As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · As the Papers Told It

Act Six

Not Guilty

20–25 June 1893

After the closing arguments Lizzie Borden was offered the chance to speak. She said she was innocent and left the rest to her counsel, and the jury acquitted her on a single ballot. Within days the papers had turned on the prosecution and the Fall River police, and letters were arriving at the house on Second Street by the hundred. One paper asked the question the verdict left: if not Lizzie, then who?

The last pleas for and against her

On the day of argument ex-Governor Robinson told the jury she was physically unable to do the deed, that there was no direct evidence, and that Bridget too had heard of the note from Mrs. Borden. Spectators were disappointed. District Attorney Knowlton then began: ‘The woman we are trying is a Christian.’ But the hate was aimed at the stepmother, he said, and there never was a note.

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

The Helena Independent · 20 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

PLEADING FOR HER LIFE.

Ex-Gov. Robinson Opens for the Defense in the Borden Murder Trial.

See moreSee less

His Argument Was Something of a Disappointment to the Spectators.

Court Adjourns Before the Prosecuting Officer Is Through Presenting His Side of the Case.

NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 19.—The day of argument in the Lizzie Borden trial opened with a great crowd at the court house, scarcely one-tenth of whom could gain admission. A large proportion of those in attendance were fashionable ladies in holiday attire. The defendant appeared fresh and smiling. Ex-Gov. Robinson opened the proceedings with an argument for the defense. He began by declaring the defendant physically unable to commit the crime in the manner it was done. He claimed that aside from that it was only possible for a maniac or devil to do it. He asked the jury to bring their homes, their hearts and their intellects into the decision of the case. Gov. Robinson then rehearsed chronologically the events connected with the crime. He saw no reason to connect a confederate of the defendant with it. There was no direct evidence whatever against Miss Borden, he said, and no knowledge of the use of the weapon had been shown. The evidence showed that the defendant did not know where the alleged weapon was kept. Lizzie Borden was at home the morning the murders were committed, and if she had gone upstairs and looked under the bed she might have seen the body of her stepmother. Both Lizzie and Bridget tell about the note which called Mrs. Borden out, and both were told of it by Mrs. Borden. Lizzie said she had been in the barn twenty minutes. An ice cream peddler who knew Bridget went by and saw the woman, but not Bridget, walking to the house from the barn.

A five minutes' recess was here taken and the address was discussed freely by the spectators, much disappointment being expressed about it. Bridget, said the ex-governor after the recess, when she heard Borden was dead, said she would go to Mrs. Whitehead's and tell Mrs. Borden, if she was there. That corroborates the note theory. Bridget Sullivan, who for two years had been closer to the family than any one else, never heard a quarrel between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden. The speaker then related the fact of the alleged bloodstained dress and the burning of it. "If Lizzie Borden killed her stepmother at 9:45," he said, "did she come down and greet her father in the bloodstained dress? She must have changed her clothing and changed it again after the second slaughter. Lizzie did not try to get Bridget out of the house. Don't you think she would have sent her on some errand?" The attorney pointed out that the doctors disagreed as to what had been used to kill the Bordens and touched upon the claw-headed hatchet and the hatchet without a handle. If those were not the implements with which the murder was committed, where are they? The exclusive opportunity theory was simply an anticipation that would be realized. Anybody could have gotten into the house by simply avoiding Bridget on the outside and Lizzie on the inside. The lawyer held that the young man seen in the vicinity was an outside spy for the person committing the deed, and that the job was not done by one person. A dinner recess was taken and the ex-governor resumed when court reassembled. If there had been any blood on the defendants' hair, he said, those who were bathing her face would have discovered it.

It was three o'clock when the ex-governor closed and District Attorney Knowlton began to sum up for the prosecution. Knowlton said: "However we may differ, we can agree that this is a most heartrending case. The woman we are trying is a Christian. It is hard to consider this woman guilty of such a crime, but the greatest criminals of the world have been women and we must face this case as men. No one who has told of it saw Lizzie Borden burn that dress. While Borden was down at the bank that morning the assassin met Mrs. Borden and killed her. It was against her the hate was directed. There was one woman in the world who believed the old woman stood between her father and herself. There was nothing in these blows but hatred, and a great strong man with one blow only, would have made an end of it." The speaker reviewed the movements of the family on the morning of the tragedy and said up to the time the murder was committed there was no opportunity for the assassin to come in. When that 200-pound woman fell it must have been heard by whoever was in the house. If Lizzie was down stairs she was in the passageway of the murderer; if she was up stairs she could not have helped hearing. She was alone in the house with the murdered woman and knew that by and by there was coming into the house a stern, just man, who would have noticed the absence of his beloved wife. He came in and she said to him: "Mother has received a note and has gone out." But there was no note; there never was any one sick and the note story originated with Lizzie Borden. Bridget Sullivan said she first heard of it from what Lizzie said.

