The report notes that Lizzie Borden of Fall River, suspected of murdering her father and mother, was taken back to prison on Friday. She will remain jailed until the Grand Jury convenes in November.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Sullivan Republican · 9 September 1892 · page 3
Lizzie Borden of Fall River, Mass., and who is suspected of murdering her father and mother, an account of which was given in the REPUBLICAN last week, was taken back to prison on Friday, where she will remain until the setting of the
The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I.
A short item recaps that Andrew Borden and his wife were murdered on August 4 in Fall River, and that his daughter Lizzie is now being tried for the crime amid strong circumstantial evidence. It describes her as a refined, good-looking Sunday school teacher who appears composed during the trial.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Olneyville Times · 9 September 1892 · page 2
SMALL TALK. Senator Vest is considered the best de bater in the United States Senate. In fact, it is hard work for his brother Sena tors to pull down this Vest. Gladstone is no cow-ard if he did run from the heifer. Henry Clay had rather be right than be president and he got his rather. It is a funny thing about Labor Day that no one is supposed to work. The long vacation is over and soon the echool children will long for anotaer. This matter of a national flower should be settled before winter strikes in.
See moreSee less
Rifles were made on the ball Learing principle, long before bicycles. Lizzie Borden. Oan the 4th of Augast, Andraw J. Bord en and his wife were murdered in their own honse, in Fall River, Mass. The daughter of Borden, by his first wife, Lizzie Borden, is now being tried for the crime. There is a strong chain of circumstantial evilence, pointiag to her as the murderer. Miss DBorden, is a good looking woman of thirty years. Refined in her tastes a member of the Central Congregational church, and a sunday schiool teacher. Duaring her trial, she is showing hers«lf singularly preposessing. Conecerning Logs and Loggers The Week'y published rccently, a page engraving, part of a series upon loggine in Wisconsin, in which a team of horses was shown, drawifN a lhad of 14 logs. The drawing was made, by T. de Thul strup, and it was interesting and pictar esque, “From wvarious parts of the country, there came communications coneerning that load of logs. Some partook of the nature of temperate exhortation, some were the vehicles of gentle censure and some betrayed the eharp pain of aroused and indignant incredulity. The artist as a matter of fact, had not depicted any thing extraordinary. So far as concernad the practice and meth ola of logging, with which he had to do; his facts were the commonplace of log ging in that region; howaver startling they might appear to persons unfamiliar to them, or how :ver irritating they might prove to loggers and amat2urs’of logging in Conn., Penn. or Me. Mr. W. A. Benedict, of D:troit,"Mich., writes us an interesting and instractive photograph, of which an engraving is given below, and he writes as fullows;— I read with interest your two very in structive, as well as graphie acecounts of lumbering in Northern Wisconsin, and take pleasure in mailing you a photo of the largest load of pine lozs ever haunled by any one team of horses in the pine woods of Michigan. The load consisted of twenty logs, all of which were 16 feet in length, and sealed 14.595 (Broad meas ure.) This Immmense load was hauled a distance four miles, from one of the num=- erous eamps of Gratwick, Smith & Fraz er lumber Co., and banked in_ Otsego Lake, Mich. A Detroit, Mich. April Sth, 18S5. Mr. R. Prentice, also writes us, from Prent ce Pine Co. Wis. Seeing some criticisms upon the picture of a load of logs, published in your paper, and referred to in others. Please allow me to give yon a few facts regarding work in camp, which will net be for oae load only, but an average for one week, In this camp, four sleighs haul forty loads per day, or 240 loads for six days. The amount of lumber hauled for one week, sealed, is 552,000 fi. Toe weizht of logs per sealed ft. is 8 pounds. 552,00) feet X S = 4 416,000 Ibs., or 220 carloads of 20.000 Ibs. each. Our boss load confained twenty three loga, 5,712 ft., of which the estimated weight, was 49,696 Ibs.. and we do not claim to bave hauled the largest load. The largest load 1 have seen was 8560 ft, hauled by four horses. We gust our many friends, who have shown so deep an interest in our logging pictures, will consider their oh;=ctions, if they have entertained any, and that those who have eavillad at the work of our artist, will turn gool nataredly about and take a lesson”. L. Sweet & Co., lomber dealers, have had the picture of the load referred to above, painted life siz> on their office, on Harris Ave., by Ww. Maxtield the artist. So many have taken an interest in the
The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I.
A brief local news item mentions that a good picture of Lizzie Borden can be found on the second page of the Times. No further details are given about the case itself.
The Olneyville Times · 9 September 1892 · page 3
An excellent picture of Lizzie Borden, can be seen on the second page of the Tivugs. A flag staff, has been erected at the Bell school house, by friends of the school. The bookcase in the Johnston Engine Station is completed and contributions of books are now in order.
A roundup column of assorted short news items from around the country includes a single line noting that Lizzie Borden's trial for murdering her father and stepmother with an ax is in progress at Fall River, Mass. The item is one of dozens of unrelated brief crime and oddity reports in the column.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
San Saba County News · 9 September 1892 · page 3
SORTINGS SERIOUS AND SENSATIONAL
The trial of Lizzie Borden charged with murdering her father and step mother with an ax is In progress at Fall River Mass Andrew Lohr 70 years old of Col umbus Ind gave his 50vcarnld
The report states that Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and mother in Fall River, Massachusetts, was held for trial following a preliminary examination. The case was sent forward to the district court.
The Fremont Clipper · 9 September 1892 · page 1
away 71.000 worth of goods. Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and mother at Fall River, Massachu setts, was held upon preliminary examination for trial before the district court.
The preliminary hearing in the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, Massachusetts, concluded on the 1st. She was remanded to jail to await trial at the November term.
rebels, who follow the leadership of Gen. Crespo. Thk hearing in the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother at Fall River, Mean, was dosed on the Ist,and the ac enaed was remanded to jail for trial
The preliminary hearing in the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, concluded on the 1st. She was remanded to jail to await trial at the November term of court.
Huntsville Gazette · 10 September 1892 · page 1
CRIMES AND CASUALTIES. On the night of the 30th the steamer tVestern Reserve broke in two off Au Sable banks, Mich., and all but one of the twenty-seven persons on board were drowned. Harry Stew-art, of Algonac, Mich., was the sole survivor. At Barinage, Belgium, on the 1st, twenty-five persons were killed and eight mortally wounded by an explosion in the Aggrappe coal mine. On the 1st the hearing in the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with the mur
Judge Blaisdell in Fall River, Mass., after hearing all the evidence, ruled that Lizzie Borden would be held for trial on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. The trial was set for the November term of the county court.
The Washington Bee · 10 September 1892 · page 2
Judge Blaisdell, at Fall River, Mass.. after hearing all the evidence, deoided to hold Lizzie Borden for trial for the mur der of her father and stepmother, at the November term of the county court.
The report states that Lizzie Borden's case will go before the grand jury after a preliminary hearing. It describes the prosecution as having successfully established a prima facie case of murder against her.
The Washington Bee · 10 September 1892 · page 4
IfTT'S? - l,2Z1E BORDEN held. A DESPERADO ' HANGED. THIS WEEK'S NEWS. a 3 -- - 5SUUCecSrUL & IBifcfeseiS&B ji a rrima Facia Case of Murder. Summary of Current Events-The World s TALTON HALL PAYS THE PENALTY TIVE kEWODSt IntheUsoof CtfMDoings for the Past Six Days Gathered Judge Blaisdel, at Fall River, Mas3., OF A HUNDRED CRIMES.
After hearing testimony, Judge Blaisdell ruled there was prima facie evidence to hold Lizzie Borden for the grand jury in the murders of her father and stepmother, surprising observers since the prosecution's theory of a will-based motive had largely collapsed. The case against her rested mainly on inconsistencies in her account of her movements that morning, contradicted in part by servant Bridget Sullivan's testimony.
The Washington Bee · 10 September 1892 · page 4
It is held that Mrs. Borden was murdered from an hour to an hour and a half be foie Mr. Borden, and that Lizzie Borden .'iid Bridget Sullivan were the only other
The report reviews the evidence from Lizzie Borden's inquest and preliminary hearing, noting her inconsistent statements, lack of poison or blood evidence, and witness sightings of a mysterious stranger near the Borden house. It concludes she was held for the grand jury on a weak prima facie case, with suggestions the District Attorney has reserved further evidence.
The Washington Bee · 10 September 1892 · page 4
1 " -.--.-- kf i ..i 5.- -&' u peiius in the house at the time, and con sequently one or the other must be guilty of the murder, either as principal or ac cessory. As Bridget Sullivan accounted for hr actions to the satisfaction of the' coroner, and Lizzie Borden did not, the latter is adjudged ou a jjriHin facia case guilty of the murder. 'J ho prosecution failed to show any evidence that Mr. Borden had intended to make a w ill, or that there was any par ticular bitcerness in the Borden house hold. The testimony of Dr. Woods, the chemist of Harvard College, showed that there was no poison in the stomachs of Mr. and-Mis. Borden, nor was there any
A brief news digest reports that the preliminary hearing for Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, Mass., concluded on September 1st. She was remanded to jail to await trial at the November term of court.
The State Capital · 10 September 1892 · page 2
Borden, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother at Fall River, Mass.,was closed on the Ist,and the ac cused was remanded to jail for trial at the November term. The sum of $3,000,000 in gold buried by the lady superior of the Concepcion convent in the City of Mexico during the war with France, has been recov ered and turned into the general treas ury of the government. United States District Attorney Lyon has entered suit in the United States court at Pittsburgh, in behalf of the government against Feeney Bros., quarrymen, to recover $ll,OOO for viola tion of the contract labor law in im porting alien workmen.
Counsel for Lizzie Borden and the state made closing arguments before Judge Blaisdell reviewing the testimony. The judge refused to release her and ordered her held for the grand jury, sending her to county jail to await trial at the November term.
The Savannah Tribune · 10 September 1892 · page 1
Counsel for Lizzie Borden and the state made arguments Thursday before Judge Blaisdell, reviewing the testimony given. The court would not release Lizzie Bor den, but held her to await the action of
Following her examination in Fall River, Massachusetts, Lizzie Borden was ordered held for the November term of court. She faces charges for the murder of her father and stepmother.
Baxter Springs News · 10 September 1892 · page 6
Southern California tho coming win ter. Lizzie Borden, after the examination at Fall River, Mass., was held for the November term of court for the murder of her father and stepmother. Nelson, the stallion, trotted a mile at Bangor, Me., in 2:13tf. TriE body of a fourteen-year-old girl, making the fourth victim, has been found in the ruins of the New York Wooster street fire. The democratic congressional con ventions at Philadelphia made nomina tions as follows: . First district, E. G. Flanigan; Second district, John J. Ma loney; Fourth district, Elbridge E.
See moreSee less
Nock. Dr. Jenkins, the health officer at New York, declared that he would ignore the president's proclamation for twenty days' quarantine, which ho conceived an unwarranted interference. Patrick Hawley died near Wilkcs borre, Ta., from a rattlesnake bite not-, withstanding that he drunk a large,
The report states that Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and mother in Fall River, Mass., has been remanded to jail after a preliminary examination. She was denied bail and will await trial in November.
Feliciana Sentinel · 10 September 1892 · page 3
IT. lizzie Borden, the younlg lady who standls chrged with the murder of her fathernud mothier, at Fall River. 3Mass.. has been remanded to jail, after prelin
At the close of the preliminary hearing, defense attorney Jennings made an eloquent but unsuccessful plea for Lizzie Borden. Judge Blaisdell ruled that the evidence showed she was probably guilty and ordered her held for the November term of court.
