As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · As the Papers Told It

Act Five

Her Life at Stake

3–17 June 1893

The trial opened at New Bedford in June 1893. The state promised two surprises, the burned dress and a hatchet blade without a handle that fitted the wounds, and Lizzie fainted when its opening was done. Then the case weakened day by day: her inquest testimony was kept from the jury, the expert found no blood on the blade, and defense witnesses contradicted the police. When the evidence closed, the Tribune’s correspondent found few who expected a conviction.

Off to New Bedford to be tried

A Providence News correspondent watches Lizzie Borden leave Taunton by the morning train for New Bedford, where she is to stand the trial on which her life may depend. The departure was kept quiet, and on the ride she kept ‘her usual calm demeanor’. So few knew she was coming that only a few people were at the New Bedford depot when Sheriff Wright took her to the jail.

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Providence News · 3 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TO FACE HER ACCUSERS.

MISS LIZZIE BORDEN LEFT FOR NEW BEDFORD THIS MORNING.

See moreSee less

She Faces Her Coming Trial With the Composure of Innocence—Few Knew That She Was to Leave Taunton Today.

SPECIAL TO THE NEWS.

TAUNTON, Mass., June 3—Lizzie Borden left here for New Bedford on the 10:01 o'clock train this morning. The preparations for her departure had been very quietly made, and it was intended to keep the time of her departure a secret, but that was an impossibility. The tickets were bought early this morning, and the party drove to the station just in time to catch the train.

As she alighted from the carriage and walked to the train her step was firm and elastic, and she showed no signs of physical breaking down.

The ride to New Bedford was an uneventful one, and the prisoner maintained her usual calm demeanor, though she fully realized that at the end of her trip she was to undergo the trial on which possibly her life depends.

The thoughts that filled her breast found no expression in her face, and as the cars whirled along through the country, now beautiful in its early summer garb, she seemed absorbed in watching the beautiful landscape. She has apparently called into requisition all that wonderful nerve which upheld her during her preliminary trial, and of which she will so sorely stand in need in the days that are to come when she will stand before the bar charged with the awful crime which the state has worked so hard to fasten upon her. Whether she will be able to go through the trial without breaking down is a question that time alone can solve. Her friends, confident in her innocence, claim that she will be able to do so, notwithstanding the awful strain that will be placed upon her.

Arrived at New Bedford.

SPECIAL TO THE NEWS.

NEW BEDFORD, June 3.—Lizzie Borden's departure from Taunton had been kept so quiet and the run was so short that her arrival here was unheralded, and so there were only a few people at the depot when the train came in. Sheriff Wright conducted the prisoner immediately to the jail.

See the clipping

The jury is quickly chosen

A New-York Tribune report of the opening day at New Bedford. Chief Justice Mason warns the talesmen that no man who could not believe anyone would commit a crime punishable with death would do as a juror. With the Attorney-General absent, William H. Moody, District Attorney of Essex County, joins District Attorney Knowlton for the state. The box fills fast; one man is excused as a relative of the prisoner.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

New-York Tribune · 6 June 1893 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL.

A SATISFACTORY JURY QUICKLY SECURED.

See moreSee less

THE PROSECUTION WILL OPEN ITS CASE THIS MORNING—CROWDS ABOUT THE COURT-HOUSE IN FALL RIVER.

New-Bedford, Mass., June 5.—The long-anticipated Borden murder trial has begun. At an early hour this morning every available shady spot on County-st. near the courthouse was pre-empted, and patiently the spectators waited until the bell on the courthouse was tolled, signifying the opening of court. Deputy sheriffs guarded the entrance at the front and New-Bedford policemen were at the rear. The talesmen began to file into their places at 10 o'clock, and at 11 o'clock all were there. At 10:58 Miss Lizzie A. Borden, the prisoner, came slowly into the room, preceded by Deputy Sheriff Kirby, and was shown to her seat in the dock. She was attired in a becoming costume of black brocaded stuff, and wore a pretty shade hat, relieved by a touch here and there of blue. As she passed the bar inclosure Melvin O. Adams, of counsel for defence, stepped to

MISS LIZZIE BORDEN.

the rail and bowed to her, but Lizzie, while acknowledging with a slight inclination of the head the salutation, never raised her eyes to his, and passed on slowly beyond to the dock. Every seat in the room was occupied by talesmen and newspaper men, no outsiders being admitted up to that time, and within the box inclosure were a few of the prominent men of the county. District-Attorney Knowlton and Mr. Moody, his assistant, were on hand.

The court came in at 11:27 o'clock. Chief Justice Mason taking the centre seat, with the Rev. M. C. Julien, of New-Bedford, who had been selected to make the regulation opening prayer, on his left. As soon as they were seated Deputy Sheriff Thomas W. Butman was instructed by Clerk Borden to make the usual proclamation to the talesmen, after which the clerk called them in alphabetical order. Seven minutes were thus taken up, after which a brief prayer was offered, Miss Borden standing. Then the District-Attorney conveyed officially to the court what has been well known for a week or so, that the Attorney-General will not be here to attend to his duty, and that William H. Moody, District-Attorney of Essex County, would act. He gave to the court the additional information in a very formal manner that Lizzie Andrew Borden had been indicted for the murder of her father and step-mother, and he had the honor to move for the impanelling of a jury for the trial of the cause. Chief Justice Mason addressed the talesmen as a body, stating that he should be obliged to put certain questions to them as they came before the court relative to forming opinions, their bias or prejudice, etc. He read a section of an opinion from the Chief Justice of the court of last resort bearing upon the matter of opinions, and he cautioned them that all of their answers must be given under oath. If any of them was so mentally constituted that he could not believe any person would commit a crime punishable with death, then that person would not do as a juror. The clerk was then directed to proceed with the impanelling of the jury. Miss Borden was asked to stand up and told of her right to challenge.

George Potter, of Westport, had formed an opinion but did not think it was sufficient to prevent being changed. He had no bias or prejudice, and was in a condition to find a verdict of guilt if the evidence warranted. There was no challenge and he was duly sworn and placed in the box at 11:54, being the first juror chosen.

William F. Dean, of Taunton, had no bias or prejudice, and his opinions would not preclude him from acting fairly to all parties. He was accepted and was sworn.

John Wilbur, Somerset, had formed an opinion, but was unbiassed and stood fair to all, and was declared indifferent. The Government, however, asked through the court whether he was a client of either of the counsel in the case, and he replied: "No." He was made the third man on the jury.

Frederick C. Wilbur, Raynham, had no prejudice and was capable of acting fairly by both parties in interest. He took the fourth seat on the jury.

Lemuel K. Wilbur, Easton, stood indifferent and was sworn.

William Wescott, Seekonk, stood indifferent, and was accepted.

Lewis B. Hodges, of Taunton, was indifferent, and was sworn in as the seventh member of the jury, there being no challenges.

Augustus Swift, New-Bedford, was accepted and sworn in as the eighth juror.

Frank E. Cole, of Attleboro, was indifferent, and was accepted, being sworn in as the ninth juror.

John C. Finn, Taunton, was accepted as the tenth juror.

Charles I. Richards, of North Attleboro, stood indifferent, and was accepted and sworn in as the eleventh juror.

Oliver E. Gifford, New-Bedford, said he was related to the prisoner at the bar, and was excused.

As he passed Lizzie Borden she looked at him in astonishment, and he smiled a cheerful "Keep your courage up" to her.

Allen H. Wardwell, of Dartmouth, stood indifferent, was not challenged, and was sworn as the twelfth juror at 4:45 o'clock.

The quickness with which the jury was impanelled was a surprise to everybody, even the counsel, and they were somewhat unprepared. In all not more than threescore talesmen were examined. The hour was so late that it was not known whether it was best to go on with the opening for the prosecution, or to defer the matter until morning, and a consultation took place in regard to the matter between Messrs. Knowlton, Moody, Robinson and Jennings. Meanwhile, the jury was formally made up, and the court then dismissed them for half an hour at the most, during which time they could make arrangements for their coming seclusion. Deputy Sheriff Butman was given a dozen sheets of paper and a dozen envelopes, one set for each juryman, and they were taken to the jury-room for the use of the men. It was decided that there should be no opening to-night, and the court was adjourned until to-morrow morning, at 9 o'clock. District-Attorney Knowlton is of the opinion that at least three weeks will be required now to finish up the trial. Charles I. Richards, of North Attleboro, was appointed foreman of the jury.

See the clipping

The state opens, and she faints

The Sun hears William H. Moody open for the Commonwealth with two surprises: days after the murders, as her friend Miss Russell looked on, Lizzie Borden burned a dress she said was covered with paint; and a hatchet blade without a handle measures just what the wounds show. When he finished she slumped behind her fan. The courtroom whispered that she was asleep; she had fainted.

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The Sun · 7 June 1893 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

LIZZIE BORDEN SWOONED. SHE FAINTED BEHIND HER FAN, AND IT WAS UNOBSERVED.

It was at a Critical Time in the Arraignment of Her as a Murderess—The Court Officer and Others Thought She Had Dropped Off to Sleep—When Her Arm was Shaken it was Seen that She was Unconscious—Two Surprises Disclosed in the Opening Speech of the District Attorney—Lizzie Borden Burned a Certain Dress After the Murder, and a Hatchet Without a Handle Has Been Found on the Place Which Fits the Skulls of the Victims. NEW BEDFORD, June 6.—Miss Lizzie Bordon fainted in court to-day, and thus brought into clearer view the singular and awful misery of her position. There she sat and is to sit for weeks, alone in the open middle of the court room, as nearly like a pilloried criminal as it is possible for a woman to be, now that there are no actual pillories. Whatever she may have done she is a woman, a being who for thirty-two of the thirty-three years of her life pursued the quiet and sheltered routine of a maiden of good family and comfortable circumstances in a little town. She was wholly respectable all her life, with respectable surroundings, family, and friends, and with the gentle but invulnerable guardianship that comes to such a daughter in such circumstances. Her rounds are even narrower and quieter than those of most girls of her degree. If she is guilty, she must now be suffering the torture of dreadful anxiety, as well as remorse, for remorse is certainly the portion of such a creature. If she is innocent, fancy the horror of her plight, seated there as the most public and notorious character in New England, and listening to the minutest details and the most complete description of the crime that she was the first to discover and that bereft her of her father.

See moreSee less

The strain which her situation produces on intelligent minds is felt by all who are connected with the court. They admit it. They talk of Hester Prynne and Jeannie Deans and of other women whose fearful experiences are suggested by this girl's misery.

But though Miss Borden fainted to-day her nerve is questioned by no one. Of a phlegmatic nature she sits like a graven image by the hour, except for the motion of the hand which plies her fan. In two days she has not been seen to alter the position she has first assumed when taking her chair each day. Occasionally she rests her head upon the rail above the back of the chair, but in the main it is only her eyes that she moves.

These reveal her intelligence and the activity of her mind. With them she sees every person and movement around her, and with them she shows how intently she is listening to all that is said. There came a time to-day, when the horrors of the butcheries of her people were being described, when she would put her fan before her face. She kept it there a long time. It seemed that she had fallen asleep, for her eyes were closed. It was found that she was unconscious. She had fainted, but with no theatricalism. With the same undemonstrativeness that is her peculiarity she had yielded to more than she could endure. One thing is certain, she has no art. Another is that her conduct is as consistent with innocence as with guilt.

The court room was not above two-thirds full and yet the imitation New York policeman at the gate seemed to have no crowd to battle with. The community is evidently used to this practical, business-like court, which refuses to recognize the wishes or even the existence of those not concerned in the trial. "The people must read the papers," says the Sheriff, and down in the town the people resignedly echo the remark and say: "We will have to read the papers." Thus it came that the tiny little court room only sheltered 120 persons this morning. The same dark red and light pink carnations were on the desk. The three grim and grizzled Judges sat behind them. The blue cloth and brass buttons of the swallow-tail coats of the sheriffs were again conspicuous, and the two groups of lawyers reassembled around their separate tables. Miss Lizzie Borden took her accustomed seat in the middle of the room, where fifty-eight persons could look into her face and sixty others could only see her hat and her glossy black hair. She wore the same black dress in which she appeared on the first day of the trial. Her heavy plain face, distinctly maidenly and younger than her years warrant, was lighted by a brighter sparkle in her eyes than on the first day.

The proceedings took on a funereal tone from the first and kept it to the end. Three men did nearly all the talking, and all adopted subdued, sad voices. The first lugubrious tones were those of Mr. Borden, the aged Clerk of the court, who arose to put Miss Borden to the bar in technical language and to read the bill of her indictment for the crimes with which she is charged. It was a solemn and old-fashioned document, that kept on saying to Miss Borden that she "feloniously, wilfully, and with malice aforethought did do murder." It ended by the Clerk addressing to the jury this statement: "She has before pleaded not guilty, and put herself upon her country, which country you are."

Then William H. Moody, the Essex county District Attorney, who is assisting the local attorney, arose to open the case for the Commonwealth. He walked over to the railing close in front of the jurors, and addressed them in a low and confidential manner, and a melancholy tone. In most other States he would have sought to have impressed the court room audience, but in Massachusetts the people are little considered. They must read the newspapers. Mr. Moody did not cover himself with forensic glory. He seemed very much constrained and ill at ease. He attempted to explain the complicated arrangement of the Borden house, and was very clumsy and confusing. He made no pretence of eloquence, but talked as one man might to another. Perhaps it was that he was sensitive to the delicacy of his task and did not want to be cruel or too plain with respect to the prisoner. For that he deserved great credit. He was most considerate. He ascribed all the villainy of the murder to the person he always called "the assailant." At the very end he said that the Government believes Miss Borden to be that assailant.

The general opinion here is that Mr. Moody made a stronger case against Miss Borden than the public had any knowledge of. He brought out some notable new points. He promised to prove that Miss Borden did not wear the dress at the time the neighbors arrived that she is said to have had on at the time of the murder, and he told a dramatic story of an occasion two or three days after the murder when Miss Borden tore up and put in the stove one of her best dresses. She said it was covered with paint and when her friend, Miss Russell, told her that she wouldn't tear up the dress where people might see her Miss Borden only moved back a little way out of sight from the door.

Then, again, Mr. Moody promised to prove that no person outside the family could have entered the Borden house between the night before the murder and its occurrence. Not even Mr. Borden could get into it when he came there to his death, and when his wife was already butchered up stairs.

There was a little dramatic quality to the scene when the axes and hatchets were brought in and rattled together and shown to the jury. They were the old, historic implements of the case, and, being exhibited, were set aside as of no importance. Then Mr. Moody brought out another one, the mere blade of a hatchet without a handle, and sought to impress the jury that with this the bloody deed was done.

For more than half an hour Miss Borden listened to the theories of the Government without taking her eyes off Mr. Moody, and yet without looking at him in any marked way. Her attitude and manner were those of a person at a lecture or a sermon. For a still longer time she sat with the edge of a Japanese fan in her mouth, looking now at the floor and again at the speaker. She was experiencing emotions which were not revealed in her face, for her third position was taken by putting her fan against her face and leaving it there during that part of his address in which he described the bloody deeds and drove the crime home to her. It was after he had finished that she fainted.

On the table in front of Mr. Moody was a strange collection of exhibits in the case. There were two blue dresses, a white petticoat, a valise, some parcels, a pile of large photographs, and a number of diagrams, and plans of houses and streets drawn on oiled paper, and printed in white on blue backgrounds. Mr. Moody began by saying that before the jury to-day a woman of good society, possessing a heretofore unquestioned good character, a member of a Christian church, and the own daughter of one of the victims was at that bar accused of murder. He said that Mr. Andrew Jackson Bordon, the father, was worth somewhere between $250,000 and $300,000. He had been retired from business for a number of years. He had got his property by earning and saving, and he retained the habit of saving to the close of his life. His home establishment was on what might be called a narrow scale. By his first wife he had two daughters. She died, and he married again twenty-five years before his death. Of this second marriage there was no issue. He was seventy and the second wife was about six years younger. He was a spare, thin man, somewhat tall, and Mrs. Borden was fat and short, weighing in the neighborhood of 200 pounds.

"The house in which these homicides occurred," said Mr. Moody, "had been occupied by the family for some twenty years. There came between the prisoner and her stepmother an unkindly feeling. Those who know most about that feeling, except the prisoner at the bar, are dead, and it is only possible to get glimpses of the cause and extent of that feeling. Mr. Borden had seen fit to do some benefaction for a relative of Mrs. Borden, and in consequence the daughters thought something should be done for them as an offset. The details are unimportant.

"It is significant that enough feeling arose to cause a change of feeling between the prisoner and Mrs. Borden. Up to that time she had addressed her as 'mother.' After that she ceased to do so. We shall show that some time before the murder a cloak maker at work for the family spoke of Mrs. Borden to the prisoner as her mother. 'Don't call her my mother,' said the prisoner. 'She is a mean thing, and we hate her.'

"'Don't you go to meals with her?' she was asked.

"'Yes, but we have as little to do with her as possible and stay in our own rooms as much as possible.'"

Mr. Moody said that he knew nothing more significant than another little incident. When one of the officers spoke to the prisoner while her father and mother lay where they had been felled by the blows of an assassin, the officer asked:

"When did you last see your mother?"

"She isn't my mother," said the prisoner, "she is my stepmother—my mother is dead."

Mr. Moody thought the jury would be impressed with the method of living in the Borden household. "It will appear," he said, "that though the family occupied the same house there was built up between certain members by locks, bolts, and bars almost an impassable wall. In the early part of the autumn, the elder sister was away at Fair Haven. The household that was left consisted of Mr. and Mrs. Borden and a servant who had been in the service of the family for nearly three years, Bridget Sullivan, and the prisoner. On Tuesday night an illness occurred in the household. Mr. and Mrs. Borden were taken suddenly ill with a violent retching and vomiting illness, and to a less degree the prisoner was affected. Bridget, the servant, was not. On Wednesday morning Mr. and Mrs. Borden arose feeling as they might after such an illness, and Mrs. Borden consulted a physician. On the morning of Wednesday, the day before the homicides, the prisoner went to a drug store and asked the clerk for 10 cents worth of prussic acid for the purpose of cleaning a seal skin cape. She was told that it could not be sold without a prescription, and after some little talk she went away.

"I think you will be satisfied," said Mr. Moody, "that the person who made application for this deadly poison was the prisoner. Three persons recognized her. Two of them knew her by sight, and the third recognized her at once when he saw her. On the evening of Wednesday the prisoner made a call on a friend, Miss Alice E. Russell, and we shall commend to your careful attention what occurred that evening. The prisoner had been intending to spend her vacation with a party of friends at Marion. The talk between the two started on that topic. The prisoner said that she had made up her mind to go to Marion, and had written that day that she would go. 'But,' she said, 'I can't help feeling depressed. I can't help thinking that something is going to happen. I can't shake it off. Last night we were all sick. Mr. and Mrs. Borden were quite sick and vomiting, and we were afraid we had been poisoned. The girl did not eat baker's bread, and we did, and we think it might be that.' 'No,' said Miss Russell, 'if it had been that other people would have been sick.' 'Well,' said the prisoner, 'it might have been the milk.' 'What time do you get the milk?' 'Four o'clock in the morning,' said the prisoner. 'It is light then,' said Miss Russell, 'and no one would dare to touch it.' 'Well, that's so.' said the prisoner, 'but father has been having so much trouble with the people he deals with, I am afraid something is going to happen. I expect nothing but that the house will be burned over our heads. The barn has been broken into twice.' 'Well, that was the boys after the pigeons,' said Miss Russell. 'Well,' said the prisoner, 'the house has been broken into when only Maggie (the Bordens called Bridget Sullivan Maggie) and Emma and I were there. The other day I saw a man lurking around the house and when he saw me he ran away. Father had trouble with a man about a store the other day, and they had words and father turned him out.'"

Mr. Moody seemed to be very much impressed with this story, and tried to make it as impressive as possible. Then he said he had come to the most difficult duty he had to perform. It was to describe the Borden house. It was a double tenement, intended for two families. The Bordens have occupied it all. It was on Second street, Fall River, one of the most frequented streets in the city, a street of shops and homes, and the Borden house was but a short distance from the City Hall. There was a rear yard, with a barn in it; and back of that was a high board fence, with a barbed wire stretched across the top. There were three entrances, a front door, a side door on the north side facing Mrs. Churchill's house and leading by a small entry to the kitchen, and a third door exactly in the rear leading to the cellar. The front door hall has doors out of it into the parlor and the sitting room back of the parlor. In the hall is a stairway leading up stairs. From the upper hall open three doors. The first leads to a large closet for dresses, almost large enough for a bedroom. Another leads to the guest chamber, over the parlor. In that chamber Mrs. Borden was murdered. "It is a matter to be carefully considered," said Mr. Moody, "that as you turn upon the stairs going to the second story and as you begin to face into the hall you can look into the door of the guest chamber. The third door leads into the bedroom that was occupied by the prisoner.

