As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · The full archive

December 1892

243 articles

The Press · Stafford Springs, Conn.

The item reports that the Lizzie Borden grand jury has adjourned, claiming the reported reason is to have her examined by experts regarding her sanity. It infers from this that prosecutors believe they have sufficient evidence of her guilt.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Press · 1 December 1892 · page 2

Thursday. December 1. . JAJUS MCLAUGHLIN & SON, PUBLISHERS. $180 a year. II paid strictly In advance ,$1.25. Dboxmber term of the superior court opens at Tolland, Tuesday, Dec. 6th. Dr. Scott, the president's father-in-l&W, died at the White House on Tuesday. Tbk astronomers now feel sure bf noth ing concerning the comet; in sight except that they know very little about it. It Isnt the Bella comet, and don't seem to be rushing toward the earth,' as was first supposed, rather to be receding. Thb grand jury In the . Lizzie Borden

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The district attorney announced the grand jury would likely report the next day on the Borden case, expected to bring a temporary end to the proceedings. A rumor that the prosecution was trying to build an insanity case against Lizzie Borden was dismissed by local lawyers as baseless.

Morning Journal and Courier · 1 December 1892 · page 3

The Grand Jury may Report To-day on the Borden murder Case The Insanity Story Discredited.

The statement made by a New Bedford pa per this morning relative to the govern ment trying to make out a oass of insanity was laughed at to-day by leading lawyers here and in Fall Biver. No insane com missioners have yet visited Ilias Borden, When Attorney Jennings said in his argu ment before Judge Blalsdell at Fall Biver "my olient is not insane" It was felt and openly ezpiessed at the time that be had closed the only loophole he had In case the evidenoe was against Hiss Borden. For the government to play into the hands of the defense by intimating and seeking to prove that Miss Borden is insane is laughed at.

See moreSee less

The statements made in re gard to the government Wanting Messrs. Triokey and MoHenry is utterly without foundation, as the whereabouts of both parties have been known for weeks. They could easily have been apprehended were it desired. It may be action for oriminal libel will result from the publication of MoHenry's story in the Globe, but in this case John V. Morse and Miss Borden will be the Interested ones. The feeling that there will be no bill is strong as ever with out no particular foundation for auoh a feeling other than the singular action of tne grand jury. SPECULaTIOnS.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The Boston Journal speculates that the grand jury's delay in deciding on Lizzie Borden's case might relate to an examination of her sanity, citing the legal process for certifying insanity instead of indictment. Witnesses like Mrs. Mary Livermore are quoted asserting no history of insanity in Borden's family, undercutting the theory.

Morning Journal and Courier · 1 December 1892 · page 3

SPECULaTIOnS. BOSTON, Nov. -, 3U. The Journal says that while the report that the grand jury suspended its finding against Lizzie Bor den, in order that she might be examined by experts as to her sanity, may prove in correct, still such a thing is within the range of possibility. The law says: "When a person held in prison on a charge of having committed an indictable offence, is not indicted by the grand jury by reason of insanity, the grand jury shall certify that fact to the court, and there upon the court, if satisfied that he is in sane may order him to be committed to a state lunatlo hospital, under suoh limi tations as may seem proper."

See moreSee less

- The court must be satisfied that the certification of the grand jury is correct that Lizzie Borden is insane, and there fore not legally responsible for her acts, and upon this issue all her friends have a right to take up her cause and show, if they can, to the satisfaction of the court that Miss Borden was a rational being. possessed of entire mental balance and control on the 4th of August last, when her father and stepmother were so hor ribly murdered. The grand jury comes in at Taunton to morrow morning and if then not agreed upon any suoh suggestions as has been surmised will report snoh fact to Judge Thompson, who thns may be called upon to pass upon the question of Miss Borden's nlty. Bat it must be remembered that the grand jurors in such case declare that they find no indiotment, because in their judgment the prisoner is insane. On this point in a recent very interesting in terview with Mrs. Mary A. Livermore, that lady stated that from a long and intimate acquaintance with L'zzie Borden's mother, dating from before her marriage with Andrew J. Borden, the girl's father, she had never known of the slightest indication of insanity nor of anything of the kind in her family. It is also definitely established tnat mere never was the slightest trace of insanity in Mr. Borden's family other than the single case of the old gentleman's brother's wife, be tween whom and Lizzie there were no ties of blood. Mrs. Livermore knew both the Borden sisters from their childhood and has never seen, she said, any indications of any lack of mental balance. A Bpeolal to the .Herald from Taunton says: Aphysloian who has had considerable experience as an insanity expert said to day, that if the issue was brought by the defense it would be a very difficult matter for the government to prove that Lizzie Borden was not insane. With the boot on

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

John V. Morse, Lizzie Borden's uncle, denies any history of insanity in her family, while defense attorney Andrew Jennings states the defense will not pursue an insanity plea. Meanwhile, the grand jury in Taunton continues examining witnesses, and the district attorney dismisses the insanity rumor as baseless.

Evening Journal · 1 December 1892 · page 1

MISS BORDEN NOT INSANE. The Defendant *» Coun»el Are Confident That She in Doth Kane and Innocent. Fall River, Mass., Dec. 1.—John V. Morse was seen yesterday in reference to the alleged insanity of Lizzie Borden.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A miscellany column jokes that the ongoing debate over whether Lizzie Borden is insane may soon drive all of Fall River insane. It is a brief, satirical aside among many unrelated witty observations on current events.

Evening Journal · 1 December 1892 · page 2

W hen the French were on the Isthmus of Panama they dug In the dirt ; now, in Paris, they have got down into tho nastiest, stickiest kind of 'mud. Placiditt of countenance is more readily produced by a full stomach than by a full mind. But there is no good reason why a sensible man may not pos sess both. Whether Lizzie Borden la insane or

See the clipping

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

This report states that Lizzie Borden, accused of killing her father and stepmother, is likely to be released because the Grand Jury has not indicted her for lack of new evidence. It speculates that her chances of release are good if nothing new emerges within a week.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The National Tribune · 1 December 1892 · page 2

Other negro preachers aro holding out emigra tion to Africa as tbo only future salvation (in a worldly sense) of the American negro race. The Cuso of Lizzie Borden. Lizzie Borden, of Taunton, Mass., who is charged with tho killing of her father, a wealthy banker of Fall River, in last August, and also of her stepmother, is likely to bo at liberty again, sinco it is believed that the Grand Jury will not indicther. No now evidence has beon given to the jury, and becauso of the

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The grand jury at Taunton reconvened to continue examining witnesses in the Borden murder case, including new witnesses Mrs. Peckham and Mrs. Bowen, with skulls of the victims again inspected by jurors. Lizzie Borden's uncle John Morse publicly denied any family history of insanity, countering rumors of an insanity defense.

Evening Star · 1 December 1892 · page 1

MISS BORDEN'S CASE.

Fat. ltem. Ma.. Dec. L --Mr. Jea Rows, ancle of Lizrie Borden. declares that tnams i no ground whatever for the ceae that h miss is insane. He had known her from he time tie was a little child, andi never had she show. 3o alighteet signs of insanity. On his ids et the family be could 'a' that there had been as insanity as far back as its hateor wee kneewn. Lizzie Borden was .quaUv fte frome danger of inheriting insanity fr -n2 her

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A brief news digest item states that the theory of Lizzie Borden's insanity has been discredited. It appears amid a roundup of unrelated national news on tariffs, pensions, and other events.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Pittsburg Dispatch, 30 November 1892, The Providence News, 30 November 1892, The Providence News, 30 November 1892.

New-York Tribune · 1 December 1892 · page 6

It scems probable that, of Speaker | mony was given before the Panama investicating hurdens. committee. The committee of the Monetary (pip and his friends favor an extra session, Conference held its first meeting: its proceedings hile the extreme tariff reformers are al ; ¢ €) ariff reformers are also are to be kept secret until its report is made © 000 4 3 av. NM ' : ) the conference. —== Herr Richter severely critia mE Fe ‘ { lev land will oized Chancellor von Caprivi's speech on the Gers hardly be disposed fv ens, ew united wishes man Army bill.

See moreSee less

==== A Japanese warship was If there is to be an extra session, it is evident sunk in a collision. The * Journal™ of Paris that the first step taken must he to replenish the he something published what it asserted was the text of the Treasury, and then there must a reducty fatest Triple Alitance treaty. stout and emphatic in the way oi In revision of Domestie.—The Nicarazua Canal Convention of duties. After that the general opened its sessions in New-Orleans, with dele the tariil may he intrusted to the Committ gates present from every State and Territory. == Hl Ways and Means, which will be appointed General Ruy submitted his annual yeport on the after the organization of the House, and whieh werk of the Pension Dureaa, Sacpatary will then able to mature during the surhe Charles Fo ter made a reply to Ashbe! Po Fiteh's mer a hill to he supported at the regular se criticism of the Treasury Department's attitudes jon a vear hence. Representative Mutehle on John 1. Davenport's accounts, === The Stone f Pennsylvania suggests that the removal of ee Punk, of Joliet, NL, suspended, with liahilic (6 sugar bounties and the restoration th jes of 2500,000, == The trial proper of Produtie a + het) ' E fessor 11. 7. Smith for heresy began in Cincinrati HELO Sugar mul be the lirst step toward c==_. The theory of Lizzie Borden's insanity is a replenishment of the Treasimy and that these diseredited. changes in the tariff will he properly accom panied hy a repeal of the duties on wool City and Suburban.—=The Presbytery of Newwill. and a reduction of the duties on woollen goods, York spent the day considering Dr. Brizgs's deAccording to his theory the only object of the murrer: two of his objections were not sustained, tepublicans in entting off the duty on sazar one he waived conditionally, and one was sis ne tained : an effort to cut off the last parigraph of “as t0 make an excuse for the larger duties the indictment failed by a vote of 70 to 68, the ON woollens, which have, however, rosalied members voting by rolleall. === Mrs. A. A in no increased revenue to the Treasury. Snutesas Site BEEN 10 Ricsvelt Nunkial oe Ey 3 4 diene) Democratic scheme, The Be pe atin — hw fee of the Sugar hounty would stop an exeh wy he Pons Penditure now amounting to eight or nine Fertig. Drcwing Conpany was Grable to pis in jos a year, and likely to be ten millions Interest on its Bonds. = Yumortant bland Ly, H year. I'he revival of the duty on sugar Sits piven rerarding the colers before the Senate would bring to the Treasury about 250.000, - Committee on Jmmigration. Bankers dis- $09 a year, so that the net result would be eusced the silver proposition made at the Drussels cquivalent to an increase of S60.000.0060 in Monetary Conference. Several members of he 1evenue. But the removal of the sugar the fucult: of St. Paul's Cathedral School at Garduty has actually lessened the cost of sugar by Se Sux ig PA Feigand. = —=— Trains were ahout 2 cents per pound, amounting to about TT Se a To lve pondlin So se ie) ig the mcreased daties on wool the bear faction was unusually agareasive. Final oy of cl ry ve hed A Se oy bag chanzes were generally declines, but exceptions States Ti a # ; 8 people of the Lited were numerous, and the industrial stocks pati u- } yer i _— ) cui fjecranse i} the Fever has Noirs weve strong. Money on call nti at 5 13 n very large, and the actual decrease in ox = penses of the people quite as large. Accord- | per cent. The Weatlicr. Forcast for to-day: Fair with js te the Democratic theory, this is all wrong, slight thermal changes: a trifle warmer at nizly {The duty on sugur mast be restored, and ‘the Davie, Temperature yesterdun : Highest, ne people compelled to pay about S85 for every { family more than they now pay each vear, grees: lowest, 27; average, 20 1-4.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A dispatch from New Bedford reports that Attorney General Pillsbury believes Lizzie Borden is insane, suggesting this is the real reason the grand jury adjourned from November 21 to December 1. The brief item frames the insanity belief as a secret explanation behind the delay.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 1 December 1892 · page 2

Belleres Lizzie Ilorden Is Insane. New Bedford, Mass.. Nor. SO. Attorney general Pillsbnry believes Lizzie Borden is insane. This is the secret of the ad journment of the grand jury in the case from Nov. 21 to Deo. 1.

See the clipping

Saint Mary's Beacon · Leonard Town, Md.

A roundup of brief news items includes a special dispatch to the Boston Herald stating the grand jury will find 'no bill' against Lizzie Borden for her father's murder. The item appears among unrelated brief notices on fires, crimes, and political news.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Saint Mary's Beacon · 1 December 1892 · page 2

NEWS IN BRIEF.

Saturday, November 26, 1892. Hog island, where Mr. Cleveland is gunning, voted unanimously for him for President. Wm. Preston Tyler will be tried in the Circuit Court for Talbot county on Monday for killing Wm. L. Shaw in Caroline county last July. The Blossburg mine, near Paton, the largest mine in New Mexico, was burned out yesterday. Five hundred men were thrown out of work. Tbe Michigan Peninsula Car Co’s,, works, in West Detroit, Mich., were burned, Lobs about $500,000. Jonas Loinbach, a well-known farmer, of Richmand township, Berks county, Pa., died last night, aged seventy-two years.

See moreSee less

Ho was the father o| twenty-six children. A special dispatch to the Boston Herald from Taunton, Mass., says the grand jury will find “no bill” against Miss Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father in ‘Fall River. Dr. W. W, Johnson, the attend ing physician, says the published reports that Mr. Blaine is seriously ill are entirely without foundation. Yesterday afternoon Mr. Blaine was dressed and sitting up. Highwaymen entered a Northern Pacific Railroad train Hot Springs, in the Slate of Washington, Thuijs- , day evening and compelled all the i male passengers in the Pullman sleeping-car to give up their valb1 ables. The women were not mb1 Jested. The robbers secured abotit i $1,200 worth 6f watches, jewelry ' and money. I

See the clipping

Ellsworth American · Ellsworth, Me.

A Boston Herald special from Taunton reports that Lizzie Borden will not be indicted by the grand jury for the murders of her father and step-mother, predicting she will soon be a free woman. It states the evidence presented was the same as at the earlier Fall River hearing and was deemed insufficient for an indictment.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Ellsworth American · 1 December 1892 · page 2

will he Dropped—The (Vrand Jury did not Deem the Kvidenee Suttirient to Hold Her. Boston-, Nov. 25.—A special from Taun ton lo the Herald says: "Lizzie Borden will not be indicted by the grand jury for the murder of her father and step-mother. In another week, without any doubt, she will be a free woman and the whole miserable pretence of a case against her will be ended. The evidence laid before the grand jury was essentially the same as that produced at the hearing in Fall Kiver and it was sot deemed sufficient to warrant the finding of an indictment."

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report claims Attorney General Pillsbury believes Lizzie Borden is insane, and that this is the true reason the grand jury adjourned rather than returning an indictment immediately. It dismisses rumors of new evidence or a quarrel between prosecutors as the real cause of the delay.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 1 December 1892 · page 1

Theory Now Strongly Advanced That Such is Her Mental Condition. * — K«»sti*v Nov. :U».—Tim Journal today : publish**!* the following despatch from New | Bedford: Attorney General I’illsbury believes that Lizzie A. Bor Jen i* insane. Thereby hangs the secret of the adjournment of the grand jury in the Borden ease, sitting at Taunton on Nov. 1*1. t«> come in again Thursday, Dec. 1. The Mercury in the morning will I »tate that this is the true reason lor the ad journment, and the Mercury’s statement ! will be based on the best of authority.

See moreSee less

It will be remembered that following the surprise to the community from this un | precedented action of the grand jury there i were all sorts of rumors as to the real rea son for the adjournment. Following so close 1> upon the visit of the grand jury to Fall lfiver and the spot where Andrew ,J. Borden and his wife were butchered in

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report claims the grand jury was ready to indict Lizzie Borden but adjourned because the attorney-general doubted her sanity, prompting an examination by experts. It also repeats the earlier theory that the murders were committed by an unidentified 'wild man' due to their brutality.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Kennebec Journal · 1 December 1892 · page 1

j IS LIZZIE BORDEN INSANE? Theory Now Strongly Advanced That Such is Her Mental Condition. * — K«»sti*v Nov. :U».—Tim Journal today : publish**!* the following despatch from New | Bedford: Attorney General I’illsbury believes that Lizzie A. Bor Jen i* insane. Thereby hangs the secret of the adjournment of the grand jury in the Borden ease, sitting at Taunton on Nov. 1*1. t«> come in again Thursday, Dec. 1. The Mercury in the morning will I »tate that this is the true reason lor the ad journment, and the Mercury’s statement !

See moreSee less

will be based on the best of authority. It will be remembered that following the surprise to the community from this un | precedented action of the grand jury there i were all sorts of rumors as to the real rea son for the adjournment. Following so close 1> upon the visit of the grand jury to Fall lfiver and the spot where Andrew ,J. Borden and his wife were butchered in broad daylight, it wi.s generally thought that new and important facts had come to light which required time for investigation and hence the adjournment. And then there came the story that Dis trict Attorney Knowlton and Attorney Gen eral lfillsbury had quarreled, and this wa.« expatiated upon as tin* reason for the won derful action of the grand jury. But the Mercury will give this story as the true rea son for adjournment. There is little doubt that the evidence submitted to the grand jury w as sufficient for the finding of an indictment, and at the time of the adjournment of that august and secret body the members were all ready to bring in a true hill. But there arose a doubt in the mind of tin* attorney-general a* to the sanity of tin* prisoner. The stories of her actions, a* told bv the witnesses, had. no doubt, great weight in influencing the attorney-general in this direction. The question of insanity, however, was looked upon in a different light by District \ttor ney Knowlton. But lie gave in to the wishes of his superior, and expressed his willingness that the jury should take a re cess while an examination as to Miss Bor den’s sanity was made. This investigation, it is understood, has been carried on since the jury adjourned, and when next tin* ju rors file into their seats in the Taunton court room they w ill In* confronted by ex perts who will give their opinions whether Lizzie Borden is of sound mind or whether she is u maniac. The horrible double murder, it w ill be remembered, was regarded at the outset as the deed of some one devoid of reason, and from its very brutality and the evident cun ning with which it was planned and executed tin theory held that it was committed by flic wild man. who lias figured so largely, gained ground. This wild nun has never been found, and no trace «»f him lias been unearthed. But the horrible evidence of the crime itself proves conclusively that none but a crazy person, one momentarily crazed.or otherwise, could have done it. Lizzie’s queer action* and doings have long since b» » n a matter of remark among her acquaintances, even before the murder drew the attention of the w hole newspaper reading public to them.

See the clipping

The Somerset Reporter · Skowhegan, Me.

The report states that the grand jury in Taunton, Massachusetts has adjourned to allow time for an examination into Lizzie Borden's sanity. This adjournment is attributed to a developing theory that she may be insane.

The Somerset Reporter · 1 December 1892 · page 1

The tlieorv of insanity of Lizzie \. Borden inow advanced athe reason lor the adjournment of t In* gi an I jury a t Taunton. 'lass. The object oftherei • i-to give opportunity for e\amination ato tin* s.init \ ot Miss Borden. ftim-'n >1r«ll«ine move* the Imwrleiieh *ln> In order to be healthy this is necessary The Somerset Reporter.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The New Bedford Mercury reports that the grand jury's adjournment was due to Attorney General Pillsbury's belief that Lizzie Borden might be insane, prompting a recess for experts to examine her mental state. District Attorney Knowlton reportedly doubted this theory but deferred to his superior.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Portland Daily Press · 1 December 1892 · page 1

Borden. _ W New Bedfobd, November 30.—Th Mercury states today that the reason for the adjournment of the grand jury from November 21 to December 1 was that Attorney General Pillsbury believes that Lizzie Borden is insane. District Attorney Knowlton, - is thought, does not believe in her insanity, but yielded to the wishes of his superior that the ju ry should tako a recess, during which experts should investigate as to Miss Borden’s sanity. The stories of her actions, as told by the witnesses, had, no doubt, great weight in influencing the attorney gen eral in this direction.

See moreSee less

The horrible double murder, it will be remembered, was regarded at the outset as the deed of some one devoid of reason, and the horrible evidence of ihe crime itself proves conclusively that none but a crazy person, one momentarily c azed, or oth erwise, could have done it. Lizzie’s queer actions and doings have long been a matter of remark among her acquain tances, even before the murder drew the attention of the whole newspaper read ing publio to them.

See the clipping

Grand Rapids Herald · Grand Rapids, Mich.

The article reports that Attorney General Pillsbury suspected Lizzie Borden was insane, which it claims explains the grand jury's adjournment from November 21 to December 1. It states that experts on her sanity would testify when the jury reconvened.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Grand Rapids Herald · 1 December 1892 · page 1

Lizzie Borden Insane. New KcrTORD, Mass., Nov. 30. At torney General Pillsbury believes that Lizzie A. Korden is insane. This is the secret of the adjournment of the grand

See the clipping

In the story →

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A New Bedford report claims the Massachusetts attorney general privately believes Lizzie Borden is insane, and that this belief caused the grand jury to adjourn her case from November 21 to December 1. The Mercury newspaper is cited as the source alleging the grand jury was otherwise ready to indict her.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

St. Paul Daily Globe · 1 December 1892 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

BELIEVES LIZZIE INSANE.

Secret of the Adjournment of the Borden Case.

See moreSee less

NEW BEDFORD, Mass., Nov. 30.—Attorney General Pillsbury believes Lizzie Borden is insane. This is the secret of the adjournment of the grand jury in the case from Nov. 21 to Dec. 1. The Mercury today publishes an article in which it says the grand jury was ready to bring in a true bill, but the attorney general's belief caused him to order an adjournment until Lizzie Borden could be examined as to her sanity.

See the clipping

Marble Hill Press · Marbel Sic Hill, Mo.

This compilation of brief domestic news items includes a line noting that the Borden murder Grand Jury has adjourned to look into evidence that may lead to further arrests. It appears amid unrelated items on politics, crime, and disasters nationwide.

Marble Hill Press · 1 December 1892 · page 3

GENERAL DOMESTIC. Wm. Binder, a Milwaukee bookkeeper, killed Wife.child and himself. Arizona offers 13,000 for "Kit," the Apache renegade, dead or alive. Dr. Jones, who killed Captain Veal at the Dallas Fair, was held without ball. At Mount Sterling, Ala , a merchant waited for burglars, killed one and cap tured two. Wm. P. Anderson, a crippled farmer, was assassinated while asleep near Dallas, Tex. The Borden murder Grand Jury has adjourned to look Into evidence that may lead to further arrests. Floods have caused a heavy loss of life and much damage to property in the

See the clipping

Marble Hill Press · Marbel Sic Hill, Mo.

A wire-service digest of national news items notes that two persons other than Lizzie Borden may be indicted at Fall River for the famous murders. The rest of the item covers unrelated stories on crime, weather, business, and markets.

Marble Hill Press · 1 December 1892 · page 3

GENERAL DOMESTIC.

A fierce storm is blowing on the great lakes and great damage has been re ported. Al Smith, the well-known New York sport, has just won $22,000 at taro in that city. An Italian at New York has unfolded a remarkable story of the Mafia to the police. The trial of Sylvester Critchlow, the first ot the Homestead riot cases, has be gun at Pittsburg. Two person other than Lizzie Borden may be indicted at Fall River for the fa mous murders. The Federal Grand Juryat Kansas City has returned a number of indictments for election frauds. Sam Woolner of Peoria is said to bf combining distillery interests against the Whisky Trust, not in favor of it. The Missouri electors will meet at Jef

See the clipping

The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.

A New Bedford newspaper report claims Attorney General Pillsbury privately believes Lizzie Borden is insane, suggesting this is the real reason the grand jury proceedings were adjourned. The report offers this as an explanation for the delay in the case.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The State Chronicle · 1 December 1892 · page 1

trustee in Wi'son Snnerior K D. Hi . Still hv nnhlin unn. I t Vt O 1 at til IWmlwr 1 ;f the Wilson Advance ' AT'KI; AND JOB 0?FICK e an; k on win or said news New Bedford, Mass., Nov. 30. The Mercury to day says: Attorney General Pillsbury believes that Lizzie A. Borden is insane. This is the secret of the adA Panenaer Train Ditched. tyt,e, fix By Telegraph to State Chronicle. nrouertv of Arkansas City, Nov. 30. Ihe north bound Missouri Pacific passenger tram, leaving here at 12:45 p. m. today,

See the clipping

The News-Herald · Hillsboro, Ohio

The report says there is a widespread impression that the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for her father's murder, but no one is certain since jury members have revealed nothing. It suggests the attorney general may prefer caution to avoid errors that could later undermine the case.

The News-Herald · 1 December 1892 · page 6

Usris Harden1 Chances. TACSTOif, Mass., Nov. 28. The im pression pnevplls that the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father, Andrew Borden, but the publac is no more certain of this than it was when the first case went into the hands of tho jury, only by in ference, since no member of that body has expressed himself in any way. It is felt that the attorney general realizes that it would be better for all concern ed to make so error of judgment now, even at th efek of oonjmring ud false appAiunAMK and to plaee Miss Sardon in a position where she will notbebeyowiMrssiifcofiijjgUc v , " -. , ' J2 A,

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

Lizzie Borden's counsel vows to fight any Government attempt to have her declared insane and committed without trial, insisting she was fully rational at the time of the murders. The grand jury convenes at Taunton the next day and may issue a certification on her mental state for Judge Thompson to evaluate.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 1 December 1892 · page 7

mentsNo Vote Beached. Ciscc-nati, Nov. 30. The trial proper of Prof. Henry Preserved Smith began torff mit a person charged with murder to an in sane asylum without a trial if the grand jury so certify, and if the court is satisfied, after examining the medical experts, that the prisoner is of unsound mind. But the court has got to be satisfied that the certi fication of the grand ' jury is correct, that Lizzie Borden is insane, and therefore not legally responsible lor ber acts, and upon this issue all her friends have a right to take up her cause and show, if they can, to the satisfaction of the court,

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The report explains that the grand jury convening at Taunton may certify Lizzie Borden as insane, which the court would then have to evaluate through medical experts. It also revives the defense's theory of a 'wild-eyed stranger' seen near the Borden house at the time of the murders, noting police failed to pursue this lead.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 1 December 1892 · page 7

SPECIAL TELEGRAM TO THE DISPATCH

The grand jury comes in at Taunton to morrow, and, if it agrees upon any such cer tification as has been surmised, will report such to be the fact to Judge Thompson, who is the sitting magistrate at the present term, and who may thus be called upon to pass upon the question of Miss Borden's sanity. But it must be remembered that the grand jurors in such cases declare that thty find no indictment because in their judgment the prisoner is insane. It Lizzie Borden is held to be insane the nnestion ot how it was possible for even an insane woman to have dealt those terrible blows, splashed the walls with blood, and

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The article reviews the defense's claim of a mysterious 'wild-eyed stranger' seen near the Borden house, criticizing police for dismissing the lead early on. It also details Uncle John Morse's own theory that an intruder hid in the house and committed both murders, noting a discrepancy over whether the cellar bulkhead door was locked.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 1 December 1892 · page 7

In this connection it is interesting to note TJncle John V. Morse's theory of the commission ot the crime, as given by him to a friend recently. He holds that an enemy oi Mr. Borden got into the house at night through the cellar window, which was open, but nothing said of it in the case; that the man secreted himself in the clothes press; that when Mrs.' Borden came np to make her bed he found it necessary to kill her to get rid of her; that he then concealed himselt to wait for Mr.

See moreSee less

Borden's return home; that when Lizzie had gone out to the barn and Bridget was washing the windows, he murdered Mr. Borden and then made his escape. This recalls a variance in the testimony, too. There is a bulkhead door leading from the back yard into the cellar ot the Borden residence. This is an upright door, and not one ot the slanting type. A police officer conducting the search in the house swore that he found this door locked,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

John V. Morse returned from a visit to Dartmouth and spoke to a reporter at the Borden house, denying reports that Lizzie Borden had gone insane. The piece also notes the Grand Jury was meeting that day amid excitement over Attorney-General Pillsbury's earlier decision to dismiss the jury temporarily.

The Providence News · 1 December 1892 · page 5

LIZZIE BORDEN. Fall River Enjoying a Revival of the Sensation. JOHN V. MORSE TALKS. No Ground for the Report That Lizzie Borden is Crazy NEVER SHOWED ANY SIGNS OF IT.

and on the Qui Vive. pm mm, M“a’ m. 1-—JOhn v. Morse came over from New Bedford on the noon train yesterday and was seen at the Borden house on Second street last evening by a newspaper representative. He went over to Dartmouth last Wednes day and has been about there ever since. He lived at Dartmouth almost wholly from the time that he came from the west until the day of the murders. Since that fatal fourth of August he has made his home at the Borden house. Hewent over

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

John Morse, returning from a Thanksgiving visit to Dartmouth, addressed rumors that an insanity defense might be used for Lizzie Borden. He insisted she had never shown signs of insanity and that no history of mental illness existed on either side of her family.

The Providence News · 1 December 1892 · page 5

cember. Mr. Morse declared without hesitation that as faras Lizzie Borden was concerned there was no ground for the claim that she was insane. The g:vernment might be acting on the idea that she was insane, but whether they were or not the defend ant's uncle was positive that she was no insane. He had known her from the time that she was a little child, and never ha she shown the slightest signs of insanity On his own side of the family he coul say that there had been no insanity as fa back as its history was known.

See moreSee less

During the day he had sought out one of the olde; members of the Borden family, and found \hat Lizzie Borden was equally Free From Any Danger &1 inheriting insanity from her father’s side. The Bordens and the Cooks, anoth

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

John Morse, Lizzie Borden's uncle, insists she has always been sane and shows no family history of insanity, describing her as rational during a recent jail visit. Defense attorney Andrew Jennings states the defense will not pursue an insanity theory and maintains his client's innocence, while hinting at undisclosed reasons for the Grand Jury's delay.