The L'anse Sentinel · 10 September 1892 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN HELD. Conclusion of the Preliminary If car In Yesterday. Fall KiVEit, Mass., Sept. 3. In the Borden murder trial yesterday Mr. Jennings opened for the defense with
Following her preliminary examination in Fall River, Massachusetts, Lizzie Borden was ordered held for the November term of court. She faces charges of murdering her father and stepmother.
The Grenada Sentinel · 10 September 1892 · page 2
ter. Lizzie Borden, after the examination at Fall River. Mass , was held for the November term of court for the murder of her father anil stepmother. Nelson, the stallion, trotted a mile
Dr. John Abbott of Fall River states that both bodies were still warm when he saw them shortly after discovery, with no sign that one had been dead much longer than the other. He theorizes Mr. Borden was killed first and Mrs. Borden was struck down afterward while fleeing upstairs toward a window.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Grenada Sentinel · 10 September 1892 · page 2
naoustjr. Taunton, Mass., Sept. 3. —Dr. John Abbott, of Fall River, knew something about the condition of the bodies of Mr. and Mrs Borden before he went west, but, as he was away before any suspicion was directed toward Lizzie, he had expressed no opinion. Now he says he saw the bodies a short time after they were discovered hy the daughter and viewed by the police and both were warm. Thera was not the slightest indication that one had been dead over an hour before the other. In fact, it is his opinion that Mr.
See moreSee less
Borden was kilted first and that Mrs. Borden was followed up stain hy the murderer and stricken down at she woe running to the window to call for assistance. It was the blow on the back, affect ing the spine, that caused death, ho thinks, and the head blows were given afterward to make sure. Senator Mills Nmdlsg Rett. 8an Antonio, Tex., Sept 5.— Senator Roger Q. Mills is here en route to fill an appointment at Laredo. In an inter view Senator Mills complained of being completely broken down physically, and said he would have to give up act ive political work and take ■ rest For this purpose he has canceled his ap pointments at Brownwood, Dublin, Eastland, Weatherford, Decatur and Gainesville, and has declined all Invita tions to speak in the north. Col. Mills ssld, with reference to the guberna torial fight between Clark find Hogg, that It was a fight for the democrat* to settle among themselves. DUE TO DIRT. a A rolohrated Mniu flWlWM «"• Ik. UrMtMl rmMUn. Mr nick, Sept 5. —Prof. flchwenniger, one of the mokt celebrated doctor* In •ary Berlin end physician in ordinary to New Prince Bismarck, in a talk upon the subject of cholera. says: "The plogne this year follows the march of the great epidemics. It attacks Europe by the north and not by the south. It wa* bound, then, to reach Hamburg, since the authorities of Russia In Europe took no steps to stop it The English officials in India took proper precau tionary measures. "There ought to be an International hygienic commission established. That is the way to kill the cholera. It must be stamped out on the spot Other measures are useless. I do not umjer stand the complaints made against the authorities at Hamburg. Nobody knows exactly when disease become* epidemic in certain European capitals Although for some montlts there hare been daily cases of cholera thedoetors did not say it was epidemic. Why, then, president should the physicians of Hamburg hare cried 'All is lost' when they had only ten cases? Almost all the measures taken at the moment when the epidemic broke out were illusory. When you are disinfecting a room with plenic acid throw it only in the place where the in valid is. it is not likely that the bac cilli will be propagated after the disin fection. "One of the first things is to make a city thoroughly wholesome. People ought to be made more careful in a city like Hamburg, where all kinds of refuse and filth are thrown into the water and where sewerage does not exist. About 30,000 persons dwell in cellars and live on fish. An epidemic in such cases is inevitable and it is almost impossible to prevent it running through Ger many. "It is only in healthy places, clean towns and among the well nourished that the malady will amount to little. In that case there may be a few cholera cases, but not thousands, as in Ham burg. If you become ill drink as hot as ever you can grog, camomile tea, no matter what, provided it is hot. ' Then it vour limbs grow cold plunge into a steaming hot bath. Should these pro duce no effect then put yourself in the hands of (Jod, for those are the only remedies known to be efficacious. "The doctors can do nothing. But don't be afraid of cholera. Those only arc afraid who lire in dirty towns and who have not tried to ameliorate the stationed. condition of the cholera. Having neg lected what they ought to have done they have prepared the way for epi demics."
A short item states that Lizzie Borden was sent to jail because she could not say who killed her father and stepmother. It notes the case has drawn more public interest than any Northern murder trial since the Almy-Warden case.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Magnolia Gazette · 10 September 1892 · page 2
Mias Lizzie Borden was sent to Jail because she couldn't tell who killed her father and step mother. No murder trial iu the North since the Altny-Warden tragedy 1ms creattd so much interest. Six miles north of Greenville on Capt. Hunt's plantation, is one ot the largest Indian tnonuds in the United States. It has an area on its top measuring !M)xl30 feet; is 50 feet high and the circnmfer euce of its base is 800 feet. it is uufortnnate for the Farm ers' Alliance to be rcgardetl us the "People's" party.
See moreSee less
The order has nothing to do with politics, and it it it did, the Ocala aud not the St. Louis demands, would be its plat form, or "some thing better." The worse than brutal prize lights in New Otleaus and else where, should be stopped by tu1 1 of Congress if nothing short of that will stop them* They do no good, but a great d<»al of harm and
A general-interest Boston correspondence column touches on various topics including journalism, art gifts to the Boston Museum, and briefly references 'the recent hearing in the Borden murder case.' The passage cuts off before elaborating on the Borden matter itself.
Narragansett Herald · 10 September 1892 · page 8
BOSTON LETTER
University by the late Dr. W. M. Randall. The Borden Case. The recent hearing in the Borden murder case of course has been a fruitful theme here, as no doubt it has all over the country. Whatever may have been the “suspicions” of the prosecution, the holding of Lizzie Borden for the grand jury was an act for which the evidence adduced by the state did not furnish the slightest pretext, and the ordeal to which she was subjected wasa most trying and unjust one in every sense of those terms.
See moreSee less
It seemed to be the deter mination of the officers of the law to find a victim—the murderer if possibl!e—but some one in any event. Whether Lizzie Borden is guilty or innocent has nothing to do with the case as it now stands, as there was noth ing proved wh ch incriminated her in any way, and until such proof is produced she is entitled to her freedom the same as any other person. I should hate very much, in common with humanity evervwhere, to believe that a woman brought up under such refining domestic infiuences as Miss Borden seems to have been could by any freak, or throuzh momentary aberration, even, commit such a horrible crime as she 1s aecused of. The theory of the prosecution seems to have been entirely at variance with both law and common sense, for, insiead of trying to find the real murderer, they bave seized upoa the nearest person at hand, and have thrown upon her and ber counsel the onus probandi in order to establish her in nocence. This is a queer precedent for a court to estabhsh, and altogether a dan gerous one. The consensus of public opinion is clearly and in most instances emphatically oppoeed to the course pursued in this re markable case, and righteously so. Courts in this eountry are not supposed to be scar let chambers, and if there was anything by which Lizzie Borden could be held for the grand jury the accused and the people are entitled to know it. There seems to be al together too much Poobahism in the lower courts, and in such cases as this the serious part of itis that its victims have no redress:
A Boston correspondent argues that Lizzie Borden's recent preliminary hearing was unjust, claiming the prosecution lacked sufficient evidence to hold her for the grand jury. He contends public opinion largely opposes the court's handling of the case and criticizes the reversal of the burden of proof onto the defense.
The Woman's Christian Temperance Union in Boston publicly expressed sympathy for Lizzie Borden. Mrs. Fessenden reportedly made a passionate plea on her behalf.
Martinsburg Herald · 10 September 1892 · page 1
ditching of a freight train on the new branch || of the Geneva aud Buffalo branch of the Le* » u.uitj imiii vau i-aujua lucuvavuui LUVJ '. ; engineer, and the serious injury of other ! train men.-The W. (’. T. U. in Boston ex [ pressed sympathy for Miss Lizzie Borden. Mrs. Fessenden made a passionate plea iu her behalf.-An extra stock train ran into j a coal train on the Pennsylvania Railroad, near South Fork Both engines were
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
The article discusses a rumored application to the governor to have Lizzie Borden admitted to bail, stating it is unlikely to succeed. It explains that the governor has no power over criminal prosecutions, which are controlled by the district attorney and courts, and notes there is no known precedent for bail in such murder cases.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 12 September 1892 · page 1
No Bail for Lizzie Borden
any results, produc Competent law f avernor has nô \ owef years say that tho in the promises, ho law puts criminal A prosecutions wholly into control of the district attorney, subject to the ad vice and direction of the attorney*«»» ' d the action of the courts. There . known precedent for theadmission j charged with murder | to bail of ix;r under these circumstances, but it r _ bo safely assumed that Lizzie Borden will be fairly d considerately dealt with, Siole a Tray of Diamonds. Lincoln, Neb., Sept.
See moreSee less
12. —About 9 o'clock, when the streets were crowded, a fairly well dressed young man, a stranger who has been attending the races and losing, smashed the heavy plate glass window of Hallet's jewelry store with a stone, grabbed a tray of diamond rings valued at $1,100 and sped up an alley. A clerk and an office Started in pursuit, but the robber out distanced them. Several shots were fired by the fugitive and the policeman, but none of them took effect, and the man escaped with his booty.
Writer Kate Field remarks that the Borden murder case grows more mysterious, calling Lizzie Borden an extraordinary figure whether guilty or innocent. She notes that if guilty, the timeline would require two murders an hour apart, too long to support an insanity defense, and praises Borden's stoic New England temperament.
Wood River Times · 12 September 1892 · page 3
Lizzie Borden's Stoicism. In her Washington Kate Field says that the Borden murder case becomes more and more mysterious and full of r-guilty, tragic interest. Innocent the heroine of the tale is one of the most extraordt ary women in the his tory of all criminal trials. It is ini possihlo to say which hypothesis pre scuts her in tlio most rema. kable light—the theory that she is guilty or the one that she is innocent. In the first case it would necessitate the com mission of two climes separated bv an .......... . interval of an hour ° r more—too ong to Dermit the probability of insane
A filler item describes a Fall River woman shopping in Boston whose mention of knowing Lizzie Borden caused a stir among store clerks. The anecdote, mixed among unrelated items on politics and the Sullivan-Corbett fight, illustrates how widely known and talked-about Borden had become.
The Providence News · 12 September 1892 · page 4
“She lwnenlly well thousht of.” Down weat the parcels which the sales woman was doing up and down she went to the other end of the counter, leaving her customer in bewilderment. ihe cause of her sudden departure was luickly learned. The womau wanted to inform her companions behind the counter of the customer from Fall River. “She knows Lizzie Borden. 'The - and the remainder of the conversation was lost. But the shovper from Fall River knew she was the subject of their coniub, for every index fluger down the aisie was
At a Boston temperance vesper service, Mrs. Susan Fessenden led an appeal on behalf of Lizzie Borden, arguing that her probable innocence was at least as great as her guilt. The assembly was presented with a petition urging the Governor of Massachusetts to release Borden on bail pending trial.