Court adjourned with Knowlton's arguments not finished.

Felix Borden has been located here. Young Borden says he knew Lizzie's father only by sight and reputation and if he told Mrs. Ramsey at Baltimore that Lizzie committed the murders his opinion was formed on newspaper reports and not from any knowledge of Lizzie's character. He could not remember either just where he was at the time of the murders, because he was then in the circus business and it kept him traveling most of the time, but he had an idea that he was in Providence.

See the clipping

Not guilty, on one ballot

The Pawtucket Tribune on the last day. Offered a chance to take the stand, she rose, said she was innocent, and added ‘I will leave it to my counsel to speak for me.’ After Judge Dewey’s charge the jury needed scarcely an hour, this paper says. At the words ‘Not Guilty’ she sank into her chair, the courtroom broke into applause, and the jurors lined up to shake her hand.

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Pawtucket Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN FREE.

Thrilling Scenes at the Verdict of Not Guilty.

See moreSee less

ONLY ONE BALLOT TAKEN.

The Defendant Bore up Bravely Under the Trying Ordeal.

NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 21.—Lizzie Borden is a free woman. Along has swept the current of the great trial to acquittal.

Scarcely an hour was required for the 12 men, "good and true," to return the verdict of not guilty.

The ending was worthy of the greatest murder tribunal of the century.

So sudden a decision was entirely unexpected, and many who were off their guard and had temporarily left the court house lost it altogether.

Judge Dewey uttered the last words of his charge as the big clock indicated 3:12 o'clock, and in 12 minutes more the jury was given notice to retire.

The trusty 12 filed out at 3:25 o'clock, and everybody settled down for a long wait that might reach through the watches of the night.

An hour of insufferable heat passed by and the hands on the dial had begun a second revolution when, suddenly, there was a little stir, as if a misplaced breeze had strayed into the courtroom. Several people who had been in the lower rooms bobbed upstairs in an unconcerned sort of way and word was passed that the jury had struck a snag and was about to ask the court for instructions.

In a minute more the three judges were in their seats, and then followed the jury with a fixed look upon their faces. Every newspaper man was alert, for the reassembling had but one meaning.

MISS LIZZIE BORDEN

"Lizzie Andrew Borden, stand up," said the clerk; "raise your right hand."

The defendant obeyed without a tremor.

"Have you agreed upon a verdict, gentlemen?" said the man of records.

"We have," said the foreman.

"He shall speak for us," said the others.

"What say you, Mr. Foreman, is the prisoner at the bar guilty or not guilty?"

"Not Guilty."

Miss Borden dropped in her chair as the last word was uttered and buried her face in her arms, as they rested on the front railing of the prisoners' dock. She had not fainted as at first supposed and reported, but was in that precious state of mind where tears and silent joy struggle for supremacy.

No Voice Was Heard, but as she dropped in her chair came a great clapping of hands that almost made the old courthouse tremble.

The defendant, however, was lost to all that took place about her, and remained with her head upon her hands until friends about raised her up to listen to the words giving her formal release.

No tears stood in her eyes, but as she sat down she took her handkerchief and brushed away those just rising to the surface.

Even as she had fallen, Andrew Jenkins had reached out for one of her hands and stood wringing it as she lay with her head downward.

Then came Judge Mason's thanks to the jury, and a second after the trusty 12 stood in a line waiting to shake the ex-defendant's hand.

Ex-Governor Robinson stood on one side and Mr. Jennings on the other, supporting Miss Borden, and if ever hands were sincerely shaken it was by the woman who had received the gift of life when death lay so handily at their disposal.

Miss Borden's Face was very red, and by this time tears coursed down her cheeks, but she had words for everyone, despite joy's intoxication. Everybody wanted to shake hands with her and few started for the doors, although the deputy sheriffs to right, left and behind them shouted and thundered. When it was seen, however, that it was too much to be asked, the crowd made a break for the front and rear doors that it might give her hearty greeting on departure.