"When you have got into this part of the house," said Mr. Moody, "you cannot go anywhere except into the clothes closet, into the guest chamber, or into the room occupied by the prisoner. All access to the other part of the house is closed—not by the natural construction of the house, but by the way in which the house was kept."

To make Mr. Moody's long story very short: Miss Lizzie slept over the sitting room, in which her father was murdered. Miss Emma had to go through Miss Lizzie's room to get to her room. The room in which Mr. and Mrs. Borden slept also adjoined Miss Lizzie's room. There was a door between the two, but Miss Lizzie hooked it on one side and her stepmother bolted it on the other. The room of the old couple was over the kitchen, and they had to go through the kitchen and up the back stairs to get to it. The daughters went up the front stairs.

Thus what was practically a wall separated the two generations. The bolts and bars and hooks were fastened always, before, during, and after the murders. Both the old people were murdered in the front of the house, he in the sitting room, under Lizzie's bedroom, and she in the guest chamber, in front of Lizzie's bedroom.

"Who occupied the house on the night before the murder?" Mr. Moody asked. "The person who came in last was the prisoner, and she locked the front door. There are three fastenings on that door. These three fastenings were drawn by the last person in the night before. The door leading to the cellar had been closed by Mrs. Borden, and by the evidence it will be shown that that door was locked during the day of the murder. Bridget came in by the back door and locked it. So when the prisoner and Bridget came in every exit was closed. Now, in the front part of the house that night the prisoner slept in her own room. Mr. Morse, a passing visitor, slept in the guest chamber. Mr. and Mrs. Borden slept in their own room. Bridget slept in her own room in the third story. In the morning Bridget was up first. She went down stairs and into the cellar to get her fuel for building a fire. Then she went to the door and took in the milk. The rear door, I may explain, was a double door, the inside or screen door being kept fastened, while the outside door was open. When opened by Bridget the outside door was opened for the day.

Then Mr. Borden came down stairs. He went out into the yard to empty some slops and then went to the barn. Bridget saw him do that. Bridget did not see Morse until after Mr. and Mrs. Borden had taken breakfast. After breakfast Mr. Morse was first to depart. He went out at 7:45 o'clock, and Mr. Borden let him out and bolted the door behind him. Soon after Morse went away the prisoner came down stairs and began eating what passed for her breakfast in the kitchen. While she was there Mrs. Borden went up stairs, and while up stairs Bridget went out into the yard because she was sick. When she came back Mr. Borden had apparently gone down town. Mrs. Borden was dusting the dining room, while the prisoner was in the kitchen. There was some conversation, we believe, between Mrs. Borden and Bridget about washing windows, and Bridget received her directions. Mrs. Borden disappeared at about that time. It will appear that she thought the prisoner had made the bed in the spare room. She was going up to put two pillow cases on two pillows up there. On the evidence you will be satisfied she never left the room alive, and was killed a few minutes after she went up.

"No living person saw her from that time till her death except the assailant. Bridget had to go to the barn and down cellar. At the screen door, as she was about to go out, the prisoner appeared, and Bridget said she need not lock the door, 'as I am coming in to get water to wash the windows.' She got the water in the barn, but it will be shown that the door was not locked at that time. Bridget went to the dining and sitting room to close the windows and there was no one there. Bridget washed windows on three sides of the house and saw neither Mrs. Borden nor the prisoner in the lower part of the house. She was at work when she heard some one at the front door. It was Mr. Borden. He had left the house at about between 9 and half past 9 o'clock, and

(according to Mr. Moody's complicated calculation) returned at a quarter to 11 o'clock, contrary to the usual custom. He found the front door locked and bolted, as well as fastened by the spring lock. He tried to get in with his latch key, and Bridget let him in. The prisoner, from the hall, made some laugh or exclamation, and at that moment Mrs. Borden lay dead within plain view of any one who stood in just the position the prisoner stood at that time, and had been dead for more than an hour. Mr. Borden went first to the dining room, and the prisoner came in and asked if there was any mail, and said Mrs. Borden had gone out. She had got a note from somebody who was sick.

"That, gentlemen, we put to you was a lie intended for no purpose except to stifle inquiry as to where Mrs. Borden was. Mr. Borden went up his own back stairs. All that occurred after he went upstairs occurred in less time than it takes to tell it. Nothing occurred afterward except the alarm which was given. Bridget came down and was sent diagonally across the street to get Dr. Bowen, at the prisoner's request. She came back quickly and was sent to go and get Miss Russell, at some distance. Almost instinctively there leaped to the lips of every one the question that was put to the prisoner, 'Where were you?' before a thought of suspicion crossed any mind. She had been the last person left with her father alive. The first question Bridget asked was 'Where were you?' 'I was out in the back yard. I heard a groan, came in, found the door open, and found father dead.' Bridget went to the doctor's, came back, and found the prisoner standing by the screen door. There had been no screams, no alarm; simply an attempt to secure Dr. Bowen. Mrs. Churchill, the next door neighbor, saw her standing at the door. Something in her appearance attracted her and she called to her. Bridget was told by the prisoner to go down to Miss Russell, whom you will remember as being the very person to whom Lizzie had predicted that disaster was about to occur. Mrs. Churchill asks the question: 'Where were you?' and receives the reply: 'I was out in the barn to get a piece of iron.' Bridget came in and asked if she should not go for Mrs. Borden. 'No,' said the prisoner 'and in telling this Mr. Moody made his voice as impressive as possible. 'I am almost sure I heard her come in.' Up to that time there was no effort to find Mrs. Borden. 'I wish you would look and see if you can't find Mrs. Borden,' said the prisoner. Mrs. Churchill went up with Bridget, and as her head reached the level of the floor she saw the dead body on the floor."

Mr. Moody thought it regrettable that Dr. Bowen was the family physician and was so naturally affected with horror and sympathy that his trained powers of observation failed when he thought Mrs. Borden had died of fright. Miss Borden went through the sitting room, where her father was lying, went up to her room, changed her dress, put on a loose wrapper, and lay down. She told Dr. Bowen she had gone out to get a piece of iron. She told Miss Russell she went to get iron or wire. She told Officer Medley she heard a peculiar noise, something like a scraping noise, and came in and found her father dead. She told Mrs. Churchill she heard a distressing noise.

"As inquiries began to multiply as to her whereabouts, another story comes into view. It is that she went out to the barn and into the loft of the barn to get lead to make sinkers. When she tells one person that she went into the barn to get the lead and to another person she says she came back and looked at the stove to see if the fire was hot enough for her to iron, and then put down her hat and accidentally discovered the homicide, gentlemen, it isn't a difference of words. In one case she tells that she discovers the murders while about her regular duties, and in another case that she heard groans. We will ask you to remember that the 4th of August was one of the hottest days of the last summer in this locality and that the loft of the barn was stifling. Officer Medley was among the first to enter the barn after the tragedy. He had heard the story and went up stairs to the loft. He found when he had touched the floor with his hands that it was thickly covered with dust. Afterward he walked there and found that every footprint was plainly to be seen.

"It is our duty to offer proof to you that Mrs. Borden died before her husband. We have evidence that when Lizzie discovered Mr. Borden's body it showed freshly running blood, and was warm. The blood of Mrs. Borden was coagulated, and the body was stiffened in death. The judgment of professional men who examined the bodies will be presented to you. The stomachs were sent to Prof. Wood and examined and prepared with exactness. Mrs. Borden's stomach contained eleven ounces of food in the process of digestion, one-fifth of which was water and four-fifths solid matter, partly digested. Mr. Borden's stomach contained six ounces, nine-tenths water and one-tenth of solids. The upper intestines of Mrs. Borden contained partly digested food, while Mr. Borden's were empty. Mrs. Borden's lower intestines were empty, while those of Mr. Borden's contained the matter which had been digested long before noon. Upon these facts the experts have determined that Mrs. Borden died at least an hour before her husband."

When Mr. Moody reached this point the impassive prisoner, who had been holding the edge of a fan between her lips for half an hour, motioned for a glass of water. It was brought to her by a deputy sheriff, and she lowered the fan and drank lightly.

"There was blood spattered in every direction," said Mr. Moody, "and it is probable spatters would be impressed on the clothing of the assassin. The clothing has been produced for the inspection of the Commonwealth. It was produced a great many days after the homicides. The clothing said to have been worn by the prisoner on the morning of the murder, shoes, stockings, dress, and skirt, was subjected to the most rigid examination, and it failed to disclose any marks of blood on the dress, but on the skirt that examination revealed one spot of blood which I don't think it worth while to call your attention to at the present time. You have in mind that an interval elapsed while Mr. Borden was up stairs. She says the reason she left the house was that she found the fire low, and she put a stick of wood on the fire and went out to the barn to wait until it ignited. When she came back the stick was there and the fire had all gone out. It will appear, and it was by a pure accident that this observation was made soon after the alarm, that Officer Tate, attracted by something Dr. Bowen was doing to the fire—I don't mean to suggest anything, gentlemen—looked in the stove and found a large roll of what appeared to be burnt paper. Dr. Bowen will say the prisoner had on a cheap calico dress, a sort of drab-colored dress. Mrs. Churchill says Lizzie had on in the morning a dress with a light blue ground and a fixed figure in navy blue without a white spot in it at all, and on being shown that dress (the one Dr. Bowen saw) she will say it was not that dress which the prisoner wore on the morning of the homicide.

"You will recall that soon after the homicide Miss Russell and the prisoner went to the bedroom. While they were there the prisoner said: 'I think I had better have Winwood for an undertaker;' and Miss Russell went away on an errand, forbidding Dr. Bowen to attend about the undertaker. When she came back she found the prisoner with a pink wrapper on; an officer informed the prisoner that she was under suspicion, and on that night Bridget Sullivan left the house, Alice Russell staying with the prisoner. Miss Emma was then at home. On the morning of Sunday Miss Russell came into the kitchen. The officers were about, but none was in the house, and there Miss Russell saw the prisoner with the skirt of a dress on her arm and what appeared to be its waist on a shelf near her side."

At this point all in the court room listened with new interest. It was suspected that Miss Borden's close friend had been assisting the Government against her, but no one was prepared for the startling information she had given the law officers. Miss Borden seemed unmindful of the importance of the news. She looked on as calmly and imperturbably as before.

"It was a cotton dress and not a silk dress," said Mr. Moody, to distinguish it from the silk the family doctor thinks she wore. "It was a light blue dress, with fixed navy blue spots in it. You will recall Mrs. Churchill's description of it. As she saw the prisoner standing by the stove Miss Emma turned and said: 'What are you going to do?' 'I'm going to burn this dress. It is all covered with paint.' Miss Russell turned away.

"She came again into the room and found the prisoner standing with the waist of the dress, and apparently tearing it apart. She said: 'Lizzie, I would not do that where people can see me.' The only consequence of that was that the prisoner stepped a little back and went on tearing her dress."

This was brand-new evidence, and apparently much the most damaging to the prisoner of all that has been brought forward. It fell upon the ears of the people in court like a lightning flash. "On another day," said Mr. Moody, "Miss Russell said: 'Lizzie, I am afraid that burning that dress was the worst thing you could have done.' 'Oh, why did you let me do it?' the prisoner replied. A considerable search was made by the officers for weapons, and they say no clothing unconcealed and covered with paint could have escaped observation."

From that point the District Attorney took up the subject of the weapons, and announced that the Government meant to lay open all the evidence it possessed at that time. An attendant brought in two axes and two hatchets and they were shown to the jury and disposed of with an explanation showing that they could not have been the weapons with which the bloody deeds were committed. Then Mr. Moody produced his second sensational disclosure. He began by saying: "On the day of the homicide another weapon or part of a weapon was found and attracted little attention."

As he spoke the young attorney held up the handleless blade of a little hatchet of precisely the sort that is kept in almost every dwelling for chopping kindling wood. "It was covered with an adhesion of dust—not the fine but the coarse dust of ashes. This adhered to all sides of it more or less. Both sides were rusty."

It was at this point that the prisoner ceased fanning herself and put her fan to her face, hiding it from nearly all in the room. Behind her fan she closed her eyes as if she was wearied with so much monotony which she found in the proceedings. "Prof. Wood will say," the young lawyer went on, "that while the fragments of the wood of the newly broken handle would render traces of blood, that on a smooth weapon blood could be easily and effectually and completely removed." Just then Mr. Jennings, of counsel of the accused, got up, and, taking the hatchet blade in his hands, examined it carefully. "The fact," continued Mr. Moody, "unquestionably as told by the skulls of the victims is, that the weapons were sharp. Another fact is unmistakably told by Mr. Borden's skull. It is that the weapon was just exactly three and a half inches on the blade—no more and no less. That is exactly the measure of that weapon. The Government does not insist that the homicide was done with this handleless weapon. It may have been. It may well have been.

The bloody weapon was not found on or beside the victims. "You will consider whether these were the acts of a bloody villian fleeing through the streets at noonday or of an inmate of the house, familiar with its means of obliteration and concealment. Nothing was disturbed, no property was taken, no drawers were ransacked.

"Mr. Borden had on his person a considerable sum of money, as well as a watch and chain. There was nothing to indicate an assault on the woman for lustful purposes. There was not a sign of a struggle. The assailant had been able to approach each victim by daylight, and, without struggle or outcry, to lay them low. Mrs. Borden was prostrate, her face on the floor and her head hacked to pieces. Some of the blows were delivered with great force, some with vacillating weakness. Mr. Borden was reclining on a sofa in the sitting room. Apparently he passed away from life into death without a struggle, and his head, too, bore the same marks."

In his peroration Mr. Moody went hastily over the main points in his argument, and then said: "There was no other human being there except the prisoner. The acts were those of a human being, the acts of a person who must have had a familiar knowledge of the premises and whereabouts and habits of those persons in occupation of the house at that time. I ask if any other reasonable hypothesis except that of the guilt of this prisoner can account for these murders on that morning"

It was 11 o'clock when he ended his presentation of the Commonwealth's case. The black figure of the prisoner had not attracted attention during the preceding half hour.

She had been sitting with the great Japanese fan close against her face. Only the correspondent of THE SUN and the deputy sheriff beside her could see behind the fan.

Therefore the rest of the people had ceased to look at her. Behind her fan her eyes were seen to be closed. But she was not asleep, she was listening. The young lawyer had built the fine meshes of his web all around her, and had seemed to shut her up in the heart of it, alone and helpless in the presence of the bloody pictures with which he filled his discourse.

Certain movements that she made with her feet and her hands and the fact that she kept the fan before her face showed that she was awake and listening. The speech ended, the jury went out, and three of the lawyers stood up close to the Judge's bench and talked with the Chief Justice. The court had been declared adjourned, and what was going on was informal.

Two or three minutes passed and the fan and the arm that held it up dropped upon the prisoner's lap. Her head was back against the rail, her eyes were shut, her mouth was open, and her breast heaved with very long breaths.

"Lizzie Borden's asleep," was the whisper that galloped through the court room. Deputy Sheriff Kirby, who sat beside her, took friendly alarm at such disrespectful behavior, and tried to awaken her before the Court should see her. He shook her arm. He might as well have shaken a pump handle. Her head rolled over so that her cheek rested on the rail at right angles to the line of her body. A purple cast came over her face. Kindly Mr. Kirby looked alarmed and helpless. City Missionary Jubb of Fall River was sitting near by, and sprang to his feet and began to fan her.

A Deputy Sheriff came quickly with a glass of water. After a little she regained partial consciousness. Mr. Jubb ordered her somewhat sharply to find her smelling salts. Her hand went into her pocket mechanically and came out with a little cut glass bottle in it.

Then she put both hands on the arms of the chair and fell back against the railing, not half over her faint. Mr. Jubb was applying the smelling salts, and was so much in earnest that her breath went from her, and she put up her hand to push the bottle away. In another minute her eyes opened, and she heard Mr. Jubb advising her to drink some water, which she did. Sheriff Wright, in the mean time, began rapping on his desk for order. The people crept back into their seats, and the episode ended with Miss Borden leaning her head against the rail, with her eyes shut, while every one wondered whether she was going to faint again.

This was at 7 minutes past 11. The jury came back, and Mr. Moody called the first witness. He was a young Fall River civil engineer named Thomas Kieran. He was questioned about the distances between various points in Fall River, as, for instance, how far it was from the Borden house to the city hall and to the police station, and from that station to another.

It turned out that he had drawn the diagrams and house plans which were to be entered as exhibits in the case. His work now was to verify and swear to them. He was the servant of the Commonwealth, but Miss Borden's lawyers took a great deal of interest in his testimony.

When he left the stand District Attorney Knowlton moved that the jury be directed to go to Fall River and take a view, not only of the interior and exterior of the Borden house, but of such other points as it might be of value for them to see.

Gov. Robinson arose and said something to the Court about its being the right and privilege of Miss Borden to accompany the jury to Fall River. He walked over to where the prisoner sat, and talked to her for a minute.

Then he said out loud that while she was, of course, entitled to accompany the jury, she did not desire to do so. She did not feel able, and would waive all her rights. "I state this in her presence," said the ex-Governor.

"If the defendant desires to participate in the view," said the Chief Justice, "she will be permitted to do so."

He ordered the Sheriff to designate four officers to go with the jury. The Sheriff stood up in his little box and named four men with good old Yankee names.

These four, in their blue shad-bellied coats, formed a line before the jury box and held up their hands in the way that an oath is administered in Massachusetts where the Bible is not used in court. Clerk Borden swore them upon the oath that they were to allow no persons except Mr. Moody for the Commonwealth and Mr. Jennings for the defence to speak to them while they were away.

They were going to trot out with the twelve jurors when the Chief Justice made them pause.

"I desire to say," said he, "that this view is not at all for the purpose of taking testimony. You will only observe the physical objects of the view. Counsel will only direct your attention to such objects. It will not be proper for you to ask questions, or for the counsel to make any statements. You are to keep all together, and all are to see what any of you see."

The last words of the proceedings in the second day of the trial were added by the

Chief Justice: "The officers will now suffer the jury to partake of luncheon." Suffering the poor chaps to eat was a new way to put it.

Miss Borden was taken back to the jail, and there sat and chatted with the Master of the House of Correction while the noonday change of guards was being made.

Mr. Josiah Hunt, the Master, is a notable man in this place, and deserves to be for he is a true gentleman, dignified, courteous, kindly, and able. He had no idea Lizzie had swooned, and nothing in her behavior suggested it. She chose for a topic in their talk to-day the fact that she was fond of books. He offered to lend her some, but she said she had plenty and was then engaged in reading one of Charles Dickens's novels. She is very fond of Dickens, she said. She spoke heartily, and there seemed nothing the matter with her. Mr. Hunt finds her an every-day, sensible woman, not gay or lively, but calm and yet of good spirits.

No one has sent her any flowers, he says, and no women have called on her. That suggests a mention of the fact that it is said here that most of the women consider her guilty

Certainly not one has shown her a kindness in the court room, not one has sat by her or spoken to her, and to-day, when she swooned, though there were twenty-one women in the room, not one went to her or showed any concern or sympathy during the excitement.

FALL RIVER, Mass., June 6.—About 1:30 o'clock the Borden jury walked to the Borden house and were admitted with the four men who had charge of them. Also accompanying them into the house were District Attorneys Knowlton and Moody, Gov. Robinson, and Mr. Jennings.

Assistant Marshal Fleet and Lieut. Edson controlled a posse of men who had been about the house since the morning keeping back the crowds of curiosity seekers.

After the jury had examined carefully the inner part of the Borden house, a survey of the outside adjoining yard was made, the distance from the house to the fence, and the location of the lumber pile were noted, and the barn loft was visited.

The jury filed out from the yard and walked up Second street to Dr. Bowen's house and other points figuring in the trial were shown and looked over. Passing to Third street considerable time was spent in Crowe's stone yard, where masons were at work at the time the murder is alleged to have been committed, and the position and distance of the porch in Dr. Chagnon's house, where the Doctor's daughter was seated at the time of the murder, was also noted. Every place mentioned in the story of the crime, including the Union Bank, were visited. The tour was finished at 4 P. M., and the jury went to a hotel here for the night.