The Atlanta Constitution · 13 September 1892 · page 9
and courteous. WILL AI’UEAL FOR LIZZIE BORDEN, hoiiundl Express Approval of a Fetltlon for Release on Bail. Boston, Mass., September B.—lnscribed in golden letters on a crimson banner, which yes terday afternoon adorned the great organ in
Fall River police claim to have discovered that Lizzie Borden wrote a letter to a friend in Marion the day before the murders, containing the eerie line about having 'a very sharp axe' to chop wood with. The report states police are searching for the letter in Marion, with the story reportedly originating from a young lady who heard it read aloud.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Providence News · 13 September 1892 · page 7
"A VERY SHARP AXE."
Letter Said to t-l:v-o Been Written by Lizzie Borden, FALL RIVER, ‘Mass.,, Sept. 13.—The police have positively discovered that Lizzie Borden wrote a letter to a friend in Marion the day before the murder, and that this letter was the one which Mr. Borden posted at 9 o'clock on the morn ing of the tragedy. A strange sentence in the letter reads: “l am coming on very soon, and when I do come I amn going to cuop all the wood for you, becanse I have a very sharp axe to do it with.” This statement comes directly from police headquarters and was told to the
This article revisits the August 4 discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's mutilated bodies, describing the brutal wounds, the eerie calm of their final postures, and the puzzling lack of blood. It notes the absence of any apparent motive or known enemies, and that only Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden were on the premises at the time.
The Star · 14 September 1892 · page 7
HISTORY OF AN EXTRAORDINARY CASE
The double murder of Andrew J. Borden nod his wife at Fall River, Mala., on the 4th of August, culminntiuii M it did in the artest of his youngest Jnnjfh -sler, Lizzie Borden, has been one of the amost extraordinary and mysterious crim inal episodes of the centtry. The circumstances surrounding the as-.-sassination of Borden snd his wife, who itM Lizzie's stepmother, were such as to :atoiind these who would pounce, off hand, upon a motive. Borden was rich and pious, aged seventy-six years, a man whose probity was equal to his thrift, lie bad not led a public life, he had no known enemy who it could be conjee turcd would go to the extent ot killing 4iira, much less his wife, and when the mutilated bodies of the couple were dis--covertd, In their own house, shortly be fore noon on August 4, the police and the public ere utterly at a loss for a iruotive, and in the intense excitemeut hat overwhelmed the community they turned to are another in helpless aston ishment and horror.
See moreSee less
The body of Borden was found on a velvet sofa in tho parlor of the house. II is head had been literally hacked to ifiicces. There were seven long gashes on his face and skull, some of them an inch and half deep through the flesh .and bone. In tho ')jMre" bed chamber on the second floor was discovered the liody of Mrs. Borden, who was sixty seven years old. There was at first no .-sight of blood and the momentary sup position was that heart failure had oc cuired. Mrs. Borden was lying prone ou the floor on her face with her arras out stretched and the toes of her shoes ret ng on the carpet. On raising the body rfhere was seen a pool of blood, and an
St. Landry Democrat · Opelousas, La. · 22 October 1892
The Star · Reynoldsville, Pa. · and 1 other paper
This report describes the posture of both bodies, noting an absence of blood and no signs of struggle, suggesting the victims were killed unexpectedly. It also relays the initial story given to police, including the claim that Mrs. Borden left the house that morning after receiving a note summoning her to a sick friend.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Star · 14 September 1892 · page 7
tXir. BORDEN HOMESTEAD WHERE lamination disclosed tho fact that death bad been caused, as in the case of the husband, by reptated blows of some licavy sharp instrument on the face, neck and head. Id the case of both there was found a deep cut into the braio. A circumstance, which was not at once observed, but which whs afterward noticed and put down as a clue, was the remarkable absence of blood from the numerous woundi on both bodies. It -was as it the life current had been re garded and partly congealed from other causes before the murderous blows were truck.
See moreSee less
sens. ABBre d. sorbin, towx victim. A slight survey served to make it equally plain that the murders were both committed unexpectedly so far as the victims were concerned. Borden's body nvas reclining on the lounge, the legs were resting easily on the floor, the left arm lay on the hip, the right was folded across the breast, the eyes were closed nd the features were unmarked by any expression of surprise or apprehension. The attitude was one of repose. The 'features of Mrs. Borden were Dot drawn and there was absolutely no evidence: of a struggle. There were, so far as yet known, but two persons other than Borden and his wife on the premises when the murders were committed. These were Bridget .Sullivan, a domestic, and Lizzie Borden, he youngest of the two daughters. The older daughter was visiting in another town. The first alarm was given by Lizzie Borden, who ran out into the yard and called for help. A neighbor responded nd the police were telephoned for. When they arrived they were told the following story ; The elder daughter bad been visiting for some time in Fair Haven. ' At 8 o'clock that morning Mrs. Borden re ceived a note asking her to call on a friend who was ill. She left the bouse end shortly after her husband followed sad went to the bank, of which Le was director. Be returned about 10:30 t'glock tad reclined on the to fa la the
St. Landry Democrat · Opelousas, La. · 22 October 1892
Pleasantville Weekly Press · Pleasantville, N.J.
A brief local news note reports that a detective sent scissors and a needle from the Preston case, along with the hatchet examined in the Lizzie Borden case, to a Boston physician for analysis. The item is part of a miscellany column covering various local happenings.
Pleasantville Weekly Press · 14 September 1892 · page 4
. October, /iiircus I larrjl^^. 4* he cottage when vacated. m are ’" waut of a fl»e pair of ^^pand at the same time wish to get Jem cheap, go see Eli S. Steelman, 1905 tlantic avenue, Atlantic City. tf —Now that cooler weather has arrived jere is no necessity for going,bare footed bile F. Dunakin is offering bargains in oots and shoes at Red Men's Hall. —We are informed that the detective as sent the l’reston scissors and needle j Boston to the physician who examined he hatchet in the Lizzie Borden case.
This article recaps the August 4 murders of Andrew Borden and his wife Abby at their Fall River home, describing the gruesome wounds and the mystery surrounding a motive. It notes the arrest of daughter Lizzie Borden and the shock felt by police and the public given Borden's reputation and lack of known enemies.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Star · 14 September 1892 · page 7
THE BORDEN CASE. HISTORY OF AN EXTRAORDINARY DOUBLE TRAGEDY.
THE BORDEN CASE. HISTOnV OK AX KXTRAOKftl fsAUY DOUllLU TKAUKDY. "Tli Mnrdernf Mr. anil Mrs. norrien t 1 Mil Hiver, Man. Whr ftna plilon Attnchos to the Ar rested tilzzle llnrtlen. The double murder of Andrew J. Borden nod his wife at Fall River, Mala., on the 4th of August, culminntiuii M it did in the artest of his youngest Jnnjfh -sler, Lizzie Borden, has been one of the amost extraordinary and mysterious crim inal episodes of the centtry. The circumstances surrounding the as-.-sassination of Borden snd his wife, who itM Lizzie's stepmother, were such as to :atoiind these who would pounce, off hand, upon a motive.
See moreSee less
Borden was rich and pious, aged seventy-six years, a man whose probity was equal to his thrift, lie bad not led a public life, he had no known enemy who it could be conjee turcd would go to the extent ot killing 4iira, much less his wife, and when the mutilated bodies of the couple were dis--covertd, In their own house, shortly be fore noon on August 4, the police and the public ere utterly at a loss for a iruotive, and in the intense excitemeut hat overwhelmed the community they turned to are another in helpless aston ishment and horror. The body of Borden was found on a velvet sofa in tho parlor of the house. II is head had been literally hacked to ifiicces. There were seven long gashes on his face and skull, some of them an inch and half deep through the flesh .and bone. In tho ')jMre" bed chamber on the second floor was discovered the liody of Mrs. Borden, who was sixty seven years old. There was at first no .-sight of blood and the momentary sup position was that heart failure had oc cuired. Mrs. Borden was lying prone ou the floor on her face with her arras out stretched and the toes of her shoes ret ng on the carpet. On raising the body rfhere was seen a pool of blood, and an
This retrospective account recounts the August 4 killings of Andrew and Abby Borden in Fall River, describing the brutal wounds to Andrew's head found on the parlor sofa and the discovery of Abby's body upstairs. It notes the lack of apparent motive and the shock of the community before explaining why suspicion fell on daughter Lizzie Borden.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 14 September 1892 · page 2
THE BORDEN CASE. HISTORY OF AN EXTRAORDINARY DOUBLE TRAGEDY.
fcul in fronl o.f ber..Bho saw the mother against his happiness; and he ieI was Lizzie's stepmother, were such as to astound those who would pounce, offhand, upon a motive. Borden was rich and pious, aged seventy-sir years, a man whose probity was equal to his thrift. He bad not led a public life, he had no
This report describes finding Mrs. Borden's body with similar wounds to her husband, noting the odd lack of blood from the wounds initially. It also relays the household's account to police, including a note supposedly summoning Mrs. Borden to a sick friend's house that morning.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 14 September 1892 · page 2
THE EORDEN HOMESTEAD WHERE 1 examination disclosed the fact that death j had been caused, as iu the ease of the j " x J it - 1 nusDana, dv reptarea diows 01 some heavy sharp instrument on the face, neck i and bead. In the case of both there was i found a deep cut it\to the brain. A circumstance, which was not at once observed, but which was afterward noticed and put down as a clue, was the : remarkable absence of blood from the 1 numerous wounds on both bodies.
See moreSee less
It was as if the life current bad been rei tarded and partly congealed from other causes before the murderous blows were struck. A slight survey served to make it equally plain that the murders were both committed unexpectedly so far as the victims were concerned. Borden's body was reclining on the lounge, the legs were resting easily an the floor, the left arm lay on the hip, the right wa9 folded across the breast, the eyes were closed and the features were unmarked by any expression of surprise 01 apprehension. The attitude was one of repose. The features of Mrs. Borden were not drawn end there was absolutely no evidence of a struggle. There were, so far as yet known, but two persons other than Borden and his wife on the premises when the murders were committed. These were Bridget Sullivan, a domestic, and L;zzie Borden, the youngest of the two daughters. The older daughter was visiting in another town. The first alarm was given by Lizzie Borden, who ran out into the yard and called for help. A neighbor responded and -he police were telephoned for. When they arrived they were told the following story: The elder daughter had been visiting for gome time in Fair Haven. At 8
The report recounts the initial story given to police by Lizzie Borden and servant Bridget Sullivan about the morning's events, including a note supposedly summoning Mrs. Borden away and Lizzie's account of finding her father dead. It also describes the subsequent police search that found a bloodstained hatchet, bloody rags under a cellar bucket, and blood spots on a skirt in Lizzie's closet.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 14 September 1892 · page 2
fcul in fronl o.f ber..Bho saw the mother against his happiness; and he ieI ? ?V?A Avna/tforl OArtn fA tt liSUJU^ CAUUI SlUU OUC CApcUbWU owwu wv make to Marion to join some Sundayschool friends who were already sojourning there. While in the bam. she heard a cry of distress coming apparently from the house. Rushing in, she found her father dead on the sofa. She called Bridget and they gave an alarm. Then they searched upstairs for Mrs. Borden and found her as described. The door of the spare room, the police were told, was closed. Such was the story as related to the police by Lizzie Borden and the servant. onH it fnrm"cV>pr? nn pIiipq nn tn work.
A short news item reports that there is no likelihood of Lizzie Borden being released on bail. It appears amid a roundup of unrelated national news briefs.
