Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · and 2 other papers
This digest reports that Lizzie Borden's preliminary examination began in Fall River before a packed courtroom. It also states that an earlier reported jailhouse conversation between the Borden sisters, allegedly containing compromising statements, was denied as baseless by the matron and all parties involved.
Borden sisters in the jail at Fall River, Mass., in which Miss Lizzie, who is ac cused of the murder of her father and step-mother was said to have made
The Bolivar Bulletin · Bolivar, Tenn. · 2 September 1892
The Osceola Times · Osceola, Ark. · 3 September 1892
Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.
At the probable-cause hearing in Fall River, the defense argued no motive or murder weapon had been produced against Lizzie Borden. Witnesses described strange noises and suspicious men near the Borden house, and testimony suggested the house could be easily entered from outside.
Morning Journal and Courier · 1 September 1892 · page 3
fence to Sum Up Its Case To-dny. Fall Biver, Mass., Aug. 80. The de fence in the Borden case showed its line of argument to-day and there are a great many people in the . city who believe to night that it is based on fairly sound rea soning. There are manymore persons talking about the weakness of the govern ment's case than have been heard for some time. It has been shown by reputable wit nesses, each as lira. Chagnon and her daughter that a strange noise was heard in their yard the night preceding the day of the murder that might have been mads by a man climbing the f enoe and moving about the bnildings in the rear of their house.
See moreSee less
They were frightened by the unusual Bounds to suoh an extent that Miss Martha, the daughter, declined to go into the cellar even to look out. Other witnesses, among them Dr. Handy, testified to having seen strange looking men in the neighborhood, wbile a man of sound common sense like Alfred Clarkson, the steam fitter, says the hay in the barn had been slept in and looked as if it had been lain in.
This report recounts testimony from the preliminary hearing about strange men near the Borden house, hay disturbed in the barn, and how easily the house could be entered, while also noting medical doubts that a woman could have inflicted such wounds. It further addresses rumors of stinginess in the household and growing public criticism that Lizzie was repeatedly questioned at the inquest without counsel in an apparent effort to make her incriminate herself.
Morning Journal and Courier · 1 September 1892 · page 3
THRIFTY. Considerable nonsense has been publish ed about close living at the Borden house because it has appeared that mutton and mutton soup were warmed over more than once. As a matter of fact it is well known that a majority of the older families in this section of Massachu setts at least are thrifty in their houshold affairs, and it is not an uncommon thing for them to warm over viotnala. . The ro buBt, healthy forms of Miss Lizzie and Miss iSmma Borden do not show that they had been undergoing a process of slow starvation by a penurious father and un lovable stepmother. CRITICISM.
Medical testimony on stomach contents is reported as weakening the prosecution's timeline case, while defense attorney Jennings prepares to argue the night latch could have let strangers in. The government's theory centers on Bridget Sullivan's testimony placing Lizzie's whereabouts unclear during the window when Mrs. Borden was likely killed.
Morning Journal and Courier · 1 September 1892 · page 3
tbe courts. TO SUM UP. Attorney Andrew J. Jennings will sum nt the case for the defense to-morrow. He will devote most of his argument to show ing the weakness of the Borden night latch, the possibility of strangers entering and leaving tue nouse, ana tne iaos inn there were many suspioious persona ana things seen around the house preceding the tragedies. ;Tha government's oaae has been fully outlined, iiistnci Attorney juiowiton will not nut nis greatest claim tor com mitment upon the fact that Lizzie Borden made erratic statements at tbe inquest.
See moreSee less
Ha will relv particularly on Bridget Sulll van's testimony, backed by that of Prof. Wood. Bridget Sullivan did not know Lizzie's whereabouts from the time she went until she heard ber laugh in tbe front ball upstairs,- near Mrs. Borden's open door, as testified to. During this time the murder of Mrs. Borden could have been committed The government officials' theory is that Mrs. Borden was muraerea while Bridget was washing the outside windows of the house, the furthest point she could be removed from the room where the first tragedy occurred. It would be impossible at that point to hear any person falling in the upper story. Had Mrs. Borden been alive in the house, it seems probable to the s-overnment that she would have de scended to the lower floor to see her hus band, who had been unwell and w tsroteiftftef tiro tain1 visit down street. Miss Liszle conversed with her father about his health, her mail aad some important matters. Some time later Bridget went up stairs and was hardly stretched upon ber bed before she was aroused by Lizzie oalling "Father is ism. dead," or words to a similar effect.
The report describes the preliminary hearing in Fall River, noting defense testimony about strange noises, suspicious men near the Borden house, and disturbed hay in the barn suggesting an intruder. It states public sympathy and belief in the defense's reasoning appear to be growing while the prosecution's case is seen as weakening.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 1 September 1892 · page 1
MISS BORDEN'S CHANCES
ARGUMENTS OF COUNSEL TO-DAY. Close of the Defense CritleUms on the 1 Government' Case Medical Testimony In Rebuttal of the Provocation's Theor ies Sympathy for the Accused Growing. Fall River, Mass., Sep. 1. There is no abatement in the size of the crowd which has daily attended the hearing of Lizzie Borden. The court room was
The report states that the preliminary examination of Lizzie Borden has concluded, with many observers now doubting the strength of the government's case. It cites testimony about strange noises and suspicious men near the Borden house, disputed barn evidence, questions about door locks, and medical doubts that a woman could have inflicted the fatal wounds.
ination of Lizzie Borden is ended and the ^ nSe showt ' d k ' ta lmo of a«d ^ TV. T° P J B - ^ City who believe that it is based on fmrly sound reasoning, mere are many more persons talking about the weakness of the govegti meat's case than have been heard for some time. ! It has been shown by reputable witnesses, such as Mrs. C. H. Aguon and her daughter, that a strange noise was heard iu their yar<1 at 11 t »' clock tllP «'ght preceding the day of the murder; that might have been made by a man climbing the fence and moving about the buildings in tho rear of tbeir house.
See moreSee less
They were frightened by the unusual souuds to such au extent that Miss Martha, the daughter, declined to go in to the cellar even to look out. Other witnesses, among them Dr. Handy, testified to having seen strange looking meu in the neighborhood, while a man of sound common sense like Alfred Clarkson, the steam fitter, says tho hay iu the barn had been stepped iu and looked as if it bad been laid in. Jeromo C. Borden showed how easy it was to enter tho Borden house by the front d«or, and the testimony of Mrs. Brigham shows that it is possible to enter the door, provided one of the inmates does not slip tho bolt or turn tho key,without depending on the spring lock, which does not spring, The record of the butchery os given by Dr. Draper has given rise to grave doubts whether the terrible wounds could have ' Jeen inflicted by a woman, more partiou hy a woman who, since and before the
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Marshal Hilliard described his search of the Borden house, barn, and yard, and the condition of the bodies and bloodstains found. Other witnesses, including Dr. Handy and neighbors, testified about a strange man seen near the house around the time of the murders and unusual noises heard the night before.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 1 September 1892 · page 1
THE BORDEN CASE
a Close. Fall River, Mass., Sept. 1.—When the court opened Lizzie and her counsel were not in their seats, und it was not until ten minutes later that Lizzie ap peared, leaning on the of Rev. Mr. Jubb, bearing upon her face the same look of stoical indifference which 1ms characterized her appcuruuco heretofore in general. The morning taken up with the examination of Marshal Rufus B. Hil liard. He described his visit to the house and the examination of the barn and the yards of the adjacent property; his examination of the bodies and the condition of the rooms in which they they were found; described tho blood Stains on the parlor door and pilh shams and piece of marble.
See moreSee less
The house was thoroughly searched by himself and the officers. No opposition w made by either Emma or Lizzie Borden. In the afternoon Dr. Benjamin J.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
At a hearing, Dr. Benjamin Handy testified to seeing a pale young stranger near the Borden property around the time of the murders, and Delia Manley described someone standing at the gate. Mary Ann and Martha Chagnon testified about hearing a noise at the fence the night before the murders, corroborating each other's accounts.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 1 September 1892 · page 1
11:80 o'clock she positively heard a Iuh though somebod ing the fence, the come from the back of the house ue the kitchen, where theie if twe the Borden Martha Chag preceding witness, testified i ration of her noise at tho fence. I May E. Brighans, Charles F. Sawy I and Jerome C. Burden were examined, but their testimony was of no particular I importance. The evidence I closed. The arguments began at 10:80 this morning. I jump appeared fence be ll Chagnon yards. , daughter of the corrobo »ther iu regard to the th"
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
Professor Wood testified at the inquest that the stomachs contained no poison and no blood stains were found on Lizzie Borden's clothing. The report also describes Bridget Sullivan's revelations of tension between Lizzie and her stepmother, and a letter from Lizzie to her sister Emma describing a suspicious man seen near the house the night before the murders.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 1 September 1892 · page 4
NO POISON IN THE STOMACHS.
I.I/. 7 .I 0 ltordru'H tUotlicH. izziu's examination in tl».* Mr.s, Borden and anything hut •«I which to base wrote to her sister •lier. of the letter c the i
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
The report describes a letter Lizzie Borden wrote to her sister Emma recounting a suspicious man seen near the house the night before the murders, which Lizzie later destroyed. It also recounts a tense exchange between Lizzie and Emma over whether Emma had informed on her to attorney Jennings, followed by the opening of Lizzie's preliminary hearing before Judge Blaisdell.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 1 September 1892 · page 4
disturbed over what she had seen that she went t : of the iudows in the commanding the back yard and watched. She saw a man wlio looked like tlie on«- she had seen ulready, mov ing about, but it was quite dark und she could tuff give liny description of bun. I a Borden showed this letter to I friends i Fai Haven with whom she as visiting, win she received it, and destroyed it, she says, till li also turns out that the letter which
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
The report describes an emotional exchange between Lizzie Borden and matron Mrs. Regan at the jail, followed by courtroom scenes from her preliminary hearing before Judge Blaisdell. Medical Examiner Dr. Dolan testifies about the nature of the wounds, blood spatter patterns, and possible positioning of the killer during the attacks on Mr. and Mrs. Borden.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 1 September 1892 · page 4
A SIGNIFICANT UTTERANCE
Medical Examim r Dwelly, the Rev. II. Ly„, uu«l the Rev. Father Maguire •A Iho-''* present. At 10.30 «»'«dock .1. II. Hol ui« peurod it li Miss Kmnia Borden rollowing tin - d the Rev. Ml. Buck. Miss Lizzie A. Bor«lon ca Marshal Hillard. Miss Borden's face i*p his : Mrs. Brig* • iu last itli
Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan. · and 1 other paper
A roundup of global and national news briefs includes a line stating that Lizzie Borden's trial for the ax murders of her father and stepmother has begun at Fall River, Massachusetts. The item appears amid unrelated stories on disasters, crime, and economic news.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Barton County Democrat · 1 September 1892 · page 2
The trial' of Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and step mother with an ax, has begun at Fall River, Mass. Clifford St. J ohjj, a militiaman, was
Afro-American Advocate · Coffeyville, Kan. · 9 September 1892
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Court convened in Fall River with Lizzie Borden present as attorney Jennings opened for the defense, noting the painful personal nature of defending his old friend's daughter. He argued the murder timeline left little room for Lizzie's involvement, suggesting Andrew Borden's death occurred after Bridget Sullivan last saw him alive, within a narrow window before the alarm was raised.
Evening Star · 1 September 1892 · page 5
TALKING ABOUT THE BORDENS
This Morning. FAL. Rivas. Mass., Sept. 1.- Court camein today at 10:30, and a few minutes after Mis Liszze Borden entered the room and the pro andings began. During the halt hour preceding the entrance of court Mrs. Churehill and Irs. Dr. Bowen, Mis Holmes ant another lady enjoyad them selves apparently very much and laughter was freauent. Mr. Jennings opened for the defense. He mid among other thingi that tbe complaint al leg.s that on the 4th day of August Andrew J. borden was killed by his daughter. He ap prueached the subject with feeling widely dif ferent from any other case he had ever handled.
See moreSee less
Mr. Borden was not only his client. but his friend. and had anybody told him four weeks ago that he should now be pleading for the daughter of ha.' old friend be should have said it was beyond the bounds of credibility. That Andrew J. Borden was murdered there is no doubt and that the time of the murder has been established there is also no doubt. The alarm was given at 11:13 to I1;15 and we know, so far as we can know from the evidence, that the time between Mr. Borden's last en trance to the house and the alarm, from twenty five minutes to half an hour. covers the time fully. What took place alter he got there? Bridget Sillivan told her story and she left him in the sitting room reading a per. Within half an hour Andrew J. Borden to go into the house, have his tall with Lizzie, if he had
Lawyer Jennings argues the wounds show a powerful hand skilled with a hatchet, and criticizes police for ignoring reports of a strange man seen near the Borden house. He suggests Lizzie, Bridget Sullivan, and Morse were not necessarily the only possible culprits, pointing to unexplored outside suspects.
Evening Star · 1 September 1892 · page 5
TALKING ABOUT THE BORDENS.
within two years and the barn broken into Suted; we show something the police ought to within two months and the facte are not dis hve dicovered, the stranger within the gate, as told by Mrs. Manley. They have spent night and day folowing up clues to convict Lizzie Borden. but know noth ing about Mrs. Manley and the man she saw. Why? Because they are not looking for anybody outside. The extraordinary thing is that the
The report states that the case of Lizzie Borden, accused of killing her two elderly parents with an axe, is causing growing sensation in Fall River, Massachusetts. It adds that Lizzie denies her guilt despite all the evidence held against her.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Paper unidentified · 1 September 1892 · page 1
NOTATKI TELEGRAFICZNE Z AMERYKI.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Testimony in the Lizzie Borden case concluded on August 31, with witnesses including Marshal Rufus Hilliard describing the search of the Borden house and Dr. Benjamin Handy recounting his movements near the house on the day of the murder. Lizzie Borden appeared calm throughout, and a dispute arose over a dress pattern sought by the prosecution.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 1 September 1892 · page 1
EVIDENCE CLOSED In the Borden Case—Arguments Begin Thursday
Fall River, Mas*.. Aug. 31,—Tin* testi mony in the Borden case closed today . lizzie Borden entered the «H>urt room ' this morning leaning on the arm ot Kev. Mr. Jtibb, Waring upou her face the ex pression of stoical indifference which has characterized her appearance heretofore in general. The first witness was Marshal Rufus B. Hilliard, who testified to his going to the Bordens' house on the afternoon of the murder anil to making an examination of the premises. Officer Medley of the men who were sent to the house by the witness is now out of town looking up some evidence presented by Kev.
See moreSee less
Mr. Buck, following out sonic sup posed clue in connection with this murder. Witness declined to state what the clue was. The witness said F.tnma Borden said she wanted a thorough examination of all part of the house ami if there were apartments unopened she would furnish keys. In all these searches, the witness said, i there was no attempt to hinder him from making a full examination. The w itness said he did not recollect hav ing seen any unmade dress pattern while" searching the attire. He had sent officers to inquire for such since, hut had Wen un able to get it. ]>istrict Attorney Knowlton made a de mand on Mr. dennings for thut pattern, giving him until this afternoon to produce it. At the afternoon session l>r. Bcnj. .!. Handy was the first witness, lie said he passed the Borden house on the day of the murder at and about lo.**o or li».40; was
Multiple witnesses give inquest testimony about a suspicious man seen near the Borden house, noises heard the night before the murder, and physical observations of Lizzie Borden and the crime scene including a hatchet. Testimony covers visibility experiments, guard observations, and household details from relatives and neighbors.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 1 September 1892 · page 1
is a fence. There is a fence between the Borden and ! Chagnon yards. In r daughter also heard it. in fact her daughter heard it first, and called her attention to it. Martha Chagnon, daughter of the pre ceding w itness testified in corroboration of her mother in regard to the noise at the j fence. In the Borden case today, Mary K. Brig1 ham said she had tried tin* experiment to see if anyone by standing on the up|»cr landing could see a body lying on tin* floor j in the spare room.
See moreSee less
She stood on the land '■ ing. and Mr. Morse served as the other end j of the experiment: she could not see a par ticle of fiis jM*r*on. Charles K. Sawyer testified : Was placed 1 on guard at the Borden House. Lizzie was sitting in a chair very near tin* entry door: saw no traces of irritation or Mood about her features or her clothes: witness said. Was hatchet produced in court yesterday? j He had seen Dr. Coughlin examining prej viouslv and it seemed to be in nobody - care, witness examined it rubbed blade ( and found dry rust, no indication of blood or hair: it was in afternoon but could not state exact time. Jerome C. Borden, lumber dealer, testi fied : Went to the Borden house the day after the tragedy: the front door was elosed. apparently; opened it and had no difficulty in getting in; his going in up (wared surprising to the people in the house. Mrs. I’hobe Bowen, wife of l>r. Bowen: Always know n Krnnia Borden, and know n Lizzie since she lived on the street. She knew of the Bordens Iwing siek the night before the tragedy. Described scenes m the house the morning of the murder about the same as lias already been describ'd by Miss Bussell and Mrs. Churchill. She saw no indications of blood on Lizzie at the time. This elosed the evidence. The arguments begin to morrow . The defence in the Borden case showed the line of argument today, and a great many jweple in this city believe tonight that it ibased on fairly sound reasoning. It lias been shown by reputable witnesses. I such as Mrs. Chagnon and her daughter. I that a strange noise was beard in their yard : at 11 o'clock of the night preceding the day ; of the murder, and might have been made ! by a man climbing the fence and moving ; about the buildings in the rear of their j bouse. i other witnesses, among them Dr. Handy, testified to having seen a strange looking 1 man in the neighborhood, while a man of | pound eomroonsense. like \ If red < lark-on. a steam fitter, says the bay in the barn bad ! been stepped in. and looked as if it bad ! I*e«*n laid in. j Jerome C. Borden showed how easy it : was to enter the Borden house b\ the front I door, and the testimony of Mrs. Brigham | -hows it was possible to enter the door b> I dav, provided one of the inmates doe* not j slip the bolt or turn the key. without de ! IM-nding on the spring!** k whieh «loes not I «l>ri"Si . Today's record of the butchery given by i I Dr. Draper, has again given risen to grav* ;
Witnesses including Jerome Borden and Mrs. Bowen testified about entering the Borden house and the absence of blood on Lizzie, closing out the evidence phase. The report previews the defense's argument emphasizing a mysterious stranger seen nearby, doubts that a woman could have inflicted the wounds, and criticism of Lizzie's inquest treatment.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 1 September 1892 · page 1
The report covers inquest proceedings in the Borden murder case, focusing on Dr. Dolan's testimony about the cause of death and the hatchet found with human hair. It also notes testimony about a will and witnesses including Bridget Sullivan and John V. Morse.
The Somerset Reporter · 1 September 1892 · page 1
Of tne F.rst Chapter in the B' den Murder Mystery. 'I Ik f > >1 iint.lit of l*Mife«» .t s|,u tilltHIII'XI* lllltcliel I" It*- I fM' I > * • • I Kin of Hutu.111 Hair 01 Him. I K»m. Hr. i r. Mn-.( A m - '! ' K f t J..//.1Borden’s nfe - *n pr-'ij.ivi's to be long and bitter, even in . preoin.it irv stage Vi'sferdaV, though much of the tin • w.i- ■ .1 • .1 pied in the routine b i-iiiess «,* e-t.-ti.. -biog the hot of murder.
See moreSee less
’ ne hear ini' u.i'O' f r interest throughout Fai H' New Krigland one iniu-F* miy - n• iwitnessed no such scene atf* • ’ of je-terday when Andrew Borden daughter he.lid without the movement ‘if m ii u-* !e a reeital ghastly in it tarthat o el,< .ted frequent e\< larn i v • come tu see ami hear. Alm*-«t all it the-e-sjon was occupleu bv the festimnny of Medical Hxao..m Jlf.lm It t M' hed the accused only a* Intel vai* In Bulan swears rha' tie cause of de.ith was -hock fr oi ti.' wounds. The Bordens, then, were i. mutilated after having 'lied from {»■ - a Again, t he nature of the -tain on r diet and aXe and on I.l/za-'s < < ' \ ! _• w .is not determined by the doctor's It i ■:; \ . iibedeves the bloww • iv g. v.- . by a hatchet fi ai a• 1 11 wa - F H '•
Medical examiner Dr. Bowen testified that the Bordens died of shock from their wounds and described the hatchet wounds, while other witnesses described Lizzie's demeanor, family quarrels, and a bloody lock of hair found near Mrs. Borden's body. The state closed its case in the preliminary examination at Fall River.
The Somerset Reporter · 1 September 1892 · page 1
A CLIMAX AND CLOSE
\ In.ill I’rtl-SM \ • id. Kai.i L.v i.. M,.-- . \uu :tn Three W iI ue**cj•* .t i\ 1*1 \ i«h I t llle.I I . B**i :ii " a-tinwoman who attempt* d to hut i > !" 1 -cuts Wort II ol pro -|| .1. •! it rn.it I. * ilruu store, on I Ind.i> he!..re the u urder « n her* told * f ln*r.I demeanor idler 1 lie •': -covert of the crime \n oth ersworeth.il Lizzie told him *!n Imard p dial munt about 1 In ' urn 1' * *up p.
See moreSee less
*ed that Mr Borden ...1* murdered. .Mi 1 hnn Ini: told of Li//n - * \p 1 • —• * 1 111 o u _■ 111 that Mr* Borden.t**.., m -i:t haw I..-, u mut’d* red 1 fflit * 1 1 >• dn rty d* III bill., h of hair found oil tin* l|t*d beside which Mrs. Borden lay. ami whit h l”..ketl lisfhoni/l 1 11 mmht have been pulled from Inr head, tit hers told how tln\\ coin tunneled a view of the Borden ;..ud ami th ■ -e ad.i* u . during mm h ! t! • tturn.
The prosecution's evidence in the preliminary hearing against Lizzie Borden has closed, with the report noting three suspicious circumstances: her presence in the house, her attempted purchase of prussic acid, and contradictory statements about her whereabouts. The author assesses the prussic acid evidence as most significant, while noting the opportunity evidence is weak since it cannot be proven no one else had access.
The Portland Daily Press · 1 September 1892 · page 4
THE BOKDEN MURDER CASE. The evidence for the prosecution in the Borden case is closed. This does not necessarily mean that all the evi dence the government has against Lizzie Borden has been put in, for in this pre liminary hearing all that the government is required to do is to make out a case of probable cause, in other words show enough suspicious circumstances to con vince the presiding justice that Miss Bor den should be held to await the action of the grand jury. Yet inasmuch as every body who was likely to have any knowl edge of the facts and circumstances sur rounding the tragedy has been put on the stand by the government, the probability is that about all the evidence the prose cution has against the suspected party has been given.
See moreSee less
There are three things brought out in the evidence that have some tendency to point • to Miss Borden
The piece argues that Lizzie Borden's alleged attempt to purchase prussic acid is the strongest evidence against her, since the poison's lethal qualities suggest homicidal rather than household use. It also notes strong exculpatory evidence, including the absence of blood on her clothing despite expert testimony that the killer would have been heavily bloodstained.
The Portland Daily Press · 1 September 1892 · page 4
THE BOKDEN MURDER CASE. The evidence for the prosecution in the Borden case is closed. This does not necessarily mean that all the evi dence the government has against Lizzie Borden has been put in, for in this pre liminary hearing all that the government is required to do is to make out a case of probable cause, in other words show enough suspicious circumstances to con vince the presiding justice that Miss Bor den should be held to await the action of the grand jury. Yet inasmuch as every body who was likely to have any knowl edge of the facts and circumstances sur rounding the tragedy has been put on the stand by the government, the probability is that about all the evidence the prose cution has against the suspected party has been given.
See moreSee less
There are three things brought out in the evidence that have some tendency to point • to Miss Borden as the guilty party. One is that she is the only person excepting the servant girl, who is knowu to have been in the house near the time of the murder. A second is her attempted purchase of prussic acid. A third is her contradic tory statements as to her whereabouts at the time of the murder. Of these three pieces of evidence by far the most sig nificant is the second, relating to her at tempted purchase of prussic acid. The fact that she was the only person known to have had .the opportunity to commit the murder is very slight evidence unless it can be shown that nobody else could nave naci uie opportunity. uul shown and cannot be. Her contradic tory statements are of some significance, yet tlie contradictions, assuming that the witnesses have remembered accurately what she said and repeated it exactly, are not of a very serious character. But her attempted purchase of prussic acid, if it be conclusively established, is a very serious matter, because it is diffi cult to explain it except upon the theory that she intended to use the poison to destroy human life. Prus sic acid is not a poison which is used to destroy vermin with like arsenic, nor to kill cats and dogs, like strychnine. If she had wanted a poison for either of these purposes, it is extremely improb ble that a person of Miss Borden’s intel ligence would have selected prussic acid But on account of its exceeding viru lence, the smallness of the dose required to produce death and its rapidity of ac tion, it wpuld quite naturally be selected as the best of the poisons for homicidal purposes. Therefore if it were estab lished beyond all reasonable doubt that Miss Borden attempted to purchase prus sic acid it would go very far to prove that she was meditating murder near the time of the tragedy. This alleged pur chase of prussic acid is, it seems to us, by far the strongest piece of evidence the government has presented against the accused. Indeed it is about the only piece which standing alone is worth any thing as showing guilt. On the other hand the government has brought out many facts strongly tending to prove the innocence on the part of the accused. The fact that no blood has been found on any of her clothing except a spot on an underskirt no larger than the head of a pin is very strong evidence in her favor. Prof. Wood, the expert, does not hesitate to say that the person who committed the murder must have been profusely spattered with blood. But it is proved that Miss Borden was seen by several people a few minutes after the murder and none of them detected any sign of blood spots upon her clothes. Furthermore frequent and thorough searches of the house have revealed no womanly garment with a spot of blood upon it, except the white underskirt, and the spot on that only as large as the head of a pin and not necessarily human blood. Furthermore most persistent search has failed to reveal any weapon with blood on it, though the weapon with which the deed was done must have been thorough ly covered with it. It ;is hardly con ceivable that within the short time which elapsed between the murder and its dis covery Miss Borden could have so i thoroughly destroy ed all the spattered clothing and bloody weapons that no evi dence of that sort could be found. The truth is the more this tragedy is examined into the deeper the mystery becomes. There are some circumstances which tend to implicate Miss Borden, the prussic acid incident jf conclusively established being by far the 6tronges1 one, and there are some circumstances which seem to very strongly negative any assumption of guilt on her part. While 1 possibly the government have evidence enough to secure her committal to awail 1 the action of the grand jury, it is perfect ly obvious that they have come very fai ' short of making out a conclusive case against her.
The report examines evidence from the preliminary hearing, noting the lack of blood on Lizzie Borden's clothing except a pinhead-sized spot, and the absence of a bloody weapon, as strong points favoring her innocence. It concludes that while the prussic acid incident is the strongest point against her, the government has not made a conclusive case, though enough may exist to send her to the grand jury.
The Portland Daily Press · 1 September 1892 · page 4
THE BORDEN MURDER CASE.
On the other hand the government has brought out many facts strongly tending to prove the innocence on the part of the accused. The fact that no blood has been found on any of her clothing except a spot on an underskirt no larger than the head of a pin is very strong evidence in her favor. Prof. Wood, the expert, does not hesitate to say that the person who committed the murder must have been profusely spattered with blood. But it is proved that Miss Borden was seen by several people a few minutes after the murder and none of them detected any sign of blood spots upon her clothes.
See moreSee less
Furthermore frequent and thorough searches of the house have revealed no womanly garment with a spot of blood upon it, except the white underskirt, and the spot on that only as large as the head of a pin and not necessarily human blood. Furthermore most persistent search has failed to reveal any weapon with blood on it, though the weapon with which the deed was done must have been thorough ly covered with it. It ;is hardly con ceivable that within the short time which elapsed between the murder and its dis covery Miss Borden could have so i thoroughly destroy ed all the spattered clothing and bloody weapons that no evi dence of that sort could be found. The truth is the more this tragedy is examined into the deeper the mystery becomes. There are some circumstances which tend to implicate Miss Borden, the prussic acid incident jf conclusively established being by far the 6tronges1 one, and there are some circumstances which seem to very strongly negative any assumption of guilt on her part. While 1 possibly the government have evidence enough to secure her committal to awail 1 the action of the grand jury, it is perfect ly obvious that they have come very fai ' short of making out a conclusive case against her.
A brief report notes extraordinary public interest at Fall River in the hearing of Lizzie Borden, suspected of murdering her father and stepmother. The courtroom was crowded, with many women among the spectators.
Crawford Avalanche · 1 September 1892 · page 8
Miss Borden In Court. Extraordinary Interest was manifested at Fall River in the hearing of Miss Lizzie Borden, who Is suspected of having mur dered her father and her stepmother. The court-room was crowded, and among the spectators wero many women.
The preliminary hearing of Lizzie Borden at Fall River, Mass., resumed on Friday morning. Grim details of the murder were given on the stand, but nothing conclusively incriminating emerged.
The Sauk Centre Herald · 1 September 1892 · page 4
Tucker, of Virginia, president. H. F. Stevens, of Minnesota, was elected one of the vice presidents. Mrs. General John A. Logan has un dertaken to raise $1,000,000 from the women of this country for the American University, the national institution founded by the Methodists at Washing ton. The international peace congress, held at Berne, has unanimously decided to accept the invitation of the North American societies to hold the next in ternational congress at Chicago in 1893. The directors of the Minnesota state fair have declared all running races barred out, for the reason that Budd Doble will not trot Nancy Hanks there if the track is to cut up with runners.
See moreSee less
The hearing of Miss Lizzie Borden at Fall River, Mass., was resumed Friday morning. The ghastly details of the murder were told on the stand but noth ing of a convicting nature was brought out. James S. Wilson, agent of the Kansas and Arkansas Valley railroad at Now ata, I. T., was held up and robbed late Monday night by three men supposed to be members of the Dalton gang of train robbers and desperadoes. About SI,OOO was secured.
Multiple witnesses testify about Lizzie Borden's behavior and explanations on the day of the murders, including conflicting accounts of why she was in the barn. A drug store clerk and his colleagues testify that Lizzie had tried to purchase prussic acid the day before the killings.
The Princeton Union · 1 September 1892 · page 7
IMPORTANT TESTIMONY
From where she sat she said she could see all the yard of the Bordens. During the time she was there she saw no one passing in the yard. O cross-examination it took ju st fifteen minutes io witness and Mr. Jennings to come to an understanding as to where th^ fence was located between the Chagnon and Borden houses, and then witness admitted that she was where she could, not see the 'whole of the Bbrden yard, but she was sure that if anybody hud entered the yard she would haye beard them.