The birds of the air carry the news as well as the wires, and within ten minutes several hundred people stood about the courthouse. The greatest crowd gathered at the rear entrance to see Miss Borden make her final exit from the building where for twelve terrible days she had struggled for her life. A great flock of school girls clustered about the doorway, while several artists camped beneath a flowery syringa drew the crowd, leaving a vacant place at the door for the familiar form of she whose victory had been flashed across every sea to anxious millions.

The little one horse coach and colored driver that had 23 times carried her to the jail stood in waiting, but this time the curtains had not been drawn. Finally Deputy Kirby emerged and sprang into the vehicle, but he was alone.

"She's gone out the front way," cried one of the deputies, and the crowd started on the run, only to learn that it had been fooled, and was back again within a minute.

Meantime the crowd waited patiently for Miss Borden. Mr. Knowlton came down the rear steps very unconcernedly smoking, and some of the crowd had a word to say to him, to which he returned the reply, "That's all right."

Suddenly a gay equipage turned around the corner—a new hack, gold-mounted harnesses and lively steeds. "This is the team," said the keen observers, and later Deputy Kirby was seen shrinking back in the corner. During this time Sheriff Wright had been driven to the jail and secured Miss Borden's handbag, which he took to the livery stable, so that her small effects were within the hack.

In a minute the

Heroine of the Hour was in the carriage with her sister, while Mr. Holmes and Mr. Robinson stood beaming at the steps.

A great crowd gathered about the vehicle, and Miss Borden readily began shaking hands. There were tears, smiles and hearty good wishes sent over that gateway, as more than a hundred elbowed their way forward to extend their greeting.

Finally Mr. Holmes and Mr. Robinson decided to accompany the sisters and entered the deputy's hack, Mr. Kirby taking the driver's place on the box. The carriage started westward down the back street in the flood of sunlight of the June afternoon.

The way led to the jail, but they were not going thither, but to Fall River.

Lizzie Borden had begun a distinct existence; she was being rolled away into a new life. The whole world was watching that afternoon journey and was saying: "Probably never will the real truth of the Borden tragedy be known." The scenes about the courthouse were as striking as might have been expected.

Mr. Jennings Happy.

It's a question if Andrew J. Jennings wasn't happier than Lizzie Borden, and there was a glad light in ex-Governor Robinson's eyes. Miss Borden seemed yesterday to lean greatly upon Charles J. Holmes, who stood nearest her at the great climax when life and death hung on a single word

Miss Borden's Future Plans.

Nobody knows what Miss Borden's plans are, but it is supposed that she will eventually begin life over again in Fall River after seeking protracted rest in some quiet spot.

When the afternoon session opened the defendant was given an opportunity to take the stand. She promptly stood up and leaning toward the jury said: "I am innocent. I will leave it to my counsel to speak for me." Her face was somewhat flushed as she took her seat, but she was far from being disconcerted.

This had, in fact, been her strongest day. She scarcely shaded her eyes from start to finish, leaning her head upon the railing behind her and looking far away toward the ceiling, when her eyes were not riveted upon the man who was making his greatest professional effort to deprive her of life.

Mr. Knowlton's Argument was of a high order, his points generally well taken, his style dramatic and his earnestness rare. For more than five hours of broiling temperature he held close attention and few forlorn hopes were ever better led. His work in the case will do much to enhance his reputation, for he grappled with an unpleasant duty, and found law against him at nearly every point.

See the clipping

The papers judge the prosecution

The Tribune gathers editorial opinion on the acquittal. The Baltimore Sun says the state’s case ‘was not strong enough to hang a dog on’, and the Albany Argus calls the verdict an indictment of the Fall River police and District Attorney Knowlton. The Utica Herald finds the trial entirely fair, and the Providence Journal tells Miss Borden there is no longer any reason for her silence.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

New-York Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

THE ACQUITTAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN.

NO JUSTIFICATION FOR HER TREATMENT. From The Albany Argus.

See moreSee less

What is there in the case made out by the prosecution which should justify the State of Massachusetts in its treatment of Lizzie Borden since her arrest six days after the Fall River tragedy? If a New-England jury, after due deliberation for a little over two hours, returns a verdict of not guilty without any seeming disagreement, if they decide that there were not facts sufficient upon which to find an indictment for murder against the accused, is not their action in itself an Indictment of the intelligence and methods of the Fall River police and District-Attorney Knowlton?

THE INDICTMENT UNWARRANTED. From The Philadelphia Record.

The grievous delay in the trial of the accused, in the light of the disclosures of the trial, is now accounted for. There never was a case so clear as to warrant indictment. Lizzie Borden will go out of court, if she be innocent, the victim of circumstances, suspicions and persecutions for which she can obtain neither redress nor remittance unless the actual murderer shall at some future time be found out. In that hope she must live.

