, and did not notice any signs of blood whatever about the accused, That was only ten or fifteen minutes after [Lizzie called for Bridget to come downstairs. The court came In at 10:45 sharp, bat at 8 o'clock the dingy courtroom was thronged. Idzzle Borden
This report details preliminary hearing testimony from Mrs. Adelaide Churchill, who described Lizzie's distressed state and strange remarks after the murders, including her statement that she feared her mother had been killed too. Prosecutors highlight this as suspicious given the timeline, while the defense counters with testimony that no blood was found on Lizzie shortly after the discovery.
Mrs. Churchill testifies about Lizzie's reactions and statements after the murders, including her agitation and comment that her father must have had an enemy. Alice Russell's testimony then contradicts an earlier witness regarding what Lizzie said about going to the barn.
New-York Tribune · 30 August 1892 · page 1
AFTER THE DISCOVERY.
Afier the nelghbors had begun to eome in, Lizzie said again that wished one would go and try she sO to find Mrs. Borden, for she was sure she had heard Hero the witness deseribod finding Mrs. her come in. Borden, Witness had seen Mr. Borden that morning about 9 o'clock; he was apparently going dowh town. She described the dress which Lizzle wore on that day as a dark blue cotton cloth dress, Mr. Jennings subjected Mrs. Churchlll to a severe eres examination, dwelling particularly on the ex cited condition of Lizzie when witness was first called tw the scene, She said that when she gol inside the house LizzZe was so much agitated that she fanned her, fearing she would faint, Witness stated that when they went up stairs to look for Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden they found the door of Mrs. Borden's room was open.
A general news roundup briefly mentions that in the Borden murder case testimony showed Lizzie Borden tried three times to buy prussic acid the day before the killings. The item is embedded among unrelated foreign and domestic news briefs.
New-York Tribune · 30 August 1892 · page 6
THE NEWS THIS MORNING.
Foreign.—Cholera made its appearance in Bremen and Berlin: there wus a death from the disease at Dundee, and cases were reported from other places in Great Britain: there was an apparent | abatement of the plague in Hemburg; sixty new oases and twenty-four deaths were reported in Havre; the pestilence is still raging ia Russia. ———— The Moorish troops defeated the main body of the insurgents, after burning four villages. Mr. Edmund Yates writes ot the world ot London. Domestic — hairman Murply, of the Democratic State Committee, offered to Judge Maynard the nemination for Chief Judge of the Court of Appeals; the proffer was declined, ==== Jolin Ww.
See moreSee less
Foster, Secretary of State, and E. W. Halford, the President's private secretury, were amobg President Harrison's visitors at Loon Lake, ===2 Dr. Oliver Wendell Hclmes celebrated his eightythird birthday at Beverly Farms, Mass, =—= In the National Lawn Tennis Association tournament at Newport, Hovey won from Wrenn, and Larned from E. L. Hull. === In the Borden murder trial testimony showed that Miss Lizzie Borden had tried to get prussic acid three times the day before the tragedy. City and Suburban.—Republicans express their satisfaction with Commissioner Peck’s labor statistics, and Democrats werg.amazed at their showing and disgusted at their publication. === Orders were issued to various municipal departments to get the city in good sanitary condition in view of the approach of cholera; stringent rules were adopted by quarantine officials. === Winmers at Sheepshead Bay: Dr. lasbrouck, Runyon,
Witnesses at the Fall River hearing testified that Lizzie Borden gave different explanations for being in the barn at the time of the murders, and that she had tried to buy prussic acid beforehand. Neighbor Adelaide Churchill described finding Lizzie distressed at the side door after the killings.
The Morning News · 30 August 1892 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL. CONTRADICTORY STORIES TOLD BY THE ACCUSED.
Pruasic Acid Proved. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 29.—The Bor den murdor trial to-day was rather sensa tional. Drug Clerk Bence and two others testified that Miss Lizzie Borden attempted to buy prussio acid of Bence before the murder. Mrs. Churchill, the first person on the scene after the murder, testified that Miss Burden bail told her she was In the barn at the time of the murder, looking for some sinkers, aud Mils Russell testified that Liz zie told her she went there to get a piece of Iron or tin to fix a window. The contra dictory statements caused a sensation. The witness said that no blood was on Lizzie’s drees after the murder.
At the inquest, neighbor Adelaide Churchill and family friend Alice Russell testify about Lizzie Borden's behavior and statements immediately after the bodies were discovered, including her claim she had been in the barn looking for iron or sinkers. Both witnesses state they saw no blood on Lizzie's dress, hands, or face at the time.
The Morning News · 30 August 1892 · page 1
A BBOONIS INQUIRY FOR UHB. BORDEN. After the neighbors had commenced to come in Lizzie said again that she wished someone would go and try to find Mrs. Borden, for she was sure she had heard her come In. Here the witness described the finding of Mrs Borden. The witness said that when she got inside the house, Lizzie was so muuh agitated that she fanned her, fearing the would taint. After thay saw the body they left Bridget in the room and have no knowl edge what she did there, if anything.
See moreSee less
The witness oould not ramemtmr that there was the least sign of blood on Lizzie's dress, hands or face at the time she first saw her; her hair was “done up" and appeared not to be disarranged in the slightest, and there was no Indications of anything in her ap pearance that any changes had been made since she arose.
Miss Russell testified under cross-examination that she saw no blood on Lizzie and no signs of exertion, and that Lizzie did not go upstairs before police arrived. Drug store witnesses testified that Lizzie had tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murders, claiming it was for a sealskin coat.
The Morning News · 30 August 1892 · page 1
THE INQUIRY FOR THE PRUSSIC ACID.
A CHANGE OF FEELING. The testimony brought out in the heari g to-day has caused a ohauge of opinion among many of Lizzie Borden's friends who have heretofore stoutly maintained her In nocence, They consider the strongest evi dence given against her to be that of Mrs. Churohill, a neighbor whom she has known and loved slnoe childhood. Mrs. Churchill is a sister of City Auditor Buf fington and a daughter of the late Mavor Buffington, and owing to nor standing In social circles her testimony has caused a profound sensation.
On the fourth day of Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, witnesses testified about inconsistencies in her account of why she went to the barn, with Alice Russell saying Lizzie first claimed it was to fix a window but later said she sought lead sinkers. Testimony also highlighted Lizzie's odd remark suggesting she suspected her mother was dead before the body was officially discovered.
The Indianapolis Journal · 30 August 1892 · page 5
HER STORIES DON'T CONSIST
Fall River. Mass., Aug. 29. This was the fourth day of the preliminary hearing of Miss Lizzie Borden, charted with the murder of herfather and moth vr. Although
At the inquest, Alice Russell testified that Lizzie first said she went to the barn for iron or tin to fix a window, contradicting her later claim of looking for sinkers. Mrs. Churchill also testified that Lizzie worried her mother might be killed too, before any body had been found, raising suspicion among prosecutors.
The Indianapolis Journal · 30 August 1892 · page 5
HER STORIES DON'T CONSIST
Mrs Borden had been dead about an hour, and when she went down' stairs and told him that his wife was out, but failed 10 ay anything about thinking she Heard Mrs. Borden come in.. On the other hand, an important iaofc was brought out by lawyer Jennings in his croao-exaniination of Miss KosdelL That lady bathed Lizzie's face and fanned . her. and did not notice any signs of blood whatever about the ac cused. 'That was only ten r liiteen min utes after Lizzie called for Bridget and came down stairs.
See moreSee less
Mrs. Adelaide B. Churchill was the first witness called, She said she lived next to the Bordens, on the north side of the street, and she remembered well the day of the tragedy. .The tirst she remembered of 'her attention being called to the atlair was when she saw Bridget going for Dr. Bowen. About the same time she saw Lizzie stand ing against the side of the side door, ap parently distressed about something. She opened the window aud asked her where herfather was. and she replied "In thesit-ting-room." Then wittiessusked her where the was when it happened, and she said she was in the barn lookinc for some sinkers. Witness said, also, that, so far as she knew, she was the tirst one outside of the family who was called tothe houo. The time, as nearly as witness could recollect, was about 11 o'clock.
Witnesses describe finding Lizzie distressed by the side door, recounting her claims of being in the barn and her concern for her missing mother. Other testimony addresses the timeline and whether anyone could have entered the Borden yard unseen.
The Indianapolis Journal · 30 August 1892 · page 5
AN IMPORTANT POINT.
'of the Bordens. During the time she was there the taw no one passing in the yard. Oi cross-examination it took just fifteen minutes for witness and Mr. Jennings to come to an understanding as to where the fence was located between the Chagnon and Borden houses, and then the witness admitted that she was where she could not see the whole of the Borden yard, but sho was sure that if anybody bad entered the yard she would have heard them. After a recess Lh Bence, drug clerk, tes tified that he remembered the day of the tragedy, and was acquainted with Lizzie Borden.
See moreSee less
Witness saw her in his store the day before, aud she asked him for ten cents' worth of prussio acid to put on a sealskin sack or cape, bnt he told her he could not sell it without a physician's pre scription. His -attention was called to the fact that she was in the store on Thursday evening, and soon after that again, about 6 o'clock. Frank Keller, medical student, testified that he knew Miss Borden, and that he saw her on Thursday. Witness was sitting in the drug storo when she came in, and Mr. Bence went behind the counter to wait on her. Witness heard ber say, Trussio acid," and Bence say, "Can't sell it without a prescription." Then he heard her say, "seal-skin cape." Then she went out,,. Fred K. B. llart, employed in the drug store, corroborated the 'testimony of the previous witnesses in regard to the prussio acid incident, and identified Miss Horden as the person who had asked for the stuff. Joseph Deroches testified by aid of an in terpreter. He was sawing wood in John Crowe's yard on che day of the tragedy. Tie saw no one going over the fenco that day. nor did heeeo anybody in the next yard.
At the resumed Fall River inquest, neighbor Adelaide Churchill testified that Bridget ran for Dr. Bowen and that Lizzie Borden, visibly distressed, called her over saying someone had killed her father. Lizzie reportedly said she had been searching the barn for sinkers and that her stepmother may have been killed too after receiving a note asking her to go somewhere.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 30 August 1892 · page 4
Der Doppelmord in Fall-River
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Mrs. Churchill recounts being called by Lizzie Borden after the murders, describing the discovery of Mrs. Borden's body and Lizzie's agitated state. Alice Russell's testimony reveals a contradiction: Lizzie told her she went to the barn for iron to fix a window screen, while she told Churchill she was looking for lead sinkers.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 30 August 1892 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Alice Russell testifies that Lizzie gave her a different reason for going to the barn than she had told Mrs. Churchill, and that Lizzie appeared agitated but had no blood on her. Druggist Eli Bence testifies that Lizzie tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murders, claiming she needed it for a sealskin coat.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 30 August 1892 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
At the preliminary hearing in Fall River, witness Mrs. Adelaide Churchill testified about finding Lizzie Borden distressed at the side door and their subsequent conversation about the murders. The report notes contradictory stories about Lizzie's account of going to the barn, but states little evidence has been produced to hold her for murder.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 30 August 1892 · page 1
LITTLE PROOF
Held for Murder. Km Kivu*. Mass.. Aug. LM.».—The hear ing in the Borden murder ease was con tinued at Id.ll this morning. Lizzie Burden pawed a fairly restful night, wa> w iled early this morning by her sister Knimn w ho remained with her until the hour for court arrived. Lizzie, upon entering the court room, greeted her counsel with a smile. Mrs. Adelaide II. Churchill, the first wit ness, sai l she lived next to the Bordens, on the north side of the street.
Mrs. Churchill testifies about Lizzie's distressed state and claims after the murders, describing how she was called over and what Lizzie said about her parents. Alice Russell's testimony reveals a contradiction with Lizzie's later account of why she went to the barn, creating a sensation in court.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 30 August 1892 · page 1
some one would go and try to find Mrs. Borden, that she was sure she had heard her come in; and here the witness de scribed finding Mrs. Borden. Mr. Jennings subjected Mrs. Churchill to a severe cross-examination, dwelling par
This report details inquest testimony from drug clerk Eli Bence about Lizzie's attempt to buy prussic acid, and from police officers describing the search of the Borden house, the hatchets found, and Lizzie's shifting accounts of her whereabouts and a mysterious man seen near the house. Officers also testified about Lizzie's demeanor during questioning and examination of the bodies.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 30 August 1892 · page 1
in the next yard ; commenced work at 7 A. M. Patrick If. Doherty, police officer, testi fied ato the examination of the bodies and their appearances. Vs soon as Incom menced Lizzie bowed her ficad on fier ban l and appeared much affected. The hou*c was searched throughout, ail hut Emma s room, and the cellar door "as found locked. Miss Borden was a-k«-d hv the witness where she was when the murder took place and she said In the barn.' She said sh»* heard some kind of a peculiar noi-r while site was there, a km l of a scraping noise. Witness said Lizzie said than neither Mr Eddy, nor any other man who worked for Mr Borden, would hurt him. Witness and officer Mullally found sev
Lizzie Borden denies ever visiting the drug store where Eli Bence worked, and her defense team is shadowing a suspicious man matching Dr. Handy's description. Friends and counsel also dispute rumors of a sisterly quarrel and suggest Lizzie may have heard her mother's fall while ironing, explaining her account of entering the house.
The Portland Daily Press · 30 August 1892 · page 1
—Suspicious Character Shadowed. Fald River, Mass., August 29.—Mis s Lizzie Borden denies positively that she was ever at D. R. Smith’s drug store, where Eli Bence is clerk. The counsel for the defence in the Borden case has been apprised of the location of a suspi cious man, said to answer the descrip tion given by Dr. Handy. The man is now being shadowed by detectives in the employ of the Misses Borden. An other story given out tonight by Miss Lizzie’s nearest friends, approved by her counsel, fittingly denies the stories of a quarrel between the twoBorden sisters.
See moreSee less
On the day when the “you gave me away” story was published, there was a caller at the Borden household in whom Miss Lizzie had more than a girlish in terest Miss Emma joked her about the visit, and then said something that caused Miss Lizzie to blush and accuse her sister of saying things that might possibly affect her maidenly re serve. “Why, Emma,” she said. “I’ll never speak to you again.” Two min utes later the sisters were conversing in the most endearing way. The defendant’s lawyers were given as authorities tonight for the following: Miss Lizzie Borden probably heard her mother struck down and perhaps heard her fall. She [Miss Lizzie] was busy clattering about the house, putting irons on the fire and pounding them on the ironing board. Hearing her mother fall would readily account for her readiness to say that she had entered the house, slammed the front door and gone direct ly to her room. Bridget Sullivan did not see Mr. Borden leave the house or yard. It does not seem improbable that others could not have seen any stranger enter or leave through the back screen door. ___
On the fourth day of the preliminary hearing before Judge Blaisdell, witnesses testified about Lizzie Borden's alleged attempt to purchase prussic acid before the murders, as well as her words and actions immediately after the killings. Mrs. Adelaide Churchill testified seeing Lizzie distressed by the door, and a sensation arose when a witness's account conflicted with another's story about a search for sinkers.
The Portland Daily Press · 30 August 1892 · page 1
WASTED PRUSSIC ACID.
TRIAL AT FALL RIVER. Besides the Poison Episode, Yesterday’s Witnesses Told of Lizzie’s Actions and Words Immediately After the Tragedy —A Sensation Caused by a Witness Who Quoted Lizzie as Telllpg a Story Which Conflicts With That of a Search for Sinkers. Fall Riveb, Mass., August 29.—The fourth day of Judge Blaisdell’s hearing upon the evidence presented by the Com” nffin wealth against Lizzie Borden opened
Mrs. Churchill testifies that Lizzie told her she was in the barn looking for sinkers when her father was killed, and described Lizzie's calm appearance despite her agitation. Alice Russell then contradicts this, testifying Lizzie said she went to the barn for a piece of iron or tin, creating a sensation in court.
The Portland Daily Press · 30 August 1892 · page 1
TRIAL AT FALL RIVER.
After the neighbors had commenced to come in, Lizzie said again that she wished some one would go and try to find Mrs. Borden, for she was sure she heard her come in. Here the witness described the finding of Mrs. Borden. Mr. Jennings subjected Mrs. Churchill to a severe cross-examination, dwelling particularly on the excited condition of Lizzie when the witness was first called to the house. Witness said when she reached the house Lizzie was so much agitated that she fanned her, fearing she would faint. Witness could not remember that there was the least sign of blood on Lizzie’s dress, hands or face at the time when she first saw her.
See moreSee less
Her hair was done up and appeared not to be disarranged in the slightest. There was no indication that any changes had been made in her ap pearance since she arose. Miss Alice M. Bussell testified that she went to the Borden house the day of the murder. Could not remember how Liz
Adelaide Churchill testifies at the Borden trial about Lizzie's behavior and statements on the day of the murders, including conflicting accounts of her whereabouts. The report also notes testimony from a drug clerk about Lizzie allegedly trying to buy prussic acid.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 30 August 1892 · page 1
A STRONG POINT.
