A double murder, and the family suspected
The day after the killings, a Fall River dispatch reports no weapon and no clue, and police drop a story about the Portuguese who ran the Borden farm. Suspicion rests on the family circle: John Morse, Mr. Borden’s brother-in-law by his first marriage, who had slept in the house the night before, and the daughter Lizzie, who found her father’s body. A week later it was Lizzie who was arrested.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 5 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
THE BORDEN MURDER
No Clue to the Slayers of the Aged Couple.
See moreSee less
A BROTHER-IN-LAW SUSPECTED.
The Weapon With Which the Millionaire and His Wife Were Mutilated Cannot Be Found--Mr. Borden Was Seen Five Minutes Before the Crime.
FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 5.--There is absolutely no clue to the murderer or murderers of Andrew J. Borden and his wife, who were found dead in their home on Second street yesterday, both frightfully mutilated about the head and face.
No implements that could have been used in the commission of the crime have been found.
Mr. Borden lay on a sofa in a room on the top floor of the house. His head had been cut, and gashes from four to six inches long were found on his face and neck.
Mrs Borden was in her own chamber on the upper floor, and the condition of her face and head was the same as that of her husband. She lay face down in the bed, which was a veritable pool of blood. The police were notified, and immediately an investigation was begun.
The daughter of the unfortunate couple was the first to make the discovery. She went up stairs after finding the body of her father, and saw that of her mother. She thought her mother had fallen in a swoon, but finding that she, too, was murdered, the girl fled down stairs and fainted.
The police have searched in vain for any clue to the murderer. They spent yesterday afternoon searching for a Portuguese who runs the Borden farm at Gardiner's Neck, and who, it was said, was in the house at 10:45 a. m., a few minutes before the bodies were discovered.
To-day the police say there is nothing in the Portuguese story.
It is reported that word was sent to Mrs. Borden in the morning that a sick friend desired to see her, but she did not go out. It is said that the servant, Bridget Sullivan, says she went into the room to make some inquiry of Mr. Borden five minutes before Lizzie Borden gave the alarm. He was then sitting on the sofa reading a newspaper.
Mr. Borden was a wealthy real estate owner and mill man, and was seen on the street half an hour before he was found dead.
Although the police have no clue, yet their suspicions rest upon persons who were in the family circle, particularly John M. Morse, brother-in-law of Mr. Borden by his first marriage; also on the daughter Lizzie, who first discovered the body of the father. John M. Morse is 55 years of age and came here from Hastings, Ia., two years ago. He became very intimate with Mr. Borden and the latter's daughter, and spent a great portion of his time with them. He came from New Bedford at noon Wednesday and spent the night at the Borden Homestead. He left there yesterday morning at 9 o'clock and was next seen on the premises about 20 minutes after the bodies were discovered.
The police say the only motive for murder was gain, else one of the victims might have been spared.
It has been decided to keep Morse under close surveillance until further developments. The murder has caused the greatest sensation here since the Granite mill fire.



