A local academy's lyceum program lists an upcoming debate on the resolution that Lizzie Borden is guilty of the crime she's accused of, with student teams assigned to affirmative and negative sides. The item appears amid routine school and local community notices.
The United Opinion · 4 November 1892 · page 4
Miscellaneous business. Declamation. Mr. Blood. Heading, Miss Jones. Question, Kesolved that Lizzie Borden is guilty of the crime of which she is accused. Affirmative, Misses Hill and Little and Mr. Chamberlin. Negative, Messrs. Cunning
A brief notice announces that a new-school phrenologist has examined Lizzie Borden's head, with the full report promised in tomorrow's Dispatch. No details of the examination's findings are given here.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 5 November 1892 · page 9
LIZZIE BORDEN'S head examined by a new school phrenologist and Reported Ixi THE DISPATCH to-morroir. PEOPLE COMING AND GOING. Dr. J, S. Hackney, of TJniontown, andE. A. Ltlmphire, of Scottdale, are stopping at
A Boston report describes a phrenologist's assessment of Lizzie Borden's head and character, done without knowing her identity, framed within speculation about her guilt or innocence. The piece discusses public perception of her as cold and self-possessed, and anticipates her upcoming jury trial.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
The Morning News · 6 November 1892 · page 11
Phrenologically Considered. Boston, Nov. 5. “Probably guilty” was the judicial finding of the court convened lest August for the trial of Lizzie Burden. "Probably guilty,” and Ant a shred of un impeachable evidence against her innocence. Two weeks of ingenious efforts to extort some sign of guilt from a woman whose stolid indifference and superb, unnatural self-posses don havo been the most damaging witnesses against her, pr duoed no proof of murder. But her trial by jury, to be held the lost week in November, may discover new and conclusive evidence for or aguinst her.
See moreSee less
If it dues not, Lizzie Borden, whether freed nr convicted, will be a doomed woman. "Not guilty ."and while she lives she must walk alone, suspected by her townspeople of the crime for which she was on trial, shunned and whispered about by women who say, “Mho was tried for the murder of her father aud mother, you know. They acquitted her, but “Guilty,” and half the public will bn hor rorstruck over the execution of a prisoner lunooent of one of the most fearful charge* in the recent history of crime. Miss Borden cam ot bo oasily character ized; her nature, a* described by the neigh
A phrenologist, without knowing whose picture he was examining, offers his reading of Lizzie Borden's likely guilt based on her features. The article frames her public image as unknowable, caught between accusations of cold guilt and the stigma of suspicion regardless of a jury's verdict.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
The Helena Independent · 6 November 1892 · page 10
rWritten for Tx IUI.zKNA INnDrz'ENDTr.l ItOiIAIILY GUILTY." WAS T1H'iE judicial finding of the court convened laset August for the trial of Lizzie Borden. "Probably guilty," and not a shred of unimpeachable evidence against her innocence. Two weeks of ingenious efforts to extort some sign of guilt from a woman whose stolid indifference and superb, unnatural self-possession have been the most damaging witnesses against her, ever. produced no proof of murder. But her trial by jury, to be hold the last week in Novem ber, may discover new and conclusive evi dence for or against her.
See moreSee less
If it does not, Lizzie B3orden, whether freed or convicted, wili be a doomed woman. "Not guilty." and while she lives she must walk alone, suspected by her townspeople of the crime for which she was on trial, shunned and whispered about by women who say, "she was tried for the murder of her father and mother, you know. They acquitted her, but -." "Guilty." and half the public will be horrorstruek over the ex' cation of a prisoner innocent of one of the most fear ful charges in the recent history of crime. Miss Borden cannot be easily character ized; her nature, as described by the neigh bors, none of whom knew her intimately, is cold, passionless, self-sufficient. They say she had no confidants, and that she was donminated only by her stern New England creeds of right and wrong. 11st it was not until the crime had been committed that they molded into wordstheir imoressions of her, and with the best intentions in the world, subsequent events must have had an influence in the estimate of human nature. Her picture has been printed in nearly every newspaper from San Francisco to the gulf. but by a curious chance a man who claims to correotly read dispositions by the contours of head and face, does not know her by her portrait. The photograph from which the accompanying cut was made mss. °ý, ubflmity
This passage is actually a newspaper's table of contents listing article titles across its pages, including one labeled 'Phrenology and Lizzie Borden.' No actual content of that article is given here, only its title in the index.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 6 November 1892 · page 1
PHRENOLOGY AND LIZZIE BORDEN
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A phrenologist, Nelson Sizer, examined a photograph of Lizzie Borden without knowing her identity and produced a character analysis based on her head and facial features. The article notes she was held 'probably guilty' at the August hearing and that her jury trial is expected later that month.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 6 November 1892 · page 18
Elbeet T. Biddick. LIZZIE BORDEN'S HEAD. The Verdict of a Xew School Phrenologist Upon the Young Woman Accased of Murdering Her Father and Step-Mother Principles of the Science.
A phrenology expert examines a photograph of Lizzie Borden without knowing its subject, producing a detailed character analysis citing her head and facial features. His reading describes her as practical, courageous, self-willed, secretive, and more forceful than prudent.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 6 November 1892 · page 18
influence in the estimate ot human nature. NeUon Sizer is President of the Amer ican Institute of Phrenology, but be claims tn read dispositions best by the contours ot the head and face. I submitted to him the photograph ot Miss Borden from which the following cut was made. I did not tell him that it was a photograph of Mis Borden and he had no means of ascertaining who the original was. - At the end of 15 minutes Prof. Sizer wrote out the following which he calls his "analysis-and criticism:"
A phrenologist offers a character analysis of Lizzie Borden based on the shape of her head and face, citing traits like bravery, business acumen, and self-possession. The piece discusses her prior August hearing and anticipates her upcoming trial in November, suggesting she will remain a social outcast regardless of the verdict.
The Salt Lake Herald · 6 November 1892 · page 16 · transcribed from the page image
BUMPS ON THE HEAD.
A Phenologist Gives His Verdict on Lizzie Borden.
See moreSee less
SCIENCE APPLIED TO AFFAIRS.
'Getting Married and Keeping Married"— The Servant Question Phrenologically Considered.
"Probably guilty" was the judicial finding of the court convened last August for the trial of Lizzie Borden. "Probably guilty," and not a shred of unimpeachable evidence against her innocence. Two weeks of ingenious efforts to extort some signs of guilt from a woman whose stolid indifference and superb, unnatural self-possession have been the most damaging witnesses against her, produced no proof of murder. But her trial by jury to be held the last week in November may discover new and conclusive evidence for or against her. If it does not, Lizzie Borden, whether
LIZZIE BORDEN.
freed or convicted, will be a doomed woman. "Not guilty," and while she lives she must walk alone, suspected by her townspeople of the crime for which she was on trial, shunned and whispered about by women who say, "She was tried for the murder of her father and mother, you know. They acquitted her, but ——." "Guilty," and half the public will be horrorstruck over the execution of a prisoner innocent of one of the most fearful charges in the recent history of crime.
Miss Borden cannot be easily characterized; her nature, as described by the neighbors, none of whom knew her intimately, is cold, passionless, self-sufficient. They say she had no confidants, and that she was dominated only by her stern New England creeds of right and wrong. But it was not until the crime had been committed that they molded into words their impressions of her, and with the best intentions in the world, subsequent events must have had an influence in the estimate of human nature.
Her picture has been printed in nearly every newspaper from San Francisco to the gulf, but by a curious chance a man who claims to correctly read dispositions by the contours of head and face, does not know her by her portrait. The photograph from which the accompanying cut was made was given him without a possible clue by which he could discover its identity. At the end of fifteen minutes' examination he gave me this "analysis and criticism," to use the technical phrase of phrenology:
"Oct. 27, 1892.
"LADY—We see in this portrait practical talent. The fullness across the lower part of the forehead evinces large perceptive faculties as a group, making her bright, quick to see, to know and to remember, giving the talents necessary for practical education, for art, mechanism and for business.
"The head seems to be broad in the sides above and about the ears, showing bravery, energy, severity, and a strong desire for ownership, and laying the foundation for good business talants and the tendency to push the cause which has business involved in it to a successful termination.
"The face indicates power. The broad cheek bones and the prominence of them, the massiveness of the lower jaw, as it makes an angle to get up toward the hair, show vital power and the tendency to be thorough and severe.
"The mouth indicates determination and resolution. The breadth of the head above and about the ears shows courage, selfishness and executive ability.
"She appears to have large firmness, that is shown in the height of the head, on a line from the opening of one ear to that of the other over the top.
"We think she has a pretty good share of self-esteem. She is self-willed, courageous, high tempered, secretive, fond of property. She is not a thinker and reasoner; she is a critic, but she is rather light in the reasoning power, though amply developed in the abilities which relate to practical knowledge, and the ability to be ingenious and artistic.
"If the back and top of the head were available it would be an aid to the full estimate of her character.
"She appears to have more courage than prudence, more determination than pliability, more force than restraint of mind.
"NELSON SIZER, "President" of American Institute of Phrenology."
This is certainly shrewd and rather keen, and Mr. Sizer asserts that it is also scientific. However that may be, there is an incorporated institute which, after a lecture course of six weeks, bestows a diploma, entitling the graduate to read human nature with his chart. It is a system which has been bounding into public credulity with its lines and angles and technical expressions, and is interesting because of its multitude of claims. It is not "bumpology," for that has been exploded by various people. Borrowing the definition used in the institute, phrenology is "the estimation of the size of the phrenological organs by the radial distance from the brain center to the periphery." A brain fibre leading to the eye is one of the organs of sight. Why may not another fibre, whose origin is in the medulla oblongata, leading to the top of the head, be the organ of firmness? asks the new school of phrenology. If the head at a fibre's terminal points is roundly developed, it proves that the organ (which, by the way, was located there by observation of 1,000 cases) is in a state of constant activity. If the fibre is seldom required, the development of surrounding organs will produce, comparatively speaking, a depression of the skull.
These are the simple fundamental claims upon which is based a science so all-embracing that men may choose, with infallible certainty, their proper occupation, and women may solve the servant problem so satisfactorily that nothing will be left to talk about.
You may get married and stay married all in accordance with the contours of your head and face. For a consideration your life partner will be chosen for you by a scientific analysis, which may not be of much service after the marriage day, however.
A person with a strongly vital temperament should seek in marriage one having the motive-mental temperament. Suppose one person has a strongly marked mental temperament, with a large head, light bones and muscles, lacking somewhat the digestive and nutritive power. That person should choose in marriage one who has a predominance of the motive and vital temperaments, with less expansion of brain, with strong features, a large neck and more brawny organization.
It is possible to learn by the chart all about temperament, for the name of every known faculty is printed in its proper spot on the head. Phrenologically speaking, everyone may be his own fortune teller. He has only to lay before his gaze his own characteristics by a system of differentiation with the chart before him.
The servant question is also answered by differentiation between mistress and maid, and a scrutiny of the model cook, housemaid, nurse and waitress, as illustrated in the little pamphlet which, with others, is going to cure all the ills arising from an ignorance of the science of phrenology.
A newspaper feature describes phrenology, the pseudoscience of judging character from skull contours, and applies it to Lizzie Borden using her widely-published photograph. A phrenologist, given the photo without identifying information, offers an analysis of her temperament, while the piece notes public uncertainty about her true nature and references her eventual acquittal.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Salt Lake Herald · 6 November 1892 · page 16
THESE ARE THE BUMPS
know They acquitted her but I I Jn the recent history of crime 1 rorstruck over the execution of a prisoner innocant of one of tho most fearful charges I Miss Borden cannot be easily charac I terized her nature as described by the I neighbors none of whom know her in I timately is cold passionless selfsufficient They say she bad no confidants and that she was dominated only by her stern New England creeds of right and wrong But it was not until the crime had been committed I i S mitted that they molded Into words their Impressions of her and with the best in I
The grand jury investigating Lizzie Borden was impaneled at Taunton with Justice Thompson presiding. Defense counsel asked the court to specifically instruct jurors to disregard newspaper coverage and consider only evidence presented, but the court declined to give a special charge, with the District Attorney noting he always reminds grand juries to rely solely on evidence.
