On 2 December 1892 the grand jury indicted her for both murders, by a vote the jurors later put at 20 to 1. The next day the Globe’s reporter, who had fled to Canada, was killed by a train. The winter brought the story of a dress put into the kitchen fire and a search for a stranger seen near the house. In May 1893 she was arraigned at New Bedford and answered each indictment: not guilty.
◆
Why the grand jury waited
A New Bedford dispatch passes on the Mercury’s explanation for the grand jury’s adjournment from 21 November to 1 December: the jury was ready to bring in a true bill, but Attorney General Pillsbury believes Lizzie Borden insane and wanted her sanity examined first. Whatever the reason, the jury indicted her on 2 December, and in June 1893 she stood trial.
St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
St. Paul Daily Globe · 1 December 1892 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
BELIEVES LIZZIE INSANE.
Secret of the Adjournment of the Borden Case.
See moreSee less
NEW BEDFORD, Mass., Nov. 30.—Attorney General Pillsbury believes Lizzie Borden is insane. This is the secret of the adjournment of the grand jury in the case from Nov. 21 to Dec. 1. The Mercury today publishes an article in which it says the grand jury was ready to bring in a true bill, but the attorney general's belief caused him to order an adjournment until Lizzie Borden could be examined as to her sanity.
After a day the Tribune’s correspondent likens to a town meeting, the grand jury at Taunton indicts Lizzie Borden on 2 December 1892: one count charges twenty mortal wounds to Abby Durfee Borden, the other ten to Andrew Jackson Borden. A third indictment is kept secret because the person named is not in custody; courthouse talk links it to Trickey, the Globe’s reporter.
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
New-York Tribune · 3 December 1892 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
LIZZIE BORDEN INDICTED.
THE GRAND JURY CHARGES HER WITH THE MURDER OF HER FATHER AND STEPMOTHER.
See moreSee less
Taunton, Mass., Dec. 2.--Lizzie Borden has been indicted by the Grand Jury on two counts. When it became known this morning that the Grand Jury was all at sea yesterday and had spent the day in a free and easy discussion, something after the style of a town meeting, there was a general expectation that no verdict would be returned against Lizzie Borden. It was evident that the jury sentiment was divided, and it was expected that the long hesitation, discussion, and rambling volume of testimony, which had been exhausted in the case had not accomplished what the District-Attorney desired. Again the fact that more witnesses were called in to-day, that McHenry and wife were again interviewed, and that two more witnesses were examined ,gave the impression that the case was likely to end in smoke. The District-Attorney, however, had been particularly smiling for two days and that was interpreted as a sign that he was sure of his case and was quietly waiting until the jury should grow weary of talking and settle down to business. This they did at about 10 o'clock this morning, and after a little over two hours of deliberation upon the matter returned an indictment. As it was the dinner-hour when they came in, the courtroom was not so full of anxious spectators as it had been. Those who were there, however, waiting for a sensation, had none to enjoy. The jury filed into the courtroom looking hungry, tired and ready to go home. The judge asked them if they had any matters to present. The foreman said they had, and passed up some papers. The judge glanced at them, handed them to the clerk, and then dismissed the jury.
The first count of the indictment charges that Lizzie Andrew Borden on August 4, 1892, inflicted upon Abby Durfee Borden twenty mortal wounds, of which she instantly died. The next count is the same as the first, merely substituting the name of Andrew Jackson Borden for Abby Durfee Borden and ten mortal wounds instead of twenty.
There is a third indictment, which was kept a secret, as the person indicted is not in custody. District-Attorney Knowlton will neither admit nor deny that the third indictment relates to Mr. Trickey, of the late sensational story matters, but such is the impression at the courthouse.
It is understood that Miss Borden will not be immediately arraigned to plead, but that the indictments will be served on her in Taunton jail. She was informed to-day by friends of the return of the indictments by the Grand Jury and is said to have preserved the same stolid demeanor which has marked her course during the trial. The friends of Miss Borden had nothing to say, except that it had come out almost as they had expected, but they affirmed that no new evidence had been found, and that it only remained for a speedy trial before a jury to establish her innocence.
When the Grand Jury met this morning Detective McHenry, his wife and an unknown veiled woman were called in. Then a small boy, before unnoticed, was introduced.