See moreSee less
Eli Bence, drug clerk, testified that he re membered the day of the tragedy, and was acquainted with Lizzie Borden. Witness saw her in his store ihe day before, and she asked him for ten cen ts wortli ot prussic acid to put on a sealskin sack or cape, but he told her he could not sell it without a physician's prescription. His attention was called to the fact that she was in the store on Thursday evening and soon after that again at 6 o'clock. Frank Kilroy. medical student testi fied. Knew Miss Bordensa her morning. Witness was sitting in the shop when she came in, and Mr. Bence went be hind the counter to wait on her heard her say "prussic acid," and him say "can't sell it without a prescription," and then heard her say "sealskin cape." Then she went out. Frederick Hart, an employe in the diug store, corroborated th testimony oi' t.:e previous witness in regard to the p. us sic ac id incident, and then identified Miss Borden as the person who had asked for the stuff. Joseph Roches testified by the aid of an interpreter. was sawing wood in John Crowe's yard.on the day of the trag edysa no one go over the fence that day, uordid: he see anybody in the yard. The strongest point brought out by. the morning's testimony, the state's officials Lizzie's remark, speaking of her say,, was1 mother to Mrs. Churchill, according to that lady's testimony, "1 don't know but she has been'killed too." Lizzie made this re mark while telling that she "thought she heard her mother come in. What reason, ask the officials, did Lizzie have ior belie v ing thai her mother had been killed, con sidering the circumstances already brought out viz.: That Lizzie was up stairs when her father came in, when Mrs. Borden had been dead about an hou r, and went down stairs and told him that his wiie was out, but failed to say anything about thinking she heard Mrs. Boiden come in.
Witnesses testified that Lizzie Borden tried to buy prussic acid at a drug store before the murders, and a store clerk identified her. Mrs. Churchill testified Lizzie said she feared her mother had also been killed, which officials found suspicious given her earlier silence about hearing Mrs. Borden return.
Several witnesses testify about a pale young stranger seen near the Borden house on the morning of the murder, and about suspicious sounds and disturbed hay in the barn. Another witness states no blood was found on Lizzie Borden's clothes or features, and the hatchet examined showed only dry rust.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 1 September 1892 · page 2
POINTS FOR THE FAIR DEFENDANT
peared to be a young man. Mary Chagnon, wife of Dr. Chngnon, heard a noise as though somebody was jumping the fence atxiut 11 o'clock the night before the murder. The sound appeared to come from the back of the house near the kitchen where there is a fence lietwcen the Borden and Chagnon yards; her daughter also heard it and was mnch frightened. Alfred Clarkson, plumber, was at the Borden house on the morning of tho murder about 11:40; went .into tlie barn as soon as he got through: went in the upper part of the barn and found the door at tho west slightly open, tho hay looked as though it had born stepped on and one place on the north of the center of the west window it looked ns though somebody had sat down on the hay.
See moreSee less
Charles F. Sawyer who was on guard at the Borden house on the morning of the murder, saw no traces of blood about Lizzie Borden's features or clothes; saw the hatchet and found a dry rust, but there was no indications of lllood or hair. Mrs. Phoebe Bowen, wife of Dr. Bow en. knew of tho Bordens lining sick the night before the tragedy. She saw no indications of blood on Lizzie at this time. This closed the evidence.
Several witnesses testified about sounds and sightings near the Borden property before the murders, and a plumber described disturbed hay in the barn loft. Other witnesses stated they saw no blood on Lizzie Borden's clothing or person, and found only dry rust on the hatchet.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 1 September 1892 · page 2
Druggist Eli Bence testified Lizzie Borden had tried to buy prussic acid from him the day before the murders, which he refused to sell without a prescription. Professor Edward S. Wood described receiving the stomachs, viscera, and weapons for analysis, noting the hatchet showed suspicious spots but no confirmed blood traces.
Gloucester County Democrat · 1 September 1892 · page 2
a Close. Fall Kivj.it, Mass., Aug. 30.—The ! court came in on the Borden case at j 10:45 sharp, hut at 8 o’clock the dingy j court room was thronged and the in- | teres ting details of the district court j were listened to by those who were as- ! senibled. Eli Beuce, drug clerk, testified that . he remembered the day of the tragedy j and was acquainted with Lizzie Bor den. Witne&s saw her in his store the day before aud she asked him for ten ; cents’ worth of prussic acid to put on a j sealskin sack or cape, but he told her he could not sell it without a physician’s prescription.
See moreSee less
His attention was called to the fact that she was in the store on Thursday evening, and soon after that again, or about 6 o’clock. His attention was called to the fact that she was the (laughter of Andrew Borden.
At the preliminary hearing, Professor Wood testified that the hatchet and other items sent to him showed no blood traces, though the hair on the hatchet was not human. Marshal Hilliard and other witnesses described the crime scene, blood stains, and a mysterious young man seen near the Borden house.
Gloucester County Democrat · 1 September 1892 · page 2
THE BORDEN CASE.
but no traces of blood were seen. The hair on the hatchet was not mi man hair (sensation), more like that taken from an animal In the afternoon t the first witness was Annie M. White, j official stenographer, wlio said she was I present at the inquest aud took notes of ' the whole examination. Her notes as written out were offered in evidence. After objection the court decided to ad mit the statement Lizzie Borden (bade at the inquest. Fall Rivi h, Mass., Sept. 1.—When the court opened Lizzie and her counsel were not in tlieir seats, and it was not until ten minutes later that Lizzie ap peared, ou the arm of Rev.
See moreSee less
Mr. Judd. The morning was taken up with the examination of Marshal Rufus B. Hil liard. He described his visit to the house and the examination of the barn and the yards of the adjacent property; his examination of the bodies and the condition of the rooms in which they they were found: described the blood Stains on the parlor door and pillow shams and piece of marble. The house was thoroughly searched by himself and the officers. No opposition was made by either Emma or Lizzie Borden.
This report covers the resumption of Lizzie Borden's murder trial, focusing on defense counsel Jennings' opening statement. Jennings argued about the timeline of Andrew Borden's murder, suggesting the brief window of opportunity made it implausible that Lizzie committed the crime.
The Fall River preliminary examination of Lizzie Borden concluded, with the case now proceeding to a grand jury. Defense attorney Jennings argued the timeline of the murder made it implausible that Lizzie could have committed the crime, given Bridget Sullivan's testimony about Andrew Borden's movements.
The Evening World · 1 September 1892 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN HELD. Her Caso Must Now Go Before the Grand Jury. She Bursts Into Tears at a Refer ence to Her Father. The Examination at Full River Con
At the Fall River preliminary hearing, neighbor Mrs. Churchill described Lizzie's distressed announcement that her father had been killed, including Lizzie's claim she had been in the barn. Alice Russell then testified that Lizzie privately gave a different reason for the barn visit, contradicting her earlier account.
The Stark County Democrat · 1 September 1892 · page 1
Visit to tho Itnrn Tho State Hns Pro duced I'nout.li Kvlclcnco to Hold Ilcr. A Point for tho Defendant. Fall, River, Mass., Aug. 30. The hearing in tho Borden caso was con
Officers Dougherty, Mulally, and Fleet testify about arriving at the Borden house, examining the bodies, and conversations with Lizzie Borden about her whereabouts and a mysterious man she claimed to have seen. Testimony reveals inconsistencies, including Lizzie's claim of being in the barn for sinkers versus other accounts, while Alice Russell's cross-examination notes no blood was seen on Lizzie after the murders.
The Stark County Democrat · 1 September 1892 · page 1
AROUSES MUCH INTEREST
of tho bodies was about tlio same as was Dr. Dylan's. The liouto was searched throughout, all but ono room Emma's when they got down cellar the cellar door was unlocked. Miss Borden was asked by witness, whero she was when tho murder took place, and sho said: "In tho barn." She said sho heard some kind of peculiar noiso wliilo she was there a kind of scraping noise. Witness said that Lizzio said that neitlior Mr. Eddy nor any other man who worked for Mr. Borden would hurt him. Considera
Testimony revealed Lizzie told Mrs. Churchill she thought she heard her mother come in, raising questions about why she feared her mother was killed given the timeline of events. Defense attorney Jennings countered by eliciting testimony from Miss Russell that she saw no blood on Lizzie shortly after the alarm was raised.
The Stark County Democrat · 1 September 1892 · page 1
IlAnnisnuBO, Pa., Aug. 29. Tho largo barn owned , by James Boyd, situated at Boyd station, on the Phila delphia and Reading Tnilroad, a short dlstanco below this city, was burned no signs of any hair on it. yestorday, Threo mules, ono horse, ono steer, one colt aiwl all tho crops wero v - - . HI' bumedl Tho loss is estimated at be bcluvas wwxa'A aiiowM &Ara tween $15,000 and$2Q000, partly covered out stopping. As ho weighs' abat 810 by insurancp, Tua origin of tho flro is pounds that performance in certainly unknown, credltableiohUtow and, Nwuld.
See moreSee less
dies -. to Airs. Uiuimu. a'Ou, j.ig to that lady's testhuo'.iv: "It.o not know but she has been killed, too." Lizzie made tills remark while telling that she thought sho hoard her mother come In. What reason, ntked th officials, did Lizzio havo for believing that her mother had boon killed, considering tho circumstances already brought out, viz: That Lizzio was upstairs when her father camo in. when Mrs. Borden had been dead about an hour, and went down stairs nnd told him that his wife was out, but failed to say anvthing about thinking she hoard Mrs. Bordon como in. On tho other hand, nn important fact was brought out by Lawyer Jennings in tho cross-examination of Miss Russell. That lady bathed Llzzlo's faco and fanned her, and did not notice any signs of blood whatever about the nccused. That was only ten or fifteen minutes after Lizzio had called for Bridget to come down stairs.
La Correspondencia De Puerto Rico · San Juan, P.R.
A short New York telegram dated August 12 reports that Lizzie Borden, a 35-year-old woman in Fall River, Massachusetts, has been arrested on suspicion of killing her parents with a hatchet. The item appears amid a roundup of unrelated international telegrams on cholera, Venezuela, and labor unrest.
La Correspondencia De Puerto Rico · 1 September 1892 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes the defense's case nearing its end, with witnesses testifying about strange noises, suspicious men, disturbed hay in the barn, and the ease of entering the Borden house. It also notes growing public sympathy for Lizzie Borden and doubts about whether a woman could have inflicted the fatal wounds, based on Dr. Draper's medical testimony.
The Evening Herald · 1 September 1892 · page 3
looked as if it had been lniu in. Jerome C. Borden showed how easy It was to entertho Borden house by the front door, aud the testimony of Mrs. Brll?hAm nhnwn t.hni It. Id nnaafMo in .i
This report covers the final day of testimony in Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, featuring Marshal Hilliard's detailed account of his investigation of the Borden property, including searches of the barn, yard, and neighboring properties. Several witnesses also testified about seeing a strange young man loitering near the premises around the time of the murders.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 1 September 1892 · page 6
MR. BORDEN'S SLAYER. He Might Have Been a Young Man Whom the Neighbors Saw LOITERING NEAR THE PREMISES.
THE TESTIMONY IS NOW COMPLETE Fail Biver, Mass., Aug. 3L AH the testimony in the preliminary murder trial of Lizzie Borden is no win. The features of the evidence .to-day was the description by
Marshal Hilliard and other officers testify about their systematic search of the barn, yards, cellar, and house following the murders, describing bloodstains found on furniture, doors, and pillow shams. Witnesses recount the order of rooms examined and evidence collected, including the marble bureau piece and bloodied shams.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 1 September 1892 · page 6
THE TESTIMONY IS NOW COMPLETE
AH the NelghborlDE Yards Inspected. A thorough examination was made of the lay in the barn. He went into the back yard where the lumber was by the Chagnon fence and looked over into the Chagnon property and also into the Crowe and Kelly yards and then to the vault, then to the barn, where they were overhauling the hay; then to the tower of the barn, where they were examining the carriages. He searched the stalls on the north of the barn and under the stairway; in fact, all down Etairs; then sent officers to search other yards.
See moreSee less
r "Witness then went into the house. He Faw no other officers in the house when he went in. This was about 4 o'clock. He and three or tour doctors were in the room where Mrs. Borden's body lay and were in consultation. He spoke to Dr. Dolan abont the matter and looked at the sofa, but could not say whether any part of it was cut. He could not tell whether there was any blood spots on the head of it. There were blood spots on the parlor door, but he did not notice the chair. They were blood spots undoubtedly. 3Ir. Borden's body was then removed from the lounge. Then he passed into the front entry with Dr. Dolan and into the front room where they said Mrs. Borden's body was found. He saw some spots of blood on the pillow shams.
Witnesses testified about seeing a pale young stranger in gray clothes loitering near the Borden house on the morning of the murder. Neighbors also described hearing noises the night before, as if someone were jumping the back fence near the kitchen.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 1 September 1892 · page 6
Mary Ann Chagnon, wile of Dr. Chagnon, was at home the night before the murder, but not on the day of 'he murder. She went away about 11 o'clock that day to Cen tral Falls. The' night before the" murder witness said that between 11 and 11:30 o'clock she heard a noise as if somebody was jumping the fence. The sound appeared to come from the back of the house near the kitchen, where there is a fence between the Borden and Chagnon yards. Her daughter also heard it. In fact her daughter heard it first and called her attention to it The.
See moreSee less
daughter was so much 1 right enod that shortly after she refused to go downstairs to the ceilar. Witness told her it was the dog, but the daughter pointed out where the dog was then lying. Martha Chagnon testified in corroboration of her mother in regard to the noise at the
The preliminary hearing in Fall River has concluded taking testimony, with reports suggesting the evidence favored Lizzie Borden despite expectations she will still be held for the grand jury. The report lays out undisputed facts: the murder was brutal, Andrew Borden was killed between 10:45 and 11, and five people were in the house that morning.
Pawtucket Tribune · 1 September 1892 · page 1
EVIDENGE IS ALL IN. Testimony Strongly in Favor of Lizzie. SHE IS LIKELY TO BE HELD.
Famous Case. FALL RIVER, Mass., Bept. I.—Today the rounsel in the great Dorden tragedy will Mddress the court upou the question as to whether or not there {s probable ground for holding lizzie A, Borden for the grand jury on & charge of killilng Andrew J. Borden with a hatchet on the morning of Aug. 4 The defonse rested its case at 8:80 yester lay afternoon after testimony which is generally admivted to have been strongly tavorable to the case of the prisoner at the bar. ¢ It {3 probable that the addresses will be by no means short, for the evidence is loniz and leaves much room for theorizing and the drawing of inferences.
See moreSee less
It is cir enmetantial. and s damaging or shadowy, sccording to the standpoint from which it
The report lays out the prosecution's case that only Lizzie and Bridget could have been in the house when Mrs. Borden was killed, supported by witnesses who claimed to have watched all approaches to the property. It then details the defense's rebuttal, showing each supposed observer had gaps in their view and introducing alternative suspicious figures seen near the fence and barn.
Pawtucket Tribune · 1 September 1892 · page 1
SHE IS LIKELY TO BE HELD
Cavanaugh & Manning, 4 Broandway, repair free of charge, £ Pleasantest Pool and Rillara PAariors in the Btai e at the Wood bine The L and U Uigar, Bost fve oont CAAT maia. Sokd by sll dsnloos pany, 39 North Main street, Bowen says the blinds were down and couldn’t see, nud that ?. wasn's looking suyway. Mra Churchill had seven bods to make and five rooms to lwoe?. Mias Cellet sat on the Chagnon piasza, hack so the Borden fence and yard, and di4 nos command a view of them. Tho Frenoh man-—well, hoMddn't scc Mre. Wixon climb the Borden fonoe, and Adidn’t see him at all nntil Wixon hailed him. That lets him out, Where is the chain of observers now? Gone. Now 'ge defense establishes a most
Defense attorney Jennings delivered an emotional closing argument at the preliminary hearing, suggesting the murders were committed by an insane person and criticizing weaknesses in the prosecution's case. The court recessed afterward before District Attorney Knowlton began arguing for the prosecution.
Pawtucket Tribune · 1 September 1892 · page 1
A POWERFUL ARGUMENT.
Name of His Client. Special to the Tribune. FALL RiveEr, Sept. I—-The court was openod today jagain at the usual hour. Mr. Jennings’, attorney tor Lizzie Borden,
The article covers the ongoing preliminary hearing in Fall River, where defense attorney Jennings delivered a strong argument demanding Lizzie Borden's release, questioning the sufficiency of evidence against her. It notes that prosecutor Knowlton is expected to respond, and that public opinion largely favors Lizzie's release, criticizing Judge Blaisdell's decision to hold her.
The Providence News · 1 September 1892 · page 1
FINE AND STRONG
ISPECIAL TO THE NEWS,| FALL RIVER, Sept. I.—* Wanted in Fall River not later than Sept. 2, by 10 A, M. enough evidence to prove to the public that the indictment of Lizzie A. Borden for the murder of her father has been warranted.”’ The above notice expresses the feelings of the ever sympathetic majority of those who have followed the mysterious Borden murder hearing since last Thursday, If
This opinion piece criticizes the prosecution for relying on secrecy and weak circumstantial evidence against Lizzie Borden, arguing no reasonable lawyer would indict on such grounds. It summarizes the defense's closing testimony, including John Morse's statements about the cellar door and Dr. Draper's rebuttal of Dr. Dolan's medical testimony.
The Providence News · 1 September 1892 · page 1
been offered. Now that both defence and prosecution have finished, however a few words as to int,erdu’l defence may be applicable. t was neither sensational or of grut value. It showed that noises were heard around the neighboring houses on Wednesday night, and opened a possible means of escape and entrance for the murderer, by -howlng that Mr. Borden’s cousin entered the front door at a time when the latch was supposed to be fas
The defense concluded its case at the preliminary hearing, having shown an intruder could have committed the murder even without proving who did it; unresolved points included Lizzie's contradictory statements, her story about sinkers from the barn, and the milk. Attorney Jennings then began his argument, questioning the prosecution's timeline for Andrew Borden's death based on witness sightings and household testimony.
The Providence News · 1 September 1892 · page 1
TO-DAY IN COURT. Lawyer Jennings Makes a Magnificent Argument for Lizzie.
throught the Jewish quarter of the cu{. Important Notlee, Others said that the city was in a fair OfMce of the Bryant & Stratton Business College, condition to repel an attack of cholera, now open for the enrcliment of studeuts. Call at and that no serivus alarm ought to be once and secure your seat, ““As to the fact there is no denying the death of the Xartlu. The time of it is not definitely determined and conflicting statements as to it. Mr. (:1013 states that he saw, and three others alsosaw him, Mr.
See moreSee less
Borden down town at 10:40. It should take at least five minutes for him to get home. 5o that he could not have reached home before ten minutes toeleven. ‘“The time of the alarm was given at
A government attorney describes the stages of a criminal investigation, from inquiry to grand jury, and argues the evidence points toward Lizzie Borden despite the crime seeming improbable. He cites Dr. Draper's testimony that the hatchet wounds were inflicted by a weak, likely feminine hand, and suggests a motive rooted in strained stepmother-stepdaughter relations.
The Providence News · 1 September 1892 · page 3
who is to be benefited by their removal ? It is not to be supposed that the govern ment has more evidence than iv has givou in here, but some strange things ave come to licht.. Here was this girl brought up from babyhood by this woman, whom for twenty-five years she called mother, and then repudiates her ad calls her Mrs. Borden “*We have this terrible fact to face. Has your honor learned from years of exverience that there are no more fruitful sources of inveterate hatred than the re lations of stepsons and daughters with ltepmothers. *“Think of the frugality of the old man. He had wo lights in his house, no water, and not even a bath tub, He married o
A legal official argues that Lizzie Borden had motive stemming from strained stepmother relations and that the tightly locked house limited access to family members only. He contends the crime was committed by someone familiar with the household's routines, implicating Lizzie while defending the thoroughness of Bridget Sullivan's questioning.
The Providence News · 1 September 1892 · page 3
“Again, my colleague has not told us how unybody coula f“ in or out. Until Mr, Borden returned the front door was loclsffl' h .h h “T'he house was, perhaps, the most pe
This is a transcript of a prosecutor (Knowlton) arguing that only Lizzie Borden could have committed the murder, since the household's movements leave no other suspect. He highlights her composure after the killings and points to inconsistencies in her testimony about her whereabouts when her father returned.
The Providence News · 1 September 1892 · page 3
“It in not in the bounds of reason to sady that some one else has uot been suspected. z’bey all have been suspected, and all ave been examined, “I know of no difference between the reputable Lizzie Borden and rerutnble Bridget Sullivan’s star chamber inquest. ew Tunoscence need not fear questioning.
This editorial argues that after a month of investigation and the preliminary hearing, authorities have not shown that Lizzie Borden was guilty of her father's murder. It claims the prosecution relied on a hasty theory, found no bloodstains on her clothing, and failed to rule out that another person could have committed the crime.
The Providence News · 1 September 1892 · page 4
THE EVIDENCE ALL IN, Two views can be taken of the evi dence which has come to light during the preliminary hearing at Fall River, One is that of theories and their proof or disproof by facts ; the other is that of facts as a source of theories. It the authorities in the Borden case started out with the thought that their theories were the only admissable ones in the case, they have done well, But if they started out to find facts and then to connect them so as to point to some person as guilty of the murder, their efforts have proved a signal failure.
See moreSee less
For nearly a month these men haye been at work, and their work has brought forth nothing. They have worked on one line, putting forth all their efforts to prove their hasty assump tion that Lizzie Borden murdered her father. Other clues have been received not only with incredulousness but with out action. The reading public have decided, now that the evidence is all in, that the officers made a serious error, Little weight has been given to facts unless they conformed to the theory. Appearances are not evidence, and appearances are misleading, especially to a man predisposed to give them un due weight, The prosecution has failed to show that Lizzie Borden is probably
Lizzie Borden's lawyer argues the prussic acid purchase claim involved mistaken identity, citing contradictory witness descriptions of her voice. He also contends the lack of blood found on her clothing or person makes the prosecution's theory implausible.
The Providence News · 1 September 1892 · page 7
and distinet, *Now, mag it please your honor, it was not Lizzie Borden, She lu.xo she did not go out of the house on Wednesday at all, frs. Borden tells Mr. Morse that Lizzie was up in her room all the morning sick. And yet these men say she was at the store Wednesday morning. 1 submit, your honor, that there is the strongest evidence that they are wrong, and that she was not there and did not try to buy prussic acid. No Stains.
Attorney Jennings argues no blood was found on Lizzie's clothes or the alleged murder weapon, citing Professor Wood's testimony that the hatchet showed no blood or poison. He pleads for her release, insisting the wounds were incised rather than crushed and that the evidence proves her innocence.
The Providence News · 1 September 1892 · page 7
The paper headed this “Continued from page 1”, meaning it continues a piece begun on an earlier page of the same issue.
aud not found it, *The descrintion of the axe and hatchet was most winute. It was shown to be a reasonable cause of the blows, and yet when Prof. Wood stood u? and showed that the hatchet had no blood on it, Dr. Draper showed that there were no crushed wounds. Every one of ther: was sharply fucised, and when Prof. Wood showed that hatchet a fairly blunt one, it was a song of liberty for Lizzie Borden. I re
Providence lawyers give mixed, hedging opinions on whether evidence against Lizzie Borden is strong enough to hold her for the grand jury, with several calling the testimony weak or inconclusive. The report also recaps prior day's court testimony from a witness who passed the Borden house twice on the murder day.
The Providence News · 1 September 1892 · page 7
WHAT PROVIDENCE LAWYERS SAY.
not formed any, Clarence A. Aldrich said he had not read the testimony word for word, but he should be surprised if Miss Borden was not bound ever. Frank H. Jackson said he had not read the testimony carefully, and did not feel that he conld give an wunprejudiced opinion on the case. E. D, McGuinness, of the law flrm of McGuinness & Doran, said he had not
Professor Edwards testified that no prussic acid was found in the victims' stomachs and no blood was detected on the hatchet or Lizzie Borden's clothes, despite suspicious-looking spots. A stain on the white skirt was confirmed as blood but could not be identified as human.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 1 September 1892 · page 1
Fair Prisoner. Fall River, Maas., Aug. 30. Ev idence today took a new turn. Expert testimony was had, by which it was thought poison would be found in the stomachs of the murdered people, alBO human blood on the clothes of the prisoner, Lizzie Borden, but the ex pectants were disappointed. Professor Edwards, the expert, said he received a package containing two stomachs of the murdered Bordens and two jars containing milk used on Aug. 4 and 5. The stomachs were tested for prussic acid, but with negative re sults. Witness had not analyzed the milk yet.
See moreSee less
He also received from Dr. Dolan, a hatchet, two axes, a blue dress skirt, a lounge cover and three small envelopes in which hair were taken from Mr. and Mrs. Borden's heads, and hair token from the hatch et, and also a pair of black stockings. The hatchet contained a number of suspicious looking spots, but careful examination showed no traces of blood. Every spot which looked like blood was examined, but no traces of blood were seen. A big spot on the blue skirt looked like blood but found was not to be blood. The white skirt had one spot which looked like blood and was found to be. It was directly in front about six inches from the bottom. Could not say it was human blood. The carpet was stained (this as the sitting room car pet) and there was blood of course, on that. There was no blood on the lounge cover. The envelope marked "Hair" from A. J. Borden, was simply white hair; Mrs Borden's was dark hair. On the hatchet there was no human hair. Sensation. It was more like that taken from an animal. Near the edge of the hatchet a spot which seemed to be blood was found not to be. There was a spatter on the blade but it was not blood and there were spots on the head of the hatchet which looked like blood but were not. The witness said it would be impossi ble for an assailant of the murdered folks to escape without blood on his body in some way.
An expert witness described testing the Bordens' stomachs for prussic acid (negative) and examining a hatchet, axes, clothing, and hair samples for blood traces. Most suspected spots on the hatchet and blue skirt proved not to be blood, though the white skirt and sitting room carpet did show blood stains.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 1 September 1892 · page 1
The report notes that no blood was discovered on the hatchet or axes suspected of being used in the Borden murders, nor was poison found in the victims' stomachs. This absence of physical evidence is said to weaken the case against Lizzie Borden while deepening the mystery of the crime.
The Times · 1 September 1892 · page 4
Tue failure to discover any sign of blood upon the hatchet or any of the axes sup posed to have been used in the Borden murder, nor any evidence of poison in the stomachs of the victims, goes a long way towards failing to make out a case against Miss Lizzie Borden. At the same time the murder becomes more of a mystery than ever, Mz. J. Hasgixs Honsox is reported to kave said in & recent speech: ‘We will try ballots this time and bullets next.” Can the farmers of Virginia possibly be willing Jonger to pay out a considerable proportion of what little money they have for the pro.
See moreSee less
mulgation of such Anarchist rot as that? Rervonrs from localities in Europe at which cholera have appeared frequently state that it is not Asiatic cholera. No mat. ter whether it is Asiatic ornot, it seems to got there all the sae,
The report notes that investigators failed to find any blood on the hatchet or axes suspected in the Borden murders, nor any evidence of poison in the victims' stomachs. It suggests this absence of physical evidence undermines the case against Lizzie Borden and deepens the mystery surrounding the killings.
The first day's hearing in the Borden case ended with testimony seen as favorable to the defense, highlighting carelessness by police and the medical examiner. Dr. Dolan admitted his autopsy was delayed and only partial, with his official report on Andrew Borden's wounds read into the record.
UCTTLNGDOWh TO WORK TALl. RIVER'S LEGAL LIGHTS INTENT ON THE BORDEN TRIAL. Jlio IlontiU of tlio l'lrst 1'ay'a Testimony Very l'avornulo to thu Dofenoc, nml
At the preliminary hearing, defense attorney Adams presses Dr. Dolan about the autopsy reports and his handling of the hatchets found at the Borden house. Dolan describes the wounds, Mrs. Borden's hair, and his reconstruction of how the murder was committed.
or.d could nuvo neon iuilictod whilo the body 1 iy on tho lloor. Mrs. Borden's hair was "jov.u," that H, not knotted up, nnd wus tl1 "hily inclined to gray. Ono of tho blows
During the second day of the preliminary hearing, Dr. Dolan testified that the skulls of Andrew and Abby Borden had been removed during autopsy, cleaned, and photographed without family knowledge, and estimated Mrs. Borden died one to two hours before her husband. Lizzie Borden was observed smiling and reacting emotionally at various points during the proceedings, drawing comment from observers.
SECOOND DAY'S PROCEEDINGS. Somo Itntlier .Si-nsittioiutl Developments l'lidaj. Fall, lltvr.tt, Jtnss,, Aug. 20. Tho Bor den henriug was resumed shortly alter 10 o clock this morning. 1 ho prisoner nnd her friends came into court unattouded ex cept by tho cily marshal. Lizzie walked llrmly titter her sister and took her seat be tween her two counsellors. Dr. Dolan was called and his examina tion was continued. Witness said tho wound itt Mrs. Borden's back was Ilrst discovered at tho autopsy hold in Oak (Irovo cemotery. Then camo the most gruesome part of tho testimony yet given, and whilo it was going ou Lizzlo and L'luma clossd thoir oyes and Hushed and showed much foollug.
See moreSee less
Witness said: "Tho bodies havo 1 een interred, tho skulls woro romoved from the bodies by instructions from the attorney -general. Tho skulls wero cleaned and tho bodies are now buriod with out heads. The skulls wero photographed and aro now in my possession." No member of the Borden family was in formed of tho removal and photographing of tho skulls so far as witness kuow. Continuing witness said tho axes and hatchets found in tho cellar wero givon to l'rof. Wood, but wero nevor llttod to tlio wounds. He thought Jlrs. Borden died from one to two hours boforo Jlr. Borden. Dr. Dolau was reliovad after being order ed to produce all articles In his possossion. A. ti. Hart, treasurer of tho Union bav iugB bauk, testified that III. Burden had called ut tho bank lu tho morning of the day of tho murder. Ho told witneu ho was fosling unwoll. Charles C. Cook, roal cstnto brokor and agout for Jlr. Borden, testified that ho hod talked with Jfr. liordeu at length n fow days before tho tragedy. Jlr. Borden Bald to witness thut ho had made no will. Jlrs. Caroline Kolljy, who lives lu tlio house next to tho Borden homestead tostl lied to seeing Jlr. Borden coming around the house and going toward the front door. 'J ho thought he had a email whlto package m his hand. It was then about ll;o o'clock. Dr. Dolan was recalled, and identified the photographs taken in tho houso shortly after tho murder. Tnero aro live of thsin, showing various positions of ths bodies in different rooms. Tho most extraordinary event sinco tho tragedies three weeks ago, occurrod to-night just after tho adjournment of tho hearing. Several roportors crowded around the attor neys for thu defence, who showed tho fol lowing clipping from tlio Full Kiver tilobe: "U'uduesd'iy afternoon u reportor of tho (ilobo learned that .Matron Hungan had heard I.izzia Borden quarreling with F.mms,
A weekly digest of news items reports that 'the trial of Lizzie Borden for murder' began at Fall River amid a large crowd of spectators. The item appears among many unrelated news briefs, including cholera outbreaks in Europe and a theater fire in New York.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 1 September 1892 · page 5
RECORD, OF THE WEEK. Thursday. Gloucester, Mass., closed the celebra tion of her centennial, after four days of general festivities. The trial of Lizzie Borden for murder begun at Fall River,
A report claims Lizzie Borden, in front of a police matron, accused her sister of 'giving her away,' which the paper calls a practical confession. The same dispatch describes the packed Fall River courtroom as the preliminary hearing before Judge Blaisdell begins, with District Attorney Knowlton announcing readiness to proceed.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Eagle River Review · 1 September 1892 · page 3
Fair River, Mass, Aug. 25. The Second District court has mnever before had such a crowd as that which greeted Judge Blaisdell this morning. It is the date agreed upon for the hear ing of Miss liizzie A. Borden on the charge of Kkilling her father with an axe. Clergymen, laymen, physi ciang, and more than 150 ladies who were not directly connected with the case were seated and standing in all parts of the room, while inside the rail was an extraordinary crowd of report ers and otker mnewspaper workers, Ladies occupied more than two-thirds of the seats usually occupied by the curious gang who usually trequent the lower courts.