The Providence News · 1 December 1892 · page 5

a mind he may have had to begin with. Mr. Morse visited Miss Borden at her eell in the Taunton jail the first of the week and found her then as Rational as Ever, It was on Monday that he saw her, and she had not at that time been examined for insanity., He would have known it if she had been, and if any one, other than her friends or the regular jail attendants bad been admitted to see her, she would bave told him. Aundrew Jennings,counsel for Miss Bor den, puts no faith in the insanity theory,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Taunton grand jury reconvened to hear additional witnesses in the Borden case, including Detective McHenry, Mrs. Peckham, Mrs. Hall, Mrs. Churchill, and Miss Russell. District Attorney Knowlton denied rumors that Lizzie Borden was insane, and the jury again examined blood-stained items and the victims' skulls.

The Providence News · 1 December 1892 · page 6

OTHER WITNESSES ARE HEARD.

Fall River, Mrs. Churchiil, Miss Russell and Detective MeHenry. It is expected the jury wlll report as soon as it tinishes the examination. The jury again called for the blood spattered linen and pillow, after it had been siiting a short time, which were taken from the rooms where the Bordens were killed. These were closely examined, as were the skulis of the two victims, The following witnesses have thus far appeared before the Grand Jury, more than half of whom did not appear in the lower court ! W. A. Dolan, M. D.; Lizzie Gormley, Bridget Sullivan, Lucky Collett, John Cunningham, Hannah H. Gifford, Mrs, Churchill, Fred. A. Pickering, Eli

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

The Taunton grand jury is expected to resume deliberations on the Borden murder case, with speculation that a verdict may already have been reached but withheld. Rumors suggest either an indictment was decided earlier or new evidence prompted the adjournment, with an announcement expected imminently.

San Antonio Daily Light · 1 December 1892 · page 1

That Borden Grand Jury Taunton, Mass., Dec. I.—The grand jury will today resume its in vestigation in the famous Borden murder case. There are those who believe that a verdict was reached indicting Lizzie Borden for the mur der of her parents on the day of the adjournment of the grand jury and for some unknown reason decision was reserved until today or tomorrow. Others profess to believe that new evidence has been developed within the last few days and that this gave occasion for the sudden adjournment. Under any circumstances it is certain that a verdict will be reached and announced today or tomorrow.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The grand jury in Taunton is expected to resume and conclude its investigation into the Borden murder case, with a verdict anticipated the following day. Speculation exists that an indictment was already decided but delayed, possibly due to new evidence.

The Salt Lake Herald · 1 December 1892 · page 2

THE BORDEN MURDER The Grand Jury to Present its Verdict in This Famous Case Today TAUNTON Mass Nov BOrSpecia1 The grand jury will tomorrow resnmo Its investigation into tho now famous Borden

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

The grand jury in Taunton resumed hearing witnesses in the Borden case, with a report expected by evening. Lizzie Borden's uncle and her attorney Andrew Jennings denied any insanity in her defense, with Jennings maintaining a theory that an intruder could have hidden in the cellar to commit the murders.

Alexandria Gazette · 1 December 1892 · page 2

Fall River, Mass.. Dec. l?Mr. John V. Morse, uncle of Lizzie Borden, declares that there is no ground what? ever for the claim that his niece is in? sane. Andrew Jennings, counsel for Miss Borden, puts no faith in the insanity theory, and slates that the defence did not propose to build anything on that idea. Miss Bordeivs friends, as far as be knew, had absolute faith in hersau ity. They believed her to be entirely innocent of the charge agaiust her. Mr. Jennings has-by no means abandon? ed bis claim that it was possible Ibra person to have hidden in the cellar un? til he had a good opportunity to mur? der first Mrs. Borden and then Mr. Barden.

See the clipping

Bellows Falls Times · Bellows Falls, Vt.

The report states that at the time, it is believed the grand jury will decline to indict Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents in Fall River due to insufficient evidence. This brief appears amid a roundup of unrelated national and international news items.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Bellows Falls Times · 1 December 1892 · page 1

At the present time it is believed that the grand jury will not indict Miss Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents at Fall River. Mass., because of lack of evi dence sufficient to convict.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A report states that Attorney Pillsbury believes Lizzie Borden is insane, suggesting this is the real reason behind the grand jury's adjournment from November 21 to December 1. The brief item ties a defense theory to the procedural delay in her case.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 1 December 1892 · page 1

Tlitnk* LII.JIU in iuinntt, New Bkdforp, Mas.1*., Nov. :>0.~Attorney Plllburg believes that Lizzie Borden is insane. This is tho secret of tho adjournment $40,000. of thecrand jury in the cuso from November HI to December 1.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The grand jury in Taunton, Massachusetts returned a true bill against Lizzie Borden, formally indicting her. The indictment contained three counts: killing her father, killing her stepmother, and killing them both.

CorrectionThis set right 6 earlier articles: The Press, 1 December 1892, The National Tribune, 1 December 1892, Saint Mary's Beacon, 1 December 1892, Ellsworth American, 1 December 1892, Daily Kennebec Journal, 1 December 1892, Bellows Falls Times, 1 December 1892.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 2 December 1892 · page 4

True Bill Against Lizzie Borden

IN BAD SHAPE. CITY FINANCES of Finance Wants Autliorh.v The Hoard lo itorrow S'-JO.OOO. The meeting of the board of finance was called to order by Mayor Webster last evening, Aldermen Thompson, Bar low and Guernsey being present. The bills against the city were approved and signed. City Treasurer Keenan reported that the city s account was at present overdrawn, J'J, i08.ua, hut that ?1,- 000 from the water department and 1 100 from Tax Collector Griggs would be received to-day. The total amount of bills outstanding is about $20,000. The road board instructed the treasurer to accept the bill of T.

See moreSee less

F. Judson, amount ing to over 1, -100 for judgment render ed against the city on account of dam ages caused by the overflow of Little brook, and to pay it with interest when it could be spared. It was also decided to ask the court of common council for authority to borrow $20,000, and for au thority to transfer the expended balance to other accounts. The board ' then bid iourned tintil Monday evening, after the meeting of the council. Malicious Stories. Mooscp, uec !. incitement and in dignation is very high here over the story which appeared this week involv ing the good name of several prominent residents here. The articles asserted that the conduct of E. E. Salisbury and Miss Bertha L. Kinney had been such as to drive the young lady s mother insane and to cause her father, the Rev Mr Kinney, pastor of the Baptist church, to resign his pastorate. A thorough in vestigation made by the Connecticut Associated Press, shows there is not a word of truth in the story. Mr Kin ney's friends, who are legion, are greatly shocked at the publication and many of them have tendered him any assistance in their power. Mr Salisbury is a prom nent business man and the people here are uniting with him in his en deavors to trace the statements to their source. Judge Tillinghast of Plainfield, a close mend oi rastor ivinney, is con fident he knows the author of the story and says no stone will be left un turned to run to earth the perpetrator of the outrage. To Connect Four Towns. Hartford, uec a. a scheme is on foot among Hartford and New Pritain capitalists to construct an electric line of street railway to connect the two cities The plan was brought to light at the annual meeting or the uedar Hill ceme tery association. The directors havi long wanted the Hartford street rail road company to extend their line to Cedar hill, but they have promised and put it off repeatedly. At the meeting it was stated tnat parties stood ready to put a line past the cemetery, and then the full scope of the scheme transpired The plan is to connect Hartford, New Britain, Plainville and Farmington with an electric roaa. rrooaDiy the trolley system will be used. It is understood that the company is tormed and is ready to go ahead as soon as prelimi naries can be arranged. True Bill Against Lizzie Borden, Taunton, Mass, Dec 2 The grand jury to day returned a true bill against Lizzie Borden. There are three counts in the bill, one for killing her father. one for killing her step-mother, and one for killing them both. The Rothchlld Plan Reported. Brussels. Dec 2. The sub-committee at the monetery conference this morn ing reported in favor of the Rothchild plan, having re-considered their nrst vote, ureat surprise was caused by the report of the committee.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A brief dispatch from Taunton, Massachusetts reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the grand jury on three counts for the murder of her father and mother. The item is short and factual, noting only the indictment itself.

Evening Journal · 2 December 1892 · page 1

... »»tu» suddenly stink out of sight T u 0 !? 1 "?^? 1 " ?/ t » ncba<lua d,d ? ot br ® a ' 1 forth but it still shows signs of coming 1 erUpti<IUS ' Lizzie Borden Indicted.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The grand jury in Taunton, Massachusetts indicted Lizzie Borden on three counts for the murder of her father and mother. Witnesses including Detective McHenry, his wife, a veiled woman, and a young boy were called before the indictment was returned.

Evening Star · 2 December 1892 · page 6

LIZZIE BORDEN INDICTED. A True Bill Found for the Murder of Hier Parents. TAnnrON. MASN.. Dec. 2.-Lizze Borden has beet. indicted by the grand jury on three counts for the mur der of her father and mother. The grand jury met this morning and began again hearing evidence in the case. Detective Mellenry, his wife and an unknown veiled lady were called in. Then a small boy, before un noticed, was introduced. The impression among court officials was that an indictment would be found and that it would be returned some time today, altbough the return to hear ing evidence and threshing over old straw dis o'zaged the most ardent supporters of the indietmnent theory.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

John V. Morse, Lizzie Borden's uncle, states there is no family history of insanity and insists she was sane. Her lawyer Andrew Jennings confirms the defense will not pursue an insanity plea, while the Grand Jury continues examining witnesses in New Bedford.

CorrectionThis set right 5 earlier articles: The Indianapolis Journal, 1 December 1892, The Portland Daily Press, 1 December 1892, Grand Rapids Herald, 1 December 1892, St. Paul Daily Globe, 1 December 1892, The State Chronicle, 1 December 1892.

New-York Tribune · 2 December 1892 · page 4

BD — LIZZIE BORDEN'S DEFENCE. IT WILL NOT BID ON THE GROUND OF INSANITY THE GRAND JURY STILL AT WORK. all River, Mass, Dee. 1,=Johin V. Morse, uncle |

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The Grand Jury examined bloodstained pillow, linen, and the two skulls from the Borden murder scene, along with testimony from new witnesses Mrs. Peckham and Mrs. Hall of Fall River. No vote was taken on the day's proceedings, with deliberations to continue the following morning.

New-York Tribune · 2 December 1892 · page 4

13 all boosh, orden was killed, and these, with the two skulls of ——— ——————————— the victims, were once more submitted to Inspection in the Jury room, Mes. Peckham and Mrs, Hall, of Full River, were two new witnesses. It 1s intimated tint thelr testimony was in the line of new evidence obtalned during the recent recess, At 11:15 a. m. the evidence was all In. The Grand Jury adjourned at 5:30 until 9:30 a. m, to-morrow, snd the general public knows no more about the Borden case than it did before, It has been lenrned, however, that no vote was taken on the matter to-day, but one may be taken to-morrow, If the evidence becomes fully digested by that Hme.

See moreSee less

The whole afternoon was occupied in going carefully over he evidence, and the DistrictAttorney was called before the jury twice to clear up matters which seemed doubtful The Rev, Mr, Jubb was in attendanee all the afternoon, bat he was obliged 10 go huie withont carrying any news io Miss Borden, — a

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A roundup of national and local news notes that the Grand Jury investigating Lizzie Borden heard additional testimony but issued no report. The item appears amid unrelated news on yachting, politics, and weather.

New-York Tribune · 2 December 1892 · page 6

THE NEWS THIS MORNING.

the President's father-in-law, was held in the White House. === Henry M. Hoyt, eX. Governor of Pennsylvama, died at Wilkesbarre, == Argument was begun before Chancellor MeGill, in Trenton, N. J.. on the application for a receiver for the New-Jersey Central Railroad's coal business, ——— The Grand Jury in the case of Lizzie Borden heard more wstimony, but made no report.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The grand jury at Taunton resumed hearing witnesses in the Lizzie Borden case, including Detective McHenry and his wife, who had been involved in a sensational courthouse publication incident weeks earlier. District Attorney Knowlton firmly dismissed the recent insanity story as false.

The Morning News · 2 December 1892 · page 1

FIGHTING OVER A FLAG. American and Italian Miners Clash at Gouverneur. Gouvhrneur, N. Y., Deo. L—Great ex oitement has prevailed at Taloville since Sunday, caused by an Italian flag being torn down aud burned by a number of American miners. The Italians opened fire on the miners at the time and the latter re sponded, but no one was hurt. Tbe Italians threaten to raise another flag, and if they do another row will be inaugurated by the Americans. LIZZIE BORDEN’S TRIAL. Tbe Examination of Witnesses Re sumed at Taunton. Taunton, Mass., Deo.

See moreSee less

1. —The grand jury resumed its session this morning and began the examination of more witnesses in the Borden case. Detective McHenry and wife, who were mixed up with the sensa tional publication a few weeks ago in the court house, were among the witnesses to testify. District Attoruey Knowltou staled squarely this morning that the last insanity story is all bosh.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The item speculates that Lizzie Borden's mental state may have deteriorated due to the stress and treatment following her arrest, suggesting she could become insane. It notes that even if insanity is confirmed, it would not clarify the case since insanity could stem from either remorse or persecution.

The Morning News · 2 December 1892 · page 4

O! counsel in the Lizzie Borden case, that she is insane, should prove true. She has undergone enough excitement and question able treatment since her arrest to turn into

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

John V. Morse, Lizzie Borden's uncle, denies claims that his niece is insane, stating no history of insanity exists on either side of her family. Defense attorney Andrew Jennings also dismisses the insanity theory, while the grand jury at Taunton continues deliberating without reaching a vote.

The Indianapolis Journal · 2 December 1892 · page 5

Story Grand Jury Not Yet Through. Fall Rivee, Mass., Dee. 1. John V. Morse, uncle of Lizzie Borden, declares there is no ground whatever for the claim that his niece is insane. He had known her from the time she was a little child and never had she shown the slightest signs ot insanity. On his own side of the family he could say there had been no insanity as far hack as its history, was known.. Lizzie Lorden was equally free from any danger of inheriting insanity lrom her father's aide.

See moreSee less

Andrew Jennings, counsel for Miss Borden, puts no faith in the insanity theo ry, and states that the defense did not pro pose to build anything on that idea. The grand jury at Taunton adjourned at B:C) p. m. until 9:30 a.m. to-morrow, and the

See the clipping

The Goodland Republic · Goodland, Kan.

A dispatch from Taunton, Mass. reports that the grand jury considering the murder case against Lizzie Borden is widely believed likely to return no indictment. It notes that jurors have said nothing publicly, but officials seem cautious about acting hastily.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Goodland Republic · 2 December 1892 · page 6

f ave promise of years of usefulness, lis hair was black, Blightly tinged with gray, and was relieved by an almost snow white beard. LIZZIE BORDEN MAY ESCAPE. Th Belief General That No Indictment for Murder Will Do Found. Taonton. Mass., Nov. 28. The 1m prossion prevails that the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father, Andrew Borden, but the publio is bo more certain of this than when the case first went into the harlots of tho jury, since ne mem ber of that body has expiessed himself in any way.

See moreSee less

It is felt that the attorney general realizes that it would be better for all concerned to make no error in Judg ment now, even at the risk of conjur ing up false appearances and to place Miss Borden in a position where she will not be beyond the reach of jus tice. The probabilities are strongly In favor of no bill. OoTernor ItueeeU's If urallty. Boston, Nov. 28. The count at trie atate housfe shews that Governor Rus sell is re-elected by a plurality of 2,890. The plurality ot Roger Wolcott, Republican, for lieutenant governor over James B. Carroll, Democrat, la 9,96.1 Seals Lev1" Alaska Kookerlei. Wasuinoton,Nov.28. Captain Ilealy of the revenue service, In his report to the department, says the seals are leaving the Alaska rookeries, and It is estimated that there are about 5,000 remaining at St George.

See the clipping

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas · and 1 other paper

The grand jury investigating the Lizzie Borden case has been dismissed temporarily. Observers believe important developments are expected to follow.

The Iola Register · 2 December 1892 · page 7

Philadelphia Typographical Union Na 2 has indorsed George Chance, its president, for the position of public printer under the Cleveland administra tion. Superintendent Bosijysiiell, of the Philadelphia mint, denies the circulated report that he has allowed anyone to take any of the world's fair souvenir coins. It is said that Cleveland is opposed to Murphy as senator from Xew York, and and that he asked him to withdraw in favor of Whitney. The grand jury investigating the Lizzie Borden case has been dismissed temporarily, and it is believed that there are important developments.

See moreSee less

President-elect Cleveland has left New York for a two weeks' hunting and fishing trip and will be lost to the .sight of office holders. Fierce flames were raging in a mine near Scranton, Pa., and a number of miners who attempted to put out the fire were nearly suffocated. At Sharpsburg, Pa., the house of II.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss. · 3 December 1892

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

John V. Morse, Lizzie Borden's uncle, states there is no family history of insanity on either side and denies claims of her insanity. Meanwhile, the grand jury in Taunton resumes examining witnesses in the Borden case, with District Attorney Knowlton dismissing the latest insanity story as false.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 2 December 1892 · page 1

GLOBE, 150-152 X JIain St. LIZZIE BORDEN. FALL Kiver. Muss., Dec, 1. Mr. John V. Morse, mi uncle of Lizzie Borden's de elHres tlint there is no ground whatever for the claim that his nieco is insane. He hud known her ever siuce 8ho was a little ;irl and she hud never shown the slightest sinii of insauity. On his own side of the family he said that there had been no in sanity ns far buck us its history waskiiown. Lizzie Borden was equally free from any danger of inheriting insanity from her father's side.

See moreSee less

Taunton, Mas., Dec. 1. The grand jury resumed us -essioti this morning aud began the examination of more witnessei in th' Borden chsc Detective Mclleury and wife, who were mixed up in the sensa tional publication a few weeks since, were in the court house and were anions: the witnesses, to testify. District Attorney Kuowltou stated i-qunrely this morning that the last insanity story is nil bosh. At 11:15 o'clock a. ru. the evideuce was in, and the grand jury took the case, with the piobability of a report early in tho afternoon.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The grand jury in Taunton resumed hearings on the Borden murder case, questioning witnesses including detective McHenry and his wife, who had previously made sensational claims. Reports that Lizzie Borden would be declared insane were denied by her relatives and her lawyer, Mr. Jennings, as absurd; the jury adjourned without announcing a decision.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 2 December 1892 · page 1

Lizzie Borden vor der Grand Jury.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Mankato Free Press · Mankato, Minn.

The grand jury in Taunton, Massachusetts reconvened on December 1 to continue investigating the Borden murder case. Speculation suggests an indictment against Lizzie Borden may have already been decided but was withheld for release on this day or the next.

The Mankato Free Press · 2 December 1892 · page 3

The Borden Case. Taunton, Mass.,Dec. I.—The grand jury will today resume its investiga tion into the now famous Borden murder case. There are those who believe that a verdict was reached in dicting Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents on the day of the ad journment of the grand jury and for some unknown reason decision was reserved until today or tomorrow.

See the clipping

Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D.

A Taunton, Mass. special reports that the impression prevails the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father and stepmother. It suggests the Attorney General favors avoiding a misstep and that probabilities favor no bill being returned.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Dakota Farmers' Leader · 2 December 1892 · page 2

roes made a full confession of the murder, IB Implicating his two fellow prisoners He says he cut the old man's throat and they crushed his head iu with rocks. Public sentiment even in Chattanooga is not averse to lynching such fiends should they cscape on trial. Bailors Kidnaped. Tacomn, Wash., special: Shipping circles are excited over the kidn pping of eight non-union sailors which occurred here. A ten-ton sloop came over from Seattle bring ing four members of the Sailors' Union. These went from ship to ship in the harbor and gathered a force of thirty union sailors, most of whom .went to the.

See moreSee less

sloop in sail boats. Shorty bofore midnight they ap proached the bark and, finding nobody on iguard. they climbed over her sides and /down into the forecastle. They rudely awakened the non-union sailors by pound ing them on the head with the butt end of revolvers. They were ordered to pack up their clothes, and they did so. Then the union men carried them forcibly aboard the sloop, locked them In the hachway and aet sail. They were landed at Port Blakely, thirty miles from Tacoma. They were left without a cent of money and with the in junction that if caught again on a non-un ion ship they would be killed. Llnlo I! or den Will Kscape. Taunton, Mas?., special: The impression prevails that the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and Mrs. Borden. Tho Attorney General realizes that it would be better for all con cerned to make no erior of judgment now, even at the risk of conjuring up false ap pearances and to place Miss Borden in a po sition where she will not be beyond the reach of justice. The probabilities are strongly in lavor of no bill. More Fighting In Samoa. San Francisco special: A correspondent Writing from Samoa November 9 says: ••The natives a: fighting in the bay. The towns are all destoyed, no native houses toeing left standing. European property Is safe yet, but the natives are threaten ing to burn the white people out. Business is at a stand-till. All the natives have now 3eft the Bay of Paso Pago, and are on thu east end of the island." A Kew I'rem'er. Ottawa, Ont., special: Sir John Calwell Abbot has at last put in his resignation as premier. Lord Stanley sent for Sir John TLompson and .d vised him of the fact, at the same time asking him to form a Gov ernment. Sir John accepted the task and was sworn in as premier. The new priem.er stated that the personnel of the cabinet 'would not be known for a few days. wi.M.At".!Aii'inri,-ri-JWritriliilifllf' Vil it

See the clipping

Asheville Daily Citizen · Asheville, N.C.

A brief dispatch from Taunton, Mass., reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the grand jury on three counts. No further details of the charges are given.

Asheville Daily Citizen · 2 December 1892 · page 1

Tbluk Her a Murderer. Tai nton, Mass.,Dcc. 2. Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the grand jury on three counts,

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The Grand Jury in Taunton, Massachusetts has indicted Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father, with three counts in the indictment including murder. The report recaps the August 4th killings of Andrew and Abby Borden, the ensuing police investigation, and Lizzie's arrest on August 11.

The Evening World · 2 December 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE IS INDICTED.

still held that a bill would bo found. v M The murder ot Andrew Borden and wife, ?"a Fall Itlver, occurred Thursday, Aug. 3. .'1 It at once became a reigning sensation ..; the day. Mr. Borden was killed In the famUy anting 'i room, Mrs. Borden In a bedroo npstatm jj Tbe old lady, subsequent evidence showed, A was killed about two hours before her bus.?' band. & The murder was a mystery. It was doas' well towards mtdday.'Nobody had been Beev to enter nor leave the house. ; Tho police ran down cine after cine In vala. t I A suspicion that Ltizle Borden knew moroj than she cared to tell about the crime deepft

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The article reviews how suspicion grew against Lizzie Borden, leading to her arrest on August 11 for her father's murder. It summarizes the weak evidence, her alibi in the barn, and the theorized motive of a family quarrel over the estate.

The Evening World · 2 December 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE IS INDICTED.

and their bodies bore many wound. .1 Yet tbe bloody work was Mlfl well aud quietly done that the servant work- 'n leg In tbe house heard nothing of anydHXj turbance. Lizzie Borden discovered tfeo'Sfl bodies herself. iM ..al

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The grand jury has formally indicted Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father and stepmother, with two separate counts in the indictment. The report recounts the case background, including the discovery of the bodies, her arrest on August 11, and her calm demeanor throughout proceedings.

The Evening World · 2 December 1892 · page 3

The Murder of Her Old Parents. Two Counts in the Bill Presented by the Grand Jury. Streams of Evidence Threshed Over Before the Finding.

ill! held Uiat a bill would be found. i "" ""- "Tlio murder of Andrew Borden and wife, ot all Hirer, occurred Thursday, Aug. ::. 1c at once becamo a reigning sensation of

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A dispatch from Taunton, Massachusetts reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted on three counts for the murder of her father and mother, described as a wealthy, prominent couple from Fall River. The item appears amid a roundup of brief national news items.

Paper unidentified · 2 December 1892 · page 2

Murdoross Indicted. TauntVln, Mass., Dec. 2. Lizzie Borden has been indicted ou three counts, on charge of murdering hor futher and mothor, a wealthy prom lueut old couple at Fall River.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Bristol County grand jury returned a three-count indictment against Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father Andrew Jackson Borden and stepmother Abby Durfee Borden. The report details the formal courtroom proceedings at Taunton where the indictment was announced by the foreman and delivered to the clerk.

The Providence News · 2 December 1892 · page 1

INDICTED.

P. Thompson of Gloucester. Distriet Attorney Knowliton walked in with his usu |1 businesslike air, and de posited books and papers in front of the clerk’s desk, his face betraying no sign of what was about to happeun. Simon Borden, Jr., the assistant clerk of the court, was in his place when Mr, Kuowlton ealmly said : “The grand jury is ready to make fur ther report, your honor.” g Mr. Borden then said; *“The criemwill make proclamation, and the grand jurors will answer as their names are called.” So the crier, Deputy Sheriff Dean, did muke praclamation and counted the graond jurors, There were twenty-one of them.

See moreSee less

Then the clerk asked ; “Mr. Foreman, have you any present ments to make?”’ The foreman answered: *“We have sir ? Deputy Sheriff Arnold thereupon ce livered the papers to the clerk. Amoung thom were the three indictments against Lizzie Andrew Borden for miu:der, That was all. Lizzie was no% presentin court and consequently there was no arraignment. The indictment was, or will be, served upon her at the jail. Chen Mr, Knowlton stated there was nothing further for the grand jury to be held for aud after a momentary lull, the district attorney stated that an indiet nent had been found against® Miss Borden, and moved that as required by the statutes, copies thereof be servec upon her, The motion was granted, There are three indictments against Miss Borden, two of one conunt, each charging the murder of her step nother and father, and a third of two counts charging the murder of both, As It Looked This Morning,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Bristol County grand jury returned indictments against Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father Andrew and stepmother Abby, consisting of three separate counts. Borden was not present in court, so no arraignment occurred, and copies of the indictment were to be served to her at the jail.

The Providence News · 2 December 1892 · page 1

THREE COUNTS TO INDICTMENT.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report assesses the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden before the grand jury's decision, noting the weapon used in the murders has never been found and that New Bedford witnesses meant to prove she tried to buy poison were not convincing. It dismisses rumors that the government might abandon the case on grounds of insanity as mere speculation.

The Providence News · 2 December 1892 · page 1

1L is not probable tuat twenity wituesses of the dulecti\m McHenry kind would appear In Tauntoun, give evidence and de part, without, at the samne time, commu nicating to the public the nature of their evience, The immysterious boxes of clothing and the bubble of the McHeury-Trickey dis clusure have been followed by the most incredible statements of all, viz., that the government would abandou the case on the wround o Miss Borden’s iusanity. This was the only loophole left if tue government bacame coavinced that it would fail to get Miss Borden indicted, but those who know District Attoruey Kunowlton bhave consistently laid this theory aside as only another canard, The only two poiuts in which the govern ment’s case needed strengthening were the finding of the weapon and the proof of motive, The weapou has not been found, and the case reduces itself to the

See the clipping

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · Clarksville, Tenn.

This single line from a roundup of miscellaneous news items states that Lizzie Borden's friends do not believe she is insane. It appears amid a long list of unrelated local stories from across the country.

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · 2 December 1892 · page 3

NEWS IN A NUTSHELL.

The Stone City bank, of Joliet, Ills.. with a capital stock of $100,000, has sus pended payments. At Borden, Ind, William Littell dis charged a cartridge on an anvil, and the load lodged in bis leg.

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

A brief dispatch from Taunton, Massachusetts reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted on three counts. No further details are given in this short wire item.

San Antonio Daily Light · 2 December 1892 · page 1

Lizzie Indicted. Taunton, Mass., Dec. 2 —Lizzie Borden has been indicted on 3 counts. RM Is for New York London, Dec. 2 —“Jem” Hall, the

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The grand jury in Taunton, Mass., adjourned at 5:30 p.m. until the next morning without taking any vote in the Lizzie Borden matter. Reports note the public still knows no more than before, and a vote is expected the next day once the evidence is fully digested.

Richmond Dispatch · 2 December 1892 · page 1

fOr YOATS. LL The Borden Case, 12) VEINS LB PE PU FRR Aram TAUNTON, MASS, December 1L.—The grand jury adjourned at 5:30 P. M. until 9:30 o'clock to morrow forencon, and the general public knows

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The grand jury in Taunton adjourned until the next morning without taking a vote on the Lizzie Borden case. The public reportedly knew no more than before, though evidence was still being considered.

Richmond Dispatch · 2 December 1892 · page 1

The Borden Case

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The grand jury in the Borden murder case resumed session, examining bloodstained items and the skulls of both victims while hearing testimony from witnesses including Detective McHenry and his wife. Prosecutor Knowlton declared the insanity theory 'bosh,' while Lizzie Borden's uncle and her own defense attorney Jennings both rejected any suggestion she was insane.

The Times · 2 December 1892 · page 1

THE INSANITY PLEA RIDICULED

Counsel Will Adopt It. TAUNTON, MASS., Dec. 1.—The grand jury resumed its session this morning and began the examination of more witnesses in the Borden murder case, Detective Me Henry and wife, who were mixed up with the sensational publication a few weeks since, were in the ccurt-house and were among the witnesses to testify, District Attorney Knowlton stated square ly this morning that the last insanity story is “all bosh.” The grand jury called for the bloodspat tered pillcw-shams and linen taken from the room where Mrs. Borden was slala, and these, with the two skulls of the two vic tims, were once more submitted to inspec tion in the jury room.

