As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · As the Papers Told It

Act Seven

She Seeks Privacy

July – November 1893

Free, she went back to Second Street and then to a new house on French Street. Some members of her church said they would not fraternize with her, two confessions were reported and came to nothing, and the jokes began. By November a Montana paper found the murders unsolved and Lizzie Borden all but shut out of Fall River society.

Some at her church will shun her

A Fall River dispatch, passed from the Salt Lake Tribune to a Nevada weekly: three leading members of the Central Church say they ‘will not fraternize with Miss Lizzie Borden’ until the murders are avenged or explained, and it is said police may be needed to protect her from insults if she comes to church. When she did attend, later that month, the Evening World reported only a mild sensation.

Eureka Weekly Sentinel · Eureka, Nev.

Eureka Weekly Sentinel · 8 July 1893 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Will Not Fraternize With Lizzie. A dispatch from Fall River, Massachusetts, to the Salt Lake Tribune says: "Three of the most prominent members of the Central Church declare that they will not fraternize with Miss Lizzie Borden until the murderers of her father and stepmother are avenged, or at least explained. It is said that police protection will be required to guard Miss Lizzie Borden from threatened insults if she attempts to attend church."

See the clipping

Women asked about women jurors

An Indianapolis Journal item recalls that about the time of the trial a Boston paper canvassed Massachusetts women on the justice of trying women charged with crime before juries of men. Mrs. Ednah D. Cheney answered that no woman is tried by ‘her peers’ if men alone sit. The Journal disagreed, but held that if women served on juries at all they should serve on an equality with men.

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The Indianapolis Journal · 23 July 1893 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

WOMEN AS JURORS.

About the time of the Lizzie Borden trial a Boston paper made a canvass among Massachusetts women as to the justice of trying women charged with crime before juries composed of men. The point was made that this was a practical denial of a woman's right to be tried by a jury of her peers. Some of the Massachusetts women have caught at the idea. Mrs. Abby Morton Diaz, a writer of some note, favors the representation of women on the jury when a woman is to be tried, and Mrs. Ednah D. Cheney, also known in literary circles, says:

See moreSee less

No woman is tried for a criminal offense by "her peers" if men alone sit upon a jury, and in all cases of divorce or inheritance, and many others, the jury may well be supposed to be prejudiced by their peculiar relation to their own interests if they represent only one-half of the community. Nor does the exclusion of women from the jury always work for the injury of women alone. It sometimes defeats the purposes of justice by the sympathy excited for one, however guilty, who has not a fair chance to defend herself, and even in a civil suit the feeling is so strong that a woman is generally the party wronged that a jury of men often decide rather by their chivalrous feeling than by the evidence.

There is something of assumption in this. We doubt if there is a case on record of a jury of men being unduly influenced against a woman on account of her sex. It is a common opinion that women are apt to judge their own sex more harshly than men do. In divorce cases, especially, we think most lawyers would say that men's sympathies are generally with the woman.

In saying that "no woman is tried by a jury of her peers if men alone sit on the jury," Mrs. Cheney seems to rest under a misconception as to the meaning of the word "peers." Its legal sense is "an equal." Under our system a juror must be a citizen, voter and freeholder, and it can hardly be claimed that a man who fills these requirements is not in a legal sense the peer of a woman. Of course, the term "peer" does not refer to mental endowments or moral qualities.

There is no reason for placing women on juries in cases where women are to be tried that does not apply with equal force to cases where men are to be tried. If they are to be admitted to partial jury service they should be admitted to all and placed on an equality with men. In their natural capacity and equipment for jury service women are like men. Some would make good jurors while others would not. Many women are as capable of weighing evidence and reaching just conclusions as is any man, and many men are as apt to be swayed by prejudice or sympathy as is any woman.

See the clipping

Back in her church pew

The Evening World reports ‘a mild sensation’ at the morning service of the Central Congregational Church in Fall River: Lizzie Borden’s first appearance there since the murders. Charles J. Holmes was among those who escorted her to her pew, and the visiting preacher was a former minister and friend of the family. By November, a Helena paper heard, more than half her church friends did not welcome her.

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The Evening World · 24 July 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN GOES TO CHURCH.

Her First Appearance Makes a Mild Fall River Sensation.