The day after the indictment, Henry G. Trickey, the Globe reporter who wrote the false Borden story, falls between the cars while boarding a train at Hamilton, Ontario, and dies within minutes. He had fled to Canada, the dispatch says, to avoid arrest for contempt of court, and registered at his hotel under another name. His brother-in-law says Trickey blamed McHenry for deceiving him.
Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 5 December 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
VERY LIKE RETRIBUTION. The Boston Reporter of the Borden Testimony Fake Is Killed. HAMILTON, ONT., Dec. 4.—[Special.]—Henry G. Trickey, a Boston Globe reporter, was killed here yesterday while trying to board a train. He came here a week ago and registered at a leading hotel under the name of Henry Melsear, representing that he was a New York commercial man. It has since been learned that he had fled to Canada to avoid arrest for contempt of court in connection with the Borden murder case. He was the reporter who wrote up the article which appeared in the Globe, containing an alleged expose of all the evidence the detectives had worked up against Lizzie Borden.
See moreSee less
Next day the paper apologized for the story and admitted that it had been deceived. Yesterday morning, as Trickey was about to leave the city, he fell between the cars and was so badly crushed that he died in a few minutes. Trickey had left word at the hotel to have his mail forwarded to P. Melsear, Evanston, Ill. The news of the accident was telegraphed there, and this evening Trickey's brother-in-law arrived. He identified the body. Melsear says that Trickey told him he had been deceived by Detective McHenry, who had offered to furnish the information in the Borden case for $500. Trickey gave him the money, and McHenry furnished the points for the article as published in the Globe, but deliberately deceived him. The body was taken to Boston to-night.
Dismissed for the year, the grand jurors talk: the vote to indict was 20 to 1. The most damaging evidence, they say, came from a defence witness, Miss Russell, who knew of the burning of a dress; and Prof. Wood found no blood on the hatchet head but found it washed and cleaned with ashes. In June 1893 a trial jury would acquit her on a single ballot.
The Providence News · Providence, R.I.
The Providence News · 6 December 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
BORDEN JURORS TALK. The Vote Stood 20 to 1 for Liz- zie's Indictment, They Say.
JURY SAW THE HATCHET.
See moreSee less
And a Witness Told of the Burning of Miss Borden's Dress—The Hatchet Had Been Cleaned—Things Look Very Dark for the Defendant.
FALL RIVER, Mass., Dec. 6.—The vote of the Grand Jury for the indictment in the Borden case stood 20 to 1. Before taking the vote the jurors solemnly agreed among themselves that the poll should be secret as far as each member's way of voting was concerned. Nothing was said about the way the vote went, and half an hour after the jury had reported it was well established that only one man was opposed to bringing in an indictment. The members of the Grand Jury, having been dismissed for the year, are talking. They are not telling the whole story all at once, but each man adds his mite, and the new evidence that so impressed the jury as to leave only one in doubt of Lizzie Borden's guilt is gradually becoming known.
In speaking to a friend of his experience at the hearing one juror solemnly asserted, "They'll hang her, sure." Others are more conservative in summing up the case, but it is evident that every one of the twenty-one men was strongly impressed with the weight of the government's evidence, and all, except one, of the lot are positive that the defendant is guilty. One juror states that the case could not have had a more complete hearing at a trial in open court. The defence might have something back, but all the evidence for the defence which was regarded as valuable was presented, and in spite of it the outlook for the prisoner looked absolutely hopeless.
No member of the grand jury can be found who expresses any fear of personal damage because of the part he has taken in the Borden case. There has been some wild talk by irresponsible people, but they have confined this talk to listeners whom they had reason to regard as friendly. Whatever may have been the real cause for the delay, it is certain that the worst piece of evidence against Miss Borden had nothing to do with it. This came from a witness for the defence, and was as much a surprise to the government as it was to the members of the jury.
That Lizzie Borden should have informed Miss Russell of the burning of the dress or allowed her to see it burned constitutes the first piece of weakness to be found in her conduct during the whole affair. Prof. Wood found no trace of blood on either the head or the piece of handle which was left in it, but he did find that the hatchet had been carefully washed and cleaned with ashes. No hint has been drawn from any juror that any indictments were brought against persons suspected of being accomplices in the crimes.