See moreSee less

It is inferred that a resume of all the evidence in the case is on the docket. Mrs. Peckham and Mrs. Hall, of Fall River, were two new witnesses befcre the grand jury this morning. It is estimated that their testimony was in the line cf new evidence obtained during the recent recess, At 11:15 A. M. the evidence was in and the grand jury took a recess, FALL RIVER, MASS., Dec. 1.—Mr. John Morse, uncle of Lizzie Borden, declares that there is no ground whatever for the claim that his niece is insane. He had known her from the time she was a little child, and never had she shown the slightest signs cf insanity. Andrew Jennings, counsel for Miss Dor den, puts no faith in the insanity theory, and states that the defense did not propose to build up anything on that idea. Miss Borden's friends, as far as he knew, had absolute faith in her sanity. : ed eaten p—

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The Taunton grand jury resumed hearing witnesses in the Borden case, examining bloodstained items and the victims' skulls again, with District Attorney Knowlton dismissing a recent insanity story as 'all bosh.' Lizzie Borden's uncle John Morse and her attorney Andrew Jennings both stated there was no basis for claims of her insanity.

The Times · 2 December 1892 · page 1

THE INSANITY PLEA RIDICULED. Neither Lizzie Borden’s Uncle Nor Her Counsel Will Adopt It. TAUNTON, MASS., Dec. 1.—The grand jury resumed its session this morning and

See the clipping

Vermont Phœnix · Brattleboro, Vt.

The dispatch states that Lizzie Borden will not be indicted by the grand jury for the murders of her father and stepmother, citing insufficient evidence beyond what was presented at the Fall River hearing. It predicts she will be a free woman within a week.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Vermont Phœnix · 2 December 1892 · page 3

The consolidation of the four mammoth export breweries of the United States the Anheuser Buseh and the William J. Lcmp of St. Louis, and the Schiltz and the Pabst of Milwaukee (the last witli its four auxiliaries) with a capital stock of $40,000,000, and bonds to tho amount of $200,000,000, to supply the world with beer, is the gigantic enterprise which Is being fathered by tho Bothseliilds of Eng land, and the consummation of which is among the possibilities. Lizzie Borden will not be indicted by the grand jury for tho murder of her father

See the clipping

The Olympia Tribune · Olympia, Wash.

A multi-topic news digest reports that in Taunton, Mass., Lizzie Borden has been indicted on three counts for murdering her father and mother, described as a wealthy, prominent Fall River couple. The item appears among unrelated wire stories on politics, crime, and disasters.

The Olympia Tribune · 2 December 1892 · page 1

Ellsworth Wyatt, one of the most desper ,aie members of the Dalton robber gang,- 1 has been captured near Terre Haute, In . At Taunton, Mass., Lizzie Borden has been indicted on three counts, on a charge of murdering her father and mother, a wealthy prominent old couple of Fall river. Peesident Diaz. of Mexico, was re-inau gurated yesterday. Judd Holland, colored, an ex-convict, killed-a dozen line cows with a knife at CO - Ohio. He was arrested. Sidney Smith. brought to Omaha from Toronto tWo months ago for forgery, plead ed guilty and was sentenced to a year in the penitentiary.

See moreSee less

He was formerly presi dent of the Association of American Ar chitects. In Davenport, lowa, 0. I. Bagley, United States express messenger. who took a pack age containing SIOO,OOO, and afterward restored it, was arraigned in the district court and pleaded not guilty.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The Taunton grand jury concluded its hearings and returned an indictment charging Lizzie Borden with the murders of her father and stepmother, Abby Durfee Borden, in Fall River. The report reproduces the formal indictment language regarding the killing of Abby Borden, noting a third indictment was withheld and that the news had yet to be broken to the prisoner.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Goodland Republic, 2 December 1892, Dakota Farmers' Leader, 2 December 1892, Vermont Phœnix, 2 December 1892.

Morning Journal and Courier · 3 December 1892 · page 3

INDICTED FOR MURDER.

THE BORDEN DICRDERS. The Grand Jury Retnrni an Indict ment Charging Lizzie Borden With the Killing or Her Father and Bis WifeA Xhlrd Indictment With held Breaking the News to the Prisoner. Taunton, Maes., Deo. 2. The grand jury met this morning and resumed hear ing evidence in the Borden murder case. Deteotive MoHenry, his wife, and an un known women were called in. Then a small boy, before unnoticed, was intro duced. At the close of their hearing they returned an indictment against Lizzie Bor den on two counts for the murder of her her father and mother in Fall River, Mass. The following is the indictment as fonnd by the grand jnry: TBS BORDEN INDICTMENT CASE OF MASSA

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The grand jury returned an indictment against Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father Andrew and stepmother Abby, detailing the wounds inflicted with a sharp instrument. A third secret indictment was also issued against an unnamed, uncustodied party, believed to relate to Mr. Trickey.

Morning Journal and Courier · 3 December 1892 · page 3

Bristol, at Fall River, in the connty of Bristol, on the fourth day of Angust, in the year 1892, in and upon one Abby Dur fee Borden feloniously and wilfully and of her malice aforethought an assault did make and with a certain weapon, to wit, a sharp cutting instrument, the name and a more particular description of which is to the jurors unknown, her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, feloniSfSlSa "1, J ft I beat and bruise in and uron the head of nB. the Bftid Abby Durfee Borden, giviDg to her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, by the said striking, cutting, beating and braising in and npon the head of her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, divers, to wit, twenty mortal wounds, of whioh said mor tal wounds and the said Abby Durfee Borden then and there instantly died.

See moreSee less

And so the jurors aforesaid upon their oatbs aforesaid do say that the said Lizzie An drew Borden, the said Abby Durfee Borden in manner and form aforesaid then and there feloniously, wilfully and of her mal ice aforethought did and kill and murder against the peaoe of the said common wealth and contrary to the form of the statuta in such case made and provided. The next count is the same as the first, merely substituting the name of Andrew Jackson Borden for Abby Durfee Borden, and ten mortal wounds instead of twenty. There is a third indictment which was kept a secret, as the party indicted is not in custody. The jury made no public re port in conrt. It 6ei in, banded its paper to the court and then was dismissed, and disappeared in the region of the treasurer's office for payment. All looked tired and much as if each had passed through the trying soenes of a town meeting. None 'was disposed to be oommunioative. Dis trict Attorney Knowlton will neither ad mit nor deny that the third indictment re lates to Mr. Trickey of the late sensational story matters, but such is the impression at the court house. It is understood that Hiss Borden will not be immediately ar raigned to plead, but that the Indictments will be served on her at her quarters in Taunton jail. She was notified to-day by friends of the return of the indictments by the grand jury, and is said to have pre served the same stolid demeanor which has marked her course during the trial. When it became known this morning that the grand jury was all at sea yester day, and bad spent the day ia a free and easy discussion, something after the style of a town meeting, there was a general ex pectation that no verdict would be returned against Lizzie Borden. It was evident that the jury sentiment was divided and it wb

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

After two days of contentious deliberation resembling a town meeting, the Bristol County grand jury finally returned indictments against Lizzie Borden, with spectators uncertain until the end whether any verdict would be reached. Rumors circulated that a third indictment might relate to reporter Trickey from the earlier witness-tampering scandal, though District Attorney Knowlton would not confirm this.

Morning Journal and Courier · 3 December 1892 · page 3

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The grand jury returned a true bill against Lizzie Borden, relieving tension in Fall River though many had expected it. The indictment contains two counts—one for each parent's murder by hatchet with 20 mortal wounds—plus a separate sealed indictment for an unnamed party.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 3 December 1892 · page 2

Bnt Few Believed That the Grand Jurj Would Do Otherwise. Fall River, Mass., Dec. 3. The news of the verdict of the grand jury in bring ing in a true bill against Lizzie Borden has relieved the people of this city from a great strain. All along the majority have bean of the opinion that an indict ment would be found against her, al though there was a large contingent who could not be induced to believe that such a result could be accomplished. These same people are the ones who even now believe iu Miss Borden's innocence and think her to be the victim of a con

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Lizzie Borden was indicted by a grand jury in Taunton on three counts related to the murders of her father and mother, with one count kept secret since the accused party was not in custody. She reportedly remained calm upon hearing the news from friends, maintaining the same composed demeanor she showed during the preliminary hearing.

The Morning Call · 3 December 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN INDICTED. Nothing Can Shake the Marble Calm ness of the Girl. Taunton, Mass., Dec. 2.— Lizzie Bordea' was indicted to-day on three counts for the ; murder of her father and mother. The first count in the indictment charge* • Lizzie Borden with the murder of bar mother and the second with the murder of * her father. The third count of the Indict-. . ment was kept secret, as the party Indicted is not In custody. It is understood tbat the ' indictments will be served on Miss Bordea' at her quarters in Taunton jail.

See moreSee less

She wa* notified to-day by friends of the return of the indictments by the Graud Jury, and It said to have preserved tne same stolid de- ; meanor which marked her course during the preliminary examination.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

A Taunton dispatch reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted on three counts for the murder of her father and mother at Fall River. The first two counts name each parent separately, while the third remains secret, and she was notified of the indictment while maintaining her composure in jail.

The Record-Union · 3 December 1892 · page 1

Lizzie Borden Indicted. Taunton (Mass.), Doc. 2.—Lizzie Bor den has boen indicted on three counts on the charge of murdering her father aud mother, a wealthy and prominent old couple at Fall Kiver. The first count of tho indictment charges Lizzie Borden with the murder of her mother and the second with ihe murder of her father. Tho third count of the indictment was kept secret, as the party indicted was not in custody. It is understood that tho indictments will lie served on Miss Borden at her quarters in the Taunton jail. She was nuliiied to day by friends ofthe return of tho indict ments by the Orand Jury, and is said to havo preserved the same stolid demeanor which marked her course during the trial.

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The grand jury in Taunton, Mass. heard testimony from Detective McHenry, his wife, a veiled lady, and a previously unnoticed small boy. In the afternoon, the grand jury indicted Lizzie Borden on two counts.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 3 December 1892 · page 1

Lizzie Borden Indicted. Taunton, Mass., Dec. 8.—The grand jury yesterday began agaiit liearing evi dence in the Bordon case. Detective McHenry, his wife, and unknown veiled lady were called. Then a small

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

A Taunton dispatch states the Grand Jury adjourned without indicting Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father and stepmother, predicting she would soon be freed. It notes the evidence was the same as at the earlier hearing and insufficient to the State's attorney, while suggesting indictments might instead be sought against those who fabricated evidence against her.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Washington Bee · 3 December 1892 · page 2

A dispatch from Taunton, Mass., re ferring to the adjournment of the Grand Jury without finding an indictment, says: Lizzie Borden will not be indicted by the Grand Jury for the murder of her father and stepmother. In another week, without any doubt, she will be a free woman. The evidence laid before the Grand Jury was essentially the same as that produced at the hearing'at Fall River, and it was not deemed sufficient by -the State's attorney to warrant the finding of an indictment. There is not one scintilla of evidence to prove that Lizzie Borden is guilty, beyond the fact that she was in the house at or about the time that the murders were committed, that the family relations were unpleasant,

See the clipping

In the story →

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The Grand Jury in Taunton, Massachusetts indicted Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother after a day of divided deliberation that initially suggested no indictment would result. Despite rumors the case might fail, the jury returned an indictment around 10 a.m. following additional witness testimony.

New-York Tribune · 3 December 1892 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN INDICTED.

THE GRAND JURY CHARGES HER WITH THE MURDER OF HER FATHER AND STEPMOTHER.

See moreSee less

Taunton, Mass., Dec. 2.--Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the Grand Jury on two counts. When it became known this morning that the Grand Jury was all at sea yesterday and had spent the day in a free and easy discussion, something after the style of a town meeting, there was a general expectation that no verdict would be returned against Lizzie Borden. It was evident that the jury sentiment was divided, and it was expected that the long hesitation, discussion, and rambling volume of testimony, which had been exhausted in the case had not accomplished what the District-Attorney desired. Again the fact that more witnesses were called in to-day, that McHenry and wife were again interviewed, and that two more witnesses were examined ,gave the impression that the case was likely to end in smoke. The District-Attorney, however, had been particularly smiling for two days and that was interpreted as a sign that he was sure of his case and was quietly waiting until the jury should grow weary of talking and settle down to business. This they did at about 10 o'clock this morning, and after a little over two hours of deliberation upon the matter returned an indictment. As it was the dinner-hour when they came in, the courtroom was not so full of anxious spectators as it had been. Those who were there, however, waiting for a sensation, had none to enjoy. The jury filed into the courtroom looking hungry, tired and ready to go home. The judge asked them if they had any matters to present. The foreman said they had, and passed up some papers. The judge glanced at them, handed them to the clerk, and then dismissed the jury.

The first count of the indictment charges that Lizzie Andrew Borden on August 4, 1892, inflicted upon Abby Durfee Borden twenty mortal wounds, of which she instantly died. The next count is the same as the first, merely substituting the name of Andrew Jackson Borden for Abby Durfee Borden and ten mortal wounds instead of twenty.

There is a third indictment, which was kept a secret, as the person indicted is not in custody. District-Attorney Knowlton will neither admit nor deny that the third indictment relates to Mr. Trickey, of the late sensational story matters, but such is the impression at the courthouse.

It is understood that Miss Borden will not be immediately arraigned to plead, but that the indictments will be served on her in Taunton jail. She was informed to-day by friends of the return of the indictments by the Grand Jury and is said to have preserved the same stolid demeanor which has marked her course during the trial. The friends of Miss Borden had nothing to say, except that it had come out almost as they had expected, but they affirmed that no new evidence had been found, and that it only remained for a speedy trial before a jury to establish her innocence.

When the Grand Jury met this morning Detective McHenry, his wife and an unknown veiled woman were called in. Then a small boy, before unnoticed, was introduced.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

After calling additional witnesses including the McHenrys, the grand jury returned an indictment against Lizzie Borden charging her with the murders of Abby and Andrew Borden. A third, sealed indictment was also issued against a person not in custody, rumored to be linked to a man named Trickey.

New-York Tribune · 3 December 1892 · page 4

MURDER OF HER FATHER AND STEPMOTHER

Abby Durfee Borden twenty mortal wonnds, of which she Instantly dled, The next count is the same as the first, merdy substituting the name of Andrew Juckson Borden for Abby Durfee Borden and ten mortal wounds instead of twenty, There 1s a third Indictment, widsh was kept a copet, ns the por=on Indieted 15 not In eistody, Dis. (Met-Attorney Knowlton wil nofther admit nor deny that the third indictment relates to Mr, ‘Frickey, of the Inte sensational story matters, but such 1s the impression at the eourtlionse, It 1 understood that Miss Borden will not be fin mealintoly arenignod to plead, but that the indie tments wil be served on her In Taunton jail, She was hformesl to«dny by friends of the return of the Ldietby the Grand Jury and ix #ald to have premeen ts vosame stolid demeanor witch has marked <orvisl cour<e during the teil, The friends of Miss her had nothing to say, except that Qt had come Bordon they had expeotid, but they affirmed out almost 0s that no new evidence bad been found, and that It only remained for a speedy trial before a jury to establish hor innocence, When the Grand Jury met this mopiaeg Detective Mellenry, his w and an nonkocown vel Women were called In, a small boy, before unnoticed, Then was lntroduced, ———— — lf Sete

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The grand jury in Taunton, Massachusetts indicted Lizzie Borden on two counts for the murder of her father and mother. The brief report gives only the bare fact of the indictment.

The Morning News · 3 December 1892 · page 1

Lizzie i. or den Indicted. Taunton, Mass., Dec. 2.— The grand jury to-day indicted Lizzie Borden on two counts for the murder of her father and mother.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A Taunton grand jury indicted Lizzie Andrew Borden for the murders of her stepmother Abby Durfee Borden and father Andrew Jackson Borden, detailing twenty and ten mortal wounds respectively. A third, undisclosed indictment was also returned against a party not yet in custody.

The Indianapolis Journal · 3 December 1892 · page 3

The Grand Jury's Presentment. Taunton. Mass., Dec 2. Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the grand jury In three counts, as follows: The jurors for the Commonwealth of Massa chusetts, on their oaths, present that Lizzie Au drey Borden, of Fall River, in the county of Bris tol, at Fall hirer, on the 4th day of August, in the year 1892, In aud upon one Abby Durfee Borden, feloniously and willfully, and of her own malice aforethought, an assault did make, and with a certain weapon, to-wit: a sharp outtlng Instru mentthe name and a more particular descrip tion of which Is to the lorors unknown ber, too said Abby Durfee Borden, feloniously, willfully and of her malice aforethought, did strike, cut,, beat and bruise lu and upon tue head of her, tao; ssld Abby Uurice Borden, giving to her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, by the said striking, cutting, beating and bruising In and upou the head ot her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, divers, to-wit, twenty mortal wounds, of which paid mor tal wounds tbe said Abby Durfee Borden there and Instantly dlei 8o tbe Jurors aforesaid, upon their oaths aforesaid, do say the said Lizzie Andrew Borden, the said Abby Durfee Borden, In manner and form aforesaid, then aud there feloniously, willfully and of her malice afore thought did kill and murder, against tbe peace of tbe said Commonwealth, and contrary to the form of the statute in such case made and pro vided.

See moreSee less

The next count is tbe same as tbe first, merely substituting tbe name ef Andrew Jackson Borden for Abby Durfoe Borden,

See the clipping

Baxter Springs News · Baxter Springs, Kan.

A brief news item states that the delay in the Lizzie Borden case stems from the court's belief that she is insane. No further detail or source is given for this claim.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Baxter Springs News · 3 December 1892 · page 6

Lizzie Borden case is that tho court be lieves her to bo insane. IT is authoritatively stated that cx Secretary of the Treasury Fairchild will again be tendered that portfolio. The Stone City bank, of Jollet, I1L, a powerful private institution, suspended, causing muuli embarrassment to busi ness firms. An Erie express struck a wagon at a crossing at EUnira, S. Y. Two women and a man were killed and a woman fatally injured. A cabinet crisis is reported in Spain, caused by the resignation of the min ister of the interior. A Japanf.sk war vessel was' sunk by collision with a British steamer. The crew of 275 men were drowned. The passengers of the British steamer were transferred to the Empress of India.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The Taunton, Mass. grand jury indicted Lizzie Borden on the morning of December 2 for the murder of her parents in Fall River on August 4. Three counts were found—one each for the murder of her father and mother, and a third kept secret because that person is in custody.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 3 December 1892 · page 3

Lizzie Borden in Slnklagezustand versetzt» Taunton, Mass., 2. Dezember. —Die Grand-Jury hat heute Morgen Lizzie Borden der Ermordung ihrer El tern zu Fall-River, Mass., am vorigen

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The grand jury in Fall River returned indictments against Lizzie Borden for the murders of her stepmother Abby and father Andrew Borden, detailing the number of wounds inflicted on each victim. A third, sealed indictment was rumored to relate to Mrs. Trickey, though the district attorney would not confirm this, and Borden was reported to have received the news calmly.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 3 December 1892 · page 1

INDICTED.

The grand jury in their finding say that Lizzie Andrews Borden, on Aug. 4th.last. <lid feloniously, wilfully, an.! of malice aforethought strike and beat Abbie l>urfee Borden w ith a certain sharp cutting weapon inflecting 20 mortal w ounds of which said Abbie Purfee Borden instantly died. The next indictment is the same as the , first, merely substituting the name of \n drew Jackson Borden for Abbie Purfee Borden and ten wounds for 20. The third indictment which is kept secret as the party indicted is not in custody. The jury made no public report in the court.

See moreSee less

It | filed and handed its papers to the court and then was dismissed and disappeared in the region of the treasurer’s office for payment. AH looked tired and much as if each had passed through trying scenes, and none were disposed to be communicative. Pis triet Attorney Know lion will neither admit nor deny that the third indictment relates to Mrs. Triekey of the late sensational story, but such is the impression at the court house. It is understood that Miss Borden will not be immediately arraigned to plead, but

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The grand jury returned a true bill against Lizzie Borden, and a second, undisclosed indictment was also handed up, rumored to involve journalist Henry G. Trickey rather than complicity in the murders. Fall River residents widely expected the indictment and discussed it as the sole topic of conversation, while Borden's friends insisted no new evidence had emerged.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 3 December 1892 · page 1

INDICTED.

affirmed. Friend* of Miss Borden had nothing to say. save that it had come out almost as they had expected. They stoutly affirm, however, that there has Wen no new evi dence found, and that it only remained for a speedy trial tie fore a jury to establish the fact of her innocence.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report reveals that an axe or hatchet introduced as evidence weighed heavily in the grand jury's decision to indict Lizzie Borden, with jurors reportedly seeing no alternative given overwhelming evidence. A second indictment, believed to target Henry G. Trickey for witness tampering, is also mentioned, along with Lizzie's calm reaction to the news and speculation about an insanity defense.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 3 December 1892 · page 1

THE GREAT MYSTERY

already given. Rev. W. \V. Juhb of the Central Con gregational church, whose self-imposed duty it was to wait uj*on M;-*s Borden and inform her of the result of the grand jury’s action, reports that the prisoner received the intelligence w ith indifference, retaining her stolid, unruffled demeanor, and betray ing n it her surprise nor emotion and say ing nothing. \s *oon athe intelligence reached Fall River that an indictment had been found. Kmma Borden left for Taunton and w as closeted for some time with Lizzie. Sim

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Fall River grand jury returns a true bill against Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father and stepmother, with evidence reportedly overwhelming and a hatchet shown to jurors. A second, secret indictment is believed aimed at Boston Globe reporter Henry Trickey for allegedly inducing witnesses to leave town.

The Portland Daily Press · 3 December 1892 · page 1

SHE WILL BE TRIED.

TO BE WANTED. He is Alleged to Have Offered Iuduce ments to Government Witnesses to Take a Journey—Rumor Says That the Evidence Against Miss Borden was Overwhelming—The Tone of Fall River Comment Hostile to the Ac cused.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A report reveals that the grand jury's decision to indict Lizzie Borden was influenced by a hatchet entered as evidence, with jurors calling the evidence overwhelming. It also notes a second, still-secret indictment rumored to target Boston Globe reporter Henry G. Trickey for allegedly tampering with witnesses.

The Portland Daily Press · 3 December 1892 · page 1

stantially as already given. Rev. W. W. Jubb of the Central Congregational church, whose self imposed duty it was to wait upon Miss Borden and inform her of the result of the grand jury’s ac tion, reports that the prisoner received the intelligence, retaining her stolid, un ruffled demeanor, betraying neither sur prise nor emotion, and saying nothing. As soon as the intelligence reached Fall River that an indictment had been found Emma Borden left for Taunton and was closeted for some time in the cell with

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The grand jury in Taunton returned an indictment against Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father, after an internal contest in which the foreman reportedly opposed finding a bill. The indictment was filed in court without arraignment, and the first count detailing the charge regarding Abby Durfee Borden's death is quoted in full.

The Portland Daily Press · 3 December 1892 · page 1

COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS, BRIS TOL, s. s. * At the Superior Court begun and hohlen at Taunton within and for the said county of Bristol, Oil the first Monday of November, In the year of our Lord one thoufaed eight, hun dred and ninety-two, the jurors for the said commonwealth, on their oath, present that Lizzie Andrew Borden of Fall River, in the county of Bristol, at Fall River, in the county of Bristol, on the fourth day of August, in the year 1892, in and upon the body ol Abby Dur fee Bordeii, feloniously, willfully, and of her malice aforethought, an assault did make, and with a certain weapon, to wit: a sharp cutting instniment.

See moreSee less

the name and more iiartieiilar de scription of which is to the jurors unknown, she tlie said Lizzie Andrew Borden, feloniously, willfully and of her malice aforethought, did strike, cut and bruise in and upon the head of her! the said Abby Durfee Borden, giving to her the said Abby Durfee Borden, by the said striking, cutting, beating and bruising in and upon the head of her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, divers to wit: Twenty mortal wounds, of which said mortal wounds the said Abby Durfee Borden then and there instantly died. And so the jurors aforesaid, upon their oatli aforesaid, do say that the said Lizzie Borden upon the said Abby Durfee Borden, in manner and form aforesaid, then and there feloniously, wilfully and of malice aforethought, did kill and murder against the peace oi’ said Common wealh. and contrary to the form of the statute in such case made and provided. The second part of tlie indictment is the same as the first, merely substitut

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A brief notice states that Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the grand jury on charges of double murder. No further details are given in this excerpt.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 3 December 1892 · page 3

Lizzie Borden Indicted by the Grand Jury for Double Murder. Chicago, Dec. Seven safe robber ies in one building in one night, within one square of police headquarters, was

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A grand jury in Taunton, Massachusetts has indicted Lizzie Borden on three counts, two of which charge her with murdering Abby and Andrew Borden. A third indictment is being kept secret because the party named in it is not in custody, possibly related to Mr. Rickey.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 3 December 1892 · page 3

INDICTED LIZZIE BORDEN. Two Counts Included in the Charge of Murder. Taunton, Mass,, Dec. Lizzie Bor den lias been indicted on three counts. The following is the indictment, as

See the clipping

The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss.

A report from Taunton, Mass. states that many believe the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for her father's murder, though no juror has confirmed this. The attorney-general is said to be cautious about making an error, wanting to ensure Borden remains within reach of justice if needed.

The Grenada Sentinel · 3 December 1892 · page 3

Kmpernr William's Ickness. London, Nov. 28.—A correspondent sends from Berlin information concern ing the emperor's present indisposi tion. There is little doubt that the "cold" from which Emperor William suffers at present is a renewal of the trouble with his car. This trouble was supposed to have been allayed for some time by the beneficial effects of the emperor's whaling voyage. It has ap peared again, however, with increased violence. _______ Lints Borden May Not Be Tried. Taurtor, Mass., Nov. 27.—The Im

See the clipping

Macon Beacon · Macon, Miss.

The report states that it is widely believed the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for her father's murder, though this is not certain. It notes the attorney general's caution in handling the case to avoid errors while ensuring she remains within reach of justice.

Macon Beacon · 3 December 1892 · page 1

Llssle Borden's Chuoea. Taunton, Mats., Nov. 28. The im pression prevails that the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father, Andrew Borden, but the public isne more certain of thla than it was when the first case went Into the hands of th Jury, only by in ference, since no member of that body has expressed himself in any way. It is felt that the attorney general realizes that it would be bettor for all concern ed to make no error of judgment now, even at the risk of conjuring up false appearances and to place Miss llorden in a position where she will not lx be yond the reach of justice.

See the clipping

The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.

This heavily garbled report appears to announce some basis for hope in Lizzie Borden's situation, though the OCR damage obscures the specific legal development being described. It follows an unrelated melodramatic anecdote about a woman who shot a man who had wronged her.

The New North-West · 3 December 1892 · page 1

HOPE FOR LIZZIE BORDEN

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Paper unidentified

A brief telegraph dispatch from Taunton, Massachusetts reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the grand jury on three counts. No further details are given.

Paper unidentified · 3 December 1892 · page 1

A Colored Man Crushed to Death. Special to the News and Observer. New Berne, N. C., Dec. 2. — Moses Conner, a colored workman, was in stantly killed at the steam saw mill of the Ciark Lumber Company this morring He was crushed between two lumber trueks and death was immediate. ■ The Borden Case. Telegraph to ine News and Observer. Taunton, Maes, Lee. 2.— Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the grand jury on three counts.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A newspaper columnist muses that the nature of the evidence strong enough to secure Lizzie Borden's indictment remains one of the case's mysteries. This comment is embedded within a miscellany of unrelated humorous and trivia items.

The Evening World · 3 December 1892 · page 4

Ilursinn friugo ou it, he could select that, or be might give Chinese sakh or Mexican I pulque or 'Jersey City coffin varnish a I whirl, as his tavte prompted. Ho could j mix his drunks without mixing his drinks, and give a delicious varioty to bis jamboreos that would make his hilarious career look like a procession of crazy quilts passing through the vorlex of a ' cyclone Tho fi.DOO other ways ot getting "chucked" may bo all right, but tho experienced toper who knows a good thing when ho sees it or has it, will not bo charmod by nuy of them nwny from his customary method of filling himself full of reliablo old "forty rod," until blue devils dauco ou his oyelids nnd am.'

See moreSee less

billon's airy halls ring with whoopees nnd resound with ta-ra-ras. The nature of that evidenoo which was deemed strong enough to hung Lizzie Borden's indictmont on is not the least of tho mysteries connected with the Borden murder case to thoso who have followed all the authorized disclosures thus far made. Tho Itev. Tom Dixon, sportsman, should have thought of the possibility of those robins coming too high before be broke the law nnd offended tho publio sense of right by shooting the little featherings. That American eagle who chose for his alightiug spot the peak of n school-house at Allegheny had the correct idea, as tho

See the clipping

Morning Appeal · Carson City, Nev.

A short wire dispatch reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted for murder. The item appears as one of several terse telegraphic news briefs with no further detail given.

Morning Appeal · 3 December 1892 · page 3

Lizzie Borden Indicted for Murder.

I fight in store for the country against the disease. The doctor thought that the restriction of immigration for one year would prove a potent factor to keep chelera out. The in dications are that the committee will adopt the idea of limiting immigra tion for one year and so report to Congress. "lack-ryes and Ballots. Sin Frnncieo, Dec. 2. During a recount of thy ballots before the Election co.nmissiou today free fights occured, black eyes and broken heads, and during the melee the Commission adjourned. Lizzie Borden Indicted Taunton, Mas3., Dec. 2. Lizzie Borden has been indicted oa three counts on a charge of murdering her father and mother, a wealthy old couple of Fall RiVur.

See the clipping

Morning Appeal · Carson City, Nev.

A brief dispatch from Taunton, Massachusetts reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted on three counts for the murder of her father and mother, described as a wealthy elderly couple of Fall River. The item appears amid a column of unrelated local news and advertisements.

Morning Appeal · 3 December 1892 · page 3

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Ohio Democrat · Logan, Ohio

A dispatch from Taunton, Mass. reports that public impression suggests the grand jury may not indict Lizzie Borden for her father's murder, though no official confirmation exists. It notes the attorney general's caution in avoiding missteps that could let Borden escape justice.