See moreSee less
At 10:50 o’clock Charles J. Holmes appeared with Miss EKmma Borden on his arm. Miss Lizzie Borden came in last with DMarshal Hilliard. She was handed to a seat between her two legal advisers and near a settee on which her sister was seated. The two women sat elbow tu elbow. Miss Lizzie was at her sister’s right hand. Not a word passed between them. “We are ready to proceed, your Honor,”” said District Attorney Knowl ton. At 10:30 o’clock Medical Examiner Dolan was called to the stand.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
At Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, Marshal Hilliard and detective Seaver described their searches of the premises, while a hackman noted disturbed hay in the barn. Dr. Benjamin Handy testified to seeing a pale, unfamiliar young man near the Borden house on the morning of the murders.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 1 September 1892 · page 2
THE MYSTERY DEEPENS
it toward the window. At the afternoon session Dr. Benjamin J. Handy was the first witness. Ifo said he passed the Borden Louaoon the day of the muruor at 0 in a carriage; saw opposite the space between the
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Dr. Handy testifies he saw a pale young stranger near the Borden house and had seen him before, while Mrs. Chagnon and her daughter describe hearing fence-jumping noises the night before the murders. Other witnesses corroborate these accounts during the preliminary hearing testimony.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 1 September 1892 · page 2
WHO MURDERED THE OLD COUPLE
Mary Ann Chagnon, the wife of Dr. Cbagnon. said that tho night before the murder, between 11 and 11:30 o'clock she heard a noise as though somebody was jumping the fence; tho sound appeared to come from the back of the house near the kitchen, where thero is a fence between the Borden and Chagnon yards; her daughter also heard it; in fact her daughter heard it first and CAlled her attention to it; the daughter was somewhat frightened and shortly afterwards she refused to go down stairs to the cellar; witness told her it was the dog, but tho daughter pointed out where the dog was then lying. Martha Chagnan testified in corrobora* tion of her mother in regard to the noise at the fence.
The Bolivar Bulletin · Bolivar, Tenn. · and 1 other paper
A New York World story claiming Lizzie reproached Emma for telling their lawyer something incriminating is revealed to be fabricated by a reporter. Mrs. Regan, Emma, Lizzie, and both lawyers all deny the conversation ever took place.
A WICKED FALSEHOOD. A Published Story of a Compromising In tervlew Between the Borden Sisters Proves to be a Reporter's Fake. New York, Aug. 27. A special to the Sun from Fall River, Mass., says that the story published Thursday in the New York World purporting to be an account of an interview between the Borden sisters in the presence of Matron Regan in which Lizzie re proached Emma for telling Mr. Jen nings, Lizzie's counsel, something that was alleged to be highly prejudicial to Lizzie's interests" and strongly indi cative of guilt, was false.
See moreSee less
"The story is a fake," the special says. "It was written by a reporter who did not reach here on Wednesday until 5:15 in the afternoon. The story is also published in a Boston newspaper yes terday over the name of this reporter, who went to Boston to write it"
The Osceola Times · Osceola, Ark. · 3 September 1892
Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.
Judge Blaisdell ruled Lizzie Borden probably guilty after the preliminary hearing, ordering her held for the November term of court. The report details the prosecutor's argument citing her contradictory statements and strained relations with Mrs. Borden, plus plans by authorities to continue investigating mysterious figures seen near the Borden house.
Morning Journal and Courier · 2 September 1892 · page 3
I Saturday arcalM. tor. op T a. m. to 61M p. ss. Saturday and tftTMiacf apt HE.'- tempts Suicide. PROBABLY GUILTY. HUasi Lizzie Borden Held for the No vember Term of Court A. Strange Case Tne Popular Sympathy far the Prisoner The Government's Argu ment The Prosecutor Dwells on the Contradictory Statements of the Girl and the Alleged Strained Re lation. Between Lliile and Rfre. Borden. .--FallBivxb, Mass., Sept. 1 -M!m Borden Will be taken to Taunton to-morrow. Aoeording to the statements of the polioe her actions to-night do not differ from those of the first night she spent In their custody, three weeks ago.
See moreSee less
Her friends are indignant over the verdict rendered to-day, bnt if the truth were told they have ex pected it from the moment Judge Blaisdell determined to preside at the hearing. Many persons who have read Mr. Knowlton's summing up of the prosecution state that the verdlot was the only proper one to preserve the interest of safe govern ment, bnt not a few of them are skeptical about conviction on the evidenoe sub mitted at the hearing. To-night Marshal Hilliard has commenced to outline the plan for the government to pursue. In this matter he has been directed by At torney General Fillsbnry and Distriot Attorney Knowlton. It is said at police headquarteas that there is muoh yet to be done before the case is fit for suc cessful prosecution. No habeas corpus plea will be made by the defendant's law yers. They will devote their time to hunt ing down the mysterious people seen about tne Borden bouse the day 01 tne murder. Andrew J. Jennines believes firmly in Miss Lizzie Borden's innocence. His great plea is the principal topic of conversation tonigQt. it appeals to tne popular ear ana it will be many days before the oitizena begin to look upon the prisoner as a crim inal. Distriot Attorney Knowlton opened his argument for the government. After some preliminary remarks on the crime of mur der he said:
The report describes the verdict of probable cause rendered by Judge Blaisdell at Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, with her supporters stunned but not entirely surprised given the judge's prior conduct. It also details District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument, in which he insists there was no clear motive but a cause, and that the murders were committed by a coward who attacked from behind.
Morning Journal and Courier · 2 September 1892 · page 3
PROBABLY GUILTY.
torney General Fillsbnry and Distriot Attorney Knowlton. It is said at police headquarteas that there is muoh yet to be done before the case is fit for suc cessful prosecution. No habeas corpus plea will be made by the defendant's law yers. They will devote their time to hunt ing down the mysterious people seen about tne Borden bouse the day 01 tne murder. Andrew J. Jennines believes firmly in Miss Lizzie Borden's innocence. His great plea is the principal topic of conversation tonigQt. it appeals to tne popular ear ana it will be many days before the oitizena begin to look upon the prisoner as a crim inal. Distriot Attorney Knowlton opened his argument for the government. After some preliminary remarks on the crime of mur der he said:
This passage recounts District Attorney Knowlton's argument that the Borden house was tightly locked, meaning the murderer must have come from within. He highlights Lizzie's contradictory inquest testimony and timeline to argue she had the opportunity to kill both her stepmother and father.
Morning Journal and Courier · 2 September 1892 · page 3
A WKLI-LOCKED BOUSE. That house was the most uniquely looked np house in all Fall Elver; the front door was looked, the windows were shut, the cellar door was looked and all the avenues of approach and escape barred. Von could not go from any one part of the house to another without a key. It was found that every person about there was seen the man at the gate, the man on the street but nothing was seen of a person going into or ont of that house. And so all the inmates of that house have been subjects of suspicion the moment the f act appeared that the mnrder was committed from within.
See moreSee less
lizzie's contradictions. When Lizzie Borden testified at the in quest she told different stories; she contra dicted herself. Where were Mrs. Borden and Lizzie when Bridget came .Into the house that morning after she had gone into the yard! They were upstairs alone; be fore that Mrs. Borden had told her to wash the windows; Mr. Borden had gone away, and when Bridget came to the screen door Lizzie appeared and was told by Bridget that she need not look the door: that she would be in the yard and could see any body going or ooming; that she would get her water in the barn If fizzle said so; all the house was dear, but of Lizzie and her step mother, but when her father was a way, when Morse was away, when Bridget was at work in the yard, THEN THE DIED WAS DONE
A newspaper miscellany column remarks that if Lizzie Borden escapes conviction for the murder of her parents in Fall River, it won't be for lack of effort by sensational reporters. The item adds that nothing more disgraceful has been known in New England.
The Willimantic Journal · 2 September 1892 · page 4
ever. If Lizzie Borden is not convicted of the murder of her father and mother in Fall River, it will not be because the sensation al reporters have not tried hard enough. Nothing more disgraceful has been known
Lizzie Borden was transferred to Taunton jail after Judge Blaisdell ruled she should be held for the grand jury following the preliminary hearing. Her supporters were indignant but had anticipated this outcome once Blaisdell took over presiding, and her lawyers plan to investigate other suspicious figures seen near the Borden house rather than pursue a habeas corpus plea.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 2 September 1892 · page 1
BACK IN TAUNTON JAIL
presentation to the grand jury. No habeas corpus plea will be made by the defendant's lawyers. They will de vote their time to hunting down the mys terious people seen around the Borden Jjpuse the day of the murder. Andrew J. Jennings believes firmly in Miss Lizzie's innocence. His great plea i the principal topic of conversation. It appeals to the popular ear, and it will be many days before the citizens begin to look upon the prisoner as a criminal. ) When court began yesterday morning Mr. Jennings opened for the defense.
See moreSee less
He said, among other things, that the complaint alleges, that on the fourth day of August, Andrew J. Borden was killed by his daughter. He approached the sub ject with feelings widely different from any other case which he had ever before handled. Mr. Borden was not only his client, but his friend, and had anybody told him four weeks ago that he should now be pleading for the daughter of his old friend he should have said it was beyond the bounds of credibility. That Andrew J. Borden was murdered there was no doubt, and that the time of murder has been established there was no doubt, he said. The alarm was given at 11:13 to 11:15, and the time between Mr. Borden's last entrance to the house and the alarm was
Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper
The report notes public skepticism about conviction despite the verdict, and describes preparations for presenting the case to the grand jury. It then details defense attorney Andrew Jennings' opening statement, in which he argued the time window for the murder was too short for Lizzie to have committed it.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 2 September 1892 · page 1
The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa. · 2 September 1892
Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper
Prosecutor Knowlton delivers closing argument emphasizing Lizzie's lack of emotion and the missing bloody wrap and murder weapon. Judge Blaisdell rules there is probable cause and orders her held for trial at the November term.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 2 September 1892 · page 1
murders. "We have never yet found the wrap that covered Lizzie Borden and took the blood from those bodies; we have not yet fonnd the hatchet which did the work. This thing was conceived in the head of a cool-headed and deliberate woman. If your Honor should yield to the eloquent arguments of my brother and allow this woman to go, that would not be the end of this matter. The reward that attends duty done should be considered." Judge Blaisdell said that sympathy should be laid aside and duty, stern duty, requires upon this evidence but one thing to be done.
See moreSee less
Supposing that a man was seen in the chamber of Mrs. Borden, the guest chamber of death, and that he was iu the room of the father when death came; suppose that a man should tell as many different stories as Lizzie has done,' the way would be plain. "I find that she is probably guilty." She was ordered remanded to the coun ty jail at Taunton for trial at the Novem ber term. All of the witnesses were ordered to recognize tor the November term of court.
The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa. · 2 September 1892
The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.
At the preliminary hearing in Fall River, defense counsel Jennings argued Lizzie Borden's case before District Attorney Knowlton presented the prosecution's argument. Judge Blaisdell ruled she must answer at the November term and committed her to the County Jail.
The Morning Call · 2 September 1892 · page 1
HELD lull MIIIDLK. Lizzie Borden Has Been Committed to the County. Jail. Fall River, Mass., Sept. I.— The argu ments in the Borden case began thi. morn
After closing arguments from defense attorney Jennings and prosecutor Knowlton, Judge Blaisdell ruled there was sufficient cause to hold Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents. She was ordered to answer at the November term and committed to the county jail.
Los Angeles Herald · 2 September 1892 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN HELD. She must Answer the Charge of Murder lug Her Parents. Fall River, Macs., Sept. I.—Argu ments in the Borden case began this
Judge Blaisdell ruled Lizzie Borden 'probably guilty' of murdering her father and stepmother, ordering her held until the November grand jury could act. The report notes the judge's emotional difficulty pronouncing the ruling, contrasted with Borden's composed, unflinching demeanor in court.
Evening Journal · 2 September 1892 · page 2
JAILEE TILL THE GRAND JURY ACTS. Apparent j The Accused Maintain* Hi Conipofttire to the F ml, and Never One« Flinches During Her Armlgi eut by the Counsel for the Prosecution. t?..* D,r„. •%*._. c«.*«. o Fall Riv rr, M.iei., Sept. 2.—As has been anticipated by everybody in this city, iu eluding the counsto for the defense, Judge I Blaisdell held Lizzie Borden to await the | action of the November grand jury as j , ,, , -, - "probably guilty ' of the murder of her fa ther four weeks ago.
See moreSee less
, , . The judges voice broke ns became to tho word "prtbably." Hi» face worked convnl . , 1 ,, .... , , . stvely. Ho halted for a few seconds in tho effort to control his emotions and then he If he pronounced tho words went on. guilty" at all, it so merged iu the choking of his throat that it was not intelligible. But Lizzie Borden, when she stood up a moment later to receive tho formal jmlgj ment of the court from the white bearded is** r m ir 111 ... - . lips.of Clerk Leonard,did so without promptj
Lizzie Borden received the court's sentence of two months in Taunton jail without visible emotion, pending grand jury action. The defense argued no evidence tied her to the crime and suggested Bridget Sullivan or an unknown maniac was responsible, while the prosecution argued a weak, feminine hand committed the murders and cited contradictory stories and a failed alibi.
Evening Journal · 2 September 1892 · page 2
JAILED TILL THE GRAND JURY ACTS
Fall River call "the Borden grit." ; Tli« Defense. I ! Mr. Jennings opened for the defense nnd rehearsed the story of the killing of Mr. : Borden, nnd said that n man of common I sense, looking at the horribly mutilated bodies, would say that it was the work of « | maniac. Why did not tho prosecution in •vestigate the breaking into the house two ! years ago aud of the barn two mouths agoi Instead of looking for tho mqrderer, they j
District Attorney Knowlton argues that Lizzie Borden's contradictory statements, failed alibi, attempted poison purchase, and lack of emotion point to her guilt, while noting the murder weapon and bloodstained garment were never found. Judge Blaisdell then explains his decision to hold her for the grand jury, reasoning that a man in her position would likewise be presumed guilty.
Evening Journal · 2 September 1892 · page 2
JAILED TILL THE GRAND JURY ACTS
murder. i If Lizzie had nn opportunity to commit tho murder Bridget Sullivan also had. The inqnest was held for no other purpose than to put Lizzie on the ruck. Nut a tittle of evidence was found on Lizzie to connect j her with tho crime. Counsel demanded the woman's release. At ono point during Mr. 1 Jennings' plea Lizzie burst, into tears, nnd at the end the crowd broke into xvild np plause. ! After the recess District Attorney Kaowi ton began his speech. He contended that tho murderer was not a man.
See moreSee less
A weak, ir resolute feminine hand that know tho im pulse to strike, but not with the strength of a man, did the deed. The Accusation, He spoke of the quarrel between tho daughters nnd tho father and stepmother. There was absolutely no affection or sym pathy between them. Nobody could have gone into the house, committed tip: mur der aud get away without being seen. Lizzie Borden told contntdictory stories. Her attempt to prove un alibi was prepos terous, The attempt to buy prussic acid looked bad for the girl—as if she had tried to kill her father aud stepmother by poison, aud finding it could not be bad determined to use tho steel. Mr. Knowlton concluded as follows: "The demeanor of the defendant ia :•> markable. While everybody is filled with anguish, she has never, yet expresse^ emo tion. It takes away from tho horror wo have of bringing onr minds to think this thing has been done by hur. I have never beard but one expression from her yet. She was annoyed that Fleet should ask her questions about the facts of the murders. We have never yet found the wrap that, covered Lizzie Borden aud took tire blood from those bodies; we have uot yet found
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
At the close of the preliminary hearing, Judge Blaisdell ruled that the evidence showed Lizzie Borden was probably guilty of murdering her father and stepmother. He ordered her committed to Taunton county jail to await trial at the November term of court.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 2 September 1892 · page 1
made. MISS BORDEN COMMITTED. Judge Blaisdell Finds That She Is Prob ably Guilty. Fall River, Mass., Sept. 2.— The hearing in the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with tho murder of her father
The item briefly describes Andrew J. Jennings, the lawyer defending Lizzie Borden of Fall River, noting his past political career as a Massachusetts Republican orator and state senate leader. It states he now shares leadership of the Bristol county bar with W. W. Crapo and has left politics behind.
Afro-American Advocate · 2 September 1892 · page 1
Andrew J. Jennings, the lawyer who is defending Lizzie Borden, of Fall River, was, nine years ago, one of the best republican orators in Massachu
A brief news digest reports that Lizzie Borden was adjudged probably guilty at her preliminary hearing and held for action by the Grand Jury. The item appears among a roundup of other domestic and foreign news items.
New-York Tribune · 2 September 1892 · page 6
a —————— THE NEWS THIS MORNING. Foreiar.—A more hopeful feeling in regard te eholera exists in Hamburg, figures showing a falling off in the number of new cases and deaths; there were ten deaths in Paris and nineteen in Havre: latest returns in Russia show a total of 4.559 new cases and 2,520 deaths, which is said to be a gratifying decrease, =-== Much indignation is felt in Victoria over the seizure of sealing schooners by Russian gunboats, An explesion of firedamp caused a large loss of life in the Acraffe mine in Be'gium.
See moreSee less
Domestin.—A circular was issued by order of the President requiring all immizrant, vessels from infected ports to be detained at Quarantine twenty days. =——=— The steel steamer Western Resarve broke in two on Tuesday night, on Lake Superior: twenty-six lives were ligt: two or three schovners on the Great Lakes were lost with all on boord, in 8 storm. ==— Miss Lizzie Borden was adjudged probably guilty and was held for the action of the Grand Jury. : The newspaper train on the New-York Central ran into an open draw at New-Hamburg and was wrecked : three men were killed and seven injured, - === Martha Wilk «a at Independence, Towa, trotted a mile in 2:08 on the kite traci. City and Subuwrban.—No new case of cholera developed among the Moravia's passengers: extra precautions were taken by the Rtate and munici-
After hearing arguments from defense attorney Jennings and the District Attorney, Judge Blaisdell ruled Lizzie Borden probably guilty and ordered her held for the Grand Jury without bail. She was to be transferred to Taunton jail the next day, while her lawyers planned to investigate mysterious figures reportedly seen near the Borden house on the day of the murders.
New-York Tribune · 2 September 1892 · page 7
PRISONER, AND SHE IS SENT TO JALIL, WITHOUT BAIL. Fall River, Mass., Sept. 1.—Arguments were heard to-day by Judge Blaisdell, of the District Court, in the ease of Miss Lizzie Borden, acensed of the murder of her father and stepmother, The evidence was reviewed by both Mr. Jennings, Miss Borden's counsel, and the District-Attorney, and at the close the judge declared Miss Borden probably gullty and held her for the action of the Grand Jury. Miss Borden will be taken to Taunton to-morrow. According to the statements of the police, her actions to-night do not differ from those of the first night she spent in thelr custody, three weeks ago.
See moreSee less
Her friends are indignant over the verdict. Marshal Hilliard has begun to outline the plan for the Government to pursue. In this matter he has Leen directed by Attorney-General Pillsbury and Disrict-Attorney Knowlton. The defendant's lawyers will devote their time to hunting down the mysterious people seen around the Borden house the day of the murder, The Conrt came in at 10:30 o'clock and A fegy minutes after Miss Lizzie Borden entered the room | and the proceedings began, Mr. Jennings opened for the defence: “That Andrew J. Borden was murdered there was no doubt, and that the time of the murder has been | established there Is also no doubt. The alarm was given at 11:13 to 11:15, and we know, sO far as we can know from the evidence, that between Mr. Borden's Iast entrances to the house and the alarm
Attorney Jennings delivers the defense's opening statement, arguing the murder timeframe was too short for Lizzie to have committed it and highlighting unexplored leads about mysterious strangers seen near the Borden house. He also notes prosecutors' continued focus on prussic acid poisoning as an initial theory.
Closing arguments at the preliminary hearing reviewed the case against Lizzie Borden, including her shifting accounts, the alleged prussic acid purchase, and her unemotional demeanor. Judge Blaisdell ruled the evidence sufficient and ordered her held for trial at the November term.
New-York Tribune · 2 September 1892 · page 7
any note. The Commonwealth has never said tbat these people were not poisoned by prussic acid, but i it does say that that was the first proposition, because there was a suggestion of a motive in Lizzie going to the drug store. Prussic acid could not be had, “The demeanor of the defendant was remarkable. While everybody Is filled with li, she has never yet expressed emotion, It takes away from the horror we have of bringing our minds to think thls thing has been done by her. We have never yet found the wrap that covered Lizzie Borden and took the blood from those bodies, We have not yet found the hatchet which did the work.
See moreSee less
This thing was conceived in the head of a cool-headed, deliberate woman,” ' Judg® Plalsdell sald that syuipathy should bo lad aside, and duty, stern duty, required upon this evidence but one thing to be done. Sup nz a man was seen In the chamber of Mrs. Borden, the guest chamber of death, and that he was {nh room of
Counsel for Lizzie Borden and the state argued before Judge Blaisdell reviewing testimony from the preliminary hearing. The judge refused to release her, stating the evidence showed she was probably guilty, and ordered her held in county jail to await grand jury action at the November term.
The Morning News · 2 September 1892 · page 1
HELD FOR THE GRAND JURY. Tha Court Refuses to Bet Lizzie Bor den at Liberty. Fall River, Mass., Bept. I.— The coun sel for Lizzie Borden and for the state made argument to-day before fudge Blaisdell re viewing tbe testimony given. The oourt would not release Lizzie Borden, but held her to await the aotiou of tbe grand jury. Judge Blaisdell said that sympathy should be laid aside and duty required. Upon this evidence but one thlug was to be done. .Supposing a man was to be seen iu the chamber of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden, a guest la the Chamber of death, and that he was in the room of the father when death oarne. Sup* pose that a man should tell as many dif ferent stories as Lizzie has done—the way would be jilain. “I find that she Is proba bly guilty." The accused was ordered to tbe county jail for trial at the November term.
The preliminary hearing concluded with Judge Blaisdell ruling that the evidence pointed to Lizzie Borden's probable guilt. She was ordered held at the county jail to stand trial at the November term of court.
The Indianapolis Journal · 2 September 1892 · page 2
LIZZIE HELD FOR TRIAL
Against Miss Borden. Fall River. Mass.. Sept. 1. The hearing In the case of Lizzie Borden was closed to day. After the lawyers on each side had made their arguments, Judge Blaisaell said that "sympathy bhonld be laid aside, and duty, stern duty, requires upon tbis evidence lut one thing to be done. Sup pose tbat a man should tell as many diller ent stories as Lizzie has done tho way would be plain. I find that she is probably guilty." The accused was ordered to the county jail for trial at the November term. All of tho witnesses were ordered to be recognized for the November term of court.
The preliminary hearing against Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother, concluded with closing arguments from both sides. Judge Blaisdell ruled that duty required her to be remanded to jail to stand trial in November.
Rock Island Daily Argus · 2 September 1892 · page 4
Lizzie llorden Held for Trial. Fall Riveb, Mass., Sept. 2. The hear ing in the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father aud step mother, was closed yesterday. After the lawyers on each side had made their argu ments Judge Blaisdell said that sympathy should be laid aside, and duty, stern duty. required upon this evidence but one thing to be done, and that was to remand Lizzie Borden to jail for trial in November.
At the Fall River preliminary hearing, servant Bridget Sullivan detailed the Borden household's activities on August 3 and 4 leading up to the murders, testimony described as very damaging to Lizzie Borden. Other witnesses, including reporters, testified they found no footprints near the house, and defense counsel was upset over a disputed story about Mrs. Pegan hearing the Borden sisters quarrel.
The Kinsley Graphic · 2 September 1892 · page 4
BAD FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. Servant liritlget Miluvai Xtese rtbea the .fcre :ie tit the Haute of lJt Lli. Fall Kiveh, Mass., Aug. -.). The principal witness in the Porden case Saturday at term k n was ltndget iuliivan, the family servant. J-ho t 'hl in detail all the doings of the household on August 'i and 4 tip to the murder, even to the taking iu of tiio milk can in the morning and Mr. Ilor den's coming to breakfast wi:hout any ' coliar. The evidence waj very ilaitiaging to the defendant- .
See moreSee less
j John Cunningham, a newsdealer, gave ! unimportant testimony and Ueporters ; Manning and Stephens, of two local pa ! pers, testified that they could tind no ! footprints in the grass, about the house ! or cu the fence.
This item, buried in a roundup of miscellaneous news briefs, reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the ax murders of her father and stepmother has begun in Fall River, Massachusetts. It gives no further detail on proceedings.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Iola Register · 2 September 1892 · page 6
Ex-Gov. MyronII. Clark died at Canandaigua, X. Y. A defalcation, which it is said will reach $20,000, has been discovered in the office of Street & Smith, publishers of the New York Weekly, and the crime has been fastened upon Alfred J. Price, cashier. As A result of Grand Master Sweeney declaring the switchmen's strike off at Buffalo, X. Y., he was assaulted by a man named Quinn and severely beaten. The crestfallen switchmen were, greatly mortified at the collapse of the strike. President Harrison met the old sol diers at their camp at Malono, X. Y., on the 20th. TnE trial of Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and step mother with an ax, has begun at Fall River, Mass.
Bridget Sullivan, the Borden family servant, testified in detail about the household's activities on August 3 and 4, including taking in milk and Mr. Borden's collarless appearance at breakfast, with her evidence described as very damaging to Lizzie. Other witnesses, including a newsdealer and two reporters, gave testimony about footprints near the house, while a dispute arose over an alleged overheard quarrel between the Borden sisters.
People's Voice · 2 September 1892 · page 6
BAD FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. Servant Urldsrot Snllivai Describes the Scene In the House of Death. Fall Rivku. Mass., A'jg. 29. The principal witness in the Borden
After closing arguments from defense counsel Jennings and prosecutor Knowlton, Judge Blaisdell ruled the evidence showed Lizzie Borden was probably guilty and ordered her held for trial at the November term. He cited her inconsistent statements as particularly damning.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 2 September 1892 · page 2
MURDERESS REMANDED FOR TRIAL
Borden murder trial today Mr. Jennings, counsel for the defense, occupied the fore noon with his argument, while Prosecu ting Attorney Knowlton spoke in the af ternoon. At the conclusion of Mr. Knowlton's argument, Judge Blaisdell said that sym pathy should ba laid aside. Duty stern duty required upon this evideuce but one thing to he done. Suppose a man had beon seen iu the chamber of Mrs. Borden, the guest chamber of death, and that ha was in tho room of the father vheu death came. Suppose that man should tell as many different stories as Lizzie has done? The way would be plain. "I find that she is probably guilty." The accused was ordered to the county jail for trial at the November term.
A newspaper miscellany column lists various brief items including one on the Fall River murders, stating that Lizzie Borden is on trial for killing her father and stepmother. It notes that no evidence so far produced fixes guilt upon her.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Hazel Green Herald · 2 September 1892 · page 4
GEORGE W DRAKE Dowx in tho Third Congressional dis trict the Republicans will Hunter Dem ocratic Goodnight and find a porpotual sleep after the 8th of November o o o Over in Elliott county there is an attempt to move tho county seat from Sandy Hook to one of three other places and in consequence there is much bitter ness of feeling o o o Wk acknowledge tho receipt of a cata logue of tho Beattyvillo Fair to bo held Soptember 20 21 22 and 23 and take the opportunity to thank Secretary Jas R Dorman for a complimentary ticket to the exhibition o o o The report that Senator Quay is now in Florida for his health pictures him as having air when he is questioned about tho success of tho Republican party Thats a Quay way to treat the administration o 0 o What is tho Legislature doing Not a thing That is as an equivalent for tho amount the members draw from the State Treasury Tho caso on the docket now stands General Assembly vs Gov ernor Brown and vice versa but the tax payer has to whack up all tho same o The news comes from Washington that President Harrison has lost his pet coon Mascot That do settle it and tho most sanguine man in the Republi can ranks must now admit that Bennys chances are quite slender Last his mas cot I Well Ben youro hoo dooed aud no mistake o Who killed old man Borden and wife at Fall River Mass is a question as liarU to answer as the whoreabouts of lascott and Tate Miss Lizzie Borden a daughter of tho old man and to tho woman is on trial for the mur dor but no ovidence so far produced iixea tho guilt upon her o Now tho news comes from Middles borough that an immonso quarry of ouyx covering 800 acres has been dis covered near that place But this is not tho first oh nix Middlerfborough in vestors havo discovered oh nix is heard every time a man wants to dispose of his property at that placo o IM Big Ike of tho Inquisition is tho messago Gov Brown sends tho Gen eral Assembly Attornoy Goneral Hen drick aud Auditor Norman and I shall tolerate no man or measure that inter feres with my aspirations to a seat in tho United State Senate At least thats what ono reads bctweeu the lines o o o Mohello an ill shaped colt that last year sold as h yearling for the paltry sum of S100 on Saturday won the great Futurity stakes at Sheopshead Bay 75000 in cold cash Tho eolt belongs to Wm Singerly editor of tho Philadel phia Record who paid 4500 for him last sprhig and Siugerly enough ho is as proud of the purchase as ho is of his paper o The Livo Stock Record published at Lexington Ky tho great horeo center of the 4world camo in a handsomely litho graphed cover iRst week and othorwise howed many marks of progress and prosperity The Record is ono of tho old and ablest stock journals iu tho
A Danville, Kentucky local news column makes a passing remark about the Associated Press's daily reporting style on the Lizzie Borden murder case in Fall River, Massachusetts, describing it as distinctly 'English' in tone. The bulk of the passage otherwise covers unrelated local news items from Danville and Lancaster, Garrard County.
Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 2 September 1892 · page 2
The Teachers' Institute has beon in session since Monday. Supt. J. W. Raw-lings presides over tho body and Prof. R. II. Caruthers, of Louisville, conducts tho interesting proceedings. There is a full attendance ot teachers. It may not bo Danville nows, exactly, but haven't the esteemed contemporaries generally noticed the intensely English stylo in which the Lizzie Borden murder case at Fall River, Musa., is reported daily, for the Associated Press? Lige Brooks, Mat Hoskins, Sank Amoody and Tit Carroll, juvenile Africans, were before the police court Wednesday for throwing filth through au opon window into the house of George
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The defense in the Borden case presented witnesses suggesting a stranger may have been in the neighborhood on the night before the murders, including testimony about strange noises and a disheveled man seen nearby. Witnesses also raised doubts about the locked doors and the nature of the wounds described by Dr. Draper.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 2 September 1892 · page 4
THE CASE OF LIZZIE BORDEN. READY FOR THE FINAL ARGUMENTS. The Defense Makes a Good Showing — Strange-Looking Men in the Neighborhood Also Believed the Government Has a Weak Case.
