As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · The full archive

October 1892

183 articles

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

A dispatch from Fall River claims evidence shows Lizzie Borden visited Providence months earlier to consult lawyer Lycurgus Sayles about disposition of her father's property in case of his death. Sayles denies ever having seen or met Lizzie Borden.

The Washington Bee · 1 October 1892 · page 4

R. L, several months since, and con sulted lawyer Lycurus Sayler in regard to the disposition of her father's property in case of his death. Lawyer Sayler de ales that he ever saw Lizzie Borden. The world's record for double team of 1.18 has been lowered at Providence, R.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report notes that District Attorney Knowlton had just finished arguing for Lizzie Borden's detention on charges of murdering her parents when Fall River entered a string of violent and tragic incidents. It catalogs numerous unrelated deaths, suicides, and assaults in the city since the August 4th murders, attributing many to alcohol.

The Providence News · 4 October 1892 · page 3

CRIME AND MISFORTUNE.

Fall River's Record Since the Terri rible Borden Murders. FaLy RiveEß, Mass,, Oct. 4.—District Attorney Knowton had hardly completed his plea for the detention of Lizzie A.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A miscellany column of personal items notes that Gail Hamilton, writing in the Boston Journal, takes up Lizzie Borden's case vigorously, insisting she be treated as innocent until proven guilty. The rest of the item covers unrelated anecdotes about literary and political figures.

New-York Tribune · 5 October 1892 · page 6

PERSONAL.

In a letter to The Loston Journal,” Gall Hamilton tukes up Miss Lizzie Borden's case with characteristic vigor, and demunds that the public and the State treat her ns an innocent (if suspected) person until she ls proven gullty. Judge Frank A. Hooker, nominated by the Michi gan Republicans for Snpreme Court Judge, is a native of Hartford, Conn, but studied law at Ann Arbor, For eleven years, beginning with 1878, he served on the State Clecult Court benches, He is a man of high attainments and fine character,

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

The report claims the State will try to prove Lizzie Borden made two trips to Providence before the murders, once six months prior and once two weeks prior, to consult a lawyer about her father's estate. It states a lawyer recalled his client's visit after the murders became known.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 5 October 1892 · page 7

AGAINST LIZZIE BORDEN". The State Will Try to Prove a Sas. picious 1'rlp to Providence. The State is ready to prove, it is aJleged, that six months before the Borden murders

See the clipping

Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D. · and 1 other paper

The report describes a prior robbery at the Borden home in which money and jewelry were taken from Mr. Borden's room, despite no sign of forced entry. Investigators found suspicious clues suggesting an inside job, and the case was abruptly dropped at Mr. Borden's request after detectives told him something astonishing.

Turner County Herald · 6 October 1892 · page 2

HERE IS A HINT

The Herald's Fall River, Mass., correspondent says: New light that will no doubt have an important bearing on the trial of Lizzie Borden lias been thrown upon the robbery of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden, which occurred on June 21, 1891. It will be remembered that the facts of this robbery had been kept secret and were not brought to the public notice until after the mysterious murder of the old couple. The police, after a investigation of the matter, were per fectly satisfied that they could place the thief under arrest, but this never occurred, because, it is stated, Mr.

See moreSee less

Borden declined to press the charge. Mr. Borden reported the robbery on the afternoon of the date mentioned, lie said his own roon over the kitchen had been entered and a desk used for his private papers broken open and jewelry and money amounting to several hundred dollars taken. Capt. Desmond and Inspector Perron were put on the case. They found that none of the members of the family had been awav trom the house during the day. All the doors as far as they knew, were locked the night before, when the articles were safe in the desk. The burglary was committed some time in the forenoon. The first clue the inspectors found was in a door at the head of the stairs which opens into Mr. Borden's room. AlO-penny nail was found sticking from the key hole. The head of the nail was on the outside of the door. It was first thought the lock had been picked, but a minute examination showed that it had not been tampered with at all. A thorough search of the premises failed to reveal any trace of the burglar. The officers reported what they had learned to Mr. Borden and the latter had a talk with Mrs. Borden, Lizzie Borden, Emma Borden and Bridget Sullivan. Finally the inspectors sent for Mr. Borden and told him that they could arrest the thief at any time. They told Mr. Borden something very as tounding and the case was dropped very quietly by the old gentleman's request. The facts concerning this myster ious robbery, it is understood, will be more thoroughly elucidated at the trial and arc expected to form an im portant part of the government's case.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D. · 6 October 1892

Paper unidentified

At the Academy, a town's lyceum program featured a mock trial based on the Lizzie Borden murder case, complete with a judge, jury, and opposing counsel. The staged proceedings were well-argued on both sides but ended in a hung jury.

Paper unidentified · 6 October 1892 · page 3

At the Academy on Friday evening a mock Lizzie Borden murder trial was held as the program for the cus tomary lyceum. The venerable Judge

See the clipping

The Herald-Advance · Milbank, S.D. · and 3 other papers

A Fall River correspondent reports new details on a 1891 burglary at the Borden home, previously kept secret, in which money and jewelry were stolen from Andrew Borden's room. Police suspected a culprit but made no arrest because Borden refused to press charges, and investigators found a nail jammed in a door lock but no clear trace of the thief.

The Herald-Advance · 7 October 1892 · page 3

The Herald's Fall River, Mass., correspondent says: New light that will no doubt have an important bearing on the trial of Lizzie Borden has been thrown upon the robbery of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden, which occurred on June 24, 1891. It will be remembered that the facts of this robbery had been kept secret and were not brought to the public notice until after the mysterious murder of the old couple. The police, after a investigation of the matter, were per fectly satisfied that they could place the thief under arrest, but this never occurred, because, it is stated, Mr.

See moreSee less

Borden declined to press the charge. Mr. Borden reported the robbery on the afternoon of the date mentioned. He said his own roon over the kitchen had been entered and a desk used for his private papers broken open and jewelry and money amounting to several hundred dollars taken. Capt. Desmond and Inspector Perron were put on the case. They found that none of the members of the family had been away from the house during the day. All the door# as far as they knew, were locked the night before, when the articles were safe in the desk. The burglary was committed some time in the forenoon. The first clue the inspectors found was in a door at the head of the stairs which opens into Mr. Borden's room. A 10-penny nail was found sticking from the key hole. The head of the nail was on the outside of the door. It was first thought the lock had been picked, but a minute examination showed that it had not been tampered with at all. A thorough search of the premises failed to reveal aa^r trace of the burglar. The officers reported what they had learned to Mr. Borden and the latter had a talk with Mrs. Borden, Lizzie Borden, Emma Borden and Bridgets Sullivan. Finally the inspectors sent for Mr Borden and told him that they could arrest the thief at any time. They told Mr. Borden something very as tounding and the case was dropped very quietly by the old gentleman's request. The facts concerning this myster ious robbery, it is understood, will be .jiore thoroughly elucidated at the trial and are expected to form an im portant part of the government's case.

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D. · 6 October 1892
  • Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D. · 6 October 1892
  • The Sully County Watchman · Clifton, S.D. · 8 October 1892

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A newspaper item describes an invalid woman in Cumberland County reputed to have 'second sight,' who, despite being kept from all news of the Borden case, allegedly declared that Lizzie Borden did not kill her parents. Instead, she claimed a young man in the neighborhood who wished to marry Lizzie committed the murders, with both Lizzie and the Irish servant girl aware of it.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Portland Daily Press · 7 October 1892 · page 8

Second Sight. In a town in the western part of Cum berland county a case of second sight is exciting much attention. A lady, who resides with her brother, and ia an inva lid, possesses the extraordinary power of accompanying her brsther in spirit, wherever he may go, and upon his re" turn from a visit to the city, for instance, wilbunhesitatingly relate withiutmost ex actness whatever ’ .a did while there, and tell just what stores and houses he called at. The most remarkable thing yet is in regard to the Borden case.

See moreSee less

The family have kept from her all newspapers and other means of knowledge of the trage dy. and she has never heard a word in relation to it. But the other day she startled them by suddenly exclaiming: ‘•Lizzie Borden did not kill her father and mother; it was done by a young man in the neighborhood, who wished to marry Lizzie. She knew about it, how ever, and so did the Irish girl.”

See the clipping

The Sully County Watchman · Clifton, S.D. · and 1 other paper

The report recounts an earlier burglary at the Borden home in which jewelry and money were stolen from Andrew Borden's room, despite no sign of forced entry or anyone leaving the house. Investigators reportedly learned something startling that led Borden to drop the case, and the report suggests these facts may become significant in the upcoming murder trial.

The Sully County Watchman · 8 October 1892 · page 7

HERE IS A HINT

The Herald's Fall Tiiver, Mass.. correspondent says: New light that will no doubt have an important bearing on the trial of Lizzie Borden has been thrown upon the robbery of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden, which occurred on June 24, 1891. It will be remembered that the facts of this robbery had been kept secret and were not brought to the public notice until after the mysterious murder of the old couple. The police, after a investigation of the matter, were per fectly satisfied that they could place the thief under arrest, but this never occurred, because, it is stated, Mr.

See moreSee less

Borden declined to press the charge. Mr. Borden reported the robbery on the afternoon of the date mentioned. He said his own roon over the kitchen had been entered and a desk used for his private papers broken open and jewelry and money amounting to several hundred dollars taken. Capt. Desmond and Inspector Perron were put on the case. They found that none of the members of the family had been away trom the house during the day. All the doors as far as they knew, were locked the night before, when the articles were safe in the desk. The burglary was committed some time in the forenoon. The first clue the inspectors found was in a door at the head of the stairs which opens into Mr. Borden's room. A 10-penny nail was found sticking from the key hole. The head of the nail was on the outside of the door. It was first thought the lock had been picked, but a minute examination showed that it had not been tampered with at all. A thorough search of the premises failed to reveal any trace of the burglar. The officers reported what they had learned to Mr. Borden and the latter had a talk with Mrs. Borden, Lizzie Borden, Emma Borden and Bridget Sullivan. Finally the inspectors sent for Mr. Borden and told him that they could arrest the thief at any time. They told Mr. Borden something very as tounding and the case was dropped very quietly by the old gentleman's request. The facts concerning this myster ious robbery, it is understood, will be uiore thoroughly elucidated at the trial and are expected to form an im portant part of the government's case.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Herald-Advance · Milbank, S.D. · 7 October 1892

The L'anse Sentinel · L'anse, L.S., Mich.

The preliminary hearing in Fall River concluded with the judge finding probable cause against Lizzie Borden despite her lawyer's defense plea. She was ordered held in the county jail to stand trial at the November term of court.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The L'anse Sentinel · 8 October 1892 · page 6

LIZZIE BORDEN HELD.

Exposition that evening. This Is the ninth annual exposition, and its eight Buecessful seasons easily break all recsertion that it is impossible to main tain interest In a local enterprise of this kind. Last year's attendance was the largest recorded, and '.he indica tions point to still greater success this j'enr. A band composed1 of 100 skilled inusicians, each a soloist of established reputation, is something the world has seldom seen or heard, and the advent of Gil more' s band in the West murks a distinct epoch in musical annals.

See moreSee less

The great bandmaster completes un engage ment in New York Tuesday morning, and a special train with banners and streamers will bring him and his 100 players to the metropolis of the West and Southwest. The Gilmore concerts will be given daily until Oct. 22, and the modest admission fee of 25 cents in cludes these concerts, ns well as the errand disnlavs of manufactured nnd ornamental goods, the art gallery with its thousands of valuable and' choice paintings, the electrical exhibition, and, indeed, every feature of the mam moth entertainment. A number of other attractions are announced and the xerogram is a very brilliant one. LIZZIE BORDEN HELD. CoiK'lu.lou of the Preliminary liearlns Yesterday, Fall Rirnn, Mass., Sept.! .In the Jennings opened for the defense with nn eloquent plea, but with poor result for his client .Tn.io-A i:iiic,i.oi com i,r,i ,.i, should be laid aside, and duty, stern duty, requires upon the evidence but one thing to be done. "Supposing a man was seen in tho chamber of Mrs. Uordcn, the guest chamber of death, and that he was in tho room of the father when ucuth came. Suppose

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

An Iowa judge's syndicated column argues that circumstantial evidence has historically led to wrongful convictions, citing the Borden case as an example where the evidence so far seems insufficient. He notes the preliminary examination failed to solve the mystery, with the hatchet and axes showing no blood stains and money left untouched on Andrew Borden's body.

Los Angeles Herald · 9 October 1892 · page 11

WHERE IT HAS MISLED JURYMEN.

of the death penalty is growing. I The Borden case has attracted the atten tion of the whole civilized world. An 'aged citizen of Fall River, Mass., a man of {wealth, together with his wife, are found Ibrutally murdered in broad daylight. The bodies we're covered with ghastly wounds, chiefly on the face aud head, evidently made by a hatchet or ax. The crime was evidently not committed for the purpose of robbery, for quite a sum of money was found on the person of old man Horden. Lizzie Borden, a daughter, was arrested charged with committing the fearful deed.

See moreSee less

The accused is a young woman of culture prominent in church aud in society. The examination before the magistrate did not solve the mystery. A couple of axes and a hatchet were introduced in evidence, but they bore no blood stains. All the testi mony tended to show that the victims were struck down suddenly by a strong and furious assassin. Some of the evidence indicated that Lizzie Borden toad a dislike for her stepmother, but it seems incon ceivable that this could offer a motive for so awful a crime. It is possible on the final trial of this cause that the mystery of this terrible deed will be unraveled, but thus far on the evidence produced, in my judgment, no jury will be justified in find ing Lizzie Borden guilty.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The Boston Globe reports on affidavits from twenty witnesses prepared to testify against Lizzie Borden, including claims she consulted a lawyer about inheritance, overheard threats from her father, and was allegedly seen at a window during the time of the murder. The report characterizes this as strengthening the prosecution's case significantly.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Evening Journal · 10 October 1892 · page 1

MORE BORDEN EVIDENCE

IBy Telegraph to tlie Evening Journal.1 Boston, Oct. 10.—The Globe this morn ing prints a dozen columns of the stories of twenty witnesses in tlio Borden mur der case who have giveu affidavits to the government. Some of these stories are of a startling nature and are as follows: Frank Burroughs, a well-known New York city lawyer will testify that eight months before the murder occurred Lizzie Borden consulted him about the disposition of property in the event of a step mother's death before that of her husband. Mr. and Mrs.

See moreSee less

Frederick Chase and Mrs. Abigail Manchester will testify that ou the night before the murder, while calling at the Borden house and before being announced, they had overheard Mr. Borden, in another room, threaten ing to turn Lizzie out of doors nnless she would repeat the name of the man who "got her into trouble." G. Romaine Pittston, a wealthy dealer in machinery supplies iii New York, will testify that Mr. Borden detailed Lizzie's trouble to him and was advised to disin herit her unless she would reveal the man s name. John H. Murphy, Mrs. Gustave F. Ron old, Peter Mabany and Augustus Guning will testify to having seen Lizzie Borden at a window, where and when Hlie must have been standing over the dead body of her step mother at a time when lier father was walking in tlie yard. Mrs. George J. Simpson will testify that at the Borden funeral she over heard Lizzie asking Biidget Sullivan, the servant, how much money she wauted to keep quiet, Private Detective McHenry will testify that lying concealed in a bath room he witnessed the quarrel in the matron's room tetween the sisters and that Lizzie kicked Emma thrice, called her a foul name, and said: "You wanted to see me hanged so you can come into the entire fortune. You are the one person whom I thought I could trust with my secret." Mrs. Regau, the matron, and one other have deposed to the same effect. Tho Globe promises to publish a cer tain piece of very important information recently gained by Officer Harrington, as soon as the interests of justice will not suffer by its publication.

See the clipping

In the story →

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The article lists numerous purported witnesses and pieces of evidence against Lizzie Borden, including claims of a hidden motive involving pregnancy, a jailhouse confrontation with her sister witnessed by a detective, and sightings placing her at the murder scene. These sensational claims, attributed to the Boston Globe, promise further damaging revelations against her.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Evening Journal · 10 October 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

MORE BORDEN EVIDENCE

Many Witnesses Prepared to Give Startling Testimony.

See moreSee less

THE STATE'S CASE STRENGTHENED.

The Prosecution Possessed of Affidavits in Which Incriminating Actions on the Part of the Accused Are Charged—Other Evidence in Possession of the State.

[By Telegraph to the Evening Journal.]

BOSTON, Oct. 10.—The Globe this morning prints a dozen columns of the stories of twenty witnesses in the Borden murder case who have given affidavits to the government. Some of these stories are of a startling nature and are as follows:

Frank Burroughs, a well-known New York city lawyer will testify that eight months before the murder occurred Lizzie Borden consulted him about the disposition of property in the event of a step mother's death before that of her husband.

Mr. and Mrs. Frederick Chase and Mrs. Abigail Manchester will testify that on the night before the murder, while calling at the Borden house and before being announced, they had overheard Mr. Borden, in another room, threatening to turn Lizzie out of doors unless she would repeat the name of the man who "got her into trouble."

G. Romaine Pittston, a wealthy dealer in machinery supplies in New York, will testify that Mr. Borden detailed Lizzie's trouble to him and was advised to disinherit her unless she would reveal the man's name.

John H. Murphy, Mrs. Gustave F. Ronold, Peter Mahany and Augustus Guning will testify to having seen Lizzie Borden at a window, where and when she must have been standing over the dead body of her step mother at a time when her father was walking in the yard.

Mrs. George J. Simpson will testify that at the Borden funeral she overheard Lizzie asking Bridget Sullivan, the servant, how much money she wanted to keep quiet.

Private Detective McHenry will testify that lying concealed in a bath room he witnessed the quarrel in the matron's room tetween the sisters and that Lizzie kicked Emma thrice, called her a foul name, and said: "You wanted to see me hanged so you can come into the entire fortune. You are the one person whom I thought I could trust with my secret."

Mrs. Regan, the matron, and one other have deposed to the same effect.

The Globe promises to publish a certain piece of very important information recently gained by Officer Harrington, as soon as the interests of justice will not suffer by its publication.

See the clipping

Asheville Daily Citizen · Asheville, N.C.

The Boston Globe reports a thirteen-column story claiming twenty-five new witnesses will testify for the prosecution, including accounts of Lizzie Borden seen in her stepmother's room wearing a rubber hood and cape, and hearing a groan. It also claims Lizzie and her father quarreled over her refusal to name who had gotten her into trouble.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Asheville Daily Citizen · 10 October 1892 · page 1

Till! I.IXZIi: HOU1U.N C VHIv. New anil (.tannine icvldencc Is II True? Boston, Oct. 10 The Globe publishes a thirlcen-colunin story Irom Fall River giving new and startling evidence in the noted Boiden murder case. Twenty-live new witnesses, il savs, will testify for the prosecution. These will testilv to having seen Lizzie Borden iu her step mother's room about the time the mur der must have been committed, con cealed in u long rubber hood and cape and that thev heard a groan. It will also be testified that l.iz,:ic and her lather had a quariel, the girl refusing to j sav who had sot her into trouble.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A Boston newspaper claims exclusive details of the Borden murder case, saying twenty-five new witnesses will testify for the prosecution at Lizzie Borden's December trial. It describes alleged testimony that a witness saw a window blind cautiously opened by a young woman identified as Lizzie, and claims of a quarrel with her father over her own 'shame' and a mysterious will.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening World · 10 October 1892 · page 3

MAY BE HER DOOM

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A Boston paper claims about twenty-five new witnesses will testify for the state in December, including a man who says he saw a woman resembling Lizzie Borden at a window near the murder scene. The article also hints at a quarrel with her father over her 'own shame' and the existence of a will.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening World · 10 October 1892 · page 3

MAY BE HER DOOM.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The Boston Globe reports that some twenty new witnesses will testify for the prosecution at Lizzie Borden's December murder trial, beyond those heard at the preliminary examination. One witness, John H. Murphy, claims he saw a young woman he identifies as Lizzie cautiously open a window blind in the room where Mrs. Borden's body was later found, shortly before the murder.

The Evening World · 10 October 1892 · page 3

MAY BE HER DOOM

Boston, Oct. la Thn Globe print) axelat, ';$;. stvety to-day a Fall ltlver story embodyuig' "rthe following points tn the Bordon murder . k mystery : M, Besides those who testified for the Govern- ,& mont in tbo preliminary examination or -lMLlzrle A. Borden, before Judge BUUsdeU. v,ff fully twenty-aro now witnesses' will be called t ,j by the state at tbe trial ot the defendant for ' iffi murder In December. tV John II. Murphy, ot Bedford street. Fall t'l.V lllver, will testify that r be waa standing on-i.-V' the sidewalk close to tbe Borden bouw when -t ;r fh Mr.

See moreSee less

Borden entered hi yard, about iao , v ,-M o'clock on the morning ot Aug. 4, and be aa-r &r blm a minute or two later Vsbered late tin " :'f: house by Bridget Sulllvan. " V &s Mr. Murphy will swear that while Mr. Bor- - den was walking In the yard he aiwawlnV u W dow blind of tho room In which 'Mrs. Bor. . ',, den's body was attenrardi 'found cauUonsly ', t :f opened by a young woman, who had that . 'K rame morning told him when he called at the ""''M Borden house, about D.30 o'olook, that her n laiber had gone downtown' and would (tot be ' -4 back until noon, or later. This woman he1 '' ,Jk lia-s identified as tbo defendant, Ltxzle A. , i' Borden. 'gjti Tbe window Mr. Murphy designate tne , '?," one In which he saw Miss lizzie ll so tuaatej . that sho must hare been atandlng over the. ,-fi mutilated remains of her mother at the very V tlmo that her rather was about to enter the '. r. bouse, between 10.30 and 10.45 o'clock. ""t. .S Tbe next new witness of importance Is Mr. J , -',y'V Gustave F. ltonald. whose husband Is a wellii known civil engineer and whose horn during ' J? Wln'erlsatPa-rtuxet, B. I. tH She and her 'husband 'were guest at tb rBv Wilbur House at the time or the murder. ' f About aao o'clock on the morning of Aug. ij" 4 she went out, with ber baby In Its carrlago . ' 'i for a walk. Sbe wheeled tbe little one up j$ second street and stopped under the'blg tr -t near tho Borden house about 10.20 o'clock, , A. A minute later she heard a terrible cry or ' v5 groan and began looking around to e ''..rj whenco It came. " . f.", she looked up at the Borden house and saw j -ii'Jj

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Several new witnesses are reported to have seen a woman identified as Lizzie Borden at an upstairs window of the Borden house around 10:20-10:30 AM on the day of the murders, wearing a dark hood or cap. Their testimony is presented as placing her near her mother's body at the critical time, shortly before her father returned home.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening World · 10 October 1892 · page 3

Own Shame-Proof that a ,-jM WUl Was Made. ' jfi? ' " ' Boston, Oct. la Thn Globe print) axelat, ';$;. stvety to-day a Fall ltlver story embodyuig' "rthe following points tn the Bordon murder . k mystery : M, Besides those who testified for the Govern- ,& mont in tbo preliminary examination or -lMLlzrle A. Borden, before Judge BUUsdeU. v,ff fully twenty-aro now witnesses' will be called t ,j by the state at tbe trial ot the defendant for ' iffi murder In December. tV John II. Murphy, ot Bedford street.

See moreSee less

Fall t'l.V lllver, will testify that r be waa standing on-i.-V' the sidewalk close to tbe Borden bouw when -t ;r fh Mr. Borden entered hi yard, about iao , v ,-M o'clock on the morning ot Aug. 4, and be aa-r &r blm a minute or two later Vsbered late tin " :'f: house by Bridget Sulllvan. " V &s Mr. Murphy will swear that while Mr. Bor- - den was walking In the yard he aiwawlnV u W dow blind of tho room In which 'Mrs. Bor. . ',, den's body was attenrardi 'found cauUonsly ', t :f opened by a young woman, who had that . 'K rame morning told him when he called at the ""''M Borden house, about D.30 o'olook, that her n laiber had gone downtown' and would (tot be ' -4 back until noon, or later. This woman he1 '' ,Jk lia-s identified as tbo defendant, Ltxzle A. , i' Borden. 'gjti Tbe window Mr. Murphy designate tne , '?," one In which he saw Miss lizzie ll so tuaatej . that sho must hare been atandlng over the. ,-fi mutilated remains of her mother at the very V tlmo that her rather was about to enter the '. r. bouse, between 10.30 and 10.45 o'clock. ""t. .S Tbe next new witness of importance Is Mr. J , -',y'V Gustave F. ltonald. whose husband Is a wellii known civil engineer and whose horn during ' J? Wln'erlsatPa-rtuxet, B. I. tH She and her 'husband 'were guest at tb rBv Wilbur House at the time or the murder. ' f About aao o'clock on the morning of Aug. ij" 4 she went out, with ber baby In Its carrlago . ' 'i for a walk. Sbe wheeled tbe little one up j$ second street and stopped under the'blg tr -t near tho Borden house about 10.20 o'clock, , A. A minute later she heard a terrible cry or ' v5 groan and began looking around to e ''..rj whenco It came. " . f.", she looked up at the Borden house and saw j -ii'Jj In a room, through a partially open window, ''''j, a woman whose head was tn part covered by' '- Jv a rubber cap or hood and whose face ah saw - '. ?i plainly, as the distance was short. , -" 'I bis ludow sbo bos designated to the anV ,W. thorltlcs, and It U tho ons nearest to the -, , -( murdered woman, a Bho lay In the guest J, 'chamber ot her homo when found by tho. '' ri I police. ' ' -; I Mrs. ltonald was almost that minute ap. ' Aj.fl proachrd by Mr. Peter Mahony, of 103 Plea. l jtj ant stroct. Fall ltlver, who. is a timekeeper ' ,gr1M In tho Troy ir.ML He likewise bad beard the " lM groan, seen the woman at lbs window who 'tM I wore the peculiar head covering, and recog- ' 5?3 nlrcd her as tho younger daughter ot the ' vj Morden family, all the members ot which he ZM I knew quite v ell by sight. "Ill Augustus Gunning, now of 308 Plalnfleld v3 street, jobnsonvllle, P. I., was at that time a q"1 lodger In Mrs. Churchill's house, and ho too, Jif about 10 o'clock on thn morning of Aug. 4, -k saw Llulo Borden In the window ot the guest ' ' ''-J chamber, n Ith a dark-colored garment on and ' jwj a hood ot similar color covering her head. -,al As ho lool.ed across she seemed to be en. ', ,J gaged In cleaning, but upon seeing him aba VftS stepped aside from tbe window. ? E-M These witnesses will fix Miss Borden at ber '(vw mother's side almost at the minute when tbe '" Wa old lady probably was killed, and when Miss '" -,n Lizzie says In ber own statement that sbe ofl was elsewhere. -' Jtta Tbe next witnesses ot Importance are Mr. J JJ and Mrs. Frederick Cbace, ot 108 Fourth $m street. Fall ltlver, and Mrs. Abigail Man i VM Chester, their daughter. J Tbey were Irlends or the elder Bordens and -'j'fl visited them on the evening previous to tb IM murder. Tbey overheard a quarrel between "131 lizzie and ber father. i.tM All beard Mr. Borden say "You can 'jj'jj make your own choice and do It to-night. 'J Either let us know what bis name Is, or take 'jM tbe door on Saturday ; and when you go nab. fl Ing, fish for somo other place to live, as I will . 11 never listen to you again. I will know tbe iv'Jsai name of tbe man who got you Into trouble." ' tfM Then tbe Cbaces and Mrs. Manchester heard Jtfl Lizzie reply: " II I marry this man, will you . be satisfied that everything will be kept from yfejw the outside worldt" c'M Then the visitors were announced and eon- ,M versed with Mr, and Mrs. Borden upon th 'oH subject ot Lizzie's shame. v! G. ltomatne lltthwn, a wealtby New York WB dealer In machinery supplies, whose place of - .'H business is on Bey street, In tbe metropolis, $wM has made affidavit that a fewdJjaDrtrto ? -JjjH Continued on FlI A f09i , iH?,?J

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report cites new witnesses—Gunning and the Chace/Manchester family—who claim to have seen Lizzie Borden at a window around the time of the murder and overheard a heated quarrel the night before involving her father demanding she reveal a man's name connected to her 'shame.' Another affidavit from a New York businessman is also mentioned as forthcoming evidence.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening World · 10 October 1892 · page 3

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A Boston paper reports that the state has found five new witnesses for Lizzie Borden's December murder trial, including John H. Murphy, who claims he saw a woman identified as Lizzie cautiously open a window blind in the room where Mrs. Borden's body was later found. The report also mentions allegations of a quarrel with her father, which Borden's counsel denies.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening World · 10 October 1892 · page 3

MAY BE HER DOOM

Are Denied by Miss -pm Borden's Counsel. MM s9 IIostov, Oct. 10. -Tim c.Uilr prints exelt 'tjU slvil) to-day a l'all Hirer story embodying J9 I tho following points In tbs llordon murder 0,U

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report cites witnesses who claim to have seen Lizzie Borden at a window near the time of the murder, contradicting her own statement of her whereabouts. It also describes neighbors overhearing a heated quarrel the night before in which Andrew Borden demanded Lizzie reveal the name of a man who had gotten her 'into trouble' and Lizzie pleaded for secrecy about a planned marriage.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening World · 10 October 1892 · page 3

A QUARREL WITH HER FATHER.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The Boston Globe reportedly claims a young man caused trouble for Lizzie Borden, suggesting this secret led to the family's discord. The story also claims twenty-five new witnesses will offer startling testimony.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pawtucket Tribune · 10 October 1892 · page 1

SALEM, Mass, Oct. 10.-There was a very narrow escape (rom a serious railroad ac cident in the Salem yard yesterday. As the Portland Pullmsan No. 11 (due in Salem at 9:50) came around the curve at Castle hill at a good rate of speed, the en gincer saw the Rockport freight standing on the track ahead. Engineer Waterman at once reversed his engine and set the air brakes, but the rail was wet and the train could not be stopped until it struck the freight. The headwork of engine 494, on the Pullman, was considerably damaged, the tank was aprung, and the baggace car was consider ably smashed.

