Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
HATCHETS IN EVIDENCE. STATE WITNESSES CONTRADICT EACH OTHER.
CONFLICTING STORIES ABOUT THE WEAPON WITH WHICH THE MURDERS ARE ALLEGED TO HAVE BEEN COMMITTED-LIZZIE BORDEN LIKELY TO TESTIFY.
See moreSee less
[BY TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNE.]
New-Bedford, Mass., June 9.—It was made plain to-day that Marshal Fleet and his assistants had searched the Borden house on that Thursday afternoon with anything but thoroughness. They looked into the clothes closet, where the women of the family kept their dresses. They glanced at the dresses, and felt of them, but did not examine them carefully. They paid little attention to the contents of the numerous trunks. The visit to the cellar, where the hatchet-head was found, was inquired into with especial scrutiny.
"Who was in the cellar when you went down there?" asked Governor Robinson.
The witness said that Officer Mullaly, Officer Devine and Dr. Dolan were there.
Q.—What were they doing? A.—Looking around.
Q.—Did you see the axes and hatchets then? A.—I did.
Q.—Where? A.—They were on the cellar floor.
Governor Robinson picked up the axes and hatchets and inquired if they were the ones he saw. Fleet said they were. "Did you see anything else of this character?" Fleet said he did not.
Q.—Then what did you do? A.—Stayed there a little while, looked around and talked.
Q.—This was the occasion of your second visit to the cellar? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Well, what then did you do? A.—I went out into the yard.
Q.—What, again? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—What for? A.—To hear reports from my men.
Q.—After that did you go into the cellar again? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Who went with you? A.—Nobody.
Q.—Who was there? A.—Some officers were there, but I don't know who.
Q.—Was this the occasion on which you found something else in the way of a hatchet? A.—No, sir.
Q.—Wasn't it? A.—No, sir.
Governor Robinson looked sharply at the witness, and, turning to the table, picked up the hatchet-head, and held it high in view.
"When did you find this, Mr. Fleet?" he asked.
"On the occasion of my second visit," said Fleet.
Governor Robinson paused and looked sharply at him again. "Why didn't you say so when you were describing what you did on that occasion?"
"You did not ask me."
"Yes, I did."
"I did not so understand it."
"Do you understand me now? When did you find this hatchet-head?"
"On the occasion of my second visit." A DRAMATIC EPISODE.
The questions and answers following, which are a verbatim report of the proceedings will be found especially interesting and important as a prelude to one of the most dramatic and sensational situations that have ever occurred in a criminal trial.
Q.—When you saw this hatchet-head, where was it?
A.—In a box.
Q.—In with those hatchets over there, and those axes?
A.—No. They were found at one time and in one place. This I found at a later time and in another place.
Q.—But you say it was in a box. A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—And with other tools, you said? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.-And all covered with dust? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—The room was an ashy, dusty room, wasn't it? A.—There were ashes there, but they were confined to a space of four or five feet.
Q.—Weren't the brickwork and box and everything else covered with ashes? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—It was an ashy old place, wasn't it? A.—Perhaps so.
Q.—It isn't strange, Mr. Fleet, is it, that everything should be covered with ashes when ashes were constantly dumped there? A.—No.
Q.—Who took it out of the box? A.-I did.
Q.—Was anybody else there? A.—Mullaly was there, but I don't know whether he saw me or not.
It is to be noted here that the piece of wood which, when the hatchet-head was found, was fastened into it, being that end of the handle which was held in the iron, has since been taken out, presumably by the State, and for the purpose of chemical and other examinations. The head and this small piece of handle were now on Mr. Robinson's desk, and were constantly being picked up by him and held for the witness's inspection during his further examination.
Q.—When you found it this piece of handle was in the blade, wasn't it? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Who took it out? A.—I don't know.
Q.—Did you? A.—No.
Q.—This was all you found? A.—Yes, sir. Q.—Just th[i]s blade, and this little piece of handle? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—And the iron on both sides was covered with ashy dust? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Was there any dust on the broken wood of the handle here where the break is? A.—It was a new break. I don't think there were ashes on it.
Q.—What did you do with it after you had looked at it? A.—I put it back in the box.
Q.—The box you found it in? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Did Mullaly see you do it? A.—I dare say he did.