The Providence News · 8 November 1892 · page 6
LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE
E : TAUNTON, Mass., Nov. 8, —~The criminal term of the superior court came in yes ly'} terday, Justice Thompson %1 Glouces ; ter on the beneh. Ordinarily there would E bave been no business but the impaneling ~ of the grand jury and its retirement for " business, but yesterday, after the roll - call, Col. M. 9. Adams, associate counsel ~_ for Lizzie'A. Borden, asked permission to ’ address the court on a matter in which 5 the defence was much interested and was backed by a petition from Miss Bor ~ den. He said that he was uncertain about ~ his position without special assignment, " but he appeared at Miss Borden’s request.
The newspaper remarks in passing that Lizzie Borden has once more become a subject of public discussion and thought. No specific details or developments are given.
The Providence News · 10 November 1892 · page 4
Axp now Lizzie Borden becomes again a topic of thought and counversa tion. A~ ——— BENJAMIN HARRISON, [From the N. Y. Sun.) The twenty-third President of the United States will go out of office on the
Professor Nelson Sizer of the American Institute of Phrenology analyzed a portrait of Lizzie Borden without knowing her identity, describing her bumps and features as indicating practical talent, business acumen, bravery, and determination. The article notes some who know her find his character assessment accurate.
The Providence News · 10 November 1892 · page 5
LIZZIE BORDEN'S BUMPS
The picture of Lizzie A, Borden of Fall River, who is charged with the murder of her father and is now in the Taunton Jail awaiting trial, has been shown to Prof. Neison Sizer, President of the American lustitute of Phrenology, who read her character from it. This bump professor did not know who his subject was, but at the end of a short examina tion he made this diagnosis of Miss Bor den’s character: ‘“We see in this portrait practieal talent. The fullness across the lower part of the forehead evinces larze per
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
A phrenologist offers a 'probably guilty' judgment on Lizzie Borden based on her character and composure, noting the August proceedings produced no conclusive evidence. The piece speculates that her upcoming jury trial, expected in late November, will determine whether she lives as a suspected but free woman or faces execution.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 10 November 1892 · page 4
LIZZIE BORDEN'S HEAD
LIZZII BOEDKM. may discover new and conclusive evidence for or against her. If it does not, Liz zie Borden, whether freed or convicted, will be a doomed woman. *'Not guilty," and while she lives she must walk alone, suspected by her townspeople of the crime for which she was on trial, shunned and whispered about by women who say: "She wai tried for the murder of her father and mother, you know. They ac quitted her, but v " "Guilty," and half the pubiio will be horror-struck over the execution of a prisoner innocent of one of the most fearful charges in the re cent history of crime.
See moreSee less
Miss Borden cannot be easily character ized; her nature,as described by the neigh bors, none of whom knew her intimately, is cold, passionless, self-sufficient. They say she bad no confidants, and that she was dominated only by her stern New England creeds of rieht snd wrong. But it was not until the crime had been com muted that they molded into words their impressions of her, and with the beat in tent ons in the world, subsequent events must have had an iniluence in the esti mate of human nature. Her picture has been printed in nearly every newspaper from San Francisco to the Gulf, but by a curious chance a man who claims to correctly read dispositions by the contours of head and face does not know her by her portrait. The photo graph from which the accompanying cut was made was given him without a possi ble clue by which he could discover its identity. At the end of fifteen minutes' examination he gave this "analysis and criticism," to Use the technical phrase of phrenology: October 27,18J2. Lady: We see in this portrait practical talent. The lullness across the lower part of the fore head evinces Urge perceptive faculties an a group, making her bright, quick to see, to know and to remember, giving the ta;en:s necessary for practical education, lor art, mechanism and for business. The head seems to be broad in the Fides above and about the ears, showing bravery, energy, severity and a strong desire for ownership, and laying the foundation for good business talent and the tendency to t>u*h the cause which has business involved in it to a successful termina tion. The face indicates power. The broad cheek bones and the prominence of them, the mas siveness of the lower jaw, as it makes an angle to get up toward the hair, show vital power and the tendency to be thorough and severe The mouth indicates determination and reso lution. The breadth of the head above end about the ears shows courage, selhshuess and executive ability. She appears to have large firmness, that is shown iu the height of the bead, on a line from theopeuiugof one ear to that of the other over tho top. We think she has a pretty good share of self esteem. She is self-willed, courageous, high tempered, secretive, fond of proj»orty. She is not a thiiiKer und reasoner: she is a critic, but sre is ratner light in the reasoning power, though amply developed in the abilities which r>.• ate to practical knowledge, and the ability to be i.igenions and artistio. if the bade and top of the head were avail able it w iuld be an aid to the lull estimate of her character. She appears to have more courage than pru dence, more determination than pliability, more force than restraint of mind. Smwott 9l*br, President of American Institute of Phrenology. fj On* lends to t?n JW other. The" cutv mm ting" of prieet f/lft leads to tne sub
The report states that if the Bristol county grand jury indicts Lizzie Borden for murder, her trial will likely take place in New Bedford in January. This is a brief forward-looking note amid other unrelated news items.
Asheville Daily Citizen · 11 November 1892 · page 1
Des Moines, Nov. 11. Harrison's plu rality is about 20,000. "The Democrats are very sore over the result," said State Chairman Fuller, "because we were the first to show that the solid northwest would be broken, and now when other States go Democratic our docs not." Lizzie Borden's Trial. Boston, Mass., Nov. 11. It is learned that if the crand iurv of Bristol county New llcdlord, prouauiy in January. A strike Off. New Orleans, Nov. 8. The big strike is off. The workmen have virtually sur a-iui tne rcsuu wua u iwluijt wi mv vm ployers. Tbe Trial ol Dr. Brlggs. New York, Nov. 11. The trial ol Rev. Charles A. Briggs, charged with heresy
The Boston Herald reports that the location dispute for Lizzie Borden's trial has been settled, with proceedings set for New Bedford pending a grand jury indictment. Officials have reportedly ordered the New Bedford courthouse prepared for the trial, expected in January.
Pawtucket Tribune · 11 November 1892 · page 3
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL Will Be Held In New Bedford In January if She Is Indicted., BosroN, Nov, 11.—=The Herald says that the much disputed guestion as to where the celebrat ] Borden murder trial will come off is setiled at last, and that if the grand jury of Bristol county fiuds an in dictiment »f marder against Lizzie A. Bor deu, the tein) will take place in New Bed ford, probably in January. [t is stated that orders have been given to have the court house in that city put in readiness for this important event,
At the opening of the Taunton superior court, defense attorney Adams asked for special instructions directing the grand jury to disregard hearsay evidence and newspaper reports. District Attorney Knowlton objected, and the court ruled no special instructions were necessary.
Huntsville Gazette · 12 November 1892 · page 2
The Lizzie Borden Trial. Taunton. M;iss.. Nov. 11.—The first hint at the Borden case came at the opening of the superior court. Mr. Adams for Miss Borden addressed the court, asking that special instructions should be given the grand jury not to be influenced by hearsay evidence or newspaper paragraphers. District At torney Knowltou promptly replied in substance that he believed that he could be relied on to properly conduct the case before the grand jury. After hear ing both of them the court decided that no special instructions for the grand ju ry were necessary. 11 ig Fire in Boston.
Within a miscellany column on women's topics, the piece notes that Mrs. McGuirk, a newspaperwoman who once knew Lizzie Borden through charity work, insists she could not have committed the murders. McGuirk is said to have written a strong public letter defending Borden against being branded a 'fiend' for not displaying expected emotion.
Arizona Republican · 12 November 1892 · page 3
WOMAN'S WORLD IN PARAGRAPHS
Borden some years ago. Both wero as sociated in the fruit and flower mission at Fall River. Mrs. McGuirk believes Lizzie Borden could no moro have
A Boston dispatch states that if the Bristol County Grand Jury indicts Lizzie Borden for murder, the trial will be held in New Bedford, likely in January. This is a brief forward-looking note on the anticipated legal proceedings.
New-York Tribune · 12 November 1892 · page 1
THE BORDLN MURDER CASE. Boston, Nov. 11.—It 1s learned that if the Grand Jury of Bristol County finds un idictment of murder aga'nst Lizzie Borden the trial will take place In New-hedford, probably In January.
The Lizzie Borden case will go before the Grand Jury in Taunton starting Monday, with detective McHenry not testifying. Officials indicate a hearing could last three days, with a trial unlikely before February, while Borden herself appears calm and composed in jail.
New-York Tribune · 13 November 1892 · page 7
TEE BORDEN CASE 10 BE ACTED ON TO-MORROW. Taunton, Mass., Nov. 12.—The Lizzie Borden case will be taken up by the Crapd Jury Monday next. McHenry, the Providence detective, will not testify. Marshal Hillard, referring to the Trickey-Mcllenry {mposture, said that the whole matter hud not been made publle yet, nor would It be until after the trial of Miss Borden, if there was a trial. “he developments would be far more interesting than the first. It 1s understood that the hearing before tae Grand Jury will occupy about three days, t is given out on ths best of authority that it will be an utter Lmpossibility for the case to be reached by a jury much before February, If such a hearing is found necessary.
See moreSee less
‘There l= a strong feeling that the Grand Jury will indlet, and an equally strong feeling that unless the evidence ls of the most convipe- {ng nature, with none of the circumstantial attachments, there will be no conviction possible in this county. Miss Borden gppears to be suffering no in convenience, and shows no great anxiety respecting the coming Grand Jury bearing. She Is outwardly as cool and composed as when she entered Taunton Jall.,
The report states the Lizzie Borden case will go before the grand jury the following Monday. City Marshal Hilliard hints at undisclosed sensational details and notes Lizzie Borden appears calm and unworried awaiting the hearing.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 13 November 1892 · page 2
THE BORDEN CASE. TaUN'TOX. Mns., Nov. 12. The Lizzie Borden case will be taken tip by the grand jury next Monday. City Marshal Hillard of Fall River hays, referting to the trick ery in the imbroglio, that the whole matter
The report states that the Lizzie Borden case will be taken up by the grand jury the following Monday in Taunton, Massachusetts. It notes a strong feeling that an indictment will result, but also doubt that conviction is possible in that county unless the evidence is highly convincing and free of circumstantial weaknesses.
The State Chronicle · 13 November 1892 · page 1
Lizzie Borden's Case. By Telegraph to the State Chronicle. Taunton, Mass., Nov. 12 The Lizzie Borden case will be taken up by the grand jury Monday next There is a
The report notes that the Lizzie Borden case will go before the Grand Jury the following Monday, and that a Providence detective involved in a controversy will not testify. It describes Borden as outwardly composed, finding solace in tending flowers while awaiting the proceedings.
Wheeling Sunday Register · 13 November 1892 · page 4
LIZZIE BORDEN STILL COOL.
Lizzie Borden case will be taken up by the Grand Jury next Monday. Mr. McHeury, the Providence detect ive, will not testify. City Marshal Hilliard, of Fall River, says, referring to the Trlckey-McHenry imbroglio, that the whoie matter bad not been made public yet, nor would it be until af ter the trial, if there was a trial. He gave his listener to understand that what was to come would make the biggest sensa tion of the day. Miss Borden appears to be suffering no inconvenience aud shows no great anxiety respecting the coming grand jury hearing.
