As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · As the Papers Told It

Act Three

A Cruel Hoax

October – November 1892

On 10 October the Boston Globe printed what it called the evidence of twenty witnesses, among them a story that her father had threatened to turn her out of the house. Within two days it apologized: a detective named McHenry had sold the story to its reporter for $500. In November the grand jury sat at Taunton, and one report said it would not indict her.

The Globe’s story of twenty witnesses

A telegraphed summary of the Boston Globe’s sensation of 10 October: twenty witnesses said to have sworn affidavits for the government. Callers overheard Mr. Borden threaten to turn Lizzie out unless she named the man who ‘got her into trouble’; Detective McHenry, hidden in a bath room, saw her kick Emma. Within two days the Globe apologized: McHenry had sold its reporter the story for $500.

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Evening Journal · 10 October 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

MORE BORDEN EVIDENCE

Many Witnesses Prepared to Give Startling Testimony.

See moreSee less

THE STATE'S CASE STRENGTHENED.

The Prosecution Possessed of Affidavits in Which Incriminating Actions on the Part of the Accused Are Charged—Other Evidence in Possession of the State.

[By Telegraph to the Evening Journal.]

BOSTON, Oct. 10.—The Globe this morning prints a dozen columns of the stories of twenty witnesses in the Borden murder case who have given affidavits to the government. Some of these stories are of a startling nature and are as follows:

Frank Burroughs, a well-known New York city lawyer will testify that eight months before the murder occurred Lizzie Borden consulted him about the disposition of property in the event of a step mother's death before that of her husband.

Mr. and Mrs. Frederick Chase and Mrs. Abigail Manchester will testify that on the night before the murder, while calling at the Borden house and before being announced, they had overheard Mr. Borden, in another room, threatening to turn Lizzie out of doors unless she would repeat the name of the man who "got her into trouble."

G. Romaine Pittston, a wealthy dealer in machinery supplies in New York, will testify that Mr. Borden detailed Lizzie's trouble to him and was advised to disinherit her unless she would reveal the man's name.

John H. Murphy, Mrs. Gustave F. Ronold, Peter Mahany and Augustus Guning will testify to having seen Lizzie Borden at a window, where and when she must have been standing over the dead body of her step mother at a time when her father was walking in the yard.

Mrs. George J. Simpson will testify that at the Borden funeral she overheard Lizzie asking Bridget Sullivan, the servant, how much money she wanted to keep quiet.

Private Detective McHenry will testify that lying concealed in a bath room he witnessed the quarrel in the matron's room tetween the sisters and that Lizzie kicked Emma thrice, called her a foul name, and said: "You wanted to see me hanged so you can come into the entire fortune. You are the one person whom I thought I could trust with my secret."

Mrs. Regan, the matron, and one other have deposed to the same effect.

The Globe promises to publish a certain piece of very important information recently gained by Officer Harrington, as soon as the interests of justice will not suffer by its publication.

See the clipping

The Globe apologizes and names its source

The Globe tenders Lizzie Borden its ‘heartfelt apology for the inhuman reflection upon her honor as a woman’, and apologizes to John V. Morse too. Detective McHenry admits he furnished the story and insists it is true; the reporter who signed it, Henry G. Trickey, says he paid McHenry $500. In December Trickey, who had fled to Canada, would die boarding a train.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 12 October 1892 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

APOLOGIZES TO LIZZIE BORDEN.

The Boston "Globe" Declares That It Was Greatly Deceived.

See moreSee less

BOSTON, Oct. 12.—The "Globe" publishes an editorial apology for its publication of the statement in the Borden case. It says:

"The 'Globe' feels it a plain duty, as an honest newspaper, to state that it has been grieviously misled in the Lizzie Borden case. It published on Monday a communication that it believed to be true evidence. Among all the impositions which newspapers have suffered, this was unparalleled in its astonishing completeness and its irresistible plausibility. Judging from what we have heard, it impressed our readers as strikingly as it did the 'Globe.' Some of this remarkably ingenious and cunningly contrived story is undoubtedly based on facts, as later developments will show.

"The 'Globe' believes, however, that much of it is false and never should have been published. The 'Globe,' having been misled, has innocently added to the terrible burdens of Miss Lizzie Borden. So far as it is in our power to repair wrong we are anxious to do so, and hereby tender her our heartfelt apology for the inhuman reflection upon her honor as a woman, and for any injustice the publication of Monday inflicted upon her.

"And the same sincere apology is tendered Mr. John V. Morse and any other persons to whom the publication did an injustice."

The "Globe" under a headline saying that the story had been proven wrong in some particulars, says:

"Detective E. G. McHenry furnished the 'Globe' with the Borden story published Monday morning. He admits it in an interview published herewith. He also asserts that the facts are true. He states that the names and residences of alleged witnesses were purposely given wrong for obvious reasons.