The Times · 14 September 1892 · page 4
NEWS NOTES OF INTEREST
govern all the rest of the needed restric. assailant shall be properly punished by | | Borden being released on bal. been held, is very significant. In Ver tions. The tax which it is proposed to ro. the law than that we shall turn all our eal s fo itself unconstitutional. It is uot mont, the majority given for Harrison young men into prize-ring bullies. The avied for revenue but for prohibition, and Completed ~“pocifications for the Labor and Material--The Site,
The St. Johns Herald · St. Johns, Arizona Territory Ariz.
A short item reports that the latest theory circulating at Fall River suggests Lizzie Borden, held for the murder of her father and stepmother, may be insane. The claim is presented as speculation rather than established fact.
The St. Johns Herald · 15 September 1892 · page 2
Homestead, Penn. It is estimated that 50,000 acres of wheat in North Dakota were de stroyed by the recent hailstorms. The latest theory advanced at Fall River is that Lizzie Borden,
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Fall River police say they have found a clue in one of Lizzie Borden's letters that may help them locate the weapon used in the murders. The letter reportedly shows Lizzie promising to cut wood with her 'very sharp hatchet' while planning a trip to a cottage in Marion.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 15 September 1892 · page 1
Looking 1« Lizzie's Ax. Fall River, Mass., Sept. 15.—Tlie police are at work upon n clew found in »f Lizzie Borden's letters that they think will enable them to find the with which tho Borden murders were committed. In making arrangements to occupy a cottage at Marion with a party of friends Lizzie promised to con tribute her part of the work b •utting the wood with her "very sharp hatchet." The Monetary Confer Vienna, Sept. 15.—It is ■ !
Reports state that Lizzie Borden allegedly tried three times to purchase prussic acid the day before the murders. Professor Wood testified he found no poison in the victims' stomachs and no blood on the hatchets recovered from the house.
Ellsworth American · 15 September 1892 · page 1
— In the Borden murder trial testimony showed that Miss Lizzie Borden had tried to get prussic acid three times the day be fore the tragedy.
A dispatch from Fall River reports that Judge Blaisdell ruled the evidence against Lizzie Borden strong enough to warrant sending her to jail to await trial at the November term. Arguments in the case had concluded the prior Thursday.
The Redwood Gazette · 15 September 1892 · page 7
Lizzie Borden Held. FALL RIVER, Mass., Sept. 2.—Argu ments in the Borden murder case were completed on Thursday, and Judge Blaisdell decided that the evidence of the guilt of Lizzie Borden was strong enough to warrant him in ordering the accused to be sent to jail to await trial at the November term. Bobbed a Corner Stone* HUITTISGTOS, Ind., Sept. &—Some thief pried the corner stone from under the White church near this city Wednes day night and stole therefrom all tly^ money, relics and Bible that had been deposited there when the church was built twentv-nine years ago.
The report notes that the latest theory circulating in Fall River suggests Lizzie Borden, held for the murder of her father and stepmother, may be insane. This is presented as one of many brief national news items in a general digest column.
Marble Hill Press · 15 September 1892 · page 3
River is that Lizzie Borden, held for the murder of her father and stepmother, is insane. The new Telegraphers' Brotherhood being orgrnized at Kansas City will not
The Women's Christian Temperance Union of Massachusetts has petitioned Governor Russell to release Lizzie Borden on bail while she awaits grand jury action scheduled for November. This brief item appears amid a roundup of unrelated national and international news items.
Iuka Reporter · 15 September 1892 · page 2
BY WIRE AND BY CABLE
At San Francisco, Cal., Ohttrles T. Tiiompson, secretary of the1 People’s Building society of St. Paul}, Minn., who absconded with $10^000 six months ago, has been arrested. The Women’s Christian Temtperance Union of Massachusetts have addressed an appeal to Governor Busspll to re lease Lizzie Borden on bail, {pending
Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D. · and 3 other papers
Lizzie Borden has been ordered to stand trial before the grand jury on charges of murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, Massachusetts. The brief item appears amid a roundup of general domestic news items.
Reporter and Farmer · 15 September 1892 · page 2
GENERAL DOMESTIC NEWS. The cholera scare is seriously affect ing eastern stock and produce mar kets. The souvenir spoon fad has been succeeded by a craze for collecting souvenir dolls. John G. Whittier, the great Amer ican poet, passed peacefully away on the 7 tli inst. McAulilfe defeated Meyer in a fifteen round prize fight at New Orleans Monday night in the presence of 6,500 people. The old Academy of Music, of Cleveland, one of the most famous theaters in America, has been de stroyed by lire. Miss Lizzie Borden has been bound
Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D. · 15 September 1892
The Herald-Advance · Milbank, S.D. · 16 September 1892
The Sully County Watchman · Clifton, S.D. · 17 September 1892
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
Isaac L. Borden, uncle of Lizzie Borden, states to reporters that he believes she committed the murders and that the grand jury will indict her. He speculates she may have worn a rubber cloak to avoid bloodstains and suggests a possible motive involving her father's will, while also predicting a jury could not convict her on the evidence so far.
The Indianapolis Journal · 16 September 1892 · page 2
River, an nncle of Lizzie Borden, said to day: "I believe Lizzie Borden is guilty of the crime for which iho bai been held by tbo coroner's jury, and I also believe the grand jury will indict her. I have fol lowed the case from the beginning, and have eome to the conclusion that the only living person who had tho opportunity to kill the old people was Lizzie Borden." When asked how he explained the ab sence of blood stains on Lizzie's clothes, Mr. Borden said: "That is easily accounted
A satirical newspaper column criticizes the Woman's Christian Temperance Union for seeking Lizzie Borden's release from jail while simultaneously objecting to a nude statue planned for the World's Fair. The piece mocks the perceived inconsistency of the WCTU's moral priorities.
Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 16 September 1892 · page 2
Toe Vf. 0. T. U. seem to be out to revolutionize the world and are taking a crack at creation. Lost week it petitioned that Lizzie Borden, who is held
An effort is being made to get the governor of Massachusetts to release Lizzie Borden on bail. Lawyers say the governor has no authority to act on such a request.
The McCook Tribune · 16 September 1892 · page 2
NEWS IN A NUTSHELL.
Lizzie Borden on bail. Competent lawyers say that the governor cannot act.The .The purchase of the Emmet villa near Albany , N. Y. , by Senator Hill is
At the preliminary hearing in Fall River, defense attorney Jennings argued the state failed to prove opportunity for the crime, while District Attorney Knowlton laid out circumstantial evidence pointing to inheritance as motive. Judge Blaisdell ruled Lizzie Borden probably guilty and held her for the grand jury, despite the murder weapon and bloody dress never being found.
Fisherman & Farmer · 16 September 1892 · page 3
PROBABLY GUILTY.
Grand Jury. Mr. A. J. Jennings, counsel for the de fendant, commenced his argument at 10:30 and closed at 11:05. He contended that the State had failed to prove that there existed an opportunity for the prisoner to commit the crime, and that it based iti case on merely the inconsistencies in the story told by Lizzie Borden of her whereabouts on the morning Gf the murder. District Attorney H. M. Knowlton fol lowed. His argument was a masterly sum ming up of the evidence. His language was simple, and he forged around the accused a solid Cham of cir cumstantial evidence.
See moreSee less
He said the motive that caused Lr'zzie Borden to kill her parents was her anxiety to inherit the property, and he declared that she, and she alone, did the deed. The hacking butchery was not the work of a man. It was the work cf a woman who knew not when she had completed her work. The hatchet hai not been found, neither was the bloody dress which she wore, but the evidence was so strong that aside from these things the Court must find that she is probably guilty. When District-Attorney Knowlton had finished his summing up for the prosecution Judge Biaisdell said: "Sympathy should be laid aside, and duty, stern duty, re quires upon this evidence that but one thing be done. Supposing that a man was seen in the cham ber of Mrs. Borden, the guest chamber of death, and that he was in the room of the father when death came; suppose that a man should tell as many different stories as Lizzie Borden had done, the way would be plain. I find that she is probably guilty.'1 When Lizzie Borden was pronounced prob ably guilty, hundreds of people gave way to tears, and the scene in the courtroom wa3 truly affecting. She was committed to Taunton Jail with out bail to await the action of the Grand Jury.
At the close of the preliminary hearing, District Attorney Knowlton argued a circumstantial case built on inconsistencies in Lizzie Borden's account of her whereabouts, citing financial motive despite the missing hatchet and bloody dress. Judge Blaisdell ruled her 'probably guilty' and ordered her held without bail at Taunton Jail pending grand jury action.
A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden is unlikely to be released on bail. It appears within a roundup of miscellaneous national news stories.
The Penn's Grove Record · 16 September 1892 · page 1
THE NEWS OF A WEEK
There Is no likelihood of Miss lizzie Borden being released on ball. After October 1, Mies Liberty, or the New York harbor, will support a 14300 search light. Elliott Burris, a defaulting cloth commission man of New York, has been round in Paris and will compro mise with creditors. Linda Myer and Annie MllleF were arrested in Reading, Pa., charged with passing spurious silver dollara. James Healey was murdered ou the road near Ashvtlle, Cambria county. Pa. His body was found badly muti
Isaac L. Borden, an uncle of Lizzie Borden, tells reporters in Utica that he believes she is guilty of the murders for which the Coroner's jury held her. He states he expects the Grand Jury will indict her, having followed the case since the beginning.
The World · 16 September 1892 · page 1
SAYS LIZZIE IS GUILTY
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Atchison Blade · Atchison, Kan.
A roundup of trivial Kansas news items and jokes includes a quip that Lizzie Borden apparently has no cousins in Kansas, calling this an 'ominous circumstance' in her case. The item is a humorous aside embedded among unrelated local filler items about crops, weather, and small-town life.
The Atchison Blade · 17 September 1892 · page 2
Lizzie Borden doesn’t seem to have any cousins in Kansas. This is one of the most ominous circumstances in connection with her case. The sectional line is still closely drawn on the watermelons in Kansas.
The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands
After a week-long preliminary examination in Fall River, Massachusetts, Lizzie Borden was judged 'probably guilty' of murdering her father and mother and committed to await grand jury action. She was to be transferred to Taunton jail and held until the first Monday in November.
The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 19 September 1892 · page 4
Lizzie Borden Held. Fall River (Mass.), September 1 At the conclusion this afternoon of the preliminary examination, which had lasted a full week, Lizzie A. Bor den was adjudged "probably guilty" of the murder of her father and mother and committed for tho action of the Grand Jury. She will betaken to the Taunton jail to-morrow. When there she will have to stay until the first Monday in November.
Local papers report that Lizzie Borden's father had been house-hunting and that she was not in financial need, undercutting a prosecution motive theory. They also claim she has cried privately, contradicting the district attorney's portrayal of her as emotionally cold.
Evening Journal · 20 September 1892 · page 5
Lizzie Borden's Case. Fall River, Mass., Sept. 20.—The papers here publish a story which has given much satisfaction to the friends of Miss Lizzie A. Borden. It is shown that her father had lieen looking (or some time for a new housa for bis daughters, also that Lizzie was not greatly in need of money. Instead of being an impassive woman, os represented by the district attorney, it is said that several times she has given way to tears, though never in public.
Local Fall River papers report that Lizzie Borden's father had been looking for a new house for her and that she was not short of money. The piece also claims that, contrary to the impassive image portrayed by District Attorney Knowlton, she has shown emotion in private, though never in public.