Fall Bivsb, M ass., Aug. ft-Xn j Adelaide B. Churchill was the first wit ! ness called in the Borden case today. | The first sue remembered of her atten i tion beine called to the affair was when | she saw Bridget going for Dr. Bowen. j About the same time she saw Lizzie S standing against the side of the side | door, apparently distressed about uuiat ! thine, and asked her where tier father was. and she replied, "In the sitting | room."" Asked her where she was when ■it happened, and she said she was in the barn loosing for some sinkers.
See moreSee less
Wituas^ also said that she was the first one outside of the family who wss called to the house. The time was about 11 o'clock. Witness asked Lizzie where her mother was. and she said her Tiother had a note to co somewhere, but
Multiple witnesses testify about the morning of the murders, including Lizzie's claims about searching the barn, her mother's whereabouts, and finding her father's body. Druggist Eli Bence also testifies that Lizzie tried to buy prussic acid from him the day before the killings.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 30 August 1892 · page 1
Lizzie Very I*l neb Arf tiled. Witness said that when she got inside the house Lizzie was so much a<ritated that she fanned her, fearing ; she would faint. Witness stated that when they went ut> stairs to look for Mrs. Borden they found the door of Mrs. Borden's room was open. „ :
Witnesses testify at the inquest, including druggists who recount Lizzie Borden asking to buy prussic acid the day before the murders, and a police officer who recalls her account of being in the barn. Assistant marshal John Fleet testifies that Lizzie showed no tears upon discovery of the bodies, and officials highlight her remark fearing her mother had also been killed.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 30 August 1892 · page 1
\ \\ \ f / / S lows: the whole of the Borden yard, bat she was sure that if anybody had entered the yard she would have heard them. Alter a recess Eli Bence, druE clerk. testified that he remembered the day of the seedy and was acquainted with Lizzie BordenWituess saw her in his store the day before, ami she asked him for 10 cents worth of J'russic acid to put , on a sealskin sack or cape, bat he told her he could not sell it without a physi cian's prescription.
See moreSee less
His attention was called to the fact that she was in the store on Thursday evening, and soon after that airam at~6 o'clock. FranK il.Kilroy. nieuical student, tes tified. Knew Miss Borden, saw her . the Seine. that morning. Witness was sitting in the shop when she came in, ana Mr. Bence went behind the counter to wait on her: heard her siy "Prussic acid" and him say "can't sell ii without a prescription," and then heard her say "sealskin cane." cThen she went out. Frederick B. Hart, employe in the drug store, corroborated the testimony of the previous .witness in resrard to. the prussie acid isckient. and then identi fied .Miss Borden as the person who had asked for the stuff. Joseph de Roches testified by the aid of an interpreter. He was sawing wood in John Crowe's yard on the day of the tragedy; saw no one go over picious case. the fence that day. nor did he see any body in the nest yard. j Patrick H. liberty, police officer, tes tified. Miss Borden was asked by wit ness where she was when the murder took place, and she said "in the barn." She said she heard some kind of pe cnliar noise while she was there, a kind of scraping noise.
Servant Bridget Sullivan testified at the inquest, recounting the household's activities on August 3-4, including Lizzie's behavior and statements before and after discovering Andrew Borden's body. The defense was reportedly upset over a separate story that a matron overheard a quarrel between the Borden sisters.
The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 30 August 1892 · page 1
BAD FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. Servant ltrldget Sullivan llrsrrllies the Scenes in the House of Death. Fall Itirnit, Mass., Aug 27. The principal witness in the Borden case yesterday afternoon was Bridget ! Sullivan, the family servant. She toiu in detail all the doings ol tuc , household on August 3 and 4 up to the murder, even to tiie taking in ot tue milk can in the morning and Mr. Borden's coming to breakfast without any collar. Some of her points were: " I washed windows on three sides of the house. I heard Lizzie laugh up stairs when 1 let Mr. Borden in. I heard Lizzie later tell Mr. Borden very slow
At the preliminary hearing, neighbor Mrs. Addie Churchill testified that Mrs. Borden's bedroom door was open when the body was found and that Lizzie had mentioned a note calling her mother away, though no such note or sender was ever confirmed. Drug store clerks also gave testimony considered damaging, while witnesses again found no blood on Lizzie's clothing or person.
The Helena Independent · 30 August 1892 · page 2
just as it belched forth its midday salute." -Bt. Louis Globe Democrat. BAD FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. The Testimony Goes to Fasten Her Parents' Murders on Her. FALL RIavn, Maas., Aug. 29.-Tho testi mony brought out in the Lizzie Borden bearing to-day caused a change of opinion
Two hotel guests, Hawkins and Shaap, give conflicting accounts of a fire at a resort hotel, disputing who tried to help whom and criticizing each other's behavior during the blaze. The dispute centers on Dr. von Ruck's wife's rescue and accusations about panic versus heroism among guests.
Asheville Daily Citizen · 30 August 1892 · page 1
TKHTIBONY. Lizzie Uordeu's Contradictory An swern lo Women Acu.uaiutai.ceH -Very Little Uluod Found on Icr Cioil.ti.tf Nor on the Axon, Fall Kivti), Mass., Aug. 30. The Borden murder trial yesterday was sensationul. Drug Clerk Hence and two others testified that Miss Lizzie Borden attempted to buy prussic acid of Hence the dav before the murders. Mrs. Churchill, the first person on the scene after themurdcr, testified that Miss Borden had told her she was in the barn
At the Borden murder trial, witnesses testified that Lizzie Borden gave contradictory accounts of her whereabouts during the murders, telling one woman she was looking for sinkers and another she was getting metal to fix a window screen. Testimony also noted a drug clerk's claim she tried to buy prussic acid the day before, and witnesses stated there was no blood found on her clothing or hands after the killings.
Asheville Daily Citizen · 30 August 1892 · page 1
Lizzie Borden's Contradictory Answers to Women Acquaintances - Very Little Blood Found on Her Clothing Nor on the Axe
Prof. Edward S. Wood testified at the preliminary hearing that chemical analysis found no blood on the hatchet, axes, or shoes, and that hair found on the hatchet was not human. He also detailed the stomach contents of Andrew and Abby Borden, while witness Alice Russell described Lizzie's calm demeanor and lack of blood on her clothing.
Asheville Daily Citizen · 30 August 1892 · page 1
In the case today the first witness was Prif. Edward S.'Wood, the man lor whom everybody has been looking for davs. He testified as to the examination of the stomachs of Mr. and Mrs. Borden that both stomachs appeared to be per fectly natural. Mrs. Borden's contained about eleven ounces of solid food, par tially digested, and showed wheat starch and water. The stomach of Mr. Borden contained six ounces chiefly water. On the 10th of August witness received from Dr. Dolan a hatchet, two axes, a blue dress skirt, a dress waist, a white starched skirt, a lounge cover and three small envelopes in which were hair I taken from Mr.
See moreSee less
and Mrs. Borden and hair taken from the hatchet. On August 1G witness received a patrol shoes and and a pair of black stockings. The hatchet contained a number of suspicious looking spots, but careful examination showed no traces of blood. livery spot which looked like blood was examined, but no traces of blood were seen. A big smooch on the blue skirt looked like blood, but wns found not to be blood. The white skirt had one spot of blood and it was directly in front about six inches from the bottom. The sitting room carpet was blood stained. There was no blood on the lounge cover. The envelope marked "hair from A. I Borden" was simply white hair; Mrs. Borden's was dark. The hair on the hatchet was not human hair sensation it was more like that taken from an ani mal. The spot on the right shoe was not blood and there was no blood on cither shoes or stockings. The hatchet was produced and Lizzii Borden examined it with us much inter est as did her counsel.
Druggist Eli Bence testified Lizzie Borden tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murders. Mrs. Churchill and Miss Russell gave contradictory accounts of why Lizzie said she was in the barn, and no blood was seen on her dress.
Paper unidentified · 30 August 1892 · page 1
Tho Borden Murder Trial. By Telegraph to News and Observer. Fall River, Mass., August 29. — The borden murder trial today was rather sensational. Drug clerk
Lizzie Borden's lawyers present reasons for believing her innocent, including theories about how she might not have seen an intruder and an explanation for her movements in the house. She flatly denies ever visiting D.R. Smith's drug store to ask for poison, and experts report finding no blood on hatchets or her clothing and no poison in the victims' stomachs.
The Evening World · 30 August 1892 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN DENIES IT.
1b the Girl's Innocence. i ji.ociATin rami. 1 Fail Rivia, Mass., Aug. 30. Defendant's lawyers, who are preparing many arguments showing plausible reasons tor believing In Miss Lints Borden's innocence of murder, sre given aa authorities for the following i Miss Ltxxle Borden probably heard her mother struok down, perhaps heard her tall, aha (Miss Llule) was busy olatterlng about the house, putting Irons on the fire and pounding them on her Ironing board. Hear ing her mother fall would readily account tor readlneis to say that Miss Borden hod en tered tbo house, slammed the front door and gone dlreotly to her room.
See moreSee less
Bridget Sullivan did not see Mr. Borden leave the house or yard, and It does not seem improbable that the others should not have aean any stranger or peddler enter or leave through the back screen door. Miss Llule Borden denies positively that sho was aver at D. it smith's -drug store, where Ell Bene is clerk. 7 BOLLinx. Experts report to-day no blood on the hatchets or on Lizzie Borden's clotbrs , submitted to Uiem. No poison in Btomachs ot murdered couple.
At trial, Prof. Edward S. Wood testified about forensic findings: only a pin-spot of blood was found on Lizzie Borden's clothes, hair on the hatchet was not human, and no poison was found in the stomachs of the murdered Bordens. The defense also circulated theories suggesting Lizzie could have misheard events and that others might have entered unnoticed.
The Evening World · 30 August 1892 · page 1
A PIN-SPOT OF BLOOD.
iichs of tho Murdered I'ulr. fur AMorrATxn rum. I Fit i. HtVKi:, Mass., i. :w. Dntendant's lawyers, who arc preparing maay arguments showing plausible reasons tor bellttlng lu .Miss Lizzie llorc.en'a Innocence of murder, are given as authorities lor the following: Miss Llzlo Dordo.i probably heard licr mother struck down, perhsps heard lierfalL hho (Miss Llirlc) was busy clattering about tho house, putting Iro.is on tho tire and pounding them on nor Ironing board. Hear ing her mother fall would rcaally account lor readiness to say that Miss Borden bad en tered the houso, slammed the Iront door and gone directly to her room.
See moreSee less
Bridget bullltan did not tee Mr. Borden leate the houso or yard, and It docs not seem Improbable that tho others should not have suen any stranger or peddler cuter or lease through tho bad: screen door. Miss Llzilu lioideu denies positively that sho was ever at D. It. smith's drug store, where 111! Hence is clerk. court opened at 10 .10 precisely this morn ing und thn first witness called was Prof. Edward 8. Wood, tho man lor whom every body has been looking lor days. He said he hud received a package contain ing two stomachs on theath cf August and two jars containing milk used on thu 4tn and r,tb of August. iho stomachs wero labelled "Mr." and " Mrs." Borden. They appeared to be per lectly nutural. Mrs. Boidcu'd stomach con. tatocd about cloven ounces or solid food; tbe food was partially digested ana shoirod wheat, starch ana meat. The digestion seemed to bo advanced In tbe neighborhood ot two and a half hours, more or less. The stomach was tested for pruwlu acid, but with a negative result. The stomach ot Mr. Borden contained only six ounces, chiefly water. In Mr. Borden's stomach there was only a small portion ot starch. TheDigestion in his esse, the con tents bring nesrly all water, was much fur ther advanced than In the case ot Mrs. Bor den. Thero were a few threads ot vege table tissue In bis stomach which might have been apple, but could have been pears. Witness had not analyzed the nillx and could not report on that. on tha loth ot Augtut he received from Dr. Dolan a hatchet, two axis, a blue dress skirt, dress waist, white starched skirt, lounge cover ana three small envelopes In which were hair taken from Mr. and Mrs. Borden and balr taxen from the hatchet. On Aug. 10 witness received a pair of black stockings. The h u tenet contained a number ot sus picious looking spots, but careful examina tion shossoa no traces ot blood Every spot which looked like blood was examined, but no traces ot blood wero seen. A big smooch on tbe blue skirt looked like blood, but was found not to be. The white skirt had ouo spot which looked like blood and was found to be. It was directly In front, about six Inches from tbe bottom. The car pet was blood-stained (this was tho sitting room carpet) and there was blood, of course, on that. There was no blood on tbe lounge cover. The envelope marked "nalr from A. J. Borden" was simply white hair; Mrs. Bor den's was dark.
Professor Edward S. Wood testified about his analysis of the Bordens' stomach contents, noting digestion stages and food particles, and found no blood on the hatchet or axes despite suspicious marks. He also reported a single blood spot on the white skirt and confirmed the hair on the hatchet was not human.
Prof. Edward S. Wood testifies about his analysis of stomach contents from both victims, finding natural digestion with wheat, starch and meat present. The headline indicates experts found minimal blood evidence, non-human hair on the hatchet, and no poison in the victims' stomachs.
The Evening World · 30 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
A PIN-SPOT OF BLOOD.
All That the Experts Found on Lizzie Borden's Clothes.
See moreSee less
Axes Not Bloodstained — Hair on the Hatchet Not Human.
And No Poison Found in the Stomachs of the Murdered Pair.
[BY ASSOCIATED PRESS.]
FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 30.—Defendant's lawyers, who are preparing many arguments showing plausible reasons for believing in Miss Lizzie Borden's innocence of murder, are given as authorities for the following:
Miss Lizzie Borden probably heard her mother struck down, perhaps heard her fall. She (Miss Lizzie) was busy clattering about the house, putting irons on the fire and pounding them on her ironing board. Hearing her mother fall would readily account for readiness to say that Miss Borden had entered the house, slammed the front door and gone directly to her room.
Bridget Sullivan did not see Mr. Borden leave the house or yard, and it does not seem improbable that the others should not have seen any stranger or peddler enter or leave through the back screen door.
Miss Lizzie Borden denies positively that she was ever at D. R. Smith's drug store, where Eli Bence is clerk.
Court opened at 10.30 precisely this morning and the first witness called was Prof. Edward S. Wood, the man for whom everybody has been looking for days.
He said he had received a package containing two stomachs on the 5th of August and two jars containing milk used on the 4th and 5th of August.
The stomachs were labelled "Mr." and "Mrs." Borden. They appeared to be perfectly natural. Mrs. Borden's stomach contained about eleven ounces of solid food; the food was partially digested and showed wheat, starch and meat. The digestion seemed to be advanced in the neighborhood of two and a half hours, more or less. The stomach was tested for prussic acid, but with a negative result.
The stomach of Mr. Borden contained only six ounces, chiefly water. In Mr. Borden's stomach there was only a small portion of starch. The digestion in his case, the contents being nearly all water, was much further advanced than in the case of Mrs. Borden. There were a few threads of vegetable tissue in his stomach which might have been apple, but could have been pears.
Witness had not analyzed the milk and could not report on that.
On the 10th of August he received from Dr. Dolan a hatchet, two axes, a blue dress skirt, dress waist, white starched skirt, lounge cover and three small envelopes in which were hair taken from Mr. and Mrs. Borden and hair taken from the hatchet.
On Aug. 16 witness received a pair of black stockings.
The hatchet contained a number of suspicious looking spots, but careful examination showed no traces of blood. Every spot which looked like blood was examined, but no traces of blood were seen.
A big smooch on the blue skirt looked like blood, but was found not to be. The white skirt had one spot which looked like blood and was found to be. It was directly in front, about six inches from the bottom. The carpet was blood-stained (this was the sitting-room carpet) and there was blood, of course, on that. There was no blood on the lounge cover.
The envelope marked "Hair from A. J. Borden" was simply white hair; Mrs. Borden's was dark.
The hair on the hatchet was not human hair. (Sensation.) Was more like that taken from an animal.
The spot on the right shoe was not blood and there was no blood on either shoes or stockings.
There was nothing on the two axes. Near the edge of the hatchet were spots which seemed to be blood, but were found not to be. There was a spatter on the blade, but it was not blood, and there were spots on the side of the head of the hatchet which looked like blood, but were not. (Hatchet produced in court and Lizzie examined it with as much interest as did her counsel.)
One paper was produced by witness on which was written "Hair," placed at (time mentioned), but no hair was there.
On cross-examination Prof. Wood said that the spot on the white skirt looked larger on the outside than on the inside. The size of the spot was about the size of a pin head.
Q. This you say was human blood? A. I don't know; I did not say so. I have not examined it.
Q. Could you tell in what direction this blood came when it struck the skirt? A. I could not.
After some general testimony about the bloodspots on the wall in the room where Mr. Borden lay, and about bloodspurts from arteries, Prof. Wood said it appeared to him that the murderer stood in the dining-room when the first blow was given; this because of the spot found on the frame of the dining-room door.
(Here witness was allowed to look at the stain on the piece of door frame, under his glass, and resuming the stand, said it was not blood.)
A smaller hatchet was handed to the witness, but he said he could not examine it in so short a time as was allowed him. He had spent six or eight hours on the other one. He said there was rust on this one, and rust spots might always be taken for blood until examined. The hatchet was put in his care for full examination.
Witness said it would be impossible for the murderer to escape getting blood on his body in some way. The stains on the sitting-room door might have gone over the head of the assailant as the instrument was lifted. The blood would hit the assailant from the knees up, and the blood on the assailant in the case of Mrs. Borden would be shown anywhere above the feet.