See moreSee less

The caboose on the freight wis smashed, The Borden Case Again, Boston, Oct, 10.~The Globe this morn ing publishes a story from Fal! River to the effect that some young man had ot Lizzie Borden into trouble, and that it led to the great family discord when the gecrct was discovered., It elaims that startling testimony will be given by twentv-tive new witnesses, Confirm ition and Dedication NAsSHUA, N. H., Oct. 10.—-Rt. Rev. D. M. Bradlev of Manchester issucsd the sacra ment of confirmation o over 200 ehildren at the Charch of the Immacnlate Concep tion vesterday afternoon. Following this he proceeded t the new convent building and performed its religions dedication. A Serlons Mistake, MiLußrinGk, Me, Oect. 10.—Fphraim Turner, while in the woods near Mill brid e, was <hiot and seriously wounded by George Mitchell, who mistook him for A deer, It is thnought that Turner will re cuver; A Novel Potition, BrapGeronr, Conn, Oct. 10, —~Attorneys for Jolin Hawley, convicted of the mur der of Mary L. Munson,ask for a new trial on the ground that one of the jurors was aslecp durving the greater part of the trial A Wronged Hushand's Revenge, Corvmpus, O, Oct. 10.--Michael Peffer anspected that s wife was entertaining » male visitor in their rooms, and retarning home unexpectedly and fiading the door locked, toreed 0% open. A seareh discov ered Joseph Waegerin a closet. Petfer drew a kuifo an® a dedperate stragele be gan, Waeger wan probably futally stabbed Neoeds Severo Panish nent, TATTLE Rock, Oct, l&- The enst end of this city was thrown into excitoment b pu assanlt made by Marion Williams, co ored, upon Miss RossMenderson. Ti: mnn, in his efforts to overpower th woman, threw her on a red hot stove burning her severely, Williams is in ja In autumn, winter and spring, colds are th rale rather than the exce tlon. Hence it s the part of every wise and pradent mother to keep on hand s supply of ln-. Bull’s Congh

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

The Boston Globe reports a sensational 13-column story claiming new evidence from twenty-five witnesses for the prosecution in the Borden case. It alleges Lizzie quarreled with her father the night before the murders over the identity of a man who had gotten her 'in trouble.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Alexandria Gazette · 10 October 1892 · page 2

Brooklyn. N. Y., October 26. The Texas Bankers' Association calls on all banks in the State to contribute from $0 to ."?10 to a fund for the families of the men who were killed by the Dal ton pan*:. Ada Gallagher, 26years old, a variety actress known ;is Ada Devere, commit? ted suicide at her lodgings in Philadel? phia some time last night by cutting her throat with a razor: Fire occurred at Crewe Station, Ya., on the Norfolk and Western Railroad this morning, burning six stores with contents. Loss ?35.000; partly insured.

See moreSee less

Tue lire originated in a bakery. Albert Leeds, professor of chemistry in Steven's Institute of Technology, Hoboken. X. J.. has renounced the re? publican party, and will support the cause of democracy. In his letter Prof. Leeds say.- the Mi Kinley tariff is a pal? pable robbery. Judge Paxsou, of the Supremo Court of Pennsylvania, in his charge to tho grand jury a: Piitsburg to-day in refer? ence tothejHomestead troubles, said: "Every ratjmher of an advisory com? mittee or by whatever name it is called, who has joined in a common purpose of resistance to the law and adenial of the rights to other citizens, has com? mitted treason against the State." The Boston Globe publishes a 13-col umn story from Fall River setting forth in detail new ami startling evidence of the prosecution iu the Borden murder ca-e which it says is in the hands of the police and is to be given by twenty-five new witnesses, who will testify for the State at the coming trial of Miss Lizzie Borden. Some of the evidence, it is. said. is very damaging against Lizzie Borden, and goes In show that the even? ing before the murders she iiad a quar? rel with her father who wanted to know lie name of I he man who had gotten her in trouble. At Torre Saute, Ind., this morning, a married man named Jas. A. Moore, ?of Prairitou, was found dead in a room at the Germania Hotel, and a woman named Sarah Ann Lowe, from the same place, lying unconscious by his side. It seems that he iiad promised, to marry her next mouth or as soon its he got a divorce. Siie says he gave her a drink of water, in which she thinks there was poison. She remembers that Moore told her many things to tell bis child? ren if he did not see them again. The evidence so far seems to be that Moore intended to kill the woman and then himself. Sitwill probably recover. At a meeting last night of local trades an?! labor unions aX -?. Louis the following was alopted: Resolved, that we call on all labor organizations to take such action as will tend to prevent in the future tin calling out of any armed bodies, state militia or otherwise, to be used for the purpose of forcing American workmen to comply with the demands of brutal aud tyranical capital. The sixty-second annual conference* id" the Mormon Church has closed at Salt Lake City. Cta . Tho reports from Utah. Idaho, Wy? oming. Colorado. Arizona; and New Mexico, showed a total membership of over 200,000. It was decided to dedicate the new temple on April4,1S93. This was commenced forty years ago and Ii is cost $2,500,000. The republican electoral ticket <>( Georgia will not bs fused with that of the people's party; Thus thero will bo four electoral tickets voted in Georgia?republican, demo? crat, people's partyand prohibition. TheAlicldgan democrats have gone into a combination with populists on legislative can iidatcs, the object being, it is said, to control if possible the choice of a United States Sena to.- by tinnext legislature. .?OiCSr.MKNTS.

See the clipping

The Olympia Tribune · Olympia, Wash.

The Boston Globe reportedly published a lengthy piece claiming several witnesses would testify they saw Lizzie Borden at her window at the moment her mother's body was discovered. Other witnesses allegedly overheard a quarrel the night before in which her father demanded she name a man who had gotten her into trouble or be turned out of the house.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Olympia Tribune · 10 October 1892 · page 1

BOSTON, October 10.-—The 01 ,‘this morning publishes e thirteen colmhp: . to the efleot. that several witnes” _Mm comingl trial of Lizzie Borden for -; ' ur derof «father and moiher. wi » that they new Lizzie 3t the window 1 her bohse on the day of the murder et g me which nukes it. certain she I! 4‘ ~ t

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Fall River is in an uproar after officials leaked suppressed evidence from the Borden murder case to the press, angering locals and prompting sympathy for Lizzie Borden. Attorney Jennings and reporters visited the Borden home, where Emma Borden and Mr. Morse denied reported quarrels, with Morse vowing legal action.

Morning Journal and Courier · 11 October 1892 · page 3

THE ALLEGED NEW EVIDENCE AGAINST LIZZIE BORDEN DISCREDITED DISCLOSURES AROUSE INDIGNATION THE EXCITEMENT INTENSE

citement Intense. Fall River, Oct. 10. The manifest breach of faith on the part of certain offi cers connected with the Borden murder cases by which certain evidence has been given to the publio has created anger in nearly all oiroles here, more particularly among the small coterie of local newspaper men who have been favored with the con fidence of the authorities with the under standing that some things should not be printed. Miss Borden baa made many friends also because of the broad publica tion of indelicate matters which were pur posely suppressed at the preliminary hear ing.

See moreSee less

In the published story there were many needless In accuracies and some new facts. These, together with some feeling of indignation, have prompted some local men to tell what they were asked to sup press. At 10 o'clock to-night the Borden mur ders are the sole topio of the conversation in hotels, clubs and streets. The story published this mnnrlnay-tian caused a re vulsion of feeling in favor of the girl. In police oiroles it is felt that the govern ment's case has been injured. Attorney Jennings went to the Borden house in com pany with two reporters. They were shown to the parlor, where Miss Emma and Mr. Morse denied emphatically all state ments made about quarrels, eto. Mr.Morse is very angry and he has commanded his lawyers to take steps at once to secure legal redress. Detectives Seaver and UoHenry are both in town to-night. The latter denies all knowledge of the matter published and says he is no way responsible for it. Bridget Sullivan and Detective Seaver spent some time together to-day looking up some minor details. There is great activity in telegraph offices and hotel corridors to-night as many out-of-town newspaper men have arrived and resumed their hustling of a few weeks ago. There is an undercurrent of feeling noticeable in some circles tbat Lizzie Borden's counsel have some sensational facts in their possession tending to show that their ollent is innocent. When Mr. Jennings was asked about this to-night he said some what significantly tbat he could not speak on that matter just now. A mistaken idea has been prevalent here for some days, that Mr. Morse is under arrest. Be has been seen with Deputy Sheriff Had field several times, but he is not in custody. The appraisal of the Borden estate has been completed, but no figures will be given before the report Is submitted to the probate conrt. It was said at the polios station to-night that this morning's story was laughed at. District Attorney Knowl ton is In New Bedford to day. Instead of appearing angry he smiled when asked about the importance of the alleged facts disclosed, and said he gnessed that the legal aspects of the case would not be hurt by the publication.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The report describes a revulsion of public feeling in Lizzie Borden's favor after a sensational story about family quarrels was published, with Emma Borden and Mr. Morse angrily denying the claims. Detectives, the district attorney, and lawyers are shown reacting calmly or dismissively to the controversy, while rumors swirl about new evidence favoring the defense.

CorrectionThis set right 11 earlier articles: Evening Journal, 10 October 1892, Evening Journal, 10 October 1892, Asheville Daily Citizen, 10 October 1892, The Evening World, 10 October 1892, The Evening World, 10 October 1892, The Evening World, 10 October 1892, The Evening World, 10 October 1892, The Evening World, 10 October 1892, Pawtucket Tribune, 10 October 1892, Alexandria Gazette, 10 October 1892, The Olympia Tribune, 10 October 1892.

Morning Journal and Courier · 11 October 1892 · page 3

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The Boston Globe reports that multiple witnesses will testify at Lizzie Borden's upcoming trial, including claims she was seen standing over her mother's body and that she quarreled with her father the night before the murders. Fall River defense attorney Andrew Jennings immediately denounces the story as a complete fabrication.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Los Angeles Herald · 11 October 1892 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE. Damaging Testimony Against the Alleged Parricide.

HIGHWAYMAN. A Remarkably Bold Case of Robbery—A Man Driving on Pico Street Kobbed of a Goodly Sum of Money. "Make a move and you are a dead man." This was the pleasant salutation that greeted Samuel McFadden early last evening as he waa driving along Pico 6treet juat eaet of the Nadeau viue,*-ard. Mr. McFadden was coming to the city from Santa Monica. He had been driv ing along peacefully, not dreaming of any halts or intermissions. He noticed juat before the above remark reached hia ears that hia horses had shied a little dot did not pay any attention to the break.

See moreSee less

When he looked up be beheld a man with au able bodied revolver cocked, which be preeented at his head. "Now, you just keep quiet, and you will be all right, was the pleasant re mark of the stranger. Mr. McFadden concluded that inas much as he was unarmed, it would be wise for him to keep quiet, and he ac cordingly did so. The man with the gun got into the wagon, and proceeded to go through Mr. McFadden. He abstrated $305 which the latter had in his pockets, and then gave the command, after getting out of the wagon: "Yon drive on, now, and if you turn around you ate a dead man." Mr. McFadden obeyed, and drove on. He came to the city, and proceeded at l once to the police station, whe<-e he re lated liis story. Capt. Roberts at once dispatched some men to take the trail and run down the robber. Mr. McF«dden is a man about 60 years of age. He has been farming in Sepulveda cation during the past Bum ! mer, and has been supplying the Sol , diera' home with potatoes. Yesterday be received a check for some of his pro* duct, from Major Thornton, the treas urer of the home. He proceeded to 1 Santa Monica, where he had some bus ■ mess to transact. There he got his i check cashed, and after paying out some small sums, he started for this city. The result was his experience with the lone highwayman on Pico street. At a late hour this morning tlie police had discovered no trace of the rival of Evans and Sontag who committed the robbery. LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE. Damaging Testimony Againtt the Al leged Parricide. Boston, Oct. 10.—The Globe this morning published a 13-colurnn story, to the effect that several witnesses at the I coming trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and mother, will swear that they saw Lizzie at the window of her houee on the day of the murder, at at a time which makes it certain that 1 she was at that moment standing over i the body of her mother. Others, it is I stated, will swear that they overheard a I quarrel between Lizzie and her father | the night before the murder, in which the latter told her that unless ehe gave , I the name of the man who got her into trouble, he would turn her out of the , houee. Mr. G. Romaine Pittson, a wealthy 1 New Yorker, made affidavit that a few i days prior to the murder, Mr. Borden • conaulted him as a friend about Lizzie, . whose trouble he related. George Sis son, it is said, will swear that less than a month before the murder, Borden told him he had made hia will, giving Emma and Lizzie $25,000 caah, which was more than he would have allowed them, , but for his wife's intercession. Bridget Sullivan will; it is said, corroborate the story of a quarrel between Mr. Barden and Lizzie; also that on the afternoon of the day of the murder Lizzie whis pered to her: "Keep your tongue still and don't talk to these officers, and you can have all the money you want." Fall River, Mass., Oct. 10.—Andrew J. Jennings, counsel for the defenaant in the Borden murder case, asserts that the matter publiahed in a Boston paper ia a "tissue of lies." The story publiebed thiß morning has caused a revulsion of feeling in favor of the girl. Miss Emma and Mr. Morse deny all the statements made about quarrels. Detective McHenry denies all knowledge of the matters pub lished.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

The Boston Globe published a lengthy story claiming new witnesses would testify to seeing Lizzie near her mother's body and overhearing a quarrel with her father the night before the murders. Lizzie Borden's counsel immediately denounced the story as "a tissue of lies."

The Record-Union · 11 October 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BOKDSN CASK. Sensational Story I'ubllshod by n Bos ton .Journal. Boston, Oct. 10.—Tho Globe this morn ing published a thirteen-eolumn story to the etlect that several witnesses at the coming trial ot Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother will swear they saw Lizzie at the window of her houso on the day of the murder at a time which makes it certain she was at that moment standing over the I ody ol' her mother. Others, it is slated, will swear they overheard a quarrel between Lizzie and her father the night before th>: murder, in which tiie latter told her that unless sho gave the name ofthe man who

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The Boston Globe claims 25 new witnesses will testify against Lizzie Borden at her upcoming trial, including a man who allegedly saw her at a window near her mother's body as her father entered the house. The report frames this as damning circumstantial evidence assembled by police for the prosecution.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 11 October 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN'S PERIL

cation by Her Lawyer. Boston, Oct. 11.—The Globe publishes a story from Fall River setting forth in detail and startling ovidence for the prosecution in tho Borden murdor case, which it says is iu the hands of tho po lice. and is to bo given by twenty-five new witnesses, who will testify for tho state at the coining trial of Miss Lizzie Borden. Tho evidence, The Globe states, is forthcoming from persous who all stand high in the communities whore they live, and who could have motive for s m aking imdioiously or untruthfully ho defendant. Briefly stated, the of t evidence, according to The Glob*, John H. Murphy, who resides in Bed ford street, Fall River, will testify that lie was standing on the sidewalk cli 10

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The report details sensational new witness claims against Lizzie Borden, including a man who allegedly saw her near a window above the murdered body and a woman who heard screams, plus claims of quarrels and overheard confessions. Defense counsel Jennings immediately denounces the entire story as 'a tissue of lies' and fabrication.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 11 October 1892 · page 1

TWENTY-FIVE NEW WITNESSES,

John H. Murphy, who resides in Bed ford street, Fall River, will testify that lie was standing on the sidewalk cli 10 the Borden homo when Mr. Borde tered his yard about 10:40 o 'clock on the inuming of August 4, and h he s him a minute two later usliured into the lobby by Bridget Sullivan. Mr. Murphy will swear that while Mr. Borden wiib walking in the yard he a window blind of the >m in which Mrs. Bor den's body w afterwarda found cau tiously opened by Lizzie A.

See moreSee less

Borden. The ow Mr. Murphy designates as the mich ho Miss Lizzie i situated that she must have been stand ing over tho mutilated body of hor mother at the very time that her fat lier was about to enter the bouse. Hoard On The next witness of inqortnnce is Mrs. Gustave A. Ronald, of Pawtuxet, R. I., who was a guest at tho Will* House. Atout 0:40 tho morning of the der she was wheeling her baby carnage ear the Borden house, whe she heard a terrible cry or gr< . She looked up at the Borden ho and thi gh a 'iiulow diose .infill part covered by rubber hood, whose face she . plainly, cap tho distance was short. This window «he has designated is the same tlioo pointed out by Mr. Murpliv. Other wit nesses there are who will gi give similar testimony. Mr. and Mrs. Chase, of Fall River, will testify to a quarrel l>etwee Lizzie and her father the night befi the murder, and Bridget Sullivan will corroborate it. r The latter will testify that on the aftera of the day of the murder Lizzie whispered to her: "Keep your tongue still ami don't talk to these officers and y lmvo all the money you want." McHenry, the detective, and his wife will, it is said, give important ndenc which relates in part to the story of the trouble betweeij Lizzie and Emma Bor den in the matron's room, in which the former accused tho latter of having "given her away." This tale, it is said, will l>e corrolioratad bv the Mi'IIenrvn, who overheafd and' saw tho affair through a hole in the wall especially •iilod by the authorities. pro\ a Fabrication. Fall River, Mass., Oct., 11.—Andrew J. Jenniugn. counsel for the ilefeudant in the Borden murder case, made the following statement: "The mnttor pub lished iu u Boston |«por i«]n(tng to the murders of Andrew J. Borden and Iris wife is a tissue of lies. The kornel of tin* whole malicious story deals with a condition which is absolutely disproved by things found in the cellar by the E rosecution and admitted to l>e what

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The Boston Globe reports a sensational story claiming twenty-five new witnesses will testify for the prosecution that they saw Lizzie Borden in her mother's room around the time of the murder, wearing a rubber hood and cape, and that they heard groans. It also claims testimony will show Lizzie and her father quarreled over a mysterious matter she refused to explain.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Morning News · 11 October 1892 · page 1

Boston, Oct. 10.—The Globe publishes a thirteen column story from Fall River giv ing new and startling evidence in the noted Borden murder case. Twenty-five new witnesses, it says, will testify for the prose cution. These will testify to having seen Lizzie Borden in her mother’s room about the time the murder must have been com mitted concealed in a long rubber hood and cape, and teat they hoard groans. It will aiao be testided that Lizzie and nor father h-.d quarreled, the girl refusing to say who had got her into trouble,

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The Boston Globe reports a sensational thirteen-column story claiming police hold new evidence from twenty-five witnesses, including people who allegedly saw Lizzie at her mother's window near the time of the murder. It also describes an alleged overheard quarrel between Lizzie and her father about a secret suitor, though the story notes it has been vigorously denied.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 11 October 1892 · page 3

Boston, Oct. 10. The Globe this morn ing publishes a thirteen-colnmn story from Fall Kiver, sotting forth in detail new and startling evidence for tho prosecution in the Borden murder case, which it says is in the hands of the police, and is to bo given by twenty-live new witnesses who will testify for the State at the coming trial of Miss Lizzie Borden. The evidence, tho Globo states, is forthcoming from people who stand high in the communities whero they live, and who could have no motive for speaking maliciously or untruthfully of the defendant.

See moreSee less

Among the witnesses given are John II. Murphy and Mrs. Gustavo F. Konald, who are alleged to have seen Lizzie Borden at the window of her mother's room about the time the latter was killed. Mr. and Mrs. Frederick Chase, of Fall Kiver, and Mrs. Abigail Manchester, their daughter, were friends of the elder Bor dens and visited them on the evening pre vious to the murder. They overheard, it is stated, a quarrel between Lizzie and her father. All heard Mr. Borden say: "You can make your own choice and do it to night. Either let us know what his name is or take the door on Saturday and go fishing for some other place to live, as I will never listen to you again. 1 will know the name of the man who got you into trouble." Lizzie is said to have replied: "If I marry this man will you be satisfied that evervthing will be kept from the out side world!" Then the visitors were an nounced and conversed with Mr. and Mrs. Borden on the subject of the quarrel. Mr. Borden said: 'I would rather see her dead than have it come out." G. Komaine Pittson. a wealthy New York dealer in machinery supplies, has made af fidavit that, a few day s prior to the mur der, Mr. Borden consulted him, as a friend, about Lizzie, whose trouble he related in detail. Mrs. George J. Sisson. of Fall Kiver. is said to have heard Lizzie say to Bridget Sullivan, the hired girl: "Why don't you say how mnch money yon want to keep quietT" Bridget's answer was: "I don't know what you mean, but you are not the girl I took you to be." Mr. George Sisson, it is said, will swear that, less than a month before the murder, Mr. Borden told him he bad made a will, giving Emma and Lizzie $5,000 cash, which was more than he would have allowed them but for his wife's intercession. Bridget bnllivan, it is claimed, will cor roborate the story of the quarrel between Mr. Borden and Lizzie; also that she beard, tho night before the murders, Morse and Lizzie talking about a vr.il 1: also that, on the afternoon of the day of tbe murders. Lizzie whispered to her: "Keep your tongue still, and don't talk to these officer, and you can have all the money you want."

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report lists sensational claims from various witnesses alleging a quarrel between Lizzie and her father, hints of blackmail, and a will favoring his daughters, suggesting a motive for murder. Defense attorney Andrew Jennings immediately denounces the published account as "a tissue of lies," disputing the existence of key witnesses.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 11 October 1892 · page 3

THE BORDEN MURDER CASE

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report disputes a sensational story involving a 'George F. Sisson' and a 'Kegan' account, with family members and Mr. Morse denying their truth while a police source calls the substance accurate despite fictitious names. It also criticizes a breach of confidentiality by officials that leaked suppressed details, including a new claim that Lizzie overdrew a letter of credit in Europe and was scolded by her father.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Indianapolis Journal · 11 October 1892 · page 3

DENOUNCED AS LIE?. A dispatch from Fall Kiver says that Andrew J. Jennings, connsel for tbe de fendant In the Borden murder cases made the following statement to-day: The matter published in a Boston paper this morning relating to the murders of Andrew J. Borden and bis wife is a tissue of lies. I have endeavored to find out about Mr. and Mr. Fred Chase at the number indicated 19S fourth street. Fall Kiver. There is not only no such number, but not any within fifty of it. There is no such name a George F.

See moreSee less

Sisson in the directory, nor can I find any person who Knows anybody of that name. The kernel of the whole mali cious story deals with a condition which is absolutely disproved by things foar.ri in the cellar by the prosecution and admitted to be what Miss Lizzie claimed they were. Subsequent events have confirmed her claim. Mr. Morse says that the whole story is absolutely false not a word of truth in iu The Kegan story has already been denied by Miss Emma and Miss Lizzie, and was admitted by Mrs. Keacan to be falo to at lo.-tst six persons." A member of tho police force says that the names used in the story indicated are fictitious, but the matter is substantially true. Tbe manifest breach of faith on tho part of certatn officers connected with the Bor den murder case, by which certain evi dence has been siveu to the public, has cre ated anger in nearly all circles at Fail Kiver, moro particularly among the small coterie of local newspaper men, who have been favored with the rontideoceof the au thorities with the understanding that some things should not be printed. Miss Borden has made many friends, a!eo, be cause of the broad publication of indelicate matters which were purposely suppressed at the preliminary hearing. In tho pub lished story thero wero many needless in accuracies and some new facts. These, to 'gether with some feeling of indignation, have prompted Fall Kiver reporters to tell what they were asked to suppress. A Fall Kiver paper says: VA creat deal Is printed regarding the family relations which is not new. It is evident that some body who has been employed by the State in this case has sold every secret in his possession or has given away the same. The pnblio is at liberty to aness who the person was, and whether or not he fattened his pocket-book by the transaction. Inns much, however, as a paid servant of the prosecution is under no obligation to hold his tongue, the paper feels at liberty to disclose any information which has come into its possession." It then goes on to state the following new facts in this case: Miss Borden was a terror to bor parents. Her character, as manifested in churches and various religious societies, was all that could be desired, but at homo she was not a pleasant person with whom to dwell. She made many of her ac quaintances believe that she was intensely interested in her property. While travel ing in Europe she overdrew her letter of credit, and a man prominent in businesses cles honored the draft. When her lather's attention was called to the matter, he com mented very severely and harshly on his daughter's extravaganoo. This statement is another addition to the number already made, showing that while Mr. Borden might have been loving, he was not an in dulgent parent. The man who was paid to give away tho State's case did not touch on the fact that Bridget Sullivan told a friend that she saw Lizzie droo something into a pan of milk which was on the stote; that she threw the niillc away when both Mr. and Mrs. Borden thought they bad been poisoned. The prosecution claimed to-day that tbe poison was used, and that Bridget Sullivan, ainonz the rest, was a sufferer from it." The Fail Kiver Globe says, to-nijrht: "A man very prominent in the case states that the district attorney now has in his pos session the hatchet with which the mur ders were committed. It is quite certain that local officers at work on the case have given np their hunt for the weapon." To-night the opinion is very prevalent at Fall Kiver that the state's case has been greatly injured by to-days developments. Whether Miss Borden is guilty or innocent, they feel that continued excitement will tend to make a tair. impartial trial more difficult than ever, and will tend to shatter the respect for the proper authorities among the general public. Both the dis trict attorney and city marshal have a well-defined idea who tho culprit is, while Mayor Couchlin is taking steps to have the local officers clear themselves and to place

See the clipping

Dziennik Chicagoski · Chicago, Ill.