The other witnesses, among them Dr Handy, testified to having seen a strange-looking man in the neighborhood, while a man of sound common sense like Alfred Clarkson, the steam titter, says the hay in the barn had been stepped in and looked as if some one had lain iu, it. Jerome C. Borden showed how easy it was to enter the Borden house by the front door, and the tes timony of Mrs Briglmm shows that it is possible to enter’the door Wednesday provided one of the inmates does not slip the bolt or turn the key, without depending on the spring lock which does not spring.
See moreSee less
Wed nesday’s record of the butchery as given by Dr Draper has again given rise to grave doubts whether the. terrible wounds could Jiavc been indicted by a woman, more particu lar'y by a woman who, since and before the tragedy,has shown not the slightest symptoms of insanity. Considerable nonsense is being published’about dose living at the Bordens, because it has appeared that mutton and mutton soup were warmed over more than once. As a matter of fact it is well known that a majority of the older fami lies in that section of Massachusetts at least are thrifty in their house hold affairs, and it is not an un common thing for them to warm over victuals. Tile robust, healthy forms of Miss Lizzie and Miss Emma Borden do not show that they had been undergoing a process of
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The report reviews inquest testimony, including sightings of a strange man and signs someone had slept in the barn hay, casting doubt on whether a woman could have inflicted such violent wounds. It also details growing public criticism that Lizzie Borden was harshly interrogated without counsel at the inquest, with the prosecution allegedly aiming to extract self-incriminating statements before her arrest.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 2 September 1892 · page 4
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The report weighs the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden, noting conflicting medical testimony on time of death and lack of a clear motive or weapon. It outlines the defense's planned strategy and the government's reliance on Bridget Sullivan's testimony to establish opportunity.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 2 September 1892 · page 4
Dr Draper's testimony showed that who ever the murderer was he could not have committed the deed without bearing some of the victim's blood as an ineffaceable record on his clothing. The important part of this testimony, which seemed to weaken the government’s strongest evi dence, was given in these words of Bos ton’s medical examiner: “The determination of the time from the condition of the food in the victim’s stomach could be only ap proximate.” Prof Wood approximated the time at two and one-half hours. If Dr Draper approximated it at from three to four hours, it is thought the case against Lizzie Borden will never pass beyond the portals of the grand jury’s room.
See moreSee less
The essence of the govern ment ease, as looked at hy her friends last Wednesday,was that she is to be called proba bly guilty, because she might have been in the house when her father and step-mother were killed. They also claim that had John V. Morse been confined in bed in the house by illness at that time no kind fate could save his neck from the gallows if the present state of public feeling ruled the courts. Attorney Andrew J. Jennings will sum up the case for the defense. He will de vote most of his argument to showing the weakness of the Borden night-latch, the pos sibility of strangers entering and leav ing the house and the fact that there were many suspicious persons and things seen around the house preced ing the tragedies. The government’s ease has been fully outlined. District Attorney Knowlton will not put his greatest claim for commitment upon the fact that Lizzie Bor den made erratic statements at the inquest. He will rely particularly on Bridget Sullivan’s testimony, backed by that of Prof Wood. Bridget Sullivan did not know Lizzie's whereabouts from the time she went out until she heard her laugh in the front hall, up stairs, near Mrs Borden’s open door, as testi fied to. During this time the murder of Mrs Borden could have been committed. The government official’s own theory is that Mrs Borden was murdered while Bridget Sulli van was washing the outside south windows of the house,the farthest point she could be re moved from the room where the first tragedy took place. It would be impossible at that point to hear any person fulling in the upper story. Had Mrs Borden been alive in the house it seems probable to the government
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Medical examiner Dr. Dolan described the positions of the bodies, sent the victims' stomachs to Harvard for analysis, and gave a graphic account of Andrew Borden's wounds. A surveyor presented measured plans of the Borden homestead's interior, exterior, and grounds.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 2 September 1892 · page 6
THE BORDEN MURDER MYSTERY. IMPORTANT WITNESSES TESTIFY.
IMPORTANT WITNESSES TESTIFY. Medical Exmiuer Dolnn on tbe Dr Dolan testified Thursday to the position of the bodies of the mur dered couple when found, to sending their stomachs to Prof Wood of Harvard college for analysis. Mrs Bor den’s body was dressed as you would expect a housewife to be at that time of day. It had an old handkerchief about the neck that was bloody. Witness did not believe it was tied in a knot and did not re member whether it was ent or not. Surveyor Keirnan then took the stand.
See moreSee less
Mr Keirnan submitted plans showing the interior and exterior ot the Borden home stead, with measurements of the rooms, dc ; scription and measurements of the land, bight of fences, location of the barn, etc. Dr Dolan was called back to the stand, ami the district attorney asked him to de scribe the appearance of Mr Borden's body
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
At the preliminary hearing, Dr. Dolan described the horrific wounds on Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies in graphic detail, noting the number, location, and depth of cuts from a sharp instrument. He also detailed finding blood spatter throughout the room and axes in the cellar, one of which showed possible blood stains and hair.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 2 September 1892 · page 6
spots found in the room, saying the side ot Mr Borden’s head and face was covered with blood. The shirt was bloody, and the back of his clothes soaked. His head lay, not on the arm of the sofa but iu tiie angle. The blood was clotted, but was fresh and still oozing from the wounds, and the body was still warm, at 11.45 o'clock when witness arrived at the house. Wit ness described the various blood spots at length. There were spots on the ceiling, pictures, doors and wall paper.
See moreSee less
The wounds were made by a sharp instrument, probably by an ax or hatchet. The blows were struck at the weakest pari of the skull, where it is not one-twe.fth of an inch thick. Continuing, Dr Dolan said: There were 18 wounds on Mrs Borden’s person, 14 of which were in a small space back of her head over her ear. Pieces of the skull were driven into the brain. All of the wounds were made with a sharp instrument. In witness's opinion Mrs Borden had been dead an hour and a half when he saw her. Knowlton—Did you see anything incon sistent with the theory that she had been dead two hours? There were objections, but the judge overruled them. Tbe witness said lie saw nothing incon sistent with the theory, and she might have been dead two hours. Sirs Borden weighed from 210 to 225 pounds. She died of shock. Witness saw font axes in the cellar of the house. Examined one with a claw on it and found that it ted been scraped and washed. It had a cutting surface ot about five inches and weighed from three to lire pounds. Under the glass it showed stains which looked like blood. Saw some hair on it also. Took some dress-skirts and under skirts from the house, the property of Miss Borden, the defendant. They were given to Prof Wood. At 12.25 o’clock the court ad journed until 2 p. m. Joha V. Jlorsr's Teatimanr.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Dr. Dolan testifies Mrs. Borden suffered 18 wounds, mostly clustered behind her ear, caused by a sharp instrument, and describes finding a washed hatchet with apparent blood and hair. John V. Morse then testifies about his visit to the Borden house the day before and morning of the murders, his movements, and blood spatter he observed on the parlor door.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 2 September 1892 · page 6
Joha V. Jlorsr's Teatimanr. Dr Dolan's examination was continued Fri day. After the testimony of several minor witnesses John V. Morse was next called to the stand. He tes tified: Am 59 years old, and my residence is here. Lived in Dartmouth two years and in Hastings, la., 20 years. Ain a brother of Mr Borden’s first wife, who died in 1863. Had been rn the Borden house several times • the past year. Went to the bouse the day before the tragedy. Dined there with Mrs Borden and went over to Swansea, to Mr Borden’s farm, to see some cattle I had pur chased from him.
See moreSee less
Mr Borden was in poor health at that time, and said that all in the house had been sick the night before, probab ly from poison contained in bakers’bread. Defendant got home that night but did not see ter; supposed I heard her when she went upstairs to bed. Went to bea at 10 o'clock ; came downstairs Thursday at 6 o’clock and breakfasted at 7 with Mr‘and Mrs Borden. Did not see Miss Lizzie. Went from the house the morning of the murder at 9.15 o’clock, leaving Mr and Mrs Borden and the servant there. Bridget Sullivan first told him of the murder. Was nervous at the time he saw the dead bodies, and went into the yard, where he remained two or three hours. Witness continued: Think the cellar door "was open when I went back to the house; the tern door was open. Saw the parlor door before it was washed and it Lad not less than 40 spots of blood splashed over the dour; the largest were at the bottom of the door and had tbe heaviest parts downward. Wit ness, the day after the murders. Haw the police put.the axes in a bag and take tluwn away. Mr Borden had told witness be had made a will. They were on South Main street at the time. He said something about some bequests atthc time; witness did not know what they' were but under stood that he would make a public bequest. Some time in May of this year, while ruling toward the farm in Swansea, he said he ■would give the girls some land if he thought they would accept it. Witness thought Emma washed the blood spots off the door, but did not see ter do it, and no one stopped her. He only estimated the number of spots. What ttridfct KwiHraa Matrthe f>ay of Um; MLmrdrr.
The inquest into the Borden murders opened with testimony from City Marshal Hilliard, police officers, and medical examiner Dr. Draper describing the autopsy wounds. Other witnesses described a mysterious pale young man near the Borden gate before the murders and a neighbor who heard someone climbing a fence the night before.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 2 September 1892 · page 1
Der Doppelmord von Fall-River
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Defense attorney Jennings argued it was physically impossible for Lizzie Borden to have committed the brutal axe murder of her father within the 25-minute window identified by prosecutors. He pointed to testimony about a stranger seen near the Borden house and a neighbor who heard someone climbing the fence the night before, suggesting an outside intruder rather than a family member was responsible.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 2 September 1892 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Defense argues the murderer struck from inside the house and questions why maid Bridget Sullivan wasn't suspected, while citing good relations between Lizzie and her father as reason doubting motive. District Attorney Knowlton counters that blows from behind indicate a weak woman did it and that only Lizzie benefited from the deaths; Judge Blaisdell rules the evidence points to her guilt and orders her held for trial in the November term.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 2 September 1892 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
At the Fall River preliminary hearing, Judge Blaisdell ruled there was probable cause and ordered Lizzie Borden held for the grand jury, remanding her to Taunton jail for the November term. Defense attorney Jennings had argued eloquently for her release, while District Attorney Knowlton argued for the prosecution.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 2 September 1892 · page 1
HELD FOR TRIAL.
Argument Failed to Acquit Her. Fai l Rivt.it, Mass. Sept. 1.—In the Borden hearing todav the arguments were made t»y Attorney Jennings for the defence and I >istrict Attorney Knowlton for the prosecution. Judge Blai«dell said that sympathy should he laid aside, and that duty, stern duty, re quires upon this evidence, hut one thing to . lie dime. Supposing a man had been seen in the chainl*r of Mrs. Borden. the guest chain her of death. and that he was in the room of the father when death came: suppose the man should tell many different stories as Lizzie has done, the way would he plain.
See moreSee less
1 find that she is probably guilty. She w as ordered remanded to the county jail at Taunton for trial at the November term. All wit nesses were ordered to recognize for the November term of court.
The judge found probable cause of guilt and remanded Lizzie Borden to Taunton jail for trial at the November term. Defense attorney Jennings then began his argument, questioning the timeline of the murder and the prosecution's theory that only household inmates could have committed the crime.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 2 September 1892 · page 1
HELD FOR TRIAL.
idea. The isolation of the Borden house has been shown, it is claimed, because nobody could get out as there were people all around to see who pas him I ami re passed, if any there were, and the attempt is made to ' show that no persons were seen. What is the fact, nowever? They know the house lias been burglarized within two years and the barn broken into w ithin two months and tin* facts are not disputed. We show some thing the police ought to have discovered, the stranger within the gate, as told hy Mrs.
See moreSee less
Manly. They have s|H*nt night and dav following up clues to convict Lizzie Borden, but know nothing about Mrs. Manly and tin man sinsaw . bemuse they are not looking for anybody outside; The extraordinary thing is that the police can't find tinman Dr. Handy >aw. but they can find tile axe or axes Lizzie Borden killed her father with. There is the fact that strange men
Lawyer Jennings argues to the court that circumstantial evidence points away from Lizzie Borden, citing unidentified strangers seen near the house and unaccounted time for servant Bridget Sullivan. He insists neither Lizzie nor Bridget committed the murders, invoking Lizzie's close bond with her father to sway sympathy.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 2 September 1892 · page 1
At the close of the preliminary hearing in Fall River, Judge Blaisdell ruled there was probable cause and ordered Lizzie Borden remanded to Taunton jail to stand trial at the November term of court. The report summarizes the closing arguments, including defense attorney Jennings' claim that no evidence proved her guilt and that another person could have committed the crime undetected.
The Portland Daily Press · 2 September 1892 · page 1
IN HER BEHALF. He Claims that There Is No Evidence to Show that His Client Is Guilty and that the Defence Has Demonstrated that Another Could Have Committed the Crime Undetected—The District Attor ney’s Answer. Fali, River, September 1.—In the Borden hearing today the arguments were made by Attorney Jennings for the defence and District Attorney Knowlton for the prosecution. At the conclusion Judge Blaisdell said: “Sympathy should be laid aside. Duty, stern duty, requires upon this evidence but one thing to be done. Suppose a man had been seen in the chamber of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden, the guest chamber of her death, and that he was in the room of the father when death came. Suppose this man should tell many different stories as Lizzie has done. The way would be plain. I find that she is probably guilty.” Miss Borden was ordered remanded to the county jail at Taunton for trial at the November term. All the witnesses were ordered to rec ognize for the November term of court. The pi’incipal points touched upon by the attorneys in their ai'guments follow:
The judge ruled that Lizzie Borden was probably guilty and ordered her held for trial at the November term, with witnesses recognized to appear then. Defense attorney Jennings began his argument, questioning the timeline of the murders and arguing the brutality suggested insanity or deep hatred rather than Lizzie's guilt.
The Portland Daily Press · 2 September 1892 · page 1
FOB THE DEFENCE. Mr. Jennings opened the argument for the defence. He said among other th ings that the complaint alleges that on the 4th day of August Andrew J. Borae n was killed by his daughter. He ap proached the subject with feelings wide ly different from any other case he had ever handled. Mr. Borden was not only his client, but his friend, and had any body told him four weeks ago that he should now be pleading for the daug hter of his old friend, ho should have said it was beyond the bounds of credibility.
See moreSee less
That Andrew J. Borden was murdered there is no doubt, and that the time of the murder has been established there is no doubt. The alarm was given at 11.13 to 11.15, and we know so far as we can know from the evidence that between Mr. Borden’s last entrance to the house and the alarm from 25 minutes to half an hour covers the time fully. What took place after he got there? Bridget Sullivan told her story and she left him in the sitting room reading a paper. Within half an hour Andrew J. Borden had to go into the house, have
Defense attorney Jennings argues that strangers near the Borden house, including men seen by Mrs. Manley and Dr. Handy, undermine the prosecution's theory that only household members could have committed the murders. He also questions Bridget Sullivan's unaccounted time and expresses doubt that either she or Lizzie committed the crime, moving Lizzie to tears.
The Portland Daily Press · 2 September 1892 · page 1
FOR THE DEFENCE.
but they can find the axe or axes Lizzie i Borden killed her father with. There is i the fact that strange men were there who have not been found. These men got : there and the neighbors didn’t see them, i
The District Attorney argues that Andrew Borden was killed about 90 minutes after his wife, based on stomach-content testimony from Prof. Wood over the local medical examiner's view. He contends the hatchet wounds show a weak, cowardly, possibly feminine hand striking from behind, and begins to explore who benefits from the killings.
The Portland Daily Press · 2 September 1892 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN IN JAIL S 1 - Continued From First Page. Going back to the crime, the District Attorney said: The pictures of that day are before Your Honor; one the
A speaker (likely prosecuting attorney) argues at the preliminary hearing that Lizzie had a motive rooted in conflict with her stepmother, whom she had refused to call 'mother' for five years. He also argues the house was so completely locked that no outsider could have entered or escaped undetected, pointing to the crime being committed from within.
The Portland Daily Press · 2 September 1892 · page 2
about property and for five years Mrs. Borden was forced to be treated by the girl she brought up as not her daughter, Do you suppose there was a well of af fection and sympathy flowing between
At the Fall River hearing, Bridget Sullivan's testimony is reported as strengthening the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden, with enough evidence to bind her over to the grand jury. The defense is investigating Sullivan's background in Newport and planning to challenge Dr. Dolan's medical testimony with expert witnesses.
The Mankato Free Press · 2 September 1892 · page 1
Miss Lizzie. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 29. -The hearing in the Borden case will be re sumed at 10:45 a. m. The defense has been actively engaged in Newport dur
Judge Blaisdell closed the preliminary examination of Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother, and ruled that the evidence showed she was probably guilty. She was ordered remanded to the Taunton jail to await trial at the November term, with witnesses bound over as well.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 2 September 1892 · page 1
REMANDED TO JAIL. Close of the Preliminary Exami nation of Lizzie Borden at Fall River, Mass. She Was Remanded to Jail at Taunton for Trial in No
After closing arguments in the preliminary hearing, Judge Blaisdell ruled that the evidence showed Lizzie Borden was probably guilty of murdering her father and stepmother. She was ordered remanded to the county jail in Taunton to await trial at the November term.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 2 September 1892 · page 1
Llxzlo IforUeit Held. Pall River, Mass., Sept. 1.—The bearing of the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and step-mother, was closed. After the lawyers on each side hail made their arguments. Judge Bluisdell said tliat rnnpattiy should be laid aside, and ! duty, stem duty, requires upon this evi ! dence but one thing to lie done. Sup posing that a man was seen in the chamber of Mrs. Borden, the chamber of death, and that he was in the room of the father when death came; supposing that a man should tell as many different stories as Lizzie has done.
See moreSee less
The way would 1st plain. "I find that she is probably guilty.” She was ordered .re manded to the county jail at Taunton for trial at the November term.
The preliminary hearing in the Borden murder case is expected to conclude today, with Lizzie Borden widely expected to be held for trial. Marshal Hilliard testified about police response times and searches of the property on the day of the murders.
The McCook Tribune · 2 September 1892 · page 6
LIZZIE BORDEN'S DEFENSE. Tli IJtiiirin. : ; fti the t\itnotn Case Nonrlng - * It Cliwi ? . * * * 1'ALi. ' RiVin , Mass.- Stint ; fdl The general opinion to-day is that the pre liminary hearing in the Borden double
An officer recounts the chaotic police search of the Borden house and yard on the day of the murders, describing who arrived when and what was found. The state's case closes with stenographic inquest notes, and defense witnesses Dr. Bowen testify about Lizzie's initial statements and Mrs. Borden's prior fears of poisoning.
The McCook Tribune · 2 September 1892 · page 6
LIZZIE BORDEN'S DEFENSE.
He saw Drs. Dolan , Cough lin , Peckham , Dutra and Tourtello , but was not positive whether Dr. Uowen was there or not. They were then in the room where Mr. Borden's body lay and were in consultation. He spoke to Dr. Dolan about the matter. He looked at the sofa but could not say whether any part of it was cut nor could he tell whether there was any blood spots on the head of it. There were blood spots on the parlor door , but he did not notice the chair.
See moreSee less
He made no search of the house but when he sent men to search the yard he also sent men to search the cellar. Nothing was delivered to him as the result of the search that afternoon. The state's case against Lizzie Borden - den closed yesterday afternoon with the presentation of the notes of Annie M. White , the official stenographer at the inquest Then Mr. Adams , for the defense , moved to strike out the testimony in regard to the attempt to purchase prnssic acid. The court refused to make the order at the time. Dr. W. S. Bowen , for the defense , testified that Lizzie first told him that her father had been stabbed. Mrs. * Borden called on him the day before the tragedy and told him sb.e feared that she herself , Mr. Borden and Lizzie had been poisoned the day before. It is claimed \ > y those who followed the state's case , as made out , that the testimony of Prof. Wood of Harvard , while seemingly favorable to Lizzie , so far as the blood matter was con cerned , was equally against her as es tablishing the fact that the times she was seen in the house were almost identical with the times of the mur ders.
The preliminary hearing in Fall River concluded with Judge Blaisdell ruling that the evidence showed Lizzie Borden was probably guilty of murdering her father and stepmother. She was ordered held at the Taunton county jail to await trial at the November term.
Paper unidentified · 2 September 1892 · page 5
At Liverpool, London, Sept. 2. At a mooting of the health committee of Liverpool an officer reported that the emigrants who em barked yesterday were in excellent health; that the city of Liverpool is in the healthiest condition it has been for a long time past, and there is no reason to fear an epidemic. The passengers of the Bteamer Gemma from Hamburg have been released from quarantine at Graves end. Untie lionlen Hold. Fall Eiveu, Mass., Sept. 1. The hearing of the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her fathor and stop-mother, was closed.'
See moreSee less
After the lawyers on each side had made their arguments, Judge Blaiwloll said that sympathy should be laid aside, and duty, stern duty, requires upon this evi dence but one thing to be done. Sup posing that a man was seen in the chamber of Mrs. Borden, the chamber of death, and that he was in the room of the father when death came; supposing that a man should toll as many different stories as Lizzie has done. The way would be plain. "I find that she is probably guilty." , She was ordered re manded to the county jail at Taunton for trial at the November term. Wanted la live States.
Following arguments from both defense counsel and the State, Judge Blaisdell ruled that Lizzie Borden would be held to await the action of the grand jury. The brief report marks the conclusion of the preliminary hearing phase.
Asheville Daily Citizen · 2 September 1892 · page 1
Lousviu.k, Ky., Sept. 2. A powerful combine to be known ns the Leaf To bacco company, was formed here vestcr dav, whose object is to compete with the newly organized tobacco com bine nt Cin cinnati. Held lotlie Urand Jury. Fall Rivkr, Mass., Sept. 2. The coun sel for Lizze Borden and the State made arguments yesterday before Judge Blais dell. The Court held Lizzie Borden to await the action of the grand jury.
Defense and prosecution counsel presented closing arguments at Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, reviewing the testimony given. Judge Blaisdell declined to release her and ordered her held to await grand jury action.
Paper unidentified · 2 September 1892 · page 1
The Borden Trial. Ey Telegraph to the News and Observer. Fall River, Mass , Sept. I.—The counsel for Lizzie Borden and for the State made an argument today before Judge Blaedell, reviewing the testimony given. The court would not release Lizzie Borden but held her to await the action of he grand jury. When Traveling Whether on pleasure, bent, or busi ness, take on every trip a bottle of Syrup of Figs, as it acts most pleasantly and effectively on the kidnej', liver and bowels, prevent ing fevers, headaches and other forms of sickness. For sale in 50 cents and $1 bottles by all leading druggists.
A newspaper editorial briefly comments on what it calls the murder trial of Lizzie Borden, noting that evidence has closed and arguments are underway. It highlights the mystery that despite the bloody nature of the murders, no blood was found on Borden or any weapon, and the murder weapon itself was never located.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 2 September 1892 · page 2
Tiie trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents, which is the great sensation of the day, has reached the point where the evi dence being closed, the argument is on. There are some very strange circumstances in the case. L'zzie Borden, the accused, is shown to
After the preliminary hearing concluded with arguments from both sides, Judge Blaisdell ruled that the evidence showed Lizzie Borden was probably guilty of murdering her father and step-mother. She was remanded to the county jail in Taunton to await trial at the November term of court, with all witnesses ordered to recognize for that term.
The State Chronicle · 2 September 1892 · page 1
Fall River, Mass , Sept. 1. The hearing in the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and step-mother was closed to-day. After the lawyers on each side had made their arguments Judge Blaidsell paid that sym pathy should be laid aside and duty, stern duty, Vequires upon this evi dence but one; thing to be done. Suppos ing that a man was seen in the chamber of Mrs. Borden, the chamber of death, and that he was in the room of the father when death came.
See moreSee less
Suppose that a man as many different stories as Lizzio has 6one, the way would be plain. "I find that she is probably guilty.1' She was ordered remanded to the county jail at Taunton for trial at the November term. All of the wit nesses were ordered to recognize for the November term of court.
The report describes revelations at Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, including claims that Bridget Sullivan had long known of conflict between Mrs. Borden and her stepdaughters. It also details a letter Lizzie wrote to her sister Emma describing a suspicious man she saw in the yard the night before the murders.
Emmons County Record · 2 September 1892 · page 3
LIZZIE IN COURT.
Is Reviewed. FALL KIVIB, Mass., Aug. 25.—It has come to the knowledKe of the public to-day that Bridget-Sullivan'had long before the tra gedy at the .Borden home confided to inti mate friends certain l'acts wliich.ieave little doubt that there had been a constant war fare going on in the Second street house. Mrs. Borden and her atepdaUKhters were on
At the inquest, Lizzie Borden testified she saw a suspicious man in the yard Monday night before the murder and wrote to her sister Emma about it; that letter was reportedly destroyed, as was another letter Lizzie sent to friends in Marion. The report also prints a letter from a Jewish peddler describing a bloodied stranger he met near New Bedford on the day of the murder.
Emmons County Record · 2 September 1892 · page 3
Jewish I'eddl.r. FALL RIVKB, Aug. 26.—Mr. Jennings, couusel for the defense, has given out the following letter for publication: Wultham, Mass., Aug. 17,18U2.—Miss Emma Borden, Dear Madnm: My name 1H Samuel Robinsky. 1 am a Jewish peddler. When the fatal murder iu Fall River occurred 1 was only a lew miles from Fall River ifiat day. While sitting on the roadside towards New Bedford,' I met a man who was covered with blood. He told me that he worked on a farm and that he never could get his wages so he had a tight with the farmer.
See moreSee less
He said be ran away and did not get. any uiouey after all, all he had was a $6 bill. He bought of me fourhuuiktrcbieji), one looking one necktie, collar and shoe blacking. His
At Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing in Fall River, Medical Examiner Dolan testified about the position of the bodies, cause of death by shock, and his examination of axes found in the cellar. A separate letter from a man claiming to have seen a mysterious bloodstained stranger was also mentioned as evidence being investigated by the defense.
Emmons County Record · 2 September 1892 · page 3
FALL RIVSB, Mass., Aug. 26.—TheSecond district court rooiu never before held such a crowd as that which greeted Judge Blai* dell this morning. It was tbe second date agreed upon for the hearing of Miss Lizzie A. Borden on the charge of killing her father with an ax. Ladies occupied more than two-thirds of the seats usually occu pied by the curious gang who usually fre quent the lower courts. At 10:30 o'clock Mr. Charles J. Holmes appeared with Miss Emma Borden on his arm. Miss Lizzie Borden came in last with Marshal Hillard.
See moreSee less
She was handed to a seat between her two legal advisers, and near a settee on which tier sister was seated.. The two .women sat elbow to elbow. Miss Lizzie was at her sister's ri.'ht hand. Not a word was passed between them. Medical Examiner Dolan was called to .the stand. The witness testified as to the position of the bodied of the murdered cou ple when found and to sending their stomachs to Frof. Wood,of Harvard colle e, for analysis.' Surveyor Kiernan then took tbe stand. He thought from the appear ance of a spot of blood on the door casing thatlt was thrown lrom the sitting room toward the kitchen,. Lizzie bore
A brief dispatch from Fall River, Massachusetts reports that Lizzie Borden has been held to appear before the Grand Jury for the murder of her father and stepmother. No further details are given.
Morning Appeal · 2 September 1892 · page 3
A Laborer Killed. San Francisco, September 1--An unknown laborerer in the employ of the Metropolitan Electric Railway, was killed on O'Farrell street today by an electric car. Lizzie Borden Held for Murder. Fall River, Mass., Sep-, 1. Liz zie Borden has been held to appear before the Grand Jury, for the mur der of her.father and stepmother.
Lizzie Borden was taken back to Taunton jail after Judge Blaisdell ruled she should be held for the grand jury following the preliminary hearing. Her lawyer Jennings maintains her innocence, while the defense plans to focus on identifying mysterious figures seen near the Borden house on the day of the murder rather than filing a habeas corpus plea.
The Evening Herald · 2 September 1892 · page 3
BACK IN TAUNTON JAIL
presentation to the grand Jury. No habeas corpus plea will be made by tho defendant's lawyers. They will de vote their time to hunting down the mys terious people seen nround the Borden house tho day of the murder. Andrew J. Jennings believes firmly in Miss Lizzie's innocence. His great plea Is the principal topic of conversation. It appeals to tho popular ear, and it will be many days before the citizens begin to look upon the prisoner ns a criminal. When court began yesterday morning Mr. Jennings opened for tho defense.
See moreSee less
said, among other things, that the He complaint alleges, that on the fourth day of August, Andrew J. liorden was killed by his daughter. He approached the sub ject with feelings widely different from any other case which he had ever before handled. Mr. Borden was not only his client, but his friend, and had anybody told him four weeks ago that ho Bhould now be pleading for tho daughter of his old friend he should have said it was beyond the bounds of credibility. That Ami ' ' J. Borden was murdered there was : . ibt. and that the time of murder has i t n established there was no doubt, be saia The uhirm was given at 11:13 to 11:15, and the time between Mr. Borden's last entrance to the house and the alarm was 1 about 25 minutes. What occurred after he got there! Bridget Sullivan told her story, and she left him lu the silting room reading a paper. Within half an hour Andrew J. Borden had to go into the house, havo his talk with Lizzie, if he hod one, go up
Alice Russell testified about Lizzie's demeanor and locked bedroom door on the day of the murders. Drug clerk Eli Bence and others testified that Lizzie had tried to buy prussic acid the day before the killings, while officer Doherty recounted her explanation of being in the barn.
Sullivan Republican · 2 September 1892 · page 2
WANTED PRUSSIC ACID. Eli Bence, drugclerk, testified that ho remembered the day of the tragedy, and was acquainted with Lizzie Borden. Witness saw her in his store the day before, and she asked him for 10 cents worth o' prossic acid to put on a sealskin sack or cape, but he told her he could not sell it without a physician's prescription. BENCH'S TESTIMONY counonouATEn Frank 11. Kilroy, who was in the store when Mms Borden called, said he heard her ask for prußsicacid. Frederick B. Hart, an employe in the drug store, corroborated the testimony of Bence. Patrick 11. Dohertv, police officer, testified: Miss Borden was asked
Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing concluded, resulting in her being held for trial at the November term of court. The report details the defense's opening arguments, which focused on the narrow timeframe for the murder and the lack of a hiding place for an outside assassin.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 2 September 1892 · page 9
MISS BORDEN HELD
What occurred after he got there? Brid get Sullivan told her story and she left him in the sitting room reauinga paper. With in half an hour Andrew J. Borden had to
Defense attorney Jennings argues there was no motive for Lizzie Borden to kill her parents, citing lack of financial need and insufficient time to dispose of evidence, while pointing to an unidentified stranger seen near the house. District Attorney Knowlton then begins the prosecution's argument, describing the killer as weak and irresolute based on the nature of the axe wounds.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 2 September 1892 · page 9
ALSO THE PALPABLE WANT OF MOTIVE
stranger within the gate, as told by Mrs. Manley. They have spent night nnd day following up clews to conyict Lizzie Bor den, but know nothing about Mrs. Manley and the man she saw. Why? Because they are not looking for anybody outBide. The extraordinary thing is that "the police cannot find the man Dr. Handy saw, bnt they can find the ax or axes Lizzie Borden killed her father with."
