The last pleas for and against her
On the day of argument ex-Governor Robinson told the jury she was physically unable to do the deed, that there was no direct evidence, and that Bridget too had heard of the note from Mrs. Borden. Spectators were disappointed. District Attorney Knowlton then began: ‘The woman we are trying is a Christian.’ But the hate was aimed at the stepmother, he said, and there never was a note.
The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.
The Helena Independent · 20 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
PLEADING FOR HER LIFE.
Ex-Gov. Robinson Opens for the Defense in the Borden Murder Trial.
See moreSee less
His Argument Was Something of a Disappointment to the Spectators.
Court Adjourns Before the Prosecuting Officer Is Through Presenting His Side of the Case.
NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 19.—The day of argument in the Lizzie Borden trial opened with a great crowd at the court house, scarcely one-tenth of whom could gain admission. A large proportion of those in attendance were fashionable ladies in holiday attire. The defendant appeared fresh and smiling. Ex-Gov. Robinson opened the proceedings with an argument for the defense. He began by declaring the defendant physically unable to commit the crime in the manner it was done. He claimed that aside from that it was only possible for a maniac or devil to do it. He asked the jury to bring their homes, their hearts and their intellects into the decision of the case. Gov. Robinson then rehearsed chronologically the events connected with the crime. He saw no reason to connect a confederate of the defendant with it. There was no direct evidence whatever against Miss Borden, he said, and no knowledge of the use of the weapon had been shown. The evidence showed that the defendant did not know where the alleged weapon was kept. Lizzie Borden was at home the morning the murders were committed, and if she had gone upstairs and looked under the bed she might have seen the body of her stepmother. Both Lizzie and Bridget tell about the note which called Mrs. Borden out, and both were told of it by Mrs. Borden. Lizzie said she had been in the barn twenty minutes. An ice cream peddler who knew Bridget went by and saw the woman, but not Bridget, walking to the house from the barn.
A five minutes' recess was here taken and the address was discussed freely by the spectators, much disappointment being expressed about it. Bridget, said the ex-governor after the recess, when she heard Borden was dead, said she would go to Mrs. Whitehead's and tell Mrs. Borden, if she was there. That corroborates the note theory. Bridget Sullivan, who for two years had been closer to the family than any one else, never heard a quarrel between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden. The speaker then related the fact of the alleged bloodstained dress and the burning of it. "If Lizzie Borden killed her stepmother at 9:45," he said, "did she come down and greet her father in the bloodstained dress? She must have changed her clothing and changed it again after the second slaughter. Lizzie did not try to get Bridget out of the house. Don't you think she would have sent her on some errand?" The attorney pointed out that the doctors disagreed as to what had been used to kill the Bordens and touched upon the claw-headed hatchet and the hatchet without a handle. If those were not the implements with which the murder was committed, where are they? The exclusive opportunity theory was simply an anticipation that would be realized. Anybody could have gotten into the house by simply avoiding Bridget on the outside and Lizzie on the inside. The lawyer held that the young man seen in the vicinity was an outside spy for the person committing the deed, and that the job was not done by one person. A dinner recess was taken and the ex-governor resumed when court reassembled. If there had been any blood on the defendants' hair, he said, those who were bathing her face would have discovered it.
It was three o'clock when the ex-governor closed and District Attorney Knowlton began to sum up for the prosecution. Knowlton said: "However we may differ, we can agree that this is a most heartrending case. The woman we are trying is a Christian. It is hard to consider this woman guilty of such a crime, but the greatest criminals of the world have been women and we must face this case as men. No one who has told of it saw Lizzie Borden burn that dress. While Borden was down at the bank that morning the assassin met Mrs. Borden and killed her. It was against her the hate was directed. There was one woman in the world who believed the old woman stood between her father and herself. There was nothing in these blows but hatred, and a great strong man with one blow only, would have made an end of it." The speaker reviewed the movements of the family on the morning of the tragedy and said up to the time the murder was committed there was no opportunity for the assassin to come in. When that 200-pound woman fell it must have been heard by whoever was in the house. If Lizzie was down stairs she was in the passageway of the murderer; if she was up stairs she could not have helped hearing. She was alone in the house with the murdered woman and knew that by and by there was coming into the house a stern, just man, who would have noticed the absence of his beloved wife. He came in and she said to him: "Mother has received a note and has gone out." But there was no note; there never was any one sick and the note story originated with Lizzie Borden. Bridget Sullivan said she first heard of it from what Lizzie said.
Court adjourned with Knowlton's arguments not finished.
Felix Borden has been located here. Young Borden says he knew Lizzie's father only by sight and reputation and if he told Mrs. Ramsey at Baltimore that Lizzie committed the murders his opinion was formed on newspaper reports and not from any knowledge of Lizzie's character. He could not remember either just where he was at the time of the murders, because he was then in the circus business and it kept him traveling most of the time, but he had an idea that he was in Providence.