See the clipping

Bridget Sullivan saw no quarrels

A Richmond Times report of the third day. Mr. Morse, brother of the first Mrs. Borden, swore he saw no officers in the yard and found the barn door shut, undercutting the police claim that an early search of the barn showed Lizzie could not have been there. The servant, Bridget Sullivan, testified that in nearly three years she saw nothing amiss: Lizzie and her stepmother always spoke.

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The Times · 8 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HEARING OF WITNESSES.

BRIDGET SULLIVAN, THE BORDEN'S SERVANT, TESTIFIES.

See moreSee less

She Says Lizzie and Her Step-Mother Lived Congenially and Peacefully. Mr. Morse's Testimony.

NEW BEDFORD, MASS., June 7.--At the opening of the third day of the Borden murder trial this morning the morbid curiosity of the female portion of the community was catered to, and nearly one-half of the spectators were women. Their necks were craned one way as Miss Borden entered the room, looking as unconcerned and fresh as any one possibly could under such trying circumstances.

After she took her seat Jennings had five minutes' conversation with her and she appeared very much interested and animated, a smile breaking out occasionally as the talk proceeded.

Kiennan, the civil engineer, who was on yesterday, was recalled for first witness.

When the witness was making the measurements of the lower floor of the Borden house his attention was called to a closet in the front hall. He was asked if his attention was called to the fact that one could go in there and be hidden with the door completely shut. He described it by saying a man went in and he shut the door on him. There was no difficulty in closing the door. While the man was in there the door was left ajar, and the man in the closet could not have been seen by witness. Witness was eight or ten feet from the closet door at the time and about the same distance from the front of the house. When the witness was near the parlor door his attention was called to the man, but before he had time to verify whether he could see him or not, he moved to the door of the closet and then he did see him. Witness had made experiments as to what could be seen of objects on the floor of guest's room from the stairs. His assistant had lain down on the floor between the bureau and bed; then he (witness) went down stairs and came up in the ordinary way. Said witness: "I saw a man stretched on the floor from the stairs, and the point from which I first saw him was the centre of one of the stairs, which brought my eye just on a level with the floor. A short distance above I could not see him."

The surveyors' and photographers' evidence being concluded John V. Morse took the stand. At first the prisoner watched him carefully with apparent anxiety, then she looked on with the same indifference as heretofore.

At 10:30, on motion of the defense, all the witnesses, except Reporters Manning, Stevens and Caldwell, Messrs. Buck, Jubb and Holmes and those summoned for expert evidence, were ordered to be excluded from the room.

Morse testified that he was a brother of Mrs. Borden, the first. He was cross-examined by ex-Governor Robinson. As bearing on the possibility of an outsider being in the house, the fact was brought out that during the evening before the murder there was no light in the sitting-room, and that, unless the front door was shut hard, the spring-lock would not catch and turning the knob outside would open the door. Morse swore that on reaching the Borden house after the murder he saw no officers in the yard, that the barn door was closed and he heard no one inside. This contradicts the Government's claims that officers, by immediate examination of the barn, ascertained that the prisoner could not have been there at the time of the murder.

The witnesses called after Mr. Morse's examination fixed the time when Mr. Borden was last seen. Cross examination developed nothing but slight confusion and uncertainty as to the exact time. Miss Borden yawned and looked on listlessly.

A buzz of excitement went around the room at 12:30, when Mr. Moody called "Bridget" Sullivan.

She was a servant in the Borden family at the time of the murder. She leaned to the left side against the rail, looked straight at Mr. Moody and spoke so low that he had to tell her to speak louder. The prisoner remained leaning back in the seat, but changed posture so as to see the witness plainly, and watch Bridget steadily with large eyes wide open. All the judges watched Bridget carefully while she testified to bolting the cellar on the inside two days before the murder, to hooking the screen door, to the sickness of the Bordens Wednesday, and to her own conduct, and the locked condition of the doors on Wednesday night and Thursday morning before the murder.

She detailed at length the movements of the various members of the Borden household during the morning of the day of the crime, and described again the scenes when the murders were discovered. As bearing upon the alleged ill-feeling existing between Lizzie Borden and her stepmother, Bridget testified upon cross-examination:

I never had any trouble in the family, and liked the place; I never saw or heard anything out of the way in the family relations, and during my nearly three years of service everything was pleasant. Lizzie and her mother always spoke to each other; I heard them all talking in the sitting-room that morning, and Mrs. Borden asked Lizzie some questions and she answered them civilly and properly. So far as I could see they lived congenially and pleasantly.

See the clipping

A dark day: the dress, the hatchet

The Sun calls it ‘a bad day for Lizzie Borden’: two witnesses say the dress she burned was the one she wore at the time of the murder, though they saw no blood on it, and the hatchet was found hidden in a tool box, freshly rubbed with ashes. Both points weakened as the trial went on: Professor Wood found no blood on the handleless hatchet, and paint on the burned dress was positively sworn to.

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The Sun · 9 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

DARK FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. THE BURNING OF HER DRESS AND THE DISCOVERY OF THE HATCHET.

Strong Testimony Against the Defendant, but Her Counsel, ex-Gov. Robinson, Succeeds in Tearing Some of It Into Tatters—Two Persons Say the Dress Was the One She Wore at the Time of the Murder—Still They Saw no Blood on It—The Hatchet Was Hidden in a Tool Box, and Had Been Freshly Rubbed With Ashes—A Bloody Handkerchief that Also Appears Mysteriously in the Case.

See moreSee less

NEW BEDFORD, June 8.—It was a bad day for Lizzie Borden—a day full of suggestion of her guilt. As usual her physical condition seemed to foreshadow what was to come. She was all but motionless most of the day. All of her stoicism seemed to have returned to her. It is the general belief that the Government brought out its worst to-day and reached the summit of its little hillock of circumstantial evidence against the unhappy woman. And yet, after all, the principal testimony was as to the burning of her dress, which had been foreshadowed by the Government. That and the facts connected with her singular action made up the measure of the injury done to her case.

Queer and unaccountable as it was for a young woman so placed to burn a dress, especially in so frugal a New England household, it was yet an easy thing for her counsel to show much that was in her favor with regard to it. For instance, she made no effort to hide her act. She did it in broad daylight, in the presence of her sister and a friend, when policemen were just outside the unlocked door. All day the Government kept bringing out its most important and, as it thought, its most damaging points, and just as steadily ex-Gov. Robinson, on behalf of Miss Borden, either riddled them or tried to do so.

In this most expeditious court a swollen tide of witnesses seems ever pouring in the court-room door. Swearing them, ridding them of their testimony, and sending them away again goes on as a lot of cooks might squeeze a basketful of lemons. To-day, as nearly all of the witnesses were very important, the tone and temper of the proceedings were feverish and strained most of the time. The witnesses and the counsel on both sides were, like pugilists, steadily sparring each to get advantage of the other.

The operation could almost be likened to a pigeon-shooting match, in which District Attorney Moody kept flinging up the birds and defying his antagonist to hit them, while the ex-Governor as constantly fired, and often, but by no means always, wounded or brought them down.

Ex-Gov. Robinson is certainly without an equal in New York city as a cross-examiner. Hamlet, in the play, is no more necessary or conspicuous than this gifted lawyer is in this case.

He has not yet found a Government witness whom he has not been able to turn more or less to his own account. His ability is very like that of an actor. He changes his mood to suit his own purposes. He is very courtly and winning to a woman witness until he lands her where he wants her, and then, if it suits him, he becomes as stern as a pirate. He is as confidential and chatty as a gossip, and his witness becomes very desirous of pleasing him and is easily led into a trap. Then his manner changes, and he makes short work of letting the witness know he has him captive.

To-day he seemed determined to anger one of the witnesses. Then he showed his consummate art by simulating irritability, sternness, and impatience. That witness was a police officer named Fleet, and was the coolest, clearest-headed, shrewdest man the wily lawyer has yet had to deal with. In the other duels the ex-Governor has matched his big brains against far smaller ones, but John Fleet's brains were as good in their way as the lawyer's.

Fleet is assistant marshal in Fall River, and is evidently a believer in Lizzie Borden's guilt. Like a typical policeman having some one in custody, he finds it simpler to construe all the evidence against that one than to take up a new clue and hunt out another prisoner. He gave a great deal of testimony which the Government evidently thinks is very hurtful to Miss Borden, and some of it the Government had not outlined. Then, again, Fleet is the man who found the handleless hatchet, which they are going to show to have borne traces of blood. Mr. Robinson set out to discredit all this testimony, and his plan was to get the witness angry and rattled. He succeeded in five minutes, and had the policeman glaring at him and answering him impudently. He also made the witness contradict himself, and in a measure disparage his own evidence. But just then it was time to close the court, so the wonderful wizard of a lawyer will have to work the witness up all over again to-morrow.

The Government kept on weaving its web all day, and the woman's counsel kept breaking through it at every vulnerable point, so that, while the web was there at the close of the day, it was all tatters. The steady effort that the Government made was to show that the doors of the Borden house were all locked on the morning of the murders, that many men and two women went through the house soon after the murder, that the officers saw workmen calmly at work on the other side of the fences around the Borden place, and that it was next to impossible that any one except an inmate committed the crimes. Then, too, they showed that other policemen were quickly sent to scour the woods and watch the depots. Testimony of this sort was incessant. How cleverly Mr. Robinson dealt with all of it will be seen in what follows.

Miss Lizzie Borden attracted general attention all day, of course, but she did nothing to deserve it. She might be said to have done nothing at all but sit still, well back in her chair, and leaning her chin on one hand, her right hand in the morning and her left one in the afternoon. Once she attracted adverse attention. It was when the first blood in this terribly bloody case was shown in the form of a saturated handkerchief carried about like a British flag by District Attorney Moody. She turned her head as she had never done before so that her chin was over her shoulder and she cast her eyes down. And yet any woman might have done the same thing.

That last reflection brings to mind the fact that unless the Government has got more than it has shown, the Borden case will pass into history as one of the most mysterious of the celebrated cases of the century. Most fairminded persons here are of the opinion, that there has been nothing yet brought forward that does not tend to prove the woman innocent quite as much as to suggest her guilty.

The Commonwealth to-day continued its efforts to exactly fix the time of the murder of Mr. Borden. It has at least narrowed things down so that if Lizzie Borden is the murderess she could have had only from 8 to 13 minutes in which to conceal all traces of the murder of her father after she did the bloody deed. In that period of from 8 to 13 minutes she must have either changed her dress or put another one over it, she must have broken the hickory handle of a hatchet, and she must have taken the bloody blade of the weapon down into the cellar and rubbed it a long while and thoroughly with ashes to remove the blood. Of course, she had to wash her face and hands and to attend to her hair and clean her shoes all in the little space of time which Bridget Sullivan says she spent up stairs, and which accords with the testimony of other witnesses.

The first witness of the day was Seabury W. Bowen, the family physician of the Bordens, who was the first person summoned by Miss Borden after the murder. He is also the first person to testify that nothing in the rooms where the murdered persons were found was disturbed by the murderer. "I asked Lizzie several times," he said, "'Have you seen anybody?' and her reply was, 'I have not.'"

"Where have you been?" the doctor asked. She said, "I have been to the barn looking for iron." She then said she was afraid her father had had trouble with his tenants, as she had overheard unfriendly conversations with them several times.

The doctor was another person to whom Lizzie said that Mrs. Borden had got a note asking her to call and see a sick person. The doctor went up and saw Mrs. Borden's body, and noted that she had been killed, probably by the same instrument that despatched Mr. Borden. When he came down he told Lizzie it was fortunate she was out of the way at the time. He denied that he had ever said that Miss Lizzie had on a drab dress at that time. All that he could say now was that the color of the dress was indefinite. Shown the blue dress which the Government keeps on the table in court, the Doctor said he did not call it drab, and that he could not tell whether that was the dress she had on or not.

Returning to his visit to the house, he told of seeing Lizzie in the kitchen, with the others leaning over her and fanning her. He told her to go to her room, and he prescribed something for her.

Mr. Melvin O. Adams took Mr. Robinson's place as crossexaminer of this witness. He had sufficient success to have satisfied even his brilliant colleague. He brought out from the Doctor the fact that Miss Borden was under the influence of morphine for several days after the murder.

On the day of the murder he gave her bromo caffeine. For Friday and Saturday he prescribed morphine. On Friday he gave her an eighth of a grain and on Saturday double as much. She had it again on Sunday and Monday

"How long did she take it?" said Mr. Adams.

"She had it all the time she was at the police station."

"Up to the time of her arrest and when she was at the station?" Mr. Adams asked.

"Yes, sir."

"After her arrest, when she was at the station, had she taken this double dose of morphine daily for several days?"

"Yes, sir."

"I suppose physicians understand that when morphine is given it affects the memory, changes the views of things, and gives people hallucinations?"

"Yes, sir."

"There is no doubt about it, is there?"

"No, sir." Of course the reader will understand the very great importance of this testimony for the prisoner. She has been accused of many contradictions in her stories, of peculiar behavior after the murder in her home and when under examination. The defence can now ascribe to the morphine as much of this as it pleases.

Bridget Sullivan was put on the stand again for ex-Gov. Robinson to ply with questions in the continuation of his cross-examination of her. He made her describe the dress she had on during the morning of the day of the murders, and as it proved to be a blue dress, it was clear that he means to argue that hers was the dress that Mrs. Churchill saw and afterward thought was worn by Miss Borden. However, the dress was little like the one Mrs. Churchill describes. The ex-Governor next took up the subject of the robberies of the Borden house and barn prior to the murders. His questions were objected to.

The Governor paused and contemplated the Judges reflectively. Then he said: "I do not want to state anything before the jury which I ought not to, but I want to bring out the fact that some time, not long before the murders, the house was entered by burglars in broad day while this witness and the prisoner were in the house."

"I think it is not competent," said the Chief Justice. "It was too long before the commission of the crime about which she is to testify."

Then ex-Gov. Robinson said he would like to bring out the fact that there had been a robbery of the barn also. He asked her when that was, and she said it was four or five months before the murders. The burglary of the residence was twelve months prior to the murders. The whole line of testimony was excluded—a loss to the prisoner's side, for her lawyers want to show that there was a good reason for the alleged anxiety of the prisoner to keep her home bolted and barred. The house had been robbed in broad daylight, and the barn behind it was pillaged twice. This the defence will argue—if they can get the evidence—was sufficient to render the Bordens very nervous, and more than commonly careful to keep the doors to the house well secured.

Mrs. Adelaide Churchill, the next-door neighbor of the Bordens to the northward, was the next witness. She is the neighbor who was the first person not of the household who entered the Borden house after the commission of the crime. She is a middle-aged matron of comfortable build and genteel, placid face. She told of seeing Andrew Jackson Borden as he started from his house on that round of business calls from which he came back to be killed. She went down town, and, in an uncertain measure of time, came back. She saw Bridget coming back from Dr. Bowen's rapidly. From her house she saw Miss Lizzie leaning against her kitchen door. The prisoner looked excited or agitated and the witness stepped to the window and said: "Lizzie, what's the matter?"

"Oh, Mrs. Churchill," said the prisoner, "do come over; some one has killed father."

The witness went over to the Borden house. As soon as she reached the door she stepped in, and there was Miss Lizzie sitting on the second stair to the right of the door. The witness put her right hand on the prisoner's arm and said:

"Oh, Lizzie, where is your father?"

"He is in the sitting room."

Then the witness asked: "Where were you when it happened?"

The prisoner replied: "I went to the barn to get a piece of iron."

The witness then asked where Mrs. Borden was. The prisoner said: "I don't know. She got a note and went out. I sent for Dr. Bowen. I must have a doctor. Father must have an enemy, for we have all been sick. I think it must be the milk. I think we were poisoned."

The witness ran over into the street, and, seeing a man, said that a doctor must be had. Soon Bridget came and Dr. Bowen. Some one told the Doctor Mr. Borden was in the sitting room. Bridget, Lizzie, and witness followed the Doctor as far as the dining room door. The Doctor then came out and said: "Come in and see him." "Oh, no," said the witness, "I don't want to see him. I saw him this morning."

The Doctor wanted a sheet to cover up the body. Bridget got the key to the bedroom of the old couple, and she and Mrs. Churchill went up. Bridget found the door locked, went in, and got the sheet. Miss Lizzie asked the Doctor if he would send a telegram to Emma, her sister. "Tell it to her as gently as you can," said the prisoner, "for there is an old person there." Miss Russell (the prisoner's closest friend and companion) soon came. After that Miss Lizzie asked would some one try to find Mrs. Borden, for she thought she heard her come in. The witness and Bridget went up the front stairs. They went up so that witness's eyes were on a level with the front hall, and saw across the hall and the spare room on the far side of the bed what looked like the form of a person. The witness went back and Miss Russell asked: "Is there another?" The witness said, "Yes, she is up there." Miss Lizzie said she should have to go to the cemetery, but the witness told her the undertaker would attend to everything.

"Was her excitement manifested by tears?"

"No, sir."

"Did you suggest any change of dress?"

"No."

"Did any one suggest it in your hearing?"

"No."

Asked what dress the prisoner wore, she said it looked like a light blue with white groundwork. It was of calico or cambric, with a dark navy blue diamond pattern printed on it. This, of course, is the dress that the Government will seek to prove was burned by the prisoner two or three days afterward. District Attorney Moody took from his table a dark blue dress and asked:

"Is that the dress?"

"No, sir. Oh, no, sir," said the witness quite emphatically.

Then it was that ex-Gov. Robinson took the witness in his charge on behalf of the prisoner, and gave another exhibition of his marvellous power as a cross-examiner. He got from the witness the fact that there was no peculiarity about Miss Lizzie's dress that attracted her to call across the yards and ask what was the matter. It was the prisoner's looks, not her acts. "Of course," said this magic-like juggler with words and vocal tones, "you did not examine that dress? You were too much excited?"

"Yes, sir."

"Of course you did not talk about dresses, then, when you heard about the murder?"

"No, sir."

"You did not notice Bridget's dress?"

"No."

"If we were to make particular inquiry, you couldn't tell?"

"No, sir."

"Mrs. Bowen came that morning. What sort of a dress did she have on?"

"I think she had on a whitish dress."

"Do you know what you had on?"

"Yes, sir."

"But beyond that you can't tell much about dresses?"

"No, sir."

"What dress did Miss Russell have on?"

"I don't remember."

Having thus weakened the Government theory about the missing dress worn during the perpetration of the murders, the ex-Governor took up another branch of the same subject in a most ingenious way. He asked the witness such questions as to produce testimony that Mrs. Churchill fancied Lizzie Borden had had a newspaper. Afterward, Miss Russell fanned Lizzie. Some one gave her something to drink, and the witness thought Miss Russell cooled the prisoner's face and hands with water. "You remained with her all the time up to noon?" the ex-Governor asked. "Did you see any blood on her dress?"

The witness did not.

"On a dress as light as that, if there had been blood you would have seen it?"

"I should think so. If it had been on the front of it I'd have seen it."

"Well," said the Governor, "you were right over her, in front of her, bathing her, fanning her?"

The witness replied that she was.

"And," said the Governor, "at no time did you see a particle of blood on her hands or her dress?"

"No."

"You saw nothing about her hair or her shoes?"

"No."

"When she lay on the lounge her feet and shoes were right up on the lounge?"

"Yes, sir."

This witness told of a conversation she overheard between a policeman and the prisoner. The officer was asking about some farm hand of her father's who had had a quarrel with the old man. The policeman suggested that, perhaps, the man was a Portuguese. The prisoner said: "He was not a Portuguese, he was a Swede." She added that she would not suspect him of doing such a thing. With a buzz from the surprised and expectant audience the name of Miss Russell was called by District Attorney Moody. This famous friend proved to be an old maid of 40, but far from fat and fair. In fact, she is a slender, prim woman of precise manners, of spare figure and sallow face. She was obliged to stand up in full length view of all the crowd, of course. She never once looked at the prisoner, who had once been her chum. On the contrary, she turned her left shoulder toward the prisoner, and kept that position for an hour and a half. If ever there was a woman who was and is superior to the frivolities of life, that woman is Miss Alice M. Russell. She testified that Miss Borden was a friend who frequently called upon her. She did so on the Wednesday night before the murder. The prisoner said:

"I feel depressed. I feel as if something was hanging over me. I can't throw it off. The other day the girls laughed in the dining room, and this feeling came over me, and they asked, 'What's the matter? Why don't you laugh?' Mr. and Mrs. Borden were awfully sick last night. We were all sick but Maggie." Lizzie thought maybe it was the baker's bread, which all ate except Maggie. Miss Russell thought if that were so others in town would be ill. Then the prisoner guessed maybe it was the milk, but Miss Russell, in her intensely practical way, showed that that could not well be the case.