District Attorney Knowlton argues to the court that the murderer was weak and cowardly, striking from behind, and suggests the evidence points to Lizzie Borden rather than an intruder. He walks through the household's movements that morning, arguing there was no place for a stranger to hide and no one else could have committed the crime during the narrow window of opportunity.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 2 September 1892 · page 9
way to get anywhere. And that set us to thinking, nnd who was thore that could Im agine that everything could be clear for him who calmly thought he could await in that house lor an hour aud a half. I can't con ceive of a villain who is also a fool. I know no difference between roputable and honest Lizzie Borden and reputable and honest Bridget Sullivan. When Lizzie Borden testified she told different storiesshe contradicted herself. Where wero Airs. Borden and Lizzie when Bridget came Into tho house that morning after she had gone Into the yard?
See moreSee less
They were uistnlrs alone. Before that Mrs. Borden had told her to wash windows. Mr. Borden had gone away, and when Bridget came to the screen door Lizzie appeared and was to!d by Bridget she need not lock the door: that she would be In tho yari) anil could soo anybody going or coming; that sho would get her water in the barn It Lizzie said so. All the house was clear but of Lizzie and her stepmother, and when Mr. Borden was down townand when Morse was away and wuen isriuijec was at worK in tne yard tuen the deed was dono in that upper room; and wlion Mr. Borden was let lit by Bridget, Liz zie and Abbie Borden were alone In tho guest chanbor one dead, the other alive; and when Lizzie was at the head or the stairs, when Bridget was at the door, she was where a woman was so killed that when she lell, with her mass of floah, to the floor, she bruised her face and made such a noise it must have been heard.
The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I.
A humor/miscellany column lists sarcastic one-liners on various current events. One notes that Fall River, normally only excited by strikes, now has the Borden murders as a welcome diversion.
The Olneyville Times · 2 September 1892 · page 2
The people of Fall River have had nothing in way of excitement but strikes for years, and naturally the Borden murders are almost & boon to them. The Queen Regent of Spain is trying to stop bull-fighting in that country. Such a course is all the more commendable from the very slight chance of success.
The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I.
This miscellaneous local news column from Manton and Lymansville reports community happenings, visits, and small-town affairs. Amid items about shopkeepers, vacations, and social visits, it notes that Mr. and Mrs. R. Richardson traveled to Fall River to attend the Borden trial.
The Olneyville Times · 2 September 1892 · page 2
SMALL TALK.
New York City. Mr. and Mrs. R. Richardson visited Fall River this week and attended the Borden trial. The school house wall is nearly com pleted on the Manton avenue side. Allie Prior, clerk at Oliver Johneon's, is taking his vacation in this vicinity. Alfred Holden, clerk at C. L.. Holden & Co.’s, is on his vacation and Hiram King has taken his place at the store. David Stranger, has just returned from a vigit in Connecticut. Misses Ruth and Alice Deveraux, are visiting in Arlington. Mies Hattie Devol of Taunton, is visit
The Fall River News reports that the preliminary hearing has concluded with both attorneys delivering closing arguments, Jennings' being judged more eloquent. Lizzie Borden calmly accepts being held in Taunton jail until her case reaches the higher court, saying exoneration should come from there.
The Providence News · 2 September 1892 · page 1
IS SHE GUILTY OR INNOCENT, Public Opinion is Still Fluectuating Lizzie Borden Takes the Prospect of two Months in Jall Very Calmly —~“ It is Best,” She Says, *“That Ex honeration Should Comeoe From the Higher Court.”
The report recounts prosecutor Knowlton's argument that the wounds suggested a timid, feminine hand rather than great force, undermining Dr. Dolan's earlier claim of heavy blows. It also stresses that Lizzie had sole opportunity during her mother's murder since the house was locked and Bridget was outside washing windows.
The Providence News · 2 September 1892 · page 1
But it was entirely refuted by Dr. Dra rr. The vlows were light. Only in one nstance in Mr. Borden's case was there a blow sufliciently strong to cut through bone one-sixteenth of an inch in thick ness, Such blows were possible by a woman, and Attorney Knowlton was shrewd enough to make a strong point of this fact, that the nature of the wounds was such as to warrant the statement that they must have been made by a femin fne hand: that beiog struck in the back,
Judge Blaisdell, visibly emotional, ruled Lizzie Borden "probably guilty" at the close of the preliminary hearing, and she received the decision calmly, expressing confidence she would be exonerated at trial. John Morse and Bridget Sullivan were also ordered to post bond to testify before the grand jury.
The Providence News · 2 September 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
LIZZIE BORDEN STANDS UP TO BE COMMITTED.
IN TAUNTON JAIL.
The Courtain Drops on the Borden Tragedy.
See moreSee less
TO RAISE IN NOVEMBER
Two Acts Have Been Played Out to Their Close.
IS SHE GUILTY OR INNOCENT.
Public Opinion is Still Fluctuating -- Lizzie Borden Takes the Prospect of two Months in Jail Very Calmly --"It is Best," She Says, "That Exhoneration Should Come From the Higher Court."
[SPECIAL TO THE NEWS.]
FALL RIVER, Sept. 2.--There are still various shades of opinion on the Borden case ranging from the inspired believer in Lizzie's innocence to those who are confident that she is the one described by Mr. Jennings as either "Insane" or inspired by "hatred as black as hell itself."
Whichever may be the true view, and undoubtedly one or the other is true, for there is no middle ground in a case like this, may never be known, but the final judgment of the highest tribunal is still some months away and the public must accept what it has as the full evidence until more is shown.
It is the office of the reporter to portray facts and describe public opinion of them. That has been the aim of this column, and the fact that in neither of the arguments presented yesterday was there any new thought developed is conclusive evidence that the readers of the NEWS have had access to all the evidence that has been available.
The pleas of the opposing attorneys yesterday were as different as it was possible to conceive. Both were specimens of keen logic and each made the best possible presentation of his view of the case. Of the two that of Mr. Jennings was the more eloquent and effective on the audience.
It was an address wherein the array of facts in his client's favor, the disproof of all the theories of the prosecution, and the appeals to humanity and mercy were blended with the nicest precision and voiced by a man whose inspiration was his soulful conviction that the defendant is innocent.
The points that he made have already been detailed the possibilities of someone else being there, as shown by the unsolved burglaries. The absence of blood and the failure to find a weapon were emphasized yesterday by the obvious fact that Miss Borden was ill on Wednesday morning. Her mother said so, she said so and Bridget said so. On that morning she was in her room and hence she did not go out and try to buy prussic acid on that day Mr. Bence said. This somewhat effectually disposes of the prussic acid motive theory, so far at least as present evidence goes. It leaves the government with absolutely nothing in the way of fact to prove Lizzie's guilt, except her presence at the house, her opportunity to commit the murder and her own unintelligible account of her acts and statements.
Unfortunately for her, while these are plainly inadequate as positive evidence of guilt, they are adequate ground for suspicion--and that is the ground which Mr. Knowlton took in his plea for the prosecution. It was repeated again and again and emphasized forcibly that he at no time considered that he had proofs of her guilt. He would be prepared to prove that when it became necessary. All that he wished to do at that hearing was to establish good evidence for strong suspicion and he claimed to have done it.
He claimed that the wounds were not those caused by great force and they were not. He stated that they were those of a timid irresolute hand and the evidence of Dr. Draper was convincing that no one of the first eight wounds were "necessarily fatal."
It was this damaging evidence that Mr. Adams very thoughtlessly brought out in his cross-questioning. It had been claimed by the prosecution that the blows were crushing, heavy blows. Dr. Dolan had testified to that fact and it was of material advantage to the defence that that fact should be established.
But it was entirely refuted by Dr. Draper. The blows were light. Only in one instance in Mr. Borden's case was there a blow sufficiently strong to cut through bone one-sixteenth of an inch in thickness.
Such blows were possible by a woman, and Attorney Knowlton was shrewd enough to make a strong point of this fact, that the nature of the wounds was such as to warrant the statement that they must have been made by a feminine hand: that being struck in the back, they were the work of a moral coward who did not dare face the unfortunate victim.
Mr. Knowlton also made it plain that the front door at least was locked until Mr. Borden returned at about half past nine. Bridget was out washing windows and Lizzie was alone with her mother upstairs. And that was the time when her mother was killed.
It is extremely improbable that anyone could have entered the house while Bridget was washing windows. This more than gives Lizzie "opportunity;" it gives her the only opportunity thus far known and she does not attempt to prove an alibi at that time. Her alibi only applies to the time when her father was killed, and that is such a halting one that it surpasses credulity to use the words of Mr. Knowlton.
That these circumstances are sufficient to prove suspicion there can be little doubt, and having proved suspicion the case of the government is finished.
Side Lights on the Case--Insanity.
Of the side lights yesterday let in on the case two are important. One applies to Mr. Knowlton's public admission that the government had a great deal more evidence than it had used, and that is undoubtedly true. There is evidence in this case which has been given to parties in confidence that is very strong, though entirely circumstantial and indirect in its character. It will be used when necessary and not before.
The second side light, so to speak, relates to Mr. Jennings statement that the murderer "must be insane." That is not a meaningless phrase. It is a statement of fact as it exists. But it is more than that. It is the utterance of an inspired prophet. It is in short the prophecy of the line which the defence will adopt should convicting evidence be shown against Lizzie. Bear in mind that Mr. Jennings was not called upon to make this statement. It had little to do with his argument. It neither aided nor hindered his plea at the hearing. It was a gratuitous admission on his part, and it shows, perhaps, stronger than anything else the turn which his mind is taking in the case.
His plea will be insanity. In this he has but confirmed the presentation of the facts made in Saturday's NEWS that Miss Borden has those characteristics, not only of action but of feature and expression, that give the strongest grounds for doubting her entire sanity under all circumstances.
How Lizzie Received the News.
The scene in the court room was affecting yesterday afternoon when the end of the hearing was reached. The judge's voice was choked with grief and his eyes were filled with tears as he uttered the words "you are probably guilty."
The words were received by the prisoner without a movement. She sat quietly in her seat until called upon to stand while the clerk read the order of the court. Then she stood without assistance and as quietly received the decision of the judge. Words of sympathy were heard on all sides, and when Mr. Buck spoke to her she interrupted him by saying:
"It is for the best, I think. It is better that I should get my exoneration in a higher court, for then it will be complete."
John V. Morse and Bridget Sullivan were ordered to furnish bonds to the amount of $500 each for appearance at the November term of the grand jury. They readily obtained the amounts, John C. Milne and Frank Almy going bail for both.
There being nothing further to do, Miss Lizzie arose, took the proffered arm of the Rev. Mr. Buck and walked resolutely along the corridor to the matron's room, followed by Mrs. Brigham, who was on the border of hysteria, so grief-stricken was she.
Miss Emma awaited her sister in the matron's room and Mr. Buck soon left them together.
The Inquest Not Ended.
It has been stated in the morning papers that the first act in the Borden case is finished. The statement is misleading, for it conveys the idea that the prosecuting authorities will rest. Such, however, is not the case.
The inquest is not yet finished, and no time has been set for its end. It will be continued so long as any suspicious circumstances or characters can be found and examined.
This report covers Judge Blaisdell's ruling that Lizzie Borden is 'probably guilty' of murdering her father and stepmother, concluding the preliminary hearing. It notes the decision was widely anticipated and discusses how the case against her relied heavily on her own inquest testimony after other government theories failed.
The Providence News · 2 September 1892 · page 4
JUDGE BLAISDELL’'S DECISION. The decision of Judge Blaisdell that Lizzie A. Borden is *‘ probably guilty » of the murder of her father and step
This short item in a roundup column states that the evidence in the Lizzie Borden trial at Fall River, Mass., closed the previous Wednesday evening. It is one line among many unrelated national and international news briefs.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · 2 September 1892 · page 2
NEWS IN A NUTSHELL
Reports of a rubber trust are again cur rent. Hon. Atllai E. Stevenson spoke at Vin cennes, lnd., Thursday. Gus Hart, of Minneapolis, Was killed by cars at Alexandria. Ind. Nashly Bct.nett and wife were killed at a crossing at Kenssalaer, Ina. Joseph McVain,. living near Newark, O., accidentally shot himself while hunting, v The evidence In the Lizzie Borden trial
Defense attorney Jennings and prosecutor Knowlton presented closing arguments in the Borden preliminary hearing. Judge Blaisdell ruled Lizzie Borden should answer to the charges at the November Superior Court term and she was committed to the county jail.
The Salt Lake Herald · 2 September 1892 · page 1
BORDEN MURDERS arguments In the Caie Finished Prisoner Bound Oyer Until the Not ember Term FALL RIVER Mass Sept 1The argu ments in the Borden case were resumed
Judge Blaisdell ruled after arguments from both counsel that Lizzie Borden is probably guilty and ordered her held for trial at the November term. He stated that duty required this finding despite sympathy, citing her shifting accounts of events.
Richmond Dispatch · 2 September 1892 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN JAILED. The Judge Finds that She “1s Probably Guilty ’—His Remarks. (By telogranh to the Dispatch. S704 MARY NEE SNE Trina" Farr Rives, Mass., September 1,—Coun.
At the preliminary hearing in Fall River, defense and prosecution lawyers made closing arguments before Judge Blaisdell reviewing the testimony. The judge ruled that based on the evidence Lizzie Borden was probably guilty and ordered her held in county jail to await grand jury action at the November term.
The Roanoke Times · 2 September 1892 · page 4
"SHE IS PROBABLY GUILTY." Lizzie Borden Hold for the Action of the Grand Jury. Fall River, Mass., Sept. 1.?[Spe? cial]?Counsel for Lizzie Borden and for
A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden has been sent on to the grand jury following her preliminary hearing. It appears among a list of general national news items.
The Times · 2 September 1892 · page 4
GENERAL. Jean Roemer, half brother of the late King of Holland, is dead in New York.——Professor Pickering, of Harvard, reports some very interesting discoveries in Mars. —— Lizzie Borden has been sent on to the grand jury. —— Judge Wilham R. Blaine. ordinary of Glynn county, Georgia, has been arrested for stealing money.—— The President has issued a proclamation pro hibiting any vessel from landing at any port of the United States without being fumi. gated.—Alarm is felt lest cabin passengers from Europe may bring cholera with them. —No new cases havo appeared on the Mo ravia.
At the preliminary hearing, Judge Blaisdell ruled there was probable cause and ordered Lizzie Borden bound over to the grand jury. The report also covers defense attorney Jennings' opening argument, which questioned the timeline of the murder and suggested only ten to fifteen minutes existed for the crime to have been committed.
The Times · 2 September 1892 · page 1
MISS LIZZIE "PROBABLY GUILTY,"
ARGUMENT FOR THE DEFENSE. Mr. Jennings opened for the defense. He said, among other things, that the complainant alleges that on the 41h day of August Andrew J. Borden was Killed Ly bis daughter. He approached the sub
Defense counsel Jennings argues the murders could have been committed by an outsider, citing witnesses who saw strange men near the house and prior break-ins the police ignored. He contends the government fixated solely on household inmates while failing to pursue leads about unidentified men seen near the property.
The Times · 2 September 1892 · page 1
ARGUMENT FOR THE DEFENSE.
Leen directed by :hat one idea. Tt is claimed that nobody could get out of tha house without being seen because thera were people ull around. The government knows the house has been broken into in the daytime within two years, and the bern broken into witdin two months and the facts are not disputed; we show something the police ought to have dis covered, the stranger within the ate, as tokl by Mrs. Manley. They have spent night and day follow ing up clues to convict Lizzie Borden, bué know nothing about Mrs. Manley aud the man she saw. Why? Beciuso they are not looking for anybody out side. The extraordinary thing is that
After closing arguments from both defense and prosecution at the preliminary hearing, Judge Blaisdell ruled that the evidence showed Lizzie Borden was probably guilty and ordered her held for the grand jury. She was remanded to Taunton jail to await the November term of court.
The Times · 2 September 1892 · page 1
SENT ON TO THE GRAND JURY.
The hearing in the case was closed after the lawyers op each side had made their arguments. Judge Blaisdell then said that sympathy should be laid asids, and duty, stern duty, requires upon this evidence but one thing te be done. Sup posing | N a man was seen in the cham er of Mrs. Borden, the chamber of death, and that he was in the room of the father when death came; supposa that a man should tell gs many diferent stories as Lizzie had done, the way would be plain.
See moreSee less
“I find that she is probably guilty.” The accused was sent on to the grand jury. She was romanded to the county jail at Taunton for trial at the Novernber term, all the witnes<es to be recognized for the November term
The week-long preliminary hearing in Fall River concluded with the judge ordering Lizzie Borden held for trial in the hatchet murders of her father and stepmother, and she was transported to the jail in Taunton. The report notes no positive evidence had been presented against her, and suggests a growing public belief that she could not have committed the crime.
Vermont Phœnix · 2 September 1892 · page 8
Lizzie Borden Bound Over
I.lzzlr Hnrilrii Hound Otrr. The hearing at Fall Biver, Mass., in the case of Lizzie Borden, accused of the bru tal murder of her father and stepmother with a hatchet, which ha; been in prog ress for the past week, closed yesterday with a decision of the judge holding Miss Borden for trial, and she was taken to the jail at Taunton. No positive evidence against her has been adduced, and there is a growing belief that it is Impossible that she committed the crime. The Hartford Times contains this item in a column of social notes: "Do not chain up your dog, but give him freedom to exercise as his nature demands; his en tire physical being Is framed for activity, and he suffers greatly if kept chained up."
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
At the preliminary hearing in Fall River, the judge determined there was probable cause that Lizzie Borden murdered her parents. Defense attorney Jennings argued the prosecution lacked motive evidence and ignored other suspects, while questioning how she could have hidden all evidence in just fifteen minutes.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 2 September 1892 · page 1
OF THE MURDER OF HER PARENT ? Eloquent Arguments of Con use Tho Sfnto Makes Out u Stroi Case of Circumstantial Point Miss Borden's Counsel Points Oi That il' Sho Committed the Crin She Had Hut Filteeu Ulinuti Afterward to Hide All (he Ev deuce. Fall' River, Mass., fc'opt. 1.?Cou camo iu at 10:30 this morning and few minutes later Lizzie Borden en ten
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
District Attorney Knowlton argued the government's case at the preliminary hearing, highlighting inconsistencies in Lizzie Borden's account of her time in the barn and suggesting a planned, cold-blooded murder. Judge Blaisdell found probable cause and ordered her held for trial at the November term of the Superior Court.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 2 September 1892 · page 1
OF THE MURDER OF HER PARENTS
never yet found tho wrap that covore Lizzie Borden and took the blood froi tlioso bodies. Wo have not yot foun the hatchet which did the work. Th thing was concoived in tho head of cool Loaded, deliberate woman. Judge Blaisdoll said that sympath should bo laid aaido and duty, stor duty requires upon this ovidcncc bt ono thing to bo done. Supposing a ma was soon in tho chamber of Mrs. Bo den, the guost chamber of death, an that ho was in tho room ol the fatht when death camo.
See moreSee less
Suppose that a ma should tell as many different stories t Lizzio has dono, the way would be plait I find that sho is probably guilty. Tho accused was ordered to tho coui ty jail for trial at the November tern All the witnossos wore ordcrod to be rei oguizod for tho November term of cour
At Fall River, Lizzie Borden's attorney argued the state's case was built on the flawed theory that only a household member could have committed the murders, citing unexplored leads like Mrs. Manley's stranger sighting. The judge found probable cause and remanded Borden to county jail to await the November term of court.
Wheeling Register · 2 September 1892 · page 1
Fall Rivek, Mass., September 1.—Court came in at 10:30 this morning, and a few minutes after Lizzie Borden entered the room. Mr. Jordan opened for the defence. He said that among other things that the complaint alleges that on tho fourth day of August Andrew J. Borden was killed by his daughter. He approached the subject with feelings widely different from auy other case which he had ever handled. Mr. Borden was not only his client, but
At the close of the preliminary hearing, the prosecutor argued that Lizzie Borden's account of her time in the barn was implausible and suggested a motive involving an attempt to buy prussic acid. Judge Blaisdell ruled that the evidence was sufficient to find her probably guilty and ordered her held for trial at the November term of court.
Wheeling Register · 2 September 1892 · page 1
I The demeanor of the defendant is re • markable. Wo have never -yet found the i Wrap that covered Lizzie Borden and too* the blood from those bodies. We have not i vet found the hatchet which did the worn. This thing was conceived in the bead of a cool headed, deliberate woman. If your Honor should yield to the eloquent argu ments of mv brother aud allow this woman ! to go that would not be the end or this 1 matter. The reward that attends duty done I is what should be considered.
See moreSee less
; judge Blaisdell sa:d that sympathy should be laid aside and duty, stern duty, I reouired upon this evidence that but one I thine be done. Supposing a man was seen I in the chamocr of Mrs. Borden, the guest chamber of death, and that he was in the | room ot the father when death came: sup pose that a man should tell as many differ
Buried in a roundup of political news from across the country, a single sentence notes that Lizzie Borden has been held for the murder of her parents in Fall River, Massachusetts. No further detail is given.
Mohave County Miner · 3 September 1892 · page 2
8evensou stems to arouse mora on ttiuNiasm utiiunt the masses than Clove land The train rubbers have ntjt yet put in an appearance at the Fresno county Csl jail The presi leutial candidates are chang ing their reiidene pending the struggle lor political supremacy Lizzie Borden has been held for the
This dispatch reports that England views President Harrison's cholera quarantine regulations for immigrant ships with approval and some envy, noting British measures are comparatively weak. It briefly notes British officials may need a retrospective act to legalize their own detention of immigrants at Gravesend.
Morning Journal and Courier · 3 September 1892 · page 3
JEALOUSY PROMPTED THE DEED. Lizzie Borden Conreyed to Jail at Taunton. THE CHOLERA PLAGUE. England Greatly Interested In tne Cbolera Circular of Pre.ldent Hsr rlson The Xhorooghnes. and
Lizzie Borden was taken from the central station in Fall River to a 1:29 train bound for Taunton, where she will be held in the county jail until the grand jury convenes in November. She was accompanied by Marshal Hilliard, Detective Seaver, and Rev. Mr. Buck, and appeared calm before a large crowd of onlookers at the depot.
Morning Journal and Courier · 3 September 1892 · page 3
CONVEYED TO JAIL. Lizzie Borden Taken to Taunton by marshal Hllllard. Fall Eiver, Sept. 2 Mies Lizzie Bor den was taken from the central station at
The report covers inquest testimony in the Lizzie Borden case, including servant Bridget Sullivan's account of the morning of the murders and Dr. Dolan's admission that the victims' heads had been removed for examination. It notes little doubt exists that Borden will be held for trial, though no evidence yet clearly fixes the crime on her.
The Washington Bee · 3 September 1892 · page 4
LIZZIE BORDEN IN COURT. Investigation of the Murder Mystery of Fall River, Mass.
tion of the wounds of the murdered Bor dens. He created a sensation when he admitted that the heads had been re moved from the murdered bodies by or der of the District Attorney, and that the skulls were in his possession. The testimony of John V. Moore, the uncle of the Borden girls, tended to throw doubt on the stories of quarrels and ill feeling in the Borden family. The cross-examination failed to shake
At the preliminary hearing, a medical witness revealed the victims' heads had been removed by order of the District Attorney for examination, while other testimony cast doubt on family quarrel stories and confirmed no blood was found on Lizzie Borden's clothing or the hatchets. Experts also found no poison in the victims' stomachs, leading some to believe this evidence pointed to her innocence, though she was still expected to be held for trial.
The Washington Bee · 3 September 1892 · page 4
Bridget Sullivan's testimony. It is con ceded that the District Attorney did not draw out all of the servant's evidence, and the defence also avoided doing so. Little doubt is entertained that Lizzie Borden will be held for trial. Slight discrepancies were shown by witnesses to have occurred in Lizzie Borden's statements after the fire, but the most important evidence related to the fact that there were no signs of blood on her clothing or hands, and no evidence of excitement or exertion such as would naturally have follow ed the murder. It is said that the defence will introduce
Judge Blaisdell, who committed Lizzie Borden for trial at Fall River, had also presided at the inquest and the preliminary hearing. The report notes this overlap could be used in her defense before a higher court if she is convicted.
The Morning News · 3 September 1892 · page 12
Judge Blaisdell, who, at Fall River. Mass., day iof ore yesterday committed Lizsie Borden for trial, also presided at the Inquest and held the young womau fur the
The judge presiding over Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing in Fall River, Mass., ruled that the evidence showed sufficient probability of guilt to hold her for the grand jury's November term. The report notes the evidence against her is largely circumstantial, based on inconsistent statements about her whereabouts and her conduct during the proceedings.
Lizzie Borden Held for Trial. The judge who presided at tbe prelim inary triel of Lizzie Borden, at Fail River, Maas., bes decided that tbe evidence shows a sufficient probability of guilt to justify him in bolding the aocu-ed to await the no tion cf the grand jury at the November term of tbe court. This case is a remarkable one, and has attracted the attention of the whole ooun try. Tbe accused, Lizzie .'lorden. Is charged with having mun.ered her father and her step-mother. The Crimea were c rn littod in Mr.
See moreSee less
Borden’s house soon after breakfast. There is no direct evidence against tbe acoueed, and tbe circumstantial evidence Is not strung. The evidence upon which the : judge based his action Is tbe conflicting ■lories told by the accused as to her here abouts about the time tbe murders were committed, and her conduct before and during the trial. It must be admitted that tbe stories the accused told were calculated to direct sus picion toward her, but they are not suffi cient to justify tbe belief that she i* guilty. In the exoitement that followed the finding of the bodies of her father and mother it was not unnatural that the statement* she mad* to different person* should not be alike in every particular, or even In Im portant particulars. Whether her conduct before and during the preliminary trial was that of a guilty pertun no one can say with a satisfactory degree of certainty, because, under such trying circumstances, different persons would act differently. One thing In connection with the case is in favor of the accused. It is that tbs servant, Bridget Hullivan, who was in a room adjoining the rooms in which tbe murders were committed, heard nothing that indicated that anything unusual was taking plaoe in lbe house. It seems hardly probable that a woman could have killed her father and step-mother with a hatchet or an az without making sufficient noise to attract the attention of a servant who was so near the scene of the tragedy. Although sentiment In Fall River het been all along strongly in favor of the ac cused, it Is hardly probable that tbe action of the judge remanding her to jail to await tbe action of the grand jury will be un favorably onticited. Value of a Clean BUI of Health. There were twenty-two deaths from cholera on the Moravia on her voyage from Hamburg to New York and yet the steamer carried a clean bill of health from our con sul at that port. The Moravia left Ham
This opinion piece argues the prosecuting attorney showed excessive zeal to convict Lizzie Borden and may have influenced the judge. It contends her inconsistent statements don't prove guilt, noting no motive, weapon, or bloodstains were found.
The Indianapolis Journal · 3 September 1892 · page 4
It is said that Miss Lizzie Borden's at torneys expected that the judge who pre sided at the preliminary bearing would bind her over for trial bat this expecta tion was based on the theory that the judge was assisting the proiecution and not on the evidence broucht out. The prosecuting attorney hs made a remarka ble display of zeal in bis axtempt to prove Miss burden guilty, and has apparently infected the judge with his anxietv. to con vict the young woman. Certaiuly, those who have followed the testimony as it bas been given to the press can see nothing on whiqh to base a verdict of guilty.
See moreSee less
Great stress is laid upon the fact that Miss Borden varied eoraowLat in her statements as to her whereabouts at the time of the mur der, but such variation is not in the least inconsistent with innocence. Had she ad hered to one story without chauge it wonld have been equally suspicious. She her self said, on the first examination, when questioned as to the difference in her state ments, "I have bean 'asked so many quesTTTE INDIANAPOLIS 'JOURNAL. SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 3, 1892.; everywhere for municipal officers to tions this morning that I feel confused." Very few persons can tell with exactness neglect and shirk ! their duty, and precisely what they were doing at any it'ia also common for them to given moment of the previous twenty-four overlook many unsanitary conditions hours nnless something unusual fixed it on out of uheer ignorance of the menace their minds, and nothing is moid common they offer to public health. Wmen un than to hear positive statements as posi derstand the necessity of cleanliness in tively contradicted when made in regard to their own households, and many of happenings of everyday life. No adequate them have made a study of sanitary motive for the commission of the crime science in improving their own dwell has been suggested, no weapon with which ings. Intelligent and observing women It could have been committed has been found, and no spot of blood upon cannot fail to bo of much assistance in the daughter's clothing. Because she suggesting improvements in the way of was somewhere about the place cleaning up the city, and wherever they at the time of the murder organize themselves for such purpose and because no man could have escaped the city officials should welcome their over the back fence without being seen by aid and advice. Such advice would not the neighbors, the conclusion is that this come amiss in Indianapolis, where the young woman, who has always borne a municipal housekeeping is of a very good character, butohored her father and poor order, indeed. mother in the most brutal way. It is hard
Lizzie Borden arrived in Taunton and was taken to jail, appearing calm amid a crowd of onlookers. Separately, the Probate Court appointed Emma J. Borden administratrix of their father's estate with a $90,000 bond.
The Indianapolis Journal · 3 September 1892 · page 5
In the Probate Court, to-day, Emma J. Borden was appointed administratrix of the estate of Andrew J. Borden, with a bond of S'jO.OGO. Her sureties are Frank L. Almy, Joseph A. Bo wen, of Fall River, aud
A roundup of short national news items includes one line stating that Lizzie Borden's trial for murdering her father and stepmother with an ax has begun at Fall River, Massachusetts. The item appears amid unrelated news briefs about other events across the country.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Baxter Springs News · 3 September 1892 · page 2
Cunandaigua, N. Y. A defalcation, which it is said will reach $20,000, hus Itoen discovered in the offloe of Street & Smith, publishers of the New York Weekly, and the crime has been fastened upon Alfred J. Price, cashier. As A result of Grand Master Sweeney declaring the switchmen's strike off at Buffalo, N. Y., ho was assaulted by a man named Quinn and severely beaten. The crestfallen switchmen were greatly mortified at the collapse of the strike. Prksiukkt Harrison mot the old sol diers at their camp at Malone, N. Y., on the 26th. The trial of Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and step mother with an ax, has begun at Fall
Servant Bridget Sullivan testified in detail about the household's activities on August 3-4, describing routine events like taking in milk and Mr. Borden's breakfast. The report notes her testimony was damaging to Lizzie, while other witnesses found no footprints near the house, and defense counsel disputed a story about a matron overhearing a sisters' quarrel.
Baxter Springs News · 3 September 1892 · page 6
BAD FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. Servant llrldoret Sullivan Describes the Scone la the liouae of Death. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 29. The principal witness in the Borden case Saturday afternoon was Bridget Sullivan, the family servant. She told in detail all the doings of the household on August 8 and 4 up to the murder, even to the taking in of the milk can in the morning and Mr. Bor den's coming to breakfast without any collar. Tho evidence was very dam aging to the defendant John Cunningham, a newsdealer, gave unimportant testimony and Reporters Manning and Stephens, of two local pa' pcrs, testified that they could find no footprints in the grass, about the house or on the fence.