"The 'Globe,' in the course of its investigation into the details of the story, interviewed Dr. and Mrs. Bowen and Rev. Mr. Buck on the question of Lizzie Borden's physical condition at the time of the murder, the result of which was the conviction that in this respect at least Mr. McHenry was wrong. The story may be wrong in some other minor particulars, but the weight of evidence favors the main facts as true."

"And now for the purpose of ferreting out the murder in the Borden case the 'Globe' has engaged the best detective talent available."

A statement by Henry G. Trickey, the reporter who signed Monday's story, is appended and is to the effect that he paid detective McHenry $500 for the story and giving the details of the bargain.

See the clipping

A rival paper exposes the hoax

A Boston letter to the New-York Tribune spells out the most serious part of the Globe’s story: that Lizzie had been ‘unduly intimate with her uncle’, John Morse, and that her father demanded the name of her betrayer. A rival paper, the Journal, sent a man to Fall River and found it false in all its essentials. The Globe’s retraction ran three columns wide in its largest type.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

New-York Tribune · 12 October 1892 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

A CRUEL HOAX IN THE BORDEN CASE. Boston, Oct. 11 (Special).—Boston has been treated to a sensation of a peculiar character this week, growing out of the. Borden murder at Fall River. "The Boston Globe" published on Monday two pages of alleged evidence which it was said had been given before the coroner's inquest, andj which had not before been given to the public. The most serious part of "The Globe's" story was the allegation that Miss Borden had been unduly intimate with her uncle, John B. Morse, and that Mr.

See moreSee less

Borden demanded the name of her betrayer, under penalty of expulsion from her home. This and much more was furnished by a private detective of Fall River, and without proper investigation into its truthfulness, the paper purchased and published the terrible story. "The Journal" sent a man to Fall River on Monday and the entire story in all its essentials was shown to be false. This afternoon "The Globe" publishes in the largest type, three columns wide, a retraction. It says it has been grievously misled in the Lizzie Borden case, and so far as it lies in its power to repair the wrong, it is anxious to do so, and humbly apologizes to Mr. Morse and Lizzie Borden.

See the clipping

A Richmond suspect, a harmless storyteller

John Wood, jailed in Richmond on suspicion, has his hands examined because Andrew J. Jennings, Lizzie’s lawyer, asked that a scar be looked for. A Fall River telegram all but rules him out: he is Henry Hahr, a would-be actor who left the city in April; his landlady, Mrs. Cross, laughs that he would not kill a kitten; and Chief Hilliard is satisfied he was not in town.

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Richmond Dispatch · 20 October 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WOULDN'T KILL A CAT

THAT'S WHAT MRS. CROSS, OF FALL RIVER, SAYS ABOUT WOOD.

See moreSee less

He Is Not Thought to Have Had a Hand in the Borden Murder—Mr. Holmes's Visit to the Jail.

John Wood, who is in the Richmond jail, charged with suspicion of being implicated in the Borden murder, which was committed at Fall River, Mass., August 4th, was visited at his cell yesterday by Constables Branch and Fussell, of Henrico county, and Mr. J. C. Holmes, of Fall River. The latter gentleman was a member of the party of callers upon request of Andrew J. Jennings, Lizzie Borden's attorney.

He was in Washington, and was accompanying his wife to Norfolk, when he saw the newspaper accounts of Wood's arrest and wired Mr. Jennings. Mr. Holmes received a telegram from the lawyer instructing him to come at once to Richmond, and that he would receive further advice upon his arrival here at the Exchange Hotel.

Mr. Holmes was telegraphed by Mr. Jennings to use his discretion in the matter of getting information here concerning Wood, but to look carefully for a scar upon one of the prisoner's hands. Something was also said about a man named John Underwood, who at one time resided in Fall River, but it was not stated whether or not this party was a friend of Miss Borden.

MAY HAVE BEEN A SCAR.

When the prisoner was taken from his cell Mr. Holmes was hidden from view. The interrogating was done by Messrs. Branch and Fussell, and Sergeant Epps examined the hands of Wood. Upon one hand a deep dimple which, it appeared, could possibly have been made by a pistol-shot was observed, but nothing more. The accused would say nothing more than has already been published in the DISPATCH as an interview with him. The result of the investigation amounted to very little, and it is not known whether Wood is the "Underwood" referred to or not.

A SPECIAL FROM FALL RIVER.