"I feel afraid sometimes that father's got an enemy," the prisoner said. "He had so much trouble with men that came to see him." A man came to the house only a few days before, and she heard her father say to him: "I don't care to let my property for such a purpose." The man said: "I should not think such a man as you would care what you let it for." and her father was angry and showed him out of the house. She spoke of some one having robbed the barn, and the matter-of-fact witness said that was only some one after the pigeons. Miss Lizzie did not heed these calming statements, but said: "I feel as if I want to sleep with one eye half open. I feel that they'll burn the house down some time. I am afraid somebody'll do something to father some time; he's so discourteous to people."

When the witness went to the Borden house on the summons of the prisoner on the morning of the double murder, Lizzie said she had been to the barn to get some tin or iron to fix a screen. When she came into the house she saw her father and that he was killed. The witness started to loosen Lizzie's dress, but the prisoner said: "I won't faint." The point in bringing this out was that perhaps she had on another gown under the outer one, and to open her clothing would have disclosed the fact.

"Are you able to give a description of the dress she had on?" Miss Russell was asked.

"None whatever," she replied. Witness went to Lizzie's bedroom with her before the prisoner changed her dress. Asked in what way it was suggested that she leave the room, she answered that the prisoner remarked that when it was necessary for her to have an undertaker she should want Winwood. Witness then went down to tell this to the family physician, Dr. Bowen, and, after waiting some time, went up stairs again. The prisoner was coming out of her sister Emma's room tying the ribbon of a wrapper which she had put on.

Then came the thunderclap of the alleged proof against the wretched prisoner—the chief stroke of the Government. The witness had been led up to Sunday morning, the day following the funeral and the third day after the murder. She had gone down into the kitchen. Miss Lizzie was at the stove and held a skirt of a dress in her hand. Her sister Emma said: "What are you going to do?"

"I am going to burn the old thing up," said Lizzie. "It's all covered with paint."

The witness turned and left the room. She spoke to neither sister. She came back into the kitchen and saw Miss Lizzie, who stood by the cupboard, and was either ripping something or tearing something apart in the garment. "I said to her," the witness went on, "'I wouldn't let any one see me do that, Lizzie.' She did not make any answer. She stepped one step further back. I don't know that it was the waist, but I saw the portion of the dress on the cupboard shelf. No officers were then in the house, but there were officers about the premises."

Witness afterward talked with officer Hanscom, and later saw Miss Lizzie. She said to her: "I am afraid, Lizzie, that the worst thing you could have done was to burn that dress. They have been talking to me about it." Lizzie said: "Oh, why did you let me do it? Why didn't you tell me?"

District Attorney Moody paused a moment and then said: "Miss Russell, you testified at the inquest, at the preliminary examination, and before the Grand Jury. At any of those hearings did you say anything about that incident?"

"No, sir," said the witness.

"Stop one moment," said the magical cross-examiner for the defence, and he so strenuously objected to that question and answer that both were excluded. The witness finished for the Commonwealth by saying that the dress in question was a light blue dress with a small dark blue figure in it—a dress the prisoner had bought no longer ago than the early spring. This tallied with the description Mrs. Churchill gave of the dress the prisoner wore on the morning of the murder, a dress unlike any now in the possession of the Government.

The ex-Governor then took the witness, but it was not his purpose to make her seem of much account. He got her to tell how she had urged the prisoner to sit down, and had found her at the time of the discovery of the murders.

"Did she seem to have on more than one dress?"

"I did not notice," the witness replied.

"Did you see any blood upon her?"

"No, not a particle," said Miss Russell.

"Didn't see any on her dress or hair or hands or shoes?"

"No," said the witness.

"Everything looked all right?"

"Yes, sir."

As the witness recalled the first search of the house, the officers went into the room of the old couple, then into the parlor. In the afternoon they went to Miss Lizzie's room by bursting open the door between it and the room of the old couple. Later she saw Miss Lizzie screw the screw-eye into the door frame again. When the officers were there they searched Miss Lizzie's room. Miss Borden's counsel, with all his ability, could not make the witness say that the search was very thorough, but he found it a good point to make her swear that the room so generally supposed to have been kept free from inspection, was searched, after all.

Mrs. Churchill had said that Miss Lizzie wore a calico or cambric dress. Miss Russell told him the dress Lizzie burned up was of Bedford cord. She was certain she knew the difference between calico or cambric and Bedford cord: these were very different materials. The Governor could not get Miss Russell to say that any woman would know the difference, but she knew it.

"Now," said the Governor, "this tearing up of the dress was in bright daylight?"

"Yes, sir."

"Did you see any blood on that dress?"

"No."

"Not a drop?"

"She held it with the edge of it toward me," said the witness, "and I could see that the edge of it was soiled."

Here it occurred to the Chief Justice that the jury needed to stretch its legs, and so he ordered a recess for five minutes.

When ex-Gov. Robinson again began to direct his fusillade of keen and subtle questions at the chief witness of the commonwealth he asked her if there was not a thorough search on the day of the funeral, Saturday, two days after the twofold murder, Miss Russell said:

"No, they did not search everywhere."

"Did they go to Miss Lizzie's room?"

"Yes."

"What did you see them do up there?"

"After they took up all the things on the bureau and opened one or two drawers they did not do any more." They opened what was called the toilet room. They went into Emma's room, and she saw them pressing against a spare pillow in a closet, and the bed was next taken to pieces. There was no objection or resistance. The public had full sway, and this was the case with regard to all the searchers.

"I never heard of any resistance," the Governor got Miss Russell to say.

To all appearances the prisoner was much less interested in the testimony than the most unconcerned among the persons in the court. She spent her time in examining her fan and putting the handle of it in her mouth and out again mechanically. District Attorney Moody, for the Government, had the witness returned to him, and after a little contention and strong objection on the part of the prisoner's lawyers, he got Miss Russell to say that Bedford cord is a cloth made of cotton and that it is a cheap material. That confirmed Mrs. Churchill's statement that when she reached the Borden house on the day of the murders the prisoner wore a cheap cotton dress.

"You saw no paint upon it?"

"No, sir."

"Couldn't it have been soiled with other things without your seeing it?"

"It could," said the witness.

The Government lays stress on the point that Lizzie Borden told a deliberate lie when she told several persons on the day of the crimes that her step-mother had received a note and gone out in consequence. The Government holds that she invented this lie to prevent an early discovery of the murder of the step-mother. Miss Russell had a story to tell about that. She testified that on the day of the murders Dr. Bowen made a search for that note, and declared to her and Miss Lizzie that he could not find it.

"May be she burned it," the witness suggested.

"Yes," said Miss Lizzie, "she must have."

"Now, then," said the District Attorney, "for what was that closet used, the cupboard in which part of Lizzie's dress lay, while she tore up the other part?"

"It was a closet for coal and wood," said the witness, "and I remember seeing some flatirons there."

That was the strongest part of the Government's case. It showed the full extent of the backbone of the theory that makes her the murderess of the old people.

John Cunningham, a Fall River newsdealer, who was the first man to whom Mrs. Churchill gave the alarm on the street, was next sworn. He was called by the commonwealth to swear that he and two reporters examined the grass and soil around the Borden house to see if they could discover the footprints of the assassin. He saw no tracks or footprints anywhere. This was part of the Government's proof that no one but an inmate of the house could have committed the crime.

Ex-Gov. Robinson turned that witness into a cipher by making him swear that he did not even see the footprints made by Mr. Borden that morning when he went under the pear tree and picked up half a dozen pears, nor did he see the tracks of Bridget where she had gone over the grass to the Kelly fence, where she had stood while chatting with the Kelly servant.

George W. Allen, a Fall River policeman, who was the first officer at the scene of the crime, testified to the fact that Miss Lizzie was not crying, and did not show a sign of tears. Up stairs he saw no person except Mrs. Borden—that is to say, no living person, for she was murdered. He went in the cellar also. He was led to say that only three feet away from where Mrs. Borden lay dead there stood a table bearing two books. There was no blood on it or the books. It will be remembered that there was other testimony yesterday showing that in other directions the man's blood had spattered more than eight feet away. The assumption is this testimony will be asked to show that the murderer need not have been bloody because this table was not. The Government holds that line of argument in check.

This witness was the means of bringing into the room the most horrible of exhibits yet seen. It is believed the progress of the case is to be punctuated with ghastly and horrible relics of the crime. The axes and hatchets shown on the first day were modest and commonplace beside this exhibit of to-day. It was a blood saturated handkerchief found near Mrs. Borden's body. It is believed to have been worn by Mrs. Borden on her head while at her housework and when she was murdered. The old policeman went through the house and noticed that the front door was doubly or trebly locked. Up stairs in the guest chamber he saw a handkerchief close to Mrs. Borden's body. It lay near her feet and reaching out toward the door.

District Attorney Moody took up a paper parcel and opened it before the witness. Out of the paper he took a large bandana handkerchief that was all but cut or torn in shreds, and that was all but stiff and wholly discolored with dried blood. In carrying this exhibit about the Essex District Attorney held it widely opened so that it hung like a scarlet banner before the general gaze. Then it was that the prisoner turned her head directly away from the horrible object. She cast her eyes down to the floor.

Francis H. Wickson, a deputy sheriff, who has been in the army and seen dead bodies on the battlefields, also saw the corpses of the murdered Bordens. It was his observation that the wounds on Mr. Borden on the morning of the murder were fresh. The blood was light colored, and he saw none of it coagulated. On Mrs. Borden's body the blood was coagulated and of a dark maroon color. The intent of this testimony was to prove that Mrs. Borden was killed before Mr. Borden had met his death. The manner of the distribution of the old man's wealth depends upon which died first, by the way. If Mrs. Borden died last the property would go to her heirs, but if Mr. Borden was killed last, as is apparently the case, the two daughters would inherit all the property. This defines the motive Lizzie Borden had in killing the couple in the theory of the Government.

Officer Wickson testified to looking over the fences around the Borden yard right after the discovery of the crime. He saw one man sawing wood on the other side of one fence and two men at work in working clothes in another direction. They asked him what was the matter. This was part of the Government's effort to prove that no one but an inmate of the house committed the murders, that no one got away afterward, and that no one could have gotten away. What ex-Gov. Robinson did to weaken the force of that testimony was to make the witness admit that he did not go to the barn, or see any one else go to it, suggesting, of course, that the murderer might have been hidden in there.

A very important witness was John Fleet, the Assistant Marshal of Fall River, who made ex-Gov. Robinson very wroth at him by his apparent assumption that Miss Borden is guilty. He is a handsome and very shrewd man, but a typical dyed-in-the-wool policeman. On the day of the murder, to give his testimony, he saw Miss Lizzie and asked her if she knew anything about the murder. She said she did not. All she knew was that her father came home at about half past 10 or quarter to 11 o'clock, went to the sitting room, sat down, took out some papers and was looking at them. She was ironing some hankerchiefs in the dining room. She saw that her father was feeble, and went in to him, and advised and assisted him to lie down on the sofa. Then she went back to her ironing, and presently she went into the yard and up in the barn. She said she remained up in the barn about half an hour. She was up stairs over the first floor of the barn. She came down and went in the house, and found her father on the lounge in the position she had left him, but killed--or dead. Asked what she did, she said she went to the back stairs and called the servant girl. She was asked if Mr. Morse did the murders. She said she thought not, as he was away since early morning. Asked if the servant did it, she said no; that Bridget had gone up stairs before her father lay down and had not come down till after the murder. Asked if she had any idea who could kill her father and mother she replied: "She was not my mother, sir; she was my stepmother. My mother died when I was a child." She told the marshal about Mr. Clegg's calls upon her father about renting a store, and about her father's quarrel with a man who wanted to rent one of his houses for an improper purpose.

The hatchets and axes were brought in at this point. They were accompanied by the clanking and dashing that seems inseparable from being handled and that sounds terrible to those who sympathize with the prisoner and try to put themselves in her place. Miss Borden had been inattentive and drowsy up to that time, but now she raised her head and looked at the weapons with some show of interest. The other day she lowered her eyes when they were in the room. The assistant marshal went on to describe how, as soon as he could do so, he sent men to cover the roads and to visit the depots so as to intercept any fleeing criminal if possible. After that he went up to search Lizzie's room. Dr. Bowen was in there with the prisoner. The door was shut and locked. The marshal knocked, and Dr. Bowen opened the door. He was told that the officers wished to search the room. The Doctor closed the door and locked it, then opened it again and said Miss Borden wished to know if it was absolutely necessary to search that room at that time. The marshal replied that it was. The Doctor closed the door, said something to the prisoner, and then opened the door and let in the officers.

The search then began. The witness asked Miss Lizzie if she had said she was in the barn half an hour. She replied she had said twenty minutes to half an hour. When asked what was the last time she saw her stepmother she replied, "At about 9 o'clock." Mrs. Borden was then in the room where she was found dead, and was making the bed.

At this point the prisoner leaned over to her counsel, Mr. Adams, and whispered to him. "She then said," continued the witness, "that some one had brought a letter or note to Mrs. Borden, and she thought she had gone out. She had not noticed her return. She said she hoped we would get through with this search quick, that it was making her tired, and we told her we would get through as soon as we could. We did not make a thorough search.

Then came what was meant to be sensational testimony about the finding of the hatchet with which the Government argues that the crime was committed. The two axes and the two perfect hatchets which are thrown aside as innocent by the Government were first found by the marshal's men, and it was not till later in the day that he came upon the handleless one in a box on a jog in the chimney. It was in the box with several tools. It was covered with a heavy layer of thick ashes while the other objects in the box were coated very differently with fine dust. Moreover, the handleless hatchet was covered with ashes on all sides; all over. The marshal did not notice all this at the time or think much of it. He put it back in the box, but afterward he went and got it, and the Government made it the star exhibit in the cause. District Attorney Moody led the marshal back to the dresses of Miss Lizzie, after he had examined the little hatchet blade and had testified that the handle was newly broken off from within the blade. On Saturday the marshal and his men searched the Borden house again.

"Did you see any dress with paint on it?"

"No, sir."

"How critically did you examine the dresses?"

"Very closely."

A hum ran through the court as the minds of the people grasped the fact that if he did not see the paint-soiled dress it must have been because it was skilfully hidden. Miss Lizzie Borden leaned over to Mr. Adams of her counsel and whispered to him again.

"Did you see any blood on any garment?" Mr. Moody asked.

"No, sir," said the assistant marshal. When ex-Gov. Robinson took hold of Assistant Marshal Fleet he did so as a terrier takes hold of a rat. He flew at him at least as if he meant to shake him. Fleet was cool and not easily angered, yet such was the manner of the formerly oily lawyer that Job himself could not have endured his tone and words with patience. The ex-Governor was short, stern, and sharp.

"You've testified before several times in this case. This time you have added to your former testimony. Don't you know you have? Don't you know how you have done it? Do you mean to deny it?"

Thus he tried to rustle the witness all over. He first charged that the witness did not name the same persons as being at the Borden house on the morning of the murder as he had named before. But that was not what the lawyer was after. He was angry at the man for introducing testimony against his client to the effect that she actually led her father to the lounge on which he was battered out of human semblance. The talk to and fro is not important enough to report, but it was hot. Finally the ex-Governor got the assistant marshal to admit that he had not made a very thorough search of Lizzie's room. "Not as thorough as it should have been," said the marshal. He asked the witness to characterize Dr. Bowen's manner of holding Lizzie's door when he went there to search the room.

"He seemed to be holding the fort," said the witness.

Then the Governor was, indeed, angry.

"Do you call that a proper way to answer my question?" he shouted. "It's the proper way to reply to your way of doing business," said the witness.

"You asked him to characterize it," said District Attorney Knowlton. The Chief Justice seemed by his manner to think that witness was not beyond his province and the battle went on. Next the Governor began to succeed in his purpose of muddling the officer. The witness had described his examination of Lizzie's dresses, and had said in the closet they hung behind a long white curtain, a covering like a sheet. Now he could not recall whether there was such a covering or not. He thought there was no such covering. Ex-Gov. Robinson made the most of this contradiction and uncertainty, because it tended to show that a man who was so uncertain about a chief fixture in the room could not be trusted as to whether or not he had examined the dresses carefully or had seen a paint-stained dress or not. Unfortunately for the plans of the vastly clever lawyer, it was then time for the night's adjournment, and the witness had to go away and cool down so that he will have to be brushed the wrong way all over again to-morrow. The white-haired jury keepers were summoned and sworn and charged to take the jury to a convenient place for the night. Then the old crier rose in his box and shouted: "Hear ye! hear ye! hear ye!" and told all persons having business with the court to depart and give their attendance at place at 9 o'clock next day. "God bless the Commonwealth of Massachusetts!" said the old man in conclusion.

See the clipping

Witnesses differ over the weapon

The Tribune’s headlines report state witnesses contradicting one another about the weapon, and predict that Lizzie Borden will testify. Officer Mullaly swore a piece of freshly broken handle lay in the box with the handleless hatchet; recalled, Marshal Fleet swore he found no other part of the handle. She never did testify: given the chance on the last day, she declared her innocence and left the rest to her counsel.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

New-York Tribune · 10 June 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

HATCHETS IN EVIDENCE. STATE WITNESSES CONTRADICT EACH OTHER.

CONFLICTING STORIES ABOUT THE WEAPON WITH WHICH THE MURDERS ARE ALLEGED TO HAVE BEEN COMMITTED-LIZZIE BORDEN LIKELY TO TESTIFY.

See moreSee less

[BY TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNE.]

New-Bedford, Mass., June 9.—It was made plain to-day that Marshal Fleet and his assistants had searched the Borden house on that Thursday afternoon with anything but thoroughness. They looked into the clothes closet, where the women of the family kept their dresses. They glanced at the dresses, and felt of them, but did not examine them carefully. They paid little attention to the contents of the numerous trunks. The visit to the cellar, where the hatchet-head was found, was inquired into with especial scrutiny.

"Who was in the cellar when you went down there?" asked Governor Robinson.

The witness said that Officer Mullaly, Officer Devine and Dr. Dolan were there.

Q.—What were they doing? A.—Looking around.

Q.—Did you see the axes and hatchets then? A.—I did.

Q.—Where? A.—They were on the cellar floor.

Governor Robinson picked up the axes and hatchets and inquired if they were the ones he saw. Fleet said they were. "Did you see anything else of this character?" Fleet said he did not.

Q.—Then what did you do? A.—Stayed there a little while, looked around and talked.

Q.—This was the occasion of your second visit to the cellar? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—Well, what then did you do? A.—I went out into the yard.

Q.—What, again? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—What for? A.—To hear reports from my men.

Q.—After that did you go into the cellar again? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—Who went with you? A.—Nobody.

Q.—Who was there? A.—Some officers were there, but I don't know who.

Q.—Was this the occasion on which you found something else in the way of a hatchet? A.—No, sir.

Q.—Wasn't it? A.—No, sir.

Governor Robinson looked sharply at the witness, and, turning to the table, picked up the hatchet-head, and held it high in view.

"When did you find this, Mr. Fleet?" he asked.

"On the occasion of my second visit," said Fleet.

Governor Robinson paused and looked sharply at him again. "Why didn't you say so when you were describing what you did on that occasion?"

"You did not ask me."

"Yes, I did."

"I did not so understand it."

"Do you understand me now? When did you find this hatchet-head?"

"On the occasion of my second visit." A DRAMATIC EPISODE.

The questions and answers following, which are a verbatim report of the proceedings will be found especially interesting and important as a prelude to one of the most dramatic and sensational situations that have ever occurred in a criminal trial.

Q.—When you saw this hatchet-head, where was it?

A.—In a box.

Q.—In with those hatchets over there, and those axes?

A.—No. They were found at one time and in one place. This I found at a later time and in another place.

Q.—But you say it was in a box. A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—And with other tools, you said? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.-And all covered with dust? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—The room was an ashy, dusty room, wasn't it? A.—There were ashes there, but they were confined to a space of four or five feet.

Q.—Weren't the brickwork and box and everything else covered with ashes? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—It was an ashy old place, wasn't it? A.—Perhaps so.

Q.—It isn't strange, Mr. Fleet, is it, that everything should be covered with ashes when ashes were constantly dumped there? A.—No.