Some controversy arose over a piece of plaster on which a spot of blood was; the plaster was handed over to Prof. Wood for examination, but Mr. Jennings objected, saying that he would not allow it to go out of his possession unless he could be assured that the blood stain would be left where it was. He was willing to admit it was human blood and leave the plaster in the possession of the Court.
The District-Attorney then requested Marshal Hilliard, since it appeared to have come to a matter of physical force, to remove the piece of wood shown on which were blood-stains before they were taken away.
Mr. Jennings asked the Court if he could have the assurance that the plaster would be retained in the custody of the Court, and the Court refused to give that assurance. Then Mr. Jennings quietly put the plaster in his pocket.
At the preliminary hearing, chemist Edward S. Wood testified about the stomach contents of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, noting partial digestion and no prussic acid. He also described examining the hatchet, clothing, and carpet, finding no human blood or hair on the weapon despite suspicious spots.
The Evening World · 30 August 1892 · page 1
A PIN-SPOT OF BLOOD.
i "a", agent for tbe Inman and achs of the Murdered Pair. bt jt.ocitTXD ratal. I Fall Kivik, Mass., Aug. 30. Defendant's lawyers, who are preparing mauy arguments showing plausible rousous tor believing In Miss Llzzlo Borden's lunoccuco of murder, nro given as authorities for the following 1 Miss Llnte Borden probably heard her mother struck down, perhaps beard her fall, bhe (Miss Llzrlc) was busy clattering about tho house, putting Irons on tho fire and pounding them on her Ironing board. Hear ing her mother fall would readily account for readiness to say that Miss Borden had en tered the bouse, Blammed tbe front door and gone directly to ber room.
See moreSee less
Bridget Sullivan did not see Mr. Borden leave the house or yard, and It does not seem Improbable that the others should not have seen any stranger or peddler enter or loave through the back screen door. ' Miss Uz?le Borden denies positively that she was ever at D. It. smith's drug storo, whero Ell Benco Is clerk. Court opened at 10 :ii precisely this morn ing and thn nrst lUtness called was I'rof. Edwnrd 8. Wood, tho man for whom every body has been looking tor days. Ho said he hud received a packago contain ing two stomachs on tho 5th of August and two Jars containing milk used on tho 4th and 3th of August. The stomacus were labelled "Mr." and " Mrs." Borden. They appeared to bo per fectly natural. Mrs. Borden's stomach con tained about cloven ounces ot solid food; the food was partially digested and showed wheat, starch and meat. Tbe digestion seemed to bo advanced In tbe neighborhood of two and a halt hours, more or less. The stomach was tested for prusslo acid, but with a negative rcnult. Thu stomach ot Mr. Uordon contained only six ounces, chlcily water. In Mr. Borden's stomach thoro was, only a small portion of starch. The digestion In bis case, tho con tents being nearly all water, was much fur ther advanced tban In tho case ot Mrs. Bor den. There wero a tow threads ot vege table tlssuo In his etomach which might have been apple, but could have been pears. ltnesa had not analyzed tbe milk and could not report on that. On the 10th of Auguiit he received from Dr. Iiolan a batohet, tno axis, a blue dress skirt, dress waist, white starched skirt, loungo coer andthrco email envelopes in which were hair taken from Mr. and Mrs. Borden and hair taken from tho hatchet. on Aug. 10 witness received a pair ot black stockings. The hatchet contained a number ot sus picious looking spots, but careful examina tion showed no traces ot blood. Every spot wblcb looked like blood was examined, but no traces ot blood woro seen. A big smooch on the blue skirt looked like blood, but was found not to be. The white skirt had ouo spot which looked like blood and as found to be. It was directly In front, about six Inches fiotn tbe bottom, ine car rel was blood-stained (this was the sitting 100m carpet) and there was blood, of course, on that. Tbcro was no blood on the loungo co er. Tbo envelope marked "Hair from A. J. Borden" was simply white hair; Mrs. Bor den's was dark. The. hair on the hatchet was not human hair. '(Seusatlon.) Was more like that taken
Professor Edward Wood testifies at the preliminary hearing about his forensic analysis of the Borden stomachs, finding no evidence of prussic acid poisoning in either victim. The report also previews defense theories suggesting Lizzie may have heard her mother's fall while ironing, which could explain her claimed movements.
The Evening World · 30 August 1892 · page 1
A PIN-SPOT OF BLOOD.
(BY ASIOCIATTD DlkM. I Fall River, Mass., Aug. 30. Defendant's lawyers, who are preparing tnauy arguments Bhowlng plaustblo reasons tor bollevlng In Miss Lizzie Borden's Innocence ot murder, are gnen as authorities tor the following: Miss Lizzie Borden probably heard her mother struck down, perhaps heard her falL She (Miss Llzrle) was busy clattering about tho house, putting Irons on the fire and pounding them on her Ironing board. Hear ing her mother fall would readily account tor readiness to say that Miss Borden had en tcred the house, Blammed the front door and gone directly to her room.
See moreSee less
Court opened at lo.uo picclsely this morn ing and the first wltncis called wai Prof. Edward B. Wood, tho man lor whom every body has been looking for days. Ho said ho bad received a package contain ing two stomachs on the 6th ot August and two Jars containing milk used on the 4th and r.th of August. The stomachs were labelled "Mr." and "Mrs." Borden. They appeared to bo per fectly natural. Mrs. Borden's stomach con tained about cloven ounces of Bolld food ; the food was partially dlgesud and showed wheat, starch and meat. The digestion seemed to bo advanced In the neighborhood ot two and a bait hours, moro or leas. The stomach was tested tor prusslc acid, but with a negative result. The stomach of Mr. Borden contained only six ounces, chiefly water. In Mr. Borden's stomach there was only a small portion of starch. Tho dlgoitlon In his case, tho con tents being nearly all water, was much fur ther advanced than In tho case ot Mrs. Bor den. There were a few threads ot vege table tissue In bis stomach which might havo been apple, but could have been pears. Witness had not analyzed the milk and could not report on that. On the loth ot Augtut ha received from Dr. Dolan a haccbet, two axis, a blue dress aklrt, dress waist, white starched sklr:, lounge cover and three small envelopes In which were hair taken from Mr. and Mrs. Borden nndhalr toxen from the hatchet. On Aug. io witness received a pair ot black stockings. Tho halchet contained a number ot bus plclous looking spot b, but careful examina tion showed no traces ot blood. Every spot which lookod like blood was examined, but no traces ot blood were seen. A big smooch on tho bluo skirt looked like blood, but was found not to be. The whlto skirt had ouo spot which looked like blood and was found to be. Itwssdlreotlyln front, about six Inches from the bottom. The car pel was blood-stained (this was the sitting loom carpet) and there was blood, or ouurse, on that. There was no bloou on the lounge cover. Iho envelope marked "Hair Irom A. J. Borden" was simply white hair; Mrs. Bor den's was dark.
Prof. Wood testifies about the stomach contents of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, noting digestion stages and no prussic acid found. He details examination of the hatchet, axes, and clothing, finding no blood except one spot on the white skirt, and determines hair on the hatchet was not human.
Expert witness Prof. Wood testified that most purported bloodstains on the hatchets, axes, and Lizzie's clothing were not actually blood, with one hatchet having rust mistaken for blood. He also described how the murderer would likely have been spattered with blood based on the crime scene evidence.
The Evening World · 30 August 1892 · page 1
bloonspots on tuo wall In the room whero Mr. Borden lay, and about Dloodpurts irom ar teries. Prof. Wcod said It appearedriojblm that the murderer stood In the dlnlug-room when the first blow was given; this tccause ot the spct lound on tho tramo of the dining-room
A clerk testified that Lizzie Borden came to his drug store three times the day before the murders attempting to buy prussic acid, and was refused each time. This testimony emerged as part of the ongoing investigation into the Borden case.
Morning Appeal · 30 August 1892 · page 3
Lizzie Borden's Case. I A . -w n - Dusmii, ."lugusc jlu lience a drug Clerk tesfitied today that Lizzie lioMen oalled at his store three times the day before the murder, for prus sic acid and was refused.
A filler item from the Eureka Sentinel, reprinted among miscellaneous local notes, muses that if Lizzie Borden killed her father she must have been insane, and if she didn't she must be nearly insane by now from the ordeal. It reflects the uncertainty and dark humor surrounding her unresolved guilt.
Daily Independent · 30 August 1892 · page 3
State Convention at Reno. R. P. Hatnill, of Wells, passed through on No. 4 to-day to attend the Republican State Canveotion at Reno to morrow. Bob is a genuine Silverite. Eureka 9tntin*l:?If Lizzie Borden killed her father she must hnve been j insane at *lre time. If Lizzie Borden |
The preliminary hearing continued with testimony from Mrs. Addie Churchill, a lifelong friend of Lizzie Borden, whose account of finding Mrs. Borden's body and Lizzie's statement about a note has caused many former supporters to doubt her innocence. No blood traces were found on Lizzie's clothing, and no evidence confirmed the note's existence.
The Evening Herald · 30 August 1892 · page 2
FRIENDS ARE DOUBTING
SHE TRIED TO BUY PRUSSIC ACID Tim TpsI Imnnr nf the Wltnpuspi Kxnmlned Ypstcrilny Crnatws n Grrnt Clinnse itl Opinion In Many Quartern Mix Ilnr ilnu Denim ths Drue Clerk's .Story. Fall Riveu, Mass., Aug. 30. Long be foro the hearing In Hie Borden murder case was continued this morning tho court room was crowded to suffocation. The examination was rosumed at 10:10. The testimony brought out in the hear ing yesterday lias caused a change ol opinion among many of Lizzie Borden's friends, who lmvo heretofore stoutly maintained her Innocence.
See moreSee less
They consider the strongest ovidenco given ngalnst lior to bo that of Mrs. Addlo Churchill, the neighbor whom she has known and loved siuco childhood. Mrs. Churrjilll Is a sister of City Audi tor Bufllngtou and duughtcr of tho late Mayor Buulngton, and her testimony has caused n profound sensation. She stated positively that Mrs. Borden's door wus open when shu and Bridget Sul livan llrst discovered tho body of the murdered woman. Again, Mrs. Churchill stated positively that Miss Lizzie to1d her that Mrs. Bor den had receivod a note to call on a sick friend. It has not been proven that any person in this city orelsewhero sent such u note or that Mrs. Borden left tho house
Mrs. Churchill describes finding Lizzie distressed after the murders, recounting Lizzie's claim she had been in the barn looking for sinkers, and notes no blood or disarray on Lizzie at the time. Alice Russell then testifies that Lizzie privately gave a different reason for the barn visit—fetching iron or tin to fix a window—creating a sensation in court.
The Evening Herald · 30 August 1892 · page 2
bors had commenced to come In Lizzie suld agaiu that she wished some ono would go aud try to find Mrs. Borden, for she was sure she had heard her come In, and hero witness described lludlng Mrs, Borden, Witness bad seen Mr. Borden that
The report describes Lizzie Borden's calm demeanor as she listens to testimony at the inquest. Witnesses reportedly swore she had tried to buy prussic acid before the murders.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 30 August 1892 · page 7
LIZZIE IS UNMOVED. She Hears Evidence of Her Seeming Guilt With Coolness.
Buy rrassic Acid. SENSATIONS IN TI1E BORDEN CASS SPECIAL TELEQB AM TO THE DISPATCH.! Fall River, Aug. 29. In the hearing of Lizzie Borden to-day the prosecution
At the hearing in Fall River, the prosecution showed the house was surrounded by witnesses who saw no one flee after Andrew Borden's murder, and that the cellar door was found locked. Testimony included the discovery of the hatchet and axes, contradictory statements by Lizzie Borden, and witnesses who said she tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murder.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 30 August 1892 · page 7
SPECIAL TELEQB AM TO THE DISPATCH.! Fall River, Aug. 29. In the hearing of Lizzie Borden to-day the prosecution showed that the house, at the time of the murfler of Mr. Borden at least, was sur-, rounded on all aides by people who would have seen the murderer had he or she hur ried from the house. None of the witnesses saw anyone enter or leave the house about the time of the killing of Mr. Borden. The State also produced witnesses who swore positively that the cellar door was found to be locked immediately after the discovery of tbe murder.
See moreSee less
Three policemen testified to the finding of the hatchet with the alleged blood on it, and the two axes and smaller hatchet Witnesses related conversations held with Lizzie Borden after the murder and in many instances the statements oHhe accused, as
The prosecution presented contradictory witness statements about Lizzie Borden's demeanor after the murders, including testimony that she tried to buy prussic acid the day before. Neighbor Adelaide Churchill testified in detail about Lizzie's words and actions immediately after discovering her father's body.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 30 August 1892 · page 7
VTlmnsses Surrounded the Honse. The courtroom was chilly and the pris oner wore a heavy black jacket Most of the time she sat with her face burled in the folds of the coat collar. District Attorney Kncwlton called Mrs. Adelaide Churchill to the ktand. Mrs. Churchill said: "I live near the Bordens on tbe north side; that is, the side that the Borden's side door is on. I looked ont of one of the windows and saw Lizzio Borden standing just inside the screen door. 'Oh! Mrs. Churchill.' she said, 'do come over, someone has killed father.'
See moreSee less
I hurried over. L'zzie sat on tbe second stair by the doorway. She said to me: 'I was in the barnnd heard a distressing noise. I came back and found the screen door open and my father dead.' I asked her where her
The report describes evidence emerging at the inquest suggesting a chain of circumstances against Lizzie Borden sufficient to hold her for the Grand Jury. It highlights testimony that she tried to buy prussic acid but was refused, and notes Assistant Marshal Fleet's testimony that she was absent in the barn longer than circumstances would allow.
Pawtucket Tribune · 30 August 1892 · page 2
THE BORDEN CASE The network of evidence seems to be closing somew hat around Lizzie Borden and at present it secms that a chain of circumstances will be woven about her that will at least make It necessary to find her probably gulilty and warrant her being held for the Grand Jury. The poison theory was given guite a promi nence by yesterday’s procecdings and the testimopy of three witnesses went to prove _ conclusively that she at
A newspaper correspondent describes the reading of Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony during the trial, noting the courtroom's intense silence. The testimony recounts her movements on the morning of the murders but becomes increasingly contradictory and vague, especially regarding her mother's whereabouts.
The Providence News · 30 August 1892 · page 1
Her sister, Lizzie said, was at FairfHaven, Bhe usually went to her room at night without saying an&thfinn to unybodr. %0 did not speak to Mr. Morse that night. Her door was fastened into the spare room. Thursday she found Mrs. Borden dust
This report recounts Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony being read at the preliminary hearing, including confused statements about her mother's whereabouts, the axe, and family disputes over property. It notes contradictions in her account and includes an interview with defense counsel Col. Adams expressing confidence after Dr. Wood's testimony.
The Providence News · 30 August 1892 · page 1
THE DEFENCE PLEASED, Col. Adams Says the Defence is Golng In to Win. FALL RIVER, Aug. 40.—Atter the ad journmeut a reporter had an interview with §Col, M. O. Adams, who said: “We were very much surprised at Dr. Wood’s evidence. ! sud b ““We had been prepared to believe we were to be deluged with human blood. ““I think his testimony shows clearly to a fair minded man that Lizzie Borden could not have been gulity of the murder. “1 see no reason now to hesitate about fighting our case to the very end in this court, I think now we may putin some evidence and do battle to win,”
At the Fall River preliminary hearing, Professor Wood testified he found no blood on the hatchet and the shoes and stockings were clean, a setback for the prosecution. A druggist's clerk named Hart testified Lizzie had tried to buy prussic acid days before the murders, while a near-riot broke out downtown over a mistaken suspect.
The Providence News · 30 August 1892 · page 1
SHOES AND STOCKINGS CLEAN.
ISPECIAL TO THE NEWSs. | FALL RIvER, Aug. 30.—Yesterday was the most important day thus far in the great Borden case. It was a day in which the disclosures were of a charscter that shed high lights and deep shadows upon the sayings and doings of Miss Borden. For these the public have anxiously waited. Now they have them-they have evidence both for and against. Are they nearer a decision than before? Perhaps not, but he who carefully weighs the evidence of wit nesses yesterday will have little cause for regret if he is a belicver in Lizzie's in nocence.
See moreSee less
: A brief summary shows that the gov ernment gained one point, though that was a somew hat doubtful testimony, while the defence made two strong points both on the best of authority, The first relates to the poison theory. This the public has looked for long, and basing its expectations upon recent re ports tha diligent search haa failed to reveal any case of the sale of prussic acid on that day, it had almost come to believe
A brief item in a miscellany column remarks that securing a conviction against Lizzie Borden looks difficult. It offers no new facts, just an opinion amid ongoing public interest in the Fall River case.
The Providence News · 30 August 1892 · page 4
—ITHE PROVIDENCE NEWS. NewpPoORT is gray and gloomy, and yet gay and festive, if you can credit such an apparent inconsistency, By the way, the New York ZTimes is not enthusiastic these days in its sup port of Cleveland. SULLIVAN wears green stockings in token that he doesn’'t mean to be done brown, Does Warwick want good roads? Why, certainly, Warwick does. Tue task of convicting Lizzie Borden
The report notes that Professor Wood's testimony at the Borden hearing strengthens the defence, since the fatal weapon has not been found. It argues that if the weapon was not in the house, guilt could not be pinned on any family member given the short window of time.