See moreSee less

FALL RIVER, Mass., July 24.—There was a mild sensation at the morning service at the Central Congregational Church yesterday, created by the first appearance there of Miss Lizzie Borden since the tragic event at her home last August.

She was escorted to her pew by Dr. Bowen and Charles J. Holmes. Her appearance was a surprise to most of the congregation.

The pulpit was filled by Rev. Mr. Burnham, of Springfield, a former minister and friend of the Borden family.

See the clipping

A confession that never was

A Boston dispatch passes on a story from Taunton that Lizzie Borden has confessed to the murders and is locked up in Taunton jail. The paper admits it is unconfirmed: all that is known is that ‘the Borden sisters were in Taunton’ and visited the jail. The story was false; in September and November she was reported living freely in a new house on French Street, Fall River.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 27 July 1893 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

BORDEN CASE REVIVED.

A Story From Taunton That Lizzie Borden Has Confessed to the Murders.

See moreSee less

BOSTON, July 27.—A special from Taunton says that Lizzie Borden has confessed to the murder of her father and mother, and is now locked up in Taunton jail.

The story has not been confirmed. All that is known is that the Borden sisters were in Taunton to-day and visited the jail.

See the clipping

A hatchet for a gavel

A comic squib from the Springfield Graphic, reprinted in Olneyville, R.I.: New Bedford’s latest horror is a ‘Lizzie Borden club’ whose president uses a hatchet instead of a gavel and whose passwords are ‘Not guilty.’ Within weeks of the verdict, the case was already a subject for jokes.

The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I.

The Olneyville Times · 4 August 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A New England Horror. The latest horror in New Bedford is the "Lizzie Borden club." The president uses a hatchet instead of a gavel, and t[h]e passwords are "Not guilty."—Springfield Graphic.

See the clipping

A confession in a bottle

From Michigan comes word of a letter found in a bottle in the Kalamazoo River, signed Max O’Reilly. Its writer says he killed Mr. and Mrs. Borden, that ‘Lizzie Borden is innocent’, and that he meant to kill only Mr. Borden, for revenge, but was discovered by Mrs. Borden. He places the Bordens in New Bedford, where the trial was held, not in Fall River, where they died.

The Yellowstone Journal · Miles City, Mont.

The Yellowstone Journal · 26 August 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Another Borden Confession.

OTSEGO, Mich., Aug. 25.—Considerable excitement has been caused by the finding of a letter in a bottle in the Kalamazoo river by H. J. Ungnitsch at Pine creek, two miles west of here. In substance it is as fo.lows:

See moreSee less

"KALAMAZOO, Mich., Aug. 22, 1893.—A guilty conscience is that which makes m- write this letter. I am the man who killed Mr. and Mrs. Borden of New Bedford. Lizzie Borden is innocent. I only intended to kill Mr. Borden for revenge, but being discovered by Mrs. Borden was compelled to kill her.

MAX O'REILLY."

See the clipping

A new house on French Street

A long Sun piece takes up the Fall River gossip. The sisters, it says, simply do not believe in wearing mourning. They have moved to a modern house on French Street, and the old house is being made ready for tenants while sightseers still linger to stare at it. The jurors sent her their group photograph. ‘Lizzie bears up extremely well’, but Emma’s health is ‘far from robust’.

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The Sun · 24 September 1893 · page 21 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN'S NEW HOME.

SHE AND HER SISTER HAVE COME INTO THEIR MONEY.

See moreSee less

Neither One Has Put on Mourning Garments —Escape from Public Scrutiny During a Visit to Newport—Nerves of Steel.

If Lizzie Borden ever tried to live so as to satisfy her critics, she has given it up as a hopeless task. They found no end of fault with her as long as she lived in the old house on Second street, Fall River, where the murders were committed, and now that she has moved into another dwelling in a better part of the city they say that she has come into the money of her murdered parents and is making it fly. Among the sensational stuff that has been published about her recently is the news that she refuses to wear mourning and goes tearing through the streets in a buggy beside her sister Emma in a very light dress, while Emma dresses in deep mourning. The fact is that she has on two occasions hired a livery team and gone out for a ride, her own and only horse being busied by the work on the farm, beyond the city limits. She has, indeed, worn a light gown—one of her old ones that the detectives pulled over as they hung in the girls' closet in the old house after the murder. But Emma has not accompanied her in deep or any other kind of mourning, for the simple reason that neither of these original and interesting women believes in wearing mourning.