The Ohio Democrat · 3 December 1892 · page 3

Is felt that tho attorney general roalizcs that it would bo better for all concern ed to mako no error of judgment now, even at tho risk of conjuring up falso appearances mid to placo Miss Borden

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A Taunton grand jury returned two indictments against Lizzie Borden, one for the murder of her mother and one for her father, plus a third sealed indictment against an unnamed person not in custody, rumored to be Mr. Trickey. Borden was to be served with the indictments at the Taunton jail and reportedly remained stoic upon hearing the news.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 3 December 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN INDICTED. Two Counts Against Her and Another Against One Whose Name Is Withheld. ,Tauxton, Mass, Dec 2. Lizzie Bor den has been indicted on two counts.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Newspapers confirm that Henry G. Trickey, accused of tampering with the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden, has been indicted by the Taunton grand jury. He is reportedly in New York drawing his Globe salary while detectives keep him under watch, with a 'gigantic sensation' expected if he is arrested and tried.

The Providence News · 3 December 1892 · page 1

ON TRICKEY'S TRAIL. THAT AN INDICTMENT HAS BEEN FOUND AGAINST HIM IS ADMITTED. GREAT SENSATION PROMISED. TRICKEY IS SAID TO BE IN NEW YORK ON A VACATION. DETECTIVES CAN FIND AND ARREST HIM AT ANY TIME.

tomary salary from the paper. Me ville O, Adams, the associate couns -1 for Miss Borden, from whom it was al leged Trickey was trying to secure the government case, refuses to discuss the

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes the Grand Jury's indictment of Lizzie Borden, noting she received the news with stolid indifference. It also reveals a second, secret indictment against Henry G. Trickey for allegedly attempting to bribe witnesses Bridget Sullivan and Detective McHenry to leave town.

The Providence News · 3 December 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE INDIFFERENT.

Rev. W. W, Jubb of the Central Con sregstlonll church, whose self-imposed uty it was to wait upon Miss Borden and inform her of the result of the Grand

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The article recaps the Borden murders and the investigation leading to Lizzie Borden's arrest and indictment, noting she was charged after suspicion deepened despite exhausted police leads. It compiles reactions from various New England newspapers debating whether the indictment implies guilt and speculating on a possible insanity defense.

The Providence News · 3 December 1892 · page 1

What the Papers Say. Woonrocket Call: Believing in the woman’s funoceuce, we hope that the graud jary will bring in au indictment agaiost her, that she may be eiven the opportunity to prove beyond question her innocence. _ Boston Journal: That Miss Borden nas been indicted should notv briug dis couragement to her friends. ITo be ac quited afeer a jury trial would bs a more satisfactory vindication than to have no indictuent fouud, Woonsocket Reporter: The finding of three indictments against Lizzie Borden by the graud jury at Taunou, Mass., comes in the nature of a surprise. Boston Herald: Lizzie Borden will

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This editorial comments approvingly on rumors that journalist Henry G. Trickey may face indictment for his questionable methods in dealing with Miss Borden and her family. It frames this as a matter of public respect for honorable journalism over disreputable news-gathering tactics.

The Providence News · 3 December 1892 · page 4

TO-MORROW EVENING, WESTMINSTER THEATRE —Sacred Concert. ALL lovers of courtesy and honorable dealings will derive satisfaction from the rumor that the questionable pro ceedings of Henry (. Trickey in his treatment of Miss Borden and her family

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The grand jury has returned a true bill against Lizzie A. Borden, surprising some who had followed the case, based on largely circumstantial evidence. The piece notes this evidence was sufficient to justify trial but not yet proof of guilt beyond doubt.

The Providence News · 3 December 1892 · page 4

MISS BORDEN INDICTED, The action of the grand jury in in dicting Lizzie A. Borden will occasion some little surprise to those who have weighed the case and its evidence, It needed but very slight evidence to cause Miss Borden to be bound over to

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A brief editorial note observes that Reporter Trickey, who had voluntarily involved himself in investigating the Borden case, is now involuntarily linked to it through a criminal indictment. The item implies his investigative activities led to legal trouble.

The Providence News · 3 December 1892 · page 4

SENATOR ARTHUR PUGH GORMAY is in terested 10 some coal mines in Maryland. [t will be interesting to note the effect of his desires upon the schedules of anthra cite conl in the next Democratic tariff bill, JAY GOULD was oone of the few specula tors who have died rich. Would-be kings of finance who draw eacouragement from his success would do well to examine the otber side of the balance sheet, REPORTER TRICKEY, who voluntanly associated himself with the Borden inves tigation, seems now to be involuntarily associated with the indictment, —— Tur demoralized condition of affairs in France has temporarily withdrawn pub lle attention from the discussion of the German army bill, EVER siace that sheriff began to hunt for him Mr.

See moreSee less

Cleveland has found hiwm selt confronted by a coudition and not & theory,

See the clipping

The Kimball Graphic · Kimball, S.D.

The New Bedford Mercury reports that Attorney General Pillsbury privately believes Lizzie Borden is insane, and that this belief caused the grand jury to adjourn on November 21 rather than issue an indictment. The report claims experts will be brought in to testify on her sanity when the jury reconvenes.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Kimball Graphic · 3 December 1892 · page 1

THINKS LIZZYS INSANE. Attorney General Pillsbury Convinced Thai Miss Borden Is Irresponsible. NEW BEDFORD, Slass., Dec. 1.—'1'hc Mercury says: "Attorney General Pillsbury believes that Lizzie A. Bor den is insane. This is the secret of the adjournment of the grand jury in the 3ase ori November 21 to December 1." The Mercury says the evidence'submit ted to the grand jury was sufficient for the finding of the indictment and the members were already to bring iu ft true .-bill, but Attorney-General Pillsbury believed so strongly that the prisoner was insane that he ordered an adjournment, so Lizzie Borden might be examined by experts as" to her san ity..

See moreSee less

The story of her actions at the time of the murder as told by the wit nesses no doubt had great weight in in fluencing the attorney-general. Tho investigation has been carried on since, the jury adjourned, and when the jurors meet again in the court thc.Mer 3ury says they will be confronted with experts who will testify as to Lizzie Borden's sanity. "ajKs-i mm NEW YORK, NOV. 30.—Informatioi. was received at the maritime exchange today that the Japanese cruiser "Rlies iiinarukan collided with tho British steamer ltavennu and was sunk. Tim Japanese schooner was bound from France to Japan and all her crew, num bering 870, are reported lost. v-.A'ftfOfi-"'', .. ,vr'_: •-."'

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The grand jury returned indictments against Lizzie Borden on three counts: separate charges for the murders of her mother and father, plus a third sealed count. She was notified by friends and reportedly remained calm upon hearing the news at Taunton jail.

The Salt Lake Herald · 3 December 1892 · page 1

tooka package containing 100000 and af torwards restored it was arraigned today in guilty tho district court and pleaded not Lizzie Borden Indicted TACSTOJT Mass Dee 2Llzzio Borden I charge of murdering her father and has been indicted on three counts on a mother a wealthy and prominent old couple of Fall River

See the clipping

The Roanoke Times · Roanoke, Va.

A brief dispatch from Taunton, Massachusetts reports that the grand jury has indicted Lizzie Borden on three counts for the murder of her father and mother. The item is short and factual, embedded among unrelated news briefs.

The Roanoke Times · 3 December 1892 · page 4

He Deserves Lyachlng. Wheeling, W. Va , Dec. 2.?Louis Hager, aged 17 years, is under arrest, chgared with criminally assaulting six little girls. lie has confessed to three of tbo cases. I.l/.zle Borden Indictvd. Taunton, Mass., Doc. 2.?Tho grand jury has indictod Lizzie Borden on three counts for tbo murder of her father and mo Iber.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

Lizzie Borden was indicted by a grand jury on three counts related to the murders of her father and mother in Fall River. The first count charges her with her mother's murder, the second with her father's murder, and a third count remains sealed; she was notified of the indictment while held at Taunton jail and reportedly remained calm.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 3 December 1892 · page 3

Lizzie Borden Indicted. TACNTON, Mass.. Dec. 2.—Miss Lizzie Borden has beeu iudicted on three counts on the charge of murdering her father and mother, a wealthy and prominent old couple of Fall River. Tbe first count of the indictment charges Lizzie Borden with the murder of her mother, the second with thd murder of her father, and the third count of the indictment was kept secret, as the party indicted is not in custody. It is understood the indictments will be served on Miss Burden at her quarters in Taunton jail, she was notified todav by friends of the return near La Union on the Gulf of Conchagua.

See moreSee less

At 10 o'clock that night came the violent earth quake and 5,000 inhabitant* of La Union fled to the beach. Shock after abock struck the city and the older building* tumbled in ruin?. The •♦one cathedral was reduced to a formless betp. Fifty or sixty other buildings were completely wrecked, and twenty-four persons were injured. Or.e-th.rd of the island of Conchagua, in the gulf, seven miles from La Union, was split off by the shocks and suddenly sank out of sight. The crater of Conchagua did not break forth, but (till shows signs of coming eruptions. [The volcano of Conchagua is in the state of San Salvador, seventy miles southeast of San Bilvador, on the west side of the entrance to the Gulf of Conchagua, called also Gulf of Fon sees, which is between the states of Sau Salva dor nnd Nicaragua. The volcano is not very lofty, but it commands a fine view, embracing eighteen other volcanoes.]

See the clipping

The Superior Times · Superior, Wis.

The article reports that Massachusetts Attorney General Pillsbury secretly believes Lizzie Borden is insane, and that this belief caused the grand jury, which was ready to indict her, to adjourn so she could be examined. It frames this as the hidden reason behind the grand jury's unexpected delay in late 1892.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Superior Times · 3 December 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN INSANE.

WRECKED TRAIN BURNED. a Collision in New En gland. . i ..mi,, Nov. ;;O.—A fast • r m this city crashed into the • ti ,r ft: •• T-t-m express at Noank. ~- resulting in a complete 5i H.-i.f a mile this side \ .ink a coupling on tiie ex ... - ■>. caves iiere a? 5 o’clock • : tram baited for repairs, m--meats later a Stonington .;.. ain h follows the express, a :r .tand plunged into the The fireman ot tiie special, ,- - 1 •aimer, jumped. He was -it will recover.

See moreSee less

Engineer rjc.pi >• - st' -d at his post and ■ : i : rt-.erst*. He was crushed wrec .age, and will die. ,ir?r;ue! three cars of the spe :i demolished. I lie dining car .-I:.-- :■ r of the express was over -i —; n: re and totally destroyed. LIZZIE BORDEN INSANE. 's :-■ Bel ef of the Attorney G:r --t 'it of the State, '■ 1; Mass., Nov. :k>.—AtV - : -ent ral Fiilsbury believes Lv c. -. -f. insane. This is the secret ■... .-at of the t r uid jury in the ■ : : 'Vs-;:.her 21 t. 1 'eccinber 1. .'a.'/u ary was ready to brii gin a : .t the attorney general's beli. f i-: ; to order an ad jourunien ■ Borden could be examined ■r -,i!.:t • .

See the clipping

Tombstone Epitaph · Tombstone, Ariz.

The report states that Lizzie Borden, held in custody since the previous summer, has been indicted on three counts for the axe murders of her parents. It notes the indictment came as a surprise given earlier reports she might be discharged for lack of evidence.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right 4 earlier articles: The Washington Bee, 3 December 1892, Baxter Springs News, 3 December 1892, The Kimball Graphic, 3 December 1892, The Superior Times, 3 December 1892.

Wrong

Tombstone Epitaph · 4 December 1892 · page 1

cholera has again appeared at Cher bourg. Two fatalities are reported from Gouneville, and tin adjacent villagt of Octoville is suffering badly from the scourge. Indicted. Taunton, Mass. Lizzie Borden, who has been in custody since last summer charged with deliberately murdering her stepfather and mother by literally hacking them to death with a small axe, has been indicted on three counts. The old couple were

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The Providence Journal reports details from the Borden grand jury proceedings, including testimony about ashes found in a stove that may indicate destroyed evidence, and a bright fire seen shortly before. It also describes the McHenry-Trickey indictment for allegedly trying to bribe Bridget Sullivan to leave the state, and notes the grand jury's ten-day adjournment was sought to secure a unanimous indictment vote, though it was not unanimous.

New-York Tribune · 4 December 1892 · page 1

DESTRUCTION OF THE BLOOD-STAINED THE GARMENTS—THE GRAND JURY'S VOTE. Providence, R. I, Dec. 3.—“The Journal” this morning says that one of the baffling points in the Borden murder case was the method used by the mur derer to destroy the garments worn during the committal of the deed which must have been covered In the evidence submitted at the pre- "with blo d. liminary trial it was developed that upon the errival of the police officers they lifted the covers from the stove and discovered the dying embers of a fire, with the presence of ashes, the latter giving indication that an attempt had been made to burn something It was diclosed before the Grand Jury by one of Lizzie Borden's most intimate friends that there

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A Fall River policeman reportedly found a hatchet with only a charred stub of handle remaining, after it had been thrust into a fire, and brought it to District Attorney Knowlton. This hatchet was presented to the grand jury, though the indictment does not specify it as the murder weapon since it was not the one found in the Borden house.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

New-York Tribune · 4 December 1892 · page 1

THE GRAND JURY'S VOTE

Jee that the murder was committed with thi ticular hatehet is eastly explained, It was not fonnA ; as s Ar- | It discovered In the Borden house. © >

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The piece reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her parents, adding another chapter to the Fall River mystery, but notes the indictment does not clarify who committed the murders. It recounts how earlier claims of mounting evidence against her repeatedly proved to be unfounded rumors.

New-York Tribune · 4 December 1892 · page 6

THE DLBORDEN CASE. Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her father and mother, and thus another chapter has been added to the famous Fall River mystery. But the indictment does not serve to accomplish anything toward clearing up the case. The public is as much in the dark to-day touching the question, Who committed the murders? as it was last spring when the awful tragedy occurred. Lizzie Borden was held for the Grand Jury early in Septemher on evidence which, it was clear, seemed inadequate to a very large number, not to say the majority, of those who attentively considered it from day to day as it was presented before the examining magistrate, Since then if anything of importance has heen discovered which tended to strengthen the case of the prosecution, the people have not heard of it.

See moreSee less

Reports have been circulated from time to time t) the effect that the cords were tightening about the accused; but these on investigation resolved themselves into scnsa-

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This article discusses the Grand Jury's indictment of Lizzie Borden, noting it carries more weight than the earlier preliminary hearing since the jury isn't open to the same criticism. It reviews the weak evidence from the inquest—no blood on hatchets, no stains on clothing, no clear motive—and questions whether new evidence was presented to the Grand Jury that might change the outlook for trial.

New-York Tribune · 4 December 1892 · page 6

tional fiction. When the friends of Miss Borden heard that she had been indicted “they aflirmed.” savs a dispatch from Taunton, *“ that no new evidence had been found, and that ii only remained for a speedy trial before a jury to establish her innocence.” When the local magistrate decided to hold her, last fall, her friends, nothing dauni@l, said that her committal was “a foregone conclusion when Judge Blaisdell, who conducted the star-chamber inquest, decided to preside at the examination.” They added that Judze Blaisdell's opinion “seems to have been formed by what he saw at the inquest, and on this rather than on what was presented at the examination his decision appears to be based.” These quoiations are from the article which appeared in “The Boston Pest” the morning after the day che was held for trial in Sepfember, and they fairly reflect the views of Miss Borden's friends.

See moreSee less

But now that a Grand Jury which is not open to any such criticism as that which they passed on the local magistrate has indicted Miss Borden, they may well feel that her case takes on a different aspect. Ter intimates may contine to assert that it only needs **a specdy trial before a jury to establish her innccence,” hut they can hardly expect that the rest of those who thus far have held her guiltless will go as far as that, The indictment of the Grand Jury is indeed not conclusive of anything, hut still it has its serious significance. The jury after carefully considering the accusations against Miss Borden decides that they are sustained by the evidence. It is safe to affirm that the trial will attract more attenticn than any similar proceeding which has taken place in New-England sines the Webster-Parkman trial. On her preliminary examination the discrepancies in Miss Borden's own statements at, the Coroner's inquest were commonly regarded as eonstituting the prosecution's weightiest evidence. There was no blood upon the hatchets which wero found: there were no stains upon the garments which Miss Borden wore the day of the murder: that she had any sufficient motive to commit so revolting a erime did not appear. Was the discrepancy testimony supplemented before the Grand Jury by fresh and important evidence? 1f not, then the chances are, we should say, that the twelve men in the box will not feel justified in pronouncing Miss Borden guilty. — me—

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report describes grand jury testimony that a woman's dress was burned in the Borden stove on the morning of the murders, though it notes the witness did not identify the dress as Lizzie's or describe bloodstains. It also covers the indictment of Trickey for allegedly trying to pay Bridget Sullivan to leave the state, and claims the grand jury's adjournment was to secure a unanimous indictment vote.

The Indianapolis Journal · 4 December 1892 · page 7

Providence, R. I., Dec. a Tbe Jonrnal this morning says that one of the battling points in the investigation by tbe State in the liorden murder case was tbe methods used by the murderer to destroy the gar ments which he or she had Worn during tbe committal of the deed, and whicb, accord ing to the medical experts, must have been covered with blood from the upward spurt ing arteries of the murdered couple. The mind naturally suggested the destruction of the tell-tale karments by fire, for that element, more than any other, could eflectually remove every trace which might lead to the apprehension of the assassin by a discovery of the clothing worn when the deed was committed, in tbe evidence submitted at the preliminary trial 11 was developed that upon the arrival of the po lice officers at the scene of the murder they lifted the covers from the stove and dis covered tbe dying embers of afire, with the presence of ashes, the latter giving in dications that an attempt had been made to burn sotnetbiug.

See moreSee less

It was disclosed be fore the Brand jury by one ot Lizzie Bor den's most intimate friends that there was a bright fire in that stove but a short time before the curious oillcer lifted the cover a fire strong enoogh to have destroyed evidences of crime even were those evi dences bloodstained clothes and in to that stove upon the morning when Andrew Borden and his wife were murdered there ' were thrnst a woman's dres and rapidlr the blazing flames destroyed the garment until a few moments after the introduction into the fire-box nothing remained of it but a few ashes. Then the tire dip d away. The pris oner's friends can say truthlully that there is no evidence to show that the dress which was destroyed by (ire on the morning of Aug. 4 belonged to her. They may add that the one who gave the above information to tbe grand jury did not describe the toxtnre of this garment, did not say that it was any way distigured by bloodstains or any other kind of stains, and failed to say that , though familiar with Lizzie Borden's ward

See the clipping

The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.

The Providence Journal reports that investigators were baffled by how the Borden murderer destroyed bloodstained clothing worn during the killings. Testimony revealed a dress was burned in the kitchen stove on the morning of the murders, though no evidence confirmed it belonged to Lizzie Borden.

The State Chronicle · 4 December 1892 · page 1

By Telegraph to State Chronicle. Providence, R. I., Dec. 3. The Journal says this morning that one of the baffling points in tbe investigation by the government in the Borden cae was the method U9ed by the murderer to destroy the garments which he or she wore at the time of committing the deed, and which, according to the medical experts, must have been covered with blood. The evidence submitted at the preliminary trial developed that upon tho arrival of the police at the scene of the murder, they lifted the covers from the stove and dis covered the dying embers of a fire, the asnes ot which gave indication that an attempt had been made to burn some thing.

See moreSee less

It was disclosed before the grand jury by one of Lizzie Borden s most inti mate friends tht there was a bright fire in the etove before the officer lifted the cover, a fire bright enough to have de stroyed every effect of the crime and into that stove upon the morning that the Boruen'3 were killed, there was thrust a woman s dress. The prisoners friends can say truthfully that there is no evi dence, however, that the dress belongs to Lizzie Borden. The testimony presented yesterday in relation to the McHenry episode was that during the negotiations between the two, the Fall River officers were kept ac quainted with all particulars and that every transaction between the two was witneseed by officers connected with the case. The indictment against Tricky was found on the ground of stories to the effect that he attempted, through Mrs. McHenry, to secure the departure of Bridget Sullivan from the state by the payment of a sum of money. The Journal further avers that the ten days adjournment of the grand jury was due solely to the desire of Attorney General Pillsbury and District Attorney Knowlton to secure a unanimous vote for an indictment by furnishing corrobora tive testimony to some already adduced, yet the vote was not unanimous although it was practically so as the dissenters re frained from voting.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report claims a burned, blood-stained dress skirt belonging to Lizzie Borden was found in a stove at the Borden mansion in Providence, Rhode Island, offering strong evidence of her guilt. It describes the garment as partially destroyed, suggesting an attempt to hide evidence.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Paper unidentified · 5 December 1892 · page 1

DAMAGING EVIDENCE

NO. 102. White Cliff Cement Works. Several gentlemen were here this morning, en route to White Cliff, Se vier county, to arrange preliminaries, necessary to the starting up of the $300,000 cement works, spoken of in these columa several weeks ago. Party was composed of the following gentlemen: Louis Dahine mid Geo. H. Bishop, of Cincinnati, ().; W. J. O’Conner, of Louisville, Ky., and W. J. Kelly of New Orleans. Latter gentle man has been prospecting on the grounds for several months, and will act as general superintendent of the cement works, when opened, we learn.

See moreSee less

The party of gentlelmcn, accompan ied by Judge L. A. Byrne, left on a special train, early this morning for White Cliff. Damaging Evidence. A most dmmiging piece of evidence has been brought to light in the Bor den murder ease, which points with terrible certainty toward the guilt of Miss Lizzie Borden, who is under ar rest charged with the horrible crime of muruering her own father and his second wife. The evidence in question is the linding of a blood stained dress skirt in a heating stove In the Borden man sion at Providence, R. 1. The skirt was in a partially burned and blacken ed condition, showing that, an attempt iiad been made to destroy the tell-tale garment. Evidence is conclusive as to tiie ownership of the dress, it being shown clearly to belong to Miss Lizzie Borden the accused murderess. Tho case is one of the most sensational mid terrible in tho criminal history of (lie country, mid causes universal ox citement in tho country. A Real Sunday. On yesterday, for tho first time in the history of our city tho Sabbath day was universally observed in a business way, every business house aud saloon being strictly closed with exception of tho drug stores and bar ber shops which were open during the usual Sunday hours. This is ns it should be mid speaks volumes for the efficiency of Texarkana’s public offi cers on both sides of tho line. Tho demand for a proper observance of tiie Sabbath, is an almost unanimous uno among 'he good people of our city and the expressed will of the peo ple should never bo disregarded or set. at defiance by any class or condi tion. We trust that there will not arise any bitterness of ieeliug or sen timent over this plain performance of an express public duty mid that all in terested persons will accept sensibly uud gracefully this new condition of things, which has beyond all question been brought about by a popular pub lic sentiment, which has been grow ing, expanding and becoming more imperative week by week for the past everal years. The Stuart Contest. Tiie five leading candidates in the contest for the Stuart pony aud phietou nt 11 o’clock Saturday night stood as follows: Mrs. Dave Edwards, Texas. Miss Willa Willimns, Arkansas Miss Mozelie Tyus, Texas. Miss Lizzie Roeborough, Texas, Miss Carrie Taylor, Texas. The positions remain tho same an last week, except that the two last have changed places. Wo nre satisfied the contest is between the two leaders, and from now on the competition will be brisk and the struggle between their friends earnest though good natured. Breaking the Record. “Chicago,” it seems does not pro pose tojbe outdone by her rivals at any stage of the game. She comes to the front now with a record breaking experience m the way of safe blowing The event In question being the un precedented activity of the cracksmen of that city in blowing into seven safes in as many different buildings, but all iu one block, ami that within a square of police headquarters. The thieves secured several thousand dol lars in money and many valuables in tho way of important papers, etc. The thieves tire still at large. Bargains. We will put ou our counters to morrow 32 pieces all wool Habit Cloth Dress Goods, 12 inches wide, at 19'cents per yard, worth 75 cents. Also 19 pieces rll wool Ladies cloth, beautiful line of colors, 54 inches wide, at 89 cents per yard, worth $1.25. We are offering special bargains iu Ladies Knit I'nderweur. Our line of Zeigler Bros.’ fine shoes is complete in Men’s Ladies’ mid Children’s wear, at ts Gali.auhek’h. Remnants. A good business always creates a big pile of roinnmits, mid you can got them very cheap at Briley’s l)ry Goods House. 12-6-3 t

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Henry G. Trickey, the Boston Globe reporter who wrote a sensational story about the Lizzie Borden murder case and was under indictment for it, was killed in Hamilton, Ontario while trying to catch a moving train. He had been hiding under an alias fearing a grand jury indictment before his death and body were identified.

Morning Journal and Courier · 5 December 1892 · page 3

TRICKEI'S TRAGIC DEATH. His Life Crushed Oat by a Hlovlne Train. Hamilton, Ont., Deo. 5. Trickey, the Boston Globe reporter who wrote the sen sational story abont the Lizzie Borden

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

A newspaper report states that a Boston reporter who had written a sensational and reportedly fabricated story about the Lizzie Borden murder case, and who was under indictment for it, was killed trying to catch a moving train in Hamilton, Ontario. The item frames his death as connected to his controversial coverage of the Borden case.

Los Angeles Herald · 5 December 1892 · page 5

A Tricky Reporter* Death. Hamilton, Ont., Dec. 4 —Tho tricky Boston reporter who wrote the sensation al story about the Lizzie Borden murder case, and who was under indictment, was killed in attempting to catch a moving train at the Grand Trunk sta tion, here, yesterday.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

A newspaper reporter who had written a sensational story about the Lizzie Borden murder case, and who was under indictment for it, was killed while trying to catch a moving train at the Grand Trunk station in Hamilton, Ontario. The brief notes his death but gives no further detail on the original story or indictment.

The Record-Union · 5 December 1892 · page 1

Has Written His Last Sensation. Hamilton (Ont.), Dec. 4.—The tricky I ■ -t..u rep')rtor who wrote a sensational story about the Lizzie Borden murder e-ase and was under indictment, was killed in attempting to catch a moving train al the Grand Trunk station here yesterday. Order to be Restored ln Samoa. London, Dei-. 1. -A Berlin correspond ent of the Dai!)/ Xeirx has learned that the Governments of England, Germany and the United States will take common action to restore order in Samoa.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Boston Globe reporter Henry Trickey, who wrote a sensational but false October 1 story claiming strong new evidence against Lizzie Borden, died after falling under a train in Hamilton, Ontario while fleeing a possible indictment for his fabricated reporting. The Globe had retracted the story and apologized to Borden and J.H. Morse after admitting Trickey was misled by a detective he paid for information.

Evening Star · 5 December 1892 · page 7

Tragte Death af Riperter Trielsey. Usury 0. Trickey, the Boston Globe reportel who wrote the sensational story about the Lizzie Borden murder case and was nder is. dtictmsent, met with a tragic death at Hamiltou, * mt., Saturday. In attempting to catch a mor ing train at the Grand Trunk station he dipped asnd 'as -swuag under the cars and his life was crushed out. On October 1 the Boston Gliobe pizbla-hed a thirteenolumn story giving nieu mnd stardling evidence obtained by the prosecu.. tion in the Borden murder ease. It stated that twenty-five new witnesses had been secared1 an-t the story made It appear that the prosecu tion hadt a strong ease against the priaoner and hintiad that at the timne of the murder she was mn trouble.

See moreSee less

The ollowing morning the Gilobe re trartedt alt these statements and apologized to Lazzie Borden and J. H. Morse. It ad mitted thgt the reporter that wrote the story had been misled. Henry G. Trickey was writer of the article. He claimed that he had paid Detective Mc Henry *50 for the information. tthortly after this and before the grand jury met at Fall River Trickey went on a visit to hi. brother-in-law. Eber B. Melner. Evanston, IlL lHe did not feet eafe there, being afraid the jury would irndiet hism, and on November 26 he weat to Hamialton, Ontario, registering at the Roal Motel under the name of Henry Melrar, Nieu York. 'I rickey was twenty-four years old. He had done excellent work for the (,Iobe. He was married a vear ago aud his young wife I prostrated with grief

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Henry G. Trickey, the Boston Globe reporter indicted for tampering with witnesses after publishing a false interview implicating Lizzie Borden, was reportedly killed by a train in Hamilton, Ontario while a fugitive from justice. The report recounts how his fabricated October 10 story, falsely attributed to Detective McHenry, claimed witnesses had seen Borden in suspicious circumstances around the time of the murders.

New-York Tribune · 5 December 1892 · page 1

EE —— {\ FUGITIVE KITLED BY A TRAIN. Bo<ton, Dee. 4 (Special).—A dispateh annonnces the death of Henry G. Trickey at Hamilton, ontario, saturday, and states that he was killed by a train. lie was a fugitive from justice, having been indicted for tampering with the time us Lizzie Borden sane consequence of Government witnesses, This wus in a story published in “The Globe” of October 10 under Trickey's name purporting to be an interview with Detective Mellenry, and alleging that several persons Lad seen Miss Dorden in situations before and at the day of the murder which Indicated plainly, if the report was trne, that Me had been concerned in the murders, Next day The Globe” published a denial, but this did not prevent actions for damages, nor did It save an indictment being found against the reporter, “The Globe” says he has been ont of the city =cveral weeks, but a reporter on another paper suys he was here on Friday, ne lf — —

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The grand jury investigating the Borden murders gave little weight to suggestions that Lizzie Borden was insane, and she must now stand trial for the murders of her father and stepmother. The report notes the evidence is strong but entirely circumstantial, acknowledging that innocent people have been convicted on such evidence before.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Morning News · 5 December 1892 · page 4

Tbe supposition that Lizzie Borden was insane did not have much weight with the grand jury investigating the Borden mur der mystery, and the young woman must stand trial on the obarge of having brutally murdered her father and step-mother. It Is bard to (relieve that a young woman of refinement and previous good reputation would have committed two euoh atrocious murders. There was either tha cunning of iusaulty displayed, or the crimes were long premeditated, for every traoe that would lead to the identification of the murderer was removed. The evidenoe against Lizzie borden is very strong, but It is all

See the clipping

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · Chicago, Ill.