Q.—Did you go off and leave it there? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—You didn't do anything with it at all? A.—No, sir.
WAS IT THE ASSASSIN'S WEAPON?
The relation of this hatchet-head to the crime up to this point in the trial is simply that the length of the blade is identical with the length of the wounds on the bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, though as that fact is only asserted, not proved, presumably the State will hereafter introduce the evidence of Professor Woods, of Harvard, to prove that fresh blood had been on it before it was covered with ashes. The reader of this dispatch will, however, when he has read it through, know as much about this hatchet as the jury yet does.
Two other hatchets, one with a long blade and claw-head, the other ordinary in size and shape, and both supplied with handles, and two axes, have been exhibited in the case. Thus far absolutely nothing has been said to show that the axes and the hatchet of ordinary size and shape had anything to do with the case. The claw-headed, long-bladed hatchet, however, when found by the officers was seen to have a red mark on the handle and a large rusty spot on one side of the blade. To these facts Fleet testified yesterday. Laying down the hatchet-head, and picking up the claw-headed hatchet, Mr. Robinson inquired:
Q.—Do you now see the red spot on the handle of this which you said was there when you found it? A.—No, sir; it isn't here now.
Q.—Who took it off? A.—I don't know.
Q.—Who has had possession of it since you found it? A.—I don't know.
Q.—Well, Lizzie Borden hasn't anyhow, has she? A.—No, sir.
Q.—You'll swear to that? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Was it a large or small spot? A.—It was a good-sized spot.
Q.—Dirt and blood? A.—I couldn't say.
Q.—Or paint? A.—It might have been blood or paint.
Q.—You saw a rusty spot on the blade too, didn't you? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Look at the blade now. Is it still there? A.—It does not seem to be there.
Q.—You were able to find it then? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—But you can't find it now? A.—No, sir.
Q.—Who took it off? A.—I don't know.
Q.—Did you? A.—I did not.
Q.—And neither did Lizzie Borden, did she? A.—I think not.
Q.—She couldn't have done it, could she? A.—No, sir.
Q.—What did you do with all these four axes and hatchets when you found them? A.—I put back the two axes and this hatchet (indicating the hatchet of ordinary size and shape with a handle) where I found them. This hatchet (indicating the claw-headed one, on the blade of which there had been a rusty spot, and on the handle of which there had been a red mark) I laid aside.
This evidently was the point Mr. Robinson had been desirous of bringing out. He put down the claw-headed hatchet and again took up the hatchet-head and the little piece of wood belonging to it.
Q.—This hatchet-head was all covered with dust when you found it? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Both sides? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—And there was dust also on the broken wood, wasn't there—in the break, I mean. A.—No, sir.
Q.—How's that? A.—There was no dust in the break. It looked like a new break.
Q.—But didn't you testify yesterday that there was dust in the break? A.—I think not.
Q.—If you did, was it true? A.—It looked like a new break.
Q.—I didn't ask you that. Listen, and I will read the stenographer's report of what you said yesterday. (Reading.) "There were ashes all over the hatchet, or, may be, dust, but it looked like fine ashes, and there was dust or ashes on the wood in the break." Did you say that? A.—I may have.
FLEET CONTRADICTS HIMSELF.
Q.—Well, what is the truth about it? Did you tell the truth then, or do you tell it now? A.—Well, I think—— (pausing).
Q.—Come, now, take your pick; have it either way; but make a choice. A.—There was no ashes on the break.
Q.—That's your answer, is it? A.—There wasn't much there anyhow.
Q.—Oh, you want to change again, do you? A.—I am answering the best I know.
Q.—Why have you told two different stories about the ashes in this break? A.—I don't know.
Q.—Are both true? A.—They can't be.
Q.—Now, try again. Did you see any ashes on this wood in the break? A.—I don't remember about it.
Q.—You put the hatchet-head back in the box? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—When did you next see it? A.—In Taunton.
Q.—Mr. Fleet, you testified at the preliminary examination in this case, didn't you? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—In your testimony then, did you say a word about this handleless hatchet? A.—No, sir.
Q.—Not a word? A.—No, sir.
Q.—Did anybody tell you not to? A.—No, sir.
Q.—You told about finding the two axes and the two hatchets with handles, didn't you? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—And when you were asked if you found anything else, you said you didn't. Isn't that correct? A.—I said I failed to find anything.