They never have worn mourning. They did not go to the burial of the elder Bordens in that attire. They did not wear mourning in court when Lizzie was tried for the murders. Lizzie wore a crêpe dress part of the time, but had a purple feather in her hat. The rest of the time she wore her black lace dress, with the same hat—but, according to the rulings of fashion, lace would not have been considered mourning, even had the hat been different. Miss Emma Borden has recently had a new dress made, the first notable purchase of the kind made by either of the women since the murder. Their neighbors watch them pretty closely, and know all that they do. This new gown is decidedly not mourning. The feminine readers of THE SUN will know what sort of a dress it is when they are told that the name of its stuff sounds like "shallee de lane." It is black with a green figure in it. The light gown that Lizzie is criticised for wearing is a light drab with blue threads in it. The neighbors—both the friendly and the unfriendly—say that the testimony at the murder trial created a false impression as to the way the Borden girls dressed. They never made any show, but always dressed very well indeed, in clothes of good material and plenty of them. They had their own means, in money and mill stocks, and they made good use of them, paying as high as $10 a yard for trimmings, each wearing silks, and each possessing an elegant sealskin jacket. Both always had their shoes made to order.

There is equal misconception, not as to how they lived, but as to the style of their home. The parlor was newly and stylishly furnished for the use of the young women, and the rest of the house was set with substantial but not new furniture. All through, the carpets were of the best. Any one may judge the style of the appointments from the fact that the girls have moved the material bodily into their new home in French street, on the hill. There will not be much to call the stepmother to mind in the new house, as Miss Emma gave all Mrs. Borden's things to that lady's sister, Mrs. Fish of Hartford. This is the elder sister. Mrs. Whitehead, the younger one, who lives in Fall River, is yet almost a girl, and would have found less use for them. But in the new house in the select residence part of the town the young women will live as they never were able to live in their old home, because their former home had practically none of the modern improvements. The old couple were satisfied without them, and the girls were far more anxious to leave that neighborhood of stores and tenements than to have the old house modernized. They moved into their new home, with its modern lighting and plumbing arrangements, two weeks ago last Thursday, and immediately the workmen whom they employed took possession of the old house and began to make it fit for rental.

It would scarcely be thought that any one would be found who would wish to live in that house of horrors, but the women have already had applicants for it and can easily keep it rented. They will only rent to persons suitable to the neighborhood, that is to say, satisfactory to their old neighbors with whom they lived twenty years. Those neighbors have had an unenviable time since the murders. There is never a day that sightseers do not linger around the old house, staring at it as if, by watching, they may be able to solve the mystery it once enveloped. Usually they stare at the right house, easily picking it out because of the barn behind it, but once in a while a man or a woman will stand for half a day studying the wrong house and the people who go in and out of it. The neighbors who own their homes do not criticise the Borden women for moving away. They would do so if they could. When they moved there the street was like a pretty residence street in Brooklyn, with blooming dooryards and tree-lined curbs. Now it is just such another street as Varick street in this city—a medley of business and tenement buildings. It turns out that the elder Bordens wanted to move away, and would have done so ere this had they lived. They waited for Mr. Borden to find just what he wanted in a better part of town. He had looked at the old Mason house on Main street and at one other. The other residents, of the older set, are remaining there in the belief that when business gets firmly intrenched in the street the property will fetch high prices.

It was rumored that the Borden sisters were going to turn their old home into a storehouse and office building, but it is more profitable to rent it as it is. Its recent history is of interest. Emma did not live alone there at any time. Her uncle Morse stayed some months and the hired woman and the farmer man afterward lived with her there. While her sister was in duress in Taunton Emma visited her during two days in every week. She never was as solitary there as Lizzie often was, for that young woman at one time made it a practice to stay alone in the big house while Mr. and Mrs. Borden and Emma spent the hottest weeks at the farm. This she did until Emma decided that it was not right and that she should remain with her. After that only the old folks went away. When Lizzie was discharged by the court and came back there to live she seemed to bear no grudges against those who had been obliged to testify during the trial. With the exception of Miss Russell, her old companion, all the old friends were taken up again. Miss Russell is the girl who told about the burning of the Bedford cord dress. She is much to be pitied, for she was rudely dealt with in the Massachusetts press at the time, although she only told the truth, and yet she suffered an agony of mind because she had not done so at first and because she feared she might harm her old friend. She was so nervous on the witness stand that, as she said afterward, she could not have told her own age if she had been asked.