The report states that Lizzie Borden in Taunton, Massachusetts, has been indicted on two charges for the murder of her parents, plus a third charge whose content is not yet known. This reflects the grand jury's action following the investigation into the killings.

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 5 December 1892 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The New York Herald sarcastically comments that after months of imprisonment under a theory of 'probably guilty,' Lizzie Borden is likely to be released under a finding of 'probably not guilty.' It suggests her accusers should then be judged 'probably knaves' and eventually dismissed as 'only fools.'

St. Paul Daily Globe · 5 December 1892 · page 4

The Borden Case

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

In the story →

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

Henry G. Trickey, the Boston Globe reporter who published a fabricated exposé of evidence against Lizzie Borden, was killed in Hamilton, Ontario while fleeing a contempt of court charge. He reportedly paid a detective named McHenry $500 for the false information used in his discredited article.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 5 December 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

VERY LIKE RETRIBUTION. The Boston Reporter of the Borden Testimony Fake Is Killed. HAMILTON, ONT., Dec. 4.—[Special.]—Henry G. Trickey, a Boston Globe reporter, was killed here yesterday while trying to board a train. He came here a week ago and registered at a leading hotel under the name of Henry Melsear, representing that he was a New York commercial man. It has since been learned that he had fled to Canada to avoid arrest for contempt of court in connection with the Borden murder case. He was the reporter who wrote up the article which appeared in the Globe, containing an alleged expose of all the evidence the detectives had worked up against Lizzie Borden.

See moreSee less

Next day the paper apologized for the story and admitted that it had been deceived. Yesterday morning, as Trickey was about to leave the city, he fell between the cars and was so badly crushed that he died in a few minutes. Trickey had left word at the hotel to have his mail forwarded to P. Melsear, Evanston, Ill. The news of the accident was telegraphed there, and this evening Trickey's brother-in-law arrived. He identified the body. Melsear says that Trickey told him he had been deceived by Detective McHenry, who had offered to furnish the information in the Borden case for $500. Trickey gave him the money, and McHenry furnished the points for the article as published in the Globe, but deliberately deceived him. The body was taken to Boston to-night.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A roundup of daily news items states that the Prosecuting Attorney has two important clews against Lizzie Borden. The item appears amid dozens of unrelated national and international news briefs.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 5 December 1892 · page 5

DOINGS OF A DAY.

win be tried for murder .... The Prosecuting Attorney has two in portunt cle.vs against Lizzie Borden.. ..An extra sesslou and tbe tariff bill are tbe questions bothering the Democracy.... l-ould's business associates described him

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Boston Globe reporter Henry G. Trickey, who wrote a controversial story about the Borden case and was under indictment, died after falling under a train at a station in Hamilton, Ontario. He had been living under an assumed name, fearing the grand jury would indict him, and his body was only identified a day after his death.

The Providence News · 5 December 1892 · page 1

HE WROTE THE BORDEN STORY

erally believed, 4 Henry G, Trickey was famons through out New Eogland as a “‘detective report er,’ and was, when killed, a fugivive from justice, The grand jury of Bristol county, which on b‘ritlnfv last indicted Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother, also indicled Trickey for interfering with a goveinment witness. ‘The Boston pa per with which Triekey was connected

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Henry G. Trickey, a Boston Globe reporter indicted for interfering with a government witness in the Borden case, fled under an assumed name and died shortly after. The report details his career, his marriage, and the scheme involving Detective McHenry that led to his indictment by the Bristol county grand jury.

The Providence News · 5 December 1892 · page 1

HE WROTE THE BORDEN STORY.

on b‘ritlnfv last indicted Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother, also indicled Trickey for interfering with a goveinment witness. ‘The Boston pa per with which Triekey was connected published on Oct, 10 4 ver‘y long and seu sational story about the Borden case, a

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

District Attorney Knowlton refused to confirm or deny reports that a grand jury indicted journalist Henry Trickey, who was reportedly dead, saying he does not prosecute the dead. He also said he had no official knowledge of reports that Lizzie Borden would be arraigned the following Tuesday.

The Providence News · 5 December 1892 · page 6

Henry G. Trickey, against whon it is al leged the grana j}:xry has tound an indict ment, Mr. Kuowiton simply said he Knew mnothing about the matter further than what he had read in the moerning papers, and statel that he was not ac quainted with Mr Trickey and never saw him to know him. The time was not ripe to state whether an indictment had been brought against the young man. It he were dead, Mr. Knowlton would never tell whether an indictment had been found, as Le did not believe in prosecuting the dead.

See moreSee less

To a suggestion that the report that Trick-y was killel mizht be a “fuke,” Mr., Knowlton still persisted in his disineli nation to talk about the alleged indiot ment, With regard to the report pubiished in the Boston Globe, that Lizzie Borden woula be arraigned on Tuesday, Mr, Kuowlton said he knew nothing oMeially of the matter After an indictment is forind his duties cease until the time of the trial. The attorney general is re quired to be present at an arraignment tor murder, but vot the distric’ attorney. The arraigninsnt will take place at some time designated by the chief justice of the supreme court, Mr. Knowlton was asked if the prisoner

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

A newspaper reporter from Boston, who had been indicted for writing a sensational and misleading story about the Lizzie Borden murder case, was killed in Hamilton, Ontario while trying to catch a moving train. The report notes his earlier legal trouble tied to his coverage of the Borden case.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 5 December 1892 · page 1

A Tricky Bualud lieporter Killed. Hamilton, Ont., Dec. 4.— The tricky Boston reporter who wrote a sensational story about the Lizzie Borden murder case, and who was under indictment, was killed today in attempting to catch a mov ing train at the Grand Trunk station here yesterday.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Attorney Jennings says Lizzie Borden's arraignment likely won't happen the next day as reported, expecting it within two weeks, with him continuing as her counsel. The indictment and grand jury proceedings have taken a toll on Emma Borden, Mrs. Bowen, and John Morse, all showing signs of nervous strain and declining health.

Morning Journal and Courier · 6 December 1892 · page 3

selSeveral Interested Parties Worn AVith Anxiety. Fall River, Mass., Deo. 5. Speaking of the Borden case to-night, Andrew J. Jennings, esq , said be did not expect that Miss Borden would be arraigned to-mor row, as has been published. The theory of the law is that when an arraignment of the commission of a capital crime ia made defendant besides pleading will also have voice saying who shall be appointed to defend her. The appointment is made by the presiding judge. There is no donbt that in this case Miss Borden will want Mr.

See moreSee less

Jennings to continue to aot for her; conse quently Mr. Jennings feels that when Mr. Pillebury shall determine the date of the arraignment he (Mr. Jennings) will, by conrtesy, bo notified. Mr. Jennings be lieves that an arraignment will be made within two weeks at latest. The nnfortunate ending of the life of Mr. Tricksy has brought to publio notice the fact that some other persons are in danger of going to early graves as the re sult of the great Eorden crimes. The news of the indictment, together with the nerv ous strain to which Miss Emma Borden was subjected before the grand jury, has made her ill, and yesterday she was almost completely prostrated. Mrs. BoweD, who was not Btrong on the day tne murders were committed, has been in a highly nerv ous condition ever since, and at times her friends have been donbtf ul as to her ability to bear up to the end. John V. Morse, the rugged farmer, uncle of Miss Borden, when Been in the postoftice oorridor to-day, also showed the loss of his hearty appearance of some weeks ago.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The report describes the toll the case has taken on Lizzie Borden's family, with Emma Borden, Mrs. Bowen, and John Morse all showing signs of illness and strain. A grand juror gives an interview describing how the indictment was secured, including defense counsel presenting evidence and last-minute damaging testimony from Lizzie's own associates.

Morning Journal and Courier · 6 December 1892 · page 3

ONE OF THE JURORS TALKS

How tne Indictment Asalnat Lizzie Borden Was Secured. Boston, Dec 5. The Globe this after noon prints an interview with one of the members of the grand jury whioh had be fore it the case of Lizzie Borden. The uror is reported as saying that the attor ney general and the district attorney in particular, were so much worked up over the abuse and vilification to which they were subjected that they sent for Andrew Jennings (of counsel for defense) and asked him to put in the evidence for de fense, and he did so.

See moreSee less

"Mr. Knowiton sat back and took no part in the matter, but left it to the jurors to ask questions." The government witnesses," said the uror, "were reluctant and aoted as it they wanted to balieve Lizzie Borden innocent. The witnesses for defense, however, came in, testified freely and handled truth care lessly, to Bay the least. At the eleventh hour the mends 01 Liz zie A. Borden oame up penitent or conscience-stricken and told that whioh

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A member of the grand jury describes threats made against jurors during the Borden case deliberations, including a man who vowed to kill jurors and a threatening letter sent to the district attorney warning against indicting Lizzie Borden. He confirms the jury returned an indictment against Lizzie A. Borden and notes rumors that her friends might reveal more information afterward.

Morning Journal and Courier · 6 December 1892 · page 3

ONE OF THE JURORS TALKS.

which he had received from Brattleboro. Vt.. which was to the effect that the best thing he, the distriot attorney, could do was to let Lizzie rsorden out ana give ner her freedom and look Bridget Sullivan np in one cell and John V. Morse in another, and ending: 'Now if the jurors find a bill against Lizzie A. Borden look out for White caps.' xne district attorney got lots of letters about the ease, and after the recess it was reported that the friends of Lizzie said they might as well tell all they knew about the case."

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The report notes that Henry G. Trickey, a Boston Globe reporter who had been indicted alongside Lizzie Borden at Taunton, Mass., was killed by a train in Hamilton, Ontario, and his funeral took place this day. The item appears as one line within a larger roundup of miscellaneous national news.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 6 December 1892 · page 3

RAFFLE TICKETS, dering Mary Maj'olis, was sentenced to be hanged on Friday, Feb. 10 next, by Judge Scudder, of Jersey City. Charles H. Decie, of Newburyport, Mass., has sued the owners or the steamei John Brooks for $5,000 for the loss of hit son Charles, who was murdered by some unknown persona on the steamer in Sep tember, 1890. The $2,500 raised at Providence, H. I., two years ago for the Irish fund will br sent to the priests in Ireland to relieve evicted tenants. H. H. Lostetter, United States Express agent at Huntingburg, Ind., was arrested while pawning diamonds consigned tc New York.

See moreSee less

William Nacle, who shot a landlord ii: Ireland, and came here two weeks ago, if in Chicago. He was allowed to land on condition that he report at Ellis Island. The funeral of Henry G. Trickey, the Boston "Globe" reporter, who was indioted with Lizzie Borden at Taunton, Mass., for murder, and who was killed by the cars at Hamilton, Onfc., occurred to day. James Cooper ran amuok with a revol ver and razor at Basset, Neb., ana wai killed by the sheriff. President Diaz's wife will send to ths Fair at her own expense a band of 46 women musicians.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A grand juror says Henry G. Trickey's death will not affect the indictment against him, noting other parties were also involved in the case. A letter from Brattleboro, Vermont, signed 'White Caps,' had been introduced in court demanding Lizzie Borden's release and the arrest of Bridget Sullivan and John V. Morse instead.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 6 December 1892 · page 1

TRICKEY'S DEATH

I’iioviiom i.. Dec. .*>. -The Journal say* that one of the battling point* in the investi gation by the government in the Borden murder ease was the method used by the murderer to destroy the garments which he

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A friend of Lizzie Borden testified before the grand jury that a woman's dress was burned in the kitchen stove shortly after the murders, destroyed almost entirely within minutes. The report also notes the indictment of Trickey over alleged payments to help witness Bridget Sullivan leave the state.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 6 December 1892 · page 1

been made to burn something. It was disclosed before the grand jury by one of Lizzie Borden's most intimate friends that there was a bright tire in that stove hut a short time before the curious officer lifted the cover, a tire strong enough to have des troyed evidence of crime, even were those evidences blood-stained clothing, and info that stove upon the morning when Andrew Borden and his w ife were murdered there was thrust a woman's dress and rapidly the blazing flames destroyed the garment until within a few moments after the introduc tion into the fire box nothing remained of it hut a few ashes.

See moreSee less

Then the tire dietl away. The prisoner's friends can sav truthfully that there is no evidence to show that the dress which was destroyed l»v fire on the morning of Aug. 4 belonged to her. They may add that the one who gave the above informatitj^fti the grand jury did not des cribe the texture of this garment, did not say that it was in any way disfigured by bloodstains or any other kind of stains, and failed to say that, though familiar with Lizzie Borden's wardrobe, the w itness had ever seen anything like this dress in the

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Following reporter Henry G. Trickey's death, Fall River speculation swirled over whether his indictment would stand, with a grand juror saying other parties were still implicated. A letter purportedly from Brattleboro, Vt., urging authorities to release Lizzie Borden and arrest Bridget Sullivan and John V. Morse instead, was said to have been introduced in court.

The Portland Daily Press · 6 December 1892 · page 1

WHITE CAPS WROTE A LETTER.

Rumor Says That Trickey Was Not In dicted After All. Fall River, Mass., December 5.—The news of the death of Henry G. Trickey was the cause of much interest and com ment in this city Considerable specula tion was indulged in as to the outcome of the indictment said to have been found against him by the grand jury. Today one of the grand jurors stated that Mr. Trickey’s death would not pro duce any effect upon the indictment, and that there were other parties concerned. It was told that a letter from Brattle boro, Vt., was introduced In court, in wliieh the authorities were warned to re lease Lizzie Borden and arrest Bridget Sullivan and John V.

See moreSee less

Morse. It was „: ~^ J KATTlGin i'n 55 ond 10 a aid fir lravo more than a little bearing upon the in dictment in question.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Henry Trickey, a Boston reporter who wrote a sensational and apparently fabricated story about the Lizzie Borden murder case and was under indictment for it, was killed in Hamilton, Ontario while trying to catch a moving train. His death came before he could face trial for the charges against him.

Omaha Daily Bee · 6 December 1892 · page 1

Killed Before He Could Be Tried

Killed lie-lore He < 'iiulil liTried. . HA.MII.TOX , Out. , Dee. "i ; Trickey , the Bos ton reporter , who wrote the sensational story about the Lizzie Borden murder case and who was under indictment , was killed in attempting to catch a moving train at the Grand Trunk station hero yesterday.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report recounts how a newspaper reporter invented false stories implicating Lizzie Borden in her parents' murder, selling them to the Boston Globe about two months earlier and claiming twenty-five witnesses supported his fabrications. After being indicted for the fraud, he was reportedly killed when he fell under the wheels of a train.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Paper unidentified · 6 December 1892 · page 2

TUESDAY, DEO -6, - 1802 Out in where the cow boys and Rattlers ho d high carni val, the Democrats don't propose to be trifled with by their Republican neighbors. Their claim that their candidate for Governor was elected, being denied, they swore him be fore a notary public forced open the State house and threaten to use dynamite to get the seals of the State. Those are the kind of Dem ocrats that are needed in Connec ticut The newspaper reporter who got up a whole lot of fictitious stories showing that Lizzie Borden must be

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The item reports the funeral of Henry G. Trickey, a Boston Globe reporter who had been indicted alongside Lizzie Borden at Taunton, Mass. Trickey died after being struck by a train at Hamilton, Ontario.

The Evening Herald · 6 December 1892 · page 2

condition that he report at Ellis Island. I The funeral of Henry Gr. Trickey, tha ' Boston "Globo" reporter, who was in dicted with Lizzie Borden at Taunton, Mass., for murder, and who was killed by the cars at Hamilton, Out., occurred to

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A grand juror discloses how Lizzie Borden's friends ultimately let details of her case slip out, and reports indicate the district attorney was threatened by White Caps during the proceedings. The arraignment is said to be coming soon.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 6 December 1892 · page 7

BORDEN SECRETS OUT. One of the Gragd Jurors fells How Lizzie's Friends Finally GAVE HER CASE AWAY AFTER ALL llie restrict Attorney In the Tana Threat ened by White Caps.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A Boston Globe interview with a Lizzie Borden grand juror reveals that the Attorney General and District Attorney, frustrated by public criticism, allowed defense counsel Jennings to present evidence to the jury. The juror claims government witnesses seemed reluctant to convict, while defense witnesses eventually gave damaging admissions that convinced jurors to indict.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 6 December 1892 · page 7

Boston, Dec 5. The Globe this after noon prints an interview with one of the members of the grand jury which bad before it the case of Lizzie Borden. The jnror is reported as saying that the At torney General and the District Attorney, in particular, were so much worked up over the abuse to which they were subjected, that they sent lor Andrew J. Jennings (of counsel for the defense) and asked him to put in the evidence for defense, and he did so. Mr. Know, of Salback, took no part in the matter, but left It to the jurors to ask the questions.

See moreSee less

Said thejnror: Tha Government wltnessos, snid the Juror, were reluctant and acted as if thoy wanted to believe Lizzie Borden Innocent. The witnesses for tho defonse, however, came in, testified freely and handled ns truthlessly, to say the least. At tho eleventh honr the friends of Lizzlo lloiden came up penitent or consclenco strickon and told that which clinched the case in the minds or the Jurors. I think the District Attorney was ntlsfled ho oould not not the indictment without the admissions made Dy tho defense. Wo found a bill against Lizzie A. Borden the day before we -came in, and the next mornlug.wuen we were considering another case, the District Attorney read ns a letter which he had received from Brattleboro, Tt , which was that tho best tliin-' he, the District Attorney could do, was to let Lizzie Borden out and lookBridget Snlllvan up In one cell and John V. Morsoln another, ending: "Xow, H the Juroig find a bill against LIzzio . Borden, look out for AVhlto Caps." The District Attorney got lots of

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A grand juror recounts how last-minute admissions from Lizzie Borden's friends helped convince the jury to indict her, and mentions a threatening letter the District Attorney received warning against finding a bill. Defense attorney Jennings says he does not expect Borden to be arraigned the next day as reported, predicting it will occur within two weeks.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 6 December 1892 · page 7

Andrew J. Jennings said he did not axpect that Mini Borden .would be arraigned to morrow, as has been published. The theory of the law i that when an arraignment tor the commission of a capital crime Is made, defendant, besides pleading, will also have an opportunitv to sav who shall be appointed to defend her. The appointment is made by the Presiding Judge. There is no doubt that in this case Miss Borden will want Mr. Jennings to continue to act for her, consequentlv Mr, Jennings feels that when Mr. Pillsbury shall determine the dato-of the arraignment he (Mr. Jennjngs) will by courtesy be notified. Mr. Jennings believes that an arraignment will be made within two weeks at the latest.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The article discusses the reported death of Henry G. Trickey, a figure connected to sensational facts in the Lizzie Borden case, and the resulting conferences between officials about whether to make such facts public. It also notes a grand jury member's comments on the significance of an indictment tied to another person, and Andrew Jennings' statement that Lizzie Borden's arraignment was not expected as scheduled.

Pawtucket Tribune · 6 December 1892 · page 1

JURORS ARE TALKING

Alm of the Grand Jury. He wis indicted in counnection with an sther and more important person; and if ihis case ever comes to trinl, the sensa tlon produced will be greater thaun that of Lue wourder itselt.” The reported death of Mr. Trickey sreated a sensntion in this city; wud many persons were beard to express themsolves as belleving the story to be a fake, This wae ¢specinily true of the police; but as the day passed and thore came no authen tic denial of the story, it becsme gouer ally accepted as true. 1 speaking of the Borden case last uight, Auvdrew J. Jounings said he did not ex

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Attorney Jennings denies reports of an immediate arraignment and expects it within two weeks, with Lizzie Borden having a say in her defense counsel's appointment. Dismissed grand jurors begin leaking details of the evidence, including a hatchet with a broken handle found to be cleaned with ashes though no blood traces were found, and confirm Henry Trickey was not indicted over his dealings with McHenry.

Pawtucket Tribune · 6 December 1892 · page 1

CASE MAY BE DELAYED.

About the Hatchet. I'nat & hautcuet was produced ne the one used in the inurders is positively asserted by oue juror. The haudle of the hatchet Lad been broken short off at the head. The Lalchet was mot new, but sharp encugh W inflict the wouuds on the heads of Mr. and Mr+. Borden. Professor Wood found no trice of blood on either the head or the plece of handle which was left in 1t but bodid tina that the Liatchet had been carefully we "od and cleaned with ashes, The Trickey Indictment.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The report clarifies that the indictment against reporter Trickey was for tampering with witness Bridget Sullivan, not McHenry, since McHenry was not a government witness. It also notes the toll the case has taken on Emma Borden's health and John Morse's appearance.

Pawtucket Tribune · 6 December 1892 · page 1

Gulug to Ferly Graves as the resul. of Ve great Borden crimes. The vewns of the indictmeunt, togetber with L g pervous strain w 0 which Miss Eiuma Horden was subjected hefore the groud jury, bes wade uer ill, aud yes terday she wias alnost complietcly pros trated. Mrs., Bowen, who was not strong on the day the murderq were committed, Lae been In & highly mervous conditloa ever since, and at times her friends have beec doubtful as to ber abllity to bear up tw the end John V. Morse, the ragged farmer, au sle of Mis« Borden, when seen sesd ip the

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The body of Henry G. Trickey, a reporter implicated in a mishap connected to the Borden case, arrived in Boston, confirming his death beyond doubt. Relatives said he had feared arrest and been deeply depressed over his error in the case; his funeral was held privately, and two police officers tied to the affair were reinstated.

The Providence News · 6 December 1892 · page 1

Trickey's Body in Boston

Trickey Xrrived in Boston at half past four o'clock yesterday afternoon, thus establishing bevoud doubt the fact of his death, It is learned from his relatives here that the ,ounu man had not only been fearful of arrest, but had been much depressed since his inistase in connection with the Borden case. v The funeral was private and took

See the clipping

In the story →

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Grand jury members, now dismissed, reveal that the vote to indict Lizzie Borden stood at 20 to 1, with evidence including a hatchet shown to the jury and testimony about the burning of her dress. Jurors indicate the case against her appeared strong, with one juror remarking she would surely hang.

The Providence News · 6 December 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

BORDEN JURORS TALK. The Vote Stood 20 to 1 for Liz- zie's Indictment, They Say.

JURY SAW THE HATCHET.

See moreSee less

And a Witness Told of the Burning of Miss Borden's Dress—The Hatchet Had Been Cleaned—Things Look Very Dark for the Defendant.

FALL RIVER, Mass., Dec. 6.—The vote of the Grand Jury for the indictment in the Borden case stood 20 to 1. Before taking the vote the jurors solemnly agreed among themselves that the poll should be secret as far as each member's way of voting was concerned. Nothing was said about the way the vote went, and half an hour after the jury had reported it was well established that only one man was opposed to bringing in an indictment. The members of the Grand Jury, having been dismissed for the year, are talking. They are not telling the whole story all at once, but each man adds his mite, and the new evidence that so impressed the jury as to leave only one in doubt of Lizzie Borden's guilt is gradually becoming known.

In speaking to a friend of his experience at the hearing one juror solemnly asserted, "They'll hang her, sure." Others are more conservative in summing up the case, but it is evident that every one of the twenty-one men was strongly impressed with the weight of the government's evidence, and all, except one, of the lot are positive that the defendant is guilty. One juror states that the case could not have had a more complete hearing at a trial in open court. The defence might have something back, but all the evidence for the defence which was regarded as valuable was presented, and in spite of it the outlook for the prisoner looked absolutely hopeless.

No member of the grand jury can be found who expresses any fear of personal damage because of the part he has taken in the Borden case. There has been some wild talk by irresponsible people, but they have confined this talk to listeners whom they had reason to regard as friendly. Whatever may have been the real cause for the delay, it is certain that the worst piece of evidence against Miss Borden had nothing to do with it. This came from a witness for the defence, and was as much a surprise to the government as it was to the members of the jury.

That Lizzie Borden should have informed Miss Russell of the burning of the dress or allowed her to see it burned constitutes the first piece of weakness to be found in her conduct during the whole affair. Prof. Wood found no trace of blood on either the head or the piece of handle which was left in it, but he did find that the hatchet had been carefully washed and cleaned with ashes. No hint has been drawn from any juror that any indictments were brought against persons suspected of being accomplices in the crimes.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Following her indictment, Fall River grand jurors speak privately about the case, with all but one convinced of Lizzie Borden's guilt based on the evidence presented. The most damaging testimony reportedly came from a defense witness, Miss Russell, who described Lizzie burning a dress, while Professor Wood found the hatchet had been carefully washed with ashes though no blood was detected.

The Providence News · 6 December 1892 · page 1

JURY SAW THE HATCHET

cousidered, witu the result that both th e officers were reinstated. thae place, ence aut the hearing one juror solemnly asserted, “phey’ll hsufi her, sure.”” Others are more conservative in summing up the case, but it is evident that every oue of the twenty-one wmen was strongly im pressed with the weight of the govern wment’s evidence, and all, except one, of the lot are positive that the defendant is guilty. One juror states that the case coula not have had a more com glot.e hear ing at a trial in open court.

See moreSee less

The defence might have something vack, but all the evidence for the defence which was re garded as valuable was ; presented, and 1n spite of it the outlook for the prisoner looked absolutely hopeless. No member of the grand jury can be found who expresses any fear of personal damage because of the part he has laken in the Borden case. ‘l'here has been some wild tulk by irrespousible people, but they have confined this talk to listeners whom they had resson to regard as ! friendly. ‘Whatever may have been the real cause for the delay, it is certaio that

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The grand jury that indicted Lizzie Borden voted 20 to 1, and with jurors now free to speak, nearly all say they are confident she is guilty. One juror called the evidence as thorough as any formal trial would produce.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 7 December 1892 · page 1

THINK LIZZIE BORDEN GUILTY. The Grand Jurv who mdict.d th. v.. Woman Confident She Is a Murderess, . Fau. River, Dec. 7. The vote of the grand jury for the indictment in the Borden cose stood 20 to 1. The mem bers of the jury having been dismissed for the year are talking. Every one of the 91 men was impressed with th weight of the Government's evi dence, and all except one Is positive that the defendant is guilty. One juror states that the case could not have had a more complete hearing at a trial in open court.

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The grand jury in the Borden case voted 20 to 1 in favor of indictment, and jurors who have since been dismissed are now speaking publicly about the case. Nearly all jurors say they were convinced by the weight of the government's evidence and believe the defendant is guilty.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 7 December 1892 · page 1

They Think Lizzie Borden Guilty.

~":i«l jury for the indictment in the Borden case stood 20 to 1. Tiie .. bers of the jury, having been dismissed for th« year, are talking. Every one of the twenty-one men was impressed with the weight of thegovemmènt's evidence, ami all, except one. is positive that the defendant is guilt)'. One juror states that the case could not have had a more complete hearing at a trial in open court. Girl Workers o Beaver Falls, Pa., De«-. 7. -The flftv girls employe«! in the art tile factory m a strike, ami the factory is idle •onsequence.

See moreSee less

The girls hail been in the habit of quitting work live minut$» before the factory whistle blew. To this Superintendent \Valker objected, and because he Would m evoke tho order directing the girls t« mtinne at

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A Boston Globe interview with a grand juror describes how the attorney general allowed defense evidence to be presented, and recounts that last-minute admissions from Lizzie Borden's own friends helped clinch the indictment. The juror also describes a threat made against jurors during recess, which he confronted directly.

Evening Star · 7 December 1892 · page 8

. I THE BORDEN MURDER CASE. Thera Was Praetieal Unanimity I. Finding the Indictment. The Boston Globe prints an interview with one of the members of the grand jury which had before it the case of Lizzie Borden. The juror is reported as saying that' the attorney general and the district attorney, in particular, were so much worked up over the abuse and vilification to which they were subjected that they sent for Andrew J. Jennings, of counsel for the defense, and asked him to put in the evidence for defense, and he did so.

See moreSee less

"Mr. Knowlton sat back and took no part in the mat ter, but left it to the jurors to ask questions." "The government witnesses," said the juror, "were reluctant and acted as if they wanted to believe Lizzie Borden innocent. The witnesses for defense, however, came in, testified freely and handled truth carelessly, to ray the least. At the eleventh hour the friends of Lizzie Borden cane up penitent or conscience stricken and told that which clinched the case in the minds of the jurors. I think the district at torney was satisfied he could get the indict ment without the admissions made by the de fense." In speaking of threats that had been made the juryman said: "Why, during the recess taken by the jury, when I was at Hargrave's mill, I heard a man who did not know I was a member of the jury say he would be one man who would kill the jurymen. Then I made my self known and told him if anything happened to any of the jury he would be the first man to be looked after. He then weakened and apolo gized. saying he did not mean anything. We found a bill against Lizzie A. Borden the day before coming in." The juror was asked if he was willing to give the exact vote of the grand jury, and said he could not consistently, but he said, however, there were two polls of the jury, the first one formal, but ter the story of defense had been put in a second poll was had, and then by permission the vote was reconsidered and the result was a practical unanimity for an in dictment.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A juror describes how government witnesses seemed reluctant to incriminate Lizzie Borden while defense witnesses testified freely and sometimes carelessly with the truth. He recounts a threat made against jurors during a recess and confirms the grand jury voted to indict Lizzie Borden after reconsidering following late revelations from her associates.

Evening Star · 7 December 1892 · page 8

THE BORDEN MURDER CASE.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The grand jury voted 20 to 1 to indict Lizzie Borden, and dismissed jurors are now privately telling reporters that the evidence convinced nearly all of them of her guilt. One juror reportedly said she would surely hang, and jurors felt the defense's best points had already been aired without changing the outcome.

New-York Tribune · 7 December 1892 · page 9

SUCRE OF LIZZIE BORDEN'S GUILT. MEMBERS OF THE GRAND JURY DROP REMARKS WHICH INDICATE THEIR BELIEF. Boston, Dee, 6.—“The Journal's" Fall River dis patch ays: “The vote of the Grand Jury for the

See the clipping

Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn.