The Portland Daily Press · 20 September 1892 · page 1
Is She Without Peeling. Fall River, Mass., September 19.— A story published in tonight's local papers has given cause for much satis faction among the friends of Miss Lizzie A. Borden. It is shown that her father had been looking for some time for a new house for his daughter, and also that she was not greatly stinted in money matters. Instead of being the impassive woman represented b,y District Attorney Knowiton, it is said that she has several tives given way to tears, although never in public. _L Bcrkman, the Anarchist,; who shot Manager Frick, of the Carnegie Steel Works, has been sentenced to 21 years in the penitentiary
The Globe reports that prosecutors plan to show Lizzie Borden twice traveled to Providence before the murders, first to consult a lawyer about her father's property disposition and later to receive further legal information. This is presented as new evidence suggesting a financial motive for the killings.
Morning Journal and Courier · 21 September 1892 · page 3
Have Consalted a Lawyer A boat Her Father. Batata. Fall River, Mass., Sept 20. The Globe will state to-night that the state ia ready to prove that six months before the murders Lizzie Borden went to Providence by way of New Bedford and consulted a prominent lawyer as to the possible disposition of her father's property In the event of his death, and more particularly aa to its disposition as affecting her. Two weeks before the murder she again went to Providence via Hew Bedford and received all the informa tion the lawyer oould give her.
See moreSee less
Then she went to several stores in Providence and made purchases, directing that the goods do snipped to her home. The pouoe are in possession of the shipping tags. On the last day of tbe preliminary hearing the lawyer was in the district court room face to face with the prisoner, and the recogni tion was mutual. These facta are oon strued to mean that the state has another olue as to the motive for the crime.
The Fall River Globe reports that six months before the murders, Lizzie Borden allegedly consulted a Providence lawyer about how her father's property would be disposed of upon his death, and returned two weeks before the murders for further advice. The lawyer reportedly recognized her at the preliminary hearing and planned to testify against her.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Evening Journal · 21 September 1892 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
THE BORDEN MURDERS.
New Evidence That the Prosecution Will Introduce Against Lizzie.
See moreSee less
FALL RIVER, Mass., Sept. 21.—The Globe publishes an array of facts bearing on the Borden case, of which the following is a summary: The state is ready to prove that six months before the murders Lizzie Borden went to Providence by way of New Bedford, and there consulted with a lawyer as to the possible disposition of her father's property in the event of his death, and more particularly as to its disposition as affecting her. This man is one of the best known lawyers in Rhode Island and has held several political offices.
He asked Miss Borden where she lived. When she said Fall River he told her he would not be able to give her an answer at once, but if she would call again later he would have looked up Massachusetts' law and would be able to advise her. Two weeks before the murder she again went to Providence via New Bedford and received all the information the lawyer could give her. Then she went to several stores in Providence and made purchases, directing that they be shipped to her home. The police are in possession of shipping tags showing that Miss Borden was in Providence on the day indicated.
When the story of the murders was published the lawyer recalled his client of two weeks previous. On the last day of the preliminary hearing he was in the district courtroom and stood face to face with the prisoner. Recognition was mutual, and the lawyer determined then to go on the witness stand and testify as to the interviews when the proper time arrived. These facts are construed to mean that the state has discovered another link in bolstering up their construction of a motive for the crimes.
The Globe reports that six months before the murders, Lizzie Borden allegedly traveled to Providence to consult a prominent Rhode Island lawyer about her father's property disposition. The lawyer reportedly recognized her at the preliminary hearing and is said to be prepared to testify about this motive-related conversation.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
New-York Tribune · 21 September 1892 · page 1
ANOTHER CLEW IN THE BORDEN CASE
A KENTUCKY EDITOR MURDERED. Somerset, Ky., Sept 20. Joseph DB. Nueler, the Editor of “The Somerset Reporte ® was foul'y mur dered here last night at 8 o'clock while on his way home. Indications point to ex-Chief of Police 1. LC. having had numer Anderson as the murderer, they Anderson was Chief of Poltes for ous quarrels, when he re three yea s previous to two mont’ s ago, signed to engage in the Uquor business, against the advice and counsel of Rucker. Anderson s hat wa round fifty feet from where the fatal shots were supposed to have been knocked of fired, where It 1s by a clothesline In his hurry to gt away from the scene.
See moreSee less
Knowing it would be identified, Anderson concluded to escapn. Telegrams have been sent to coveral plac s to intercept him. He was a'so Tax Collector for this dty. Rucker Jeaves a widow and four children. Anderson leaves a wife and baby. —— pe — ANOTHER (LEW IN THE BORDEN CASE. Fall River, Mass, Septe 20. “The Globe” will publish an array of facts bearing on the Borden cass The to-night, of which the following 1s a summary: stats 1s ready to prove that six months b fore the murders Lizzie Borden went to Providence by way of New-Pedford, and there consulted with a liwyer a to the possible dispofition of Ler father’s property La ease of his death, and more particularly as to Its disposition as afiecting her. This man is one of tie pest known lawyers In Rhode Is'and. Every el! rt was made to get dim to come to this eity and iden 1fy the girl. On the last day of the preliminary heath 7 he was In the Listrict Court rom, and stood face to tare with the prisoner. The r1e€ gnition was mu We, and the lawyer determined then ty gy on the w.tiess cand and testify to the interviews when the proper time arr.ved, These facts are construed to mean thot the State has another clew as to the motive for the crime, Et en——— ——
The report claims Lizzie Borden consulted a Providence lawyer twice, once six months and once two weeks before the murders, about her father's estate and its disposition affecting her. It states police have a shipping tag proving she was in Providence on the relevant date and that the lawyer recalled her as a client after the murders were reported.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 21 September 1892 · page 3
there will be trouble. Jehn A. Den ham, the magistrate In the district Is attending the county court of claims at this place. A warrant was culled for Tuesday evening and Issued by Deuham at this place. LIZZIE BORDEN. Seme New und Damusliiff Kvlilenee ARiiliMt the (llrl. Fall Uivkh, Mass., Sept 21. The state is ready te prove that six months before the murders Lizzie Berden went te Providence, by way of New Bed ford, and there consulted a lawyer as te the possible disposition of her father's property in the event of his death, and mere particularly as te its disposition as affecting her.
See moreSee less
T his man is one of the best known lawyers in Rhede Island and has held several political offices. He obtained all of the information that she oeuld give him about a suppositious ease, and then asked her where she lived. When she said Fall River lie told her he would net be able te give her un answer at once, but that if she would call upon him later he would have looked up the Massachusetts law, and would be nble te advise 'her. Twe weeks before the murder she again went te Providence, via Bedford, and re ceived all the Information the lawyer could give her. Then she went te several stores in Providence and made some purchases, directing that they tc shipped te her home. The police are in posses-sien of a shipping tag showing that Miss Berden was In Providence en the day indicated. When the story of the murders was published the lawyer
The report notes that friends of Lizzie Borden were pleased with a Fall River evening paper's account defending her character, claiming her father had been generously seeking a new house for his daughters and was not stingy. It also states that, contrary to District Attorney Knowlton's portrayal of her as unfeeling, Lizzie had shed tears privately during the ordeal.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 21 September 1892 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Fall River Globe reports that the state plans to prove Lizzie Borden consulted a prominent Rhode Island lawyer in Providence twice before the murders, once six months prior and again two weeks before, regarding disposition of her father's estate. Prosecutors reportedly see this as evidence of a premeditated motive, with the lawyer recognizing her at the preliminary hearing and agreeing to testify.
The Portland Daily Press · 21 September 1892 · page 2
Against Lizzie Borden. Fall River, Mass., September 20.— Tlie Globe says this afternoon that the state is ready to prove that six months before the murders, Lizzie Borden went
The Fall River Globe reports that several weeks before the murders, Lizzie Borden consulted a Providence lawyer about the disposition of her father's property in case of his death. The report states this lawyer will testify at the trial.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 21 September 1892 · page 4
Evidence Against Lizzie. Fall River. Mass., Sept. 20.— The Globe this evening prints statements that Lizzie Borden, several weeks be fore the murders, consulted a Provi dence lawyer as to disposition of her father's property, in tlie event of his death. Tiie lawjwt wiU give evidence at lUe irnu.
The Globe reports that prosecutors have found evidence Lizzie Borden secretly consulted a Providence lawyer twice before the murders about how her father's property would be divided after his death. The report claims a shipping tag and a witness in the lawyer's office corroborate her visits, suggesting premeditation.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Pittsburg Dispatch · 21 September 1892 · page 1
Fall River, Mass., Sept 20. The Globe will publish an array of facts bearing on the Borden case to-night It will say that the State is ready to prove that six months before the murders Lizzie Borden went to Providence by way of New Bedford and there consulted with a lawyer about the possible disposition of her father's property
At a Fall River District Court hearing, defense attorney Jennings argued the State failed to prove opportunity for the crime, while District Attorney Knowlton built a case on circumstantial evidence and motive (inheritance). Judge Blaisdell ruled Borden probably guilty and bound her over for the Grand Jury.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 21 September 1892 · page 2
guilty and held her for the action of the Grand Jury. Mr. A. J. Jennings, counsel for the defendant mmmonra? hh (trmmimt At 10:39 I and closed at 11:05. He contended that the State had failed to prove that there existed an opportunity for the prisoner to commit the crime, and that it based its c^se on merely the inconsistencies in the story told by Lizzie Borden of her whereabouts on the morning of the murder.
Judge Blaisdell ruled that the evidence showed Lizzie Borden was probably guilty of the murders, citing her shifting accounts of events. She was ordered held without bail at Taunton Jail to await action by the Grand Jury.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 21 September 1892 · page 2
PROBABLY GUILTY
hio mmminff nn for th? nrosecution UUiflUQU UW BU?M..|.MQ - Mr? ? Judge Blalsdell said: "Sympathy should be laid aside, and duty, 6tern duty, re quires upon this evidence that but one thing be done. Supposing that a man was seen in the chamber of Mrs. Borden, the guest chamber of death, and that ha was in the room of the father when death came; suppose that a man should tell as many different stories as Lizzie Borden bad done, the way would be plain. I find that she is probably guilty."
See moreSee less
When Lizzie Borden was pronounced probably guilty, hundreds of people gave way to tears, and the scene in tne courtroom was truly affecting. She was committed to Taunton Jail with out bail to await the action of the Grand Jury.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The Fall River Globe reports that several weeks before the murders, Lizzie Borden consulted a Providence lawyer regarding the disposition of her father's property in the event of his death. The lawyer is expected to testify about this at the trial.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 21 September 1892 · page 6
New Evidence In The Borden Case
and the aheriff will ace ttiat no harm befalls them. y?w Kvldtoee la the BorJen Cm*. Fall River, Mis*., Sept. 20.?The Globf will tbia evening print autcmenta tn the efleet that Lizzie Borden several weeks before the murders consulted a Providence lawyer iu to the diipoiitlon of her lather's property in tho ovent of
Lizzie Borden's lawyers forcefully deny a report from the Fall River Globe claiming she consulted a Providence lawyer about estate distribution two weeks before her father's murder. They call the story a complete fabrication.
New-York Tribune · 22 September 1892 · page 7
he caught in Mrs, Deacon’s apartments in the Hotel Splendige, at Cannes. 4 DENIAL IN THE BORDEN CASE. Boston, Sept. 21 (Special) ~“The Journal” will say to-morrow morning: “Lizzie Borden's lawyers deny fn the most positive terms that there is any truth in the sory sent out hy “The Fall River Globe,” to the effect that Miss Borden consulted a lawyer Ww» Providence, ahout two weeks before her father's mur der, a3 to the probable distribution of the estate in the event of her father's death without a will, The story is pronounced a pure fabrication.”