Q.—But you had found this hatchet-head, hadn't you? A.—Yes, sir. Q.—Why didn't you tell them so? A.—Well, I hadn't taken it away.
Q.—Why didn't you take it away? A.—Because I didn't think it important.
Q.—The thing you thought important was the claw-headed hatchet with the rust on the blade and the red mark on the handle, wasn't it? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—And this poor little thing you didn't consider of any account, did you? A.—No, sir.
This completed the examination of Marshal Fleet. It had not ended well for the prosecution. The defence had shown that he had a bad memory; that his search of the house after the murders had been extremely superficial, and that it had not been adequately guarded. They had shown, too, that he was testifying to several things, all extremely important, which in his earlier testimony he had not mentioned. But the incident most destructive of the value of Fleet's evidence was yet to come. It was a complete surprise to Court and counsel.
A SURPRISE TO COURT AND COUNSEL.
Officer Harrington succeeded the marshal on the stand. Harrington is now a captain of the Fall River police. He has been promoted since the Borden murders. So has Fleet, and so have two or three others of the policemen who were engaged in "ferreting out" the Borden mystery. It might have been better, perhaps, had the promoting power awaited the result of this trial before distributing its favors so generously. Officer Harrington was a somewhat la-de-dah young man for a policeman.
He has an exceedingly glib tongue and a truly marvellous facility for describing feminine costumes.
When he was asked what Lizzie Borden had on, here is what he said. Said it quick, as if he had it by heart; said it, too, without a blush:
LIZZIE BORDEN'S DRESS DESCRIBED.
"She was dressed in a house dress, pink, with a pink and light brown stripe alternating. On the light stripe was a diamond figure. The dress fitted close to the form, almost a tailor-made fit, and was shirred at the neck."
The audience began to titter. Governor Robinson stared through his spectacles at the witness; then glanced anxiously at the Court; then drew his hand over his forehead, as if to see if he couldn't get it in, and then said:
"Dear me, dear me. What's that you say?"
"Why, shirred," said Policeman Harrington, with an expression of pained surprise that he did not seem to be understood. "Shirred, you know,—ah, gathered at the neck, that is," and Mr. Harrington, police captain, guardian of our liberties and lives, put up his hand to his throat and made a gesture as if gathering himself in at that point.
Governor Robinson did his best to follow the witness.
"Ah, yes," he said, "I see," and the Governor put up his hand to his throat, and tried to gather himself in as Mr. Harrington had illustrated. "Is that all?" he asked. "It had a number of bows," said Mr. Harrington, "and on either side was a red ribbon about an inch wide, which was brought around and tied in a bow at the front. It was cut en train, or what is called bell skirt."
HARRINGTON'S PROBABLE INSPIRATION.
They say that over Mr. Harrington's desk in his office at Fall River he has a beautifully embroidered perfumed sachet. Maybe it was out of this that he drew the inspiration which enabled him to give so fine a description of a dress which Lizzie Borden did not wear at that time, and has never either worn or possessed. As a description coming from a police officer, it was a wonderful description, and if such a dress had ever been in existence, it would probably have been a wonderful dress. The dress that Lizzie Borden really wore on that occasion was thus described yesterday by her next door neighbor, Mrs. Churchill:
WHAT SHE REALLY WORE.
"It was a light-blue and white ground, with a dark navy-blue diamond spot in it."
Mrs. Churchill had often seen the dress, and in reply to other questions she said that the skirt and the waist were alike; that it was a blouse waist; that the colors in the groundwork were blended, and that the diamond figure was large and conspicuous. When Harrington had done with his shirrs, his stripes, his en traines and his bell skirts, Governor Robinson quietly inquired: Q.—What was your business before you went on the police force? A.—I was a painter.
Q.—And before that? A.—I was in the boot business.
Q.—Were you ever a dressmaker? A.—No, sir.
Q.—Ever in the dry goods business? A.—No, sir.
Q.—Did you ever have anything to do with colors except when you were in the paint business? A.—No, sir, except to admire them.
The Governor threw a native-born Yankee twang into the tones of his voice, and a queer little squint into his eyes, as he asked:
"And do you admire a red ribbon on a pink waist?"