Boston papers published dramatic witness testimony against Lizzie Borden that turned public opinion against her, but these claims were soon found largely fabricated. Many of the supposed witnesses could not be located or did not exist, restoring public sympathy for the accused.

Dziennik Chicagoski · 11 October 1892 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The Boston Globe publishes a thirteen-column story claiming twenty-five new witnesses will testify against Lizzie Borden at trial, including damning quotes allegedly overheard by Mrs. Sisson and Bridget Sullivan. The alleged testimony includes Lizzie offering money to buy silence and references to a disputed will.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 11 October 1892 · page 2

THE BORDEN CASE.

GENERAL ALGER. KANSAS Cm", Oct. 10. General Russell A. Alger spoke to a great crowd in Kansas City, Kan., this eveniug, it being the first of a series of speeches which ha will de liver in that state. He discussed briefly the tariff and financial issues iu the cam paign, but devoted the principal portion of his speech to the old soldiers. He urged those who would dosert the Republican part-, to fol low after false gods, to remain and those who had deserted to leturn. The Repub lican party, he said, was the ouly one which could bs expecred to givo the veter ans of the war their just deserts.

See moreSee less

Noth ing could be expected of the other two parlies, which were not favorable to pen sioning old soldiers and who denounced pensioners as paupers and leeches. THE BORDEN CASE. BOSTON, Oct. 10. Th6 Boston Globe this morning publishes a thirteeu-column story from Fall River, setting forth in de tail new and startling evidence for the prosecutiou in the Borden murder case, which it says, is in the hands of the police. Tne evidence is to be given by twenty-five new witnesses, who will testity for the state at the coming trial of Miss Lizzie Borden. The evidence, tho Globe states, is forthcoming from people all of whom stand high in the communities where they live, aud who could have no motive for speaking maliciously or untruthfully of the defendant. According to the evidence Lizzio Borden is the guilty partv. Of these witnesses. Mrs. George Sisson of Fall River is said to have heard Lizzie say to Bridget Sullivan, the hired girl, "Why don't you say how much mouoy you want to keep quiet?" Bridget's answer .was: "L don't know what vou mean, but you are not the girl I took vou to be." Mr." Sisson, it is said, will swear that less than a month before the murder Mr. Borden told him that he had made a will giving Emma and Lizzie S'JS.ODO in casn, which was more than he would have allowed them but for his wife's interces sion. Bridget Sullivan will, it is claimed, cor roborate the other wituess in the story of the quarrel between Mr. Borden and Liz zie; also that she heard the night before the murder Morse and Lizzie talking about a will: also that on the afternoon of the day of the murder Lizzie whispered to her. "Keep your tongue still, and don't, talk to the ottlceis. and you cau have all themoney you wa'nt." Fall River, Mass., Oct. 10. Andrew Jennings, counsel for Lizzie Borden, made a statement to the Associated Pi ess cor respondent today, saying that the matter published iu the Boston paper this morn ing relating to tho murder of Andrew Bor den and wife is a tissue of lies. He had looked for several of the witnesses men tioned in the article, but could not find them, A member of the police force says that the names used in the Boston Globe's story are fictictious, but that the matter is substantially true. Fall river, Mass Oct. 10. rhe mani fest breach of faith on the part of certain officers connected with the Borden minder case, by which certain evidence has been giveu to the public, has aroused the anger ot nearly all interested here, more particu larly among a small coterie of local news paper men, who had been favored with the coufider.ee of the authorities with the un derstanding that some things should not be printed. Miss Borden lias been made many friends also because of the publica tion of indelicate matters, which wore pur posely suppressed at the preliminary hear ing. Iu the published stories thete were many needless inaccuracies and some new facts. These, together with some feeling of indignation, have prompted sorau local newspaper men to tell what they were ask ed to suppress. A local paper says that a great deal has been printed regarding the family rel i tions that is not new. It is evident that somebody who has been employed by the government in this case has sold about every secret iu his possession, or has giveu away the same. Iuasmuch, however, as a paid servant of the prosecution has no ob ject in holding h's tougue, the paper feels at liberty to disclose any information which has come into its possession. It then crocs on ro sav that Miss Borden was a tenor to her parents. Her character as ! manifested iu church and in various re ligious societies was nil that conld be de sired, but at homo she was not a pleasant person "with whom to dwell. She made many of her acquaintances believe that she w!i mt.Hiisi'lv interested in the disnosal of the nroperty. Mfcs Jesie Rodman, an J intimate friend of Lizzie's whs peisiiaded t by the latter to maKe a win m ner (liz zie's) favor. Another fact, showing her interest in the property, is the family quarrel which followed the deeding of some property to lier stepmother. The quarrel was prolonged and bitter. The Globe says tonight that a man prominent in the case says that the dis trict attorney now has in his possession the ha'chet with which the murder was committed. Tonight the opinion ir preva lent here that the government's case has been Injured greatly by today's develop ments. Whether Miss Borden is. guilty or innocent, they feel that the continued ex citement will tend to make an Impartial trial more difficult than ever.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The report details alleged testimony from witnesses like Bridget Sullivan and Mrs. Sisson suggesting Lizzie tried to bribe Bridget for silence and discussed her father's will before the murders. Lizzie's attorney calls the published account 'a tissue of lies,' while a police source claims the names are fictitious but the substance is true, amid anger over leaked confidential evidence.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 11 October 1892 · page 2

less than a month before the murder Mr. Borden told him that he had made a will giving Emma and Lizzie S'JS.ODO in casn, which was more than he would have allowed them but for his wife's interces sion. Bridget Sullivan will, it is claimed, cor roborate the other wituess in the story of the quarrel between Mr. Borden and Liz zie; also that she heard the night before the murder Morse and Lizzie talking about a will: also that on the afternoon of the day of the murder Lizzie whispered to her.

See moreSee less

"Keep your tongue still, and don't, talk to the ottlceis. and you cau have all themoney you wa'nt." Fall River, Mass., Oct. 10. Andrew Jennings, counsel for Lizzie Borden, made a statement to the Associated Pi ess cor respondent today, saying that the matter published iu the Boston paper this morn ing relating to tho murder of Andrew Bor den and wife is a tissue of lies. He had looked for several of the witnesses men tioned in the article, but could not find them, A member of the police force says that the names used in the Boston Globe's story are fictictious, but that the matter is substantially true. Fall river, Mass Oct. 10. rhe mani fest breach of faith on the part of certain officers connected with the Borden minder case, by which certain evidence has been giveu to the public, has aroused the anger ot nearly all interested here, more particu larly among a small coterie of local news paper men, who had been favored with the coufider.ee of the authorities with the un derstanding that some things should not be printed. Miss Borden lias been made many friends also because of the publica tion of indelicate matters, which wore pur posely suppressed at the preliminary hear ing. Iu the published stories thete were many needless inaccuracies and some new facts. These, together with some feeling of indignation, have prompted sorau local newspaper men to tell what they were ask ed to suppress. A local paper says that a great deal has been printed regarding the family rel i tions that is not new. It is evident that somebody who has been employed by the government in this case has sold about every secret iu his possession, or has giveu away the same. Iuasmuch, however, as a paid servant of the prosecution has no ob ject in holding h's tougue, the paper feels at liberty to disclose any information which has come into its possession. It then crocs on ro sav that Miss Borden was a tenor to her parents. Her character as !

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The Boston Globe publishes a thirteen-column story claiming 25 new witnesses will testify at Lizzie Borden's trial, including one who allegedly saw her standing over her mother's body through a window. Other witnesses reportedly saw her at the same window after hearing a scream, and friends of the Bordens allegedly overheard a revealing quarrel the night before the murders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 11 October 1892 · page 3

Neue Enthüllungen über den Borden'schen Doppelmord

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The Fall River Globe reports multiple witnesses claiming to have seen Lizzie Borden standing over her mother's body, identified by a distinctive rubber cap, and describes an overheard argument between Lizzie and her father about a mystery man, plus an alleged bribe to maid Bridget Sullivan. Defense attorney Jennings immediately denounces the entire story as fabricated lies, claiming none of the named witnesses exist in Fall River, while police claim the substance is true despite deliberately falsified witness names.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 11 October 1892 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Lizzie Borden's attorney Andrew J. Jennings calls a Boston newspaper's report on the Borden murder case a complete fabrication, noting the names used don't appear in the city directory. However, a police officer counters that while the names may be fictitious, the substance of the story is accurate.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 11 October 1892 · page 1

Lizzie Borden. Fall Rivkk, Mass.. Oct 10.—Andrew J. Jennings, counsel for Lizzie Borden, said today that the matter published in the Bos ton papers this morning about the Borden murder is a tissue of lies. There are no such names in the directory as some of those mentioned in the story. A member of the police force today says that i the names used in the story are fictitious but the matter is Substantially true.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Fall River reacts angrily to leaked inquest evidence in the Borden case, with the Boston Globe retracting parts of its earlier reporting. New claims emerge portraying Lizzie Borden as domestically difficult and financially extravagant, contrasted with her public reputation for piety.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 11 October 1892 · page 1

Proving Mill Linin'* Innoctnc*. Fall Kivkk. Mass.. Oct. 10.—The man ifest breach of faith on the part of certain officers connected with the Borden murder cases, by which ivrtain evidence has been given to the public, ha* created anger in nearly ali circles here. In the published story were manv needless inaccuracies and sonic new facts. A local paper says : * A great deal is printed regarding the family relations which is not new. It is evident that somebody employed by the government in this case has told alajut every secret in his possession.

See moreSee less

Inasmuch as the paid servant of the prose cution is under no obligation to hold hi* tongue, this paper feels at liberty to dis close any information which has come into its possession. ' It goes on to state the following new fact# in the case : Miss Borden was a terror to her parents. Her character, as inatii fested at church and in various religious societies, was ail that could be desired, but at home she was not a pleasant person with whom to dwell. She made many of her acquaintance* believe that she was intense ly interested in property. While travelling in Europe she overdrew her letter of credit, and a man prominent in business circles honored her draft. When her father's attention was called to the mat ter he commented very severely and harsh ly'on his daughter # extravagance. Some years ago Mis# .losie Hodman was very intimate with Lizzie Borden. The influence Miss Borden exercised over her was not relished by Miss Rodman's friends. Miss Borden attempted to persuade Mi*# Hodman, who was in failing health, to make a w ill in her favor, promising at the same time to make a will in favor of Mis* Hodman. Mr. Jennings drew Mis# Hodman'* will, hut it has not been shown that Lizzie Borden was tin* lieneticiary. although sinsought to be. Another fact, showing her interest in property, i# the family quarrel which fol lowed tin* deeding df some property to her stepmother. The quarrel wa* prolonged and hitter. The man who wa# paid to gin* aw ay the government's case did not touch on tin* fact that Bridget Sullivan told a friend that sin* saw Lizzie drop something, into a nan of milk which wa* on the stove : that sin* threw the milk away: that Mr. and Mrs. Borden both thought they had b -cn j*oi*oni‘d. The prosecution claims today that poison wa# used an i Bridget Sullivan, among the rest, was a sufferer from it. Mr. Borden talked wish Secretary Hounsevilb* <»f the Manufacturer* Assoca

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A local paper claims a government-paid source leaked unsavory details about Lizzie Borden, portraying her as obsessed with property and difficult at home, including an overdrawn letter of credit and attempts to secure a friend's will. It also reports a secondhand claim that Bridget Sullivan saw Lizzie put something in milk that allegedly poisoned the Borden household, and notes a grand juror's indiscreet comment about the case.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 11 October 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN CASE.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A local Fall River paper reports that someone connected to the prosecution leaked case details to the press, prompting the paper to publish further unconfirmed claims about Lizzie Borden's character, finances, and family quarrels. It also repeats a secondhand claim that Bridget Sullivan saw Lizzie put something in milk, feeding a poisoning theory the prosecution reportedly endorsed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Portland Daily Press · 11 October 1892 · page 1

THEIR EFFECT HAS BEEN TO ADD TO PUBLIC SYMPATHY.

Fall River, Mass., October 10.—The manifest breach of faith on the part of certain officers connected with the Bor den murder cases by which certain evi dence has been given to the public, lias created anger in nearly all circles here. In the published story were many need less inaccuracies and some new facts. A local paper says: “A great deal is printed regarding the family relations which is not new. It is evident that somebody employed by the government in this case has told about every secret in his possession.

See moreSee less

Inasmuch as a paid servant of the prosecution is under no obligation to hold his tongue, this paper feels at liberty to disclose any informa tion which has come into its possession.” The paper goes on to state the follow ing new facts in the case: Miss Borden was a terror to her parents. Her character, as manifested in church and various religious societies, was all that could be desired, but at home she was not a pleasant person with whom to dwell. She made many of her acquaintances believe she was in tensely interested in property. While travelling in Europe, she overdrew her letter of credit, and a man prominent in business circles honored her draft. When her father’s attention was called to the mnltpr lip .‘■ 11 n,1 t'o,] vprv spvprplv aild harshly on his daughter’s extravagance. Some years ago, Miss Josie Rodman was very intimate with Lizzie Borden. The influence Miss Borden exercised over her was not relished by Miss Rodman’s friends. Miss Borden attempted to per suade Miss Rodman, who was in failing health, to make a will in her favor promising at the same time to make a will in favor of Miss Rodman. Mr. Jen nings drew Miss Rodman’s will, but it has not been shown that Lizzie Borden was a beneficiary, although she sought to be. . Another fact showing her in terest in the property, is The Family Quarrel Which Followed the deeding of some property to her step mother. The quarrel was prolonged and bitter. The man who was paid to give away the government’s case did not touch on the fact that Bridget Sullivan told a friend that she saw Lizzie drop some thing into a pan of milk which was on the stove; that she threw the milk away, and that Mr. and Mrs. Borden both thought they had been poisoned. The prosecution claims today that poison was used and that Bridget Sullivan, among the rest, was a sufferer from it. Mr. Borden talked with Secretary Rqunseville of the Manufacturers’ Asso ciation shortly before his death about his family affairs. He told Mr. Rounseville that he was not living on his farm during the summer because there was so much trouble in his family he did not feel like going. Since the hearing, a grand juror has been indiscreet enough to remark that he could not bring an indictment if the pow ers above testified against the prisoner. District Attorney Knowlton lias the juror’s name and he will not sit on the case. The Fall River Globe says tonight: “A man very prominent in the case states that the district attorney Now Has the Hatchet with which the murders were committed It is quite certain that the local officers

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

This report describes a flurry of conflicting claims in the Borden case, including a prosecution theory that poison was used and that Bridget Sullivan was also poisoned, alongside a report that the district attorney now has the murder hatchet. It also debunks earlier rumors, including a supposed witness sighting of a fleeing man and a false report that Mr. Morse had been arrested.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Portland Daily Press · 11 October 1892 · page 1

at work ^n the case have given up the hunt for the weapon.” The story telegraphed some time ago from Pawtucket to the effect that Mrs. James Marshall would tesnry to Having seen a man escape from the Borden yard by way of Third street proves to have little foundation in fact. The younger Mrs. Marshall, who was with the lady at the time says they saw no such person as described. Tonight the opinion is very prevalent here that the government’s case is great ly injured by today’s developments. Whether Miss Borden is guilty or inno cent, it is felt that continued excitement will tend to make a fair, impartial trial more difficult than ever and tend to shat ter respect for the proper authorities among the general public.

See moreSee less

Attorney Jennings went to the Borden house tonight in company with two re porters. Miss Emma and Mr. Morse denied emphatically all the statements made about the quarrels, etc. Mr. Morse was very angry and has com manded his lawyers to take steps at once to secure legal redress. Detective McHenry denies all knowledge of the matter published. He says he is no way responsible for it. There is an under current of feeling noticeable in some circles that Lizzie Borden’s counsel Have Some Sensational Facts in their possession, tending to show their client innocent. A mistaken idea has been prevalent here for some days that Mr. Morse was under arrest. The appraisal of the Borden estate is completed, but no figures will be given before the report is submitted to the probate court. It was said at the police station tonight that this1 morning’s story was laughed at. District Attorney Knowlton smiled when asked about tlie Importance of the alleged facts dis closed and said he guessed the legal aspects of the case would not be hurt by the publication.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Detective McHenry denies selling a sensational story about new witnesses to the Globe, while the paper admits parts of its own report were inaccurate after checking with Dr. and Mrs. Bowen. Lizzie Borden's lawyer Jennings calls the entire account, which claimed witnesses saw a rubber-capped woman and heard groans during the murder, a 'tissue of lies.'

The Portland Daily Press · 11 October 1892 · page 1

AS TOLD IN BOSTON.

It is quite certain that the local officers at work ^n the case have given up the hunt for the weapon.” The story telegraphed some time ago from Pawtucket to the effect that Mrs. James Marshall would tesnry to Having seen a man escape from the Borden yard by way of Third street proves to have little foundation in fact. The younger Mrs. Marshall, who was with the lady at the time says they saw no such person as described. Tonight the opinion is very prevalent here that the government’s case is great ly injured by today’s developments.

See moreSee less

Whether Miss Borden is guilty or inno cent, it is felt that continued excitement will tend to make a fair, impartial trial more difficult than ever and tend to shat ter respect for the proper authorities among the general public. Attorney Jennings went to the Borden house tonight in company with two re porters. Miss Emma and Mr. Morse denied emphatically all the statements made about the quarrels, etc. Mr. Morse was very angry and has com manded his lawyers to take steps at once to secure legal redress. Detective McHenry denies all knowledge of the matter published. He says he is no way responsible for it. There is an under current of feeling noticeable in some circles that Lizzie Borden’s counsel Have Some Sensational Facts in their possession, tending to show their client innocent. A mistaken idea has been prevalent here for some days that Mr. Morse was under arrest. The appraisal of the Borden estate is completed, but no figures will be given before the report is submitted to the probate court. It was said at the police station tonight that this1 morning’s story was laughed at. District Attorney Knowlton smiled when asked about tlie Importance of the alleged facts dis closed and said he guessed the legal aspects of the case would not be hurt by the publication.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report says a story claiming Lizzie Borden consulted a Providence lawyer about her father's estate before his death has been investigated and found baseless, likely originating from barbershop gossip. It also criticizes the judge for presiding over the preliminary examination after already hearing the inquest, calling the prosecution's methods and Fall River's rumor-mongering improper.

The Portland Daily Press · 11 October 1892 · page 4

There seems to be either a concerted attempt in Fall Kiver to prejudice the case of Miss Lizzie Borden before the public, or else there is some reckless newspaper work done in that city. Not long ago a story was sent out t.o the effect that the government would be able to prove that Miss Borden had been to Providence to consult a lawyer about the division of her father’s estate in case the latter should die. It was stated that a prominent lawyer was ready to step for ward and substantiate this.

See moreSee less

This story has been investigated, and as nearly as can be ascertained there is not even the slightest foundation for it. It apparent ly arose from some fragments of conver sation in a Fall Kiver barber shop. Whether Miss Borden is guilty or inno. cent of the charges against her will be left for the trial to determine, and any expressions of opinions from persons or papers in other cities and states are valueless on this question. But as to the methods which the prosecution are em ploying against her, and the manner in which these methods are supplemented by reckless stories put in circulation from Fail Kiver, the public may form a cor rect idea. And wo believe that there is a general condemnation of the methods used against Miss Borden, beginning with the singular indelicacy of the judge who insisted in presiding at the prelimi nary examination after he had already heard the case at the inquest, and ending with the baseless and prejudicial stories pilt in circulation from time to time in certain of the Fall Kiver papers.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The Boston Globe published lengthy stories attributed to twenty prosecution witnesses, including claims of threats, inheritance disputes, and sightings of Lizzie at a window during the murders. Lizzie's counsel denounced the account as a tissue of lies, and many believed it damaged the government's case.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

St. Paul Daily Globe · 11 October 1892 · page 4

STATE'S TESTIMONY.

Bostoh, Oct. 10.— The Globe this 'morning prints a dozen columns of the stories of twenty witnesses in the Bor den murder case, who have Riven af fidavits to the government. Some of these stories are of au alarming nature and are as follows: ' Mr. Frank Burroughs, a well known New York city lawyer, will testify thai eight months before the murder oc curred Lizzie Borden consulted him about the disposition of property in the event of a stepmother's death before that of her husband. Mr. and Mrs. Frederick Chase and Mrs.

See moreSee less

Abigail Manchester will testify that on the night before the murder, while calling at the Borden house, aud before being announced, they had over heard Mr. Borden in another room threatening to turn Lizzie out of doors unless she would repeat the name of the man "who got her -into trouble." G. Komaind Pittson. a wealthy dealer In machinery supplies in New York, . will testify that Mr. Borden Detailed Lizzie* Trouble to him. and was advised to disinherit her unless she would reveal the man's name. John N. Murphy, Mrs. Gustave F. Ronald, Peter Mahany and Augustus Gunning will testify to having seen Lizzie Borden at a window where and when she must have been standing over the dead body of her stepmother at a time when her father was walking in the yard. Mrs. G. J. Simpson will testify that at the Borden funeral she over heard Lizzie asking Bridget Sullivan, the servant.how much money she wanted to keep quiet. Private Detective McHenry will tes tify that, lying concealed in a bath room, he witnessed the quarrel In the matron's room between the sisters, aud that Lizzie kicked Emma thrice, called her a foul name and said: "You wanted to,, see me banged so you could come into the entire fortune. You are the one person whom 1 thought I could trust with my secret." Mrs. Reagan, the ma tron, and one other deposed to the same effect. The Globe promises to publish a certain piece of very important in formation, recently gained by Officer Harrington, as soon as the interests of justice will not suffer by its publication. Fall River Ausry. i Fall Riveh. Mass.. Oct. 10.— The manifest breach of laith on the part of certain officers connected with the Bor den murder cases, by which certain evi dence has been given to the public, has created anger in nearly all circles here, moreparticularly among the small -coterie of local newspaper men who have " been favored with the confidence of the authorities, with the understanding that some things should not be printed. Miss Bor den has made many friends also because of the broad publication of indelicate matters which were purposely sup pressed at the preliminary hearing. In the published stories there were many needless inaccuracies and some new facts. These, together with some feel ing of indignation, have prompted some local men to tell what they were asked to suppress.' ' A local paper srys: "A great deal is printed regarding the family relations which is not new. It is evident that somebody who has been employed by the government in this case has sold about every secret In his possession or has given away the same. The public is at liberty to guess who the person was, and whether or not he fattened his pocketbook by the transaction. Inasmuch, however, as a paid servant of the prosecution is under no obligation to hold his tongue, the paper feels at liberty to disclose any 111 --formation which has come into its pos session." ,- Helped Lizzie. The Fall River Globe says tonight: A man very prominent in the case says that the district attorney now has in his possession the hatchet with which the murder was committed. it was quite certain that local officers at work on the case have given up their hunt for the weapon. The story telegraphed some time ago from Pawtucket, to the effect that Mrs. James Marshall would testify to having seen a man escape from the Borden yard by way of Third street proves to have little foundation in fact. The younger Mrs. Marshall, who was with the lady at the time, says they saw no such person as described. Tonight the opinion is very prevalent here that the government's case has been injured greatly by today's devel opments. Whether Miss Borden is guilty or innocent they feel that con tinued excitement will tend to make a fair, impartial trial more difficult than ever and will tend to shatter the respect of the proper authorities among the general public. Both the district attorney and the city marshal have a well-defined idea who the cul prit is, while Major Couchlin is taking steps to nave the local officers clear themselves and to place the responsi bility for the premature publication where It rightfully belongs."-'. Names Are Fictitious. Andrew J. Jennings, counsel for the defendant in the Borden murder cases, made the following statement today. The matter published in a Boston paper this morning relating to the murders of Andrew J. Borden and his wife is a tissue of lies. I have en deavored to find out about Mr. and Mrs. Fred Chase -at the number indicated (198 Fourth street, Fall River). -There is not only no such number, but notany within fifty of it. There is no such name as George F.-Sisson in the directory nor can Mind any person who knows any body "of that name. The kernel of the whole malicious story deals with a con dition which is absolutely disproved by tilings lound in the cellar by the prosecu tion, and admitted to be what Miss Liz zie claimed they were. Subsequent events have confirmed her claim. Mr. Morse says that the whole story is ah-' salutely false— not a word of truth in it. The Reagan story has already been denied by Miss Emma and Miss Lizzie, and was admitted by Mrs. Reagan to be false to at least six persons." ' A member of the 'police force says that the names used in the story are fic titious, but the matter is substantially true. - Emphatic Denials. j At 10 tonight .the Borden murders are the sole topic of *: conversation in hotels, clubs and the streets. The story published this morning has caused a re vulsion of feeling in favor, of the girl. Attorney General Jennings wantto th*»

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A newspaper lists numerous witnesses supposedly set to testify against Lizzie Borden, including claims of a quarrel with her sister witnessed by a hidden detective and a bribe offered to the servant. Fall River locals are reported angry at leaks of suppressed, inaccurate information to the press.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

St. Paul Daily Globe · 11 October 1892 · page 4

STATE'S TESTIMONY

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Reports describe leaks from someone close to the prosecution, a claim that the district attorney now has the murder weapon, and a retracted story about a witness seeing a man flee the Borden yard. Defense counsel Jennings denounces a Boston paper's story about mysterious figures as a fabrication, saying the names and addresses given do not exist.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 11 October 1892 · page 4

Names Are Fictitious. Andrew J. Jennings, counsel for the defendant in the Borden murder cases, made the following statement today. The matter published in a Boston paper this morning relating to the murders of Andrew J. Borden and his wife is a tissue of lies. I have en

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

A headline reading 'The Borden Case' appears in the column, but the body text beneath it is badly scrambled OCR mixed with an unrelated story about a Montana man's government post. No legible facts about the Borden investigation can be recovered from this fragment.

The Anaconda Standard · 11 October 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN CASE

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

The Boston Globe published a lengthy story claiming witnesses would testify to seeing Lizzie Borden near her mother's body and to a violent quarrel with her father over a secret affair, with supporting affidavits about a will. Defense attorney Jennings immediately denounced the entire account as a pack of lies.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Anaconda Standard · 11 October 1892 · page 1

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

The Boston Globe published a lengthy story claiming several witnesses would testify at Lizzie Borden's upcoming trial that she was seen near her mother's body and had quarreled with her father the night before the murders. Lizzie's counsel immediately denounced the story as a complete fabrication.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Helena Independent · 11 October 1892 · page 1

STARTLING IF TRUE.