A special telegram received from Fall River by the DISPATCH at a late hour last night appears to dissolve the possibility of Wood being connected with the murder, and shows him up as just such a man as was pictured in the article published in this paper exclusively on Tuesday morning. The special is as follows:

"News of the arrest of 'John Wood' as a Borden murder suspect created much interest in this city to-day when the local papers reproduced the DISPATCH'S story of Tuesday. Wood's real name is Henry Hahr, and he is a native of New York city. He came to Fall River two years ago and went to board with Mrs. Cross, at 17 John street. That lady to-day informed the DISPATCH correspondent that Hahr came of a Swedish family, and that his twin brother was at present a theatrical manager in New York. The name Wood he sometimes uses as a stage cognomen, and he was well known locally as Henry Wood. His twin brother gained much notoriety through a law suit with Maggie Mitchell over the right to produce a certain play.

"While here he dressed well, but had little or nothing to do, his only work being as a 'tip-printer' in Marshall's hat-factory. He worked three months and threw up the job. His acquaintances consider him harmless, of a bragadocio spirit, and fond of story-telling. He is always the hero of his own narratives. He left this city last April and has not been here since. The Borden murders were committed the 4th of August.

"In May he wrote to Mrs. Cross of his intention to sail for London on a theatrical venture. She supposed he had gone. In September she received a message from Hahr dated New York, and saying that he had just arrived from Europe and passed safely through quarantine. She had not heard from him since until to-day, when the news was broken to her of his arrest as a Borden murder suspect.

HENRY A HARMLESS MAN.

"At this the lady laughed outright and said: 'Why, Henry was in London, and besides he would not kill a kitten. He has been playing a joke and got into trouble. He never knew Lizzie Borden, although he may have seen her on the streets. As for going to the theatre with her, that is all bosh. Henry was an actor, so he said, and he has travelled all over the country, and frequently goes to England.'

"Inquiry among the local theatrical people disclosed the fact that Hahr was well known; that he was like many others, a venturesome youth with no higher ambition than to pose before the matinee crowds clad in the latest-style dress. Occasionally he got hard up and worked as a hat-finisher.

"Chief Hilliard, of the police force, takes no stock in the theory that Hahr was connected with the famous Borden tragedy. He has satisfied himself that the man was not in this city at the time of the killing.

"Robert Marshal, for whom Hahr worked says that he knew him as an honest well-meaning man, of more than ordinary good sense, but inclined to relate ghost stories of his own adventures. It was also learned that Hahr was received at the Cross household with more favor than the ordinary boarder.

"Mrs. Cross is a young widow and to her Hahr, it is alleged, paid considerable attention. She has announced her determination to put herself in communication with him and show the Richmond authorities that he is guiltless of crime."

See the clipping

A phrenologist on Lizzie Borden

A Salt Lake column of phrenology turns to Lizzie Borden. It says the August hearing found her probably guilty though it produced no proof of murder, and that if acquitted ‘while she lives she must walk alone’; Nelson Sizer, shown her photograph without her name, read her as ‘secretive, fond of property’. After her acquittal, a Helena paper found her unwelcome to more than half her church friends.

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The Salt Lake Herald · 6 November 1892 · page 16 · transcribed from the page image

BUMPS ON THE HEAD.

A Phenologist Gives His Verdict on Lizzie Borden.

See moreSee less

SCIENCE APPLIED TO AFFAIRS.

'Getting Married and Keeping Married"— The Servant Question Phrenologically Considered.

"Probably guilty" was the judicial finding of the court convened last August for the trial of Lizzie Borden. "Probably guilty," and not a shred of unimpeachable evidence against her innocence. Two weeks of ingenious efforts to extort some signs of guilt from a woman whose stolid indifference and superb, unnatural self-possession have been the most damaging witnesses against her, produced no proof of murder. But her trial by jury to be held the last week in November may discover new and conclusive evidence for or against her. If it does not, Lizzie Borden, whether

LIZZIE BORDEN.

freed or convicted, will be a doomed woman. "Not guilty," and while she lives she must walk alone, suspected by her townspeople of the crime for which she was on trial, shunned and whispered about by women who say, "She was tried for the murder of her father and mother, you know. They acquitted her, but ——." "Guilty," and half the public will be horrorstruck over the execution of a prisoner innocent of one of the most fearful charges in the recent history of crime.

Miss Borden cannot be easily characterized; her nature, as described by the neighbors, none of whom knew her intimately, is cold, passionless, self-sufficient. They say she had no confidants, and that she was dominated only by her stern New England creeds of right and wrong. But it was not until the crime had been committed that they molded into words their impressions of her, and with the best intentions in the world, subsequent events must have had an influence in the estimate of human nature.