Except for his description of the dress, Officer Harrington's testimony was not notably different from what was said by the rest. There were, how- ever, some points in the evidence which are worth consideration. He says, for instance, that when he asked Lizzie if she had any idea who could have had a motive to kill her father, she said she didn't know of any, and when he asked if robbery might have been the cause, she said: "No, everything is all right, even to his watch and the ring on his finger." THE EVIDENCE ALL INDEFINITE. This is a case in which all the evidence is circum- stantial, all indirect, all scrappy, and indefinite. No one thing signifies much, and 500 things must be taken and put together in order to make a case of any kind. It is worth while to pause, therefore, on this remark of Lizzie's. It showed that the ring on his finger and the watch in his pocket had been in her mind. If innocent, because when she found her father dead she herself looked around for signs of a robbery. If guilty, with the thought of them in her mind, she had utterly neglected to undertake to throw suspicion away from herself by making the mock marks of a robbery. According to the State, the house was in her possession. Except for Bridget in the attic, Lizzie was the only live person there. She herself set the time limit on the affair, for it was she who called Bridget from the attic and Mrs. Churchill from over the fence. If she was so close as she must have been to commit these murders; anyhow, if the watch and the ring were in her mind, as they were when she spoke to Officer Harrington, why might she not have tossed things around, destroyed or concealed or lost in the well a few valuables from the persons of her victims, and then instead of calling Bridget and Mrs. Churchill have quietly walked downtown and paid a visit to a friend? If she was capable of doing the thing as the State says she did it, she was equally capable of doing it thus. If she was as incredibly provident as the State alleges, by the concealment of every trace of how the crime was done, her providence would have been equal to the making of the plan of going downtown and of letting the world do the discovering.
AN UNEXPLAINED INCIDENT.
The witness, in answer to the question what he saw when he went into the kitchen, replied as follows, introducing an incident of which nothing had formerly been said and which is still unexplained:
I saw Dr. Bowen with some scraps of note paper in his hand, standing to the west of the door leading to the rear hall. I asked him what they were, and he said he guessed they had nothing to do with this case. He started to arrange them in some order, as though to read them, and I noticed in the upper left-hand corner of one sheet the word "Emma." The rest was written in lead-pencil. I asked him again what they were, and he said they were from his daughter; then he lifted the lid of the stove and put them in.
Did you notice anything?
I noticed in the south end of the fire box there was a small fire; I should think a coal fire. Some paper had been burned there before, and it had been charred, but still held a cylindrical form. It was about a foot long, two inches in diameter.
Lizzie's unwillingness to allow suspicion to attach to anybody on account of anything she might say was further shown in the talk Mr. Harrington had with her:
I asked her if she had any reason to suspect any one. No matter how insignificant it might appear to her, it might have some bearing on the case. She said: "No, I haven't any. A few weeks ago father had some angry words with a man, but about what I don't know."
I asked her if she heard it. She said: "No, I was in another room." I asked her if her father had said anything about it. She said: "No. About three weeks later he came again, and they had some more angry words, when father went away, and he said to the man if he came in town again to call on him and he might tell him something more definite about the store."
I suggested that she might not be in a frame of mind to give a clear statement of the facts on account of it being so soon after the murder, and perhaps to-morrow might be a better time to talk with her, and that she might give me the name of the man who wanted the store. She answered: "No; I can tell all I know about it now just as well as at any other time."
OFFICER MULLALY'S STORY.
It was late in the afternoon when the dramatic incident occurred to which the testimony of Marshal Fleet about the hatchet head and the little piece of broken wood in it was the prelude. Officer Mullaly was on the stand. He is the man who was in Fleet's company down in the cellar when Fleet found the hatchet and examined it. Fleet testified that Mullaly was there. In his main examination Mullaly's testimony was merely corroborative of what had already been testified to by other policemen. But under the cross-examination of Governor Robinson, he was required to be extremely definite and particular. His story of the discovery of the various hatchets was as follows:
Q.--Who went to the cellar with you the first time? A.--Officer Dougherty and Bridget Sullivan.
Q.--What did Bridget do? A.--She went to show us where the hatchets were.
Q.--What made her do this? A.--Miss Borden said she would show us where the hatchets were.