The Fall River Globe reports that six months before the murders, Lizzie Borden consulted a Providence attorney about what she would inherit if her father died. The lawyer later recognized her at the inquest and will testify against her at trial.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 22 September 1892 · page 1
Mehr Beweise gegen Lizzie Borden
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Lizzie Borden's counsel, Andrew Jennings and Colonel Adams, denied a Fall River Globe report claiming she had consulted a Providence attorney about her father's estate before the murders. They called the story false and criticized newspapers for running ahead of the prosecution's case.
Pawtucket Tribune · 22 September 1892 · page 3
THEY SAY IT I 3 UNTRUI. Lizzie Borden's Counsel Speak of the Fall River Newspaper Story. BoSTON, Sept. 22.—Says The Post: An drew J. Jennings, the I"all River lawyer with whom Colonel Adams Is nssociated
Boston attorneys for Lizzie Borden deny a previous report that she consulted a lawyer in Providence or elsewhere about disposing of family property. The denial refutes claims about her legal dealings following the murders.
San Antonio Daily Light · 22 September 1892 · page 1
She Denies the Story. Boston, Mass., Sept. 22.—Lizzie Borden’s attorneys deny the report that she consulted a lawyer in Provi dence or anywhere else, concerning the disposition of the family property.
Fall River police insist that earlier reports of Lizzie Borden consulting a Providence lawyer about dividing her father's estate are substantially correct, despite denials and press criticism. Local papers name Lycurgus Sales as the lawyer allegedly consulted, though it remains uncertain whether he could be compelled to testify.
Morning Journal and Courier · 23 September 1892 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
THE STORY RE-AFFIRMED. The Police Say That Lizzie Borden Did Consult a Lawyer About the Division of Her Father's Estate. FALL RIVER, Mass., Sept. 22.—Despite positive denials of the Providence lawyer episode in the Lizzie Borden case, also the severe criticism made by local and out-of-town papers, the police authorities say tonight that the statements already published are substantially correct. They cannot account for the leak of a party of the investigation by the officers and the city marshal has said that he will deal severely with the person who gave out the information, should he be found.
See moreSee less
There is much doubt here as to whether the lawyer consulted by Miss Borden can be called to testify. It is currently rumored and was published in the local papers tonight that Lycurgus Sales was the lawyer consulted.
A brief dispatch reports that Lizzie Borden's attorneys deny claims she ever consulted a lawyer in Providence or elsewhere about disposing of her father's property. The item appears among a list of unrelated telegraphic news briefs.
The Indianapolis Journal · 23 September 1892 · page 3
TELEGRAPHIC BREVITIES.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Lizzie Borden's attorneys issued a denial stating she never consulted a lawyer in Providence or elsewhere regarding the disposition of her father's property. The brief item refutes an earlier circulating rumor about her legal consultations.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 23 September 1892 · page 12
Three Immigrants were killed In a rail road wreck on the Burlington Railroad near Sibley, la. The track slipped and threw tho train down an embankment. Thomas Bentlev, a sparmaker, has left Halifax for tho Paclflo coast, where he will load a large boat with Oregon pine masts for Nova Scotia the first importation of that kind. Lizzie Borden's attorneys deny the re port that she ever consulted a lawyer in Providence or anywhere else concerning the disposition of tho property of her father. After a week's wild debauch. TTamirt Beckwitb, the only heir to his father's es Cass Citv. Mich.. tate oi ncany si,uuu, ouo, at
Despite earlier denials, Fall River police now say published reports that Lizzie Borden consulted a Providence lawyer are substantially correct. Doubt remains over whether the lawyer, reportedly Lycurgus Bayles, can be compelled to testify.
Pawtucket Tribune · 23 September 1892 · page 1
POLICE ADMIT 17. Further Evidence That Lizzie Borden Dl4 Consult & Providence Lawyes FALL RIVER, Mass., Bept £23.~Despits positive denl:sla o(l 0};0 Providence lawyn episode in the Lizzie rde'peug severe criticlsms made by local J‘:fl
Isaac L. Borden, uncle of Lizzie Borden, states publicly that he believes she is guilty of the murders for which the Coroner's jury held her. He predicts the Grand Jury will indict her, reasoning that she was the only person with opportunity to kill the elder Bordens.
The World · 23 September 1892 · page 7
Girl, Believes She Is the Murderess. Utica, Sept. 15.—Isaac L. Borden, of Fall River, an uncle of Lizzie Bor den. said to-day : , “ I believe Lizzie Borden is guilty ot the crime for which she has been held by the Coroner’s jury, and I also be lieve the Grand Jury will indict her. I have followed the case from the be ginning. and have come the conclusion that the only living person who had the opportunity to kill the old people was Lizzie Borden.”
Lawyer Lycurgus Sayles of Providence denies reports that Lizzie Borden had consulted him about how her father's estate would be distributed if he died. He states he never spoke with Lizzie Borden and was not even in Fall River during the preliminary hearing.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 24 September 1892 · page 1
Providence, R. I., Sep. 24 Lycurgus Sayles, said to be the lawyer to whom Lizzie Borden is alleged to have applied for information as to the distribution of her father's estate in the event of his death, says that there is not a word of truth in the story so far as he was con cerned; that he never saw Lizzie Borden to talk with, and that he was not in Fall River during the preliminary hearing. Ho Canadian Copyright. Ottawa, Sep. 24. The imperial author ities confirm the Canadian Government in declining copyright to citizens of the United States, as the Canadian statute confers that right only upon a country having a copyright treaty -with Great Britain.
The report recounts the killing of Andrew Borden and his wife in Fall River, Massachusetts, noting that no one in the house heard anything and that the murderer left no trace despite presumably being bloodied. It states the motive appeared to be robbery and that three men have been arrested on suspicion.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Washington Bee · 24 September 1892 · page 2
children 15cente. u by Columbus 400 years ago, followed by the war vessels. Parades, illumin ations and banquets followed. A Mjstrlou Murder. .Andrew J. Borden, the millionaire
Isaac L. Borden, an uncle of Lizzie Borden, gave an interview in Utica stating that he believed his niece was guilty of the murders. The statement was reported as one of several unrelated news briefs from around the country.
The Washington Bee · 24 September 1892 · page 2
TELEGRAPHIC BRIEFS.
It is sated that the deaths from chol era throughout Europe have been 250.00C it lea--., of which about 300,000 have been in Russia. Isaac L. Borden, of Fall River, ar uncle oT.' Lizzie Borden, in an interview t Ut'..a. said he believed his niece wai guilty of the crimes. The authorities of the Catholic Churci
The editorial questions the leaked story that Lizzie Borden had consulted a Providence lawyer about her father's property in case of his death, suggesting it originated from officials or detectives building the case. It condemns such leaks as improper, arguing officials should gather evidence but not prejudice public opinion before trial.
The Portland Daily Press · 24 September 1892 · page 4
against her, it shows that some of these people do not have a correct conception of their duty. It is undoubtedly the business of officers of the law to gather all the evidence they can bearing cn the case, but it is not their duty, but an ou * rageous transgression of their duty, to lay it before the public, before it is sifted by a competent tribunal. It is not the business of the officials to convict Miss Borden, their business is to see as far as
Providence attorney Lycurgus Gayle denies the rumor that Lizzie Borden consulted him about how her father's estate would be distributed in the event of his death. He states he never spoke with Lizzie Borden and was not even in Fall River during the preliminary hearing.
The Evening Herald · 24 September 1892 · page 3
Lawyer guyle. Denlen the Stury. Providence, R, I., Sep. 24. Lycurgus Eayles, said to bo tho luwyer to whom Lizzie Borden is alleged to bavo applied lor liuorniuHou asio iuu uistrimttlon of her fathers estnto iu tlio event of bis death, says that there Is not a word of truth iu tho ntory so fnr as he was con cerued; that be uover baw Lizzie Borden to talk with, uud that be wns not in Fall IJiver during tho preliminary hoarlng.
Mary A. Livermore writes an open letter describing the harsh conditions of Lizzie Borden's confinement in Taunton Jail, including lack of light, no outdoor exercise, and limited visits with her sister Emma. The letter argues Borden is being treated worse than convicted criminals despite no proof of guilt being presented.
The Providence News · 24 September 1892 · page 1
IN HER PRISON CELL
may not set her foot out doors on the green earth in God's lunllfht. dhe is treated more severely than criminals con vieted of crime, and up to the preseat moment she is only suspected of crime, and not a particle of proof of her Bflm has been brouihz forward, Judge is dell to the contrary, notwithstanding, Lizzie Borden is magnanimously allowed the privilege of an interview with her one sister three times a week,
A lawyer previously cited as the source for claims that Lizzie Borden was inquiring into the disposition of her father's estate has denied the story absolutely. The denial contradicts an earlier circulated report about her motives.
San Antonio Daily Light · 24 September 1892 · page 1
The lawyer quoted as authority for the report against Lizzie Borden, iu that she was enquiring Into the dis position of her father’s estate, denies the story absolutely.
A Providence lawyer named Lycurgus Sailes denies rumors that Lizzie Borden consulted him about her father's estate distribution. He states he never met or spoke with her and was not in Fall River during the preliminary hearing.
Wheeling Register · 24 September 1892 · page 1
Does Not Kuow Lizzie Borden. Providence, R. I., September 33.—Ly curgus Sailes, said to he the lawyer to whom l.izzie Borden is alleged to have ap plied for informaiion as to the distribution of her father's estate iu the event of his death, said to-day that there was not a word of truth in the story so far as he was concerned: that he never saw Lizzie Bor den to talk wi:h, and he was not in r all River during the preliminary hearing.
Fall River police stated that despite denials and media criticism about the 'Providence lawyer episode' in the Lizzie Borden case, their earlier published statements remain substantially correct. The report notes ongoing controversy between official claims and public skepticism.
Wheeling Register · 24 September 1892 · page 2
I Mack, book-keeper, and Frank W. Black, collector. The *raan arrested in Chicago is j M. C. Curtis, formerly assistant cashier. Say the statements are Correc". Fall Rivek, Mass., September 23 — Despite poaitive denials of the Providence lawyer episode in the Lizzie Borden case, also* the severe criticisms made by local aud out-of-town papers the police authorL ties sav to-night that the statement al ready published are substantially correct.
A Providence lawyer named Lycurgus Sayles denied reports that Lizzie Borden had consulted him about how her father's estate would be distributed in the event of his death. He stated there was no truth to the story as far as he was concerned.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 25 September 1892 · page 18
Another Lizzie Borden Story Spoiled. Peottdence, B. L, Sept 24. Lycnrgut Sayles, said to be the lawyer to whom Lizzie Borden is alleged io have applied for in formation as to the distribution of her
The report states that the story claiming Lizzie Borden consulted a Providence lawyer before her parents' deaths, regarding disposition of her father's property, was traced to an offhand remark in a barber shop or livery stable as relayed to a private detective. The paper dismisses the rumor as not worth printing.
The Providence News · 26 September 1892 · page 12
‘h story that Lizzie Borden con ultec & PROVIDENCE lawyer before her ‘father and mother were killed, relative _;\, the disposition that would be made of Mr. Borden's property if he were to ; g, has been traced to a remark made by somebody in a barber shop or a ‘livery stable as reported to a private detec We mnever considered the A worth printing.