The Providence News · 30 August 1892 · page 4
Does political history furnish another instance in which a rarty’n plan of cam paign has been totally upset by the de partment report of one of its own party officials? Thus the Worcester Telegram. We infer that the Telegram refers to the re port of Labor Commissioner Peck of New York. It was rather an upset, wasn't it? . Pror. Woon's testimony in the Bor den hearing to-day strengthens the de fence materially, It is evident the fatal weapon has not been found, and if it was not in the house the guilt can hardly be brought home to any member of the family. The awful ten minutes in which Mr. Borden was killed cannot
Testimony at the Fall River hearing, especially from neighbor Mrs. Addie Churchill, damaged Lizzie Borden's case by stating Mrs. Borden's door was open when the body was found and that Lizzie had mentioned a note calling her mother away, though no such note was ever proven to exist. Witnesses also noted no blood was found on Lizzie's clothing, while drug store employees gave testimony considered damaging to her defense.
The Salt Lake Herald · 30 August 1892 · page 1
LOOKS BAD FOR LIZZIE
FALl RIVER Mass Aug 29The testi mony brought out in the Lizzio Borden tearing today caused a change of opinion among her friends c who have heretofore
Witnesses at the Borden murder trial testified that Lizzie Borden attempted to buy prussic acid the day before the murders, and gave inconsistent explanations to Mrs. Churchill and Miss Russell about why she was in the barn. Mrs. Churchill also described Lizzie's distressed state and her claims about her father's enemies and her missing mother.
Richmond Dispatch · 30 August 1892 · page 1
PORCEN MURDER TRIAL. A Sensation—Alleged Contradictory State: ments from Miss Lizaie, a gag pS al LF ml i a oe aadbumiie: RA RD I ol Farr Rives, Mass, August 29.—The Bor den murder trial to-day was rather sensa tional. Drug-Clerk Bence and two others testified that Miss Lizzie Borden at. tempted to buy Prussic acid of Bence the day betore the murder. Mrs. Churchill, the first person on the scene after the murder,
Miss Russell testified under cross-examination that Lizzie showed no blood or signs of exertion after the murders and had not gone upstairs before police arrived. Drugstore clerks testified Lizzie tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murders, while Mrs. Churchill testified the bedroom door was open when the body was found and that Lizzie mentioned a note calling her mother away, though no such note was ever proven to exist.
Richmond Dispatch · 30 August 1892 · page 1
Joliing tee door open, and of her request. ng to be allowed to look 1n first, because she did not know what condition it was in. She looked in, and flading it all nght, let them in, Eh Bence, drug clerk; Frank Kilroy, medieal student, and Frederick B. Hart, employed in a drugstore, testified that the day before the tragedy Miss Borden came into the store and wanted to buy ten cent’
At the Fall River trial, pharmacy clerk Eli Bence testified that Lizzie Borden came to his store three times the day before the murders asking to purchase prussic acid, and that he refused to sell it to her. This testimony was presented as part of the prosecution's case suggesting premeditation.
Alexandria Gazette · 30 August 1892 · page 2
In the Horden trial at Fall River, Mass., yesterday Eli Beuce, a drug clerk, testified that Lizzie Borden call? ed at his store three times the day be? fore the murders for prussic acid and was refused.
Prof. Edward S. Wood testified at the Borden hearing about his analysis of the Bordens' stomach contents and the physical evidence, including hatchets, axes, and clothing. He found no blood on the hatchet, axes, shoes, or stockings, though the sitting room carpet was bloodstained, and determined the hair on the hatchet was not human.
Alexandria Gazette · 30 August 1892 · page 2
The Borden Murder Investigation.
' Mrs. Borden. 1 Continuing, the witness said: On j the 16th of August I received from Dr. ; D?lau a hatchet, two axes, a blu< dress I skirt, dress waist, white starched skirt j lounge cover and three small envelopes, i iu which were hair taken froin Mr. and j Mrs. Borden and hair taken from the ! hatchet. On August 16th witness re i ceived a pair of black stockings. Tl hatchet contained a number of susni cious looking spots, but careful exami? nation showed no traces of Every spot which looked like was examined but no traces of blood were seen.
See moreSee less
The carpet was blood stain? ed. (This was the sitting rooniearpet. Ami there was blood, of course, on that. There was no blood on the lounge cover. The envelope marked '?Hair from A. .1. Borden" was simply white hair. Mrs. Borden's was dark. The hair on the
A witness describes examining bloodstains on the carpet, hatchet, axes, shoes, and clothing, concluding that most suspected blood spots were not actually blood and that hair found on the hatchet was not human. The witness also testified that an assailant would likely have been spattered with blood from the knees up.
Alexandria Gazette · 30 August 1892 · page 2
; Mrs. Borden would be shown anywhere : above the feel. Forcijjn NcwsJ London'. Aug. 30.?A dispatch from Bridgend, Wales, states that the water is flooding some of the galleries in the
At the Fall River hearing, witnesses described Lizzie Borden's demeanor and statements on the day of the murders, noting a contradiction about whether she went to the barn for 'sinkers' or for iron/tin to fix a window. Drug store clerks also testified that Lizzie had tried to purchase prussic acid the day before the killings.
The Times · 30 August 1892 · page 1
EPridget going for Dr. Bowen. About the same time she saw Lizzie standing aeninst the side of the door apparently distressed about something. ‘I opened the window and asked her what was the matter, and she said: ‘Oh, Mrs, Churchill do come over; somebody bos killed father.” 1 went over and asked Ler where her father was and she replied, ‘In the sitting room." Asked her where sl¢ was when it happened and she said she was in the barn looking for something for sinkers.” : Miss Alice M. Russel, next witness, $ ii on the day of the murder she went to the house and found Lizzie Jeaning asriust the door.
See moreSee less
Lizzie told her in an svwer to a question that she went into the barn to get a piece of iron or tin to fix a window with. This testimony caused Al sensstion, as it flatly contradicted st tements made by Lizzie Borden that
Witnesses at the inquest testify about contradictions in Lizzie Borden's accounts of her whereabouts during the murders, including conflicting stories about going to the barn for sinkers versus iron to fix a window. A drug clerk and his colleague testify that Lizzie had tried to buy prussic acid the day before the killings, while police officers recount her vague statements about a mysterious man near the house.
The Times · 30 August 1892 · page 1
"rederick P. Hart, employed in the drag store, corroborated the testimony in rezard to the [russe acid incident and id ntified Miss Borden as the person who hed asked for it. Pitrick H. Dougherty, police officer, testified that he went to the Borden resi
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
Testimony from neighbor Mrs. Addie Churchill and drug store clerks at the Fall River hearing shook the confidence of Lizzie Borden's supporters. Churchill testified that Mrs. Borden's door was open when the body was found and that Lizzie claimed her stepmother had left to visit a sick friend, a claim never corroborated.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 30 August 1892 · page 1
THE BORDEN MURDER CASE. Damaging Evidence Against Little Borden Agitates the Accused Woman. FAI.L RIVER, Mass., Aug. 29.—The testi mony brought oat in the Lizzie Bor
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
The report recounts the August 5 murders of Andrew and Abby Borden by hatchet and notes Lizzie Borden's arrest and detention in Taunton. It outlines the district attorney's anticipated case, including servant testimony placing Lizzie in the house and inconsistencies in her account of the murders.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 30 August 1892 · page 4
SUSPECTED INSANITY
CSIUSPBCTKD ISBANITT. Andrew J. Borden, a rich man of Fall River, and hi* wife, were found murdered in their bouae on the morning of Friday, August 5. Both had been killed by a hatchet, with which the murderer had split their heads open, inflicting numerous wounds. Mr. Borden had been killed while asleep on a sofa in the sitting room on the first floor, while Mrs. Borden waa found lying face downward on the floor in a spare bedroom in the second story, hav ing been struck from behind by the assaa sin.
See moreSee less
Mr. Borden was killed about 11 o'clock, while the condition of Mrs. Bor den's bodv showed that she had been killed at least an hour, and probably one and a half hours, before her husband. Lizzie Borden, the daughter of the mur dered man, has been arrested for the crime, and is now in a felon's cell in Taun ton. The district attorney expects to show that the girl's story concerning her actions during the time that her father and mother must have been murdered Is untrue; the servant girl will testify that the accused daughter was in the house and not at the barn when her father was killed. The state will show that the daughter hated her ftepmother most cor dially and had been on bad terms with her parents for a long time, and will plausibly argue that a stranger, having murdered Mrs. Borden, would not delay escaping a fall hour and a half in order to murder Mr. Borden without knowing when he could arrive home; no robbery was committed. By her own testimony the daughter was in the house when the mother was killed, and yet she did not hear her fall, and the murderer was able to enter and leave the house without being seen by either the daughter or the servant girl, or by persons who were outside the bouse when Mr. Borden was murdered.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
The report details the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden, including servant testimony placing her in the house and the lack of robbery. It draws a parallel to the Norcross bombing case to argue that outwardly sane people can commit insane murders, suggesting Lizzie may be an 'unsuspected homicidal lunatic.'
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 30 August 1892 · page 4
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
An op-ed compares Lizzie Borden to a known insane murderer, arguing she may be an 'unsuspected homicidal lunatic' driven mad by a bleak home life and fear of disinheritance. It cites the brutal, purposeless nature of the killings and Lizzie's allegedly false statements as evidence that an insane person, likely her, committed the crime.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 30 August 1892 · page 4
If Norcross could do business for years without having his sanity suspected until he exploded his bomb in New York city, why may not Lizzie Borden belong to the class of unsuspected homicidal lunatics? Norcross had brooded all his life over his failure to get rich, and finally, his brain giving way, his lunacy took the form of killing a man notorious for succeeding splendidly on the field where Norcross had failed. Why may not Lizzie Borden, brooding for years over the cheerless life she led with a stingy, non sympathetic father and an equally hard nnd avaricious stepmother, whom she hated, have lost her mental balance, and, hearing that her father was about to make a will disinheriting her, or leaving the stepmother the bulk of his property, killed both her parents.
See moreSee less
Of course this provocv tion would be too slight to prompt a sane person to commit so awful a crime, but a»l Burning, as the state does, that the girl had become insane, only a spark was needed to set her brain in a flame of frenzy. Whoever killed the murdered pair was evidently insane; the head of Mr. Borden was hacked repeatedly, showing twelve wounds. The object of the crime was not robbery; the hour and a half which elapsed between the re orders was ample to secure plunder, but none was taken. There was nobody who bad any hostility to Mrs. Borden outside the house, and yet the murderer kills her, makes no attempt to escape, and then kills her husband when it was not necessary to kill Lim to escape, for he was asleep. Add to this the fact that no person, sane or in sane, was seen by anybody to enter the bouse; that Lizzie Borden's story of her
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
At the Borden inquest, drug clerk Eli Bence testified Lizzie tried three times to buy prussic acid before the murders, while Alice Russell revealed Lizzie gave conflicting explanations for her barn visit (iron/tin versus lead sinkers). Neighbor Adelaide Churchill also testified about the morning of the murders and Lizzie's demeanor.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 30 August 1892 · page 2
THE BORDEN HEARING - SOME SENSATIONAL EVIDENCE Regarding the Girl's Visit to the Barn - A Drug Clerk Testifies That She Tried to Buy Prussic Acid From Him Three Times - Her Strange Actions When the Murders Were Discovered
Miss Alice M. Busaell created a actuation by testifying that immediately after the discovery of the murder, Miaa Lizzie Borden told her that her alleged visit to the.barn waa to procure a piece
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Multiple witnesses testify about the morning of the murders, including Lizzie's agitated state and shifting accounts of her whereabouts, plus a neighbor's inability to see intruders in the yard. A drug clerk reveals Lizzie allegedly tried to buy prussic acid the day before the killings.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 30 August 1892 · page 2
SOME SENSATIONAL EVIDENCE
room was open. j Miss Alice M. Russell, the next witness said she went to the house and found Lizzig leaning against the door and she remembered Lizzie telling her, in answered a question, that she went into the bam to get a piece of iron or tin to fix a window with (sensation). Miss Lucy Coolet testified that she was stopping at Dr. Cbagnon's house on the day of the murders to tako care of the telephone. She went at 11:10 and : stayed until 12 o'clock noon. She sat on the piazza all the time because she MAtilri wot intn thn hnusn. From where she sat ?he said she could see all the yard of the Bordens. Daring the
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
This report covers preliminary hearing/inquest testimony including Eli Bence's account that Lizzie Borden tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murders, plus testimony from police and other witnesses about the crime scene and Lizzie's demeanor. It also highlights the prosecution's focus on Lizzie's seemingly premature remark that her mother might also have been killed.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 30 August 1892 · page 2
' after that again about 6 o'clock Fred D. ; Hart, druir clerk, Frank H. Kllroy, me^ dlcal student, corroborated the above. % Joseph Derocbes testified by the aid of an interpreter. He was sawing wood i in John Crowe's yard on the day of the tragedy. Saw no one going over the fence that day nor did he see anybody in the next yard. Patrick H. Doherty, police officer, testified Miss Borden was asked by wit iiesa where ana waa waon tao muraor took place, and alio aald: "In the barn."
See moreSee less
She aald ihs hoard aomeklnd of peculiar noise while the waa there. John Fleet, assistant city marshal,stold < the itory of going to the honse and finding tho bodies. At no timo, the %>;< witness laid, waa Lizzie In teara. The court adjourned until 10:15 a. ra. to-morrow. The atronraat point brought out by this .morninipa teatimony, the v state's officials aav. waa Lizzie's remark,
At the inquest hearing, witness Alice Russell testified Lizzie first said she went to the barn for iron/tin to fix a window, contradicting her later claim of seeking lead sinkers. Druggist Eli Bence testified Lizzie tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murders, while neighbor Adelaide Churchill described the scene immediately after the bodies were discovered.
Wheeling Register · 30 August 1892 · page 1
STILL REMAINS A MYSTERY
Fall River, Mass., Aug.'i* —The court was called to ordor in the mysterious Bor lien case at 10 4f» sharp. but at 9 o'clock the dingy court room was thronged. During tho tuking of testimony Mis* Alice M. Russell created a sensation Oy testifying that immediately after the dis covery of the murder. Miss Lizzie Borden told her that her allogod visit to the barn was to procure a niece of Iron or tin with which to lix a window. This contradicts subsequent statements of .Miss Lizzie that she weut there for lead sinkers.
See moreSee less
Kli Bence, a drug cleric, testified that Liz/io Borden called ut his store three times the day before the murders for pros siac acid, and was refused. Mrs. Adelaide B. Churchill was the first witness eallod. She said she lived next to the Bordens on the north side of the street,
Witnesses at the preliminary hearing describe Lizzie Borden's agitated behavior and statements after the murders, including her claims about going to the barn and concern for her missing mother. Druggist Eli Bence testifies that Lizzie had tried to buy prussic acid from him the day before the killings, claiming it was for a cape.
Wheeling Register · 30 August 1892 · page 1
OUT AT YESTERDAY'S HEARING OF
could ri'f all the yard of tho Borden**. During t#)(• time she was there she saw no one pasjf dk in the yard On cross e'un.i naliunyfhe admitted thu* she was where ono roftiu not see the whole of the Borden
Witnesses testified at the hearing including drug clerks who said Lizzie tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murders, and others who saw no one in the Borden yard that day. Testimony also covered Lizzie's statement to police about being in the barn, her remark to Mrs. Churchill about her mother being killed, and Miss Russell's observation that Lizzie showed no blood shortly after the murders were discovered.
Wheeling Register · 30 August 1892 · page 1
yesterday of the linn of Itedfern. Alexan der & Core pan j*; Australian and New Zealand merchants and bankers, of No. 8 Creat Winchester street Their liabilities amount to 250,000 pounds. There is nothing left of the great rail • road strike at Buffalo, N. 5'. The police : had full charge Sunday night, and xeport ! everything quiet in the yards. A terrible collision of two freight trains, a few miles west of Horton, Kansas, oc curred yesterday on the Chicago, Rock Island and Pacific road, in whicn Brake man Thomas T)ouelass lost his life.