See moreSee less
She is outwardy the same cool, composed wo man who entered Taunton so many weeks ago. She is very fond of flowers, and in their care appears to forget for the time that she is a prisoner. Her health continues good.
The Lizzie Borden case is set to go before the grand jury in Taunton, while Marshal Hilliard reports receiving threatening letters. Lizzie Borden herself remains calm and in good health while awaiting the hearing, tending flowers given to her in jail.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 14 November 1892 · page 3
To Ba Tukrn Up By the Graud Jury To day Pro.eoutur Thruateited. Taunton, Mass., Nov. 14. The Lizzie Borden case will be taken up by the graud jury to-day. Marshal Hilliard is in almost daily re ceipt of threatening letters and epistles containing all sorts of advice, from an in timation that it would be well for him to leave the country to a direct threat on his life, with a few words of advice as to the proper method of doing his duty thrown in. Judge Blaisdell has alsofelt the Influ ence of the crank.
See moreSee less
Miss Borden appears to bo suffering no inconvenience and shows no great anxiety respecting the coining grand jury hearing. Sho is outwardly the same cool and composed woman who en tered Taunton Jail so many weeks ago. During the day, when she desires, she takes exercise in the corridors of the woman's apartment, and spends much of her time in the hospital room above, where Mrs. Wright has given her two windows full of flowers to look after and in a measure divert her mind. Her health continues good.
A roundup of national and world news notes that the Taunton, Massachusetts grand jury will take up the Lizzie Borden case on Monday. The item appears as a brief line among many unrelated news items of the day.
The Indianapolis Journal · 14 November 1892 · page 3
NEWS IN SUNDAY'S JOURNAL
Abroad Chronicled in the Isae of Xgt13. The war in Venezuela is not yet ended. Tho corn blockade in Mexico has been lifted. Every State in Mexico will be represented at the world's fair. President Harrison will not rxtond.tbe classified service greatly. Henry Irving's new "King Lear" received the highest praise in London. Constitutional prohibition is now prac tically a dead letter in Kansas. The Taunton (Mass.) grand jury will tak up the Lizzie Borden case Monday, W. J. Stone's pluralitv over Warner, for Governor of Missouri, will be over S0.0J0. Candidates for oQico under the Cleve land administration are springing up every
The Lizzie Borden case is set to go before the grand jury in Taunton, while Marshal Hilliard receives threatening letters over his handling of the case. Lizzie Borden herself remains calm and composed in jail, tending flowers and taking exercise, showing little anxiety about the upcoming hearing.
The Evening Herald · 14 November 1892 · page 2
Tu rtn Taknn Up lly tlitt (iriiiul Jury To day Ironuuturil Thraat.ned. Tauntox, Mass., Nov. 14. The Lizzio Borden case will be taken up by the grand jury to-day. Marshal Illlliurd is In nlmnst dally re ceipt of threatening letters and epistles containing all sorts of advice, from an In timation that it would be well for him to leave the country to a direct threat on his life, with a few words of advice as to tho proper method of doing his duty thrown in. Judge BUisdoll has also felt tho infillnco of tho crank.
See moreSee less
Miss Borden appears to bo suffering no inconvenience aud shows uo great anxiety respecting the coming grand jury hearing. She is outwardly the same cool und composed woman who en tered Taunton jail so many weeks ago. During the day, when slio desires, she takes oxercise in tho corridors of the woman's apartment, and spends much of her time iu the hospital room above, where Mrs. Wright has given her two windows full of flowers to look after and In a measure divert her mind. Her health continues good.
The Lizzie Borden case is set to go before the grand jury in Taunton, with City Marshal Hilliard hinting at undisclosed sensational developments related to the Trickey-McHenry affair. Borden herself appears calm, spending her time tending flowers and exercising in the jail corridors.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 14 November 1892 · page 3
Marshal Hilliard, of FalA River, says, re ferring to the Trickey-McHenry imbroglio, that the whole matter had not been made public yet, nor would it be until after the trial, if there is a trial. He gave his listener to understand that what was to come would when made public make the biggest sensation of the day. A dispatch from Taunton, Mass., says: Miss Borden appears to be Buffering no in convenience and shows no great anzietv respecting the coming grand jnry hearing.
The grand jury takes up Lizzie Borden's case in Taunton, with reports that an indictment will likely be found and the hearing expected to last three days. Detective McHenry will not testify, and Marshal Hilliard hints at future revelations about the Trickey-McHenry affair, while Borden remains calm and occupied with gardening in jail.
The Providence News · 14 November 1892 · page 2
THAT CAUSE CELEBRE
- TAUNTON, Mass., Nov. 14.—The Lizzie Borden case will be taken up by the Grand " Jury today. Mr. McHenry, the Provi denoce detective, will not testify. ¢ City Marshal Hiiliard of Fall River, re fering to the Trickey-McHenry imbroglic said that the whole matter had not been made public yet, nor would it be until af ter the trial of Miss Borden, if there wasa trial. And the second crop was going to be far more interesting than the first one. In fact, he gave his listener to understand that what was to come would make the
Marshal Hilliard denies a Boston paper's report that Lizzie Borden's trial was set for January in New Bedford, calling it absurd and premature. He also addresses the Trickey-McHenry detective controversy, promising a bigger sensation to come after any trial, while describing Borden's routine in jail and threatening letters he receives.
The Providence News · 14 November 1892 · page 2
AN INDICTMENT WILL BE FOUND
business by his bandllng of the witnesses and upon the number summoned and heard. The court will come inas usual on Monday and regular criminal trials will be begun, the district attorney ap m:tl: asubstitute to carry on the gov . il he gets through "}::ho Borden case,
The report discusses legal maneuvering ahead of the grand jury hearing, including venue speculation and divided public opinion on whether an indictment or conviction is likely. It also describes Lizzie Borden's composed demeanor at Taunton Jail, where she maintains good health and spends time with flowers in the hospital room.
The Providence News · 14 November 1892 · page 2
MISS BORDEN HERSELF Bhe is Well, Cool and Composed Over the Future. T‘m" M“.o’ No'o 1.. _ Mi.. BOI'" den appears to be suffering no inconven fence and shows no great anxiety respectIng the grand jury hearing. She is ontwardly the same cool and composed Yyoung lady who entered Taunton Jail sc many weeks ago. During the day when she desires she takes exercise in the cor ridors of the woman’s apartment, and she spends much of her time in the hospita! room above where Mrs. Wright has kindly
The grand jury is secretly hearing testimony in the Lizzie Borden case, with witnesses including Prof. Wood, Bridget Sullivan, and Mrs. Churchill summoned. Bridget Sullivan is expected to testify about an alleged attempted robbery at the Borden home, and a guarded box of evidence is said to contain valuable materials.
The Providence News · 15 November 1892 · page 7
Sullivan and Mrs. Churchill. It is expected that not more than two will be called upon to testity, and that the hearing will continue for four orfive days, All the material used in the hearing is in a big box, which is counstantly under guard., The box is heavy and apparently contains articles of great value, : Iv 1s given out that the story of the alleged attempt to rob the Borden home will igure quite prominently 1n the hear Ing, and there are vague rumors that start ling developments are sure to ensue. Bridget Sullivan is looked upon as the most important witness for the State, and it is from her lips that the details of the alleged robbery are expected,
Fall River police spent the day summoning witnesses to appear before the Grand Jury sitting in Taunton, with more witnesses expected than at the preliminary hearing. No major new developments were anticipated, and the session could last up to five days.
The Providence News · 15 November 1892 · page 7
FALL RIvER, Mass., Nov, 15. - Police of. ficers were busy yesterday summoning witnesscs in the Borden murder case to attend the sitting of the Grand Jury at
The report describes new evidence allegedly being presented to the grand jury against Lizzie Borden, though she remains unmoved by the claims. It also mentions a phrenologist's examination of her head, claiming her skull showed a bump of destructiveness and a lack of moral/affectionate development.
Arizona Republican · 16 November 1892 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The grand jury reconvened in Taunton with seven witnesses summoned, including Prof. Wood, Bridget Sullivan and Mrs. Churchill. Reports indicate significant new evidence, possibly related to a prior house robbery, will be introduced implicating Lizzie Borden, with Bridget expected to testify about it.
The Portland Daily Press · 16 November 1892 · page 1
AGAINST LIZZIE BORDEN.
The New Evidence Said To Be Ready for the Grand Jury. j Boston, November 15.—A Taunton, Mass., despatch to the Boston Journal srys: The Borden case was reopened again this morning before the grand jury, sev en witnesses, including Prof. Wood, Bridget Sullivan and Mrs. Churchill, hav ing been summoned today. A close guard is kept about the grand j ury room, and all the stuff to be used has been packed in a big box and put under lock and key where the district attorney can get at it handily.
See moreSee less
The liackman who brought it from the Fall River train said it was heavy enough to warrant the assertion that there was a small hardware store inside. There is said to be no doubt that important evi dence, as has been hinted before, rela tive to the house robbery and seriously implicating Miss Borden will be intro duced, and that Bridget will have some thing to say about it.
The grand jury took up the Borden case on Tuesday at Taunton, Massachusetts. Seven witnesses were scheduled to be examined, with the process expected to take four or five days.
Connecticut Western News · 17 November 1892 · page 3
Lizzie Borden. The grand jury took up the Borden oase on Tuesday at Taunton, Mass. Sev en witnesses are to be examined and it will probably require four or five days to take all the testimony. The Duchess of Marlborough will receive $1,000,000 insurance on the duke's life. He had taken out policies in this large amount as a recognition of the immense sums the duch ess had expended in repairing and beautify
The grand jury considering the Borden case is meeting behind closed doors, with guards preventing reporters from learning details. Officials indicate a report may not come for over a week, and hint that new chemical evidence could strengthen the case for indictment.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 17 November 1892 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE. It Will be Several Uays Refore ilie Grand Jury Reports. Taunton, Mass., Nov. 17. Eavesdrop pers have no chance at getting a crumb
The grand jury in the Borden case has again convened, with seven witnesses called and more expected, requiring four to five days to complete testimony. New evidence is reported to have been discovered, and the maid Bridget Sullivan is expected to be an especially important witness.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 17 November 1892 · page 4
Lizzie Börsen's Prozeft
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report states that the Borden case is being reopened in Massachusetts. It claims damaging evidence has been secured against defendant Lizzie Borden.
Morning Appeal · 17 November 1892 · page 3
Tiie Borden case is to be opened up again in Mass. Some very dam aging evidence is said to have been secured against the defendant Lizzie Borden. Judge Street, an old Nevadan, formerly one of the founders of the Elko Independent, is dead. He was a prominent man in Nevada politics in the 70's. The Governor issued the following commissions yesterday: r rank Bryant, First Lieutenant of Company F; Homer Thaxter, Second Lieuten ant of same Company. Advice to Mothers. Mrs. Wins low's Sothing Syrup should always be used for children teething. It 9ootha the child, softens the gums, allays the pain, cures wind colic indls the best remedy for diarrhoea Twenty five cents a bottle.
The grand jury examining the Borden case is meeting in strict secrecy, with guards preventing witnesses from being interviewed by reporters. It is expected to take all of this week and part of next before a report is issued, with hints that new chemical evidence may support an indictment.
The Evening Herald · 17 November 1892 · page 3
LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE. It Will be beverul Days IteTure the Grand Jury lleporta. Tacnton-, Mass., Nov. 17. Eavesdrop pers huva no chance at getting a crumb from the grand jury room where the Borden cuso is under examination. A deputy sheriff und a stalwart policeman guard the door aud people are kept at a proper distance. When witnesses arrive ut the court bottle they are quickly secluded from in terview .s, or it one succoeds in eluding the wu ..u. eye of au officer for a mo ment a.. 1 t.ilks with im innocent stranger, tho thread of conversation is snapped short when the eyo of the war den takes in the situation.