Q.—Who took it out of the box? A.-I did.

Q.—Was anybody else there? A.—Mullaly was there, but I don't know whether he saw me or not.

It is to be noted here that the piece of wood which, when the hatchet-head was found, was fastened into it, being that end of the handle which was held in the iron, has since been taken out, presumably by the State, and for the purpose of chemical and other examinations. The head and this small piece of handle were now on Mr. Robinson's desk, and were constantly being picked up by him and held for the witness's inspection during his further examination.

Q.—When you found it this piece of handle was in the blade, wasn't it? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—Who took it out? A.—I don't know.

Q.—Did you? A.—No.

Q.—This was all you found? A.—Yes, sir. Q.—Just th[i]s blade, and this little piece of handle? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—And the iron on both sides was covered with ashy dust? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—Was there any dust on the broken wood of the handle here where the break is? A.—It was a new break. I don't think there were ashes on it.

Q.—What did you do with it after you had looked at it? A.—I put it back in the box.

Q.—The box you found it in? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—Did Mullaly see you do it? A.—I dare say he did.

Q.—Did you go off and leave it there? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—You didn't do anything with it at all? A.—No, sir.

WAS IT THE ASSASSIN'S WEAPON?

The relation of this hatchet-head to the crime up to this point in the trial is simply that the length of the blade is identical with the length of the wounds on the bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, though as that fact is only asserted, not proved, presumably the State will hereafter introduce the evidence of Professor Woods, of Harvard, to prove that fresh blood had been on it before it was covered with ashes. The reader of this dispatch will, however, when he has read it through, know as much about this hatchet as the jury yet does.

Two other hatchets, one with a long blade and claw-head, the other ordinary in size and shape, and both supplied with handles, and two axes, have been exhibited in the case. Thus far absolutely nothing has been said to show that the axes and the hatchet of ordinary size and shape had anything to do with the case. The claw-headed, long-bladed hatchet, however, when found by the officers was seen to have a red mark on the handle and a large rusty spot on one side of the blade. To these facts Fleet testified yesterday. Laying down the hatchet-head, and picking up the claw-headed hatchet, Mr. Robinson inquired:

Q.—Do you now see the red spot on the handle of this which you said was there when you found it? A.—No, sir; it isn't here now.

Q.—Who took it off? A.—I don't know.

Q.—Who has had possession of it since you found it? A.—I don't know.

Q.—Well, Lizzie Borden hasn't anyhow, has she? A.—No, sir.

Q.—You'll swear to that? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—Was it a large or small spot? A.—It was a good-sized spot.

Q.—Dirt and blood? A.—I couldn't say.

Q.—Or paint? A.—It might have been blood or paint.

Q.—You saw a rusty spot on the blade too, didn't you? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—Look at the blade now. Is it still there? A.—It does not seem to be there.

Q.—You were able to find it then? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—But you can't find it now? A.—No, sir.

Q.—Who took it off? A.—I don't know.

Q.—Did you? A.—I did not.

Q.—And neither did Lizzie Borden, did she? A.—I think not.

Q.—She couldn't have done it, could she? A.—No, sir.

Q.—What did you do with all these four axes and hatchets when you found them? A.—I put back the two axes and this hatchet (indicating the hatchet of ordinary size and shape with a handle) where I found them. This hatchet (indicating the claw-headed one, on the blade of which there had been a rusty spot, and on the handle of which there had been a red mark) I laid aside.

This evidently was the point Mr. Robinson had been desirous of bringing out. He put down the claw-headed hatchet and again took up the hatchet-head and the little piece of wood belonging to it.

Q.—This hatchet-head was all covered with dust when you found it? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—Both sides? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—And there was dust also on the broken wood, wasn't there—in the break, I mean. A.—No, sir.

Q.—How's that? A.—There was no dust in the break. It looked like a new break.

Q.—But didn't you testify yesterday that there was dust in the break? A.—I think not.

Q.—If you did, was it true? A.—It looked like a new break.

Q.—I didn't ask you that. Listen, and I will read the stenographer's report of what you said yesterday. (Reading.) "There were ashes all over the hatchet, or, may be, dust, but it looked like fine ashes, and there was dust or ashes on the wood in the break." Did you say that? A.—I may have.

FLEET CONTRADICTS HIMSELF.

Q.—Well, what is the truth about it? Did you tell the truth then, or do you tell it now? A.—Well, I think—— (pausing).

Q.—Come, now, take your pick; have it either way; but make a choice. A.—There was no ashes on the break.

Q.—That's your answer, is it? A.—There wasn't much there anyhow.

Q.—Oh, you want to change again, do you? A.—I am answering the best I know.

Q.—Why have you told two different stories about the ashes in this break? A.—I don't know.

Q.—Are both true? A.—They can't be.

Q.—Now, try again. Did you see any ashes on this wood in the break? A.—I don't remember about it.

Q.—You put the hatchet-head back in the box? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—When did you next see it? A.—In Taunton.

Q.—Mr. Fleet, you testified at the preliminary examination in this case, didn't you? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—In your testimony then, did you say a word about this handleless hatchet? A.—No, sir.

Q.—Not a word? A.—No, sir.

Q.—Did anybody tell you not to? A.—No, sir.

Q.—You told about finding the two axes and the two hatchets with handles, didn't you? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—And when you were asked if you found anything else, you said you didn't. Isn't that correct? A.—I said I failed to find anything.

Q.—But you had found this hatchet-head, hadn't you? A.—Yes, sir. Q.—Why didn't you tell them so? A.—Well, I hadn't taken it away.

Q.—Why didn't you take it away? A.—Because I didn't think it important.

Q.—The thing you thought important was the claw-headed hatchet with the rust on the blade and the red mark on the handle, wasn't it? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—And this poor little thing you didn't consider of any account, did you? A.—No, sir.

This completed the examination of Marshal Fleet. It had not ended well for the prosecution. The defence had shown that he had a bad memory; that his search of the house after the murders had been extremely superficial, and that it had not been adequately guarded. They had shown, too, that he was testifying to several things, all extremely important, which in his earlier testimony he had not mentioned. But the incident most destructive of the value of Fleet's evidence was yet to come. It was a complete surprise to Court and counsel.

A SURPRISE TO COURT AND COUNSEL.

Officer Harrington succeeded the marshal on the stand. Harrington is now a captain of the Fall River police. He has been promoted since the Borden murders. So has Fleet, and so have two or three others of the policemen who were engaged in "ferreting out" the Borden mystery. It might have been better, perhaps, had the promoting power awaited the result of this trial before distributing its favors so generously. Officer Harrington was a somewhat la-de-dah young man for a policeman.

He has an exceedingly glib tongue and a truly marvellous facility for describing feminine costumes.

When he was asked what Lizzie Borden had on, here is what he said. Said it quick, as if he had it by heart; said it, too, without a blush:

LIZZIE BORDEN'S DRESS DESCRIBED.

"She was dressed in a house dress, pink, with a pink and light brown stripe alternating. On the light stripe was a diamond figure. The dress fitted close to the form, almost a tailor-made fit, and was shirred at the neck."

The audience began to titter. Governor Robinson stared through his spectacles at the witness; then glanced anxiously at the Court; then drew his hand over his forehead, as if to see if he couldn't get it in, and then said:

"Dear me, dear me. What's that you say?"

"Why, shirred," said Policeman Harrington, with an expression of pained surprise that he did not seem to be understood. "Shirred, you know,—ah, gathered at the neck, that is," and Mr. Harrington, police captain, guardian of our liberties and lives, put up his hand to his throat and made a gesture as if gathering himself in at that point.

Governor Robinson did his best to follow the witness.

"Ah, yes," he said, "I see," and the Governor put up his hand to his throat, and tried to gather himself in as Mr. Harrington had illustrated. "Is that all?" he asked. "It had a number of bows," said Mr. Harrington, "and on either side was a red ribbon about an inch wide, which was brought around and tied in a bow at the front. It was cut en train, or what is called bell skirt."

HARRINGTON'S PROBABLE INSPIRATION.

They say that over Mr. Harrington's desk in his office at Fall River he has a beautifully embroidered perfumed sachet. Maybe it was out of this that he drew the inspiration which enabled him to give so fine a description of a dress which Lizzie Borden did not wear at that time, and has never either worn or possessed. As a description coming from a police officer, it was a wonderful description, and if such a dress had ever been in existence, it would probably have been a wonderful dress. The dress that Lizzie Borden really wore on that occasion was thus described yesterday by her next door neighbor, Mrs. Churchill:

WHAT SHE REALLY WORE.

"It was a light-blue and white ground, with a dark navy-blue diamond spot in it."

Mrs. Churchill had often seen the dress, and in reply to other questions she said that the skirt and the waist were alike; that it was a blouse waist; that the colors in the groundwork were blended, and that the diamond figure was large and conspicuous. When Harrington had done with his shirrs, his stripes, his en traines and his bell skirts, Governor Robinson quietly inquired: Q.—What was your business before you went on the police force? A.—I was a painter.

Q.—And before that? A.—I was in the boot business.

Q.—Were you ever a dressmaker? A.—No, sir.

Q.—Ever in the dry goods business? A.—No, sir.

Q.—Did you ever have anything to do with colors except when you were in the paint business? A.—No, sir, except to admire them.

The Governor threw a native-born Yankee twang into the tones of his voice, and a queer little squint into his eyes, as he asked:

"And do you admire a red ribbon on a pink waist?"

Except for his description of the dress, Officer Harrington's testimony was not notably different from what was said by the rest. There were, how- ever, some points in the evidence which are worth consideration. He says, for instance, that when he asked Lizzie if she had any idea who could have had a motive to kill her father, she said she didn't know of any, and when he asked if robbery might have been the cause, she said: "No, everything is all right, even to his watch and the ring on his finger." THE EVIDENCE ALL INDEFINITE. This is a case in which all the evidence is circum- stantial, all indirect, all scrappy, and indefinite. No one thing signifies much, and 500 things must be taken and put together in order to make a case of any kind. It is worth while to pause, therefore, on this remark of Lizzie's. It showed that the ring on his finger and the watch in his pocket had been in her mind. If innocent, because when she found her father dead she herself looked around for signs of a robbery. If guilty, with the thought of them in her mind, she had utterly neglected to undertake to throw suspicion away from herself by making the mock marks of a robbery. According to the State, the house was in her possession. Except for Bridget in the attic, Lizzie was the only live person there. She herself set the time limit on the affair, for it was she who called Bridget from the attic and Mrs. Churchill from over the fence. If she was so close as she must have been to commit these murders; anyhow, if the watch and the ring were in her mind, as they were when she spoke to Officer Harrington, why might she not have tossed things around, destroyed or concealed or lost in the well a few valuables from the persons of her victims, and then instead of calling Bridget and Mrs. Churchill have quietly walked downtown and paid a visit to a friend? If she was capable of doing the thing as the State says she did it, she was equally capable of doing it thus. If she was as incredibly provident as the State alleges, by the concealment of every trace of how the crime was done, her providence would have been equal to the making of the plan of going downtown and of letting the world do the discovering.

AN UNEXPLAINED INCIDENT.

The witness, in answer to the question what he saw when he went into the kitchen, replied as follows, introducing an incident of which nothing had formerly been said and which is still unexplained:

I saw Dr. Bowen with some scraps of note paper in his hand, standing to the west of the door leading to the rear hall. I asked him what they were, and he said he guessed they had nothing to do with this case. He started to arrange them in some order, as though to read them, and I noticed in the upper left-hand corner of one sheet the word "Emma." The rest was written in lead-pencil. I asked him again what they were, and he said they were from his daughter; then he lifted the lid of the stove and put them in.

Did you notice anything?

I noticed in the south end of the fire box there was a small fire; I should think a coal fire. Some paper had been burned there before, and it had been charred, but still held a cylindrical form. It was about a foot long, two inches in diameter.

Lizzie's unwillingness to allow suspicion to attach to anybody on account of anything she might say was further shown in the talk Mr. Harrington had with her:

I asked her if she had any reason to suspect any one. No matter how insignificant it might appear to her, it might have some bearing on the case. She said: "No, I haven't any. A few weeks ago father had some angry words with a man, but about what I don't know."

I asked her if she heard it. She said: "No, I was in another room." I asked her if her father had said anything about it. She said: "No. About three weeks later he came again, and they had some more angry words, when father went away, and he said to the man if he came in town again to call on him and he might tell him something more definite about the store."

I suggested that she might not be in a frame of mind to give a clear statement of the facts on account of it being so soon after the murder, and perhaps to-morrow might be a better time to talk with her, and that she might give me the name of the man who wanted the store. She answered: "No; I can tell all I know about it now just as well as at any other time."

OFFICER MULLALY'S STORY.

It was late in the afternoon when the dramatic incident occurred to which the testimony of Marshal Fleet about the hatchet head and the little piece of broken wood in it was the prelude. Officer Mullaly was on the stand. He is the man who was in Fleet's company down in the cellar when Fleet found the hatchet and examined it. Fleet testified that Mullaly was there. In his main examination Mullaly's testimony was merely corroborative of what had already been testified to by other policemen. But under the cross-examination of Governor Robinson, he was required to be extremely definite and particular. His story of the discovery of the various hatchets was as follows:

Q.--Who went to the cellar with you the first time? A.--Officer Dougherty and Bridget Sullivan.

Q.--What did Bridget do? A.--She went to show us where the hatchets were.

Q.--What made her do this? A.--Miss Borden said she would show us where the hatchets were.

Q.--Did she call Bridget, or did you ask her? A.--When we got through the attic we went to the cellar direct.

Q.--You had told Bridget what you wanted? A.--Yes.

Q.--And she led the way to the little room on the south side of the house? A.--Yes.

Q.--What did she do? A.--She went where the hatchets were and took them out of the box.

Q.--Did she look around the room? A.--I don't know about looking around. She didn't step around.

Q.--They were in the box? A.--Yes.

Q.--Describe it. A.--It was from 14 to 16 inches long. Q.—Did it have a cover? A.—None that I saw.

Q.—Were things pretty well covered with ashes and dust? A.—The axe handles were pretty well covered.

Q.—How many things did she take out? A.—Two hatchets.

Q.—Did she hand them to you? A.—She did.

Q.—Was one larger than the other? A.—Yes.

Q.—Did they look about the same as now? A.—There was a rust spot on one of them which I don't see now (looking at one which he held in his hand).

Q.—You said that the handle of this hatchet was covered with ashes? A.—I don't say it of that.

Q.—Was there any dust or ashes on the other? (Showing it.) A.—I think this one looked about the same as now.

Q.—Then they were not at that time covered with dust or ashes? A.—No; the axes had their handles covered with dust.

Q.—Did you find them? A.—I won't say if I did or Bridget handed them to me.

Q.—You discovered nothing else on them? A.—I believe the handle of the big hatchet was cleaner than the other.

At this point Mr. Robinson took in his hand the hatchet-head which Fleet had discovered, and asked Mullaly when he first saw it. Mullaly said he saw it when Mr. Fleet called his attention to it.

Q.—How did the metal look? A.—Then as compared with now, it looked different.

Q.—How different? A.—It was covered with ashes.

Q.—It was found in a box, wasn't it? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—Do you know what became of the box? A.—No, sir.

Q.—What was taken out of it while you were there? A.—Nothing but the hatchet and a piece of freshly broken handle.

FLEET'S TESTIMONY CONTRADICTED.

Governor Robinson looked sharply at the witness and then turned around to consult his colleague. Fleet had said time and time again that there was no other piece of handle anywhere discovered except the little bit of wood broken off in the hatchet's eye.

Q.—What do you mean by a piece of freshly broken handle? A.—There was a piece of handle there.

Q.—Detached from the blade? A.—Yes.

Q.—Where is it? A.—I'm sure I don't know.

Q.—Did you ever see it after that? A.—Never.

Q.—Who took it out? A.—Mr. Fleet.

Q.—How long was it? A.—Somewhat shorter than the handles of those hatchets there on the table.

Q.—You say you saw Mr. Fleet take that piece of handle out of the box? A.—Yes, sir; I saw him.

Q.—And did you see him put it back? A.—Yes, sir. I saw him put it back.

Governor Robinson paused again. His colleague, Mr. Adams, keenly alive to the importance of this disclosure, had sent out an officer of the court to find Marshal Fleet and to see to it that no one had a chance to talk with him until he was brought back to the court-room. This was a wise precaution. Turning once more to the witness, Mr. Robinson said:

"You are perfectly sure of the facts which you are now testifying to, are you, Mr. Mullaly?" Mr. Mullally said he was, and seemed surprised that there was so much fuss about it.

District-Attorney Moody seemed anxious to take a hand in the proceedings; in fact, to take control of them. Addressing the court, he said:

"Your Honors, nothing was said on the direct examination about this piece of wood. I submit that I ought to be allowed to inquire about it before the defence proceeds with its cross-examination."

The court put their heads together and held a short but animated conversation. Then the Chief Justice quietly observed: "Mr. Robinson will proceed with his cross-examination." Whereupon Mr. Moody dropped back into his seat.

"Did you ever tell this to any one before?" asked Mr. Robinson.

The witness said he never did.

Q.--Do you know where Mr. Fleet is now? A.--I don't know, sir.

Q.--Is he below? A.--I don't know.

Governor Robinson--You will remain where you are, sir, and we will await the result of the effort we are making to find Mr. Fleet.

FLEET BROUGHT BACK TO COURT.

Officers were moving in all directions upon this quest. It appeared also that one of Fleet's Fall River police, who had been hanging around and had observed the extraordinary contradiction between his and Mullaly's evidence, had also started on the hunt for him. This man approached Fleet just as he was seized by one of the officers of the court. He endeavored to engage Fleet in conversation, but the court officer interfered, and hustled him away. Fleet was brought into the courtroom without having received any intimation of the situation. He looked surprised, and of course he realized that something was the matter. He took his place on the witness-stand, however, and awaited developments.

Meanwhile an interesting altercation had taken place between counsel. Governor Robinson made a formal demand on District Attorney Knowlton for the production of that piece of handle, but the District-Attorney, who was evidently as much surprised as anybody else at the turn the evidence had taken, insisted that he had never heard of it before.

When Fleet appeared Mr. Moody again insisted on his right of questioning the officer in direct examination before the defence was permitted to get at him. Mr. Moody, indeed, started to do so, and perhaps to give Fleet an intimation of what the matter was. But Governor Robinson sternly checked the District-Attorney, and the court quickly intervened, directing the defence to go ahead. Then came these questions and answers:

Q.—Recalling to your mind, Mr. Fleet, the box which you found in the cellar, in which you said you found this hatchet here, please state what was in that box and all what was there? A.—There were some other tools, and some scraps of iron. I don't know just what they were.

Q.—Who was with you when you examined the box? A.—Mr. Mullaly.

Q.—Anybody else? A.—No, sir.

Governor Robinson held up the hatchet-head and the little piece of wood that had been fastened in its eye.

Q.—You found these there, didn't you? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—This small piece of wood was then in the eye of the hatchet—so, wasn't it? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—Was there any other wood in the box? A.—No.

Q.—Now, Mr. Fleet, answer me this: Did you find in that box any other part of this hatchet than this blade and this little piece of the handle? A.—No, sir.

Q.—You found no other part of the handle? A.—No, sir.

Q.—You're sure of that? A.—No.

FLEET GREATLY PERPLEXED.

Mr. Fleet was evidently much perplexed and troubled. His swarthy face was quite red, and he was slow to answer. Finally, however, he said: I found, no other part of the handle. Q.—Are you positively sure of that? A.—Yes, sir.

Q.—As sure as you are of anything else to which you have testified? A.—Yes, sir.

Governor Robinson looked keenly and fixedly at Fleet. Then he turned and looked at the jury. Every man of them was turned full toward the witness, and had watched his every motion and had heard his every word. The court, too, had drawn forward, and had kept sharp and critical watch upon the scene. The great crowd in the courtroom was absolutely still. Every eye was fixed upon the witness. Governor Robinson turned from the jury to the court; from the court he looked full and hard into the faces of the prosecuting officers. Then he dropped into his seat. "That will do," he said.

It was a most extraordinary scene, the fitting close of an extraordinary day in the trial of one of the most confused, strange, unnatural, improbable and altogether mysterious cases of homicide known in the history of crime. The further testimony of the day was unimportant. There was little of it.