A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her father and mother, with the location given as Taunton, Mass. The murders actually occurred in Fall River; Taunton was where the grand jury handed down the indictment.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Morris Tribune · 7 December 1892 · page 4

BRIEF NEWS ITEMS. CRIMES AND CASUALTIES. Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her father and mother at Taunton, Mass. The steamer Greystone was wrecked at the mouth of the Elbe and twenty three of tho crew drowned. James Stone and William Blanken ehip were arrested in a deserted iron mine near Anniston, Al.a., whila in the act of counterfeiting nickels. Mgr. Satolli, the papal de»egv:e, has been empowered by the holy set hear to and decide without appeal all religious questions between bishops and priests in the United Slates.

See the clipping

Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn.

A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her father and mother at Taunton, Massachusetts. It appears among a roundup of short crime and casualty items from around the world.

Mower County Transcript · 7 December 1892 · page 8

BRIEF NEWS ITEMS. CRIMES AND CASUALTIES. Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her father and mother at Taunton, Mass. The steamer Qreystone was wrecked

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

A Boston reporter, under indictment for writing a sensational and false story about the Lizzie Borden case, was killed while trying to catch a morning train at the Grand Trunk station in Hamilton, Ontario. The report frames his death as 'justice' catching up with him for his earlier fabrication.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Helena Independent · 7 December 1892 · page 2

but will probably be between $250,000 and $300,000. with insurance of $160,000. The cause of the ftire is unknown. It originated in the basement and through an air shaft quickly spread to the top floor. The fles of the paper were all saved and many rare and costly articles in Childs' private office. Mr. Childs ar rived soon after the fire started and post lug himself across the street watched the building burn. tie assumed charge of af fairs and issued directione in the way of providing for the issue of the paper to morrow.

See moreSee less

While the firemen were at work they were urged to greater eforts by the announcement that Childs intended to dis tribute $5,000 among them for their pre vention of the total destruction of the bailding. When the fire was extinguished Childs provided them with bountiful re freshments at a neighboring restaurant. With the exception of presses the Ledger has a complete new plant on Locust street, and there to-morrow's paper is being pre pared. During the fire Childs was tendered the use of the presses of every daily and weekly paper in the city, and accepted the Record's offer. The business manager of the paper said to-night the Ledger's total lose is estimated at $150,000, including $100,000 on the building and $50,000 on the contents. The lose to tenants is $50,000. The presses and machinery were only dam aged to the extent of $25.000. Repairs on the building will be commencel at once. Justice Overtook Him. HAMILTON. Ont., Dec. .--'rThe tricky Bos ton reporter who wrote a sensational story about the Lizzie Borden case. and who is under indictment, was killed in attempting to catch a morning train at the Grand Trunk station here yesterday.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

A newspaper opinion column dismisses the claim that Lizzie Borden is insane as a last desperate tactic by sensational papers. It sarcastically suggests the next claim will be that no such woman exists.

Weekly Union · 7 December 1892 · page 4

President Diaz has just been inaugurated and entered upon another term of office as the executive head of that country. The once turbulent republic is as quiet and | peaceful as a Juve evening undaer Diaz’ rule. 1 Judging from rumors about patroimen | who are caught “‘napping,” in other words sleeping soundly on their beats, 1t would secm that Manchester needs a good roundsman about as much as anything. el e e s Politics in France is getting serious. M. Brisson has abandoned the attempt to form a cabinet after several trials, falling of seeuring two representative meu he sought for high positions.

See moreSee less

x e e et Rt The clalm that Miss Lizzie Borden is insane is evidently the last ditch of the sensational papers, unless they bring forth the claim that there is no such woman. - How’s This! ‘ We offer One Hundred Dollars Reward ‘for any case of Catarrh that can notbe curea by Hall’s Catarrh Cure.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

The Bristol County grand jury reconvened and, after hearing more testimony including from Detective McHenry, returned an indictment against Lizzie Borden for willfully killing her father and mother. A third indictment was also found against an unnamed party not in custody.

Weekly Union · 7 December 1892 · page 1

; ’!"hlrd Indictment Found Agalnst e Party Not in Custody. : v . TAUNTON, Mass., Dec. 2.—The grand i'jury et this morning and began again ~ hearing evidence in the Borden case. De :fii,te('ti\'e McHenry, his wife and an unknown ‘Veiled woman were called in and a small boy before unuoticed. The {impression - among the court officials is that an indlet ment will be fourd and that it will be ren dered sometime today, although the return to hearing of evidenee and threshing over of old straw, has discouraged the most ardent supperters of the indictment theory. As 1t was dinner heur when the iury

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

The report covers the grand jury's dismissal after returning indictments against Lizzie Borden for the murders of her stepmother Abby Durfee Borden and father Andrew Jackson Borden. It reproduces the formal indictment language, including the alleged number of wounds inflicted on each victim.

Weekly Union · 7 December 1892 · page 1

: MISS LIZZIE BORDEN. anxious spectators as it had been. Those . Who were present rose however, waiting for a sensation, but had none to enjoy. The foreman passed up some papers to the court, who glanced at them and handed them to the clerk and then dismissed the jury. The jury then disappeared in the region of the treasurer’s office for payment. All locked tired and much asifeach had passed through trying scenes. None was disposed to be communicative. Tre indictment against Miss Borden reads as follows: Commonwealth of Massachusetts.

See moreSee less

Bris tol, ss. At the superior court begun and holden at Taunton within and for the sald county of Bristol on the first Monday of November in the year of our Lord one thoussnd eight hundred and ninety-two. The jurors for the said commonwealth, on their oath, present that Lizzie Audrew Borden: of Fall River,in the county of Bristol,at Fall River, in the county of Bris tol, on the 4th day of August, in the year 1892, in and upon the body of "Abby Dur fee Borden, felonlously, wiitully and of her malice aforethought, an assault did make, and with a certain weapon, to wit, a sharp-cutting instrument, the name and, more particularly, the description of which ig, to the jurors, unknown, her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, feloniously, wilfally and of her malice aforethought did strike, cut and bruise in and upon the head of her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, glving to her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, by the “said striking, cutting, beating and bruising in and upon the head of her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, divers to wit, twenty mor ds, of which said mortal wounds

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

The grand jury returned an indictment charging Lizzie Borden with murdering her father Andrew Jackson Borden, and a mysterious third indictment was rumored to involve reporter Henry Trickey. The report also notes the foreman opposed the indictment, and details Trickey's accidental death at a train station in Hamilton, Ontario, after fleeing to avoid being indicted.

Weekly Union · 7 December 1892 · page 1

pression at the court house. ¢ It is understood that Miss Borden will not be immediately arraigued to plead, but that the indictments will be served on her at her quarters in Taunton jall, She was notitied today by friends of the return of the indictments by the grana jury and is said to have preserved the same demeanor which has marked her course duling the trial.

See the clipping

Morning Appeal · Carson City, Nev.

Henry G. Trickey, a Boston Globe reporter notorious for publishing a 'fake' story in the Lizzie Borden case, was killed by a train in Hamilton, Ontario. He was fleeing prosecution after being indicted in Bristol County for tampering with government witnesses in connection with the report.

Morning Appeal · 7 December 1892 · page 3

A Reporter's Death

Stewart Looms Up. Washington, Dec. 0 Senator Wm Stewart's intentions are not known. He may trade with Senators to se cure the passage of some silver bill. There is some gjssip heard Luii to day concerning the disposition of the Federal patronage in Nevada under Cleveland s administration. Senator Stewart is the nearest approach to a Democrat that Nevada has in Con gress, and it is believed he expects to distribute some of the offices. A Importer's Death Boston, Mass., December 5.-r-Henry G. Trickey, the reporter of the (5 lobe who made himself notor ious by publishing a "fake" story in the Lizzie Borden case, was killed Saturday at Hamilton, Out, by a railroad train.

See moreSee less

He was a fugitive from justice, having been indicted in Bristol county last week for tam pering with Government witnesses in the publication of the report.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Fall River News argues the Borden trial should be held locally for reasons of economy and convenience, noting the defense agrees. It also suggests the burned dress evidence has been exaggerated by newspapers and that grand jury testimony was one-sided, with rebuttal witnesses yet to be heard.

The Providence News · 7 December 1892 · page 1

FALL RivER, Dec. 7. —Speculations con cerning all phases of the Borden case have taken on an increased activity, and it is more generally talked of than the city election. Regarding the place of trial the Fall River News savs; On the ground of economy, hotel and court conveniences and the accommoda tion of a majority of all interested in the case, Fall River has the strongest claim to have the trial conducted here. To say that the seutiment of this community Is nonsense. I'hetrial ought to take place in this city. The defence has Already in timated that it prefers that the trial should be held nere, and quotes the broad laws of the constitution to show that it should take place as soon as possible, and

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The defense argues that newspaper coverage has overstated the importance of the allegedly burned dress and that grand jury testimony was one-sided, with key defense points yet to come. John Morse plans to return home to Iowa with his bondsmen's consent, while Emma Borden is bedridden from shock and Lizzie struggles to maintain composure under the charges.

The Providence News · 7 December 1892 · page 1

THE ALLEGED BURNED DRESS.

establishing the guilt of the prisoner, The evideuce given before the xnud{iuty, they say, was necessarily tinged with a goverumental flavor, but it must be re membered that the defence has not yet been submitted, nor were the defendant’s mauny stroug poiunts brought out to the best advantuge; besides mueh of the tes timony given by government witnesses can be coutradicted by witnesses yet to be called. Jolin V. Morse intends to leave for his home in lowa at once, where neglected business interests demand his attention. He goes with the full conseut of his bondsmen and will be within call when ever bis presence here Is desired.

See moreSee less

The langth of his stay 1s otherwise not deter mined, Miss Emma Borden has been confined to her bed since Friday. She went to Taunton at noon on that day before she was informed of the action of the grand jury, and the shock and disappointment unnerved her. Miss Lizzie Borden, though trying to bear up under the awful charges that confront her, is also much distressed, though she brings her unusual will power

See the clipping

The Vermont Watchman · Montpelier, Vt.

The report states that a Taunton grand jury indicted Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents, with a secret third indictment believed to target Boston Globe reporter Henry G. Trickey for witness tampering. It also reports Trickey's death in Hamilton, Ontario, after slipping under a train while trying to catch it, noting he was initially misidentified as Henry Melzar.

The Vermont Watchman · 7 December 1892 · page 5

buildings of Mrs. J. G. Brown, at North Haverhill, N. H. Rev. Db. John Withrrspoon Scott, President Harrison's aged fatlier-in-law, died at the White House last week Tues day. The funeral was held Thursday, and the remains were taken to Washington, Pa. Six safes helonging to as many different nrmi iu tlie big offioe building, corner of Washington anu Dearhorn streets, Chicago, were blown open aud riHed last Thursday night. The building is within oneMpiare of tlie city hall aud polioe headquarters. At Tauuton, Mass., last Friday, the grand jury indicted Lizzie Borden for the murder of ner mother and father, at Fall River,

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A brief dispatch reports that Lizzie Borden was indicted by a grand jury on December 2 on three counts related to the murders. The item is terse, offering no further detail on the charges or proceedings.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 8 December 1892 · page 6

15/./. i® Burden Indicted fur Murder. 'I 1 .s ton. .M ass., Dec. 2. — Lizzie Borden was to-day indicted the three counts. .V the grand jury

See the clipping

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

The Grand Jury at Taunton, Mass., returned three indictments against Lizzie Borden on Dec. 2 for the murder of her father and mother, with a third indictment kept secret because that party was not in custody. She is expected to be arraigned soon, and reportedly remained calm upon hearing the news.

The National Tribune · 8 December 1892 · page 12

Lizzie Uordcn Indicted. Tho Grand Jury at Taunton, Mas3., returned threo indictments against Lizzie Borden on Dec. 2, for the murder of hor father aud mother. There is a third indictment, which was kept a secret, as the party indicted is not in custody. The jury made no public report in court. It filed in, handed its papers to the court, and then was dismissed. It is understood that ilis3 Borden will be immediately arraigned to plead, hut that the

See the clipping

Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan.

A roundup of miscellaneous news items includes a brief note that the delay in the Lizzie Borden case is attributed to the court believing her to be insane. No further detail or source is given for this claim.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Barton County Democrat · 8 December 1892 · page 2

The passenger rate from Louisville to Chicago has fallen to fl.50. This means that the fight has reached a point where it must be settled at once. James Knott, of Newcastle-on-Tyne, England, has determined to put on a egular line of steamships between Charleston, S. C, and Mediterranean ports. The report of the commission ap pointed by the Ontario government to investigate the subject of dehorning cattle with a view to determining whether the practice is humane, rec ommends that the practice be permitted. The reason given for the delay in the Lizzie Borden case is that the court be

See the clipping

Ellsworth American · Ellsworth, Me.

The Fall River grand jury returned a true bill against Lizzie Borden, confirming what most locals had already expected given the evidence. Sources from the jury room indicated an axe or hatchet was presented as evidence and was influential in the decision to indict.

Ellsworth American · 8 December 1892 · page 2

Lizzie Borden's Indictment, The finding of a true bill against L zz'e A B rden t»y tin grand jury the jjt.-u t-ral t«>{ ;«• <>f conversation in Kail Kiv« r. Fr; !iy night. Comments and opinions

See the clipping

The Redwood Gazette · Redwood Falls, Minn.

A short news brief reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted, among other unrelated short news items of the day. No further details are given in this fragment.

The Redwood Gazette · 8 December 1892 · page 4

Seveu Italians Perish. SAN FRAXCISCO, Dec. "—A report was received Thursday evening that several boats had been capsized near West Berkeley, Cal., and that seven Italian fishermen had been drowned. Fire at Gowrie. la. FORT DODGE, la., Dec. 1.—The busi ness portion of the town of Gowrie was gutted by fire Wednesday morning. The loss is estimated at 350^000, with about one-third insurance. Lizzie Borden indicted.

See the clipping

The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN

A brief news digest reports that the Taunton, Massachusetts grand jury has indicted Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and mother. The item appears amid a roundup of unrelated national and local news items.

The Kanabec County Times · 8 December 1892 · page 2

The grand jury of Taunton, Mass., has indicted Miss Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and mother. It was announced, the 3d, that all of the barbed wire factories of the coun

See the clipping

Warren Sheaf · Warren, Minn.

A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden was indicted by the grand jury on two counts for the murder of her father and mother at Fall River, Massachusetts. The item appears as a short notice amid a roundup of miscellaneous national news.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Warren Sheaf · 8 December 1892 · page 2

N. Y. ANNIE BELL and Chauncey Mori an were married in a New York city mu seum. The bridegroom is 21 years old and weighs 442 pounds. The bride is a year younger and tips the scale at 570 pounds. BETWEEK New York and Galveston, Tex., thieves on the fast train secured $25,000 by "substituting for a package of money containing that sum brown paper of similar bulk. ON the Erie road a fast"train struck a wagon at a crossing in Elmira, N. Y., and Edward Blanchard and his wife and Mrs.

See moreSee less

W. Conklin and Mrs. Maggie Pitts were killed. Gov. HENRY HAYT, who was the chief official of Pennsylvania from 1878 to 1883, died at his home in Wilkes barre, aged 62 years. AT Erie, Pa., Joseph Kane, a Lake Shore railroad employe, killed his wife and himself. Domestic trouble was the cause. Tins great financier and railway king, Jay Gould, died at his home in New York of pulmonary consumption, aged 56 years. He leaves four sons and two daughters, his wife having died three years ago, and a fortune es timated at from $60,000,000 to $150,- 000,000. HIS term having expired Charles Bud densiek, the New York builder who was sant to prison June 24, 1885, for manslaughter, has been discharged from Sing Sing. LIZZIE BORDEN was indicted by the grand jury on two counts for the, mur der of her father and mother at Fall River, Mass. v^"?-^^-^

See the clipping

Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo.

The grand jury at Taunton, Massachusetts, indicted Lizzie Borden on two counts for the murder of her father and stepmother on December 2. The report appears as a brief item within a roundup of unrelated national news.

Iron County Register · 8 December 1892 · page 2

Lizzie Borden was indicted on two counts for the murder of her father and step-mother, by the grand jury at Taunton, Mass., on the 2d. The steamer Graystoke, of London, was wrecked at the mouth of the river Elbe, on the 2d, and her entire crew of twenty-three persons were drowned.

See the clipping

Iuka Reporter · Iuka, Miss.

The grand jury at Taunton, Massachusetts indicted Lizzie Borden on three counts for the murder of her father and mother, despite public opinion. This brief item appeared among a roundup of miscellaneous telegraphic news items.

Iuka Reporter · 8 December 1892 · page 2

public. rtoiwunsuuiuing puouc opinion tno grand jury at Taunton, Mass., in dicted Lizzie Borden on three conuts for tho murder of her father and mother.

See the clipping

Cherry County Independent · Valentine, Neb.

A special report from Taunton, Mass. states the prevailing belief that the grand jury will decline to indict Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father and stepmother. It suggests the Attorney General favors caution, expecting 'no bill' to be the likely outcome.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Cherry County Independent · 8 December 1892 · page 2

Lizzie Borden Will Escape

WIND AND RAIN DOING MUCH DAMAGE Reports Received that Several Fishing lloats Were Capsized and that Several Italians ero browned Ferryboats Are iot Running Ships Cannot lut to Sea Storm Swept California San Francisco special A rain and wind storm which began several days ago con tinues at intervals with some damage to signs fences and shipping Ferryboats are not running and ships could not put to sea A number of small schooners were washed ashoru and several vessels went adrift but were recaptured without damage At isolated points several frame buildings were blown down but no fatalities were re ported Communication with points out side of the city by wire was more nearly cut off than at any time during tho storm Reports were received that several fishing boats capsized near Wcstberkeley Cal and that several Italians had been drowned Later reports state that there are many washouts on the railroads Much damage was done in tlio upper Sacramento and Feather River valleys by high water The American River has also risen rapidly causing much damage MIX cits STAKVIXG Starling Talo of Suffering In tho Flood ed Districts of Washington Seattle Wash special A startling story of starvation among the miners in the mountains east of Snohomish lias just reach hero by E T Keit and Fritz Elling stone who had been for fifty hours without food The freshets hemmed the miners in and on account of their exhausted condi tion they were unable to reach the trans port and obtain a new supply of food Koit and Ellingstone are to only men out of fifty miners who started for Snohomish to get in The others dropped along the route from sheer exhaustion and want of food and it is feared they are lost in the woods The sur vivors had scarcely any clothing when they arrived tvhich with their pinched and guant features testified to the truth of their alarming tale News from tho flood in the distant Sky wansish River shows the damage to be enormous and that the next freshet may cause the river to take a new course thereby destroying the business portion of the town of Sultan A famine is likely to occur among the railroad camps both among the men and horses unless some means is devised of getting supplies from east of tho mountains A tree fell across tne camp of James Park near Stevens City killing three men and seriously in juring Edward OBrien and two other No mails have gotten into Sultan since Novem ber IS Alter At any Long Yqars Wooster O special William Wilson son of Rev I S Wilson a Methodist min ister liberally educated and tenderly reaied left here for Missouri in 1S5S He soon married a daughter of Senator Clymer and since then nothing has been heard of him and he was mourned as dead Word has just been received here that he is in prison in Texas convicted of horse stealing Since his conviction lie confessed his identity and says further that he served in the Con federate army during the war and was sent on a private mission lo the North by Jeffer son that after the deatli ot his wife and children he joined the band of tho no torious Younger brothers and was also as sociated with the James brothers He be came remorseful and went to Texas and was ordained a preacher in the Christian Church and while in holy orders he bor rowed a horse sold it and was convicted Many Heads Wore Cracked Dublin special The Nationalists held a meeting at Limerick to celebrate the mem ory of the Manchester martyrs The auti Parnellites ignored the object of the meet ing and pretended to regard it as a purely 1arnellito show They attacked the pro cession with stones and clubs at a late hour but were repulsed with many cracked heals and other damages Mr Allen manager of the Dublin Independent addressed tho meeting and in tilt course of his speech said that the union cf Irish and English hearts was impossible until the political prisoners were released Other conspicu ous Paruellites addressed the meeting but nothing of importance was said Lizzie IJordeii Will Kscapo Taunton Mass special The impression prevails that the grand jury will not indict Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and Mrs Borden The Attorney General realizes that it would bo better for all con cerned to make no error of judgment now even at the risk of conjuring up false ap pearances and to place Miss Borden in a po sition where she will not be beyond the reach of justice The probabilities are strongly in favor of no bill He Took Every tiling of Value Milwaukee special Frank Worms an ex convict was captured us lie was head ing for the depot with his pockets full of plunder obtained by a raid on Andrew Ko lafas boarding house Worms made a raid on tne house and swept it clean So com plete was his work that the use of chloro form was suspected He went through the rooms of the proprietor boarders and do mestics taking everything of value that came in his way Aiding the Locked Out Cotton Men London special The locked out cotton operators are gaining confidence and sup port from different sources is coming in The operatives of Bolton deposited 1000 to the credit of the central reliof fund and valuable offers of assistance have been re ceived from other districts Caused by Jealousy Chicago special Charles Brown shot his wife and John Leavitt probably fatally wounding tho latter The woman will re cover Jealousy was the cause TH li 31 A ItKhXS

See the clipping

The Alliance-Independent · Lincoln, Nebraska

Henry Trickey, the Boston reporter who wrote a sensational story about the Lizzie Borden murder case and was under indictment, was killed attempting to catch a moving train at the Grand Trunk station in Hamilton, Ohio. The report notes he died the previous day.

The Alliance-Independent · 8 December 1892 · page 1

A Llszle Borden Reporter Dead. Hamilton, O., Dec. 6 Eenry Trickey, the Boston reporter, who wrote the sensational story about the Lizzie Borden murder case and was

See the clipping

The Sioux County Journal · Harrison, Nebraska

John Morse, Lizzie Borden's uncle, states she has never shown signs of insanity and that none exists in her family. Her attorney Andrew Jennings dismisses the insanity theory, saying the defense will rely on her innocence and sanity instead.

The Sioux County Journal · 8 December 1892 · page 2

Nut Insane. Boston, Dec. 2. A Fall Hiver, Mass. special to the Journal says that Jolit Morse was seen in reference to the alleged insanity of Lizzie Borden. The government might be acting on the idea that she was insane, but the de fendant's uncle was positive that she was not insane. He had known hei from childhood and never had she shown the slightest sign of insanity. Moreover there had been no insanity in any branch of pier family. Andrew Jennings' counsel for Miss Borden if quoted as saying he put no faith in the insanity story, that the defense did not propose to build up on that idea and jthat Miss Border's friends, as far as he Knew, had absolute faith in her sanity 'as well as innocence of murder.

See moreSee less

l'aper Makers fyn icato.

See the clipping

Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J.

A roundup of the week's news notes that Lizzie Borden was indicted by the grand jury at Fall River, Massachusetts, for the murder of her parents. The item appears among other unrelated news briefs from early December 1892.

Gloucester County Democrat · 8 December 1892 · page 2

Saturday, Dec. 3. Miss Lizzie Borden was indicted for the murder of her parents by the grand jury, at Fall River, Mass. There has been no abatement in the

See the clipping

Der Westbote · Columbus, Ohio

A German-language report states Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the grand jury in Taunton, Massachusetts, for the murder of her father and stepmother and held without bail. It also claims a mysterious, still-unidentified accomplice may share guilt in the crime.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Der Westbote · 8 December 1892 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa.

The grand jury in Taunton indicted Lizzie Borden on three counts: one for the hatchet killing of Abby Durfee Borden with twenty wounds, and a duplicate count naming Andrew Jackson Borden as victim. A third sealed indictment was issued against an unnamed party not in custody.

Freeland Tribune · 8 December 1892 · page 4

Minister of Public Instruction M. Charles Dupuy. Lizzie Itordcn Indicted. TAUNTON, Mass., Dec. B.—Lizzie Borden has been indicted on three counts by the grand jury. The first count of the indict ment charges her with killing Abbey Bur lee Borden with a hatchet, indicting twen ty mortal wounds. The second count is the same as the first, substituting Andrew Jackson Borden for Abby Durfce Borden.

See the clipping

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa.

Henry G. Trickey, a Boston reporter who had been indicted for contempt of court in connection with the Borden case, was killed by a train in Hamilton, Ontario. The brief item gives no further detail on the circumstances of his death.

Freeland Tribune · 8 December 1892 · page 4

Reporter Trickey Killed

an aged lodging house keeper. Ho is uov In fail. l{'lorter Trlckey KTOftd. HAMILTON, Ont.. DE' - Hen<> G Trlckey, a Bostou repci*or. who WAD IU dieted for contempt of court Iu count ctioii with the Borden case, was killed by i -rui hero. K.I Stallion King Nelson Kelnstated NEW YORK Dec 0. -At a private session of the national board of review the stallion Nelson and his owuer. C H Nelsou. were reinstated Did John lloey Leave * Will? NKW YORK, Dec. 7.-No will of the late

See the clipping

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa.

A news brief states that Lizzie Borden allegedly burned a dress at Fall River just before her parents' murder was discovered, in order to conceal blood spots on it. The item is part of a roundup column of miscellaneous national and world news items.

Freeland Tribune · 8 December 1892 · page 4

Rome during the carnival. Monday, Dec. 5. It is alleged that Lizzie Borden burned a dress at Fall River just before the murder of her parents was discovered to conceal the blood spots upon it. The first practical gun test of the Brown segmental wire wound gun at Birdsboro, Pa., was a success. Yale Union Debating society voted to ac cept Princeton's challenge for u debate this winter. Commander R. I). Hitchcock, Jr., United States navy, died suddenly at New Y'ork. Herr Miquel, the Prussian minister of finance, is seriously ill with bronchitis.

See moreSee less

Miss Mary Allen West, the American Woman's Christian Temperance union lec turer and editor of The Union Signal, died in Japan. At Springfield, 0., Henry Landerstager, aged forty years, declares that he poisoned Nora O'Neil, of McVeyton, Pa., and Bar bara Killierease, of Mapletou, Pa., in 1867; S. Murray, of New Moorefield, 0., in 1872; John Landerstager, his father, and Mrs. Fox (colored) in 1876. Tuesday, Dec. 6.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report states that a Massachusetts grand jury has indicted Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father and stepmother, though the public still knows little of the actual evidence. It criticizes sensational and unverified stories circulating in the press, including one from a reporter who was also indicted for attempting to suborn a witness and later died in a railroad accident.

The Providence News · 8 December 1892 · page 4

THE BORDEN CASE, Thongh the Massachunsetts grand jury bas indicted Miss Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and step-mother but very little more is known by the

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The passage discusses the grand jury's indictment of Lizzie Borden and a Boston reporter (since killed in an accident) for attempting to suborn a witness. It argues the government's case relies on circumstantial evidence, not direct proof, and that guilt is not yet established pending the defense.

The Providence News · 8 December 1892 · page 4

’ must be held to show that the govern While the action of the grand jury ment has a stronger case against Miss Borden than the public generally be lieved, and hoped, it is not safe to con clude that her guilt is established, The defence is yet to be heard, and it has given no hint of its strength or its weakness. The best defence the acensed woman can possibly have is the extreme reluctance of the people to believe that such a fiendish crime as she is charged with could possibly have been commit ted by her, It will require evidence that admits of not the slightest doubt to convict the Fall River girl, and it s entirely plain that the government is not yet in possession of such evidence, The chief point upon which the gov ernment seems as yot to be satisfied is that it cannot conceive who could have committed the muarder if Lizzie Borden

See the clipping

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · Clarksville, Tenn.

The grand jury has returned a true bill charging Lizzie Borden with murdering her parents, and the report claims family members gave damning testimony against her. The piece reflects on the shocking nature of the crime given Borden's refined background.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · 8 December 1892 · page 2

The fate of Lizzie Borden, the Fall Rlvw. Mas!)., murderess, seems about sealed. The grand jury, after a long.sitting on the case, has return ed a true bill charging her with the

See the clipping

Herald and News · West Randolph, Vt.

The report states that Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the grand jury at Taunton, Massachusetts, on two counts for the murder of her father and stepmother. This marks a brief news item among many other unrelated regional stories.

Herald and News · 8 December 1892 · page 1

NO.D--9U8The United Suites Express Company ia out $2,000 by a daylight robbery oa a railroad near Dwigbt, III. A colony of Bohemians has left P.aitimora for Savannah, where they will in employed in an oyster canuery. Accused of embezzling $23,000 from his employers. Baud, ilcXiilly & Company, Charles K. Williams of Chicago, ha fled. Joseph WesthaefTer, of Annville, Pt.( wants the court to restrain the Lalintia:i & Ai.nvillf Railway from coutinuijj! business. The Michigan-Peninsular Car com pany's works in West Detroit were burced Saturday. The loss will be half million dollars.

See moreSee less

Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the grand jury at Taunton, Mast., on two counts for tha murder of tier father and stepmother. Missouri has adopted the coustifuUoiia! amendment to enable cities to pension disabled firemen and to provide for tha widows of deceased firemen. Gen. Robert S. Crawford, a prominent Nor walk. Conn., man, and at oue time commander ot the Connecticut National Guard, is dying of peritonitis.

See the clipping

Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · and 1 other paper

The grand jury considering the Lizzie Borden case, who was charged with murdering her father and mother in Fall River, Mass., returned two indictments against her. This marks the formal charging decision following the inquest investigation.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Barton County Democrat, 8 December 1892, Cherry County Independent, 8 December 1892.

Griggs Courier · 9 December 1892 · page 2

THE grand jury, which has been con sidering the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and mother at Fall River, Mass.. re

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · 8 December 1892

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The report describes rumors from the grand jury about a dispute between reporter Henry Trickey and Detective McHenry, each allegedly seeking personal gain from the Borden case. It claims Trickey tried to convince McHenry that Professor Wood had been bribed by the defense, which the paper denies.