See moreSee less
It is given out that it will tako all of this week uud a portion of next before a report is made to the court. There ara hluts, however, that thero is n lot of new evideuce that will clinch the matter of an indictment and that much of it will come from chemical experts who did not show their bund at the preliminary ex
The grand jury has finished other cases and will take up the Borden case starting where it left off at Fall River, but no witness list has been made yet. Marshal Hilliard confirms detective McHenry will not testify, citing the unresolved Trickey-McHenry controversy.
LIST OF WITNESSES IN LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE NOT YQt MADE OUT. Hearing Harnre the Grand Jury will l'robalilr Occupy Three Hays Throat, en Ina dollars lining Iteonlved by Mar,
The grand jury in Taunton, Massachusetts began considering the Lizzie Borden case on Monday. Reports suggest a trial could not occur before January, with opinion split on whether the jury will indict and whether conviction is likely given the circumstantial evidence.
Bellows Falls Times · 17 November 1892 · page 1
The case of Lizzie Borden was taken up by the grand jury at Taunton, Mass., Monday. It ts given on the best of au thority that it will be an utter impossi bility for the case to be reached by a jury much before January if such a hear ing is found necessary. There is a strong feeling that the grand jury will indict and an equally strong feeling that unless the evidence is of the most convincing nature with none of the circumstautial attachments there will be no conviction possible in the county.
The grand jury investigating the Borden murders continues hearing testimony, with rumors circulating that two people close to the family could be indicted as accessories if Lizzie Borden is found guilty. Witnesses connected to the family have reportedly been reluctant or misleading, prompting the Attorney General to press them hard for the truth.
Morning Journal and Courier · 18 November 1892 · page 3
THE BORDEN CASE. The Hearing; Continued Rumors of More Indictments An Exacting Jury Evidence Thoroughly sifted. Fill Bivib, Mass , Nov. 17. -The Bor den murders are again the principal sub
The report says Fall River is abuzz with rumors that the grand jury may indict two other persons connected to the case if Lizzie Borden is found guilty, citing their evasive and misleading testimony. It notes the attorney general pressed one witness hard and that some believe a conspiracy involving accessories preceded the murders.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 18 November 1892 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE Indictments May be Brought Against Two Witnesses. GRAND JURY PROCEEDING SLOWLY.
Topfo of Conversation In Full ltivur. Fall River, Muss., Nov. 18. The Borden murders are again the prominent subject of couverautiou in this city, anil a rumor is being generally circulate.! that indictments may bo brought against two persons other than Miss Liz zie Borden, provided the jury finds a ver diet of guilty against her. These persons have been intimately connected with tho case, more particu larly since police attention was directed to it. On the stand thev have uroved to be not only unwilling, but even mislead ing, witnesses.
See moreSee less
Attorney-General Pillsbury pressed one of these witnesses very hard, in a manner which lf t no doubt in the minds of the jurymen that he proposes to have the whole truth, if the hearing is pro longed three mouths. Because of the reticence of the persons indicated, the police and other the authorities have been to a great dual ol trouble ami expense in getting evidence of the family relatious a day or two previ ous to the murders; consequently there is much feeling expressed ugainst them in police circles. The closest friends of Miss Borden, who have thought the prisoner may possibly be proven guilty by the law have con tended all along that some kind of a con spiracy must have preceded the atfair, and that perphaps one, probauly two per sons talked ot were accessories before the fact. It is evident from the few words spoken by local witnesses who have given testi mony within the p.ist two days, that the present grand jury is a very exacting body and proposes to hear all the govern ment can offer before agreeing that Lizzie Borden committed the crimes. They ask many pointed questions and are giving the evidence a very thorough sifting. It is expected that the grand jury will visit this oity to-duy and view the scene of the murders.
The grand jury investigating the Borden murders is proceeding slowly, with witnesses described as unwilling or misleading and the Attorney-General pressing them hard. Friends of Lizzie Borden speculate a conspiracy with accessories may have preceded the murders, while the jury thoroughly questions local witnesses and plans to visit the murder scene.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 18 November 1892 · page 2
GRAND JURY PROCEEDING SLOWLY
police circles. The closest friends of Miss Borden, who have thought the prisoner may possibly be proven guilty by the law have con tended all along that some kind of a con spiracy must have preceded the atfair, and that perphaps one, probauly two per sons talked ot were accessories before the fact. It is evident from the few words spoken by local witnesses who have given testi mony within the p.ist two days, that the present grand jury is a very exacting body and proposes to hear all the govern ment can offer before agreeing that Lizzie Borden committed the crimes.
See moreSee less
They ask many pointed questions and are giving the evidence a very thorough sifting. It is expected that the grand jury will visit this oity to-duy and view the scene of the murders.
A dispatch from Taunton, Mass. claims that the day's hearing in the Borden case 'proved conclusively' that Lizzie Borden is not responsible for her actions, suggesting she inherited insanity from her mother. It also notes the prison matron believes Lizzie is guilty.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 18 November 1892 · page 4
Lizzie ltorlen's Queer Actions. Tavxton, Mass, Nov 18. To-dav's hearing in the Borden case proved con clusively that Lizzie Borden is not re sponsible for many of her actions. It is believed that she inherited insanity from her mother. The matron of the prison believes that Lizzie is guilty. Henry Again Ignored. The state board of eqalization met in
The Fall River grand jury is reportedly conducting a thorough examination of the evidence in the Borden murder case, questioning witnesses closely before reaching a decision. A rumor circulates that two other persons connected to the family might also face indictment if Lizzie Borden is found guilty, though testimony in a related Taunton hearing contained nothing new.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 18 November 1892 · page 1
Nothing New in Borden Nearing. Tai vro\. Mass.. Nov. 17. — Nothing particularly new or startling in the line of evidence was produced iu the Borden hear ing today, most of the witnesses having
The Fall River grand jury is thoroughly examining the government's case against Lizzie Borden, with witnesses noting pointed questions from jurors. Rumors suggest two other persons closely connected to the family may also face indictment if Borden is indicted.
The Portland Daily Press · 18 November 1892 · page 1
THEY ARE SIFTING IT.
About the Case in Fall River. Fall River, November 17.—The Bor den murders are again the (principal sub ject of conversation in this city and to night a rumor is being generally circu lated that indictments may be brought against two persons other than Miss Liz zie Borden, provided the jury brings an indictment against her. These persons have been intimately connected with the family, more particularly since police at tention has been directed to it. On the stand they proved not only unwilling but misleading witnesses. It is evident from the few words spoken by the local witnesses who have given testimony within the past two days, that the pres ent grand jury proposes'to hear all the government can offer before agreeing that Lizzie Borden committed the crimes.
See moreSee less
They ask many pointed ques tions and are giving the evidence a very thorough sifting.
Rumors circulate in Fall River that the grand jury may indict two other persons closely connected to the Borden household if Lizzie Borden is found guilty. The Attorney-General has been pressing evasive witnesses hard, and police are frustrated by their reticence in establishing family relations before the murders.
The Evening Herald · 18 November 1892 · page 3
LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE Indictments May be Brought Against Two Witnesses. GRAND JURY PROCEEDING SLOWLY.
police c rclu-t. Tho cioest friends ot Miss Borden, who havo thought the prisoner may possibly be proven guilty by the law have con tended all along that some kind of a con spiracy must have preceded tho affair, aud tliat perphaps one, prob.ioly two per sons talked ot wero accessories before tho fact. It is evident from tho few words spoken by local witnesses who nave given tesu moiiy within the past two days, that tho present grand jury is a very exacting body and proposes to hear all the govern tnent can offer before agreeing that Lizzie Borden committed the crimes.
See moreSee less
They ask many pointed questions and aro giving the evidence a very thorough sifting. It is expected that tho grand jury will visit this city to-day uud YluW thu sceno of tho murders.
The grand jury is pressing witnesses hard, with Attorney-General Pillsbury determined to uncover the whole truth even if the hearing drags on for months. The jury is reportedly exacting, questioning testimony thoroughly before deciding on Lizzie Borden's guilt, and is expected to visit the murder scene.
The report states that the Grand Jury at Taunton is considering the evidence in the Borden murder case and is expected to bring an indictment against Lizzie Borden. It notes that the evidence before the Grand Jury is necessarily one-sided and incomplete compared to what will emerge at trial.
Paper unidentified · 18 November 1892 · page 4
Secretary of State. Tbe Gazette will be issued one day late next week on account of Thanksgiving. -<♦► Tbe Grand Juiy al Taunton is con sidering the evidence in tbe Borden murder case, and it is expected will bring an indictment against Lizzie Borden. Know one knows what evidence may be brought out al the trial, as that liefore tbe Grand Jury la necessarily one-sided and incom plete.
Fall River is abuzz with rumors that two people close to the Borden family may face indictment as accessories if Lizzie Borden is found guilty. Attorney General Pillsbury has pressed uncooperative witnesses hard on the stand, suggesting he intends to uncover the full truth even if the hearing drags on for months.
The Providence News · 18 November 1892 · page 1
indicated, the {)olloe and other authorlties have been put to a fimt deal of trouble and expense in getting evidence concern ing the family relations a day or two pre vious to the murders, conm?uently much t:elllng is expressed against them in police c rc “. The closest friends of Miss Borden,
The grand jury investigating the Borden murders is described as thorough and exacting, with Attorney-General Pillsbury pressing a reluctant witness hard. Friends of Lizzie Borden speculate a conspiracy involving one or two accomplices may have preceded the killings, while Rev. Mr. Buck, her regular visitor, was injured in a fall at the train depot.
The Providence News · 18 November 1892 · page 1
before the fact. It is evident from the few words spoken by local witnesses who have given testi mony within the past two days, that the gor?ent dgnnd jury I 8 a very exacting v and proposes to hear all the govern ment can offer before agreeing that Lizzie Borden committed the crimes. They ask many pointed questions and are giving
The report claims the grand jury hearing revealed sensational secrets justifying Lizzie's detention, including hints she talked in her sleep and suffered hereditary mental traits. It also recounts an anecdote claiming Lizzie's mother (actually stepmother) died from a fit of temper over a flower pot.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Providence News · 18 November 1892 · page 6
THE BORDEN CASE. Sensational Disclosures Made at the Hearing This Morning, LIZZIE TALKED IN HER SLEEP, A Vindication for the Prosecution-The First Mrs, Borden Died From the Effects of a Bad Temper-The Jury Gone to Fall River.
to-day that the hearing before the grand jury has disclolocfl secrets of the most sensational character. It is alleged that the wisdom of holding Lizzie for the crime is fully borne out by the testimony. She is said to be the vie tim of Lereditary traits which render her almost unaccountable for her actions. There isu't any doubt whatever that Mrs, Churchill has cousiderable in her head. She did not see a ghost while Lizzie was down there, but it 18 quite reason able to suppose she heard a voice in the night, and it may come out before this case is ended that Lizzie talked in her sleep.
See moreSee less
The matron is known to have been made ill by her contact with Lizzie and there is no doubt that she has firm con victions relative to lLizzie's position in this matter. Lizzie Borden comes rightly by any singularity of disposition. Her mother died from the effects of a bad temper.
The report recounts testimony before the grand jury, including Capt. Smalley's account of a Fall River man's claims about a quarrel in the Borden family, which the man later denied making. It also includes an unverified anecdote about Lizzie's mother's fatal temper and a prediction about Lizzie and Emma's future conduct.