Just before the adjournment the prosecution offered in evidence the testimony of Lizzie Borden given at the Coroner's inquest just after she was arrested, after she had been taking morphine daily for over a week, upon her physician's prescription, and at hearings where she was produced by subpoena and compelled to testify without the presence or assistance of couns[e]l. In New-York this evidence would be clearly inadmissible. There is a statue existing protecting accused persons and enabling them to decline to testify without pleading their statutory privilege, and forbidding the use upon their trial of any involuntary statement. This law was elucidated by the Court of Appeals when it decided that Judge Barrett had erred in admitting upon the trial of Jacob Sharp the evidence he had given before the Senate Committee. In Massachusetts, however, there is no statute bearing on this matter.

The defence objected to Mr. Moody's motion on the common law principle that no one can be compelled to testify against himself. Neither side seemed ready to argue the issue at once, and the argument was deferred until Monday. Later the attorneys on both sides met in conference and to-night it is announced that they have agreed on a statement of facts to be presented. If the evidence is admitted the defence will of course explain the numerous contradictions by saying that Lizzie was under the influence of morphine.

MISS BORDEN LIKELY TO TESTIFY.

It is almost certain that in any event she will herself go on the stand. The prosecution will have an opportunity to cross-examine her on any changes there may be in the story she tells now from that she told at the inquest.

Every day adds to the improbability that Lizzie Borden committed these murders. Every day brings out developments that seem to render such a thing incredible. It is an incomparable case.

See the clipping

Her inquest statements kept out

A point for the defense: all three judges sustain ex-Governor Robinson’s contention that at the inquest Lizzie Borden was in effect a prisoner, her testimony ‘in No Sense Voluntary’, and keep it from the jury. She bursts into tears as the decision is announced. A Pennsylvania report the next day judged that without the inquest evidence the prosecution would have to get along as best it could.

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The Sun · 13 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

A POINT FOR LIZZIE BORDEN.

HER TESTIMONY AT THE INQUEST EXCLUDED AT THE TRIAL.

See moreSee less

Gov. Robinson's Contention that at the Time of the Inquest Miss Borden Was in Effect a Prisoner, and that Her Testimony Was in No Sense Voluntary, is Sustained by All Three of the Judges—The Prisoner Bursts Into Tears and Her Body Shakes with Suppressed Emotion as the Decision is Announced—Gruesome Exhibits in the Case—The Hatchet.

NEW BEDFORD, June 12.—The seventh day of the Borden trial did not discredit the reputation the cause has earned as unique and crowded with sensations. Gore and hatchets, axes, plaster casts that might have been borrowed from a Bowery chamber of horrors, bloody garments, bits of bloody carpet and blood-spattered furniture and house fittings—these were the stage properties in this legal drama that is winding itself out to the length of a Chinese play. The talk of the witnesses and lawyers went further and dealt with autopsies, and even with things that, though not unfit for publication, are yet much better out of print than in it. In the hallway just outside the court room was the bloody sofa on which poor old Mr. Borden died so horribly. It was covered all over with gunny sacking, but whoever did not know what it was had it pointed out, so that all were prepared on the very threshold for the legal saturnalia that was to go on within.

Miss Borden is not well, and her face and manner showed it. She is utterly at fault with the reputation she first set up as a human barometer that showed each morning what the state of her cause would be during the day. Her illness is trifling, but it served to bring her before to-day's crowd of spectators with all her old heaviness of features and absence of facial mobility. At the jail it is explained that it was the grip that she had in Taunton, and, though she had it lightly, she is far from well of it. Those who are superstitious have given her up as a guide to each day's developments, and now depend upon a study of the flowers that deck the bench before the three grizzled Judges. They repaid the glances that were bestowed upon them, for where the blue heliotropes had been on Saturday there stood a vase of white carnations—snow-white ones—between the guilty red ones and the uncertain pallid pinks. Much the most important event of the day was the argument for and against the admissibility of the testimony Miss Borden gave at the inquest, when District-Attorney Knowlton questioned her and she made contradictory replies to questions as to her whereabouts at the time her father must have been butchered. It will be remembered that this battle for and against the admission of this testimony raises a new point in law in the old Bay State. But that is important outside of this cause. What was important here was how the Court would decide it, for all who are pledged to convict Miss Borden if they can were most anxious to get in the testimony, while her friends were as intensely desirous of keeping it out. The Government would have liked to have read what she said on that occasion for the edification of this jury; and then, again, if it was admitted they could cross-examine her upon it all over again in case she should be put on the stand. Miss Borden's lawyers were opposed to this course because they say she was under the influence of morphine, and because she was without guidance by counsel and was in the hands of Mr. Knowlton, whose manner toward her, as well as his persistence in construing every act and word of her's against her, has led her to fear him and to shrink ward from him as, perhaps, any woman so placed would fear a powerful man whom she regarded as her enemy and persecutor. Out of court, in the hotel, and the streets it has been popularly believed that it would be a bad day for the prisoner when this testimony, given in her befogged condition during a day of badgering, should be read to this jury. Some wanted her to have the worst that could befall her. Others wanted her to have a fresh bill of health with which to meet this ordeal. Thus is society here rent in twain upon the question of her guilt or innocence. As to the new point in law, the facts are these: Plenty of persons in Massachusetts have borne witness at inquests and inquiries and then been accused and confronted with their own previous testimony, but in every such case the first testimony has been given voluntarily. The point raised in this cause was that Miss Borden did not give voluntary testimony at the inquest after the murders in her home. Her lawyers hold that she was not formally arrested, but that she was to all intents a prisoner and accused of committing the crimes. A warrant was indeed out for her, she was surrounded and watched by the police, she was told by the Government that she had got to answer its questions "if she stood on the stand all day." The benefit of counsel was denied to her and she stood alone, a helpless woman who had never been in a court before, surrounded by this band of police and Government officials that now again gather at the Court House door and is seen to be the source of nine-tenths of the evidence in the case against her. This morning was set apart for the hearing of this argument. The court room was crowded. Even on the sidewalk the lawyers had to struggle to get through the perpetual and now swollen crowd of women idlers. Great was the curiosity to hear the master lawyer, ex-Gov. Robinson, as a speech maker. District Attorney Moody, assistant to the local District Attorney, made the argument for the admission of the woman's previous testimony, and addressed himself solely to the Court and to the legal precedents for what he demanded. It was to be presumed that Gov. Robinson would follow the same course, but he had his client's cause too deeply at heart, and he departed so far from a merely legal argument that the audience enjoyed a sample of the eloquence and art that makes him so strong before a jury. Miss Borden got leave to retire during the argument, and the jury was excluded from the room. After two hours of talking pro and con, the three dignified Judges left the room to consult and reach their decision. They were gone a little more than an hour. When they filed back into the room and the High Sheriff, with his suit of blue and brass, commanded all to rise until the Court was seated, the strain upon the people in the room was such that at the end an explosion of suppressed sounds marked the relief that had come to all.

The Judges found that Miss Borden had been to all intents and purposes a prisoner charged with two murders, and her testimony at the inquest was not voluntary. The feeling of both sides in the controversy over her guilt was that this was a grand piece of good fortune for her. When the decision was reached by the Chief Justice there was a man in front of and a man behind the correspondent of THE SUN. Both spoke to him, and almost simultaneously. "That is logic and good law," said one, "the Commonwealth would have been disgraced [by] any other decision." "Great God!" said the other, "it is a crying shame that justice should be defeated and a murderer protected because of so slight a point as that decision is based upon." Miss Borden had come into the room and was sitting behind Mr. Robinson. She burst into tears, hiding her face in her handkerchief, while her body shook with the force of her emotion. It was then that all who had felt the strain of the uncertainty as to the decision of the Court first realized what that strain must have been in the case of the prisoner. She wore a new dress and it was one that was many times more expensive than the old one which had grown so very familiar. This new one was a black silk covered with fine black lace. The lace fell over her shoulders and was treated with artistic taste in the decoration of the front of the basque. Her hat was the same one she had worn before. It has been said in these reports that this young woman has no art. That is a mistake. She has shown little weaknesses and her own conceptions of what she ought and ought not to do under given circumstances. These are seen in trifling ways, and accurate knowledge of her develops very slowly, for she is extraordinarily phlegmatic and undemonstrative, yet she is no more ingenuous than the rest of us. Whenever the lawyers who oppose her come to the subject of bloodstains, and the discussion of the gory details of the murders, she hides her face in her hands, but when her own lawyers take up the same subjects of inquiry she keeps her head up and her eyes bright, and tries not to miss a word of what is said. At first it was thought she could not endure the horrible topic, but enough time has passed to show that it depends upon who discusses it. Of course, this is very natural, and quite feminine, and amounts to nothing one way or the other, yet a great many things that are not important are watched just as if they were. Miss Borden's womanhood was fully established when she burst into tears at hearing the decision of the lawyers, and with womanhood there must be at least a modicum of the arts and ways of femininity.

Seldom can any person have seen quite such another woman as this prisoner. Her face is part of the time like that of a graven image, and at other times it is as responsive to one emotion as the face of an actor. That one emotion is her sense of the ridiculous. She has been seen to weep but once, and that was to-day. Her father never even once gave relief to his sorrow or joy in tears. She has laughed many times thus far in court. Mr. Robinson made her laugh more than once today. In repose hers is a dull and lifeless looking face. When she smiles or laughs it is a bright and sensitive countenance, but her evidences of pleasure and humor are very evanescent. Always in a minute she casts off all traces of what stirred her, and her face becomes once again a dull and heavy mask.

The occasion for the exhibition of all the Government's ghastly trophies was the appearance on the witness stand of Dr. Dolan, the medical examiner of Fall River, custodian of the skulls of the dead couple, performer of the autopsy, measurer of the blood spots in the house, and analyst of the contents of the stomachs of the deceased couple. The Doctor in private life may be a pleasant man for a lady's tea party, but on the witness stand he shows himself competent to add new horrors to the most bloody murder case in New England's history.

The proceedings opened with the withdrawal of the jurors and the hearing of the arguments on the admissibility of Miss Borden's testimony at the inquest. The argument took practically all the morning. Mr. Moody, District Attorney for Essex, argued for the admission of the testimony, and ex-Gov. Robinson argued against it for Miss Borden. Mr. Moody argued; Gov. Robinson made a speech. By permission of the Court Miss Borden left the room while the arguments were made and went down stairs and sat in a room by herself.

After quoting or citing one case after another, mainly causes tried in other States, Mr. Moody said:

"It becomes evident that what a person says at the inquest becomes competent if that person is afterward charged with the crime."

He repeated this in this form: "On an inquiry as to the death of a person, if one who is under suspicion is informed that he is under suspicion, and responds to the call of the State and voluntarily gives testimony, what he has said at the inquiry is admissible against him. It is a matter within the knowledge of your Honors and of the counsel for the prosecution that hardly a term of this court passes without the admission of precisely this [a]gainst kind of testimony which is sought to be introduced in this case."

He told of a woman charged with burning a building who was first tried for arson and then put to the bar for perjury on her testimony at the fire inquest. Mr. Moody reminded the Court that the Government could take no exception if the testimony was ruled out, whereas if it were admitted the defence could appeal to the Supreme Court.

When he concluded, Mr. Robinson spoke for the prisoner. "Your Honors are to inquire if these have been departures from the established view of the law, and if they have been rightly taken. This court is not to take chances. We stand to-day on the right of this defendant, at this hour, no matter what the variations have been. Whatever has been done it shall have no effect unless it receives the sanction of the highest judicial tribunal in the Commonwealth."

The ex-Governor produced several copies in typewriting of points he had jotted down and meant to enlarge upon in his argument. He received permission to hand these copies to the Judges and the lawyers for the Commonwealth. Taking a copy of his own in his hand he used it as a guide. The first point in the list was that the medical examiner is shown by the evidence to have taken charge of the bodies upon which the inquest was to have been held. Second, Miss Borden testified on Aug. 9, 10, and 11. From the second day after the crimes the woman was kept under the constant observation of the police, all the time until the conclusion of her testimony. Her house was surrounded by the police, there was no time, day or night, when the eye of the police was not on her house and all the inmates of it. So far as any effect on the defendant was concerned she knew the police were around her and she was under uninterrupted surveillance. Before testifying the defendant made a request for counsel. This was denied, and no counsel was allowed to her, she stood alone, a woman, for three days, unguarded by counsel, confronted by the District Attorney, watched by the City Marshal, and at all times surrounded by the police.

The next point made by the shrewd and earnest ex-Governor was that Miss Borden was not properly cautioned.

"The complaint had been made against her and the warrant for her arrest was issued. That mandate was held by the Marshal when he escorted that woman to the inquest. Can any one say she had not been proceeded against? She had not been formally arrested, nay, but the Commonwealth had asserted its power and the City Marshal stood ready at any moment to make her his prisoner. We must assume in common sense that that was at the direction of the District Attorney. It was not at random that that was done. Some one in authority asked it. She was, in fact, a prisoner, never free. Then, later, she was arrested on another warrant. Perhaps this was done in order to say she was arrested subsequent to her testimony; so that, perhaps, without its being intended, it was, in fact, an evasion of the law. It may appear, it might appear, to deprive this defendant of the rights guaranteed to her by the laws.

"She was a woman, she couldn't run, with the hand ever on her shoulder, under those circumstances she was taken to the inquest to testify, with no one authorized to tell her or who was bound to tell her that she had any rights at all. She stood alone. a defenceless woman. in that attitude. If that is freedom. God save the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. If anything that is done by a woman under such circumstances is voluntary, then compulsory must hereafter be known as voluntary.

"The crimes had been committed. and knowledge of the fact was in the possession of the law. That inquiry was only used to extort from this woman something to be used against her in her trial.

"It is not to be lost sight of," the Governor continued, "that at the time she was examined she had been formally charged with the commission of the murders. She was not summoned in order to find who had done the deed, for the Government had already sworn that she did it. Instead of serving that warrant they hid it away and said to themselves that perhaps they could get something out of her before they served it. Then they issued another warrant, and said that they would consider her testimony as previous to that warrant. I hope I have not said more than I ought to. If I do so I hope the court will consider that it is the defendant who is speaking to you out of her knowledge of her experience in Fall River and out of a jealous regard for her rights, into which she was born.

"It makes no difference that our statutes say a defendant so placed may testify, if he or she so desires, for they say, further, that no inference is to be drawn against her from the fact that he or she refuses to testify. We hear the constitution of Massachusetts read, and it passes glibly over the tongue, in and out, and that until some one plants his feet upon it and fails to recognize its declarations. Miss Borden stands on that ancient document to-day. It says that no person shall be forced to testify against herself. It was written when Massachusetts was born. It was the instinct of that hour. It has been the bulwark of our liberties ever since. When the Constitution of the United States was drawn it said in simple phrase: 'No person shall be compelled in any criminal cause to be a witness against himself. The shield of the State and the shield of the nation are her protection in this hour.'"

Leaving his notes and turning to the consideration of the precedents offered by the Commonwealth, the ex-Governor said a number of things which, taken at random, show the drift of his argument, the drift being all that there is room to report here. For instance, he said that it was true that the unserved warrant was in the Marshal's pocket. But that pocket did not belong to Marshal Hilliard; it was the pocket of the Commonwealth.

"The Commonwealth was bound to say to a woman in her position. We ask you nothing. We don't want to put you on the rack or fail to caution you or exclude your counsel. We won't do that because we have charged you with the crime. We have accused you in court and put a warrant for your arrest in the City Marshal's hands, and we will not ask you a question. That is what old Massachusetts wanted to speak in the ear of that woman that day, but the Commonwealth did not have that voice."

Mr. Robinson having finished his argument, Mr. Moody arose to reply for the Government. "I could not help," said he, "when hearing what my learned friend was pleased to call his argument, recalling the remark made by a French officer upon hearing of the charge of the Light Brigade--slightly changed to suit this case--it is magnificent, but it is not law. This delivery is surrounded by many vocal gymnastics and fireworks, but it is not law. I had hesitated to say that there is no precedent for the position taken by the defence, but now that the other side has finished its argument, we can safely assume that there is not any case or precedent to justify the exclusion of this testimony in this case. All this wasted rhetoric is due to misunderstanding of the law. It was the duty of the Court to make inquiry beyond the mere finding that a crime had been committed.

In explanation of this assertion Mr. Moody said that there were but two persons in the house when the murders were committed, and added: "Does any one say that it is not competent to examine them as to this crime?" Again he asserted stoutly that "Miss Borden was represented by counsel who was also her friend, though that does not appear in the evidence, and before she appeared under examination we certainly can presume that he cautioned her on her rights, and gave her full counsel, and she knew her rights when she went into the court room. She testified as a voluntary witness in every sense of the word, legal or otherwise. It was not a case of failure to caution, but a case where she was cautioned, a case of the exercise of caution in the most considerate way that could have been chosen. Mr. Moody denied that the District Attorney knew of the issue of the first warrant, gotten out before Miss Borden testified and never used. "It is not proven that the District Attorney knew of it," said Mr. Moody "and any assumption on the part of our learned friends that the District Attorney knew of it is entirely unwarranted. Later he said: "No case has been cited over the length and breadth of this land or England to warrant the exclusion of this testimony." At the conclusion he mentioned the very important fact that has been already explained when he said: "Even if you admit this testimony the rights of the defendant will still be protected." It was half past 11 o'clock when, with customary formality and dignity, the three Judges withdrew to consider the arguments. It was twenty minutes to 1 o'clock when they returned. Chief Justice Mason always shows a sad and almost melancholy face, but this appearance was exaggerated strangely when he came back into court on this occasion. He looked so sad as to all but draw tears, if not to shed them. It was as if he was going to sentence Miss Borden to death, and yet in fact he was really the messenger who brought to her the best news she has heard since her arrest. He sat in impressive silence for a full minute, looking the whole court room over, and then he picked up a pair of spectacles, adjusted them slowly and carefully before his eyes, and read the decision he and his associates had reached. It was as follows: The propriety of examining the prisoner and of all that occurred in connection therewith is entirely distinct from the question of the admissibility of her statements at that examination. It is with the latter question that this Court has to deal. The common law regards this species of evidence with distrust; statements made by one accused of crime are admissible against him only when it is affirmatively established that they were voluntarily made. It has been held that statements of the accused as a witness under oath at an inquest before he had been arrested or charged with the crime under investigation may be voluntary and admissible against him in his subsequent trial, and the mere fact that at the time of his testimony at the inquest he was suspected of the crime does not make them otherwise. But we are of the opinion, upon principle and authority, that if the accused was at the time under arrest charged with the crime in question, the statements so made are not voluntary and are inadmissible at the trial.

The common law regards substance more than form. The principle involved cannot be evaded by avoiding the form of arrest. If the witness at the time of such testimony is practically in custody—from the agreed facts and the facts otherwise in evidence, the prisoner at the time of her testimony was, so far as relates to this question, as effectually in custody as if a formal precept had been served, and without dwelling on other circumstances which distinguish the facts in this case from other cases on which the Government rely—we are all of the opinion that this consideration is decisive, and the evidence is excluded.

Miss Borden, in her chair in front of the dock and close behind the line of chairs in which her lawyers sat, leaned forward and drank in every word of the decision. For a moment after the reading and during the veritable gush of relief that sounded in the court, she still sat thus stoical and heavy faced. Then, like lightning, a purple cast spread all over her face, her hand sought her handkerchief, and almost too quickly for her to get it to her face the tears shot into her eyes. A strange, strong convulsion racked her body at the same moment. She pressed the handkerchief almost into her eyes, and again and again her body shook with the sobbing form that her overstrained emo- [...]sion Packe[t?] tion took. She was soon able to control her- self, but when she showed her face again it was blue. She then had recourse to her smell-

ing bottle.

Albert C. Dedrick, a doctor, was put on the stand to show that Mrs. Borden died first—a fact that the defence admitted when the trial began. Joseph Hyde followed with a sort of a bugaboo story about how he saw Miss Bor- den go down cellar on the night of the day of the murder with a lamp and followed by Miss Russell. She had a slop pail and she emptied it in the water closet.

Miss Russell was dreadfully frightened—she shook with fright. By and by, while the wit- ness, who is a Fall River policeman, was watching the cellar window, down came Miss Borden again with a lamp and was seen to stoop over the sink within five or six feet of the tub full of bloody clothing that had been taken from the bodies of the murdered couple.

That was all he had to say, but ex-Gov. Rob- inson made him say it all over again with great elaboration, as if to show how utterly without significance it was. That is, it was without significance, as it seemed that the prisoner's second visit to the cellar had to do with a certain pailful of towels that was in the cellar and which both sides have agreed not to discuss during this trial.