Q.--Did she call Bridget, or did you ask her? A.--When we got through the attic we went to the cellar direct.
Q.--You had told Bridget what you wanted? A.--Yes.
Q.--And she led the way to the little room on the south side of the house? A.--Yes.
Q.--What did she do? A.--She went where the hatchets were and took them out of the box.
Q.--Did she look around the room? A.--I don't know about looking around. She didn't step around.
Q.--They were in the box? A.--Yes.
Q.--Describe it. A.--It was from 14 to 16 inches long. Q.—Did it have a cover? A.—None that I saw.
Q.—Were things pretty well covered with ashes and dust? A.—The axe handles were pretty well covered.
Q.—How many things did she take out? A.—Two hatchets.
Q.—Did she hand them to you? A.—She did.
Q.—Was one larger than the other? A.—Yes.
Q.—Did they look about the same as now? A.—There was a rust spot on one of them which I don't see now (looking at one which he held in his hand).
Q.—You said that the handle of this hatchet was covered with ashes? A.—I don't say it of that.
Q.—Was there any dust or ashes on the other? (Showing it.) A.—I think this one looked about the same as now.
Q.—Then they were not at that time covered with dust or ashes? A.—No; the axes had their handles covered with dust.
Q.—Did you find them? A.—I won't say if I did or Bridget handed them to me.
Q.—You discovered nothing else on them? A.—I believe the handle of the big hatchet was cleaner than the other.
At this point Mr. Robinson took in his hand the hatchet-head which Fleet had discovered, and asked Mullaly when he first saw it. Mullaly said he saw it when Mr. Fleet called his attention to it.
Q.—How did the metal look? A.—Then as compared with now, it looked different.
Q.—How different? A.—It was covered with ashes.
Q.—It was found in a box, wasn't it? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Do you know what became of the box? A.—No, sir.
Q.—What was taken out of it while you were there? A.—Nothing but the hatchet and a piece of freshly broken handle.
FLEET'S TESTIMONY CONTRADICTED.
Governor Robinson looked sharply at the witness and then turned around to consult his colleague. Fleet had said time and time again that there was no other piece of handle anywhere discovered except the little bit of wood broken off in the hatchet's eye.
Q.—What do you mean by a piece of freshly broken handle? A.—There was a piece of handle there.
Q.—Detached from the blade? A.—Yes.
Q.—Where is it? A.—I'm sure I don't know.
Q.—Did you ever see it after that? A.—Never.
Q.—Who took it out? A.—Mr. Fleet.
Q.—How long was it? A.—Somewhat shorter than the handles of those hatchets there on the table.
Q.—You say you saw Mr. Fleet take that piece of handle out of the box? A.—Yes, sir; I saw him.
Q.—And did you see him put it back? A.—Yes, sir. I saw him put it back.
Governor Robinson paused again. His colleague, Mr. Adams, keenly alive to the importance of this disclosure, had sent out an officer of the court to find Marshal Fleet and to see to it that no one had a chance to talk with him until he was brought back to the court-room. This was a wise precaution. Turning once more to the witness, Mr. Robinson said:
"You are perfectly sure of the facts which you are now testifying to, are you, Mr. Mullaly?" Mr. Mullally said he was, and seemed surprised that there was so much fuss about it.
District-Attorney Moody seemed anxious to take a hand in the proceedings; in fact, to take control of them. Addressing the court, he said:
"Your Honors, nothing was said on the direct examination about this piece of wood. I submit that I ought to be allowed to inquire about it before the defence proceeds with its cross-examination."
The court put their heads together and held a short but animated conversation. Then the Chief Justice quietly observed: "Mr. Robinson will proceed with his cross-examination." Whereupon Mr. Moody dropped back into his seat.
"Did you ever tell this to any one before?" asked Mr. Robinson.
The witness said he never did.
Q.--Do you know where Mr. Fleet is now? A.--I don't know, sir.
Q.--Is he below? A.--I don't know.
Governor Robinson--You will remain where you are, sir, and we will await the result of the effort we are making to find Mr. Fleet.
FLEET BROUGHT BACK TO COURT.