The Providence News · 18 November 1892 · page 6
She had a big flower pot on the st.es outside which she wanted moved, an she cnillml to her husband to come and move it. He was reading at the time, and said that he would eome as soon as he finished, “You needn’t come,’”’ shouted Mrs, Borden, and she moved the plant herself. In twenty-four hours she was dead, Some time before her death and when, perhaps, there was an indication of the shadow, she is said to have remarked to a friend: *lf there is another woman brought into this house Emma will make her life a perfect hell, and I guess when ‘Liz’ grows up she will help her.” The jury went to Fall River at 1 o’clock to view the premises, and will finish the investigation in that city, Among the witnesses examined this morning was Capt, Smallev, of the New Bedford overseers of the poor, who told bis story of the Fall River man, who re lated to him what Andrew Borden is al leged to have told him about the quarrel in the Borden family, This man has siuce denied that he made any such statement about the Bor deus contending that it was another fam ily., But Capt.
See moreSee less
Smalley is positive as to the correctness of his statement.
This weekly news digest briefly notes that Lizzie Borden's murder trial is expected to take place in January at Taunton, Massachusetts, among many other unrelated national and international news items. The mention is a single-line blurb within a broad roundup of current events.
The Washington Bee · 19 November 1892 · page 1
It is thought the Brooklyn Navy Yard foice f workmen will be largely in ereahed at once. U o&t Mr. Gilroy $3,343.56 to become Mayor of New York, according to his sworn statement. It is claimed by the friends of Senator Quay I hat his re-election as United States ."-ena'or is assured. It is probable that Lizzie Borden's mur der trial will take place in January at jx'titow, Mass. The evidence at the second trial of the negro Lingo, in Camden, N. J.t has been unfavorable to the defence. Governor Brown, of Maryland, has fixed December 30 for the execution of the fight niuiderers of Dr.
See moreSee less
J. H. Hill. After the big naval review at New Yoik. Uncle Sam will send a few of his wai.ships to cruise in the Mediterranean, Parnell's executors will publish a por tion of his private political documents with the idea of influencing Home Rule debates. Captain Deusmore, for many years chief usher at the White House, is lying at the point of death at his residence in Washington. The Ruasian committee appointed to
The article discusses public uncertainty over Lizzie Borden's guilt after her August hearing ended inconclusively, noting she will be judged by community opinion regardless of the verdict. It also reports that a phrenologist has offered his reading of her head and character, despite not knowing her identity.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 19 November 1892 · page 6
LIZZIE BOEDER HEAD. A. Phrenologist Gives His Verdict Upon the Accused. Ha Did Nt Know Her Namt-Tk Sctaaea a Applied to All Affairs of Ufa "Getting Married, and Keep ing Harried.1 'Probably guilty" was tae judicial finding of the court convened last Aug ust for the trial ef Lizzie Borden. "Probably guilty," and not a shred of unimpeachable evidence against her in nocence. Two weeks af ingenious efforts to extort some sign of gmlt from a wo man whose stolid indifference and superb unnatural self-possession have been the most damaging witnesses against her, produced no proof of murder.
See moreSee less
But her trial by jury, to bo held the last week in Hbvembsr, may discover new and con clusive evidence for or against ber. If it does net, Lizzie Uordeu, whether freed or convicted, will be a doomed woman. "Not guilty," and while she lives she must walk alone, suspected by her townspeople of the crime for which she she was on trial, shunned and whispered about by women who say: "She was tried for the murder of father and mothar you know. They acquitted her, but " "Guilty," and half the public will be horrorstruck over the execution of a prisoner innocent of one of the most fearful charges in the raccnt history ef crime.
The grand jury in the Borden case adjourned until December 1 without returning a true bill against Lizzie Borden for murder. No further details are given.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 21 November 1892 · page 1
Brooklyn Briefs. The pupils of the Bank street school have started a subscription among themselves and agree to give as much as they can each month until enough has been secured to purchase a 24 foot United States flag and a staff for their school building. The funeral of James Horigan, Sr, aged 65, who died Saturday evening after a short illness, took place from his late residence, corner of Bank and South Leonard streets, at 2:30 this after noon with services in St Patrick's church, of which the deceased was a faithful member and constant attendant.
See moreSee less
He leaves two sons, James Jr, and Timothy Horigan, both well known business men in the Brooklyn district. The interment was in St Joseph's cemetery. A. Feat of Cossack Horse. In the mines of the Altai, in Liberia, gold is found in fair quantities. A con voy of about sixteen thousand pounds of the pure metal was lately being transported across the wide plain watered by the Irtish, when suddenly a numerous band of highwaymen broke from an ambush and opened firo on the caravan. Tho captain saw that his force was too small to make a success ful stand and gave orders to give the horses the spurs and try to escape. The robbers, having failed to blockade the road in any way, in vain forced their horses. The Cossacks escaped and were greatly praised for their rapidity oi movement when they arrived at the government at Omsk to deliver their treasure. The Borden Case. Taunton, Mass, Nov 21 The grand jury in the Borden case has adjourned until December 1, without finding a true bill against Lizzie Borden for murder.
The grand jury investigating Lizzie Borden adjourned until December 1st without returning an indictment. Speculation abounds about whether this means more evidence is being sought or that the case may be dropped entirely.
The Providence News · 21 November 1892 · page 1
NO REPORT MADE TO-DAY
NOREPORT MADE TO-DAY Lizzie Borden May Yet Escape Indictment and Trial, THE GRAND JURY ADJOURNED Until December Ist, and Nobody Knows What the Singular Proceeding Means
The grand jury investigating Lizzie Borden unexpectedly adjourned until December 1 instead of issuing an indictment, after Attorney General Pillsbury gave reasons for leaving the case open. Speculation grows about a farm worker's possible involvement and an accessory to the crime, with public opinion reportedly shifting in Lizzie's favor.
The Providence News · 22 November 1892 · page 1
FALL RIVER, Mass.,, Nov. 22 —Atty.- Gen. Pillsbury caused a surprise yester day in the case of the government ag.inst Lizzie A. Borden. Saturday the presentation of the gov ernment's case was practically finished. Ninety-four witnesses had given tneir testimony, and four minor oues were to be head. With their evideace finished
The report describes more thorough grand jury testimony than given at the preliminary hearing, including Bridget Sullivan's account of a mysteriously emptied kettle and dying fire shortly after the murder. It also covers Fall River's surprise at the grand jury's dismissal until December 1 and mentions a relative, Orrin Gardner, questioned by the jury.
The Providence News · 22 November 1892 · page 1
Think of the Grand Jury's Move. FALL RIVER, Nov. 22.~The people of Fall River, who have followed every movemeut in the Borden case from the begiuning, do not know what to make of the dismissal of tne grand jury until
The grand jury's surprise adjournment until December fuels competing theories—some believe it signals evidence of Lizzie's innocence, others suspect investigators are building a case against a possible accomplice. District Attorney Knowlton summoned defense lawyer Jennings to Taunton, exciting much public curiosity and comment from courthouse officials who call the delay unprecedented.
The Providence News · 22 November 1892 · page 1
OPINION IN THIS CITY, The Adjournment is Unprecedented in Court Procedure, The prevaiiing opinion among the court house officials in this city 1s that the Fa!l River authorities could not bring sufficient evidence against lizzie Borden to convince the grand jury of her implieatiou in the crime. The action of the jury in adjourning uontil a later date for a further consideration of the case is pronounced unpre edented in the anoals of court history and gossip, as far as memory serves them. To some the theory that the andjournment was taken to allow
The Taunton grand jury adjourned until December without reaching a decision on the Borden case, leaving no new information for public speculation. The editorial argues this delay will further sway public opinion in favor of Lizzie Borden, criticizing the prosecution's halting approach and dismissing information from a private detective as unreliable.
The Providence News · 22 November 1892 · page 4
THE BORDEN CASE, The action of the Taunton grand jury, : n adjouring to December | without oC ming to a decision respecting the Bor
This editorial argues that the prosecution has failed to produce evidence sufficient to indict Lizzie Borden, calling the government's case weak and its officials slow to act. It criticizes the grand jury's indecision and suggests belief in her guilt rests more on assumption than demonstrated fact.
The Providence News · 22 November 1892 · page 4
prosecution and the delay in their ful fillment, It is perfectly plain that “he pathway to an indictment and conviction of Miss Borden is not found to be as straight and as easy to travel as the slothful of ficials, who did not awake to the awful gravity of the erime they were charged with avenging until the scent wig three days old, at first seemed to imagine, There is such a thing as the Jinjustice of justice, and unless somevidence of solf-reliant aetion shall soon be shown by the Mussachusetts officials who are groping about for evidence that will justify the trial of Lizzie Borden it will be apparent that this is an aggravated example of it,
The grand jury in Taunton, Mass., considering charges against Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother, has postponed its session until December 1. This surprising delay is explained by rumors that police have found a new lead and may arrest additional suspects as accomplices.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 23 November 1892 · page 4
Jury, welche sich mit der Anklage gegen Lizzie Borden, die der Ermordung ih res Baiers und ihrer Stiefmutter angeschul digt ist. bejchäsligte, bis zum 1. Dezember einlassen worden. Es hat Dies allgemein überrascht, und mau kann es sich nur dadurch
The passage mentions Mrs. McGuirk, a newspaper woman who once worked with Lizzie Borden in a Fall River charity mission, defending her innocence. McGuirk reportedly wrote a strong letter to a New York paper arguing Borden could no more have committed the murders than an angel could.
The Record-Visitor · 23 November 1892 · page 3
for generations, with little plmpofin: and luxury, gives the daughters sue firm, beantiful figures. If today a seulp tor were fo lmg in Ameriea for the model of the Venus of Milo, he wonld be more apt to find it among the colored girls than among the white ones, Mre. McGuirk, that able and enthnsi astic newspaper woman, knew Lizzie Borden some years ago. Both were as wociated in the fruit and flower mission ot Fall River, Mre. MeGuirk believes Lizzie Borden conld no more have murdered her father and stepmother than an angel conld, and she has writ ten & powerfal letter to the New York
The report discusses the Taunton grand jury's postponement of a verdict against Lizzie Borden, suggesting it indicates weakness in the government's case. It dismisses earlier theories like the 'wild-eyed man' and the Portuguese suspect as already discredited speculation.
Pawtucket Tribune · 23 November 1892 · page 1
SOME GREAT GUESSING
Attorney General Pillsbury is not satis fied with the state’s ease, He is a carcful man and well kl&)\!’l what the resuit would be if his Case Was Weak lu Spots, The stuteinent that v e graod jury, if left to themnsclves, would have brought in an indictinent against Lizzie Borden is ludicrous. How does any one know they wouldt Do grand jurors generally tell their indings to the public? Not a bit of It; that's all conjecture, I he failure to find a true bill is taken in another way, and that is that they are peckiug to give the impression that some one else is being looked for in order to run down points ou the Miss Borden end, This ruse is probably as vear to their
The report dismisses supposed new clues like the "Wild-Eyed Man" and the Portuguese suspect as already investigated and discredited months earlier, quoting Marshal Hilliard that every clue was "worked for all it was worth." It also notes the unusual move of Attorney General Pillsbury personally addressing the grand jury, and Colonel Adams's continued belief in Lizzie Borden's innocence, predicting any trial would not occur until January.
Pawtucket Tribune · 23 November 1892 · page 1
was innocent, He said Le did not know of any myste rlons young man who was being shadowed becausc he visited the Borden residence, Then sgain, he said that the burzlar story was in the famous McHeury ~tory, which had been declared a tissue of lies, even by she paper that prinved it, He thought the trial would not come oft antil January in event of an indictment
A report claims that a majority of the Taunton grand jury favor acquitting Lizzie Borden, with ten of the jurors reportedly believing there isn't enough evidence to indict. The recess is said to be a stall tactic to let prosecutors find more witnesses, including Henry Trickey and Detective McHenry, who cannot currently be located.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Providence News · 23 November 1892 · page 7
BELIEVE HER INNOCENT
TAUNTON, Nov. 23 It is stated here now that the true reason why the grand “Jjury engaged on the Borden case was given a recess until Dec. 1, was because a majority of the members were in favor of Lizzie's acquital, It is given out quietly in official circles that ten of the jury believed that not enough evidence had been heard to find au indictment. The stave-off was given to enable the prosecution to hustle around and secure witnesses they claim to have. An active search is now going on for Heunry G.