Murder of the IHordens. BoSvoT, Oct. 10.-The Globe this morn fog prints a thirteen column story to the effect that several witnesses at the coming trial of Lizzie Borden, for the murder of her father and mother, will swear they saw Lizzie at the window of her bors. on the day of the orime and at a time which makes it certain she was at that moment standing over the body of bar mother. Others, it is stated, will ewser they overheard a quarrel between Lizzie and her fattier on the night before the murder, in which thit latter tlld her that unless she gave the name of the roan who got her into trouble he would tern her out of the boste.

See moreSee less

G. Ito maine, Fitteson, a wealthy New Yorker, htis made as aflidavit that a few days prior to the murder, 1Iafder consulted hits as a friend about Lizzie, whose trouble he re lated. George Hisson, it is said, will swear that less than a month before the murder Borden told him he had mnade a will giving Emma and Lizzie $20,000 cash, which was more than he would have allowed them but for his wife's intercession. Bridget Sullivan will, it is claimed, corroborate the story of the quarrel between Mr. Borden and Lizzie, and will also swear that on the afternoon of the day of the murder Lizzie whispered tto her "Keep your tongue still and you can have all the money you want." A distratch from Fall Rtiver says that Lizzie Borden's counsel declares the story in the Boston Globe is a tissue of lies.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The Boston Globe reports a sensational story claiming 25 new witnesses will testify against Lizzie Borden, including claims she was seen in her stepmother's room wearing a rubber hood and cape, and that a groan was heard. The story also alleges a quarrel between Lizzie and her father over her refusal to name someone who had 'got her into trouble.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Paper unidentified · 11 October 1892 · page 1

STARTLING* EVIDENCE In the Fall River Borden Murder Case. 8y Telegraph to the News and Observer Boston, Oct. 10.—The Globe pub lishes a 13-column story from Fall River, giving new and startling evi dence iu the noted Borden murder case. Twenty-five new witnesses, it says, will testify for the prosecu tion. These will testify to having seen Lizzie Borden in her step mother’s room about the time the murder must have been committed concealed iu a long rubberffiood and cape, and that they heard a groan. It will also be testified that Lizzie and her father had a quarrel, the girl refusing to say who had got her into trouble.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The Boston Globe published lengthy affidavits from witnesses alleging a quarrel between Lizzie and her father over a mysterious man who had gotten her 'into trouble,' plus a lawyer's account of her inquiring about inheritance before the murders. The defense attorney is reported to deny the story.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Sun · 11 October 1892 · page 5

SAID ABOUT LIZZIE BORDEN

A aOXTHlf NKVUPAVKHS BTOnT OF A SCAN DAI IV TIIK CASE I The Story Denied by the Attorney f the Prle oner Her Name MId to be Compromise In Connection with n Mitn Who NON I Not GlrcnNexr riniru or the eMe BOSTON Oct 10Tho dole till mornlne prints thirteen columns of 8torles of twenty wltnossos In tho Borden murder caso who have given affidavits totho Government Some

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The report lists witnesses expected to testify to incriminating observations of Lizzie Borden around the time of the murders, including alleged statements about paying for silence. Defense attorney Jennings vehemently denies a related Boston scandal story as fabricated, while local reporters claim suppressed details are now leaking.

The Sun · 11 October 1892 · page 5

selrot Tho lllitle promises to publish a certain piece of xory important Information recently giiincd by OtlluiM HurnnBton nx HOI as tho t ntoicsts i of justice will not Duller by It publicatIon 1Aii Hixnn Oct 10 Andiow J Jennings counsel for the defendant In time Borden mur der case made the following statement to n ler mllo reporter today The mutter published in a Iloston paper this morning rotating to the minders 01 Andruw 1 lionivn nnd his wife Is a tissue of llo 1 Imxe endeavored to find out bout Ml and Mr Fred Chase nt tile uImmnipr Indicated 1IW Fourth street Fall Illxcr Thoro tq 1 not only no mich numher but not any wIthIn llfty of I Them is no such name IS George iSlsson In tli directory nor cal I find uny person who knows anybody of that name Tho kernel of tho whole malicious story dealt with a condition whiIIi Is absolutely dlsproxed by things found In tho cellar bv tlu prosecu <

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A paid source for the prosecution allegedly leaked details portraying Lizzie Borden as troublesome and obsessed with property, including a disputed will and overdrawn letter of credit. The report also claims Bridget Sullivan saw something dropped into milk that the Bordens suspected was poisoned, and that Andrew Borden confided to an acquaintance about ongoing family turmoil.

The Sun · 11 October 1892 · page 5

The influence that Miss Borden exercised oor her was not relished by Miss Hodmans friends but while frequent complaints were made there was no open runturo Miss llor den attempted to persuade Miss Itodnmn who xuis in falling health to maRe a will In her favor premium at the same time to mako a will in favor of Miss Hodman tmo Mr Jennings drew Miss Hodmans will but It has not In en shown that lizzia Borden was a henellolnri although she sought to be An othoi feet showing her Interest In property Is the family quarrel l which followed the deeding i of snmo property to her lepmother Tlio quarrel wus prolonged I and bitter

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A Boston newspaper had published a story claiming new evidence against Lizzie Borden from Detective Edwin McHenry, which was widely circulated. The paper now admits the statements were inaccurate in several vital points, suggesting the detective misled them.

The Evening World · 11 October 1892 · page 4

A CABE FOR PROMPT ATTEBT10H. A Boston paper printed veslcrday, in good faith, a long story bearing upon the Borden murder case in Fall itiver. It act forth what was represented as fresh evidence, which, it was stated, would be clven at the approiching trial of Lizzie Bjbdzn. :he girt accused of murdering her father and stepmother. Tbo stste ments contained In this story bore heavily sgainst the accused girl. If veri fied on the stand, they (werued enough, of themselves, to seal the doom of the prisoner. They assumed vast importance in the public ej be-1 reuse, undoubtedly, there is a large por tion of the public which refusea to be lieve Ibat evidence sufficient to hold Lizzie Borden was produced at the pre liminary hearing in the ciue.

See moreSee less

Through special services and through press associations this story printed in Boston was circutsted all over the coun try. And sinpe the Fsll Blver murder case baa become one of National interest, owing to Its mystery and its unusual cir cumstances, the fresh detsils were eagerly seized upon. The story waa exceedingly live news of the dsy. But to-day the Boston psper announces that it is convinced, after further Investl. gation. that the statements printed jes. terday were inaccurate in a number of vital points. Itjssya the story vrss sold to iu reporter by Detective Edwin Mc Hkkkt, of Providence, who has been actively engaged In looking up evidence in the Borden case, presumably for

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A Boston paper had printed a widely circulated story claiming new evidence against Lizzie Borden, sourced from Detective Edwin McHenry. The paper now admits the story was inaccurate in several vital points, suggesting the detective misled them.

The Evening World · 11 October 1892 · page 4

A CASE FOR PROMPT ATTENTION

A CASE FOR FBOMPT ATTEHTI0", A Boston paper printed yesterday, In good faith', a long story bearing upon the Borden murder case in Fall River. It aet forth what waa represented aa fresh evidence, wblcb, it wai stated, would be given at the approaching trial of Lizzie B3BDEM. he girl accused of murdering her father and stepmother. The state ments contained In thle story bore heavily against the accused girl. If veri fied on the stand, tbey teemed enough, of themselves, to teal the doom of the prisoner. Tbey assumed vast importance in the publio eye be cause, undoubtedly, there It a large por tion of the public which refuses to be lieve that evidence sufficient to hold Lizzie Borden waa produced at the pre liminary hearing in the case.

See moreSee less

Through special services and through press Associations thia atory printed in Boston wai circulated all over the coun try. And since the Fall Itiver murder case has become one of National interest, owing to its mystery and its unusual cir cumstances, the fresh details were eagerly aeized upon. The storv was exceedingly live news of the day. But to-day tbe Boston neper annouures that it la convinced, after further invstl Ration, that the statements printed jes. terday were inaccurate in a number of vital points. It taya tbe story was sold to its reporter by Detective Edwin Mo. Henbt, of Providence, who has been actively engaged in looking up evidence in the Borden case, presumably for the State. Plainly it in inti mated that the detective deceived tbe paper and allowed to be spread before the publio statements calculated to do the utmost injury to a girl already bearing the weight of a terrible accusation, but who yet baa the chance, not denied to any person under the law, to provo her-1 aelf free from guilt. If thin intimation is correct, tbe accused detective standi in a worse light before tbe peonle than the accused womtn. 8ht has symiathirers. He will have none, Hia act waa worse than a cruelty to Liziik Borden if ehe be innoccut ; It might work mischief to '

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A Boston newspaper now says details it printed about the Fall River murder case were inaccurate, claiming the story was sold to its reporter by Detective Edwin McHenry of Providence. The piece argues McHenry deceived the paper with statements damaging to Lizzie Borden, and calls for the matter to be addressed regardless of whether Borden is guilty or innocent.

The Evening World · 11 October 1892 · page 4

A CASE FOR PROMPT ATTENTION

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

A Boston paper's story about alleged family quarrels involving Lizzie Borden has reportedly shifted public sympathy toward her, with officials worried the prosecution's case has been damaged. Jennings, Emma Borden, and Morse angrily deny the quarrel claims as fabricated, with Jennings calling it a 'tissue of lies' and disputing specific named sources and addresses as nonexistent.

The Evening Herald · 11 October 1892 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE

MORSE WILL SEEK LEGAL REDRESSStntnments ltsiir.lliic Quarreli, etc., In. dlgliHUtly DunUrl by ailss II m m 11 llor den, Attorney Jennings aud Mr. Murse--J'nHTUut Um Prosecution la Wesliounil, Fall River, Mass., Oct. 11. The Borden murder cato is ngain the sole toplo of conversation. The story published yesterday has influenced feeling in favor of the girl, and it is felt that the govern ment case has been Injured. Attorney Jennings, Miss Emmit and Mr. Morse em phatically deny nil statements regarding quarrels, etc. Mr. Morse is intensely angry and will seek legal redress.

See moreSee less

Bridget Sullivan und Detectlvo Seaver spent some time together yesterday look ing Into the minor details. The appraisal of the Borden estate has been completed, but no figures will be given out until tho report is submitted to the Probate Court. District-Attorney Knowlton Is In New Bedford. Regarding the publication, he expressed the opinion that the case would not bo hurt thereby. Mr. Jennings made the following statement to n reporter: "The matter, published in a Boston paper relating to tho murders of Andrew j. Borden and his wife is a tissue of lies.

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Morse and others deny a lurid rumor claiming Lizzie was pregnant and quarreled with her father the night before the murders, with witnesses allegedly overhearing threats and bribery attempts. The report states the names and addresses in the story cannot be verified and calls it a malicious fabrication, though a police source claims the substance is true despite fictitious names.

The Evening Herald · 11 October 1892 · page 2

MORSE WILL SEEK LEGAL REDRESS

their daughter, were friends of the elder Borden, and visited them on the evening previous to the murder. They overheard, it is stated, a quarrel between Lizzie and hor father. All heard Mr. Borden say: "You can inako your own choice and do it to-uight. Either let us know what his namo is or take the door on Saturday, mid when you go Ashing, fish for some other place to live, as 1 will never listen to you again. I will know the name of tho man who cot you into trouble."

See moreSee less

Lizzie is said to have renlied: "If I marry this mau will you be satisfied that everything will be kept from the outside world!" Then the visitors were an nounced nnd conversed with Mr. and Mrs. Borden on the subject of che funeral. Mr. Borden said: "1 would rather see lier dead than have it come out." Mr. George J. Sissou of Full River is said to have hoard Lizzie say to Bridget Sullivan, the hired girl: "Why don't you say how much money you want to keep quiet! Bridget s answer was: "I don t know what you mean, hut you are not tho girl 1 took you to be." Mr. George bisson, H is said, will uwear that less thun a mouth before the murder Mr. Borden told him he had made a will giving Emma and Lizzie $20,000 each, which was more than he would havo ah lowed them but for his wife's interces sion. Bridget Sullivan will, it is claimed, corroborate the story of the quarrel of Mr. Borden and Lizzie; also that sho heard the night before the murders Morse aud Lizzie talking about a will: also that on tho afternoon of tho day of the murder, Uzzlo whispered to her, "Keep your tongue still, and don't talk. to tbo otliccrs and you can have all the aionoyyou want."

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A newly published story about alleged family quarrels has shifted public opinion in Lizzie Borden's favor. Emma Borden and Mr. Morse emphatically denied the quarrel claims to Attorney Jennings and reporters, with Morse vowing legal action and a detective denying involvement.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 11 October 1892 · page 1

SYMPATHY FOR LIZZIE.

Causes a Kevnlslon of Feeling. Fall River, Mass., Oct. 10. At 10 o'clock to-night the Borden murders are the sole topic of conversation nt hotels, clubs and on the streets. The story published this morning has caused a revulsion of feel ing in favor ot the girl. Attorney Jennings went to the Borden

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The Boston Globe claims to have obtained sensational new evidence from twenty-five witnesses for the prosecution, including a man named John H. Murphy who says he saw Lizzie Borden open a window blind in the room where her mother's body was later found. The story suggests this placement proves she was near the murder scene at the critical time.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pittsburg Dispatch · 11 October 1892 · page 6

maliciously or untruthfully of the defend ant. Briefly stated, the new evidence, ac cording to the Globe, is as follows: John H. Murphy, of Fall River, will testify that he was on the sidewalk close to the Borden house when Mr. Borden entered his house about 10:40 on August 4, and he saw him a minute or two later ushered into the lobby by Bridget Sullivan. Mr. Murphy will swear, that while Mr. Borden was walking in the yard, he saw a window blind of the room, in which Mrs. Borden's body was found, cautiously opened by a young woman who had that same morning told him, when he called at the Borden house about 6:30 o'clock, that ''her father had gone down town and wouldn't be back till noon or later."

See moreSee less

This woman he had identified as the defendant, Lizzie Borden. The window Mr. Murphy designates, as the one in which he saw Miss Lizzie, is so situated that she must have been standing over the mutilated remains of her mother at the very time her lather was about to enter the house. , Saw Llzzir at the "Window. The next witness of importance is Mrs. Gustav Ronald, of Pawtucket, It. L, who was a guest at the "Wilbur House. About 9:40 o'clock on the morning ot the murder, she was wheeling her baby carriage near the Borden house when she heard a terrible cry or groan. She looked up at the Borden

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The report describes anticipated testimony from several witnesses—Murphy, Mrs. Ronald, Mahany, and Gunning—who claim to have seen Lizzie Borden at a window of the murder room around the time of the killing. It also describes an alleged dinner-table quarrel between Lizzie and her father the night before the murder, witnessed by family friends.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pittsburg Dispatch · 11 October 1892 · page 6

STORIES OF PARENTAL QUARRELS

seen Lizzie Borden in the vrindowat the same time and under the same circum stances. These witnesses, the Globe says, fix Miss Borden at her mother's side almost at the minute nlipn she probably was killed a-jd wlieu Miss Lizzie, according to her own statement, was eltc where. Heard the Quarrel With Lizzie. Mr. and Mrs. Frederick Chase, of Fall Eiver, and Mrs. Abigail Mauchester, their daughter, were friends of the elder Borden s and visited them on the e cuing previous to the murder. Thev overheard, it is stated, a quarrel between Lizzie and her father.

See moreSee less

All heard Mr. Borden say: "You can roaks you own choice and do it to-night Either let us Luott what his name is or take the door on Saturday; and, when you go, fish for some other place to live, as I will never listen to you again. I will know the name ot the man wnn cot you into trouble." Lizzie is a d to ue icplied: "If I marr this man, will you hi satisfied that evert thin; will be kept from the outside world." When the isitor? were announced and conversed with Mr. and Mrs. Borden on the subject of the quarrel, Mr. Borden said: "I would rather see her dead than have it come out." M-. G. Ilomain Pittson, a wealthy dealer in machinery supplie?,has made an affidavit that a few days prior to the murder Mr. Borden consulted him as a friend about Lizz'e, whose trouble he related in detail. Mrs. George . I. Sisson, ot Fall Rier, is slid to!iae heard Lizzie say to Bridget Sullivan, the lured girl: "Whv don't you fav how rmch money you want to Keep quiet?" Bridget's answer was: "I don't know what you mean, but you are not the girl I took you to be." Urldget Also Hoard the Quarrel. Mr. George Sisson, it is said, will swear that less than a month belore the murder Mr. Borden toid him he had made a will giving Emma and Lizzie 23,000 cash, which was more than he would have allowed them

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The report claims multiple witnesses will testify to a bitter quarrel between Andrew Borden and Lizzie over a mysterious pregnancy scandal, with Borden allegedly saying he'd rather see her dead than have it come out. It also describes alleged overheard conversations about wills, money, and Lizzie supposedly trying to bribe Bridget Sullivan for silence.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pittsburg Dispatch · 11 October 1892 · page 6

STORIES OF PARENTAL QUARRELS

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The Boston Post declares a sensational Globe story about new developments in the Borden case a 'colossal fake,' tracing it to Detective McHenry who allegedly tried to sell it to papers for money. The defense calls the fourteen columns of affidavits the most remarkable fabrication ever built for a newspaper.

Pawtucket Tribune · 11 October 1892 · page 1

SENSATION EXPLODED

The Globe concerning the “new develop ments’ in the Borden case asa “colossal fake. '’ It says that when the facts of the epce are made publie, as they soon will be, there will be tfie biggest kind of a laugh on The Globe and its reporter. The fol lowing is a special to The Post from Fall River. The defense is perfectly calm in the face of the startling story published in a Bos. ton paper in relation to the Borden mur der mystery; calm with regard to its hear

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The report exposes a sensational story about Lizzie Borden's alleged shame and blackmail as a fabrication peddled by Detective McHenry to newspapers for money. Emma Borden and family physicians deny knowing the supposed witnesses and refute claims of Lizzie's 'delicate condition,' revealing the names and details as false.

Pawtucket Tribune · 11 October 1892 · page 1

A TISSUE OF FALSEHOODS

she does not know any such pople as the Chaces, who were such elose [riends of the family that they were admitted by the back door, and standing in the stairs overheard old mau Borden ehorge his daughter with her shaime and the danghe tor's reply. She does not know such a person as George Bisson, who wus so close a friend that he attended the funeral and overheard Lizzie Borden ask Bridyoet why she did not name her price for silence, Furthermore she says Lizzie is not sick; is not in a condition to have brought shame upon herself el her parents, The proofs of this, she says, were found in the ovllar by the oflicers themselves during their search, nnd she has further proofs se cured since Lizzie has been confined inthe Taunton jail.

See moreSee less

Dr. Bowen, the family physician, who was & witness for the defense, and D, Dolan, the medical examiner, who was n witneuss for the prosecution, both earrobe orated this statement that Lizzie Borden

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Lizzie Borden's attorney Jennings is reported furious after investigating and branding a Boston Globe story about his client as false and an attempt to prejudice public opinion. Other papers including the Herald and Journal call the story a fake, while the Globe itself admits its source, Detective McHenry, was wrong on many details including Lizzie's physical condition.

Pawtucket Tribune · 11 October 1892 · page 1

A Thoroughly Angry Man was Mr. Jennings last night. e awoke yesterday morning aod was astonnded at the flood of accusation involving the per sonal honor of his client, He began to in vestigate, He spent as much of the day as he could spare in this research, nud lnst evening he issued au authoritative bulle tin over his signature, branding the story in the Boston Globe as false, and an in famous attempt to prejudice the puablie mind againat Miss Borden, and holster up the government theory of hoer guilt, Other Newspapers Speak,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A Fall River report describes anger among local newspapermen after officials leaked confidential details from the Borden case, including indelicate matters suppressed at the preliminary hearing. It accuses an unnamed paid government agent of breaching trust, while claiming much published material contained needless inaccuracies mixed with some new facts.

The Providence News · 11 October 1892 · page 2

BORDEN "REVELATION." The Story Printed Was Mostly Fake and the Rest a Breach of Faith. MORSE IS MADE VERY ANGRY. A Lot of Irresponsible Gossip About the Borden Case that Rests on No Better Foundation than the Imagination of Irresponsible Would-be Detectives.

FaLL River, Mass., Oot, 11,—The manlest breach of faith on the part of cer tain officers connected with the Borden murder cases by which certain evidence has been given to the public, has created anger in nearly all eircles here, more par ticularly among the small coterle of local mewspaper men, who have been favored with the confidence of the authorities, with the understanding that some things should not be printed. .~ Miss Borden has made many friends also, because of the broad publication of indelicate matters which were purposely

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A local paper claims a paid government informant leaked unflattering details about Lizzie Borden, including alleged financial extravagance, family quarrels over property, and an attempt to influence a friend's will in her favor. The report criticizes an earlier published account for inaccuracies while presenting these new unverified claims as fact.

The Providence News · 11 October 1892 · page 2

ndulgent parent. | Bome {un ago Miss Josie Redman was wery intimate with Lizzie Borden. The Anfluence that Miss Borden exercised over her was not relished by Mirs Red man’s friends, but while frequent com plaints wero made there was no open rupture. Miss Borden attempted to per suade Miss Redman, who was in tnlflu::

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This report collects circulating rumors about the Borden case, including claims that Lizzie poisoned milk, that the district attorney possesses the murder weapon, and that a potential juror was indiscreet. It also debunks an earlier story about a witness seeing a man flee the yard, noting the second woman present saw no such person.

The Providence News · 11 October 1892 · page 2

The man who was paid to glve away zmnmfllt'a case did not touch on fact that Bridget Sullivan told a friend that she saw Lizzie drop some into a pan of milk which was en . 3 that she threw the milk away a‘.tm Mr., and Mrs. Borden both ought they had been poisoned. The prosecution claims that the poison was used and that Bridget Sullivan, among the rest, was a sufferer from it. | "Mr. Borden talked with Seoretary Rounseville of the Manufacturers Asso tion, shortly before his death about

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Boston Globe published an apology admitting it had been misled into printing a false communication about the Lizzie Borden case earlier that week. The paper stated it believed much of the story was fabricated, though some elements might later prove true, and offered Lizzie Borden a heartfelt apology for the harm caused.

The Providence News · 11 October 1892 · page 7

irresistable plausibility. Judging from what we have heard it impressed our readers as strougly as it diorthe Globe, g Some ol this remarkably engenious and cunningly contrived story i~ uncoibtedly based ou lacts, as later developements will show. The Globe believes, however, that much of it is false, aud never should have been publisned, I'he Globe being thus misled h¢ inno cently added to the terrible burdens of Miss Lizzie Borden. - So far as is in our power to repair the wrong we are anxious to do so, and here by teuder her our heartfelt apology.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The Boston Globe published an extensive exposé claiming witnesses would testify to seeing Lizzie Borden near the murder scene and to overhearing a violent father-daughter quarrel over money and a secret. Lizzie's counsel immediately denounced the story as a 'tissue of lies,' while Emma Borden, Mr. Morse, and Detective McHenry also denied its claims.

The Salt Lake Herald · 11 October 1892 · page 1

SENSATIONAL STORY V IcBlon Globe lublhlies Serious Statement V V in Begard 30 Lizzie Borden BOSTON Oct 10The Globe this morn Ing publishes a thirteencolumn story to V which several witnesses at the coming V trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and mother will swear They V saw Lizzie at the window her bouse on the day of the murder at a time which

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The Boston Globe reports a sensational thirteen-column story claiming witnesses will testify at Lizzie Borden's upcoming trial that they saw her at a window over her mother's body, and overheard her father threatening to disown her unless she named a man who had gotten her 'into trouble.' It also cites alleged affidavits and testimony about a will Borden supposedly made favoring his daughter Emma.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 11 October 1892 · page 3

THE BORDEN MURDER. Alleged Damaging Evidence Against Lizzie Discovered.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The Boston Globe published a lengthy story claiming witnesses would testify at Lizzie Borden's trial to seeing her near the body, overhearing a father-daughter quarrel about a scandal, and hearing her offer hush money to Bridget Sullivan. Defense counsel Jennings called it "a tissue of lies," and Emma Borden, John Morse, and Detective McHenry all denied the reported statements.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 11 October 1892 · page 3

you can have all the money you wank" FALL RITXB, Mass., Oct 10.—Andrew J. Jennings counsel for the defendant in the Borden murder case, asserts that the mat ter published in a Boston paper is "a tis sue of lies." t The story published this morning has caused a revulsion of feeling in favor of the girl. Miss Emma and Mr. Morse deny all statements made about the quarrels. Detective McHenry denies all knowledge of the matter published.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

Fall River newspapers report that officials have leaked confidential case details to the press, including claims that the district attorney possesses the murder hatchet and contradictory accounts of Lizzie's conversation with servant Bridget Sullivan. The report notes anger among local journalists over broken confidentiality agreements and acknowledges the published stories contain inaccuracies alongside new facts.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 11 October 1892 · page 1

murder cases by which certain evidence has been given to tho public, has created anger in nearly all circles hero, more particularly among tho small cotorie of local newspaper men who have been favored with tho confidence of tho authorities with the understanding that somo tilings should not be printed. Miss Borden has mado many friends

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

Local papers report that government secrets and suppressed preliminary hearing details have been leaked to the press, including a claim that the district attorney possesses the murder hatchet, while a Pawtucket witness story about a man fleeing the Borden yard is now said to be baseless. Separately, affidavits from Boston businessmen allege Borden discussed Lizzie's troubled behavior and a will leaving her and Emma $25,000 shortly before the murders.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 11 October 1892 · page 1

SOMEBODY GIVES SECRETS AWAY

from Pawtuckot to the effect that -Mrs. James Marshall would testify to having se(mi :i man escape from the Borden yard by way of Third street, proves to have iittle foundation in fact. Tho

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A newspaper account lists alleged witnesses and testimony against Lizzie Borden, including claims of quarrels about money and a will, overheard remarks, and a scuffle with her sister Emma. Defense attorney Andrew Jennings immediately denounces the entire report as a fabrication, saying the named persons and addresses do not even exist.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 11 October 1892 · page 1

CLAIM IT WAS A LIE

row between Lizzie and Emma Borden in the matrons room in which tho former accused tho latter of "hnvinir given her away." This tale, it is said, will bo corroborated by tho Mclienrys who 1 overheard and saw the nftalr through a 1 holo in tho wall especially provided by the authorities. It is claimed in this quarrel Lizzie kicked Kuiina fcoveral 1 times in the leg. Mr. 1'rauk Burroughs, a lawyer of Now York, formerly of Fall ltivor, it is eaid, is tho attorney consulted by Lizzie Borden about tho proporty rights in a father's estate should a stepmother dio

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A Boston paper claims to have affidavits from numerous witnesses who will give damaging testimony against Lizzie Borden, including tales of a secret lover, threats, and quarrels overheard before the murders. The report lists specific names and lurid anecdotes meant to implicate her motive and behavior.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Wheeling Register · 11 October 1892 · page 1

BAD FOR LIZZIE BORDEN

Boston, Mass., October 10.—1 to day prints a dozen columns of th of witnesses in the Borden mun who bavo given affidavits to the menu Some of these stories ar atioual nature, aud are as folloa Mr. Frank Burroughs, a w New York City lawyer, will t eight mouths before the murde Lizzie Border consulted him at> position of proper!v in the even mother's death before that of hi Private Detective McHenry that, lying concealed in a batt witnessed the quarrel In the on between the sisters, and that L Emma thrice, called her a foul said: “You wanted to see me ht AOft iwytrk tho sunt i BA fnrtll the person whom 1 thought 1 with my secret.” Mr and Mra.