Officers were moving in all directions upon this quest. It appeared also that one of Fleet's Fall River police, who had been hanging around and had observed the extraordinary contradiction between his and Mullaly's evidence, had also started on the hunt for him. This man approached Fleet just as he was seized by one of the officers of the court. He endeavored to engage Fleet in conversation, but the court officer interfered, and hustled him away. Fleet was brought into the courtroom without having received any intimation of the situation. He looked surprised, and of course he realized that something was the matter. He took his place on the witness-stand, however, and awaited developments.
Meanwhile an interesting altercation had taken place between counsel. Governor Robinson made a formal demand on District Attorney Knowlton for the production of that piece of handle, but the District-Attorney, who was evidently as much surprised as anybody else at the turn the evidence had taken, insisted that he had never heard of it before.
When Fleet appeared Mr. Moody again insisted on his right of questioning the officer in direct examination before the defence was permitted to get at him. Mr. Moody, indeed, started to do so, and perhaps to give Fleet an intimation of what the matter was. But Governor Robinson sternly checked the District-Attorney, and the court quickly intervened, directing the defence to go ahead. Then came these questions and answers:
Q.—Recalling to your mind, Mr. Fleet, the box which you found in the cellar, in which you said you found this hatchet here, please state what was in that box and all what was there? A.—There were some other tools, and some scraps of iron. I don't know just what they were.
Q.—Who was with you when you examined the box? A.—Mr. Mullaly.
Q.—Anybody else? A.—No, sir.
Governor Robinson held up the hatchet-head and the little piece of wood that had been fastened in its eye.
Q.—You found these there, didn't you? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—This small piece of wood was then in the eye of the hatchet—so, wasn't it? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Was there any other wood in the box? A.—No.
Q.—Now, Mr. Fleet, answer me this: Did you find in that box any other part of this hatchet than this blade and this little piece of the handle? A.—No, sir.
Q.—You found no other part of the handle? A.—No, sir.
Q.—You're sure of that? A.—No.
FLEET GREATLY PERPLEXED.
Mr. Fleet was evidently much perplexed and troubled. His swarthy face was quite red, and he was slow to answer. Finally, however, he said: I found, no other part of the handle. Q.—Are you positively sure of that? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—As sure as you are of anything else to which you have testified? A.—Yes, sir.
Governor Robinson looked keenly and fixedly at Fleet. Then he turned and looked at the jury. Every man of them was turned full toward the witness, and had watched his every motion and had heard his every word. The court, too, had drawn forward, and had kept sharp and critical watch upon the scene. The great crowd in the courtroom was absolutely still. Every eye was fixed upon the witness. Governor Robinson turned from the jury to the court; from the court he looked full and hard into the faces of the prosecuting officers. Then he dropped into his seat. "That will do," he said.
It was a most extraordinary scene, the fitting close of an extraordinary day in the trial of one of the most confused, strange, unnatural, improbable and altogether mysterious cases of homicide known in the history of crime. The further testimony of the day was unimportant. There was little of it.
Just before the adjournment the prosecution offered in evidence the testimony of Lizzie Borden given at the Coroner's inquest just after she was arrested, after she had been taking morphine daily for over a week, upon her physician's prescription, and at hearings where she was produced by subpoena and compelled to testify without the presence or assistance of couns[e]l. In New-York this evidence would be clearly inadmissible. There is a statue existing protecting accused persons and enabling them to decline to testify without pleading their statutory privilege, and forbidding the use upon their trial of any involuntary statement. This law was elucidated by the Court of Appeals when it decided that Judge Barrett had erred in admitting upon the trial of Jacob Sharp the evidence he had given before the Senate Committee. In Massachusetts, however, there is no statute bearing on this matter.
The defence objected to Mr. Moody's motion on the common law principle that no one can be compelled to testify against himself. Neither side seemed ready to argue the issue at once, and the argument was deferred until Monday. Later the attorneys on both sides met in conference and to-night it is announced that they have agreed on a statement of facts to be presented. If the evidence is admitted the defence will of course explain the numerous contradictions by saying that Lizzie was under the influence of morphine.
MISS BORDEN LIKELY TO TESTIFY.
It is almost certain that in any event she will herself go on the stand. The prosecution will have an opportunity to cross-examine her on any changes there may be in the story she tells now from that she told at the inquest.
Every day adds to the improbability that Lizzie Borden committed these murders. Every day brings out developments that seem to render such a thing incredible. It is an incomparable case.