See moreSee less
Trickey and Dotective MeHenry, but neither can be found, McHenry 18 Out of Town, A report was receivid this «fternoon stating that the grand jury in the DBor d'n case were looking tor Detective K. D. McHenry of this city. A reporter called at Mr. McHenry's plice of business at 26 College street and was told that McHenry was in New York ad the time of his reurn is indefinite, Nothing farther ¢ uld be learned.
The grand jury considering the Lizzie Borden case has been dismissed until December, surprising the public. Rumors suggest officers are seeking additional evidence to secure more than one indictment.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 24 November 1892 · page 5
DAHOMEY ANS ROUTED. Paris, Nov. 21. A dispatch from Porto Nova states that the French fmnna havA entered Abomev. the capital of Dahomey without meeting anv opposition, iiin? uenaDzin nas vanished and the French are ln full possesion of the capital. The Lizzie Borden Case.
A satirical column item reacts to reports that Lizzie Borden is thought insane because she alternates between smiling and weeping. The writer mocks this reasoning, suggesting it would unfairly brand most women as insane.
The Globe-Republican · 25 November 1892 · page 6
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Fall River police are trying hard to compel Private Detective McHenry to testify before the grand jury in the Borden case, but he remains out of state due to separate criminal proceedings against him. Authorities reportedly distrust McHenry, suspecting he deceived Marshal Hilliard about evidence used to justify Lizzie Borden's arrest, and refused to pay him until his claims were verified before the grand jury.
The Evening Herald · 25 November 1892 · page 3
AFTER DETECTIVE M'HENRY.
II 1. Hfllua; vonfilll lu Tn.tlfy B f.ira tha Grand Jury In tb 11 n!n C-t-o. Providinci, K. L, Nov. 25. The Fall River police, under the direction of Mar shal Htlllard, are making desperate at tempts to Induce Private Detective Mc Ueury to go before the grand jury in tho Lizzie Borden murder case. McHenry remains ,uway from this State, whsre criminal proceedings have been Instituted against htm by a Boston diamond broker nuined Barrett. It Is believed he has been deceiving Marshal Milliard all through and thut it was upon alleged evidence which he claimed to hava thut tho arrsst of the unfortunate Borden girl was made.
See moreSee less
The Fall Itlver authorities distrusted Mclleiiry aud refused to pay for bis work ou the Borden case until they mw the evidence materialize before the grand jury. On account ot the unpaid bill lie Heury went to New York und refused to appear at Taunton. Leading attorneys and judges are puzsled over the adjournment of the grand jury without detluite action la the
A report from Taunton claims the Massachusetts attorney general has ordered the district attorney to halt proceedings, fueling belief that the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden when it reconvenes December 1. The piece cites the jury's earlier recess and lack of new evidence, including failed poison and drugstore theories, as grounds for the rumor that she will soon be freed.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Providence News · 25 November 1892 · page 1
SHUT OFF! This Is the Order Given By the Attorney General TO THE DIST.-ATTORNEY And It May Result in Setting Free Miss Lizzie Borden
ISPECIAL TO THE NEWS.) TAUNTON, Nov, 25.—1 t is now believed that l.izzie Borden will be a free woman before Dec. 1. It is stated that the government has failed to secure the new evidence it ex pected and that the grand jury will not return an indictment, So strong has the feeling grown that Miss Borden 1s to be released during the past twelve hours, that it has become generally accepted as a fact in many cir cles, It is now known that the grand jury was given a recess because it showed indi cations of refusing to find an indictment against the girl on the evidence submit ted to it This fact is believed to be the ground gork of the present report that Miss Bor den is to be freed.
See moreSee less
v The staterthent of Mr, Jennings from the first, that his client was not guilty, scems to have been borne out by the facts, snd he knew more about the affair than ~hat was told him by that client, and by her friends. Lizzie didn’t get what she wanted it she did go to That drug store, and there , vas no poison in the system of the victims, Every theory was worked for all it was worth, and not a particle of strength for the government case came from it, apd the groping in the dark continued right along, with painful regularity. The attorney general saw that there was no use in the government pursuing this line any further. On the dav that the grand jury went to Fall River he told Mr. Knowlton to “shut off,” and the order was obeyed at once. Black Dress Goods Are the most satisfactory in the long run. We have a good line Black Crepons at isc¢. and £l,OO, Are desirable. J. K. Joxgs & Co., 20 10 20 Arcade,
A report from Taunton says the grand jury is widely believed to be unlikely to indict Lizzie Borden for her father's murder, though no juror has confirmed this. It notes no significant new evidence has emerged, leaving about a week for prosecutors to find more before the jury's term ends.
Morning Journal and Courier · 26 November 1892 · page 3
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL Everything Looks Favorable for Her Discharge by the Jury. Taunton, Mass., Nov. 25. The Impres sion prevails that the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for the mnrder of her father, Andrew Borden, bnt the public is no more certain of this than it was when the case first went into the hands of the j ary, only by inference, since no member of that body has expressed himself in any way. It is quite certain, however, that no new evidence of any importance has been given before the jury and that proceedings are delayed because the evidence is not con sidered sufficient to warrant the finding of an indictment.
See moreSee less
There is yet a week nearly for unearthing fresh evidence, and in that time enough may be gathered to make things assume an entirely different aspect. It is a faot, however, that as conditions are now the chances for Miss Borden's early release from confinement are bright. If she is indicted and the jury at that trial fail to oonviot, there would be little hope of ever bringing her before the court again, even though she should be charged the next time with murdering the other member of the family, whose name was not mentioned in the warrant for her arreBt. If the grand jury sets her free it does not mean that she is forever clear of any future action of that body, bnt on the contrary, she can be hauled up any time on a new charge, provided there is at that time fresh and convincing evi dence against her. It is felt that the at torney general realizes that it would be better for all concerned to make no error of judgment now, even at the risk of conjuring up false appearances and to place Miss Borden in a position where she will not be beyond the reach of j ustice. The probabilities are strongly in favor of no bill.
The report discusses the pending grand jury decision on indicting Lizzie Borden, noting insufficient evidence so far but a week remaining for new findings. It predicts that the probabilities favor no indictment, while explaining the legal implications of either outcome.
Morning Journal and Courier · 26 November 1892 · page 3
The report states that the grand jury considering the murder case against Lizzie Borden seems unlikely to indict her, as no significant new evidence has been presented. It notes that proceedings are delayed because the existing testimony is deemed insufficient for a true bill, though time remains for new evidence to emerge.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 26 November 1892 · page 1
MISS BORDEN'S CHANCES
Taunton, Mass., Nov. 20. The im pression prevails that the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father. Andrew Borden, but the public is no more certain of this than it was when the case first went into the hands of the jury, only by inference. since no member of that body has ex pressed himself in any way. ' It is quite certain, however, that nc new evidence of any importance has been given before the jury and that pro ceedings are delayed because the evidence is not considered sufficient to warrant the finding of an indictment.
See moreSee less
There is yet a week nearly for unearth ing fresh evidence and in that time enough may be gathered to make things assume an entirely different aspect. It is a fact, however, that as conditions are now the chances for Miss Borden's early release from confinement are bright. If she is indicted and the jury at the trial fail to convict, there would be little hope of ever bringing her before the court again, even though she should be charged the next time with murdering the other member of the family, whose name was not mentioned In the warrant for her arrest. If the grand jury sets her free it does not mean that she is forever cleared of any future action of the body, but on the contrary, she can bo hauled up at any time on a new charge provided there is at the time fresh and convincing evidence against her. It is felt that the Attorney-General realizes that it would be better for all concerned to make no error of judgment now, even at the risk of conjuring up false appearances, and to place Miss Bor den In a position where she will not be beyond the reach of Justice. The probabilities are strongly in favor of no bill.
The grand jury investigating the Lizzie Borden case has been dismissed temporarily. It is believed that important developments are forthcoming in the case.
The Atchison Blade · 26 November 1892 · page 1
Lizzie Borden case have been dis missed temporarily, and it is believed that there are important develop ments. There was a grand rush of the Homestead strikers to get their old positions back yesterday, but only a small number of them were successful. A federal grand jury has returned a number of indictments against county officers in Arkansas, charging that they appoia^ed only Democrats to be judges of election. When the people find out that a man is mean at home they don’t care ho t good he professes to be at church.
A dispatch from Taunton reports strong indications that the Grand Jury will return 'no bill' against Lizzie Borden due to insufficient evidence. The report explains the legal implications of such a decision versus an indictment followed by acquittal.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
New-York Tribune · 26 November 1892 · page 2
THE BORDEN MURDER CASE
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The grand jury investigating the Lizzie Borden case has been dismissed temporarily. Observers believe important developments are expected to follow.
Baxter Springs News · 26 November 1892 · page 6
Srinter under the Cleveland administra ion. 7 Sctebistexd'ST Hosbtshkll, of the Philadelphia mint, denies the circulated report that he has allowed anyone to take any of the world's fair souvenir coins. It is said that Cleveland is opposed to Murphy as senator from New York, and and that he asked him to withdraw in favor of Whitney. The grand jury investigating the Lizzie Borden case has been dismissed temporarily, and it is believed that there are important developments.
A special dispatch reports that Lizzie Borden will not be indicted by the grand jury for the murders of her father and stepmother, predicting she will soon be a free woman. It claims the evidence presented was essentially the same as at the earlier Fall River hearing and insufficient for indictment.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Daily Kennebec Journal · 26 November 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TO GO FREE.
Reported that Lizzie Borden Will Not be Indicted by Grand Jury.
See moreSee less
Boston, Nov. 25.—A special from Taunton to the Herald says, "Lizzie Borden will not be indicted by the grand jury for the murder of her father and step-mother.
In another week, without any doubt, she will be a free woman and the whole miserable pretence of a case against her will be ended.
The evidence laid before the grand jury was essentially the same as that produced at the hearing in Fall River and is was not deemed sufficient to warrant the finding of an indictment."
Reports from Taunton and Boston say the grand jury is widely expected to return no indictment against Lizzie Borden for her father's murder, as no significant new evidence has emerged. The article notes uncertainty remains and explains the legal implications of an indictment versus no bill.
The Portland Daily Press · 26 November 1892 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN MAY BE FREED.
Taunton, Mass., November 25.—The impression prevails that the grand jury will not indiet Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father, Andrew Borden, but the public is no more certain of this than it was when the case first went into the hands of the jury, except by infer ence, since no member of that body has expressed himself in any way. It is quite certain, however, that no new evi dence of any importance has been given before the jury and that the proceedings were delayed because the evidence was not considered sufficient to warrant the finding of an indictment. There is yet nearly a week for unearthing fresh evi dence and in that time enough maybe gathered to make things assume an en
A brief dispatch from Boston reports that Taunton sources claim the grand jury will decide not to indict Lizzie Borden. This is presented as speculation ahead of the grand jury's actual decision.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
St. Paul Daily Globe · 26 November 1892 · page 1
Boston, Nov. Nov. 25.— Tauntou specials declare that the grand jury will find "no bill" against Lizzie Borden.
A special dispatch to the Boston Herald from Taunton, Massachusetts states that the grand jury will find 'no bill' against Lizzie Borden. This suggests the case against her would be dropped without trial.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The State Chronicle · 26 November 1892 · page 1
Sf.atti.k. Washington. Nov. 25. The overland west bouDd traiu on the North ern Pacific railroad was held up last evening near Hot Springs by three masked men. who robbed all of the male n.assenL'ers in the Pullman sleeper. Ladies were not molested. Tha robbers secured about 1200, nearly all from one pas senger. No Hill Against Lizzie Borden. Bv Teleitraph to State Chronicle. Boston Nov. 25. A special to the Herald from Taunton Mass., states that tha grand jury will find "no bill" against Lizzie Borden.