See moreSee less
The two firemen were fatally injured. A mis understanding of orders is said to have caused the collision. Bill Hughes, a noted negro desperado of Chapeyville, Tex , was shot and killed yesterday by Branch Anderson with whom he had’been trying to pick a quarrel for several days. Anderson surrendered. Hrother. At Hopkinsville. Ky., because he refused to loau Henry Jones, a colored mendicant, ten cents, William Miller was fatally shot by Jones last night. Jones escaped. A collision occured yesterday just out side the city of Brussels between an Ostend express train and an Antwerp train. Two persons were killed outright | and eighteen seriously injured. At Springfield. O., forty teamster’s and ! one hundred sho’.vers employed on the city paving have struck for higher wages. Contractor Whitely says he will import labor and the strikers threaten violence. Oliver Wendell Holmes was <1 yester day and to all appearances he is in the en joyment of agood health as at, any time i the past ten years. The Supreme Lodge K. of P. yesterday ; decided upon Washington City as the place I for the next encampment. fere. A special to the Indianapolis ycica from j Anderson, lad., is to the effect that u cbal ! ienge has been issued from that city on be i half of Cfir.gtessmar. Brnurn for a joint de bate with William McKinley, to take place at the great tin plate rally at Elmwood, j Ind., on the loth inst. ; The British bark Newfield. Cant. Scott, | from Sharpness. May 2s. for Brisbane, has been wrecked near Port Campbell Yic ! toria. Eleven of her crew were drowned. An American petition in favor of the re lease from prison of Mrs. Mavbrick, and ne^r i j wfaieh contains the names of Me*damts ti i Harrison and Blaine was presented to the i Queen yesterday. ^ one pasjf dk in the yard On cross e'un.i naliunyfhe admitted thu* she was where ono roftiu not see the whole of the Borden yardjAut shu was sure mat if anybody b*d CR’.fwd the yard she would ha\o heard them. Aftor a recess F.li Hence, drug clerk, tes tilled that he remembered Mu day of the tracedy and was acquainted with I.izz «» Borden. Witness saw her in his store tl o day lieforc and she asged him for ten < « n' * worth of prussic acid to put on a seal »k<r> saeque, or cape, but ho to’.d her he could hut sell it without, a physician's prescription. His attention was called to the fact that she was in the store on Thursday evening and again about six o'clock Fred 1). Hurt, drug clerk, and Frank H. Kilroy, medical student, corroborated the above. .Joseph Poroche* testified l*v tlie aid of an interpreter. Ho was sawing wood in John < rowo s yard on the day of the trn : ody. Saw no one goin * over the fence that day, nor did he see adybody in the next yard. Patrick H Doherty, police oflleor, testi fied Miss Borden was asked by witness where she was when the murder tonic place, and she said: “In the barn ” She said she heard s<•me kind of peculiar no!'* wllilo she waa there. John Fleet told the story of going to the house und finding »bo bodies. At no time, witness said, waa L z ziein tears. Too court aajourneu until ju:i.»b m.to morrow. The strongest point brought out by this mornings testimony theSut«'» oftl ••fain say was Lizzie's remark, speaking of her mother to Mrs. Churchill a< rordfug to that lady’s testimony: “I don't know brt she has been kin** l too.” Lizzie made this remark while telling that she thought she heard her mother come in. What reason, asked the official, did Lizzie have for believing that her mother had been killed, considering the circumstances already brought out, vizi That Lizzie was up stairs when her father came in, when Mrs. Borden had i»een de^d about an hour, and went down stair* aud • told him that his yvife was out, but fai'ed to say anything about thinking she hear t Mrs Borden come in. On tit9 other band, an important fact was brought by Lawyer Jennings in his cross-examination of Miss itusselJ. That iady bathed Lizzie's face and fanned her and did not notice any sign* of blood whaf ever about the accused. 7 nat wes on.y ten or flfteeu minutes after Lizzie called for Bri«lget to come down btairs.
At Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, neighbor Mrs. Addie Churchill testified that Mrs. Borden's bedroom door was open when the body was found and that Lizzie had mentioned a note calling Mrs. Borden to visit a sick friend, though no such note or trip was ever confirmed. Testimony from drug store clerks who saw Lizzie there was also described as damaging to her defense.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 30 August 1892 · page 1
Guilt Fastening on Lizzie Borden Fall River. Mass., Aug. 29.—The testimony brought out in Lizzie Borden’s hearing today caused a change of opinion among her friends, who heretofore stoutly maintained her innocence. They consider the strongest evidence against her to be that of Mrs. Addie Churchill, a neighbor whom she has known and loved since childhood. Mrs. Churchill stated posi tively that Mrs. Borden’s room door was opened when she and Bridget Sullivan* first discovered the body of the murdered woman It already has been stated that Lizzie Borden was in the hallway near the open door when Bridget Sullivan was opening the front door at 1:35 o’clock.
See moreSee less
Again Mrs. Churchill stated positively that Lizzie told her Mrs. Borden had received a-note to call on a sick friend, but it has not yet been proven that any person in the c’tv or elsewhere sent such a note, or that Mrs. Borden left the house at anv time during the day. Like all the rest of the witnesses for the government, she failed to find any traces of blood on Miss Lizzie’s clothing or person. During this testimony the prisoner bit her lip. flushed and bent toward Attorney Adams. The testimony also of Spence, a drug clerk; Frank Kilroy, a Harvard medical student, and Fred Hart, assistant drug clerk, all of whom were in Smith’s drug store when Lizzie was there, seems very damaging to the defendant.
At the preliminary hearing, Prof. E. S. Wood testified he found no trace of poison in the Borden bodies and no blood on the hatchet presented as a possible weapon. He did confirm that Mrs. Borden had been killed roughly two and a half hours before Mr. Borden, based on stomach contents.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 31 August 1892 · page 3
Ueiti Ira Cnae. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 31. Tht court room in which the hearing of Lizzie Borden is being held could not commence to hold tho crowd that gathered long be fore tho hour set for the continuation ol
Prof. Wood testified he found no poison or blood traces on the hatchet, and that stomach contents indicated Mrs. Borden died roughly two and a half hours before her husband, around 9:30 a.m. The report also notes a courtroom clash between Knowlton and Jennings and mentions Knowlton reading Lizzie's inquest testimony aloud.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 31 August 1892 · page 3
THE PRISONER'S STATEMENT READ.
It is stated that all tho .DistrictAttor ney hoped to prove by Prof. Wood's testi mony was that Mrs. liorclen was killed some time before her husband. This fact was well established. He said that the matter in her stomach showed that it had been undergoing the process of diges tion for two or three hours, in his ouni ion about two and a half hours. This proved that Mrs. Borden dieil between S) and 10 o'clock, probably about 0:30. The State has already established that Lizzie was in the hallway leading to Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden's room at 10:35 o'clock, and slit has not yet been able to prove that slit was net in the house between U:15 and ll:l o'clock, when both murders occurred. The unfortunate quarrel between Dis trlct-Attorney Knowlton and Mr. Jen nings at the morning session causes much comment in intelligent circles. The most interesting testimony 01 the day to the general public was that given by District Attorney Knowlton, when In read Miss Borden s testimony at the in quest. There is a creat deal of talk about tht intentions of tho defence. Mr. Adams and Mr. Jennings assert that the govern ment s presentation of its case was in complete, and have deculod to call many witnesses who were supposed to nave been summoned by the State. Dr. Bowen and many others will be called on. Trof. Wood was the first witness called. Ho said he had received a package con tainingtwo stomachs on thooth of August and two jars containing milk used on the 4th and oth of Auust. All were prop erly labelled. The stomachs were labelled "Mr. and Mrs. Borden." The stomachs appeared to he perfec tly natural. Mrs. liorden s stomach con tained about eleven ounces of solid food. Tho stomach was tested for prussic acid but with a negative result. Tho stomach of Mr. Borden contained only six ounces, chiefly water. In his stomach there was only a small quantity of starch; the digestion in his case, the contents being nearly all water, was much further advanced than in tho case of Mrs. Borden. There were a few threads of vegetable tissue in his stomach, which might have been apples. Q. Could they have been pearsl A. Yes.
At trial, Professor Wood described analyzing the Bordens' stomachs, finding no prussic acid and differing digestion levels, and examining the hatchet, axes, and clothing for blood. He testified that suspicious spots on the hatchet and clothes were not blood, except for one spot on the white skirt and blood on the sitting-room carpet.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 31 August 1892 · page 3
At the preliminary hearing in Fall River, Marshal Hilland and other witnesses testified that on the day of the murder the Borden sisters cooperated fully with investigators. The report states it is generally believed Lizzie Borden will be discharged.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 31 August 1892 · page 4
Hearing For the Defense. Fall River, Mass, Aug 31. The hearing for the defense in the Borden case was begun to-day. Marshal Hil lard and other witnesses testified that at the investigation on . the day of the murder the Borden sisters assisted them in every way. It is generally believed that Lizzie Borden, the accused, will be discharged.
Marshal Rufus Hilliard testified at the Borden hearing about being notified of the murders and organizing the search of the barn, yard, and neighboring properties. He described the methodical examination of the hay, lumber area, carriages, and nearby yards for evidence.
Evening Journal · 31 August 1892 · page 1
FORGING THE LINKS,
Blood Spot* - Iiispecting the Ftltow Sham*— Dr. Learned Tc.nttftc*. [By Tel «graph to the Evening Journal.1 Fall IltVHH, Mass., Aug. 31.—It is the general opinion this morning Hint today will close the testimony in tho I Borden Court came in at 10 o'clock case. but Lizzie Borden and her counsel were I n °t in their seats iSnl it was not until ten
A police witness details the methodical search of the barn, yard, and house following the murders, including examination of hay, carriages, and vaults. He describes finding blood spots on the parlor door, pillow shams, and marble, and recounts how two hatchets were later found to have hair on them, discovered by Officer Edson.
Evening Journal · 31 August 1892 · page 1
HOW THE SEARCH WAS MADE.
o'clock. Saw Drs, Dolan, Coughlan, Peclftiam, Dutra and Tourtollet. There were undoubted blood spots on the parlor door but witness did not no tice the chair. He then passed into tlie front entry with Dr. Dolan and into the front room where they said Mrs, Borden's body was found and saw some spots of hi i xi*! on pillow shams. Tlie shams were produced and identi fied; witness said they were given to him oa Wednesday the 10th; he saw them on the bed, however, on the 5th. Tlie bed spread of white was examined aud also the shams. Tho sham with the blood lay next to the bureau. No Personal Search Viatic.
Witnesses describe the police search of the Borden house, including blood spots found on marble and the discovery of hair on a hatchet examined by Dr. Dolan. Dr. Learned also testifies about finding Mrs. Borden's body, noting her arms were under her, not above her head.
Evening Journal · 31 August 1892 · page 1
HOW THE SEARCH WAS MADE.
physician iu Fall he was a practicing River,, and was at the Borden house at 3.15 on the day of the tragedy. Horden'* Position. Mr*. The witness saw Mrs, Boydeu where she was lying ; her arms weiro under the body and not over her head. There were
Professor Woods testified at the inquest that no blood was found on the hatchet examined, and that a pinhead-sized blood spot was found on Lizzie Borden's white skirt. He also stated no poison traces were found, dispelling earlier theories about poisoning.
Evening Journal · 31 August 1892 · page 2
NO BLOOD FOUND ON THE HATCHET, I Th« Foison Theory Disproved by Pro j fessor Woods* Testimony— The Strong I Point Against the Accused Woman Now | Is Her Own Conflicting Testimony, Fall Ritzr, Mass.. Ang. 31.—The testi mony of Professor E. 8. Woods in the Borden inquiry was a combination of sur prises. Two things have been demon strated by the evidence—one, that Lizzie was in her stepmother's room at 0:30, and that was about the time of tho murder, and that she was in her father's room about tho time of bis death.
See moreSee less
It was tho popular belief that Professor Woods would show some traces of poison in the stomachs of tho murdered people and would produce a murdt r-'us looking ax, having a blade 1 from five to seven inches in length. On tho contrary, be pulled ont an innocent looking hatchet from a medium sized trav eling valise, and qnietly but firmly told tho court he could not find tho slightest trace of blood on It, nor was it believed that such an instrument in the bauds of a woman could inflict ghastly wounds. The professor al»o testified that ho had examined the clothiag worn by Lizzie Borden on the day of the murder. Every spot which looked like blood wan examined, but no trace» of blood were »een. A big smirch on the blue skirt looked like blood, but ws* found not to be Mood. The white skirt bad one spot which looked like blood and was found to be blood, and it was directly In front, about nix inches from the bottom. The size of the spot was ifbont the •izo of a piu head. He could not swi a* that it was human blood, as he had not ex amined it sufficiently. The I'nl.on Theory DemotUliua.
Professor Wood's forensic testimony found only a pinhead-sized blood spot on Lizzie's white skirt and no poison traces, undermining the prussic acid theory. His stomach-contents analysis placed Mrs. Borden's death around 9:30 a.m., well before Mr. Borden's, strengthening the prosecution's timeline case against Lizzie.
Evening Journal · 31 August 1892 · page 2
ago that the district attorney hoped to - Î rove by Professor Woods' testimony that 1rs. Borden was killed some lime before j-t her husband. This fact was well estah. Uzhed He said the materials in her stom hch showed that they had boon undergoing the process of digestion between two and throe hours—in his opinion about two hours nud a half. This proves that Mrs. Borden died between U and 10 o'clock, probably als m t 9;30. Tho government has already established that Lizzie was in the hallway leading into Mrs Borden's room at 10:35 o'clock, and she baa not been able yet to prove that she was not in the house between 0:15 and 11:15 o'clock, when both murders occurred.
See moreSee less
The government does not disguise its pleasure at tho positive statements about time made by Professor Wood, which wore unshaken when his cross examination was concluded. During Undertaker Wiuynrd's croas ex amination Attorney Jennings dwelt at length on the position of some keys on thu key »ng taken from Mr. Borden's pocket. The tame matter was referred to in Dr. Do lan's cross examination. The purpose of it has not yet appeared. John Dinme's testimony regarding the impossibility of a man going over the back fence after having committed the murders without being seen drives another contra dictory nail into the defendant's theory that acme one bad escaped undetected in that way. Officer Philip Harrington's description of Miss Borden's cool and collected manner was atrangely at variance with tho agita tiou spoken of by others. Uo also em phasized a well recognized fact when he said that Miss Lizzie heard her father any he would not içt his property for any such purpose, meaning the keeping of a liquor atore. The most interesting testimony of tho day to the general public was that given by Dietrict Attorney Knuwltou when ho read Miss Borden's testimony at tho inquest. Untie*. Evidence at tb. Inquest,
The report covers trial testimony including cross-examinations of Professor Wood, Undertaker Winward, and Dr. Dolan, plus witnesses Dinme and Harrington describing the crime scene and Lizzie's demeanor. It also details District Attorney Knowlton reading Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony about her family relationships, finances, and the morning of the murders.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Professor Edward S. Wood testified at the inquest that he found no poison in the Bordens' stomachs, only partially digested food. He also reported finding no traces of blood on the hatchet despite suspicious spots, though a small bloodstain was found on Lizzie's white skirt.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 31 August 1892 · page 1
NO HUMAN HAIR ON THE HATCHET
The stomachs •o labeled "Mr. and Mrs. Borden." The sto 'hs appeared to lie perfectly natural. Mrs. Borden's stomach contained about eleve of solid food. The food was partially digested ami showed wheat, March and meat. The contents contained chiefly «neat, and there were Vegetable pulp cells which might bo broad or apples. The digestion seemed to be advanced in the neighborhood of two and one-half hours, more less. The stomach w tested for prussic acid, but with negative result. Tire stomach of Mr. Borden contained only ;es, chiefly water. In Mr. Bor I ' I den's stomach there was only a tuiall
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
The report covers trial testimony including Professor Wood's analysis of blood evidence and timing of death, followed by the reading of Lizzie Borden's inquest statement describing her movements, the stepmother relationship, and prior suspicious incidents at the house. Dr. Dolan then filed autopsy records, and Mrs. Churchill was recalled regarding a note Bridget mentioned.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 31 August 1892 · page 1
ment will feel quite certain that there b no flaw in its chain. The first witness was Annie M. White, •fficial stenographer, who said she E esent at the inquest and took notes of s whole examination. Her notes Written out were offered in evide After objection the court decided to ad mit lire statement Lizzie Borden made At the ii quest. It recited the relation ship existing between her and lrer step mother; the story of tire visit, of tiie man to her fat lier about hiring the ■tore; stated that she bad w a navy bine dress on the morning of the der; related the old story of how the family lived; what Bridget was doing the morning of the murder, and the movements of Morse.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Testimony continues in the Borden case preliminary hearing, including Dr. Bowen's account of Mrs. Borden's fear of poisoning the night before the murders and Mrs. Churchill's recollection about a note Bridget mentioned. The defense and prosecution clash over evidence regarding prussic acid, and the court adjourns for a defense conference.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 31 August 1892 · page 1
whether Bridget had said it came from Lizzie or Mrs. Borden. The answer was that Bridget did not say who told iter about the ■r-. A)-^ r A Adains aRke( l n9 a special ruling that the court Btrike out all of that por tion of the evidence relating to prussio acid, but the court declined fc I ha present. the first witness for the defi mse was Dr. 8. W. Bov , wire described the
A court stenographer described how Lizzie Borden's inquest examination was conducted back in August, noting who was present and the duration of sessions. Her inquest testimony was then read into the trial record, covering her age, lack of knowledge about her father's wealth, and a recollection of a dispute her father had with a man seeking money.
Evening Star · 31 August 1892 · page 7
RL&aPt, LIZZIE soztDzq TEnu*ONY. exaumbatwo of Mit Lizzie Borden at inquest waw read. in which she stated sub tiallI th:bt he w-As thirty-two years old;
This fragmented OCR passage describes inquest testimony touching on blood near the stepmother's body, mention of prussic acid, and details of the autopsy performed on the Borden victims. It also references Dr. S. W. Bowen, the family physician, and his account of the timeline between 11 o'clock and the discovery of the bodies.