Morning Journal and Courier · 9 December 1892 · page 3

NOT IN THE FIXING BUSINESS. Gossip About the Jury, Officer, and Reporter, lntere.ted In the Dorden Trial. Fall River, Mass , Deo. 8. The latest gossip concerning the Borden murders is

See the clipping

The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn.

The report states Lizzie Borden of Fall River has been indicted by the grand jury on two counts for killing her mother and father. It also claims an unknown person was separately indicted.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Willimantic Journal · 9 December 1892 · page 7

Factory Accident* the Fait Year. The annua) report of Faotory Inspector W. S. Simmons has been submitted to the governor. The number of factories visited were 414. The whole number of persons employed in these factories is 51,000. In 193 factories it was found that many changes were needed, Three hundred aDd fifty orders were gtrjn for better pro teciion from dangerous machinery, 27 for improved sanitary conditions and 64 for improved elevators. During the year more than 20 persons were killed in fac tories in this stat*, and a large number received injuries that no report was made of.

See moreSee less

Several of the accidents were caused by projecting screws on shafting. Other bad accidents were cause) by the bursting of emery wheels. The inspector recom mends the appointment of inspectors in each city to see that laws in regard to fac tories are enforced. Lizzie Borden of Fall River has been in dicted by the grand jury on two counts, for killing her mother and her father and an uuknonn person is also indicted.

See the clipping

The Goodland Republic · Goodland, Kan.

Henry Trickey, the Boston reporter who wrote a sensational account of the Lizzie Borden murder case and was under indictment for it, was killed while trying to catch a moving train at the Grand Trunk station in Hamilton, Ohio. The brief report notes his occupation and his legal trouble tied to the Borden case.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Goodland Republic · 9 December 1892 · page 6

Atchison. Kan.. Dec. 8. The Mis souri Pacific employes here held servi es this afternoon in memory of the late Jay Gould. Several addresses were made and appropriate resolutions adoDted. The headquarters of the company here are draped In monrnlng. A Mule Ilorden Reporter Dead. Hamilton, O.. Dec. Henry Trickey, the Boston reporter, who wrote the sensational story about the Lizzie Borden murder case and was under indictment, was killed in attemntiuur to cateh a moving train at the Grand Trunk station here yester day. Osborne Still Hold tha Fori. Ciikyknnk, Wyo., Dec.

See moreSee less

0 Governor elect Osborne is spending day and nltrht in the executive rooms, a bed having been put in through the win dow by which he entered. A Millionaire Coal Stan Dead. PrrrsBuno, Pa., Dec 8. Joseph Walton, the millionaire coal operator, (iiml midlenlv of anpolexv at 10:45 this morning at his home in Allegh any. He was 7') years of age. Senator f.lbeon Very Low. Itor Sphinos. Ark.. Dee. . Senator Gibson of Louisiana is barely alive. and that is all that can be said of his condition. The doctors tninn ne can not possibly live another day. Embexsler Kerr Raoehea New York. Naw York. Deo, 6 Kerr, the KanCitv defaulter, is on board the .tanmnr Anrania. which arrived thl mnrnlnv frnm Llvemooi He ia in charge of a Chicago dete. tlve. PrUon Officers Will Not Strike. LitAVBNWOimt, Kan., Dec. 8. OS eers at the state penitentiary deny most positively that tbey propose to wnllc nut In a bodv whenever Warden Case retires. A Leavenworth Candidate for Marshal. TV Undei i ai n a v a s -- ' 6her.ff Chauncey Flora is a candidate for United States marshal unaer tne Democratic administration.

See the clipping

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

The item reports that the delay in the Lizzie Borden case is due to the court believing she is insane. It appears as a brief news note among other unrelated items of the day.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Iola Register · 9 December 1892 · page 2

The reason given for the delay in the Lizzie Borden case is that the court believes her to be insane. The fire in the Honeybrook mine at nazlcton, Pa., has commenced raging again. An Erie express struck a wagon at a

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Fall River residents and press argue the trial should be held locally for reasons of economy and convenience, dismissing concerns about local prejudice. The report notes the defense believes the burned dress evidence has been overblown by newspapers and that grand jury testimony favored the prosecution.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 December 1892 · page 5

WHERE WILL MISS BORDEN BE TRIED? Fall River People Claim it Nhonld be in that City—Other Movsip About the Case. Speculations concerning all phases of the Borden case took on an increased activity in

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Following Lizzie Borden's indictment by a 20-1 grand jury vote, reports emerge of jurors discussing the case despite secrecy rules, with one juror predicting she will hang. The piece also covers debate over trial venue, the burned dress evidence, John Morse's departure for Iowa, and the ailing health of both Borden sisters.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 December 1892 · page 5

WHERE WILL MISS BORDEN BE TRIED?

stay is otherwise not determined. Miss Emma Borden has been confined to her bed since Friday. She went to Taunton at noon on that day before she was informed of the action of the grand jury and the shock and disappointment unnerved her. Miss Lizzie Borden, though trying to bear up un der the awful charges that confront her, is also much distressed, though she brings her unusual will power into play when special ordeals confront he The Boston Journal’s Fall River special said: The vote of the grand jury for the in dictment in the Borden case stood 20 to one.

See moreSee less

The members of the jury having been disI missed for the year, are talking. They are not telling the whole story all at once, but each man adds his mite, and the new evi dence that so impressed the jury as to leave only one in doubt of Lizzie Borden’s guilt is gradually becoming known, in speaking to a iriend of his experience at the hearing, one juror solemnly asserted, “they’!! hang her, sure.” Others are more conservative in summing up the case, but it is evident that every one of the 21 men was strongiy im pressed with the weight of the government’s evidence, and all, except one, of the lot is positive that the defendant is guilty. One juror states that the case could not have had a more complete hearing at a trial in open court. The defense might have something back, but all the evidence for the defense which was regarded as valuable was pre sented, and in spite of it the outlook for the prisoner looked absolutely hopeless. Henry G. Trickey, the Bos ton Globe re porter who wrote the sensational story about the Lizzie Borden murder case and was under indictment, met with a tragic death at Hamilton, Ont., Saturday. In attempting to catch a moving train at the Grand Trunk station he slipped and was swung under the cars and his life was crushed out.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The grand jury at Taunton concluded its proceedings and returned an indictment against Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father and stepmother. The report quotes the formal legal language of the indictment count concerning the killing of Abby Durfee Borden, detailing the alleged wounds inflicted with a sharp cutting instrument.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 December 1892 · page 12

INDICTED FOR TWO MURDERS. THE BORDEN HEARING FINISHED And «h* llanchter ot Mr nnd Mrs Andrew •1. Bordru Will be Tried for Causing Their Deaths—A Third Indictment Found.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report quotes the formal indictment language charging Lizzie Borden with the murders of Abby and Andrew Borden, detailing the wounds alleged in each count. It also notes a secret third indictment possibly tied to Trickey, and describes the grand jury's lengthy, divided deliberations before reaching its decision.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 December 1892 · page 12

THE BORDEN HEARING FINISHED And «h* llanchter ot Mr nnd Mrs Andrew •1. Bordru Will be Tried for Causing Their Deaths—A Third Indictment Found. The grand jury at Taunton finished its work Friday and found an indictment against Lizzie Borden on two counts. Alter the usual legal introduction the first count reads as follows:— The jurors for said commonwealth, on their oath present that Lizzie Andrew Borden of Fall River, in the county of Bristol, at Fall River, in the county of Bristol, on the 4th day of August, in the year 1892, in and upon one Abby Durfee Borden feloniously and wilfully and oi her malice aforethought, an assault did make and with a certain weapon, to wit, a sharp cutting instru ment, the name and a more particular description of which is to the jurors un known, her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, feloniously, wilfully and of her rnalico afore thought did strike, cut, beat and bruise in and upon the head of her, the said Abby Durfee Bor len, giving to her, the said Abby Durfee Bor den, by the said striking, cutting, beating and bruising in and upon the head of her, the said Abby Durfee Borden divers, to wit, 20 n ortai wounds, of which said mortal wountis the said Abby Duriee Borden then and there instantly died.

See moreSee less

Arid so the jurors aforesaid upon their oaths aforesaid do say that the said Lizzie Andrew Bor den, the said Abby Durfee Borden in manner and form atoresaid then aud there feloniously, w’iifully and of her malice aforethought did kill and mur der against the peace of the said commonwealth, and contrary to the form of the statute in such case made and provided. The next count is the same as the first, merely substituting the name of Andrew Jackson Bor len for Abby Durfee Borden and 10 mortal wounds instead of 20. There was a third indictment which was kept a secret, us the party indicted is not in custody. The jury made no public report in court. It banded its paper to the court and then was dismissed. No one was dis posed to be communicative. District At torney Knowlton would neither admit nor deny that the third indictment relates to -Mr Trie key of the late seusatioual story matters, but such was the impression at the court-house. It is understood that Miss Borden will nut be immediately ar raigned to plead, but that the indictmeuis will be served on her at her quarters in Taun ton jail. She was notified Friday by friends of the return of the indictments by the grand jury, and is said to have preserved the same stolid demeanor which has marked her course during the trial. XX’hen it became known Friday morning that the grand jury was all at sea Thursday and had spent the day in a free and easy manner of discussion, something after the style of a town-meeting, there was a general expectation that no verdict would be returned against Lizzie Borden. It was evident that the jury’s sentiment was

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The grand jury returned a true bill against Lizzie Borden, and a mysterious third paper submitted to the court sparked speculation of a separate indictment unrelated to the murder itself. Fall River residents largely expected the indictment given the evidence from the preliminary hearing, while a small group of sympathizers clung to theories of persecution or insanity.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 December 1892 · page 12

INDICTED FOR TWO MURDERS. THE BORDEN HEARING FINISHED And «h* llanchter ot Mr nnd Mrs Andrew •1. Bordru Will be Tried for Causing Their Deaths—A Third Indictment Found. The grand jury at Taunton finished its work Friday and found an indictment against Lizzie Borden on two counts. Alter the usual legal introduction the first count reads as follows:— The jurors for said commonwealth, on their oath present that Lizzie Andrew Borden of Fall River, in the county of Bristol, at Fall River, in the county of Bristol, on the 4th day of August, in the year 1892, in and upon one Abby Durfee Borden feloniously and wilfully and oi her malice aforethought, an assault did make and with a certain weapon, to wit, a sharp cutting instru ment, the name and a more particular description of which is to the jurors un known, her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, feloniously, wilfully and of her rnalico afore thought did strike, cut, beat and bruise in and upon the head of her, the said Abby Durfee Bor len, giving to her, the said Abby Durfee Bor den, by the said striking, cutting, beating and bruising in and upon the head of her, the said Abby Durfee Borden divers, to wit, 20 n ortai wounds, of which said mortal wountis the said Abby Duriee Borden then and there instantly died.

See moreSee less

Arid so the jurors aforesaid upon their oaths aforesaid do say that the said Lizzie Andrew Bor den, the said Abby Durfee Borden in manner and form atoresaid then aud there feloniously, w’iifully and of her malice aforethought did kill and mur der against the peace of the said commonwealth, and contrary to the form of the statute in such case made and provided. The next count is the same as the first, merely substituting the name of Andrew Jackson Bor len for Abby Durfee Borden and 10 mortal wounds instead of 20. There was a third indictment which was kept a secret, us the party indicted is not in custody. The jury made no public report in court. It banded its paper to the court and then was dismissed. No one was dis posed to be communicative. District At torney Knowlton would neither admit nor deny that the third indictment relates to -Mr Trie key of the late seusatioual story matters, but such was the impression at the court-house. It is understood that Miss Borden will nut be immediately ar raigned to plead, but that the indictmeuis will be served on her at her quarters in Taun ton jail. She was notified Friday by friends of the return of the indictments by the grand jury, and is said to have preserved the same stolid demeanor which has marked her course during the trial. XX’hen it became known Friday morning that the grand jury was all at sea Thursday and had spent the day in a free and easy manner of discussion, something after the style of a town-meeting, there was a general expectation that no verdict would be returned against Lizzie Borden. It was evident that the jury’s sentiment was divided, and it was expected that the long hesitation, discussion and rambling vol ume of testimony which bad been exhausted in the case had not accomplished what the district attorney desired. Again the fact ' that more witnesses were called in yester day, that McHenry and his wife were again interviewed, and that two more witnesses were examined, gave the impression that the case was likely to end in smoke. The district attorney, however, had been particu larly smiling for two days and that was in terpreted as an omen that he was sure of his case and was quietly waiting until the jury should weary of talking aud should settle down to business. This they did at about 10 o’clock yesterday morn ing and after a little over two hours of deliberation, passed upon the matter aud returned indictments as given. As it was the dinner hour when they came in, the court-room was not so full of anxious specta tors as it had been. Those who w’ere there, however, waiting for a sensation, had none to enjoy. The jury filed into the court-room looking hungry, tired ind ready to go home. The court asked them if they had any matters to present, The foreman said they had and passed up some papers. The court glanced at them, handed them to the clerk, and then dismissed the jury. They struck a bee-line for the county treasurer's office. The court was then adjourned for dinner and the few spectators went out to talk it over and wonder what the third paper was that the jury passed in. It soon leaked out that there was another indictment, but no cajoling, coaxing or guessing at names could secure an affirma tion or denial from the district attorney. It was generally assumed, however, that it was not an indictment for participation in the murder, either as accessory before or after the fact, but that it grew out of some thing which hail occurred since the case had fallen into the hands of the government and that the party wanted was not at present just where the hand of the law can be laid upon him in an instant. That he will be secured in time if on this continent is affirmed. The district attorney did nut want to be interviewed, but was inclined to com pliment the jurors for their faithful work ana disposition tu sift things thoroughly. The friends of Miss Borden had nothing to say, save that it had come out almost as tbev had expected, but they stoutly affirmed that there had been no new evidence found and that it only remained for a speedy trial be fore a jury to establish the fact of her inno cence. The finding of a true bill against Lizzie A. Burden by the grand jury was the general topic of conversation in Fall River Friday mght. Comments and opinions are advanced freely by all, with the exception of those directiy interested in the case, and they are all very reticent. Fall River people as a whole expected an indictment. They were directiy acquainted with all the facte leading up from the tragedy to the preliminary hear ing, and were morally certain that the jury would be sure to find a true bill. The gleanings of the evidence from the hear ing served only to clinch their opinion, and consequently they were Dot surprised. A few, women for the most part, have been loth to believe Lizzie guilty, aud have adhered to the idea that she is being victimized by plot ters. They were confident that the jury would be unable to find sufficient evidence to warrant an indictment, but accept the result as a continu ance of the prisoner’s persecution and martyrdom. These few are now grasping at the insanity theory and are making great capital of it. They have undoubtedly good grounds for advancing this proposition, as Lizzie’s demeanor through the whole pro ceeding has been sach as to excite comment and to be regarded as unnatural. The de fense, however, if they introduce this as an araiun^nL will have to contend against the THE SPRINGFIELD WEEKLY REPUBLICAN: FRIDAY, DECEMBER 9, 1892.—TWELVE PAGES. date for governor, would not send in such a CONTEST FOR THE SPEAKERSHIP. statement made by Lawyer Jennings at the report until he had cudgeled not only his preliminary hearing, in which he laid par own memory but that of every other man ticular emphasis upon the fact that his client BENNETT OF E VERETT AND BARRETT I who had seen the ballots. These returns, was not insane. i therefore, of “no defective vote” from a full From the wording of the indictmeut as quarter of all the towns in the state gives ns ; The Mituntion < on.pn red with that of published Friday, it would lead to the in an idea of the importance of this par Three 1 ears Ago - The McnHtorxhip, and ference that the implement used in inflicting ticular blunder. Consider for a moment the what Bearing the Other Matter May Have Ou 11. blunders which are necessarily involved the wounds upon the murdered couple had in the final blunder of marking for William From Our Special Rejiorter. ! not yet been unearthed. It has been learned, H. Haile and Wolcott Hamlin. The voter however, on authority direct from the Boston, Friday, December 2. must overlook first, the title, “For Governor. iury room, that an ax or hatchet was Speaker Barrett must fight for his chair if Mark one;” second, the name, “Hamlin:” brought in as evidence and had con he expects to fill it next term. He does want third, the designation, “Prohibitionfourt h, siderable weight in the decision of the next name, ’‘William E. Russell;” fifth, it and hits already begun to “hustle,” as the the jury. It is also known from the the next title, “Lieutenant-Governor. Mark same source that the evidence introduced political! of the day puts it. Representative one;” sixth, the name, “Ruger Wolcott, Re was overwhelmingly against the prisoner, Frank P. Bennett of Everett is a candidate publican.” and that there was no other course for the against him and says that he is in the fight In fact, it was no easier to commit tins grand jury to pursue than to bring in an in particular blunder than any other blunder, dictment. The party against whom the to stay till the speaker is elected. Public and there is absolutely no ground for assum second indictment has been brought is yet a knowledge of the situation is only 24 hours ing that the few’ republican blunders secret, but is generally understood to be old and the field is not yet clearly which were made were not fully offset Henry G. Trickey. The charge said to have by blunders upon the other side. in view. Every one who has had been preferred against him is that of tamper But the Advertiser has performed an ing with government witnesses and it is experience with Speaker Barrett knows important public service. By going alleged that he approached both Bridget Sul that he is an active politican and that his systematically to work to collect what are livan and Detective McHenry and offered opponent must be very smart to get ahead of confessedly nothing but unofficial partisan them inducements to leave for parts un him. Barrett claims that he has received guesses, it has disclosed to its readers the known. letters from every old member of the House true nature of the attack which has been except seven, saying they congratulate him Lawyer Jennings, when interviewed Friday made upon the governor’s title. It has bad, on his election and were for him for speaker. night, said that he had nothing for publica too. the candor to admit that even upon the His prestige will doubtless hold some mem tion aud his remarks were substantially as basis f its own canvass it is “probable that bers to him who believe that he will win and Gov Russell might have had a narrow mar already given. Rev XV. XV’. Jubbof the Cen they want to be on the winning side. It is gin even over the errors us the blunderers.” tral Congregational church, whose self-im possible that Barrett will get some votes posed duty it was to wait upon Miss Borden which would go to an opposition candidate INDICTED FOR TWO MURDERS. who was less pugnacious tnan Representative and inform her of the result of the grand Bennett. The latter’s fighting qualities jury’s action, reports that the pris have always been fully recognized by oner received the intelligence with in THE BORDEN HEARING FINISHED his fellow members injthe House. On the difference, retaining her stolid, unruf other hand, a less pugnacious candidate tied demeanor, betraying neither sur than Bennett would be slow tu make a con And «h* llanchter ot Mr nnd Mrs Andrew prise nor emotion and saying nothing. test, and so those who wanted some other •1. Bordru Will be Tried for Causing As regards his personal opinion he had noth Their Deaths—A Third Indictment man might wish for him in vain. Other men ing to say other than that he was not sur Found. have been mentioned. Current gossip takes prised at the outcome of the hearing. As The grand jury at Taunton finished its up the names of XVellman of Malden and soon as the intelligence reached Fall River Meyer of Boston. Either would make a that an indictment had been found, Emma work Friday and found an indictment good speaker. Mr Wellman is sick of ty Borden left for Taunton and was closeted against Lizzie Borden on two counts. Alter phoid fever and is wholly out of considera for some time in the cell with Lizzie. She the usual legal introduction the first count tion at this juncture, whatever might returned home last night, but refused an au be true if he were a well man in dience with reporters. Medical Examiner reads as follows:— fact as fully as in name. As to Mr. Dolan refused to be interviewed, and Rev E. The jurors for said commonwealth, on their Meyer, he is not likely to weaken the antiA. Buck could not be found. oath present that Lizzie Andrew Borden of Fall Barrett strength, and if he runs it will be River, in the county of Bristol, at Fall River, in Dr Bowen said there was little for him to the county of Bristol, on the 4th day of August, with the good of the party in view. Mr Ben say worthy of publication other than that the in the year 1892, in and upon one Abby Durfee nett’s declaration that he is in the field to Borden feloniously and wilfully and oi her malice indictment was not what he expected. He stay till the speaker is elected makes him an aforethought, an assault did make and with a avowed candidate and no other candidate was not surprised, but thought that in the certain weapon, to wit, a sharp cutting instru with the good of the party in view is likely trial Lizzie would be able to prove her inno ment, the name and a more particular to take the field, unless it should appear description of which is to the jurors un cence. Marshal Hilliard was not furnish that two candidates are better than one for known, her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, ing much news and is desirous of feloniously, wilfully and of her rnalico afore drawing support from Barrett. But, iu view ' enjoying well-earned rest. The indict thought did strike, cut, beat and bruise in and of the contest three years ago between Bar ment has served to vindicate himself upon the head of her, the said Abby Durfee rett and XVardwell, it is very clear that con and his officers against the great amount Bor len, giving to her, the said Abby Durfee Bor centration, nut dispersion of forces, is the of abuse heaped upon the department by den, by the said striking, cutting, beating and most hopeful course. bruising in and upon the head of her, the said ihe friends of the prisoner, who claimed that Abby Durfee Borden divers, to wit, 20 n ortai the circumstances of the case did not warrant The situation is different from that of wounds, of which said mortal wountis the said the extreme measures employed by them. three years ago in some essential features. Abby Duriee Borden then and there instantly died. They were the ones who firmly believed that Arid so the jurors aforesaid upon their oaths Then the opposition came in the main from the grand jury would now’return a bill aforesaid do say that the said Lizzie Andrew Bor the foremost republican members of the Leg against Lizzie. It is .surmised not that the den, the said Abby Durfee Borden in manner and line of the defense taken up will be the in form atoresaid then aud there feloniously, w’iifully islature, who had had oue year’s experience and of her malice aforethought did kill and mur sanity theory. In the time remaining be with Barrett, who formed their deliberate der against the peace of the said commonwealth, tween now and the trial the people would judgment that he was not the kind of man for and contrary to the form of the statute in such have an opportunity to ponder and reflect the party to raise to high position, and that case made and provided. upon all the incidents connected with the the interests of good legislation, as well as of The next count is the same as the first, case and prepare themselves for the startling the party as a whole, required the election revelations which, it is said, will be made at merely substituting the name of Andrew of another man. This movement rallied the trial. about Mr XVardwell and in the decisive vote Jackson Bor len for Abby Durfee Borden

See the clipping

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A brief dispatch from Taunton, Massachusetts reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the grand jury on three counts for the murder of her father and mother. The item appears as a short item amid other news briefs including Jay Gould's death and a Chicago safe-blowing spree.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 9 December 1892 · page 9

Lizzie Borden Indicted. TAUNTON, Mass., Dec. 2.—Lizzie Bor­ den has been indicted by the grand jury on three counts, for the murder of her father and mother.

See the clipping

Oakes Weekly Republican · Oakes, N.D.

The report states that Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her father and mother. It places the crime at Taunton, Massachusetts.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Oakes Weekly Republican · 9 December 1892 · page 1

THE WEEK'S NEWS. CRIMES AND CASUALTIES. Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her father and mother at Taunton, Mass. The steamer Grey stone was wrecked at the mouth of the Elbe aud twenty three of the crew drowned. Mgr. Satolli, the papal delegate, lias been empoivtred by the holy see to hear and decide without appeal all religions questions between b.shops and priests in the United States. A dispatch from Kong Kong says that seventy-four lives were lost by the wreck of tlio Japanese dispatch boat Chisimakan which was suiik in the Sea of Japan in a collision with the English steamer Ravenna.

See the clipping

The Cambria Freeman · Ebensburg, Pa.

Henry G. Wickey, the Boston Globe reporter who authored a sensational story about the Lizzie Borden murder case and was under indictment for it, died tragically in Hamilton, Ontario. He slipped while trying to catch a moving train and was crushed under the cars.

The Cambria Freeman · 9 December 1892 · page 2

Henry (.!. Wickey, the Itn-ton Uttiht reixirter who wrote the sensational story alxnit t he Lizzie Borden murder case and was under indictment, ne-t with a tragic

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The paper reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her father and mother, noting this was contrary to general expectation. It adds that her friends remain steadfast in support.

Paper unidentified · 9 December 1892 · page 4

Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her father and mother, contrary to general expec tation. Her friends are steadfast. Contradictory statements regarding

See the clipping

The Londonderry Sifter · South Londonderry, Vt.

Boston Globe reporter Trickey, under indictment for his sensational Borden story, died after being struck by a train while fleeing under an assumed name. Separately, Lizzie Borden was indicted by the Taunton Grand Jury with her trial expected in January.

The Londonderry Sifter · 9 December 1892 · page 1

Trickey, the Boston Globe reporter who wrote the sensational story about lhe Lizzie Borden murder case, and was under indictment, met with atragic death at Hamilton, Ont, Saturday.

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

Henry Trickey, the Boston Globe reporter who wrote a sensational story about the Lizzie Borden case and was under indictment, died in Hamilton, Ontario. He slipped while trying to catch a moving train and was crushed under the cars.

The United Opinion · 9 December 1892 · page 1

IIEiNUY TK1CKKY DEAD. He Received Considerable Notoriety In the liorden Case. Hamilton, Out., Dec. 5. Trickey, the Boston Globe reporter, who wrote the sensational story about the Lizzie Borden murder case and was under indictment, met with a tragic death here Saturday. In attempting to catch a moving train at the Grand Trunk station, he slipped and was swung under the cars and his life was crushed out.

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

The grand jury in Fall River, Mass., returned a double indictment against Lizzie A. Borden for the murders of her stepmother and father. The first count, detailed in full legal language, charges her with the murder of Abby Durfee Borden on August 4, 1892, by striking her with a sharp instrument and inflicting twenty mortal wounds to the head.

The United Opinion · 9 December 1892 · page 6

FOR DOUBLE MURDER

FOK DOUBLE BlUKDEIt. Lizzie Borden ii Indicted on a Double Count by the Grand Jury. FALL River, Mass., Dee. 7. The fol lowing Is the result of the work of the

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

The report quotes the formal indictment language charging Lizzie Borden with the murders of Abby Durfee Borden and Andrew Jackson Borden, detailing the wounds inflicted (twenty for Abby, ten for Andrew). It notes Borden was informed of the indictment and maintained her composed demeanor.

The United Opinion · 9 December 1892 · page 6

Count by the Grand Jury. FALL River, Mass., Dee. 7. The fol lowing Is the result of the work of the grand jury, as reported in the famous Borden case: The Indictment for Murder against Lizzie A. Borden was on two counts, the first of which was as follows: Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Bristol B. s. At the superior court begun and holden at Taunton, within and for the said county of Bristol, on the lirstjMonday of November, In the year of our Lord one thousand eight hun dred and ninety-two, the jurors of the said commonwealth, on their oath, present that Lizzie Andrew Borden of Fall Kiver, in the county of Bristol, at Fall Kiver, in the county of Bristol, on the fourth day of August, iu tlie year WHS, in and upon the body of Abby Dur fee Borden, feloniously, wilfully, and of her malice aforethought, an assault did make, and with a certain weapon to wit: a sharp cutting instrument, the name and more a particular description of which is to tlie jurors unknown, her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, feloniously, wilfully and of her malice aforethought, did strike, cut and bruise in and upon the head of her, the said Abby Durfee Borden, giving to her, the said Abby Durfoo Borden by the said striking, cutting, beating and bruising in and upon the head of her, tlie said Abby Durfee Borden, divers.to wit: Twenty mortal wounds.

See moreSee less

of which said mortal wounds the said Abby Durfee Borden then and there instantly died. And so the jurors aforesaid, upon their oat h aforesaid, do say that the said Lizzie Borden the said Abby Borden, in mti iner and form aforesaid then and there feloniously, wilfully, and of hemalice aforethought, did kill ami murder, against the peace of said common wealth, and contrary to the form of the statute, in such case made and provided. The next count is the same as the lirst, merely substituting the name of Andrew Jackson Borden for Abby Durfee Borden, and ten mortal wounds instead of twenty. Miss Borden has been notified by friends of the' return of the indictment, and is said to have preserved the same stoical de meanor that has marked her course during the preliminary hearing.

See the clipping

The Osceola Times · Osceola, Ark.

The report states that Lizzie Borden was indicted on two counts for the murder of her father and step-mother by a grand jury at Taunton, Massachusetts, on December 2nd. This is listed among other brief news items of the day.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Osceola Times · 10 December 1892 · page 2

of at least, half a dozen others. Lizzie Borden was indicted on two counts for the murder of her father and step-mother, by the grand jury at Taunton, Mass., on the 2d. The steamer Graystoke, of London, was wrecked at the month of the river Elbe, on the 2d, and her entire crew of twenty-three persons wer* drowned.

See the clipping

The Savannah Tribune · Savannah, Ga.

A special dispatch from Taunton, Massachusetts reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the grand jury. The brief notice gives no further details of the charges.

The Savannah Tribune · 10 December 1892 · page 1

Lizzie Borden Indicted. A special of Friday from Taunton, Mass., says: Lizzie Borden has been in dicted by the grand jury of three courts.

See the clipping

The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss.

A brief news item reports that the reason given for the delay in the Lizzie Borden case is that the court believes her to be insane. No further details are provided about the source of this claim.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

The Grenada Sentinel · 10 December 1892 · page 2

The reason given for the delay in the Lizzie Borden case is that the court believes her to be insane. The fire in the Honeybrook mine at Hazleton, Pa., has commenced raging again. An Erie express struck a wagon at a crossing at Elmira, N. Y. Two women and two men were killed and a woman fatally injured. Ex -Gov. IIoyt, of Pennsylvania, died on the 1st He was years old. The telegraph operators on the New Jersey Central have been given satis factory concessions. Two men of Paterson, N. J., have been sent up for two years for beating their wives.

See moreSee less

Jay Gould, the famous millionaire and railway king, died at New York on the 2d of pulmonary consumption. The North German Lloyd steamship Bpree was reported overdue at New York. Fire destroyed a Williamsburg, N.