PHENOMENAL FORTITUDE. From The Washington Post.

Assume what theory we may, the fact remains that no woman is of record who ever demeaned herself under similarly trying circumstances with such phenomenal impassibility and unnerved fortitude. Was it a high-born, heroic consciousness of innocence or a stoicism steeled to the menace of fate?

NO JURY COULD HAVE CONVICTED HER. From The Baltimore Sun.

No jury composed of men entitled to be at large could possibly have convicted her on the evidence presented at the trial without being false to their oaths and to their intellects. The case made out by the State was not strong enough to hang a dog on, and the wonder is, not that she was acquitted, but that she should have been subjected to a long imprisonment and a bitter prosecution on the testimony produced before the jury.

A FAIR TRIAL. From The Utica Herald.

Never was a trial conducted more fairly than that of Lizzie Borden. Neither prosecution nor defence omitted any effort to secure the truth, and the trial and its result are satisfactory.

THE EVIDENCE FELL FAR SHORT. From The Boston Herald.

People—and there are a good many of them—who have believed from the first that she was not clear of grave suspicion have been compelled to recognize that the evidence as brought out at the trial fell far short of fixing the crime upon her. The charge of Judge Dewey was practically and logically an instruction to acquit.

LET HER FIND A SOLUTION. From The Providence Journal.

There is no reason now for Miss Borden's silence. Let her speak. And let her also, as we have said, spare no effort to bring this horrible case to a more satisfactory conclusion than it has now reached, after months of investigation by the Government, and floods of eloquence from the defence; with so much evidence barred out by the Court, and the presumption of innocence most strenuously insisted upon by the learned judge who delivered the charge.

AN EXCELLENT JUDICIAL SYSTEM. From The Boston Globe.

There may well be congratulations also for Massachusetts and her people upon the possession of so excellent and so impartial a judicial system as that under which, without delay as without haste, one of the most celebrated cases of the time has been heard and definitely decided.

See the clipping

Home to the house on Second Street

The morning after the verdict Lizzie and Emma Borden, who had spent the night at the Holmes house on Pine Street, drove in a closed carriage to the old home on Second Street; a servant is reported to have said both broke down once inside. Congratulations reach Mr. Jennings from across the country, and ‘The temper of the people of the city has changed greatly by the verdict’.

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The Times · 22 June 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN AT HOME.

With Her Sister Emma, She Returns to the Blighted Hearthstone.

See moreSee less

FALL RIVER, MASS., June 21.—Lizzie Borden returned with her sister this morning to her home on Second street, after having spent the night at Mr. Chas. B. Holmes' residence, on Pine street. They drove up to the gate in a closed carriage, and their entrance was most painful to witness. There were very few spectators, for the crowds of last night knew nothing of the hour when the long imprisoned girl would return. They denied themselves to all newspaper men, in accordance with the suggestions of their counsel. The sofa on which Mr. Borden laid when he was murdered, is at the Central police-station, and will not be removed for a day or two. Miss Lizzie spent a very pleasant night, and was very cheerful at breakfast in the Holmes' residence.

This morning a domestic in the family house, on Second street, is reported to have said that the two girls broke down completely when they had entered their old home. To-day Andrew J. Jennings is receiving letters and telegrams of congratulation from all parts of the country, and Miss Borden's mail at the postoffice is very heavy. The temper of the people of the city has changed greatly by the verdict, and there is a manifest respect for the decision of the jury.

See the clipping

Two hundred letters in one morning

A Sun dispatch from Fall River: at least 200 letters were carried to Lizzie Borden’s home in a single morning, many from Christian Endeavor members across the country. The sisters have not gone out, but receive callers. Marshal Hilliard, meanwhile, has been sent a large leather medal, and she is reported to have had an offer to appear in a museum at a very heavy salary.

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The Sun · 24 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN'S LARGE MAIL. Marshal Hilliard Not Forgotten, Either—A Leather Medal Sent to Him. FALL RIVER, June 23.—Lizzie Borden's daily mail is. something extraordinary. At least 200 letters were taken to her home this morning by the man who resides in the house. He makes frequent visits to the Post Office during the day. Many of the letters come from members of the Christian Endeavor and W. C. T. U. societies throughout the country. nearly all of the large cities being represented. The girls have not stirred out since their arrival home.