See moreSee less

Frederick Cha _ Abigail Maucheatar will testify' night before the murder, whiU the Borden house, and before nounced, they had overheard .\ in another room threatening to out of doors unless she would name of tho maa “who got trouble.” Mr. G. Iiomaino Pittstonu i dealer in machinery supplies York, will testify that Mrs. |B' tailed Lizzie’s trouble to him, vised to disinherit her unless • vest the man s name. John H. Murphy, Mrs. Gus aid, Peter Mahuuy and Augu will testify to having seen 1 ut tho window, whero and w havo boon standing ever the her stepmother at thdVme a was walking in the yank Mrs. George J. Bimpsoh » at the iiordun funeral *b* asking Bridget Bullivai much money she’sgiflUE*. ^.oey Mrs. Iteagan, the mation, and have deposed to the same effect. Tho Ololx promises lo publish piece of very important lnfonnstU i v gained by Oflier Harrington, a the Interests of Justloe will not its publication.

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A sensational story claimed witnesses would testify Lizzie Borden had a hidden pregnancy or scandal involving her stepmother, naming several people set to testify to this effect. Lizzie's attorney Andrew Jennings publicly denounced the entire account as fabricated, stating the names and addresses given could not even be verified to exist.

Wheeling Register · 11 October 1892 · page 1

THE STORY DKNIII Miss Hordeo's Attorney Ssyt i Ntory Is a Pack of U« Fall River, Mass., Octobe drew J. Jennings, counsel fori ant In the Borden murder casei following statement to an Assoc correspondent to-dsy: “The msttor published In. paper this morning relating to/l of Andrew J. Borden and/Ui

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

The Boston Globe says it has found that a previous report about Lizzie Borden's physical condition was untrue, based on statements from Dr. and Mrs. Bowen. It also reports that other inaccuracies were found in the supposed new evidence given to its reporter by Detective McHenry.

Arizona Republican · 12 October 1892 · page 1

The lloaton lllnbe. Is Worked by He lectlve In tho Ilordeu Case. Boston. Oct. 11. Associated Press. Tho.filobo this morning says that upon investigation it is saiiBueu mat tno statement published yesterdny concern ing Lizzie Borden's physical .condition is not true and bases its belief upon the statement of Dr. and Mrs. Bowcu. The Globe also eays that other inaccuracies of importance havo boen found in tho THE ARIZONA REPUBLICAN

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Public sentiment in Fall River has shifted in support of Lizzie Borden, with her counsel receiving encouraging telegrams condemning recent case disclosures. Local newspapers are calling for the state to dismiss its hired detective, and defense counsel Jennings has been instructed to pursue libel suits.

Morning Journal and Courier · 12 October 1892 · page 3

Opea Evarr Kvanlaa. Wednesday and Thunder Close S:15 p. n. a fall of Niagara which occupied the length toraopeaT a, m. to 8:10 p. as, Baturdav ant of the bridge irom tower to Wffir, xmBBav.aa. . w below Port ITuron, Mich., the body of Captain K-s Bhepard's wife, who accompanied her husband on the fatal trip, it was the first titllnaa received aa to the tite of the crew ana two women. Owing to unavoidable delay In getting the Boa. ton art commission Uigttherand securing a hear ing regarding the Buyen's statue of Columbus, Archbishop Williams at the request of the Co lumbus committee baa granted a site on the Cathedral grounoa, corner ahioKton ard Mai den streets, for the statue.

See moreSee less

The unveiling will taae place uciooer i, Tbe general feeling in Fall River has changed in regard to tbe Borden case and the defendant's counsel is receiving encouraging telegrams from all sections condemning tee alleged disclosures in the case and encouraging him to oon'ti.ue his work for Lizzie Borden. The three local papers express editorial opinions of a similar character

See the clipping

In the story →

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper

The Boston Globe publishes an editorial apology admitting it was deceived into printing a fabricated statement in the Lizzie Borden case, calling the hoax 'unparalleled' in its plausibility. It apologizes to Lizzie Borden and John V. Morse for the damage done, and reveals detective Edwin McHenry supplied the false story.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 12 October 1892 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

APOLOGIZES TO LIZZIE BORDEN.

The Boston "Globe" Declares That It Was Greatly Deceived.

See moreSee less

BOSTON, Oct. 12.—The "Globe" publishes an editorial apology for its publication of the statement in the Borden case. It says:

"The 'Globe' feels it a plain duty, as an honest newspaper, to state that it has been grieviously misled in the Lizzie Borden case. It published on Monday a communication that it believed to be true evidence. Among all the impositions which newspapers have suffered, this was unparalleled in its astonishing completeness and its irresistible plausibility. Judging from what we have heard, it impressed our readers as strikingly as it did the 'Globe.' Some of this remarkably ingenious and cunningly contrived story is undoubtedly based on facts, as later developments will show.

"The 'Globe' believes, however, that much of it is false and never should have been published. The 'Globe,' having been misled, has innocently added to the terrible burdens of Miss Lizzie Borden. So far as it is in our power to repair wrong we are anxious to do so, and hereby tender her our heartfelt apology for the inhuman reflection upon her honor as a woman, and for any injustice the publication of Monday inflicted upon her.

"And the same sincere apology is tendered Mr. John V. Morse and any other persons to whom the publication did an injustice."

The "Globe" under a headline saying that the story had been proven wrong in some particulars, says:

"Detective E. G. McHenry furnished the 'Globe' with the Borden story published Monday morning. He admits it in an interview published herewith. He also asserts that the facts are true. He states that the names and residences of alleged witnesses were purposely given wrong for obvious reasons.

"The 'Globe,' in the course of its investigation into the details of the story, interviewed Dr. and Mrs. Bowen and Rev. Mr. Buck on the question of Lizzie Borden's physical condition at the time of the murder, the result of which was the conviction that in this respect at least Mr. McHenry was wrong. The story may be wrong in some other minor particulars, but the weight of evidence favors the main facts as true."

"And now for the purpose of ferreting out the murder in the Borden case the 'Globe' has engaged the best detective talent available."

A statement by Henry G. Trickey, the reporter who signed Monday's story, is appended and is to the effect that he paid detective McHenry $500 for the story and giving the details of the bargain.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa. · 12 October 1892

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The Boston Globe apologizes to Lizzie Borden and John V. Morse for injustice caused by its Monday story, after detective McHenry admitted supplying it and giving false witness names. The Globe's own investigation found McHenry wrong about Lizzie's physical condition at the time of the murder, though it still claims the main facts are true.

CorrectionThis set right 23 earlier articles: Los Angeles Herald, 11 October 1892, The Wilmington Daily Republican, 11 October 1892, The Wilmington Daily Republican, 11 October 1892, The Morning News, 11 October 1892, The Indianapolis Journal, 11 October 1892, The Indianapolis Journal, 11 October 1892, The Wichita Daily Eagle, 11 October 1892, Der Deutsche Correspondent, 11 October 1892, Der Deutsche Correspondent, 11 October 1892, The Portland Daily Press, 11 October 1892, St. Paul Daily Globe, 11 October 1892, St. Paul Daily Globe, 11 October 1892, The Anaconda Standard, 11 October 1892, The Helena Independent, 11 October 1892, Paper unidentified, 11 October 1892, The Sun, 11 October 1892, Pittsburg Dispatch, 11 October 1892, Pittsburg Dispatch, 11 October 1892, Pittsburg Dispatch, 11 October 1892, The Seattle Post-Intelligencer, 11 October 1892, The Seattle Post-Intelligencer, 11 October 1892, The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer, 11 October 1892, Wheeling Register, 11 October 1892.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 12 October 1892 · page 2

Was Greatly Deceived. Boston, Oct. 12. The "Globe" pub lishes an editorial apology for its publi cation of the statement in the Borden case. It says: 'The 'Globe' feels it a plain duty, as an honest newspaper, to state that it has been grieviously misled in the Lizzie Borden case. It published on Monday communication that it believed to be true evidenoe. Among all the imposi tions which newspapers have suffered, this was unparalleled in its astonishing completeness and its Irresistible plausi bility. Judging from what we have heard, it impressed our readers as strik ingly as it did the 'Globe.'

See moreSee less

Some of thi remarkably ingenious and cunningly con trived story is undoubtedly based on facts, as later developments will show. U"The 'Globe' believes, however, that much oi it is raise and never should have been published. The 'Globe,' having been misled, has innocently added to the terrible burdens of Miss Lizzie Borden. So far as it is in our power to repair wrong we are anxious to do so, and hereby tender her our heartfelt apology for the inhuman reflection upon her honor as a woman, and for any injustice the publication of Monday inflicted upon her. "And the same sincere apology is ten dered Mr. John V. Morse and any other persons to whom the publication did an injustice." The "Globe" under a headline saying that the story had been proven wrong in some particulars, says : "Detective Jfi. Ut. ilctlenry lurmshed the 'Globe' with the Borden story pub lished Monday morning. He admits it in an interview published herewith. He also asserts that the facts are true. He states that the names and residences of alleged witnesses were purposely given wrong for obvious reasons. 'The 'Globe,' in the course of its in vestigation into the details of the story, interviewed Dr. and Mrs. Bowen and Rev. Mr. Buck on the Question of Lizzie Bor den's physical condition at the time of the murder, the result or which was the conviction that in this respect at least Mr. McHenry was wrong. The story may be wrong in some other minor particu lars, but the weight of evidence favors the main facts as true." 'And now for the purpose ot ferreting out the murder in the Borden case the 'Globe' has e ngaged the best detective talent available." A statement by Henry G. Trickey, the reporter who signed Monday's story, i appended and is to the effect that he paid detective McHenry $500 for the story and giving the details or the bargain. Da Vita Gets Twenty Tears. Newark, N. J., Oct. 12. Carmine De Vita, who was tried in the Court of Oyer and Terminer tor the murder ot 1 nomas Burns, was sentenced yesterday to twenty years in btate s prison, ihe homicide took place about 12 o'clock on the night of Sept. 12. De Vita and Burns quar reled about Annie Klein, a notorious woman, ihe Italian drew a knite ana ripped Burns' abdomen from side to side. He died shortly after. The Blanc Divorce Suit. New York, Oct. 12. A motion made by counsel in behalf of Baron Blanc for a bill of particulars or bis wife's cnarges oi adultery against him, has been denied by Justice Patterson of the Supreme uourt. The counsel for the Baroness said it was imnossible to sive the names ot the women of the town with whom the Bar oness said her husband had consorted. Hambure's Cholera Record. Hamburg. Oct. 12. -There were 13 fresh cases of cholera here yesterday, three deaths and 132 burials. In the hospitals 891 natients are being treated. J.he offi cial report states that there have been altogether 17,910 cases ot oholera in the city and 7,588 deaths. It is expected that by Oct. IS the city can truthfully be de clared free of the plague.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The Boston Globe announced it was retracting its earlier published claims about Lizzie Borden's physical condition after determining them to be false. The paper admitted it had been deceived by fabricated evidence sold to a reporter by a Providence detective, and issued a public apology.

The Morning Call · 12 October 1892 · page 1

AN UNTRUE STORY

AN LNTKUfc STOKY. The Boston "Globe's" Statement About L'lsis Borden Withdrawn Boston, Oct. 11.— The Globe this morn ing t>ays that vi.on investigation.it is satis fied tbe statement published yesterday con cerning Lizzie Borden's physical condition is not true, aud bases its belief upon the statements of Dr. and Mrs. Bowen. The Globe also says there are other inaccuracies in the alleged new evidence, which was Bold to its reporter by Detective Edwin McHenry «l Provideuce.

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The Boston Globe announced it no longer believes its previous report about Lizzie Borden's physical condition, citing statements from Dr. and Mrs. Bowen. The paper also noted other inaccuracies in evidence it had purchased from Providence detective Edwin McHenry.

Los Angeles Herald · 12 October 1892 · page 2

A SENSATION EXPLODED. The Boston Globe Takes Back Part of its Lizzie Borden Story. Boston. Oct. 11.—The Globe stated this morniDg that upon investigation it

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

The Boston Globe says it investigated and now believes yesterday's story about Lizzie Borden's physical condition was untrue, citing statements from Dr. and Mrs. Bowen. It also notes other inaccuracies in the supposed new evidence sold to its reporter by Detective Edwin McHenry of Providence.

The Record-Union · 12 October 1892 · page 1

The Story Not True. Bostox, Oct. IL—The Globe this morn ing says that upon investigation it is satis fied the statement published yesterday concerning Lizzie Borden's physical con dition is not true, and bases its belief upon the statement of Pr. and Mrs. Boweu. The Globe also says there are other inaccuracies in the alleged new evi dence, which was sold to its reporter by Detective Edwin McHenry of Provi dence.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The Boston Globe publishes an editorial apology admitting it was deceived into printing a fabricated statement about the Lizzie Borden case. It retracts the damaging claims and apologizes to Lizzie Borden and John V. Morse for any injustice caused.

Evening Journal · 12 October 1892 · page 5

LIZZIE BORDEN MALIGNED. The ItuNton Globe Apologh for Its Sen National Statementfi# Boston, Oct. 12.—The Qlobe publishes an editorial apology for its publication of the statement in the Borden case. It says: "The Globe feels it n plain duty os an honest newspaper to state that it has been grievously misled in the Lizzie Borden case. It published on Monday a communication that it believed to be true evidence. Among all the impositions which newspapers have suffered this was unparalleled in its as tonishing completeness and irresistible plausibility. Judging from what we bud beard, it impressed our readers ns strongly us it did The Globe.

See moreSee less

Some of Ibis remark ably ingenious and cunningly contrived story »is undoubtedly tiased on facts, as later developments will show. "The Globe, however, believes that much of it is false and never should have been published. The Globe, being thus misled, has innocently added to the terri Aa bur dens of Miss Lizzie Borden. So far us it is in our power to repair wrong we are anx ious to do so, and hereby tender her our heartfelt apology for the inhuman reflec tion upon her honor as a woman, and, for any injustice the publication of Monday inflicted upon her. And the same sincere apology is hereby tendered to Mr. John V. Morse and any other persons to whom the publication did an injustice. '

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

Several Boston newspapers investigated and discredited The Globe's sensational story about Lizzie Borden, calling it a fabrication full of false claims. Public sentiment shifted in her favor, with local papers condemning the hired detectives and defense counsel preparing libel suits.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 12 October 1892 · page 1

FAVORING LIZZIE BORDEN. Th* Globe's Story Asserted to be a Gigantic Fabrication. Boston, Oct. 12. — Several Boston pn]>or8 print two or more columns each giving tlie results of their investigations

See the clipping

In the story →

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The Boston Globe published a sensational story alleging Lizzie Borden was unduly intimate with her uncle John Morse and that her father demanded to know her 'betrayer.' After the Boston Journal investigated and found the story false, the Globe printed a large retraction and apology to both Morse and Borden.

New-York Tribune · 12 October 1892 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

A CRUEL HOAX IN THE BORDEN CASE. Boston, Oct. 11 (Special).—Boston has been treated to a sensation of a peculiar character this week, growing out of the. Borden murder at Fall River. "The Boston Globe" published on Monday two pages of alleged evidence which it was said had been given before the coroner's inquest, andj which had not before been given to the public. The most serious part of "The Globe's" story was the allegation that Miss Borden had been unduly intimate with her uncle, John B. Morse, and that Mr.

See moreSee less

Borden demanded the name of her betrayer, under penalty of expulsion from her home. This and much more was furnished by a private detective of Fall River, and without proper investigation into its truthfulness, the paper purchased and published the terrible story. "The Journal" sent a man to Fall River on Monday and the entire story in all its essentials was shown to be false. This afternoon "The Globe" publishes in the largest type, three columns wide, a retraction. It says it has been grievously misled in the Lizzie Borden case, and so far as it lies in its power to repair the wrong, it is anxious to do so, and humbly apologizes to Mr. Morse and Lizzie Borden.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

Fall River reports a change in public sentiment toward the Borden case, with defense counsel Jennings receiving encouraging telegrams condemning alleged disclosures in the investigation. Local papers call for the state to dismiss its hired detectives, and libel suits are being prepared.

The Morning News · 12 October 1892 · page 1

LIZZIS BOBDBK’3 CASE. A Change In Public Opinion in Favor of tho Prisoner. Fall River, Mass., Oct 11.—The gen eral feeling has changed in regard to the Borden cose, and the defendant’s oouusel is receiving enoouraging telegrams from all seotious condemning tbe alleged disclosures in the case and enoouraging him to continue Ids work for Lizzie Borden. Throe local papers express editorial opinions of a sim ilar character, aud call upon tbe state to get rid of its hired detectives. Direction to bring libel units have been given to Mr. Jennings of tho counsel for tho defense.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The Boston Globe states that upon investigation, there is no truth to the Borden murder news it had published the previous day. The paper issues an editorial apology, admitting it was grievously misled in the Lizzie Borden case.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 12 October 1892 · page 2

THE BORDEN CASE. BOSTON Oct. ll. The Globe will say this morning tiiat upon investigation it is satished that there is no truth iu the alleged neWs V1 tUe i5ortieQ murder published C-.rillilV. BoSTOK Oct. 11. The Globe tonight publishes nn editorial anolov for its nubitcation of the, statements in regard to tha Bordeu case yesterday. It says that the Globe feels it a plain duty ;ia an hoDest newspaper to state that it. has been f grievously misled in the Lizzie Borden civsi.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The Boston Globe publicly admits it was misled into printing a false and damaging story about Lizzie Borden on Monday, calling it an unparalleled deception that seemed highly plausible. The paper apologizes to both Lizzie Borden and John V. Morse for the injustice caused by the fabricated report.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 12 October 1892 · page 1

that it has been grievously misled in the Lizzie Bon Ion ease. It published Monday a communication that it believed to be true evidence. Among all the impositions which new spain'rs have suffered this was unparallelled in its aston ishing completeness and irresistible plausi bility. Judging from what we have heard, it im pressed our readers as strongly as It did the (ilobe. Some of this * remarkably ingen ious and cunningly contrived story is un doubtedly based on facts, as later develop ments will show. The (doin' indieves. however, that much of it is false and never should have been published.

See moreSee less

The (doin' being thus misled. has innocently added to the terrible burdens of Miss Lizzie Borden. So far as lies in our power to repair the wrong, we are anxious to do it, and {hereby tender to her our lie art felt ajnilogy for the inhuman reflection upon her honor as a woman and for any injustice the publica tion of Monday inflicted upon her. The same sincere apology is hereby ten dered to John V. Morse and any other per sons to whom the publication did all in justice.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The piece notes that many sensational stories about Lizzie Borden's involvement in the murder are proving false, including claims about lawyers she consulted about her father's estate, which two attorneys have publicly denied. It criticizes the prosecution for allowing such unverified details to leak before trial, arguing this is unjust and is building public sympathy for the accused.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 12 October 1892 · page 2

Conflicting and startling stories concern ing the Borden murder and the alleged con nection of Lizzie Borden with the tragedy has been industriously published of late,

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The Boston Globe publicly admits it was misled by a fabricated story (from detective McHenry) published earlier that week, and apologizes to Lizzie Borden and John Morse for the damage done to their reputations. The report notes libel suits may follow and that the prosecution now worries about finding unbiased grand jurors.

The Portland Daily Press · 12 October 1892 · page 1

Very Mad. Boston, October 11.—The Globe to night prints the following: “The Globe feels it a plain duty as an honest news paper, to state that it has beta grievous ly misled in the Lizzie Borden case. It published Monday a communication that it believed to be true evidence. Among all the impositions which newspapers have suffered, this was unparalleled in its astonishing completeness and irresist ible plausibility. Judging from what we have heard, it impressed our readers as strongly as it did the Globe. Some of this remarkably ingenious and cunning ly contrived story is undoubtedly based on facts, as later developments will show.

See moreSee less

The Globe believes, however, that much of it is false, and never should have been published. The Globe, being thus misled, has innocently added to the terrible burdens of Miss Lizzie Borden. So far as lies in our power to repair the wrong, we are anxious to do so, and hereby tender her our heartfelt apology for the inhuman reflection upon her honor as a woman, and for any injustice ± 1 . ii« _ _ . • _ j* i r J „J 3 .... U11V/ |JUU11UUUV'U JJA.vyiiV.lMiJ lUiUUivvi v»j_jv/a» her. A sincere apology is herei y ten dered to Jolm'V. Morse, and any other person to whom the publication did an injustice.”

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Detective McHenry fled Fall River after denying he gave the fabricated interview to the Boston Globe, with reporters chasing him for names of witnesses he had withheld. Locals discuss the exposed fake story, while Lizzie Borden's family remains angry despite the Globe's apology, and prosecutors worry about securing an unbiased grand jury.

The Portland Daily Press · 12 October 1892 · page 1

THEY ARE STILL ANGRY,

yet recovered from their anger. Mr. Morse still urges his counsel to sue the offending paper. Mr. • Jennings left the city this afternoon for Boston, and it is generally understood he had with him material for serving a writ of attach ment. The police say that many weak points in the evidence already submitted have been materially fortified, and before the grand jury meets they will have a strong case on the lines laid down by them when the arrest of Miss Borden was decided upon.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The Boston Globe's story about Lizzie Borden, based on detective McHenry's account and paid for by the paper, is now admitted by the Globe itself to be false in key details, including claims of witnesses seeing her in a waterproof cape. The article criticizes McHenry for selling a fabricated story for profit and faults prosecution officials for leaking information to reporters.

The Portland Daily Press · 12 October 1892 · page 4

THE UOItDEN CASE. The sensational developments in the Lizzie Borden case rest, and rest solely, so far as now appears, upon the testi mony of one McHenry, a detective of rather unsavory reputation. These de velopments were used not by McHenry to further the ends of justice but to put money in his own pocket. He got several hundred dollars for his story from the Boston Globe. The purchaser of the tale is now convinced, and publicly says so, that one of the gravest charges in this story against Miss Borden, is utterly groundless. It is also convinced that no such persons exist in Fall River as the persons alleged in the story to have seen Miss Borden at the time of the

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

The Boston Globe reports that an earlier story about Lizzie Borden's physical condition was false, based on denials from Dr. and Mrs. Bowen. The bogus information had been sold to a Globe reporter by Detective Edwin McHenry of Providence, and other inaccuracies in the supposed new evidence were also noted.

The Helena Independent · 12 October 1892 · page 2

Bogus News Sold

lng says that upon investigation it is eats -ed that the statement published yesterday concerning Lizzie Borden's physical condi tion is not true. It bases its belief upon the statement of Dr. and Mrs. Bowen. 'he Globe also says there are other inaoouracies in the alleged new evidence, which was sold to one of its reporters by betective Edwin Moeienry, of Providence.

See the clipping

Asheville Daily Citizen · Asheville, N.C.

The Boston Globe claims to have obtained affidavits from witnesses alleging threats, blackmail, and a staged confession by Lizzie Borden, including a detective's claim of spying on a quarrel between the sisters. Lizzie's counsel denounces the stories as lies, though detectives on the case insist the Globe's account is true.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Asheville Daily Citizen · 12 October 1892 · page 1

Ki.Nr.sTON, N. Y., Oct. 1". Residents of Madalin, in Dutchess count v, have learred to expect almost anything from fien. Watts De I'eyster. On Saturday night when the carpenters cj-.iit work on the new De I'eyster Memorial church, the General appeared upon the scent with ; i.,-.. !.. r , ... mint enslaving oi i resilient 11 ai ris'in, which he ordered one of the nu n to place at the top of the steeple, which has just becu completed. A carpenter obeyed th command. Un Sunday morning a crowd galheied around the church.

See moreSee less

The Democrats in the crowd determined to cover Han i sou's picture with that of Cleveland. Despite the protests of many, a man as. cendeil to the perilous height, and soon placed tue picture of the Democratic candidate over that ol Harrison. Alter much loud talking the excite ment increased by a Republican at tcn.nt i"H in ciimo up me sciiiokling leading to tlie spue, lie was pulled back, and a fierce struggle bigaii, in which mane prominent citizens joined. Suddenly the man I rokc away 'rom the crowd and succeeded in getting up out of -acli he fort he could lie pulled hack. A . lie as cended and took down the Cleveland pic ture he was greeted w ith wild cheering from one faction and stones from the other. When another attempt was made by a Cleveland admirer tn get up the steeple another fight ensued. This was contin ued hull way up the steeple, and the crowd below stood speeehh ss, cxpciiim to see someone fall. When at iciigth I he Cleveland picture bearer suce-edeil in gelling to tin.' top the Urn below was dcalening (,cn. Dil'ctster came o.h when the last picture li.it! been put in place. He was almost beside hiuiseb with wrath, but in t!:e howling mob his words were wasted. The Iienioirats reui.-.iucd aro;'iul the church at! day, and tiiiuiL-h several el torts were made to tear tin pictutcdoyvn it rcmaintd l hi re the rest ol iliiday. In the cvcnir.u the clt-;.-yinen of the town dino-it.ced tl cdisg.aii.ini affair from the Pulpit. Gen Dc IVystcr's action am' the ttrug gle on Sunday will be the chief topic oi conversation in M.-ulahn lor a lon-j time Fd ward Siurges, the well known D. mocrat, was one of the most intercsieil spectators. X. Y. Sun. Tin: i.izzii; n(itiii;Mcti;. IletallM of tlie ;. llmrci-u AKiltiis! aaer Cliaraclt r. Boston, Mass., Oct The ('.lobe prints a doi-.en miliums of the sw.riis of the o. w iivcssc in me imrucn uiiiniir case, who have given affidavits to the govei iiinci't. Mr. and Mis. Fredrick C base and Mis. Abigail Manchester will testily that on the night before the murder, while call ing at the B'liden house, and before be for being announced, they had heard Mr. Borden in another room, threaten to turn Mz.ic out of doors unless she would reveal the name ol the man who rot her into trouble. Mr. G. R. l'itison, a wealthy dealer in machinery supplies in New York, will testily that Mr, Borden detailed Lizzie's, trouble to him and was advised to disin herit her unless she would reveal tin man's name. Mrs. Geo. . Simpson will testily that at the Borden luner.il she overheard Liz zie asking Bridget Sullivan, tac servant, how much money she wanted to keep ipiict. Private Detective Mclicnry will testify that, lying coticcakd in a balhtoom, he witnessed the quarrel in the matron's room between the sisters, and that Liz zie kicked Lmma thrice, called her a foul name and said: "You waul to sec un hanged so von can conic into the entire lortur.e. You tire the one person! whom I thought 1 could trust with my secret." Mrs. Reagan, the matron, and oae ol her have deposed to the same ef'ccl. Lizzie Borden's counsel denounce all these stories as "a tissue ol lies," Inn the detectives who have ken on thecase say tin' Globe's story is true " Tin: "yvit Ki ii vi rsiie A Republican Candidate Not tva! iHlied Willi Hie n:ble F.eu. Gastonia, Oct. 1D-S. M. llolton, Re-1 publican candidate lor elector, was met heicby J. R Lcwcllyn, Democratic can didate, li.ai li bpoke an hour and a quarter. When llolton arose to make his rejoinder several pirsons started to leave. Leivi-llvn asked all his Pit nils to stay and they returned. At this point llolton said ; "Yes, stay please; if win leave now, just as 1 start in.il will ha ve to be said o you, 'The wicked pursue whin no man llnth.' " This wholly unintentional and ex tremely ludicrous but apt transpoMtiou created one of the greatest storms of laughter ever lienrd in Gnslonia Char lotte Observer. All Incendiary Muclililv. Boston, Oct. 10 An ingenious device was found iu an unoccupied dwelling in Cliftondale yesterday by which il was intended fo burn the property. The gong had been lemoved from a common nickel alarm clock and a bunch ol matches so arranged that the hammer would strike them when the alarm went off. The whole was placed in a box fill ed with material soaked with kerosene and the lloor in the viiiuity was also saturated with oil. N. Y. Sun. lioes Over lu I lieUeinocratH Parkersiurc, . Va , 10. M. C. C. Church, heretofore one of the most prom inent men in the Republican party ol this State, the advisor and counscller of the leaders, the man who has dictated the policy of tliatpartviiioicfrequentlv than any other in this Stale, has announced himself as opposed to Harrison and Rcid. His action has created consterna tion with the party in this State. Tciiuvhou-m Fuueral, London, Oct. 12. Tennyson was

See the clipping

The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.