This report debunks an earlier story claiming Lizzie Borden had consulted a Providence lawyer about her father's estate before the murders. Two different lawyers were named in the rumor, and both denied ever meeting or being consulted by her.
Pawtucket Tribune · 27 September 1892 · page 1
A LUCID EXPLANATION
was Lycugus Sayles, whose office is on Collego stroet, ilr. eaylu promptly de pled to a reporter that he know h[l’su Bor den, had ever becn consulted by her or that he was in Fall River during the pre. Hminary examination of the acoused. Bunday another Providence lawyer was designated as the one Miss Borden had talked with, but he had already denfed the story, Monday morning the gentleman
A man explains how a rumor spread that Lizzie Borden had consulted him about her father's estate, after someone overheard him mention the Borden name was familiar to him. He insists he never said she was his client or that she had ever been in his office, and was not even in Fall River during her first trial.
Pawtucket Tribune · 27 September 1892 · page 1
A LUCID EXPLANATION
knowledgel. The assurance to the people of the Main street. a stagtling marder, or the newspapors publish anything of importance about a person, some one instantly recalls the name of that Jmmn in connection with something antedating the latter incldent, I remember that 1 pead of the Borden murder, and that onoe in & barber shop aud ogadn fu w stable in this city | sald that the Bordou vame was familiar to me, partioularly that of Andrew J, Borden. 1 dould nos recall that ldzzie Borden had been to sce me, but I had the
Miss Moore recounts how a man posing as a top detective discredited local officers Weedon and Boardman and claimed to have worked on the Lizzie Borden case. The story reveals he was actually an impostor reporter, exploiting the public fascination with the ongoing Borden investigation.
Evening Star · 28 September 1892 · page 6
else l, eonnection with the colonel's suicide. After expatiating at length upon his wonder ful %kill he told me never again to speak to either Detectives Weedon or Boardamn.because tIe% were absolutely no good as detectives. He said they had secnred their appointments' through influence and not through merit and were unn corthy a moment's consideration even in a cans of the slightest importance. He said further that Boardman and Weedon and Wheeler were mixing this affair up so thoroughly th'at no man less skilled than he woud ever be able to bring out the facts.
See moreSee less
Wh.n he had cautioned me at great length about talking to the local officers he told me he would be my friend and pro ceede-l at once to relate the experiences he rad he had In the Lizzie Borden case. on which he siated he had been engaged for some time past. I really believed his stories, but I found out this morning that he as a reporter, but not on Tau irAn. Those who know of his shameful conduct have expressed themselves with considerable warmth. My father is here now and he will otect me. If it is possible we will ae this fellow arrested for impervnating an officer. I understand that he
The report disputes Mrs. Livermore's account of Lizzie Borden suffering in jail, quoting Sheriff Wright who says the jail is heated by steam and Borden is not mistreated. It describes her cell, her access to sunlight, and her reluctance to go outdoors despite claims she is denied the privilege.
The Providence News · 28 September 1892 · page 1
MISS BORDEN WELL TREATED.
;ni::’ol( in regard to the matter he r u - The charge that Miss Borden “sits shivering in the chillness of her temp - rary tomb wrapped iu shawls for com fort,” will not stand the light of investi gation. Taunton jail is heated by steam throughout and every portion of it is kept alan even temperature the year round. “Lizzie Borden is not allowed the privi lege of exerciso in the opeu air,” wrote Mrs. Livermore, The strongest yoke of oxen in Bristol county would be necessary to drag Lizzie into the open air just pow.
See moreSee less
She shuns everybody but those whom she knows. Her cell is whitewashed, but iv isn't, strictly speaking, a comfortless one, any more than are hundreds of similar cells all over the commonwealth. Lizzie Bor den can sit in the sun all day, it she so chooses, for the women's wing of 'hjail
Sheriff Wright disputes Mrs. Livermore's published claims that Lizzie Borden is cold, wrapped in shawls, and denied outdoor exercise in Taunton jail. He states the jail is steam-heated throughout, her cell gets morning sun, and she herself refuses to go outside.
The Providence News · 28 September 1892 · page 1
MISS BORDEN WELL TREATED.
everybody but those whom she knows. Her cell is whitewashed, but iv isn't, strictly speaking, a comfortless one, any more than are hundreds of similar cells all over the commonwealth. Lizzie Bor den can sit in the sun all day, it she so chooses, for the women's wing of 'hjail has the sun geerlng in at the windows from the time it rises until it sets, and when it first makes its app-arauce it looks directly into Lizzie Borden's cell,
Lizzie Borden's attorneys issued a denial that she ever consulted a lawyer in Providence or elsewhere about disposing of her father's property. The brief notice refutes an earlier circulating report.
Ceredo Advance · 28 September 1892 · page 2
Th<? Bt.ory D-nted. IkMTOR, sept. 88.—Lizzie Borden's attorneys deny the report that she ever consulted a lawyer in Providence or anywhere else concerning the dis|x> sition of the property of her father.
The report describes a mysterious 1891 robbery at the Borden house that was kept secret until after the murders, claiming police knew the thief's identity but Andrew Borden refused to press charges. It implies the thief may have been Lizzie herself, listing stolen items including money, watches, and a lock of hair in a pocketbook.
Evening Journal · 29 September 1892 · page 5
AGAINST LIZZIE BORDEN
ders, and That Her Father Knew It and Refurt«*<l to Proterutu the Ciirl. Fall HlVIsn, Mass., Sept. 29.—New light that will no doubt have un important Is-ur ing on the trial of I.lzzic Borden has been ihi-own upon the r.ii-l. n «.f tin ruunlcu-il 'ir and Mrs. Andrew J. Bor«len, which Jccurml on June 24, 1H»1. it will be rc mcmlm-isl that the facts of this robbery ha«l lx?en kept secret and were not brouglit to the ]>ublic notice until after the tnys terious murder of the old couple. Thepo Hélice, after a long investigation of tiie mat rer.
See moreSee less
wenperfectly satisfied that they could place the tiiii-f under arrest, but thin never Mscurred because, it is stated, Mr. Borden ieclined to press tiie ebargu. Mr. Borden reported the robbery on the Afternoon of the date mentioned. He said bis own room over tiie kitchen had been uttered and a desk used for his private pa pers broken open. From this desk luul la-ea taken eighty «iollars iu bills, thirty dollars in gold coin, a number of horse car tickuts for use by directorsof tlie.company, a lady's zolil watch, a lady's gold watch chain with tassel charm, a lady's pixketlsxik made of Russian leaf lier and some trinkets of more jr less value. All the articles except the money and tickets belonged to Mrs. Borden, and in the ' stolen pockettiook was aiock of hair, which the old lady dearly prized. The private papers of Mr. Borden were scattered about inside the desk, and some of them appeiircil to tiuvc liceii the subject of scrutiny liy tin thief. ■ No Tcares of u Burglar.
The report describes a prior theft from Andrew Borden's desk, including money, a watch, and a chain with a lock of hair prized by Mrs. Borden. Police investigated but never recovered the stolen items, and the case was quietly dropped at Mr. Borden's request after detectives told him something that astonished him.
Evening Journal · 29 September 1892 · page 5
searched. I An Important Link. I Finally the inspectors sent for Mr. Borden land told him that they could arrest the Ithiefat any time. They told Mr. Borden Isomething which astounded him, and the lease was dropjxxl very quietly at the old ■gentleman's reijuest. He told the poli«* ■authorities that he did not care about the I money or the watch, bat he wanted the I chain and lock of hair, because Mrs. Borden I prized t hem beyond all worth. The deteo I lives had worked very, secretly in the I matter.
See moreSee less
Newspaper men were kept in the I dark about the whole affair until the exeit I ing hours following the discovery of the I murdered old couple. Then the fact that a I mysterious roblx-ry had occurred was de I vcloped, but the police were loath to give I any information to the reporters. I Some of Mrs. Borden's friends, who be I came possessed of some facts regar«ling the I theft, made statements which were worked I on by the newsjmjier men. Chief Hilliard was seen in his office and told just what has Ixsmi written. He showed u great deal of surprise, and when questioned about the matter lie said: "I'm not ready to go into that matter yet. I must find if any one has been giving information from this department. Home of the statements are true; some are not. No, I will not talk about the matter." I The facts concerning this mysterious rob I Iiery, it is umlerstixxi, will be more thor I oughly elucidated at the trial, and are ex I jx-cted to form an important part of the I government's case.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
A speculative article argues Lizzie Borden may have stripped naked before the killings to avoid getting blood on her clothing, explaining the absence of bloody garments as evidence. It also dismisses the prussic acid purchase attempt as weak evidence, arguing any plan would have been made well before Wednesday.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 29 September 1892 · page 8
DID SHE STRIP TO STRIKE?
A. Curtis Bond lu n, y. Herald. The speculation among those who have looked at tho credible side of the Borden mystery is, not whether Lizzie Borden is guilty, hut how she com mitted tho crime and how she did i cleverly as to escape thus far absolute detection. Up to this time there has been Jlt tempt to show how the murder was done, but merely to demonstrate that no one other than Lizzie B uden was in a position to do it, and yet the strongest points that have, thus far been made against the girl are not strong at all when dissected, and tho ph alble ex phmatiou has been overlooked alto gather,
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
This report theorizes that Lizzie first planned poison but switched to an axe, stripping naked before killing her stepmother and father to avoid bloodstains. It cites her father's parsimony and restrictive control as motive, comparing her case to a prior axe-murder by Mrs. Druse.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 29 September 1892 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
DID SHE STRIP TO STRIKE?
One Presumption That Points to Lizzie Borden's Guilt.
See moreSee less
She May Have Removed Her Clothing and Thus Avoided All Suspicious Blood Stains While Perpetrating the Double Crime.
A. Curtis Bond in N. Y. Herald.
The speculation among those who have looked at the credible side of the Borden mystery is not whether Lizzie Borden is guilty, but how she committed the crime and how she did it so cleverly as to escape thus far absolute detection.
Up to this time there has been no attempt to show how the murder was done, but merely to demonstrate that no one other than Lizzie Borden was in a position to do it, and yet the strongest points that have thus far been made against the girl are not strong at all when dissected, and the plausible explanation has been overlooked altogether.
The importance attached to the attempted purchase of prussic acid is entirely misplaced, and if of any value whatsoever, has that value in clearing rather than in condemning Lizzie. The district attorney claims that Lizzie's first idea was to destroy her father and step-mother by poison, but when she discovered on Wednesday afternoon the impossibility of procuring the poison, she then changed her plans and resolved to use an axe.
This is incredible and impossible. Whoever did that murder arranged for it further ahead than from Wednesday afternoon to Thursday morning. If Lizzie did it, she had long before settled on the means with which to do it, the disposition to be made of her blood-stained clothing and the weapon used, so as to battle the closest search of shrewd officers. This required much more time than from Wednesday afternoon till Thursday morning at 9.30 o'clock to provide for.
PRECEDENTS.
The sentimental argument against a woman indulging in such butchery will not hold—we are dealing with an extraordinary woman. And even with the commonplace woman there are precedents to prove the instability of this sentiment. Mrs. Druse was hanged in New York state a few years ago for murdering her husband in precisely this same manner, Governor Hill declining to commute her sentence.
How, then, did Lizzie Borden kill her father and stepmother and what led to it?