A Taunton dispatch says the government is slow to arraign her, believing her insane, and makes public the story of the dress: days after the murders Lizzie came in with one, said ‘They are making so much fuss over things about here’, and burned it in the kitchen fire as an old dress with paint on it. The dress would be central to the state’s case at the trial.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 30 December 1892 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
WHY LIZZIE BURNED THE DRESS.
She Said She Did It to Avoid a Fuss— The Delayed Borden Trial.
See moreSee less
A Taunton dispatch to a Boston paper says there is no intimation yet in regard to the time of arraigning Miss Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother. It is asserted that the government is in no hurry to have the case presented, because of a belief that the woman is insane, or if not so now, that she will be before the trial. If she is insane the enormous expense of a trial will be avoided and the ends of justice practically attained. If she is placed on trial the only important fact to be explained will be in regard to the dress, and for the first time the details of that affair are now made public. Miss Russell and the two Misses Borden were in a room on the third or fourth day after the murder. Lizzie went out and then came into the room again holding in her hand a dress, which she pointed to, at the same time saying: "They are making so much fuss over things about here that I guess that I will burn this. It is an old dress upon which I spilled some red paint," she passed out into the kitchen and put the dress into the fire. When the officers in their search found a piece of this dress in the ashes, they sought to learn what it meant, and it was for this reason that the New Bedford purchase was so closely examined into. Miss Russell said nothing about this matter at the first hearing, nor did Emma Borden but when Miss Russell was asked point blank in regard to the occurrence the day before the grand jury reported, she told the story. Bridget Sullivan was shown the piece and said that Lizzie wore a dress like that on the morning of the murder. Emma said, in explanatian of the affair, that it was a general custom in the family to burn up their clothes when they were of no further use.
The Fall River News answers the dress story point by point: Bridget Sullivan testified she did not know which dress Lizzie wore that morning, the dress was not burned until the Sunday after the murders, and Miss Russell never said the paint was red. It adds that Lizzie’s Christmas in jail was not lonely: Emma and Lawyer Jennings visited, and presents were sent.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 6 January 1893 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
MORE BORDEN YARNS DENIED.
The Fall River News Gives a Different Account of the Prisoner's Christmas.
See moreSee less
In relation to the story recently published concerning Lizzie Borden's burned dress, the Fall River News said last night: "As Bridget Sullivan testified at the preliminary hearing that she did not know what dress Miss Borden wore the morning of the murders, as the police only fonnd in the stove the remains of some charred paper which are easily accounted for, as the dress was not burned until the Sunday after the murders, and as the fact of its burning was unknown to the district attorney or the police until after the 10-days' adjournment of the grand jury last month, and as Miss Russell did not say "red" paint, although a juryman put the question as to that color to draw her out, the real value of this 'true story now published for the first time' can be easily estimated by any person of common sense."
The News also says regarding the stories concerning the prisoner's Christmas: "The dispatch which reported a cheerless, lonely Christmas for Lizzie A. Borden was an error. On Sunday, as usual on the Sabbath, no visitors were allowed to see her, although one called; 'but on Monday Miss Borden was visited by Lawyer Jennings, Miss Emma L. Borden, and perhaps others, while a number of presents were sent to her. Before the end of last week she had begun to receive these tokens of kindly remembrance. Her sister visited her Friday afternoon, bearing presents."
Michael Snow, a cotton spinner known as ‘Mike the Soldier’, has been found in Fall River. He is supposed to be the ‘wild-eyed man’ Dr. Handy said he saw near the Borden house on the day of the murders; Snow says he was in town that day but left soon after. The Fall River Daily Globe promises new evidence and another sensation.
The Times · Richmond, Va.
The Times · 12 January 1893 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
DR. HANDY'S "WILD-EYED MAN."
Discovery of One Who is Thought to Know About the Borden Murders.
See moreSee less
FALL RIVER, MASS., Jan. 11.—Important developments are promised in the Lizzie Borden case.
Michael Snow, a cotton spinner, known as "Mike the Soldier," who has been sought all over New England, has been located in Fall River. He is supposed to be the "wild-eyed man" whom Dr. Handy said he saw on the day of the murders near the Borden house.