Rival Boston newspapers denounce the Globe's sensational story about Lizzie Borden as a fake, with the Journal calling it a 'gigantic fabrication' and others using similar terms; the Globe's own detective source admits giving false witness names. Public sentiment in Fall River is reported shifting in Lizzie Borden's favor, with her counsel receiving supportive telegrams and local papers calling for the state to dismiss its detectives.

The State Chronicle · 12 October 1892 · page 1

TEECiL.OKK DENOUNCED I'Oil ITS SENSATIONAL FAKE. Public Sentiment Ciiansiuy: Itapidly in Favor of the Pretty Borden, the Ace lined. By telegraph to the state Chronicle. Boston, Mass., Oct. 11. Several Bjs ton papers this morning print two or more columns each giving the results of their investigations into the details ol the Globe's story yesterday in connection with the Borden murder case. In their head lines the Journal pronounces the story a "gigantic fabrication the Iferald says "it is full of flaws and based on falsehoods;" the Post calls it a "colossal fake:" and the New says "it is all lies.'' The papers agree in stating that the asser tion that Lizzie Borden has been unchaste is demonstrably untrue.

See moreSee less

Ttey agree too in the conclusion that many of the al leged "witnesses" whose testimony was anticipated have no existence in fact. The Globe says: "Detective E. G. Mc Henry furnished the Globe with the Barden story published yesterday morning. He admits it and also asserts that the facts are true. He states that the names and residences of alleged witnesses were purposely given wrong for obvious rea sons. Sentiment With mis llord' ti.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

An editorial criticizes sensationalist newspapers for prematurely convicting Lizzie Borden in print before any trial evidence has been presented. It argues she must be considered innocent until proven guilty in a proper court, and criticizes the judge who presided over her preliminary hearing.

Weekly Union · 12 October 1892 · page 4

Innocent Until Proven Guilty. 1f the enemies of Lizzie Borden inand around Fall River do not succeed in con victing her of the terrible crime of which she stands accused, it will not be for any lack of support on the fpart of as least one sensational newspaper writér, and he is not:winning for himself an enviable reputa tion by the course he is pursuing. Certaln newspapers have “convicted” her, but thus far no damaging testimony has been pre

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The Boston Globe prints an apology to Lizzie Borden and John V. Morse for injustice done by its Monday story, after investigation showed detective McHenry had given false names and residences for witnesses. The paper insists the main facts still stand and announces it has hired new detectives to pursue the murder investigation.

The Evening Herald · 12 October 1892 · page 3

APOLOGIZES TO LIZZIE BORDEN

for obvious reasons. "Tho 'Globe,' in the course of Its In vestigation into the details ot the story, interviewed Dr. nnd Mrs. Bowen and Uev. Mr. Buck on the question of Lizeie Bor den's physical condition at tlie time of tho murder, the result of which was the conviction that in this respect at least Mr. MuIIeury was wrong. Tho story may be wrong In some other minor particu lars, but tho weight of evidence favors tho main fncts us true." "And now for the purpose ot ferreting out tho murder in tho Borden case the 'Globe' bos e ngaged the best detective talent available." A statement by Henry G. Trlokey. the reporter who signed Monday's story, it

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Following the Boston Globe's retraction of its false story about a confession in the Borden case, the Post's Fall River correspondent examines who was really responsible for the fabrication. The piece questions whether detective McHenry would have been foolish enough to solicit a bribe and leak false information, suggesting instead that reporter Trickey may have entrapped him.

Pawtucket Tribune · 12 October 1892 · page 1

WHO WAS TO BLAME For the "Developments" in the Borden Case? GLOBE RETRACTS ITS STORY By Admitting That a Large Part of It Was False.

Was False. Bosrox, Oct, 12 —~The Post’s special cor respon ‘ent at Full River has this to say of the Borden ‘‘fake” this morning: The more the Globe’s backdown is dis

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The Boston Globe publishes a humble apology admitting it was deceived by a fabricated story about a Lizzie Borden confession, calling it an unparalleled imposition on an honest newspaper. Public opinion speculates that reporter Trickey bribed detective McHenry into the hoax, and that the apology was prompted more by threats of libel suits than genuine remorse.

Pawtucket Tribune · 12 October 1892 · page 1

GLOBE RETRACTS ITS STORY

as reasonable as the conclusion of Lizzie Borden's guilt that so many have adopted, Another thing that has oceasioned gen eral comment and the greatest astonish ment is that The Globe should aceept and publish such a story without the slightest attempt at verification, as it confesses having done, espeecially since it was full of statements that must have heen known to Trickey, in view of his familiarity with the case, to be absolutely false, contradie tory and impossible, Tle hmmble, abject apology published by The Glohe occasioned another flurry, The general comment was that The Globe had done the only honorable thing possi ble, though it wonld have come with a better grace yesterday morning; but al most evervhody attribated the apology to the promptness with which libel suits and ceriminal libel proceedings were said to have been ordered unless satisfactory rep aration were made,

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The Globe newspaper issues a formal apology, admitting it was deceived into publishing a fabricated account presented as genuine evidence in the Lizzie Borden case. It retracts the story, apologizes to Lizzie Borden and John V. Morse for the injustice done to them, and pledges to correct errors openly.

Pawtucket Tribune · 12 October 1892 · page 1

GLOBE RETRACTS ITS STORY

The Globhe's Apology. The following appeared iu last evening's issue of The Globe, The Lizzie Borden Case, The Globe s, first of all, an honest news paper. Toerr is human, and as newspapers have to be run by men and not by angels, mis takes are inevitable, The Globe fecls it aplain duty, as an honest newspaper, to state that it has been grieve ouslv misled in the Lizzie Borden case, It publizhed on Monday a commmunication that it Lelieved to be true evidence, Among all the impositions which newspapers have suffered, this was unparalleled in fits astonishing comnleteness and {rresistihle plausibility, Judiing from what we have heard, it im prosood our readers as strongly as it did The Globe, Some of this remarkably ingenious and cunningly eontrived story is undoubtedly ba el on facts, as later developments will gliow.

See moreSee less

The Globe believes, however, that much of it isfalse, and never should have been published, The Globe, being thus misled, has innocently added to the terrible burdens of Miss Lizzie Borden, So far as lies in our power to repair the wrong, we are anxious to do so,and hereby

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The Boston Globe admits it was misled and publishes a retraction of sensational claims about Lizzie Borden's physical condition, which it had purchased from Detective Edwin McHenry. The paper calls the false story one of the most convincing impositions ever perpetrated on a newspaper.

The Salt Lake Herald · 12 October 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN MALIGNED

r The Boston Globe Setracs lit Sensational fctatf mpnt Concerning Her f BOSTON Oct 1L The Globe this morn ing upon investigation is satisfied that the statement published yesterday con cerning Lizzie Bordens physical condition ie not true and bases its belief on a state

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

Multiple Boston newspapers investigated and discredited the Globe's sensational story about Lizzie Borden, calling it a fabrication, collection of falsehoods, and lies. They found that claims about Borden's chastity were false and that many cited witnesses did not actually exist, with a detective admitting he deliberately gave wrong names.

The Times · 12 October 1892 · page 1

THE GLOBE'S STORY DENIED.

Fall River, Mass, Oct. 11.—The ger oral feeling has changed in regard to the Borden case, and the defendant's counsel is receiving enconraging tele grams from ull sections condemning the

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The Boston Globe stated it had investigated and found its previous report about Lizzie Borden's physical condition to be untrue, citing statements from Dr. and Mrs. Bowen. The paper also noted other inaccuracies in evidence sold to its reporter by a detective working for the prosecution.

Wheeling Register · 12 October 1892 · page 2

Interesting New* by Wire Boiled Down f«»f Hurried Bender*. The Boston Globe said yesterday morn-, ing that upon Investigation it is satisfied that the statement published yesterday concerning Miss Lizzie Borden’s physical

See the clipping

Audubon County Republican · Audubon, Iowa

The Boston Globe reports affidavits from twenty witnesses claiming damaging new evidence against Lizzie Borden, including claims her father threatened to disinherit her over a secret scandal and witnesses who saw her near the crime scene. It also cites a detective and others alleging she tried to bribe the maid Bridget Sullivan into silence.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Audubon County Republican · 13 October 1892 · page 1

NEW TESTIMONY PROMISED IN THE CASE. The Kyhlence <»f Muny Witnesses Wlll Benr Heavily Aguliiat the Prisoner—- Said to Hava Told Her Mvret to Her bitter. Boaton, Out. I’J.- The Globe yes terday printed n dozen columns of the stories of twenty witnesses in the Borden murder case, who have given nftldiivits to the government. Some of these stories are as follows: Frank Burroughs, a well-known New York lawyer, will testify that eight months before the murder occurred Lizzie Borden consulted him it bout the dispo sition of property in the event of a stepdeath before that of her hua bund.

See moreSee less

Mr. and Mrs Frederick Chanc und Mrs Ahigi.il Manchester will testify that on the night before the murder, while calling at the Borden house and before being* announced, they had overheard Mr Borden in another room threatening to turn Lizzie out of doors unless sin* would repeat the name of the man who “g d her into trouble.” G. Romance Pittston of New York will testify that Mr. Borden detailed Lizzie’s trouble to him and uas advised to disinherit her unless she would reveal the man's name. John 11. Murphy, Mrs. Gustave F. Rohald. Peter Mahany and Augustus Gunning will testify to having seen Lizzie Borden at a window where ami when she must have been standing over the dead Ihmlv of her st<‘pmoth<‘r at a time when her fauht r was walking in the yard Mrs. George J. Simpson will testify that al the Borden funeral sh ' overheard Lizzie asking Bridget Sullivan, the servant, how much m< ncy she wanted to keep quiet. Private Detective McHenry will fes tify that, lying concealed in a bath room, he wit iiessed t ie qmiri el In the matron’s room between tin* sisters, and that Lizzie kicked Emma Ihriee, called her a foul naim* and said: “You wanted to see me hanged, uo you can come into the entire fortune. You arc the one person whom I thought I could trust with my secret.” Mrs. Reagan, the matron, and one other person hav»' deposed (o the same effect. The Globo promises to publish a cer tain piece of very important in forma tion recently gained by Oflieer Hur rington as soon as Hu* interests of jus tice will not suffer by its publication

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The Boston Globe issued a full retraction of its earlier 'revelations' in the Borden case, apologizing to Lizzie Borden and her relative Morse for the wrong done to them. Public anger focused on detective McHenry, who supplied the false material, while sympathy for Lizzie Borden grew and the prosecution worried about finding an unbiased jury.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 13 October 1892 · page 3

Der Doppelmord in Fall-River. Widerruf der Enthüllungen des Bostoner Globe. Sympathie für Lizzie Borden.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The item criticizes the Boston Globe for sensationalized and allegedly false reporting on the Borden murder case, accusing it of effectively trying and convicting a woman before any court trial. It contrasts this with the Globe's claim that it wishes to repair harm from its earlier false and malicious statements.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 13 October 1892 · page 2

The anper-sensational Boston Globe is leas entitled to the confidence of intelligent readers in New Kngland than ever, not withstanding its statement that so far as pmudble it ta anxious to repair the injure gm^dune by publishing the false and malicious ||B atiooa regarding the Borden mur*

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The Philadelphia Ledger criticizes newspapers for once again trying Lizzie Borden in print before her court trial, noting that earlier newspaper claims were not supported by courtroom evidence. It calls the current wave of unverifiable stories, sourced from untraceable people, to be in bad taste given she will receive a fair trial.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 13 October 1892 · page 2

Again Tried in the Newspapers. Philadelphia Ledger.) Lizzie Borden is again tried in the news papers for the murder of her father. In the first trial the newspaper stories were not sustained by the evidence given in c ourt, and these new stories appear to be based on the evidence of people who can not he found at the addresses given. As there is no doubt that Lizzie Borden will In given a fair trial in the Massachusetts courts, the effort to c onvic t her in the news papers is in had tastea to say the least.

See the clipping

The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn.

The Boston Globe reports it has obtained details of new prosecution evidence in the Borden murder case, to be presented by twenty-five new witnesses at trial. The witnesses are described as reputable community members with no motive to lie.

The Princeton Union · 13 October 1892 · page 7

HARD CITIZENS ARE FILLED WITH LEAD. Two Prisoners Are Murdered While in Charge of Wyoming OfficersThe Murder tBordenF the ront Ca Once More. Crime's Calendar. Casper, Wyo., Oct. 11.Meager details

See the clipping

The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn.

The Boston Globe claims to have obtained new evidence from the police, to be presented by twenty-five new witnesses at Lizzie Borden's upcoming trial. Among the claims: witnesses who saw Lizzie at a window near the time of the murder, others who heard a quarrel between Lizzie and her father, and a New York lawyer consulted about property rights in the event of a stepmother's death.

The Princeton Union · 13 October 1892 · page 7

Startling: Evidence. Boston, Oct. 11.The Boston Globe pub lishes a thirteen-column story from Fall HiA'er, setting forth in detail new and start ling evidence for the prosecution in the Bor den murder case, Avhich, it says, is in the hands of the police, and is to be given by tAAenty-five new AA'itnesses, who will testify for the state at the coming trial of Miss Lizzie Borden. The eAidence, the Globe states, is forthcoming from people, all of Avhom stand high in the community where they live, and who could have no motive for speaking maliciously or untruthfully of the defendant.

See moreSee less

A number will testify, so it is churned, of seeing Miss Lizzie Borden at a window at a time when she must have been standing over the dead body of Mrs. Borden. Others, it is said, will testify to having overheard a quarrel betAA-een Lizzlo and her father on the night previous to the murder. Prank Burroughs, a lawyer of New York, formerly of Fall ltiver, is, it is said, the at torney consulted by Lizzie Borden about the property rights in a father's estate should a stepmother die firsts

See the clipping

Asheville Daily Citizen · Asheville, N.C.

The Boston Globe, which had published alleged 'new evidence' in the Lizzie Borden case, now says it was 'grievously misled' and apologizes for the harm done to her reputation. The paper calls its earlier report an 'inhuman reflection upon her honor.'

Asheville Daily Citizen · 13 October 1892 · page 1

Apology to Lizzie Borden

CONSTITUTIONAL. New York mate Is Democratic All R IE lit Albany. N. Y Oct. 13. The legisla tive apportionment law has been de claredconstittttiomil. The court isunnnimous upon all questions except those discussed in the opinion by Judge An drews. The result practically assures Democratic control ot the legislature. Apoloxv lo Lizzie llorden. Boston, Mnss., Oct. 13. The Iloston Globe, which published the alleged "new evidence" in the Lizzie Borden case, says, editorially, that it was "grievously mis led, nnd that it has innocently added to the terrible burdens ol Miss Borden It rentiers her a "heartfelt apology for the inhuman reflection upon her honor." rit-.uliniuoiiH Mlu to Plitht Hall

See the clipping

Asheville Daily Citizen · Asheville, N.C.

A brief editorial comment suggests that either Lizzie Borden is a very bad woman, or several other people in Massachusetts are telling desperate lies about her. It reflects the uncertainty and public speculation surrounding the case during the investigation.

Asheville Daily Citizen · 13 October 1892 · page 2

THURSDAY. OCTOBER 13. 1892. Lizzie Borden is either a very bail woman, or else there are several persons almost as bad in Massachusetts who are telling desperate lies about her.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The Boston Globe admits that the story it published the previous day about Lizzie Borden's physical condition was untrue. It also states that other parts of the 'new evidence' bought from Detective Edwin McHenry contained inaccuracies.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 13 October 1892 · page 1

The Borden Evidence Was Bogus. Boston, Oct 11. Tbe Globe to-day sayt that upon investigation it is satisfied that the Statement it published yesterday con cerning Miss Lizzie Borden's physical con dition is not true. The Olobo also says that

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This item is a collection of editorial snippets, several of which criticize the Boston Globe for publishing a false or fabricated story about Lizzie Borden without verifying it. It notes near-unanimous condemnation from newspaper exchanges over the 'dastardly fake' and mentions Detective McHenry defending himself against being portrayed as a villain in the Globe's account.

The Providence News · 13 October 1892 · page 4

’ THERE are no reports of the Mos ~wansicut or the Woonasquatucket being ‘get in a blaze by the proximity of N Page and Lapham, but perhaps she miracle is yet to appear, f Tae Warwick regulars and the War ~ wick reformers still glare at each other _@cross the bloody chasm with their right hands ostentatiously thrust behind their ' Packs and no sign of a shake, . THE Boston Gllobe ought to apologize *jo the public now for having such stupid . editors as to allow the gigantic Borden - fake to be published without making —any effort to ascertain its truth, ~ Mavor Hoxey makes a good presid ~ Ing officer, but when it comes to speech . making he seems to believe that the

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The Boston Globe claims twenty-five new witnesses will testify for the prosecution, saying they saw Lizzie Borden hiding in her stepmother's room wearing a rubber hood and cape, and heard a groan. It also claims Lizzie and her father quarreled over a mysterious 'trouble' she refused to explain, while noting defense counsel Jennings has begun libel suits over such hired-detective stories.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 13 October 1892 · page 4

svidenes in the noted Horden marder case, | wonty-five new wiinesses, it op will testify for the [intacution, and these gay they saw Lizzie Borden in her step-mother's room about the time the murder must have been committed

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The report states that general feeling at Fall River has changed regarding the Borden murder case, with the defendant's counsel receiving encouraging telegrams from across the country regarding alleged disclosures in the case. Local newspapers editorially call for the state to dispense with its hired detectives, and defense counsel Mr. Jennings has been directed to bring libel suits.

Richmond Dispatch · 13 October 1892 · page 4

story from Fall River giving new and startling svidenes in the noted Horden marder case, | wonty-five new wiinesses, it op will testify for the [intacution, and these gay they saw Lizzie Borden in her step-mother's room about the time the murder must have been committed

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

The Boston Globe publishes twelve columns of witness affidavits in the Borden case, including a claim that Lizzie asked Bridget Sullivan how much money would keep her quiet, and detective testimony of a quarrel between Lizzie and Emma. The paper promises further disclosures as the investigation continues.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Laramie Republican · 13 October 1892 · page 8

The Borden Clue. ' " Boston, Oct. 11. — The Globe this morning prints twelve columns on the Borden murder case, giving affidavits of witnesses. These stories tend strongly to throw the guilt upon Lizzie Borden. Mrs. George J. Simpson’s statement is to the effect that she overheard] Lizzie ask Bridget! Sullivan, the servant girl, how much money she wanted to keep quiet. Detective McHenry testified tc overhearing an angry colloquy between Emma and Lizzie in which the latter declared the former was trying to hang her and had betrayed her sister.

See moreSee less

The Globe promises further disclosures when they can be made without fear of defeat ing the ends of justice. Covington Sport. Und> . Arrest. Dakota City, Neb., Oct. 11.—Keefe. O’Donnell, Lytle and Cahill, who were implicated in the prize fight at Coving ton in which George Roway, alias “Billy the Kid,” lost liis life, were held by Judge Williams of Covington tc answer to the charge of murder. Keefe. O’Donnell and Lytle waived exam ination and gave bonds for their appear ance at the district court, the formei $1,500 and the latter SSOO each. Cahil. was charged with being Roway’s second He stood trial and was discharged. H. immediately crossed the river into lowa and thereby escaped being rearrested foi abetting prize fighting.

See the clipping

The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn.

The piece criticizes the prosecution for apparently trying to sway public opinion by leaking sensational advance testimony to a Boston newspaper, which was then promptly denied. It argues this backfired, leading some who believed Lizzie Borden guilty to feel the prosecution had inadvertently helped her defense.

The Willimantic Journal · 14 October 1892 · page 4

GEORGE M. CLARK of Haddam. The republicans of the Fourth Congres sional district of this state,have nominated Hon. Frederick Miles as their candidate for congress. He is unquestionably the strongest man they could have named, and has, in times past, been elected from that * district. With Russell, Henry, Kellog and Miles as candidates for congress, the re publicans of Connecticut deserve the full delegation. An attempt on the part of the prosecu tion to forestall public opinion in the Borden murder case in Fall R ver was so manifest in the publication of sensational advance testimony in a Boston newspaper and its prompt denial within a few hours, that those who have heretofore believed that Lizzie Borden was guilty, acknow

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The item reports that the coil of circumstantial evidence is tightening around Lizzie Borden in the Fall River case, suggesting she will be proved the murderess of her parents. It predicts the crime and trial will become a celebrated case in Massachusetts criminal history.

The Morning News · 14 October 1892 · page 4

'I he coil of circumstantial evidence Is tightening about Lizzie Borden at Fall River, and it appears that sue will be proved the murderess of her parents. The

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The Boston Globe published a sensational report implying strong evidence of Lizzie Borden's guilt, based on details from a detective. After investigation it was found the Globe had been misled, and the paper issued a full retraction and apology.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 14 October 1892 · page 5

U. Strong, only daughter of Mr and Mrs E. 11. Strong of the Vendome, and Prof W. B. Clark of Johns Hopkins university, Balti more, son of B. A. Clark of Brattleboro, Vt. The ceremony was performed at the Em manuel church, Newbury street, at 11:30 bv the brother of the bride, Rev G. A. Strong. The 2d councilor democratic convention at Dedham has nominated William R. Rice o 1 Quincy. A very sensational mess about the Borden murder case was served up in the Boston Globe this week. It reflected scandalizingly upon Lizzie Borden and with much circum stantial detail made it appear that there was no question of her guilt.

See moreSee less

It made a great stir in Fall River and investigation proved that the Globe had been imposed upon by one of the detectives in the vase. It promptly acknowledged as much and made complete retraction and apology.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The Boston Globe's recent sensational 'revelations' about the Lizzie Borden case turn out to be false. The reporter who wrote them was duped by detective McHenry.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Richmond Dispatch, 13 October 1892, The Laramie Republican, 13 October 1892.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 14 October 1892 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The Boston Globe published a communication claiming startling new evidence against Lizzie Borden, which turned out to be a swindle perpetrated by Detective McHenry. The Globe has now issued an apology to Miss Borden, admitting it was deceived by its correspondent.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Paper unidentified · 14 October 1892 · page 2

JAMES C. MacRAE. FRIDAY, OCT. - - U, 1892 The Boston Globe recently printed a communication that contained some startling new evidence against Lizzie Borden, had it been true; but it was a swindle on the part of a wretched fellow. The Globe now comes forward and makes an hum ble apology to Miss Borden and

See the clipping

Sullivan Republican · Laporte, Pa.

The Boston Globe reports on new evidence from twenty-five witnesses the prosecution plans to call at Lizzie Borden's trial. Witnesses include a man who claims he saw a woman identified as Lizzie open a window blind in the room where her mother's body was found, and a woman who claims she saw a capped figure in the window after hearing a cry.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Sullivan Republican · 14 October 1892 · page 2

QUEER STORIES OF LIZZIE BORDEN

A WOMAM IX THE ROOM. John 11. Murphy, who resides on Bedford street, Fall River, will testify that ho was standing on the sidewalk close to the Borden house when Mr. Borden entered his yard about 10:40 o'clock on the morning of August 4, and he saw him a minute or two latter ushered into the lobby by Bridget Sullivan. Murphy will swear that while Mr. Borden was walking in the yard he saw a window blind of the room in which Mrs. Borden's body was after wards found cautiously opened by a young woman who had the same morning told him when he called at the Borden house about 9:30 o'clock, that her father had gone down town and would not be back untd noon or later.

See moreSee less

This woman he has identi fied as the defendant, Lizzie A. Borden. The window Mr. Murphy designates as the one in which he saw Miss Lizzie is so situated that she must have been standing over the mutilated remains of her mother at the very time that her father was about to enter the house, between 10:35 and 10:45 o'clock.

See the clipping

Sullivan Republican · Laporte, Pa.

The report describes unnamed witnesses—Murphy, Mrs. Ronald, and Gunning—claiming to have seen Lizzie Borden at a window near the time her mother was killed, contradicting her own account of her whereabouts. It also recounts secondhand stories of a father-daughter quarrel over a secret suitor and an alleged blackmail exchange with the maid Bridget Sullivan.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Sullivan Republican · 14 October 1892 · page 2

RECOGNIZED THE FACE. The next witness of importance is Mrs. Gustave F. Ronald, of P-tw tucket, R. 1., who was a guest ol the Wilbur House. About 9:40 on the morning of the murder she was wneeling her bah}' carriage near the Borden house when she heard a terrible cry or groan. She looked up at the Borden house and saw in a room through a partially open window a woman whose head was in part covered by a rubber cap or hood, whose face she saw plainly, as the distance was short.

See moreSee less

She recognized her as the younger daughter of the Borden family, the members of which she knew quite well by sight. Augustus Gunning, at the time a lodger in Mrs. Churchill's house, is said to have seen Lizzie Borden iD the window at the same time and under the same circumstances. These witnesses, the Globe says, fix Miss Borden at her mother's side almost at the minute when she probably was killed, and when Miss Lizzie, accoiding to her story, was elsewhere.

See the clipping

Sullivan Republican · Laporte, Pa.

A Boston paper had published claims of a bitter family quarrel, blackmail talk, and a secret will involving the Bordens and Bridget Sullivan. Lizzie's attorney, Andrew Jennings, calls the entire account a 'tissue of lies,' noting the named witnesses and addresses do not exist.

Sullivan Republican · 14 October 1892 · page 2

JEXXIXUS lUOVIKSTHE STORY. Lizzie Borden'* Lawyer Nays the Whole Thing In False. Fall River, Oct. 10. —Andrew J. Jennings, council for the defend ant in the Borden murder cases,

See the clipping

Vermont Phœnix · Brattleboro, Vt.

The Boston Globe published a sensational 10-column article claiming to reveal new government evidence against Lizzie Borden, including character charges and testimony allegedly bought from a private detective. The story proved to be entirely fabricated, and the Globe retracted it and apologized, drawing criticism for irresponsible journalism.