That Mr. Borden deserved some such summary removal may be no excuse for the deed, but it furnishes a reason. His grinding parsimony and brutal selfishness had ruined the life of his two daughters, had deprived them of all opportunities for pleasure and had interfered forever with their chances of marriage. Lizzie Borden in all probability wished to enjoy life. She had seen Europe once; she realized what living is and what there was beyond the confines of Fall River. But her father was immovable; he could find no reason why she should have anything, see anything, do anything, other than what suited his narrow views. This unnecessary restraint finally so affected her, her mind became so fevered over its mental imprisonment, that she became irresponsible and sought relief by breaking down the iron selfishness that held her just as an every day prisoner would break down the stone walls that hold him.
That was the reason.
An having the reason Lizzie planned accordingly.
THE METHOD.
When Mrs. Borden went to the room that had been occupied by their guest the night before in order to make the bed and otherwise put it in order, Lizzie followed and proceeded to her own apartment, where she already had the axe selected for the deed. Reaching here she removed her clothing, even to her shoes and stockings, for it will be remembered Dr. Wood examined these latter with the same care he did her dress, seeking blood stains. Thus prepared she stepped noiselessly into the guest's room and struck Mrs. Borden on the head with the axe, felling her to the floor.
All the suppressed resentment against her stepmother's symathetic selfishness with her father that had helped to make Lizzie's life miserable then broke forth, and she buried the weapon again and again in the unresisting body that lay before her.
During this time she stood with her foot on either side of the body, as the physicians' evidence at the inquest showed was necessary in order that the blows be delivered as they were, and before the blood had coursed along the carpet sufficiently to stain her feet and thus leave footprints as she left the room she had concluded her work and withdrew.
THREW OUT THE WATER.
She then returned to her room, washed the spattering blood stains from her flesh, dressed again and went down stairs. According to the testimony of the neighbors and others familiar with the household arrangements there it was customary for the Bordens to throw their waste water on the grass, and the porous earth would quickly absorb the reddened basinful Lizzie had removed from her limbs and body.
It is a significant fact that whoever committed this deed, conceding that a doubt may exist in some minds as to the integrity of my conclusions, left no footprints behind when he or she stepped from the room whose floor was saturated with the life blood of Mrs. Borden.
When Mr. Borden entered and took his place upon the lounge it was no more difficult matter for Lizzie to disrobe a second time in the dining room or kitchen adjoining the parlor where her father lay, and repeat upon her father the deed that had already taken place above.
The weapon was then either dropped in a hole already prepared for its reception in the yard, the earth thrown back and a sod neatly placed above it, or else a loosened board was lifted in the floor, and there the axe rests to-day.
Accepting this solution of the mystery, Bridget Sullivan's puzzling evidence that Lizzie wore the same dress immediately after the murders that she did immediately before becomes less puzzling, and the strained explanation by the prosecution that Lizzie indulged in the folly of a duplicate dress of the same pattern becomes useless.
A Boston paper had claimed Lizzie Borden secretly consulted a Providence lawyer before her father's death about inheritance, supplying a motive for the murders. Investigation found the Providence lawyer denied ever meeting her or giving such advice, proving the entire story fabricated.
The Prison Mirror · 29 September 1892 · page 2
CRIMINAL SENSATIONALISM. The maimfacture of sensations is a business that some newspapers engage in regardless of the injury or wounds it may inflict. For the purpose of sensa tion purely, a Boston paper published a story to the effect that a short time prior to the murder of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, their daughter Lizzie, who is accused of the crime, visited a Provi dence lawyer and secured from him an opinion as to tbe course to pursue in case of death of her father in regard to the distribution of his property.
See moreSee less
This was told with great circumstantiality, with many details, one of which was, that the lady client of the Providence law’yer was somewhat mysterious, and at neither interview did she give her name or residence. After her arrest NEWS OF A WEEK, September 21. The telegraph operator* and train dispatchers on the 8., C. R. & N. railway strike for higher wages. Senator W. G. Ward dies at his home in Wa seca, Minn. He was a native of Oneida C 0.,. New York.
Lycurgus Davies, the lawyer Lizzie Borden allegedly consulted about her father's estate distribution, denied the story entirely. He stated he never spoke with Lizzie Borden and was not even in Fall River during the preliminary hearing.
Courier Democrat · 29 September 1892 · page 2
ciaiaia he struck the woman in ici .-lei'ense. tbe Whole Story. PMVCDE5CZ, E. I., Sept. -4.—Lycurgus navies. aa be She lawyer to whom Liz zie Soriea a aLeged to have applied to for intormatLon as to the distribution of her lather1s estate in the event ot hu death aaid tu-lay that there was net a word of troth in tee story so far as he was con cerned: that he never saw Lizzie Borden to talk with, and that he was not in Fall River daring ttie preliminary hearing.
Police reveal new details about a 1891 robbery at the Borden home that had been kept secret until after the murders. Andrew Borden had reported cash, gold coins, and his wife's jewelry stolen from his desk, but declined to press charges against a suspect police believed they could identify.
The Providence News · 29 September 1892 · page 6
THE BORDEN ROBBERY. Fall River Police Claim to Know Who Committed It. FACTS FOR LIZZIE'S TRIAL.
FALL Riveß, Sept. 20.—New light that will, no doubt, have an important bear ing on the trial of Lizzie Borden has been thrown upon the robbery of the murdered Mr. and Mprs. Andrew J. Borden, which oceurred on June 24, 1801, It will be re membered that the facts of this robbery had been kept secret and were not brought to the public notice until after the mysterious murder of the old couple. The police, after a long investigation of the matter, were perfectly satisfled that they could place the thiel under arrest, but this never occurred, because, it is stated, Mr, Borden declined to press the charge.
See moreSee less
Mr. Borden reported the robbery on the afternoon of the date mentioned. He said his own room over the kitchen had been entered and a desk used for his private
The report recounts an earlier burglary at the Borden home in which money, tickets, and a watch were stolen, along with a lock of hair Mrs. Borden treasured. Police investigated quietly at Andrew Borden's request and apparently identified a suspect, but the case was dropped and kept from reporters until after the murders brought it to light.
The Providence News · 29 September 1892 · page 6
FACTS FOR LIZZIE'S TRIAL
were searched, Fivaliy the Inspectors sent for Mr. Bor den aud told him that they couid airest the tuief at any time. They tola Mr, Bor den bomot.hluf whica astounded him, and the cass was dropped very quietly av the old geatleman’'s request. ide wold the volice anthorities tuat he d.d not care about the money or the watch, but he wanted the chain and lock of nair, be cause Mrs. Borden prized them beyond all worth. The detectives had worked very secretly in the mutter. Newspaper men were Kept in the dark abouv the whole affair until the exciting hours fol lowing the discovery of the murdercd oid couple.
See moreSee less
Then the fact that a mysterious robbery had occurred was developed, but the poiice were loath to give any inlorm atiou to the reporters, Some of Mrs. Borden's friends, who be came possessed of some facts regardiug the toeft, made statements which were worked ou by the uewspaper men. Couief Hilliard was seen in his odice. He showed a great deal of surprise and when ques tioned about the matter said: *l'm not
A report of a mysterious robbery connected to the Borden case emerged, but police, including Chief Hilliard, refused to confirm details to reporters. Separately, a man named Lycurgus Sayles wrote to Lizzie Borden's attorney denying newspaper claims that he had counseled her or attended her preliminary examination.
The Providence News · 29 September 1892 · page 6
newspapers in connection with your client, Miss orden, as hu\'mf at some time coun selled and advised with Ler about certain matters; and also, that | was present at her preliminary examination—l decsm it not only proper but my duty tosay to you that there 18 not one word of truth in it. I never have seen or et Miss Borden at any time or place, neither was 1 present at the preliminary ex amination. Respectrully yours, LYcunGaus SHYLES, PROVIDENCE, Sept. 20, 1802,
A year-old burglary at the Borden home, previously kept secret at Lizzie's request, is now said to hold new significance for the murder case. Police had identified a suspect but never arrested him because Mr. Borden declined to press charges.
Omaha Daily Bee · 30 September 1892 · page 5
ANOTHER BORDEN MYSTERY CLEW
Important 1-urt In the Trlul. NEW YOKK , Sept. 20. The Herald's Fa River , Mass. , correspondent says : Ne ! lo light whlcu will have an Important beann loot on tbo case of Lizzie Borden has been throw
The report describes an earlier burglary at the Borden home in which money and jewelry were stolen from Mr. Borden's private desk, with police investigating but the case mysteriously dropped at Mr. Borden's request after officers told him something that astounded him. The article states this mysterious robbery is expected to be elucidated at the murder trial as part of the government's case.
Omaha Daily Bee · 30 September 1892 · page 5
traces of the burglar. The officers reported what they had learned to Mr. Borden and later had a talk with Mrs. Borden , Llzjlo and Kmraa Borden and Bridget Sullivan. Finally the Inspector sent for Mr. Oordcn
The State says it will prove Lizzie Borden visited Providence twice before the murders—once six months prior and again two weeks before—to consult a lawyer about her father's property. After the murders were reported, the lawyer recalled meeting her shortly before the killings.
Fisherman & Farmer · 30 September 1892 · page 7
AGAINST LIZZIE BORDEN. The State Will Try to Prove a Sus picious Trip to Providence. The State is ready to prove, it is alleged, that six months before the Borden murders at Fall River, Mass., Lizzie Borden went to Providence by way of New Bedford and there consulted with a lawyer as to the pos sible disposition of her father's property. Two weeks before the murder she again went to Providence, and received all the in formation the lawyer ecu d give her. Ttten she went to several stores in Providence and made purchases. When the story of the murders was published the lawyer recalled his client of two weeks previous.
Lizzie Borden's attorneys deny a report claiming she had consulted a lawyer in Providence or elsewhere regarding the disposition of her father's property. The brief item appears amid unrelated news items in the paper.
Addressed the Veterans. MILLER, S. D., Special, Sept 23.—^The dis trict G. A. R. reunion at St.. Lawrence closed to-day. Sheldon, Republican can didate for governor, and Van Osdeil, the Independent candidate, spoke, She don highly acquitting himself. Capt. Kellogg of woonsocket was chosen commander. Next year's leunion will be held at Wes sington Springs, Jerauld county. Bremerhayen—Arrived: Spree from New York.' Geoa— Arrived: Fulda trom New York llrowhead—Passed: Britannic from New York Bevic from New York. Kinsale— Passed: Mlchiaan from Boston. ^ScHly—Passed: Kaiser Wllhelm trom New Lizard—Passed: Minneaota 'from Philadel phia.
See moreSee less
London—Arrived: Lydlan Monarch from New York. Philadelphia—Arrived: Pennsylvania Irom Antwerp, British Prince Irom Liverpool.- Llzard—signalled: Kussla fr-m Baltimore. Lizzie Borden's attorneys deny the report that she ever consulted a l.wyer in Providence or anywhere else concerning the disposition ot the property ol her fatber. A New Pipe Lias Gnmpsny. BRADFORD. Pa,, Sept. 22—Thenew Onited 8tates Pipe Line company is an anti-Stand ard corporation that.wilf revolutionise oil affairs in the near future, according to the' promises of its promoters. Its aim is to lay a pipe line4n a sliort tinie trom Bradford to the sea-board for the transler of oil irom the wells to the.Eastern and foreign mar kets. The enterprise has. been a pet scheme-' of oil producers for years. The new com pany has enlisted the aid of American and European capitalists. It' also prjtpOsfes tfc erect,immense refining plants, both in the'' oil Country Tind on tbe Ea-tern seaboard, and will endeavor to boldly meet the de mands of the company.