The Salt Lake Herald · 6 November 1892 · page 16 · transcribed from the page image
BUMPS ON THE HEAD.
A Phenologist Gives His Verdict on Lizzie Borden.
See moreSee less
SCIENCE APPLIED TO AFFAIRS.
'Getting Married and Keeping Married"— The Servant Question Phrenologically Considered.
"Probably guilty" was the judicial finding of the court convened last August for the trial of Lizzie Borden. "Probably guilty," and not a shred of unimpeachable evidence against her innocence. Two weeks of ingenious efforts to extort some signs of guilt from a woman whose stolid indifference and superb, unnatural self-possession have been the most damaging witnesses against her, produced no proof of murder. But her trial by jury to be held the last week in November may discover new and conclusive evidence for or against her. If it does not, Lizzie Borden, whether
LIZZIE BORDEN.
freed or convicted, will be a doomed woman. "Not guilty," and while she lives she must walk alone, suspected by her townspeople of the crime for which she was on trial, shunned and whispered about by women who say, "She was tried for the murder of her father and mother, you know. They acquitted her, but ——." "Guilty," and half the public will be horrorstruck over the execution of a prisoner innocent of one of the most fearful charges in the recent history of crime.
Miss Borden cannot be easily characterized; her nature, as described by the neighbors, none of whom knew her intimately, is cold, passionless, self-sufficient. They say she had no confidants, and that she was dominated only by her stern New England creeds of right and wrong. But it was not until the crime had been committed that they molded into words their impressions of her, and with the best intentions in the world, subsequent events must have had an influence in the estimate of human nature.
Her picture has been printed in nearly every newspaper from San Francisco to the gulf, but by a curious chance a man who claims to correctly read dispositions by the contours of head and face, does not know her by her portrait. The photograph from which the accompanying cut was made was given him without a possible clue by which he could discover its identity. At the end of fifteen minutes' examination he gave me this "analysis and criticism," to use the technical phrase of phrenology:
"Oct. 27, 1892.
"LADY—We see in this portrait practical talent. The fullness across the lower part of the forehead evinces large perceptive faculties as a group, making her bright, quick to see, to know and to remember, giving the talents necessary for practical education, for art, mechanism and for business.
"The head seems to be broad in the sides above and about the ears, showing bravery, energy, severity, and a strong desire for ownership, and laying the foundation for good business talants and the tendency to push the cause which has business involved in it to a successful termination.
"The face indicates power. The broad cheek bones and the prominence of them, the massiveness of the lower jaw, as it makes an angle to get up toward the hair, show vital power and the tendency to be thorough and severe.
"The mouth indicates determination and resolution. The breadth of the head above and about the ears shows courage, selfishness and executive ability.
"She appears to have large firmness, that is shown in the height of the head, on a line from the opening of one ear to that of the other over the top.
"We think she has a pretty good share of self-esteem. She is self-willed, courageous, high tempered, secretive, fond of property. She is not a thinker and reasoner; she is a critic, but she is rather light in the reasoning power, though amply developed in the abilities which relate to practical knowledge, and the ability to be ingenious and artistic.
"If the back and top of the head were available it would be an aid to the full estimate of her character.
"She appears to have more courage than prudence, more determination than pliability, more force than restraint of mind.
"NELSON SIZER, "President" of American Institute of Phrenology."
This is certainly shrewd and rather keen, and Mr. Sizer asserts that it is also scientific. However that may be, there is an incorporated institute which, after a lecture course of six weeks, bestows a diploma, entitling the graduate to read human nature with his chart. It is a system which has been bounding into public credulity with its lines and angles and technical expressions, and is interesting because of its multitude of claims. It is not "bumpology," for that has been exploded by various people. Borrowing the definition used in the institute, phrenology is "the estimation of the size of the phrenological organs by the radial distance from the brain center to the periphery." A brain fibre leading to the eye is one of the organs of sight. Why may not another fibre, whose origin is in the medulla oblongata, leading to the top of the head, be the organ of firmness? asks the new school of phrenology. If the head at a fibre's terminal points is roundly developed, it proves that the organ (which, by the way, was located there by observation of 1,000 cases) is in a state of constant activity. If the fibre is seldom required, the development of surrounding organs will produce, comparatively speaking, a depression of the skull.
These are the simple fundamental claims upon which is based a science so all-embracing that men may choose, with infallible certainty, their proper occupation, and women may solve the servant problem so satisfactorily that nothing will be left to talk about.
You may get married and stay married all in accordance with the contours of your head and face. For a consideration your life partner will be chosen for you by a scientific analysis, which may not be of much service after the marriage day, however.
A person with a strongly vital temperament should seek in marriage one having the motive-mental temperament. Suppose one person has a strongly marked mental temperament, with a large head, light bones and muscles, lacking somewhat the digestive and nutritive power. That person should choose in marriage one who has a predominance of the motive and vital temperaments, with less expansion of brain, with strong features, a large neck and more brawny organization.
It is possible to learn by the chart all about temperament, for the name of every known faculty is printed in its proper spot on the head. Phrenologically speaking, everyone may be his own fortune teller. He has only to lay before his gaze his own characteristics by a system of differentiation with the chart before him.
The servant question is also answered by differentiation between mistress and maid, and a scrutiny of the model cook, housemaid, nurse and waitress, as illustrated in the little pamphlet which, with others, is going to cure all the ills arising from an ignorance of the science of phrenology.
THESE ARE THE BUMPS.