Snow says he was in town on the day of the murders, but left soon after and returned here last Friday.
In regard to the present status of the case, the Fall River Daily Globe says: "There have been new developments in the Borden case within the last five days. They are of such an important nature that Marshal Hilliard and District Attorney Knowlton have been in long and earnest consultation. Last Friday the Marshal left New Bedford on the noon train and returned at night, but remained but a short time. He disappeared again Friday night and has not been seen at the office since. The officers refuse to tell where the Marshal is at the present time, and they do not know when he will return.
"The district attorney was called upon by Marshal Hilliard because of the newly-discovered evidence in the case. The evidence will soon be given to the public, which promises to add another sensation to the great murder mystery."
Nine months after the murders, and as quietly as the authorities could manage, Lizzie Borden is arraigned in the Superior Court at New Bedford. The clerk reads three indictments of two counts each, for each murder and for both together, and after each she answers ‘I am not guilty.’ Then she is taken back to Taunton jail, where she has been since August, to await trial.
The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.
The Record-Union · 9 May 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
LIZZIE BORDEN ARRAIGNED
On Three Charges of Murder—She Pleads Not Guilty.
See moreSee less
NEW BEDFORD (Mass.), May 8.—Lizzie Andrew Borden, who has been an inmate of the Taunton Jail ever since August last, under indictment for the murder on August 4th, in Fall River, of her father, Andrew Jackson Borden, and her stepmother, Abbie Durfee Borden, was arraigned this afternoon in the Superior Court of this city. The authorities sought to keep the arraignment quiet, and preserved the utmost secrecy. However great has been her mental sufferings during her imprisonment, she carried no outward sign of them.
When the ripple of excitement which marked her entrance into court had subsided the District Attorney moved that Miss Borden be arraigned, and the Clerk of Court read slowly and solomnly three indictments of two counts each. Two of them charged her with the murder of Andrew J. Borden and Abbie Durfee Borden, separately, and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end of each indictment she replied clearly, calmly and steadily: "I am not guilty." The court then adjourned and Miss Borden was taken back to Taunton, where she will be imprisoned till the trial.
Mrs. Mary A. Livermore, who knew her as a Sunday-school girl, visits Lizzie Borden in Taunton jail and tells the Boston Post what she said. On her stolidity: ‘What would they have me do?’ On her stepmother: ‘the best step-mother I ever heard of’. On the crime, she asks why she would have chosen noonday, with Bridget washing windows and her uncle likely back at any time, over the night.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 May 1893 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image
A TALK WITH LIZZIE BORDEN.
Mrs Mary A. Livermore Visits Her In Taunton Jail.
See moreSee less
Mrs Mary A. Livermore, who knew Lizzie Borden as a girl in Sunday-school at Fall River years ago, and who has corresponded with the prisoner regularly of late, recently visited her in Taunton jail. She told the story of her call to a reporter of the Boston Post, and here it is: "I found Lizzie in the matron's room, which is pleasant and prettily furnished, and where she is as comforable as she can be under the circumstances. Lizzie is of larger build than her sister, with blue eyes and lighter hair. All the pictures I have seen have been caricatures of her. She has really a refined and intelligent face, though she is not pretty and probably about 30. Her sister must be about a dozen years older. Emma looks like the Bordens, but Lizzie neither looks like her father or mother. She talked to me freely of the whole case, but very calmly and sadly. The comments on her stolidity are absurd. You can see that the girl feels her position keenly. She has changed little since her imprisonment. She has not grown thin, but is pale from the long confinement within doors. Her cough troubles her a great deal and she is quite hoarse. She begged me to stay longer, but I felt that it was taxing her strength too much to talk with her more.
"When I saw the girl and talked with her, face to face, it seemed incredible that she could be the Lizzie Borden of the newspapers. I have corresponded with her all through these months of waiting for the trial, but this was my first sight of her since early youth. 'Do you know,' I said to her, 'I want to go down stairs into some cell to find the woman charged with the murder of her parents, because I cannot believe it is you?' 'Unfortunately I am that woman!' she replied sadly. Then I spoke of the comments on her stolid indifference. 'What would they have me do?' she asked, sadly. 'Howl? Go into hysterics? I am wrongly accused of two horrible crimes. I know it is useless to cry out in indignation at the outrage, and so I am trying hard to keep calm and self-controled until I shall be proved innocent.