Evening Star · 31 August 1892 · page 7
aside door of the Mys ILnw. He e hadl beern given est. him. izasse beenI stabbed. p-to what macthe - ,nobody. nr had .he told him her r.d wham witess iterehilt andi Mis and ionsd that r.. I, 'Mr. Borden
The Macon Telegraph reprints a sensational anonymous letter claiming two tramps murdered both the Woolfolk family in Georgia and the Borden family in Fall River. It also notes a 'crazy' individual had confessed to the Borden murders, though detectives remain uncertain of the facts.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Dawson News · 31 August 1892 · page 6
A SENSATIONAL STORY THAT COMES FROM PITTSBURG. Two Tramps Said to Have Murdered the Woeolfolk Family in Bibb County--Cor roborating Circumstanuces. From the Macon Telegraph. Can this be true? Is it possible that an innocent man ‘was hung when Tom Woolfolk met death on the gallows for the murder of his family? One of the most sensational stories ever read has been brought out in con mection with the horrible massacre. The Woolfolk murder has been laid at the door of the murderers of the Borden family at Fall River, Mass.
See moreSee less
People throughout the world have read of the sickening butchery of the family of old man Thomas Woolfolk in Bibb county. It was the most horrible deed then known in the annais of crime. Recently a crime similar in concep‘ion and detail was committed in the little city of Falls River, Mass. An old man named Andrew J. Borden and his wife were brutally murdered in their home on the 4th instant. Circumstantial evidence pointed strong 1y to the guilt of Lizzie Borden, their daughter, and the young woman is now in jail awaiting further developments. Since that time an individual, believed to be crazy, has confessed the crime, but the detectives find themselves as much in the dark as ever as to what they con sider the real facts in the case. The Woolfolk’s Murderers. Yesterday the jpress throughout jthe country was thrown into a fever of ex citement by telegrams stating that a let ter had been received by the Pittsburg, Pa.,|Dispatch, saying that two tramps killed the Borden family and that they were the same who killed the Woolfolk family in Georgia. . The Telegraph received a copy of this letter by wire yesterday from the Pitts burg paper, and every word of it will Pprove interesting reading. . The Letter. - The letter is as follows: ! Pittsburg, Aug. 22.—The following anonymous letter, written on. the paper of a city hotel, was received by the Dis patch through the mails yesterday. ‘lt is self->xplanatory: S “The following are a few and impor tant facts which I wish to make known to the public, and I am very sorry that I can’t come forth and make them per sonally. lam well acquainted with the
A letter sent to the Pittsburg Dispatch claims the Borden murders were committed by itinerant criminals who also killed the Woolfolk family in Georgia. The anonymous writer describes in detail how one of these men allegedly killed Mr. and Mrs. Borden after being surprised in the house.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Dawson News · 31 August 1892 · page 6
FROM PITTSBURG.
I can’t come forth and make them per sonally. lam well acquainted with the party who took the lives of Mr. and Mrs. ‘ Borden of Fall River, Mass. - There are
At the Fall River court hearing, Professor Edward S. Wood testified that no poison was found in the stomachs of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, and that the hatchets and axe showed no blood traces, with hair found on the hatchet being animal rather than human. A bloodstain was found on Lizzie's white petticoat, apparently from contact with the bloody carpet, while her blue dress showed no blood.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 31 August 1892 · page 4
Der Doppelmord in Fall-River
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A German-American newspaper reports inquest testimony about forensic evidence from the Borden murders, including hair found on a hatchet (determined to be animal, not human) and a bloodstain on Lizzie's underskirt attributed to contact with a blood-stained carpet. The report also covers testimony from the undertaker and a policeman, plus excerpts from Lizzie Borden's own inquest statement about family finances and her stepmother relationship.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 31 August 1892 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Testimony at the preliminary hearing covers Lizzie Borden's statements about family finances, a house her father briefly gave then repurchased, her strained but not hostile relationship with her stepmother, and her denial of trying to buy prussic acid in New Bedford. Dr. Bowen, the family physician, testified that Mrs. Borden had come to him fearing she'd been poisoned, and that the household suffered vomiting and nausea the night before the murders.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 31 August 1892 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes a dramatic shift in public sentiment toward Lizzie Borden's innocence after Professor Wood of Harvard testified he found no blood on her clothing or axes and no poison in the victims' stomachs. It notes the government's case appeared weak as the prosecution rested and the defense began.
The Portland Daily Press · 31 August 1892 · page 1
LIZZIE IS GUILTY In the Opinion of Many of Fall River's Leading Men. THE EVIDENCE, HOWEVER, FAILS TO PROVE THEM RIGHT.
Yesterday'* Developments Make the Gov ernment Case Look Feeble—Prof. Wood Could Find No Blood on Clothes and Axes—Lizzie’s Statement at the Inquest—The Case for the Govern ment Closed and the Defence Begun. [Special to the Press.] Fall Riveb, August 30.—Yesterday and today have been eventful in shaping public sentiment as to the guilt or inno cence of Lizzie Borden. Last night
Professor Wood's testimony revealed no human blood was found on Lizzie Borden's clothing and no poison in the victims' stomachs, shifting public opinion toward her innocence. However, prosecution officials claimed this was expected since they believed Lizzie had tried and failed to buy prussic acid before the murders, leading them to theorize she used an axe instead.
The Portland Daily Press · 31 August 1892 · page 1
TO PROVE THEM RIGHT.
was a marked change of opinion. But to those who were posted on the methods pursued by the prosecution,this result was no suri-rise. As one of the leading officials connected with the case said to your correspondent tonight: ’“Do1 you suppose we expected to find poison in those stomaohs? Not much. We might have thought so at one time but when we found that Lizzie Borden had tried to purchase prussic acid the clay be fore the murder and failed in the attempt we gave up expecting much on that poipt.
See moreSee less
Then it was that we realized that as the attempt to procure poison h.ul failed the determined and brooding young woman had resorted to the axe or hat chet.” As far as public opinion in the concrete is concerned it is, as in all such cases, divided, but not divided evenly. Tlio solid business men of the town, such as mill agents, cotton brokers and profes sional men, either give you a direct an swer to the effect That Lizzie Borden is Guilty or else a knowing smile and a refusal to express opinions. Those are the men who, well informed,on the seoluded life: and penurious habits of Andrew J. Borden, know and know well that there has been dis
Professor Edward Woodman describes his analysis of the Bordens' stomachs and organs, noting Mrs. Borden's stomach contained more solid food and less advanced digestion than Mr. Borden's. The report also notes public opinion remains divided on Lizzie's guilt, with skeptics citing sentiment and rumors like the 'wild eyed man' seen by Dr. Handy.
The Portland Daily Press · 31 August 1892 · page 2
Accused Woman. Fall. River, August 30.—Court came in at 10.20, and the first witness called was Prof. Edward 8. Woodman, for whom everybody has been looking for for days. He said he received a package containing two stomachs on the 5th of August and two jars containing milk used on the 4th and 6th of August. All were properly labelled. The stomachs were labelled “Mr.” and “Mrs. Borden.” The stomachs appeared to be perfectly natural. Mrs. Borden's stomach con tained about 11 ounces of solid food. The food was partially decayed aud showed wheat, starch and meat.
See moreSee less
The contents contained chiefly meat and there were vegetables, the pulp cells of which might be bread or apples. The diges tion seemed to be advanced in the neigh borhood of two and one half hours, more or less. The stomach was tested for prussic acid, but with a negative re Dll it. The stomach of Mr. Borden contained only six ounces, chiefly water. In Mr. Borden’s stomach there was only a small portion of starch. The digestion in hil case, the contents being nearly all water, was much further advanced than in the case of Mrs. Borden. There were a few
Dr. Dolan had submitted hatchets, axes, clothing, and hair samples to Professor Wood for forensic analysis. Wood testified that most suspicious spots were not blood, except for one tiny spot on Lizzie's white skirt and blood on the sitting room carpet, and that hair from the hatchet was not human.
The Portland Daily Press · 31 August 1892 · page 2
THE DAY'S PROCEEDINGS.
side of the skirt than on the inside. The ’ size of the spot was about the size of a pin head. The envelope marked “Hair from A. J. Borden” was simply white hair. Mrs. Borden’s was dark. The hair on the hatchet was not human hair,
A medical witness describes bloodstain patterns and testifies that the assailant must have been standing in the dining room when the first blow was struck. A dispute arises over a second hatchet and a blood-stained piece of plaster, with defense attorney Jennings briefly pocketing the evidence in a dramatic courtroom confrontation.
The Portland Daily Press · 31 August 1892 · page 2
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn. · and 1 other paper
A roundup of miscellaneous news items reports that the murder trial of Lizzie Borden has begun at Fall River, Massachusetts. The item is a single sentence among many unrelated news briefs.
New Ulm Review · 31 August 1892 · page 2
4 A general fight occurs at a political meeting South Carolina. The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for mur der begins at Fall River, Mass. W. W. Blackwell ol Kentucky is elected supreme chancellor of the Knights of Pvth las. Miss'Ella Reid, neice of Whitelaw Eeid, will soon be married at Ophir farm to Robert C. Harrison, judge of the supreme court.at California. is seventy years old.* A report touching upon the recent lynch ing of Italians in New Orleans is^presented at the .meeting of the American Bar asso-
The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn. · 1 September 1892
Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn.
The report notes that the hearing of Lizzie Borden at Fall River, Massachusetts, resumed Friday morning. Gruesome details of the murder were presented on the stand, but nothing conclusively incriminating emerged.
Morris Tribune · 31 August 1892 · page 4
Tucker, of Virginia, president. H. F. Stevens, of Minnesota, was elected one of the vice presidents. The controller of the currency has re ceived an application from Fred Pabst and associates of Milwaukee to organize the Wisconsin National bank of Milwau kee with a capital of $1,000,000. The international peace congress, held at Berne, has unanimously decided, to accept the invitation of the North American societies to hold the next in ternational coagrcs^- a.t- .ClLicag[t The directors of the Miime o:a state fair have declared all running races barred out, for the reason that Budd Doble will not trot Nancy Hanks there if the track is to cut up with runners.
See moreSee less
The hearing of Miss Lizzie Borden at Fall Eiver, Mass., was resumed Friday morning. The ghastly details of the murder were told on the stand but noth ing of a convicting nature was brought out. James S. Wilson, agent of the Kansas and Arkansas Valley railroad at Now ata, I. T., was held up and robbed late Monday night by three men supposed to be members of the Daltca gang of train robbers and desperadoes. About $1,000 was secured. There is no use of talking, neither Harrison nor Cleveland will be elected unless they take De Witt's Little Early Risers. They have a "get there" quality possessed by no other pill. Hulburd & Co.
The hearing of Lizzie Borden at Fall River, Mass., resumed Friday morning with ghastly details of the murder presented on the stand. However, nothing of a convicting nature was brought out during the proceedings.
Mower County Transcript · 31 August 1892 · page 3
Tucker, of Virginia, president. H. F. Stevens, of Minnesota, was elected one of the vioe presidents. The controller of the currency has re ceived an application from Fred Pabst and associates of Milwaukee to organize the Wisconsin National bank of Milwau kee with a capital of $1,000,000. The international peace congress, held at Berne, has unanimously decided to accept the invitation of the North American societies to hold the next in ternational congress at Chicago in 1898. The directors of the Minnesota state fair have declared all running races barred out, for the reason that Budd Doble will not trot Nanoy Hanks there if the track is to cut up with runners.
See moreSee less
The hearing of Miss Lizzie Borden at Fall River, Mass., was resumed Friday morning. The ghastly details of the murder were told on the stand but noth ing of a convicting nature was brought out. James S. Wilson, agent of the Kansas and Arkansas Valley railroad at Now ata, I. T., was held up and robbed late Monday night by three men supposed to be members of the Dalton gang of train robbers and desperadoes. About $1,000 was secured.
At the Fall River court hearing, Alice M. Russell testified that Lizzie Borden gave conflicting explanations for her barn visit, first citing a need for metal to fix a window, later claiming she sought lead sinkers. Drug clerk Eli Bunce testified that Lizzie had tried three times the day before the murders to buy prussic acid, but was refused.
Daily Yellowstone Journal · 31 August 1892 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
At the preliminary hearing in Fall River, Prof. Wood testified he found no trace of blood on the hatchet shown in court and no evidence of poison in the victims' stomachs, weakening the prosecution's murder weapon and poisoning theories. The report notes this contradicts the popular belief that Wood would support theories of a bloody axe or prussic acid poisoning, though prosecutors still emphasized Lizzie's unexplained whereabouts during the murder window.
The Helena Independent · 31 August 1892 · page 2
NOT SUCH A STRONG CASE
NOT SUC(' A ST'rONG ('ASE. rroe. Wood's Testimony Very Much in Favor of l.izzle IBorden. FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug, 30.-There were many surprises in the Borden hearing to day, not the least among them being Prof. Wood's testimony. It was the popular be lief that he would show somel traces of poison in the stomach of the murdered people, and would produce a murderous looking ship carpenter's axe having a blade from five to seven inches in length. On the contrary he pulled out an innocent looking hatches, but firmly told the court he could not find the slightese trace of blood on it.
See moreSee less
nor was it likely, he said, that suchan instrument in the hands of a woman could inflict such ghastly wounds. He also demolished the trussio acid and other poisoning theories, and the crowd in the court room wonderedwhat was coming next. Prof. Wood said be looked for traces of all kinds of poison. His failure to find them added much weight to Miss Lizzie Borden's strong denials that she was ever in Smith's drug store. The government has already established that Lizzie was in the hallway leading into Mrs. Borden's room at 10:30 o'clock, and she has not been able yet to prove she was not in the house between 9:15 ynd 11:15 o'clock, when both murders occurred. The government does not die. guise its pleasure at the positive statements about the time made by Prof. Wood. which was unshaken when the crossexamination concluded, John Dintle's testimony regarding the possibility of a man going over the back fence after having committed the murders, without be ing seen, drives another contradictory nail into the defendant's theory that some one escaped undetected that way. The most interesting testimony of the day to the gen eral public was that given by District At torney Knowlton when he read Miss Bor den's testimony at the inquest.
The report describes stenographer's transcript of district attorney questioning Lizzie about her twenty minutes in the barn, during which she claims to have eaten pears and looked for lead. She also described discovering her father's body, not knowing how blood got on the hatchet, and recalled tension with her stepmother over property.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 31 August 1892 · page 1
MISS LIZZIE BORDEN'S STORY
after he camo in: never fixed his head I when he laid down, nor touched the pillow of the lonnge. Lizzie said further that Mrs. Borden's homestead was for sale, and it was bought in by Mr. Bor ; den for her: Lizzie stated that she said
Lizzie Borden testified at the inquest about blood on her skirt, denied ever trying to buy prussic acid, and described seeing a mysterious figure run from the house on two occasions. Family physician Dr. Bowen also testified about arriving at the murder scene and about Mrs. Borden's earlier fear that she had been poisoned.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 31 August 1892 · page 1
the government's case. Dr. H. Bowen, a neighbor and family physician of the Bordens, testified. On the day of the tragedy lie was driving up to his house when bis wife and Thomas Bolles informed him of the af fair. He went directly to the side door of the Borden house, where he met Miss Lizzie. Miss Lizzie said: "Fatlier has been killed; lieen stablied.” She said she had seen nobody nor had she heard anyliody, and then she told me her father was in the sitting room and when witness got there he found Mrs.
See moreSee less
Church ill anil Mrs. Russell; examined Mr. Borden and found that death had come and then said: "Mr. Borden has lieen murdered; when Lizzie went to her room it was liecaiise of advice of witness. He was at the house the morning before, shortly after he had eaten breakfust; had talked Wit h Mrs. Borden at his office anil then went over and talked with Mr. Borden. Mrs. Borden called on witness early Wednesday morning and she was afraid she luid been jsiisoned, and while she was there she came near vomiting; she said that Mr. Borden and herself had been sick the night liefore lietwecn 9 and 18 and that Miss Lizzie had been sick about midnight. _
At the Borden trial, Professor Wood's analysis of Mrs. Borden's stomach contents indicated she died between 9 and 10 a.m., contradicting earlier assumptions about the timeline. This placed Lizzie Borden in the house during the critical period, undermining her alibi despite the absence of bloodstains on her clothing.
Asheville Daily Citizen · 31 August 1892 · page 1
Fall Kiver, Aug. 31. Two things were demonstrated by the evidence yes terday in the Horden case. One was that Lizzie was in her step-mother's room at 9:30 and t lint was about tlu time of the murder, and that she was in her father's room about the time of his death. While to the general public the testimony of Prof. Wood was favor able to Lizzie, because it appeared to demonstrate there was no blood stains on her clothes, it was really against her because of his evidence in regard to the time of death.
See moreSee less
Wood said the contents of Mrs. liorden's stomach showed that they had been undergoing digestion be tween two and three hours. This proved that Mrs. Horden died between 9 and 10 o'clock. The government has already ctablished that Lizzie was in the hall way leading to Mrs. Borden's room at 10:35 o'clock and she has not been able to prove that she was not in the house between 10:15 and 11:15 o'clock, when both murders occurred. The examination of Lizzie Borden at
Lizzie Borden's coroner's inquest statements were presented, including her account of being in the barn and denying ever buying prussic acid at a drug store. Prof. Wood's chemical analysis found no evidence of poison, undermining claims she had purchased it from Smith's drug store.