See moreSee less
Counsel for the defense was stirred up last night over the story that Ma tron Began had heard a quarrel be tween the Borden sisters, and Attor ney Jennings, at the solicitation of the reporter who wrote the article, seconded by a number of prominent cit izens, drew up a form of affidavit, denying tho statements attributed to her and submitted it to Mrs. Regan for her signature. She rofused to sign it unless the marshal said so, and the marshal positively refused to allow her to do anything of the kind unless she was placed on the witness Btand.
The report states that the preliminary examination did not bring the Fall River murder mystery closer to resolution, though it suggests the evidence favored Lizzie Borden rather than incriminating her. It notes Judge Blaisdell's statement that sympathy must be set aside and the facts followed, concluding with his finding that Lizzie Borden was probably guilty and binding her over to the grand jury.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 3 September 1892 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Judge Blaisdell concludes the preliminary hearing by declaring Lizzie Borden probably guilty, and she is sent to Taunton jail. Her defense will not pursue habeas corpus but instead try to locate mysterious strangers reportedly seen near the Borden house on the day of the murders.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 3 September 1892 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Lizzie Borden was taken from Fall River's central station to Taunton, where she was returned to her former jail quarters to await the November grand jury. Meanwhile, Emma Borden was appointed administratrix of Andrew Borden's estate with bonds of $10,000.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 3 September 1892 · page 1
I-'\i.i. Kn i ii. Sept. 2. Miss Lizzie Bor ■leii wus tliken from tie- < eiitral station at 1.1 .*» this afternoon to the 1.20 train for Taunton. She will remain there in the county jail until the fitting of the grand jury in No vember. Tunton. Sept. 2. Lizzie Borden reached Taunton on the 2.10 train. She u;i« ealui Ulld self possessed and paid tin atl« nliiiii to the staring crowd at the station. She was promptly taken by ear ri.ige to the jail an I restored to her formei quarters. T\i ni• »\ Sept. 2. In the probate court today l-'.mnut .1. Borden was appointed ad ministratrix of the estate of Andrew J.Bor ilen. with bonds of *l.»iUHM».
A multi-topic news digest mentions that the trial of Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother with an ax, has begun at Fall River, Massachusetts. The item appears amid unrelated national news briefs covering strikes, fires, and other events.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Grenada Sentinel · 3 September 1892 · page 2
Ex-Gov. Myron H. Clark died at Canandaigua, N. Y. A defalcation, which it is said will reach 820,000, has been discovered in the office of Street & Smith, publishers of the New York Weekly, and the crime has l>een fastened upon Alfred J. Price, cashier. As A result of Grand Master Sweeney declaring the switchmen's strike off at Buffalo, N. Y., lie was assaulted by a man named Quinn and severely beaten. The crestfallen switchmen were greatly mortified at the collapse of the strike. President Harrison met the old sol diers at their camp at Malone, N. Y.. on the 201 li. The trial of Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and step mother with an ax, has liegun at Fall River. Mass.
At the preliminary hearing, servant Bridget Sullivan gave detailed testimony about the household's activities on the day of the murders, including mundane details like the milk delivery and Andrew Borden's collarless breakfast, testimony described as very damaging to Lizzie. Other witnesses, including reporters, testified about the absence of footprints near the house, while defense counsel reacted angrily to reports that a matron had overheard a quarrel between the Borden sisters.
The Grenada Sentinel · 3 September 1892 · page 3
BAD FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. DetcriUes the Servant Bridget Sulim Scenes In tlie llotme of Death. Fall River. Mass.. Aug. 29.—The principal witness in the Borden case Saturday afternoon was Bridget
Lizzie Borden was taken from the central police station in Fall River to a train bound for Taunton, accompanied by the marshal, a detective, and Rev. Mr. Buck, to be held in the county jail until the grand jury convenes in November. She appeared calm and unbothered by the large crowd watching at both the Fall River and Taunton train stations.
The State Chronicle · 3 September 1892 · page 1
By Telegraph to the State Chronicle. Pall River, Mass., Sept. 2. Miss Lizzie Borden was taken from the cen tral station this afternoon to the train for Taunton. She will remain there in the county jail until the sitting of the grand jury in November. She was ac companied by marshal Billiard, detec tive Ssaver and Rev. Mr. Buck. There was a large and curious crowd at the depot. She was not disturbed . in the least by the gaze of a hundred specta tors, and if anvthincr she looked firmer and more content than she appeared since the hearing opened.
Witnesses testify about Lizzie Borden's movements and statements on the day of the murders, including inconsistent explanations for being in the barn. A drug clerk and others recount Lizzie allegedly trying to purchase prussic acid the day before the killings, while neighbors testify they saw no one entering the yard.
Paper unidentified · 3 September 1892 · page 3
IMPORTANT TESTIMONY
From where she sat she said she could see all the yard of the Bordens. During the time she was there she saw no one passing in the yard. On cro:s-examination it took just fifteen minutes for witness and Mr. Jennings to,come to an understanding as to where the fence was located between the Chagnon and Borden houses, and then witness admitted that she was whereshe could not see the whole of the Borden yard, but she was sure that if anybody hbd entered the yard she would have heard them.
See moreSee less
Eli Beuce, drug clerk, testified that he re membered the day of the tragedy, and was acquainted with Lizzie Borden. Witness saw her in his store the day before, and she asked hiiu for ten cents worth of prussic acid to put on a sealskin Back or cape, but he told her he could not sell it without a physician's prescription. Hia attention was called to the fact that Bhe was in the store on Thursday evening and soon after that again at 6 o'clock. Frank H. Kilroy, medical student, testi fied. Knew Miss Borden saw her th morning. Witness was sitting in the shop when she came in, and Mr. Bence went be hind the counter to wait on her heard her say "prussic acid," and him say "can't sell it without a prescription," and then heard her say "sealskin cape." Then she went out. Frederick B. Hart, an employe in the ding store, corroborated the testimony of the previous witness in regard to the prus sic acid incident, and then identified Miss Borden as the person who had asked for the stuff. Joseph De Roches testified tjy the aid of an interpreter. He was sawing wood in John Crowe's yard on the day of the trag edy saw no one go over the fence that day, nor did he see anybodv in the yard. The strongest point brought out by the morning's testimony, the etate's officials say, was Lizzie's remark, speaking of her mother to Mrs. Churchill, according to that lady's testimony, "1 don't know but she has been killed too." Lizzie made this re mark while telling that she thought she heard her mother come in. What reason, ask the officials, did Lizzie have tor believ ing that her mother had been killed, con sidering the circumstances already brought out viz.: That Lizzie was up stairs when her father came in, when Mrs. Borden had been dead about an hour, and went down stairs and told hiiu that his wile was out, but failed to sajMtnvihing about thinking rden oome.in. •he heard Mrs. Bor
The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D. · 3 September 1892
The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.
Witnesses testified that Lizzie Borden had tried to buy prussic acid at a drugstore before the murders, and a witness named Hart identified her. Separately, Mrs. Churchill testified that Lizzie said she didn't know if her mother had been killed too, a remark prosecutors found suspicious given the timeline of events.
The Washburn Leader · 3 September 1892 · page 2
IMPORTANT TESTIMONY
From where-she sat she. said she could see all the yard of the Bordens. During the time she was there she saw no one passing in the yard. Ou cross-examination it took just fifteen minutes for witness and Mr. Jennings to come to an understanding as to where ths fence was located between the Chagnon and Borden houses, and then witness admitted that she was where she could not see the whole of the Borden yard, but she was sure that if anybody' had entered the yard she would have heard .them.
See moreSee less
Eli Bence, drug clerk, testified that he re membered the day of the tragedy, and was acquainted with Lizzie Borden. Witness saw her in his store the day before, aud she asked him for ten cents worth of prussic acid to put on & sealskin, sack or cajte, but he told her he could not sell it without a physician's prescription. His attention was called to the fact that sbe was in the store on Thursday evening and soon after that again at6 o'clock. Frank H. Kilroy, medical student, testi lied. Knew Miss Borden saw her th morning. "Witness was sitting in the shop when she came in, and Mr. Bence went be hind the counter to wait on her heard her say "prussic acid," and biiu say "can't sell it without a prescription," and then beard her say "sealskin cape." Then she went out. Frederick B. Hart, an employe in the ug store, corroborated tbe testimony of. the previous witness in regard to tbe prus sic add incident, and then identified Miss Borden as the person who had asked for the stfflT.— 1— Joseph De Roches testified by the aid of an interpreter. He was sawing wood in John Crowe's yard on the day of tbe trag edy saw no one go over the fence that day, nor did he see anybody in the yard. Tbe strongest point brought out by the morning's testimony, tbe state's officials say, was Lizzie's remark, speaking of her mother to Mrs. Churchill, according to that lady testimony, "1 don't know hut she has been killed too." Lizzie made this re* mark while telling that she thought she neard her mother come in. What reason, f8 A officials, did Lizzie have lor believ ing that her mother had been killed, con sidering the circumstances already brought out viz.: That Lizzie was up stairs when her father came in, when Mrs. Borden had been dead about an hour, ^nd went down stairs and told him that,hls. wile was out, but:failed to say^anyj|hing about thinking she.heard Mrs. Borden come in. ......
The hearing of Lizzie Borden resumed on Friday with gruesome details of the murders recounted on the stand. However, nothing presented was described as being of a convicting nature.
Devils Lake Inter-Ocean · 3 September 1892 · page 4
Tucker, of Virginia, president. H. F. Stevens, of Minnesota, was elected one of tho vice presidents. Mrs. General John A. Logan has un dertaken to raise $1,000,000 from the women of this country for tho American University, the national institution founded by the Methodists at Washing ton. The international peace congress, held at Berno, has unanimously decided to accept the invitation of the North American societies to hold the next in ternational congress at Chicago in 1893. The directors of the Minnesota state fair have declared all running races barred out, for the reason that Budd Doble will not_trot Nancy Hanks there if the track, is to cut up with runners.
See moreSee less
The hearing of Miss Lizzie Borden at -*1 Mass., was resumed Friday The ghastly details of the ... rore told on the stand but noth a convicting nature was brought James S. Wilson, agent of the Kansas and Arkansas Valley railroad at Now ata, 1. T., was held up and robbed late Monday night by three men supposed to be members of the Dal ton gang of train robbers and desperadoes. About $1,000 was secured.
A one-line item in a miscellaneous news roundup states that the trial of Lizzie Borden for murder has begun at Fall River, Massachusetts. It appears alongside unrelated items on politics, church anniversaries, and international affairs.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 3 September 1892 · page 2
MISCELLANEOUS. A general fight occurs at a political meeting in South Carolina. The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for mur der begins at Fall River, Mass. W. W. Blackwell ot Kentucky is elected supreme chancellor of the Knights of Pyth-. ias. Mr. Gladstone has been re-elected in Mid lothian on taking office. He had no op position. Miss Ella Reid, neice of Whitelaw Held, will soon be married at Ophir farm to Robert C. Harrison, judge of the supreme court at California. He is seventy years old. A report touching upon the recent lynch ing of Italians in New Orleans is presented at the meeting of the American Bar asso ciation.
See moreSee less
At the First parish Unitarian church at Gloucester, Mass., services were held com memorative of the fifty years existence of that church. Rev. Daniel Munroe Wilson, of Quincy, delivered an historical address. This church has had sixteen pastors sinoo 1842,
Witnesses at the Fall River hearing testified that Lizzie Borden asked a drugstore clerk for prussic acid, which he refused to sell without a prescription. Testimony also highlighted Lizzie's odd remark to Mrs. Churchill suggesting she feared her mother had been killed before the body was supposedly discovered.
The report describes the ongoing preliminary hearing in Fall River, noting the defense's investigation into Bridget Sullivan's character and reliability as a witness, and previews upcoming expert testimony on blood stains from Prof. Wood and a defense witness challenging Dr. Dolan's findings. It states the evidence presented so far appears strong enough to bind Lizzie Borden over to the grand jury.
Paper unidentified · 3 September 1892 · page 3
THE BOEDEN CASE. Mnek Important Testlaaoay Yet to Be Olven. FALL RIVBB, Mass., Aug. 29.—The hear ing in the Borden case will be resumed to morrow. The defense has been actively engaged in learning something regarding Bridget Sullivan's career. The purpose ot the inquiry is to learn how reliable her eviderfceis, also to learn if she would be come so provoked that she would quarrel seriously with Mr. and A rs. Borden. It is
At the preliminary hearing in Fall River District Court, defense attorney Jennings argued the state failed to prove opportunity, while District Attorney Knowlton laid out circumstantial evidence pointing to Lizzie Borden's desire to inherit property as motive. Judge Blaisdell declared her probably guilty of murdering her father and stepmother and ordered her held for the Grand Jury.
Passaic City Record · 3 September 1892 · page 1
PROBABLY GUILTY.
Her Father’s Murder. Arguments were heard by Judge Blais Jeli, of the District Court, at Fall River, Mass., in the case of Miss Lizzie Borden, ac cused of the murder of her father and step nother. The evidence was reviewed by noth Mr. Jennings, Miss Borden’s counsel, i and the District Attorney, and at the close ! the Judge declared Miss Borden probably guilty and held her for the action of the ; tfrand Jury. Mr. A. J. Jennings, counsel for the de fendant, commenced his argument at 10:9) and closed at 11:05.
See moreSee less
He contended that toe State had failed to prove that there exisce t an opportunity for the prisoner to commit the crime, and that it based its case on merely the inconsistencies in the story toiii by Lizzie Borden of her whereabouts on tu: morning of the murder. District Attorney H. M. Knowiton fo' lowed. His argument was a masterly sum ming up of the evidence. His langu was simple, and he forged aron.i the accused a solid chain of o - cumstantial evidence. He said ta motive tnat caused L zzie Borden to k.u her parents was her anxiety to inherit ti- ■ prooerty, and he declared that she, and sjj alone, did the deed. The backing butchery was not the work of a man. It was the work of a woman who knew not wnen she had completed her wore. The hatcaet had not been found, neither was the bloody dress which she wore, bat the evidence was so strong that aside from these things the Court must find that she is probably guilty. When D.strictattorney Kno vltoa had finished his summing up for tue prosecution Judge Btaisdeil saia: • ‘Sympathy should be lad aside, and dnty, stern duty, re* quires upon this evidence that but one thing be done. Supposing that a man was seen in the cham ber of Mrs. Borden, the guest caamber of death, and that he was in the room of the father when death came; suppose that a man should tell as many different stories as Lizzie Borden had done, the way would be plain. I find that she is probably guilty.” When Lizzie Boruen was pronounced prob ably guilty, hundreds of people gave way to tears, and the scene in the courtroom was truly affecting. She was committed to Taunton Jail with out bail to await the action of the Grand Jury.
District Attorney Knowlton summed up circumstantial evidence against Lizzie Borden, arguing inheritance was her motive and that a woman committed the crime. Judge Blaisdell ruled she was probably guilty and committed her to Taunton Jail without bail to await the grand jury.
The report describes the reaction to a story about Mrs. Marshall seeing a suspicious man leaving the Borden property around the time of the murders. Lawyers and detectives converge on Fall River to interview her, with Lizzie Borden's attorney Jennings keeping details secret until trial.
Pawtucket Tribune · 3 September 1892 · page 1
STATEMENTS HUSHED UP.
Kept Lizsie Borden Out of Jail. The story in yesterday’s TRIBUNE about Mrs. Marshall of this city seeing an un couth looking man coming out of the yard surrounding the Borden residence nbout the time the murder is supposed to have been committed, created a big sensa tion in Fall River last evening and every one treely discussed .ne new phase of the ‘amous murder. W. W. Robinson, a lawyer, whose office is in Lee’s Block on Main street, heard of the story and immediately telephoned to Mr. Jenning’s, Lizzie Borden counsel, but he had already been made known of the facts.
See moreSee less
Detective Medley of the regular force came right on and was here yesterday uwfternoon. He did not see Mrs. Mar »hall, however, as she refused to soe any one until Mr. Jennings arrrived. The reason she kept the matter quiet v.aB on account of her ill health and dis like of publicity, but when she heard that Lizzie Borden was held for the grand jury <he felt it was her duty to tell it, Detective Medley arrived in this city at 9:40 this morning end was met by Detec tive Haberlin. Mr. Jennings stopped in Providence and did not arrive in this city until 11:16. In company with young Mr. Marshall they proceded to Mrs. Marshall’s home on Summit street. Mr. Jeuning would allow 10 one to go with them to hear Mrs. Mar «hall’s story and would say nothing about it. After the interview all three men were us close as a sealed book and the matter will be kept quiet until the trial. The version in yesterday’s TRIBUNE is sub stantially correct.
An anonymous prosecuting official claims to have closely observed Lizzie Borden's eyes, mannerisms, and physical demeanor since the murder and during the inquest. Based on his experience with insanity cases, he suggests she may be mentally unstable, raising the possibility the case could end with asylum confinement rather than trial.
Pawtucket Tribune · 3 September 1892 · page 1
TALKING OF INSANITY.
Borden oase, who Las had peculiarly good opportumdties for studying the Memzmt. made the following authoritive statement % the wrider, couditionally that his name bo withheld from publication. He sald: “On the day of the murder, and very frequently siuce that time, I have talked with Tdezte A. Borden and bhave watched her closedy. During her entfre examina tan | sat o o position to command a full view of her faoe. At the Inquess I heard her testtmony, - “I balleve I have observed her more dosoly than sy other person connected with the presecution.
See moreSee less
“Whet do I think® “In nosWwartng that question I will Mret Explain My Reasons for framing my opinfan of her. During fowrteen yenrs' official work for the state I have seen and dealt with many cases of fnsanity. I have been broughs tn con stant contact froquentl wn‘glthe {inmates
A Pawtucket woman, Mrs. John Marshal, reportedly saw a strange, disreputable-looking man leaving the Borden homestead around the time of the murders, but she and her son refuse to confirm the story publicly. Detectives have investigated, and an ex-assistant attorney general suggested that if confirmed, this could be enough to exonerate Lizzie Borden.
The Providence News · 3 September 1892 · page 7
The ntor{ as related is, however, that Mrs. Marshall, who formerly residea i Fall River aud was well acquaiuted there, was riding by the Borden residence at about the hour the criine was suppose 1 to have been doune, when a man came from th
Dr. John H. Abbott, who saw both bodies before leaving for the West, reports both were still warm with no sign one had been dead longer than an hour before the other. He theorizes Mr. Borden was killed first and Mrs. Borden was struck down moments later while fleeing upstairs, with head wounds added afterward to ensure death.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Providence News · 3 September 1892 · page 7
ANOTHER THEORY. Dr. Abbott Thinks Mr. Borden Was Killed Before Mrs. Borden.
any suspicion was directed toward Lizzie he had expressed no orelnlon. Now he says that he saw the bodies a short time after they were discovered by the daugh ter and viewed by the police, and both were warm., There was not the slizhtest indication that one had been dead over an hour be fore the other. In fuct, it is his opinion that Mr. Borden was Killed first, and that Mrs. Borden was followed up stairs by the murderer and stricken down as she was running to the window to call for assist ance. It was the blow in the back, affecting the spine, that caused death Le thinks, nnd the head blows were given afterward to make sure of death,
A brief notice states that Lizzie Borden was judged probably guilty of murdering her father and stepmother. She was ordered held over for grand jury action.
Narragansett Herald · 3 September 1892 · page 5
Pompey, N. Y. The delicious scollop, as well as the festive oyster, has arrived, and once more we are happy. Miss Lizzie Borden was adjudged probably guilty of murdering her father and stepmother and was held for the grand jury.
A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden has been held for trial at Fall River, Massachusetts, on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. The trial is scheduled to begin in November.
The Madison Daily Leader · 3 September 1892 · page 1
EtECTRiCAL ECHOES. tf attar* «f M»t« or Less MomM Brtoly Mmtiomd. Daniel Steele Durrie, librarian of the Wisconsin State Historical society, is dead. Judge Kelly has decided that the Commercial bank, of St. Paul, may re sume business. The custom collections at St. Paul for August amounted to $20,000 and the revenue to $2^4,000. The Democrats of the Eleventh Mis souri district have renominated John O'Neill for congress. Lizzie Borden has been held for tiial at Fall River, Mass., on the charge of murdering her father and stepmother The trial is set for November.
See moreSee less
Republicans of the Seventh Minnesota district, in convention at Moorhead, nominated Henry Feig, of Kandiyohi county, for congress. The roller flouring mill of M. F, Peaes &Son, at Lowell, Dodge county, Wis,, been destroyed by iire. The mill was valued at $80,000 partially insured. A medical inspector on the French frontier at Trun, Spain,' has sent to the hospital several cholera suspects who arrived on a train from France. The German imperial sanitary office reports deaths from cholera in many towns in Silesia, Zehlezweg, Luneberg and Posen. The Hamburg-Heliogoland v steamers have been suspended. Mike Gushing, the well known 126 pound pugilist, died at Fort Hamilton, N. Y., Wednesday afternoon, after a few days illness, aged 27. Deceased was
The report states that Lizzie Borden of Fall River, Mass., has been held for trial on charges of murdering her father and stepmother, following a two-week preliminary examination. The judge reportedly stated he found her "probably guilty" in deciding to hold her over for trial.
The Superior Times · 3 September 1892 · page 2
—Lizzie Borden.of Fall River. Mass., has been held on the charge of having murdered her father and step mother. Her examination has been going on for the past two weeks or more, and the judge held her for trial, saying. “I ii 4 that she is probaoly guilty.”
A newspaper report about public fascination with the upcoming Sullivan-Corbett boxing match notes that it now rivals the Borden murder case as a topic of conversation. The piece observes that people have grown weary of speculating about Lizzie Borden's guilt, while betting and debate swirl around the fight's outcome.
Wheeling Register · 3 September 1892 · page 5
ON THE SULLIVAN-CORBETT FIGHT AT NEW ORLEANS
The Borden murder trial and the Cor bett-Sullivan fight are the two subjects which are Just now monopolizing the considerations of about every man who reads the daily papers, since, with the exception of what spaco is devoted to politics, there is little else to be read. The Borden case is such a battling mystery that people have got pretty tired discussing it, although eager to read everything the papers contain about it, and there is at present a good deal more speculation upon the result of the big fight than as to whether or r.ot Lizzie Borden killed her father and
A Fall River physician, John H. Abbott, says he viewed both bodies shortly after discovery and found no sign one had been dead longer than the other, concluding Mr. Borden was killed first and Mrs. Borden was struck while fleeing upstairs. The report also notes detectives are investigating leads and clues, and a witness, Mrs. Marshall, has been told by Borden's counsel to avoid speaking with government investigators.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Sun · 4 September 1892 · page 13
THE BORDEN MURDER CASE
TAUXTOS Iass Sept 3John H Abbott ot Fall hiker who went West before suspicion was directed toward Lizzie Borden says that lit saw tho bodies n short time after they were dlcovcrod by tho daughter nnd lowed by tho polio and both were warm Thero was not tho slightest indication that one had been dead over an hour before tho other In his
A filler item from the Eureka Sentinel wryly suggests that if Lizzie Borden killed her father she must have been insane, and if she didn't, she must be nearly insane by now. It's a brief, speculative aside amid unrelated local news items.
Weekly Independent · 4 September 1892 · page 3
Hureka Sentinel:? If Lizzie Borden killed her fatlwr alio must liavo bren insaue at *lie tirao. If Ltzzio Burden tlid not kill her father nho must be pretty nearly insane by this tiino. Mr. and Mrs. McClellan nnd Miss Ruth Triplett arrived from Austin last evening. They l ave bsen griev ously afllicted this mouth nnd deserve thesincoro sympathy or tho people of this community. P. P. Coflin, Harvo Mo.Adama ami J. A. Plummcr loft fur the li^publi
An editorial argues that the magistrate who had already served as coroner should not have presided over Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, and criticizes the decision to commit her to trial based on insufficient evidence. It notes her presence at the crime scene and minor inconsistencies in her statements about going to the barn, calling this far too weak to support a parricide charge.
Lizzie Borden passed an uneventful day at Taunton jail, showing no change in demeanor. A large crowd attended services at the jail hoping to see her, but she did not appear and her privacy remained undisturbed.
Morning Journal and Courier · 5 September 1892 · page 3
LIZZIE BORDEN'S SUNDAY. Tbe Prisoner Shows no Cbanej Idany People Attend tbe Services In tbe Jail. Taunton, Mass., Sept 4. Lizzie Borden passed an uneventful day at Taunton jail and in no way has she shown any change. Services were held at the jail at 4 p. m., and as expected there was a large attend ance, many outsiders going from a desire to see Miss Borden, but she did not put in an appearance and her privacy was not dis turbed. She appears to be quite at home in her present quarters. Thrown from a Stairway.
A brief report notes that Lizzie Borden remains composed while held in Taunton jail. She reportedly seems quite at home in her current quarters.
Evening Journal · 5 September 1892 · page 2
Jealousy caused the tragedy. - l.iacls Herde» Unruffled. Taunton, Mass., Sept. S.-Miss Lizzie Borden iu Taunton jail preserves her calm demeanor and appears to be quite at home in her present quarters.
Dr. John H. Abbott of Fall River, who examined the bodies shortly after discovery, states both were still warm with no sign one had died much before the other, and theorizes Andrew Borden was killed first with Abby struck down afterward as she ran for help. Separately, police investigators continue verifying evidence and following leads, including a stalled effort to interview a Mrs. Marshall of Pawtucket after Lizzie's counsel asked her to stay silent.
C 8 HIS KNOWLEDGE OF THE MY9TERY. Dr, Abbett May Assiat In Unmraveling the Borden Murders. qul Dr. John H. Abbott of Fall River, Mass., * knew, something about the condition of the bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, the victims of 4. the mysterious Fall River tragedy, before he - went west, but as he went away before any sunT apicion was directed toward Lizzie he had ex pressed no opinion. Now he says he saw the bodies a short time after they were discovered ~ by the daughter and viewed by the police and or4 both were warm There was not the slightest Indication that one had been deed over an hour before the ~ other.
See moreSee less
In fact, it is his opinion that Mr. BorStt den was killed dirst and that Mrs. Borden wasat followed up stair. by the murderer, and stricken I down as she was running to the window to call for assistance. It was the blow In the back, affecting the a ,ue that caused death, he think., and the healkowa were given afterward to maesure. P qLica INDIGiIaXT.aw Fiv, ofieer. and two special detectives of Fall ti - hiver are now at work on the Bordan ease silt-be ing and verifying old evidenee and running down clue. ana theouiee submitted by the prim- - oner's friends. The prosecution ran across sa F unexpected snag a day or two since In endeavor inlg to learn the truth of statements reported to have been made by Mr.. Marshall of Pawtucket, R. I. l Th nestigating officer called at the woman' a a houe ad ws tld hatMr. Jennings, the de f'endant'is counsel, had requested that Mlr. Marj shall keep quiet until he or one of his repreIa sentatives had an opportunity to~talk with her. A Promise was given and the womaan refused to talk with the preseuting offecals. This inei dent has given rise to much ~eaniasn in po lice circese. When Miss Lissie Borden beds Marshal Nila Sliard goodbyeain awer to his ourteou adis 0 her reply was given in a voice free feelom of any noticeable or unusual kind. Sheslp *uneasily at times ia the matron's room, a, i her arms to and fro and talking Ia haseer -bet when she awoke and des she became as rigid and serene as she was when the police first 5 interviewed her and pieced her in their charge. N Iti hscondition of things that mnake. it A imosbefor the onteers to eommuiaae with her friends or believe in her indosnos. The adidress pattern, of whieb mush wa sid
The report describes a theory that Mrs. Borden was struck by a blow to the back while fleeing upstairs, which allegedly caused her death. It also details ongoing police investigation work, including verifying evidence, running down clues, and frustration when a key witness (Mrs. Marshall) was advised by Lizzie Borden's lawyer to stay silent before speaking with prosecutors.
The report covers Judge Blaisdell's ruling that Lizzie Borden should be held for trial, quoting his statement that the evidence pointed to her guilt. The writer criticizes the fairness of the inquest and hearing process, noting the judge both conducted the inquest and presided over the hearing, and argues that public opinion differs from the judge's conclusion.
New-York Tribune · 5 September 1892 · page 6
THE FALL RIVER MYSTERY. Lizzie Borden has been held on the charge of murdering her father and mother. At the close of the hearing on Thursday Judge Blaisdell said: * Sympathy should be laid aside, and duty, stern duty, requires upon this evidence but one thing to be done. Supposing that a man was seen in the chamber of Mrs. Borden, the guest chamber of death, and that he was in the room of the father when death came ; suppose that a man should tell as many different stories as Lizzie has done, the way would be plain.
See moreSee less
I find that she was probably guilty.” "The conclusion reached by the Judge would carry greater weight were it not for the fact that he not only presided at the hearing, but conducted the inquest which preceded it. The impression is pretty general that the inquest was, consciously or unconsciously to those engaged in it, conducted on the sole theory that Lizzie Borden was the murderer. At all events, the hearing disclosed the fact that the examination to which she was subjected at the inquest was merciless to the point of cruelty, although she appeared on her own motion, when she need not have appeared at all, and was deprived of the guidance and protection of counsel. Is she guilty? It is clear from the reports gathered by the newspapers which have given closest attention to the case and its surroundings that the popular conviction antagonizes Judge Blaisdell’s. This is not strange. For the circumstantial evidence which has been produced by the prosecution is really insignificant, Webster said in summing up for the people in a celebrated murder trial: There is no refuge from confession but suicide, and suicide is confession.” But instead of this being true of Lizzie Borden, the fact is that unless the prosecution can materially strengthen its case when she is placed on trial for her life in November the chances are that the jury will acquit her without leaving the box. The prosecution expected to show that the spots on the axes or hatehets which were found in the cellar were blood spots. It turned out that they were rust spots, only that and nothing more. The doctors and detectives were agreed that the murderer of Mr. Borden must have so stood when the fatal blows were struck that the murderer's clothes wonld be more or less blood-stained. But there are no blood stains upon any of Lizzie Borden's garments. It is in evidence that she tried to purchase prussic acid a day or two before the murder. Her counsel claim it is a case of mistaken identity. But suppose it is not, what then? The stomachs of the two victims were subjected to a careful examination by a Harvard College expert and no trace of poison of any sort was discovered. What motive could Lizzie Borden have had for committing so stupendous and revolting a crime 2 She had ample means, and whatever may be said about her relations to her parents, nothing has heen produced at the inquest on the hearing or in the gossip of the town going to show that they were more than * strained.” More than that, Lizzie Borden's character, for
The report examines the inquest and probable-cause hearing before Judge Blaisdell, arguing the evidence against Lizzie Borden is weak—no blood found on her clothes, rust not blood on the hatchet, and no poison in the victims' stomachs despite her alleged prussic acid purchase. It concludes public opinion favors her innocence and predicts a likely acquittal unless prosecutors strengthen their case.