Her picture has been printed in nearly every newspaper from San Francisco to the gulf, but by a curious chance a man who claims to correctly read dispositions by the contours of head and face, does not know her by her portrait. The photograph from which the accompanying cut was made was given him without a possible clue by which he could discover its identity. At the end of fifteen minutes' examination he gave me this "analysis and criticism," to use the technical phrase of phrenology:

"Oct. 27, 1892.

"LADY—We see in this portrait practical talent. The fullness across the lower part of the forehead evinces large perceptive faculties as a group, making her bright, quick to see, to know and to remember, giving the talents necessary for practical education, for art, mechanism and for business.

"The head seems to be broad in the sides above and about the ears, showing bravery, energy, severity, and a strong desire for ownership, and laying the foundation for good business talants and the tendency to push the cause which has business involved in it to a successful termination.

"The face indicates power. The broad cheek bones and the prominence of them, the massiveness of the lower jaw, as it makes an angle to get up toward the hair, show vital power and the tendency to be thorough and severe.

"The mouth indicates determination and resolution. The breadth of the head above and about the ears shows courage, selfishness and executive ability.

"She appears to have large firmness, that is shown in the height of the head, on a line from the opening of one ear to that of the other over the top.

"We think she has a pretty good share of self-esteem. She is self-willed, courageous, high tempered, secretive, fond of property. She is not a thinker and reasoner; she is a critic, but she is rather light in the reasoning power, though amply developed in the abilities which relate to practical knowledge, and the ability to be ingenious and artistic.

"If the back and top of the head were available it would be an aid to the full estimate of her character.

"She appears to have more courage than prudence, more determination than pliability, more force than restraint of mind.

"NELSON SIZER, "President" of American Institute of Phrenology."

This is certainly shrewd and rather keen, and Mr. Sizer asserts that it is also scientific. However that may be, there is an incorporated institute which, after a lecture course of six weeks, bestows a diploma, entitling the graduate to read human nature with his chart. It is a system which has been bounding into public credulity with its lines and angles and technical expressions, and is interesting because of its multitude of claims. It is not "bumpology," for that has been exploded by various people. Borrowing the definition used in the institute, phrenology is "the estimation of the size of the phrenological organs by the radial distance from the brain center to the periphery." A brain fibre leading to the eye is one of the organs of sight. Why may not another fibre, whose origin is in the medulla oblongata, leading to the top of the head, be the organ of firmness? asks the new school of phrenology. If the head at a fibre's terminal points is roundly developed, it proves that the organ (which, by the way, was located there by observation of 1,000 cases) is in a state of constant activity. If the fibre is seldom required, the development of surrounding organs will produce, comparatively speaking, a depression of the skull.

These are the simple fundamental claims upon which is based a science so all-embracing that men may choose, with infallible certainty, their proper occupation, and women may solve the servant problem so satisfactorily that nothing will be left to talk about.

You may get married and stay married all in accordance with the contours of your head and face. For a consideration your life partner will be chosen for you by a scientific analysis, which may not be of much service after the marriage day, however.

A person with a strongly vital temperament should seek in marriage one having the motive-mental temperament. Suppose one person has a strongly marked mental temperament, with a large head, light bones and muscles, lacking somewhat the digestive and nutritive power. That person should choose in marriage one who has a predominance of the motive and vital temperaments, with less expansion of brain, with strong features, a large neck and more brawny organization.

It is possible to learn by the chart all about temperament, for the name of every known faculty is printed in its proper spot on the head. Phrenologically speaking, everyone may be his own fortune teller. He has only to lay before his gaze his own characteristics by a system of differentiation with the chart before him.

The servant question is also answered by differentiation between mistress and maid, and a scrutiny of the model cook, housemaid, nurse and waitress, as illustrated in the little pamphlet which, with others, is going to cure all the ills arising from an ignorance of the science of phrenology.

THESE ARE THE BUMPS.

See the clipping

Word that she will not be indicted

A special from Taunton to the Herald reports that the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden: the evidence put before it was essentially that of the Fall River hearing and was not thought sufficient. In another week, it says, she will be ‘a free woman’. The report was wrong: on 2 December the grand jury indicted her, by a vote said to be 20 to 1.

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Daily Kennebec Journal · 26 November 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TO GO FREE.

Reported that Lizzie Borden Will Not be Indicted by Grand Jury.

See moreSee less

Boston, Nov. 25.—A special from Taunton to the Herald says, "Lizzie Borden will not be indicted by the grand jury for the murder of her father and step-mother.

In another week, without any doubt, she will be a free woman and the whole miserable pretence of a case against her will be ended.

The evidence laid before the grand jury was essentially the same as that produced at the hearing in Fall River and is was not deemed sufficient to warrant the finding of an indictment."

See the clipping

← Back to Act Two: Lizzie Borden Arrested