Asheville Daily Citizen · 31 August 1892 · page 1
DISPROVED
traces of all kinds of common poisons. His failure to find them added much weight to Miss Borden's strong denials that she was ever in Smith's drug store as testified by Bence and others who did not know her personally. All the dis trict attorney hoped t3 prove by Prof. Wood's testimony was that Mrs. Bor den was killed some time before her hus band.
Crowds gathered outside the courthouse in Fall River as Lizzie Borden's preliminary examination resumed, with her lawyer Andrew Jennings and witnesses including Bridget Sullivan and Dr. Bowen present. The prosecutor announced readiness to proceed and called Dr. Dolan to testify.
Weekly Union · 31 August 1892 · page 1
THE FALL RIVER TRAGEDY
_G€rcase was ushered in this morning with the early gathering of crowds about the z@tone building in Court square, where Liz .v’:zie A. Borden is incarcerated. - Although the examination was assigned
At the preliminary hearing, Medical Examiner Dolan gives detailed testimony about the horrific wounds on Andrew Borden's head and face, describing their number, size, and the blood spatter pattern on the wall. He states death resulted from shock due to the wounds and estimates Borden had been dead no more than half an hour when found.
Weekly Union · 31 August 1892 · page 1
and deliberate answers were made. | Thomas Karen, a surveyor, was sworn, | and testified to the correctness of a plan submitted. | Mr. Dolan was recalled: ““As I pulled the sheet off Mr. Borden's face it was the
Dr. Dolan testifies about the wounds on the victim's head and back, describing blood spatter patterns on the bed rail, dresser, and walls. The preliminary hearing before Judge Blaisdell resumes with Dolan under cross-examination by defense attorney Adams, as Lizzie Borden appears calm while Bridget Sullivan looks anxious.
Weekly Union · 31 August 1892 · page 1
OVERCOME
and genial as usual. District-Attf.)rney Knowlton looked as though he hagl el})oyed a good night’s rest. Lawyer Melvin O. Adams was as chipper and graceful as he alwaysis., Lawyer Andrew J. Jennings studiously looked over his notes, and smiled as he thought of some points his side made yesterday. Lawyer Phillips struggled manfully to keep up with Mr. Adams in his cross-ex amination, making longhand notes at short hand speed. Marshal Hilliard looked happy, and the crowd of spectators looked interested. These were the principal poiants in the Borden bearing when Judge Bla,isdell ordered the case to proceed at 10 o’clock this morning, - with Medical Examiner Dolan on the stand, to be further cross-ex amined by Attorney Melviu 0. Adams.
The maid Bridget Sullivan describes the household's morning activities on the day of the murders, including Mr. Borden's breakfast with Morse, her own illness, and instructions from Mrs. Borden to wash windows. She recounts her movements around the house and says she never saw Mrs. Borden alive again after leaving her in the dining room.
Weekly Union · 31 August 1892 · page 2
THE FALL RIVER TRAGEDY
union for 1892, the occasion that hasso long been looked forward to by the sol diers all over the state, and in fact New mEbR RO, o o then went up stairs and put on his tie and - Idid not feel well and was sick to the { came down. stomach and went ouf into the yard to vomit. Came in at 9 o’clock; saw Mrs. Borden in t_he dining roew ; she told me to wash the windows as they were very dirty.
Maid Bridget Sullivan recounts washing windows inside and outside the Borden house on the morning of August 4, describing Lizzie's and Mr. Borden's movements and conversations. She details Lizzie ironing handkerchiefs, discussing a note Mrs. Borden received, and instructions about locking doors.
Weekly Union · 31 August 1892 · page 2
l leading fropa the frofit hall was shut; saw ‘ rothing of Miss Lizzie nor Mrs. Bordea, while I went around the house. There were three windows in the parlor, two in the dining room; two in the sitting room. ' The sink where the dipper was procured was on the east side of the kitchen. Did’nt see Lizzie when I returned first to the house after washing the windows | outside; and began washing the upper part of the inside of the sitting room windows. Had one part of a window done when I went to ~the front door; had heard some one rattling with a key; sup posing it to be Mr.
See moreSee less
Borden went to let him in; found the bolt across the door and the key turned inward. While I was trying to open the lock I Heard Lizzie Laughing Upstairs, in the front hall. Did not expect to hear ber.. Witness here said that she made an ex ' pression which she did not want to repeat. - i and this probably caused Lizzie to laugh.
Bridget Sullivan testifies at the preliminary hearing about the morning of the murders, describing errands, Lizzie's summons to find Mr. Borden dead, and discovering Mrs. Borden's body upstairs. A separate note reports the defense investigating her background in Newport to test her reliability as a witness.
Weekly Union · 31 August 1892 · page 2
BRIDGET'S CAREER IN NEWPORT.
| Dolan’s Testimony Unreliable. ’ FaLL RIVER, MAss., Aug. 28.—The ! hearing in the Borden case will be resumed ! at 10:45 tomorrow morning. The defense has been actively engaged in Newport to-
Police Superintendent Smith received a letter from Lizzie Borden's lawyers stating that Davidson's history is being investigated. Despite the earlier lengthy newspaper coverage, authorities in Fall River now consider Davidson a fraud and attach no importance to developments in his story.
The Jersey City News · 31 August 1892 · page 1
DAVIDSON IS A FR.tUD. Davidson, about whom long screeds were written for yesterday’s papers, is consideieil a fraud in Fall River. Po lice Superintpndaut Smith this afternoon received a letter from the lawyers of Lizzie Borden in which they say that, Davuisuu’s history is being investigated but no importance is attached to the de velopments.
Expert testimony found no blood on either hatchet from the Borden household, which the report says disproves the idea that Lizzie Borden committed the murders herself since no weapon trace exists. The writer concludes she likely knows who did it and was an accessory, rather than the actual killer.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Jersey City News · 31 August 1892 · page 2
since August 11. At the Post Office it is told there Is no remedy. The officials are too busy to do anything about it. This is the result of having the Post office run as a machine under a poli tician like Van Cott with a chief like Wanamaker. There is precisely the same trouble here, a little less in de gree, merely. The Postofflce goes as it pleases and the political bosses of it are too busy to give it any attention. The expert evidence, proving that there was no blood on either of the hatchets in the Borden household, | finally disposes of the notion that Lizzie Borden committed the murder, herself; for, if she did, what did she do with the weapon?
See moreSee less
This conclu sion is borne out by the absence of all trace of blood upon her clothing. But, as the case stands, the pre sumption is almost irresistible that she knows who did it and was in some way accessory to it.
At the Fall River preliminary hearing, expert testimony from Prof. Wood discredited the poison theory and cast doubt on blood evidence from the hatchet, axes, and Lizzie's skirt. The prosecution then closed its case by reading Lizzie Borden's contradictory inquest statements, after which the defense began with Dr. Bowen as its first witness.
The Sun · 31 August 1892 · page 3
THE BORDENS NOT POISONED
I A alaat tha Aceoied Rcit Mittaly oa the Comtradletloaa IB Sfrr Own Tel k ony lit the Inquest nnd In Her Slnlr nanta to Varlnn Caller nt the Ilonia What Hho Maid ci the InnucM PALL RrvKn Aug 30The cose of tho prose cution in the Lizzie Borden case closed at 4 oclock this afternoon The evidence ot the
This report describes the courtroom scene at Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, detailing the judge, counsel, and reporters present. Prof. Edward S. Wood of Harvard then testifies about his examination of the Bordens' stomach contents, finding no evidence of inflammation or irritation, only partially digested food.
The Sun · 31 August 1892 · page 3
POISONED
has a heavy voice and Is short spoken To his ICt facing tho Court sat Lawyer Adams the senior counsel for tho defence Col Adams Is S tall slendor and straight A brown moustache hides a firm mouth and sets on a prominent noeo His forehead is remarkably broad He is quick and nervous and while crossexamin jag witness ho tiros question after question With llghtnlngllko rapidity The prisoner sat directly behind Col Adams Llzzlo Borden is showing the effects of the ordeal through which slio Is passing Her facols palo and worn and the lines are deep ening about her eyes and mouth To tho left of Cot Adams sat Lawyer Jonnlngs Mr Jen nings Is excitable Ho has a drawling voice that Is frequently heard Ills faco is email j t and K bristly moustache hides his mouth
Dr. Edward Wood testifies about his examination of Andrew and Abby Borden's stomach contents, describing food digestion states and timing, and negative results for prussic acid. He also describes receiving evidence including hatchets, axes, clothing, and hair samples from investigators.
The Sun · 31 August 1892 · page 3
PROF. WOOD'S TESTIMONY
t onetenth Bold I omitted to say boforo that 50 in ra Bordeus stomach there wore some t solid bits ot meat In Mr Bordens stomach there was n small quantity of starch and a small quantity of meat Tho principal portion of the solid food In his stomach was vegetable pulp cells They might have been apple or pear cells I judge hat the digestion In his case thero boluc iio little food In his stomach had advanced from throo to four hours It was much further advanced than that of Mm Borden wnK What would you nay the difference was From an hour and a half to two hours There worn n few threads of vegetable thslo 11 In Mr Bordnnb stomach its well I tested the
At Lizzie Borden's murder trial, Professor Edward Wood testified that the stomachs tested negative for prussic acid and that most "blood" spots on weapons and clothing were not blood at all. He also stated that hair found on the hatchet was not human hair, undercutting both the poison and bloodstain theories against Lizzie; the stenographic record of her secret inquest testimony was also introduced as evidence.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 31 August 1892 · page 7
THE DEFENSE FOLLOWING A NEW CLEW
This afternoon was marked by the introduc tion as evidence of the stenographic report of the prisoner's testimony at the secret in quest s Concerning the stomachs of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, which he examined, Prof. Edward Wood said they appeared to be perfectly natural. Tbe stomachs were tested for prus sic acid, hut with a negative result. On 10th of August he received from Dr. Doian a .hatchet, two axes, a blue dress skirt, dress waist, white starched skirt, lonnge cover and three small envelopes, in which were hair taken from Mr. and Mrs. Borden and hair taken from the hatchet.
Prof. Wood, cross-examined at the hearing, held firm that a pinhead-sized blood spot was found and described likely blood spatter patterns on the assailant. The stenographer's transcript of Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony was then read, detailing her account of her father's visitor, family relations, and her shifting statements about her whereabouts during the murders.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 31 August 1892 · page 7
0 blood. Witness said it would be impossi ble for the assailant on the murdered peo ple to escape receiving blood on his body in some way, and that the stains on the sitting room doors might have gone over the head of the assailant as the instrument was lifted. The blood would hit the assailant from the knees up. The blood on the as sailant in the case of Mrs. Borden would be shown anywhere above the feet
The report details Lizzie Borden's testimony before the District Attorney about her movements on the day of the murders, including her account of going to the barn for fishing sinkers and eating pears, and her inability to explain blood found on her skirt. It also includes Dr. Bowen's testimony about Mrs. Borden's fear of poisoning days before the killings.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 31 August 1892 · page 7
Rather a Lnng Time in the Bafrn. - Several pages of the stenographer's copy were devoted to a tilt between the District Attorney and Lizzie, caused by his trving to find out just what Lizzie was doing in the barn to occupy 20' minutes. She ate three pears, and looked out of the window and overhauled a box for the lead. Lizzie raid that Mrs. Borden's homestead was ior sale, and it was bought in bv Mr. Borden for her., Lizzie stated that she said that what she did for her he ought to do lor tnem, meaning-herselt and Emma.
See moreSee less
Then, or about that time, she commenced to feel sorely towards her stepmother. Lizzie conld not tell how the blood came to be on her skirt, unless it cathe from a flea bite; if the blood came from Jhe outside she 'could not tell where it came from. Lizzie said she never went into any drug store in New Bedford at any time to inquire for prussic acid. This closed the government case. Mr., Adams asked as a special ruling that the
Professor Wood testified that he found no blood or human hair on the hatchet, no blood on Lizzie Borden's clothing or shoes, and no poison in the stomachs, surprising the prosecution. The murder weapon has apparently not been found despite thorough searches of the house, including walls and chimneys.
Pawtucket Tribune · 31 August 1892 · page 4
A CLIMAX AND CLOSE
Human Hair and Blood. FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 81.—The stat has closed its cage In the examination of Lizzie Borden amid a serfes of sensations, Protessor Wood bas submitted the result of bis Inquiries, and thoy formed the first sensation. He was expected to produce a whole lot of blood corpuscles ou the scene. Hedid not do it. He testified that he found po blood on the hatchet, no human bair on the hatchet, no blood on the walst or skirt of the outer dress, no blood on the shoes ar stockings, no prussic acid or other polson and no evidence of any in cither of the stownachs. This testimony, delivered with the mat ter-of-fact deliberation of a man of science,
The prosecution closed its case by having the court stenographer read Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony, revealing sharp, contradictory statements about her whereabouts the morning of the murders. The reading exposed tensions with her stepmother and inconsistencies in her account of being on the stairs versus in the kitchen.
Pawtucket Tribune · 31 August 1892 · page 4
The stenographer’s story, fn ite fatthtul ness of detail, (rreoenu a picture of bick erings and bandying of words between the witnéss and prosecuting attorney that with all fair minds should be kept in view, when o«mslderlnfi the frequent con tradiction aa to detalls which the testi mony presenta. The record was of three sittings, st which Miss Borden was frequired to an swer, telling over and over again her ev ery act of that day of the murder. The first sitting consumed three straight hours.
The report describes Lizzie Borden's inconsistent statements to investigators about her whereabouts when her father came home and during the time of the murders, including contradictions about being on the stairs versus in the kitchen. It also covers her explanations about searching for sinkers in the barn, finding pears, and discovering her father's body, as well as her denial of purchasing prussic acid and mention of a mysterious figure seen near the house.
Pawtucket Tribune · 31 August 1892 · page 4
magazine to read until the fire burned up. After following & new line for some time she was asked what made her say she was on the stairs when her father came bome. Bhe sauid she had in mind another occasion when some one came in. She went upetairs after her father went out, lhoulrto sew a pilece of tape on her dress, and didn’t thipk she was gone niore than five minates. She went down cellar, “fiu Mrs. Borden fu the dining room. en she returned the latter was not
The report states the prosecution has rested in the preliminary hearing and that its theories on motive and bloody evidence have been undermined. It argues the government's case is far weaker than the public believed and does not establish probable guilt.
The Providence News · 31 August 1892 · page 4
THE BORDEN CASE. The prosecution in the preliminary hearing against Lizzie Borden has rested, and the mystery of the awful murders remains unsolved, While there is uildoubtedly enough collateral evidence to emable Judge Blaisdell to commit Miss Borden, no one who has carefully followed the case can fail to see that one by one the al leged claims of the government have been shown to be groundless. Its theory of & motive, the supposed blood upon the hatchet, and Miss Lizzie's clothes have been proven entirely without foun dation, According to reports the government was reduced yesterday to the alternative of having no case against Miss Borden or of compelling her to become a wit ness agaiust herself, thereby divulging the full strength of its evidence should she ever be brought to trial.
See moreSee less
The pros ecution chose the latter method, and in so doing confessed that it had no grounds for its assumed confidence in Miss Borden's guilt, Her own testi mony leaves her guilt still open to question because the circumstances were such that straightforward evidence could scarcely have been expected, At that point the case stands, It is much weaker than the public had sup posed. It does not stand the strain of sharp criticism and save in a few pare ticulars it fails to point even indirectly at Miss Borden. The public must still be lenient toward Miss Borden, for the legal lights of a Distriot Attorney, backed by the Attorney General, a whole police force and a corps of private detectives have failed to show good and sufficient reason for believing in the probable guilt of Miss Borden.,
The piece argues that Lizzie Borden's contradictory statements at the inquest should not be seen as evidence of guilt, since an innocent person going about ordinary tasks would not have a clear memory of minor movements before an unexpected tragedy. It suggests a true criminal would more likely have a consistent, rehearsed story, implying the prosecution misjudged human nature in holding her chiefly on this basis.
The Providence News · 31 August 1892 · page 4
MISS BORDEN’'S CONTRADICTIONS. If, as stated, Lizzie Borden was held for examination chiefly on her own con tradictory testimony at the inquest, the prosecution showed very little knowl
This is mostly a satirical political column mocking newspaper editorials and presidential campaign rhetoric through biblical pastiche. It includes a brief aside noting the Borden case is unusual because it seems impossible to determine either guilt or innocence.
The Providence News · 31 August 1892 · page 4
Would not the Democrats have done better had Lho(g framed their tariff plank after Labor Commissioner Peck’s facts were submitted to them ?—N. Y. Com mercial Advertiser. They could, but would they? A Bour bon forgives nothing, forgets nothing, learns nothing. Unless the government has evidence it has not submitted, its course will be stig matized for all time as indecent persecu tion.—Attleboro Suun. This is severe seeing that the Borden case is singular in this, it appears im possible either that Lizzie should or should not have committed the murders.
The report recounts the August 4 murders of Andrew and Abby Borden, describing the axe wounds and the timeline suggesting Mrs. Borden died well before her husband. It notes Lizzie Borden raised the alarm, was later arrested after a week's investigation, and states the case remains largely unresolved with no certainty of conviction.