Taunton newspaper specials report that the grand jury will return 'no bill' against Lizzie Borden. This forecast proved incorrect, as the grand jury later indicted her.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Evening World · 26 November 1892 · page 2
FAVORABLE TO LIZZIE BORDEN. Declarations tbat the Grand Jury Will Not Indict Hor. nv associated rr. 1 Hostov. Nov. as. Taunton specials to tho Iltralrt an& Journal clec'.nro tbnt the Urand Jury will Und "no bill" ngalnst Uzzlo Borden.
The Taunton correspondent reports that the impression prevails the Grand Jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for her father's murder, citing a lack of significant new evidence. The piece also speculates on the legal complications of double jeopardy should she later be tried for her stepmother's murder.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Sun · 26 November 1892 · page 5
MilXut Indict I.lrIe llorltrn. Taunton, Mass.. Nov. 25.-The Impression prevails that the Grand Jury will not Indict Lizzie Borden for the muidor of her father. It is qulto certain, however, that no nowevl dencoof any importance has beeneivon be fore the jury, and the procoedlncs are delayed because tho evidence Is not eoiisidercd sulll (lent to Viiirrunttha finding of an Indictment. If bhn Is udh'ti'il. and a jury fails to conviel. it woiilil bediillciiltto try her for Mllinc hei htopmother. even in nso new eviili-nco should be discovered. It tho Grand Jury sets her free, it means that sho may bo rearrested at any time, Wurir Is O'Connor und UN Wlirrllnrrn r
A report from Taunton states that the grand jury considering the murder of Andrew Borden has not been given significant new evidence, leading to speculation that it will not indict Lizzie Borden. The article notes there is still time for new evidence to emerge before the jury's session ends.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Evening Herald · 26 November 1892 · page 3
MISS BORDEN'S CHANGES Not Thought That the Grand Jury Will Indict Her.
nn entirely diffei ullferent aspect. It L.a 'tJ'T.fl"' .th,"t as conditions are now tho chances for Mis Borden's early release from confinement are right. If she is indicted and the jury at the trial fail to convict, there would be little hope of ever britiKlnir her bofore the court again, even though she should be charged the next time wltu murdering the other member of the family, whose uamo was not mentioned in the warrant for her arrest. If the grand jury sets ber free it does not mean that she is forever cleared of any future action of the body, but on the coutrary, she can be hauled up at any time on a new charge provided there Is lit the time frushaud convincing evidence Hgaiust her.
See moreSee less
It is felt that the Attornoy General realises that it would be better for all concerned to make no error of judgment now, even ut the risk of conjuring up false appearances, and to place .Miss Bor den in a position where she will not bo beyond the reach of justice. The probabilities are strongly iu favor of no bill.
A Taunton newspaper dispatch reports that the grand jury is expected to return 'no bill' against Lizzie Borden. This would mean no formal charges would be brought against her.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Pittsburg Dispatch · 26 November 1892 · page 7
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The grand jury investigating Lizzie Borden unexpectedly took a ten-day recess just as a decision was anticipated, fueling wild speculation about indictments of her and possible accomplices. By the report's end, opinion had shifted toward believing the evidence was too weak for prompt action, suggesting 'no bill' was likely.
Pawtucket Tribune · 26 November 1892 · page 1
EXPECTED FROM JURY IN THE BORDEN CASE. TRICKEY IS MENTIONED. IN A SENSATIONAL RUMOR OF A GRAND JURY INDICTMENT.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
This report discusses speculation that the grand jury may return 'no bill' against Lizzie Borden, reasoning that prosecutors doubt their ability to convict at trial. It also covers rumors that reporter Henry Trickey, tied to a fake story about the case, may be indicted for tampering with an official, and notes detective McHenry's denial that he fled to New York to avoid legal proceedings.
Pawtucket Tribune · 26 November 1892 · page 1
TRICKEY IS MENTIONED
this city yesterday, says The Post, that | Heunry G, Trickey, the reporter identified | with the Borden-Mcllenry ake, had been indicted for litel by the present gran ! | jury inthis civy, It has been reporie l also, that Mr. T'rickey and Detective Me- | Henry had been for some time together in | New York, cich secking to avoid lezal | proceedings—=possibly belngeatlobapon to f lA'.\(il)’ belore the grand jary at Uruauton, | What littleean be leavue L upon th s poiat will be found in the dispatches below: !
See moreSee less
A Story from Providence, w PROVIDENCE, Nov. 23, —Au evening paper | publisi e< the following: ‘ It 1s within probability that the “seqnels™ to the grand jury hearing in Lizzie Borden's case may inclade the andictment of a well known newspaper man on the charge of tome pering with an ofileial in the employ of the government, This is an npshot that people on the tnside of the sensation have been speoi. lating upon ever since a Boston daly eno out with an alleged expose of the ovidence The whole of the “revelation™ was found to be a fake, and soon atrcr ity appearance, the proseenting aunthori ties at Fall River decided that the perpeirator should suffer, Accordingly, us it is ramored, a formal fndietment of the author wasap. proved of, and the purpose formed toak the srand Jury to bring a bill against him, Whether it is the grand jury whoe sitting was reeently interrupted or another whicl is to return the finding and sanction the reporis er's arrest is not stated explicitly. Meltenry Heurvd From.
A newspaper editorial comments that recent news suggests predictions of many observers may be vindicated regarding the Borden case. It states that if the grand jury fails to indict Lizzie Borden for her father's murder, many people who have doubted her guilt will feel vindicated.
The Providence News · 26 November 1892 · page 4
~ THE news yesterday a 8 : indicated that the expectations and predictions of a large majority of people . who have carefully followed the course ! *m affair may be expected to e ustified. If the grand jury fails to dic ie Borden for the murder of her father there will be a very large 0 number of fervent amens uttered by ‘people who have continued to believe
A satirical article about ready-made sermons jokes that a Pawtucket preacher could use his pulpit to complain about many topics, including that Massachusetts's grand jury was keeping Lizzie Borden in jail without evidence against her. The piece is primarily about commercial sermon-writing services, with the Borden reference used only as a rhetorical aside.
The Providence News · 26 November 1892 · page 4
Lizzie Borden in jail without any evi dence against her; he could buck agalnst the Yalo eleven and the 30,000 foolish people who deserted the church to see the Thanksgiving day game ; he could even reach out to Boston and hold up bis hands and denounce the growing popularity of Zola. All this he conld do and yet feel secure from attack. The harvest is ripe and this Pawtucket preacher wounld be the proper person to run the mowing machine, But, oh the laggard! he goes 1o the Philadelphia sermon store and buys, mavhap, “The Glospel in the
A dispatch from Taunton, Massachusetts claims the grand jury will return 'no bill' against Lizzie Borden, who had been arrested for murdering her father and mother. The report calls the earlier preliminary hearing evidence circumstantial.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · 26 November 1892 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN. A Likelihood That She Will Never be Convicted of Murdering Her Father. Boston, Nov. 20. A special to the Herald from Taunton, Mass., de
The report states that public impression favors the grand jury returning no indictment against Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father and stepmother, though no jury member has confirmed this. It notes the attorney general may proceed cautiously to avoid errors, even if it creates false impressions.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 27 November 1892 · page 1
FAVOR NO BILL
About the Lizzie Burden Case. T.\rxro\, Mass.. Nov. 'JO.— The inn Dression prevails that the grand jury will noi indict Lizzie Borden for the murder ot her father and Mrs. Borden, but tho public is no more certain of this than it wns when the case first went into the hands of the jury, only by in ference, since no member of that boily has expressed himself in any way. It is felt that the attorney general real izes that it would be better for all con cerned to make no error in judgment now, even at the risk of conjuring up false appearances, and to place Miss Borden in v position where she will not be beyond tlie reach of justice.
See moreSee less
Tha probabilities are strongly in favor of no bill.
The item reports that the grand jury is considering the Lizzie Borden case but that 'reliable' newspapermen predict it will not return a true bill against her for killing her father and mother. This reflects speculation during the investigation phase before formal charges were decided.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 27 November 1892 · page 2
Borden case bes re it; but “relia ble” newspaper men say that the body will hardly bring in a true bill against her for killing her
The report states that the latest news indicates the Grand Jury will decline to indict Lizzie Borden for her parents' murder, citing insufficient evidence. It notes the evidence presented was the same as at the Fall River hearing, with only circumstantial factors like her presence in the house and family discord.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Times · 27 November 1892 · page 4
Latest reports from the Borden case are to the effect that the Grand Jury will not indict her for the murder of hé&r parents, and that in another week she will be free. The evidence laid before the Grand Jury was essentially the same as that produced at the hearing in Fall River, and it was not deemed sufficient by the State's attorney to warrant the finding of an indictment, There is not one scintilla of evidence to prove that Lizzie Borden is guflty, beyond the fact
A grand juror leaked to a Providence source that evidence presented was sufficient to warrant an indictment against Lizzie Borden, despite public belief that no indictment would come. The juror said the grand jury adjourned until December 1 at the Attorney General's request to properly frame the indictment, and that no other indictments were expected.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 29 November 1892 · page 1
SHE MAY BE INDICTED. One ot the Jurymen in the Borden Case Is Persuaded to Talk. Providkn! k. Nov. ‘is.—Public indigna tion is at a high pitch over the delay in the grand jury w ork in the Lizzie Borden case, and the hundreds of rumor* which have gained currency since the celebrated mur der mystery has been “hung up" have only served to further the excitement m South ern New England. The common belief i* that there will be no indictment again*! the unfortunate woman, hut this opinion doe* not teem to l«e founded upon anything that has developed from the hearing Ih» fore tin grand jury.
See moreSee less
A member of that jury was found in Bris tol county. In response to some adroit questioning by a neighbor with whom the juror had been on intimate terms for many years he “leaked" sufficient!} to showthat theiM witnesses w ho appeared before them had uncovered enough in the great my stery to warrant an indictment. To the question “Why did you adjourn then until Decem ber l?” the juror admitted that it was at the request of Attorney General Pillsluiry . Then he said that the attorney general had impressed upon the grand jury the neces sity of framing an indictment that would hold water when presented to the court. The juror then *md that the law officers would require all of the ten days for the purpose of writing the indictment. Farther the juror said that there would be no indictment except that against Lizzie Borden.
The report describes a flurry of contradictory rumors after the grand jury adjourned without issuing an indictment in the Lizzie Borden case, including claims that Borden and others might be charged, that she would go free, and that key figures were missing. It highlights an alleged disagreement between District Attorney Knowlton and Attorney General Pillsbury over handling the prosecution.
The Providence News · 29 November 1892 · page 1
THE MYSTERY DEEPENS.
Additional Developments in the Cele brated Case May be Expected. [{SPECIAL TO THE NEWS.) FALL RIvER, Nov, 29.—Since the grand jury adjourned without reporting on the case of Miss Lizzie Borden numerous rumors have been spread about concern ing the affair that Miss Borden and others would be indicted, perhaps Heury G. Trickey and Edwin D. McHenry—that Miss Borden would go free—that I'rickey and McHeury were missing—that John V. Morse cannot be found—and now it is sald that District Attorney Knowlton and Atworney General Pillsbury cannot
The report notes disagreement among officials over the Borden grand jury proceedings at Taunton, questioning why Attorney-General Pillsbury personally appeared if no indictment was sought. It also mentions police tracking John V. Morse's whereabouts to New Bedford, suggesting he may have been in Dartmouth.