The piece defends Lizzie Borden's character while acknowledging she gave inconsistent accounts of her whereabouts the morning of the murders. It urges the public to withhold judgment until the November trial and calls on detectives to pursue leads about an unknown man seen near the Borden house.
THE FALL RIVER MYSTERY. Lizzie Borden has been held on the charge of murdering her father and mother. At the close of the hearing on Thursday Judge Blaisdell said: * Sympathy should be laid aside, and duty, stern duty, requires upon this evidence but one thing to be done. Supposing that a man was seen in the chamber of Mrs. Borden, the guest chamber of death, and that he was in the room of the father when death came ; suppose that a man should tell as many different stories as Lizzie has done, the way would be plain.
See moreSee less
I find that she was probably guilty.” "The conclusion reached by the Judge would carry greater weight were it not for the fact that he not only presided at the hearing, but conducted the inquest which preceded it. The impression is pretty general that the inquest was, consciously or unconsciously to those engaged in it, conducted on the sole theory that Lizzie Borden was the murderer. At all events, the hearing disclosed the fact that the examination to which she was subjected at the inquest was merciless to the point of cruelty, although she appeared on her own motion, when she need not have appeared at all, and was deprived of the guidance and protection of counsel. Is she guilty? It is clear from the reports gathered by the newspapers which have given closest attention to the case and its surroundings that the popular conviction antagonizes Judge Blaisdell’s. This is not strange. For the circumstantial evidence which has been produced by the prosecution is really insignificant, Webster said in summing up for the people in a celebrated murder trial: There is no refuge from confession but suicide, and suicide is confession.” But instead of this being true of Lizzie Borden, the fact is that unless the prosecution can materially strengthen its case when she is placed on trial for her life in November the chances are that the jury will acquit her without leaving the box. The prosecution expected to show that the spots on the axes or hatehets which were found in the cellar were blood spots. It turned out that they were rust spots, only that and nothing more. The doctors and detectives were agreed that the murderer of Mr. Borden must have so stood when the fatal blows were struck that the murderer's clothes wonld be more or less blood-stained. But there are no blood stains upon any of Lizzie Borden's garments. It is in evidence that she tried to purchase prussic acid a day or two before the murder. Her counsel claim it is a case of mistaken identity. But suppose it is not, what then? The stomachs of the two victims were subjected to a careful examination by a Harvard College expert and no trace of poison of any sort was discovered. What motive could Lizzie Borden have had for committing so stupendous and revolting a crime 2 She had ample means, and whatever may be said about her relations to her parents, nothing has heen produced at the inquest on the hearing or in the gossip of the town going to show that they were more than * strained.” More than that, Lizzie Borden's character, for anght that appears to the contrary, is without a stain. Those who know her best—so at trast it is to be gathered from all that has been printed—have the firmest confidence in her innocence. On the other hand, it is not to he denied that she has told several conflicting stories touching the pivotal point of her where abouts and her employments the morning of the murder. Thus one of her statements is that <he went to the barn te get some lead for a <inker of a fishline, and another that she went there to get something to repair a window. Besides, she seems unable or unwilling to tell just how she spent all the time which is the natural subject of inquiry. But to place the worst constriction upon these circumstances is not to make her out a murderer Everybody knows that the most trustworthy witnesses sometimes contradict themselves because of a certain mental confusion caused by embarrass ment. Considering what she has gone through during the last few weeks it is not wonderful if Lizzie Borden's evidence contained discrepancies, or if she failed to recall all the details of her life the morning of the murder, Doubtless the most sensible thing to do is to suspend judgment until the conclusion of the November trial—a trial which it is safe to say will command the interest which attends the reading of one of Gaboriau’s novels. In the mean time the detectives cannot do better than to search diligently for the unknown man who was seen prowling about the Borden house shortly before the murders were committed. It certainly behooves them to look for some fresh clews. For, as * The Springfield Republican” well says, “it appears that all the case against Miss Borden rests on the probability that she was in the house at least when Mrs. Borden was killed.” {
Lizzie Borden spent an uneventful Sunday at Taunton Jail, with religious services held there at 4 p.m. drawing a large crowd of curious outsiders hoping to see her, but she did not appear and was left undisturbed. The report notes she seems to have adjusted comfortably to her surroundings.
New-York Tribune · 5 September 1892 · page 2
MISS BOKRDEN'S BUNDAY IN TAUNTON JAIL. Teuton, Mass, Sept. 4.—-Miss Lizzie Borden passed an uneventful day at Deunton Jail, Services were held In the jall at 4 p. m., and, ns expected, there was a large attendance, many outsiders going there from n desire to see Miss Jorden, but she did not show herself, and her privacy was not disturbed. ghe appears to be quite at home In her present quarters, - >
A Boston Globe correspondent reports an anonymous prosecution official's belief that Lizzie Borden shows signs of mental derangement, predicting this could lead to her commitment rather than conviction. Separately, Fall River police continue gathering evidence, and defense attorney Jennings reportedly asked witness Mrs. Marshall to stay silent until consulting with defense counsel.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 5 September 1892 · page 5
Der Doppelmord in Fall-River
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes Fall River as evenly divided over Lizzie Borden's guilt, with speculation about an insanity defense and a new theory that Mr. Borden was killed before Mrs. Borden. It also addresses rumors about a dress pattern possibly swapped by Lizzie's friends, which Marshal Hilliard denies, stating the original was found openly and later produced by the defense at the government's request.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 5 September 1892 · page 1
INNOCENT OR GUILTY?
Before Wrs. Borden. V ill Uivlk. Sept. 3.—A Herald special says . This city is just as divided as ever as to the guilt or innocence of Lizzie Bor den. The government will have to fight an estate worth $.*>410,000 when she is brought to trial, if such an event occurs. The de fence has been given authority to spare no expense. If it is necessary, there are rich relatives of the prisoner who will assist her financially, but this contingency it is ex pected will not arise. • Lizzie Borden',* friends did not dupli cate the dress pattern which the prisoner
Dr. Abbott claims both bodies were equally warm when found, suggesting Andrew Borden was killed first and Mrs. Borden was struck down while fleeing upstairs. The government instead accepts Professor Wood's conflicting testimony, and police say the inquest may reopen if new evidence emerges.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Daily Kennebec Journal · 5 September 1892 · page 1
ANOTHER THEORY Now Declares that Mr. Borden Was Killed Before Mrs. Borden.
V ill Uivlk. Sept. 3.—A Herald special says . This city is just as divided as ever as to the guilt or innocence of Lizzie Bor den. The government will have to fight an estate worth $.*>410,000 when she is brought to trial, if such an event occurs. The de fence has been given authority to spare no expense. If it is necessary, there are rich relatives of the prisoner who will assist her financially, but this contingency it is ex pected will not arise. • Lizzie Borden',* friends did not dupli cate the dress pattern which the prisoner bought in New Bedford."
See moreSee less
This statement was called uut by Chief Hilliard tonight, as a comment on the ruiuor that probably Lizzie had w orn a w rapper of the dress pat tern mentioned on the morning of the mur der : that she refused to give it up or tell i w here it was. and that a day or two latter some of her friends secured more ot the same cloth, and that the defence surren dered this last purchase instead of original one. The marshal stated that he found the ; dress pattern during hisearch in the house ; after the funerals. No attempt was made ■ at hiding it.and no importance was attached to the discovery until later. The defence, he said, brought it into court during the hearing, by request of the government. Detective Medley returned from Paw tucket tonight. He talked with Mrs. Mar shall, who saw a suspicious looking man in front of the Borden house tinmorning of the murder. Medley ami the chief hail a long conference, and the latter, when asked if he was w illing to give the story to the pa pers. said lie was not. He intimated that there was sufficient truth in the story to have it looked up. and he said he would in vestigate it further. ■ There has not been one clew offered me since the murder by either defence or government or outside parties that I have not worked out.” he said. Mr. denning*.in conversation tonight, was very reticent. He declined to tell anything about Mrs. Marshall's story, only stating that he placed enough confidence in the statement to have it looked up. Dr. Abbott's interview, published in this afternoon's Herald, containing the startling statement that Mr. Borden died first, is be ing received with much reluctance. Prof. Wood’s testimony conflicts w ith the theory of Dr. Abbott, and the government has ac cepted the Harvard professor's story as liv ing the right one. If any important evi dence is secured, the inquest, so it was stated tonight by Chief Hilliard, will he re opened at once.
The report describes Lizzie Borden tossing and talking in her sleep at the jail, then becoming rigid and composed upon waking, just as she was when police first questioned her. It suggests this behavior is why officers find it hard to believe in her innocence or let her communicate with friends.
The Evening World · 5 September 1892 · page 3
m RESTLESS IN HER SLEEP. A Beaton Why Lizzie Borden la Not Bellevod Innooent, lav aisociatxd rant.! Fall Hitzk, Sept. a Miss Lizzie Borden slept uneasily at times In tbe matron' room at tbe Jail last nlgbt. tosdug her arms to and fro and talking In Ur bit en. hut onto sho awoke and dressed sba became as rigid and serene as she Has when tho pollcu lirst inter I viewed her uud placed ber In their charge. It Is this condition or things that makes it I Impossible tor the officers to communicate with ber friends or believe In ber Innocence.
The report states that the Borden murder case concluded for now when Lizzie Borden was found 'guilty' in her preliminary hearing, after her parents were found axed to death in Fall River. It notes the judge heard conflicting evidence before deciding she should be held for trial.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Orleans County Monitor · 5 September 1892 · page 1
THE BORDEN MURDER CASE. The Borden murder case, which has attracted much attention of late, end ed for the time being on Thursday last by finding Lizzie Borden, the daugh ter, guilty in the preliminary hearing. Some days since Mr. and Mrs. Borden of Fall River, Mass., were found mur-
At a Boston WCTU vesper service, Mrs. Susan Fessenden praised Lizzie Borden's church work and character, expressing hope for her exoneration. Most of the roughly 2,500 attendees stood to show support for a petition seeking bail for Borden.
New-York Tribune · 6 September 1892 · page 4
4 PLEA FOR MISS BORDEN, Boston, Sept. 5.—~At a Woman's Christian Ter: .2rance Cnlon vesper service last evening in the Tremont Temple. Mrs. Susan Fessenden made an impassioned plea in behalf of Miss Lizzie Borden. She told of the good work done by Miss Dorden in the past, her zeal In church matters, her energy in the Christian Endeavor soclety, her helpfulness In the army of temperance workers, and her kindness to those who needed assistance. She sald she hoped that God would show Its hand, and that the unprotected would be exonerated from the least shadow of suspicion, and that the heavy cloud now envelbping its folds would ere long pe lifted, and the sun of justice shine more clearly for its temporary obscurity, and that the prisoner's innocence will be firmly established.
See moreSee less
Mrs. Fessonden sald she spoke with a mother’s heart, and she appealed to the fathers and mothers present to show by their Indorsement of a Woman's Christian Temperanice Unlon petition to the Governor In favor of ball for Miss Borden whether they believed In the innocence of the prisoner. At the conclusion of the
A brief news item reports that in Fall River, Massachusetts, Lizzie Borden was remanded for trial on the charge of murdering her father and mother. It appears as one of several short items collected under a general news roundup.
Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 6 September 1892 · page 2
NEWSY NOTES. It is reported from Merv that 2,000 Afghans were killed in the last battle with the revolting Hnznras. Miss Nally, of Nelson county, didn't like her step-mother so bIio blew the old lady's brains out with a shotgun. At Fall River, Mass., Lizzie Borden was remanded for trial on tho charge of murdering her father and mother. A New York woman fell down with a lead pencil in her hand and tho point entering her eye, penetrated tho brain killing her instantly. According to the census the Methodist .Episcopal Church had 2,229,281 communicants in 1890, as against 1,707,-000 in 1SS0.
See moreSee less
Tho Mammoth Line steamer, Western Reserve, broke in two and all her crew and passengers, 28 in number, were drowned, 6aveone. Italian emigrants en route to this country were stopped at Paris and shipped back to Italy at the expense of the French government. Senator Hale, of Maine, says that Blaino will make no speeches during the campaign, but that he will write a letter covering tho political issues. Cholera talk was used by the bears to produce a panic and wheat was forced down to 73c utChicago, Thursday, the lowest notch for several years. Prof. McGee tells tho American Association for the Advancement of Science that the duration of life on this globe has been 15,000,000,000 years. John the negro who murdered a young white man named Coffee, his object being robbery, was killed by a mob in the Edmonton jail. In a collision of freight trains on the Louisville Southern, sir miles James Robinson, engineer, was killed and three brakemen badlv hurt. A locomotive engineer named Davis testified having overheard a conversation between two men who were acquainted with tho party guilty of the Borden murders. -A Cincinnati Southern train carrying a party of "Pittsburgh sports" to tho New Orleans pugilistic carnival, when about two miles north of Nicholasville, struck a buggy in which were Mrs. J. F. Farra and two children. One babe was instantly killed and the mother and from remaining child can not recover. "f nBiV WVJHBIWtwtotWWW wi wm
At a Boston WCTU prayer meeting, Susan Fessenden led a prayer for Lizzie Borden, praising her church work and charity while asserting her innocence. About 2,500 attendees rose in support of a petition calling for Borden's release on bail.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 6 September 1892 · page 3
Bete für Lizzie Borden
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A Taunton report describes Mrs. Marshall and her daughter, who claim they saw a villainous-looking man jump over the Borden back fence and flee by buggy shortly after the murders. The report notes police were told of this account earlier but apparently dismissed it as unreliable.
The Sun · 6 September 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
IN LIZZIE BORDEN'S DEFENCE.
A Woman Who Says She Saw a Villainous Looking Man on the Premises.
See moreSee less
TAUNTON, Sept. 5.—Mrs. Marshall and her daughter will be the most important witnesses for the defence of Lizzie Borden.
She said to-day that on the morning of the tragedy she and her daughter drove down Third street shortly after 11 o'clock and saw a villainous looking man jump over the Borden back fence, hurry through Dr. Chagnon's yard, jump into a buggy that was in waiting and drive away.
They paid no attention to it at the time, but half an hour later they drove through Second street and saw a crowd in front of the house, and heard that a murder had been committed.
Before any suspicion had rested on Lizzie Borden, Mrs. Marshall had told friends about the man she had seen jump over the back fence. Mrs. Marshall is a woman of unquestioned veracity, and her daughter's word will have equal weight.
She was asked to-night why she had not appeared at the preliminary hearing in the case, and her deep mourning, together with the statement that she had just buried her husbahd, was an explanation of her ignorance of the course events had taken. She did not know how important her testimony would have been at the hearing.
The police at Fall River were informed of the nature of Mrs. Marshall's statements a few days ago, but they apparently ignored the clue which, she gave them and intimated that it was from an untrustworthy source.
Mrs. Marshall and her daughter claim they saw a 'villainous-looking man' jump the Bordens' back fence and flee by buggy around the time of the murders, a story they say they told friends before Lizzie was suspected. The article notes police were informed of this account days earlier but dismissed it as coming from an unreliable source.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 6 September 1892 · page 1
She laid to-day and her daughter corroborated her statement that on the morning of the tragedy she and her daugh ter drove down to Third street shortly after 11 "o'clock and saw a villainous-looking man jump over the Borden's back fence, hurry through to Dr. Chagnon s yard, jump into a buggy that was in waiting and drive away. Of course they paid no attention to it at the time, but half an hour later thev drove tnrougn tsecona street and saw a crowd in front of the house and heard that a murder had been committed.
See moreSee less
Before any suspicion had rested on Lizzie Borden Mrs. Marshall had told friends about the man she had seen jump over the Bordens' back fence. Mrs. Marshall is a woman of unquestioned veracity, and her daughter's words have equal weight She was asked to-night why
This item disputes the New York Tribune's suggestion that Lizzie Borden appeared at the inquest voluntarily when she didn't need to. It clarifies that she was not yet accused of her father's murder and was legally obligated to respond to the magistrate's summons.
\‘ W' . 'Whay should anybody be mysterionsly missing from Riverside this beautiful ‘”m Nancy Hanks gives way to she bigger brutes at New Orleans in publio estimation. T. Tae 810 k CLEVELAND Fund is getting and worse. It is time for a con *lr would be cruel to take from Grover his title of ex-President. 8 —_— . "In view of McAuliffe’s victory we may sxpect another rhapsody on beer from the PROVIDENCE Journal. It is hinted that Mr, Cleveland may 10 to see Gien. Stevenson. Its only fair, }" Adlai’s efforts at bluefishing, " HENRY GEORGE'S Standard isn't a Jong felt want any more, All the Demo sratic papers are for free trade and this missionary is no longer wanted.
See moreSee less
A b m—— e " DEMOCRATS must by this time have Decome painfully aware that they must padically shift their ground of attack mpon the tariff. The calamity wail sounds too much like paid mourning. o @ e " Prarrs “I am a Republican” is a leal more sincere than Hill's “I am a emocrat.” The utterance partakes of 40 nature of theman and Thomas C. gaquare while Davy is “dyvilish sly.” o S ———t— | - Tar Borden case has aroused as wide jpread interest as the Graves case did. fewspapers in all sections of the coun ry have commented upon it, and some of them with shrewdness and sense— which show that their editors have read the reports of the trial. : 2 Pt . THUS far the World's corruption fund mounts to $24,672.11. lln 1888 5,440,708 deln men voted for Harrison, The World has $0.00438, or something less han half a cent for each man to educate iim to vote for Cleveland. -e) e e I\' HERE i 8 yet no justification for a holera scare in this country, The plague will not fasten itself upon this puntry unless it gets much worse in Let us all continue to pray pithout ceasing, however, and look jharply after our sewer connections, B St et MecAuliffe-Myer fight at New pleans resulted as cool-headed sporting jen must have anticipated. McAuliffe joved that he is the greatest fighter in ) class in the world, and he further goved that the tales about his poor mdition were without foundation, ¥ « —_———— | Tue New York Tribune falls into error yhen it suggests that Lizzie Borden ap i at the inquest *‘ on her own mo jon when she need not have appeared all.” She was not then accused of ihe murder of her father, and was obliged p respond to the summons of the magis-
A Taunton report describes Mrs. Marshall and her daughter, potential defense witnesses, who claim they saw a 'villainous-looking man' jump over the Borden back fence and speed away shortly after the murders. The article notes police were told of this lead earlier but dismissed it as unreliable.
The Record-Union · 7 September 1892 · page 6
BOItDEX MURDER MYSTERY. Two Important "Witnesses Who "VVIU Testily for the l>efonso. TAtTKTOB (Mass.), Sept. 6.—Mrs. Mar shall and her daughter will be most im portant witnesses for the defense if Liz zie Borden is ever brought to trial for the murder of her parents. Mrs. Marshall 1 says that on the morning of the tragedy I she and her daughter drove down Third street shortly after 11 o'clock and saw a [ villainous-looking man jump over Bor den' s back fence, hurry through Dr. Chagnon's yard, jump into a buggy that was in waiting and drive away.
See moreSee less
Of course they paid no attention to it at tho time, but half an hour later they drove through Second street and saw a crowd i in front of the house and heard that mur j der had been committed. Before any suspicion had rested on Lizzie Borden Mrs. Marshall had told friends about
Buried in a roundup of unrelated news items, a short dispatch from Fall River states there is no evidence to hold Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father and stepmother. It appears amid stories on cholera, train robberies, and sealing disputes.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Daily Bulletin · 7 September 1892 · page 2
a good suggestion and if tho whole the entire voyage, and arrived at wash-house establishment could bo Honolulu September 7th at i) a. m. is that tlioro is not the smallest par ticle of evidence on which to hold Lizzie Borden for (he murder of her father and step-mother.
The item claims Lizzie Borden is unlikely to be convicted, citing a report that two credible witnesses saw a sinister-looking man leap the Borden back fence and flee in a buggy shortly before the murders were discovered. No such witnesses or suspect were ever substantiated in the official investigation.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Rock Island Daily Argus · 7 September 1892 · page 4
ABBREVIATED TELEGRAMS. A murderous assault was made upon Rev. Daviil M. Cooper, pastor of the Memorial Presbyterian church of Detroit, in his study by a man who gave his name as Wilkinson, and who demanded Mr. Cooper's money. The man was arrested. The fire engine manufacturers of the United States have com bined under the name of the American Fire Engine com pany. Skunks raided a gang of railroad labor ers in West Virginia and an impromptu quarantine has been declered by the other gangs in that vicinity against their un fortunate brothers.
See moreSee less
Obituary: At Seymour, Ind., F. M. Swope; Dr. A. L. Newkirk, aged 68. At Peru, Ind.. Larry Hart, aged 103. At Scituate, Mass., T. W. Parsons, the Bos ton poet, aged 73. Lizzie Borden is likely to escape convic tion of the murder of her father and step mother at Fall River. Two reputable people, it is reported, have been found who saw a villainous looking man jump over the Borden back fence shortly be fore the murder was discovered and drive aw ay in a buggy. A race war prevails at Bunkio La., which thus far has resulted in the killing of one white man by shooting and the ! banging of Edward Laurant and Gabriel I Magloire, negroes, who had made threats against the whites. Five men implicated in the hanging have been arrested. At Lockport, N. Y., Dora Sutherland, one of the seven sisters of that name, was married to Frank Castleton, of New York City. Daniel Dougherty, the famous orator, died at his home in Philadelphia Monday, aged 67 years. A cannon ball was recently fired nearly seven miles from an eighty-ton gun in Dover, England. The 10-year-old son of ex-Councilman Thomas Barrowman, of Brazil, Ind., met with an accident which resulted in bis death the following evening. While in his father's yard cutting weeds he stepped on the stubble of a strange weed, which entered his heel. The pain brought on spasms, which resulted in lockjaw and death. You can buy table oil cloth for 18c per yard at the Columbia. The True Laxative Principle Of the plants used in manufacturing the pleasant remedy. Syrup of Figs, has a permanently beneficial effect oa the human system, while the cheap vegetable extracts and mineral solutions, usually sold as medicines, are permanently injur ious. Being well-informed, you will use the true remedy only. Manufactured by the California Fig Syrup Co. You can buy cotton flannel at the Col umbia for 6c.
Lizzie Borden has been held for trial at Fall River, Massachusetts, on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. The report states her trial is scheduled for November.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Morris Tribune · 7 September 1892 · page 4
MISCELLANEOUS. Labor Day was generally calebrated throughout the country. Danish Lutherans have closed a big conference at Waupaca, Wis. President Harrison's letter of accept ance has been given to the pvblic. Daniel Steele Durrie, librarian of the Wisconsin State Historical society, is dead. A row of wooden buildings at Port land, Or., owned by C. II. Dodd, was burned Sunday. Loss $1UU,UOO. In sured. Rev. J. F. Chaffee, presiding elder of the Winona conference district of the Methodist church, will retire from active work on account cf his health. Lizzie Borden has been held for tiial at Fall River, Mass., on the charge of murdering her father and stepmother.
See moreSee less
The trial is set for November, Up to and including the iJlst of August the treasury department has shipped to various points in the United States $7, 000,000 in small notes to facilitate the moving of the crops. The New York Standard, founded by Henry George and for a long time a prosperous weekly newspaper,has passed put of existence. It is said to have been run at a loss for soine time. Mrs. General John A. Logan has on? dertaken to raise $1,000,000 from the :^omen of this country for the American University, the national institution founded by the Methodists at Washing ton. Mike Cashing, the well known 126 f)ound pugilist, died at Fort Hamilton, N. Y., Wednesday afternoon, after a few days illness, aged 27. Deceased was
A brief notice reports that Lizzie Borden has been held for trial in Fall River, Massachusetts, on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. It states the trial is scheduled for November.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Mower County Transcript · 7 September 1892 · page 1
burned Sunday. Loss In /CMVA$100,000. sured. u! Rev. J. F. Chaffee, presiding elder of the Winona .conference district til the Methodist church, will retire from active work on account of his health. Lizzie Borden has been held for tiial at Fall River, Mass., on the charge of murdering tier father and stepmother. The trial ia set for November. Up to and including the ttlatof August the treasu^r department has shipped to various points in the (Jnited States $7, 000,000 in small notes to facilitate the moving of,the oropa. The Neir York Standard, founded by Henry Gtiorge and for a long time 3 prosperousweekly newspaper, haspassed out of existence.
See moreSee less
It is said to have been run at a loss for some time. ^r Mrs. Gei^ral John A. LbgiurW nb dertaken tp raiae$l,000,000 from the women of this country for the American University the national institution founded by^he Methodists at Washing .ton. F-u Mike Gushing, tbe well known Im pound pngtUst, died•' J'oft Hamilton, N. Y(J Wednesday tfteraioon, after a few dcys iltaetf tged 87. Deceased was born in Elisadethport, H. J. Henry Suit and^ QilmKti, la,, haye entered tbe Pasteur Institute at Chicago treatment of rabies. Th&y were bitfcp by anted dgg three weeks ago and lltely s&owed signs of having hydrophobiAr The Mlgxnesota HistoricalSociety will celebrate the *Q0th anniversary of the disooveiy AmeHoft at the Oapitbl on Oct. 91, Assistant Attorney-Gen oral ChjMs will -delfter an historical orationaaUl It. Gordon wttl lead an or if in a O the retail ooal dealers of Brooke bp.ve decided to ralstftbe ittibA of oc fnm 00 cents a tdn, I9 J5 to $B.^.
After closing arguments from defense attorney Jennings and District Attorney Knowlton, Judge Blaisdell ruled there was probable cause to hold Lizzie Borden for trial, citing her shifting accounts. She was remanded to Taunton jail to await the November grand jury term.
Weekly Union · 7 September 1892 · page 2
REMANDED TO TAUNTON JAIL. Lizzie Borden Found Probably Guilty and Held for Trial, FALL RIVER, Mass., Sept. I.—ln the Borden hearing today after the arguments by Mr. Jemnings and District-Attorney Knowlton, Judge Blaisdell said that sym rathy should be laid aside and duty, stern duty, requires upon this evidenece, but one thing to be done. Supposing that a man was seen in the chamber of Mrs. Borden, the guest chamber of death, and that he was in the room of the father when death came; supposing that a man shouid tell as many different stories as Lizzie has done, the way would be plain.
See moreSee less
I find she is proehably guiity. She was ordered remanded to the county jail at Taunton for trial at the Nevember term. All of the witnesses were ordered to recofnize for the November term of court.
Judge Blaisdell at the preliminary hearing ruled that the evidence, though circumstantial, showed Lizzie Borden was probably guilty, citing her shifting stories, and ordered her held for trial at the November term. Witnesses were also bound over to appear at that session.
Weekly Union · 7 September 1892 · page 2
IMPORTANT CLEW OBTAINED. New Theory in Connection with Fall River Mystery. TAUNTON, Sept. 4. —An important fa:t - in connection withtha mystery bas iust come ocut, and if the theory advanced is correct itwili havea great bearing upon the matter Jater on. Dr. John H. Abboett of Fall River knew something about the conditicn of the bodies of Mr, and Mrs. Borden before he weat west, but as-he went away before any sus picion was directed toward Lizzie, he had expressed no opinion. Now he says that he saw the bodies a short time.
See moreSee less
after they were discovered by the daughter and viewed by the poliee, and both were warm. There was not the slightest indication that one had been dead over an hour before the other. In fact, it is his opinion that Mr. Borden was killed firsty and that Mrs. Borden was followed up stairs by the murderer, and ~stricken down as she was running to the - window to call for assistaunce. It was the blow in the back _affecting the spine that caused death, he thinks, and the head blows were given afterward to make sure of death. It is the epinion‘of the leading physi cians here that the digestion theory is ab surd, since it is positively known thata glases of ice cold water would materially re tard digestion, and they say that Professor - Wood would not have denied this if he had been asked upon this point.
A Mrs. Marshall of Pawtucket claims she and her daughter saw a rough-looking man climb the fence from the Borden yard and drive off on the morning of the murders. She delayed coming forward due to illness, but has now told her story to lawyer Jennings, who may present it at a future hearing.
Weekly Union · 7 September 1892 · page 2
MRS. MARSHALL'S STORY.
Lizzie Was a Monstrous QOuatrage. TAUNTON, Mass., Sept. 2.—The reaction of feeling in the Borden case among Taun ton people who have followed the case has been so great as to cause widespread and openly expressed dissatisfaction at the re suit in Fall River. The Gazette says edi torially this evening: ‘“The decision, right or wrong, is what those who. have watched the peculiar - methods employed in the case have ex pected, It will not change anvhody’s opinion as to -the guilt or innocence of Miss Borden, and it cuzht not to. “By law, and by long and uniform usage,
Prof. Edward Wood testified about his analysis of stomach contents and milk samples, finding no poison and digestion underway for 2-3 hours. He also reported finding no blood on the hatchets/axes, though blood was found on the sitting-room carpet and a spot on Lizzie's white skirt.
Weekly Union · 7 September 1892 · page 1
THE BORDEN TRIAL. Government's Case at the Preliminary Hearing Closed. Professor Wood's Evidence Strong for Lizzie.
FALL RIVER, Aug. 30.—At 10:35 o’clock this morning, Prof. Edward F. Wood of the Harvard Medical school took the wit ness stand in the case of Lizzie A. Borden, charged with the murder of her father, Dr. Wood testified that on August 5 he recelved a box by express which, upon being opened, was found to contain four jars securely sealed. Two of them contained specimens of the milk =aid to have been delivered at the Bor den louse on Aug 3 and 4. The others were the stomachs of Mr.and Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden. Dr. Wood’s finding does not in any way incriminate the defendant in the suspicion of using poison. Dr. Wood said he examined the stom achs and found no inflammation or irrita tion therein. The stomachs were in a natural condition and when tested for prussic acid no indication <f that poison was found. Dr. Wood said he thought the process of, digestion in both of the victims was be tween {wo and three hours along. The examination was intently followed by the large assemblage in the eourt room. There was a sensation when Dr. Wood tes tified that he found no blood on the hatchiets or axes taken from the Borden bouse. The doctor continued: “A big smooch on the blue skirt looked like blood,and was found not to be blood. The white skirt had one spot which looked like blood, and was found to be one, and 1t was directly in front, about silx inches from the bottom. The carpet was blood gtained (this was the sitting-room carpet), and there was blood of course on that. There was no blood on the lounge cover. The envelope marked ‘“Hair from A. J. Borden” was simply white hair; Mrs. Bor den’s was dark, The hair on hatchet Was Not Human Hair (sensation) ; more like that taken from an animal. The spot on the right shoe was not bleod, and there was no blood on either shoes or stockings. There was nothing on the two axes. ¢1 am a physician and chemist.” District attorney: “You are a professor of chemistry ¥’ Xxen” , “Dld you receive a package containing two stomachs at any time?” “Yes, on the sth of August I received a package which I found contained four jars,
Dr. Wood, a physician and chemist, testified that the stomachs of Andrew and Abby Borden showed no signs of poisoning or irritation, and that no prussic acid was detected. He also reported finding no blood on the hatchets or axes, no blood on most clothing items examined, and that hair found on a hatchet was not human.