See the clipping

Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio

A brief news item reports that the grand jury considering the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and mother at Fall River, Mass., returned two indictments against her. This item appears in a roundup of miscellaneous national news from the period.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Perrysburg Journal · 10 December 1892 · page 2

The grand jury, which has been con sidering the caso of Lizzie Borden, charged with tho murder of her father

See the clipping

The Superior Times · Superior, Wis.

After the Lizzie Borden grand jury hearing concluded in Fall River, Mass., jurors spoke to reporters about their impressions. One juror said she would surely hang, and all but one juror reportedly expressed belief in her guilt.

The Superior Times · 10 December 1892 · page 1

SAYS MISS BORDEN WILE HANG. Granil Jury Cot ti lent That the Voting Worn ah is Guilt s*. Fait. Rived. Mass.. Dec.fi.- The Lizzie Borden grand jury is talking now that the hearing is over. In s.pe iking to a friend of his experience at the.hearing, one juror said: ”1 hey'll hangher sure." All except tine of the jurors express the conviction that trie defendant is guilty.

See the clipping

The Daily Bulletin · Honolulu, Hawaii

A brief item reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her parents at Fall River, Massachusetts. It notes that before returning the true bill, the grand jury had obtained knowledge of the defense to be set up.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The Daily Bulletin · 12 December 1892 · page 3

shot and reckless with his gun, es caped. Lizzie Borden has been indicted for tho murder of hor parents at Fall Rivor, Massachusetts. Boforo returning thoir true bill, tho grand jur3 had obtained the defense to bo sot up. Tho Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers insist on a now contract witli the Now York Central Railway without which tho men will not work. There is liable to bo trouble at aii3 moment in Wyoming over tho two rival Governors. Nathan Zuckoman is afraid to prosecute two Italians who tried to take his life at Cleveland, O. Ho is evidently tinder fear of tho Mafia, has aged percoptibl3 in a few daj's and declares ho will leavo tho city. An international controversy is threatened 03 tho killing of an

See the clipping

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

The report states Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the brutal murders of her father and mother in Fall River, Massachusetts. It notes her friends maintain her innocence, but claims the State has a very strong case against her.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 13 December 1892 · page 5

$6S4,019,289. In one night seven safes were successfully cracked within one block of police headquarters in Chicago. The police are paralyzed. Lizzie Borden, who is accused of

See the clipping

Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis.

After the Lizzie Borden grand jury hearing concluded, a juror told a friend that she would surely hang, and nearly all jurors reportedly believed in her guilt. The report reflects informal post-hearing opinions rather than an official verdict.

Watertown Republican · 14 December 1892 · page 3

SAYS Miss tiOHuE.N WILL HANG. Grand. Jury Cm fluent That the Young Woman is Guilty, Fall River. Mass., Dec. 6.—The Lizzie Borden grand jury is talking now that the hearing is over, in speaking to a friend of his experience at the hearing, one juror said: “They’ll hang her sure.” All except one of the jurors express the conviction that the defendant is guilty.

See the clipping

Der Fortschritt · New Ulm, Minn.

The report states that the grand jury considering the murder charges against Lizzie Borden was adjourned until December 1, a development that surprised observers. It speculates that police may have uncovered new leads and could be preparing to arrest additional suspects as accomplices.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Der Fortschritt · 15 December 1892 · page 8

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Herald and News · West Randolph, Vt.

The passage reports among various news items that Henry G. Trickey, a Boston Globe reporter who had been indicted at Taunton alongside Lizzie Borden in connection with the murders of her father and stepmother, was killed in Hamilton, Ontario after being run over by a train. The item appears as a brief notice amid unrelated crime and news items from around the country.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 6 days earlier.

Wrong

Herald and News · 15 December 1892 · page 4

reporter, indicted at Taunton, Mass.. with Miss Lizzie Borden for the murder of the latter s father and stepmother, was killed at Hamilton, Out., last week by being run over Dy a tram.

See the clipping

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.

A Fall River report says the Lizzie Borden grand jury, now that the hearing is over, is confident of her guilt. One juror reportedly told a friend 'They'll hang her sure,' and all but one juror expressed conviction she is guilty.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Eagle River Review · 15 December 1892 · page 2

SAYS LIZZIE BORDEN WILL HANG.

FALL RIvER. Mass.. Dec. 6.—The Lizzie Borden grand jury is taiking now that the hearing is over. In spe.king to atriend of Lls ¢xperience at ithe bßearing, one juror sa.d: **lhey’ll hang her sure.” All exccept one of tine Jjurois express the eonvieuon that the defendant is guilty.

See the clipping

The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss.

A brief dispatch reports that members of the grand jury which indicted Lizzie Borden claim the evidence against her is of the strongest kind. The item appears among a roundup of short regional and national news items.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The Grenada Sentinel · 17 December 1892 · page 2

secretary. THIS EAST. Members of the grand jury which in dicted Lizzie Borden say that the evi dence against her is of the strongest kind. A wealthy widow of Reading, Pa., named Lizzie R. Bechtel has gone in

See the clipping

The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.

A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her father and mother. The report erroneously places the crime in Taunton, Massachusetts.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

The New North-West · 17 December 1892 · page 2

CRIMES AND CASUALTIES. Lizzie Borden has been indicted for the murder of her father and mother at Taunton, Mass. The steamer Greystone was wrecked at the mouth of the Elbe and twenty three of the crew drowned, James Stone and William Blanken ship were arrested in a deserted iron mine near Anniston, Ala., while in the act of counterfeiting nickels. Mgr. Satolli, the papal delegate, has been empowered by the holy see to hear and decide without appeal all religious questions between bishops and priests in the United States. A dispatch from Hong Kong says that seventy-four lives were lost by the wreck of the Japanese dispatch boat Chisimakan which was sunk in the Sea of Japan in a collision with the English steamer Ravenna.

See moreSee less

A most curious accident happened to a boy at Neenah, Wis. In coming down stairs in his .ather's barn he slipped and fell head foremost into a barrel at the foot of the stairs in such a way that he could not extricate himself nor make his cries heard. He was nearly dead when released after several hours confinement, and cannot recover.

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

A brief item in a national news roundup reports that Lizzie Borden was indicted in Taunton, Massachusetts, for killing her father and stepmother with a hatchet. It also claims a third indictment was returned against a separate, unnamed mysterious person.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 21 December 1892 · page 7

THE NEWS EPITOMIZED. EaateVn and Middle States. J. Ross Faulkner, a young student in the University Medical College, committed suicide by swallowing poison in Bellevue Hospital, New York City. He was the son of General Lester B. Faulkner, wrecker of the Dansville (N. Y.) Bank. Lizzie Borden was indicte l in Taunton, Mas?., for killing her father and stepmother with a hatchet, and a third indictment was returned for a mysterious person. Joseph Kane was sent to prison some time ago for the protection of his wife and children, and when released, finding his wife at the house of a neighbor he shot her through both cheeks.

See moreSee less

Mrs. Kane seized the weapon and pleaded for her life, bat Kane fired the remaining flveiihots into her Head and bodf. He then killed himself. The Allentown (X. J.) Bank robber3 were sentenced to ten years' imprisonment each. The Erie Canal has been close 1 for the winter.

See the clipping

The State Herald · Holyoke, Colo.

A reporter named Thickey, formerly of Boston, had presented a set of affidavits claiming to prove Lizzie Borden's guilt, but these were later found to be bogus. Having fled to Canada to avoid indictment, he was killed after falling under a moving train.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 8 days earlier.

The State Herald · 23 December 1892 · page 2

Hotting forth the guilt of Lizzie Borden, which affidavits had tho dis tinguished peculiarity of being bogus, is no longer a fugitive from justice. He has the unhappiness to bo dead. WltUo .In Canada, whither desire to avoid personal contact with an in ilictinunl had suggested Ills going, ho fell tinder a moving car. Doubtless the justice he dreaded would have been far less harsh than this. Un. OI.IV! a \V| mo i. li'M.MKs has be-u invited to furnish the ode for the May day opening of the world's fair. The honor could not have been more worthily bestowed.

See moreSee less

Tho ••Autocrat,” although more than eighty years old. ha* not lost ills poetic tire, ami should be accept, will prove a luurcatc worthy of the occasion Since the deaths of J/ongfellow, Whittier ami Dr.

See the clipping

Scranton Wochenblatt · Scranton, Pa.

A German-language newspaper article discusses sensational murder trials involving women, using the Lizzie Borden case as a current example. It compares her unfavorably in looks to other famous female murder defendants but notes she may avoid the fate of executed murderess Roxalana Druse.

Scranton Wochenblatt · 23 December 1892 · page 6

Heldinnen von Mordprocessen

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Authorities in Taunton, Mass. are reportedly delaying Lizzie Borden's arraignment, possibly due to concerns about her sanity. The report reveals that Alice Russell told the grand jury about Lizzie burning a dress days after the murders, claiming it had paint stains on it.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 25 December 1892 · page 5

DELAYING THE TRIAL. Authorities Believe Lizzie Borden Is on the Verge of Insanity. Tauxtox. Mass., Dec. 24.— There Is no intimation yet in regard to time of arraigning Miss Borden for the murder of her father and step-mother. It is as serted that the government is in no hurry to have the case presented, be cause of a belief that the woman is in sane, or if not so, fear that she will be before tiie trial. If she is insane, the enormous exuense of a trial will be avoided and the ends of justice practi cally attained.

See moreSee less

If she is placed oii trial, the most important fact to be explained will be in regard to the dress and for the first time the details of that affair are now made public. Miss Russell and the two Misses Borden were in a room on the third or the fourth day after tho murders. Lizzie went out and then came into the room again holding in her hand a dress which she pointed to,at tiie same time spying: "They are making so much fuss over things about here that I tiuess that I wi.il burn this. It is an old dress upon which I spilled some red paint." She passed out into the kitchen and put the dress into the fire. When the officers in their search found a piece of this dress in the ashes they sought to learn what it meant, and it was for tiiis reason that the New Bed ford purchase was so closely examined into. Miss Russell said nothing about this matter at the first hearing*, nor did Emma Borden; but when Miss Russell was asked point blank in regard to the occurrence the day before the grand jury reported she told the story.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The report notes no trial date has been set for Lizzie Borden, as many reportedly believe she is insane, which could end the case. It also mentions key evidence against her: a burned dress and testimony from maid Bridget Sullivan contradicting claims that burning dresses was a Borden family habit.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 26 December 1892 · page 3

Lizzie Borden's Kall. Taunton. Mass., 24. Dezember. Nicht« verlautet darüber, waun der Prozeß gegen Lizzie Borden, welche der Ermordung ihres Vaters und ihrer Stiefmutter beschul digt und von der Grand-Jury in Anklage

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A roundup of short national and foreign news items includes a one-line mention that Miss Lizzie Borden may be crazy. No further detail or context is given about this claim.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 26 December 1892 · page 11

liana suspected of burning a house in New Orleans Immigration suspension forcing tho Gulon line out of business. ...A It-year-old murderer in West Virginia, ....Cincinnati people want tho Erie Canal badly.. ..Live national topics from Washington. ...Cramp hopes for all the new naval vessel contracts. ...Senator McMillan a gas magnate... .A Maine bov's suicide in Philadelphia. ...Miss Lizzie Borden may be crazy. ...The Republican National Committee called to meet. ...Wright is unopposed for the Democratic State Chairmanship.. ..Republicans gain a point in the Montana contest. ...Cleveland and Crisp will meet and heal their differences

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A Taunton dispatch reveals that Lizzie Borden burned a dress days after the murders, telling her sister and Miss Russell it was ruined by paint, and that Bridget Sullivan identified the fabric as similar to what Lizzie wore the morning of the killings. Emma Borden explained that burning old clothes was a family custom, and the report notes uncertainty about when Lizzie's arraignment will occur.

Wheeling Register · 27 December 1892 · page 4

New Bedford purchase was so closely examined into. Miss Russell said nothing about this mattes at the first hearing, nor did Emma Borden; but when Mis? Russell was asked point blank In regard to the occurrences, : the day before the Grand Jury re ported, she told the s.ory. Bridget Sullivan was shown the piece, and said that Lizzie wore a dress like that on the morning of .the mur der. Emma said, in explanation of the affair, that it was a general custom in the family to burn up their clothes when they wero of no further use.

See moreSee less

There is no intimatiou as to the time of arraigning Miss Borden. It is as serted that the Government Is In no hurry to have the case presented, be cause of a belief that the woman is In sane, or, if not so now, that she will be beforo the trial. If she is insane the enormous expense of a trial will be avoided, and the euds of justice prac tically attaiued.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's dismal Christmas in the Taunton jail, noting she received no visitors and nothing marking the holiday beyond the ordinary jail routine. It notes she remains arraigned for the murder of her father and stepmother, awaiting the Attorney-General's appearance in court.

New-York Tribune · 28 December 1892 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN'S CHEERLISS CHRISTMAS, Taunton, Mass, Dee, Lorden’s Christmas appears to have been a most cheerless I'p tS Monday noon, aed wd ng to the Jail report, he Lad been visited by none of her friends, had received Lo remembratices Christmas dinner said now that it ds ralgned for tie mnrder of until the Attorney-General, attend court. FENSE—— IAzz1e Ly Miss one, indicative of the time, and her wus the ordmary jail affair. It i fmprobable that she will be ar her futlier and stepmother Ww dl, Is able to no

See the clipping

The Daily Bulletin · Honolulu, Hawaii

The article reports that Henry Trickey, a Boston reporter indicted by the Massachusetts Grand Jury for contempt in the Borden case, was killed by a train near Hamilton, Canada. It details the grand jury's indictments of both Lizzie Borden for murder and Trickey for interfering with a government witness, alleging a scheme with Detective McHenry to profit from a sensational but false story.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 7 days earlier.

The Daily Bulletin · 28 December 1892 · page 8

October 10th a very long and sonsa tional story about tho Borden case, a groat part, of which was false.

See the clipping

Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn.

A short news item states that Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her parents in Fall River, Massachusetts, is reported to be insane or expected to become so. The claim is presented as unverified rumor among other unrelated news briefs.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 11 days earlier.

Morris Tribune · 28 December 1892 · page 2

A. P. Dye, Ch’n. Attest: —N. R. Spurr, Auditor. Indians at the Bad River agency, Wis consin, claim that government timber is being cut illegally. Lizzie Borden, the alleged murderer of her parents at Fall River, Mass., it is reported, il insane or will soon be. The discrimination against American roads by the Canadian Pacific will be investigated by the United States gov ernment The resignation of William B. Greene, secretary of the American Bankers’ As sociation, which was tendered on the 30th has been accepted.

See the clipping

Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn.

A short news digest item reports that Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her parents in Fall River, Mass., is said to be insane or soon to become so. No further details or sources are given for this claim.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Mower County Transcript · 28 December 1892 · page 7

Monday, Dec. 26. Mrs. Langtry is pronounced out of danger. A call has been issued for a Catholic convention, to be held in Chicago next September. The White, Honse will remain closed --on New Year's Day for the third time »n its history. Indians at the Bad River agency, Wis consin, claim that government timber being cat illegally. Lizzie Borden, the alleged murderer her parents at Fall Biver, Mass., it is -.•ported, insane or will soon be. The discrimination against American oads by the Canadian Pacific will be nveetigated by the United States gov ernment.

See moreSee less

The resignation of William B. Greene, SK ^etary of the American Bankers' As sociation, which was tendered on the 20th inst., has been accepted. The United States vessel Constella tion, which has on board some of the art treasures of Italy for exhibition at the world's fair at Chicago, has arrived at Havre. Tuesday, Dec. J87. E. S. Corser, a Minneapolis real estate dealer, fails with $1,000,000 liabilities. Theat speculation is the cause. Hagen retains the championship of the irorld as a skater, again defeating Mc 'prmick in a match at Minneapolis. A man in Boston murders his daugh fatally wounds his wife, seriously ligures his mother and finally kills himThe so-called Canadian warships Qn be Great Lakes are said to be merely revenue cutters, each with one small 1?J»e United States congress may take hand in investighting the Panama M?al scandal. D^niaging developments areexpected, jrerdict of acquittal is rendered in A

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The Clerk of Courts in Taunton states that Lizzie Borden's trial may not occur for months, pending the attorney general's availability. She will be arraigned for the murder of her father and stepmother once court proceedings can begin.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Pawtucket Tribune · 28 December 1892 · page 1

Had to Leave Their Vessel, PorrsmovTH, N. H, Dec. 25 —Light house steamer Lilae arrvived here, with Captain Rawling and crew of the steamer Gold Hanter, That vessel went ashore ou Boon island lelge one week ago last night. The crew took to the boats and after hard pulliog reached Boon island, where they remained until yesterday, the weather preventing any sattempt to reach the mainland, One Voot Wus Frozen WALTHAM, Mass,, Dec 28 The police found » man named John Armitage, aged 53 venrs, who lives at West Newton, wan dering about the streets of Waltham in a dazed condition.

See moreSee less

He bad no boot or eov ering to one of his feet and it was found that it was badly frozen. Physicians think the foot will have to be amputated, Whole Crew Frosthitten WINEYAND HAVEN, Mass.,, Dec 2% Schooner Centennial of Perth Ambhoy, Captain Spravue, Baltimore to Boston, arrived here after a bard passage. All of her crew are more or less frostbitten, The second mate had his feet so badly frozen that it was necessary to land him At the marine hospital here Lizzie Borden's Trial TAUNTON, Mass., Dec. R Clerk of Courts Borden say« that thetrial of Lizzie Borden may not take place for months She will be a: vignel for the muarder of ber father and stepm ther when the at torney @eueral is able to attend court, which may not be for inany weeks. The American Was a Good shot, Bruns,Dee 2e Tageblatt pub lishes a dispaich trom Nice sayiug that Connt Peter Komo 1 weame involved i a quarrel vith « Brooklyn man at the Causino gambling tihie oad taat the two fought w duel with pistols on the seashore yosteriay, the ¢ unt g killed sweetness Licked Up by Flames GALVESTON. Dec 88 ~The sugar mlis, warehouses aud 1% barccls of refined sugnr on the Darlington plantation, in Fort Bend eonnty, were burnel, entailing a loss of £BO,OOO The Chinn plantation snffered a similar disaster,entailing 4 loss of aver $lOO,OOO Court Woodlawn, No 1,984 A O F of A, will hold a social In their ha'l,

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The report notes that Lizzie Borden's Christmas while awaiting trial was bleak, with no visits from friends or holiday remembrances. Her Christmas dinner was described as an ordinary affair, nothing special.

Pawtucket Tribune · 28 December 1892 · page 3

Lizzie Borden's Christmas. TAUNTON, Mass., Dec. 27.--Miss lizzie Borden’s Christmas uppears to have becn & cheerless o.e. She was visited by none of her fricuus, received no remems brances indicative of the time, and her

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Taunton's Clerk of Courts states that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother may not occur for months. She will be arraigned only once the attorney general can attend court, which could be weeks away.

The Providence News · 28 December 1892 · page 8

Trial of Lizzle Borden. TavxtoN, Dec. 28, Clerk of Courts Borden says that the trial of Lizzie Borden may not take place for months. She will

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A piece of Lizzie Borden's burned dress found in a fireplace at the Borden residence is being examined as possible evidence in the Fall River murder case. Lizzie claims the stain was red paint, a story corroborated by a family servant, but experts have yet to determine whether the substance is actually blood.

The Morning News · 29 December 1892 · page 4

The fragment of Lizzie Borden’s burned dress that was found in a fireplace at tbe Ilorden residence not long ago, does not ap pear to be worth much as evidence in the great Fall River murder trial. Lizzie burned the dress because she had spilled red I>alot on it, to she says, and the family serv ant confirms her story. Still, some of the experts in the cate, after they have con cluded their analyses, may decide that the “red paint” is blood, in which cate tbe young woman would be placed in a very dangerous positioo. Should Mrs. lAUgtry’a Illness prove fatal •be would be remembered for a short time ooly, and then more on aocount of having betrayed bsr own character than having portrayed the characters of other*.

See the clipping

The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.

The clerk of court reports that Lizzie Borden cannot be arraigned for the murder of her father and stepmother because the attorney general is too ill to attend court. The proceedings are postponed until he recovers.

The Austin Weekly Statesman · 29 December 1892 · page 8

Taunton, Mass., Deo. 27. The clerk of the court says now it is im possible for Lizzie Borden to be ar raigned for the murder of her father and steomother until the attorney

See the clipping

Bellows Falls Times · Bellows Falls, Vt.

A brief news item notes that Lizzie Borden's arraignment for the murder of her parents will be postponed due to the illness of the Attorney General. No new date is specified for the arraignment.

Bellows Falls Times · 29 December 1892 · page 1

Michael Davitt, returned as member of parliament for North Mtaih, has been unseated on the groind of clerical in timidation. On account of the illness of the Attor ney General Lizzie Borden i)l not be arraigned for the murder of her parents for some time. Severe cold weather prevails through out the country, and there is tleigbiug at CharhBton, South Carolina.

See the clipping

In the story →

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report details how Lizzie Borden burned a paint-stained dress days after the murders, witnessed by Miss Russell and her sister Emma. It explains how investigators discovered the burned fabric in the stove ashes and later questioned witnesses, including Bridget Sullivan, about the dress Lizzie wore the morning of the killings.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 30 December 1892 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

WHY LIZZIE BURNED THE DRESS.

She Said She Did It to Avoid a Fuss— The Delayed Borden Trial.

See moreSee less

A Taunton dispatch to a Boston paper says there is no intimation yet in regard to the time of arraigning Miss Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother. It is asserted that the government is in no hurry to have the case presented, because of a belief that the woman is insane, or if not so now, that she will be before the trial. If she is insane the enormous expense of a trial will be avoided and the ends of justice practically attained. If she is placed on trial the only important fact to be explained will be in regard to the dress, and for the first time the details of that affair are now made public. Miss Russell and the two Misses Borden were in a room on the third or fourth day after the murder. Lizzie went out and then came into the room again holding in her hand a dress, which she pointed to, at the same time saying: "They are making so much fuss over things about here that I guess that I will burn this. It is an old dress upon which I spilled some red paint," she passed out into the kitchen and put the dress into the fire. When the officers in their search found a piece of this dress in the ashes, they sought to learn what it meant, and it was for this reason that the New Bedford purchase was so closely examined into. Miss Russell said nothing about this matter at the first hearing, nor did Emma Borden but when Miss Russell was asked point blank in regard to the occurrence the day before the grand jury reported, she told the story. Bridget Sullivan was shown the piece and said that Lizzie wore a dress like that on the morning of the murder. Emma said, in explanatian of the affair, that it was a general custom in the family to burn up their clothes when they were of no further use.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The Clerk of Courts at Taunton reports it is unlikely Lizzie Borden will be arraigned for the murder of her father and stepmother until the ill attorney-general recovers. This brief item appears amid a roundup of unrelated regional news items.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 30 December 1892 · page 5

age was 4.90 per cent. Clerk of Courts Borden at Taunton says that it is improbable that Lizzie Borden will be arraigned for the murder of her father and stepmother until the attorney-general, who is ill, is able to attend court.

See the clipping

Oakes Weekly Republican · Oakes, N.D.

A brief news item claims that Lizzie Borden, the accused murderer of her parents, is reported to be insane or soon to become so. No source or detail is given for this claim.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Oakes Weekly Republican · 30 December 1892 · page 1

Afonluyf Dec. 86. Mrs. Langtry is pronounced cut of danger. A call has been issued for a Catholic convention, to bo held in Chicago next September. The White House will remain closed on New Year's Day for the third tinw in its history. Indians at the Bad ltiver agency, Wis consin, claim that government timber is being cut illegally. Lizzie Borden, tho alleged murderer

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Fall River News disputes a recently published account of Lizzie Borden's burned dress, noting Bridget Sullivan never specified the dress and the burning actually occurred days after the murders, unknown to police until later. It also corrects claims of a lonely, visitor-less Christmas for Borden, stating she received visits from her lawyer, sister, and gifts throughout the week.

The Providence News · 30 December 1892 · page 1

ITS TRUE VALUE

concerning the prisoner’s Christmas: “The dhrwh which ngoned a cheerless, lonely Christmas for Lizzie A. Borden, was an error. On Sunday, as usual on the Sabbath, no visitors were allowed to see her, although one called; but on Monday Miss Borden was visited by Lawyer Jenn

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's bleak Christmas and holiday season at Taunton jail, noting she received no visitors and the delay in her trial due to the Attorney General's illness. It also mentions her apparent nervousness about Thursdays, which have been marked by significant events in her case, and recounts the family history back to William the Conqueror.

Evening Star · 31 December 1892 · page 5

AWAITING HER TRIAL

Correspondence of The Eveninr Star. FALL Rivan, MAsS., Dec. 27, 1892. Lizzie Borden spent a cheerless Christmas at Taunton jail. She received no callers either on Sunday or on the holiday, Monday, and there was nothing in the prison regime to indiate to the unfortunate girl that the season of peace and good will to men was passing. The continued illness of Attorney General Pillsbury, who is down with pneumonia at Northampton, has deferred the arraignment of Miss Borden many weeks, and it is doubtful if January sees the day out for her trial.

See moreSee less

The suspense and delay is having a marked effect on the prisoner, and there are some who say that if her mind is not already affected it will be come so. She does not talk much, but seems to dwell upon the train of events that has brought her to the prison doors.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 1 other paper

The report explains that Attorney General Pillsbury's illness has postponed Lizzie Borden's trial into uncertain future weeks, and describes her growing nervous anxiety. It recounts how every major development in her case—the murders, her arrest, her probable-cause ruling, and her indictment—occurred on a Thursday, fueling superstitious dread about the trial's start date.

Evening Star · 31 December 1892 · page 5

A DAT TO BE FEARED. There is one day in the week that Lizzie Borden has become nervous about. That day is Thursday. The prospect of a trial for mur der is never reassuring, but the ordeal will have added terrors for her if it proves to begin on this particular day. Thursday has been marked by such startling ill omens in connection with her case that she may well dread its weekly re currence in the calendar. Such consistency in portentious happenings seems like something more than mere coincidences; it smacks of fatality, and may well awaken the apprehen sions of a young woman quite as resolute and devoid of ordinary superstition as Miss Lizzie Borden.

See moreSee less

Thursday, August 4. was the day that An drew J. Borden and Abby Borden were mur dered-a day that must live as one of horror in the mind of the daughter, whether she be innocent of the crime or not.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me. · 5 January 1893

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The report recaps the preliminary hearing and grand jury indictment of Lizzie Borden, noting each major step occurred on a Thursday. It then shifts into a feature on the Borden family's ancestry, tracing them to Norman nobility and explaining the origin of Lizzie's name.

Evening Star · 31 December 1892 · page 5

1Ew PHASEs OF INTEREAr. The Borden case is one of the few tragedies that continually develop new phases of inter est. The more we learn about it the more re Wiarkable it appears. The tendency of all strange occurrences to resolve themselves upon closer scrutiny into the familiar elements of the commonplace is quite absent here. The more closely the exact facts are followed the better the "story," in a newspaper sense. The prominence of the family gives the coming trial an interest in this part of the state sur passing anything in the annals of the old colony.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

This year-end summary of 1892's major crimes lists the Dalton gang's destruction and the Alice Mitchell case among the year's events. It singles out the Borden murder and a Wells Fargo express theft as the year's most remarkable unsolved mysteries.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 31 December 1892 · page 11

CELEBRATED CASES, EMBEZZLEMENTS AND DEEDS OF BLOOD.

reduces wages. Buda-Pesth made a capital and royal 11 Ex-Premier Mercier,. of Quebec, indicted. 16 Canadian cut-nail makers organise and residence. . raise prices. alter a long series of baufc and train rob beries. Many of the deeds of mob vio lence are so closely interwoven with indus trial events that it is hard to 'sever them. A curiosity in crime is the case of Alice Mitchell, the Memphis homicide. As mysteries, the Borden murder and the ex press theft, in which packages of brown paper were substituted for currency shipped to New Orleans, were the most remarkable.

See moreSee less

The violatiou ot American neutrality laws by Mexican bandits operating under the guise of revolutionists are among the notale events ot tne year, a melancholy ieature is the growth of lynch law in the South.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

This is a year-end almanac-style digest of major 1892 news events, including brief entries noting the murder of Borden and his wife on August 4, Lizzie Borden's arrest on August 11, and the start of her preliminary trial on August 25. It appears amid dozens of unrelated crime and labor-unrest items from throughout the year.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 31 December 1892 · page 11

eral Anderson captured by treachery. 19 General Carr.es soldiers march to the relief of Camp Anderson, Tenn., and rescue General Anderson; a sheriff's posso repulses the miners but falls to reach Camp Anderson. 21 Fonr masked farmers hold up and rob a train near Augusta, Kan.; they are all captured. 23 A gang supposed to be the Daltons at the Missouri, Kansas and Texas station of Nowata, Ark..holds np the station agent, traveling passonger agent and traveling anditor, and rob the station of$I,cco. 25 Tho preliminary trial or Lizzie Borden begins.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

This passage is a chronological digest of national events from August and September 1892, listing crimes, strikes, and legal proceedings in brief date-stamped entries. Among them it notes that Lizzie Borden's preliminary trial began on August 25 and that she was held for trial on September 1.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 31 December 1892 · page 11

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

The report notes that Lizzie Borden had a cheerless Christmas in jail, receiving no visitors or holiday remembrances as of Monday noon. Her Christmas dinner was described as the same as any ordinary day's meal.

Narragansett Herald · 31 December 1892 · page 8

The New England engine was considerably damaged aud three cars of the other tran were smashed up. The tracks were blocked for six hours. g&ssen;grs and express mat ter were transferred. o 0 one was hurt. Miss Lizzie Borden’s Christmas appears to have been a cheerless one. Up to Monday noon, according to the jail report, she had been visited by none of her friends; had re ceived no remembrances indicative of the time, and her Christmas dinner was just the ordinarv affair.

See the clipping