One other incident in the old house was the visit of Bridget Sullivan, who was the family servant at the time of the murders. She called on the day that Lizzie reached home. It was a short call, and has never been repeated.

Very much that is utter nonsense has been published about the fortunes that the sisters have come into. The "fortune" of the stepmother consisted of about $1,700 in cash and half of a tenement of the value of, possibly, $2,000. This property the Borden girls gave to the sisters of their stepmother, Mrs. Fish and Mrs. Whitehead. It will be remembered that this tenement was referred to in the testimony at the murder trial. Mr. Borden had given the property to Mrs. Borden, and as it was apparently to the advantage of Mrs. Borden's relatives, the sisters were vexed with their father and his wife, but particularly her. It was after this that Lizzie ceased to address Mrs. Borden as "mother." Emma never had called her anything but Abby.

It is not true that the sisters of Mrs. Borden threatened to sue for more than has been given to them, or for any part of the estate. The method of the murderer of the old couple rid them of all title as heirs, because it was proven that Mrs. Borden was murdered first. Her property, therefore, went to his heirs, and, when he was murdered next, his property went to his daughters. Mrs. Borden's sisters had this explained to them, and had no intention to bring suit for a share in the estate. The gift to them of their dead sister's little belongings was an unforced kindness on the part of the Borden girls. They have taken their father's estate, which is commonly spoken of as of the value of $400,000. It is probably less than that, but is of a nature to increase greatly as time goes on. On Aug. 5 Emma Borden filed a petition with the Clerk of the Probate Court in Taunton and qualified, with a bond of $50,000, to act as administratrix of her father's estate. The bond filed with the court by Lawyer Wood, as administrator of Mrs. Borden's estate, was one of $500 only. Miss Emma Borden is now in control of the estate for her own benefit and that of her sister Lizzie. She has not yet filed a schedule of the properties which compose her trust, but must do so within a few weeks, and must thereafter report her operations as administratrix once a year. The cruel and gratuitous insinuation that there may have been a will, and that there was talk of forcing the sister into court again, in order to air this supposition, has no basis. If Mr. Borden had made a will, he would have kept it where he kept all his papers, in the vaults of the financial institutions with which he was connected. It was said that he was about to make his first will at the time he was murdered, but that was not brought out on the trial.

The new home of the Borden girls on French street is not on the best street in the town, but it is in a good neighborhood and near the most fashionable avenue. It was occupied by a man of means and good social position, who sold it because he wished to live where he could enjoy the fine prospect that is to be had from another point on the same hill. It has been said that the sisters paid $11,000 for the place, and that may be the fact, though the house scarcely warrants a belief that such was a true figure. French street is a modern thoroughfare, set with pretty villas, generally wooden, in open grounds with a showing of neat lawns, a few vases and flowers, and plenty of shade trees. The houses are small, and of the type of dwellings with which most of the smaller suburbs of this city are built up. The new Borden dwelling is a yellow and brown frame house, with a little pointed tower on one corner of the roof and a porch in front and partly on one side. The house might have cost $3,000 or $4,000 to build. It is not as fine as several neighboring cottages. It is said that the sisters employ only one servant, as they did in the old house down town.