Yorkville Enquirer · 31 August 1892 · page 2
opposition is expected from the ignorance of \vi the people whom it will 1)0 desirable to in-' 0c I oculate with the remedy. f fv< j ?The Borden tragedy, at Fall River, I Mass., is still the absorbing sensation in the . i Northern newspapei-s. On tlie morning |of August 4, at about 11 o'clock. Andrew |su , J. Borden, a rich man of Fall River, and his i wife, were found murdered in their home at j I Fall River. The heads of both victims had Ssl, i been frightfully* hacked, and there is no other j X< theory than that their murder was accomCI plished by means of an axe or a hatchet.
See moreSee less
I jn, Circumstances showed that Mrs. Borden died j at least an hour or an hour and a half before j her husband. She was in an upstairs room, ' * and her husband down stairs. The murderer, pe is believed to have killed Mrs. Borden, and ed then waitiug for Mr. Borden to return from th the city, took a favorable opportunity to put | nc him out of the way also. The first alarm Lj [ of the tragedy was given by Miss Lizzie I. Borden, a daughter of Mr. Borden, and a step j daughter of Mrs. Borden, within fifteen minbe utes after Mr. Borden was known to have so been alive. After a week's investigations, T1 the police, having run down a theory that sc outsiders were connected with the crime, . directlv charged Lizzie Borden and arrested , - th her. The only motive that tne prosecuuuu has yet been able to assign, was dislike on ca the part of Lizzie Borden for her step mothnc er. Several points have developed in the pV case that seem to indicate Miss Borden's m guilt, but to a very large extent the whole
A brief mention notes that in the Borden case proceedings today, the first witness was Professor Edward S. Wood. No further detail on his testimony is given in this fragment.
Richmond Dispatch · 31 August 1892 · page 1
The Prisoner's Inquest Evidence. By telegraph to the Diepatoh. Farr Rives, Mass, August 30.—In the Borden case to-day the first witness was Professor Edward 8. Wood, the man for whom everybody has been looking for many He the examination of the stomachs of Mr, and Mrs, Borden; that boths stomachs appeared to be per. fectly natural. Mrs. Borden’s con. tained about eleven ounces of solid food, partially digested, and showed wheat, starch, and mest. The stomach of Mr. Borden contained only six ounces, chiefly water, On the 10th of August he recetved from Dr. Dolan Hatcher two axes and a blue dress skirt ; the dress waist, a white starched shirt, a
Testimony details the examination of the Bordens' stomach contents, clothing, and two axes plus a hatchet for bloodstains. The analyst reported no blood found on the hatchet, axes, shoes, or stockings, and that hair on the hatchet was not human.
Richmond Dispatch · 31 August 1892 · page 1
Hatcher two axes and a blue dress skirt ; the dress waist, a white starched shirt, a loungewover, and three small envelopes, in which were hair taken from Mr. and Mra, Borden and hair from the hatchet, on August 16th, The witness received a pair of shoes and a pair of black stockings. The hatchet contained a number of sus. picious-looking spots, but a careful ex amination showed no traces of blood.
The report covers testimony from the preliminary hearing, including medical evidence on time of death, Officer Harrigan's account of Lizzie's calm demeanor and barn alibi, and Lizzie's own inquest statements about family matters, a will, a mysterious visitor, and her shifting accounts of her whereabouts. It also details her strained relationship with her stepmother over the years.
Richmond Dispatch · 31 August 1892 · page 1
THE PRISONER'S EVIDENCE
TROUBLE WITH HER STEPMOTHER, Tazzie had bad some trouble with her step. mother about five years ago, but it was trivial. In some way her relations with her stepmother were not as between mo ther and daughter; changed from calling ber mother to ** Mrs. Borden,” when there were some words over her stepsister, now Mrs. George Whitehead. Emma had stood as a mother to her. She made two state ments about her whereabouts on the day of the murders, when her «father came home. At first she said she was up stairs, then she said she was in the kitchen and to this last story she stuck.
See moreSee less
When she found her father she ran at once to call ber servant, never thinking of calling her stepmothen because she supposed she was out, and she said to Mrs. Churchill that she wished somebody would see if she was in the house. She thought it was not more than five minutes after her father came in when she went to the barn and was there twenty minutes.
The report recounts Lizzie Borden's testimony about past friction with her stepmother, the purchase of the Borden homestead, and her shifting accounts of her whereabouts the day of the murders. It also describes surprising testimony from Professor Wood, who found no blood or poison traces and downplayed the hatchet as a murder weapon.
Richmond Dispatch · 31 August 1892 · page 1
THE HOMESTEAD SOLD, Lizzie said further tbat Mrs, Borden's homestead was for sale and it was bought in by Mr. Borden for her. Lizzie stated that she said that what he did for her be ought to do for them, meaning herself and Emma. About that time she commenced to feel sorely towards her stepmother. she said she never went into any drug store for prussic acid. She said thatabout two weeks before the tragedy she heard or saw somebody run down the steps and away. See saw something similar about the house last winter.
See moreSee less
When she first saw the form recently it was on the back steps and ran towards the baru, Last winter she saw a person run away on a sunday night when she was commg home irom church and told her father of the occurrence, but said nothing to him about the second atiair. This closed the government's case.
The report states that evidence presented at Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing in Fall River, Mass. is very damaging and unfavorable to her acquittal. It predicts she will certainly be sent to the grand jury for indictment.
Staunton Spectator · 31 August 1892 · page 2
-—_____—. '_*he evidence in the p:emlinary tria' of Miss Lizzie Borden of Falls River, j Mass., charged with the murder of her | father and step-mother is very damag- '
Professor Edward Wood testified about the time of death, suggesting Lizzie was in her stepmother's room around the time of that murder and near her father around his death, despite no blood being found on her dress or the hatchet. Officer Harrington also testified she seemed cool and uncommunicative when found, and her coroner's inquest testimony about her father's will and a mysterious visitor was read into evidence.
The Roanoke Times · 31 August 1892 · page 1
BAD DAY FOR LIZZIE BORDEN
Fonnd Upon Her Dress or Hatchet. Rivkh, Aug. 30.?fSpeclall? Two things were demonstrated by evi? dence ?bis mornintr ia the Borden trial. One ia tbat Lizzie was in her step mother's room at 9:30 and that was about the time of tho murder, and that she was ii? her father'sroom about the time of hie death. It is understood that while, to tho general public, the testi? mony of P*of. Wood wae favorable to* Livciie because it appeared to demon? strate there was no blood stains on her clothes or batchet, that it was really against her because of his evidenoe in regard to the time of death.
See moreSee less
Officer Harrington testified-that in one room be found Miss Lizzie and Miss Alice Russell. Lizzie was cool and col? lected, but would not or could not toll the witness anything about tho matter. The examination of Lizzie Borden at the coroner's inquest was put in evi? dence. Miss Borden said her father
Lizzie Borden's coroner's inquest statement was read into evidence, covering her father's property dealings, tensions with her stepmother, and her shifting accounts of her whereabouts on the day of the murders. She also described strangers she claimed to have seen near the house in the weeks and months before the killings.
The Roanoke Times · 31 August 1892 · page 1
BAD DAY FOR LIZZIE BORDEN.
changed from calling her mother to. Mrs. Borden when there were somo words ovor her step sister, now Mrs. George Whitehead. Emma had stood, as a mother to Lizzie. Sho made two statements about her whereabouts on the day of the murders. At first she said she was upstairs, then sho said she was in the kitchen, and to this last Story she stuck. When she found her father she ran at once to call her servant, never thinking of calling her stepmother, because she supposed sho was out, and she said to Mrs.
See moreSee less
Churohill that sho wished some? body would sec if she was in the house. She thought it was not more than five minutes after her father came in when she went to the barn, and was there twenty minutes. Lizzie said further that Mrs. Borden's homestead was for sale and that it was bought in by Mr. Borden for her. Lizzie stated that she said that what he did for her he onghfc to do for them, meaning herself and Emma. About that time she commenced to feel sorely towards her step-mother. She said she never wont into any drug storo for prussic acid. She said that about two weeks before the tragedy she heard or saw somebody run down the steps and away; she saw something sim? ilar about the house last winter. When she first saw tho form recently it was on the back Jteps, and ran towards the barn: last winter she saw a person run away on Sunday night when she was coming homo from church and told bor father of the occurrence, but said noth? ing to him about the second affair. This closed the government's caso.
Dr. Wood testifies at the inquest about his analysis of the Borden stomachs, clothing, and weapons, finding no definitive blood on the hatchet or axes despite suspicious spots. Officer Harrington also describes Lizzie Borden's composed demeanor during the police search of the premises.
The Times · 31 August 1892 · page 1
Borden trial to-day the < in called was Professor Edward 8. Woods. He said he had received a package containing two stomachs on the 5th of August, and two jars containing milk used on the 4th and 5th of August. The stomachs were labeled HR VL ANE EEE. ANT SWVIRaLus TERIT avaunta “Mr, and Mrs. Borden.” The stomachs “Mr, and Mrs. Borden.” The stomachs appeared to be perfectly natural. Mrs, appeared to be perfectly natural. Mrs, Borden's stomach was tested with prussic Borden's stomach was tested with prussic acid, but with a negative result.
See moreSee less
The stom. acid, but with a negative result. The stom. ach of Mr. Borden contained only six ach of Mr. Borden contained only six ounces, chiefly water, Witness had not yet ounces, chiefly water, Witness had not yet apalyized the milk and could not report on apalyized the milk and could not report on that. On the 10th of Augus. [ received that. On the 10th of Augus. [ received frou: Dr. Dolan a hatchet, two axes, a blue frou: Dr. Dolan a hatchet, two axes, a blue dress skiry, dress waist, white starched dress skirt, dress waist, white starched skirt, lounge cover and three small enve skirt, lounge cover and three small enve lopes, in which were hair taken from Mr, lopes, in which were hair taken from Mr, and Mrs. Borden and hair taken from the and Mrs. Borden and hair taken from the
Officer Harrington describes finding Lizzie Borden calm but unable to account for her time in the barn during the murder. The stenographer's notes from Lizzie's inquest testimony are read, detailing her shifting accounts of her whereabouts and relationship with her stepmother.
The Times · 31 August 1892 · page 1
OFFICIAL STENOGRAVPHER EXAMINED, Annie M. White, official stenographer who was present at the inquest aud took notes of the whole examination, was next examined, Her notes as written ont at the examination of Lizzie Borden at the inguest were then | read. Lizzie had stated substantially that she was thirty-two years old; that her father had been married to her stepmother about twenty-seven years; she had no idea of what her father was worth and only knew about part of her father’s real estate, Miss Borden said Ler father about two weeks ago had trouble with a& man whom she did not know.
See moreSee less
They had some talk and she heard the man say: “I thought a man with a reputation for getting money like you would accept my offer.” Her father requested the man to get out, and he went away, saying he would consult
This report details Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony about her twenty minutes in the barn eating pears and searching for lead, and her discovery of her father's bleeding body. It also covers her denial of ever seeking prussic acid at a New Bedford drug store, leading into the start of the defense's case.
The Times · 31 August 1892 · page 1
he chopping block. z GAVE THE ALARM, When she found her father she ran at nee to call her servant, never thinking of alling her stepmother because she sup. osed she was out, snd she said to Mrs, ‘hurehill that she wished somebody would ea if she was in the house, She thought bat 1t was no more thau five wioutes after ier [ather came in when she went to the arn, lizzie said further that Mrs. Bor. len's homestead was for sale and it was ought by Mr. Borden for her.
See moreSee less
Liz. ie stated that she seid that what he did or ber Le ought to do for them, meaning | erself aud Emma, Then, or abouttbat time | he commenced to feel sorely toward her tepmother. Lizzie said she never went nto any drug store in New Bedford at any | ime to inquire for prussic acid: never went |
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
At the Borden hearing, Professor Wood testified he found no trace of poison or blood on the hatchet, undermining theories of poisoning and casting doubt that it caused the wounds. The government nonetheless maintained Lizzie could not account for her whereabouts during the murder window.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 31 August 1892 · page 2
No Poison Found in the Victims' Stom achs—Lizzie's Hatchet Exonerated. FALL RIVKR, Mass., Aug. 30 —There were many surprises in the Borden hearing to day, not the least among them being Pro
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
Professor Wood's testimony undermined poisoning theories and supported Lizzie Borden's denial of visiting a drug store, while also reinforcing the prosecution's timeline placing her near the crime scene. The hearing also covered testimony about escape routes and included District Attorney Knowlton reading Lizzie's inquest statements aloud.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 31 August 1892 · page 2
THE BORDEN MURDER TRIAL.
He also demolished the prussic acid and otner poisoning theories, and the crowd in the court-room wondered what was coming next. Professor Wood looked for stains of all kinds of poisons. His failure to find them added much weight to Miss Lizzie's strong denials that she ever was in Smith's drug store. The government has already established that Lizzie was in the hallway leading into Mrs. Borden's room at 10:35 o'clock, and she has not been able yet to prove that she was not in the house be tween 9:15 and 11:15 o'clock, when both murders occurred.
See moreSee less
The government did not disguise its pleasure at the positive statements about time made by Professor Wood, which were unshaken when the cross-examination was concluded. John Dintle's testimony regarding the possibility of a man going over the back fence after having committed the mur ders, without being seen, drives another contradictory nail into the defendant's theory that BiAe one escaped undetected in that way. The most interesting testi mony of the day to the general public was that given by District Attorney Knowlton when he read Miss Borden's testimony at the inquest.
A report claims Lizzie Borden confessed to police, accusing her sister of betraying her, while simultaneously describing the crowded preliminary hearing before Judge Blaisdell in Fall River with Lizzie and her sister Emma present. The hearing proceeds with District Attorney Knowlton calling Medical Examiner Dolan to testify.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Watertown Republican · 31 August 1892 · page 3
LIZZIE BORDEN CONFESSES. She Declares Her Sister Is the One Who Betrayed Her Guilt.
Betrayed Her Guilt. Boston, Aug. 25. —It is reported that Lizzie Borden, in the presence of tne police matron, accuses her sister of “giving her away.” The story amounts to a practical confession. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 25. — The Second Listrict court has never before had such a crowd as that which greeted Judge Blaisdell this morning. It is the date agreed upon for the hear ing of Miss Lizzie A. Borden on the charge of killing her father with an axe. Clergymen, laymen, physi cians, and more than 150 ladies who w T ere not directly connected with the case were seated and standing in all parts of the room, while inside the rail W’as an extraordinary crowd of report ers and other newspaper workers.
See moreSee less
Ladies occupied more than two-thirds of the seats usually occupied by the curious gang who usually frequent the lower courts. At 10:30 o’clock Charles J. Holmes appeared with Miss Emma Borden on his arm. Miss Lizzie Borden came in
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Professor Edward S. Wood testifies at the preliminary hearing about his examination of the Bordens' stomach contents, finding no poison and documenting the digestion state of their last meals. His analysis of the hatchet, axes, and clothing found that supposed bloodstains were not blood and hair on the hatchet was not human, weakening the prosecution's case.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 31 August 1892 · page 2
IN LIZZIE'S FAVOR
milk used on the fourth and fifth of i August. All were labelled. The stomachs were labelled "Mr. und Mrs. Borden." The stomachs appeared to be perfectc ly natural. Mrs. Burden's stomach t contained abont eleven ounces of solid
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Professor Wood testified about his forensic examination of the hatchet, axes, clothing, and stockings submitted by Dr. Dolan, finding that nearly all suspicious spots thought to be blood were not blood at all. He also noted the hair found on the hatchet was not human and likely from an animal, undermining prosecution evidence linking Lizzie Borden to the murder weapon.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 31 August 1892 · page 2
SET BACK FOR THE PROSECUTION
careful examination showed no traces of blood. Every spot which looked like <. blood was examined, but no trlicos of j blood were to bo seen. A big spot on tho blue skirt looked like blood, but _ u ui 1 . rp,.? ? was lounu not iu uu uruuu. &uu c nkirt had ono spot which looked liko v blood and was found to be ono, and it was directly in from, aboar six incltos from tiro bottom. The carpet was blood_ stained (this was the sitting room car8 pet) and thero was no blood on that.
See moreSee less
a There was no blood on the loungo r cover. . | The entry marked "hair from A. J. ( Borden" was simply white hair; Mrs. , Burden's was dark. The hair on the ,
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The government rests its case at the preliminary hearing, with Professor Wood's testimony establishing that Mrs. Borden died 2-2.5 hours before her husband, around 9:30 a.m., despite finding no poison in Lizzie's stomach samples. Cross-examination covered contradictions in Lizzie's statements, the impossibility of an intruder escaping over the back fence unseen, and Officer Harrington's account of Lizzie's calm demeanor.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 31 August 1892 · page 2
This closod tbe government's case. Prof. Wood's failure to find poison added much weight to Miss Lizzie's strong denials that sho was over in timitns drug store, but although popular opinion ran in these channels it is well to remember that the government officials did not depend especially upon the poison theory. It was given out semi-offlcially some days ago that all the district attorney hoped to prove by Prof. Woods was that Mrs. Borden was killed before ber