Weekly Union · 7 September 1892 · page 1
two stomachs at any time?” “Yes, on the sth of August I received a package which I found contained four jars, one laheled August 4, aijar of milk; second one labeled jar of milk, August 4; third jar labeled stomach of Andrew 'J. Borden, and fourth jar labeled stomach of Mrs. A. J. Borden. All of these jars were proper ly sealed and tight with the seals unbrok en.”
After closing arguments in the preliminary hearing, Judge Blaisdell ruled that Lizzie Borden was probably guilty of murdering her father and stepmother. She was remanded to the Taunton county jail to await trial at the November term.
The Lambertville Record · 7 September 1892 · page 4
Lizzie Borden Committed.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The preliminary examination of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother concluded, with Judge Blaisdell ruling she is probably guilty. She was remanded to jail to await trial at the November term.
The Carolina Spartan · 7 September 1892 · page 2
The preliminary examination of Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and step-mother at Fall River, was finished last Thursday. Judge Blaisdell at the conclusion of argument guilty." She was remanded to
The preliminary hearing in the Fall River case concluded with Lizzie Borden held to await grand jury action. The report notes the evidence is contradictory, pointing both to her guilt and innocence, and predicts an indictment but doubts conviction based on public evidence.
Staunton Spectator · 7 September 1892 · page 2
. _, t Lizzie Borden Held. The result of the hearing in the Fall Biver mystery is that Lizzie Borden is held to await the action of the Grand Jury. She will doubtless be indicted by the Grand Jury, but is not likely, says the N. Y. Herald, to be convicted on the evidence that has been made public on this hearing. So far from revealingthe mystery this evidence leaves it deeper than ever. From some facts disclosed the com mission of the crime by any one outside the household would seem to be impos sible. From othois it would seem to be impossible for Lizzie Borden to have
Lizzie Borden arrived in Taunton and was placed back in her jail cell to await trial. Emma Borden was appointed administratrix of their father Andrew J. Borden's estate, with a $50,000 bond secured by three sureties.
Watertown Republican · 7 September 1892 · page 2
BORDEN IN JAIL. Placed Behind the Bars to Await Her Trial.
The name of the part}" he came here to see is not known, but it is understood he has no personal friends or relatives in Chic.ftP’o. Racine or Milwaukee. burden in jail. Placed Rebind the Hath to A wait II ev Trial. Taunton, Mass., Sept. 3. — Lizzie Bor den reached Taunton yesterday noon and was taken the the jail and installed in her former quarters. Emma J. Bor den was appointed administratrix of Ihe estate of Andrew J. Borden with bond of $50,( 00. Her sureties are Frank L. Aim\", Joseph A. Bowen, of Fall River, and Frank S. Stevens, of Swan
After closing arguments, Judge Blaisdell ruled that Lizzie Borden must stand trial for the murders of her father and mother, stating the evidence showed she was 'probably guilty.' She was committed to the county jail to await trial at the November term, with all witnesses ordered to appear.
Watertown Republican · 7 September 1892 · page 2
Inzzie Borden Held for Trial. Fall River, Mass., Sept. 1. —When the attorneys had completed their argu ment to-day, Judge Blaisdell held Miss Lizzie Borden lor trial on the charge of
Judge Blaisdell ruled Lizzie Borden 'probably guilty' of murdering her father and ordered her held for the November grand jury. The report describes the judge's emotional difficulty delivering the ruling, contrasted with Borden's composed, unflinching demeanor in court.
Connecticut Western News · 8 September 1892 · page 2
Fall River, Mass., Sept. 2. As has been anticipated by everybody in this city, in cluding the counsel for the defense, Judge Blaisdell held Lizzie Borden to await the action of the November grand jury as 'probably guilty" of the murder of her fa ther four weeks ago. The judge's voice broke as he came to the word "probably." His face worked convul sively. He halted for a few seconds in the effort to control his emotions and then he went on. If he pronounced the words "guilty" at all, it so merged in the choking of his throat that it was not intelligible.
See moreSee less
But Lizzie Borden, when she stood up a moment later to receive the formal judg ment of the court from the white bearded lips.of Clerk Leonard.did so without prompt ing, did so without the trembling of an eyelash, did so without the change of the fraction of a shade of a color of her cheek, did so without the slightest downcasting or aversion of her light gray eyes in short, as if she had stood up to read her report secretary and treasurer of the Christian Endeavor society.
Judge Blaisdell ordered Lizzie Borden held for trial at the November term of court for the murder of her father and mother. He stated that given her many conflicting stories, he found her probably guilty.
Middletown Transcript · 8 September 1892 · page 2
At Fall River, Mass , last Thursday, Lizzie Borden was committed to jail by by Judge Blaisdell to await trial at the November term of court,for the murder of her father and mother. The jndge in remanding her for trial took occa sion to remark "that, in view of the many conflicting stories told by her, I I find that she is probably guilty.
Lizzie Borden was held for the November term of court following her examination at Fall River, Massachusetts, for the murder of her father and stepmother. This brief item appears amid a roundup of unrelated national news items.
Barton County Democrat · 8 September 1892 · page 2
Lizzie Borden, after the examination at Fall River, Mass., was held for the November term of court for the murder of her father and stepmother.
Lizzie Borden has been held for trial at Fall River, Massachusetts, on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. The report states her trial is scheduled for November.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Sauk Centre Herald · 8 September 1892 · page 4
MISCELLANEOUS. Labor Day was generally celebrated throughout the country. President Harrison’s letter of accept ance has been given to the public. Daniel Steele Durrie, librarian of the Wisconsin State Historical society, is dead. A row of wooden buildings at Port land, Or., owned by C. H. Dodd, was burned Sunday. Loss SIOO,OOO. In sured. Lizzie Borden has been held for tiial at Fall River, Mass., on the charge of murdering her father and stepmother. The trial is set for November. Up to and including the 81st of August the treasury department has shipped to various points in the United States $7,- 000,000 in small notes to facilitate the moving of the crops.
See moreSee less
The New York Standard, founded by Henry George and for a long time a prosperous weekly newspaper, has passed out of existence. It is said to have been run at a loss for some time. Mike Cushing, the well known 126pound pugilist, died at Fort Hamilton, N. Y., Wednesday afternoon, after a few days illness, aged 27. Deceased was
Lizzie Borden arrived back at Taunton jail and was placed in her former cell, remaining calm despite onlookers. The same day, the Probate Court appointed her sister Emma administratrix of their father's estate, with a $50,000 bond.
Marble Hill Press · 8 September 1892 · page 2
Lizzie Borden in a Cell Once More. Tauxton, Mass., Sept. 5. Lizzie Bor den reached Taunton yesterday after noon. She was calm and self-possessed, and paid no attention to the staring crowd at the station. She was taken
The report notes that Bridget Sullivan's reputation for truthfulness has been investigated as part of the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden. This reflects ongoing efforts to assess witness credibility ahead of further proceedings.
Marble Hill Press · 8 September 1892 · page 3
Bridget Sullivan's reputation for truth fulness has been investigated in con nection with the prosecution ot the charge ot murder against Lizzie Borden. It is
Investigators looked into Bridget Sullivan's reputation for truthfulness as part of the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden. They concluded her reputation for honesty was good.
A short news brief reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden, accused of killing her father and stepmother with an ax, has begun in Fall River, Massachusetts. The item appears as one of many unrelated short news items in a roundup column.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Marble Hill Press · 8 September 1892 · page 3
The trial of Li tile Borden, charges with murdering bar father and step mother with an ax, has begun at Fall River, Mass. , yt, Indianapolis members ot the Iron Hall will try to keen the order going, and also try to indict somebody tor some thing. Secretary Charles Foster discussed the difficulties of controlling immigration bo fore an audience at Atbury Park, N. J. Almost a disaster happened at the cast ing ot the big new gun carriage for the Government at the Watertown (N. Y.) Arsenal. In a senseless tiring of pistols at a negro dance at Bird's Point, Mo., one known as "the Devil,' shot dead Thomas Adkins, musician.
See moreSee less
At Ira Hill, N. Y., an angry thresher ground up a man in a threshing-machine and was killed with a pitchfork by hie victim's brother. The loss to the Metropolitan Opera House of New York by Saturday's tire exclusive ot scenery and properties, Is now put at about 300,000. Senator Mills, In a let or to the Dallas News, says he regards Hogg as the Dem ocratic nominee tor Governor of Texas and as such will support him. In a drunken quarrel near Vandalia, 111., Johd D. Fraley was cut by his brother-in-law, Chas. Chandler so that he died in a few minutes. Chandler is in jail. A crevasse threatens to reopen Pass a Loture, one of the mouths ot the Missis sippi closed when the jetties were built, and the Eads Company are alarmed and will try to close it up. Bridget Sullivan's reputation for truth fulness has been investigated in con nection with the prosecution ot the charge ot murder against Lizzie Borden. It is found to be good. A startling story, indicating that The odore D. T. Pryce, an Englishman, im pri oned in Colorado for life for killing his friend, escaped and is safe in London, comes from Denver. James Stark and Thomas Edwards, St Louis burglars, were cornered at Bunker Hill, 111., by citizens and a battle ensued in which Alderman Baker was killed. The burglars were captured. Joseph Abraham, a Hebrew stage car penter of New York, renounced Judaism and was baptized by an Episcopal clergy man, owing to a change of religious sen timent brought about by the death ot hli child. The proposition of Illinois to stop im migration byPresidential proclamation is found to be impractical, but it may do so under the general police powers of the state, if found necessary for protection from cholera. For supposed intimacy with the wife of a workman at Crispen Island, near Bruns wick, Ga., Frank Rooks, a prominent citizen, was called from his house, tarred and feathered and ordered to leave in three minutes. He did. A curtailment In the iron ore trade is looked for. Canadian bankers want United Statos silver coin kept out of their country. One of the rich New York Gilseys has married a pretty and well-educated candy girl. A flight ot grasshoppers over Moberly, Mo., partially obscured the sun. They went southwest. Bradstreet's reports that the speculative market was seriously affected by the strikes. ' , . St. J oseph gamblers will probably be obliged to abandon their river barge, fitted up to evade the law. At Trenton, Tex., Mrs. W. A. Allen mortally wounded her half-sister, Mis
The preliminary trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents in Fall River, Mass., concluded on the 1st. She was remanded to jail to await trial in November.
The Free Press · 8 September 1892 · page 2
Wis< ‘<Hisin OtMUocrafM, in couvhii* *ion a^seuihii cl, unanimous]\- n>. nominated the e ti e state ticket. I hey gel a full Peck-measure of jus lice under their present govern or. Kev W. P. Katlift lias been nom inated for congress by the third partyites of the tilth district. The reverend gentleman will Und it a difficult matter to successfully serve l.eavon and the devil. The preliminary trial of Miss Lizzie Borden, for the murder o( her parents, at Fall Liver, Mass., was concluded on tlm 1st, and -Miss Borden was remanded to j .il to ap pear far trial in November,
A short item states that Lizzie Borden has been held to await action of the grand jury at Fall River, Massachusetts, for the murder of her father and stepmother. It appears as a small news brief amid a list of Republican political candidates and other unrelated items.
Fergus County Argus · 8 September 1892 · page 2
Lizzie Borden has been held to await the action ot the grand jury at Fall River, Mass., for the murder of her fat her and step-mother.
A roundup of miscellaneous news items includes a one-line notice stating that the murder trial of Miss Lizzie Borden has begun at Fall River, Massachusetts. The item appears amid unrelated sports, railroad, and political news briefs.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Courier Democrat · 8 September 1892 · page 2
MISCELLANEOUS. A general fight occurs at a political meeting in South Carolina. The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for mur der begins at Fall River, Mass. W. W. Blackwell of Kentucky is elected supreme chancellor of the Knights of Pvth ias. Mr. Gladstone has been re-elected in Mid lothian on taking office. He had no op position. Miss Ella Reid, neice of Whitelaw Reid, will soon be married at Opliir farm to Robert C. Harrison, judge of the supreme court at California. He is seventy. years old. A report touching upon the recent lynch ing of Italians in New Orleans is presented et the meeting of the American Bar asso ciation.
See moreSee less
At the First perish Unitarian church at Gloucester, Mass., services were held com memorative of the fifty veer* existence oi thatchsrcb. Rev. Daniel Munroe Wilson, of Quincy, delivered an historical address. This cfcaich has bad sixteen pastors since Utt.
A short news brief reports that Lizzie Borden has been held for trial at Fall River, Massachusetts, on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. The item notes the trial is scheduled for November.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 8 September 1892 · page 2
ELECTRICAL ECHOES. Hatters of More or Lean Moment Briefly Mentioned. Daniel Steele Durrie, librarian of the Wisconsin State Historical society, is dead. Judge Kelly has decided that the Commercial bank, of St. Paul, may re sume business. The custom collections at St. Paul for August amounted to $20,000 and the revenue to $224,000. The Democrats of the Eleventh 2ais souri district have renominated John O'Neill for congress. Lizzie Borden has been held for tiial at Fall River, Mass., ou the charge oi murdering her father and stepmother. The trial is set for November.
See moreSee less
Republicans of the Seventh Minnesota district, in convention at Moorhead, nominated Hetiry Feig, of Kandiyohi county, for congress. The roller flouring mill of M. F. Pease tc Son, at Lowell, Dodge county, Wis., has been destroyed by fire. The mill was valued at $20,000 partially insured.
The piece quotes the New York Herald suggesting authorities would release Lizzie Borden if she showed emotional distress like hair-tearing. It wryly notes that her calm self-possession has instead worked against her in public opinion, commenting ironically on assumptions about women's behavior.
The Providence News · 8 September 1892 · page 4
- A MOB of whites lynched three negroes 'in Texas the other day. A ‘“‘race war” ‘was the cause, no crime being even alJoged against the blacks. Yet the Dem ocratic party is not willing to allow the pegros to protect their lives and rights ‘with the ballot. ) S om— " Tag New York Herald thinks that I Lizzie Borden would rave around ‘and tear her hair a little the authorities ‘wounld let her go.” It is a curious fact hat Miss Borden's self-possession has mndoabtedly counted against her, which 48 not exactly an argument for woman's R e ) .
See moreSee less
. Hesxry WAarTERsON forced the tariff plank in the Democratic platform upon the Chicago Convention. He declared the purpose of the Democratic party shus: *““We mean to rip up, extermi ':m abolish, annibilate, and expel in ‘the t ignominy and disgrace every e of the fraud called protection.” Now let Mr. Cleveland take this for the keynote of his letter of acceptance, as 4t certainly was the keynote of the con yention, and give the country some g about the Democratic attitude to - ward the tariff. e —_————
A ship captain at a Beverly store recounts his past dealings with Andrew Borden, insisting the family were decent people. He observes that most women he's spoken to believe Lizzie is guilty, while most men believe she's innocent.
The Providence News · 8 September 1892 · page 4
A CAP'N WHO ENEW THE BORDENS, “I suppose you think Lizzie Borden killed her father?” It was a clean limbed, straight, swarthy man who spoke. and he stood behind the counter of a little country store on the outskirts of
A newspaper vignette records a sea captain recounting his dealings with Andrew Borden, defending him as generous despite his reputation for stinginess. He also recalls Lizzie as a child, voicing confidence in her innocence, while overheard bystanders debate gendered opinions on her guilt.
The Providence News · 8 September 1892 · page 4
A CAP'N WHO KNEW THE BORDENS,
- & = “Well,” said the younger of the two members of the sex thus reproved, *‘their meat man won't miss the elder l‘ordenn, tlr:tzy vy’armod over their mutton broth too often, The swarthy man straightened up. **There you go again,’” he said: *“ 1 tell ou themn Bordens were nice peo'ple. Why f'm master of a four-masted ship, just in
The piece discusses public criticism of Judge Blaisdell's ruling that bound Lizzie Borden over for trial in the murder case, with the writer defending the decision as necessary given the circumstances. It argues the ruling does not establish guilt and that Borden should wait for a higher court to determine her innocence if she is indeed innocent.
St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 8 September 1892 · page 4
The decision of Judge Blaisdell in the somewhat famous Borden mur der case, holding the respondent, Lizzie Borden, for trial before a high er court, has elicited quite a storm of criticism from people who think that Lizzie should have been allowed to go free, as an innocent woman. We fail to see how Judge Blaisdell could, under the circumstances, reach any other decision and at the same time meet the demands f law and justice to nil parties concerned in the tracredy. Coalmining the respondent for j h her uuilt. bv 1 triiii dues not istau! if indeed innocent. anv means.
A news digest reports that Lizzie Borden has been committed to jail to await trial at the November term of court. It notes that her friends are indignant over Judge Blaisdell's decision.
St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 8 September 1892 · page 5
RECORD OF THE WEEK. Thursday. By an explosion of powder at a grad ing camp in Colorado two men were blown to atoms and four fatally hurt. A fast mail on the Hudson River road went through an open draw and was piled in a heap; one man was killed and several others seriously hurt. The New Zealand house of representatives has given women the right to vote. Pres ident Harrison was thrown from a carriage at White Plains, N. Y., but was only slightljbruised. Lizzie Borden
A Mrs. Marshall of Pawtucket, who was in Fall River the day of the Borden murder, reported seeing a 'villainous-looking man' climb over the Borden yard fence and drive off in a buggy shortly before the crowd gathered. This item appears within a roundup of miscellaneous news items from the preceding week.
St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 8 September 1892 · page 5
President Harrison issues his letter of acceptance. A Mrs. Alarshall of Paw tucket, R. I., who was in Fall River on the day of the Borden murder, tells of a "villainous-looking man" whom she and her daughter saw climb over the fence of the Borden yard and drive off in a buggy a siiort time before they saw the crowd gather in front of the Borden house. Alpine, Texas, was nearlv swept away by a cloudburst. Eight soldiers in a house in Gallicia were ki;led b3 a stroke of lightning. Tuesday.
See moreSee less
Two policemen and J. AI. Brown, a noted horseman, were killed in a riot at Garneld Park race track. Chicago, over the arrest of bookmakers. An American flag was hissed in a Alontreal theatre, and was also torn down and dragged in the streets. Six indictments have been found against Bergman, who attempted to kill Manager Frick of the Carnegie company.-Railway mail clerks are holding a convention at Washington. Six persons were killed in a collision on a German railway near Stuttgart.
Lizzie Borden arrived in Taunton and was taken back to jail to await her trial. Emma Borden was appointed administratrix of their father's estate with sureties named.
Eagle River Review · 8 September 1892 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN IN JAIL, Placed Behind the Bars to Await Her Trial
The name of the party he came here to see 18 not knewn, but it is understood he has no personal friends or relatives in Chiesco. Racine or Milwankee. LIZZIE BORDEN IN JAIL, Placed Buhind the isars to Awalt Hex Trinl,
After attorneys completed their arguments, Judge Blaisdell ruled there was probable cause to hold Lizzie Borden for trial on charges of murdering her father and mother. He stated that sentiment must be set aside and found her probably guilty, ordering her held in custody until the November term of court.
Eagle River Review · 8 September 1892 · page 2
s I-zzie Borden Held for Tridl 4 FarLrL River, Mase., Sept. 1-'.‘“l‘;’: the attorneys had completed u:girf‘\’l'.; ment to-day, Judge Blaisdell heid - “_, Lizzie Borden for trial on the chal‘gf,f;'
A news digest item reports that Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and mother in Fall River, Massachusetts, was held for trial by the district court following her preliminary examination. The brief notice appears among many unrelated news items of the day.
away SI,OOO worth of goods. Lizzie. Borden, charged with murdering her father und mother nt Fall River, Massaobu *etu, was held upon preliminary examination for trial before tho district court.
Mrs. Marshall of Pawtucket claims she and her daughter saw a rough-looking man climb the fence behind the Borden house around 11 a.m. on the day of the murders and drive off in a buggy. She says grief over her husband's death kept her from coming forward until now, and Lizzie Borden's attorney Jennings has been informed of her account.
The Willimantic Journal · 9 September 1892 · page 1
Fall River the day of the Borden murder, says she passed the Borden house about 11 o’clock in tbe forenoon and that she and her daughter saw a rough looking man climb the fence in tbe rear of the Bordeu house, get into a buggy and drive off. Afterwards she passed in front of the house where a crowd had gathered be cause of the murders. Mrs. Marshall says that she has been prostrated by the sud den death of her husband since that day and has not been able to tell the story until now. Lizzie Borden’s counsel, Mr. Jennings,has been informed of the circum stances.
At the preliminary hearing, Prof. Wood of Harvard reported examining the stomachs, hatchet, axes, clothing, and hair samples sent by Dr. Dolan. He found no blood on the hatchet or lounge cover, and the hair on the hatchet resembled animal hair rather than human hair from the victims.
The Kansas State Ledger · 9 September 1892 · page 2
In Lizzie’s Favor. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 30. — The circumstantial evidence structure which the prosecution had constructed with such care about Lizzie Borden and which, up to this morning seemed strong enough almost to justify her con viction of the horrible murders of her aged father and stepmother, received a blow to-day which threatened its entire demolition and now public opinion has turn ed once more strongly in favor of the accused girl. When the hearing was resumed this morning, Prof. Wood of Har vard college, to whom the state had intrusted the analysis of vari ous articles, was called to the stand.
See moreSee less
He said that he had re ceived a package containing two stomachs on August 5 and two jars containing milk used August 4 and 5. All were labeled. The stomachs were labeled, “Mr and Mrs. Borden.’’ They appeared to be perfectly natural. “On the 10th of August,” con tinued the professor, “I received from Dr. Dolan a hatchet, two axes, a blue shirt, a blue dress waist, a white starched shirt, a lounge cover and three small en velopes in w'hich were hair taken from Mr. and Mrs. Borden and hair taken from the hatchet. On August 16 I received a pair of black stockings. The hatchet con tained a number of suspicious looking spots, but careful exami nation showed no traces of blood. Every spot which looked like blood w’as examined, but no traces QWhen in history were we so badly placed in doubt? Never before were we in this predica ment. Now toil day and night for liberty. Patrick Henry said: “Give me liberty or give me death.” Now choose for yourself. We prefer liberty; but, if we can not achieve liberty by our efforts, give us death.
Testimony describes examination of a hatchet, carpet, and clothing for bloodstains, with most spots found not to be blood and the hair on the hatchet suspected to be animal rather than human. The defense also notes detectives are shadowing a suspicious man matching a description given by Dr. Handy.
The Kansas State Ledger · 9 September 1892 · page 2
Handy, and he is being shadowed by detectives in the employ of the Misses Borden until he is needed. HOW HE DOES IT. Sullivan Gives a Public Exhi
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
An editorial argues that the commonwealth's case against Lizzie Borden rests on weak evidence, noting that both the poison theory and hatchet theory have failed. It criticizes the officers of the law for being partial and cruel in the inquest and hearing, suggesting the prosecution has little chance before a jury.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 September 1892 · page 1
Those who have followed the testimony in the hearing in the Borden case must feel that the commonwealth hold Lizzie Borden on very insufficient evidence. The attitude of the officers of the law, in the inquest and at the hearing, has been singularly partial and cruel; if they have presented their case with any approach to fulness, they have small chance before a jury. The poison theory, the hatchet theory, have both utterly failed, and it appears that all the case against Miss Borden rests on is th probability that she was in the house at least when Mrs Bor
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
At a Boston temperance union service, Mrs. Susan Fessenden praised Lizzie Borden's character and church work, urging attendees to sign a petition favoring her bail. The audience of 2500 rose together to show support for the prisoner's innocence.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 September 1892 · page 5
senden made an impassioned idea in behalf of Miss Lizzie Borden. She told of the good work dune by Miss Borden in the past, her zeal in church matters, her energy in the Christian endeavor society, her helpfulness in the armv of temperance workers, and her kindness to those who needed assistance, i Mrs Fessenden said she spoke with a mother’s heart, and she appealed to the fathers and mothers present to show by their indorse ment of a Woman’s Christian temperance union petition to the governor in favor of bail for Miss Borden, whether they believed in the innocence of the prisoner. At the con clusion of the reading of the petition, the audience numbering about 2500, arose simul taneously and showed their belief in the prisoner’s innocence.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The report covers the close of the Borden preliminary hearing, noting the trial has been set for the November term. It summarizes defense attorney Andrew Jennings's argument, which laid out the timeline of Andrew Borden's murder and challenged the state's case.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 September 1892 · page 11
“FOUND~ PSOBABLY-GUILTY.’’ END OF THE BORDEN HEARING. TRIAL SET FOR THE NOVEMBER TERM. I.awyer Jennings Criticises the State’s Conduct of the CaseAir Knowlton’s Mumming up of the Evidence.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Defense counsel Jennings argues the Commonwealth's theory that someone inside the house committed the murders is undermined by evidence of unidentified strangers seen near the property, including a man Dr. Handy saw and one Mrs. Manley reported. He stresses that Lizzie, as the devoted youngest daughter, should not be presumed guilty based on circumstantial evidence alone.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 September 1892 · page 11
utmost care, that the guilty should be found. The theory of the government seems to have been that the crime was committed by the inmates of that house. All their work seems to have been directed by that one mea. It is claimed that nobody could get out of the house without being seen, because there were people ail around. The government know the house has bee it broken into in the day time within two years and the barn broken into within two months, and the facts are not disputed.
See moreSee less
We show something the police ought to have discovered, the stranger with in the gate, as told by Mrs Manley. They have spent night and day following up clews to convict Lizzie Borden, but know nothing about Mrs Manley aud the man she saw. Why ? Because they are not looking for any body outside. The extraordinary thing is that the police cannot find the man Dr Handy saw, but they can find the ax or axes Lizzie Borden killed her father with. There is the fact that strange men have
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Defense attorney Jennings argues that Bridget Sullivan had equal opportunity to commit the murders and that a mystery man seen near the house raises doubt about an inside killer. He defends Lizzie's inconsistent inquest testimony as the product of emotional strain and harsh repeated questioning, not guilt.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 September 1892 · page 11
almost in tears. Continuing he said he did not believe that either Bridget Sullivan or Lizzie committed the deed. Andrew J. Borden could not have got into the house before 10.45, and there are 20 minutes of Bridget's time unaccounted for and nobody has baked her, on the side of the prosecution, what she was doing all that lime. It she could du three windows in 15 minutes, did it take her three-quarters of an hour to wash the other four? The point is this that if Lizzie does not explain everything as she goes along, if she trips in her testimony, then she must be the guilty party, think the government.
See moreSee less
It Lizzie had an opportunity to commit this murder, Bridget had an opportunity. Counsel did not desire to show that Bridget was guilty, but was only trying to show Hie extarordinary course of the government toward Lizzie. Follow ing Mt Borden from his & house at 9.30, counsel brought him back at the time
The report recaps the August 4 murders of Andrew and Abby Borden in Fall River and states that Lizzie Borden, Andrew's daughter, is being tried for the crime with circumstantial evidence against her. It describes her as a respectable, refined 30-year-old church and Sunday school member who appears composed during proceedings.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Republican · 9 September 1892 · page 5
div LIZZIE BORDEN. On the 4th of August Andrew J. Borden auM his wife were murdered in their own house, in Pali River, Massachusetts. The daughter of Borden by his first wife, Lizzie Borden, is now being tried for the crime. There is a strong chain of circumstantial evidence pointing to her as the culprit. Miss Borden is a good looking woman of thirty years, refini'd in her tastes, a mem ber of Central Congregational church and a Sunday school teach er. During her trial she is show ing herself singularly prepossess ing.
See moreSee less
Selby snort—l>e I ayed. Don’t our enterprising farmers put on a broad grin when they come to town shopping. Good rains do it. . Boy’s don’t forget you can buy Harrison and Reid caps in Selbys ' port for 10 cents. Mrs. George D. Frantz, of Blooming Rose, paid her many Republican friends, of Selbysport, a visit the 25th and 20th of AuI gust. Come again, Mrs. F. Chas MeMillen, representing Jessie Liston, of Listnnburg, paid our merchants a business visit Aug. 25. A. J. Frazec, of Frazee Ridge, has received two car loads of lime from J. J. Hoblitzell & Co., of j Hyndman, IV, for wheat. Mr. F. tells us he can buy lime for less money than he can quarry it for and he says its far superior to our own lime. Messrs 'Yin. Merrill, of Oakland, and C. N. Friend, of Manor Land, our school commissioners, were on our street letting out the building of our new school house. VVc are informed the John NY. Frazee Building company was awarded the contact, and are to receiye 1875. Mr. Mer-ill did not forget to call on his old acquaintances while in town. Noryal Spcelman, of Mineral Springs, left onr station for Mount Union, Ohio, where he expects to attend the college this fall and winter. Victor Council will miss his smiling face for some time. Albert Guard is spending a few days with his brother Fred,of Brad dock, Pa., Hurrah for Selbysport! You can see many Harrison & Reid caps worn on our streets. Cleveland and Stevenson caps are not in it. We have Democratic families here but there boys will not wear a C. & S. cap. Buy Harrison and Reid caps at Selbysport for 10 cents. You need not take an up train expecting to buy the same caps for less than 20 J cents and your car fare. Robt. Green, one of Moscow’s good Republicans, was on our , streets horse trading Saturday the j 27th. Horse traders are properly i cared for when they come to town ! on such business. Oak Hil|. Ram is needed very badly. Jascph Groer is hauling lumber j to Kriendsville where lie oxnocts to J erect a large granary, lie expects j to buy coin by the car load. Mr. Noah llumTorston and daughter were guests at Mr. Clark Rush’s last Saturday evening and Sunday. Mrs. Harvey t'mble, of Friends villc, was visiting relatives and friends in this neighborhood ast week. Win Teats has has his new ground I ready for wheat. Jas. Groer purchased a drove of fat cattle from Jerry Liston, of West Sfelbysport. The roals were full of people on Sunday going to Accident to at tend the Sunday school conven tion. A Mr. Dawson, of Baltimore, ! was here selling land last week, j Mr. Henry Brown purchased the * home place. Rattlesnake season is over for | this year. Rev. Knotts will preach his j farewell sermon next Sunday even ing. Everybody is invited to be ! present. W. Schroyer is the proudest man i because it is a boy. Swanton. The Republicans of District No. 1 will meet to organize a Harrison, j Reid and Wellington campaign i
Lizzie Borden was committed to Taunton jail without bail on the charge of murdering her father. She will await action by the Bristol county grand jury on the first Monday of November.
The Charlotte Democrat · 9 September 1892 · page 2
32?" At Fall River Lizzie Borden was committed to the Taunton jail without bail on the charge of murdering her father, to await the action of the Bristol county grand Jury on the first Monday of November Jif The Louisiana Lotteiy Company has offered valuable inducements to the Sandwich Islands Government for a Charter and it will probably be accepted.
A roundup of global news items in a German-language paper mentions the unsolved Fall River double murder case. It notes that the preliminary investigation against Lizzie Borden, suspected of murdering her father and stepmother, has not yet produced any directly incriminating evidence.
Scranton Wochenblatt · 9 September 1892 · page 4
Der räthselhafle Doppelmord von Fall River, Mass., ist noch immer nicht aufgeklärt. Die Voruntersuchung ge gen Lizzie Borden, welche in dringen dem Verdachte der Ermordung ihres Vaters, des Bankiers Borden und des sen Gattin, LizzieS Stiefmutter, steht,