Vermont Phœnix · 14 October 1892 · page 1

MINOR NOTES

In tho case against Lizzie Borden. New charges against Miss Borden's character wero made, and a large amount of testimony presented which tended to show her guilt. The tostimouy was supported by affidavits from tlie different persons who gavo it, and was sold to a Globe reporter by a private de tective. Tho whole story was a fako of the worst kind, and tlie Globe has retracted it and apologized. Hut tho wholo business was a piece of sensational journalism, which detracts from the Globe's reputation, and disgusts right-minded people.

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

The Boston Globe retracted its sensational story claiming a young man's affair with Lizzie Borden caused family discord, admitting much of it was false. Papers debate whether detective McHenry or reporter Trickey was responsible for bribing and fabricating the fake testimony.

The United Opinion · 14 October 1892 · page 1

WHO WAS TO BLAME

Boston, Oct, 10. The Globe this morn Ing publishes a story from Fall River to the effect that some young man had got Lizzie Bonlen into trouble, and that it led to the great family discord when the secret was discovered. It claims that startling testimony will be given by twenty-five new witnesses. BOSTON, Oct. 13. The Post's special cor respondent at Fall River has this to say of the Borden "fake this morning: The more the Globe's backdown Is dis

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

The Globe newspaper publishes an abject apology admitting it was deceived into printing a fabricated story about a Lizzie Borden confession, obtained through reporter Trickey and detective McHenry. Public speculation debates whether McHenry was duped by Trickey or whether McHenry himself concocted the scheme for money or revenge.

The United Opinion · 14 October 1892 · page 1

WHO WAS TO BLAME

The Globe's Apology. The follow-iii -.r appeared in last evening's issue of The ;ilobe. The I.ir.ie Borden Cane. The Globe is, lirMt of all, nn honest news paper. To err is human, and as newspapers have to be run by men uud not by angels, mis takes are inevitable. The Ulobe feels it a plain duty, as an honest newspaper, to btale Unit it has been griev ously misled in tiie 'Lizzie Borden case. It published on .Monday a i-oimmiiiication that it believed to be true evide nce. Among all the Impositions winch newspapers lime suffered, this was unparalleled 111 its astonishing Completeness and irres.sti.

See moreSee less

plausibility. Judging from what we iiuv ,,-aril, it im pressed our readers as s'roiigiy as itdid The Ulobe. Some of this i.-aiiirk.inly ingenious and cunningly contrived -im-y is undoubtedly based on tu is, as lni r ii'e!oiiiieiits will Show. The i.l-ibe belie,.--, li.iAover, tbat much of it is false, and never should have been published. The Ulolie, being thus misled, has Innocently added to the terrible burdens of Miss Lizzie Borden. So far as lies in our power to repair the wrong, we are anxious to do so.and hereby

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

The Globe newspaper publicly apologizes for publishing a fabricated account about Lizzie Borden earlier in the week, admitting it was misled by a deceptive and plausible-seeming communication. The paper extends its apology to both Lizzie Borden and John V. Morse for the injustice caused by the false publication.

The United Opinion · 14 October 1892 · page 1

The I.ir.ie Borden Cane. The Globe is, lirMt of all, nn honest news paper. To err is human, and as newspapers have to be run by men uud not by angels, mis takes are inevitable. The Ulobe feels it a plain duty, as an honest newspaper, to btale Unit it has been griev ously misled in tiie 'Lizzie Borden case. It published on .Monday a i-oimmiiiication that it believed to be true evide nce. Among all the Impositions winch newspapers lime suffered, this was unparalleled 111 its astonishing Completeness and irres.sti.

See moreSee less

plausibility. Judging from what we iiuv ,,-aril, it im pressed our readers as s'roiigiy as itdid The Ulobe. Some of this i.-aiiirk.inly ingenious and cunningly contrived -im-y is undoubtedly based on tu is, as lni r ii'e!oiiiieiits will Show. The i.l-ibe belie,.--, li.iAover, tbat much of it is false, and never should have been published. The Ulolie, being thus misled, has Innocently added to the terrible burdens of Miss Lizzie Borden. So far as lies in our power to repair the wrong, we are anxious to do so.and hereby

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

The Boston Globe reports on affidavits from twenty witnesses against Lizzie Borden, including claims she consulted a lawyer about inheritance before the murders, was overheard arguing with her father about a secret lover, and was seen near a window during the time of the murder. A private detective claims to have witnessed a violent quarrel between Lizzie and her sister Emma, including physical assault and incriminating statements.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Iowa County Democrat · 14 October 1892 · page 6

Fusion, Oct. 10.—The Globe this morning prints a dozen coliimiis of the stori.-s of twenty witnesses in the Borden murder case, who have given aflidavits to the government. Some of these stories are as follows: Frank Burroughs, a well-known New 7 York lawyer, will testify that eight months before the murder occurred Lizzie Borden consulted him about the dispo sition of property in the e'-ent of a step mother's death before that of her hus band. Mr. and Mrs. Frederick Chase and Mrs. Abigail Manchester will testify that on the night before the murder, while calling at the Borden house and before being announced, they had overheard Mr.

See moreSee less

Borden in another room flirealening t<> turn Lizzie out of doors unless she would repeat the name of the man who ‘ g>t her into trouble.” G. Romance Bittston of New York will testify that Mr. Borden detailed Lv.zie's tronb'e to him and was advised to disinherit her unless she would reveal the man’s name. John il. Murphy, Mrs. Gustave I*'. Rohald, BelerMahany and Augustus Gunning will testify to having seen Lizzie Borden at a window w.iere and when she must have been standing over the dead body of her stepmother at a time when her fauher was walking in the yard. Mrs. George J. Simpson will testify that at the Borden funeral she overheard Lizzie asking Bridget Subivan, the servant, how much money she wanted to keep quiet. Brivale Detective McHenry will tes tify that, lying conealed m a bath room, he witnessed the quarrel in the matron’s room between the sisters, ami that Lizzie kiked Emma thrice, calUd her a foul nai>e and said: “You wanted to see me hanged, so you can come into the entire fortune. You arc the one person whom I thought I could trust with my secret.” Mrs. Eengan. the matron, and one other person have ' • posed to tiesaineeffect. The (Hr!., v-• unises <-> . uhlish a cer

See the clipping

Huntsville Gazette · Huntsville, Ala.

The report states that Boston and Fall River newspapers are complicating the Lizzie Borden case by prematurely publishing details of the evidence the state plans to use. It remarks sarcastically that if the allegations are true, she must be as two-faced as Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.

Huntsville Gazette · 15 October 1892 · page 1

Mass., are seriously complicating the case of Lizzie Borden by premature publication of lines of evidence relied upon by the state to convict. If half of the allegations against the defendant are true she must have been as two

See the clipping

Arizona Weekly Citizen · Tucson, Ariz

A brief Fall River dispatch reports that Lizzie Borden's counsel calls a story published in the Boston Globe false. No further detail is given about the content of the disputed Globe report.

Arizona Weekly Citizen · 15 October 1892 · page 4

Washington, D. C, Oct. 10. Mrs. Harrison did not rest as well n usual last night but this morning is sleeping com foit ably. Fall River, Mass., Oct. 10. Lizzie Borden's counsel says the story in the Boston ilobeis a falsehood.

See the clipping

Arizona Weekly Citizen · Tucson, Ariz

The Boston Globe reportedly published a story claiming witnesses at Lizzie Borden's committal trial saw her at a window at the moment her mother was being murdered, and also described a prior quarrel in which her father threatened to turn her out of the house. The report appears amid other unrelated wire dispatches on Homestead Strike proceedings, a shipwreck, and the Columbus Day parade in New York.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Arizona Weekly Citizen · 15 October 1892 · page 4

Boston, Oct 10. The Glebe this corning publishes a thirteen column stcry to the effect that several wifne-ses at the commits trial of L zz e Borden for the murder of her father acd mother wm iy iue saw Li zzie at the window OW

See the clipping

The State Capital · Springfield, Ill.

The report states that Boston and Fall River newspapers are complicating the Lizzie Borden case by prematurely publishing details of the evidence the state plans to use for conviction. It remarks sarcastically that if the allegations are true, she must have had a Jekyll-and-Hyde personality.

The State Capital · 15 October 1892 · page 2

Mass., are seriously’ complicating the case of Lizzie Borden by premature publication of lines of evidence relied upon by the state to convict. If half of the allegations against the defendant are true she must have lieen as two

See the clipping

Baxter Springs News · Baxter Springs, Kan.

A roundup of national news notes 'important developments' in the Borden case that make matters look 'very black' for Lizzie Borden, without specifying what the new evidence is. In the same digest, the Boston Globe admits that an earlier sensational story it ran about the Borden case was fabricated.

Baxter Springs News · 15 October 1892 · page 6

Important developments in the fa mous Borden cuse makes things look very black for Lizzie Borden. A Chinese sailor en route to New York died from a disease "common to Chinamen." In the Homestead treason cases the charge of Chief Justice Paxson to the grand jury was very unfavorable to the accused. Thousands of school children and college students took part in the first of the New York parades of the anni versary celebration. M. J. O'Brien, the embezzling treas urer of the Catholic Knights of Ameri ca, has been arrested in Philadelphia.

See moreSee less

The grand jury at Pittsburgh, Pa., returned true bills against all the men charged tvtyh treason, murder and riot. Also true bills against Frick, Love joy. Potter and others, charged with mur der, etc The Columbus nnval pageant in New York harbor was witnessed by count less thousands and presented an impos ing and beautiful sight The Boston Globe acknowledges that its sensational story la the Borden case rwa a fake.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Fall River City Marshal Hilliard returned from Boston-area business related to the Borden case and declined to comment on Detective McHenry's alleged statements reported by the Boston Globe. He promised a forthcoming statement and gave the impression authorities held important evidence not yet revealed to the press.

The Portland Daily Press · 15 October 1892 · page 1

COOKING ANOTHER SENSATION. Marshal Hilliard Hints of New Evidence Against Lizzie Borden.

Against Lizzie Borden. Fall Biveh, Mass., October 14.—City Marshal Hilliard was at home today, af ter spending most of the week in the vi cinity of Boston, Providence and New Bedford on business connected with the Borden case. Concerning Detective Mc Henry’s alleged statements as reported in the Boston Globe, he said he was not prepared to make a formal statement at this time, as he had not had an opportu nity yet to read the matter published. He promised he would soon make a statement which he thought would clear up many things about which the public were now in doubt.

See moreSee less

Detective McHenry is not now in the employ of the city. He was employed by the city marshal through authority given by Mayor Cougnlan. From all that could be gathered from the city marshal’s manner, there is every reason to believe the government has some very important evidence which has not yet been hinted at by the newspapers

See the clipping

The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.

The Boston Globe published a lengthy story claiming multiple witnesses would testify at Lizzie Borden's trial to incriminating evidence, including a window sighting, a quarrel over a pregnancy, and a whispered bribe to Bridget Sullivan. Lizzie Borden's lawyer immediately denounced the story as a complete fabrication.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The New North-West · 15 October 1892 · page 4

STARTLING DEVELOPMENTS. A Story Printed in Boston About the Murder of the Bordens. BosTox, Oct. 10.-The Globe this morn ing prints a thirteen-column story to the effect that several witnesses at the comn ing trial of Lizzie Borden, for the murder of her fath'er and mother, will swear they saw Lizzie at the window of her house on the day of the crime and at a time which makes it certain she was at that moment standing over the body of her mother. Others, it is stated, will swear they overheard a quarrel between Lizzie and her father on the night before the murder, in which the latter told her that unless she gave the name of the man who got her into trouble he would turn her out of the house.

See moreSee less

0. Romaine Pittson, a wealthy New Yorker, has made an affidavit that a few days prior to the murder, Borden consulted him as a friend about Lizzie, whose trouble\he related. George Sisson, it is said, will swear that less than a month before the murder Borden told him he had made a will giving Emma and Lizzie $25,000 cash, which was msore than he would have allowed them but for his wife's in tercession. Bridget Sullivan will, it is claimed, corroborate the story of the quarrel between Mr. Borden and Lizzie, and will also swear that on the afternoon of the day of the murder Lizzie whis pered to her, "Keep your tongue still and you can have all the money you want." A dispatch from Fall River says that Lizzie Borden's counsel declares the story in the Boston Globe is a tissue of lies. Next week the NEW NORTHIWEST will begin a review of the candidates for the tvarious offices on the Republican county ticket. No attempt will be made to cover the entire ticket in one issue, but the candidates will be mentioned in the order in which the most complete infor mation concerning them comes to hand. "Not all is gold that glitters" is a true saying; it is equally true that not all is sarsaparilla that is so labelled. If you would be sure of the genuine article, ask for Ayer's Sarsaparilla, and take no other. Health is too precious to be trifled with. established fact, of course each state should have its representation and each state should, as a state, send some beau tiful and characteristic contributions; but it should be remembered that it is not a country fair, where individual and ama teurish products will be given a place. Products of the brush, pencil, chisel or needle, which have excited the enthusi astic admiration of loving friends at home, would only be laughed at when placed in competition with works of the great masters, which alone should find or will find a place there.

See the clipping

The Dickinson Press · Dickinson, N.D.

Boston papers denounce the Globe's earlier article about Lizzie Borden as a fabrication, stating claims of her being unchaste were false and many cited witnesses did not exist. The Globe admits it was deceived by detective McHenry, who was reportedly paid $500 for the fake story, and publishes a formal apology.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Sullivan Republican, 14 October 1892, Iowa County Democrat, 14 October 1892.

The Dickinson Press · 15 October 1892 · page 1

Tlie Slory Proves iitrue. Boston, Oct. 12.---Several Boston papers Ivday referred to tlie article iu the Globe in connection with the Borden murder case. The Post calls it a colossal fake, uml the News soys it is all lies. The papers agree in stating that the assoriioti that Lizzie Bor den has been unchaste is untrue. They agree, too. in ihc conclusion that many of the alleged witnesses have no existence in fact. The Globe says that the story has been proven wrong In some particulars. The paper claims that Detective K.

See moreSee less

C. Me Henry furnished the story as published. It is reported that McHenry received $500 for the story. The Globe to-night publishes an editorial apology for its publication of the statements in tlie Borden case. It says: "The Globe feels it a plain duty us an honest newspaper to state that it has been grievously misled in the Lizzie Borden case. It published on Monday a communlcutlou that it believed to be true evidence. Among all the Impositions which newspapers have suffered this was unparalleled in Its aston ishing completeness aud irrcsisthle plausi bility. Louis Kossuth, tne Hungarian patriot,who has been living in Italy during recent years, is reported to be iti an alarming state of debility. He is ninety years of ago. Kmperor William In Austria. Vienna, Oct. 12. Kmperor Wilihtm ar rived at the railway station here to-day. Kmperor Fram-is Joseph, a number of high military officials ami several of tbe ministers awaited his coming. As soon as the train bearing the German emperor had come to a stop in the station his uuijesty sprang to the platform. The emperor of Austria stepped forward and the two rulers threw their arms about each other and kissed repeatedly. After salutations were exchanged with the other notabilities pres ent the emperors entered a carriage and were driven to the imperial chateau at Schoabruna. The entire route from the railway stutlou to Schohbrunu was lined with people, who gave the German em peror au enthusiastic welcome. Bound to Have Trouble. Washington, Oct. 12. No mioriaation of :v threatened trouble at the Pine Kidge Indian agency has been received by the Indian otlicUis here, and they uuhesitatingly express the opiuiou that tDere is absolutely no fouadntiou lor the alarmist stories which have been published to that effect. Death of i'r. S. L. littrr. Hurcu, S. P.. eviul. Oct. 3 2.—A telegram from Washington to-day announced tbe death in that city last night of 1H\ S. L. Barr of Ca vour. He went to thcM-rand Army encampment three weeks ago. Dr. Harr was a prominent physiciau of th.s state, a member of the board of (tension examiners and a pioneer resident of this county.

See the clipping

The Dalles Times-Mountaineer · the Dalles, Or.

The Boston Globe admits its earlier story about Lizzie Borden's physical condition was untrue, based on faulty information from Dr. and Mrs. Bowen. It also notes other inaccuracies in evidence sold to its reporter by Detective Edwin McHenry of Providence.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Dalles Times-Mountaineer · 15 October 1892 · page 2

Tli a oiobe Takes It Back. Boston, Oct. 11. The Olobe this morn, ing says, upon investigation, it is satisfied the statement published yesterday concerning Lizzie Borden's physical condition was not true. Its basis ol belief was upon the state ment ot Dr. and Mrs. Bowen. The Globe also says there were other inaccuracies in the alleged new evidence, which was sold to its reporter by Detective Edwin McHenry, of Providence.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

City Marshal Hilliard discusses reports about Detective McHenry's alleged statements to the Boston Globe, declining to say McHenry has not treated him fairly. He indicates the government's case against Lizzie Borden has been strengthened by recent disclosures, though he won't specify details yet.

Pawtucket Tribune · 15 October 1892 · page 1

HILLIARD'S OPINION.

Not Treated Him Square. FALL RivER,, Muss, Ot 15 -—City Mar ehal Hilliard was at home yesterday after spending most of the week in the vicinity af Boston, Providenece and Now Dodford on business connected wit! the Lizzie A, Borden cinse. He was asked 17 he eared to

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

City Marshal Hilliard, questioned about his relationship with detective McHenry, says the case has been strengthened by new disclosures made during his absence, though he won't specify details. He also expresses regret over imputations on Lizzie Borden's character, insisting the government never intended to harm her more than any other prisoner.

Pawtucket Tribune · 15 October 1892 · page 1

HINTS AT NEW TESTIMONY

! Lizzie Borden’s Character had'been made while the prison r wo s un der the protection of the gov o 0 “Certainly,” said he, *“this kind ol thine was never warranted by anvitane Lor oy officers have said, that I know of. 1 14 not the purpose of the goverioe o T as I know, to harm this womnun v more than any other prisouer. I repen: now, as I have said before, there was evidence enough adduced at the hearing to warrant Miss Borden’s detention, whatever the re sult of a fair and impartial tvial may be, later on.” From all that eonld bea gathered from the city marshal 's manner, there is every reason to believe that the government has some important evidence which has not yet even been hinted at by the newspapers,

See the clipping

Grand Rapids Herald · Grand Rapids, Mich. · and 1 other paper

Amid a miscellaneous advice column on women's figures and bicycle attire, a brief mention notes that Mrs. McGuirk, who knew Lizzie Borden through a fruit and flower mission, believes she could not have committed the murders. McGuirk reportedly wrote a letter to the New York Recorder defending Borden against being branded a fiend for not showing public emotion.

Grand Rapids Herald · 16 October 1892 · page 13

Lizzie Borden could no more have murdered her father and stepmother than an angel could, and she has writ ten a powerful letter to the New Y'ork

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo. · 14 October 1892

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A young man calling himself John Wood was arrested in Richmond on suspicion of connection to the Borden murders, but denied real knowledge of the family or crime. The report recounts unconfirmed earlier claims of a man seen leaping the Borden fence and references friends of the Bordens, the Chases and Mrs. Manchester.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 18 October 1892 · page 1

HE HAS SEEN LIZZIE.

KNOWS NOTHING ABOUT IT. The Prisoner Denles Acquaintance With the Familiy or the Trigedy Ex. cept In a General Way, A young white man, decidedly good. looking, possessing more than ordinary in telligence, and claiming to be John Wood, of most anywhere and nowhere in par ticular, is 1n the Richmond jail under sus picion of having been in some way con nected with the celebrated Fall-River mur. der, in which Mr. and Mrs, Borden were foully assassinated and for which crime Lizzie Borden, their eldest daughter, is pow on trial in the State of Massachu. pelts, Shortly after the arrest of Miss Borden sowe months ago there were newspaper

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The report revisits earlier unverified claims that a man was seen leaping the Borden fence, noting no affidavit was ever secured and the witness reportedly denied it. It also reprints an Albany Telegram story claiming witnesses overheard a furious quarrel between Lizzie and her father over a secret suitor shortly before the murders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 18 October 1892 · page 1

THE MAN IN THE CASE.

& quarrel between Lizzie and her father. All heard Mr. Borden say: ‘Youcan make

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Constable Branch arrested a man named Wood in Henrico on suspicion of involvement in the Borden murder, based on rumors linking him to Lizzie Borden. A pop-corn vendor named Watkins claimed Wood had told him he knew who committed the murder, though Fall River authorities said no such man was known to be connected to the case.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 18 October 1892 · page 1

THE POP-COBN MAN, A Dispaton reporter called on Mr. Wat. kins at his pop-corn stand yesterday and was told by the proprietor that Wood had spoken to him about many ‘** curious things.” Mr. Watkins saxd Wood told him that he knew Lizzie Borden: that he on wany occasions took her to the theatre, and had a number of times met the young woman wien she would be going for morphine at the same drugstore at which he purchased whiskey on Sun day mornings. According to the story

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A political roundup column includes a brief sarcastic aside stating that the Lizzie Borden case resembles a trial of bungling detectives rather than of Borden herself. It appears among other unrelated political jabs about the 1892 election season.

Evening Journal · 19 October 1892 · page 4

FOR COUNTY COMPTROLLER, JOHN F. STAATS, of Appoqulnlmlnk Hundred. Blakrby Blaine did not beguile even little Egan. Foraker will speak in Brooklyn tonight; hence if a blizzard results tomorrow it should not be credited to Minnesota. It does not seem so much a trial of Lizzie Borden at Fall River for murder

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The article dismisses an interview with Thomas W. Robinson published by a competing paper as a fabrication with no more truth than the Boston Globe's report about Lizzie Borden. It uses this as a brief aside while mainly focused on local political unity ahead of an election.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Arizona Weekly Citizen, 15 October 1892, Richmond Dispatch, 18 October 1892, Richmond Dispatch, 18 October 1892.

Pawtucket Tribune · 19 October 1892 · page 2

A SILLY “FAKE.” Our readers want 1o underst thnt th interview which our ¢ovntown contem porary publishod yeste) with the H Thomas W. Robhinsan was nothing mor than a fake, and as little truth in 't as there was in the Boston Clobe's r about Lizzie Borden. An!! usual of political tattlers that buzz around th Times office, like bees round a hive, fa) the remainder of the story of withdrava

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

John Wood, a young peanut vendor, was arrested on suspicion of involvement in the murder of Mr. and Mrs. Borden of Fall River, Mass. He was implicated after talking about his acquaintance with Lizzie Borden, though he claims he can prove his innocence.

Pawtucket Tribune · 19 October 1892 · page 4

Suspected of Killing the Borvdens, Rici Mon, Ocp. 19, John Wood, a young peanut vénder, was arrested here l on suspicion of heing implicated in the | murder of Mr. and Mrs. Borden of Fall | River, Mass, He elaiins to be able to prove his innocence. His arrest was brought about on acconunt of his ralking | of his acquaintance with lizzie Borden, ! Resigned by Reqguest, ’ WASHINGTON, Oct, 19, —lt is stated that | Judge T. J. Anderson of the Fourth |

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

John Wood, arrested in Richmond on suspicion of connection to the Lizzie Borden murders, is held in jail while authorities seek more evidence. He denies earlier boasts of knowing Lizzie Borden, though witnesses say he made such claims, and Fall River's District Attorney reports no man is currently implicated.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Times · 19 October 1892 · page 5

| that he was acquainted with Lizzie Bor | den, the girl now on trial in Fall River for the murder of her parents, and had frequently gone to the theatre and to church with her, but when I saw lim in jail yesterday he denied baving made any of the statements credited to him. Sev eral persons of veracity and character, however, testify that Wood made similar statements to them, and there can be no doubt that he did talk knowingly of the Borden murder, but whether in a spirit of braggadocio or otherwise remains to be seen.

See moreSee less

Constable Branch's suspicions in regard to Wood were strengthened by a recent newspaper report that a lady would testi fy that on the night of the murder she saw a man leave the Borden premises by jumping over the yard fence. However, a telegram sent by Constable Branch to Fall River Monday was re plied to by the District-Attorney of that place, saying that as yet no man was known in the affair. The county officers have written and telegraphed to other sources for informa tion of Wood, and will hold him until they hear further concerning him. ~The estimate of the case made by The Times Monday as being of no special pub | lic Interest was further proven yesterday

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

John Wood was arrested in Virginia after boasting to acquaintances that he knew the Borden family and had escorted Lizzie Borden to theater and church. Authorities held him for further investigation, suspicious his claims might connect him to the murders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Times · 19 October 1892 · page 5

ONLY SUSPECTED. John Wood Held Here Because He Talked of the Borden Murder Case. John Wood, arrested by Constable Pranch, of Henrico, on a warrant sworn out before Justice Lewis Monday on the suspicion that he was in some way con nected with the Lizzie Borden murder, is still in jail, his case having been post poned by Justice Lewls for ten days in order to secure further evidence of his guilt or innocence. Wood, who came here at the beginning of the Exposition, secured employment “at “the popcorn stand of Watkins Brothers, and from time to time he dis cussed the famous Borden tragedy in

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A young man arrested in Richmond, Virginia claimed acquaintance with Lizzie Borden, saying he had taken her to church and seen her at theatres, though he denied direct involvement in the murder. Officers questioned him about inconsistencies in his story, including his claimed residence in Fall River and his employment history.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 20 October 1892 · page 5

the prisoner t«>l«l him he, W Is, had taken Lizzie Borden theatres and to church a number of times, When first « pmstioued as to how long he l all River, tiie accused replied only lour months, two years ago. He alterwani admitted that he resided there the tirst half of this year. leuvi about the first ul Jiffy. Who lived in tho place where the crime w; committed he was, according nient, in the employ of James .Marshall, hat manufacturer. He once went under a different name. he worked j there his state Imits that he

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A young man calling himself John Woods was arrested in Richmond, Virginia, on suspicion of being connected to the Borden murder. He gave conflicting accounts of how well he knew Lizzie Borden, first claiming only passing acquaintance, then telling arresting officers they were good friends.

The Indianapolis Journal · 20 October 1892 · page 3

43 & 45 South Meridian St, John -Woods, who came here alont two weeks ago. hns been arrested on suspicion, of harln? been in some way connected with the Borden murder. He was seen in the jail and denied statements credited to him to the effect that ha wax well acquainted with Lizzie Uordea. Whea asked where he was at the time of the tragedr, he could not answer, but said that he was prob ably in Jersey City or Newark or rhiladelpbia. Ho stated in tbe interview that he knew Lizzie Borden by reason of having seen her on tho streets of Fall Itivor twice and airain in church, but that he never spoke to her.

See moreSee less

Wood, however, told the officers who arrested film that he knew the girl well and 'that he and she were good fi lends. ---HB-MSH-M--a-a---------------a

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

A well-dressed young man calling himself John Woods was arrested in Richmond, Virginia, on suspicion of connection to the Borden double murder. He denied being well acquainted with Lizzie Borden, though he admitted seeing her twice and gave conflicting accounts of his whereabouts and use of a false name.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 20 October 1892 · page 3

Ein Bekannter von Lizzie Borden in Virginien verhaftet.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Grand Rapids Herald · Grand Rapids, Mich.

A man calling himself John Wood was arrested in Virginia on suspicion of connection to the Borden murder after claiming acquaintance with Lizzie Borden. His accounts of his whereabouts and relationship with her were inconsistent and contradictory under questioning.