Few of the overcurious ever get there to disturb the women with their staring, and, so far as that goes, the change is a delightful one for both of them. But it will be a long while before either of the sisters will be allowed to resume the privacy that others enjoy. Whenever they go shopping or to market they are stared at, watched, and followed. Lizzie got her first welcome respite from this constant, though unintentional, persecution when she went to Newport quite recently. There she stopped with old friends in a private house and remained unidentified by the townspeople. She walked on the famous cliff walk and about the old town, and even went to church, feeling such a sense of freedom as she had begun to believe must only be known to the birds. She had a less successful experience during a visit to the town of Warren. One of the Boston newspapers put her in a pother recently by establishing a most-popular-candidate contest, in which she led for a long time. Altogether she got something like 96,000 votes, and the editors—if that is what contest managers are called—notified her that she was about to win and would be entitled to a free ticket to the World's Fair. Her very able counsellor, Mr. A. J. Jennings, courteously requested the "editor" to give the prize to the next person on the list—but just then the friends of somebody else made a rush with their votes, and the prize went to their candidate. The jurors who acquitted Lizzie next had their pictures taken in an impressive group, and despatched the New Bedford juror with a copy of it to Miss Lizzie Borden, with their compliments, doubtless fancying that if she possessed a copy it would complete her happiness by enabling her to frame it and hang it in her sitting room as a constant reminder of an episode in her life which she might otherwise forget. Unfortunately she was out and could not personally thank the jury for its thoughtfulness. She has had a narrow escape from breaking her decision never to be interviewed. She made the decision as part of her plan to contribute nothing that would lengthen her notoriety or increase it. But soon after her return to Fall River a woman who had been kind to her in her trouble sent an interviewer to her with a written plea that he be given what he wanted. This was hard to refuse, but she kept firmly to her decision.

Lizzie bears up extremely well after her remarkable experience; indeed, she appears to be as well as she ever was, and stouter and better looking. The case is different with the older sister. The family affliction, the horrors of the murders, and the long strain during Lizzie's trial, were more than her nerves could endure, and she is nothing like the woman she was. Her health is far from robust, and she frequently has to give up, or, rather, to break down. Lizzie says that she made up her mind not to allow her troubles to get the better of her, and she has had will enough to remain proof against all that has happened. At the trial the lawyers on both sides declared her to be a most remarkable woman, and people generally are coming to the same conclusion.

See the clipping

Shunned, and the murders unsolved

In November the Helena Independent finds the murders ‘still shrouded in mystery’. Lizzie lives on French Street with Emma and a servant, not Bridget Sullivan, and two families have moved into the old house. She never visits Mrs. Churchill or Miss Russell, attends church irregularly, and ‘is practically ostracized’. The police tell a New York World correspondent that five people they know could clear up the mystery.

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

The Helena Independent · 21 November 1893 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

PURSUES A DARKENED PATHWAY.

Lizzie Borden's Life Clouded by the Shadow of Her Parents' Murder.

See moreSee less

The notorious Borden murders are still shrouded in mystery and continue to furnish a theme for conversation and speculation among the gossips of Fall River, Mass. Lizzie Borden, the younger daughter of the victims, the only known person who last saw her father alive, is living in a neat and comfortable home on French street, a mile or more from the scene of the tragedy and in the center of an aristocratic neighborhood. Her sister Emma and a servant—not Bridget Sullivan—live with her.

The interior of the old homestead has been remodeled, and two families have moved into it. One is that of A. C. Peckham, a grocer; the other that of L. L. Hall, a horse trader. The heads of the two families do business within two blocks of the gloomy house, and they smile derisively when their customers question them about ghosts.

MISS BORDEN'S NEW HOME.

Not since Lizzie Borden left her old home has she been near it. Mrs. Churchill and Miss Russell, her old time friends, still live in the vicinity, but she never visits them. She is practically ostracized, and when she appears on the streets she attracts no especial attention. She goes to church, but not regularly. Her presence is not welcomed by more than half her church friends, and after her occasional appearances it is not uncommon to hear many bitter statements regarding her. She has not taken up the church work she dropped many months ago, but one of her very few intimates recently said that she had expressed a wish that she might be enabled to enter into some of the work she "used to do before her pathway in life was darkened."

Her three firmest friends are the daughters of Charles J. Holmes and her sister Emma. They are very kind to her. Her new house is far more attractive than the one in which she formerly lived. Her reception room and parlor will compare favorably with those of any refined young woman, and the domestic facilities are as good as can be procured anywhere.

She recently visited the World's fair with Miss Caroline Borden, a maiden lady, who is much interested in her, though not a relative. She attracted little or no attention while on her way to and from the exhibition, and she told a friend on her return that she enjoyed every minute of her visit.

An inquiry at police headquarters by a New York World correspondent elicited the interesting information that five persons known to the police could clear up the mystery if they would tell the truth. Who these five persons are cannot be learned at present, but eventually they will speak if the police surmises are correct.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Six: Not Guilty