"How long was she there in the cellar?" the Governor asked. "Not a minute," said the witness. "You know the pail that was in the cellar; was it right there?" indicating on the dia- gram of the cellar. "Pretty near there," said the Fall River po- liceman. "Yes, I thought so," said the ex-Governor, triumphantly.

Dr. William A. Dolan, the medical examiner, was the next witness called. District Attorney Knowlton made his first appearance as an examiner in handling this trump witness for the Commonwealth. District Attorney Moody has done all the examining of the Government witnesses up to this point, but he has worked too hard and is very tired. Dr. Dolan told Mr. Knowlton that when he saw Miss Lizzie Borden soon after the discovery of the murders, she told him that Mrs. Borden had got a note from some one who was sick and had gone out earlier in the morning. Asked where the note was, she said she did not know; she thought probably that Mrs. Borden had burned it in the kitchen stove. The Doctor told how he saw Mr. Borden's body, freshly murdered, with bright blood oozing from it.

The prisoner covered her face with her great black fan. She kept it covered while the Doctor told of seeing Mrs. Borden's dead body all covered and with the blood dried and powdery in her matted hair.

Mr. Knowlton, heavy voiced, big bodied, and with the appearance of a redoubtable Roundhead of Cromwell's time, waved the blood-saturated handkerchief that was found beside Mrs. Borden at the witness and asked him what he knew about it. Witness Dolan knew that it was buried with the rest of the things found on the murdered couple. These things were dug up by the Commonwealth and certain articles were recovered. Then the handkerchief was buried again, and again it was dug up and preserved. The sturdy Roundhead produced a yard of light carpet horribly stained with Mr. Borden's blood and a smaller piece of dark carpet still like leather with the blood of Mrs. Borden.

The witness identified both, and they were put in as exhibits, while Miss Borden pressed the edge of her fan against her eyes. Then the medical examiner went on to say that Mr. Borden wore a Cardigan jacket, and that he (Dr. Dolan) found $81.65 and a silver watch and chain on the old man's person.

The medical examiner got Bridget Sullivan to give him samples of that day's milk and of the milk delivered on the morning before. The prussic acid theory was rampant soon afterward, and possibly the witness was expecting to find some of that poison in the milk. Nothing was found in it, by the way. But this is aside from his testimony. He next identified the clanking hatchets and axes, and said he took out the stomachs of the victims, put them in jars, sealed the jars, and sent them to Prof. Wood of Harvard.

At this point half the people in court were looking at Miss Borden and believed she was going to swoon again. It was another hot day, like the one a week ago to-day when she did faint. Two deputy sheriffs jumped in opposite directions to get water for her, and after a deep draught from the glass that came to her first she appeared to recover. She had made no demonstration except that her face had become blue and she had been resting heavily on the rail beside her.

The medical man next examined the counterpane from the bed in the room where Mrs. Borden died, and as it was held up a solitary spot of blood was found on it. Next, an apparently spotless slab of marble from the washstand in the same room was brought in and identified. After that, pieces of door jambs and great hunks of wainscotting were paraded be[f]ore the witness and the jury identified, and piled up on the table before the jury box. The witness ventured the remark that he also had the shoes and stockings of the victims which had been sent to Prof. Woods. There was a feeling of relief when District Attorney Knowlton said he was not going to produce the clothing taken from the dead bodies. He added that if anybody wanted he would send and get it. He did not address the prisoner's counsel, but looked around the court room as if he thought the reporters or the women on the back benches were going to express a wish to have the mortuary relics sent to their home addresses at once. The witness got in a great bother in trying to get the hang of one of Miss Lizzie Borden's white petticoats. It was the skirt she wore on the morning of the murder, and it had a stain of blood down by the hem in the front of the garment. Whether the blood is to figure as important in the trial has not yet been developed. The clumsy witness tried to get the pesky garment straightened out so as to show where the stain was, and in the course of five minutes he gave it up. Mr. Knowlton next sent for and got a plaster bust or cast of a man's head and chest at the top of a plaster pedestal. It was one of those casts that Italian modellers peddle around New York, and was the identical one that they sometimes sell as the head of Tasso and at other times as that of Julius Caesar. In the language of the school children, he played it was the head of the murdered Mr. Borden. He steadied it on the rail before the jury and began to mark it all over with blue strokes to show where the blows were rained by the murderer upon the old man's face and head. There were ten of these blows, one cut one eye in half, another split the mouth and chin. Six of the blows sunk into the brain. The Doctor gave the measurements of the wounds. He said that one was four inches long, another was three and a half inches long, and another was only two inches in length. This was important, because when Mr. Moody introduced the hoodoo hatchet he said it was three inches and a half in length on the edge of the blade, and that was the precise length of the principal wounds it made.

Mr. Knowlton got the witness to say he had the skulls, and then asked him to explain the process by which they were cleaned and prepared. To his credit be it said that he did not pursue that branch of the inquiry and the witness did not answer him. Mr. Borden's was comparatively a thin skull, the witness said. He next went into a dissertation upon the contents of the stomachs of the murdered man and woman, the purpose being to show that in the woman the morning meal was not digested, while in the man it was nearly all digested.

There was one great gash upon Mrs. Borden that was not on her head. It was on her back at the base of the neck and top of the spine. The witness put down the plaster cast representing Mr. Borden and took up one no longer than a clothespin and no bigger than a woman's fist, offered by Mr. Knowlton as a model for describing Mrs. Borden's wounds. It looked like the head that the Italians offer as that of the good Saint Anthony. The witness, in [l]ist, describing these wounds, said that a space of Mrs. Borden's skull four or five inches long and an inch wide was crushed in. Two dramatic questions, or one that was put twice with a slight change the second time, were then put by the District Attorney. "In your opinion, were the wounds found on the head of Mr. Borden such as could have been inflicted with a hatchet by a woman of ordinary strength?" "Yes." "In your opinion, were the wounds found on the head of Mrs. Borden such as could have been inflicted with a hatchet by a woman of ordinary strength?" "Yes." Finally the witness said that Mrs. Borden appeared to have died first. The afternoon wore along and time did not cause Miss Lizzie Borden to change her position or cease to conceal her face. She had brought into court a bunch of pansies, and these she left lying in her lap. Ophelia's words, "There is pansies, that's for thought" leaped to the mind. What thoughts were these delicate flowers dedicated to upon this occasion? If to the prisoner's, who would dare to say what was their nature? Were they guiltless as those of the poor mad girl in the play, or deep and damned like Lady Macbeth's? Mr. Melville O. Adams of Boston took the witness in hand for cross-examination. The elastic and accommodating character of Fall River testimony has become proverbial, but the depth and extent of its peculiarities had not yet been measured, it seems. When Dr. Dolan came into the hands of Mr. Adams the hoodoo hatchet began its pranks again, and it again began to play its demonish havoc. It was not brought out, it is true; it was not even directly referred to, but Dr. Dolan is one of its sponsors and has been its guardian. That is enough for this bewitched destroyer of firewood and Fall River officials. Mr. Adams took up the claw-hammer hatchet, which the police first thought to be the murderer's weapon, because it looked as if it had been scraped and cleaned. It measures four and a half inches on the edge of its blade, and therefore is longer than the longest wound in either of the victims. Everything was made to conform to the theory that this was the guilty weapon, when the previous examination in the case was made in court. After that the handleless or hoodoo hatchet was suspected of being the murderous weapon and the Fall River officials came into new conclusions. "Do you remember having testified that this claw-hammer hatchet was adequate to cause the wounds on the skulls of the victims?" Mr. Adams asked. "Yes, sir." "Do you care to change that opinion now?" "I do." "Why?" "Because that hatchet is four and a half inches long," said the Doctor. The reader will remember that the later and pet hatchet, called the hoodoo, is but three and a half inches long on the blade. "Do you remember at a former trial I gave you a china doll's head, and you marked it to show a certain wound on Mrs. Borden's head?" "Yes." "The skull was crushed in?" "Yes." "And did you not call attention to the claw head of this hatchet and say, it was made by that?" "Yes." "Do you desire to change that answer?" "Yes." "Why?" "Because I don't think it was done with that instrument." "Why?" "I had not then prepared the skulls." "What? Did you not have the skulls at that time?" "I would not say so. At least they were not prepared" "Did you not say they were?" "I don't remember; but I certainly had not examined them." "You described the hatchet that made the wounds as one with a cutting edge of about five inches, if not more?" "Yes, sir." "Did you notify the daughters, or either of them, or any one of the family, that you was about to take the heads and skulls?" "No, sir." "When you had done it did you notify these daughters, or either of them, that you had done so?" "No." "Did you notify them that the interment occurred under such circumstances as that?" "No, sir." These questions and answers fell upon the court room air with theatrical force, and nearly all eyes were turned upon the lonely girl in deep black as she sat listening with her calm face. A new bond of sympathy was created for her in every sympathetic heart. heart, and for her sister also, who had not been told what dismemberment followed the mutilation of the bodies of their father and stepmother.

The witness said that not counting the contusions or the wounds on Mrs. Borden's back the woman was butchered with eighteen strokes of an axe.

"Did you swear there was blood on one of the hatchets?" Mr. Adams asked, meaning the claw-hammer one which was the basis of the earliest Fall River findings.

"No, sir; only the appearances of it," said the witness.

"Did you say there was hair on that one?" "Yes, sir."

And so there was, the hair of a cow, it will be remembered.

Then, after the crier had cried "Hear ye!" once for every Judge on the bench and had asked God to save the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, the day's proceedings ended.

See the clipping

No blood on the handleless hatchet

The Evening Herald of Shenandoah, Pa., on the medical evidence. Professor Wood of Harvard found no poison in the stomachs or the milk, and no blood on the claw-hammer hatchet, the axe or the blue dress; the handleless hatchet bore none either, though he allowed it might have been cleaned. On such evidence, the paper judged, ‘she will never be convicted’, and some lawyers had gone home expecting acquittal.

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The Evening Herald · 14 June 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

MISS BORDEN AFFECTED

She Would Not Listen to Dr. Draper's Testimony.

See moreSee less

SKULLS PRODUCED IN COURT

Evidence to Show That the Instrument Which Made the Wounds Was Three and One-Half Inches Long, the Exact Length of the Handleless Hatchet.

NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 14.—Long before the appointed time the court room was crowded. Lizzie Borden came in a few minutes before 9 o'clock, and shortly after that time the proceedings of the ninth day began.

When court opened yesterday Dr. Dolan took the stand again, and Mr. Adams continued his cross-examination. A manikin's head was set up on a chair beside the jury box and the doctor described how the blows fell upon the head of Mr. Borden when he was murdered.

He described the position of the b dies and the blood spots and said the blows came from left to right and were of moderate force. The prisoner sat with closed eyes and a fan over her face.

Continuing, Dr. Dolan said that the blows were made by a sharp instrument, and some of them on Mrs. Borden by an assailant astride of the body. A juryman was taken sick and a recess of five minutes was taken. The prisoner was affected, and was led from the room.

When the session was resumed, Dr. Dolan admitted testifying in preliminary hearing that Mrs. Borden's death was an hour to an hour and a half before his examination of her, but now thought it was an hour to an hour and a half before Mr. Borden's death. He could not safely judge priority within an hour from blood coagulation alone or from digestion alone, if they had been sick.

On re-cross examination Dr. Dolan said the length of the wound would not determine the length of the edge of the instrument.

Dr. E. S. Wood, of Harvard Medical College, was then called and described the examination of the stomachs.

Prof. Wood found nothing to indicate disease or irritation in either stomach, and their contents showed a difference of an hour and a half in the time of death. There was no evidence of poison in the stomachs or in the milk used by the family on Aug. 3 and 4. Examination showed no blood on the claw-hammered hatchet or axe or on the blue dress. The hair found on this hatchet was not human.

Prof. Wood said the blood spot on the white skirt probably came from outside and was human blood. The shoes and stockings and dining-room door casing had no blood spots. The handleless hatchet had no blood. The break in its handle contained no dust.

The handleless hatchet had dust like ashes on the blade tightly adhering. Under defendant's objection and exception, Prof. Wood testified that the handleless hatchet might have been cleaned of blood before the handle was broken off.

Dr. Draper then took the stand and described the wounds in the skull of Mr. Borden.

Cross-examined by Mr. Adams—Witness said the heaviest blow given Mr. Borden was the one which cut his eye, and then he was obliged to give a detailed statement of the character of the eye and its position and surroundings in the head. He thought the blood spots on the wall near the sofa were caused by spattering rather than from arteries. The assailant of Mr. Borden, provided a short-handled hatchet was used, would necessarily stand close to his head, and would receive some spatters on the clothes, if the right hand was used then the upper right part of the body would be spattered; if the left hand was used then the spatters would be on the upper left hand side.

(Here counsel produced a new hatchet which he asked Dr. Draper to see if it would fit the wounds; this was attempted, but would not fit because it had not been sharpened and was blunt, it was 3 3-8 inches wide on the cutting edge.)

On Mrs. Borden's body the witness found 22 wounds, 18 of the cuts in the head, 1 in the back, and 3 contusions on the face. The wound in the back may have been caused while she was standing, or it may have been caused when she was lying on the floor. It proceeded from below upward. He saw nothing about the cutting of the hair on Mrs. Borden's head to indicate that a sharp instrument like a razor had been used.

On Mrs. Borden's head there appeared to be blows which were beveled in both ways; taking the injuries on Mrs. Borden's head altogether, he thought they had all been given in one direction, from right to left. The assailant of Mrs. Borden must have been more or less spattered with blood in front, although some of the blood might have gone in the air and come down behind, and that the face and hair might reasonably have received some blood spatters.

On conclusion of Dr. Draper's testimony the court adjourned at 5 o'clock.

If the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, which the crier of the court here calls upon the Almighty to save at the opening and closing of the session each day, does not present any stronger evidence as to why Lizzie Borden should be convicted of having hastened her stepmother and father to death, she will never be convicted of the awful crime of which she stands charged in the indictment. That fact has become so apparent that some of the lawyers (one of them came all the way from Georgia to attend the trial) who have been present from the first have gone home, thoroughly convinced that the jury will acquit the young woman now on trial for her life.

What the prosecution can have in reserve with which to convince the jury of the guilt of Miss Borden, if it has anything at all, is a subject of speculation. The evidence taken at the inquest, which furnished the prosecution with wedges which could have been used to advantage when she went on the stand, having been excluded, the prosecution will have to get along with it as best it may.

See the clipping

The police on trial

The Tribune on the defense case. The police, it says, had long seemed to be on trial as well as Lizzie Borden. If the defense witnesses were to be believed, she was in the dock through a deliberate police conspiracy, and Assistant Marshal Fleet and Officer Medley, who had described the thick dust in the barn loft, had sworn falsely.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

New-York Tribune · 16 June 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THREE SEVERE SETBACKS FOR THE STATE.

BEGINNING HER DEFENCE.

BORDEN PROSECUTION RESTS.

See moreSee less

MR. JENNINGS STATES THE CASE FOR HIS CLIENT.

PROMISING TO SHOW THAT HER STORY ABOUT VISITING THE BARN IS TRUE—STRONG EVIDENCE TO PROVE IT INTRODUCED—ANOTHER BLOW FOR THE STATE.

(FROM A STAFF CORRESPONDENT OF THE TRIBUNE.)

New-Bedford, Mass., June 15.—The tenth day of Lizzie Borden's trial has ended, and has probably brought her close to the day of vindication and liberty.

The prosecution rested this morning, and the defence began promptly. Mr. Jennings opened with the startling statement that he intended to prove that Lizzie Borden's story about going to the barn was true; that her story about the dress she burned having paint on it was true; and that he intended to prove the falsity of a good deal of the evidence given in behalf of the Commonwealth by the police officers. Much of this promise was redeemed before the session closed. Mysterious as is the whole affair, including the prisoner's behavior, it begins to look as if she not only might be, but must be, innocent. It cannot be said that Mr. Jennings's evidence was precisely conclusive, but its tendency to prove innocence was strong. It seemed trustworthy, and it stood solid and upright against a cross-examination admirably adapted to break it to pieces had it been flimsy or fraudulent.

MISS BORDEN MOVED TO TEARS.

Somehow or other, the prisoner at the bar has not seemed greatly moved by the feeling of hope and almost confidence which the results of the day might well have inspired. She yielded slowly to the heavy strain to which the prosecution's story, with its accompanying theatrical properties, its axes and hatchets, its skulls and plaster casts, and its long-drawn-out and dreadful details of blood and horror, subjected her. She revives as slowly as she yielded. Many amusing situations developed during the day, but they did not amuse the prisoner. She sat through everything, except the speech of her counsel, stolid and depressed. As he talked and told of his intimate relations with her father and with her; as he told of the home she had lived in, and of what she had been to it and in it; as he described her love for her father, her care for him in his old age, the interest she took in his affairs, and the aid she gave to him, and as he drew the utterly sad picture of the position she is now placed in, she buried her face in her handkerchief and cried heartily.

During the recess of the court at noon, for the first time in these long and terrible ten days, one of her own sex was seen to speak to her. It is difficult to account for the hostile attitude in which even yet the women who attend this trial stand toward the prisoner. If ever there were an object entitled to pity and commiseration, it is she. At no time has her guilt seemed inevitable; at no time have the presumptions of innocence proceeding from human nature and from her history as a woman and a daughter been overcome. Her homeliness is by no means that which a coarse or cruel nature would be apt to impart.

So far as outward appearances tell any story they show only a poor wretched woman, borne down with the weight of an accusation than which in all the record of crime there is none more horrible. They show a woman of refinement, whose manner and bearing from the moment she took her seat in the prisoners' dock until now have been most exemplary. There has not been a look or a gesture, a word or an attitude suggestive of the qualities which she must possess, not vaguely or in small measure, but developed in an abnormal and hideous degree, if she is the deplorable creature charged by the State. Her very grief and unhappiness, keen beyond comparison, and deep beyond sounding, have been expressed only because nature could not bear the burden this trial has imposed. They have been displayed despite a superhuman effort to hold them in subjection.

And yet, with all this in her favor, not a woman in New-Bedford has given so much as a kind look to her. Not one has offered to shake her hand or to speak in her ear a single word of consolation or hope. Her isolation has been complete. The feeling of her sex against her is so positive and manifest that women in the courtroom actually look disappointed when a witness says anything to her advantage. When Professor Wood concluded the statement of his examination of each of the objects sent to him to be tested for blood with the declaration that no trace of blood was to be found anywhere upon them, the women in the audience looked positively disgusted and angry. No doubt the most of them came away believing that Professor Wood was no such chemist as he has been cracked up to be.

WELCOMING FALL RIVER WOMEN.

To-day at noon three women came forward from the audience and spoke to Miss Borden. Even they were not strangers, moved by a kind and generous impulse. They were friends who had known her in Fall River. But they were mightily welcome. She talked with them long, and seemed to draw keen enjoyment from their presence and from the consolatory looks they gave to her. On Monday she came into the courtroom with a little bunch of white and red pinks. They were the only flowers she has had since the trial began.

Everything was bright to-day around the handsome little building where the trial goes on. The sun moved brilliantly through a cloudless sky. Cool winds from the water blew over the town, tempering the heat and giving vivacity and brightness to nature of every kind. They were cutting the grass on the courthouse lawn, and as the mower made its way along the wind caught up the little grass blades its knife had parted and sent them whirling all around. The sparrows from the capitals of the big Grecian columns that give so stately a front to the courthouse building came down and made little sheaves of grass, took them up to their nests above the capitals and made great sport with them there. Chasing one another in light-hearted frolic, they flew into the arching elms, they dashed into the flower plots, giving screams of fun and defiance as they went. It does not take many days of such sights and sounds as have been encountered in this indescribable trial to give one a feeling of fondness for these little birds and flowers and leaves and grasses.

PRUSSIC-ACID EVIDENCE RULED OUT.

The Court decided, after all, that it would not admit the evidence of the drug clerk as to Lizzie Borden's attempt to buy some prussic acid on the night before the tragedy. The judges expressed themselves as impressed with the claim of the defence that this drug was often used for household purposes of one kind or another, and they held that the prosecution were under the necessity of proving to the contrary before the evidence would be admissible. It was not enough, they said, to show that the prisoner had that night bought something with which murder might have been committed, especially in view of the fact that it was not committed with that or with anything like it. If prussic acid was such a poison as to render its purchase by an ordinary person of itself suspicious, they thought the evidence might be brought in. The Commonwealth started out this morning with an effort to produce proof of the kind thus called for, but did not succeed to the Court's satisfaction. Their expert witnesses said that they never heard of prussic acid being used for any household purpose, but when under cross-examination they were asked to declare the properties of the poison, and to say whether, with those properties, it might not produce such an effect when used in such a way, they said, Yes, it might. The Court listened to this sort of thing for some time, and then suggested to the District-Attorney that he would better abandon the attempt to work in the prussic-acid incident. The Court looked upon it with disfavor, anyhow, and could not be reconciled to its use unless the conditions made it evidently pertinent.