Grand Rapids Herald · 20 October 1892 · page 1

Suspicion of Murder. ILriimom-, Va., Oct. 19. A good looking and iutelligent young man, claiming to be John Woods, who came here about three week ago, has een arrrattd on su.-piciouot having been m (tome way connecte d, with ttie Borden tnurdtr. He was seen ui the jad and denied statements credited to hint to the stlect that he was well acquainted with Lizzie Borden. When asked where he waa at the time of the tragedy he could not auswer, but said he was probably in Jersey City or New ark or Philadelphia.

See moreSee less

He stated in ths interview that he knew Lizzie Borden by reason of having seen her ou the streets of Fall Uiver twice and again iu church, but that he never spoke to her. Wood, however, told the otticcrs wnD arrested him that he knew the girl we.1 and that he and she were good triendJ. The popcorn man lor whom ht worked states that the prisoner toid him that he (Wood) had taken Ltzne Borden out to the theaters and to church a number of times. When first questioned as to how 1 ng he lived at Fall Kiver the accused replied only lour months, two years ago. He after wards admitted that he resided there the first half of this year, leaving there about the 4th of July. When he first lived in the place where the crime was committed, he was, according to his statement, in the employ of James Marshall, a hat manufacturer. He ad mits that he once went under a ditler ent name.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Among a list of unrelated news snippets, the item notes that at the W.C.T.U. state convention in Brockton, Mass., Mrs. Fessenden made a plea for justice to Lizzie Borden. No further detail is given about the nature of the plea or its context.

Pawtucket Tribune · 20 October 1892 · page 1

TELEGRAPHIC BREVITIES

At the W. C, T, U, state convention at Brockton, Mass., Mrs, Fessenden made o plea for justice to Lizzie Borden, The London Chironicle says the deeision in the Michigan electoral case may mean the downfall of the electoral college, TLouis Le PPage was sentenced at Wor cesier, Mass, to twenty-five years in pr son, under the habitual eriminal act. The Salem (Mass,) electric works, alarmed at the low condition of Wenham lake. is nrevaring to sink arteslan wells, T ¢ Golden Sceret of Long Life Keep the head cool, the feet warm and the bowels open. Avnt Fann s Health Restorer lsn viogelable proeparstion an! acts as a nalural axative, and (s Ihe greatest remedy ever discovered for the cae of dyspeps) MHeer compaint and wll blood, hver .n:‘

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

A man arrested in Richmond under aliases matching a former Fall River boarder is investigated, but police confirm he was not in the area during the Borden murders. The report also notes unidentified private detectives working the case and a mysterious, flashily dressed woman again drawing attention at a local hotel.

Pawtucket Tribune · 20 October 1892 · page 1

| plained, who lived here with Mra, Hough : ton,at 17 Johu street,also with her daughe i ter, Mrs. Cross, He worked at a loeal hat factory last year, but was not in the vicin l ity of Faull River whea the Borden mur ders were committed, The police report that there are strange detectives here at work on the Borvlen | case, and t ey know that they are not in

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A man under arrest in Richmond, Virginia under multiple aliases matches the description of a former boarder in Fall River, but was not in the area during the murders. Police report that unidentified detectives, not employed by the government, are working on the Borden case, and the mysterious woman who drew attention at the hearings has reappeared at the Mellen House.

The Providence News · 20 October 1892 · page 3

STRANGE DETECTIVES

Are Reported to be at Work on the Borden Mystery, FALL RIVER, Mass., Oct. 20.—The de scription of John Wood, alins Henry Wood, alias Henry Habr, who is under

See the clipping

In the story →

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Constables and a Fall River associate of Lizzie Borden's attorney visited suspect John Wood in a Richmond jail, searching his hands for a telltale scar. Officials found only a dimple that might have come from a pistol shot, but Wood revealed nothing new.

Richmond Dispatch · 20 October 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WOULDN'T KILL A CAT

THAT'S WHAT MRS. CROSS, OF FALL RIVER, SAYS ABOUT WOOD.

See moreSee less

He Is Not Thought to Have Had a Hand in the Borden Murder—Mr. Holmes's Visit to the Jail.

John Wood, who is in the Richmond jail, charged with suspicion of being implicated in the Borden murder, which was committed at Fall River, Mass., August 4th, was visited at his cell yesterday by Constables Branch and Fussell, of Henrico county, and Mr. J. C. Holmes, of Fall River. The latter gentleman was a member of the party of callers upon request of Andrew J. Jennings, Lizzie Borden's attorney.

He was in Washington, and was accompanying his wife to Norfolk, when he saw the newspaper accounts of Wood's arrest and wired Mr. Jennings. Mr. Holmes received a telegram from the lawyer instructing him to come at once to Richmond, and that he would receive further advice upon his arrival here at the Exchange Hotel.

Mr. Holmes was telegraphed by Mr. Jennings to use his discretion in the matter of getting information here concerning Wood, but to look carefully for a scar upon one of the prisoner's hands. Something was also said about a man named John Underwood, who at one time resided in Fall River, but it was not stated whether or not this party was a friend of Miss Borden.

MAY HAVE BEEN A SCAR.

When the prisoner was taken from his cell Mr. Holmes was hidden from view. The interrogating was done by Messrs. Branch and Fussell, and Sergeant Epps examined the hands of Wood. Upon one hand a deep dimple which, it appeared, could possibly have been made by a pistol-shot was observed, but nothing more. The accused would say nothing more than has already been published in the DISPATCH as an interview with him. The result of the investigation amounted to very little, and it is not known whether Wood is the "Underwood" referred to or not.

A SPECIAL FROM FALL RIVER.

A special telegram received from Fall River by the DISPATCH at a late hour last night appears to dissolve the possibility of Wood being connected with the murder, and shows him up as just such a man as was pictured in the article published in this paper exclusively on Tuesday morning. The special is as follows:

"News of the arrest of 'John Wood' as a Borden murder suspect created much interest in this city to-day when the local papers reproduced the DISPATCH'S story of Tuesday. Wood's real name is Henry Hahr, and he is a native of New York city. He came to Fall River two years ago and went to board with Mrs. Cross, at 17 John street. That lady to-day informed the DISPATCH correspondent that Hahr came of a Swedish family, and that his twin brother was at present a theatrical manager in New York. The name Wood he sometimes uses as a stage cognomen, and he was well known locally as Henry Wood. His twin brother gained much notoriety through a law suit with Maggie Mitchell over the right to produce a certain play.

"While here he dressed well, but had little or nothing to do, his only work being as a 'tip-printer' in Marshall's hat-factory. He worked three months and threw up the job. His acquaintances consider him harmless, of a bragadocio spirit, and fond of story-telling. He is always the hero of his own narratives. He left this city last April and has not been here since. The Borden murders were committed the 4th of August.

"In May he wrote to Mrs. Cross of his intention to sail for London on a theatrical venture. She supposed he had gone. In September she received a message from Hahr dated New York, and saying that he had just arrived from Europe and passed safely through quarantine. She had not heard from him since until to-day, when the news was broken to her of his arrest as a Borden murder suspect.

HENRY A HARMLESS MAN.

"At this the lady laughed outright and said: 'Why, Henry was in London, and besides he would not kill a kitten. He has been playing a joke and got into trouble. He never knew Lizzie Borden, although he may have seen her on the streets. As for going to the theatre with her, that is all bosh. Henry was an actor, so he said, and he has travelled all over the country, and frequently goes to England.'

"Inquiry among the local theatrical people disclosed the fact that Hahr was well known; that he was like many others, a venturesome youth with no higher ambition than to pose before the matinee crowds clad in the latest-style dress. Occasionally he got hard up and worked as a hat-finisher.

"Chief Hilliard, of the police force, takes no stock in the theory that Hahr was connected with the famous Borden tragedy. He has satisfied himself that the man was not in this city at the time of the killing.

"Robert Marshal, for whom Hahr worked says that he knew him as an honest well-meaning man, of more than ordinary good sense, but inclined to relate ghost stories of his own adventures. It was also learned that Hahr was received at the Cross household with more favor than the ordinary boarder.

"Mrs. Cross is a young widow and to her Hahr, it is alleged, paid considerable attention. She has announced her determination to put herself in communication with him and show the Richmond authorities that he is guiltless of crime."

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Following an earlier report naming 'Vohn Wood' as a Borden murder suspect, this story reveals his real name is Henry Hahr, a Swedish-American actor who boarded with a Mrs. Cross in Fall River. Multiple sources—his landlady, his former employer, and the police chief—state he was in London at the time of the murders and had no connection to Lizzie Borden.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Richmond Dispatch · 20 October 1892 · page 1

A SPECIAL FROM FALL RIVER.

city last April and has not been heresince. Tho Borden murders were committed the 4th of Au gust. “in May he wrote to Mrs, Cross of his intention to sail tor London cn a theatrical venture, She supposed he nad goane, In September she re ceived a message from Hahr dated New York, and saving that he had just arrived from Earope and pass-d sately through quarantine. She had not heard from him since until to-day, when the news was broken to her of his arrest as a bBor den murder suspect.

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A man identified as Henry, a sometime actor and hat-finisher who had lodged with a widow, Mrs. Cross, was rumored to be connected to the Borden murders. Police Chief Hilliard dismissed the theory, confirming Henry was not in the city at the time of the killings.

Richmond Dispatch · 20 October 1892 · page 1

HENRY A HARMLESS MAN.

‘At this the lady laughed outright and said: ‘Why, Henry was in London, and besides he would uot kil a kitten, He has been playing a joke and got into trouble. He never knew Lizzie orden, although he may have seen her on the gtroets. As for going to the theatre with her, that is all bosh., Henry was an actor, £o he said, and he has travelled all over the country, and frequently goes to England.’ “Inquiry among the local theatrieal people dis closed the fact that Hahr was well knows; that he was like many otuers, a venturesome youth with no higher ambition than to pose before the matinee crowds clad in the latest-styie dress.

See moreSee less

Ocensionaily he got hard up and worked asa hat-finigher. “ (Chiet Hilliard, of the police force, takes no stock in the theory that Hahr was connected with the famous Borden tragedy. He has «atis fied himself that the man was pot in this city at the time of the Killing. “ Kobert Marshal, for whom Hahr worked says that he knew him as an honest well-ipeaning man, of more than ordinary good senso, but ine clined to relate ghost stories of his own advens tures, It was also learned that Lahr was re ceived at the Cross household with wore favor thun the ordinary boarder. “Airs. Cross is a young widow and to her Hahr, it is alieged, paid considerable attention. She has announced her determination to put harself in communication with Yim and glow the Rick.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A man calling himself John Woods was arrested in Richmond, Virginia on suspicion of connection to the Borden murder. His account of knowing Lizzie Borden kept changing, from casual sightings to claims of being her close friend who took her to theatres and church.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 20 October 1892 · page 3

KNEW LIZZIE BORDEN

Conflicting htories. Richmond, Va., Oct. 10.?A good looking and intelligent young man, claiming to be named John Woods, who came bore about two weeks ago, has been ar rested on suspicion oi waving uoeu ia some way connected with tho Bordon murdor. Ho was seen in the jail and denied statements credited to him to the effect that ho was well acquainted with Lizzie Borden. When asked where he was at the time of tho tragedy, ho could not answer but said that ho was probably in Jersoy City, or Newark, or

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A man calling himself John Woods was arrested in Richmond, Virginia, on suspicion of connection to the Borden murder after claiming to know Lizzie Borden well. His accounts of his whereabouts and history were inconsistent, though he denied being well acquainted with her despite contrary claims from his employer.

Wheeling Register · 20 October 1892 · page 4

THE BORDEN CASE A Young Man Arrested at Richmond, Virginia—Supposed to Know Something of the Crime.

THE POP CORN MAN whom he worked for, states that the prisoner toll him that he (Woods) had taken Lizzie Borden out to the theaters and tc church a number of times. When

See the clipping

Baxter Springs News · Baxter Springs, Kan.

John Woods was arrested in Richmond, Virginia, on suspicion of being an accomplice to Lizzie Borden in the Fall River double murder case. No further details are given about the nature of the accusation.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

Baxter Springs News · 22 October 1892 · page 6

XUfi LATEST. Tire French chamber of deputies has appointed M. Loubct, prime minister, and M. Victtc, minister of public works, arbitrators of the Carmaux labor and political disputes. The porte in a brief note in reply to an obligatory request from the Russian government some tlmo ago virtually re jects Russia's demand that the sultan of Turkey shall not give audience vo m. Stambouloff, the Bulgarian premier. Ex-Presidext Cleveland denies pos itively that Gray Gables will be sold. Johx Woods has been arrested at Richmond, Va, charged with being an accomplice of Lizzie Borden in the

See the clipping

St. Landry Democrat · Opelousas, La.

The report recounts the August 4 murders of Andrew Borden and his wife in Fall River, describing the gruesome wounds found on each body and the public's shock at the lack of an apparent motive. It notes that Lizzie Borden, Andrew's daughter, was eventually arrested amid the ensuing investigation.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

St. Landry Democrat · 22 October 1892 · page 2

THE BORDEN CASE. HISTORY OF AN FXTKAOKDI .NAllY DOUBIjE TiiAOKDY. The Mnrderot Mr. and Mr«, Borden at l'ail Hiver, Mas-.—Why Sus picion Attached to the Ar rested .Lizzie Horden. The double murder of Andrew J. Boruen and his wife at Fall River, Mass., on the 4rli of August, culminating as it did m tue ariest of his youngest daugh ter, L zzie Boruen, has been one of the most extraordinary and mysterious crim inal episodes ot the centiry. The circumstances surrounding the as sassination of Borden and his wife, who ■was Lizzie's stepmotner, were such as to astound these who would pounce, oil hand, upon a motive.

See moreSee less

Borden was rich and pious, aged seventy-six years, a man whose probity vvas equal to his thrilt. He bad not led a public life, he had no known enemy who it could be conjec tured would go to the extent ot killing him, much less his wile, and when the mutilated bodies of the couple were dis covered, in their own house, shortly be fore noons on August 4, the police and the public were utterly at a loss for a motive, and m the intense excitement that overwhelmed the community they turned to one another in helpless aston ishment and horror. The body of Borden was found on a velvet sofa in the parlor of the house. His head had been literally hacked to pieces. There were seven long gashes on his face and skull, some of them an inch and a half deep through the flesh and bone. In the "spare" bed chamber on the second floor was discovered the body of Mrs. Borden, who was sixty seven years old. There wa3 at first no sight of blood and the momentary sup position was that heart failure had oc curred. Mrs. Borden was lying prone on the floor on her face with her arms out stretched and the toes of her shoes rest ng on the carpet. On raising the body there was seen a pool of blood, and an

See the clipping

The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss.

A news item reports that Boston and Fall River newspapers are complicating the Lizzie Borden case by prematurely publishing details of the evidence the state plans to use for conviction. It remarks that if even half the allegations are true, she must have had a shocking double nature.

The Grenada Sentinel · 22 October 1892 · page 2

The press of Boston and Fall River, Mass., are seriously complicating the case of Lizzie Borden by premature publication of lines of evidence relied upon by the state to convict If half of the allegations against the defendant are true she must have been as two faced as Dr. Jekyl and Mr. Hyde.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

A man known as Thomas Wood or Thomas Hahr was arrested at the Exposition grounds due to his own suspicious talk, linking him vaguely to the Lizzie Borden murder case. Subsequent investigation dissipated any grounds for suspicion, yet he remains jailed with no clear justification.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The Times · 22 October 1892 · page 4

MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING. A Question That Would Puzzle the OfMicers and the People Thomas Wood, or Thomas Hahr, ar rested on the Exposition grounds on the testimony of bis own wild talk, under suspicion of being in some mysterious way connected with the Lizzie Borden murder case in Fall River, Mass, 13 still . in jail, The ground for suspicion, if thére ever was any of sufficient weight to warrant his arrest, has been dissipated by subse

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

This item reports that the detective who fed a false story about Lizzie Borden to a Boston Globe reporter claims he did it to test the reporter's motives. The piece condemns the detective for defaming her reputation and calls for his indictment for criminal libel.

Paper unidentified · 25 October 1892 · page 1

That DetectlTO . Story. Oregonian. The detective who sjld the disgracefully false story about Lizzie Borden tothe Boston Globe reporter, says he did it to discover what was the reporter's object in wanting to know so' much. The good name of a young woman already Under a heavy burden was wantonly and unfeelingly aspersed in the public press of the whole country in order that an alleged detective might score a little point. - He should be in- ! dieted for criminal libel, to. teach him that even detectives are bound by the same laws of decency and respect for the good name of a deft-nseless woman that apply to ordinary mortals.

See the clipping

Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan.

John Woods was arrested in Richmond, Virginia, accused of being an accomplice to Lizzie Borden in the Fall River double murder case. The brief item appears amid a roundup of miscellaneous national news items.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Barton County Democrat · 27 October 1892 · page 2

John Woods has been arrested at j Richmond, Va., charged with being an I accomplice of Lizzie Borden in the I double murder case at Fall River, Mass.

See the clipping

Herald and News · West Randolph, Vt.

A roundup of miscellaneous news items notes that at the W.C.T.U. state convention in Brockton, Mass., Mrs. Fessenden made a public plea for justice to be done for Lizzie Borden. The item appears amid unrelated brief news items from late October 1892.

Herald and News · 27 October 1892 · page 7

nmler any flag other than that of the United Stats. A rumor is afloat implicating Governor Johnston I Barler of yommg in the county invasion.. General Miles proposes a spectacular display of military tactics at uighl, lor the benefit of Chicago s visitors. At the W. C. T. U. state convention at Brockton, Mass., Mrs. Fessenileu made a plea for justice to Lizzie Borden. Iyouis I-e Page was sentenced at Wor cester, Mass., to twenty-five years in j prison, under the habitual criminal act. There was another collision on the WUrtown branch of the Fitchburg railroad. Two freights collided, but no one was killed

See the clipping

Herald and News · West Randolph, Vt.

A peanut vendor arrested in Richmond, Virginia in connection with the Lizzie Borden case was identified as Henry Hahr, a man who had formerly lived in Fall River, Massachusetts. The item appears as a brief item within a roundup of miscellaneous national and international news.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

Herald and News · 27 October 1892 · page 7

The peanut vender arrested at Ri J mond, Va., in connection with the Borden case is lh-urj Hahr, and be formerly lived in Fall Kiver. Mass.

See the clipping

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.

A young man calling himself John Woods was arrested in Richmond, Virginia, on suspicion of connection to the Borden murder after giving conflicting accounts of his whereabouts and relationship with Lizzie Borden. He first denied knowing her well, then told others he had taken her to the theater and church, and gave inconsistent details about how long he had lived in Fall River.

Eagle River Review · 27 October 1892 · page 6

ANOTHER BORDEN SUSPECT.

was probably in Jersev City, or Newark, or Philadelphia. He stated that he knew Lizzie Borden by reason of havingseen her on the streets of FFall River twice and again in church, but that he never spoke to her. Wood, however, told the officers who arrested him that he knew the girl well, and that he and she were good friends, The popcorn man for whom he worked, states that the priscner told him that he (Wood) had taken lizzie Borden out to the theaterand to church anumber of times. When first questioned as to how long he lived in Fall River, the accused replied only four months, two years ago. He atterwards admitted that he resided there the first half of this year,

See the clipping

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

A dispatch reports that John Woods was arrested in Richmond, Virginia, on suspicion of being an accomplice to Lizzie Borden in the Fall River double murder. No further details are given about the basis for this charge.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Iola Register · 28 October 1892 · page 2

TJIK RODTII. The drought has been broken in north and northwest Texas. Near Montgomery, Tex., an explod ing saw-mill boiler tore a boy into frag ments and beheaded the engineer. Capt. Willie, a notorious Creek mur derer, has been captured and taken to Fort Smith, Ark. A feud between Dr. Alsop and Hon. Ben Walton at Shaw, Bolivar county, (Miss.) culminated in a duel on sight in which Dr. Alsop was dangerously wounded and Mr. Walton mortalh. Uuknown persons threw rocks through the windows of the private car in which Gov.

See moreSee less

McKinley and party were riding at Hurricane, a small station in West Virginia. A fuss in religious circles is reported at Abilene, Tex., where an evangelist named Lincoln is accused of being long winded. The pool rooms at Little Rock, Ark., have been closed. John Woods has been arrested at Richmond, Va., charged with being an accomplice of Lizzie Borden in the double murder case at Fall River, Mass. Protestant Episcopalians at Balti more, Md., passed a resolution against giving government support to denorni national schools for the Indians. A reign of terror is reported at Scott's Ridge, Ky., because of feuds between the Shipps and their friends on one side and the Underwoods, Buleys and Skaggs on the other. Nine prisoners escaped from jail at Hampton. Ark. The city council of Dallas, Tex., has reduced salaries of all officials 40 per cent Four children living near Claremont S. C, were recently burned to death. They were locked in the house while the parents went to a religions meeting. Greenleaf beat Martha Wilkes at Nashville, Tenn. Time, 2:10 . A boy named Ncunlist set a gun trap for chicken thieves at Louisville, Ky. His mother was first to open the door of the chicken coop and her head was almost blown off. The boy was released on bail.

See the clipping

The Penn's Grove Record · Penn's Grove, N.J.

A man calling himself John Woods was arrested in Richmond, Virginia, on suspicion of a connection to the Borden murder case. He gave contradictory accounts of his acquaintance with Lizzie Borden and admitted having once used an assumed name.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Penn's Grove Record · 28 October 1892 · page 1

John \voods, has been arrested in Richmond, Virginia, on suspicion of having been in some way connected with the B< rden murder. He has told contradictory stories concerning his ac quaintance with Lizzie Borden, and admits having once lived under an assumed name. Julius Greiner, of Jasper, Ala., com mitted suicide because be could not pass examination for mall carrier. The centennial celebration of llie in corpora loo of Raleigh, North Caro lina, will begin with a procession. The city is handsomely decorated, and the eelebration will last several days. The 950 telegrapb operators of the Missouri Pacific Railroad system have compromised their differences with the company.

See moreSee less

4 At Bloom inglon, llh,from the effects of poison, Susie Hoobler died suddenly, and her lover, Simons, was arrested on suspicion. On hearing of Susie's death, lier younger sister became ill and to relieve her, Mrs. Banks, with whom she lived, administered, by mistake, carbolio acid. Tbe girl Is now dying. At Quincy, 111., Vera Avb, the no torious Dias de Bar was arrested here j on the charge of stealing $1000 from Mrs. John Mitchell, at Elgin, 111.

See the clipping

The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · the Dalles, Or.

A detective admitted selling a false story about Lizzie Borden to a Boston Globe reporter, claiming he did it to test the reporter's motives. The piece condemns this as a wanton attack on the reputation of a woman already under suspicion and suggests he should be indicted for criminal libel.

The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · 28 October 1892 · page 2

Svcamohe, 111., Oct. 24. Fred Ulrich, a boy, was almost devoured by two sav age dogs yesterday morning. He was attacked by one dog and made a good fight, but another dog attacked him, and before aid arrived, he was knocked down and nearly all the flesh on one leg and one arm was bitten off, and he was frightfully torn in other parts of the body. There are no. hopes of his re covery. That Detective Story. Oregonian. The detective who sold the disgracefully false story about Lizzie Borden to the Boston Globe reporter, says he did it to discover what was the reporter's object in wanting to know so much.

See moreSee less

The good name of a young woman already under a heavy burden . was wantonly and unfeelingly aspersed in the public press of the whole country in order that an alleged detective might score a little point. . He should be in dicted for criminal libel, to teach him that even detectives are bound by the same laws of decency arid "respect for the good name of a defenseless woman that apply to ordinary mortals.

See the clipping

The Bolivar Bulletin · Bolivar, Tenn.

A report states that John Woods was arrested in Richmond, Virginia, accused of being an accomplice to Lizzie Borden in the Fall River double murder. No further details are given about the nature of the evidence against him.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Bolivar Bulletin · 28 October 1892 · page 1

West Virginia. . Rich lead and silver ore has been found at Segar, Ok. John Woods has been arrested at Richmond, Va., charged with being an accomplice of Lizzie Borden in the

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

A brief news item reports that new and startling evidence has been produced incriminating Lizzie Borden of Fall River, Mass., who is accused of killing her parents. No details of the evidence are given.

Iowa County Democrat · 28 October 1892 · page 2

CONDENSED NEWS.

New and startling evidence incrimin ating Miss Lizzie Borden, of Fail Itiver, Mass, accused of killing lier parents, Is produced. Geo. G. Geer, who was engineer of

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

A dispatch reports that John Woods was arrested in Richmond, Virginia, on suspicion of having some connection to the Borden murders in Fall River, Massachusetts. No further details are given about the nature of the suspicion or evidence against him.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Washington Bee · 29 October 1892 · page 1

John Woods has been arrested in Rich mond, Va., on suspicion of having been in 60me way connected with the Borden murders at Fall River Mass. "Drank himself to death," is the end

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

The passage reports that detectives sold false stories to newspapers in an attempt to incriminate Lizzie Borden, causing outrage among her supporters. Her friends are said to be preparing libel suits against Fall River newspapers that printed these fabrications.

The Washington Bee · 29 October 1892 · page 4

London Tillies says: "The conclusion on the w hole case is tho present year will be a disastrous one for the British far mer." Recent false reports, sold to newspapers by detectives, and tending to erinunate Lizzie Borden, have aroused much indig nationimoug the friends of the young woman, who will bring libel suits against

See the clipping

The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss.

A man named John Woods was arrested in Richmond, Va., on suspicion of being an accomplice to Lizzie Borden in the Fall River double murder case. The brief item offers no further detail on the charge or evidence against him.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Grenada Sentinel · 29 October 1892 · page 2

THE SOUTH. Uuknown person* threw rocks through the windows of the private car in which Gov. McKinley and party were riding at Hurricane, a small station iu West Virginia. A fuss in religious circles is reported at Abilene, Tex., where an evangelist named Lincoln is accused of being long winded. The pool rooms at Little Rock, Ark, have been closed. John Woods has been arrested at Richmond, Va., charged with being an accomplice of Lizzie Borden in the double murder case at Fall River, Mass. 1'rotestant Episcopalians at Balti more. Md, passed a resolution against giving government support to denomi national schools for the Indiana A reion of terror is reported at Scott's Ridge.

See moreSee less

Ky., because of feuds between the Shipps and their friends on one side and the Underwoods, Buleys and Skaggs on the other. Nine prisoners escaped from jail at Hampton. Ark. The city council of Dallas, Tex., has reduced salaries of nil officials 40 per cent. Four children living near Claremont, S. C., were recently burned to death. They were locked in the house while the parents went to a religious meeting. GRKKNi.EAr beat Martha Wilkes at Nashville, Tenn. Time, 2:10%. A boy named Neunlist set a gun trap for chicken thieves at Louisville, Ky. His mother was first to open the door of the chicken coop aud her head was almost blowu off. The boy was released on bail. The plant of the Phoenix powder mill at Kellogg, W. Va., has blown up No one was hurt Georok Huffacre, a farmer, after spending a day in Sherman, Tex., start ed home and was found dead at Collins ville. with his head cut nearly off. He was struck by a train on the Texas A Pacific. ■

See the clipping