"'What hurts me most,' she said again, 'is the malignant feeling that has been shown. I have done no harm to any one. Is my character of 30 years to count for nothing—nothing—because I am accused of so terrible a crime?' Lizzie spoke of her step-mother throughout as 'mother.' 'She was the best step-mother I ever heard of,' she told me; 'she never spoke or acted unkindly to either of us in all the years. She married my father when I was three years old, and she always seemed like my own mother.'
"She admitted that the Borden family was 'close' when I referred to some incidents between her Aunt Abby and her father, but not that her father was hard. 'He was never hard to me. He was close in money matters, but I never asked him for anything that I wanted very much that I didn't get it, though sometimes I had to ask two or three times. And then if I wanted anything that I didn't care to ask of father, I would go to mother, and she would always see that he humored me.'
"In reference to the crime, she told me of her discovery of her father: 'I had covered him up and fixed his pillow and cared for him but half an hour before, and when I opened the door of the sitting-room the first that I saw was the blood pouring down the side of his head as he lay. I do not know what I thought first—that he was dead, that some one had killed my father. I did not think of my mother at all.' Then she grew more excited and spoke of the crime itself. 'How can they think me guilty? What a fool must I have been if I committed a crime like that in broad daylight, with the certainty of detection, with people going to and fro on the street, with Bridget washing windows and likely to come in for water at any minute; with my uncle visiting us and likely to be back at any time, with the curtains up and the neighbors astir? I knew every foot of that house. I could have walked all over it in the dark, sure of my way. Why, if I contemplated that crime, should I not have done it at night? Two blows as they lay asleep, no noise, no stir; I could have opened wide the street door, made evidence of a struggle in the room, and then with plenty of time to remove from myself all traces of the blood, gone quietly to bed. But they say that I committed both crimes at noonday and removed from myself all evidence of the horrible work. How can they believe that?'"
Days before the trial, a Providence editorial reports another killing: Bertha Manchester, a milkman’s daughter left alone at home in the suburbs of Fall River, found murdered on the floor, and ‘a hatchet, as in the Borden case, was used to commit the crime’. The paper blames the law’s delay and loose police methods. At the trial, the Tribune would write that the police were on trial too.
The Providence News · Providence, R.I.
The Providence News · 31 May 1893 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
FALL RIVER'S LATEST CRIME.
The law's delay in the Borden case seems to have been provocative to some extent at least of another brutal murder. Yesterday afternoon while the district attorney was in consultation over details in the prosecution of Lizzie Borden, the news came to him that another crime was awaiting his attention. The crime of yesterday was the murder of Miss Bertha Manchester, daughter of a milkman living on a lonely road in the suburbs of Fall River. The girl had been left alone in the house while her father and brother were attending to the duties of their occupation. On their return she was found lying murdered upon the floor. Curiously enough, a hatchet, as in the Borden case, was used to commit the crime.
See moreSee less
At the present writing no clue seems to have been left behind by the murderer, and if the same loose methods of police examination are employed that characterized the Borden case the affair will remain shrouded in mystery.
The long delay in the Borden case in bringing the perpetrator of that crime to punishment has had its effect by leading to the supposition that criminals in that county, more than elsewhere in the state, have better chances for doing their evil work in safety.
The law to be effective as a preventive to crime must be enforced promptly. Punishment must follow crime or the fear of would-be criminals of its terrors is so far lessened as to become nil.
Within a fortnight a report has come from Fall River that efforts are being made to induce the nol prossing of cases against a man who fourteen years ago embezzled a large amount from one of the mills there, on the ground that he has spent years in "exile" in Canada and is now an old man. His guilt is admitted, his crime was a most serious one, for he was a man who stood high in the community, whose social connections were of the best, and who, because of his high standing was all the more trusted.
Under such circumstances, is it any wonder that a general belief exists that under certain conditions the laws may be violated with impunity? There is something lacking in the administration of justice in Fall River, and to an unprejudiced person that something appears to be either competency or a willingness to enforce the laws.
It may be a matter only of coincidence that such circumstances exist in Fall River, but if so the coincidence is most unfortunate for Fall River.