THREE SEVERE SETBACKS FOR THE STATE.

The State's case has been much weakened by the Court's refusal to admit this and other bits of evidence. Its case against the prisoner required everything it possessed in the way of suggestion and information. If all had been admitted, the issue would still be extremely doubtful. The State had no resource to spare; and in the decisions declining to receive the evidence given by Miss Borden at the Coroner's inquest, together with that of Miss Anna Borden, the friend with whom Lizzie went abroad in 1890, as to Lizzie's statement that her home was an unhappy one, and excluding this prussic-acid story, the prosecution has encountered three severe blows. Their main case, as it now stands, comes from the Fall River police department. This is most unfortunate for the State, not only because the police contradicted themselves so often and on such important points, but because it has all along been felt that the police were on trial as well as Lizzie Borden. If that was true before the defence opened, it was much more true at the close of this afternoon's session. If the evidence introduced by Mr. Jennings is true—and it had all the appearances of verity—Miss Borden is in that dock as the result of a deliberate police conspiracy. If what the defendant's witnesses have sworn to commands belief, Assistant Marshal Fleet and Officer Medley are perjurers; and if there is a particle of police perjury in the prosecution's case it tumbles to the ground in a heap. It is purely circumstantial, anyhow, and unless it can all be depended upon, no part of it is worth considering. The position of Officer Fleet and Officer Mullaly was particularly bad when they themselves had left the stand. They swore that they were together when Fleet found the hatchet-head. Fleet swore that the handle which had been broken off close to the iron was nowhere to be seen. Mullaly swore that it was there in the box with the head it belonged to; that he handled it, and Fleet handled it, and Fleet put it back in the box. Then before Fleet and Mullaly could communicate or anybody could tell Fleet what Mullaly had said, Fleet was brought back to the witness-stand and made to repeat his statement that the handle was not there; that he did not see it or touch it.

ALLEGING A POLICE CONSPIRACY.

Mistakes, of course, are always possible, but they ought not to be possible to police officers who are swearing away a human life. And now the defence comes forward with a story which makes other parts of Fleet's testimony impossible and which convicts Mullaly of having received the information, on the very day of the tragedy, that a witness had seen Lizzie Borden, at fifteen minutes past 11, coming from the barn, where she says she had been since 11 o'clock. This looks like bad faith on the part of the police, and taken in connection with their own contradictions, evasions and undoubted blunders, it points darkly at a conspiracy. The inquiry has arisen already in every rational mind whether these policemen, having failed to catch the real murderer, have not deliberately put away clews that they might have successfully followed and deliberately ignored facts which spoke for Miss Borden's innocence, and whether they have not done something even worse than this. If they have, there ought to be a day of reckoning for Mr. Fleet and Mr. Medley and Mr. Mullaly. If the promotions and increased salaries which all these fine detectives have secured since they put Lizzie Borden into prison are the fruit of perjury and of a league among themselves to hunt an innocent woman to her death, there is no punishment possible under the law too severe for them. The point is already reached where that jury has got to decide between witnesses who can have no possible motive for false swearing, and whose testimony is firm and reasonable, and in many respects corroborated, and the evidence given by these policemen. For what they said the policemen have a motive. It is the motive of hiding their own stupidity and of finding a victim for public clamor and a claim on their own part for public reward.

There should be a suspension of judgment, of course, until the case is closed; but the present situation justifies watchfulness and suspicion. Since it seems to be the habit in Fall River for persons in authority to carry around warrants in their pockets to be used in their discretion, it might be well for some competent person to get out a warrant for a few of these policemen. It might be well for Mayor Coughlin to advise them, as he took so much pains to advise Lizzie Borden, not to go out of their houses for the present. It might be well for him to place some trusty minions armed with these warrants all around their houses and to keep watch on them day and night. If that kind of thing was justifiable procedure against a girl suspected of murder, it is justifiable against men who are suspected of false swearing against her life.

See the clipping

Evidence closed, few doubt acquittal

At the end of the eleventh day the evidence is all in, and the Tribune’s correspondent finds few who doubt the verdict: most believe her innocent, many the victim of a police conspiracy. ‘The Commonwealth has been in full retreat’, he writes. The headlines add that paint on the burned dress was sworn to, and that the police matron’s story of Lizzie accusing Emma of giving her away was contradicted.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

New-York Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

BRIGHT FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. HER SISTER EMMA'S EVIDENCE

PAINT ON THE BURNED DRESS POSITIVELY

See moreSee less

SWORN TO.

THE "YOU GAVE ME AWAY" STORY CONTRADICTED, AND LIZZIE'S LOVE FOR HER

FATHER SHOWN—THE TESTIMONY ALL IN.

[FROM A STAFF CORRESPONDENT OF THE TRIBUNE.]

New-Bedford, Mass., June 16.—At the end of the eleventh day of the trial the case of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts against Lizzie Andrew Borden is closed. The evidence on both sides is in. That part of the record is sealed, and nothing now remains but the arguments of counsel, the charge of the Court, and the verdict of the jury. Few people who have attended the trial doubt what the verdict will be, and if it is what they look for, there will still be a score to settle before Lizzie Borden and her extraordinary entanglement with the law may be permitted to drop out of sight. The belief in the prisoner's guilt is now confined to that class of people who are naturally suspicious, who have at least a tendency toward hard-heartedness, and who are also so narrow and prejudiced in their views that, having once obtained an impression, they can never allow themselves to part with it. All others, if a judgment can be formed without actually taking a full vote of the courthouse audience, believe that she is innocent, and of these a great majority are convinced that she has been the victim of a police conspiracy.

It is certainly difficult to understand the testimony in any other way. Every suspicious circumstance brought forward by the prosecution has been at least relieved of the necessity of regarding it as suspicious, and on most of such circumstances the defence have placed by trustworthy and corroborated evidence a natural interpretation that is plainly innocent. With the police the issue has been squarely joined, and Governor Robinson's policy in treating them in his cross-examination as not only hostile but malignant witnesses has been vindicated by the production of disinterested testimony which cannot be true unless they are perjurers, and which seems to be true. The prosecution's evidence in rebuttal was mostly confession. The Commonwealth has been in full retreat since the defence put its first witness on the stand, and toward the last of to-day's session the retreat became a disorderly and confused flight.

MISS BORDEN NOT PUT ON THE STAND.

Lizzie Borden did not go on the stand. Some persons will undoubtedly draw an inference from this fact to her disadvantage. This is the natural, almost the inevitable, thing to do. Her best friends here, and her friends are now beginning to multiply, to hold up their heads and to avow their friendship, however diffident they may be about opposing their judgment to that of her counsel, cannot avoid a feeling of regret that she was thought to be unable to stand the strain of such an ordeal. Nevertheless, the claim of her counsel is quite true, that they have proved substantially everything the evidence of which she can supply. Their case would be strengthened only in a moral sense by the mere fact of her taking the stand and subjecting herself to the batteries of the prosecution. On the other hand, it cannot be denied that there is danger of her breaking down. She is utterly tired, almost ill. The pressure and excitement under which she has been during the last two weeks, to say nothing of the last ten months, have left her nervous and in a mental condition anything but healthy. The awful loneliness of her position has weighed upon her, and it is not at all clear that conditions, physical and metaphysical, would not operate to render her, though innocent, an easy victim to the stern, merciless and artful methods of the District-Attorney. Her counsel says she stands in mortal terror of him, and she has good reason to do so.

She remembers how, after seven days of excitement following the murders; after being subjected to searches and questionings almost without number; after being examined by this policeman and then by that one, and by another and another, until it really seemed as if the entire force were set upon her in relays and reliefs; after awful scenes of blood; after the funeral; after being informed that she was under suspicion; after being required to give up her clothing; after actual illness and the constant medicinal application of morphine, she was brought before this District-Attorney, her counsel barred out, and put under a two days' examination in which torture exquisite and brutal was applied to her for hours at a time. She remembers how, after questions were asked plainly conveying his suspicion and his bulldog purpose to get something out of her, he inquired: Did she see her father lying on the sofa? Did she realize that he was dead? Did she see the blood spurting from his wounds? Did she see pools of it on the floor? Did she see the holes in his head? Did she see the wounds lying open? Did she see his eyeballs hanging down? Then she buried her face in her hands and begged for time to think.

EXPLANATIONS DUE FROM MR. KNOWLTON.

If the jury acquits Lizzie Borden, Mr. Knowlton will have some rather ugly things to explain. It appears that there is not a fact that has been told by the defendant's witnesses of which he was not informed before the Grand Jury indicted her. He probably thinks she is guilty. He is just the kind of man to think so. His figure is heavy and stout; his head is big; his face is fat; he has light, sandy hair, and a beard which, while growing all over his face, is heaviest on his chin. He has a round, snub nose, absurdly little for so big a head and so fat a face. His eyes are blue, uncomfortably small and deeply set under his forehead. He has a harsh voice, with a distinct snarl in it.

"Who is this District-Attorney Knowlton?" inquired a stranger to-day, leaning over toward the benches where the little group of New-York correspondents sit.

"He is a gentleman," replied one of them, looking up, "who came here in 1632, and has lived here ever since. He conducted the cases against the Salem witches, achieving his first distinction in that performance. He is probably without an equal in that kind of practice."

The remark was a little rough, perhaps, and yet it was an illustrative answer. The methods of the prosecution of Lizzie Borden, until it reached this court, are not to be defended; and even here Mr. Knowlton has presented evidence which, knowing the extent and character of the proof available to show its falsity, he should have been most cautious in using. That is a safe proposition, whatever the jury's verdict may be.

EMMA BORDEN'S EFFECTIVE TESTIMONY. Emma Borden, Lizzie's sister, was the main witness to-day. She gave the strongest possible testimony in favor of the prisoner, and gave it in the strongest possible way. She, too, is plainly a woman of education, character and refinement. She did not submit to be misunderstood or carried where she was not minded to go. Her answers to the District Attorney were given with precisely that manner and in just that tone which rendered them most effective. There was nothing resentful about her toward the prosecution, but there was everything loving and tender and true toward her sister. Not a note of defiance, not an accent of irritation, not a gesture of impatience escaped her. But the District Attorney could not make her say a syllable to the hurt of the prisoner. At times he pressed her hotly, with the evident intention of getting her confused. But she neither became confused nor angry, and the answers she gave were plainly the answers of a truthful, honest heart. They did not avail the State in its prosecution of Lizzie Borden, because the facts do not avail it. There was no motive for her to commit the crime alleged against her. If anything were lacking to prove that before Emma took the stand, it is not lacking now.

"I was the one," she said, "who felt resentfully toward Mrs. Borden. It was not Lizzie. Their relations were always cordial until that matter of property came up. Six years ago Lizzie did not feel nearly so strongly about that as I did, and the last three years of their lives together were the pleasantest of all. They were on terms of absolute and constant cordiality."

She turned to the jury as she concluded that statement, and said slowly and with a solemnity that I dare not emphazise lest I give some touch of the affectation from which it was so perfectly free:

"What I have said is just the truth."

Every man in the box, I think, believed her.

THE STORY OF THE BURNED DRESS.

Then she told about the burned dress. She was away, it will be remembered, visiting at Marion, when the tragedy occurred. She was summoned home by telegram. The women of the Borden family kept their dresses in a clothes-press in a large window-lighted closet on the second floor of the house. Saturday morning (the murder occurred on Thursday) when Emma went to the closet to hang up her dresses, every hook was occupied, and she saw on one of them Lizzie's old Bedford-cord dress, which, since the preceding May, had been all covered with paint. The paint, Emma says, was all down its front and on many places on each side and along the bottom of the skirt. She says she told Lizzie that that old dress was in the way and ought to be destroyed, and that the burning of it the next morning was the result of her suggestion. That dress, Miss Borden on her oath declared, was in that closet in the full glare of the open window, with the paint all over it, and observable at a glance. When the police officers on Saturday afternoon searched the house they went through that closet in squads and platoons. She says she saw it there. Officer Fleet says he handled every dress and did not see it at all. Two or three officers, I forget their names, told the same story. None of them saw it. Which shall be believed?

CONFIRMED BY THE DRESSMAKER'S EVIDENCE.

Miss Borden is not alone in her statement that the dress was thus covered with paint. Mrs. Raymond, the dressmaker, who made it, says it was, too. She was in the house making dresses when Lizzie got the paint on it, and she remembers all about it. So as to the paint there is the evidence of the painter himself, who, acting under Lizzie's instructions, was painting the house. He does not know that she got any paint on her clothes, but he knows that she stood around while the work was going on, constantly giving instructions. There is the testimony of Mrs. Raymond and of Emma Borden, and there is nothing against it but the evidence of a knot of policemen who say they did not see it.

She burned it in broad daylight. It was a foolish thing to do, but why should she have been thinking about what not to do lest she, the dead man's own and loving daughter, be accused of murdering him?

MISS RUSSELL CONTRADICTED.

Miss Russell, in whose testimony for the prosecution the dress incident was first brought out, appears to be the sort of young woman of whom householders in Fall River may well beware. When she told the story she said that as Lizzie entered the kitchen with the dress on her arm, and started toward the stove, Emma looked up and said:

"What are you going to do with that dress?"

Emma says she didn't say it. Emma says she knew just exactly what Lizzie was going to do with the dress, because she herself had suggested the doing of it. Miss Russell testified that when Lizzie, replying to Emma's alleged question, said: "I'm going to burn it; it is all over paint," she (Miss Russell) quickly remarked: "I wouldn't do that if I were you, Lizzie, where anybody could see me," and that Lizzie thereupon stepped back a pace or two from the window. Emma testified to-day that she was in the room all the time: that she didn't hear anything of that kind said, and she doesn't believe it was said. The burning was done as a matter of course, without thought of consequences. There were consequences in Miss Russell's mind, there is no doubt of that, and her thoughts quickly took expression. Monday morning--this is Emma's testimony-- "Miss Russell came from the dining-room and said that Mr. Hanscom had asked her if all the dresses were there that were there on the day of the tragedy, and she had told him yes, and that she had told him a falsehood. It was decided by my sister and myself that she should go and tell him that a dress had been burned."

Mr. Hanscom was a private detective, the chief of the Pinkerton bureau, employed by the Borden sisters. Miss Russell went to him as agreed and told him of her falsehood. It may have been a kindly, well-meant lie, but it was as little appreciated by the Borden sisters as the apparently unkind and ill-meant truth she has since been telling.

No candid person can listen to the evidence which the defence has produced to-day without a tremendous feeling of indignation. It is directed chiefly against the Fall River police, but the District-Attorney deserves a share of it. At the close of yesterday's session it seemed clear that at least three policemen had committed perjury, and that the whole crowd of them had been contriving to convict Lizzie Borden on evidence either entirely false or false in color. That is, it seemed as if they had taken a number of little incidents and added to them, or subtracted from them, clearly producing the effect of suspicious circumstances, which, truthfully represented, they were not. Let it be remembered that it is on these little circumstances, scores of them and all strung together and brought to bear on the one great fact that Lizzie was present in or about the house when these murders were done, and that she only was there throughout that time, so far as is known—it is on these circumstances that the Commonwealth asks the forfeit of her life.

MANY PEOPLE AT THE BARN.

One of these is her tale about being in the barn from about 11 o'clock until fifteen minutes after, that being the time when her father at least was killed. Officer Medley seemed to make it sure that she must have told a falsehood. He said he reached the Borden house on the day of the murders about 12:20, and before any one else was there except two other officers and Lizzie's friends—Dr. Bowen, Mrs. Churchill and Miss Russell; that, hearing Lizzie's account of herself, he straightway went to the barn and searched it upstairs and down; that, finding nothing suspicious, he was about to come away, when it occurred to him to put his eyes on a level with the floor, and, doing so (the barn was not in use as such, nor for any other purpose than as a storehouse), he noticed the footprints he had made showed in the sediment of dust there, but could not see any smaller footprints. This was damaging evidence, but now it turns out that nearly a dozen people had been to the barn and all over it before Medley had so much as reached the Borden house. The proof of this is overwhelming. It comes from persons of every degree, some of whom saw one another, and none of whom saw Medley until after they had come out of the barn and returned to the house; and the best and clearest of these witnesses, Mr. Stevens, the Fall River reporter, having thus visited the barn, actually saw Medley turning in from the street to go into the house at the very time which Medley gives as the time of his first arrival.

The witnesses who have demonstrated the valuelessness of Medley's fancy sketch are all

Fall River people, all acquaintances of the police officers, and they all at that time freely told of their visit to the barn. The police must have known that Medley's story could be impeached. If they didn't, they were grossly incompetent detectives. If they did, they give occasion to doubt their integrity. The first of these infer- ences might be accepted but for the fact that throughout this trial the stories of the police-

men have been so often self-contradictory, and are now by the defendant's witnesses so often and so positively denied. From the time Gov-

ernor Robinson worked the fact out of Officer

Mullaly that the handle of the hatchet to which police suspicion finally attached was found by Officer Fleet in the same box where he found the head, Fleet having previously sworn that the handle was not there at all, and had never been discovered—from that time the police testimony has been breaking to pieces. Perhaps the worst example of this is the last—the story of Mrs.

Reagan, the matron of the Fall River police station. She swore that on the 26th of August,

Lizzie being then confined as a prisoner in the matron's room, Emma visited her and the two sisters had a quarrel. She said she was in the room all the time, and yet the only part of the quarrel she heard was Lizzie's charge, "Emma, you gave me away"; Emma's reply, "Lizzie, I

did not give you away," and Lizzie's retorting declaration, "Yes, you did give me away, but I

shall not give in an inch." Then Mrs. Reagan polished up her story by telling how Lizzie, who was lying on the sofa, turned over and refused to have anything further to do with her sister, and how they parted without saying goodby.

THE POLICE MATRON'S EVIDENCE DISPOSED OF.

Mrs. Reagan told this story boldly. The cross-examination was directed to discover whether she had not, when that story got out, declared that it was wholly false, and that she was not a witness to any such quarrel or to any quarrel. She was asked whether she had not offered to sign a paper containing this denial and had not been restrained from doing so by the positive interposition of Marshal Hilliard. All this was positively denied by Mrs. Reagan. She insisted that she had overheard the quarrel; that it occurred precisely as she had testified; that she never denied having overheard it, and never offered to sign the paper. To-day Miss Emma Borden solemnly assured the jury that no such quarrel ever occurred; that Lizzie never said anything of the kind to her nor she to Lizzie; that when the story first came out in the newspapers, she went to Mrs.

Reagan about it, and Mrs. Reagan did deny it and offer to sign the paper.

It is not hard to find out who is the perjurer here. The defence produced half a dozen witnesses to whom Mrs. Reagan did deny it. They put the correspondent of "The New-York Herald"

on the stand. He said that he was present when in Marshal Hilliard's presence she offered to sign the paper, and the Marshal forbade her doing anything of the kind. The prosecutor called Marshal Hilliard in rebuttal, but oddly enough, he didn't rebut at all. He said that Mrs. Reagan came to his office with a Mr. Buck. Mr. Buck handed a paper to him and said that Mrs. Reagan was willing to sign it if he said so. He glanced at it, and told her that she must not sign it, but must go to her room and attend to her business.

Now, what was the use of the prosecution bringing forward such testimony as that of the Reagan woman? They must have known that she had been lying at some time, either when she told of the quarrel or when she expressed her willingness to deny it. It is the simple truth that you cannot touch the police testimony at any point without evoking a hollow sound, and if Lizzie Borden is acquitted somebody ought to be made to pay dearly for the unconscionable wrong that has been inflicted upon her. All these policemen have been promoted since the Borden tragedy. Where then they were special officers and patrolmen, they are now captains, inspectors and assistant marshals. Their salaries have been increased. What are these rewards for? It looks as if that were a question for the Grand Jury of Bristol County to find the answer to, and it is to be hoped that District-Attorney Knowlton will be no less active and serviceable in assisting the Grand Jury in solving that question than he has been in driving Lizzie Borden to her peril.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Four: True Bill