The Providence News · 29 November 1892 · page 1
Jurymen to their homes. When the grand jury again convenes, the fublio may well exfnct, additional developments, which will excite further curiosity concerning the conduct of the case from the government’'s side. Watch the Tauoton jJail for the next few days, and take notes on Miss Borden’s visitors, particularly those outside of her counsel and circle of friends. Whereabouts of Morse, ISPECIAL TO THE NEWS. |
A newspaper opinion roundup includes a quip suggesting Lizzie Borden, held for months under a presumption of guilt, will likely be freed under a presumption of innocence. It sarcastically suggests her accusers should then be jailed as 'knaves'.
The Providence News · 29 November 1892 · page 4
After months of imprisonment on a theory of “‘probnbly guilty” Miss Lizzie Borden is likely to be released on a ny pothesis of “trobnblv not guilty.” When she walks out her accusers should take
A report from Taunton, Mass. states the prevailing impression is that the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for her father's murder, though no juror has spoken publicly. The piece suggests prosecutors prefer caution now while keeping her within reach of justice, with probabilities favoring 'no bill.'
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Columbus Journal · 30 November 1892 · page 2
WILL LIKELY BE ACQUI TTED. The General Opinion that Lizzie ISordeu Will not Ve 1'unUhed. Tauxtox, Mass., Nov. 2S. The im pression prevails that the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father, Andrew Borden, but the public is more cer tain of this than it was when the case first went into the hands of the jury, only by inference, since no member of that body has expressed himself in any way. It is felt that the Attorney General realizes that it would be bet ter for all concerned to make no error in judgment now, even at the risk of conjuring up false appearances and to place Miss Boydcn in a position where she will not be beyond the reach of justice.
See moreSee less
The probabilities are strongly in favor of no bill.
The newspaper argues that the case against Lizzie Borden is flimsy and predicts the grand jury will not indict her, calling the prosecution an unjust persecution of a defenseless woman. It criticizes the Fall River authorities and Judge Blaisdell for pursuing the case despite weak evidence.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Weekly Union · 30 November 1892 · page 4
one hag yet been offered. CRER R RSI The Treatment of Lizzie Borden. From all indications at this time it is safe to say there will be no indictment found against Lizzie Borden for the mur der of her father and mother at Fall River, and, as the dispatches say in another week, without any doubt, she will be a free woman, and the whole miserable pretense of a case against her will be ended. In the judgment of THE UNION, a more miserable 1 and unholy warfare was never waged agalnst a defenseless woman.
See moreSee less
The author fties at Fall River were not able to dis cover who the murderer was, and as Liz zle Borden happened to be in the house they began a monstrous effort to make a case against her. We stated after the evi dence was put in before the judge that no greater outrage was ever committed than to hold her by the evidence. Without a doubt this voiced, the sentiments
A newspaper miscellany column quotes the New York Herald suggesting Lizzie Borden, held for months on a theory of 'probably guilty,' may soon be released under a new view of 'probably not guilty.' It sarcastically suggests her accusers should then be judged 'probably knaves' and eventually 'only fools.'
Weekly Union · 30 November 1892 · page 4
——— R ————. The New York Herald forcibiy says: “Affer months of imprisonment oa a theory of ‘probably gullty’ Miss Lizzie Borden is likely to bereleased on a hypoth
The report states that the grand jury considering the murder case against Lizzie Borden appears unlikely to return an indictment, based on inference since jurors have not spoken publicly. It notes no significant new evidence has emerged and suggests her prospects for release are favorable, though a week remains for more evidence to surface.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Weekly Union · 30 November 1892 · page 2
TAUNTON, MASS., Nov. 25.—The impres slon prevails that the grand jury will not convict Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father,Andrew J. Borden,but the pub lic 13 mo more certain of this than it was when the case first went into the hands of the jury, only by inference, since no mem ber of that body bas expressed himself in any way. 1t is quite certain, however, that no new evidence of any importance bas been given before the jury and that the proceedings are delayed because the ¢vidence 1s not con sidered sufficient to warrant the finding of anindictment. There is yet a week nearly
The report discusses delays in the grand jury proceedings due to insufficient evidence for an indictment against Lizzie Borden. It notes that if she is not indicted now, double jeopardy could protect her from future prosecution even if new evidence later emerges.
Weekly Union · 30 November 1892 · page 2
BRIGHTER FOR LIZZIE BORDEN.
convineing evidence against her. It 1s felt that the attorney-general r%@}- izes that it would.be better for all con cerned to make no error of judgment now, even at the risk of conjuring up false ap pearances and to place Miss Borden ina position where she will not be beyond the reach of justice. The probabilities are strongly in favor of no bili.
A special report claims Massachusetts Attorney General Pillsbury suspects Lizzie Borden is insane, which allegedly caused the grand jury's adjournment to allow for expert examination of her sanity. The New Bedford Mercury is cited as the source, asserting the grand jury was otherwise ready to indict her.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Pittsburg Dispatch · 30 November 1892 · page 1
the present Government to depart from the programme to which it is pledged, ot estab lishing one Irish Parliament LIZZIE BORDEN INSANE. Attorney General Pillsbury Thinks Thero Is No Doubt of It. New Bedford, Mass., Nov. 29.
The New Bedford Mercury reports that Attorney General Pillsbury allegedly believes Lizzie Borden is insane, suggesting this is the real reason the grand jury adjourned until December 1. The article also notes suspicions about reporter Henry Trickey possibly tampering with a government witness.
Pawtucket Tribune · 30 November 1892 · page 1
IS LIZZIE BORDEN INSANE? Strong Belief That She is, Gilven ns & Renson for the Adjournment, New BEDFORD, Mass., Nov. 80, -Attor. ney Gieneral Pillsbury believes that lLizzie A Horden is insane. Thereby hangs the
The grand jury considering the Lizzie Borden case is set to reassemble after a recess, amid widespread newspaper speculation about the evidence and reasons for the delay. Rumors claim Attorney General Pillsbury doubts there is enough evidence to indict and even suspects Borden may be insane, while District Attorney Knowlton reportedly disagrees and believes an indictment is warranted.
The Providence News · 30 November 1892 · page 1
NEw Beprorp, Nov, 80.-To-morrow the grand jury, which has under consid eration the case of Lizzie Borden, will reassemble after a brief recess. In the interval since the adjournment of the jury the newspapers have been filled with speculation concerning the evidence which has been presented aund the reasons for the break in the session. One story that bas attained a wider circulation than it deserved commeanced with the statement that Lizzie Borden would not be indicted by the grand jury. It goes on to say that not a sciutilla of evidence was presented to the jury to show that Miss Borden was conunected with the crime beyond the fact that she was in the house at the tims of the mur der, that the family relations were un pleasant, and that there were discrepan cies in the story of the suspected woman, Then it says that Attorney General Pilisbury believed that there was no sense or reason in asking the jury to in dict on such testimony as had been pre sented, and ordered Mr.
See moreSee less
Knowlton to shut off after agreeing to allow ven days for the district. attornev to get together any further evidence which was obtained. Out of this has grown another story of * & bitter disagreement between Mr. Pills bury aud District Attorney Kuowlton on the advisability of muking an attempt to indict Lizzie Borden, These stories, it is now said, have but the shadow of fact for a foundation, Attorney General Pillshury believes that iiizzle A. Borden is insane. Thereby hangs the secret of the adjo
The report sifts through competing rumors about why the grand jury adjourned without indicting Lizzie Borden, including a claim that Attorney General Pillsbury doubted the sufficiency of the evidence and clashed with District Attorney Knowlton. It settles on another theory—reported by the Mercury as authoritative—that Pillsbury privately believed Borden was insane, which supposedly caused the adjournment.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Providence News · 30 November 1892 · page 1
ported to Believe So, WHAT WILL THE GRAND JURY DO It s Sald That the Attorney General and the District Attorney are at Variance, the Latter Holding That Miss Borden is Not Insane—-Rumors About the Bos ton Newspaper Man's Unlucky Predicament, NEw Beprorp, Nov, 80.-To-morrow the grand jury, which has under consid eration the case of Lizzie Borden, will reassemble after a brief recess. In the interval since the adjournment of the jury the newspapers have been filled with speculation concerning the evidence which has been presented aund the reasons for the break in the session.
See moreSee less
One story that bas attained a wider circulation than it deserved commeanced with the statement that Lizzie Borden would not be indicted by the grand jury. It goes on to say that not a sciutilla of evidence was presented to the jury to show that Miss Borden was conunected with the crime beyond the fact that she was in the house at the tims of the mur der, that the family relations were un pleasant, and that there were discrepan cies in the story of the suspected woman, Then it says that Attorney General Pilisbury believed that there was no sense or reason in asking the jury to in dict on such testimony as had been pre sented, and ordered Mr. Knowlton to shut off after agreeing to allow ven days for the district. attornev to get together any further evidence which was obtained. Out of this has grown another story of * & bitter disagreement between Mr. Pills bury aud District Attorney Kuowlton on the advisability of muking an attempt to indict Lizzie Borden, These stories, it is now said, have but the shadow of fact for a foundation, Attorney General Pillshury believes that iiizzle A. Borden is insane. Thereby hangs the secret of the adjo the grand jary in the Borden case, !'!t'ng
The report claims the grand jury had been ready to indict Lizzie Borden but adjourned after the attorney general raised doubts about her sanity, prompting a secret psychiatric investigation. It also repeats unconfirmed rumors that reporter Henry Trickey tampered with a government witness.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Providence News · 30 November 1892 · page 1
WHAT WILL THE GRAND JURY DO
at Taunton on Nov. 21, to come in again Thursday, Dec. 1. The Mercury stat's this morning that this is the true reason for the adjournment, and the Mercury's statement is based on the best of au thority. It will be remembered that following the surprise to the community from this unprecedented action of the grand Jjury there were all sorts of rumors as to the real reason for the adjournment. Follow ing 8o closely upon the visit of the grand jury to Fall River and the spot where Aundrew J.
See moreSee less
Borden and his wife were butchered in broad daylight, it was gen erally thought that new and important facts had come to light which required vime for investigation, and hence the ad jourument, There is little doubt that the evidence submitted to the grand jury was suffi cient for the finding of an indictment, apd at the time of the adjournment of that august and secret body the mem bers were already to bring in a true bill. But there arose a doubt in the mind of the attorney general asto the sanity of the prisoner. The stories of her actions, as told by the witnesses. had, uo doubt, kreat weight in influenciug the attorney geveral in this direction, The question of insanity, nowever, was looked upon in a different light by District Attorney Kunowlton. Buat he gave in to the wishes ol bis superior, and expressed his willing ness that the jury should take a recess while an examination as to Miss Bordsn’s sauity was made. This iuvestigation, it is understood, has been carried on since the jury aajourned, and when next the jurors file into their seats in the Taunton court room they will be confronted with experts who will give their opinions whether d.izzie Borden is of sound mind r or whether she is a maniac. | The horrible double murder, it will be remembered, was regarded at the outset as the deed of some oue devoid of reasou, and from its very brutality and the evi dent cunning with which it was planued and executed the theory held it was som mitted by the wild man, who has figured 80 largely, gained ground. This wild man has never been found, and no trace of him has been unearthed. But the hor rible evidence of the crime itself proves conclusively that none but a crazy person, one momentarily crazed or otherwise, eould have done it. Lizzie's queer actions and doings have long been a matier of re mark among ber acquaintances, even be fore the murder drew the attention of the whole newspaper reading public to them. The rumors that Henry G. Trickey, the newspaper man, is wanted for attempting to interfere with a government witness, are believed to have foundation in fact, and in the event of their truth they will form an important feature of the case, Not & Dollar In It GALVESTON, Tex., Nov, 30, Wells, Far go & Co., delivered to the Island City Savings Bank here a package supposed to contain $lO,OOO in ecurrency, shipped by Kounts Bros., bankers, in New York, for account of H. Rungle A Co., Cuero, Texas.