See moreSee less

but are kept very busy receiving callers. Marshal Hilliard and Mayor Coughlin are receiving some astonishing letters. Among the curiosities the Marshal has received is a large leather medal. It is reported to-day that Miss Borden has received an offer to appear in a museum at a very heavy salary. This offer came in her mail. just as the offer came to Capt. Philip Harrington to accept a place in a millinery establishment at the rate of $5.000 per year.

See the clipping

If not Lizzie, then who?

A Fall River special to the Providence Journal spells out what the verdict requires: a stranger who sent Mrs. Borden a note, hid in the house, killed her, waited an hour or more for her husband, and left unseen with the axe and the note. Ten months of clues pointing one way must be discarded. In the New York World’s special, Mr. Jennings says the sisters ‘will leave no stone unturned’ to find the murderers.

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Richmond Dispatch · 25 June 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

WHERE IS THE ASSASSIN?

There Is Mystifying Work Ahead for the Fall River Police.

See moreSee less

Now that it has been proved to the satisfaction of twelve men that a mistake was committed and that Miss Lizzie Borden did not butcher her father and stepmother, as alleged, says a Fall River special to the Providence Journal, the crime is thrown back to the afternoon of August 4, 1892, when the police were scouring the country for the murderer. Nothing remains except the fact that Mr. and Mrs. Borden were slain in cold blood, and the community is still saddled with a tragedy that remains unexplained. Opinions, whether changed or unchanged by the decision reached, no longer count. The accused has been removed from consideration.

It is now necessary to pursue an entirely new line. No member of the family took the lives of the aged couple, and an assassin must be found, or it must be said of Fall River that a fiend can kill there as he pleases and escape punishment. The work of the authorities has just begun. The investigation which has been pursued and the mass of evidence which has been collected are worthless. Every clue which has been pointing in one direction for ten exciting months must be discarded.

FOLLOWING THE MURDER.

From a legal standpoint, if from no other, it is plain that some monster did just what it has been claimed no monster could do. He sent a note to Mrs. Borden on the morning of August 4th and stole into the house on Second street. He entered by the front door, which was double locked, or through the side door, which was hooked, or by means of the chimney. It matters not how he entered so long as it has been demonstrated that he got in and accomplished his unholy undertaking. He concealed himself somewhere on the premises. The world knows that he was not seen there and that he has not been seen since. Perhaps he secreted himself in the cellar or in a clothes-press on the second floor, or in the attic; it doesn't matter where. He finds that his note has not accomplished his purpose, and, being discovered, strikes down Mrs. Borden.

AN OLD STORY WITH A NEW CHARACTER.

It is the old story, but a new character is playing the part of the villain, and circumstances must be made to fit his convenience. He is not detected, and he waits an hour or an hour and a half until Mr. Borden arrives. It is fair to presume that he does not go to the stable. He follows Miss Lizzie Borden down-stairs if he is hiding in that part of the house, or he waits until she disappears if he is in the basement or on the first floor, and then wields the axe again. He takes himself off noiselessly north, south, east, or west, with the axe and the note in his possession. His motive cannot be imagined. If it were robbery, he lost the nerve which enabled him to endure the strain after the first crime, and fled without helping himself to plunder. If it were revenge, he surely had it.

A DIFFICULT TRAIL TO FOLLOW.

To track him will be difficult. He has nearly a year's start. He has no name and no description of him can be furnished. Nothing short of a miracle will ever reveal his identity. But this is an age of miracles and he may be overtaken. At all events, the above is a shadowy picture of the individual who drove a blade into the skulls of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, and who has never been suspected except for a few hours after the discovery of the frightful deed.

It seems inconceivable that with three people about the premises there could have been more than one such individual. It isn't necessary to double the difficulties of the unsolved problem. But there is no denying that as this perplexing slaughter stands to-night some scoundrel who answers this meagre picture is still at large, and if he keeps his own counsel he is likely to remain at large. It is safe to assert that he cannot be painted in stronger colors. He is a phantom so far as the most brilliant imagination goes. Nobody can set him down as a farm hand, as a sailor, as a tramp, or as a businessman. Who and what he was cannot be determined. Nevertheless, he must be substituted at this late hour in this marvellous case and the interest which once centred elsewhere must henceforth centre in him.

THE SISTERS WILL LEAVE NO STONE UNTURNED.

The New York World's Fall River (Mass.) special says: Lawyer Jennings has no theory which he can sustain with proof as to who did commit the Borden murders. Nevertheless, he says, Miss Borden and her sister will leave no stone unturned to discover, if possible, who the murderers are. The hunt is already on and will continue.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Five: Her Life at Stake